WEBVTT

00:00:00.005 --> 00:00:03.545
<v Alice>In the end, you want all your shows to have that surprise of the first time

00:00:03.545 --> 00:00:05.025
<v Alice>you watch The Usual Suspects.

00:00:05.125 --> 00:00:09.205
<v Alice>And at the end of the show, you're like, ah, Kevin Spacey was a rapist all along.

00:00:12.825 --> 00:00:18.325
<v Stu>This episode is being brought to you by ScriptUp, which are expert story and script consultants.

00:00:18.525 --> 00:00:23.885
<v Stu>They're listeners of the show. And they reached out to us and demonstrated, demonstrated.

00:00:24.425 --> 00:00:28.265
<v Chas>Being fans helped their cause. But what got them across the line is the fact

00:00:28.265 --> 00:00:33.265
<v Chas>that they offered us use of their services and you and I just finished a script

00:00:33.265 --> 00:00:35.425
<v Chas>that we needed independent feedback from.

00:00:35.605 --> 00:00:38.945
<v Chas>We got an amazing detailed report from them.

00:00:39.065 --> 00:00:44.105
<v Chas>But for me, what most sort of coverage and competition and feedback services

00:00:44.105 --> 00:00:47.425
<v Chas>lack is that actual back and forth and to and fro on stories.

00:00:47.885 --> 00:00:53.905
<v Chas>And ScriptUp builds into their feedback an actual Zoom call, which was fantastic.

00:00:54.425 --> 00:00:58.545
<v Stu>So if you're looking for an experienced, independent insight into how your story

00:00:58.545 --> 00:01:01.725
<v Stu>is working or not working, consider using ScriptUp.

00:01:02.025 --> 00:01:05.905
<v Chas>Yeah. And they don't do any of that promise of access bullshit.

00:01:05.905 --> 00:01:09.305
<v Chas>Like if you pay us X number of thousands of dollars, there's a chance that we

00:01:09.305 --> 00:01:12.305
<v Chas>may just circulate your script to blah, blah, blah.

00:01:12.325 --> 00:01:15.625
<v Chas>So they're just about making your story work.

00:01:15.625 --> 00:01:19.905
<v Stu>And if you tell them that DraftZero sent you, by using the promo code DZ10,

00:01:19.905 --> 00:01:24.325
<v Stu>as in the letters D, Z, and then the number 10, you'll get 10% off.

00:01:24.525 --> 00:01:27.785
<v Stu>Just see the link in the show notes with the promo code in there.

00:01:28.665 --> 00:01:32.185
<v Chas>And now for Front Matter.

00:01:33.687 --> 00:01:35.267
<v Stu>Isn't this the front matter?

00:01:42.667 --> 00:01:44.127
<v Chas>Hi, I'm Chas Fisher.

00:01:44.347 --> 00:01:45.607
<v Stu>And I'm Stu Willis.

00:01:45.827 --> 00:01:50.007
<v Chas>And welcome to Draft Zero, a podcast where we normally work out what makes great

00:01:50.007 --> 00:01:52.427
<v Chas>screenplays work, but today...

00:01:52.427 --> 00:01:59.627
<v Stu>We are trying to work out what tools screenwriters can take from stand-up comedy specials.

00:02:00.367 --> 00:02:04.507
<v Stu>It's storytellers, stand-up comedians are fantastic storytellers that can hold

00:02:04.507 --> 00:02:08.227
<v Stu>your attention for an hour, an hour and a half, a couple of hours.

00:02:08.427 --> 00:02:14.727
<v Stu>And we think they've got some great tools to teach us that we can use in our own screenwriting.

00:02:14.887 --> 00:02:18.107
<v Stu>And we are joined by a wonderful special guest, Alice Fraser,

00:02:18.587 --> 00:02:23.247
<v Stu>a comedian, podcaster, documentarian, just all-round fantastic human.

00:02:23.727 --> 00:02:24.867
<v Stu>Welcome to the show, Alice.

00:02:25.527 --> 00:02:26.807
<v Alice>Hello. Thank you for having me.

00:02:27.107 --> 00:02:28.967
<v Stu>And, Taz, what are we going to be looking at?

00:02:28.967 --> 00:02:34.487
<v Chas>Okay, so we're going to have some discussion around Alice's amazing show,

00:02:34.487 --> 00:02:39.027
<v Chas>Savage, which is available on Amazon Prime here in Australia,

00:02:39.027 --> 00:02:41.607
<v Chas>and I presume around the globe.

00:02:41.787 --> 00:02:46.047
<v Stu>And in podcast form as well, isn't it? It's still in podcast form, get through ABC.

00:02:46.327 --> 00:02:51.547
<v Chas>And we're also going to look at the specials Nanette by Hannah Gadsby,

00:02:51.887 --> 00:02:57.667
<v Chas>Baby Cobra by Ali Wong, and It's the Fireworks Talking by Daniel Kitson.

00:02:57.667 --> 00:03:01.087
<v Stu>All right, so why did we decide to do this, Chaz?

00:03:01.587 --> 00:03:05.527
<v Chas>Maybe because we're all in lockdown and we all just needed to,

00:03:05.527 --> 00:03:09.627
<v Chas>like, inject six hours of comedy into our veins.

00:03:10.067 --> 00:03:13.147
<v Stu>And more interestingly, why did Alice decide to join us?

00:03:13.247 --> 00:03:18.067
<v Alice>I am also in lockdown and my motivation is much more sinister.

00:03:19.147 --> 00:03:23.047
<v Alice>By analysing comedy, I promise to take the joy out of it for you.

00:03:23.427 --> 00:03:25.047
<v Alice>I'm just sharing the pain.

00:03:25.307 --> 00:03:27.087
<v Stu>So there's two interesting things that...

00:03:27.313 --> 00:03:32.433
<v Stu>Audiences should know about you, which is that you, and I'm quoting you,

00:03:32.653 --> 00:03:35.573
<v Stu>is you've got this view of the world that's the empirical versus the poetic.

00:03:35.793 --> 00:03:40.893
<v Stu>And as we talked about in our pre-talk, Draft Zero is about finding the empirical in the poetic.

00:03:41.053 --> 00:03:46.293
<v Stu>And more specifically with your show, Shavage, you've translated it from a stage

00:03:46.293 --> 00:03:53.773
<v Stu>show into a stand-up, a recorded special, and also that you are looking at developing it into a series,

00:03:53.993 --> 00:03:56.493
<v Stu>right? So moving it from stand-up into drama.

00:03:56.773 --> 00:03:59.493
<v Stu>So, it's that kind of combination of the analytical mind, but thinking about

00:03:59.493 --> 00:04:02.773
<v Stu>how the slight differences in long-form storytelling.

00:04:03.053 --> 00:04:06.073
<v Stu>So, stand-ups are long-form storytelling, right?

00:04:06.233 --> 00:04:10.073
<v Stu>And it feels to me that they use some techniques that are similar and some techniques

00:04:10.073 --> 00:04:12.193
<v Stu>that are different from drama.

00:04:12.533 --> 00:04:16.133
<v Stu>And we spend a lot of time thinking about screenwriting and talking about screenwriting,

00:04:16.213 --> 00:04:22.453
<v Stu>but we're very specifically looking at drama as kind of a meta-genre of what we're talking about.

00:04:22.813 --> 00:04:26.273
<v Stu>And just as a note, this originally started as a, because we were interested

00:04:26.273 --> 00:04:30.333
<v Stu>in talking about Bo Burnham's Inside, but we watched it and don't feel like

00:04:30.333 --> 00:04:32.933
<v Stu>it's a comedy special in the way you think about it.

00:04:32.973 --> 00:04:37.653
<v Stu>It's kind of like a film essay, like If It's For Fake or Sans Soleil,

00:04:37.793 --> 00:04:39.673
<v Stu>that draws inspiration for comedy specials.

00:04:39.733 --> 00:04:43.133
<v Stu>So we might talk about it, but it's so much more immersed in film form.

00:04:43.333 --> 00:04:46.053
<v Stu>And where what you do, when you see Alice's show, other than

00:04:46.053 --> 00:04:48.753
<v Stu>you pulling out a ukulele occasionally doing a little

00:04:48.753 --> 00:04:55.953
<v Stu>bit of a music banjo sorry how dare you yes you are largely holding people's

00:04:55.953 --> 00:05:00.133
<v Stu>attention with just the story that you were telling so i mean we let let's talk

00:05:00.133 --> 00:05:04.553
<v Stu>about the process of translating to a show because i think taking savage talking

00:05:04.553 --> 00:05:08.493
<v Stu>about what savage is and then moving into the show before we analyze um nanette.

00:05:08.493 --> 00:05:13.893
<v Chas>Yeah now alice do you want to pitch us what Savage is as a stand-up show or

00:05:13.893 --> 00:05:16.873
<v Chas>should we go to the Wikipedia summary and read it out?

00:05:17.133 --> 00:05:24.013
<v Alice>Oh, God, I don't think I could bear a Wikipedia summary. It's a show about... about loss.

00:05:26.094 --> 00:05:28.854
<v Excerpts>So there are going to be points in this show where you're not going to be sure

00:05:28.854 --> 00:05:31.814
<v Excerpts>if you should laugh or feel sorry for me. I suggest you laugh.

00:05:33.434 --> 00:05:38.934
<v Excerpts>If you don't laugh, this shit still happened, but it will have happened for nothing.

00:05:46.214 --> 00:05:47.534
<v Excerpts>And that is on you.

00:05:49.034 --> 00:05:52.334
<v Alice>I think a lot of people think of it as a show about death, but it's not.

00:05:52.334 --> 00:05:56.074
<v Alice>It's a show about the slow process of losing someone you love.

00:05:57.034 --> 00:06:02.514
<v Alice>And for me, there's one important moment in the show that I begin with that

00:06:02.514 --> 00:06:07.234
<v Alice>I want to bring people to an understanding of the emotional impact of that moment.

00:06:07.354 --> 00:06:12.634
<v Alice>So I start with the moment and then I come back to it later with kind of the import.

00:06:12.794 --> 00:06:16.434
<v Alice>So the whole structure of Savage is kind of your unloaded gun,

00:06:16.694 --> 00:06:23.054
<v Alice>loaded gun scenario. I repeatedly introduce ideas with low stakes only to bring

00:06:23.054 --> 00:06:24.174
<v Alice>them back with higher stakes.

00:06:24.774 --> 00:06:29.314
<v Alice>So I think, is that a summary of a show? I don't know. That's the way I think of the show anyway.

00:06:29.634 --> 00:06:33.354
<v Chas>And I was just about to like give an example from your show,

00:06:33.354 --> 00:06:39.774
<v Chas>but you have warned me quite fairly that comics hate non-comics,

00:06:39.974 --> 00:06:43.174
<v Chas>repeating a joke back to them and getting it completely wrong.

00:06:43.514 --> 00:06:46.354
<v Alice>So I'm here to correct you, so it's all right. It's all right.

00:06:46.354 --> 00:06:51.094
<v Chas>But like setups and payoffs is something that we're going to talk about throughout all the shows.

00:06:51.214 --> 00:06:56.094
<v Chas>But you had what I thought was like a throwaway joke about buttholes.

00:06:57.434 --> 00:07:00.154
<v Excerpts>That is what is wrong with everything that we live in a world where everything

00:07:00.154 --> 00:07:02.734
<v Excerpts>has to look good and smell good and taste good and not have hair on it.

00:07:04.694 --> 00:07:07.454
<v Excerpts>This is the slippery slope that leads to anal bleaching.

00:07:10.754 --> 00:07:12.914
<v Excerpts>You know, that's a thing now. It's not just sitting on a lemon.

00:07:16.354 --> 00:07:19.814
<v Excerpts>People pay and they've got like a Bunnings paint colour chart to figure out what shade,

00:07:22.978 --> 00:07:29.678
<v Excerpts>If you take nothing else away from this show, let it be these three facts.

00:07:30.678 --> 00:07:36.198
<v Excerpts>Buttholes are brown. They are meant to be brown. And we are all going to die.

00:07:37.238 --> 00:07:44.578
<v Chas>That then suddenly comes back at the end of your show to be hugely painful and poignant.

00:07:44.778 --> 00:07:49.418
<v Chas>And this incredible foreshadowing. And you do bring the buttholes back throughout.

00:07:49.418 --> 00:07:53.258
<v Stu>It sort of appealed to Chaz's sense of very fecal-orientated humour.

00:07:54.798 --> 00:07:59.258
<v Alice>Yeah, I think sometimes what I think stand-up is really good for,

00:07:59.398 --> 00:08:02.438
<v Alice>and there's so many different kinds of stand-up. I should start with that.

00:08:02.498 --> 00:08:05.018
<v Alice>There's so many different things that you can do with comedy and so many different

00:08:05.018 --> 00:08:08.938
<v Alice>things that people legitimately do with comedy, from giving just ridiculous

00:08:08.938 --> 00:08:14.298
<v Alice>relief from the stresses of the world to dealing with quite difficult and complicated ideas.

00:08:14.298 --> 00:08:19.498
<v Alice>The thing that I quite like doing is reaching for difficult things,

00:08:19.718 --> 00:08:23.678
<v Alice>really hard things that are hard to grasp or hard to wrap your mind around or

00:08:23.678 --> 00:08:27.518
<v Alice>even hard to pay attention to because they're emotionally painful and using

00:08:27.518 --> 00:08:31.898
<v Alice>comedy to kind of make people open to those ideas.

00:08:32.158 --> 00:08:35.618
<v Alice>And the reason I called the show Savage is because I feel to a certain extent

00:08:35.618 --> 00:08:39.778
<v Alice>that's quite a cruel thing to do sometimes to force people to look at stuff

00:08:39.778 --> 00:08:41.298
<v Alice>they might not necessarily want to do.

00:08:41.298 --> 00:08:50.498
<v Alice>And that includes this sort of combination of visceral and brutal humanity and silliness.

00:08:50.758 --> 00:08:57.238
<v Alice>The butthole is about confronting our deep vulnerability and our humanity and

00:08:57.238 --> 00:09:02.738
<v Alice>the pain and sort of the horrifying indignities of chronic illness, but also...

00:09:03.977 --> 00:09:05.537
<v Alice>In a way that people can absorb.

00:09:07.117 --> 00:09:10.737
<v Stu>It does make me think of, I think,

00:09:10.897 --> 00:09:13.897
<v Stu>that kind of structure of starting with something that's either the silliness

00:09:13.897 --> 00:09:19.997
<v Stu>or seemingly slight and then pushing deeper and deeper is something that I think

00:09:19.997 --> 00:09:22.677
<v Stu>all the comedy specials that we're going to look at do. I mean,

00:09:22.797 --> 00:09:23.797
<v Stu>and Savage, no exception.

00:09:23.997 --> 00:09:27.017
<v Stu>We should say that, yes, there are many different types of stand-up comedy,

00:09:27.097 --> 00:09:32.357
<v Stu>and obviously Chaz and I are now filtering of picked stuff that has got a larger

00:09:32.357 --> 00:09:36.757
<v Stu>pattern to it, right? All of them, on some level, come full circle,

00:09:36.957 --> 00:09:38.537
<v Stu>is the very basic structure.

00:09:38.737 --> 00:09:42.937
<v Stu>We didn't pick something that's just a series of skits, for lack of a better word.

00:09:44.757 --> 00:09:50.057
<v Stu>We're possibly going to be using the incorrect non-comedian jargon for this kind of stuff.

00:09:50.617 --> 00:09:56.677
<v Stu>Also, that kind of theme. All of the specials are really focused on some kind of unifying idea.

00:09:57.557 --> 00:10:00.557
<v Stu>I don't think Savage is any exception, but when you structured the show,

00:10:00.637 --> 00:10:03.897
<v Stu>this is what I'm kind of curious. I don't want this to turn into an interview,

00:10:03.957 --> 00:10:06.197
<v Stu>but it's really interesting to hear you talk about it because I think it will

00:10:06.197 --> 00:10:08.177
<v Stu>help us analyze how other people do it.

00:10:08.417 --> 00:10:11.197
<v Stu>Did you start off with that kind of circular structure and go,

00:10:11.317 --> 00:10:15.017
<v Stu>I'm going to start off with something that's offhand, the unloaded gun,

00:10:15.077 --> 00:10:17.037
<v Stu>and then you're going to load it or tightening the spring?

00:10:17.577 --> 00:10:20.477
<v Alice>So part of it is just feeling out the audience as you go.

00:10:20.717 --> 00:10:27.097
<v Alice>The story of me doing the show the first time was that mum was in the palliative

00:10:27.097 --> 00:10:31.737
<v Alice>care ward and I rang the Sydney Comedy Festival and said, I cannot do a show.

00:10:32.337 --> 00:10:36.537
<v Alice>I can't do a show. And they said, Shane Smith at the Sydney Comedy Festival,

00:10:36.557 --> 00:10:37.417
<v Alice>I'll always be grateful.

00:10:37.557 --> 00:10:40.837
<v Alice>He said, you can cancel until five minutes before the doors open.

00:10:41.137 --> 00:10:43.137
<v Alice>So don't worry about it. Don't think about it.

00:10:43.677 --> 00:10:48.657
<v Alice>And so I went in and I literally had printed out all the jokes I was working

00:10:48.657 --> 00:10:51.757
<v Alice>on at the time, all the jokes that I was doing in sets and all the jokes that

00:10:51.757 --> 00:10:53.217
<v Alice>I'd written and tweets and everything.

00:10:53.497 --> 00:11:00.257
<v Alice>And I printed out this story about my encounter with the guy who I call Dick in the show.

00:11:00.737 --> 00:11:04.217
<v Alice>And I had literally, I had two stools, one on each side, and I was,

00:11:04.337 --> 00:11:07.957
<v Alice>how many jokes do I need to tell before I can tell another thing?

00:11:09.140 --> 00:11:10.260
<v Alice>Bit of this story.

00:11:12.740 --> 00:11:17.900
<v Alice>So before I can sort of smack you in the face again. So it was the initial kind

00:11:17.900 --> 00:11:22.200
<v Alice>of feeling out of the show in the very first kind of trial of it was just that,

00:11:22.360 --> 00:11:27.860
<v Alice>trying to balance out how much I could demand of them and how much I needed

00:11:27.860 --> 00:11:29.440
<v Alice>to make them feel comfortable again.

00:11:29.980 --> 00:11:33.860
<v Alice>And so that, I think, was the first stage.

00:11:33.860 --> 00:11:38.000
<v Alice>So I didn't plan it out as having that circular structure, but I realized slowly

00:11:38.000 --> 00:11:42.300
<v Alice>that if you introduce this idea in a harmless form, then they're willing to

00:11:42.300 --> 00:11:47.700
<v Alice>swallow it later, when if you presented it raw out front, they would recoil.

00:11:48.560 --> 00:11:54.620
<v Alice>So that happens repeatedly from the first story I tell about Mark Abercrombie all the way through.

00:11:55.520 --> 00:12:01.000
<v Alice>You get the idea in a harmless form, and then you get it kind of as a full dose,

00:12:01.000 --> 00:12:03.140
<v Alice>and I find that quite satisfying as well.

00:12:03.140 --> 00:12:05.880
<v Stu>I mean, Baby Coppa, I noticed, was doing that.

00:12:05.980 --> 00:12:10.020
<v Stu>She would almost go for the cliched joke, the obvious joke, and then use that

00:12:10.020 --> 00:12:15.760
<v Stu>as the way in to kind of push you further and further before she – or deepen the joke.

00:12:15.880 --> 00:12:21.680
<v Stu>I mean, her purpose seems a little less emotionally driven than what you were

00:12:21.680 --> 00:12:25.580
<v Stu>doing, but it's that same kind of structural idea, I think. Yes.

00:12:25.840 --> 00:12:31.160
<v Alice>And interestingly, I think you're sort of, as a female comedian on stage,

00:12:31.400 --> 00:12:35.920
<v Alice>and particularly as an Asian American female comedian on stage,

00:12:36.300 --> 00:12:40.240
<v Alice>just being on stage and saying anything is a political statement.

00:12:40.960 --> 00:12:48.440
<v Alice>So the first thing she has to do is just be funny. And that in itself is kind of a political act.

00:12:49.480 --> 00:12:57.660
<v Excerpts>I can tell that I'm getting older because now when I see an 18-year-old girl,

00:12:58.140 --> 00:13:03.400
<v Excerpts>my automatic thought is, fuck you.

00:13:04.580 --> 00:13:06.700
<v Alice>And so I think...

00:13:07.681 --> 00:13:10.701
<v Alice>The fact that she doesn't then do a kind of an Edinburgh-style show,

00:13:10.821 --> 00:13:13.621
<v Alice>first of all, she's working in the American format, which is quite different

00:13:13.621 --> 00:13:16.581
<v Alice>from the English and Australian festival circuit format.

00:13:17.401 --> 00:13:20.381
<v Stu>I'm going to interrogate you about that because that's interesting, but go on.

00:13:21.181 --> 00:13:26.841
<v Alice>But yeah, I feel like the story that she's telling is partly told by her presence on stage.

00:13:27.061 --> 00:13:33.241
<v Alice>And, you know, again, this is where kind of the screenwriting part of it comes in.

00:13:33.821 --> 00:13:37.241
<v Alice>One of the things you realize when you put something on screen is that there

00:13:37.241 --> 00:13:43.301
<v Alice>there's a story that is told by the picture as well as by the words and her

00:13:43.301 --> 00:13:48.721
<v Alice>being like visibly pregnant on stage is also telling a story just her doing

00:13:48.721 --> 00:13:53.541
<v Alice>that on stage is telling a story at the same time as all of the jokes that she tells and.

00:13:53.541 --> 00:13:58.021
<v Stu>Very early Hannah Gadsby and Annette brings up the fact that you know that she's

00:13:58.021 --> 00:14:02.641
<v Stu>been mistaken for a man that's kind of really an early part of her set is dealing

00:14:02.641 --> 00:14:07.381
<v Stu>with that kind of visual element, her presence there, her being misgendered.

00:14:08.601 --> 00:14:12.981
<v Excerpts>Now, I don't feel comfortable in a small town. I get a bit tense,

00:14:13.381 --> 00:14:15.461
<v Excerpts>mainly because I'm in this situation.

00:14:16.541 --> 00:14:19.401
<v Excerpts>And in a small town, that's all right from a distance.

00:14:20.793 --> 00:14:26.153
<v Excerpts>People are like, oh, good bloke. And then you get a bit closer and it's like,

00:14:26.253 --> 00:14:28.133
<v Excerpts>oh, no, no, trickster woman, what are you doing?

00:14:30.733 --> 00:14:36.133
<v Alice>Yes, well, that whole show is sort of about mistaken identities and sort of

00:14:36.133 --> 00:14:39.293
<v Alice>where things are mistakes and where they're malicious and where they're done

00:14:39.293 --> 00:14:43.653
<v Alice>purposefully and where they're not done purposefully and telling half the story

00:14:43.653 --> 00:14:45.293
<v Alice>versus telling all of the story.

00:14:46.073 --> 00:14:51.413
<v Alice>So her telling you that she is often mistaken for a man, And I think of as a

00:14:51.413 --> 00:14:55.673
<v Alice>way of introducing that idea of what she is and isn't mistaken for.

00:14:55.933 --> 00:14:59.913
<v Stu>I'm going to put a pin in that because I do want to come back to that when we break down the net.

00:15:00.333 --> 00:15:04.413
<v Stu>I just think it's just finding these connections now. I want to come back to

00:15:04.413 --> 00:15:05.893
<v Stu>the format thing, right?

00:15:06.053 --> 00:15:08.593
<v Stu>Like, because it's not something like, it's a format.

00:15:08.793 --> 00:15:11.293
<v Stu>Okay, of course it's a format. And that's going to be a structural thing.

00:15:11.433 --> 00:15:13.773
<v Stu>And so I'm going to be particularly thinking about it, like,

00:15:13.873 --> 00:15:15.933
<v Stu>because we get too often hammered with screenwriting that there's,

00:15:16.153 --> 00:15:19.233
<v Stu>and now that you may be looking at screenwriting, I know you said you've got

00:15:19.233 --> 00:15:20.993
<v Stu>a master's. narrative rhetoric.

00:15:22.173 --> 00:15:24.553
<v Alice>Yes. From Cambridge University, yes.

00:15:25.293 --> 00:15:29.033
<v Stu>But, you know, we've got, like, the hero's journey is a dominant way of telling

00:15:29.033 --> 00:15:31.453
<v Stu>stories, right, in Western screenwriting.

00:15:31.653 --> 00:15:35.013
<v Stu>And then there's so many versions of it, whether it's Dan Harmon's Story Circle

00:15:35.013 --> 00:15:37.393
<v Stu>or Save the Cat, they're all variations of it, right?

00:15:37.553 --> 00:15:39.473
<v Stu>But what's interesting is when you see different structures,

00:15:39.693 --> 00:15:40.993
<v Stu>right, and they all serve different purposes.

00:15:41.213 --> 00:15:44.973
<v Stu>And it's interesting because I think you are perhaps more liberated in stand-up

00:15:44.973 --> 00:15:49.393
<v Stu>to pursue different things. What is the difference between an Edinburgh format

00:15:49.393 --> 00:15:51.573
<v Stu>and a Sydney format and an American format?

00:15:52.613 --> 00:15:58.673
<v Alice>So, the Edinburgh and Australia, the UK and Australia structure of a show is –.

00:15:59.799 --> 00:16:04.239
<v Alice>Influenced by the festival circuit, which is that you have a one-hour show,

00:16:04.359 --> 00:16:09.719
<v Alice>you book these one-hour slots into the venues because that's the size of slot

00:16:09.719 --> 00:16:11.639
<v Alice>the venue offers you unless you're a very famous act.

00:16:11.699 --> 00:16:16.939
<v Alice>So you have an hour to work with and you're competing with, in Edinburgh,

00:16:17.099 --> 00:16:21.059
<v Alice>3,000 other shows and you have to be memorable.

00:16:21.319 --> 00:16:27.339
<v Alice>So an hour of jokes just doesn't cut it. People don't remember you because there's

00:16:27.339 --> 00:16:29.019
<v Alice>nothing distinctive about you necessarily.

00:16:29.999 --> 00:16:34.039
<v Alice>But also, in addition, if you're turning over a new hour every year for the

00:16:34.039 --> 00:16:37.119
<v Alice>festival circuit, you have to turn over a whole new hour.

00:16:37.259 --> 00:16:41.699
<v Alice>That lends itself more to storytelling than just to joke writing because joke

00:16:41.699 --> 00:16:44.199
<v Alice>writing is very, very energy intensive.

00:16:44.459 --> 00:16:49.239
<v Alice>In America, they're all, or certainly until recently, until the kind of Louis C.K.

00:16:49.859 --> 00:16:55.959
<v Alice>Era, Netflix era, content machine era, their pressure was to make a five-minute

00:16:55.959 --> 00:16:59.859
<v Alice>set for television, that you would get a five-minute set for television,

00:16:59.959 --> 00:17:01.919
<v Alice>you'd get on Conan or you'd get on late-night shows.

00:17:02.139 --> 00:17:08.259
<v Alice>So what you had was people honing five minutes for years and then maybe 20 minutes

00:17:08.259 --> 00:17:10.859
<v Alice>and then that would be their headline set.

00:17:11.159 --> 00:17:14.499
<v Alice>And they would have that and they would work that And then they would build

00:17:14.499 --> 00:17:19.239
<v Alice>an hour from these small pieces, which is why American stand-up specials tend

00:17:19.239 --> 00:17:23.579
<v Alice>to come across as more disconnected, more just jokey bits.

00:17:24.779 --> 00:17:26.739
<v Alice>You know, five-minute bits or 10-minute bits.

00:17:26.759 --> 00:17:30.579
<v Alice>And they might sort of cohere and there might be a structure that emerges or

00:17:30.579 --> 00:17:33.979
<v Alice>themes that emerge by virtue of what they're interested in as people.

00:17:34.899 --> 00:17:39.599
<v Alice>But the pressure of the festival circuit is that you have to hold the audience's

00:17:39.599 --> 00:17:44.119
<v Alice>attention for the hour. and there's a way that audiences' energy moves in an

00:17:44.119 --> 00:17:47.619
<v Alice>hour, like you know there'll be a dip at around 40, 45 minutes.

00:17:47.879 --> 00:17:51.439
<v Stu>I'm sure if you looked at the Beau Bohannum inside special where he accuses

00:17:51.439 --> 00:17:54.839
<v Stu>the audience of looking at their phones, it's probably roughly at that point, right?

00:18:17.022 --> 00:18:21.562
<v Alice>Yeah, so you need to stick in a song or a big thing or a high-energy thing or

00:18:21.562 --> 00:18:25.142
<v Alice>you have to have their attention in the first 30 seconds in this way and you

00:18:25.142 --> 00:18:29.322
<v Alice>have to – these are things that are necessary to control an audience in the room,

00:18:30.002 --> 00:18:33.142
<v Alice>and that also influences the structure of the show.

00:18:33.502 --> 00:18:37.202
<v Alice>Whereas in America – in an American special, they might not be thinking like

00:18:37.202 --> 00:18:40.602
<v Alice>that because they're not used to doing the show as an hour.

00:18:40.742 --> 00:18:43.602
<v Alice>They're used to doing it as 10-minute bits in clubs.

00:18:44.102 --> 00:18:53.642
<v Chas>So you must have performed Savage, I guess, hundreds of times before the recording that's on Amazon?

00:18:54.042 --> 00:18:59.382
<v Alice>Yeah, so I would have done it at the festivals and then I recorded it for the

00:18:59.382 --> 00:19:04.802
<v Alice>ABC as a podcast, the trilogy podcast, and then brought it back again.

00:19:05.182 --> 00:19:09.942
<v Alice>Yeah, it would have been about a year after that, which was very surreal because

00:19:09.942 --> 00:19:12.802
<v Alice>you're not used to thinking of them as something that you bring back.

00:19:13.602 --> 00:19:17.862
<v Chas>So, was that part of why you, because you told us that you were reluctant to

00:19:17.862 --> 00:19:21.642
<v Chas>take it from stage to screen,

00:19:22.042 --> 00:19:26.002
<v Chas>was the revisiting part of that reluctance or was it actually something to do

00:19:26.002 --> 00:19:28.682
<v Chas>with the form that you were pushing against?

00:19:29.122 --> 00:19:33.482
<v Alice>There are a couple of different things. First of all, it's a very specific slice

00:19:33.482 --> 00:19:40.502
<v Alice>of time that that show tells and I didn't want to do it a disservice by not

00:19:40.502 --> 00:19:42.762
<v Alice>feeling it in the same way anymore.

00:19:43.602 --> 00:19:47.022
<v Alice>The second thing about it is that...

00:19:48.522 --> 00:19:53.962
<v Alice>I feel that the screen flattens stand-up. Stand-up is so much as an art form

00:19:53.962 --> 00:19:57.462
<v Alice>about the live art form. It's about the experience of the people in the room.

00:19:57.642 --> 00:20:00.902
<v Alice>There's a way that audiences laugh that says, oh, we've had too much or this

00:20:00.902 --> 00:20:03.542
<v Alice>is too much for us or we want more of that.

00:20:03.682 --> 00:20:07.462
<v Alice>And even if you're saying the same words night in and night out,

00:20:07.602 --> 00:20:12.502
<v Alice>the way you deliver those words might be more intense or more diffident or more

00:20:12.502 --> 00:20:17.322
<v Alice>self-deprecating or more shy or more questioning depending on the audience.

00:20:18.022 --> 00:20:23.662
<v Alice>And Savage is so much about the intimacy of that show because I didn't want

00:20:23.662 --> 00:20:25.502
<v Alice>it to be misinterpreted.

00:20:25.622 --> 00:20:28.822
<v Alice>It was such an important story for me to tell that I felt like I had to be in

00:20:28.822 --> 00:20:30.622
<v Alice>the room to control the room.

00:20:31.242 --> 00:20:35.902
<v Alice>When I performed it live, I would be on stage as the audience walked in and

00:20:35.902 --> 00:20:41.042
<v Alice>I would offer them water or snacks and I'd be like, this is my space, you're in my space.

00:20:41.202 --> 00:20:45.942
<v Alice>I kind of undermine and reset all of the expectations that you have going into

00:20:45.942 --> 00:20:49.422
<v Alice>a stand-up show, which is that the stand-up emerges triumphantly to a blare

00:20:49.422 --> 00:20:53.482
<v Alice>of lights and noise and you're presented as a kind of a figure.

00:20:54.022 --> 00:20:57.442
<v Alice>Savage was about that kind of shared humanity and I was like,

00:20:57.502 --> 00:20:59.722
<v Alice>how do I do that on a screen?

00:21:00.622 --> 00:21:05.462
<v Alice>You know, I can't absorb people in my space. I can't control their experience in that way.

00:21:07.102 --> 00:21:11.082
<v Alice>So a lot of the choices that I discussed with the director and the director

00:21:11.082 --> 00:21:16.822
<v Alice>of photography were about trying to maintain that intimacy or to give some sort of proxy of it.

00:21:17.642 --> 00:21:24.222
<v Chas>Other than the, and we can get into the actual shooting and staging, but did the content...

00:21:25.087 --> 00:21:30.467
<v Chas>Of the show change in any way to try and provide that intimacy to an audience

00:21:30.467 --> 00:21:32.787
<v Chas>sitting on a couch you know at home.

00:21:32.787 --> 00:21:37.707
<v Alice>Uh yeah to a certain extent i cut all the songs um because in the show in the

00:21:37.707 --> 00:21:42.447
<v Alice>live show in the room the songs were there was about four songs that were necessary

00:21:42.447 --> 00:21:47.227
<v Alice>to break tension but because you can't build tension across the screen in the

00:21:47.227 --> 00:21:50.007
<v Alice>same way as you can in the room I didn't need them.

00:21:50.427 --> 00:21:53.767
<v Alice>That was, I think, the major content change.

00:21:53.987 --> 00:21:58.727
<v Alice>There was a few things that their lawyers flagged at Amazon Prime.

00:21:59.387 --> 00:22:02.827
<v Alice>There's a joke I have about Tom Cruise that they said, oh, he's very litigious.

00:22:04.027 --> 00:22:07.467
<v Excerpts>So if you do not like action movies, do what I do when I watch action movies.

00:22:07.527 --> 00:22:09.427
<v Excerpts>You know, in that sequence where they're running and they're running and then

00:22:09.427 --> 00:22:11.647
<v Excerpts>they run around the corner of a building. If it's Tom Cruise,

00:22:11.787 --> 00:22:13.867
<v Excerpts>it's a very extreme angle because he's got a low centre of gravity.

00:22:15.987 --> 00:22:19.067
<v Alice>And I'm like, you can't libel someone on facts.

00:22:20.787 --> 00:22:27.167
<v Alice>So, yeah, I changed a few jokes. Probably one or two jokes that I would want

00:22:27.167 --> 00:22:30.687
<v Alice>people to be in the room for to make sure that they really got it.

00:22:30.987 --> 00:22:33.647
<v Alice>But, yeah, other than that, it's substantively the same.

00:22:33.867 --> 00:22:34.987
<v Chas>Are we ready to...

00:22:36.451 --> 00:22:42.351
<v Chas>Transition, uh, super awkwardly into talking about other people's standup.

00:22:42.511 --> 00:22:48.151
<v Chas>It's like, yes, I just thought we, we had in our pre-chat, you know,

00:22:48.431 --> 00:22:50.751
<v Chas>talking about how the sausage is made, uh,

00:22:51.051 --> 00:22:56.131
<v Chas>we identified some tools that seem to be common throughout all the three different

00:22:56.131 --> 00:22:57.831
<v Chas>specials that we're going to talk about.

00:22:58.031 --> 00:23:01.451
<v Chas>And I'm just going to rattle them off now and hope that we get to

00:23:01.451 --> 00:23:05.051
<v Chas>all of them in some form or another but uh

00:23:05.051 --> 00:23:08.031
<v Chas>theme is you know you've spoken

00:23:08.031 --> 00:23:11.331
<v Chas>about the you know the edinburgh and the festival model and

00:23:11.331 --> 00:23:14.171
<v Chas>i think you know theme as much of a story seems to

00:23:14.171 --> 00:23:18.291
<v Chas>be tying a lot of this material together pacing set

00:23:18.291 --> 00:23:21.211
<v Chas>up some payoffs we've already uh got some great references from

00:23:21.211 --> 00:23:24.891
<v Chas>from your work alice recontextualization which

00:23:24.891 --> 00:23:27.731
<v Chas>uh if i don't know if you listen to script notes alice but they talked

00:23:27.731 --> 00:23:31.511
<v Chas>about today as backshadowing rather than foreshadowing shadowing a

00:23:31.511 --> 00:23:34.531
<v Chas>measure of self-awareness which i do wonder is just whether it's

00:23:34.531 --> 00:23:37.351
<v Chas>become a mandatory trend in stand-up now that

00:23:37.351 --> 00:23:40.391
<v Chas>i'll be interested to talk about but just like it would

00:23:40.391 --> 00:23:44.871
<v Chas>appear to me that you know you kind of almost have to comment on who you are

00:23:44.871 --> 00:23:49.031
<v Chas>as a comic and how you're relating to an audience and again like sort of tell

00:23:49.031 --> 00:23:53.511
<v Chas>them how you're making the sausage at the time and all the different comics

00:23:53.511 --> 00:23:57.091
<v Chas>that we're about to dive into do that at one point or another they sort of step

00:23:57.091 --> 00:24:00.371
<v Chas>back from the material and comment on their craft.

00:24:00.551 --> 00:24:05.051
<v Stu>They're preemptively retroactively thinking. Yeah.

00:24:06.257 --> 00:24:10.257
<v Chas>Shtick in terms of all writing from character and catharsis,

00:24:10.557 --> 00:24:13.137
<v Chas>which may be tied into theme as well.

00:24:13.717 --> 00:24:14.297
<v Stu>Yes and no.

00:24:14.637 --> 00:24:14.997
<v Chas>Okay.

00:24:15.217 --> 00:24:16.737
<v Stu>Well, yes, but also no.

00:24:18.157 --> 00:24:22.877
<v Chas>All right. So just a gentle reminder that we're going to do Nanette,

00:24:23.037 --> 00:24:26.017
<v Chas>Baby Cobra, and Is the Fireworks talking.

00:24:26.597 --> 00:24:30.277
<v Chas>But Alice, I also don't want to dump you in trouble by like,

00:24:30.477 --> 00:24:34.437
<v Chas>we only pick things that we love and want to talk about how they do things well.

00:24:34.437 --> 00:24:38.337
<v Chas>So I didn't want to go, oh, God, are we going to ruin Alice's career by having

00:24:38.337 --> 00:24:43.997
<v Chas>her shit on these huge stand-up specials? But yes.

00:24:44.457 --> 00:24:49.737
<v Alice>It's the fireworks talking was the first stand-up show that I saw that really

00:24:49.737 --> 00:24:53.857
<v Alice>opened up to me what stand-up could be.

00:24:54.117 --> 00:24:58.157
<v Alice>I had, as I think most people do, a very fixed idea of what stand-up was.

00:24:58.297 --> 00:25:02.217
<v Alice>And I saw his show in Melbourne in 2007, before I was doing comedy at all.

00:25:03.797 --> 00:25:07.117
<v Alice>And as he came to the end of the show I had

00:25:07.117 --> 00:25:09.937
<v Alice>tears in my eyes not because the show was particularly sad but

00:25:09.937 --> 00:25:14.277
<v Alice>because he had hit every beat perfectly the rhythm was so perfect and the delivery

00:25:14.277 --> 00:25:17.417
<v Alice>was so perfect and in that last five minutes I could feel him bringing these

00:25:17.417 --> 00:25:21.097
<v Alice>threads together and I was like don't fuck it up like just don't fuck it up

00:25:21.097 --> 00:25:24.957
<v Alice>and I had tears in my eyes just of the like don't fuck it up variety and then

00:25:24.957 --> 00:25:28.897
<v Alice>he brought it home and it was this immense uh catharsis just to

00:25:28.957 --> 00:25:31.297
<v Alice>see him perform that skill.

00:25:32.854 --> 00:25:35.574
<v Alice>In the way that, you know, watching the Olympics at the moment,

00:25:35.614 --> 00:25:39.874
<v Alice>you see people doing a sport that you have no idea what that sport is,

00:25:39.954 --> 00:25:41.574
<v Alice>but you can tell which ones are good at it.

00:25:43.534 --> 00:25:48.474
<v Alice>And so, yeah, I wanted us to have a look at that show because it is so,

00:25:48.694 --> 00:25:53.654
<v Alice>for me, as a very inexperienced, well, at that time, completely unexperienced

00:25:53.654 --> 00:25:57.014
<v Alice>comedian, it was just such a perfect example of the art form.

00:25:57.274 --> 00:26:01.034
<v Stu>I definitely want to get into it. I think we'll leave it towards the end because

00:26:01.034 --> 00:26:03.714
<v Stu>it's going to be something that presumably a lot of people are not familiar

00:26:03.714 --> 00:26:05.974
<v Stu>with, or they should go and get it on Bandcamp.

00:26:06.094 --> 00:26:08.814
<v Stu>And I think it'll be really useful because you'll be able to bring all the loose

00:26:08.814 --> 00:26:14.114
<v Stu>threads together and make the audience cry at the end, breaking down that show for us, right?

00:26:14.374 --> 00:26:15.794
<v Alice>The perfect podcaster.

00:26:16.294 --> 00:26:19.454
<v Stu>Yeah. Somehow that's what we're going to do, but we just make it up on the spot

00:26:19.454 --> 00:26:21.134
<v Stu>rather than carefully crafted over years.

00:26:21.514 --> 00:26:25.414
<v Stu>Okay. So, Nanette, which was, I have to say, it was a bit of a phenomenon,

00:26:25.714 --> 00:26:30.774
<v Stu>right? It felt like it was a genuine, at least in the West, the Anglo-American

00:26:30.774 --> 00:26:32.894
<v Stu>West anyway, a phenomenon, right?

00:26:33.014 --> 00:26:35.474
<v Stu>And it kind of really hit a nerve thematically.

00:26:36.914 --> 00:26:43.194
<v Excerpts>There is too much hysteria around gender from you gender normals.

00:26:44.034 --> 00:26:48.054
<v Excerpts>You're the weirdos. You're a bit hysterical. You're a bit weird.

00:26:48.194 --> 00:26:51.514
<v Excerpts>You're a bit up top. You need to get a, you know, your gender normals.

00:26:52.714 --> 00:26:54.774
<v Excerpts>Seriously, calm down, gender normals.

00:26:55.977 --> 00:27:00.837
<v Excerpts>Get a grip. No, I'm in and a dress. That's so weird. No, it's not.

00:27:01.037 --> 00:27:03.637
<v Excerpts>Do you know what's weird? Pink headbands on bald babies.

00:27:06.757 --> 00:27:11.757
<v Alice>It felt like it was very much at the right time and also that it was America's

00:27:11.757 --> 00:27:15.377
<v Alice>first proper introduction to the Edinburgh format of show,

00:27:15.537 --> 00:27:20.677
<v Alice>where it isn't just jokes, where there is a heart to it and there is a meaning

00:27:20.677 --> 00:27:24.997
<v Alice>to it and a story that is brought home and this catharsis at the end that may

00:27:24.997 --> 00:27:26.337
<v Alice>not be entirely comedic.

00:27:26.777 --> 00:27:31.077
<v Alice>And she got the credit for that and also the backlash for that from people who

00:27:31.077 --> 00:27:34.717
<v Alice>were not familiar with that very well-established form of comedy,

00:27:34.717 --> 00:27:37.837
<v Alice>which is that festival format.

00:27:38.117 --> 00:27:43.617
<v Stu>Not just the well-established form of storytelling, which is why,

00:27:43.777 --> 00:27:47.517
<v Stu>like, essentially on some level, we'll break down, like, the more technical

00:27:47.517 --> 00:27:50.677
<v Stu>aspects of catharsis later, but on some level you get to the end of something

00:27:50.677 --> 00:27:52.657
<v Stu>and you want to know why it's worthwhile, right?

00:27:52.657 --> 00:27:56.977
<v Stu>Why have I spent an hour listening to you to tell this story?

00:27:57.177 --> 00:28:02.097
<v Stu>And Annette is like, brings that home. You're like, okay, so this is why you

00:28:02.097 --> 00:28:05.337
<v Stu>have gotten up and spoken to me for an hour. And this is what makes it worthwhile.

00:28:05.457 --> 00:28:08.317
<v Stu>Right? And I think that's something that a lot of people don't actually ask

00:28:08.317 --> 00:28:10.837
<v Stu>enough of their own work, which is what is that?

00:28:11.277 --> 00:28:14.777
<v Stu>This is such not the reference, but I'm just going to bring it up because it's

00:28:14.777 --> 00:28:19.317
<v Stu>the perfect example, which is Wrath of Man, the new Guy Ritchie movie. Chaz and I watched it.

00:28:19.477 --> 00:28:22.057
<v Stu>And the end of it was like, that was really cool. It did a bunch of really cool

00:28:22.057 --> 00:28:23.617
<v Stu>shit. but the end is just like,

00:28:24.917 --> 00:28:28.977
<v Stu>It's over now. Go home. Like, that's it. That's the ending.

00:28:29.157 --> 00:28:33.017
<v Stu>And I'd love a good action movie, but it didn't even bother to try to have,

00:28:33.117 --> 00:28:35.297
<v Stu>like, some kind of, like, family moment.

00:28:35.637 --> 00:28:38.357
<v Stu>You know, at least Fast and Furious, that's becoming a running joke,

00:28:38.477 --> 00:28:41.937
<v Stu>but at least it tries to make it about something, you know?

00:28:42.597 --> 00:28:46.137
<v Alice>Yeah, it felt like a lot of the pacing choices in Wrath of Man were distancing

00:28:46.137 --> 00:28:47.777
<v Alice>you from the central character.

00:28:47.777 --> 00:28:53.077
<v Alice>And the affect that flattened affect of american masculinity was so all pervasive

00:28:53.077 --> 00:28:58.557
<v Alice>that it showed no emotional depth at all he expressed his happiness in the same

00:28:58.557 --> 00:29:03.817
<v Alice>way as he expressed his sadness which was uh you know through inarticulate grunting.

00:29:03.817 --> 00:29:06.797
<v Chas>Well i mean so we're

00:29:06.797 --> 00:29:10.377
<v Chas>kind of talking broadly about theme here like why have

00:29:10.377 --> 00:29:13.437
<v Chas>we just watched what we've just watched and for for me

00:29:13.437 --> 00:29:16.577
<v Chas>for screenwriting like I often I've got

00:29:16.577 --> 00:29:19.257
<v Chas>a I've got a strong theme idea coming in but I

00:29:19.257 --> 00:29:22.017
<v Chas>know a lot of people don't there's no right or wrong way

00:29:22.017 --> 00:29:28.057
<v Chas>to do it but my theme nearly always changes like I get a a better idea of what

00:29:28.057 --> 00:29:33.197
<v Chas>I'm talking about after having written it and Alice like you were so clear about

00:29:33.197 --> 00:29:37.477
<v Chas>savages about a show about loss did you know that going in or was it something

00:29:37.477 --> 00:29:39.897
<v Chas>that came from the creation of it?

00:29:40.361 --> 00:29:44.481
<v Alice>Savage was a while ago now, and I was very sad when I wrote it,

00:29:44.521 --> 00:29:45.281
<v Alice>so it's hard to remember.

00:29:45.321 --> 00:29:48.281
<v Alice>But most of my shows, I'll think that I know what I'm writing about,

00:29:48.401 --> 00:29:50.881
<v Alice>and then about two weeks into performing it every night at a festival,

00:29:50.881 --> 00:29:53.521
<v Alice>I'll be like, oh, that's what it's about.

00:29:54.721 --> 00:30:00.661
<v Alice>It reveals itself in that way. But this kind of, what you're calling theme,

00:30:00.801 --> 00:30:01.961
<v Alice>this kind of pathos thing,

00:30:02.301 --> 00:30:07.401
<v Alice>this like, it's really, I think for stand-ups, that old school Aristotelian

00:30:07.401 --> 00:30:10.701
<v Alice>rhetorical structure is a good way to think about it, which is that you have

00:30:10.701 --> 00:30:14.041
<v Alice>the ethos and the logos and the pathos, and they all have to be present.

00:30:14.181 --> 00:30:18.381
<v Alice>Ethos being the comedian telling you who they are, and they can tell that to

00:30:18.381 --> 00:30:22.421
<v Alice>you either by how they look or by the jokes that they tell or by explicitly

00:30:22.421 --> 00:30:25.001
<v Alice>being like, hey, a funny thing about me.

00:30:26.201 --> 00:30:29.061
<v Alice>That's a thing that all comedians do. They tell you a little thing about themselves.

00:30:29.601 --> 00:30:33.161
<v Stu>We've mentioned what Hannah Gadsby talks about, the misgendering.

00:30:33.321 --> 00:30:36.441
<v Stu>We've talked about Bo Hennem. It literally starts off with his song,

00:30:36.961 --> 00:30:38.821
<v Stu>I'm healing the world with comedy.

00:31:08.520 --> 00:31:14.980
<v Stu>You've got Baby Copperhead, as you talked about. She steps on the stage as a

00:31:14.980 --> 00:31:16.680
<v Stu>pregnant Asian woman doing comedy.

00:31:17.920 --> 00:31:26.820
<v Excerpts>Hello. We are going to have to get this shit over with because I have to pee in like 10 minutes.

00:31:28.480 --> 00:31:31.940
<v Stu>And Daniel Kitson, I mean, it's a little bit more interesting what he does there.

00:31:32.140 --> 00:31:33.380
<v Stu>I'm trying to put my finger on it.

00:31:35.500 --> 00:31:39.060
<v Excerpts>It's got a title, this show. It's got a title. It's called It's the Fireworks

00:31:39.060 --> 00:31:41.400
<v Excerpts>Talking. That's what it's called. It's the Fireworks Talking.

00:31:41.600 --> 00:31:43.980
<v Excerpts>And it's called that for various reasons, not least, I think,

00:31:44.040 --> 00:31:47.360
<v Excerpts>because if we want our words to resemble anything in our brief time hurtling

00:31:47.360 --> 00:31:49.720
<v Excerpts>through space on this planet, then it's fireworks, isn't it?

00:31:49.800 --> 00:31:53.520
<v Excerpts>We want our words to be explosive, to be beautiful, to be transient,

00:31:54.040 --> 00:31:57.780
<v Excerpts>you know, to be disproportionately moving when set to classical music.

00:32:00.420 --> 00:32:03.800
<v Stu>It's also because I'm listening because it's an audio stand-up,

00:32:03.820 --> 00:32:08.340
<v Stu>not a visual one, but I think there's this sense of him just starting, like, I don't know.

00:32:08.600 --> 00:32:13.880
<v Alice>So visually speaking, if you see him live, he comes on very disheveled and very

00:32:13.880 --> 00:32:19.240
<v Alice>sort of professorial. He's always performed as a 45, 50-year-old man,

00:32:19.320 --> 00:32:21.020
<v Alice>even when he was in his early 20s.

00:32:21.680 --> 00:32:26.680
<v Alice>That's his thing. It's a non-threatening kind of persona, which allows him to

00:32:26.680 --> 00:32:28.540
<v Alice>play with status in the way that he does.

00:32:29.220 --> 00:32:33.380
<v Alice>That he has also the stammer as well is a way of...

00:32:34.444 --> 00:32:38.204
<v Alice>It's not that he has a stammer on purpose, but he uses his stammer and he plays

00:32:38.204 --> 00:32:42.104
<v Alice>against it. It gives him more room to be high status on stage.

00:32:42.344 --> 00:32:44.824
<v Alice>And every time he's high status, it's a surprise.

00:32:45.244 --> 00:32:49.004
<v Stu>So he's low status playing high status. That's interesting.

00:32:49.184 --> 00:32:53.484
<v Stu>I'm going to write that down, I think, because I reread that Keith Johnston

00:32:53.484 --> 00:32:55.084
<v Stu>chapter this week on status. Anyway.

00:32:55.864 --> 00:32:58.844
<v Alice>And then you have Logos, which is the structure, and then Pathos,

00:32:58.904 --> 00:33:03.284
<v Alice>which is why are we watching? Why do we care? And that's what you're talking about.

00:33:04.024 --> 00:33:07.884
<v Stu>Yes. But like, so let's just repeat those three things again for me,

00:33:07.964 --> 00:33:10.584
<v Stu>if you don't mind, because these feel like this is actually what we're talking about.

00:33:11.684 --> 00:33:15.384
<v Alice>Ethos, logos, and pathos is what I think about.

00:33:15.784 --> 00:33:21.464
<v Alice>So ethos being who you are in relation to the audience. Why should they listen

00:33:21.464 --> 00:33:23.044
<v Alice>to you? What's your position?

00:33:23.784 --> 00:33:27.624
<v Alice>So, you know, I'm a maths professor, and therefore I can talk about this maths subject.

00:33:28.444 --> 00:33:33.304
<v Alice>Logos is the structure, and that's the joke structure. Are the jokes funny? Do they work as jokes?

00:33:33.464 --> 00:33:37.844
<v Alice>Does the story make sense? Does the story follow? Does it, if it is non-linear,

00:33:37.964 --> 00:33:39.864
<v Alice>are all the pieces in place?

00:33:40.024 --> 00:33:46.004
<v Alice>Do they come back in a satisfying way? Does the logos work? And then pathos, why do I care?

00:33:47.144 --> 00:33:51.044
<v Alice>And that's, you know, that can be sad or it can be, it doesn't need to be sad,

00:33:51.044 --> 00:33:52.984
<v Alice>but it is incredibly important.

00:33:53.184 --> 00:33:55.744
<v Alice>You know, if this math professor is telling you math problems that all make

00:33:55.744 --> 00:33:58.404
<v Alice>sense, I don't give a shit.

00:33:59.104 --> 00:34:02.924
<v Alice>Are these math problems relevant to my life? Maybe I give a shit.

00:34:03.404 --> 00:34:03.524
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:34:03.704 --> 00:34:03.984
<v Alice>You know?

00:34:04.284 --> 00:34:08.704
<v Chas>To bring this back to Nanette and sort of, I guess, render it down to,

00:34:08.864 --> 00:34:14.624
<v Chas>let's apply these to the practical example that we've got. I mean, she was-

00:34:16.075 --> 00:34:18.475
<v Stu>This will connect to what you're going to say, but I would just want to inject.

00:34:18.615 --> 00:34:21.995
<v Stu>I think the reason that theme is interesting and pathos is more useful is I

00:34:21.995 --> 00:34:26.715
<v Stu>think theme in the way that we think about it has two separate meanings that are related.

00:34:27.115 --> 00:34:31.235
<v Stu>I think there's theme is like the organizing principles of material, okay?

00:34:31.495 --> 00:34:35.335
<v Stu>That you can have a theme where stuff is organized by color,

00:34:35.615 --> 00:34:40.155
<v Stu>you know, or melody, or I'm just using examples in other artwork, you know.

00:34:40.235 --> 00:34:43.775
<v Alice>Or it's an hour about cars, but actually it's about family.

00:34:44.135 --> 00:34:45.535
<v Chas>Yeah, exactly.

00:34:45.535 --> 00:34:48.435
<v Stu>So it's a unifying principle. And, you know, something like,

00:34:48.515 --> 00:34:51.675
<v Stu>I'm going to use inside because it's so visually obvious. It's literally called inside.

00:34:51.915 --> 00:34:55.635
<v Stu>And he's inside a room the whole time, even though there's, you know,

00:34:55.675 --> 00:34:58.275
<v Stu>Chas and I had a discussion about this. It's like, there's no bathroom.

00:34:58.515 --> 00:35:02.655
<v Stu>The kitchen's got stuff, but it's not food. It's clearly this artificial unifying

00:35:02.655 --> 00:35:06.775
<v Stu>idea of being inside and representing mental illness, getting to the pandemic, right?

00:35:06.975 --> 00:35:11.675
<v Stu>But, you know, Baby Copper and Nanette and Fireworks, by the title,

00:35:11.775 --> 00:35:14.315
<v Stu>has got these unifying elements, these little threads of storytelling.

00:35:14.315 --> 00:35:17.095
<v Stu>They come back to and i think the net has got

00:35:17.095 --> 00:35:19.875
<v Stu>those unifying elements that they they bring together

00:35:19.875 --> 00:35:23.015
<v Stu>but you don't always similarly some of the tangents

00:35:23.015 --> 00:35:26.515
<v Stu>are only connected like they're just like branches of

00:35:26.515 --> 00:35:30.255
<v Stu>the story that don't connect to the ending but they kind of fit within the unifying

00:35:30.255 --> 00:35:34.115
<v Stu>theme which i think is something that screenwriters can take can take is they

00:35:34.115 --> 00:35:38.955
<v Stu>don't actually think about enough about the unifying elements you know i mean

00:35:38.955 --> 00:35:41.675
<v Stu>like we joke about fast and furious but that's what that franchise is it's got

00:35:41.675 --> 00:35:44.915
<v Stu>an incredibly powerful theme which is It's about family. It's about cars.

00:35:45.075 --> 00:35:46.735
<v Stu>You know, it's kind of like an action

00:35:46.735 --> 00:35:48.795
<v Stu>movie, and that's what brings it all together on top of the meaning.

00:35:48.975 --> 00:35:53.295
<v Stu>But I think Nanette's got a bunch of those kind of unifilming elements on top of its pathos.

00:35:53.795 --> 00:35:59.615
<v Alice>Well, and also having those kind of moments, even if they don't really connect

00:35:59.615 --> 00:36:02.115
<v Alice>or pay off, which sometimes they do, sometimes they don't.

00:36:03.283 --> 00:36:11.003
<v Alice>The amount that people will bring to it if you give them these points of connection is amazing.

00:36:11.203 --> 00:36:15.243
<v Alice>So much of the work of Savage is done by the audience. So much of the work of

00:36:15.243 --> 00:36:17.803
<v Alice>Nanette is done by the audience.

00:36:18.683 --> 00:36:23.743
<v Alice>Because even though Hannah Gadsby speaks very explicitly about her experiences

00:36:23.743 --> 00:36:26.763
<v Alice>and her trauma, she's not telling the whole story.

00:36:27.303 --> 00:36:34.223
<v Alice>She's allowing you to understand the whole story with your own stuff. You know, definitely.

00:36:34.863 --> 00:36:40.023
<v Chas>You've spoken about how pauses are so important in your stand up because it's

00:36:40.023 --> 00:36:43.203
<v Chas>about audiences, you know, filling that gap.

00:36:43.423 --> 00:36:47.083
<v Chas>But in terms of what you're saying for theme, I think, yeah,

00:36:47.263 --> 00:36:51.283
<v Chas>the word theme is like kind of too broad. It almost becomes useless at a certain point.

00:36:52.203 --> 00:36:56.723
<v Chas>For me, the pathos thing, like, why should I care? And the logos thing,

00:36:56.843 --> 00:36:58.763
<v Chas>like, you know, how is this structured?

00:36:59.023 --> 00:37:03.763
<v Chas>To me, one of my most important things when writing to have a vague idea of

00:37:03.763 --> 00:37:07.163
<v Chas>what my theme is, is I know what doesn't belong in the story.

00:37:07.323 --> 00:37:12.143
<v Chas>Like, I know what stories or characters or moments I don't want in there.

00:37:12.223 --> 00:37:15.123
<v Chas>And I imagine with these long stand-up specials, like Stu was saying,

00:37:15.223 --> 00:37:18.583
<v Chas>there's, you know, lots of tangents and branches, and we can probably come up

00:37:18.583 --> 00:37:19.863
<v Chas>with examples from all three,

00:37:20.063 --> 00:37:23.063
<v Chas>where they leave the central trunk or

00:37:23.063 --> 00:37:28.923
<v Chas>the central kind of unifying idea of the the special but you know either thematically

00:37:28.923 --> 00:37:34.943
<v Chas>bring it back through segue or you know through transition or it just always

00:37:34.943 --> 00:37:39.643
<v Chas>feels of a piece that they got there you can see kind of how they got off the

00:37:39.643 --> 00:37:42.703
<v Chas>trunk and then how they get back to the trunk as well.

00:37:42.703 --> 00:37:47.863
<v Alice>Well an example in nanette is the apparent tangent about uh picasso.

00:37:49.763 --> 00:37:54.803
<v Excerpts>But he did suffer a mental illness Picasso did he suffered badly and it got

00:37:54.803 --> 00:38:02.743
<v Excerpts>worse as he got older Picasso suffered the mental illness of misogyny split the room.

00:38:02.743 --> 00:38:05.703
<v Alice>So that's that's telling you

00:38:05.703 --> 00:38:08.463
<v Alice>something about Hannah Gadsby her interest in art

00:38:08.463 --> 00:38:11.363
<v Alice>history so she's she's revealing something of

00:38:11.363 --> 00:38:14.743
<v Alice>herself there and it is also giving you

00:38:14.743 --> 00:38:18.083
<v Alice>this structural template for what men

00:38:18.083 --> 00:38:21.623
<v Alice>are forgiven for and how society forgives

00:38:21.623 --> 00:38:24.483
<v Alice>men and will will tell

00:38:24.483 --> 00:38:27.423
<v Alice>stories that work in certain people's favors or

00:38:27.423 --> 00:38:31.003
<v Alice>not in other people's favors and that is her introducing

00:38:31.003 --> 00:38:36.323
<v Alice>this theme that comes in importantly towards the end about stories half told

00:38:36.323 --> 00:38:41.763
<v Alice>and why those stories are half told who it suits to tell those stories short

00:38:41.763 --> 00:38:48.943
<v Alice>and in the way that she then reveals that she has told her story short and her

00:38:48.943 --> 00:38:50.023
<v Alice>motivations for doing that.

00:38:50.900 --> 00:38:55.040
<v Chas>I think, you know, we don't want to like retell jokes or necessarily spoil an

00:38:55.040 --> 00:38:58.000
<v Chas>ending of something because it takes away the power of it a little bit.

00:38:58.120 --> 00:39:01.580
<v Chas>But here on Draft Zero, we do spoil things like there's no tomorrow.

00:39:01.880 --> 00:39:08.680
<v Chas>But just to give some context is like almost the first half of Hannah's stand

00:39:08.680 --> 00:39:14.140
<v Chas>up of Nanette is, you know, a series of connected jokes and bits.

00:39:14.140 --> 00:39:20.600
<v Chas>But it stops, you know, she starts alternating between stand-up and,

00:39:20.600 --> 00:39:25.760
<v Chas>like, just pure kind of anger and emotion without trying to make anyone laugh at all.

00:39:25.860 --> 00:39:30.220
<v Chas>And as she's going, she's commenting deliberately on, you know,

00:39:30.460 --> 00:39:32.620
<v Chas>whether she's trying to make people laugh or not.

00:39:33.740 --> 00:39:37.420
<v Excerpts>To the men in the room, I speak to you now, particularly the white men,

00:39:37.540 --> 00:39:39.080
<v Excerpts>especially the straight white men.

00:39:40.260 --> 00:39:42.560
<v Excerpts>Pull your fucking socks up!

00:39:44.561 --> 00:39:50.621
<v Excerpts>How humiliating. Fashion advice from a lesbian. That is your last joke.

00:39:53.681 --> 00:39:58.401
<v Chas>And to me, one of the unifying structures of it that she comes in quite early

00:39:58.401 --> 00:40:02.681
<v Chas>on, but it's not in the opening few minutes, is I'm quitting comedy.

00:40:04.401 --> 00:40:10.361
<v Excerpts>I do think I have to quit comedy, though. And seriously, it's probably not the

00:40:10.361 --> 00:40:13.101
<v Excerpts>forum to make such an announcement, is it?

00:40:14.541 --> 00:40:17.321
<v Excerpts>In the middle of a comedy show, but I have been questioning,

00:40:17.341 --> 00:40:21.981
<v Excerpts>you know, this whole comedy thing. I don't feel very comfortable in it anymore.

00:40:23.281 --> 00:40:27.481
<v Excerpts>You know, over the past year I've been questioning it and reassessing,

00:40:27.481 --> 00:40:31.921
<v Excerpts>and I think it's healthy for an adult human to take stock, pause and reassess.

00:40:32.501 --> 00:40:36.081
<v Excerpts>And when I first started doing the comedy over a decade ago,

00:40:37.281 --> 00:40:39.341
<v Excerpts>my favourite comedian was Bill Cosby.

00:40:40.981 --> 00:40:43.861
<v Chas>And she's described it on she

00:40:43.861 --> 00:40:47.181
<v Chas>was i heard her on mike babelia's podcast working

00:40:47.181 --> 00:40:50.041
<v Chas>it out she called the structure of nanette

00:40:50.041 --> 00:40:55.741
<v Chas>a fugue which i had to google because i didn't know what it was but it's a a

00:40:55.741 --> 00:41:01.061
<v Chas>musical contrapuntal compositional technique in two or more voices built on

00:41:01.061 --> 00:41:05.521
<v Chas>a subject a musical theme that is introduced at the beginning in imitation repetition

00:41:05.521 --> 00:41:09.481
<v Chas>at different pitches and which recurs frequently in the course of the composition.

00:41:09.821 --> 00:41:13.681
<v Chas>And I think we've got that not just in your show, Alice, but in all three other

00:41:13.681 --> 00:41:17.441
<v Chas>shows that we've done here. So she tells the same stories.

00:41:18.651 --> 00:41:23.631
<v Chas>And then tells how she's been telling the stories and constantly moving between

00:41:23.631 --> 00:41:28.711
<v Chas>making the audience laugh and then also like kind of revealing the truth of

00:41:28.711 --> 00:41:31.931
<v Chas>her own story and being able to not make them laugh.

00:41:32.151 --> 00:41:36.071
<v Chas>And at the same time telling the audience when and why she's making them laugh

00:41:36.071 --> 00:41:38.431
<v Chas>or not, which is incredible.

00:41:38.871 --> 00:41:43.211
<v Alice>Yes, she introduces the structure of the whole in miniature,

00:41:43.211 --> 00:41:48.291
<v Alice>which is the telling of a joke and then the telling of why she's not going to tell that joke anymore.

00:41:48.651 --> 00:41:53.151
<v Alice>Why that joke is no good, whether it's her self-deprecating and then telling

00:41:53.151 --> 00:41:58.431
<v Alice>you why she's not going to self-deprecate, all the way through to this story

00:41:58.431 --> 00:42:01.751
<v Alice>that she told at the beginning and then she tells the full version of at the end,

00:42:02.211 --> 00:42:05.791
<v Alice>her kind of underlying artistic thesis.

00:42:06.051 --> 00:42:13.691
<v Alice>And I'm never sure if she believes this or not, is that comedy is not a complete story.

00:42:13.931 --> 00:42:16.051
<v Alice>But I think by comedy, she means a joke.

00:42:16.931 --> 00:42:20.051
<v Alice>She says it's just two parts. It's a set up and a punchline.

00:42:20.671 --> 00:42:26.711
<v Alice>And that that is doing a disservice to the complexity and then the fullness of stories.

00:42:27.571 --> 00:42:31.051
<v Alice>And I don't know how much I agree with her about that, but it's certainly a

00:42:31.051 --> 00:42:35.051
<v Alice>very powerful message that that special puts across.

00:42:35.331 --> 00:42:40.711
<v Chas>As I said, we'll probably play excerpts rather than me butchering the material.

00:42:41.471 --> 00:42:44.611
<v Stu>But you could save the material so we can laugh at you and then we can replace

00:42:44.611 --> 00:42:45.791
<v Stu>it with an excerpt if you want.

00:42:45.931 --> 00:42:49.411
<v Chas>Well, you know how she tells the joke of her mother,

00:42:49.671 --> 00:42:54.811
<v Chas>of coming out to her mother and her mother's response and then recontextualizes

00:42:54.811 --> 00:42:59.671
<v Chas>that later by retelling the story and then like saying this is what our relationship

00:42:59.671 --> 00:43:03.751
<v Chas>is now and deliberately doesn't tell a punchline on that true moment.

00:43:04.571 --> 00:43:08.631
<v Excerpts>I looked at my mum in that moment and I thought, how did that happen?

00:43:10.456 --> 00:43:15.056
<v Excerpts>How did my mum get to be the hero of my story?

00:43:21.096 --> 00:43:25.536
<v Excerpts>She evolved. I didn't.

00:43:27.476 --> 00:43:34.056
<v Excerpts>I think part of my problem is comedy has suspended me in a perpetual state of adolescence.

00:43:34.396 --> 00:43:38.376
<v Excerpts>The way I've been telling that story is through jokes.

00:43:39.956 --> 00:43:46.116
<v Excerpts>And stories, unlike jokes, need three parts, a beginning, a middle, and an end.

00:43:46.456 --> 00:43:51.056
<v Excerpts>Jokes are only two parts, a beginning and a middle.

00:43:52.016 --> 00:43:59.236
<v Excerpts>And what I had done with that comedy show about coming out was I froze an incredibly

00:43:59.236 --> 00:44:04.176
<v Excerpts>formative experience at its trauma point, and I sealed it off into jokes.

00:44:04.936 --> 00:44:08.436
<v Excerpts>And that story became a routine, and through repetition.

00:44:08.976 --> 00:44:12.696
<v Excerpts>That joke version fused with my actual memory of what happened.

00:44:12.916 --> 00:44:18.196
<v Excerpts>But unfortunately, that joke version was not nearly sophisticated enough to

00:44:18.196 --> 00:44:20.636
<v Excerpts>help me undo the damage done to me in reality.

00:44:24.199 --> 00:44:33.359
<v Excerpts>Punch lines need trauma because punch lines need tension and tension feeds trauma.

00:44:33.939 --> 00:44:39.459
<v Stu>That is definitely like a joke structure to me, you know, set off payoff reversal, right?

00:44:39.699 --> 00:44:42.679
<v Stu>There's a setup, which is the joke, the original, there's the payoff,

00:44:42.859 --> 00:44:45.459
<v Stu>which is like, I'm going to tell the emotional payoff and there's a reversal,

00:44:45.659 --> 00:44:49.079
<v Stu>which is like, you're going, Oh yeah, her mom is really sweet and she has evolved.

00:44:49.199 --> 00:44:52.739
<v Stu>And she's like, she even takes that away from me. And then she kind of like

00:44:52.739 --> 00:44:54.079
<v Stu>undermines it a bit, but that's interesting.

00:44:54.199 --> 00:45:00.079
<v Stu>Because she jokes, makes a serious comment on the joke, and then jokes to let

00:45:00.079 --> 00:45:04.619
<v Stu>the tension off the hook, and then deliberately removes that final joke at the end.

00:45:04.699 --> 00:45:10.859
<v Stu>That's kind of what Jim, it's ABC, ABC, ABC, AB, right? It's kind of like unresolved.

00:45:10.999 --> 00:45:15.239
<v Stu>If you think of musically, she is finishing on the Discord as the structural idea.

00:45:15.699 --> 00:45:18.339
<v Stu>I mean, it's beautifully structured. I mean, this is why we're doing it first,

00:45:18.459 --> 00:45:23.939
<v Stu>because it is an astounding piece of kind of storytelling that feels so effortless when you watch it.

00:45:24.199 --> 00:45:29.139
<v Stu>And I'm sure it was anything but effortless on top of the actual trauma she had to experience.

00:45:29.599 --> 00:45:33.439
<v Stu>Look, this is, I'm just going to speak freely. It is interesting that I find

00:45:33.439 --> 00:45:38.559
<v Stu>it harder to speak about these stand-up shows than I do movies because the connection

00:45:38.559 --> 00:45:40.519
<v Stu>with the creator is stronger, right?

00:45:40.719 --> 00:45:47.099
<v Stu>So, I feel like I can, we praise the work of other films all the time and we

00:45:47.099 --> 00:45:51.199
<v Stu>try to not be negative in terms of what we talk about from storytelling.

00:45:51.199 --> 00:45:55.399
<v Stu>It does feel like, ah, we're commenting on someone's work that is intimately

00:45:55.399 --> 00:45:56.399
<v Stu>connected to who they are.

00:45:56.859 --> 00:45:59.679
<v Stu>And that's something that we fail to do with Pablo Picasso, right?

00:46:00.679 --> 00:46:04.819
<v Stu>Like, as in we fail to not to see the person connected to who they are,

00:46:04.859 --> 00:46:05.999
<v Stu>we always separate them.

00:46:06.279 --> 00:46:09.159
<v Stu>And I'm just going to say, it made me think of David Bowie, because there are

00:46:09.159 --> 00:46:11.479
<v Stu>stories about David Bowie, and he seems to get a free pass.

00:46:12.266 --> 00:46:15.866
<v Alice>Well, yeah, it's an interesting thing with stand-ups and that's part of the

00:46:15.866 --> 00:46:18.366
<v Alice>way that different stand-ups deal with that.

00:46:18.606 --> 00:46:22.366
<v Alice>Intimacy is always interesting to watch, whether they do create a persona to

00:46:22.366 --> 00:46:24.486
<v Alice>give them some distance from the audience.

00:46:25.126 --> 00:46:29.506
<v Alice>Or, you know, even just a joke is a shield between you and the audience.

00:46:29.906 --> 00:46:34.146
<v Alice>Or it can be a door between you and the audience. It can be an invitation and

00:46:34.146 --> 00:46:35.706
<v Alice>depends on how you use it.

00:46:35.706 --> 00:46:40.786
<v Alice>And I think certainly in Nanette, Hannah Gadsby has comments on the fact that

00:46:40.786 --> 00:46:46.166
<v Alice>she has been using jokes as a distancing mechanism, as a way to distance herself

00:46:46.166 --> 00:46:50.446
<v Alice>from her traumatic experience, a way of rewriting those traumatic experiences,

00:46:50.786 --> 00:46:53.786
<v Alice>a way of getting the dig in before other people do.

00:46:53.786 --> 00:46:57.566
<v Alice>This self-deprecation is a way of distancing you from yourself because you are

00:46:57.566 --> 00:47:02.566
<v Alice>making fun of yourself, which in itself implies a distance.

00:47:03.186 --> 00:47:06.466
<v Alice>It implies that you're outside yourself and you can make fun of yourself.

00:47:07.286 --> 00:47:12.226
<v Alice>So there are different ways that you can use a joke, structurally speaking.

00:47:12.546 --> 00:47:17.926
<v Chas>I noticed you doing it a lot in Savage where, you know, you'd hit us with this

00:47:17.926 --> 00:47:23.126
<v Chas>huge emotion bomb and you'd let us sit with it. and you would nearly always pull us out of it with,

00:47:24.050 --> 00:47:27.130
<v Chas>a relatively quick joke not to this is

00:47:27.130 --> 00:47:29.990
<v Chas>going to sound terrible but you've told

00:47:29.990 --> 00:47:33.050
<v Chas>us already like you've got the benefit of when

00:47:33.050 --> 00:47:35.790
<v Chas>you're writing stand-up shows you're performing it again and again

00:47:35.790 --> 00:47:39.150
<v Chas>and you can feed off the audience the trick that we aspire

00:47:39.150 --> 00:47:42.010
<v Chas>to as screenwriters is to develop that level of

00:47:42.010 --> 00:47:45.470
<v Chas>control and manipulation of the audience without unless you're

00:47:45.470 --> 00:47:48.250
<v Chas>in animation that iterative process of being able

00:47:48.250 --> 00:47:51.350
<v Chas>to test it and do it over and over and over again and you

00:47:51.350 --> 00:47:54.210
<v Chas>know there's obviously ways of like staged readings and things like that to

00:47:54.210 --> 00:47:59.770
<v Chas>try and approximate that process but i do think the control that all of the

00:47:59.770 --> 00:48:04.570
<v Chas>specials that we're looking at today exhibit over their audience that is something

00:48:04.570 --> 00:48:09.810
<v Chas>that we can aspire to in long form writing yes.

00:48:09.810 --> 00:48:12.030
<v Alice>Certainly certainly it's a really

00:48:12.030 --> 00:48:15.710
<v Alice>interesting process to watch yourself to stand up after you've done it.

00:48:15.710 --> 00:48:19.350
<v Chas>That's extremely uh surreal.

00:48:19.350 --> 00:48:22.270
<v Alice>And weird so you you there's different forms of

00:48:22.270 --> 00:48:25.270
<v Alice>the iterative process as a director or a screenwriter you get

00:48:25.270 --> 00:48:30.650
<v Alice>to change things and you get to see them done or shift them or change the order

00:48:30.650 --> 00:48:35.210
<v Alice>of things post hoc whereas in stand-up you have to kind of run the whole thing

00:48:35.210 --> 00:48:40.030
<v Alice>through or you know if you're doing it american style uh run 10 minute bits

00:48:40.030 --> 00:48:44.710
<v Alice>in different clubs and then stitch them together in the order that you think is right.

00:48:45.070 --> 00:48:50.410
<v Chas>That would be so strange because a lot of what makes all these specials to me- Special.

00:48:50.690 --> 00:48:56.110
<v Chas>Special is their transitions, right? So, Hannah got on to the- What a transition.

00:48:56.270 --> 00:48:56.530
<v Stu>Chaz.

00:48:56.730 --> 00:49:00.050
<v Chas>Thank you. Hannah gets on to Picasso-

00:49:01.464 --> 00:49:06.124
<v Chas>And earlier on to Van Gogh, you know, Van Gogh, she was talking about.

00:49:06.344 --> 00:49:09.944
<v Stu>Yeah. She's already seeded the idea of Van Gogh, right? Because she connects

00:49:09.944 --> 00:49:12.884
<v Stu>that to mental illness and a guy being like, you can't take your meds.

00:49:13.104 --> 00:49:16.764
<v Stu>She seeds that idea. Then she brings up the art history. There's nothing else

00:49:16.764 --> 00:49:18.644
<v Stu>I can do. I've got a degree in art history.

00:49:18.924 --> 00:49:22.064
<v Stu>Right. That's the structure, right? So she's already connected thematically,

00:49:22.204 --> 00:49:23.604
<v Stu>unifying elements, connected art.

00:49:23.824 --> 00:49:27.464
<v Chas>Well, both of them, she gets to them because she's talking about quitting comedy.

00:49:27.464 --> 00:49:31.484
<v Chas>Like in the first one, it's a guy who's come and given her some,

00:49:31.624 --> 00:49:35.884
<v Chas>not feedback, but an opinion on her show just after doing it.

00:49:35.984 --> 00:49:39.764
<v Chas>And the next time she's saying, as you said, Stu, what would I do with my life?

00:49:39.924 --> 00:49:46.924
<v Chas>But she uses that kind of the logos of I'm quitting comedy and leaves us at

00:49:46.924 --> 00:49:48.744
<v Chas>the end with why she's quitting comedy.

00:49:48.884 --> 00:49:52.444
<v Chas>Like, why should we care that this person in front of us, ostensibly,

00:49:52.784 --> 00:49:57.084
<v Chas>you know, we came here to buy a ticket to be comedied at. and we're getting

00:49:57.084 --> 00:50:00.864
<v Chas>told why no more comedy will be forthcoming.

00:50:01.204 --> 00:50:05.064
<v Stu>I mean, what a great central dramatic question, right? Like going and just out

00:50:05.064 --> 00:50:07.704
<v Stu>there and going, I'm quitting comedy. And you're like, really? Are you?

00:50:08.404 --> 00:50:10.644
<v Stu>Check your watch like at the end of the show?

00:50:10.904 --> 00:50:14.344
<v Chas>Like you said, Stu, like foreshadowing. I mean, this isn't even foreshadowing.

00:50:14.464 --> 00:50:21.564
<v Chas>A central dramatic question isn't foreshadowing. It's posing a question in the audience's mind.

00:50:21.744 --> 00:50:26.344
<v Chas>But Alice, you did this as well in your show. You told the audience the experience

00:50:26.344 --> 00:50:29.064
<v Chas>that they're going to have right at the beginning in a way is kind of setting

00:50:29.064 --> 00:50:31.344
<v Chas>them up and preparing them for it.

00:50:32.324 --> 00:50:35.084
<v Alice>Yes. The central question is what is comedy for?

00:50:35.878 --> 00:50:40.518
<v Alice>Is it for taking our eyes away from difficult things or is it for dealing with difficult things?

00:50:40.978 --> 00:50:44.298
<v Alice>Can you do comedy about things that are very sad? Question mark.

00:50:45.378 --> 00:50:49.178
<v Alice>And then I hope that I answer that in the course of the show.

00:50:49.398 --> 00:50:52.918
<v Stu>So yes, it doesn't stop them being sad.

00:50:53.378 --> 00:50:56.898
<v Stu>And, you know, Inside is very clearly set up with like its song.

00:50:57.298 --> 00:51:00.478
<v Stu>I mean, it's almost like a musical. I want song where it's like,

00:51:00.558 --> 00:51:02.878
<v Stu>you know, I'm healing the world with what is it?

00:51:02.978 --> 00:51:05.378
<v Stu>I'm literally healing the world with comedy metaphorically. Right.

00:51:05.378 --> 00:51:06.618
<v Stu>And that is actually a question.

00:51:06.818 --> 00:51:09.318
<v Stu>It's like, are you going to heal the world? And there's also just that running

00:51:09.318 --> 00:51:11.598
<v Stu>question of like, can I complete this special?

00:51:11.778 --> 00:51:16.058
<v Stu>Like we know he's completed the special because- We're watching it. We're watching it.

00:51:16.638 --> 00:51:19.678
<v Stu>Right. And it's very deliberate. I mean, it's a tangent back to that,

00:51:19.718 --> 00:51:22.338
<v Stu>but I think it's very deliberate. The beginning is just like written,

00:51:22.498 --> 00:51:23.898
<v Stu>performed, directed, and edited by Bo.

00:51:24.158 --> 00:51:27.058
<v Stu>And it's just that at the beginning. And at the end, you get the credits for

00:51:27.058 --> 00:51:31.078
<v Stu>all the online editors and the sound mixes and the colorists and the rest of the team.

00:51:31.178 --> 00:51:34.958
<v Stu>But part of the shtick of that, the Egos, am I saying that correctly?

00:51:34.958 --> 00:51:40.098
<v Stu>Ethos is the positioning yeah i've just combined it with the ego from freud

00:51:40.098 --> 00:51:42.038
<v Stu>and got egos ethos i mean that is the.

00:51:42.038 --> 00:51:45.218
<v Alice>Other question is can you do a show that's entirely up your own ass.

00:51:47.238 --> 00:51:49.558
<v Stu>Apparently so um and people.

00:51:49.558 --> 00:51:50.118
<v Alice>Will love it.

00:51:50.118 --> 00:51:54.198
<v Stu>But that's part of like that is an ethos that is a presentation there and her

00:51:54.198 --> 00:51:57.458
<v Stu>what's interesting about the can i quit comedy is that something that's very

00:51:57.458 --> 00:52:03.958
<v Stu>personal to her and the ethos and your thing about i've experienced loss um and i'm sorry Like,

00:52:04.118 --> 00:52:07.118
<v Stu>not only talking about a comedy, I just talked about my uncomfortableness about

00:52:07.118 --> 00:52:10.838
<v Stu>talking about people's stand-up show, I'm talking about a stand-up show that you wrote about loss.

00:52:10.998 --> 00:52:16.738
<v Stu>So, I'm hopefully not going to step on any landfines.

00:52:16.998 --> 00:52:20.378
<v Stu>And then you're us basically exploring that question for you,

00:52:20.518 --> 00:52:21.778
<v Stu>right? These are questions for you.

00:52:21.878 --> 00:52:26.898
<v Stu>And in some ways, it feels like Hannah is debating about debating within that

00:52:26.898 --> 00:52:31.838
<v Stu>kind of rhetorical sense between the positions of, is there value in comedy, right? Right.

00:52:32.040 --> 00:52:35.000
<v Stu>I'm quitting comedy comes from her having come to a conclusion,

00:52:35.000 --> 00:52:39.240
<v Stu>but it seems the show's structure is literally debating the value of comedy.

00:52:39.480 --> 00:52:41.120
<v Stu>I don't think Baby Copper has that.

00:52:42.300 --> 00:52:45.360
<v Stu>I don't think, and it's going to be interesting to look at because I actually

00:52:45.360 --> 00:52:48.240
<v Stu>think it's an example of the American style, which is it's more of a series

00:52:48.240 --> 00:52:51.360
<v Stu>of like 10 minute bits strung together thematically.

00:52:51.600 --> 00:52:53.940
<v Stu>And it does an attempt of pathos at the end.

00:52:54.280 --> 00:52:57.940
<v Alice>And also the nature of that American style is it's more explicit.

00:52:58.320 --> 00:53:01.540
<v Alice>One of the things you notice if you perform to an American audience is that

00:53:01.540 --> 00:53:05.180
<v Alice>they are a very polite and mainstream American audience.

00:53:05.440 --> 00:53:08.120
<v Alice>There are, of course, alternative rooms all over the place, and this is a very

00:53:08.120 --> 00:53:09.060
<v Alice>generalized statement.

00:53:09.300 --> 00:53:15.200
<v Alice>They like to know when to laugh. They like to have a punchline that's very clearly set out for them.

00:53:15.320 --> 00:53:19.780
<v Alice>They like that rhythm of stand-up that's familiar to them so that they know

00:53:19.780 --> 00:53:21.680
<v Alice>when they should laugh and when they should stop laughing.

00:53:22.275 --> 00:53:25.935
<v Alice>And that's different in the UK, different in Australia, again.

00:53:26.055 --> 00:53:28.835
<v Stu>I think that coming back to storytelling, because I've been thinking about this

00:53:28.835 --> 00:53:30.495
<v Stu>recently with Turning Points, right?

00:53:30.615 --> 00:53:34.155
<v Stu>And one of the dilemma of having all our screenwriting education focused on,

00:53:34.155 --> 00:53:37.055
<v Stu>like, the hero's journey, right, in various forms.

00:53:37.135 --> 00:53:40.635
<v Stu>And you see this criticism around, like, Marvel films, and you watch all these

00:53:40.635 --> 00:53:44.575
<v Stu>video essays on YouTube, and they pick a film, like, that we love,

00:53:44.875 --> 00:53:46.155
<v Stu>Manchester by the Seaside.

00:53:46.295 --> 00:53:49.615
<v Stu>And they sit there and criticize it because it's missing these structural elements

00:53:49.615 --> 00:53:52.495
<v Stu>that come from the book, right? And you're like, you are missing this incredibly

00:53:52.495 --> 00:53:55.135
<v Stu>powerful story about fucking grief, right?

00:53:55.255 --> 00:53:58.155
<v Stu>Because it doesn't adhere to the structure that you're expecting.

00:53:58.335 --> 00:54:01.955
<v Stu>So you end up creating this feedback loop because people are taught to like this structure.

00:54:02.135 --> 00:54:06.215
<v Stu>It's like Pavlo's dog, right? And then because then something doesn't have that

00:54:06.215 --> 00:54:07.675
<v Stu>structure, they find it really frustrating.

00:54:07.875 --> 00:54:12.775
<v Alice>So I did a reading of the pilot episode of the show that I'm basing off,

00:54:12.895 --> 00:54:14.775
<v Alice>Savage, with a number of actors.

00:54:15.535 --> 00:54:18.635
<v Alice>And sorry to bring it back to my own experience here.

00:54:18.635 --> 00:54:21.455
<v Alice>But it was fascinating listening to the

00:54:21.455 --> 00:54:24.255
<v Alice>actors afterwards i asked for for notes and what that

00:54:24.255 --> 00:54:28.175
<v Alice>you know what they'd gotten from it and all of that and specifically

00:54:28.175 --> 00:54:31.095
<v Alice>the young men actors in the

00:54:31.095 --> 00:54:36.555
<v Alice>room were like what's her arc what's her journey how does she feel about this

00:54:36.555 --> 00:54:40.875
<v Alice>and why isn't she following her dream here and all of the female actors and

00:54:40.875 --> 00:54:44.755
<v Alice>the older men actors i didn't have to say anything they were like it's so obvious

00:54:44.755 --> 00:54:47.695
<v Alice>what is motivating her she's just getting through the day. She's,

00:54:47.735 --> 00:54:49.515
<v Alice>you know, all of these different competing interests.

00:54:49.735 --> 00:54:54.555
<v Alice>And then I got these notes afterwards from these screenwriting friends who were

00:54:54.555 --> 00:54:59.175
<v Alice>like, well, you need to show her development over the course of the,

00:54:59.255 --> 00:55:02.215
<v Alice>and by her, I mean the character that's based on me. So it's all very stressful.

00:55:06.791 --> 00:55:10.491
<v Alice>That she has to change and learn and grow and be moving towards a goal.

00:55:10.851 --> 00:55:15.611
<v Alice>And for me, the whole point of that episode is to show this person who is in a trap.

00:55:16.191 --> 00:55:20.931
<v Alice>You know, in that the context of it in this broader version of Savage,

00:55:21.051 --> 00:55:23.611
<v Alice>in this broader universe of Savage is that she's looking after her mum,

00:55:23.691 --> 00:55:28.291
<v Alice>she's working in the law firm, she's doing stand-up, and she's trying to keep everybody happy.

00:55:28.571 --> 00:55:33.971
<v Alice>She's doing all the right things and she cannot, like it's too much.

00:55:33.971 --> 00:55:41.011
<v Alice>She's completely trapped by all of these competing wants and needs and her kind of her journey is,

00:55:42.191 --> 00:55:45.991
<v Alice>irrelevant you know she is completely in this in

00:55:45.991 --> 00:55:48.911
<v Alice>this trap of her own making without ever having done anything

00:55:48.911 --> 00:55:51.731
<v Alice>wrong and that's the if there's an arc it's

00:55:51.731 --> 00:55:54.611
<v Alice>just her realizing the corner that she's backed herself

00:55:54.611 --> 00:55:57.951
<v Alice>into but to have that be so evident

00:55:57.951 --> 00:56:01.511
<v Alice>and obviously this is down to my very rudimentary like

00:56:01.511 --> 00:56:04.831
<v Alice>screenwriting skills i'd have no screenwriting skills but just

00:56:04.831 --> 00:56:07.871
<v Alice>for me that this like screen the criticism i

00:56:07.871 --> 00:56:12.731
<v Alice>got was very screenwriting 101 according to this script we need to have this

00:56:12.731 --> 00:56:16.691
<v Alice>arc and in my head i'm like well i need to listen to these people because they're

00:56:16.691 --> 00:56:19.691
<v Alice>the ones who actually know what they're talking about but equally i don't want

00:56:19.691 --> 00:56:26.631
<v Alice>there to be an arc i want this to be the i want you to see that this is a frustrated arc i want the don.

00:56:26.631 --> 00:56:31.431
<v Stu>Draper You don't watch the pilot episode of Mad Men and go, wow,

00:56:31.711 --> 00:56:34.031
<v Stu>Don Japer didn't really learn from his experience, right?

00:56:35.031 --> 00:56:37.891
<v Stu>What changes is our understanding of it.

00:56:37.971 --> 00:56:41.831
<v Stu>The pathos in Mad Men is the pathos isn't the actor changing.

00:56:41.831 --> 00:56:46.371
<v Stu>It's us going, it's deliberately bookended by him from every of the pilot.

00:56:46.571 --> 00:56:50.771
<v Stu>Like it's him waking up with a mistress and then going home to his family, right?

00:56:51.469 --> 00:56:56.629
<v Stu>That's kind of like the journey, but he doesn't change. He doesn't change for seven seasons.

00:56:58.109 --> 00:57:04.029
<v Stu>Right? But that's interesting because it comes back to what you're talking about with ethos, right?

00:57:04.089 --> 00:57:07.549
<v Stu>And the presentation and also our expectation of characters, right?

00:57:07.669 --> 00:57:11.789
<v Stu>And her being a woman on stage in the Sydney Opera House and also then presenting

00:57:11.789 --> 00:57:14.249
<v Stu>to American audiences, it's all very connected.

00:57:14.249 --> 00:57:20.169
<v Stu>That we, for so long, male characters have allowed to be unchanging and the

00:57:20.169 --> 00:57:24.849
<v Stu>kind of, this writer, I called it her, called the steadfast arc, okay?

00:57:25.049 --> 00:57:27.489
<v Stu>So a character doesn't change and they change the world around them, okay?

00:57:27.809 --> 00:57:30.889
<v Stu>And it's usually because they hold some kind of truth, you know.

00:57:31.729 --> 00:57:35.529
<v Stu>Hunger Games is a great example of that. She doesn't change Jennifer Lawrence's

00:57:35.529 --> 00:57:38.569
<v Stu>character. She just convinces everyone that she's right and then you can stand up.

00:57:38.689 --> 00:57:43.009
<v Stu>That feels so unusual because it's a kind of structural thing that we've attached to men.

00:57:43.989 --> 00:57:48.769
<v Stu>And that is, it's interesting because stand-up, because it's so obviously closely,

00:57:49.129 --> 00:57:53.629
<v Stu>more closely tied to the ethos that is being presented to us,

00:57:53.769 --> 00:57:55.449
<v Stu>that they have to kind of tackle that,

00:57:55.909 --> 00:58:00.389
<v Stu>you know, that they kind of have to speak about the elephant in the room,

00:58:00.489 --> 00:58:02.569
<v Stu>which is literally them on stage, you know, alone.

00:58:02.569 --> 00:58:07.949
<v Alice>Yes, who am I? Who am I to you? And some, you know, surprisingly often you'll

00:58:07.949 --> 00:58:12.549
<v Alice>see a comedian address that directly and they'll say, I know what I look like to you.

00:58:13.229 --> 00:58:18.269
<v Alice>Next time you watch a stand-up special, see, I would say the majority of stand-ups

00:58:18.269 --> 00:58:22.369
<v Alice>at some point will go, I know what I look like to you. You are thinking this

00:58:22.369 --> 00:58:23.369
<v Alice>when you're looking at me.

00:58:24.009 --> 00:58:29.549
<v Chas>And that's the challenge when introducing any character in scripted storytelling as well.

00:58:29.909 --> 00:58:34.449
<v Chas>Like, how do we want the audience to react to their character?

00:58:34.609 --> 00:58:37.249
<v Chas>Are they aware of how they come across or not?

00:58:38.409 --> 00:58:41.689
<v Chas>Do they revel in it? Is it a choice? All those kind of things.

00:58:42.655 --> 00:58:46.835
<v Stu>So, I want to get to the catharsis moment, right? Because I think it is definitely in the net.

00:58:47.055 --> 00:58:50.995
<v Stu>So, my memory of our episode of catharsis, but I didn't revisit it because I

00:58:50.995 --> 00:58:54.595
<v Stu>was lazy and I was still preparing the homework for this episode,

00:58:54.775 --> 00:58:58.615
<v Stu>is that it was this idea, the beats of catharsis. And what I remember is that

00:58:58.615 --> 00:59:00.975
<v Stu>there's this moment of discombulation, right?

00:59:01.055 --> 00:59:02.035
<v Stu>Something that seemingly came out

00:59:02.035 --> 00:59:05.975
<v Stu>of nowhere that threw us back to the beginning of the film of the story.

00:59:06.035 --> 00:59:10.035
<v Stu>And that caused a moment of self-reflection on the audience.

00:59:10.035 --> 00:59:14.335
<v Stu>And then that is connected to the reflection of the character, right?

00:59:14.435 --> 00:59:17.215
<v Stu>So the character, or is it more that the character, that makes the character

00:59:17.215 --> 00:59:20.895
<v Stu>reflect and then we connect with them. It's, I can't remember the exact order of beats.

00:59:20.895 --> 00:59:26.915
<v Chas>From my memory, like there's something, a setback happens, like,

00:59:27.035 --> 00:59:33.575
<v Chas>as you say, like a discombobulation, and then the character has a realization, and then the,

00:59:34.015 --> 00:59:36.055
<v Chas>you're kind of prompting, and look,

00:59:36.615 --> 00:59:41.335
<v Chas>Alice, with your masters in rhetoric and telling us about Aristotle,

00:59:41.475 --> 00:59:43.375
<v Chas>you've probably got this at the fingertips.

00:59:43.375 --> 00:59:47.635
<v Chas>But then the audience is thrown before all this the audience is thrown back

00:59:47.635 --> 00:59:52.415
<v Chas>to the beginning of the film or the story so that they go this what we're about

00:59:52.415 --> 00:59:55.755
<v Chas>to see is what this has all been about.

00:59:55.755 --> 01:00:00.255
<v Stu>And these are the specific techniques that allow the structural stuff that allows

01:00:00.255 --> 01:00:04.435
<v Stu>this to happen and i think what hannah gatsby does is that i can't remember

01:00:04.435 --> 01:00:07.695
<v Stu>the exact moment but when she transitioned is it no it's the story it's the

01:00:07.695 --> 01:00:12.435
<v Stu>story about the guy and the her being assaulted That's when it really goes to the next level, right?

01:00:12.575 --> 01:00:14.955
<v Stu>When she talks about, oh, I was nearly killed by someone, and she goes,

01:00:15.095 --> 01:00:18.015
<v Stu>like, ha-ha, and he laughed at me because he called her a faggot and realized.

01:00:18.175 --> 01:00:21.675
<v Stu>And then she tells the rest of that story. And that, to me, is the final,

01:00:22.195 --> 01:00:23.995
<v Stu>like, it's becoming more serious.

01:00:24.275 --> 01:00:27.215
<v Stu>You know, the structure of the show is it becomes less joke-suffy.

01:00:27.435 --> 01:00:31.335
<v Stu>You know, she tells joke, joke, joke, then it's joke, serious joke, serious joke.

01:00:32.134 --> 01:00:34.854
<v Stu>Joke serious, then it's just more and more serious, right? And she goes into

01:00:34.854 --> 01:00:39.494
<v Stu>that moment, and it forces us to reflect on the very beginning and the what is it all about.

01:00:39.634 --> 01:00:44.234
<v Stu>And it kind of brings everything together. And as you say, we might self-reflect

01:00:44.234 --> 01:00:46.814
<v Stu>because to her talking about it, you know, I start thinking about her being

01:00:46.814 --> 01:00:50.454
<v Stu>in Tasmania and her mum, and I think about Nanette.

01:00:50.874 --> 01:00:55.054
<v Stu>She said, like, she never explains why, who Nanette was, but you get this sense

01:00:55.054 --> 01:00:57.814
<v Stu>it might be connected to the story at the end.

01:00:57.974 --> 01:01:01.314
<v Stu>And all those things bring the feels together.

01:01:01.994 --> 01:01:06.434
<v Stu>And I'm not just using feels, I mean, it sounds so flippant given what she's

01:01:06.434 --> 01:01:10.554
<v Stu>talking about, but it's literally making me feel and reflect on what I've been

01:01:10.554 --> 01:01:11.494
<v Stu>watching and listening to.

01:01:11.774 --> 01:01:16.994
<v Alice>So, that is the process of catharsis, which is more often associated with tragedy than with comedy.

01:01:17.574 --> 01:01:24.334
<v Alice>It's that in its very most basic form, you attach the audience to the characters.

01:01:25.374 --> 01:01:29.834
<v Alice>You invest the audience in the process of the character. So the crisis of the

01:01:29.834 --> 01:01:32.454
<v Alice>character becomes a proxy for the crises of the audience.

01:01:32.794 --> 01:01:37.674
<v Alice>And then the resolution of that crisis is cathartic for the audience because

01:01:37.674 --> 01:01:40.974
<v Alice>they have attached to the character.

01:01:41.434 --> 01:01:48.794
<v Alice>And so in that way, I think of the structure of Nanette as being this process

01:01:48.794 --> 01:01:53.334
<v Alice>of she couldn't tell that story at the front of the show.

01:01:53.334 --> 01:01:59.954
<v Alice>She has to give you all of this context and build-up so that when she reveals

01:01:59.954 --> 01:02:02.254
<v Alice>the second half of this story, you know who she is.

01:02:03.093 --> 01:02:08.033
<v Alice>And you know, you've seen, you've witnessed her coping mechanisms, healthy and unhealthy.

01:02:08.453 --> 01:02:12.673
<v Alice>You've witnessed what it's done to her character and to her anger.

01:02:13.593 --> 01:02:19.693
<v Alice>It provides a kind of a retrospective context for all of this anger that has

01:02:19.693 --> 01:02:21.573
<v Alice>been peeping through throughout.

01:02:22.133 --> 01:02:26.513
<v Alice>And all of a sudden, this anger is so justified by that final story.

01:02:26.713 --> 01:02:31.253
<v Alice>It reframes all of the moments before that were deliberately not comedy.

01:02:31.433 --> 01:02:34.873
<v Alice>And it justifies them. in a very satisfying way.

01:02:35.093 --> 01:02:38.593
<v Chas>And it allows us to leave, even though we're not left with a...

01:02:40.013 --> 01:02:46.993
<v Chas>Happy comedy jaunt out of the auditorium we're not left with baggage like she does,

01:02:47.873 --> 01:02:51.013
<v Chas>deliberately provide us as an audience with catharsis

01:02:51.013 --> 01:02:53.693
<v Chas>so that we can reflect on it

01:02:53.693 --> 01:02:56.513
<v Chas>like we're not leaving burdened but all the all

01:02:56.513 --> 01:02:59.833
<v Chas>the specials do it and and your work as

01:02:59.833 --> 01:03:03.713
<v Chas>well alice like they all very deliberately throw

01:03:03.713 --> 01:03:06.913
<v Chas>the audience back as they're wrapping up to what

01:03:06.913 --> 01:03:10.753
<v Chas>they've started with baby cobra

01:03:10.753 --> 01:03:15.593
<v Chas>as much as it is more of like the american style a collection of bits there

01:03:15.593 --> 01:03:21.733
<v Chas>is an organizing structure to it which is all about um nearly all of the material

01:03:21.733 --> 01:03:30.013
<v Chas>that she's chosen to keep in there is about her relationship with her now husband as she's talking.

01:03:31.453 --> 01:03:38.873
<v Excerpts>I grew up a lot this past year. This past year I also got married. Yeah.

01:03:41.773 --> 01:03:45.473
<v Excerpts>To a man who now has HPV.

01:03:47.413 --> 01:03:52.113
<v Excerpts>Very lucky guy. He gave me something.

01:03:52.753 --> 01:03:57.613
<v Excerpts>I gave him something that will also last forever.

01:03:58.333 --> 01:04:03.133
<v Chas>And I don't want to ruin it because it's like the whole thing is like a setup,

01:04:03.433 --> 01:04:07.213
<v Chas>the whole organizing structure is a setup for a gag at the end,

01:04:07.233 --> 01:04:10.493
<v Chas>but it is the organizing principle is all about her relationship.

01:04:10.493 --> 01:04:14.433
<v Chas>And she goes at various points, retelling all the beats of their relationship

01:04:14.433 --> 01:04:17.113
<v Chas>to just keep orienting us, keep orienting us.

01:04:17.413 --> 01:04:22.853
<v Chas>And then at the end, you know, it lead that retelling of that whole thing is a joke.

01:04:23.013 --> 01:04:27.353
<v Chas>Now, I wouldn't say it's catharsis at that point, because it's not about us

01:04:27.353 --> 01:04:30.833
<v Chas>having an emotional experience, it is really just a joke.

01:04:32.076 --> 01:04:36.896
<v Chas>At the end but it is using that tool of throwing us back to the beginning to

01:04:36.896 --> 01:04:39.836
<v Chas>go like this is what this was all about yes.

01:04:39.836 --> 01:04:43.756
<v Alice>It's structural resolution to things that didn't necessarily look like they

01:04:43.756 --> 01:04:45.076
<v Alice>were purposive at the time.

01:04:45.076 --> 01:04:51.696
<v Stu>And i think what's interesting about inside is it does coming back to i i know

01:04:51.696 --> 01:04:54.836
<v Stu>you're trying to set up to baby cobra and i want to find a way to come back

01:04:54.836 --> 01:04:57.416
<v Stu>to nanette And I'm going to do that via inside.

01:04:57.876 --> 01:05:04.416
<v Stu>Bo keeps on intercutting the musical numbers with the shots of him alone in the room, right?

01:05:04.676 --> 01:05:09.616
<v Stu>And that is exactly like Hannah Gadsby punctuating her jokes with a serious moment.

01:05:09.676 --> 01:05:14.096
<v Stu>And then he just brings it back at the end by the show ending with him watching

01:05:14.096 --> 01:05:16.016
<v Stu>himself projected trapped in the house, right?

01:05:16.176 --> 01:05:18.616
<v Stu>It's very kind of performance arty by the end.

01:05:19.136 --> 01:05:22.336
<v Stu>You know, I was like, oh, this reminds me of Sheila Booth watching whatever

01:05:22.336 --> 01:05:25.256
<v Stu>it was, three days of Sheila Booth or whatever that weird thing.

01:05:25.416 --> 01:05:28.916
<v Stu>But it's the same kind of structure, right? And sometimes it's introducing the

01:05:28.916 --> 01:05:32.076
<v Stu>bum note or whatever it is. God, that's such a weird way of expression.

01:05:32.356 --> 01:05:35.616
<v Stu>The moment of contrast that then you can bring it together.

01:05:35.836 --> 01:05:38.876
<v Stu>You know, it is the fugue kind of structure, right? And I think that's a really

01:05:38.876 --> 01:05:40.676
<v Stu>interesting structural position.

01:05:41.656 --> 01:05:47.276
<v Stu>I wanted to come back to Hannah Gatsby because not only is she meta about her

01:05:47.276 --> 01:05:49.796
<v Stu>process of writing the show, she's meta about the structure,

01:05:49.936 --> 01:05:51.816
<v Stu>this idea that I'm the master of tension.

01:05:51.816 --> 01:05:55.816
<v Stu>All this is, is about tension, this tension, and then I resolve the tension,

01:05:55.976 --> 01:05:57.136
<v Stu>jokes are the half the story.

01:05:57.296 --> 01:06:00.796
<v Stu>And we've talked about that briefly, but I think it'd be interesting holding

01:06:00.796 --> 01:06:04.236
<v Stu>onto that idea because it's something that we do talk about in screenwriting.

01:06:04.316 --> 01:06:08.736
<v Stu>We've got a three and a half hour podcast about questions in sequences, right?

01:06:08.856 --> 01:06:12.276
<v Stu>The films ask a question and then they answer the question and that often the

01:06:12.276 --> 01:06:13.556
<v Stu>answer prompts a new question.

01:06:14.243 --> 01:06:21.503
<v Alice>Certainly with Gatsby, she's doing this as meta-commentary on society as well.

01:06:21.583 --> 01:06:24.203
<v Alice>The reflection is both inwards and outwards in that she's saying,

01:06:24.403 --> 01:06:27.023
<v Alice>I'm the master of tension, tension release.

01:06:27.363 --> 01:06:30.783
<v Alice>I build the tension, I release the tension. She's also commenting on the ways

01:06:30.783 --> 01:06:34.463
<v Alice>in which, and this is one of the reasons why the special hit so hard at the

01:06:34.463 --> 01:06:35.403
<v Alice>time that it was released,

01:06:35.923 --> 01:06:41.443
<v Alice>that she's commenting on the ways in which women are held responsible for making things okay,

01:06:41.443 --> 01:06:44.563
<v Alice>even when those things are things that have happened to

01:06:44.563 --> 01:06:48.063
<v Alice>them and every woman has experienced that

01:06:48.063 --> 01:06:51.323
<v Alice>where something has happened to you and you

01:06:51.323 --> 01:06:54.263
<v Alice>tell someone even in the process of telling someone oh

01:06:54.263 --> 01:06:57.683
<v Alice>this person did this thing to me and then

01:06:57.683 --> 01:07:00.423
<v Alice>you go I'm fine I'm fine I'm fine it's okay and you have

01:07:00.423 --> 01:07:03.483
<v Alice>to make it all right all of a sudden because female anger

01:07:03.483 --> 01:07:07.023
<v Alice>and female pain is seen as as inappropriate or uncomfortable

01:07:07.023 --> 01:07:10.343
<v Alice>in ways that we are not

01:07:10.343 --> 01:07:15.643
<v Alice>equipped as a society to properly deal with and so her refusal at the end even

01:07:15.643 --> 01:07:20.303
<v Alice>if it is just an artistic refusal to resolve that tension as you say she does

01:07:20.303 --> 01:07:24.403
<v Alice>it is a satisfying show so she does in some way resolve the tension but her

01:07:24.403 --> 01:07:27.363
<v Alice>express refusal to resolve that tension,

01:07:28.183 --> 01:07:33.883
<v Alice>is a comment on this kind of call to action that the show makes of stop making

01:07:33.883 --> 01:07:37.283
<v Alice>it all right Stop only telling the funny half of the story. Stop.

01:07:38.203 --> 01:07:42.263
<v Alice>Or I'm going to stop doing that. And as the audience attached to her story,

01:07:42.343 --> 01:07:44.143
<v Alice>we think, well, we will also stop doing that.

01:07:45.436 --> 01:07:48.536
<v Stu>And it is, I think, part of the reason the show made people uncomfortable and

01:07:48.536 --> 01:07:53.036
<v Stu>they were not happy with, or more specifically, the reason that people did not

01:07:53.036 --> 01:07:56.456
<v Stu>like the show is because it set out to make them feel uncomfortable and they

01:07:56.456 --> 01:07:59.096
<v Stu>did not like sitting in their discomfort.

01:08:00.316 --> 01:08:06.436
<v Stu>Right? And so they're looking for a way out. And it ends with her going home with tea, which I love.

01:08:06.796 --> 01:08:10.076
<v Stu>She looks so happy and she's got these dogs. And it's like she's dropped this

01:08:10.076 --> 01:08:13.776
<v Stu>truth bomb and then she is detaching and we are seeing her in her private.

01:08:13.776 --> 01:08:19.816
<v Stu>We're getting access to her private life, you know, and that is an interesting framing device.

01:08:20.016 --> 01:08:24.156
<v Alice>Which, yeah, is also a statement and comment about trauma, you know,

01:08:24.216 --> 01:08:28.396
<v Alice>that women who tell their traumatic stories are not obliged then to be constantly

01:08:28.396 --> 01:08:31.656
<v Alice>in a state of suffering. You don't have to be the martyr.

01:08:32.036 --> 01:08:35.856
<v Stu>I'm going to awkwardly transition now to Baby Copper unless there's any other

01:08:35.856 --> 01:08:40.816
<v Stu>conversation about Nanette because this idea that you brought up about women,

01:08:40.816 --> 01:08:43.156
<v Stu>because she uses this just a little

01:08:43.156 --> 01:08:47.496
<v Stu>bit about bossy and that we call women bossy and bossy is being bad.

01:08:47.636 --> 01:08:52.516
<v Stu>So that feels like this connection to what Alice Wong is doing because she does

01:08:52.516 --> 01:08:57.996
<v Stu>that really dirty comedy and it's coming out of a pregnant Asian woman and that

01:08:57.996 --> 01:09:01.976
<v Stu>is definitely meant to be a contrast in the same way that Hannah Gadsby was

01:09:01.976 --> 01:09:04.656
<v Stu>commenting on about angry white men can be so,

01:09:05.036 --> 01:09:06.996
<v Stu>like they're allowed to be angry comedians.

01:09:07.156 --> 01:09:10.296
<v Stu>I do it and it's no longer, I'm no longer a comedian, right?

01:09:10.296 --> 01:09:12.076
<v Stu>And it seems to be something that she's saying.

01:09:12.596 --> 01:09:17.716
<v Stu>And then Alice Wong's embracing that kind of American-style dirty humour,

01:09:17.776 --> 01:09:20.636
<v Stu>and it's coming out of someone that we normally wouldn't, or I wouldn't,

01:09:20.696 --> 01:09:22.016
<v Stu>and this is revealing my prejudice.

01:09:22.176 --> 01:09:23.196
<v Alice>I think it's just Ali Wong.

01:09:24.116 --> 01:09:25.196
<v Stu>Oh, it is Ali Wong.

01:09:25.276 --> 01:09:25.736
<v Chas>You're correct.

01:09:26.116 --> 01:09:26.796
<v Alice>I'm Alice.

01:09:29.586 --> 01:09:34.186
<v Stu>But, you know, she is creating, playing with that idea that she's a small woman

01:09:34.186 --> 01:09:38.266
<v Stu>telling these big jokes and she's taking up a lot of space on the stage with

01:09:38.266 --> 01:09:40.046
<v Stu>her volume and her gestures.

01:09:40.566 --> 01:09:44.126
<v Stu>So, Chaz, do you want to kind of summarize what the show is about?

01:09:44.366 --> 01:09:52.026
<v Chas>Yeah. Like I said, it's mainly a show about, like, how she got to be pregnant

01:09:52.026 --> 01:09:53.926
<v Chas>and married and, like, meet her husband.

01:09:53.926 --> 01:09:58.966
<v Chas>That's kind of, like, the story she keeps coming back to and ultimately resolves

01:09:58.966 --> 01:10:01.386
<v Chas>with. but it goes through a lot.

01:10:01.606 --> 01:10:05.286
<v Chas>I think she does less of the commentary.

01:10:05.626 --> 01:10:10.806
<v Chas>So there's only one point where she directly talks about kind of who she is

01:10:10.806 --> 01:10:12.406
<v Chas>as a person, as a female comedian.

01:10:13.506 --> 01:10:21.786
<v Excerpts>It's very rare and unusual to see a female comic perform pregnant because female

01:10:21.786 --> 01:10:24.566
<v Excerpts>comics don't get pregnant.

01:10:29.246 --> 01:10:32.606
<v Excerpts>Just try to think of one, I dare you, there's none of them,

01:10:33.106 --> 01:10:37.646
<v Excerpts>once they do get pregnant, they generally disappear, that's not the case with

01:10:37.646 --> 01:10:42.166
<v Excerpts>male comics, once they have a baby, they'll get up on stage a week afterwards,

01:10:42.586 --> 01:10:45.726
<v Excerpts>and they'll be like, guys, I just had this fucking baby,

01:10:46.086 --> 01:10:49.766
<v Excerpts>that baby's a little piece of shit, it's so annoying and boring,

01:10:50.066 --> 01:10:53.726
<v Excerpts>and all these other shitty dads in the audience are like, that's hilarious

01:10:53.726 --> 01:10:56.406
<v Excerpts>i identify and their

01:10:56.406 --> 01:11:01.366
<v Excerpts>fame just swells because they become this relatable family funny man all of

01:11:01.366 --> 01:11:06.906
<v Excerpts>a sudden meanwhile the mom is at home chapping her nipples feeding the fucking

01:11:06.906 --> 01:11:11.866
<v Excerpts>baby and wearing a frozen diaper because her pussy needs to heal from the baby's

01:11:11.866 --> 01:11:14.766
<v Excerpts>head shredding it up she's busy and.

01:11:14.766 --> 01:11:18.806
<v Chas>She brings it back to a joke which is like you know in nanette hannah's talking

01:11:18.806 --> 01:11:21.346
<v Chas>about quitting comedy in Baby Cobra.

01:11:21.486 --> 01:11:26.786
<v Chas>She's talking about trying to retire as soon as possible. Like she wants to stop working.

01:11:27.186 --> 01:11:30.646
<v Alice>Well, so that's the interesting thing from a screenwriting perspective as well,

01:11:30.806 --> 01:11:36.906
<v Alice>because so much of Ali Wong's special is about the typecasting that her audience,

01:11:37.346 --> 01:11:41.666
<v Alice>and particularly America, is very racially aware.

01:11:41.826 --> 01:11:49.126
<v Alice>I started stand-up when I was living in New York and so many of the jokes that are told are racial.

01:11:50.066 --> 01:11:53.066
<v Alice>And certainly they were in 2009 when I was there.

01:11:53.326 --> 01:11:58.106
<v Alice>It was an incredible thing to see as part of the culture.

01:11:58.266 --> 01:12:01.186
<v Alice>It's an obsession within the culture of people being very conscious of their

01:12:01.186 --> 01:12:04.406
<v Alice>demographic within that society in a way that,

01:12:04.766 --> 01:12:07.946
<v Alice>although Australia has its kind of racist issues, I don't think we have that

01:12:07.946 --> 01:12:13.346
<v Alice>quite as much, or certainly not to that degree, of people performing or understanding

01:12:13.346 --> 01:12:16.286
<v Alice>themselves as their demographic rather than just as a person.

01:12:16.486 --> 01:12:22.086
<v Alice>And that all ties in with these ideas about privilege and so on that we can go into or out of,

01:12:22.206 --> 01:12:26.726
<v Alice>but let's say that this tendency exists in the American audience too,

01:12:26.746 --> 01:12:32.946
<v Alice>so that they will look at Ali Wong and they will think that they'll cast her in their mind as a type.

01:12:33.226 --> 01:12:36.886
<v Alice>And most of her jokes are playing against that type.

01:12:38.006 --> 01:12:43.006
<v Alice>So it's a thing that I don't know if you can do as much as a screenwriter because

01:12:43.006 --> 01:12:47.546
<v Alice>so much of it, casting is about casting the right people who fit these types,

01:12:47.566 --> 01:12:51.726
<v Alice>who tell the story with their presence or their face or what they look like.

01:12:51.886 --> 01:12:55.186
<v Alice>But that's one of the great things that you get to do in a special is if you

01:12:55.186 --> 01:13:01.006
<v Alice>understand how the audience sees you, you can play with or against that story.

01:13:02.026 --> 01:13:08.146
<v Chas>So what do you, like in terms of her humour, like I've watched the special three times now.

01:13:08.286 --> 01:13:12.066
<v Chas>Her brand of disgusting humour really does appeal to me.

01:13:13.906 --> 01:13:16.566
<v Chas>But she's got a running line about HPV.

01:13:18.086 --> 01:13:21.386
<v Excerpts>But I did it on purpose. because I knew that he was a catch.

01:13:21.506 --> 01:13:26.926
<v Excerpts>So I was like, all right, Allie, you gotta make this dude believe that your body is a secret garden.

01:13:33.146 --> 01:13:35.566
<v Excerpts>When really, it's a public park.

01:13:40.506 --> 01:13:41.246
<v Excerpts>That's true.

01:13:43.973 --> 01:13:58.233
<v Excerpts>That has hosted many reggae fests and has even accidentally let two homeless people inside.

01:13:59.713 --> 01:14:03.893
<v Chas>She's using these bits that seem kind of outside of the theme,

01:14:03.993 --> 01:14:09.893
<v Chas>but she does keep bringing it back to that structure in a way that I was very impressed by.

01:14:09.893 --> 01:14:13.173
<v Chas>And that I can now see it after hearing what you've said, Alice,

01:14:13.573 --> 01:14:18.293
<v Chas>how there are two kind of different formats to it. And I can see how this kind of fits.

01:14:18.493 --> 01:14:22.513
<v Chas>But when I watched it the first time, I kind of felt like it was like an Edinburgh

01:14:22.513 --> 01:14:26.133
<v Chas>special. Like it felt like one story with just like tangents.

01:14:26.253 --> 01:14:30.833
<v Alice>I mean, it is. It is very much a cohesive story. And that's due to,

01:14:30.873 --> 01:14:33.533
<v Alice>you know, her putting it together as a special like that.

01:14:33.533 --> 01:14:38.953
<v Alice>I think that is a tendency now more and more in the American specials to come

01:14:38.953 --> 01:14:42.533
<v Alice>more towards this long-form storytelling type thing.

01:14:42.613 --> 01:14:46.613
<v Alice>I think you can see it's interesting because it's still in transition.

01:14:47.093 --> 01:14:51.773
<v Alice>You can see where the bits are club bits and where the bits are deliberately

01:14:51.773 --> 01:14:56.073
<v Alice>written to be interstitial or storytelling or connecting tissue.

01:14:56.653 --> 01:15:01.353
<v Alice>But she is such a consistent performer and her voice is so clear that it all

01:15:01.353 --> 01:15:06.133
<v Alice>works cohesively to tell the story that she is telling, which is about how women

01:15:06.133 --> 01:15:09.553
<v Alice>should be, how relationships should be, what women should be interested in.

01:15:10.733 --> 01:15:15.973
<v Alice>The idea that all you want is to get married and have kids and, you know, retire.

01:15:16.373 --> 01:15:20.293
<v Alice>And she's simultaneously telling that story and going against that story.

01:15:20.813 --> 01:15:25.493
<v Chas>The one bit where it felt really transgressive for me was none of the actual body humour.

01:15:25.613 --> 01:15:29.733
<v Chas>It was her bit around housewives and feminism.

01:15:30.793 --> 01:15:35.033
<v Excerpts>I think feminism is the worst thing that ever happened to women.

01:15:36.223 --> 01:15:39.463
<v Excerpts>Our job used to be no job.

01:15:41.663 --> 01:15:48.343
<v Excerpts>We had it so good. We could have done the smart thing, which would have been

01:15:48.343 --> 01:15:54.503
<v Excerpts>to continue playing dumb for the next century and be like, we're dumb women.

01:15:54.703 --> 01:15:59.003
<v Excerpts>We don't know how to do anything. So I guess we better just stay at home all

01:15:59.003 --> 01:16:00.823
<v Excerpts>day and eat snacks and watch Ellen.

01:16:03.258 --> 01:16:05.718
<v Chas>And I was just like sitting there like laughing, but also like,

01:16:05.858 --> 01:16:07.338
<v Chas>am I allowed to laugh at this?

01:16:08.058 --> 01:16:13.018
<v Stu>And that was something that got passed around, like either as viral marketing

01:16:13.018 --> 01:16:14.938
<v Stu>or because people took it without context.

01:16:15.058 --> 01:16:18.598
<v Stu>Because I think the recontextualization she does at the end,

01:16:18.758 --> 01:16:23.378
<v Stu>the punchline is to make you recontextualize everything that she's just said, right?

01:16:23.478 --> 01:16:29.738
<v Stu>It's not an emotional one, but it's a intellectual kind of reversal at the very end of the special.

01:16:30.678 --> 01:16:34.298
<v Stu>I do want to kind of like dive a little bit deep because it also connects to

01:16:34.298 --> 01:16:36.718
<v Stu>the rhythm, right? The club bit versus the storytelling bit.

01:16:36.878 --> 01:16:41.178
<v Stu>Because for some reason, the way I would describe the rhythm of the Ali Wong

01:16:41.178 --> 01:16:46.978
<v Stu>special is it's a lot more like super fast jazz. It reminds me of like Jimmy Smith, you know?

01:16:47.178 --> 01:16:50.398
<v Stu>It feels like it's really fast and they just riff on this idea and they go,

01:16:50.538 --> 01:16:52.038
<v Stu>we're just going to explore this idea.

01:16:52.158 --> 01:16:55.078
<v Stu>And then it comes back to the drum beat and then it goes on this other like

01:16:55.078 --> 01:16:59.678
<v Stu>solo and it comes back. but whereas the Hannah Gadsby is a little bit more symphonic

01:16:59.678 --> 01:17:03.338
<v Stu>right like it's a feel like maybe you've got it in my head because you've described

01:17:03.338 --> 01:17:04.478
<v Stu>it as a fugue and I'm like she.

01:17:04.478 --> 01:17:08.498
<v Chas>Described it as a fugue I didn't even know what the word fugue was so just.

01:17:08.498 --> 01:17:11.918
<v Stu>It's casting me my mind back when I studied music

01:17:11.918 --> 01:17:14.958
<v Stu>composition and wanted to be a composer and and that structural stuff

01:17:14.958 --> 01:17:17.898
<v Stu>and Ali Wong feels more like yeah she's just riffing on an idea and

01:17:17.898 --> 01:17:21.658
<v Stu>explores it and she introduces like a simple joke right

01:17:21.658 --> 01:17:25.198
<v Stu>and then she kind of builds on the joke and builds on the trick which is building

01:17:25.198 --> 01:17:30.518
<v Stu>the tension she's tightening the spring to come and or as you you know she's

01:17:30.518 --> 01:17:33.358
<v Stu>loading the gun but i think maybe now as i think about it's like you crank it

01:17:33.358 --> 01:17:36.318
<v Stu>tighter and tighter she takes something simple and makes it then turns it into

01:17:36.318 --> 01:17:39.258
<v Stu>the disgusting joke right and then pushes it into,

01:17:40.018 --> 01:17:43.838
<v Stu>uncomfortable territory i'm sure that bit i would be surprised if that bit about

01:17:43.838 --> 01:17:46.838
<v Stu>feminism is halfway through the show or close to 40 minutes when people are

01:17:46.838 --> 01:17:48.518
<v Stu>getting restless and she's actually,

01:17:49.078 --> 01:17:52.518
<v Stu>playing with the rhythm of it there by pushing people into a place where they're

01:17:52.518 --> 01:17:55.598
<v Stu>either like oh yeah, or like, I can't believe she's saying this,

01:17:56.098 --> 01:18:01.598
<v Stu>probably is at that point to re-energize people. So what is the...

01:18:02.345 --> 01:18:05.085
<v Stu>Kind of difference between the club stuff and the kind of written stuff,

01:18:05.585 --> 01:18:07.205
<v Stu>Alice, that you can kind of feel?

01:18:07.725 --> 01:18:13.525
<v Stu>Because you're the expert here in terms of you've got to have an instinctive reaction to that stuff.

01:18:13.745 --> 01:18:17.925
<v Alice>I would find it difficult to describe it unless we were sitting in front of it watching it.

01:18:18.025 --> 01:18:22.685
<v Alice>But there are these self-contained bits in there that you can feel.

01:18:22.905 --> 01:18:25.785
<v Alice>As you say, there's a joke and it's introduced,

01:18:26.025 --> 01:18:28.745
<v Alice>it's unpacked, it's explored to its nth degree, and then

01:18:28.745 --> 01:18:32.725
<v Alice>it's resolved and brought back i would say i

01:18:32.725 --> 01:18:35.665
<v Alice>i don't know ali wong's process whether she has enough people

01:18:35.665 --> 01:18:38.485
<v Alice>to have done full uh however many

01:18:38.485 --> 01:18:41.645
<v Alice>full previews before she did the show but i imagine that certainly at

01:18:41.645 --> 01:18:47.825
<v Alice>least each of those bits was done in a club as a bit as a self-contained piece

01:18:47.825 --> 01:18:53.645
<v Alice>that it holds itself together and it kind of is satisfying in itself and then

01:18:53.645 --> 01:18:59.745
<v Alice>all those are put all next to one another and then there's these interstitial bits that connect them.

01:19:00.725 --> 01:19:01.385
<v Excerpts>I'll be like,

01:19:03.386 --> 01:19:06.486
<v Excerpts>doing anything look at that housewife just walking around all day

01:19:06.486 --> 01:19:16.406
<v Excerpts>getting massages and her lululemon pants like that bitch is a genius she's not

01:19:16.406 --> 01:19:25.966
<v Excerpts>a housewife she's retired I do write for fresh off the boat on ABC yeah which is,

01:19:26.766 --> 01:19:31.506
<v Excerpts>it's a great show I love it a lot I love my co-workers it's a great writing

01:19:31.506 --> 01:19:36.246
<v Excerpts>staff And in terms of day jobs, it's probably one of the best you could ask for.

01:19:36.446 --> 01:19:39.806
<v Excerpts>But I still got to work at an office.

01:19:40.046 --> 01:19:45.286
<v Stu>Yeah. I think it's Robert Bresson who was like, a movie is three good scenes and no bad ones.

01:19:45.466 --> 01:19:49.366
<v Stu>It's like maybe a comedy show is three good bits and no bad ones.

01:19:49.546 --> 01:19:53.966
<v Alice>Well, I think I would say the bits where she returns to the reprise are the

01:19:53.966 --> 01:19:59.246
<v Alice>connective tissue. And then the bits where she's exploring a joke are the more clubby bits.

01:19:59.466 --> 01:20:02.486
<v Stu>Okay. So you've just used a rhetorical term here. And this is great because

01:20:02.486 --> 01:20:05.426
<v Stu>this is cool. Like reprise. What are you talking about by reprise?

01:20:05.726 --> 01:20:10.546
<v Alice>I'm talking about returning to the theme, reprising or repeating the chorus.

01:20:11.066 --> 01:20:14.966
<v Stu>Yeah, which is about when she met her husband. Would you see that as one of them? Yes.

01:20:15.186 --> 01:20:19.566
<v Alice>Yeah, absolutely. That's the skeleton of the show. That's the bit that all the

01:20:19.566 --> 01:20:21.146
<v Alice>other things are attached to.

01:20:23.066 --> 01:20:27.026
<v Excerpts>Don't try to tell me to get my shit together when I heard you not have your shit together.

01:20:30.706 --> 01:20:36.986
<v Excerpts>My father-in-law had this huge sit down with me and my husband recently and

01:20:36.986 --> 01:20:43.006
<v Excerpts>he was like hey i want to talk to you guys about money you guys need to make

01:20:43.006 --> 01:20:47.666
<v Excerpts>a lot more money if you want to provide your children with the same kind of

01:20:47.666 --> 01:20:50.306
<v Excerpts>privileged childhood that you guys had,

01:20:52.036 --> 01:20:53.096
<v Excerpts>like, why are you telling me this

01:20:53.096 --> 01:20:58.236
<v Excerpts>shit? I should not be a part of this conversation. You tell your son that.

01:20:58.696 --> 01:21:02.616
<v Excerpts>Don't you understand that I trapped your son for his earning potential?

01:21:03.116 --> 01:21:10.696
<v Alice>And by returning to that central theme, she makes those bits relevant,

01:21:10.696 --> 01:21:15.396
<v Alice>which they might not otherwise be, but she ties them back in.

01:21:15.596 --> 01:21:18.956
<v Stu>It makes the audience think they're relevant and look for ways for them to be

01:21:18.956 --> 01:21:21.176
<v Stu>relevant, which is a structure you can use in a feature.

01:21:21.316 --> 01:21:24.056
<v Stu>I mean, a lot of features people can see, you can write stuff that's really

01:21:24.056 --> 01:21:25.716
<v Stu>episodic, which may be an epic.

01:21:26.076 --> 01:21:27.336
<v Chas>Or sequence-based.

01:21:27.756 --> 01:21:30.456
<v Stu>Yes. So, you can have stuff that, I mean, and we've talked about it,

01:21:30.536 --> 01:21:33.376
<v Stu>the Pixar stuff is very sequence-based, right? And they'll do,

01:21:33.496 --> 01:21:35.516
<v Stu>here's the horror sequence, here's the heist sequence.

01:21:35.736 --> 01:21:38.296
<v Stu>They do genre, really genre-driven sequences.

01:21:38.876 --> 01:21:42.056
<v Stu>And yet, because they're really thematically driven, they can kind of get away

01:21:42.056 --> 01:21:44.736
<v Stu>with stuff that's quite episodic in some ways, right?

01:21:44.856 --> 01:21:48.116
<v Stu>Like literally changing genres in the middle of the film.

01:21:48.336 --> 01:21:51.076
<v Stu>And I guess like Fast, I haven't seen the new Fast and the Furious because it

01:21:51.076 --> 01:21:54.396
<v Stu>could be such a good counterpoint because it just, it just like there's a bit,

01:21:54.516 --> 01:21:55.836
<v Stu>there's an action, all the rock.

01:21:56.116 --> 01:21:59.516
<v Stu>We watched that with, uh, for our lockdown movie. And it's just like,

01:21:59.596 --> 01:22:00.816
<v Stu>why is this car chasing here?

01:22:00.976 --> 01:22:04.536
<v Stu>It's literally the equivalent of a bit, right? It's like, we need to do this

01:22:04.536 --> 01:22:08.836
<v Stu>cool thing and we'll just connect it to, to the main trunk of the story and

01:22:08.836 --> 01:22:10.516
<v Stu>people will be, just go with it.

01:22:11.199 --> 01:22:14.759
<v Alice>I mean, the thing that I've always loved about the Fast and the Furious series

01:22:14.759 --> 01:22:16.399
<v Alice>is the car choreography.

01:22:16.679 --> 01:22:20.579
<v Alice>Because I was always a big Hong Kong action movie fan for the fight choreography

01:22:20.579 --> 01:22:25.659
<v Alice>and the way that they can tell the stories with this camera cinematography and

01:22:25.659 --> 01:22:27.739
<v Alice>the movement of the cars and you follow the narrative,

01:22:27.739 --> 01:22:33.679
<v Alice>even though it's just cars driving presumably fast. I don't know.

01:22:33.979 --> 01:22:37.999
<v Stu>Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, the other thing is the kind of transition that she

01:22:37.999 --> 01:22:42.499
<v Stu>uses, right? Because I think if we can kind of, if there's any observations,

01:22:42.719 --> 01:22:43.499
<v Stu>that would be fantastic.

01:22:43.699 --> 01:22:46.299
<v Stu>Otherwise, it's like, yeah, it does this thing. Yes, it does it very well. Cool.

01:22:46.679 --> 01:22:49.659
<v Stu>You know, obviously, if she's doing that kind of like, here's the main theme,

01:22:49.759 --> 01:22:52.259
<v Stu>the trunk, and then we're doing these little bits that are branching off and

01:22:52.259 --> 01:22:56.699
<v Stu>we're kind of connecting in or that she's building, I guess it's more specifically the bits.

01:22:56.819 --> 01:23:01.659
<v Stu>The bits feel like she's transitioning, right? They've got really tight transitions between ideas.

01:23:01.959 --> 01:23:06.799
<v Chas>There was one where, like in terms of transitions, the one that really stood out to me as not,

01:23:06.799 --> 01:23:10.079
<v Chas>as being bit driven is she had resolved a

01:23:10.079 --> 01:23:12.919
<v Chas>bit and there was a big laugh and then she comes

01:23:12.919 --> 01:23:16.059
<v Chas>in with so I'm pregnant and there's no

01:23:16.059 --> 01:23:20.379
<v Chas>connective tissue whatsoever so it was clear like one section finished and another

01:23:20.379 --> 01:23:24.659
<v Chas>section started and the reason why that jumped out at me is it was one of the

01:23:24.659 --> 01:23:29.759
<v Chas>few moments where it felt like that like of that American style like I'm moving

01:23:29.759 --> 01:23:34.979
<v Chas>from one section into another one and I'm you know almost starting from scratch as it were yeah.

01:23:34.979 --> 01:23:38.039
<v Alice>And again And I'm purely speculating on her methodology, but I can imagine her

01:23:38.039 --> 01:23:42.739
<v Alice>walking on stage at Caroline's in New York and going, so I'm pregnant and getting

01:23:42.739 --> 01:23:47.219
<v Alice>that big laugh at the beginning of a set and doing the rest of that bit as her set.

01:23:48.690 --> 01:23:54.170
<v Chas>The bits that stand out to me, you know, is the one where she's describing her

01:23:54.170 --> 01:23:58.250
<v Chas>body as a public park that's had two homeless people sleeping in it.

01:23:58.470 --> 01:24:02.470
<v Stu>And then she riffs on that to tell a story about the time she's met a homeless

01:24:02.470 --> 01:24:04.590
<v Stu>person. Yeah. So, building on that idea.

01:24:06.250 --> 01:24:11.810
<v Chas>Where she is talking about, you know, she's glad that her husband is Asian so

01:24:11.810 --> 01:24:13.410
<v Chas>they can be racist together.

01:24:13.650 --> 01:24:16.390
<v Chas>Like, there's an extended bit about racism.

01:24:16.390 --> 01:24:24.030
<v Excerpts>But i think that for marriage it can be nice to be with somebody of your own

01:24:24.030 --> 01:24:30.170
<v Excerpts>race the advantage is that you get to go home and be racist together,

01:24:35.150 --> 01:24:43.810
<v Excerpts>you get to say whatever you like you don't gotta explain shit my husband half

01:24:43.810 --> 01:24:45.870
<v Excerpts>filipino half Japanese.

01:24:46.810 --> 01:24:50.010
<v Excerpts>I'm half Chinese and half Vietnamese.

01:24:50.450 --> 01:24:58.370
<v Excerpts>And we spend 100% of our time shitting on Korean people. It's amazing.

01:24:59.070 --> 01:25:03.790
<v Chas>She's got a whole lot of stuff with her mom. And then leading up to the end,

01:25:03.930 --> 01:25:07.230
<v Chas>so after the housewife bit, which I think you're right, Sue,

01:25:07.310 --> 01:25:09.450
<v Chas>I think she's deliberately placed that,

01:25:10.047 --> 01:25:15.067
<v Chas>that very transgressive, awkward section, you know, around that lull,

01:25:15.187 --> 01:25:19.487
<v Chas>because then she starts talking, you know, almost like workplace observational humor.

01:25:19.607 --> 01:25:23.507
<v Chas>She starts talking about her job as a writer on Fresh Off the Boat.

01:25:23.647 --> 01:25:27.227
<v Stu>Which undermines this very story, because she's talking about how the dreamy

01:25:27.227 --> 01:25:30.387
<v Stu>women, and you're like, wow, you are a really important, you know,

01:25:30.467 --> 01:25:33.887
<v Stu>you're telling a story about Asian Americans. You're a writer in that.

01:25:34.027 --> 01:25:38.467
<v Stu>Like, that's incredibly empowering. and she places it specifically after the

01:25:38.467 --> 01:25:41.527
<v Stu>story where she says that feminism is the worst thing that happened to women.

01:25:41.827 --> 01:25:48.567
<v Chas>Well, I feel I almost have to undermine the joke at the end because the punchline,

01:25:48.607 --> 01:25:52.587
<v Chas>I'm not going to say what the punchline is, but the punchline is that she is working, right?

01:25:52.747 --> 01:25:58.407
<v Chas>That's the recontextualization of the whole bit about she's looking to retire,

01:25:58.407 --> 01:26:03.687
<v Chas>she's looking to not work anymore, and the punchline is she has a job.

01:26:04.187 --> 01:26:07.627
<v Stu>She doesn't just have a job, it's that she's successful at it and she's got

01:26:07.627 --> 01:26:08.727
<v Stu>economic independence.

01:26:09.567 --> 01:26:13.627
<v Alice>Yes, and I think that's one of the... So with Ali Wong's special,

01:26:13.787 --> 01:26:17.587
<v Alice>I think one of the interesting things she plays with is honesty and truth.

01:26:18.027 --> 01:26:23.267
<v Alice>Because she says these really transgressive things and you're never sure if she means them.

01:26:23.947 --> 01:26:28.287
<v Alice>And often she is talking against these narratives.

01:26:28.727 --> 01:26:33.187
<v Alice>You just said she's very happy that her husband is Asian so they can be racist together.

01:26:33.687 --> 01:26:39.287
<v Alice>That is an example of she's playing against an assumption that the audience

01:26:39.287 --> 01:26:45.507
<v Alice>has, which is that Asian people have racism at them. They don't put racism out.

01:26:45.947 --> 01:26:49.627
<v Alice>So the joke is not the joke that you think it is necessarily.

01:26:49.627 --> 01:26:54.107
<v Alice>It's not the joke that's on the surface. It's also playing with a kind of these

01:26:54.107 --> 01:26:56.247
<v Alice>currents that are working in society around her.

01:26:56.979 --> 01:27:01.979
<v Alice>So where she appears to be being very, very explicit and aggressive,

01:27:02.339 --> 01:27:05.119
<v Alice>I think often she's being quite subversive.

01:27:05.679 --> 01:27:10.159
<v Chas>Sue and I have been debating what is theme for a while now,

01:27:10.159 --> 01:27:15.719
<v Chas>and we actually had a reader of one of our most recent scripts kind of question

01:27:15.719 --> 01:27:24.679
<v Chas>the theme of the script because the lead character's arc didn't dramatise what the movie was about.

01:27:24.979 --> 01:27:28.679
<v Chas>You know, Sue and I were like, You know, this script is doing very well for

01:27:28.679 --> 01:27:32.579
<v Chas>us. We're really excited about it. It's getting a lot of good traction.

01:27:33.219 --> 01:27:37.599
<v Chas>And our theme is actually like around the commentary around it,

01:27:37.699 --> 01:27:40.979
<v Chas>like the world, the setting, the challenges.

01:27:41.059 --> 01:27:46.019
<v Chas>But it's not, we're not like having the plot go argument, counter argument back

01:27:46.019 --> 01:27:48.619
<v Chas>and forth around what the theme is.

01:27:48.739 --> 01:27:51.279
<v Chas>We're not arguing it through the plot. We're not arguing it through the character journey.

01:27:51.499 --> 01:27:54.459
<v Chas>It's in our setting more than anything else.

01:27:54.819 --> 01:27:56.619
<v Stu>And are you saying that's like Ali Wong?

01:27:56.619 --> 01:28:03.239
<v Chas>I think so. Like she, it's like the way she goes about her comedy is the ethos

01:28:03.239 --> 01:28:11.279
<v Chas>for her is, and the logos is kind of more strong in her stuff than the pathos in contrast to Nanette.

01:28:11.559 --> 01:28:16.779
<v Alice>She is very self-aware. She is very conscious of the narratives that are being

01:28:16.779 --> 01:28:18.939
<v Alice>brought onto her by her audience.

01:28:19.719 --> 01:28:25.099
<v Alice>And, and she is using those, what the, what the audience has brought in.

01:28:25.099 --> 01:28:28.739
<v Alice>And she's using that as part of the material that she's playing with and playing against.

01:28:28.939 --> 01:28:32.319
<v Alice>And so there's these two stories that are happening at the same time.

01:28:33.259 --> 01:28:37.139
<v Alice>And this constant question of whether she means what she's saying.

01:28:37.239 --> 01:28:39.599
<v Alice>She's casting herself as the villain or the anti-hero.

01:28:40.259 --> 01:28:44.579
<v Alice>But as you've seen in this kind of modern trend for anti-hero movies,

01:28:44.819 --> 01:28:48.139
<v Alice>the audience sympathizes with her and empathizes with her.

01:28:48.479 --> 01:28:50.479
<v Stu>She's literally calling herself the baby cobra.

01:28:52.232 --> 01:28:55.012
<v Stu>I just kind of realized, I was like, what's that got to do with anything?

01:28:55.152 --> 01:28:59.292
<v Stu>Now I'm like, oh, this is pre-contextualizing, nice.

01:29:00.532 --> 01:29:05.552
<v Alice>So, yeah, she's playing with that. And even within that, with the kind of ideas

01:29:05.552 --> 01:29:11.012
<v Alice>of agency for women and for Asian women and for pregnant women and the ideas of sexuality,

01:29:11.352 --> 01:29:14.692
<v Alice>you know, just even wearing leopard print, a tight leopard print bodycon dress

01:29:14.692 --> 01:29:16.392
<v Alice>while pregnant is a statement.

01:29:16.992 --> 01:29:20.232
<v Alice>It tells a story and it tells a counter story at the same time.

01:29:20.732 --> 01:29:26.052
<v Alice>I see that as very much part of the show, how she's chosen to dress. Yeah.

01:29:26.512 --> 01:29:30.032
<v Stu>The tension of the show, coming back to Hannah's thing, she's creating a tension

01:29:30.032 --> 01:29:32.472
<v Stu>that she's cutting and she literally cuts it at the end.

01:29:32.852 --> 01:29:36.312
<v Stu>But it is interesting that you're talking about like Hannah's got this misidentity

01:29:36.312 --> 01:29:39.912
<v Stu>as a structural element and you've been talking about the truth and the honesty

01:29:39.912 --> 01:29:41.032
<v Stu>as this structural element.

01:29:41.212 --> 01:29:44.712
<v Stu>And I think it's interesting because what we didn't do in our script is that

01:29:44.712 --> 01:29:50.392
<v Stu>we had all this social commentary, but that commentary didn't actually appear in the final scene.

01:29:50.472 --> 01:29:54.672
<v Stu>It had been existing through the bulk of the second story, but we added just

01:29:54.672 --> 01:29:57.912
<v Stu>this tiniest moment that reminded the audience...

01:29:58.975 --> 01:30:02.275
<v Stu>Of the, of the social commentary. And it made it so much work,

01:30:02.375 --> 01:30:03.915
<v Stu>but it made them go, oh, that's what it's all about.

01:30:03.975 --> 01:30:06.715
<v Stu>It's like, that's what we've been saying for like, we've been telling you,

01:30:06.855 --> 01:30:08.895
<v Stu>we told you, and we were telling you.

01:30:09.055 --> 01:30:12.835
<v Chas>For a hundred pages, but we didn't put it on page 101.

01:30:13.715 --> 01:30:16.475
<v Stu>You know, it's that idea. You tell people what you're going to tell them,

01:30:16.535 --> 01:30:19.055
<v Stu>then you tell them, and then you tell them what you just told them.

01:30:19.155 --> 01:30:22.095
<v Stu>And it's like, that's what we didn't do. We didn't tell them what we just told them.

01:30:22.475 --> 01:30:26.175
<v Alice>What's the, it's the Betty Crocker cake mix situation, I think,

01:30:26.235 --> 01:30:29.475
<v Alice>is the real question for all art creation, maybe.

01:30:29.555 --> 01:30:31.615
<v Stu>Okay, I like this, go on.

01:30:31.715 --> 01:30:36.255
<v Alice>So they used to, the original Betty Crocker cake mix was just powdered cake

01:30:36.255 --> 01:30:42.515
<v Alice>mix and you added water and it was very unpopular because at that time housewives

01:30:42.515 --> 01:30:47.215
<v Alice>were mostly making things from scratch and this convenience was, it felt too impersonal.

01:30:47.535 --> 01:30:51.715
<v Alice>So then they took out an egg from the recipe and the powder.

01:30:51.715 --> 01:30:56.355
<v Alice>So you add water and an egg and all of a sudden it becomes this best-selling

01:30:56.355 --> 01:30:59.055
<v Alice>product that is still immensely popular today.

01:30:59.435 --> 01:31:03.975
<v Alice>So, I mean, that is the question, I think, is how much work...

01:31:04.871 --> 01:31:08.671
<v Alice>Do you let the audience do? How much work do you demand of the audience?

01:31:08.871 --> 01:31:11.011
<v Alice>How far do you guide them?

01:31:11.291 --> 01:31:15.031
<v Alice>And how much do you tell them? Because at a certain point, it's the Betty Crocker

01:31:15.031 --> 01:31:19.891
<v Alice>cake with the powdered egg inside. There's no interest for the audience.

01:31:20.031 --> 01:31:22.491
<v Alice>They're not engaged because you're doing all the work for them.

01:31:22.571 --> 01:31:28.251
<v Alice>There has to be space for them to come in and bring their egg and feel part of it,

01:31:28.471 --> 01:31:33.071
<v Alice>which is one of the things that the screen makes more difficult,

01:31:33.071 --> 01:31:35.491
<v Alice>that intimacy of them being in the room.

01:31:35.631 --> 01:31:39.211
<v Alice>It's very easy to make them feel like they are necessary for the journey of

01:31:39.211 --> 01:31:43.231
<v Alice>the show. They are compulsory for the journey of the show. If they don't laugh, the show doesn't work.

01:31:43.891 --> 01:31:50.311
<v Alice>Whereas you can't pretend that with an audience that is not present temporarily in the room.

01:31:50.311 --> 01:31:54.971
<v Alice>So you have to find ways to give that proxy, whether it's by making space in the show,

01:31:55.531 --> 01:31:59.951
<v Alice>whether it's through the use of camera angles and lighting, choices that you

01:31:59.951 --> 01:32:04.831
<v Alice>make ways that you break up narratives that they might be bringing in that you

01:32:04.831 --> 01:32:06.151
<v Alice>let them do some of the work.

01:32:06.151 --> 01:32:10.511
<v Chas>Yeah i mean that's a constant tension in all

01:32:10.511 --> 01:32:16.151
<v Chas>screenwriting is like how on the nose should this dialogue be do i have to say

01:32:16.151 --> 01:32:19.991
<v Chas>it can we like have it for the in the script for the reader so the reader gets

01:32:19.991 --> 01:32:22.811
<v Chas>it but we know it's going to be cut in the edit later because audiences will

01:32:22.811 --> 01:32:26.511
<v Chas>get it when two people are performing it like it's that constant So.

01:32:26.511 --> 01:32:32.851
<v Alice>That is huge in terms of transferring Savage to the screen, because I am used

01:32:32.851 --> 01:32:36.151
<v Alice>to saying all the things with my mouth.

01:32:36.531 --> 01:32:40.911
<v Stu>Can you, I mean, it feels like it's all the rage, even though it's at least

01:32:40.911 --> 01:32:44.091
<v Stu>500 years old. Can you use soliloquies like Fleabag?

01:32:45.664 --> 01:32:48.404
<v Alice>Well, I thought about all of these things, but one of the things that you have

01:32:48.404 --> 01:32:51.904
<v Alice>to learn or that I have had to learn or am still in the process of learning

01:32:51.904 --> 01:32:57.124
<v Alice>is how much you can show because I have to create the whole scenario with my

01:32:57.124 --> 01:33:00.924
<v Alice>voice and I have to explain where I'm coming from and all of that if I'm on

01:33:00.924 --> 01:33:02.584
<v Alice>stage, if I'm the only person on stage.

01:33:02.584 --> 01:33:09.844
<v Alice>Whereas you can do things with actors and setting and screen and things can be told in a glance.

01:33:10.204 --> 01:33:15.384
<v Alice>I don't have to say certain things, which is super interesting because I already

01:33:15.384 --> 01:33:20.704
<v Alice>think of Savage as a very restrained, very held back, very withheld, very thin story.

01:33:21.184 --> 01:33:26.224
<v Alice>And so at the same time as I'm building this kind of visual world and this performance

01:33:26.224 --> 01:33:29.384
<v Alice>world and all these characters and everything, which feels like adding a lot,

01:33:29.604 --> 01:33:31.504
<v Alice>there's also all this wordage,

01:33:32.184 --> 01:33:36.024
<v Alice>wordage, verbiage that I have to take away or that I can take away,

01:33:36.184 --> 01:33:37.544
<v Alice>that I should be taking away.

01:33:37.664 --> 01:33:40.944
<v Alice>So it isn't just somebody saying, hello, I am a stand-up comedian. Like...

01:33:42.206 --> 01:33:47.886
<v Stu>I think this will let us transition into Daniel, I think, but I think Baby Copper

01:33:47.886 --> 01:33:50.226
<v Stu>does it. We brought up the park thing a few times.

01:33:50.406 --> 01:33:54.106
<v Stu>Something that I've been thinking about is all of them have to use imagery in

01:33:54.106 --> 01:33:55.566
<v Stu>the words that they say, right?

01:33:55.686 --> 01:34:00.186
<v Stu>That they've all got visual systems in what they talk about, right?

01:34:00.266 --> 01:34:04.926
<v Stu>Hannah comes back to the tea in the saucer a few times, and then we actually visually see it.

01:34:05.426 --> 01:34:08.126
<v Stu>Baby Copper, she's got these stories that have been around visuals.

01:34:08.126 --> 01:34:14.026
<v Stu>I think Daniels, in particular, is really good at creating pictures with words.

01:34:14.566 --> 01:34:18.406
<v Excerpts>As love, for example, thrives on a delusion of uniqueness. We all like to tell

01:34:18.406 --> 01:34:21.486
<v Excerpts>ourselves that our love is different, our love is special, our love is unique.

01:34:21.686 --> 01:34:25.926
<v Excerpts>How dare the plebeian monsters that roam the streets use the same word for their

01:34:25.926 --> 01:34:31.546
<v Excerpts>TikTok tin hearts that I use for my capacious, thudding monster of affection. How dare they?

01:34:31.746 --> 01:34:36.206
<v Excerpts>How dare they? Let us march upon utopia, my sweet. When other people talk of

01:34:36.206 --> 01:34:39.066
<v Excerpts>love, they may as well talk of turnips and trousers for all they know.

01:34:39.366 --> 01:34:42.626
<v Stu>And something I think as screenwriters that we don't think about enough with dialogue.

01:34:42.826 --> 01:34:46.366
<v Stu>We think about imagery that we see, that we write in action lines,

01:34:46.466 --> 01:34:51.106
<v Stu>but we don't necessarily think about the images that characters conjure with their words.

01:34:51.346 --> 01:34:55.006
<v Stu>And that is also related to dialogue, okay?

01:34:56.394 --> 01:35:01.854
<v Stu>I don't know if Ali Wong does it, but obviously Daniel and Hannah both play characters.

01:35:02.034 --> 01:35:05.934
<v Chas>Ali puts on her Asian and her mum a lot as well.

01:35:06.154 --> 01:35:10.114
<v Stu>I mean, it's that whole heightened dialogue. The dialogue is not naturalistic, right?

01:35:10.274 --> 01:35:14.214
<v Stu>And so you get this interesting tension with the kind of casual storytelling

01:35:14.214 --> 01:35:18.474
<v Stu>of the stand-up comedian with these clearly artificial characters, right?

01:35:18.614 --> 01:35:26.474
<v Stu>And how they can kind of heighten it to an essence. And it's just so interesting to see that on screen.

01:35:26.654 --> 01:35:31.094
<v Stu>I'm not sure if there's a lesson to take beyond the heightenedness of dialogue.

01:35:31.134 --> 01:35:36.214
<v Stu>But the imagery that they use and how that imagery can kind of be passed around

01:35:36.214 --> 01:35:43.874
<v Stu>and becoming a unifying element, like the fireworks in Daniel's work and in Baby Copa.

01:35:43.874 --> 01:35:45.714
<v Stu>I mean, there's obviously the visual imagery of her pregnant,

01:35:45.754 --> 01:35:49.074
<v Stu>and she actually knows that she's got a lot of really abject stories.

01:35:49.294 --> 01:35:52.634
<v Stu>Like, part of her challenge and that honesty and truth is how much she loves

01:35:52.634 --> 01:35:53.954
<v Stu>talking about bodily fluids, right?

01:35:55.094 --> 01:35:57.634
<v Chas>She conjures a lot of mental images.

01:36:01.634 --> 01:36:09.734
<v Excerpts>I also decided to have a kid because I'm only 33, which I know is not technically

01:36:09.734 --> 01:36:14.114
<v Excerpts>high risk. but my body was starting to show signs of change.

01:36:14.574 --> 01:36:17.294
<v Excerpts>And it scared me. Like, I'm only 33,

01:36:20.314 --> 01:36:24.374
<v Excerpts>and my pussy is not as wet as it used to be.

01:36:27.329 --> 01:36:32.869
<v Excerpts>It's very demoralizing, okay? Do you remember when you were 18 years old and

01:36:32.869 --> 01:36:36.689
<v Excerpts>your pussy was just sopping wet all the time?

01:36:37.009 --> 01:36:40.909
<v Excerpts>All the time, you just took it for granted that you could just reach your hand

01:36:40.909 --> 01:36:43.249
<v Excerpts>down your pants at any given moment.

01:36:43.289 --> 01:36:47.849
<v Excerpts>You throw up the peace sign afterwards and there would be that snail trail in

01:36:47.849 --> 01:36:49.289
<v Excerpts>between your fingers. Oh my

01:36:49.289 --> 01:36:53.909
<v Excerpts>God, it was so juicy. You could just blow a bubble wand with it. Just, ah!

01:36:55.709 --> 01:36:58.869
<v Stu>It's transgressive it's abject and it's interesting and

01:36:58.869 --> 01:37:02.209
<v Stu>i think i can only speak from my experience with being a male

01:37:02.209 --> 01:37:07.249
<v Stu>it's it's that access the interiority the intimacy of something that is normally

01:37:07.249 --> 01:37:13.149
<v Stu>that people don't feel comfortable about right somehow it's the male comedians

01:37:13.149 --> 01:37:17.229
<v Stu>can talk about bodily fluid but it feels progressive when female comedians don't

01:37:17.229 --> 01:37:21.669
<v Stu>but it's really visual strong language that creates pictures in your head.

01:37:21.669 --> 01:37:25.129
<v Alice>Yeah yeah and certainly that that one

01:37:25.129 --> 01:37:28.289
<v Alice>of the things that you sort of have to be aware of is that the words somebody's saying

01:37:28.289 --> 01:37:31.069
<v Alice>are not necessarily what they mean and and

01:37:31.069 --> 01:37:34.549
<v Alice>that the performance is sometimes playing

01:37:34.549 --> 01:37:37.729
<v Alice>against you know the villain speech where they talk about how they only want

01:37:37.729 --> 01:37:42.909
<v Alice>the best for everyone is is important and i think that's one of the reasons

01:37:42.909 --> 01:37:46.849
<v Alice>why i called for a lot of these long shots where you can see my whole body because

01:37:46.849 --> 01:37:52.069
<v Alice>there's jokes that i deliver in Savage that I am pulling away from physically as I deliver them.

01:37:52.709 --> 01:37:57.489
<v Alice>And that physical awkwardness is an important part of what you're telling.

01:37:57.889 --> 01:38:02.949
<v Chas>So with going into Daniel's special, It's the Fireworks Talking,

01:38:03.209 --> 01:38:09.109
<v Chas>I can rattle off some things I think it has very much that it does the same

01:38:09.109 --> 01:38:12.589
<v Chas>as Hannah and Allie and yourself, Alice.

01:38:12.589 --> 01:38:17.669
<v Chas>But then I'm really interested to hear what you found to be so mind-openingly

01:38:17.669 --> 01:38:21.089
<v Chas>different in terms of how stand-up works.

01:38:21.369 --> 01:38:25.389
<v Chas>So, do you mind if I jump in with what it does the same? So, again...

01:38:27.000 --> 01:38:33.780
<v Chas>The title of the show is also like what his opening line is about and he repeats it a lot.

01:38:33.980 --> 01:38:38.500
<v Chas>He comes back to the topic of fireworks a lot and then concludes cathartically

01:38:38.500 --> 01:38:43.340
<v Chas>by bringing it back to the fireworks to round out the show.

01:38:43.620 --> 01:38:51.780
<v Chas>He also is very aware, not just of himself, but also of the,

01:38:52.200 --> 01:38:54.940
<v Chas>like, there's two moments that really stood out for me.

01:38:54.940 --> 01:38:57.740
<v Chas>Like you said he's got a stutter which for his

01:38:57.740 --> 01:39:00.620
<v Chas>brand of comedy is quite astonishing because

01:39:00.620 --> 01:39:03.360
<v Chas>he speaks at a breakneck pace and a lot

01:39:03.360 --> 01:39:08.380
<v Chas>of his comedy is not about they're not necessarily jokes or even observations

01:39:08.380 --> 01:39:14.900
<v Chas>that are funny it's how he articulates very mundane things talking at a breakneck

01:39:14.900 --> 01:39:20.180
<v Chas>speed with an amazing uh turn of phrase so for him to have a stutter like he

01:39:20.180 --> 01:39:23.340
<v Chas>does stutter quite considerably at one point early on,

01:39:23.380 --> 01:39:25.840
<v Chas>and he calls it out as a- as a joke.

01:39:26.520 --> 01:39:27.840
<v Excerpts>It's a complex feeling, you know.

01:39:29.861 --> 01:39:34.681
<v Excerpts>And for me, for sort of a city of Edinburgh, by the way, it would appear my

01:39:34.681 --> 01:39:37.801
<v Excerpts>stutter is going to play up a bit tonight, so the initial timing estimates may have been optimistic.

01:39:39.421 --> 01:39:43.401
<v Chas>And then there's one point where he looks like he's made a mistake,

01:39:43.901 --> 01:39:49.641
<v Chas>covered for his mistake and told a joke or, you know, made a silly observation and everyone laughs.

01:39:49.781 --> 01:39:52.241
<v Chas>And then he points out that he did that on purpose.

01:39:53.561 --> 01:39:57.001
<v Excerpts>It was about two years after, not two years, about two weeks after Bonfire Night.

01:39:57.001 --> 01:40:00.141
<v Excerpts>Two years after Bonfire Night, of course, is Bonfire Night.

01:40:01.441 --> 01:40:05.921
<v Excerpts>Now, hang on, hang on, hang on, hang on, hang on, hang on.

01:40:06.121 --> 01:40:07.481
<v Excerpts>That looked improvised, didn't

01:40:07.481 --> 01:40:09.941
<v Excerpts>it? I looked like I made a mistake and I corrected it with wit and verve.

01:40:10.221 --> 01:40:13.461
<v Excerpts>That wasn't improvised. That is now the 60th time I've done that.

01:40:15.141 --> 01:40:19.701
<v Chas>And it makes everyone feel awkward. Like even you can feel it,

01:40:19.761 --> 01:40:23.501
<v Chas>even in the audio, like that it doesn't get a laugh, that he points out that

01:40:23.501 --> 01:40:26.521
<v Chas>he's like controlling their reactions.

01:40:27.001 --> 01:40:31.381
<v Chas>In the same way that Hannah does the same commentary of like, I'm in control.

01:40:31.721 --> 01:40:36.581
<v Stu>Yeah. It kind of connects us back to that ethos thing that they kind of pull,

01:40:36.861 --> 01:40:39.481
<v Stu>they take the mask of the wizard, so to speak.

01:40:39.561 --> 01:40:42.821
<v Stu>I'm mixing so many metaphors there, destroying.

01:40:43.201 --> 01:40:47.141
<v Alice>They're also doing something that is an observation about what the audience

01:40:47.141 --> 01:40:50.881
<v Alice>is thinking that makes the audience feel exposed and revealed.

01:40:51.221 --> 01:40:55.121
<v Alice>Because by saying, I did that on purpose and I'm in control,

01:40:55.281 --> 01:41:00.481
<v Alice>they're also saying, I know that you didn't think I was in control I know that

01:41:00.481 --> 01:41:05.261
<v Alice>you underestimated me and I know why you underestimated me and then they're

01:41:05.261 --> 01:41:07.541
<v Alice>also relying on the fact that they are,

01:41:09.001 --> 01:41:16.541
<v Alice>likable in this way that plays on the perceived low statusness to reassert itself

01:41:16.541 --> 01:41:22.121
<v Alice>and give them back that power of the audience even though they've showed their hand and

01:41:22.531 --> 01:41:27.051
<v Alice>Even though I've showed you how this magic trick works, you are going to fall for it again.

01:41:27.351 --> 01:41:30.611
<v Alice>And that says something about you as an audience.

01:41:31.171 --> 01:41:35.031
<v Stu>Which is exactly, Bo Burnham does the same thing we pointed out with that song

01:41:35.031 --> 01:41:39.171
<v Stu>about like, you're looking at your phone, it's having a commentary on the audience.

01:41:39.551 --> 01:41:43.831
<v Stu>Does Ali do it in Baby Cobber? Is there, I mean, I suppose the feminism speech

01:41:43.831 --> 01:41:47.211
<v Stu>maybe because you're sitting there listening to a pregnant woman who was delivering

01:41:47.211 --> 01:41:50.631
<v Stu>a stand-up show, who's clearly working while pregnant, telling a story about

01:41:50.631 --> 01:41:52.651
<v Stu>feminism being bad for women.

01:41:53.071 --> 01:41:56.091
<v Stu>But I don't think she has anything that quite makes the audience,

01:41:56.211 --> 01:41:57.331
<v Stu>it makes us uncomfortable.

01:41:57.571 --> 01:42:02.231
<v Alice>I think she does it in a sort of a slightly step to the side way in that all

01:42:02.231 --> 01:42:05.811
<v Alice>of her jokes are a joke about how the audience sees her and how she is not what

01:42:05.811 --> 01:42:07.011
<v Alice>the audience thinks she is.

01:42:07.511 --> 01:42:11.951
<v Alice>And even though she's kept telling you about this HPV or this or that,

01:42:12.211 --> 01:42:15.891
<v Alice>you still keep projecting these ideas of what a woman should be and what an

01:42:15.891 --> 01:42:17.851
<v Alice>Asian woman should be and what a pregnant woman should be.

01:42:17.971 --> 01:42:20.351
<v Alice>So this comes as a shock every time.

01:42:20.691 --> 01:42:23.851
<v Alice>So she's doing the same thing in a slightly different way.

01:42:24.051 --> 01:42:27.911
<v Chas>She just doesn't have to call out how she's controlling the audience.

01:42:28.131 --> 01:42:32.431
<v Chas>She just is controlling the audience. She just doesn't stop to point out to

01:42:32.431 --> 01:42:33.491
<v Chas>them that she's doing it.

01:42:34.371 --> 01:42:40.291
<v Chas>Yeah, so I was just going to ask you, Alice. So I've kind of seen the similarities,

01:42:40.291 --> 01:42:42.231
<v Chas>I guess, in the work that we've looked at.

01:42:42.251 --> 01:42:46.531
<v Chas>But what to you stood out as it opened up? stand-up for you?

01:42:47.391 --> 01:42:50.531
<v Alice>Well, for me, I think I hadn't been exposed to a lot of stand-up.

01:42:50.651 --> 01:42:55.751
<v Alice>I had some pretty basic ideas of what stand-up was, which was club sets, wear...

01:42:56.519 --> 01:42:59.679
<v Alice>Men tell dick jokes you know that I

01:42:59.679 --> 01:43:02.479
<v Alice>hadn't until that point seen stand-up that

01:43:02.479 --> 01:43:06.119
<v Alice>was even trying to be art

01:43:06.119 --> 01:43:08.839
<v Alice>I was trying to talk about something in a

01:43:08.839 --> 01:43:14.659
<v Alice>beautiful way I was trying to elicit emotions other than shock and laughter

01:43:14.659 --> 01:43:20.839
<v Alice>that was trying to really do this thing that Daniel Kitson has been so influential

01:43:20.839 --> 01:43:27.799
<v Alice>for which is tell these beautiful stories that that aren't about him,

01:43:28.479 --> 01:43:32.899
<v Alice>necessarily they're about the human experience and that they make the audience

01:43:32.899 --> 01:43:37.899
<v Alice>feel more human which is kind of my project in all the work that i do is i want

01:43:37.899 --> 01:43:41.279
<v Alice>people to feel more human and be more conscious of the humanity of the people

01:43:41.279 --> 01:43:45.379
<v Alice>around them and i at that time thought that the The only way that you could

01:43:45.379 --> 01:43:47.679
<v Alice>do that was through real art,

01:43:48.279 --> 01:43:54.219
<v Alice>you know, novel writing or, you know, academia or something that I was drawn to.

01:43:54.959 --> 01:43:59.179
<v Alice>And yeah, genuinely as an influential moment in my own life,

01:43:59.479 --> 01:44:05.879
<v Alice>watching that show was like, oh, this is a really interesting way to move people

01:44:05.879 --> 01:44:11.499
<v Alice>and change the way that they, not change what they think, but change the way that they think.

01:44:11.679 --> 01:44:15.499
<v Stu>That's why you're so keen for us to look at it. And I think what is interesting

01:44:15.499 --> 01:44:22.919
<v Stu>is that he tells anecdotes, but the, like you, the anecdotes aren't focused on him.

01:44:23.159 --> 01:44:27.099
<v Stu>He introduces characters. He kind of seemingly adopts their voice,

01:44:27.239 --> 01:44:33.039
<v Stu>but he's able to effortlessly move between him as the character and him as an observer.

01:44:33.259 --> 01:44:36.859
<v Stu>But he's also aware of his position as an observer.

01:44:37.657 --> 01:44:42.297
<v Stu>It's awfully done. I mean, I'm trying to, I want to come up with more specific techniques.

01:44:42.537 --> 01:44:46.817
<v Stu>I'm looking at Chaz over Zoom to see if he's like, well, Chaz is like, I've got the list.

01:44:47.477 --> 01:44:53.237
<v Chas>The logos, the structure of his show, he starts out talking about how fireworks makes him feel.

01:44:53.677 --> 01:44:59.157
<v Chas>And then he starts, the show is essentially a list with wonderful branches off

01:44:59.157 --> 01:45:02.957
<v Chas>to the side of all the things that make him feel that way.

01:45:03.997 --> 01:45:06.537
<v Excerpts>I'm not talking about happiness. Let me be clear on that. I'm not talking about

01:45:06.537 --> 01:45:09.697
<v Excerpts>happiness. That's not too simplistic, you know, too mainstream,

01:45:09.897 --> 01:45:11.997
<v Excerpts>too bland a feeling for me. I'm not talking about happiness.

01:45:12.097 --> 01:45:16.017
<v Excerpts>I'm talking about happiness tinged with melancholy joy entwined with despair.

01:45:16.137 --> 01:45:18.877
<v Excerpts>That's what I'm talking about. That sort of wonderful moment where it suddenly

01:45:18.877 --> 01:45:22.537
<v Excerpts>hits you that you're alive, but you also realise that does mean you will one day die.

01:45:22.817 --> 01:45:29.357
<v Chas>And he ends up near the end of the show re-describing those moments as moments

01:45:29.357 --> 01:45:32.997
<v Chas>and like defines moments as being different from a second.

01:45:33.717 --> 01:45:37.237
<v Chas>You know, Alice, when you said, you know, he doesn't really talk about himself,

01:45:37.477 --> 01:45:42.877
<v Chas>I'm like, wow, I felt such intimate connection with him because he is telling

01:45:42.877 --> 01:45:46.897
<v Chas>me the things that make him feel the way that I want to feel.

01:45:47.077 --> 01:45:53.497
<v Chas>He's prompting in me constantly what makes me feel that exact same way.

01:45:53.897 --> 01:46:00.737
<v Alice>Yes. And that is more intimate because you're not asking somebody to come and look at your face. Yeah.

01:46:01.466 --> 01:46:06.766
<v Alice>Which is necessarily in a mirror. So you've already got these layers between you and them.

01:46:06.926 --> 01:46:09.506
<v Alice>If you're telling someone a story about you and what am I like,

01:46:10.206 --> 01:46:14.906
<v Alice>you're telling them how you think you appear to, you know, there's these layers.

01:46:15.046 --> 01:46:18.406
<v Alice>Whereas if you're asking someone to come and look through your eyes,

01:46:18.526 --> 01:46:24.406
<v Alice>even though you're not telling them about you, I feel it as a much more intimate way of storytelling.

01:46:25.306 --> 01:46:29.826
<v Stu>Question for you, Chaz. Did you listen to it on headphones or did you play it through speakers?

01:46:30.566 --> 01:46:32.706
<v Chas>Headphones. I was out walking.

01:46:33.026 --> 01:46:36.166
<v Stu>I mean, I'm just, it's a tangent.

01:46:36.426 --> 01:46:39.486
<v Stu>It's a branch off our trunk. But because you work in podcasts,

01:46:39.626 --> 01:46:44.586
<v Stu>I just think there's also, I wonder if it's just the effect of watching stand-up on a television,

01:46:45.446 --> 01:46:51.626
<v Stu>versus watching stand-up or listening to stand-up as a podcast that changed the intimacy, right?

01:46:51.726 --> 01:46:55.446
<v Stu>There's looking at the screen, a speaker's over there, whereas having headphones

01:46:55.446 --> 01:46:58.186
<v Stu>always feels more intimate in terms of spoken word.

01:46:58.186 --> 01:47:01.946
<v Alice>So that's one of the reasons why I was super reluctant to do Savage as a screen

01:47:01.946 --> 01:47:06.546
<v Alice>special, because I'd already done the trilogy podcast, which is Savage,

01:47:06.666 --> 01:47:11.006
<v Alice>The Resistance and Empire, three shows that I did that are all on the same theme,

01:47:11.626 --> 01:47:13.026
<v Alice>different explorations.

01:47:13.026 --> 01:47:18.766
<v Alice>I had already done them as a podcast with the ABC and I did them with binaural microphones,

01:47:19.246 --> 01:47:21.946
<v Alice>so that it's essentially surround sound and I don't

01:47:21.946 --> 01:47:24.966
<v Alice>know if it had been done for comedy before I know it had been done for action audio

01:47:24.966 --> 01:47:27.726
<v Alice>but that you feel like you're sitting

01:47:27.726 --> 01:47:30.526
<v Alice>in the audience and if you listen with your

01:47:30.526 --> 01:47:34.486
<v Alice>eyes closed you can hear people laughing around you and for me that was sort

01:47:34.486 --> 01:47:40.586
<v Alice>of a much quote-unquote better replication of being in the audience than you

01:47:40.586 --> 01:47:45.086
<v Alice>can get with a with a screen special and so so much of the way that i asked

01:47:45.086 --> 01:47:48.166
<v Alice>them to film that special was trying to compensate for,

01:47:49.016 --> 01:47:50.876
<v Alice>the distance created by the screen.

01:47:51.176 --> 01:47:54.756
<v Stu>I mean, obviously you're related to this guy, Chaz. You've been middle-aged

01:47:54.756 --> 01:47:58.776
<v Stu>since you were 17. So there's definitely a connection.

01:47:59.236 --> 01:48:03.336
<v Chas>So, you know, one of his moments was just him driving in the back of a car late

01:48:03.336 --> 01:48:04.876
<v Chas>at night down English country lanes.

01:48:04.956 --> 01:48:07.396
<v Chas>And that is one of my moments as well.

01:48:07.496 --> 01:48:11.316
<v Chas>I remember my parents getting plastered at one of their friend's houses.

01:48:11.436 --> 01:48:13.536
<v Chas>Hopefully one of them wasn't plastered as they drove us home.

01:48:13.676 --> 01:48:17.436
<v Chas>But I like, I know the feeling of looking out the car window when i'm supposed

01:48:17.436 --> 01:48:21.036
<v Chas>to be asleep in a car as i'm driving home down an english country lane i've

01:48:21.036 --> 01:48:27.436
<v Chas>also been dumped by waves uh on australian surf beaches and so he's got like an extended bit about.

01:48:28.396 --> 01:48:31.736
<v Excerpts>I know i know what to do daniel don't panic i've won the wave and now you're

01:48:31.736 --> 01:48:34.576
<v Excerpts>outside i've under the wave and now you're outside daniel do not panic daniel

01:48:34.576 --> 01:48:37.476
<v Excerpts>dive under the wave and now you're outside what i didn't know is if if the waves

01:48:37.476 --> 01:48:40.636
<v Excerpts>already start to break on top of you you can't dive under the wave and now you're

01:48:40.636 --> 01:48:43.416
<v Excerpts>outside if you try to do that what you're essentially doing is presenting yourself

01:48:43.416 --> 01:48:48.336
<v Excerpts>to the wave and asking the wave if he wouldn't mind awfully fucking your face into the sand.

01:48:49.516 --> 01:48:54.156
<v Chas>It comes back to his dad that he's tying it back to, but it's also about mortality

01:48:54.156 --> 01:48:57.876
<v Chas>and being aware of your own existence and things like that.

01:48:58.056 --> 01:49:02.376
<v Chas>So maybe it is just my personal experience of relating to him.

01:49:02.556 --> 01:49:08.616
<v Alice>His choice of language also in terms of advice for screenwriters is like colour grading.

01:49:08.956 --> 01:49:13.556
<v Alice>The language that he uses and the height of the language that he uses the elaborateness

01:49:13.556 --> 01:49:19.156
<v Alice>of the language that he chooses in each scene shades the scene.

01:49:19.316 --> 01:49:23.836
<v Alice>So he can tell a knockabout joke with quite simple vocabulary.

01:49:24.236 --> 01:49:27.476
<v Alice>Then those are the jokes that come across as like, he's your mate in the pub,

01:49:27.536 --> 01:49:29.656
<v Alice>which you've commented on.

01:49:30.056 --> 01:49:35.556
<v Alice>There's also these incredibly elaborately worded, beautiful word pictures of

01:49:35.556 --> 01:49:39.536
<v Alice>the experience of, for example, seeing fireworks or birds.

01:49:40.160 --> 01:49:44.160
<v Alice>Being at night in the car of your parents, going home, knowing that you ought to be asleep.

01:49:46.080 --> 01:49:49.980
<v Alice>And I'd forgotten that, but there's a bit that I have in Empire,

01:49:50.120 --> 01:49:53.160
<v Alice>which is the third in my trilogy where I talk about pretending to be asleep

01:49:53.160 --> 01:49:55.180
<v Alice>so your parents carry you out of the car.

01:49:55.460 --> 01:49:59.060
<v Alice>I think that's such a human experience.

01:49:59.520 --> 01:50:05.120
<v Chas>Well, I mean, going to Daniel's special, like, he's clearly got a structure,

01:50:05.400 --> 01:50:08.880
<v Chas>like he brings us back to it, but it doesn't feel, like

01:50:08.880 --> 01:50:11.720
<v Chas>it feels essential for that catharsis you have at the end because it

01:50:11.720 --> 01:50:14.360
<v Chas>is just building and building building on that emotion to then pull it

01:50:14.360 --> 01:50:17.700
<v Chas>off at the end but it doesn't doesn't feel essential to make to

01:50:17.700 --> 01:50:21.580
<v Chas>his skill set to maintaining my interest over

01:50:21.580 --> 01:50:24.420
<v Chas>an hour he could just talk at me about

01:50:24.420 --> 01:50:27.620
<v Chas>a series of unrelated unstructured things in his

01:50:27.620 --> 01:50:30.900
<v Chas>amazing turn of phrase and i would be engaged the entire time

01:50:30.900 --> 01:50:34.800
<v Chas>and i think people there are there are clearly screen

01:50:34.800 --> 01:50:38.240
<v Chas>storytellers who rely very heavily on

01:50:38.240 --> 01:50:41.400
<v Chas>the moment to moment experience like in terms

01:50:41.400 --> 01:50:44.100
<v Chas>of terms of phrase yep um well i was

01:50:44.100 --> 01:50:46.900
<v Chas>actually going to go like tarantino and diablo cody in terms of

01:50:46.900 --> 01:50:51.300
<v Chas>just we can just sit and hear their characters talk and that is entertaining

01:50:51.300 --> 01:50:56.360
<v Chas>while nothing might be happening right um which is not to say they're not masters

01:50:56.360 --> 01:51:01.000
<v Chas>of what is also happening in the background but that's they've got that tool

01:51:01.000 --> 01:51:04.360
<v Chas>set of just um turns of phrase but we're,

01:51:05.176 --> 01:51:09.376
<v Chas>You said Richard Linklater, Stu. So, he keeps you engaged moment to moment.

01:51:10.096 --> 01:51:14.476
<v Stu>Yeah. I mean, what do you think is keeping you engaged in it before Sunrise?

01:51:14.916 --> 01:51:15.636
<v Chas>Oh, yeah.

01:51:17.016 --> 01:51:20.636
<v Stu>You know, and most of his films are those kinds of moment by moment people.

01:51:21.016 --> 01:51:26.476
<v Stu>Oh, boyhood. Like, they're all seemingly anecdotes connected by this thread, right?

01:51:26.636 --> 01:51:29.896
<v Stu>In his film. Oh, do you disagree, Alice?

01:51:30.336 --> 01:51:34.476
<v Alice>No. So, this is just a side of what might seem like a complete side tangent.

01:51:34.476 --> 01:51:39.996
<v Alice>It was a piece of advice that I got about satirical comedy by Benedict Hardy,

01:51:40.216 --> 01:51:45.136
<v Alice>who was at that point directing the Arts Review and is now quite a famous Hollywood actor.

01:51:45.536 --> 01:51:52.996
<v Alice>But he said about doing political sketches that even if people don't get the

01:51:52.996 --> 01:51:54.696
<v Alice>joke, it still has to be funny.

01:51:55.076 --> 01:52:00.096
<v Alice>So say, for example, if I'm to tell a joke about what happened in the news today,

01:52:00.476 --> 01:52:04.316
<v Alice>even if people don't know that news story, the joke still has to work.

01:52:04.956 --> 01:52:07.996
<v Alice>So there has to be some rhythm to it some pace

01:52:07.996 --> 01:52:10.656
<v Alice>to it or something about the way that you deliver it or something about the

01:52:10.656 --> 01:52:17.316
<v Alice>the containing within it the seeds of its own logic that it will work even if

01:52:17.316 --> 01:52:21.316
<v Alice>you haven't watched the news today so either you can set up do it in the setup

01:52:21.316 --> 01:52:26.536
<v Alice>you can explain the story in the setup or it has to be about the way that you deliver it and,

01:52:27.236 --> 01:52:31.356
<v Alice>your tone of voice or your tone of phrase that makes it funny yeah.

01:52:31.356 --> 01:52:36.016
<v Chas>Oh he is a master of humour through just language.

01:52:36.256 --> 01:52:42.556
<v Chas>Like he turns nothing into laughs, like in terms of the thing that he's talking about isn't funny.

01:52:43.911 --> 01:52:49.131
<v Alice>Yeah, he's so good at words that he creates these pictures.

01:52:49.371 --> 01:52:53.371
<v Alice>And even if you had never gone home in your parents' car pretending to be asleep,

01:52:53.431 --> 01:52:56.331
<v Alice>you would understand that experience and it would be heartwarming,

01:52:56.931 --> 01:53:01.731
<v Alice>and it would make you feel this nostalgia because it's so imbued in the language

01:53:01.731 --> 01:53:08.271
<v Alice>and, as I said, the vocabulary and the tone is this colour grading that conveys the mood.

01:53:08.891 --> 01:53:14.311
<v Stu>Is there anything technical that he's doing in terms of the language?

01:53:14.511 --> 01:53:17.811
<v Stu>We're talking about word pictures. So he's obviously using strong imagery,

01:53:17.951 --> 01:53:21.551
<v Stu>but there is anything more technical, anything rhythmic, anything structural

01:53:21.551 --> 01:53:24.731
<v Stu>in the kind of sentences? Is he using mirrored structures?

01:53:25.011 --> 01:53:29.211
<v Stu>Is he using building structures where, you know, you take that idea and you

01:53:29.211 --> 01:53:32.851
<v Stu>build on that, you know, it's a house, a big house, it's a big,

01:53:33.031 --> 01:53:36.991
<v Stu>bright, I'm just making that up in the spot. I'm trying to give structural examining.

01:53:36.991 --> 01:53:44.351
<v Alice>He's using very specific and precise language where in vernacular speech,

01:53:44.351 --> 01:53:50.151
<v Alice>you might use an approximation or a more common word just to be more comfortable

01:53:50.151 --> 01:53:53.511
<v Alice>or because you can't reach for the word in the moment.

01:53:53.511 --> 01:53:56.631
<v Alice>He is using the exact

01:53:56.631 --> 01:54:00.411
<v Alice>right word you know he won't say a

01:54:00.411 --> 01:54:03.251
<v Alice>screwdriver he would say exactly which screwdriver it was

01:54:03.251 --> 01:54:06.251
<v Alice>it's a phillips head or it's a he he go

01:54:06.251 --> 01:54:09.031
<v Alice>he this microscopic in terms of what he's doing is

01:54:09.031 --> 01:54:11.991
<v Alice>a very close focus on the specifics of

01:54:11.991 --> 01:54:15.891
<v Alice>each scene that make it seem uh like

01:54:15.891 --> 01:54:19.391
<v Alice>if you're thinking in filmic terms it's hyper realized it's hyper

01:54:19.391 --> 01:54:22.591
<v Alice>focused it's almost slow motion

01:54:22.591 --> 01:54:26.371
<v Alice>it's very intense and

01:54:26.371 --> 01:54:30.011
<v Alice>that that specificity of language and the rapidity with which he delivers it

01:54:30.011 --> 01:54:34.751
<v Alice>the smoothness with which he delivers it gives you this feeling of intensity

01:54:34.751 --> 01:54:42.971
<v Alice>and and hyper hyper real reality and it's a very arresting way of using words.

01:54:43.775 --> 01:54:48.195
<v Chas>It's the fireworks talking. He's even got a moment where he calls out.

01:54:48.355 --> 01:54:52.955
<v Excerpts>Like, Occasionally during the course of the show, I will lend voice to your

01:54:52.955 --> 01:54:54.315
<v Excerpts>collective internal monologue.

01:54:54.495 --> 01:55:00.515
<v Excerpts>And when I do that, I may insert words you wouldn't ordinarily have conversational access to, like folly.

01:55:02.055 --> 01:55:03.235
<v Excerpts>You're very welcome.

01:55:04.795 --> 01:55:07.755
<v Excerpts>Thank you, Daniel. That's remarkably perspicacious of you. Yes.

01:55:09.495 --> 01:55:13.295
<v Excerpts>How typical of an audience to slightly misuse the word perspicacious.

01:55:14.915 --> 01:55:17.935
<v Alice>Yeah, yeah, he does. He does draw attention to the thing that he's doing.

01:55:18.315 --> 01:55:21.855
<v Alice>Yeah, so again, you can say, I picked up a screwdriver and screwed in the screw.

01:55:22.115 --> 01:55:25.435
<v Alice>Or you can say, I picked up a seven and a half inch Phillips head screwdriver

01:55:25.435 --> 01:55:27.275
<v Alice>with a black and white striped handle.

01:55:27.695 --> 01:55:30.515
<v Alice>And it becomes a completely different scene.

01:55:30.955 --> 01:55:32.875
<v Stu>It's almost like what ASMR does.

01:55:33.662 --> 01:55:35.162
<v Stu>But with, like, word pictures.

01:55:37.322 --> 01:55:39.662
<v Stu>And the other thing you're saying is playing with status, right?

01:55:39.662 --> 01:55:45.082
<v Stu>And we haven't, we've done an episode on status, but, like, many years ago.

01:55:45.242 --> 01:55:49.702
<v Stu>And sadly, Chaz and I's status has not really changed the intervening seven years.

01:55:50.402 --> 01:55:54.882
<v Stu>But it's interesting because, you know, it's something that I think theater people talk about.

01:55:55.102 --> 01:56:00.722
<v Stu>Maybe comedy. I picked it up because of doing improv and Keith Johnston's book on improv.

01:56:00.722 --> 01:56:05.562
<v Stu>And then yet it's not talked about that much, at least in Australian filmmaking

01:56:05.562 --> 01:56:10.022
<v Stu>circles, maybe because we're not as socially aware of status in this country,

01:56:10.022 --> 01:56:11.902
<v Stu>or we just don't have that background.

01:56:11.902 --> 01:56:17.342
<v Stu>But you've talked about it a lot with all of these performance playing with status.

01:56:17.662 --> 01:56:21.742
<v Stu>Is he doing any kind of status shifts in his storytelling?

01:56:21.742 --> 01:56:28.202
<v Alice>Knowing yes absolutely all of the time all of the time uh all comedy is playing

01:56:28.202 --> 01:56:33.342
<v Alice>with status one way or another and it again depends also on which country you're

01:56:33.342 --> 01:56:37.242
<v Alice>doing it in that will affect the way that you play your status on stage and

01:56:37.242 --> 01:56:39.762
<v Alice>it will also affect because it will also affect what,

01:56:40.362 --> 01:56:45.842
<v Alice>assumptions people make about you coming onto stage you don't want to play too

01:56:45.842 --> 01:56:50.022
<v Alice>low status because then people feel sorry for you and they can't laugh you don't

01:56:50.022 --> 01:56:53.882
<v Alice>want to play too high status because then people think, who the fuck do you think you are?

01:56:54.102 --> 01:57:03.442
<v Alice>So it's this line of being high status but puncturing that or letting people in to be on your side.

01:57:04.722 --> 01:57:11.782
<v Alice>So, yeah, Daniel does it a lot in that he is so dominant on stage in the way

01:57:11.782 --> 01:57:13.142
<v Alice>that he presents all of his stories.

01:57:13.142 --> 01:57:17.642
<v Alice>He's so in control of the audience and he will occasionally draw attention to

01:57:17.642 --> 01:57:21.982
<v Alice>that but he's very capable of playing it down as well.

01:57:22.282 --> 01:57:25.582
<v Alice>His use of the stammer, for example, is a really good example.

01:57:25.882 --> 01:57:29.282
<v Alice>It's a thing that could be an impediment but he...

01:57:30.622 --> 01:57:35.142
<v Alice>He absolutely knows how to deal with it and the ways in which it affects the

01:57:35.142 --> 01:57:40.442
<v Alice>delivery and the ways in which he can recover from that all play into his status on stage.

01:57:40.662 --> 01:57:46.722
<v Stu>And him shifting between that kind of more simplistic is just a guy at the pub

01:57:46.722 --> 01:57:50.702
<v Stu>telling a joke and him going into those kind of really highly detailed word

01:57:50.702 --> 01:57:52.182
<v Stu>pitches is kind of, I would say,

01:57:52.522 --> 01:57:56.502
<v Stu>and look, status is culturally based, I would suggest.

01:57:56.922 --> 01:57:59.542
<v Stu>I don't want to say I would say, but there's definitely cultural implications

01:57:59.542 --> 01:58:04.582
<v Stu>to it. And I would say using those kind of more complicated word structures is high status.

01:58:04.902 --> 01:58:05.902
<v Alice>Yes, absolutely.

01:58:06.342 --> 01:58:10.322
<v Chas>Like we've talked about status, not just in like status shifts and how that

01:58:10.322 --> 01:58:14.542
<v Chas>can like drive energy into a scene by like changing status.

01:58:14.782 --> 01:58:18.502
<v Chas>But, you know, as Stephen Cleary has talked about it in our dialogue thing,

01:58:18.662 --> 01:58:23.202
<v Chas>like different people will talk in different ways to other characters,

01:58:23.362 --> 01:58:27.362
<v Chas>depending whether they're feeling high status or low status in relation to them.

01:58:27.362 --> 01:58:31.622
<v Chas>So just an awareness of that in any kind of scene writing will make the scene

01:58:31.622 --> 01:58:35.822
<v Chas>inherently more interesting and make your characters feel more individuated.

01:58:36.202 --> 01:58:40.642
<v Alice>You can absolutely change how a character, if a character is a villain or a

01:58:40.642 --> 01:58:44.642
<v Alice>hero, by bringing in someone higher status or lower status than them and having

01:58:44.642 --> 01:58:47.482
<v Alice>the way that they interact with that new person change.

01:58:48.262 --> 01:58:52.222
<v Alice>So you can have someone who's seemingly lovely and then they treat a serving

01:58:52.222 --> 01:58:55.082
<v Alice>person badly and you know they're a villain.

01:58:56.062 --> 01:59:00.542
<v Alice>Equally, you know, you can have somebody who seems in control and is very reassuring

01:59:00.542 --> 01:59:03.342
<v Alice>and comforting and then someone comes in who's higher status than them and you

01:59:03.342 --> 01:59:08.362
<v Alice>see them behaving as a sycophant and you immediately lose respect and they can

01:59:08.362 --> 01:59:09.682
<v Alice>never regain that status.

01:59:09.922 --> 01:59:13.342
<v Alice>And you can do that in stand-up all the time, in everything.

01:59:14.182 --> 01:59:19.442
<v Stu>In fact, some of the kind of shifts in character voiceover, like I'm just thinking

01:59:19.442 --> 01:59:23.382
<v Stu>about like casting our mind back to Hannah when she plays those characters,

01:59:23.502 --> 01:59:25.002
<v Stu>there's a status shift in the characters.

01:59:26.442 --> 01:59:34.502
<v Excerpts>But in all the debate about homosexuality, no one ever really talked about the lesbians.

01:59:35.460 --> 01:59:37.940
<v Excerpts>Do you know? Like, it's all the gay men. They're the problem.

01:59:39.260 --> 01:59:41.440
<v Excerpts>Anal sex, that's when the devil will get you.

01:59:43.700 --> 01:59:45.200
<v Excerpts>But lesbians, they're like, no.

01:59:47.300 --> 01:59:49.400
<v Excerpts>What even are they? What they do, they really?

01:59:50.360 --> 01:59:52.280
<v Stu>You know, she is doing these shifts of

01:59:52.280 --> 01:59:58.020
<v Stu>people and the way that then she is interacting with the world, I guess.

01:59:58.280 --> 02:00:01.680
<v Alice>And then by definition, by telling the story, you are automatically the most

02:00:01.680 --> 02:00:05.540
<v Alice>high-status person in it because you're the one who has the control of the story.

02:00:06.060 --> 02:00:09.660
<v Stu>Yeah, and I was thinking about that with ethos, coming back to what,

02:00:09.960 --> 02:00:12.100
<v Stu>because we talked about it before, but let's come back to it.

02:00:12.240 --> 02:00:16.240
<v Stu>Like Daniel's ethos, if he is kind of being a documentarian,

02:00:16.440 --> 02:00:19.760
<v Stu>telling these other people anecdotes, mostly focused on other people,

02:00:19.940 --> 02:00:22.460
<v Stu>how is he positioning himself as the framing device?

02:00:22.700 --> 02:00:27.380
<v Stu>What is his voice on these moments? Is that he, is it this hyper real,

02:00:27.740 --> 02:00:28.580
<v Stu>there's that great line.

02:00:29.440 --> 02:00:32.080
<v Excerpts>Increasingly, as human beings, we're disengaged from the moment,

02:00:32.080 --> 02:00:34.180
<v Excerpts>from the actual moment of our own lives.

02:00:34.240 --> 02:00:37.600
<v Excerpts>We live retrospectively or aspirationally or increasingly, for me,

02:00:37.860 --> 02:00:39.980
<v Excerpts>preemptively retrospectively. That's a new thing.

02:00:40.680 --> 02:00:43.660
<v Excerpts>Quite often, I'll find myself in a situation, not engaging with a situation,

02:00:43.840 --> 02:00:46.400
<v Excerpts>but already planning how well it's going to work in anecdote form.

02:00:47.980 --> 02:00:49.540
<v Excerpts>That is no way to live your life.

02:00:50.700 --> 02:00:53.760
<v Stu>How is he positioning himself as the storyteller?

02:00:54.140 --> 02:00:57.580
<v Alice>Look, I don't want to speak for Daniel. I could ask him.

02:00:57.860 --> 02:01:00.260
<v Stu>I mean, sorry, I'm not talking about this on a process level.

02:01:00.260 --> 02:01:02.100
<v Stu>I'm looking at it as the text.

02:01:02.400 --> 02:01:05.560
<v Stu>And this makes it hard because it's stand-up, but really what I'm interested

02:01:05.560 --> 02:01:07.780
<v Stu>in is how the text presents itself.

02:01:07.900 --> 02:01:14.900
<v Alice>In that show specifically, in the fireworks show, it's him or I feel that his

02:01:14.900 --> 02:01:21.020
<v Alice>ethos is he's going through a scrapbook that he's found in an old bookshelf

02:01:21.020 --> 02:01:22.340
<v Alice>and you're looking over his shoulder.

02:01:22.980 --> 02:01:27.140
<v Alice>And so he plays with, oh, look at this old thing that I've just found.

02:01:27.180 --> 02:01:28.940
<v Alice>And that's the kind of blokey thing.

02:01:29.633 --> 02:01:34.533
<v Alice>Kind of character, and then he draws you into it, and then he becomes this kind

02:01:34.533 --> 02:01:40.513
<v Alice>of archivist of human experience who's revealing these things to you in this

02:01:40.513 --> 02:01:43.213
<v Alice>slightly melancholy, slightly nostalgic way.

02:01:43.533 --> 02:01:47.133
<v Stu>That's a great description. It's interesting that you've given his voice,

02:01:47.153 --> 02:01:49.973
<v Stu>his character voice, an actual character.

02:01:50.273 --> 02:01:54.333
<v Stu>And I love that because I think if you want to do a lesson, character voice,

02:01:54.533 --> 02:01:58.153
<v Stu>the person who's telling the story in the big print.

02:01:58.293 --> 02:02:04.493
<v Stu>So, with character voice, there's how the story is told, capital, structural stuff.

02:02:04.753 --> 02:02:09.753
<v Stu>But there's also the voice in terms of how it's being told just in the in-between, in the big print.

02:02:09.913 --> 02:02:13.473
<v Stu>And just thinking of that as having a character is useful.

02:02:13.673 --> 02:02:17.813
<v Stu>And now having met Shane Black after being such a fan of his scripts and the

02:02:17.813 --> 02:02:21.853
<v Stu>kind of, like, asides with him, it's like that's obviously a bit of a persona, right?

02:02:21.853 --> 02:02:24.573
<v Stu>He's literally putting on a persona in the scripts that he writes,

02:02:24.833 --> 02:02:28.873
<v Stu>you know? Being that kind of like, he is playing the character of the smartass

02:02:28.873 --> 02:02:32.313
<v Stu>detective, the noir detective in the scripts that he writes.

02:02:32.913 --> 02:02:34.433
<v Stu>And it's such an interesting idea.

02:02:35.413 --> 02:02:40.693
<v Stu>And it's great to kind of unpack, because I think you can play with that without necessarily being I.

02:02:41.753 --> 02:02:45.773
<v Stu>Whatever is in it comes to my mind is we read the pilot of True Detective, right?

02:02:45.893 --> 02:02:51.593
<v Stu>And the style of that, beyond the dialogue, his style is really commanding on the page.

02:02:51.753 --> 02:02:57.373
<v Stu>It's like, notice this, notice that. Like, he is issuing you instructions, right?

02:02:57.653 --> 02:03:01.953
<v Stu>And it's got a personality to it that you could describe as a character in the same way.

02:03:01.993 --> 02:03:05.513
<v Stu>It's like, oh, it's an archivalist. And I think, you know, if you want to look

02:03:05.513 --> 02:03:09.493
<v Stu>at a script from the perspective of who is the character that is actually writing

02:03:09.493 --> 02:03:13.653
<v Stu>the words, I think that could actually be really helpful in terms of character voice.

02:03:14.433 --> 02:03:17.813
<v Stu>Is there anything else you kind of wanted to say about Daniela?

02:03:19.052 --> 02:03:22.332
<v Stu>Anything that he's doing, we've talked about status word pitches, transitions.

02:03:23.072 --> 02:03:27.352
<v Stu>I mean, the transitions just seem with all of them. It's like they have an idea

02:03:27.352 --> 02:03:30.052
<v Stu>and then they just take one step beyond the idea. I mean.

02:03:30.332 --> 02:03:33.832
<v Alice>Yes. I think in the way that you do a show, if you've done it a number of times,

02:03:33.992 --> 02:03:35.172
<v Alice>everything follows naturally.

02:03:35.752 --> 02:03:40.292
<v Alice>Everything knocks on, whether it logically ought to or not.

02:03:40.632 --> 02:03:43.992
<v Alice>It follows on by association in your mind.

02:03:44.232 --> 02:03:47.932
<v Alice>And so it seems natural. And that's partly just the force of character of the

02:03:47.932 --> 02:03:49.452
<v Alice>comedian delivering the bit.

02:03:49.692 --> 02:03:52.032
<v Alice>It makes sense because it's what happens next.

02:03:52.912 --> 02:03:57.612
<v Alice>Sometimes things happen in a show because they have to have happened by the end of the show.

02:03:57.912 --> 02:04:01.792
<v Stu>Yeah. In terms of you being able to get to the point at the end, getting to the pathos.

02:04:02.092 --> 02:04:04.652
<v Alice>Yes. Sometimes the setup is

02:04:04.652 --> 02:04:08.632
<v Alice>just there because it needs to have been there for the punchline to work.

02:04:09.612 --> 02:04:12.572
<v Chas>Well i mean we've spoken about we we did a whole i

02:04:12.572 --> 02:04:17.392
<v Chas>think god three episode run on character motivations in particular when they

02:04:17.392 --> 02:04:20.772
<v Chas>feel like they don't work and that's because the writer has needed something

02:04:20.772 --> 02:04:27.072
<v Chas>to happen in the story without like doing the work to make the it ring true

02:04:27.072 --> 02:04:30.272
<v Chas>for that character in that moment in that story yeah.

02:04:30.272 --> 02:04:33.192
<v Stu>I mean i think it's like i can't remember i'm going to attribute it to shane

02:04:33.192 --> 02:04:36.252
<v Stu>black but it mightn't be he because he talks about setup and payoffs and reversals

02:04:36.252 --> 02:04:38.652
<v Stu>and he's like on the first draft i write all the payoffs and then the second

02:04:38.652 --> 02:04:42.032
<v Stu>draft, I wrote all the setups, right?

02:04:42.192 --> 02:04:44.852
<v Stu>And it feels like he could possibly do the same way in structuring it.

02:04:45.412 --> 02:04:48.292
<v Stu>Because what I think the big thing I've taken away from this,

02:04:48.372 --> 02:04:54.592
<v Stu>and it's come from you, Alice, is ethos, logos, and pathos. I think they're all forms of theme.

02:04:56.225 --> 02:05:02.085
<v Stu>The way that screenwriters think about theme is actually all those things intermingled, right?

02:05:02.205 --> 02:05:05.625
<v Stu>And if you want your writing to be better, being conscious of the ethos.

02:05:05.745 --> 02:05:08.805
<v Stu>Who the person is telling the story, as we heard from Ali Wong,

02:05:08.965 --> 02:05:11.345
<v Stu>is part of what the thing is about, right?

02:05:11.865 --> 02:05:15.305
<v Stu>Okay, it doesn't have to be, but it can be. You've got Logos,

02:05:15.365 --> 02:05:18.685
<v Stu>which is the overall structure, can be what the theme is about.

02:05:18.825 --> 02:05:22.905
<v Stu>And even though we didn't talk directly to Inside, the structure of Inside,

02:05:23.265 --> 02:05:26.885
<v Stu>the way it's structured, is what it is about. more than the ending itself.

02:05:27.085 --> 02:05:30.905
<v Stu>But even Nanette does that beautifully, right? It's about the tension and release

02:05:30.905 --> 02:05:36.405
<v Stu>and then her very structure of joke and then the serious part and then joke

02:05:36.405 --> 02:05:38.885
<v Stu>serious part and I'm just going to leave you on the serious part is part of

02:05:38.885 --> 02:05:40.525
<v Stu>what it is about, is the theme.

02:05:40.705 --> 02:05:44.265
<v Stu>And then you've got the pathos which is how it all brings together and makes

02:05:44.265 --> 02:05:47.345
<v Stu>you go, what is it all about? It's actually what it is all about.

02:05:47.465 --> 02:05:48.845
<v Stu>But it's not just about your ending.

02:05:49.065 --> 02:05:53.745
<v Stu>And I think for me that is super insightful because I can sit there and go...

02:05:54.470 --> 02:05:58.010
<v Stu>Because I definitely think structure is theme. And I look at a film like Zero

02:05:58.010 --> 02:06:02.110
<v Stu>Dark Thirty that is supposedly anti-torture, and I'm like, the whole structure

02:06:02.110 --> 02:06:05.150
<v Stu>opens with torture, right?

02:06:05.270 --> 02:06:08.470
<v Stu>Oh, it's anti-torture. No, you open with them torturing someone to get information,

02:06:08.590 --> 02:06:11.490
<v Stu>you end with that information leading to them getting Osama Bin Laden.

02:06:11.710 --> 02:06:16.070
<v Stu>The structure of the film, the text itself, says torture works, right?

02:06:16.330 --> 02:06:20.670
<v Stu>Regardless of what the externality of the filmmakers are. And the ethos of that

02:06:20.670 --> 02:06:24.870
<v Stu>film doesn't cut against that, right? The storytelling of that film doesn't

02:06:24.870 --> 02:06:25.990
<v Stu>undermine its own structure.

02:06:26.170 --> 02:06:29.170
<v Alice>And the people whom you are meant to care about as well, the pathos,

02:06:29.270 --> 02:06:32.270
<v Alice>who you're meant to identify with in that movie and who you're meant to care

02:06:32.270 --> 02:06:35.410
<v Alice>about in that movie doesn't cut against that message either.

02:06:35.730 --> 02:06:40.590
<v Stu>Yeah. So the externality of the author intent, I'm someone who's,

02:06:40.730 --> 02:06:44.350
<v Stu>weirdly, as a screenwriter, is someone who doesn't care about author's intent.

02:06:44.510 --> 02:06:47.750
<v Stu>Because I think as soon as you think film should be about the author's intent,

02:06:47.970 --> 02:06:49.770
<v Stu>it makes your work lazy. Yeah.

02:06:49.910 --> 02:06:52.350
<v Alice>That's the great thing about comedy. You might think it's a joke,

02:06:52.590 --> 02:06:55.790
<v Alice>but the audience will tell you if it's a joke or not.

02:06:56.810 --> 02:07:00.350
<v Stu>Yeah. You know, and they have to laugh at it without knowing what,

02:07:00.630 --> 02:07:03.970
<v Stu>without having to get it, which I actually think is really super insightful as well.

02:07:04.090 --> 02:07:08.110
<v Stu>This idea that people have to understand it without having to understand it.

02:07:08.190 --> 02:07:12.550
<v Stu>That having a highfalutin theme, right, that may connect to bigger ideas,

02:07:12.770 --> 02:07:15.230
<v Stu>if they, if, if it still has to be funny.

02:07:15.230 --> 02:07:20.970
<v Alice>It has to work even if they don't necessarily get the other stuff around it

02:07:20.970 --> 02:07:22.310
<v Alice>or what you're trying to say.

02:07:24.627 --> 02:07:30.107
<v Stu>And I think all of these stand-ups all use these three things as part of how

02:07:30.107 --> 02:07:33.427
<v Stu>they create meaning and a meaningful – like, that's how they make them funny.

02:07:33.427 --> 02:07:37.447
<v Stu>But in terms of them being funny and, you know, healing the world literally

02:07:37.447 --> 02:07:40.487
<v Stu>metaphorically is connected to how they use these three elements.

02:07:41.347 --> 02:07:46.347
<v Alice>Yes. Yeah. And I think the satisfaction, I don't know, I can't speak to the

02:07:46.347 --> 02:07:48.967
<v Alice>other shows, but the satisfaction,

02:07:49.347 --> 02:07:53.367
<v Alice>a lot of the satisfaction in Savage is in resolving these things that might

02:07:53.367 --> 02:07:56.367
<v Alice>not have seemed important, but were important.

02:07:57.387 --> 02:08:02.327
<v Alice>All of my shows, I think, I write like they're detective novels.

02:08:03.767 --> 02:08:07.567
<v Alice>So things that seem like throwaway things, when you come to the end of the show,

02:08:07.667 --> 02:08:14.487
<v Alice>when all the threads come together, you go, Oh, that thing actually was really important all along.

02:08:15.247 --> 02:08:18.027
<v Stu>The but was really important.

02:08:18.347 --> 02:08:19.847
<v Alice>Yeah, everything was really important. Turns out of all the things.

02:08:20.067 --> 02:08:24.067
<v Stu>The but was the important part, which is really, you know, everything.

02:08:25.107 --> 02:08:28.987
<v Stu>I've been watching David Mamet masterclasses, forgive me, and he's been like,

02:08:29.107 --> 02:08:30.647
<v Stu>everything tends towards the punchline.

02:08:30.667 --> 02:08:32.847
<v Stu>So he's got a whole thing about, you know, I spent, you know,

02:08:32.947 --> 02:08:35.287
<v Stu>you ask a comedian what they've been doing all week in America,

02:08:35.567 --> 02:08:39.027
<v Stu>in LA, and they're like, I've been taking off a few syllables, right?

02:08:39.187 --> 02:08:41.887
<v Stu>That's it. like all everything is about the punchline and i

02:08:41.887 --> 02:08:44.567
<v Stu>don't think that's strictly true but what is interesting particularly about what

02:08:44.567 --> 02:08:48.707
<v Stu>you did in savage is everything connects and was that something that you were

02:08:48.707 --> 02:08:51.187
<v Stu>i mean now i'm ending with the question even though we're meant to be right

02:08:51.187 --> 02:08:54.767
<v Stu>but was that something you were conscious of or was it that you put them in

02:08:54.767 --> 02:08:58.427
<v Stu>there and you had to you were consciously trying to make them integrate them

02:08:58.427 --> 02:09:03.927
<v Stu>into the end or was it they were naturally because it's in the soup of what you the stone soup.

02:09:03.927 --> 02:09:08.707
<v Alice>It was all backwards when i was structuring it after the first trials and was

02:09:08.707 --> 02:09:13.027
<v Alice>thinking what is this show what am i writing about what am i trying to say the

02:09:13.027 --> 02:09:17.787
<v Alice>things that i was trying to say were all the difficult things and everything

02:09:17.787 --> 02:09:23.167
<v Alice>else is just laying the groundwork for people to be able to take it.

02:09:24.385 --> 02:09:27.485
<v Alice>Either building up the strength of the audience, building up the trust of the

02:09:27.485 --> 02:09:31.645
<v Alice>audience, or building up these reference points for the audience to understand

02:09:31.645 --> 02:09:33.845
<v Alice>these stories retrospectively.

02:09:34.185 --> 02:09:39.845
<v Alice>So, you know, every harmless story is the shell of something that I'm then going

02:09:39.845 --> 02:09:42.385
<v Alice>to pack with gunpowder and give back to you.

02:09:42.665 --> 02:09:45.605
<v Alice>And you will accept it because you've held it before as a harmless shell.

02:09:46.545 --> 02:09:50.905
<v Alice>So whether it's about the story about, what do I call him?

02:09:51.565 --> 02:09:56.665
<v Alice>I'm trying not to say his real name. at Toby in the Savage special,

02:09:56.925 --> 02:10:04.505
<v Alice>that at the beginning of the show, which is ostensibly, and it does also work as a status thing.

02:10:04.605 --> 02:10:09.105
<v Alice>It lowers my status. It shows me as awkward and vulnerable as an opening piece,

02:10:09.105 --> 02:10:12.825
<v Alice>but it also introduces the idea of the unfinished containing the infinite,

02:10:13.585 --> 02:10:15.965
<v Alice>this idea that comes back right at the end.

02:10:16.005 --> 02:10:21.085
<v Alice>And I feel like everything is like that. Everything in the show is like that.

02:10:21.425 --> 02:10:26.965
<v Alice>I think, well, how can I tell people this thing that I think is important and

02:10:26.965 --> 02:10:29.625
<v Alice>have them actually listen to and hear it and feel it properly?

02:10:30.707 --> 02:10:34.607
<v Alice>And it's often about laying that harmless groundwork so they're used to it.

02:10:34.907 --> 02:10:40.947
<v Chas>I think in screenwriting, there's a lot of plot recontextualization.

02:10:41.127 --> 02:10:46.247
<v Chas>Like you lay groundwork, you know, set up and pay off for story things to be

02:10:46.247 --> 02:10:48.587
<v Chas>surprising or to happen.

02:10:48.947 --> 02:10:53.607
<v Chas>But I think what all these stand-ups do, these specials do, is they do it for

02:10:53.607 --> 02:10:56.227
<v Chas>emotional reasons as well.

02:10:56.327 --> 02:11:02.027
<v Chas>And I think TV is particularly good at that. The current run of like limited

02:11:02.027 --> 02:11:07.047
<v Chas>series stuff where, you know, you can lay groundwork in episode one that you

02:11:07.047 --> 02:11:09.867
<v Chas>can recontextualize in episode six.

02:11:10.427 --> 02:11:14.967
<v Chas>So, I mean, the main thing that I'm taking from this that isn't the theme,

02:11:15.167 --> 02:11:16.607
<v Chas>because I think that is the big thing.

02:11:16.747 --> 02:11:22.587
<v Chas>She's hit the nail on the head is I'm going to look for opportunities to lay

02:11:22.587 --> 02:11:26.947
<v Chas>emotional groundwork for recontextualization later in the story.

02:11:26.947 --> 02:11:33.147
<v Chas>And also I'm going to be less afraid, I think, look, the different projects

02:11:33.147 --> 02:11:35.747
<v Chas>will call for different things, but I am...

02:11:37.030 --> 02:11:42.350
<v Chas>I'm amazed at the ballsiness of telling the audience what you are doing.

02:11:42.550 --> 02:11:47.610
<v Chas>And I've just recently been rereading a run of comic books called Sex Criminals.

02:11:47.750 --> 02:11:52.030
<v Chas>I am definitely betraying my sense of humor in this podcast.

02:11:52.270 --> 02:11:59.670
<v Chas>But there's one bit in like the fourth book of the six, like it's the low point of the run.

02:12:00.210 --> 02:12:04.570
<v Chas>And the girlfriend says, I want us to stop being criminals.

02:12:04.570 --> 02:12:07.550
<v Chas>And the boyfriend's response is but it's

02:12:07.550 --> 02:12:11.050
<v Chas>the premise of the book you know and and

02:12:11.050 --> 02:12:14.990
<v Chas>it's just such like kind of throwaway line but i think now we're getting so

02:12:14.990 --> 02:12:19.370
<v Chas>sort of cinema and story literate or audiences are as in particular that you

02:12:19.370 --> 02:12:26.530
<v Chas>can get away with the obvious or as daniel does like tell the seeming innocuous

02:12:26.530 --> 02:12:30.350
<v Chas>and just like how you tell it can make it powerful big.

02:12:30.350 --> 02:12:35.090
<v Stu>Big mouth i just I'm still making my way last through season four, but they had this line.

02:12:35.930 --> 02:12:40.050
<v Excerpts>Hey, Missy. Oh, hey, Devon. Look, I'm sorry Devin said that stupid shit about

02:12:40.050 --> 02:12:43.770
<v Excerpts>your hair on the bus. Yeah, it was not 100.

02:12:44.370 --> 02:12:48.630
<v Excerpts>Sure, 100. It's just that I'm really struggling with my racial identity right

02:12:48.630 --> 02:12:51.170
<v Excerpts>now. My mom's white, my dad's black.

02:12:51.410 --> 02:12:54.690
<v Excerpts>I'm voiced by a white actress who's 37 years old.

02:12:55.270 --> 02:12:57.750
<v Excerpts>It's all very overwhelming. Yeah, I hear that.

02:12:58.050 --> 02:13:01.750
<v Stu>And then they just kind of walk past it, But they kind of have to acknowledge

02:13:01.750 --> 02:13:06.170
<v Stu>it, partly because I think they obviously have decided she just stepped back

02:13:06.170 --> 02:13:08.130
<v Stu>from that role and they're recasting it.

02:13:08.250 --> 02:13:12.210
<v Stu>But they kind of almost needed to just do the innocuous acknowledgement of,

02:13:12.330 --> 02:13:16.330
<v Stu>we know this is problematic. We know that you know and something is going to happen.

02:13:16.510 --> 02:13:19.530
<v Stu>And I think that it's funny because it's transgressive.

02:13:20.290 --> 02:13:25.470
<v Stu>But it helps you understand, we know we're watching a show. We know it's artificial.

02:13:26.581 --> 02:13:32.101
<v Alice>The way that I come on stage in Savage is deliberately not the way you come

02:13:32.101 --> 02:13:37.001
<v Alice>on stage because I didn't want to have that thing where you're backstage with

02:13:37.001 --> 02:13:40.221
<v Alice>the comedian who's looking over their notes solemnly and then they come out

02:13:40.221 --> 02:13:41.921
<v Alice>to the blaze of light and the big announcement.

02:13:41.921 --> 02:13:46.541
<v Alice>And I didn't want to have that for that show in particular.

02:13:46.541 --> 02:13:52.681
<v Alice>You ought to have this kind of vulnerability and slight discomfort as a way

02:13:52.681 --> 02:13:55.621
<v Alice>of inviting the audience in and going, look, I know how this is meant to go

02:13:55.621 --> 02:13:57.241
<v Alice>and I know how I'm meant to be doing it.

02:13:57.381 --> 02:14:02.961
<v Alice>But, yeah, and in the end you want all your shows to have that surprise of the

02:14:02.961 --> 02:14:06.821
<v Alice>first time you watch The Usual Suspects and at the end of the show you're like,

02:14:07.001 --> 02:14:09.481
<v Alice>ah, Kevin Spacey was a rapist all along.

02:14:12.361 --> 02:14:15.921
<v Stu>Wow, I think that is an in point. That is the pathos.

02:14:16.961 --> 02:14:21.001
<v Chas>But thank you so much for doing two and a half hours.

02:14:21.261 --> 02:14:27.621
<v Chas>And I've decided I need to get a master's in narrative rhetoric because I pretend

02:14:27.621 --> 02:14:32.441
<v Chas>to have the knowledge that you just are able to rattle off. And it's, yeah, thank you so much.

02:14:32.721 --> 02:14:35.441
<v Alice>Oh, thank you so much for having me. It was really fun and interesting.

02:14:35.961 --> 02:14:36.321
<v Stu>Yeah.

02:14:39.001 --> 02:14:41.441
<v Excerpts>And now for Backmatter.

02:14:42.861 --> 02:14:46.141
<v Stu>Okay, so there's something I want to fix that, and then you talked about tension,

02:14:46.281 --> 02:14:48.961
<v Stu>and that's something that Hannah Gadsby talks about, tension,

02:14:49.121 --> 02:14:53.741
<v Stu>that, you know, punchlines is you create this tension and then the punchline relieves it, right?

02:14:55.081 --> 02:14:59.741
<v Stu>So I'm curious now, like the difference between tension on stage versus doing

02:14:59.741 --> 02:15:02.321
<v Stu>it recorded, how do you feel?

02:15:02.421 --> 02:15:05.741
<v Stu>Is it just something you feel in the tension or is it something that you purposefully

02:15:05.741 --> 02:15:07.441
<v Stu>construct when you're doing a live show?

02:15:08.236 --> 02:15:12.016
<v Alice>When you're doing a live show, you can construct it live because you have a

02:15:12.016 --> 02:15:15.576
<v Alice>very clear sense of the audience.

02:15:16.336 --> 02:15:23.596
<v Alice>It's difficult to describe because it is so intangible, but for comedians it's

02:15:23.596 --> 02:15:25.596
<v Alice>very palpable and we will talk about it backstage.

02:15:25.876 --> 02:15:32.236
<v Alice>The vibe of the audience is so strong. So you can feel their breaking point in the room.

02:15:32.316 --> 02:15:35.976
<v Alice>You can feel where you're losing them or where they're slipping. so

02:15:35.976 --> 02:15:39.276
<v Alice>it gives you more leeway to push them to

02:15:39.276 --> 02:15:42.236
<v Alice>take them into interesting places sometimes you don't

02:15:42.236 --> 02:15:46.836
<v Alice>even need a joke to make get a laugh you just need to play with the with the

02:15:46.836 --> 02:15:52.656
<v Alice>tension there's there's a joke in the show about Turia Pitt that is the longest

02:15:52.656 --> 02:15:57.556
<v Alice>the longest joke in the world there's no swearing but it is the most dangerous

02:15:57.556 --> 02:16:01.316
<v Alice>joke in the show because it is purely about building tension.

02:16:01.596 --> 02:16:06.776
<v Alice>It's just feeling out the audience and how far I can push this story,

02:16:07.016 --> 02:16:10.456
<v Alice>building the tension before I get to a very, very fucking harmless punchline.

02:16:10.656 --> 02:16:16.956
<v Alice>The punchline is way for thin. It is just about the timing and the delivery of this tension.

02:16:17.176 --> 02:16:20.396
<v Stu>What it's telling me is that you're conscious of the tension, right?

02:16:20.996 --> 02:16:23.656
<v Stu>You're sitting there going, I need to tell this joke. I'm going to inflate the

02:16:23.656 --> 02:16:24.976
<v Stu>balloon and whatever the metaphor is.

02:16:25.356 --> 02:16:28.996
<v Stu>And then I've got to time it right live. But when you're translating that on

02:16:28.996 --> 02:16:31.436
<v Stu>screen, How did you think about that?

02:16:31.536 --> 02:16:35.636
<v Stu>Because obviously screenwriters, we've got to be really conscious of an audience

02:16:35.636 --> 02:16:37.536
<v Stu>that we can't see or interact with, right?

02:16:37.776 --> 02:16:40.996
<v Stu>And the art of really good screenwriters and directors and editors,

02:16:40.996 --> 02:16:44.296
<v Stu>when it all comes together, is that feels effortless, right?

02:16:44.456 --> 02:16:48.016
<v Stu>And not everyone, like, you can see the divisive nature of a lot of content,

02:16:48.156 --> 02:16:49.616
<v Stu>the people, it doesn't always work for people.

02:16:51.040 --> 02:16:54.060
<v Stu>It still comes from somewhere and you've got that advantage that you can feed back.

02:16:54.420 --> 02:16:58.200
<v Stu>I'm assuming if you've done Savage Habitages of times, it fed into the show

02:16:58.200 --> 02:17:00.020
<v Stu>and the nature of the show and how you tell that joke.

02:17:00.280 --> 02:17:02.720
<v Stu>But then how did you change it when you had to put it on screen?

02:17:03.400 --> 02:17:07.000
<v Alice>Well, it's an interesting thing having done now a year of Zoom shows.

02:17:07.240 --> 02:17:12.680
<v Alice>It is this kind of approximation. You kind of go for the safe middle ground of attention.

02:17:13.160 --> 02:17:17.860
<v Alice>If it were a particular audience in a particular room, if the audience is full

02:17:17.860 --> 02:17:21.080
<v Alice>of drunkards, you might tell that story a lot quicker. and if the audience is

02:17:21.080 --> 02:17:25.260
<v Alice>full of people who are on your side and you can just feel the love coming off

02:17:25.260 --> 02:17:27.420
<v Alice>them, you might push that story further.

02:17:28.160 --> 02:17:33.080
<v Alice>But for an audience that you cannot feel, you just go with the one that you

02:17:33.080 --> 02:17:34.900
<v Alice>know is probably going to work.

02:17:35.580 --> 02:17:39.500
<v Alice>So because you've done it so many times, you have a sense of where those boundaries

02:17:39.500 --> 02:17:45.740
<v Alice>are on each side, where the lane markers are, and you sort of steer in the middle there.

02:17:46.120 --> 02:17:49.200
<v Alice>And then also you play off the audience that you have. in the terms of a special,

02:17:49.260 --> 02:17:51.520
<v Alice>you play off the audience that you have on the night.

02:17:51.960 --> 02:17:57.900
<v Alice>And that was an interesting thing as well, because I was reluctant to have any audience shots at all.

02:17:58.520 --> 02:18:02.060
<v Alice>I said, I don't want to see the audience laughing. If you're going to cut to

02:18:02.060 --> 02:18:03.160
<v Alice>the audience, show them crying.

02:18:03.540 --> 02:18:05.980
<v Alice>And actually what I said was, if you're going to show the audience,

02:18:06.140 --> 02:18:12.840
<v Alice>show them along the row, because that weird thing of no one ever turns around

02:18:12.840 --> 02:18:15.420
<v Alice>and looks full in the face of the audience. Yeah.

02:18:15.941 --> 02:18:18.821
<v Alice>In because I wanted to have this proxy for the intimacy

02:18:18.821 --> 02:18:22.641
<v Alice>of the experience of being in the show I was like film over the shoulders of

02:18:22.641 --> 02:18:28.141
<v Alice>the audience if you want to have that feeling or go sideways I didn't want that

02:18:28.141 --> 02:18:33.781
<v Alice>from behind shot where you see the audience although in the end I had to negotiate

02:18:33.781 --> 02:18:37.861
<v Alice>down and they did do a few from behind shots which you know.

02:18:37.861 --> 02:18:41.021
<v Chas>Well we're going to talk about interiority and

02:18:41.021 --> 02:18:43.701
<v Chas>how like this is slightly in how to

02:18:43.701 --> 02:18:47.341
<v Chas>direct a special not how screenwriters can learn from stand-up specials

02:18:47.341 --> 02:18:50.621
<v Chas>but your show has a like

02:18:50.621 --> 02:18:53.721
<v Chas>an audio visual component of the written

02:18:53.721 --> 02:18:56.721
<v Chas>words of an interview that you

02:18:56.721 --> 02:19:02.561
<v Chas>conducted and in the special because you got to see you live but I I've only

02:19:02.561 --> 02:19:08.181
<v Chas>ever seen it on on Amazon but the the words are playing often over the top of

02:19:08.181 --> 02:19:12.581
<v Chas>a shot of you like the audience in the live show would presumably be reading

02:19:12.581 --> 02:19:14.741
<v Chas>the words up on a screen behind you,

02:19:14.921 --> 02:19:19.241
<v Chas>whereas the juxtaposition of hearing the words and being able to read them,

02:19:19.381 --> 02:19:25.781
<v Chas>but also got that tension from it because we're just sitting watching you be still?

02:19:26.281 --> 02:19:30.401
<v Alice>In the original live versions of the show, there was no written component.

02:19:30.401 --> 02:19:34.301
<v Alice>It was just the lights would go down enough that you could still see me,

02:19:34.401 --> 02:19:36.861
<v Alice>but not well, and the audio would play.

02:19:37.981 --> 02:19:43.881
<v Alice>These very small movements that I would make in that darkness to keep focus

02:19:43.881 --> 02:19:47.241
<v Alice>were all movements that showed me listening,

02:19:48.062 --> 02:19:50.722
<v Alice>to the thing and gave that indication that you should be listening and that

02:19:50.722 --> 02:19:53.582
<v Alice>your focus should be on these words that are coming through on

02:19:53.582 --> 02:19:56.802
<v Alice>the audio and of course that doesn't work on screen

02:19:56.802 --> 02:20:00.122
<v Alice>you can't just have a black screen for a minute uh with

02:20:00.122 --> 02:20:04.942
<v Alice>audio playing over it uh without fearing you know losing the kind of the dynamism

02:20:04.942 --> 02:20:08.262
<v Alice>of the show or that absorption of the show and so that was the kind of compromise

02:20:08.262 --> 02:20:12.642
<v Alice>that we came to going through the fonts that would be the most the big thing

02:20:12.642 --> 02:20:16.782
<v Alice>that i fought for was to have the words appear as they are spoken not to have

02:20:16.782 --> 02:20:18.822
<v Alice>them come up as blocks of text.

02:20:19.062 --> 02:20:23.662
<v Alice>I didn't want people reading ahead. I wanted that immersive experience of having

02:20:23.662 --> 02:20:28.722
<v Alice>it come at the same time and appear as in water as well.

02:20:29.830 --> 02:20:33.170
<v Stu>Because, I mean, I think that's one of the things with stand-up versus that

02:20:33.170 --> 02:20:37.030
<v Stu>it's live and not read is that people are reading one word at a time and you've

02:20:37.030 --> 02:20:41.430
<v Stu>got control of pacing, which is something that filmmakers, in a broad sense,

02:20:41.510 --> 02:20:42.790
<v Stu>not just screenwriters, have control.

02:20:43.070 --> 02:20:46.230
<v Stu>Like, that's what we can do is control pacing. For me, you know,

02:20:46.610 --> 02:20:53.690
<v Stu>screenwriting is about how we can control time and time is like a resource of

02:20:53.690 --> 02:20:54.470
<v Stu>where we hold attention.

02:20:55.010 --> 02:20:57.950
<v Stu>We don't want to get into too much bogged in the details of directing a special,

02:20:58.130 --> 02:21:02.050
<v Stu>but the fact is a writer, like it's a writer can write in a script.

02:21:02.290 --> 02:21:06.050
<v Stu>We project words on screen, right? And that's a choice. And we can choose not

02:21:06.050 --> 02:21:10.310
<v Stu>to play it in black or this is how we hold the audience's attention at this moment.

02:21:10.490 --> 02:21:12.570
<v Stu>They're all things that a writer can do on the page.

02:21:12.970 --> 02:21:17.390
<v Alice>Well, in stand-up, the words are the only bit that is sort of explicitly written,

02:21:17.390 --> 02:21:21.150
<v Alice>but so much of the performance is also in the script.

02:21:21.810 --> 02:21:25.550
<v Alice>So one example, I don't know if this is relevant for your screenwriting,

02:21:25.710 --> 02:21:31.590
<v Alice>but the people who directed Savage, who filmed it, were the people who'd done Nanette.

02:21:31.970 --> 02:21:36.090
<v Alice>And they had very strong ideas about what shots they wanted to use and what

02:21:36.090 --> 02:21:37.970
<v Alice>shots best conveyed intimacy.

02:21:38.770 --> 02:21:42.550
<v Alice>And that was basically from the point at which, this was their thesis,

02:21:43.170 --> 02:21:46.870
<v Alice>from the point at which it becomes intimate, we're going to do a close-up of

02:21:46.870 --> 02:21:48.730
<v Alice>your shoulders and head.

02:21:49.672 --> 02:21:54.672
<v Alice>And I said, no, not that we wouldn't have any of those shots,

02:21:54.812 --> 02:21:58.152
<v Alice>but that I wanted a number of shots of me from quite far back,

02:21:58.492 --> 02:22:03.252
<v Alice>isolated full body shots of showing me alone on stage quite small,

02:22:03.652 --> 02:22:10.252
<v Alice>partly because the performance was whole body and the way that my body moved

02:22:10.252 --> 02:22:12.252
<v Alice>was important to communicating the meaning.

02:22:12.252 --> 02:22:18.272
<v Alice>It was part of the script and also partly because I thought actually sometimes

02:22:18.272 --> 02:22:21.072
<v Alice>it is more intimate to see somebody on their own from far away,

02:22:21.292 --> 02:22:23.352
<v Alice>particularly in emotional moments.

02:22:23.552 --> 02:22:27.092
<v Alice>You don't ever really, like if you've ever been with a friend who's weeping

02:22:27.092 --> 02:22:31.492
<v Alice>uncontrollably or sharing something really vulnerable, it's extremely unlikely

02:22:31.492 --> 02:22:33.232
<v Alice>that you'll be staring them full in the eyes.

02:22:34.892 --> 02:22:39.092
<v Alice>So the way that my yeah the way that the physicality of that performance that

02:22:39.092 --> 02:22:44.692
<v Alice>is part of the script is about looking away and where i shield myself and that

02:22:44.692 --> 02:22:49.912
<v Alice>process of you witnessing me shielding myself is i think more vulnerable and

02:22:49.912 --> 02:22:53.632
<v Alice>intimate than necessarily being right in up close on my face the.

02:22:53.632 --> 02:22:57.872
<v Stu>Bo burnham inside special is absolutely lots of little moments of him in an

02:22:57.872 --> 02:23:02.212
<v Stu>empty environment wide shot right they use that as a device as a transition

02:23:02.212 --> 02:23:07.632
<v Stu>device right But it's also about showing that vulnerability and spending alone time with someone.

02:23:07.812 --> 02:23:12.412
<v Stu>That's a screenwriting idea I've fixated on recently is that I'm often really

02:23:12.412 --> 02:23:15.792
<v Stu>scared about giving my characters private moments because it slows the story

02:23:15.792 --> 02:23:17.752
<v Stu>down. You've got to keep the plot pushing forward.

02:23:17.912 --> 02:23:19.952
<v Stu>And in my film, Restoration, we actually shot...

02:23:20.692 --> 02:23:23.752
<v Stu>I could say it's now, it's many years later. We shot pickups because I wouldn't

02:23:23.752 --> 02:23:24.692
<v Stu>shoot that stuff, right?

02:23:24.872 --> 02:23:28.352
<v Stu>I'd be like, we don't need it. And the editor's like, oh, we need a little moment

02:23:28.352 --> 02:23:30.892
<v Stu>of just the character at the end of the scene processing.

02:23:31.312 --> 02:23:34.612
<v Stu>And it's so much better, but sometimes I feel you don't have it.

02:23:34.692 --> 02:23:37.952
<v Stu>And it can be something that is a wide shot. It sounds like that's something

02:23:37.952 --> 02:23:42.752
<v Stu>that you're aware of, that idea of the moments that you give the audience of

02:23:42.752 --> 02:23:44.852
<v Stu>just, for lack of a better word, looking at you.

02:23:45.872 --> 02:23:52.152
<v Alice>Yeah which is this odd thing of of being conscious as you perform of how you are perceived,

02:23:52.952 --> 02:23:57.632
<v Alice>so one of the framing devices i use in the show is i take my mom's rings off

02:23:57.632 --> 02:24:01.872
<v Alice>i wear them on the middle finger of my left hand my mom's wedding ring and her

02:24:01.872 --> 02:24:05.892
<v Alice>engagement ring and so the beginning of the show is me taking those rings off

02:24:05.892 --> 02:24:11.052
<v Alice>because at the time that i'm set the show she's not dead,

02:24:12.232 --> 02:24:16.972
<v Alice>so for me that's just a small thing and then at the end of the show i put the

02:24:16.972 --> 02:24:22.032
<v Alice>rings back on and no one would notice that really but it's for me that's really

02:24:22.032 --> 02:24:26.892
<v Alice>important part of the storytelling of the show is that we're placing ourselves

02:24:26.892 --> 02:24:28.692
<v Alice>at a particular point in time.

02:24:35.191 --> 02:24:41.971
<v Chas>But now that you're you know you're now adapting this same piece again into

02:24:41.971 --> 02:24:47.411
<v Chas>a longer form but a scripted form for television what have what have you found

02:24:47.411 --> 02:24:52.511
<v Chas>are the the major challenges or or joys that you found there so.

02:24:52.511 --> 02:24:57.771
<v Alice>The major challenge the really core challenge for me is how much of the story I tell.

02:24:58.591 --> 02:25:01.711
<v Alice>Savage is an illusion of intimacy. I

02:25:01.711 --> 02:25:05.171
<v Alice>create the illusion of intimacy by giving you very close-up shots

02:25:05.171 --> 02:25:08.971
<v Alice>of specific moments emotionally or comedically

02:25:08.971 --> 02:25:11.911
<v Alice>or very detailed vignettes and then

02:25:11.911 --> 02:25:16.611
<v Alice>I pull quite far back and speak in generalities and the audience comes to me

02:25:16.611 --> 02:25:21.951
<v Alice>with their own personal intimate moments that they load in their own emotions

02:25:21.951 --> 02:25:27.031
<v Alice>and that that's the trick of Savage is to appear to be revealing a lot because

02:25:27.031 --> 02:25:30.051
<v Alice>I'm revealing unusual things that you wouldn't normally reveal.

02:25:30.791 --> 02:25:34.551
<v Alice>But I don't, for example, ever describe my mum's physicality.

02:25:34.731 --> 02:25:39.371
<v Alice>I never, there's only one point where I quote her where it's not in her own

02:25:39.371 --> 02:25:42.371
<v Alice>words. My twin brother doesn't appear in the show at all.

02:25:43.031 --> 02:25:45.451
<v Alice>My father, I don't think, appears in that show at all.

02:25:46.151 --> 02:25:52.271
<v Alice>It's a razor thin slice of this very intimate experience and that was all I

02:25:52.271 --> 02:25:56.631
<v Alice>felt comfortable telling at the time because I didn't want to expose my family.

02:25:56.631 --> 02:26:01.251
<v Alice>It was very important, as you hear in the audio sections, that mum gives me

02:26:01.251 --> 02:26:02.831
<v Alice>permission to talk about her.

02:26:03.251 --> 02:26:09.931
<v Alice>So having to expand that out from this very fine...

02:26:11.049 --> 02:26:15.229
<v Alice>Story thread which is mostly told through

02:26:15.229 --> 02:26:18.349
<v Alice>gesture uh to

02:26:18.349 --> 02:26:21.129
<v Alice>having to unfold a whole world to show what it

02:26:21.129 --> 02:26:26.189
<v Alice>looks like to to tell these other stories to bring them in or not um that's

02:26:26.189 --> 02:26:28.849
<v Alice>the real challenge for me how much do i feel comfortable telling how much do

02:26:28.849 --> 02:26:33.049
<v Alice>i have to fictionalize uh my brother doesn't want to ever be in my stand-up

02:26:33.049 --> 02:26:37.949
<v Alice>so how do we do that do we have him be part of the show do we recast him do

02:26:37.949 --> 02:26:40.989
<v Alice>we like all of that is that is the big challenge for me.

02:26:40.989 --> 02:26:45.029
<v Chas>I don't understand how you can be a stand-up comic and have a twin brother and

02:26:45.029 --> 02:26:48.909
<v Chas>not have them be part of your stand-up that must be one hell of a challenge.

02:26:48.909 --> 02:26:51.829
<v Alice>Well i i never talk about my uh

02:26:51.829 --> 02:26:57.429
<v Alice>private life which is weird because people assume that i talk about my private

02:26:57.429 --> 02:27:01.669
<v Alice>life because i talk about things that most people don't talk about i think of

02:27:01.669 --> 02:27:05.949
<v Alice>myself as an open book with some sealed sections so like i never I talk about

02:27:05.949 --> 02:27:10.089
<v Alice>my sexuality or my relationships or my, you know, that, that kind of thing.

02:27:10.846 --> 02:27:13.986
<v Stu>I mean, I think it's that illusion of intimacy is a really interesting concept,

02:27:13.986 --> 02:27:16.626
<v Stu>and that is kind of what we're doing as screenwriters, right?

02:27:16.706 --> 02:27:20.186
<v Stu>We're creating this illusion of intimacy with these characters,

02:27:20.386 --> 02:27:22.146
<v Stu>right? And all this stuff kind of alludes to it.

02:27:22.366 --> 02:27:26.986
<v Stu>People feel that they know Hannah, that they feel like they might know you,

02:27:27.106 --> 02:27:30.786
<v Stu>that they know Bo, you know, oh, he understands me, you know,

02:27:30.826 --> 02:27:31.606
<v Stu>and what we're going through.

02:27:31.606 --> 02:27:37.806
<v Stu>And then Daniel Kitson absolutely feels like he's just a mate telling you stories, you know, anecdotes.

02:27:37.966 --> 02:27:41.906
<v Stu>And it's that power of the anecdote, I guess, you know, that these really powerfully

02:27:41.906 --> 02:27:46.246
<v Stu>detailed vignettes give people access or this illusion of intimacy.

02:27:46.466 --> 02:27:49.026
<v Stu>And then you pull out wider and you can make those connections.

02:27:50.026 --> 02:27:53.446
<v Alice>Yes. And then you sort of say, oh, well, they are all true.

02:27:53.686 --> 02:27:56.586
<v Alice>But then some of them are not true. Some of them are embellished or they're,

02:27:56.606 --> 02:28:00.786
<v Alice>you know, they're all artistically true. They're all reaching for a deeper truth.

02:28:00.786 --> 02:28:04.246
<v Stu>Yeah, and I guess it's that creation of the shtick. It was something I brought

02:28:04.246 --> 02:28:08.346
<v Stu>up earlier, this idea that there's this kind of a level of a persona that's

02:28:08.346 --> 02:28:10.986
<v Stu>seemingly constructed that kind of presents the show.

02:28:11.066 --> 02:28:13.806
<v Stu>And look, that might be, I don't want to speak on behalf of your art,

02:28:13.946 --> 02:28:17.186
<v Stu>that is it a defense mechanism? Is it just a way of telling the story?

02:28:17.286 --> 02:28:20.986
<v Stu>But it feels like there is this construction of a persona that is leading us

02:28:20.986 --> 02:28:23.766
<v Stu>through the show on some extent.

02:28:24.326 --> 02:28:27.406
<v Stu>And how important, like, does that get changed per show?

02:28:27.486 --> 02:28:30.346
<v Stu>And is that something you have to be conscious of is if you're translating it

02:28:30.346 --> 02:28:35.546
<v Stu>to screen on both on the special in terms of the sitcom as well?

02:28:36.301 --> 02:28:42.581
<v Alice>Yes. So it's harder to do in the sitcom, to think of yourself as a character

02:28:42.581 --> 02:28:46.861
<v Alice>and to think of my younger self as a character is a little easier than thinking

02:28:46.861 --> 02:28:48.061
<v Alice>of my current self as a character.

02:28:48.181 --> 02:28:52.941
<v Alice>But thinking about the flaws of that person and the blind spots of that person

02:28:52.941 --> 02:28:54.941
<v Alice>and what makes them interesting.

02:28:54.941 --> 02:28:58.881
<v Alice>I'm not used to thinking of myself as interesting.

02:28:58.881 --> 02:29:03.741
<v Alice>I mean the way that I think about it often is that I am not a character in my

02:29:03.741 --> 02:29:08.441
<v Alice>stand-up I'm the observer and the audience sees through my eyes and that's not

02:29:08.441 --> 02:29:11.181
<v Alice>true of all stand-ups there's a lot of a lot of stand-ups that are like what

02:29:11.181 --> 02:29:15.221
<v Alice>am I like and that's their shtick that's their they're conscious of the persona

02:29:15.221 --> 02:29:17.801
<v Alice>that they are projecting I'd like to be as invisible as

02:29:18.081 --> 02:29:24.681
<v Alice>possible in the way that I tell stories I I kind of prefer that neutral narrator,

02:29:25.981 --> 02:29:29.881
<v Alice>character on stage, that you're coming with me and seeing things through my

02:29:29.881 --> 02:29:32.161
<v Alice>eyes rather than looking at me.

02:29:32.381 --> 02:29:36.001
<v Alice>That's the way that I think of it. And then, of course, there are incredible

02:29:36.001 --> 02:29:37.861
<v Alice>stand-ups when all they talk about is themselves.

02:29:38.001 --> 02:29:44.081
<v Alice>Ali Wong and Nanette both are telling stories about themselves as characters or actors in the world.

02:29:44.961 --> 02:29:50.441
<v Alice>And that is very effective in what they do. Daniel Kitson doesn't tell stories

02:29:50.441 --> 02:29:54.721
<v Alice>about himself as much, but he is very much a persona.

02:29:55.841 --> 02:29:58.981
<v Alice>So having that persona is telling a story about himself.

02:30:00.060 --> 02:30:05.180
<v Chas>And that's a lot, like, from a screenwriting perspective, there's a lot of stuff

02:30:05.180 --> 02:30:07.420
<v Chas>around voice of a screenwriter.

02:30:07.600 --> 02:30:12.720
<v Chas>So, you know, how much do you want to express the fact that a script has been

02:30:12.720 --> 02:30:15.240
<v Chas>written in the action lines?

02:30:15.380 --> 02:30:19.100
<v Chas>You know, so some, for some comedy scripts, they'll tell jokes in the action

02:30:19.100 --> 02:30:23.660
<v Chas>lines that the audience of the end movie or TV series will never experience.

02:30:23.860 --> 02:30:27.460
<v Chas>But it's, and also like your choice of words and your turn of phrase and all

02:30:27.460 --> 02:30:33.200
<v Chas>that kind of stuff. You can write from a persona when you are writing a screenplay as well.

02:30:35.360 --> 02:30:40.380
<v Chas>As always thanks to our amazing patreons who bring you more draft zero more

02:30:40.380 --> 02:30:47.840
<v Chas>often and in particular thanks to our awesomest of patreons randy beyond garrett

02:30:47.840 --> 02:30:54.220
<v Chas>jesse crobb sandra and tom you are all amazing thanks guys.

02:30:54.220 --> 02:30:58.060
<v Excerpts>I hope you all feel like arguing with either stew or myself about anything

02:30:58.160 --> 02:31:01.120
<v Excerpts>on this episode or anything in general and you can find many

02:31:01.120 --> 02:31:04.320
<v Excerpts>ways of getting in touch with us at our website at

02:31:04.320 --> 02:31:07.440
<v Excerpts>draft hyphen zero dot com at the

02:31:07.440 --> 02:31:10.400
<v Excerpts>website you'll also find the show notes for this and all our

02:31:10.400 --> 02:31:13.360
<v Excerpts>other episodes as well as links to support us

02:31:13.360 --> 02:31:18.580
<v Excerpts>and spread the word for free via a rating and review on apple podcasts very

02:31:18.580 --> 02:31:22.440
<v Excerpts>important for spreading the word or if you think that what we do here is worth

02:31:22.440 --> 02:31:27.180
<v Excerpts>a dollar or preferably more than a dollar then you can also find links to our

02:31:27.180 --> 02:31:32.240
<v Excerpts>Patreon page to support us getting these episodes to you quicker.

02:31:32.600 --> 02:31:35.500
<v Excerpts>Thanks. And thanks for listening.