Kevin Shindel, a social studies teacher with 28 years in class, argues schools should pause three or four months and study AI in schools before they buy or adopt anything.
Kevin Shindel, a high school social studies teacher with 28 years of experience, makes the case for slowing down on AI in schools. He asks you to start with purpose, then spend three or four months learning about AI before you buy a platform or roll one out.
Shindel names four forces behind the rush: money, power, fear and hubris. He and Jethro Jones differ on whether to call the pause a moratorium or a four-month delay, and Jones argues that every tool you adopt brings its creator's mindset with it.
Times are for the episode without ads. Your player may be off by the length of any ads.
Should schools pause before adopting AI?
Shindel says yes. He proposes a three or four month moratorium on AI usage and on buying AI platforms, and he stresses it is not a ban. Schools would spend that time teaching about AI before they use it. Jones suggests a four-month delay between deciding and adopting.
Why does Kevin Shindel say AI is an ecosystem and not a tool?
Shindel says adopting AI changes what happens in the classroom, so you take on a new paradigm, not just another tool. If a tool fails you can blame the user. If AI has devastating effects in classrooms, he argues, that is not user error.
How should school leaders protect student data when using AI?
Jones says educators must demand that student data stay siloed and not train a vendor's model. He points to School AI, which has an agreement with OpenAI that data sent through the API will not be used for training. Shindel adds that trust is still an issue.
High school social studies teacher with 28 years of experience who created a digital detox program for students ten years ago.
Working on this at your school? Get a free preview of a 10-week leadership pathway built from episodes like this one at transformativeprincipal.com/start.
Jethro Jones interviews instructional leaders from around the nation to learn and teach what it takes to become a transformative principal. Episodes address topics like Response to Intervention (RTI), Multi-Tiered System of Support (MTSS), Positive Behavior Interventions and Supports (PBIS), the latest advances in educational research, standards-based grading, and interviews with industry leaders like Bill Daggett, Rick Wormeli, Todd Whitaker and even people outside the education like Seth Godin, JeVon McCormick, Liz Wiseman, and more.
If you've been thinking about news broadcast, but don't know where to start and don't want to have that lift, use broadcastmadeeasy.com to make it super easy for yourself. I am really excited about our sponsor, Broadcast Made Easy. As a principal, I created a daily news show at all of my schools, but you know what? It took a ton of work. Broadcast Made Easy makes it super simple for you to get started.
They provide templates, scripts, job descriptions, applications, the whole nine yards. You buy it once, no subscription, and it makes getting started so much easier. Another thing they have is specific videos for every holiday you could possibly imagine. So that as part of your news broadcast, you can share what holidays are coming up, less than a minute, and very simple, straightforward, just the facts that makes it really easy to start conversations about those holidays.
So go check it out at broadcastmadeeasy.com and let them know that you heard about it on Transformative Principle. That's broadcastmadeeasy.com. This B Podcast Network show is presented by IXL. IXL's all-inclusive online teaching and learning platform simplifies edtech needs and accelerates achievement in 95 of the top 100 U.S. school districts. IXL delivers personalized learning across a comprehensive pre-K-12 curriculum, including math, language arts, science, and social studies, and helps you assess student performance through actionable, real-time insights at every level of your school or district.
This one solution performs work that typically requires dozens of tools. Want to find out why so many leading districts trust IXL? Visit IXL.com slash B-E. That's IXL.com slash B-E. Welcome to Transformative Principle, where I help you stop putting out fires and start leading. I am your host, Jethro Jones. You can follow me on Twitter at Jethro Jones. Welcome to Transformative Principle. This is part of the Summer of AI series, and I'm happy to have Kevin Shindell on the program today.
He's a high school social studies teacher with 28 years experience. He has taken a keen interest in technology and its impact in the classroom. Ten years ago, he created a digital detox program for students, and he runs this experience every year with his students now. He's very interested in the holistic impact of technology on students when that technology is adopted in schools. We're grateful to our sponsors for this Summer of AI series, School of AI, Aileader.info, and a couple other great ones.
You'll hear about those in just a moment. Kevin, welcome to Transformative Principle. Great to have you here. Thank you, Jethro. Appreciate being here. Yeah. So, I'm really excited about this conversation. We were just going to chat and then decided that we should just record it and see what came of it. And so, there's no, like, organized way of asking questions. We just had a conversation, and I think it turned out really well, and I'm glad that we did it.
So, what do you think people should walk away with from this, Kevin? I think people should walk away with this idea of artificial intelligence, right? That the pace and the scale at which this is coming at us. And I speak specifically from my standpoint in the classroom and school system. I think the main thing is that we have to have, there needs to be a pause button, right?
And we need to basically learn as much as we can about artificial intelligence and all of the impacts it's going to have, not just on the ability to learn facts or the ability to get help with writing or something like that, but all of the impacts, the social impacts, the psychological impacts, and the emotional impacts in the classroom before we kind of get this off the ground and really start to implement it, right?
And so, I just, I want people to see what this can do. Is this aligned? And that word alignment becomes really, really important. What's our purpose as an educational system? What's my purpose as a teacher? And is this technology aligned to that? And insofar as it is, and we can identify what our common values are and enhance those through artificial intelligence, we should. But if we can't do that, then I think we need to put the brakes on it.
That's going to be really difficult because all the money and all the messaging seems to be lined up to, you know, break stuff real fast, go forward, and let's get this off the ground. Yeah, yeah, for sure. And you give a lot of good insight throughout this conversation about reasons why we should pump the brakes a little bit, reasons why we should be more thoughtful. The thing that I really took away from this, and it's going to be the title of the episode, is that AI is not a tool.
It's an ecosystem. And we have to understand that we are adopting more than just a tool. We're using more than just bringing in a drill or a hammer. We are adopting a whole ecosystem. And I think that that idea that we just barely touched on at the end, it's so good. That idea, I think, is so powerful and something that we need to be paying a lot of attention to because it's really easy to think, oh, this is just another tool.
It's a way of doing things. It's a way of believing. And it's a way of aligning our values to something. And if we're not careful, then we're going to align it to the wrong thing. So we don't talk about this, but one of those things is a class dojo that we didn't bring up at all. But when teachers implemented class dojo, their classrooms took on a different feel, and you could feel what that was like.
And depending on how they used it, there were different things. But however they used it, they couldn't change what it was, which was tracking behavior and publicly praising or giving shame to those who met or did not meet expectations. And so that idea of a tool being an ecosystem is a very real thing. So really great conversation. Appreciate your time. And thank you so much. We're going to hear the rest of this conversation with Kevin in just a moment.
Okay. All right. So tell me what your thoughts are about AI. And you said after listening. If you've been listening to Transformative Principle for any amount of time, you know that I have a love-hate relationship with edtech. We have the ability to personalize learning for every single one of our students. And yet, so many of our edtech tools fall short. We need our technology to do more for us.
That's why it's so important for me to know that IXL provides true personalized learning across the entire pre-K-12 curriculum. And that it's proven to benefit all student populations, including English language learners and students in special ed programs. As a principal, I've used this in my school. As a parent, I've had my children use it as well. And let me tell you, this is a tool that definitely helps students learn and practice better.
IXL is research proven to accelerate achievement. Studies across 45 states show the IXL schools outperform non-IXL schools on state assessments. And independent research from Johns Hopkins University verifies the IXL meets ESSA Tier 1 standards. With those results combined with IXL's teacher-friendly reputation, what more could you ask for? Now, you also know that I don't care so much about test scores, but I know that they are legislatively convenient and something that we have to deal with and manage on a day-to-day basis.
If you can implement something that is easy and effective, why wouldn't you do it? If you have a goal to increase achievement for all students, make sure to find out what IXL can do for you. Visit IXL.com slash B for a demo. That's IXL.com slash B E. In my episode and my office hours, you're like, I have even more questions. Tell them what you're thinking, Kevin. Right.
So, you know, I think we need to begin with purpose, right? And so the first question I ask is, what's the purpose of AI, right? And then once we know what the purpose is, that helps us design the structure, design how to implement it, what the best sustainable practices are. And so I think I'm a skeptic by nature. And I have some kind of deep-seated skepticism with AI, certainly the people that are driving it, the reasons that, you know, this push seems to be coming kind of all in this moment.
We know that AI has been around for over 50 years, right? We're going back to the 50s. But in this moment, right, why this dramatic, you know, you can't turn on the news without seeing AI. You can't open your computer without seeing AI. You know, why in this moment do we have to take this leap forward into what I think a lot of people, and even the people that are closest to the know, have some real concerns with, right?
And the pace of growth and the spread of this, as someone who seemed to embrace the technology, like, what do you see as the ultimate purpose of this? Yeah, I think that's... And then more specifically, what's the purpose for the classroom? Yes, okay. That's a different, that could be an altogether different question. Yeah. So I'd like to start with the second one first. What's the purpose of AI in the classroom?
Because I think that the purpose of AI in the classroom is different than the purpose of AI in general. Agreed. Here's what I, my educational philosophy is we give kids what they need when they need it. And so that has been my educational philosophy for a very long time. And the way that I think about education is that we should give kids what they need when they need it, regardless of what it is, and regardless of whether or not we agree with whether or not they need it.
And so there are a lot of structures in our system that we do because they're convenient, like state assessments. Kids do not need to be tested altogether, all at once, at this specific time, in a specific way, for their benefit. That's for our benefit as the adults. And so is that giving kids what they need when they need it? No, it's definitely not. So to me, that doesn't really fit into my educational philosophy.
However, I know that we need that. And so we should do it. So I explained that just a little bit. I could go on for hours about that. In fact, I have on this podcast. So let me ask you, maybe Ms. Herjee, you said whether we can agree on what they need or not. Yeah, it's not our choice about what they need. It's their life. It's their learning.
They're the ones who are the ones who actually need it. And they may not even know what it is that they need in the moment. Sometimes they need a harsh taskmaster. Sometimes they need empathy and compassion. Sometimes they need encouragement. Sometimes they need to just shut up and learn the thing they need to learn that they're struggling with. And so that's where that piece for me matters.
And the way that relates to AI is that if AI can help make it personalized and help them get what they need, then it's a tool we should definitely be employing. So to me, the purpose of really anything in the classroom is to make it more possible for kids to get what they need when they need it. That's how I personally approach that. Thoughts? Yeah, lots. And so the first thing, right, is kids need more than ever before social connection and the ability to collaborate and the ability to really, and when I say the word love in a public classroom, it's kind of like, it's not welcomed, right?
And it's kind of strange. But I think kids need love and connection. And I don't know how AI necessarily gets us there, right? So one of the things you mentioned was personalization. And I think personalization is important, right? And I've been inspired and kind of looking at some of the things. I wrote a post a couple of weeks ago, and what hit me was Aristotle's golden meme, right?
The virtues and the idea that even things that are seemingly virtuous, they have vices at the extremes, right? And so when we look at personalization, for example, I think it's important. But I think the idea that we're going to sell an educational system on personalization, I think, could be really, really detrimental, right? Hyper-personalization leads to more isolation. And we know COVID, I always say COVID didn't start mental illness.
COVID didn't start student disengagement. And it just dialed everything up, you know? And so the latest, I think the latest CDC research said 44% of American teens feel anxious, depressed, or hopeless at some point. And I see AI being, I don't know, I need some help from you. I see AI being a toxic contributor to that, that will even exacerbate those problems. Yeah, so let me give a spin on it that I think is essential to understanding how AI could help.
And if AI is not working in this way, I totally agree with you. If our idea is that we put kids on a device and have the device be the teacher and they have no other connection, I think you're absolutely right. Totally toxic, not appropriate. However, if we can delegate to the AI, whatever the AI is, right? If we can delegate to that, the academic type stuff, the two plus two equals four kinds of things, the very specific, here's how you do things.
And we utilize the teacher's time for love and connection. To me, that is the win-win in the situation that we're looking for. We want to have more of those opportunities for teachers to connect with kids and to build real, positive, healthy relationships with them. And to be a supportive connection that they have that helps them see more of what the kid needs. And to really focus the teacher's time not on grading, not on giving assignments, not on things that an AI can do, but on the human connection that the kids really need.
OK. And that makes some sense to me, right? The idea that AI can free up the mundane tasks and let the relationship flourish. I think from a practical standpoint, I don't know how many taxpayers are going to pony up the amount of money, right, in order to have someone in a classroom basically holding hands, right? Holding hands and singing kumbaya, right? Right. And just offering encouragement, right?
And so I think, again, I think this push to embrace AI, let's bring it in. I think teachers are justifiably scared out of their wits that ultimately this could be a replacement. And whether the AI does a better job, you seem to think that it can do a better job with those academic tasks of teaching. And I mean, even if we agree to that, right, even if it doesn't do that and the AI is cheaper, these are economic decisions.
And so that brings us back to kind of why the push, why now, and who's going to benefit from that? And I think the big idea is that we already see this. There are companies that are laying off writers. The AI is not there yet, but the AI is free. And the writer that may have cost $40,000 or $50,000 or $70,000 a year is now superfluous. They're not needed because just good enough is good enough to save $70,000 a year.
And so I think that I agree that it'd be great to free up some time, but I still have questions about what all this free time entails, right, and how it will be used. And I think a lot of the people in the spaces say it'll free up time to produce and be creative, all these what are seemingly kind of individualistic endeavors, right? And I'm not saying that they monopolize what we're supposed to do with our free time.
I think the point is we decide what we do with our free time. But I think what's been promoted is you get to expand your leisure time mostly, right? You do what you want to do. And I think that that has some real social consequences as well. Yeah, so you said something twice now that I want to highlight and talk a little bit more about and get your perspective on.
What is it that you mean when you say that why is this happening right now? Like what are the bigger social things that you're seeing are driving this and some of the consequences? Let's talk about that a little bit. Yeah, so I think number one is money, right? I'd be hard-pressed to find a motivation greater than money for why this is being pushed in all of the sectors that it's being pushed in right now, right?
We should probably still stick to education, right? But number one is money. I think number two is power and status. And when you look at who's driving this and who's pushing this, they are generally people who have a lot of money and already occupy a very lofty status in the tech world, which translates to status in the political, economic, social world that we all live. I think fear is a huge motivator when you get to the global scale, right?
We're told we can't regulate, we can't stop what we do because somebody else is going to jump ahead of us. And for this one, the fear is that there is no second place, right? There's going to be one company, one person that monopolizes this. And once they get it, everybody else has lost the race. There is no second place. And so I would, again, I'd say money, power, fear, and I'm no fan of big tech and Silicon Valley.
I think they're hubris, right? I think the idea that they're confident that they can use the technology that they create to solve the world's ills, it hasn't happened yet. And we have direct evidence that, in fact, if we look at social media, for example, right, it's probably contributed to more ill than good, certainly among our school-age population. Yeah. Yeah. So I think this last piece, especially about the hubris, is so fascinating to me because I've been involved in the tech and education space for my whole career.
I've seen many different technology companies come in and say, we'll solve this problem for you, right? And I want to highlight one opposite example of that, which was Adam Pizzoni, who created a scheduling tool called ABLE, A-B-L. And I had him, I met him and had him on the podcast a few years ago. And what his focus was really understanding very well what issues school leaders faced when building a master schedule.
And then he wanted to help solve that problem. And what's interesting is that his, the way the company went was that it started out doing that. And then it went basically into how to make sure that scheduling is equitable, that everybody's getting what they need and not getting preferential treatment. Because for example, the classic one is that if you're in band and algebra in eighth grade, then you're also in all the same other classes.
And so how do you bring kids together so that you're not just with the same group of kids in every single class? And when these singletons that you have to take are only offered at a certain times, then it makes it difficult to balance all of that. And so anyway, Adam did a great job of really understanding what the issue was. And this hubris part comes in where most of these other tech companies are like, we know how to solve your problem and we're going to do that.
But they really don't have an understanding of how to actually solve that real problem. And so they think this is what we can do to solve it. But then when it comes to boots on the ground, like teachers in the classrooms, they're not actually solving it and they just miss the mark. And my big thing that I've been saying lately is with social media companies, we as educators, we just let them define all the rules and how everything was going to go and didn't do anything to say, this is how things need to be.
And what I've been saying about AI is we can't let that happen again, we as educators need to be a voice in our sector, we need to be talking about what we're going to adopt. And we need to have frameworks and systems in place to make sure that the things that we're adopting are actually going to be beneficial for our students and the communities that we serve and not just beneficial for the tech companies who are solving a problem that we may very in very real terms may have a problem.
But we can't just take whatever they say and bend to their will, we have to say, no, this is how it needs to work like privacy, for example, you cannot use our students data to go and train your model so that you can make more money, like our student data has to be siloed off and has to be separate and you have to ensure that our students data is going to be protected.
And at the very least, asking that question and talking about it, because most of the times people are just using or can use that I'm not going to accuse anybody people can use that to do whatever they want with and that's not that's not okay. Right. I mean, how many times has Google itself been brought in front of the FTC for misusing and collecting too much student data?
It's been a number of times over the last dozen years and all we've done, I think we're on the same page in terms of this has to be beneficial for the classroom and students and teachers, right? But I think where we and we I think we're even on the same page with respect to big tech, it sounds like, right? Like they're going to do what's best for them, not what's best for our classroom.
And yet they run the show. It's their money, which is off the charts, right? When you look at when you look at capital and things like that, you know, Silicon Valley Bank foreclosing that not, you know, but when you look at their money and you look at their messaging, it gets to be really, really exploitative. Right. And I think, again, I'll go back to that fear. They knock on the school superintendent's door and they say, if you don't hire us to do this, your kids are going to fall behind.
Your parents, your parents are going to want you out because you're not preparing your kids for the future. Right. And so when the lack of anything else, right, and any kind of real knowledge on what AI is, they fall prey to these, but I'll call them profiteers and pariahs. And I would say definitely there are a lot of those around right now. In fact, I had a company reach out that was interested in sponsoring this Summer of AI series for Transformative Principle.
And I felt like it was so much just profiteering that I was like, I don't want anything to do with this because that's not what I'm interested in. And the companies that we have selected to sponsor this Summer of AI series are companies that I believe are approaching this in the right way. And so that I think is incredibly important and it has to be something where you have to know who they are and what they're doing and what they really stand for.
And it's not just about them providing a service. And there are a lot of different services out there that you can use and try in your schools often for free. And you need to understand what it is that you're paying with because you're always paying with something and you need to be aware of that. And whether it's money or something else, it's important to know that there's something there.
So I think it's so important to know what their goals are, what their purpose is, and how they're trying to make education better. And whether or not they're a collaborator or if they are a service provider. And there's a difference between those two. And we need collaborators. That's who we need to be working with. We don't need to be working with service providers because the service providers are saying, here's the service, take it or leave it.
And if you leave it, your kids are going to fall behind. The collaborators say, here's what we have. How can we adjust this to make it work better for you? And I, for example, real quick, school AI, one of the companies, they said that their people, their schools needed a FERPA compliant chat GPT experience in the schools. So what they have is they have an agreement with open AI that they can use the API and that the that open AI is not going to use the data to train their models in the future.
So that is, whether or not we trust, that's another issue, right? But they're at least saying, we're not going to use the student data or the teacher data that you're putting in here to train our models in the future. We're going to use other data. That, to me, is really important, that we can keep the data private, we can keep it away from everything, and we know that it's not going to be used to train in the future because our data should be private, and we should have control over where that goes and what it does.
And so far as we can trust them, right? Right, exactly. That's not, we've taken that leap of faith before and been burned by it quite a bit. And so that trust becomes a big issue, but I also, I wonder to what extent those things will be circumvented, right, along the way, because the AI needs the data, can't do anything without the data. And so how can we get around, whatever the case may be, you know, some of those guardrails that are in place to kind of push those out of bounds a little bit more.
So I think privacy is obviously an important issue, right? And until we have, right, again, I'll go back to this, why now, why this much, with basic privacy, you know, compliance and procedures, without those in place, I don't know why any system, and we know they will, they'll trust, right? Without those basic data and privacy concerns in place, I think there's major issues there. And that's just one thing, right?
I think, Jethar, I'll still get back to, because you mentioned companies will come out, right, and they will identify a problem, or even the best companies will say, you tell us what your problems are, and we'll configure solutions for you. Maybe we should have some discussion on what the problems are in today's classroom, right? And there's a ton of them, there's no shortage of problems, right? And I'm interested in finding out which of those AI can potentially mitigate and help solve.
And if there are some, then let's employ it. That's not what I see, right? I mentioned one problem, mental illness of our students is a huge problem, right? And so what other problems do you see that AI may be able to kind of help us with? Yeah, let's take mental health for an example. One of the tools that exists out there is an AI-driven therapist, which, the idea that I can have access to a quote-unquote therapist whenever I need it, that sounds like a great idea, and definitely something that is beneficial.
However, we don't know what that therapist is going to recommend, whether or not it's going to be good information for that student, and I think it's just too early for us to be experimenting with that with young kids. So for me, that would be a pretty hard no right away, because that's not how we solve that problem right now. So go ahead. Kids have access to that right now with Snapchat.
If they've got GPT embedded into Snapchat, kids are using it right now, right? And so I think we always have this tremendous, you know, one of the things I'm working on some presentations myself, and, you know, I kind of have this faith in technology spectrum, right? On the one side, you have tech utopians and idealists, and on the other side, the other extreme would be the tech dystopians and the alarmists, right?
And I think we always have a gap between what our ideals are and the people who are the utopians trying to sell their ideals as the reality. But as you mentioned, we don't even know the advice that it would give. But then there's really, really good evidence to support that even if it did a great job of therapy, it might further isolate people, because the level of comfort that an individual develops with an AI that is personalized and configured to their needs, to be their assistant, right?
To be their guide, I think there's good evidence to support that that's going to replace other types of physical human advice that they can get and the bonds that they need, right, to not be isolated. So I don't see a way out of the mental health thing, and in fact, there's no evidence, right, that AI will not impact mental health in a negative way in a classroom, right?
And if you Google AI and mental health, exactly what you said will come up, a lot of therapy, and it can be used for this. And I've had conversations with GPT, where I've said, I'm really sick and lonely. Can you help me out? And I love always the disclaimer in there, maybe you need to seek professional help, but here's what you should do. You know, the next comment, maybe you should seek professional help, but let me offer these suggestions.
Yeah, maybe you should seek professional help, but that's also hard, and there are other challenges in place. So the other part of that is, if we can have AI take the load of other things so that there is more time and space for mental health support for students in the classroom, then maybe that is a way that AI can help with the mental health. So those are just two options.
One, mental health therapist. Two, offload so that more adult connection and support can exist. And I think we could go on for a long time about all these different things that we could do. So the question then becomes, this is where, going back to my education philosophy is, to me, so important is, what is it that our community and our kids need right now, and what do they need in the future, as best we can tell?
Because none of us can predict the future. But what are they going to continue to need? What's that? We can? I think we, yeah, I think we can, right? I think that's what AI is designed to do. It's a prediction, right? And so there are definitely people who can predict the future. Predict the future is just a matter of time and information, right? If I know you and I are talking, and I get a text message that says an asteroid is about to hit Spokane, Washington, and you haven't gotten that message.
I can predict your future, right? It's a matter of time. I know before you, and I have the information. And so I do the, yeah, so we can't, you know, I'm not trying to play Nostradamus, but at the same time, when we say we can't predict the future, we've got a lot of evidence with or without AI that says this could have a negative impact or this could have a positive impact, right?
That's all about prediction, right? And I think a lot of people say we have to put our kids on it because it's inevitable, right? They don't use this in the future. They're not going to have jobs. I want to know what jobs they will have in the future, right? I think there's a lot of people who will kind of operate under the paradigm. Technology always comes along and displaces people, and then those people go and get better jobs.
I think we know, we can predict this is not going to be that, right? You can augment someone's intelligence and productivity to the tune of one person can now do the work of 50 or 100 or 1,000 people, right? Those 1,000 people don't go get better jobs, right? And then I think that ties back into this kind of what is the problem? Is this the solution? And then if we tie it back into mental illness, you know, you have aspiring writers, right?
Who are in classrooms who are going to get a crack at GPT and some of this stuff. And, man, I don't think that's going to go very well for a lot of them. Yeah. I mean, here's the thing. I feel like I can tell when something is written by chat GPT. And I can feel that pretty well. I don't know that I'm perfect at it. And I don't know that I would take a book, for example, that was wholly written in it and think this is definitely written by AI.
Or I don't know that it would even matter all that much. However, as a writer myself, I know how hard it is to write well and how challenging and difficult it is to really get my real ideas across in a way that I'm satisfied that people are going to understand them in the way that I intend them. And this is a really challenging aspect. I have heard comments of college students who have basically given up getting a job in their desired field because AI is already going to displace them.
And I don't know how real that is. This is all like secondhand information. I haven't heard it myself personally. But I have heard these ideas going around college campuses. And that is just a sad state of affairs to be in, but also very realistic that if you're not exceptional at what you do, it could be very easy for an AI to take over that job and for you to be incredibly replaceable.
And I certainly learned this being in education that you are just a cog in a machine as an employee in a school district because there may be a teacher shortage, but boy, they are looking everywhere they can for anybody who can do that work. And if you leave, you're going to be. And you're certainly going to be forgotten very quickly. And that has happened to me numerous times as I've left jobs and they found someone else.
And I was just the cog in a machine and there was no like, there was no morning period. There was no, oh, bummer that guy left. It was, okay, who's next up and let's put them in. And when a machine can start doing that, then I think that it's, I don't know, it's, it's pretty close to game over at that point, because why would you hire a human to do a job that a machine can do so much better?
And I've been advocating this, that thought for many years, if a machine can do it better, then just have the machine do it because they're not going to get tired. They're not going to make mistakes. They're going to do it right every single time. And if that's what education is, is just that like, then we don't really need adults, but I think that we do. I think we need teachers to do the other stuff that is education that is so much more than just two plus two equals four.
Here's the truth. School leadership is demanding. It's rewarding, but it can also feel lonely and so overwhelming sometimes. That's why we created Linked Leaders, to make sure great leaders keep leading and good leaders get the support to become great. At Linked Leaders, you're never on your own. Whether you're building culture, navigating board relations, or tackling special education challenges, you'll find solutions from leaders who've been in your shoes.
And the best part, you don't have to wait months for a big conference or spend thousands of dollars hoping to make the right connection. With Linked Leaders, you can log in today, get straight answers from experienced mentors, and walk away with a playbook that works right when you need it. Linked Leaders is efficient, personalized support that keeps you moving forward. Sign up for free at linkedleaders.com. I think that it would be difficult to replace me in a classroom right now, but these are the dumbest AIs we will ever work with.
Yeah, that's true. And where it will be two years, four years, ten years from now. Again, I think we can make some predictions. And the thing that I think would derail the exponential growth and intelligence would be the physical space itself, right? And one of the conversations, we keep telling kids that AI is the future, right? And it's inevitable, and they have to learn how to use it.
What we never tell the kids is, for example, what AI's carbon footprint is. And it's astronomical, right? To train a model is thousands, just to train one model is thousands of homes worth of energy that they use in a year, right? And so as we have more AI platforms going on, now, I don't think that's necessarily an unsolvable problem, but I don't think that they're interested in looking at that until they get the AI models to where they want to be.
And then they'll look at the disastrous climate effects, right? And so I, sorry, I don't know how we got to that. That's okay. Well, it's very real that we don't look at the unintended consequences of the things that we're doing. And so that is a shout to everybody that I think we need to be paying attention to. We need to look at what are the unintended consequences of adopting and implementing these tools in our schools.
And we should be asking that question from the very beginning. Like what, what could go wrong here, not in an alarmist or like acting out of fear way, but from a, a realistic, what could be the negatives with doing this? And is this going to make us feel more isolated to just ban it all together, which I know is something that you, you and I talked about briefly as well.
To ban it all together doesn't really make any sense either because kids are going to access it on their own. Teachers are going to access it on their own from their own devices at home, whatever. And so banning it completely doesn't make any sense either. What are your thoughts on that? I'm not in favor of banning, right? And in fact, when I first started using with my students last year, I told them, and I would probably go back and, and I teach government, I teach social studies, and I've been teaching about the impacts of technology on society and humans and individuals.
I've been working in that space for, for a couple of decades now, right? And, and really focused my classroom on it. But I told my kids last year, you have to be able to use this. You have to know what its capabilities are. And I told them flat out, this is the greatest learning tool ever constructed by humans. I don't find any evidence to, to discount that this is the greatest learning tool ever created by humans.
It's also the greatest cheating tool. And it's also the greatest find a roundabout way tool, right? I don't believe that we should ban it. The word that I use was a moratorium. I really do believe that we should have a three or four month moratorium on AI usage, on purchase of AI platforms, from school systems, things like that. I would support a four month moratorium. And that's not a ban.
What that allows us to do is to learn, right? And I don't think AI is a tool, but even if it is a tool, we know that it's powerful. We know that it may not be aligned to what we want, even individually, right? In the classroom, it's a powerful tool. And I think you got to read the instructions first. I think we need to unleash learning about AI for the next three or four months in class before we unleash usage of AI.
And again, this isn't the first time AI has been in our classrooms, right? AI has had a really detrimental impact on our students already with respect to social media and, you know, those things. But before we kind of say, you know what, let's come in and bring this in and start using it. I think we need to learn about it first. And that should be a curriculum that says, how will this affect human relationships?
How will this affect the privacy? How will this affect our data, right? And in the absence of that, I see people wanting to get this plane off the ground with very little instructions on how to fly it or how to land it or how to change course when something goes wrong. There's this monumental push, let's get this off the ground. And I think that's mostly, as I said, you know, a result of money, fear, and power.
Okay, so you talked about some things that we should learn. So I have a slightly different take on that that I'd be curious on your input on. But what are the things that we should be learning? You said how will this affect human relationships, privacy data, et cetera. What are the other et cetera's that we should be talking about? And we don't have to have answers for them or anything like that.
But just what are the things we should be paying attention to and thinking about before we adopt something? So in a classroom, I think one of the big things, I've been trying to work out this over the last couple weeks, because it's always been blatant in the background, but the concept of hard work, right? And the promise of offloading hard work. And I don't think it's put in those terms.
Sometimes it is. It's quite stark. They said, why would you continue to beat your head against the wall and do that? That's really hard. We've got an AI that will now free up the time, right? And the AI can do that work for you. And I just, I wonder what the effects are of that in an academic setting. I think you and I both would agree it's really, really hard to be educated.
It's really, really hard to be intelligent. You have to put the time in. And I don't know what becomes of education and teaching and learning when we say we're going to dramatically reduce the amount of time. We're going to collapse the time. We're going to make it much easier for you. And then you can get involved in these other endeavors. I think the value of hard work and, you know, Jethro, for you and I to communicate with each other.
It's hard to communicate. It's hard to solve problems. And I see AI kind of coming along saying, you know what? You don't need to put that effort in because this is smarter and this will take care of that. To solve, we mentioned carbon footprint. To solve climate change, it's going to be really, really, really hard. And I don't see AI being capable of doing that. To teach a student the ability to read and communicate with others.
And I'm skeptical of whether an AI can actually do that. I know there's technical skills that come along, but in the broader philosophical experiential existence, I don't know what happens when everybody doesn't work hard, right? Or there's no value. There's no ethic to hard work. And that's fundamentally detrimental to classrooms. That is an existential threat to classrooms. And we say, you don't need to work. Yeah. Oh, man, this is so good.
So I've lost 50 pounds in the last six months. And this is how you lose weight. You eat good, healthy foods and you exercise. And you always make sure that you eat less than you need to maintain your weight. Like, that's it. That's really simple. But let me tell you, it has been so hard losing that weight. Because it has been a mental battle every single day about whether or not I should do certain things.
And so that is one example of the power of hard work and why it's valuable. And so I think that that point of what are we trying to take the hard work out of and why are we trying to get rid of the hard work? And there's a difference between hard work that's meaningful and hard work that's hard just because it's hard and does not add value.
And, for example, when the new math came out and parents had to do this really difficult work of working with their kids and they knew the answer, but the kids weren't allowed to do it in that same way as what parents keep telling me. That was hard, meaningless work because the goal was still the answer for what kids needed to turn in. They still needed to get the right answer, but they just had an additional, more difficult step of doing it in a certain way that made a lot of parents frustrated because there was no point to it.
Now, as I've talked to parents and coached them through that and said, here's why we're doing it this way and here's why it is actually valuable because we want kids to understand mathematical concepts and have number sense and be able to know how to solve a problem, regardless of whether or not they've memorized the formula, this is why we're doing it. Then parents will say, okay, now I get it.
Now I can understand it. I'll work through the hard work to make this happen. And so there are hard things that we do need to do and then there are pointless hard things that don't give us a benefit. And so balancing which of those we should take away, taking away the meaningful hard work is like, I think we agree on this, is a bad idea. The meaningful hard work makes us better human beings.
Taking away the pointless hard work. For example, a teacher grading student work is pointless hard work if they are just giving a score and saying you got 10 out of 15 correct. If they are giving feedback and learning about those students and the errors that they make so they know how to teach them better, that's meaningful hard work that's worthwhile. Does that make sense or am I getting off base?
No, I think it makes sense. I think, I don't think that you and I, right, even just the two of us could come together and decide what is hard work for purpose and what is hard work just for the process of hard work, right? So we probably would have some disagreements with that. And then when you throw the corporations into it, right, they don't make any distinction between that at all, right?
So when they come to schools and they're selling their platforms, they don't make a distinction between what is meaningful hard work and what is non-meaningful hard work. I think their idea is we're just going to replace the hard work and the hard work of teaching. You're a writer. It's really, really hard, right? We stopped teaching handwriting. Handwriting was, we decided, handwriting is really, really hard. Why do we need to use this?
We're on computers, right? And so people, I think people always try to make the calculator analogy too, right? Just because we have calculators doesn't mean our kids are going to not know how to add and subtract and divide. Well, guess what? They don't know how to add, subtract, and divide. And anybody who wants to show, just because we've got a graphing calculator doesn't mean the kids can't solve algebraic formulas.
Oh, I can give you thousands of kids that I've taught who now can't solve algebraic formulas, right? And now is that meaningful hard work? I guess not if they're not going to be a scientist or a mathematician, right? And so I think defining what that hard work is and looking at the evidence, what we've continually defined as or mundane work that stresses people out that we can kind of offload, I'm very skeptical of that.
I don't know what they would come and sell if they weren't selling a replacement for hard work, right? I think it really explodes most of our educational system. The purpose is to help somebody find gainful employment, right? Well, if we remove that, now what are we working hard for, right? And I'm not saying that we can't find a replacement answer, an alternative. What I am saying is we should speculate and design and develop those before we start jumping in and saying, hey, let's see what we can do with these.
Yeah. So, so fascinating. So were you saying that the purpose of our education system is to help someone find gainful employment? Yeah, I think, I think that's, I think so. I mean, there are other purposes, but I mean, parents don't, parents don't spend that tax money to have their kids learning philosophy, which is unfortunate because I teach philosophy, right? But the, I think, yeah, the college and career ready, right?
I mean, this is, this is what we want kids to be upon graduation. Yeah. And yeah, this is an area where I, I, I'm not totally decided on it yet, but I feel, I feel consternation inside me when we say that that is the purpose of education, because I don't really believe in my heart of hearts that that's what the purpose is. But I know that that's what we have to do.
So is the purpose of the system, the institution of education to help kids get gainful employment? Yes, that's how we make our society run. Is that my goal for education? I'd say definitely not, but that's, but my goal doesn't mean that that's your goal, but we need those values and those beliefs to help guide our decisions. Because if the purpose is to help people get gainful employment, but then AI makes it so that nobody has gainful employment, then that opens up a whole nother can of worms.
So we don't have time to go into all that, but I do want to share, you mentioned a moratorium. I said that I had a slightly different idea. I wouldn't say that there needs to be a moratorium, but I would say that there needs to be a, I don't know the best way to say this, but a delayed time period before you officially dot a new piece of AI in your school.
So you said a four month moratorium, let's go with four months. Let's say that from the time you decide that you want to do an AI piece in your school and the time that you actually purchase and send money or actually adopt and implement in your classroom, that there is a four month time period where there is investigation, there's training, there's all these things that go into place before, before you actually adopt it to ensure that it's going to meet the needs and specifications that we have.
And so assuming that it can as well, right? Exactly. I just don't see any way out of increased use of AI. I don't see any way out than, than further isolation of our students. I don't. And if there is, you got four months to figure it out. Right. And, and so go ahead. I'm sorry to cut you off. No, that's okay. I, I think that having, having a process that you go through during those four months or a system of evaluation to say whether or not this is good.
I, I spoke in another podcast about the A plus framework about adopting AI. And so that's something that you could use as a, as a basis for asking those questions. I don't think that's perfect, but I think that's a good step in the right direction. I think that's a good step in the right direction.
I think that's a good step in the right direction. Whether or not we're okay with those failures and being able to take a, a clear headed approach to this. That is not based on hype. That's not based on fear, but is based on us making the best decision that we can for the people in front of us.
I mean, things already move super slowly in education and what's crazy is how fast things are going with this, especially with schools adopting it. And so that I'm sure people would not appreciate that, especially the tech companies, but, but I think that having some sort of way to say, let's take a breath and pause and evaluate first, and then we can, we can go in from there.
And that's, that's kind of where I've been in trying to speak to other educators and systems, things like that is we need to learn before we use very basically, right? This is a powerful, powerful, I know everybody wants to say it's a tool. It's not a tool. AI is not a tool. AI is an ecosystem, right? AI is, you're adopting a new paradigm. You're not just, you're not going to add to what you do.
AI is fundamentally going to alter what we do in the classroom, right? And so to not have a comprehensive view of what that looks like emotionally, psychologically, socially, politically, economic is, I think that's malpractice, right? And the reason, I don't know, why wouldn't someone support the idea that we should learn as much as we can before we, before we take the reins of this, again, it's four things, money, power, fear, and hubris, right?
And you don't open up a table saw, having never used a table saw before, and just start screwing around with it. You read the directions, and that's what needs to happen here, and it needs to happen in a lot of different ways, right? I mean, Jethro, if you've been in public education for a while, you know that our students get zero, zero training in ethics. They can't tell you what utilitarianism is.
They can't tell you what hedonism is. There's zero ethical training, right? And this is because parents say, keep your ethics off my kids. We'll teach our kids in the space of that. There's virtually zero capacity for kids to think with an ethical framework. And this is something that has real, real, as we all know, ethical implications, right? And so I think you need to teach ethics in that four months.
I think you need to teach misinformation, right? These information overload has already taken a hell of a toll on our kids, on society, on everybody, right? When you're looking at the span at which the amount of information on the internet is going to grow in the next two years, and how much of that will be outright fake or outright produced with the combination of human and AI, right?
I mean, we're thinking of these things to scale, and this is the calm before the content storm. It's going to have an impact on our elections. We need to sit down with kids and say, hey, you have to suspend belief because what you see is no longer verification that something is true, right? And that takes some time to figure that out, and I don't think you figure that out while you're succumbing to it.
Yeah, I totally agree, and I think there's so much value in us recognizing, and I'm so glad you said that AI is not a tool. It's an ecosystem because every tool is really an ecosystem, and if you adopt any tool in your school, you adopt the mindset and framework that the creator of that envisioned for you. And so Jason Fried wrote a great post about this that I will put in the chat here for you so you can read that later.
But basically, the gist is any tool that you have is a – it defines how you work and how you do things. And if you adopt a tool that does not align with your beliefs, then the tool is going to run things instead of you. That is a reality. And I think about, broadly speaking, the student information systems that we had in all my schools where the emphasis was on the completion of things and whether or not it was right and all those things.
It wasn't about character development, about who these kids were becoming, they were, again, just numbers in a system, even assigned ID numbers specifically, and weren't seen as real individuals. We're seen as, you know, in parts of a whole rather than as who they really were as an individual. And I think that stuff is just going to continue even more with AI for sure. Yeah, I think I agree with a lot of what you said there, right?
And I think the metaphor of the tool really kind of – it gets us, right? Because it's certainly what it's sold. If you listen to the podcast or anything, it's these are tools. And I'd have to think more on if a tool always adopts a paradigm, right? And this one, I think AI, because of what it is, is certainly a paradigm ecological shift. I don't know if I would necessarily say the same about a drill.
I can see where it would be, right? But generally, when we think of tools, those are things that have a specific design for a specific function. And if it's a Swiss Army knife, great. It's got a bunch of different functions, right? So that's a tool, I think. But I think what we really, you know, misconstrue a little bit is that if we look at something as a tool and it doesn't work, it's the user's error.
And that doesn't apply to this case, right? If we bring in AI to classrooms and it has devastating impacts, it is not the user's error, right? And so that design, this all-encompassing design, this whole ecosystem that's built into the ecosystem, not into the usage of it, right? And so I think that I would make that just one little distinction there. Yeah. Man, Kevin, this is good. I'm sad that we need to end this conversation, but this has been awesome.
I so appreciate your thoughts on this and pushing my thinking as well. We definitely need to do this again. So thank you. All four. Let's do it. Thank you. Edited by Gage Sanderson. Do you want to simplify your school's technology, save teachers' time, improve students' performance on state assessments? You can do it all, but don't waste another minute. Head straight to IXL.com slash BE to learn how IXL's research-proven teaching and learning platform can help you achieve all these goals.
That's IXL.com slash BE. When I was a principal at a Title I elementary school, we had Playworks, and it dramatically changed how our school functioned. Kids show up to school when they want to be there, and that's the whole idea behind Playworks. What they do is they train staff to build belonging and connection right into recess so the kids feel connected and want to come back. They have tons of games that they teach the kids that are fun, enjoyable, and games where either everybody wins or the loss gets you back in the game very quickly.
One principal put it, when the teacher hops in the game and everyone's playing together, that builds camaraderie between students and adults. And the research backs it up. There was a UC Berkeley study that found that Title I schools partnering with Playworks had significantly lower chronic absenteeism. If you're thinking about attendance this year, and we all are, visit playworks.org slash podcast to get the 30-day attendance reset and additional helpful resources that you can implement today.
Don't wait on this.