WEBVTT

00:00:00.400 --> 00:00:11.280
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Hey, folks. Welcome back to another episode of the Cabbage Coins Podcast. My name is Tony Gryckiewicz. I'm the owner operator of a little company called Cabbage Coins. And today, we're welcoming back a fantastic guest that we had.

00:00:11.280 --> 00:00:32.480
Just recently, we talked about commemorative $0.5 with Larry Shepherd. It was one of the most successful episodes I've had. Tons of comments, lots of people talking about how much they learned in the episode and how wonderful it was. And Larry said, you know, I'm also an expert on peace dollars, and I'd love to come back and talk about a little bit of a peace dollar analysis. So today, again, we have Larry Shepherd.

00:00:32.480 --> 00:00:49.765
He is the president and owner of Simco Numismatics, as well as president and owner of Shepherd Expo Management. He is the host of the Great American Coin and Collectibles show in Rosemont, Illinois. And hey, welcome back to the program. How has life been post, you know, the first podcast episode?

00:00:49.765 --> 00:01:13.625
<v Larry Shepherd>Well, thank you, Tony. But I appreciate you you inviting me back. Yes. We've always had a we've had a great response to the first podcast And I've had every coin show I've been to since then, I've had numerous people come up to the table and tell me how much they enjoyed it. I actually had one kind of cute or funny exchange where a couple walked up to my table at the the E and A in August.

00:01:13.705 --> 00:01:45.645
And the wife said that her husband had watched that session like 10 times. And the guy just, you know, he acted like he was just really thrilled that mainly like I was a big movie star or something on, you know, I know, you know, it's a little bit flattering, it's a little bit over the top. Interestingly, he asked me what was the least expensive command line had in my case? And I told him my thought about command, I told him which one it was. And he says, okay, I'll take that.

00:01:45.645 --> 00:02:01.030
And I said, don't you even wanna see it? And he says, no, I just wanna buy a coin that came from you. So I guess that's pretty effective when works like that, but I do appreciate all the good publicity you gave us. I'm glad it went well.

00:02:01.205 --> 00:02:12.245
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Yeah. Well, there's a couple of thoughts I had there as you're responding there. First off, you said, you know, you're not a movie star, but I think I see an Oscar sitting behind you Oh, on the yeah.

00:02:12.725 --> 00:02:17.045
<v Larry Shepherd>That was was given me for best performance in a movie by an aging coin dealer.

00:02:19.420 --> 00:02:23.100
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>All right, no, but that is real actual Numismatic award, is that right?

00:02:23.100 --> 00:02:28.620
<v Larry Shepherd>It is, yes. It's a lifetime achievement award by the National Silver Dollar Roundtable, NSDR.

00:02:28.620 --> 00:02:52.540
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>All right, very cool. So Silver Dollar Roundtable, we're talking about silver dollar today. I feel like we've got, you know, there's no one better than the guy here to talk about the, you know, the guy, the expert on Peace Dollars. So very excited to get into this. So to kind of like lay things out for folks that are maybe new to the series or they maybe collected it for years, I mean, how do you approach this set of coins?

00:02:52.540 --> 00:03:06.185
These are Peace Dollars starting in 1921 and I believe ending in 1935. This is the last great kind of full 90% silver dollar I think that we've made as nation. So how do you approach this series? What do you... How do you think about it?

00:03:06.345 --> 00:03:32.885
<v Larry Shepherd>Well, it's an eminently collectible series because it can be collected in any budget. There's, you know, you could put together a circulator set for a very reasonable amount of money. So there are thousands of collectors out there who collect circulated silver dollars. That's not my area of expertise. So I won't be making a lot of comments about the circulating ones today except for maybe the twenty eight pm thirty four as the traditional key dates of the of the circulated series.

00:03:32.965 --> 00:04:28.545
But it's as I said, an eminently collectible series. Doesn't really get expensive until you get up to m s 65 where some of the dates take huge jumps, the '25 s goes from 1,500 to 20 plus thousand and '28 s goes from 1,000 to 18, 20000 and 65. So it becomes much more expensive than '65 and it becomes almost prohibitively expensive for for some way trying to put together a complete set with every date in MS '66. A lot of the dates are affordable, but there are some, I mean, well, the 25 S doesn't even exist in '66. So, it can be collected on almost any budget from a few $100 up to, if you wanted to try to put together the absolute top set, it would probably be know, also a 7 figure investment, but there are collectors that ever range in between.

00:04:28.545 --> 00:05:42.550
And I've dealt with collectors and it ever range in between, but it's a beautiful collection. I've done a lot of Morgan dollars in my career and then in earlier years, but I always had a special love for the Peace Dollars, just because I thought that they were so beautiful. When they come nice, they're really attractive, like some of the coins you're gonna see here in a few minutes. But the other thing is that back in the pre internet days when I used to put mail out a written price list, I would come frequently make the comment about some of these dollar saying that you pick any Morgan dollar back in the days when the gray sheet, if you open the front sheet of the front page of the gray sheet, you'd have peace dollars on one side and you'd have Morgan dollars on the other side. And I used to say, if you just blindly put your finger down on the mortgage dollar side and you'd look at whatever that price was, let's say you'd point and it says $900 If you'd go over to the Peace Dollar side and circle all the coins that were priced around $900 I would comment that I could probably find you five really nice more than dollars of that date, that $900 date for every one $900 piece dollar that day.

00:05:42.630 --> 00:06:14.075
Was just that much that much scarcer. Then, you know, we're just going back to what I said a minute ago about the the twenty five s thing, not even existing in '66. So, you know, a nineteen twenty five s, if it were to occur in m s '66, but probably be a $300,000 coin. And if one were ever to pop up, that was too true genuine MS 60 7 quality, it would be right up there in the price range with the the key date market and the 93 s. In fact, it's high grade 25 s's are scarce over the high grade 93 S's.

00:06:14.075 --> 00:06:38.810
I could see all them as 67, 25 S selling for a million dollars or more. Yeah, they're they're they're very, very scarce in very rare. It's much harder to find really gemmy peace dollars than really gemmy mortgage dollars. Take nothing like the mortgage, I love them, but peace dollars just are really special. Nice thing is there's only 24 dates, so you don't have to go through nearly as many dates as you do in other shares.

00:06:39.295 --> 00:07:11.915
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>We recently saw a rise in market values for the ninety three s. I think it was kind of led or kicked off by an incredible auction record. I think it was... It might have been an MS 65 that sold at one of the major auction sites, and then also we started seeing a lot of '93 s's kind of going up in value in the Morgan dollars. Do you find just based upon that relative scarcity of the two different series, the '93 s versus some of these kind of really rare dates in in Peace Dollars, Do you think peace dollars are relatively undervalued today in some of those kind of really rare grades?

00:07:12.635 --> 00:07:55.120
<v Larry Shepherd>I think so. There's a conundrum in the pricing of peace dollars in that, in my opinion, most of the key date Peace Dollars in existence now for the tougher dates, like the twenty four S, twenty five S, twenty eight S. So I think most of the coins on the market are overrated. So even though the populations appear to be high, coins that are in MS65, MS66 holders tend to be a lower end coins, which isn't necessarily the case for the Morgan dollars. Weren't made nearly as well as the Morgan dollars and a lot of them were held in bags for decades because when they were when they were men and they really weren't needed for commerce.

00:07:56.160 --> 00:08:27.390
Many, many of the dates were held in in in bank vaults and in bags and not distributed till the 1940s, 1950s or in the big distribution in the 1960s. So consequently, a lot of them are very heavily bag marked and there's there's very few dates that in pay sellers that weren't bagged quantity dates. So that's part of the problem. You don't get nearly as many, with the exception of the early PMS, as many 67s or you don't see 68 peace dollars like you see frequently in Morgan dollars.

00:08:27.615 --> 00:08:32.975
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>In the Morgan side. Is there a particular reason why they're overgraded in your opinion or often go Yeah.

00:08:34.095 --> 00:09:19.160
<v Larry Shepherd>Anytime there's a big jump between in price between two grades, that's a very seductive feature for the professional operators. And so consequently, since I think most peace dollars were all basically what used to be a 65 is now 65 plus. What used to be a 65 plus is now 66. And it's because like I said, there's a huge jump that you can get a if you can get a 25 best to go from a thousand dollar 64 point into 65, it's it's $25,000 So that's that's a 25 times profit on that. So consequently, a lot of the PQ 60 fours have existed over the years and get tried over and over and over again.

00:09:19.320 --> 00:10:09.170
And when one of them finally works, a PQ 64 becomes a low end 65. And so many of the many of the big dates, they have a lot of low end coins because they've been with the population has been swollen by upgraded 60 fours that were nice when they were 60 fours, but they're kind of low end with their 65. And consequently, you have a conundrum there where many of the pay stylists, certain dates, at least like the, I mentioned the 1921, it's on the price sheets for $4,000 and about 65. Well, I think that's grossly overpriced for the average quality 1921 because the average quality nineteen twenty one, sixty five is just really horrible, awful. But same time, a really gem 1921 with a full strike and great booming luster would be worth a lot more than that.

00:10:09.650 --> 00:10:18.290
The price guides kind of fall in between what a low end coin is worth and what a really high end coin is worth.

00:10:18.290 --> 00:10:47.340
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Okay. Well, I think that 21, so that's a good jumping off point for some of the coins that we're going to show here. So I'm going to go ahead and just get moving into our presentation, what we're sharing, starting with the course of 1921. So for those who don't know, 1921 was the first day of the series and they originally designed this image with peace in a high relief design, and then they found that it was difficult to strike. Do you have any comments or or commentary, you know, about that?

00:10:47.340 --> 00:10:53.820
The the kind of the history of this design and and and why they started with this high relief design and what happened afterwards?

00:10:54.185 --> 00:11:23.975
<v Larry Shepherd>Well, it is similar to the 1907 high relief $20 saints. There was a desire to have more artistic, more beautiful coins. So it was a well intentioned effort, But what they found was just like with the 20... With the $190.07 saints, that it was very difficult for the mint to get enough pressure on their process to strike the 21 and get it to fully strike up with all the details. So because of the high relief.

00:11:23.975 --> 00:11:54.465
So consequently, the coins were coming out of the mint with a lot of softness in the hair behind the ear and above the ear, and on the reverse on the eagle's feathers, particularly on the on the lower breast, and that the right leg going down to where it says peace. You see a tremendous amount of softness there. Now, this picture is one of the best truck 21 piece you'll ever see. That's why I sent you this photo because they don't normally come like this. They don't come with it with this kind of strike.

00:11:54.545 --> 00:12:06.545
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Yeah. I I mean, today with our... The presses that we have today, I mean, they could execute this strike on a high relief coin like this, but back at this time, so this is considered a very well struck '21.

00:12:06.545 --> 00:12:09.080
<v Larry Shepherd>That's correct. Yes. Yeah. Gotcha. And you don't...

00:12:09.080 --> 00:12:33.305
And you won't see very many like this. And the other thing about the '21, while while we have this up here is that for some reason, which I'm not... I'm really not sure. The 20 ones, you don't see them coming with a blazing booming luster like you see on the 22 piece, 23 piece, 24 piece, 25 piece. Instead, you see coins that are very kind of dulled down luster.

00:12:33.465 --> 00:12:57.915
And for some reason, a high number of the percentage of the 20 ones have kind of an unattractive kind of yellowish brown patina or toning to them. Mean, almost, I'd say more than 50% of the ones I see in the market that they haven't been dipped, look like that. It's not a really attractive look for the coin.

00:12:57.915 --> 00:13:16.650
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>So why would that be in the production process at this time that let's say coins developed a certain sort of look to them when they do start to tone and develop? Mean, it have anything to do with the production process or how they were stored following their time at the mint or what usually would result in somebody having this yellow pukey kind of look?

00:13:16.895 --> 00:14:23.535
<v Larry Shepherd>Yeah. Well, going back to the commemorative podcast you and I did together a few months ago, I talked about this in length relative to commemorative, the mystery of how certain issues of commemorative toned differently from other issues of the same series. For example, like the 1926 P Oregon, which tends to not tone in blue colors, but in the 1926 S, which tends to be almost always tone blue, or the or the 1936 PDF sets where even though the three coins were mailed out in the same polar at the same time, and they slept in that holder together for fifty or sixty years when you would open up open those sets, they would have three distinctly different types of toning. And so I've always speculated that it had something that it could be the alloy that was being purchased at each respective meant. It could be some type of cleaner that they were putting on the on the plants just before they were flushed out when, you know, when the the plants just come in big metal rolls and they they do wash that and clean it.

00:14:23.535 --> 00:14:50.305
As you've seen with some of the modern coins where they have white milky spots, they don't always get all that all that cleaned off those plants. So it could be there are some kind of chemical residue that stayed on the on those sheets. Once they got punched in the plants, it was different. You know, I I really don't know. In the case of a coin like this, I'm not aware of them being held or stored any differently, except I would say that this...

00:14:50.305 --> 00:15:16.175
When I when I talked about most peace dollars were stored in bag quantities in the banks. This is one day that I don't think was ever was ever released in bank quality. It's a little bit different than the other peace dollars. But in answer to the question, no, can't I really can't answer it. Going back to the Morgan dollars, if you go to 1,900 in the Philadelphia mint, you see 1,900 piece with bright booming luster.

00:15:16.255 --> 00:15:32.540
But the same... And the same year and the same mint, they made the Lafayette Dollar, and you just never see that with bright booming luster. So you scratch your head and say, why does that occur? I wish I had the answer to that, but I really don't.

00:15:32.700 --> 00:15:47.685
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>All right. Well, for the sake of time, we'll keep this show on the road. Keep going here. So the 22 I think you mentioned this is a higher mintage coin, but this particular example is quite nice. What would you like to say about the 22D?

00:15:47.685 --> 00:16:16.405
<v Larry Shepherd>Well, a 22D is the highest managed DMAT and it's one of the highest, probably the highest population DMAT, but it has unusual surfaces. I describe it now, this is a really gem quality coin. So this is a But phenomenal a lot of the coins have just kind of, even though they're bright luscious, the surfaces are almost like a little bit splotchy. I often describe it as being kind of like aluminum foil. Yes, you're seeing that right there.

00:16:16.485 --> 00:16:32.550
So they're not hard mirrors mirrored surfaces like you will see on the P mats. It's a surface quality that's pretty much unique to that day. You don't see it on another twenty two days. Deeds. Now, in this case, a coin like this, it could be quite attractive.

00:16:32.795 --> 00:16:46.075
But in most of the 22ds, it's not attractive. So even though the 22d is a high mintage coin and a high population coin, it's really hard to find one that you're really satisfied with, that's very attractive.

00:16:46.310 --> 00:17:00.070
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>I see. So you mentioned about grading Peace Dollars. Just for folks out there that are really new to this, what are the focal areas, particularly on the Peace Dollar and the obverse, we'll start there, to focus on for grading?

00:17:00.455 --> 00:17:14.455
<v Larry Shepherd>Well, the most important one's gonna be the the Miss Liberty's cheek, the side of the face. Yeah. Right there, what you're where you're looking at. If you if you catch a bag mark there, it just stands out like a sore thumb. But if if there's a bag mark up in the hair, it gets hidden as well.

00:17:14.630 --> 00:17:32.815
But the other place where if I perform is on the left side, left obverse seal. Yeah, right there where you're going. You have to be, you know, pay close attention to marks or hairlines in that area, because those are the most important areas. Then on the reverse, it's gonna be marks on the eagle. Okay.

00:17:32.815 --> 00:17:46.330
Usually up in feathers and in the middle part of the bird is where you typically see the most damaging mark, because that's the high point on the reverse, so it catches more marks than the lower point.

00:17:46.410 --> 00:17:56.810
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Yeah. And also for those out there, people might be wondering where to find the mint mark. It's kind of hidden. I mean, this is one... It got to be one of the tiniest mint marks on US coins appeal.

00:17:57.545 --> 00:18:06.425
It's it's really, really small, especially relative to the size of of the coin. It's it's not like a Morgan dollar where it's really, really clear and large, but...

00:18:06.745 --> 00:18:20.570
<v Larry Shepherd>Some of the some of the dates actually have two different size mint marks. The 34D for example, has a small mint mark like the one we just looked at, but they also have a much larger demint mark. So there is some variability to the mint marks.

00:18:20.570 --> 00:18:21.530
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>I did not know that.

00:18:21.530 --> 00:18:27.005
<v Larry Shepherd>But you're right for in most cases, the mint marks are much smaller than on modern dollars.

00:18:27.245 --> 00:18:49.490
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Yeah. I I do just have to comment that I really do like surfaces like this that are a little bit unique and unusual. This kinda has, I don't wanna say orange peel kind of a surface kinda quality to it, but it reminds me of that. And it also just sort of speaks to like metal flow and the original striking. I feel like these surfaces are very wholesome, like original exactly as the coin, you know, came off the press.

00:18:49.570 --> 00:19:02.265
<v Larry Shepherd>I agree with why I think this is just a fabulous coin and I love it, but as I was pointing out that it's just, it's different from any of the other dates. You don't see that on any of the other dates at Peace Dollars.

00:19:02.665 --> 00:19:16.650
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Now, how important is the blast white character of a coin like this from an investment perspective, from a collector perspective? How much should collectors out there avoid toning? What's kind of your perspective on that specifically with regard to peace dollars?

00:19:16.650 --> 00:19:36.775
<v Larry Shepherd>Well, there's... I have a lot of thoughts on that subject. I've probably worked with, you know, six or 700 collectors over the years in building mint state peace dollars. And basically, 100% of them wanted bright white flashy coins. It's just one of those coins that looks great when it when it looks like the coin that you're showing there in the image.

00:19:37.015 --> 00:20:16.370
Just a super beautiful coin when it has that kind of luster. And so consequently, in my experience over thirty five years of selling peace dollars, almost every phone call I've ever gotten for a peace dollar is relative to white coins. That was one of the comments I made. And I don't mean to be putting down tech, but because of tax preference for originality and for toning or maybe more splotchy toning. I I've I've made comments before that initially, CAC was very, very, very hard on white coins in a white piece solid.

00:20:16.370 --> 00:20:54.225
It was all... It was very hard to get a white piece solid for the CAC signal. And that created a real shortage in the market and created what I called CAC rarities, where there were coins or selling for multiples of what an ungraded CAC coin was, if you wanted a white coin because you just couldn't get the white points. But my comments were that you know, all the years that that I've sold Peace Dollars, I've never once answered my phone and had the the the collector on the other end say, mister Shepherd, I'm just calling to see if you have any ugly tone, splotchy, crusty peace dollars for sale. That's just not a call that that you'll ever get.

00:20:54.225 --> 00:21:10.210
It takes nothing away from the originality of those pieces. And I understand that that's the personal preference of the people who are grading attack at that time. But that was one area where I felt like CAC was really out of touch with the collector market.

00:21:10.210 --> 00:21:29.465
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Alright. So moving on to something that has a little bit of tone to it. This is a 24 s. Now this is one of these dates where it gets pretty tough as you go higher in in in quality and in numerical grade. So this is a lovely coin from an originality perspective, I'll let you take it away about the 24 s.

00:21:29.770 --> 00:22:10.010
<v Larry Shepherd>Well, the twenty four S is my favorite date in terms of what I think is the most undervalued date in the series. It's really hard to find knives. When I talk about knives, I'm talking about a coin that has all the characteristics that use for credit, luster, I appeal, strike, marks, know, all 20, almost all 24 us fail on one or two or more of those those features. It's very hard to find a well struck twenty four hours, virtually impossible. The luster tends to be so, so they just weren't made with good overall quality.

00:22:10.010 --> 00:22:41.985
So it's one of the poorer made points. And it's one of the coins I referred to a while ago earlier that if you looked at the population report, you'd think it would be an easy easy coin. But the problem is almost in in any grade you're looking at, MS 64, MS 65, whatever the the coins that exist in the... In those those grades tend to be low end. Whereas a really gemmy coin like the one that we're looking at there is really, really difficult and really, really undervalued in my opinion.

00:22:41.985 --> 00:23:28.990
I think that the 24 s in true GM quality condition is every bit as rare and valuable as the as the much higher priced and much more well known 28 s. I think it ranks just right behind the the 25 s, which is the the toughest of all the peace dollars. But, yeah, I think if you can find... If you're looking just for investment purposes, if you can find a a 24 s that has great luster, great IOP, good stripe, and it's properly graded for the for the holder, it's a good buy, but don't expect to get it for cheap prices because unless you're buying or somebody who just doesn't really know what they're doing because that's a coin that is worth significant premiums if you find such a coin as that.

00:23:29.070 --> 00:23:44.395
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Yeah. Yeah. This is very eye opening to me because I feel like there's great opportunities here. I love finding and seeking out value in things, walking through shows. So, you know, keeping my eye open for some good, very nice high quality 24 S's.

00:23:44.395 --> 00:23:49.950
I realize this is going be something that's pretty valuable from a collector perspective. They're gonna be Well willing to step up and

00:23:50.110 --> 00:24:12.815
<v Larry Shepherd>I would, I would say the same thing about the '24 S and MF 64. It's actually easier to find a '28 S and MF 64, multiple times easier to find a really nice 28 S in '64 or a '25 S in '64 than a '20 four S. So it's, you know, finding a nice '24, 64, 24 S is difficult even.

00:24:13.130 --> 00:24:28.845
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Yeah. And and also you said this is part of the fact that they were very poorly made. Does that kind of come up with these San Francisco mint examples? Were a lot of them kind of poorly made and what would be the reasons for that? Why would they make them poorly at the Mint for a period of time?

00:24:28.845 --> 00:25:02.485
<v Larry Shepherd>Well, they just had poor quality control during that period. You look, I walked in Liberty House made in San Francisco in the nineteen twenties and you have the same problem, poor striking quality and and so forth. Now, once you get into the nineteen thirties, the story flips because the peace dollars made in the nineteen thirties at San Francisco are among the the best made, the most beautiful coins of the entire series. But in the nineteen twenties, the twenty two s tends to be poorly struck. Again, it's a high population coin, but it's extremely difficult to find to find nice.

00:25:02.485 --> 00:25:44.400
The 23 s says, is my second favorite coin. If you could find a true gemmy coin for investment purposes, because it's it's high population, it's it's low price on the price sheets, but I can tell you almost every advanced collector when they're putting together a great set, it's one of the dates that are on their want list when they're down to the final three or three or four points because they just can't find one that they like. 24 s is poorly made, the 25 s is horrible, just absolutely horrible. The 26 s is made pretty nice, 27 s made pretty nice. But yeah, from from '22 through '25, ball to control San Francisco Met was just very bad.

00:25:44.400 --> 00:26:02.775
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Interesting. I think there's some good value stuff out there for folks that are watching right now and paying attention. So you mentioned the 25S is the king or queen of peace dollars. I thought that like, you know, the twenty eight's the key date or the thirty four s is the key date, but you think this is actually more so the the the king of the the of the series?

00:26:02.775 --> 00:26:41.480
<v Larry Shepherd>Well, depends on what you're talking about. If you're if you're putting together a circulated set, the '28 and the thirty four fs are the two p dates. But the whole light switch changes when you get into the higher mint state, you're great. Once you get up to ms 64 and ms 65 coins, the estimates take over and they're much scarcer than the 28 or well, 38. 34 S is considered to be a really high value coin in almost all grades, but certainly 28 P, even though it is a really good date in say, MS65, it falls behind the earlier estimates.

00:26:41.480 --> 00:26:53.015
And it's much easier to find even in some of the estimates that are higher priced, So a 28 P is harder to find than say a 22 ounce or something like that.

00:26:53.015 --> 00:26:57.175
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>This is an absolutely stellar coin. Do you remember off top of your head what the grade is on this?

00:26:57.175 --> 00:27:02.780
<v Larry Shepherd>That's a 65 plus, And this is the finest 25 ounce I've ever seen.

00:27:02.860 --> 00:27:03.740
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Interesting. Okay.

00:27:03.740 --> 00:27:31.010
<v Larry Shepherd>There's a toned one out there that, believe it or not, a young man, a lion that we have a close relationship turned up and the coins absolutely magnificent. Unfortunately, I didn't have a picture of it, but it has kind of reddish oranges, toning, but very attractive. And but this is the finest white 25 I've ever seen. And this is the kind of coin that the the serious collectors look for. What they want their points to look like.

00:27:31.010 --> 00:27:44.075
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>It's interesting this thing actually is only a 65 plus and maybe I'm just not, you know, very good at at creating peace dollars just yet. But I look at this and I say this coin is higher, this coin could be a 66 maybe, but, you know.

00:27:44.075 --> 00:28:25.780
<v Larry Shepherd>I think I think you're correct. I think it would be, but as I've said a a while ago, you know, the grading services that, you know, I think they would deny this if you put them on if you put them on the speaker, but they might shake their heads up and down if they weren't on the speaker. You know, they're they're they always seem very reluctant to make that first coin in the higher grade when they know there's gonna be a huge price jump. So I think if there were 25, 25 assets that were just slightly less nice than this one, this coin would go up to 20 to 66. But as I said earlier, a 25 asset in '66 would probably command a $300,000 price.

00:28:26.100 --> 00:28:37.085
So I think there, sometimes the graders are just reluctant to take the coin up to that level. But I agree with you. If I am on this point, I would be trying it for a 66.

00:28:37.085 --> 00:28:59.510
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Now, when you also look at a coin for a collection and you're you're analyzing a coin, you're looking at all all over, how do you, let's say, you know, some of the qualities of the obverse here to with the reverse. If you were to land and take your loop out, you take a look and you're like, oh, you got this reed mark, this kind of heavy reed mark right here in the in the eagle's feathers. How do you look at that? I mean, do you put this coin back down? Obviously not.

00:28:59.510 --> 00:29:13.645
You think... I mean, this is the one of the finest known ones you've ever seen. Right? So from your perspective, what is the most important things? How do you weigh, you know, what qualities of the coin you're gonna choose to, you know, purchase it versus put it back and so forth?

00:29:13.645 --> 00:30:04.985
<v Larry Shepherd>Well, it's about two thirds odd verse and one third reverse. So that mark in the Eagle is not nearly as severe as it would be if it was on the obverse where it's where it'd be much more visible and people tend to choose coins more based on the adverse than the reverse. And so consequently, like I said, as the same size, more kitten in the hair of the the adverse would be viewed as over on the cheek of the of the Miss Liberty or in the left side feel would be viewed more critically than a mark on the eagle. Lot of experience dollars, even the Gemini coins have marks on the eagle because it's a high relief barrier that catches marks. But collectors tend to overlook that a little bit more when they're in the reverse.

00:30:04.985 --> 00:30:18.800
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Yeah. Okay. Makes sense. If it was on the obverse, perhaps it would limit the grade to maybe if it was on the cheek or something in a really key focal area, it might limit the upper grade of, you know, up to a 64 possibly because

00:30:18.800 --> 00:30:31.505
<v Larry Shepherd>it 60 was four plus or 65. That's correct. If it was right there in the middle of the cheek, yeah, that's a killer. You can get away with it on the back on the eagle's feathers, but put that same mark in the middle of the cheek and it's killer.

00:30:31.585 --> 00:30:44.145
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Yeah. Alright. So moving on to this 26 and the image is a little bit a little bit... It's okay. It's not as clear as otherwise, but I think you guys get all the the idea here of the of the coin, but we got this 26 d.

00:30:44.510 --> 00:30:50.670
So how should I approach the 26 Denver coin? I mean, they're usually well, fairly well made it seems, right?

00:30:50.750 --> 00:31:03.325
<v Larry Shepherd>Yeah. There's... There are two d mounts in the Peace Dollar series that really are... Were made extremely well and they have just awesome luster. And the $20.16 is one, the 34 deals together one.

00:31:03.885 --> 00:31:34.595
Is twenty sixteen can be one of the most beautiful points in the entire series. They're not common like that, but they're not overly rare. So you can, if you're putting together a high grade set, you find a really attractive, highly lustrous 26D at a reasonable price. You should be patient enough to find one like that as opposed to just settling for a lackluster piece or a piece that's heavily marked. They can come really nice.

00:31:34.675 --> 00:31:50.000
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>I have to say this has got to be one of the most... The best strike, well, most well struck coins, peace dollars I've I've ever seen. I mean, both sides, the the eagle is just, I mean, you see everything and of course, all of those hair in front of over her ear, I mean, it's just perfect.

00:31:51.000 --> 00:32:19.600
<v Larry Shepherd>Absolutely Yeah. So it's so different because in the earlier years, like I said, the 22D was a higher minage, but much more coily made. The 23D was not as nice as the 2660D, but it was better than the 22D. But the 23D has big die cracks on the on bars, which a lot of people don't mind. Matter of fact, just like you were saying, there are features on that 22D we're looking at to appeal to you.

00:32:19.600 --> 00:32:36.595
Surprisingly, a lot of people like those big die cracks on the 23D and find them interesting. The 26D is the first thing that they seller that just jumps off the page as being really superb quality and superb luster. The luster is just unbeatable on the on the state.

00:32:36.675 --> 00:32:46.710
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Yeah. Yeah. This is absolutely fantastic. I mean, I don't know what this one graded, but this has gotta be pretty high up there. Maybe 66 or 66 plus.

00:32:46.710 --> 00:32:59.270
<v Larry Shepherd>Yeah. When when I had I had two of them that were, you could... Were like identical twins and you couldn't tell them apart. And when I owned them, they were both sixty sixes. I don't know what they are today, but they're both 60 sixes.

00:32:59.555 --> 00:33:04.755
Absolutely They were above 60 sixes while I own them. I'm sure of it probably higher graded now.

00:33:05.075 --> 00:33:15.130
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>All right. So then moving on to another $19.26. This is the absolutely phenomenal coin. It might be one of my favorites of the of the series hero. At least the photography is is excellent.

00:33:15.130 --> 00:33:24.650
This is a twenty six s. Yeah. So the twenty six s, what did you say this is the best truck, a best made pre nineteen thirty s date. So what else do wanna tell us about this one?

00:33:24.730 --> 00:33:45.130
<v Larry Shepherd>It's the best man. It's the best made peace seller of the of the nineteen twenties. And when they're pretty like this, they can just be stunningly beautiful, but they're not all like this. I mean, you you have to kinda search around to to find a nice one, but they can come really, really nice. And this coin is just stunning.

00:33:45.770 --> 00:34:08.935
It's fully struck. It's got great luster, fabulous eye appeal. So finding a coin like this, as I've said in other series, if you're lucky enough to find a coin like this, don't pull your price guide out and your price sheet out and get hung up on the price. Because you buy the coin and walk away and pat yourself on the back because you might not see another one like it for twenty years.

00:34:09.220 --> 00:34:31.435
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Yeah. That... Unfortunately, I mean, that's what I see happen too often. And this is kind of a little bit of a side note, but it happens too often at shows is that a collector comes by, they see a really fantastic coin, and then they get hung up with the differential between the price for the for the coin and where the price guide has to say. It just happened at this past pan show, and it was at o four s Morgan that was in a '64.

00:34:31.435 --> 00:34:56.705
It was a beautiful blast white coin, and I wanted a premium because the coin was exceptionally nice for for for the grade. The collector passed on it and within an hour or two, a dealer came by and paid the price I asked and bought it because they saw the value in, you know, in in the coin and just happens and you feel bad for the the collector who passed it up because simply relying too much on price guides. Yeah. So...

00:34:56.705 --> 00:35:41.450
<v Larry Shepherd>We had we had a a situation just in the in the last week. It wasn't a peach dollar and I won't I won't say what the coin is because that was the the collectors involved may watch this podcast, but we have just a magnificent example, half one, highest grade of a particular coin. And so consequently, wasn't any there wasn't any reliable auction records or or price guide, but the coin was so phenomenal, you know, it's our headband, it probably would have been still been at a substantial premium. And I went to the person I viewed as the likely top buyer of that set, actually the guy who was number one on the registry, but he just got... He got real hung up on the price.

00:35:41.450 --> 00:36:19.685
I mean, the coin was just phenomenal, but he got hung up on the price. So after a waiting turn to make a decision in about a week, we put it up on our website and sold it within like an hour to someone else who said, they'd been looking for this coin for like twenty years. They said they they've been looking for a coin like that in that day for twenty years. So that just shows you that, you know, that's sophisticated collectors. I may have mentioned, I don't recall if we actually talked about it or not in the in the Command Podcast, but I've always told the serious collectors that there is what I call the market above the market.

00:36:19.685 --> 00:36:46.945
Yeah. Which is where coins like this reside and price sheets are just useless in the market of the market. Because when you have the sophisticated collectors who have somewhat more deep pockets, they want a coin like this, they're not gonna get hung up on the price. And so those coins trade out of line with price sheet. Like I said, if you'd like you to share that you see one of those, the old 4 s a good example, it's a very tough coin.

00:36:46.945 --> 00:37:03.910
So if you have a PLO PQO for us, you should not expect to buy that coin out at price sheets, the price that inferior coins sell for. And most price sheet prices are based on interior coins. Most, almost all auction prices are based on interior coins, Tom.

00:37:03.990 --> 00:37:15.895
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Yeah. All right, so moving on to a 28 s. So this is another pretty difficult date. This is in your your top three, right, in terms of the the harder dates in the series?

00:37:15.895 --> 00:37:44.635
<v Larry Shepherd>Yeah. This is historically the the second highest priced date. Now, you go back twenty years ago, it was priced exactly the same as the twenty five s. They were both around on the price guides at about $25,000 But I always felt the 28 was a lot easier to find than the than the 25. Now, recent years, the 28 has moved downward from the 25 somewhat, but it's still the second highest priced peace dollar.

00:37:44.635 --> 00:38:00.520
And I'm not I'm not saying it's an easy coin. It's it's a coin that is plentiful. There are tons of nice ms 64, but the strike really holds it back. The coin we're looking at is a really well struck example for a 28 s. Typically, they're they're not like this.

00:38:00.520 --> 00:38:23.520
That's why a lot of coins, there are a lot of nice looking 28 s's, but they won't like the 65 grade because of the strike. Back in the nineties, I had a 28 s that was just totally flawless. It was white satiny, snowy luster. It looked like the We're gonna look at a picture of a 35 s here in a few minutes. It looked like that like that coin.

00:38:23.520 --> 00:38:50.920
It was just something I had never seen before. If it had had a good strike, the coin would have, you know, I would have graded the coin in of 67, but it had one of the worst strikes I've ever seen for a 28 s. And I couldn't get the coin into any any grade higher than mf 64 for that reason. But but you know, I was just it was a dichotomy because it was just a drop dead gorgeous coin with just a drop dead awful strike.

00:38:50.920 --> 00:39:00.185
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Interesting. Okay. So 34D, this is excellent. I love this coin. This is just really nice, Really nice 34.

00:39:00.185 --> 00:39:17.740
<v Larry Shepherd>It's it's a fabulous coin. It's a fabulous coin and it ranks there with the 26 d as the two best demons. They're both better than the the 27 d could come pretty nice, but 26 D and 34 D are much nicer than than any of the other D mins. This is a great coin.

00:39:17.740 --> 00:39:18.620
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Phenomenal.

00:39:18.700 --> 00:39:24.725
<v Larry Shepherd>This is one of the dates that I've said, cones are two different size mint marks, small mint mark and

00:39:24.725 --> 00:39:28.245
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>large mint mark. I'm assuming this is a small, it looks pretty.

00:39:28.245 --> 00:39:30.245
<v Larry Shepherd>Yes, that looks like a small mint mark.

00:39:30.245 --> 00:39:44.460
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Yeah. Yeah, know 34 Ds, I know them from time to time and they definitely come fairly nice and they make, in my opinion, great type coins. But we'll move on because I know you have, I think you mentioned this. Well, is a 34S. So this is going be a mint state 34S.

00:39:44.460 --> 00:39:59.615
And I think I asked you about like, okay, if a person is trying to buy their 34S for their mint state Peace Dollars set, what should they look for? What things that are important to make sure you find in the coin you select, and so you show me this example here for the 34S.

00:39:59.695 --> 00:40:43.360
<v Larry Shepherd>Well, 34S has always been viewed as one of the key dates of steroids, but it's not nearly as rare as a twenty five s or twenty eight s or even a twenty four s, even though it's priced significantly higher than a than a twenty four s or a twenty seven s, which are scarcer coins. 34 s's can come extremely nice. I've handled five or six of them that are as nice as the coin that we're we're photographing here, but you would never see a a 25 s or a 24 s that looks like this. But it's also a very expensive coin and all sort of all circulated rate. You asked me, what was the value of raid in thirty four hours?

00:40:43.360 --> 00:41:13.000
And it's probably, you know, AU 58. Yeah, what I refer here, this is a coin that is pretty vague of 58, but it's what I have always referred to as an AU 64 or an AU 65. In other words, it's a 6 coin that looks like a 64 or 65, but has just enough minor rub that the... That's a grading services will call it a u. I would much rather own an a u 58 that looks like this than a heavily bag marked m s 63.

00:41:13.000 --> 00:41:59.430
If I'm a little 63 quality coin or the 63 graded coin would have a much higher price tag. So that's one of the things that I always look for in modern dollars and peace dollars are what I call the AU 60 fours and AU 65. Going back to some of the modern dollar, key date modern dollars, 84 S, 92 S, so forth. You can sometimes find the AU coins that have the visual appeal of a 64 or 65, but they're 10% or less than 10% of the price of that just because they have a minor amount of rub. But if you buy a mint state coin in '61 or '62, that it costs 20 times as much, it's probably gonna be a very ugly unattractive coin.

00:41:59.670 --> 00:42:49.765
And so in the thirty four hours, it is the date that I think is overvalued in '65 and '66, just because I've seen so many nice ones over the year. In the population for piece of GSM 65 that's something like $2.25 coins or or something in that range. That's much higher than say 24 s's, let's say $35.34 s's to 25, the 27 s which is price lowers 146 and the 24 s which is even which is also much lower is 133 so it's a much higher population coin now it's not one of those coins that's explained as I've explained the other day to what I'm saying. They're high population coins because so many of that upgrade. The 34 S's can come really nice.

00:42:49.765 --> 00:42:59.040
It's not that hard to find a nice piece. It's a great point, but it's the one point I think is overly promoted and overly priced in the in the high grades.

00:42:59.040 --> 00:43:26.770
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>It's becoming a lot of attention and because of that, the higher demand and, you know, people seek out kind of, you know, key dates, men say key dates and so forth, driving up the price on them, but it's actually more available, more common than you're mentioning some of these other estimates from the 1920s. So yeah, good information, good value information from folks out there looking to go in and go to shows and find some some great value out there potentially. All right. And so then we have our quintessential type coin, 19

00:43:26.770 --> 00:43:47.475
<v Larry Shepherd>Yeah. 35 should admit, if I was only looking for one piece dollar for my type set, I would kick in a few extra bucks instead of buying a 22, 23, 24, 25 p, which are Yeah. Extremely common. And I would I would love for a 20... A 35 s like this because when they come nice, they're absolutely the most beautiful peace dollars of all.

00:43:47.690 --> 00:44:06.175
Extremely well made. The the luster is is very satiny. It's very brilliant. And I see I see 35 s's that I compare to looking out my bedroom window on a on a winter morning and seeing there's a fresh snowfall and it's it's pristine. There's no there are no tracks in it.

00:44:06.175 --> 00:44:19.460
There's no dirt or anything. Just if you if you live in the Northern Clang, that's where where you get snow like that, you'll know what I'm talking about. That's that's what these 35 s's can sometimes look like. They're just they're just dropped out gorgeous.

00:44:19.540 --> 00:44:23.700
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Yeah. Yeah. No. They're very... This one is absolutely killer.

00:44:23.700 --> 00:44:29.060
This coin has gotta be at least in the 66, well, 67. Right. Like the seventh.

00:44:29.140 --> 00:44:30.500
<v Larry Shepherd>I think it was a 66 plus.

00:44:30.715 --> 00:44:35.115
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>A 66 plus. Okay. Yeah. Mark's kinda heavy, but it is what it is. Alright.

00:44:35.115 --> 00:44:44.955
So the last thing we wanted to talk about is color on peace dollars. This is an important topic, folks, because there are some colorful peace dollars, but you're of the opinion that a lot of this is artificial. Let's you take it away.

00:44:45.280 --> 00:45:30.395
<v Larry Shepherd>Well, I've looked at tens of thousands, maybe a 100 thousands of peace dollars over the years. I actually sold one collector 70,000 men's state peace dollars. And in the 1980s, 1990s and early 2000s up until COVID, it was very, almost impossible, very rare to see a colorful tone peace dollar that pretty much just didn't exist. And now there were ugly tone coins that had gotten ugly because of poor storage or whatever. But whereas there are dramatically beautiful Morgan dollars because of the bag storage, the peace sellers, they don't have the right kind of surfaces to develop the same kind of toning that the Morgan dollars do.

00:45:30.395 --> 00:45:59.105
Toning forms best on coins that have hard mirrored surfaces, like a of Morgan dollars. So when they were stored in in bags and bank vaults for for sixty or seventy years, they often took on just awesome color. And there's there's thousands of beautifully toned Morgan Dollars around. But you don't see the Peace Dollars with with that kind of awesome toning and you don't see it with the same colors as on the more... Morgan dollars.

00:45:59.185 --> 00:46:28.795
So suddenly, just in the last two or three years, the market just seems to be flooded with tone peace dollars. And and I'm of the opinion that the whole tone dollar market is in a little bit of a speculative bubble right now with prices getting pushed up to some very, very high levels for the quality of the coin. And that's happening with the peace dollars as well. These peace dollars that are coming out of the woodwork are bringing very high prices. I'm not saying they're artificially towed, I don't know.

00:46:28.795 --> 00:46:55.485
But I'm just saying that I'm seeing far more of them now than I ever did in the first thirty five years or so. I work with these dollars and so my advice on that would be buyer be aware. Now, let me read you a quote from David Hall because I pulled this aside. You all know who David Hall is, founder of Peace suggests. I'm the guy who really set the grading standards for Peace suggests.

00:46:55.645 --> 00:47:37.290
And David, I'm gonna read this. This is a word for word exactly. He said, I am of the very strong opinion that any peace dollar that has any rainbow colors, blue, green, red, etcetera, is absolutely artificially toned. While not very scientific, my approach to toning on coins is to remember the colors I saw in the nineteen sixties and nineteen seventies, and if a new look appears, it's artificial to me. This is kind of an old school approach, and I may be wrong, but unless you believe global warming has created new colors for coins, it just seems illogical to me that new colors would suddenly appear naturally on coins.

00:47:37.850 --> 00:48:05.060
I may not be as harsh as that in my comments, and I wasn't around in the sixties and seventies, but I can say, as I mentioned a while ago, based on my experience in the eighties and nineties and the early two thousands, those kinds of coins weren't around or except maybe once a year or once every two years or something like that. So yeah, I kind of agree with what David is saying in that comment.

00:48:05.140 --> 00:48:05.620
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Okay.

00:48:05.620 --> 00:48:46.585
<v Larry Shepherd>Now the 22 that you have up there, that's a different story. If I won't go through the whole process of talking about the evolution what I call California Toning. If you're interested in learning more about that, Tony's Podcast number 45, where we've talked about Coneverus. And I went through a long explanation of the artificially tone commems that people in the commem world refer to as California toning. But the problem that I see now is even though that toning has been around since the early 90s and I and I taught, I took those point, I'm the one who exposed that as artificial.

00:48:46.585 --> 00:49:15.075
And I took it to the grading services, both pieces of just meant you see at the time and said, look, these coins are artificial. Here's how you can tell the diagnostics and you need to show these to your graders and so because they're getting through it because the coins are not criticized like radius, the coins for you. I mean, they fooled me. Only reason I found out about it was I bought three or four of them in a very short order. I came to realize that I bought three or four commems that absolutely do not tone the same way.

00:49:15.075 --> 00:49:46.550
And that's when I started looking more closely, then I started seeing more coins. So I bought up seven or eight of them and I took them to David Hall and I really started studying them. What I noticed is that the toning can be very beautiful when they're fresh, when they're newly made, blue, green, kind of purple and red, they all have the same tonings, colors, and they all have the same pattern. If you can look at this coin closely, tell it to blow up. The pattern is it looks like cracked mud.

00:49:46.630 --> 00:50:00.710
Was my description of it is. Yep. There are there are little fine lines that that kinda look like the... Like a dried up pond surface. And that was the diagnostics that that we looked for.

00:50:00.885 --> 00:50:35.355
Now, those have been around for a long time. Got services the to mostly stop grading them in the nineties. And then when eBay came along and you could sell colorfully toned coins, even though they were artificial. On eBay, they foraged again, they came out like all over the place. And for three or four years after eBay came into existence, every time I'd go to a coin show, some collector would come up to my table over like side and say, Hey, Larry, I just gotta show you this amazing command like I bought on eBay last week.

00:50:35.355 --> 00:51:11.620
And I would know right away what they were gonna pull out of briefcase. And so, the coins were being sold raw then. And now we are seeing the market getting flooded with these coins again, in commems and peace dollars and Morgan dollars and walking Liberty House and Washington porters. And I suspect that's because, you know, we have had total total turnover in the grading force of the graders who who are grading now compared to the ones who are grading in the 1990s. A lot of the graders are grading now and I'm not I'm not putting them down.

00:51:11.700 --> 00:51:37.370
They're quite they're quite most cases quite talented. But many of these guys weren't even born when California toning came into existence back in 1991 or 1992. So they haven't been taught to look for it. So these coins are coming back out on the market. You really need to be careful of them because while they can be very, very attractive in their initial life, they change.

00:51:37.690 --> 00:52:00.855
And this is a coin that where it has already gone through considerable amount of change. The changes of the reds, greens, and the blues that are very attractive, turned to gray. And then after a few more years, they turned pretty much black, charcoal ish. So this is something you really need to be to be aware of and be careful. If you see these...

00:52:00.855 --> 00:52:32.705
The red, blue, green looks like this and with that craft mud appearance, run as fast as you can, no matter how much how beautiful the coin looks. And there are a lot of them on the market. I've seen, we've seen quite a few this year in all of those series. Now, as I said, if for anyone, I know a lot of your viewers watch all of your all of your episodes. So I won't go through the whole process because many of your viewers saw that when we talked to you about them and come out.

00:52:32.705 --> 00:52:42.040
But if you're new and didn't see that, then go back to that. And if you're interested, go back to that podcast and and and I go through the whole sequence of events.

00:52:42.040 --> 00:52:55.265
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Alright. Very good. Very good. We're kinda getting short on time, so we'll kind of, I think we'll we'll we'll wrap it up wrap it up there. This episode's probably going to release on the week of the Whitman Expo in Baltimore.

00:52:55.265 --> 00:52:56.705
Are you planning to attend it?

00:52:56.705 --> 00:53:01.505
<v Larry Shepherd>I'm not gonna be able to attend this time, but I will have three of my staff members there.

00:53:01.505 --> 00:53:17.240
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Okay. Alright. Alright. Well, next time when one of you guys out there see Larry at the show, be sure to walk up to his case and just ask to buy any coin site unseen, and I'm sure Larry will be happy to to to get you hooked up with a really nice commemorative or peace dollar or whatever. Come out to Baltimore show.

00:53:17.240 --> 00:53:27.295
I will be at Table 655, and yeah, hopefully, hopefully I'll get a chance to see you at the fun show. I mean, that's the that's the big one, right? So hopefully we'll get together then.

00:53:27.295 --> 00:53:29.775
<v Larry Shepherd>Okay. Sounds great, Charlie. Thank you for having me.

00:53:29.775 --> 00:53:32.975
<v Tony Gryckiewicz>Alright. Sounds good. See you, Larry. Thank you so much. Alright.

00:53:32.975 --> 00:53:33.695
Take care.

00:53:33.695 --> 00:53:34.015
<v Larry Shepherd>Bye.
