WEBVTT

00:00.000 --> 00:18.620
Hey everyone, it's Mikki here, you're listening to Mini-Mikkipedia, and today I'm going to tackle one of those questions I get a lot with regards to why scale weight always tracks heavier than actual fat gain.

00:18.620 --> 00:38.240
And I get comments and questions a lot from clients checking in with me and just people on social media saying, you know, my weight has skyrocketed by two kilos this weekend, or, you know, I've gained four kilos in three weeks, amounts that are sort of seemingly impossible.

00:38.680 --> 00:48.300
And even if, you know, you have a big weekend, got Friday night dinner with friends and a couple of wines, then you've got brunch or long lunch on a Saturday, Sunday,

00:48.300 --> 01:00.860
there might be some sort of family birthday. And then Monday morning, you step on the scales and you're up two kilos. And it's really easy to think, gosh, I've undone a month of work in this instance.

01:01.220 --> 01:12.220
And of course, what you decide to do on Monday morning really depends entirely on what you think that that number means. So if you think it's two kilos of actual fat, then the logical response is panic.

01:12.220 --> 01:18.280
You'll skip breakfast, you'll cut carbs, you'll punish yourself in the gym, you'll white knuckle your way through.

01:18.300 --> 01:29.240
And that'll last two to three days before you crash and burn on Wednesday. But if you knew what that number actually was, I think that the response is a lot calmer and it's a lot more useful.

01:29.620 --> 01:38.480
And I will say that you have to let your rational brain overtake the irrational and emotional thoughts that come with that increase in scale weight.

01:38.480 --> 01:47.620
So if you've spent any time around nutrition, I'm sure you have heard that a kilo of fat is worth about 7,700 calories.

01:47.620 --> 01:54.900
Or 3,500 calories per pound. That's actually a more recognisable number.

01:55.520 --> 02:02.940
So the maths goes like this then. You eat 500 calories a day, more than you need, and in about 15 days, you've gained a kilo of fat.

02:03.440 --> 02:14.100
Eat 100 calories extra a day, a biscuit or a decent splash of milk and a couple of coffees, and it takes about 11 weeks to gain that same kilo of fat.

02:14.300 --> 02:17.560
Eat 1,000 calories a day and you're there in about eight days.

02:17.620 --> 02:26.660
It's neat. It's tidy. It's been printed in textbooks, government websites, in apps, and of course, Instagram for decades.

02:26.920 --> 02:33.520
Not Instagram for decades, but everywhere else. And also plenty of health professionals use it as well because it's sort of easy.

02:33.920 --> 02:41.280
And it's, you know, it is a bit of a rough guide, if you like. The question is, really, does that even hold up?

02:41.280 --> 02:47.060
And I'd say that the short answer is, well, sort of. And of course.

02:47.620 --> 02:52.040
The long answer is what I'm talking about today. So let's dive in.

02:52.040 --> 03:05.200
The figure traces back to a paper by Wyschnowski. He was a physician who published a short paper in 1958 in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition called Caloric Equivalence of Gained or Lost Weight.

03:05.540 --> 03:13.060
He pulled together what was known at the time and landed on that 3,500 calories for a pound of body weight gained or lost.

03:13.640 --> 03:17.040
And if you convert that to metric, you'll get that roughly 7,700 calories.

03:17.620 --> 03:24.820
And the logic is pretty reasonable. Pure fat contains around 9 to 9.4 calories per gram.

03:25.440 --> 03:38.500
But the fat on your body isn't pure fat. Adipose tissue, the actual tissue, is mostly lipid, mostly fat, but it also contains water, protein, and the structural bits of the cells themselves.

03:38.500 --> 03:47.600
So in a follow-up letter a couple of years later, Wyschnowski put the energy in adipose tissue at around 8.3 calories per gram.

03:47.620 --> 03:51.820
So a little over 8,000 calories in a kilo of fat tissue.

03:52.540 --> 03:55.580
So, I mean, that's not 7,700, obviously.

03:56.300 --> 04:02.120
And that's because 7,700 was never meant to describe a kilo of fat tissue specifically.

04:02.820 --> 04:11.500
It was his estimate for a kilo of body weight change on the assumption that most of the change would be fat tissue with a bit of extra stuff mixed in.

04:11.740 --> 04:16.780
And super interesting, in the same letter, Wyschnowski pointed out that

04:17.620 --> 04:33.020
So a gram of weight gained as glycogen or protein with its water only represents about one calorie of stored energy, compared with about eight for fat tissue.

04:33.500 --> 04:37.140
So carbohydrate and protein, they are about four calories a gram.

04:37.460 --> 04:47.600
But when they're stored with around three grams of water each, every gram of weight you gain as glycogen or lean tissue is mostly water and only carries about one calorie of stored energy.

04:48.140 --> 04:56.700
So as an estimate of how much energy is sitting in a kilo of body fat, that number, 7,700 calories, is defensible.

04:57.080 --> 05:01.820
But it isn't perfect because the composition of adipose tissue varies from person to person.

05:02.400 --> 05:07.400
The problem is not necessarily that number, but it's what we've done with that number since.

05:07.640 --> 05:15.480
We took that number about stored energy and turned it into a prediction about what happens when you eat more or less than usual.

05:16.100 --> 05:17.480
And they aren't the same thing.

05:17.620 --> 05:23.620
So, the first problem is that the extra food isn't the same as extra stored energy.

05:23.620 --> 05:28.620
When you eat 500 calories more than usual, your body doesn't just open the door and file it all away.

05:28.620 --> 05:33.620
Digesting, absorbing, processing food, all of that costs energy.

05:33.620 --> 05:36.620
So when you eat more, you burn a bit more doing it.

05:36.620 --> 05:40.620
Storing that energy also has a cost, and the cost depends on what you're storing.

05:40.620 --> 05:47.420
When researchers put people in a whole room calorometer, which is essentially a sealed room,

05:47.420 --> 05:52.420
that measures every breath you take in and out, so you can work out exactly what you're burning,

05:52.420 --> 05:58.420
and overfed them by 50% above their needs for two weeks, the type of surplus did matter.

05:58.420 --> 06:03.420
When the extra came from carbohydrate, the body ramped up how much carbohydrate it burned.

06:03.420 --> 06:10.420
Total energy expenditure crept up, and around 75-85% of that extra energy was stored.

06:10.420 --> 06:15.420
When the extra gap came from fat, fat burning barely shifted,

06:15.420 --> 06:17.420
and 90-95% of fat was stored.

06:17.420 --> 06:22.420
The gap was biggest in the early days of overfeeding.

06:22.420 --> 06:26.420
So it doesn't mean that you gain more fat with carbs.

06:26.420 --> 06:30.420
Three quarters or more of the carbohydrate surplus still got stored.

06:30.420 --> 06:33.420
It just means that the body handles different surpluses differently,

06:33.420 --> 06:37.420
and that straight line calculation assumes that it doesn't.

06:37.420 --> 06:45.420
And protein? Well, protein is the most forgiving when you eat extra calories from protein.

06:45.420 --> 06:47.420
And there are studies in trained lifters,

06:47.420 --> 06:50.420
for example from Professor Antonio's group,

06:50.420 --> 06:55.420
where people ate well over 4 grams per kilo and didn't really gain fat.

06:55.420 --> 06:58.420
And these studies did rely on food diaries,

06:58.420 --> 07:02.420
and when researchers ran the experiment properly with people living in a metabolic ward,

07:02.420 --> 07:06.420
and every mouthful was measured, it did look a little different.

07:06.420 --> 07:10.420
Overfed by about 950 calories a day for 8 weeks,

07:10.420 --> 07:15.420
people gained the same amount of fat whether the diet was low, normal, or high in protein.

07:15.420 --> 07:16.420
What protein changed?

07:16.420 --> 07:19.420
What protein changed was pretty much everything else.

07:19.420 --> 07:25.420
The higher protein groups gained around 3 kilos of lean tissue and burned more energy at rest.

07:25.420 --> 07:27.420
So protein doesn't make your surplus disappear,

07:27.420 --> 07:30.420
but it just changes what that surplus turns into.

07:30.420 --> 07:32.420
And then of course there's movement, right?

07:32.420 --> 07:34.420
And this is where it does get really interesting.

07:34.420 --> 07:38.420
In 1999, Levine and colleagues at the Mayo Clinic,

07:38.420 --> 07:45.420
they published a study in Science where they overfed 16 non-obese adults by 1000 calories a day for 8 weeks.

07:45.420 --> 07:47.420
Same surplus for everyone.

07:47.420 --> 07:53.420
And the amount of fat people stored varied tenfold between the lowest and the highest gainers.

07:53.420 --> 07:56.420
And the biggest part of that difference comes down to NEAT,

07:56.420 --> 07:59.420
or non-exercise activity thermogenesis.

07:59.420 --> 08:03.420
That's the fidgeting, the standing, the pacing while you're on the phone,

08:03.420 --> 08:06.420
the general moving around that isn't formal exercise.

08:06.420 --> 08:11.420
And about two thirds of the increase in people's daily energy expenditure came from NEAT.

08:11.420 --> 08:14.420
Some people ramped it up big time in response to all of that food.

08:14.420 --> 08:17.420
And some people barely changed at all.

08:17.420 --> 08:22.420
And how much somebody's NEAT went up predicted how well they resisted fat gain.

08:22.420 --> 08:28.420
So two people eating exactly the same extra food can end up storing very different amounts of it.

08:28.420 --> 08:32.420
And there was some, there was a twin study actually out of Quebec.

08:32.420 --> 08:39.420
And it was led by Bouchard and colleagues and published in New England Journal of Medicine in 1990.

08:39.420 --> 08:43.420
And they took 12 pairs of identical twins, all young men,

08:43.420 --> 08:49.420
overfed them by 1,000 calories a day, six days of the week, for 84 days,

08:49.420 --> 08:51.420
spread across a 100-day period.

08:51.420 --> 08:55.420
This was supervised, so they knew exactly what went in.

08:55.420 --> 09:00.420
Over the whole study, each man ate about 84,000 extra calories.

09:00.420 --> 09:04.420
So if you ran that through that 7,700 rule,

09:04.420 --> 09:10.420
then 84,000 divided by 7,700 is nearly 11 kilos.

09:10.420 --> 09:12.420
And if the rule were a reliable prediction,

09:12.420 --> 09:16.420
every one of those men should have gained somewhere around 11 kilos,

09:16.420 --> 09:18.420
and most of that should have been fat.

09:18.420 --> 09:20.420
But that's not what happened.

09:20.420 --> 09:23.420
So the average weight gain was 8.1 kilos,

09:23.420 --> 09:26.420
and of that, roughly 5.5 kilos was fat.

09:26.420 --> 09:28.420
And the range was huge.

09:28.420 --> 09:30.420
Same extra food, same supervision,

09:30.420 --> 09:33.420
the lowest gainer put on 4.3 kilos,

09:33.420 --> 09:36.420
and the highest put on 13.3.

09:36.420 --> 09:38.420
That's a three-fold difference.

09:38.420 --> 09:42.420
And interestingly, the twins tended to respond just like that.

09:42.420 --> 09:47.420
There were about three times more variation between the pairs than within them.

09:47.420 --> 09:49.420
And where they stored the fat,

09:49.420 --> 09:51.420
how much went on the belly versus elsewhere,

09:51.420 --> 09:54.420
how much ended up as visceral fat deep in the abdomen,

09:54.420 --> 09:56.420
was even more similar within pairs.

09:56.420 --> 09:59.420
So the author's conclusion was that genetics played a big role

09:59.420 --> 10:01.420
in how you respond to a surplus.

10:01.420 --> 10:05.420
How much of it you store, whether you store it as fat or lean tissue,

10:05.420 --> 10:07.420
and where it goes.

10:07.420 --> 10:10.420
And I guess one caveat which is definitely worth highlighting

10:10.420 --> 10:11.420
is that these were young men.

10:11.420 --> 10:15.420
We can't map those numbers directly onto a woman in her late 40s

10:15.420 --> 10:17.420
going through perimenopause.

10:17.420 --> 10:19.420
And nobody's really run this kind of tightly controlled,

10:19.420 --> 10:22.420
long overfeeding study in that group.

10:22.420 --> 10:23.420
Wouldn't that be interesting?

10:23.420 --> 10:26.420
But the principle holds that the same surplus

10:26.420 --> 10:29.420
does not produce the same outcome in different bodies.

10:29.420 --> 10:33.420
And the second problem is that not all weight gain is fat.

10:33.420 --> 10:36.420
So when you gain weight, some of it is fat,

10:36.420 --> 10:38.420
some of it might be lean tissue,

10:38.420 --> 10:40.420
but a lot of it, especially in the short term,

10:40.420 --> 10:42.420
is glycogen and water.

10:42.420 --> 10:44.420
Particularly if we're thinking about these, you know,

10:44.420 --> 10:46.420
weekend benders, right?

10:46.420 --> 10:49.420
Glycogen is how you store carbohydrate in your muscles and your liver.

10:49.420 --> 10:51.420
And it's stored along with water.

10:51.420 --> 10:55.420
So, as I said before, for every one gram of carbohydrate you store,

10:55.420 --> 10:59.420
there's typically three to four grams of water that goes along with it.

10:59.420 --> 11:03.420
So when you do top up your glycogen after a few days of eating more carbs,

11:03.420 --> 11:05.420
the scales can jump quickly.

11:05.420 --> 11:06.420
But it's not fat.

11:06.420 --> 11:08.420
It's fuel and fluid.

11:08.420 --> 11:10.420
There's a classic study from 1900,

11:10.420 --> 11:11.420
1970,

11:11.420 --> 11:13.420
by Olson and Sultan.

11:13.420 --> 11:17.420
Researchers had people do a hard bout of exercise to drain their glycogen,

11:17.420 --> 11:20.420
then eat a low-carb diet for three days,

11:20.420 --> 11:23.420
then switch out to a high-carbohydrate diet for four.

11:23.420 --> 11:25.420
Over those four days of eating more carbs,

11:25.420 --> 11:28.420
body weight went up 2.4 kilos.

11:28.420 --> 11:31.420
In total body, water went up 2.2 litres.

11:31.420 --> 11:33.420
Almost all of that weight change from water

11:33.420 --> 11:35.420
came along with the glycogen they were storing.

11:35.420 --> 11:37.420
So, for athletes listening,

11:37.420 --> 11:39.420
this is why you can be up a kilo or two

11:39.420 --> 11:41.420
after carbo loading before a race.

11:41.420 --> 11:43.420
But of course it's got nothing to do with body fat.

11:43.420 --> 11:45.420
I will also just caveat here that

11:45.420 --> 11:48.420
not everyone actually gains weight with a carb load.

11:48.420 --> 11:52.420
In fact, a study came out last year showing exactly that too.

11:52.420 --> 11:57.420
So, again, the way the body stores fuel is highly variable.

11:57.420 --> 12:00.420
And there was another recent study

12:00.420 --> 12:03.420
comparing moderate and high-carb intakes over a few days,

12:03.420 --> 12:06.420
finding a difference of about 0.7 of a kilo in body mass,

12:06.420 --> 12:08.420
tracking the difference in muscle glycogen.

12:08.420 --> 12:10.420
What I will say is,

12:10.420 --> 12:13.420
even though I always say three to four grams of water

12:13.420 --> 12:15.420
come along with a gram of carbohydrate,

12:15.420 --> 12:18.420
that exact ratio actually isn't that fixed.

12:18.420 --> 12:21.420
So muscle biopsy work has backed up the idea,

12:21.420 --> 12:23.420
but there are other studies that haven't found

12:23.420 --> 12:25.420
such a tidy relationship.

12:25.420 --> 12:28.420
So that's worth mentioning in case in your head you're like,

12:28.420 --> 12:30.420
hang on, not all research shows that.

12:30.420 --> 12:32.420
But it's basically, it's ballpark,

12:32.420 --> 12:34.420
and it's the direction that really matters.

12:34.420 --> 12:37.420
And then if I'm thinking back to a big weekend

12:37.420 --> 12:39.420
of sort of eating and celebrating,

12:39.420 --> 12:41.420
if you're eating out, there's extra sodium

12:41.420 --> 12:43.420
that tends to come with that.

12:43.420 --> 12:46.420
And that'll make your body hold more water.

12:46.420 --> 12:48.420
Alcohol, that'll shift fluid around.

12:48.420 --> 12:51.420
And in the physical weight of the food and drink,

12:51.420 --> 12:53.420
that's still making its way through your gut.

12:53.420 --> 12:55.420
If you're eating more food in total,

12:55.420 --> 12:57.420
that's also going to register on the scale.

12:57.420 --> 13:00.420
But again, it's not actually body fat.

13:00.420 --> 13:04.420
And the third problem is energy balance is not static.

13:04.420 --> 13:07.420
So that 7,700 rule,

13:07.420 --> 13:09.420
as it's often used,

13:09.420 --> 13:11.420
treats your body like a fixed calculator.

13:11.420 --> 13:15.420
Eat X extra, you will gain Y amount of fat.

13:15.420 --> 13:17.420
Forever, linear, in a straight line.

13:17.420 --> 13:19.420
But as your body mass changes,

13:19.420 --> 13:22.420
so does the energy cost it takes

13:22.420 --> 13:24.420
to run and move that body.

13:24.420 --> 13:27.420
Kevin Hall at USNIH

13:27.420 --> 13:29.420
has done a lot of the work around here.

13:29.420 --> 13:32.420
And in 2013, he and his colleague Chao

13:32.420 --> 13:35.420
wrote a short piece in the International Journal of Obesity,

13:35.420 --> 13:36.420
literally titled,

13:36.420 --> 13:41.420
Why is that 3,500 kilocal per pound weight loss rule wrong?

13:41.420 --> 13:44.420
And their answer is probably as nuanced

13:44.420 --> 13:45.420
which you probably would expect

13:45.420 --> 13:47.420
coming from the likes of Kevin Hall.

13:47.420 --> 13:49.420
So they argued that most of the series error

13:49.420 --> 13:52.420
isn't really that number, 3,500.

13:52.420 --> 13:54.420
It's the assumption that the gap between what you eat

13:54.420 --> 13:57.420
and what you burn stays the same over time.

13:57.420 --> 13:58.420
And it doesn't.

13:58.420 --> 13:59.420
Your body changes,

13:59.420 --> 14:01.420
and you're expended to changes with it.

14:01.420 --> 14:03.420
The body moves the goalposts.

14:03.420 --> 14:05.420
They actually worried that people would walk away

14:05.420 --> 14:07.420
thinking the problem was just the number,

14:07.420 --> 14:09.420
and that swapping in a better number would fix it.

14:09.420 --> 14:11.420
But because it is dynamic,

14:11.420 --> 14:13.420
that's not going to work.

14:13.420 --> 14:15.420
So I suppose that's where I say

14:15.420 --> 14:17.420
that it's sort of correct,

14:17.420 --> 14:18.420
but it sort of isn't.

14:18.420 --> 14:21.420
Like this whole premise around that 3,500 calories

14:21.420 --> 14:24.420
or 7,700 calories per kilo.

14:24.420 --> 14:26.420
In another study published

14:26.420 --> 14:29.420
in the New England Journal of Medicine in 1995,

14:29.420 --> 14:32.420
where people were held at 10% above their usual body weight,

14:32.420 --> 14:34.420
their total daily energy expenditure went up,

14:34.420 --> 14:37.420
beyond what you'd expect just from being bigger.

14:37.420 --> 14:40.420
Most of that increase came from that NEAT again,

14:40.420 --> 14:43.420
non-exercise activity thermogenesis,

14:43.420 --> 14:45.420
which is how much they moved.

14:45.420 --> 14:49.420
So your body can push back against gaining weight

14:49.420 --> 14:52.420
as much as it can against losing weight.

14:52.420 --> 14:53.420
So ultimately,

14:53.420 --> 14:56.420
the bigger problem isn't the number,

14:56.420 --> 14:58.420
but it's how we apply the rule.

14:58.420 --> 14:59.420
Having said that though,

14:59.420 --> 15:02.420
there are researchers who have questioned the figure as well.

15:02.420 --> 15:04.420
And when you look at what's happening,

15:04.420 --> 15:05.420
and what they've found,

15:05.420 --> 15:08.420
it does come back to Wyschnowski's original assumption

15:08.420 --> 15:10.420
that most of the weight that changes is fat.

15:10.420 --> 15:12.420
Because when you actually measure the energy content

15:12.420 --> 15:14.420
of weight change in real people,

15:14.420 --> 15:17.420
it isn't fixed at 7,700.

15:17.420 --> 15:19.420
Hall has shown with modeling

15:19.420 --> 15:21.420
that that figure I just mentioned

15:21.420 --> 15:23.420
roughly fits people with obesity

15:23.420 --> 15:25.420
who carry a lot of body fat,

15:25.420 --> 15:27.420
more than around 30 kilos of it.

15:27.420 --> 15:28.420
For leaner people,

15:28.420 --> 15:30.420
it overestimates how big a deficit you need

15:30.420 --> 15:32.420
per kilo lost,

15:32.420 --> 15:34.420
because more of what they lose is lean tissue,

15:34.420 --> 15:37.420
which holds far less energy than fat.

15:37.420 --> 15:38.420
In early weight loss,

15:38.420 --> 15:41.420
the energy per kilo lost can be much lower.

15:41.420 --> 15:44.420
When Hamesfield's group tracked people

15:44.420 --> 15:46.420
with body composition scans during the first months

15:46.420 --> 15:48.420
of a calorie restriction trial,

15:48.420 --> 15:51.420
the energy content of each kilo lost at week four

15:51.420 --> 15:54.420
was just under 4,900 calories.

15:54.420 --> 15:55.420
By week six,

15:55.420 --> 15:57.420
it had risen to around 6,000,

15:57.420 --> 15:59.420
and then it settled there.

15:59.420 --> 16:01.420
That early phase is when a lot of what comes off

16:01.420 --> 16:03.420
is glycogen and water rather than fat.

16:03.420 --> 16:05.420
So they also found a sex difference

16:05.420 --> 16:07.420
with each kilo lost by women

16:07.420 --> 16:11.420
carrying more energy than each kilo lost by men,

16:11.420 --> 16:15.420
around 6,800 versus 6,100 calories.

16:15.420 --> 16:17.420
So what is the actual answer?

16:17.420 --> 16:20.420
Well, I mean, everyone's got an opinion, obviously.

16:20.420 --> 16:22.420
Here's how I'd frame it,

16:22.420 --> 16:24.420
just after the digging that I did.

16:24.420 --> 16:27.420
So when people say a kilo of fat,

16:27.420 --> 16:30.420
they're usually blurring three different things.

16:30.420 --> 16:32.420
That's a kilo of pure stored fat,

16:32.420 --> 16:34.420
a kilo of pure stored lipid,

16:34.420 --> 16:38.420
which is around 9,400 to 9,500 calories,

16:38.420 --> 16:40.420
a kilo of adipose tissue,

16:40.420 --> 16:42.420
the actual fat tissue on your body,

16:42.420 --> 16:45.420
which is a little over 8,000 calories,

16:45.420 --> 16:48.420
depending on how much of the adipose is actually lipid,

16:48.420 --> 16:49.420
and a kilo on the scales,

16:49.420 --> 16:52.420
which could be fat, water, glycogen,

16:52.420 --> 16:54.420
gut contents, muscle,

16:54.420 --> 16:57.420
or most likely a mix of all of them.

16:57.420 --> 16:59.420
That kilo could represent anything

16:59.420 --> 17:02.420
from about 1,000 calories,

17:02.420 --> 17:04.420
if it's mostly glycogen and water,

17:04.420 --> 17:07.420
to more than 9,000 calories if it's mostly fat.

17:07.420 --> 17:10.420
7,700 calories tells you roughly how much energy

17:10.420 --> 17:14.420
is sitting in a kilo of body weight that's mostly fat.

17:14.420 --> 17:16.420
It doesn't tell you exactly how many extra calories

17:16.420 --> 17:19.420
you need to gain a kilo of fat.

17:19.420 --> 17:21.420
It's just not the same question.

17:21.420 --> 17:26.420
So if a kilo of fat tissue holds a bit over 8,000 calories

17:26.420 --> 17:29.420
and your body stores somewhere between three quarters

17:29.420 --> 17:31.420
and almost all of a surplus,

17:31.420 --> 17:33.420
depending on what it's made up of,

17:33.420 --> 17:35.420
you actually need to eat somewhere in the region

17:35.420 --> 17:38.420
of 9,000 to 11,000 calories

17:38.420 --> 17:41.420
to add a kilo of actual fat tissue.

17:41.420 --> 17:43.420
At 500 extra calories a day,

17:43.420 --> 17:45.420
that's about three weeks,

17:45.420 --> 17:48.420
rather than that 15 days original estimate,

17:48.420 --> 17:51.420
and 1,000 extra calories a day,

17:51.420 --> 17:53.420
that's around 10 days.

17:53.420 --> 17:55.420
And that's before your body starts moving more,

17:55.420 --> 17:57.420
burning more as it gets bigger,

17:57.420 --> 17:59.420
and responding in its own particular way,

17:59.420 --> 18:01.420
which, as the twins showed us,

18:01.420 --> 18:04.420
can vary a lot from one person to the next.

18:04.420 --> 18:07.420
So treat those numbers as a rough guide, clearly,

18:07.420 --> 18:09.420
and not as like this definitive rule.

18:09.420 --> 18:11.420
So if you go back to that big weekend,

18:11.420 --> 18:14.420
and let's say you did eat 1,500 calories

18:14.420 --> 18:17.420
over your needs on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday,

18:17.420 --> 18:19.420
which is genuinely a big weekend,

18:19.420 --> 18:22.420
that's 4,500 extra calories

18:22.420 --> 18:26.420
spent by those extra drinks and a night out on Friday,

18:26.420 --> 18:30.420
that birthday on the Sunday and the brunch on Saturday.

18:30.420 --> 18:32.420
Even if every single one of those calories

18:32.420 --> 18:35.420
was stored as fat tissue, which it won't be,

18:35.420 --> 18:37.420
you're looking at a bit over half a kilo.

18:37.420 --> 18:39.420
Once you account for the energy the body spends

18:39.420 --> 18:41.420
handling and storing that surplus,

18:41.420 --> 18:45.420
you're realistically looking at around 400 to 500 grams

18:45.420 --> 18:47.420
at the very most.

18:47.420 --> 18:49.420
And a fair chunk of that carbohydrate from the weekend

18:49.420 --> 18:52.420
will have gone into topping up your glycogen first.

18:52.420 --> 18:56.420
So of course, you can gain fat over a weekend.

18:56.420 --> 18:58.420
But the two kilos on the scales on a Monday

18:58.420 --> 18:59.420
is mostly glycogen,

18:59.420 --> 19:02.420
water, salt, and food in transit.

19:02.420 --> 19:04.420
When you go back to your normal way of eating,

19:04.420 --> 19:07.420
a good chunk of it will be gone within a few days.

19:07.420 --> 19:10.420
And then of course, that same logic applies in reverse, right?

19:10.420 --> 19:12.420
So the first week of a new plan

19:12.420 --> 19:14.420
where the scale drops two kilos,

19:14.420 --> 19:16.420
a lot of that is glycogen and water as well.

19:16.420 --> 19:19.420
And it's why the first week always looks amazing,

19:19.420 --> 19:21.420
and the third week can feel like nothing is happening,

19:21.420 --> 19:24.420
even when you're doing everything the same way

19:24.420 --> 19:26.420
and you're actually seeing progress.

19:26.420 --> 19:28.420
The fat loss is there all of the time,

19:28.420 --> 19:31.420
it just wasn't the whole story on the scales.

19:31.420 --> 19:33.420
And the reason I wanted to chat about this really

19:33.420 --> 19:35.420
is because that 7,700 rule

19:35.420 --> 19:38.420
gives people this false precision in both directions.

19:38.420 --> 19:40.420
It makes them think they've gained more fat

19:40.420 --> 19:42.420
than they have after a few big days,

19:42.420 --> 19:44.420
and it sets up expectations around fat loss

19:44.420 --> 19:47.420
that their body was never going to be able to meet,

19:47.420 --> 19:49.420
regardless of what they did.

19:49.420 --> 19:52.420
The scales can change much faster than body fat does,

19:52.420 --> 19:56.420
and just knowing that hopefully helps you stop panicking

19:56.420 --> 19:57.420
on a Monday morning,

19:57.420 --> 20:01.420
and instead of going to extremes then

20:01.420 --> 20:04.420
to quote unquote fix the damage,

20:04.420 --> 20:07.420
you just make some good decisions

20:07.420 --> 20:10.420
and carry on as you would have anyway.

20:10.420 --> 20:12.420
And I think this is what I always say to people

20:12.420 --> 20:15.420
when they have weekends like the one that I sort of talked about.

20:15.420 --> 20:19.420
The most important decision is what you do next.

20:19.420 --> 20:21.420
So just make a good one.

20:21.420 --> 20:24.420
All right, guys, hopefully you followed along with that.

20:24.420 --> 20:26.420
Let me know I'm on Instagram, Threads and X,

20:26.420 --> 20:28.420
at Mikki Williden.

20:28.420 --> 20:31.420
I'm at Facebook, at Mikki Williden Nutrition,

20:31.420 --> 20:33.420
or head to my website, mikkiwilliden.com.

20:33.420 --> 20:35.420
Scroll right down to the bottom,

20:35.420 --> 20:37.420
pop your name in that box,

20:37.420 --> 20:39.420
and you can jump on my email list.

20:39.420 --> 20:40.420
Guys, you have a great week.

20:40.420 --> 20:41.420
See you later.