“I thought you were snapping a few photographs, not reopening the whole case.”

We’re not sure how Kathryn Bigelow came to direct the adaptation of Anita Shreve’s book “The Weight of Water” for the big screen, but it feels a bit odd in her body of work. It’s arguably the least masculine film she’s made, and is a mystery told between two time periods, so it feels different for her. But what did we think of it? Join us – Pete Wright and Andy Nelson – as we continue our Journalists series with Bigelow’s 2002 film The Weight of Water.

Is there much weight to The Weight of Water?

This is a film we really struggle with. For a mystery film, it doesn’t leave much mystery. And the relationship angle feels sloppy. Why did Bigelow take on this project? Was the book any better? We didn’t connect with the two stories and their lack of actual connection. That being said, the actors largely work.

It’s just a shame they didn’t either focus on the story of the true murders on Smuttynose Island or the story in present day. Dancing between the two of them just doesn’t work.

Regardless, it’s another film checked off our Bigelow filmography, and we’re always happy to do that. So check out the movie if you can track it down and then tune in. The Next Reel – when the movie ends, our conversation begins!

Join the conversation with movie lovers from around the world on The Next Reel’s Discord channel!

Film Sundries

Learn more about supporting The Next Reel Film Podcast through your own membership.

• Find places to watch this at JustWatch
• Theatrical trailer
• Poster artwork
• Original Material
• Flickchart
• Letterboxd

• Cinema Scope: Bridging Genres, Subgenres, and Movements
• The Film Board
• Movies We Like
• Sitting in the Dark

• The Web
• Letterboxd
• Facebook
• Instagram
• Threads
• Bluesky
• YouTube
• Flickchart
• Pinterest
• Pete 
• Andy

• You can buy our movie-related apparel, stickers, mugs and more from our MERCH PAGE.
• Or buy or rent movies we’ve discussed on the show from our WATCH PAGE.
• Or buy books, plays, etc. that was the source for movies we’ve discussed on the show from our ORIGINALS PAGE.
• Or renew or sign up for a Letterboxd Pro or Patron account with our LETTERBOXD MEMBERSHIP DISCOUNT.
• Or sign up for AUDIBLE.