WEBVTT

00:00.000 --> 00:11.600
Hey everyone, it's Mikki here, you're listening to Mini-Mikkipedia on a Monday, and do you do what I do and like stack all your powders together?

00:12.400 --> 00:23.800
I'm in the habit of putting my greens with my aminos and my creatine, collagen if I've got it on hand, which I mostly do, and just downing it all at once alongside my coffee.

00:23.800 --> 00:36.420
You might be someone who, in fact, puts your collagen, puts your creatine in your coffee, and thinks that's the best approach to save you time, be a bit more efficient in the morning, and save one extra glass.

00:36.500 --> 00:53.780
And then, of course, someone in your training group or a reel on your phone tells you that, in fact, you've just wasted your creatine, that hot liquid destroys it, coffee will cancel it out, and while you're at it, your creatine monohydrate is actually, it's the wrong kind because it isn't.

00:53.800 --> 00:55.280
It isn't water-washed or buffered.

00:55.700 --> 01:21.020
So, I wanted to just address a few of these claims today, just to see where the evidence lies, because, of course, I get a bit curious about this too, because you do see a lot of this noise on social media, and whilst I've never really heard the likes of Darren Kandell, Scott Forbes, Jose Antonio, who are people who publish in the area of creatine research talk about it, I see it a lot from other people.

01:21.580 --> 01:23.780
So, let's look at what actually happens.

01:23.800 --> 01:38.040
When you put it in something warm, whether caffeine blunts what creatine does, what actually differs between tubs of creatine monohydrate, and where the whole acid wash versus base wash thing comes from.

01:38.440 --> 01:45.620
So, I just think that these are good things to explore, just so we sort of know what the evidence says.

01:45.760 --> 01:53.700
So, firstly, when people say creatine breaks down, what they mean is that creatine can fold in on itself.

01:53.800 --> 02:02.440
It can lose a molecule of water and become creatinine, which is, in fact, what your sort of blood results measure when you're looking at kidney function.

02:02.600 --> 02:02.840
Interesting.

02:03.520 --> 02:09.440
So, creatinine is the waste product your kidneys clear every day, and it doesn't really do anything useful for your muscles.

02:10.020 --> 02:15.380
So, the question isn't really, you know, is creatine fragile in a vague way.

02:15.380 --> 02:21.260
The question is how fast that one reaction happens under the conditions you actually use it in.

02:21.580 --> 02:23.580
Because if it happens too quickly, you may not...

02:23.800 --> 02:27.840
You may not get the benefits of creatine because it's broken down too quickly.

02:28.800 --> 02:32.880
So, if we're thinking about just the tub of creatine, the answer is basically never.

02:33.520 --> 02:43.320
Creatine monohydrate powder held at 40 degrees for more than three years showed no measurable conversion, even when stored at 60 degrees Fahrenheit.

02:43.740 --> 02:50.780
Creatinine only turns up in trace amounts after about 44 months, which is close to four years, right?

02:51.080 --> 02:53.320
So, in the tub, the answer is...

02:53.320 --> 02:54.680
Well, it basically never does.

02:54.880 --> 03:03.880
So, creatine monohydrate powder held at 40 degrees Celsius for more than three years showed no measurable conversion from creatine to creatinine.

03:04.220 --> 03:10.040
Even when stored at 60 degrees, creatinine only turned up in trace amounts after about 44 months.

03:10.040 --> 03:20.820
So, your gym bag in a hot car is no problem at all to creatine monohydrate if that's how you store it and how you transport it from gym to work to home, etc.

03:21.600 --> 03:23.200
However, once creatine is dissolved...

03:23.320 --> 03:24.880
It is a different story.

03:25.500 --> 03:30.260
And three things determine the speed with which that creatine converts.

03:30.500 --> 03:34.600
The acidity of the liquid, the temperature, and time.

03:35.020 --> 03:48.880
So, data from a lab that was reproduced in a 2022 review by Creda and colleagues shows that at room temperature, creatine at a neutral pH, so roughly water or milk, is relatively stable for three days.

03:48.880 --> 03:53.140
As the liquid gets more acidic, those losses do climb.

03:53.520 --> 04:11.120
So, after three days at 25 degrees Celsius, you see about 4% loss at a pH of 5.5, 12% loss or conversion at a pH of 4.5, so we're getting a bit more acidic, and 21% conversion at a pH of 3.5.

04:11.220 --> 04:15.080
Now, the thing is, though, is that that pattern doesn't keep going as things get more acidic.

04:15.340 --> 04:20.080
Below a pH of about 2.5, the conversion essentially stops because the part of the molecule that has to swing around in class...

04:20.080 --> 04:23.300
Below a pH of about 2.5, the conversion essentially stops because the part of the molecule that has to swing around in class...

04:23.320 --> 04:24.060
...closes that ring.

04:24.400 --> 04:28.540
It does something, it gets protonated, and it locks in place.

04:28.860 --> 04:35.840
And your stomach pH sits below that, which is why at least 1% of creatine monohydrate is degraded during digestion.

04:36.240 --> 04:42.320
And around 99% of what you swallow is either taken up by the tissue or shows up in your urine as creatine.

04:43.200 --> 04:44.780
So, do remember that.

04:45.280 --> 04:46.220
So, what about coffee?

04:46.220 --> 04:49.840
Coffee sits at a pH of around 5, and it starts hot.

04:50.220 --> 04:53.220
So, in principle, it's a faster environment for that reaction.

04:53.320 --> 05:04.440
The truth, though, is that nobody has ever published a study timing creatine breakdown in a normal mug of coffee, minute by minute, and measuring what's left.

05:04.900 --> 05:08.980
What we can do is take the published kinetic data and run the numbers.

05:08.980 --> 05:14.980
So, if you extrapolate the room temperature rates using the temperature relationships reported in stability studies...

05:15.660 --> 05:21.700
...a coffee held at around 70 degrees Celsius for 20 minutes lands at a loss in the low single digits.

05:21.960 --> 05:22.980
Somewhere around 1 to 5%.

05:23.640 --> 05:25.100
Depending on those assumptions.

05:25.360 --> 05:27.320
And, of course, your coffee doesn't stay at 70 degrees.

05:27.420 --> 05:29.520
It cools from the moment you pour it.

05:29.520 --> 05:34.660
On a 5 gram scoop, we're essentially arguing about a fraction of a gram.

05:35.320 --> 05:41.760
So, and remember, creatine's job is to keep your muscles saturated and topped up over weeks.

05:41.920 --> 05:47.300
Not to deliver a precise dose by the milligram on every single day.

05:47.460 --> 05:49.920
So, I just don't think that it matters that much.

05:50.260 --> 05:52.480
And, of course, however, it does.

05:52.600 --> 05:52.860
It is worth noting...

05:52.860 --> 05:58.540
It is worth knowing that the warm liquid was part of how the creatine was given in some of the earliest research.

05:58.880 --> 06:05.840
In the original work showing that oral creatine raised muscle creatine stores, it was dissolved in warm to hot water.

06:06.160 --> 06:08.280
And other earlier studies used hot tea.

06:08.600 --> 06:19.180
Partly this was practical because creatine dissolves far better as the temperature rises, about 14 grams per litre at 20 degrees, compared with 45 grams per litre at 60 degrees.

06:19.800 --> 06:22.840
So, I mean, it doesn't really matter if it dissolves for you.

06:23.000 --> 06:26.300
Your muscle's taking it up because if you swallow that grit, you're still getting it.

06:26.300 --> 06:33.640
But the warm does fix some of that dissolving problem or its ability to dissolve.

06:34.040 --> 06:42.340
There is actually a new laboratory paper from 25 where researchers put commercial creatine through heat from 60 to 200 degrees.

06:42.740 --> 06:48.360
UV light, different pH levels in drinks, including coffee, orange juice, and an energy drink.

06:48.600 --> 06:51.200
And temperature came out as the biggest driver of change.

06:51.200 --> 06:52.760
They identified a range.

06:52.840 --> 06:55.480
Of degradation products beyond creatinine.

06:56.020 --> 06:57.300
So it's sort of useful.

06:57.640 --> 07:00.940
And it is a reason not to bake creatine into things or boil it.

07:01.260 --> 07:04.340
And someone actually asked this on a post I did on social media.

07:04.740 --> 07:06.560
They said, oh, I bake it into my breakfast bake.

07:06.600 --> 07:08.440
And I'm like, you may not want to do that.

07:08.880 --> 07:12.260
But it was a stress test designed to characterize what forms.

07:12.460 --> 07:17.620
It wasn't a measurement of how much you lose stirring a scoop into a flat white and just drinking it.

07:18.380 --> 07:21.100
So practically, stir it in and drink it.

07:21.500 --> 07:22.620
Where you'd actually lose creatine.

07:22.840 --> 07:32.220
And what you lose a meaningful amount is actually time, a big batch of creatine lemonade made on a Sunday or to sip throughout the week or a coffee you forget about and reheat at lunchtime.

07:32.600 --> 07:33.720
That's the problem, right?

07:34.000 --> 07:36.880
So make it and have it overnight is fine as well.

07:36.900 --> 07:45.840
If you're making your preparation on a Sunday before having it at a gym, having it on the Monday morning before having breakfast, I don't think that's a problem.

07:46.280 --> 07:49.680
Now, caffeine doesn't actually cancel out creatine.

07:49.720 --> 07:51.700
There is a 1996 study.

07:51.700 --> 07:58.080
And it took nine men who had a very high creatine dose, half a gram per kilogram of body weight per day.

07:58.080 --> 08:01.500
So about 35 to 40 grams daily for six days.

08:01.500 --> 08:07.100
In one condition, they added caffeine at about five milligrams per kilogram per day.

08:07.660 --> 08:14.580
Creatine alone improved performance by about 10 to 23 percent when they looked at these maximal knee extensions.

08:15.060 --> 08:17.620
But with caffeine on board, that improvement disappeared.

08:18.560 --> 08:20.500
However, muscle phosphocreatine.

08:21.700 --> 08:25.360
Ended up around the same amount in both conditions, four to six percent.

08:25.540 --> 08:28.480
Caffeine didn't stop creatine getting into the muscle.

08:28.840 --> 08:31.900
So whatever happened, happened downstream of that.

08:32.160 --> 08:33.880
And there are two explanations.

08:34.180 --> 08:40.160
Follow up from the same research group found creatine shortens muscle relaxation time or caffeine lengthens it.

08:40.460 --> 08:43.380
So when both were taken, caffeine's effect won out.

08:43.900 --> 08:48.580
But of course, the second explanation may also hold, and that's a gut upset, right?

08:48.800 --> 08:51.400
So in a conference abstract by a group.

08:51.700 --> 08:59.680
By another lab, several people loading big doses of creatine reported GI distress that eased with placebo, but not with caffeine.

08:59.680 --> 09:05.060
And the authors also raised the point in the original study, caffeine was withdrawn before testing.

09:05.600 --> 09:10.080
So withdrawal from caffeine rather than the caffeine itself may have played a part.

09:10.320 --> 09:12.680
Now, that isn't a full peer reviewed paper.

09:12.840 --> 09:16.120
So it was just an abstract, but I just think it's worth noting that.

09:16.880 --> 09:21.140
And then another study in a trial of 54 active men.

09:21.700 --> 09:28.200
Creatine loading with coffee with caffeine pills or on its own produced no real differences between the groups.

09:28.200 --> 09:36.120
And a 2022 systematic review pulled together 10 studies and found that when caffeine is taken acutely before exercise,

09:36.300 --> 09:39.680
after you've already loaded creatine, there's no interference.

09:40.280 --> 09:47.640
When two are taken together daily during a loading phase, two studies showed interference, three showed none, and one showed a benefit.

09:48.040 --> 09:49.740
So with regards to your coffee,

09:49.740 --> 09:51.520
I think the.

09:51.700 --> 10:01.140
The protocol that showed the problem was the heavy loading doses plus a substantial daily caffeine dose tested on a very specific lab protocol of knee extensions.

10:01.400 --> 10:05.760
So there is that potential for the GI distress.

10:05.760 --> 10:08.560
And I think that's what the researchers sort of put that down to.

10:08.620 --> 10:10.900
So if you're GI sensitive, just do that.

10:10.900 --> 10:11.260
Right.

10:11.380 --> 10:16.000
Other thing is, of course, the, the way the creatine monohydrate is prepared.

10:16.480 --> 10:20.880
So creatine monohydrate is made industrially by reacting sodium,

10:20.880 --> 10:27.260
psychosinate with cyanide and water at around a pH of 10 and at 80 degrees,

10:27.260 --> 10:30.560
then crystallizing it, filtering it and drying it.

10:30.560 --> 10:34.120
When that process is well controlled, you get something extremely pure,

10:34.440 --> 10:39.860
which is probably most of what you're seeing in very well-regulated markets for supplements.

10:40.280 --> 10:49.660
When it isn't, you can end up with leftovers and byproducts, creatinine, diacydiamide, dihydrotreazine, theuria.

10:49.660 --> 10:52.180
And in some cases, heavy metals.

10:52.440 --> 10:56.780
When Italian researchers tested 33 creatine supplements off the market,

10:56.780 --> 11:00.900
44% had more than 100 milligrams per kilogram of creatinine.

11:01.000 --> 11:07.900
About 15% had detectable dihydrotreazine and diacydiamide.

11:08.800 --> 11:10.900
Listen to me fumbling over those.

11:10.960 --> 11:11.660
What a surprise.

11:12.040 --> 11:16.880
And these were above 50 milligrams per kilogram and mercury was present at trace levels.

11:17.080 --> 11:19.360
None of that means that those products were dangerous.

11:19.360 --> 11:19.640
Just so you know.

11:19.660 --> 11:25.840
But it does mean 100% creatine monohydrate, it doesn't hold true, actually.

11:26.420 --> 11:33.600
The German-made Cre-Pure is the one most of the clinical research has used, reported at 99.9% purity.

11:34.060 --> 11:38.760
You don't have to buy that specific brand, but you do want to know that a product is third-party tested

11:38.760 --> 11:43.320
and ideally one that will show you its certificate of analysis, if you ask.

11:43.480 --> 11:48.460
Two other labels you'll see, micronized, just means the particles are smaller, so it makes us better.

11:48.640 --> 11:49.460
There's no evidence.

11:49.660 --> 11:51.240
There's no evidence it's more bioavailable, though.

11:52.080 --> 12:01.740
And anhydrous creatine had the water molecule driven off with heat, so it's 100% creatine by weight rather than about 88%.

12:01.740 --> 12:06.160
Trade-off is that the drying step tends to produce more creatinine as an impurity.

12:06.860 --> 12:10.480
So plain monohydrate is a sensible option.

12:11.160 --> 12:16.200
Now, it's interesting when people talk about acid versus base, and I do just want to sort of mention this.

12:16.200 --> 12:19.520
So the claim is used in a couple of ways.

12:19.740 --> 12:21.440
The first one is about manufacturing.

12:21.860 --> 12:27.360
So the suggestion that cheap creatine is acid-washed leaves you bloated, and that the good stuff is water-washed.

12:27.800 --> 12:33.700
So what the manufacturing literature shows is that acids are used during the synthesis to adjust the pH,

12:34.080 --> 12:40.260
and the crude creatine is then purified by washing with cold or hot water and recrystallizing it.

12:40.580 --> 12:48.640
I couldn't find any peer-reviewed evidence that acid-washing creatine exists as a distinct product category, or that it causes bloating.

12:48.960 --> 12:49.120
If you know of any, please let me know in the comments.

12:49.120 --> 12:55.480
If you know of studies, please let me know, because I'd really like to understand this better, but I couldn't find anything myself.

12:56.000 --> 13:00.600
What actually differs between good and bad product is that impurity profile I was mentioning.

13:00.840 --> 13:03.200
That's something you can test for and see on paper.

13:03.680 --> 13:14.020
And on bloating, an analysis pooling the side effects from 685 creatine trials found gastrointestinal complaints occurred at rates similar to placebo.

13:14.300 --> 13:15.040
So that's interesting.

13:15.200 --> 13:19.080
The second version is the base side, so it's buffered alkaline.

13:19.280 --> 13:28.180
The pitch is that your stomach acid destroys regular creatine, so you need a buffered version at a smaller dose to get it through intact.

13:28.180 --> 13:32.240
But actually, that is the exact opposite of the chemistry we covered at the start.

13:32.720 --> 13:39.660
Strong acidity is what stops creatine converting, and when it is tested properly, that claim doesn't actually hold up.

13:40.260 --> 13:48.880
Jagem and colleagues took 36 resistant-trained people and compared the buffered product at the manufacturer's dose of 1.5 grams a day,

13:49.120 --> 13:55.060
the buffered product at a standard creatine doses and ordinary monohydrate with muscle biopsies.

13:55.060 --> 14:04.480
They found that the buffered creatine didn't raise muscle creatine more, didn't improve strength or body composition more, and didn't cause fewer side effects.

14:04.960 --> 14:10.060
So if anything, muscle creatine tended to rise more with monohydrate than with the low-dose buffered version.

14:11.020 --> 14:19.060
Creatine hydrochloride, or HCL, does get marketed of a similar logic as being dramatically more soluble, so it's just needed in tiny amounts.

14:20.080 --> 14:27.340
The headline solubility figure compared the HCL form in a very acidic solution against monohydrate in an alkaline one.

14:27.920 --> 14:32.620
So these are just two different things, and better mixing doesn't mean better uptake into the muscle.

14:32.740 --> 14:45.540
It's also only about 78% creatine by weight, and in a 2025 trial in elite handball and softball players given 5 grams a day of either form for 8 weeks, outcomes were actually no difference.

14:45.860 --> 14:47.240
So, takeaway then.

14:47.540 --> 14:48.960
Creatine in the tub.

14:49.120 --> 14:55.900
Creatine hydrochloride is rock solid, and a hot drink that you're going to start and finish, losses are small, and the warmth does help it dissolve.

14:56.480 --> 15:05.760
Caffeine doesn't stop creatine getting into the muscle, and the evidence for blunting comes from a protocol that looks nothing like what your daily scoop in your cup of coffee is.

15:06.180 --> 15:17.440
So the things that are important though are buying a third-party tested monohydrate, skipping the forms that promise more for less, like the creatine hydrochloride, which tends to be more expensive,

15:17.540 --> 15:19.040
and take 3-5 grams.

15:19.120 --> 15:25.920
Don't bake your creatine, and don't make it up on a Monday and then drink it on a Thursday, right?

15:26.140 --> 15:27.860
These are the things that I want you to think about.

15:28.440 --> 15:33.200
So just have it where it best suits you, and don't worry about the noise.

15:33.420 --> 15:35.180
Alright guys, that's it for this week.

15:35.760 --> 15:38.320
Let me know any thoughts around this or questions.

15:38.560 --> 15:47.880
I'm over on Instagram, the thread is x, at Mikki Williden, Facebook at Mikki Williden Nutrition, or head to my website, mikkiwilliden.com.

15:47.880 --> 15:48.780
Alright guys.

15:48.780 --> 15:49.520
Have the best week.

15:49.740 --> 15:50.220
See you later.

15:55.560 --> 15:56.560
Bye.