1
00:00:00,085 --> 00:00:03,256
Open the pod bay doors, Hal. Welcome to
Primary Technology,

2
00:00:03,256 --> 00:00:04,857
the show about the tech news that matters.

3
00:00:04,857 --> 00:00:07,148
Big news this week, Google had its Pixel
event.

4
00:00:07,148 --> 00:00:08,999
We're gonna get into all the features that
they announced,

5
00:00:08,999 --> 00:00:12,020
the hardware. Mark Zuckerberg wrote an AI
manifesto,

6
00:00:12,020 --> 00:00:13,701
which sounded like a fever dream.

7
00:00:13,701 --> 00:00:16,792
We'll get into that. Claude is gonna
watermark its writing and you'll

8
00:00:16,792 --> 00:00:19,323
be able to tell whether text was actually
generated with AI.

9
00:00:19,323 --> 00:00:21,204
Spotify's trying to kill podcasts,

10
00:00:21,204 --> 00:00:22,985
YouTube made it harder to get monetized,

11
00:00:22,985 --> 00:00:26,676
and a ton more. This episode is brought to
you by Decagon and you,

12
00:00:26,676 --> 00:00:28,207
all of the members who support us
directly.

13
00:00:28,387 --> 00:00:29,539
I'm one of your host Stephen Robles,

14
00:00:29,539 --> 00:00:31,303
joined by my friend Jason Aten.

15
00:00:31,303 --> 00:00:32,303
How's it going, Jason?

16
00:00:32,299 --> 00:00:34,852
It's good because our our espresso maker
works again.

17
00:00:34,852 --> 00:00:36,069
So I'm f I'm

18
00:00:35,427 --> 00:00:36,427
Now listen,

19
00:00:36,069 --> 00:00:37,069
caffeinated.

20
00:00:37,011 --> 00:00:39,055
it always is a good day when you're
caffeinated.

21
00:00:39,055 --> 00:00:41,550
I'm pre caffeinated. I cold brew it up
before every show.

22
00:00:41,550 --> 00:00:42,893
That's how I'm able to come out the gate.

23
00:00:42,583 --> 00:00:43,583
That does

24
00:00:43,065 --> 00:00:44,390
not look like a cup of coffee,

25
00:00:44,390 --> 00:00:46,879
Steven. It looks like you're drinking

26
00:00:45,099 --> 00:00:46,840
Here's the thing. I don't want to.

27
00:00:46,879 --> 00:00:47,879
a smoothie there.

28
00:00:48,001 --> 00:00:51,392
This is gonna be I'm just anticipating

29
00:00:50,787 --> 00:00:51,787
Put it in a room.

30
00:00:51,392 --> 00:00:54,084
the YouTube. I listen, listen.

31
00:00:54,084 --> 00:00:57,125
We have the fancy ninja espresso maker.

32
00:00:57,125 --> 00:00:59,487
I love doing that. But in the morning,

33
00:00:59,487 --> 00:01:05,600
I drink cold brew because there's very
high I drink concentrated,

34
00:01:03,277 --> 00:01:04,277
Concentrated.

35
00:01:05,600 --> 00:01:06,600
non-diluted

36
00:01:06,481 --> 00:01:09,035
chameleon cold brew. You're supposed to
cut it with water.

37
00:01:09,035 --> 00:01:11,493
I don't cut it with anything. I cut it
with my mouth.

38
00:01:11,493 --> 00:01:14,415
All right. And I drink the chameleon cold
brew.

39
00:01:15,085 --> 00:01:18,716
Put some half and f in there. And I know
there's gonna be some comments about this.

40
00:01:18,716 --> 00:01:20,997
I'm just bracing myself for the YouTube
comments.

41
00:01:20,997 --> 00:01:25,579
I put protein powder in the cold brew and
I blend it up,

42
00:01:25,579 --> 00:01:28,841
and that is my breakfast. And it is the
breakfast of champions,

43
00:01:28,841 --> 00:01:32,002
Jason, because that I turn cold brew into
podcasts.

44
00:01:32,002 --> 00:01:34,283
That's literally what I do. Okay?

45
00:01:34,283 --> 00:01:38,154
And videos. But you know. I'm just I
listen.

46
00:01:38,154 --> 00:01:40,435
Whenever I say I put cold protein powder
in cold brew,

47
00:01:40,435 --> 00:01:42,646
people get upset. But listen, it works.

48
00:01:42,646 --> 00:01:44,487
It works for

49
00:01:43,145 --> 00:01:44,527
I mean, I didn't

50
00:01:44,527 --> 00:01:47,019
even know you went that far. So literally
you are drinking a smoothie.

51
00:01:47,019 --> 00:01:48,201
That's the thing.

52
00:01:47,631 --> 00:01:49,103
I mean kind of, kind

53
00:01:49,103 --> 00:01:50,934
of. You probably know the quote from
today.

54
00:01:50,934 --> 00:01:52,596
It's a movie I've seen.

55
00:01:51,766 --> 00:01:52,888
Yes. I I did

56
00:01:53,129 --> 00:01:55,384
just to be clear, I I knew where the movie
was from,

57
00:01:55,384 --> 00:01:58,060
but I looked it up because I feel like the
rest of the conversation is very good.

58
00:01:58,060 --> 00:01:59,814
But anyway, it's from ~ Space Odyssey,

59
00:01:59,814 --> 00:02:01,327
Stanley Kubrick, two thousand and one.

60
00:02:00,812 --> 00:02:02,303
That's that's exactly right.

61
00:02:01,327 --> 00:02:02,409
Yes.

62
00:02:02,924 --> 00:02:08,330
I saw that movie probably in my early
twenties and it felt like a trip.

63
00:02:08,330 --> 00:02:09,511
Like I don't even know what happened.

64
00:02:09,511 --> 00:02:10,793
I remember there's an obelisk.

65
00:02:10,793 --> 00:02:15,017
I know that the the computer traps in the
sh like there's just crazy stuff going

66
00:02:15,017 --> 00:02:16,017
on there. I need to watch it again,

67
00:02:15,958 --> 00:02:18,020
I think. Probably apropos in today's
world.

68
00:02:18,020 --> 00:02:19,020
And I need

69
00:02:18,294 --> 00:02:19,294
Yeah.

70
00:02:18,711 --> 00:02:19,711
to watch iRobot again.

71
00:02:20,219 --> 00:02:21,219
And Jurassic Park.

72
00:02:21,718 --> 00:02:24,239
Jurassic Park. Okay, we had some great
comments by the way.

73
00:02:24,239 --> 00:02:25,620
Everyone watching on YouTube, thanks for
that.

74
00:02:25,620 --> 00:02:29,051
People said Bending Spoons is the
velociraptor of tech companies,

75
00:02:29,051 --> 00:02:30,422
which is an excellent comment.

76
00:02:30,422 --> 00:02:32,532
Actually, correct. Hope you guys enjoyed
that.

77
00:02:32,532 --> 00:02:34,443
And we have a bunch of five star review
shout-outs to give.

78
00:02:34,443 --> 00:02:36,404
We're so close to five hundred reviews.

79
00:02:36,404 --> 00:02:39,305
Thank you for your help. Douglas Sanchez
from Brazil.

80
00:02:39,305 --> 00:02:41,396
We have several international listeners
and viewers.

81
00:02:41,396 --> 00:02:44,777
We actually a picture of our night in
another continent.

82
00:02:44,777 --> 00:02:48,229
We'll get to that. But he said Jason's
humor is hilarious and they make

83
00:02:48,229 --> 00:02:49,229
a fantastic team. Look at that,

84
00:02:49,209 --> 00:02:51,020
Jason. You got a lot of love in in this
week's

85
00:02:51,400 --> 00:02:55,491
Use. They even use your name. They didn't
even say the other guy.

86
00:02:51,414 --> 00:02:52,816
Yeah, they didn't they even use my name.

87
00:02:52,816 --> 00:02:54,239
They didn't say the other guy.

88
00:02:54,239 --> 00:02:55,841
This is

89
00:02:55,491 --> 00:02:56,491
We have to get

90
00:02:56,201 --> 00:02:58,992
the bring the joke back because the maybe
newer listeners don't know.

91
00:02:58,720 --> 00:03:00,141
This is how I know I've made it.

92
00:02:58,992 --> 00:03:01,733
That's it. That's

93
00:03:00,141 --> 00:03:01,190
I have a name.

94
00:03:01,733 --> 00:03:04,224
it. You have a name. So Far and So Bad
from the USA.

95
00:03:04,224 --> 00:03:05,404
Looks forward to each new episode.

96
00:03:05,404 --> 00:03:08,035
Jeff Woo ninety nine from the USA says
these guys great.

97
00:03:08,035 --> 00:03:10,926
Best tech podcast. I listened to Carpick
from India.

98
00:03:10,926 --> 00:03:13,717
Yes, I finally tried Raycast and he gave
us five stars for that.

99
00:03:13,717 --> 00:03:15,197
I have an entire video on Raycast.

100
00:03:15,197 --> 00:03:17,178
Do you what are you a spotlight guy?

101
00:03:17,178 --> 00:03:18,208
Do you have a special launcher?

102
00:03:18,249 --> 00:03:19,566
~ I use Alfred.

103
00:03:20,844 --> 00:03:22,800
Alright, well tune into the next Mac Power
users,

104
00:03:22,800 --> 00:03:24,425
okay, Jason? Cause me and David

105
00:03:23,658 --> 00:03:24,931
I'm not s I'm not switching.

106
00:03:25,289 --> 00:03:27,716
we go head to head. I got some thoughts,

107
00:03:27,716 --> 00:03:28,716
okay.

108
00:03:27,851 --> 00:03:28,851
It's just not

109
00:03:28,491 --> 00:03:30,582
it's not important enough to me to think
about switching.

110
00:03:30,582 --> 00:03:34,615
I do have ~ sh I do have Spotlight
assigned to a different hotkey so

111
00:03:34,615 --> 00:03:37,636
I can still pull it up because the new
version of Spotlight's better.

112
00:03:37,636 --> 00:03:40,708
I just Yeah, yeah, yeah,

113
00:03:38,178 --> 00:03:42,198
~ I mean better than before. Yeah.

114
00:03:40,708 --> 00:03:41,839
yeah, yeah. That's all I'm saying.

115
00:03:41,839 --> 00:03:42,839
It's better

116
00:03:42,209 --> 00:03:44,960
than before 'cause well, it's like
Spotlight was incredible,

117
00:03:44,960 --> 00:03:47,402
then it was useless, and now it's

118
00:03:47,011 --> 00:03:48,011
Sure.

119
00:03:47,402 --> 00:03:48,402
like fine.

120
00:03:48,332 --> 00:03:49,812
Well, and here's here's my thing.

121
00:03:49,812 --> 00:03:54,135
Spotlight was ~ meh. And then in macOS 26,

122
00:03:54,135 --> 00:03:55,715
it's really good. Clipboard history,

123
00:03:55,715 --> 00:03:58,097
file search, quick keys, all very good.

124
00:03:58,097 --> 00:04:03,490
But the macOS 27 Spotlight, I feel like it
gets slower because you got Siri

125
00:04:03,490 --> 00:04:06,441
AI in there at the same time. And they're
always like whenever

126
00:04:06,441 --> 00:04:07,802
you type something into the new spotlight,

127
00:04:07,802 --> 00:04:10,883
Mac OS 27 or on your iPhone, it's always
like fighting.

128
00:04:10,883 --> 00:04:13,445
Like, is this an AI thing? Is he just
trying to open an app?

129
00:04:13,445 --> 00:04:15,826
What are we doing here? And so I talk
about that.

130
00:04:16,256 --> 00:04:20,323
Yeah, I use Alfred and I'm probably not
ever gonna switch unless they stop making

131
00:04:20,323 --> 00:04:25,052
it and whatever because I use it thirty
nine thousand times a day and I just

132
00:04:24,546 --> 00:04:25,546
Yeah, yeah.

133
00:04:25,052 --> 00:04:27,387
cannot afford the mental overhead of
switching to something else.

134
00:04:27,628 --> 00:04:29,142
We're gonna talk about Alfred and

135
00:04:29,142 --> 00:04:30,876
launchers in the bonus episode today.

136
00:04:30,876 --> 00:04:33,232
It's it's been decided. It's now been
decided.

137
00:04:32,692 --> 00:04:34,076
Okay, good. I love

138
00:04:34,076 --> 00:04:36,884
when I can talk you into a bonus episode ~
topic.

139
00:04:35,916 --> 00:04:38,168
Perfect. Perfect. I one always comes one's
always comes up.

140
00:04:36,884 --> 00:04:38,669
Yes.

141
00:04:38,168 --> 00:04:39,366
~

142
00:04:39,369 --> 00:04:42,451
Chris from Washington said, I'm in the
camp of assigning apps

143
00:04:42,451 --> 00:04:45,203
to particular spaces and hope hopping
between them,

144
00:04:45,203 --> 00:04:47,154
whether I'm on a work machine or personal
machine.

145
00:04:47,154 --> 00:04:49,045
So yeah, I'd kind of do that too.

146
00:04:49,045 --> 00:04:51,817
I'm doing it right now. We talked about
spaces on macOS last week.

147
00:04:51,817 --> 00:04:57,361
Right now, I have my primary tech podcast
space where I have Notion,

148
00:04:57,361 --> 00:05:01,324
Riverside, Safari tab group with all the
links I'm going be sharing today,

149
00:05:01,324 --> 00:05:03,636
and a PDF of the sponsor read.

150
00:05:03,926 --> 00:05:05,436
That's my space. And then on the other
space,

151
00:05:05,436 --> 00:05:07,297
I got ~ work stuff. I got final code over
here.

152
00:05:07,297 --> 00:05:09,147
So yeah. You're still not a spaces guy,

153
00:05:09,147 --> 00:05:12,118
right? You haven't tried? Not open right
now,

154
00:05:09,452 --> 00:05:12,652
You have final cut right now? Okay.

155
00:05:12,118 --> 00:05:13,519
but usually that's open. No, no.

156
00:05:12,652 --> 00:05:16,385
Okay. That's the whole point of the dots.

157
00:05:13,519 --> 00:05:16,029
I quit I quit all that. I'm not a monster.

158
00:05:16,890 --> 00:05:18,530
Yeah, I know. I'm not a monster.

159
00:05:18,530 --> 00:05:21,551
essay Digital from the USA gave us six out
of five stars.

160
00:05:21,551 --> 00:05:24,262
Thank you for that. And podcast seven two
eight had a question.

161
00:05:24,262 --> 00:05:27,032
Do we listen to anything in the shower and
what books are we reading?

162
00:05:27,032 --> 00:05:28,113
A little little bit different.

163
00:05:28,113 --> 00:05:30,693
I will say rarely do I listen to something
in the shower,

164
00:05:30,693 --> 00:05:32,134
but when I do, it's a podcast.

165
00:05:32,134 --> 00:05:33,134
And

166
00:05:33,441 --> 00:05:38,854
What books are we reading? I actually just
started reading what is the book?

167
00:05:38,854 --> 00:05:42,333
I think it's a like a Seneca Stoicism
book.

168
00:05:42,333 --> 00:05:45,258
I forget what it's called on the Jason's
face.

169
00:05:45,258 --> 00:05:49,370
It just gave me a crazy look. there's that
and there was I forgot

170
00:05:49,370 --> 00:05:50,881
the books I're reading. I'll have to bring
them for next time.

171
00:05:50,881 --> 00:05:52,222
Are you reading anything, Jason?

172
00:05:52,502 --> 00:05:57,284
Well, I mean I do read I do read books.

173
00:05:57,284 --> 00:05:58,384
I don't read them in the shower.

174
00:05:58,384 --> 00:06:01,685
Just to be clear.

175
00:05:58,986 --> 00:06:00,931
No, no. Two different questions.

176
00:06:00,931 --> 00:06:02,164
Yeah.

177
00:06:01,685 --> 00:06:02,825
~

178
00:06:02,945 --> 00:06:04,606
I are you reading the Daily Stoic?

179
00:06:04,606 --> 00:06:06,006
Are you reading

180
00:06:04,959 --> 00:06:05,981
No no no no no.

181
00:06:06,006 --> 00:06:11,488
Let Letters from a Stoic? Meditations by
Marcus Aurelius.

182
00:06:08,064 --> 00:06:10,537
No, I already read Stillness is the Key.

183
00:06:10,537 --> 00:06:16,276
I've read some of that. There's I don't
know,

184
00:06:11,488 --> 00:06:15,820
Why do I know this many stoicism books?

185
00:06:15,820 --> 00:06:16,820
I can't figure it out.

186
00:06:16,276 --> 00:06:17,276
it's a it's

187
00:06:16,766 --> 00:06:21,784
a book it's the Seneca like life is short
but long if you know how to

188
00:06:21,784 --> 00:06:24,598
use it or whatever. Like whatever that
book is.

189
00:06:24,998 --> 00:06:26,829
That sounds a lot like Zuck's Manifesto.

190
00:06:26,829 --> 00:06:29,922
We'll get to that later. ~ I listen to
podcasts sometimes in the shower.

191
00:06:29,922 --> 00:06:31,823
That's about it. I don't listen to music
in the shower.

192
00:06:31,296 --> 00:06:32,380
Right. Same.

193
00:06:31,823 --> 00:06:32,823
I just

194
00:06:32,404 --> 00:06:34,325
sometimes will listen to a podcast.

195
00:06:34,325 --> 00:06:38,669
~ It's kinda weird because I have a lot of
podcast listening time.

196
00:06:38,669 --> 00:06:40,160
I don't really have to do that in the
shower.

197
00:06:40,160 --> 00:06:43,523
Also, I can only do it in the shower if
there's like no one else around because
then

198
00:06:43,434 --> 00:06:46,076
Yeah. R

199
00:06:43,523 --> 00:06:44,954
they just think I'm talking to some dudes.

200
00:06:46,076 --> 00:06:49,839
Now if you were, yeah. ~ On the Shortness
of Life is the book,

201
00:06:49,839 --> 00:06:53,442
from Seneca. So just I actually want to
get the name there.

202
00:06:53,090 --> 00:06:54,090
Great. I

203
00:06:53,480 --> 00:06:57,145
and the last book I've read is I just it's
taken me a while because I have read

204
00:06:57,145 --> 00:06:59,537
it in spurts. I just finished Apple and
China,

205
00:06:59,537 --> 00:07:00,537
so

206
00:07:00,596 --> 00:07:02,667
there you go. Yeah, I'm in the middle of
that one still.

207
00:07:02,667 --> 00:07:05,629
And ~ my wife and I just finished The Body
Keeps the Score,

208
00:07:05,629 --> 00:07:08,380
which is a heavy book, but is is very
good.

209
00:07:08,380 --> 00:07:11,793
All right, I wanted to thank the pins have
made it to more places.

210
00:07:11,793 --> 00:07:16,555
Andre in South Africa sent me an this
incredible photo.

211
00:07:16,555 --> 00:07:19,917
It is the medieval night riding the polar
bear with Table Mountain

212
00:07:20,318 --> 00:07:22,199
in the background in Cape Town,

213
00:07:22,199 --> 00:07:26,661
South Africa. Amazing. The night is
traversing the globe.

214
00:07:26,661 --> 00:07:27,762
Super fun.

215
00:07:28,474 --> 00:07:33,855
And Steve sent me an email. He and ~ his
spouse went to the Tour de France

216
00:07:34,235 --> 00:07:37,076
and took the medieval knight on the polar
bear,

217
00:07:37,076 --> 00:07:40,897
has a picture of it outside a French Apple
store,

218
00:07:40,897 --> 00:07:42,387
and sent me a bunch of other pictures.

219
00:07:42,387 --> 00:07:44,418
And so very, very kind, very fun.

220
00:07:44,418 --> 00:07:45,918
We're all over the world, Jason.

221
00:07:45,918 --> 00:07:47,719
The knight is making

222
00:07:47,617 --> 00:07:48,617
I love it.

223
00:07:47,719 --> 00:07:48,719
it.

224
00:07:48,299 --> 00:07:51,119
Yeah, it's very cool. on one funny post I
want to say,

225
00:07:51,119 --> 00:07:54,920
you know, we sometimes try to say hey
dingus to not activate everyone's voice

226
00:07:54,920 --> 00:07:57,901
assistance, and then we forget and we say
it a thousand times in an episode anyway.

227
00:07:58,293 --> 00:08:01,435
But Chipionic found a car that has a
license plate,

228
00:08:01,435 --> 00:08:03,360
a vanity license plate that says Dingus.

229
00:08:03,648 --> 00:08:04,648
How bad

230
00:08:04,019 --> 00:08:06,075
do you want to just drive up rolling on
your window and be like,

231
00:08:06,075 --> 00:08:07,075
hey dang us?

232
00:08:06,921 --> 00:08:07,921
Hey Dingus.

233
00:08:07,822 --> 00:08:10,203
That's the that was perfect. So yeah,

234
00:08:10,203 --> 00:08:11,203
that exists in the real world.

235
00:08:11,084 --> 00:08:12,705
All right. There's a ton of pixel news.

236
00:08:12,705 --> 00:08:17,338
Google's hardware, software. Is Alex
Cooper really gonna switch from an iPhone

237
00:08:17,338 --> 00:08:18,989
to an Android? I wanna talk about that.

238
00:08:18,989 --> 00:08:22,251
Because the Google the Made by Google
event was is quite a thing.

239
00:08:22,251 --> 00:08:25,613
So, but real quick, just want to plug
before we get into that.

240
00:08:25,613 --> 00:08:27,855
Apple Immersive is gonna get more content.

241
00:08:27,855 --> 00:08:31,337
MLB games, since we're basically a sports
ball podcast.

242
00:08:31,989 --> 00:08:35,013
Major League Baseball, Friday night
baseball is gonna have several games

243
00:08:35,013 --> 00:08:38,263
in Apple Immersive and while I don't you
know,

244
00:08:38,263 --> 00:08:42,202
I'm not a big sports guy, I am from New
York and I am a Yankees

245
00:08:42,343 --> 00:08:45,146
fan just because that's required if you
live in New York,

246
00:08:45,146 --> 00:08:47,209
unless you're a Mets fan, but nobody's
perfect.

247
00:08:47,209 --> 00:08:49,311
just kidding. I probably just made a bunch
of people mad.

248
00:08:49,311 --> 00:08:50,491
I'm so sorry. I don't know.

249
00:08:50,262 --> 00:08:51,262
Yeah,

250
00:08:50,606 --> 00:08:52,177
yeah, that's not the other guy.

251
00:08:52,177 --> 00:08:53,177
I just want to be clear.

252
00:08:53,089 --> 00:08:54,369
I don't know, it's not the other guy.

253
00:08:54,369 --> 00:08:58,070
But yeah, you'll be able to watch the
Yankees Red Sox game in Apple Vision

254
00:08:58,070 --> 00:08:59,951
Pro live as well as other games.

255
00:08:59,951 --> 00:09:04,782
I'm curious how this will go. Ben Thompson
was already upset without this even

256
00:09:04,782 --> 00:09:09,854
happening yet, because if you had watched
the NBA games in Apple Vision Pro,

257
00:09:09,854 --> 00:09:12,354
they switched the camera angle throughout
the game,

258
00:09:12,354 --> 00:09:14,595
and his argument is that could be jarring.

259
00:09:14,595 --> 00:09:17,436
Just stick me in one place as though I am
actually experiencing it,

260
00:09:17,436 --> 00:09:21,597
which I totally get. I watched an NBA game
in Apple Vision Pro as well.

261
00:09:21,597 --> 00:09:22,597
And

262
00:09:22,569 --> 00:09:25,356
I'm curious how they do it. Are they going
to be switching you all over the park?

263
00:09:25,356 --> 00:09:27,361
Are you going to able to choose a seat?

264
00:09:27,361 --> 00:09:29,669
Probably not, but yeah. I don't know.

265
00:09:29,669 --> 00:09:30,669
I'm going to I'm going to watch it.

266
00:09:30,590 --> 00:09:31,773
I'm going to put on Vision Pro to watch
it.

267
00:09:32,115 --> 00:09:33,716
I wanna just say and I don't I mean,

268
00:09:33,716 --> 00:09:35,678
he's probably right as often as he's not,

269
00:09:35,678 --> 00:09:38,120
but Ben Thompson is a hundred percent
right on this.

270
00:09:38,120 --> 00:09:40,963
Apple has no idea what they're doing with
this.

271
00:09:40,963 --> 00:09:45,037
It's such a stupid idea. They're gonna
have bespoke commentators.

272
00:09:45,037 --> 00:09:46,448
~ you just listen,

273
00:09:45,504 --> 00:09:46,504
Yeah, that's not good.

274
00:09:46,448 --> 00:09:48,312
go l subscribe to Dithering and just
listen to it.

275
00:09:48,312 --> 00:09:49,450
I don't have to get into the whole thing.

276
00:09:49,450 --> 00:09:50,450
But the

277
00:09:49,537 --> 00:09:50,537
Yeah, yeah.

278
00:09:49,981 --> 00:09:54,215
point is you have the most incredible way
to feel like you're actually at the game,

279
00:09:54,215 --> 00:09:57,758
but they're treating it like it's a two D
broadcast and they're gonna just

280
00:09:57,268 --> 00:09:58,268
Right.

281
00:09:58,078 --> 00:10:00,630
And then you're gonna just move you all
over where you should just get to

282
00:10:00,630 --> 00:10:02,981
be able to pick a spot. It it should be
like theater.

283
00:10:02,005 --> 00:10:03,863
Right. Yes.

284
00:10:02,981 --> 00:10:04,312
Isn't that Lystigoris?

285
00:10:04,312 --> 00:10:06,804
Where you can choose where you wanna be
sitting in the theater.

286
00:10:06,227 --> 00:10:09,405
Yes, exactly. Yeah.

287
00:10:06,804 --> 00:10:09,415
You should just be able to choose where
you wanna be at at the game

288
00:10:09,415 --> 00:10:11,096
and you can just watch the whole game.

289
00:10:11,096 --> 00:10:12,417
And if you wanna have a replay,

290
00:10:12,417 --> 00:10:14,459
you just hit rewind and move to a
different seat.

291
00:10:14,459 --> 00:10:15,459
Like

292
00:10:14,953 --> 00:10:15,953
Yeah.

293
00:10:15,709 --> 00:10:16,709
this is so simple.

294
00:10:16,935 --> 00:10:20,838
And I would I long thought, and I actually
sent the team,

295
00:10:20,838 --> 00:10:22,679
I think, this suggestion or whatever,

296
00:10:22,679 --> 00:10:26,082
like orchestra concerts, musicals,

297
00:10:26,082 --> 00:10:31,737
whatever. If you if they had a deal with
some venue or a number of venues where

298
00:10:31,737 --> 00:10:34,609
you could buy a ticket to watch an event
live,

299
00:10:34,609 --> 00:10:37,521
whether it's you know, a pop music type
concert,

300
00:10:37,521 --> 00:10:39,473
if it's actually a stage musical,

301
00:10:39,473 --> 00:10:44,577
rock concert, whatever, and you just get
the center seat.

302
00:10:45,161 --> 00:10:49,293
A little ways back and you can experience
the concert right there,

303
00:10:49,293 --> 00:10:53,505
live, with the live crowd around you and
hearing everything that's going on.

304
00:10:53,505 --> 00:10:56,556
I feel like that would be a particular
selling point.

305
00:10:56,556 --> 00:10:59,627
One, people just can't get out to events
like that.

306
00:10:59,627 --> 00:11:06,060
Artists like I follow ~ Leve because sh ~
my oldest son really likes

307
00:11:06,060 --> 00:11:08,371
her as an artist. I like her music as
well.

308
00:11:08,371 --> 00:11:12,353
She's like a jazz artist. But she doesn't
come to the US super often to tour.

309
00:11:12,921 --> 00:11:15,063
And she's only been here like once in the
last couple of years.

310
00:11:15,063 --> 00:11:16,204
And like that would be an artist for like,

311
00:11:16,204 --> 00:11:18,546
man, it would be awesome if I could
experience a live concert.

312
00:11:18,546 --> 00:11:22,260
My son could experience one in Apple
Vision Pro because you can do that.

313
00:11:22,260 --> 00:11:23,311
It doesn't matter where she was.

314
00:11:23,311 --> 00:11:24,812
You just stick one of the immersive
cameras.

315
00:11:24,812 --> 00:11:27,915
And you just need one then. And I feel
like you'd be able to multiply your
efforts

316
00:11:28,035 --> 00:11:32,469
by just putting one immersive camera in a
venue where you can buy that seat

317
00:11:32,469 --> 00:11:34,511
as if you're there. Because when you're
actually at an event,

318
00:11:34,511 --> 00:11:35,822
you just have that one perspective.

319
00:11:35,822 --> 00:11:37,514
You can't move around. Just do that.

320
00:11:37,514 --> 00:11:38,514
So I don't know.

321
00:11:38,240 --> 00:11:39,240
Yeah,

322
00:11:38,450 --> 00:11:41,648
if only there was like an international
monopoly where you could make a deal

323
00:11:41,648 --> 00:11:44,245
to put these cameras in every single venue
in America.

324
00:11:45,068 --> 00:11:47,205
See, the joke there is Ticketmaster

325
00:11:47,221 --> 00:11:49,413
Right. Live Nation is literally that.

326
00:11:49,413 --> 00:11:50,604
Just I guarantee

327
00:11:50,116 --> 00:11:51,116
That monopoly.

328
00:11:50,604 --> 00:11:53,796
you Apple could get a deal done with Live
Nation and

329
00:11:53,376 --> 00:11:54,376
Yes.

330
00:11:53,796 --> 00:11:55,688
just be like, here's the d well we're
gonna do this,

331
00:11:55,688 --> 00:11:57,459
we'll cut it. We'll cut you guys in.

332
00:11:57,459 --> 00:12:01,292
We'll just like you know, we'll just give
you a cut of every time someone uses this

333
00:12:01,292 --> 00:12:04,815
app. It's like I this is they're thinking

334
00:12:04,213 --> 00:12:05,213
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

335
00:12:04,815 --> 00:12:06,326
of it like T V. It's not T V.

336
00:12:06,815 --> 00:12:08,516
Right, exactly. We should we should be on
the team.

337
00:12:08,516 --> 00:12:11,207
They should do a brain trust and we'll c
we'll come out there.

338
00:12:11,207 --> 00:12:13,576
We'll come out and yeah, we'll talk about
it.

339
00:12:13,576 --> 00:12:17,229
All right. The Pixel Eleven event was last
night.

340
00:12:17,229 --> 00:12:22,021
Odd time for a live keynote, but also all
the YouTube videos came out earlier

341
00:12:22,021 --> 00:12:24,312
in the day, like Mr. Who's the Boss,

342
00:12:24,312 --> 00:12:28,754
MKBHD, a bunch of creators, Brian Tong all
posted videos about the Pixel Eleven

343
00:12:28,754 --> 00:12:33,336
and the entire lineup. And then there was
the live keynote at six PM Eastern

344
00:12:33,656 --> 00:12:36,297
on a Wednesday, hosted by Trevor Noah.

345
00:12:36,907 --> 00:12:40,438
Which was interesting. We'll get into
that.

346
00:12:40,438 --> 00:12:43,920
On the face of it, the hardware,

347
00:12:43,920 --> 00:12:45,641
I don't think, is the biggest story.

348
00:12:45,641 --> 00:12:47,801
You know, there's a new Tensor G6 chip.

349
00:12:47,801 --> 00:12:51,683
The camera hardware is a little better on
the Pixel 1111 Pro.

350
00:12:51,683 --> 00:12:54,024
They are more expensive, $100 more,

351
00:12:54,024 --> 00:12:56,005
but the base storage is now $256.

352
00:12:56,005 --> 00:13:00,907
Ramagedin. The 11 Pro now starts at 12
gigs of RAM instead of 16.

353
00:13:00,907 --> 00:13:03,728
So there's a bunch of like little hardware
updates and improvements.

354
00:13:03,728 --> 00:13:06,439
The fold is out there, slightly improved.

355
00:13:06,899 --> 00:13:11,980
Still thick, but there's a lot of software
things that I think

356
00:13:11,980 --> 00:13:16,112
are pretty interesting. Google's taking
some shots at Whisper Flow

357
00:13:16,552 --> 00:13:18,932
and doing some interesting software things
with the camera.

358
00:13:18,932 --> 00:13:22,093
There is one hardware thing that Joanna
Stern was very excited about,

359
00:13:22,093 --> 00:13:25,414
which is the light on the back of the
Pixel phones.

360
00:13:25,414 --> 00:13:28,065
There's now a BlackBerry

361
00:13:25,516 --> 00:13:26,516
Blackberry light.

362
00:13:28,065 --> 00:13:31,856
light where it's a notification light in
the camera bar.

363
00:13:31,856 --> 00:13:33,937
There's multiple colored LEDs,

364
00:13:33,937 --> 00:13:35,417
so this is not just like a solid

365
00:13:36,065 --> 00:13:39,627
Color flash. This is like actually
different colors that can meld

366
00:13:39,627 --> 00:13:45,421
and do animations kind of. But it can only
tell you when one of your favorites

367
00:13:45,421 --> 00:13:50,054
are calling and when Gemini is doing stuff
on the phone.

368
00:13:50,054 --> 00:13:53,656
Which if you've asked Gemini to do stuff
on the phone,

369
00:13:53,656 --> 00:13:55,017
you're probably looking at the screen,

370
00:13:55,017 --> 00:14:00,331
just you know, figure. And for when your
favorites call,

371
00:14:00,331 --> 00:14:03,723
that's interesting, but I think it would
probably be more beneficial

372
00:14:03,723 --> 00:14:05,624
if you could tell it when they text you.

373
00:14:06,066 --> 00:14:10,100
Or customize what apps like will light up
this thing.

374
00:14:10,100 --> 00:14:13,824
It's called the highlight L E D H I L I G
H T.

375
00:14:13,824 --> 00:14:17,758
I don't know. You can also make a shortcut
that just flashes the flashlight when

376
00:14:17,758 --> 00:14:21,614
you get a call. So that's I'm sorry,

377
00:14:19,678 --> 00:14:21,828
Well, actually isn't that an accessibility
feature?

378
00:14:21,614 --> 00:14:24,635
it's an it's an accessibility feature
because it's not a shortcut's automation
for

379
00:14:21,828 --> 00:14:23,356
Okay.

380
00:14:24,635 --> 00:14:27,577
calls, unfortunately, but it is a
accessibility feature.

381
00:14:27,577 --> 00:14:29,460
You could just have it flash your
flashlight,

382
00:14:29,460 --> 00:14:30,460
but

383
00:14:29,610 --> 00:14:30,610
Right,

384
00:14:29,890 --> 00:14:32,273
because there are a lot of people who
that's the only way they would know that
their

385
00:14:32,273 --> 00:14:34,755
phone is ringing. So that makes a lot of
sense.

386
00:14:33,266 --> 00:14:35,558
Yeah, a hundred percent. Yeah.

387
00:14:34,755 --> 00:14:35,755
So yeah, I

388
00:14:35,666 --> 00:14:37,177
d it is kind of a weird restriction.

389
00:14:37,177 --> 00:14:39,775
It seems like I mean, I don't want this.

390
00:14:39,775 --> 00:14:42,563
I don't want my phone to flash at me when
anything's happening.

391
00:14:42,563 --> 00:14:43,894
I turn most notifications off.

392
00:14:43,894 --> 00:14:46,737
I just don't just like I don't even want
to know people are trying to get

393
00:14:46,737 --> 00:14:49,990
a hold of me. But if I did, it would be
kinda cool just to be able to

394
00:14:49,990 --> 00:14:53,551
see that that is you know the the reason I
hated Blackberry is that

395
00:14:53,551 --> 00:14:54,551
the light just never went.

396
00:14:55,422 --> 00:14:57,811
I always had emails, I always had
notifications.

397
00:14:55,493 --> 00:14:57,172
Right, which is on all the time.

398
00:14:57,172 --> 00:14:58,886
I yeah.

399
00:14:57,811 --> 00:14:59,126
But I do think it should

400
00:14:59,126 --> 00:15:00,522
you should be able to decide what it's
for.

401
00:15:01,158 --> 00:15:04,670
Yeah, exactly. So and they s Google says
they're working on more customizations.

402
00:15:04,670 --> 00:15:07,572
But there's a couple of software things
that I want to focus on.

403
00:15:07,572 --> 00:15:10,114
This first one is called Rambler.

404
00:15:10,114 --> 00:15:13,036
And so this was a segment, this is Trevor
Noah,

405
00:15:13,036 --> 00:15:17,699
and he was using this feature and it's now
going to be built into the Pixel phones.

406
00:15:17,699 --> 00:15:21,962
It is dictation, but it's like dictation
supercharged.

407
00:15:21,962 --> 00:15:27,006
And I've actually been using WhisperFlow a
little more on my Mac,

408
00:15:27,006 --> 00:15:30,408
especially as I've been doing the whole
can do vibe coding.

409
00:15:30,751 --> 00:15:33,383
Because when I have a long thing I want to
tell an LLM to do,

410
00:15:33,383 --> 00:15:37,185
it's just easier to just talk it rather
than type it all,

411
00:15:37,185 --> 00:15:38,366
you know, when there's a lot of things.

412
00:15:38,366 --> 00:15:44,450
And Whisperflow is really good because you
can correct yourself mid-dictation.

413
00:15:44,450 --> 00:15:47,672
You can say, no, actually, I meant this.

414
00:15:47,672 --> 00:15:52,455
And it understands all of those little
quirks in your speech and provides

415
00:15:52,455 --> 00:15:56,678
a very clean message or transcription when
you're ready to send.

416
00:15:56,678 --> 00:16:00,260
Now, the annoyance with whisperflow on
iPhone is.

417
00:16:00,510 --> 00:16:03,581
Is that you have to switch to a
third-party keyboard in order for it

418
00:16:03,581 --> 00:16:08,212
to have that full functionality of pasting
what you just dictated and being able

419
00:16:08,212 --> 00:16:11,363
to turn it on. There's a weird action
button shortcut workaround,

420
00:16:11,363 --> 00:16:13,724
but it's just nowhere near as convenient
as on the Mac.

421
00:16:13,724 --> 00:16:18,305
And Pixel is saying we're gonna build this
just right into our phone.

422
00:16:18,305 --> 00:16:21,266
And so this Rambler feature is basically
that.

423
00:16:21,266 --> 00:16:25,827
It is the Whisperflow style transcription
that is very accurate,

424
00:16:25,827 --> 00:16:29,278
but also smart enough to know when you've
corrected yourself or you say,

425
00:16:29,278 --> 00:16:30,278
actually say this.

426
00:16:30,656 --> 00:16:33,447
Trevor No did a demo and it's it did
exactly what you would expect.

427
00:16:33,447 --> 00:16:35,937
Like correcting himself, changing what
he's saying.

428
00:16:35,937 --> 00:16:39,238
Bottom line, I want this on iPhone.

429
00:16:39,238 --> 00:16:42,529
And I know we're not going to get it
because Apple just improved

430
00:16:42,529 --> 00:16:45,540
the ejectation and all it did was just get
slightly more accurate.

431
00:16:45,540 --> 00:16:50,101
But it is nowhere near the Whisper Flow
self-correction type transcription.

432
00:16:50,101 --> 00:16:53,903
And this is a feature. I would not switch
to a Pixel for this,

433
00:16:53,903 --> 00:16:56,883
but man, I so want this. Or let Apple.

434
00:16:56,883 --> 00:16:59,044
I don't know if

435
00:16:59,156 --> 00:17:04,421
Figure out a way where it can do a third
party dictation service like Whisper
rather

436
00:17:04,421 --> 00:17:05,652
than have to use the built in one.

437
00:17:05,652 --> 00:17:07,364
So I want this feature. That's all.

438
00:17:07,936 --> 00:17:12,718
Yeah, I mean, we are getting to a point
where people just are talking it's weird.

439
00:17:12,718 --> 00:17:15,809
Like we're g we talk at our phones but no
one's there listening.

440
00:17:15,809 --> 00:17:17,310
Like we used to talk at our phones all the
time.

441
00:17:17,310 --> 00:17:18,310
That was the whole point

442
00:17:17,504 --> 00:17:18,504
Sure, sure.

443
00:17:18,220 --> 00:17:20,741
of having a phone, but now people are just
talking at it so you don't have

444
00:17:20,741 --> 00:17:22,572
to talk at someone. It's like just

445
00:17:21,842 --> 00:17:22,842
Yeah, exactly.

446
00:17:22,572 --> 00:17:25,283
take these words, turn into text so I can
send the text somewhere,

447
00:17:25,283 --> 00:17:28,175
whether that's to a human or a robot.

448
00:17:28,175 --> 00:17:32,096
That's fine. I I I don't find like on the
iPhone,

449
00:17:32,096 --> 00:17:36,268
I just use dictation and it's generally
fine for what I'm doing.

450
00:17:35,752 --> 00:17:36,752
It's fine.

451
00:17:36,309 --> 00:17:37,309
Yeah, it's fine.

452
00:17:36,993 --> 00:17:37,993
I

453
00:17:37,093 --> 00:17:40,786
don't know that it's great, but I do feel
like it's mostly fine.

454
00:17:40,786 --> 00:17:43,068
I used and on the Mac I used the
dictation.

455
00:17:43,068 --> 00:17:46,111
I think we talked about this when I had a
problem with like my wrist

456
00:17:46,111 --> 00:17:48,353
and it's like that's a problem 'cause I'm
a writer so I type all day

457
00:17:48,353 --> 00:17:53,077
and I just spent a week having to talk to
my computer and it was fine.

458
00:17:53,077 --> 00:17:56,700
What was it that made you think I need a
third party app to do this?

459
00:17:56,700 --> 00:17:59,042
Like you're doing it that much or?

460
00:17:59,600 --> 00:18:03,601
Well, David Sparks, I mean, just talked it
up so much.

461
00:18:03,601 --> 00:18:08,462
And when it comes to how I've been
prompting Claude for things on my app,

462
00:18:08,462 --> 00:18:12,684
there'll be times where I like I have a
bunch of bullets in a bear note

463
00:18:13,184 --> 00:18:16,705
of changes and bug fixes that people have
reported and they're

464
00:18:16,705 --> 00:18:19,745
not formatted enough where I can just copy
and paste that list into Claude

465
00:18:19,745 --> 00:18:23,406
and say go because there it's lacking some
clarity and context.

466
00:18:23,406 --> 00:18:27,007
And so what I will do is I'll look at that
bulleted list and think to myself,

467
00:18:27,007 --> 00:18:29,048
I could type this all out.

468
00:18:29,722 --> 00:18:33,593
And be more specific, or I could just hold
a key on my keyboard,

469
00:18:33,593 --> 00:18:38,535
talk through these bullet points in a
messy way that's not super precise.

470
00:18:38,535 --> 00:18:42,656
And Whisperflow not only dictates but
cleans it up for me in a way that

471
00:18:42,656 --> 00:18:44,856
I can just hit return and send it to
Claude.

472
00:18:44,856 --> 00:18:48,717
And so that use case has been nice.

473
00:18:48,717 --> 00:18:53,479
And we're gonna get to Claude actually
watermarking text that

474
00:18:53,479 --> 00:18:57,610
it generates and what I feel a little
weird about that.

475
00:18:58,320 --> 00:19:02,573
in because of how I use it. And so I might
start doing it even more because

476
00:19:02,573 --> 00:19:04,438
I want it to be my words and not Claude's.

477
00:19:04,438 --> 00:19:06,303
So for those reasons.

478
00:19:06,826 --> 00:19:09,380
Yeah. Do you think that this is a feature
that's gonna convince people

479
00:19:09,380 --> 00:19:11,394
to buy pixels? Okay.

480
00:19:10,438 --> 00:19:11,438
No, not at all. No one's gonna buy

481
00:19:11,398 --> 00:19:15,212
a pick. I mean, listen, Google stacks this
event with celebrities.

482
00:19:15,212 --> 00:19:16,613
I mean, Stephen Curry's in this,

483
00:19:16,613 --> 00:19:19,956
Trevor Noah's hosting it, Alex Cooper from
Caller Daddy.

484
00:19:19,956 --> 00:19:21,797
I'm gonna about to talk about her segment.

485
00:19:21,797 --> 00:19:26,670
And like, it's hilarious how much juice
Google tries to like put into this Pixel

486
00:19:26,670 --> 00:19:29,684
event, but everyone just still buys the
Samsung Galaxy S26.

487
00:19:29,684 --> 00:19:32,036
So it's like, I don't know. I mean,

488
00:19:32,036 --> 00:19:35,248
they're great, it's great hardware and
they're really interesting features.

489
00:19:35,248 --> 00:19:37,990
I'm gonna talk about all the camera stuff
and the creator suite in a minute,

490
00:19:37,990 --> 00:19:39,770
but yeah, no one's gonna buy a Pixel
because of that.

491
00:19:39,904 --> 00:19:40,904
Yes.

492
00:19:41,387 --> 00:19:42,387
Yeah.

493
00:19:41,707 --> 00:19:44,369
I don't know. I mean, it's in some ways
the same thing,

494
00:19:44,369 --> 00:19:47,831
like Microsoft makes Surface stuff and
they're good laptops.

495
00:19:47,831 --> 00:19:49,793
Google makes very good phones.

496
00:19:49,793 --> 00:19:51,574
It's just not a lot of people buy them,

497
00:19:51,574 --> 00:19:54,576
but they're sort of just putting these
things out there because what's really

498
00:19:54,576 --> 00:19:56,837
important to them is that Android exists.

499
00:19:57,778 --> 00:19:59,509
Right. And it's Google's like,

500
00:19:59,509 --> 00:20:03,291
hey, here's what an ideal Android phone
with Gemini and that's the other thing

501
00:20:03,291 --> 00:20:05,342
is they increase Gemini intelligence.

502
00:20:05,342 --> 00:20:07,413
It works with more apps, a bunch of apps
you never heard of,

503
00:20:07,413 --> 00:20:09,955
plus Zoc Doc and ~ Open Table.

504
00:20:09,955 --> 00:20:12,866
you know, so they're they build those
features in first so they can show

505
00:20:12,866 --> 00:20:14,557
you what's possible. But again,

506
00:20:14,557 --> 00:20:17,139
I don't think people are going to switch
to use it.

507
00:20:17,139 --> 00:20:21,531
But speaking of switching, there was this
entire segment of the Made

508
00:20:21,531 --> 00:20:24,913
by Google event where Alex Cooper goes on
stage and she talks

509
00:20:24,913 --> 00:20:26,804
to somebody from Google and they

510
00:20:27,210 --> 00:20:32,284
Talk about how easy it is to switch to an
Android phone from an iPhone

511
00:20:32,665 --> 00:20:35,437
and how Google worked with Apple earlier,

512
00:20:35,437 --> 00:20:38,930
like throughout this year. So when you
transfer your stuff,

513
00:20:38,930 --> 00:20:41,192
not only it brings your pictures,

514
00:20:41,192 --> 00:20:45,195
it also ~ get brings your passwords over
from Apple Passwords.

515
00:20:45,195 --> 00:20:47,697
And that switching is super easy.

516
00:20:47,697 --> 00:20:49,829
Alex Cooper even asked the guy,

517
00:20:49,829 --> 00:20:52,121
like, So are my group texts gonna be good?

518
00:20:52,121 --> 00:20:54,623
And he was like, Your group texts are
gonna be great.

519
00:20:54,623 --> 00:20:55,623
And it's like, well.

520
00:20:56,432 --> 00:20:59,273
Yes, RCS has gotten way better.

521
00:20:59,273 --> 00:21:03,255
Group techs are better. Still not the same
as iMessage,

522
00:21:03,255 --> 00:21:05,796
but fine. And I just wanted to mention
this segment.

523
00:21:05,796 --> 00:21:08,037
One, Alex Cooper has a very popular
podcast,

524
00:21:08,037 --> 00:21:12,279
Caller Daddy. And so let's check after the
iPhone 18 launch,

525
00:21:12,279 --> 00:21:15,600
a couple weeks after that, what phone is
Alex Cooper using.

526
00:21:15,600 --> 00:21:18,581
That's all I'm saying. I'm saying this is
all fine.

527
00:21:18,581 --> 00:21:22,517
Great. Switching is now easy. Let's see
what happens when the rubber meets the
road.

528
00:21:22,517 --> 00:21:25,374
Because one of the my favorite parts of
old Twitter.

529
00:21:25,940 --> 00:21:31,012
was when someone would make a deal with
Samsung or whoever and talk about

530
00:21:31,012 --> 00:21:37,324
how great the new phone Android phone is
and then like Oprah and then someone looks

531
00:21:37,324 --> 00:21:41,326
at a tweet that they post and it says sent
from iPhone and everybody would just call

532
00:21:41,326 --> 00:21:43,347
that out. Which you don't have that
anymore,

533
00:21:43,347 --> 00:21:46,288
the like the Twitter posted from this
thing.

534
00:21:46,288 --> 00:21:49,269
But when you have a big video podcast like
Alex Cooper,

535
00:21:49,269 --> 00:21:51,390
I'm sure she's gonna hold her phone at
some point.

536
00:21:51,390 --> 00:21:53,070
Let's just all see. I'm just curious.

537
00:21:53,070 --> 00:21:54,301
Let's see. Is it gonna be a pixel?

538
00:21:54,653 --> 00:21:57,005
Or is it gonna be the iPhone eighteen when
that comes out,

539
00:21:57,005 --> 00:21:59,090
~ later Sept late September? So we'll see.

540
00:21:59,090 --> 00:22:00,090
That's all.

541
00:21:59,778 --> 00:22:03,844
To be clear, I think it was actually
Samsung's account that posted something
that

542
00:22:03,844 --> 00:22:07,549
said sent from iPhone. But I also think

543
00:22:05,425 --> 00:22:07,354
Okay, very good. Very good.

544
00:22:07,549 --> 00:22:10,414
that it was like I've El at one point I'm
pretty sure Alicia Keys

545
00:22:10,414 --> 00:22:13,078
was like the creative director for Samsung
and then people like spotted

546
00:22:12,115 --> 00:22:13,115
Yes.

547
00:22:13,078 --> 00:22:14,740
her using an iPhone or something like
that.

548
00:22:14,740 --> 00:22:15,740
So yeah.

549
00:22:15,239 --> 00:22:16,239
It was that and

550
00:22:16,190 --> 00:22:19,516
I r I do think ~ Oprah was one because she
like talked about it

551
00:22:19,516 --> 00:22:21,729
and something and then she tweeted it
whatever was from her iPhone.

552
00:22:21,729 --> 00:22:25,014
There was a bunch of cases, like if you
just Google celebrities that yeah,

553
00:22:25,014 --> 00:22:26,014
anyway.

554
00:22:25,558 --> 00:22:28,881
To be fair, the switching thing is
actually really cool that the Apple

555
00:22:28,521 --> 00:22:30,330
Sure. Yeah.

556
00:22:28,881 --> 00:22:30,377
and Google work together. This

557
00:22:30,377 --> 00:22:31,722
was but it

558
00:22:32,074 --> 00:22:35,495
It's also very self serving. It's like d
we're not a we're a duopoly.

559
00:22:35,495 --> 00:22:37,616
We're not monopolies. Just be clear,

560
00:22:37,616 --> 00:22:38,777
we are not monopolies.

561
00:22:37,927 --> 00:22:38,927
Right.

562
00:22:38,777 --> 00:22:41,018
See, you can easily go back and forth
between the two.

563
00:22:41,018 --> 00:22:43,809
You can't go to anything else because
nothing else exists because we have

564
00:22:43,809 --> 00:22:46,200
the entire market, but we're not a
monopoly.

565
00:22:46,200 --> 00:22:49,331
But it is nice. I've used it obviously
some people like us,

566
00:22:49,331 --> 00:22:54,063
and by people like us, I just mean weirdos
who change phones all the time.

567
00:22:54,063 --> 00:22:55,254
I don't there's

568
00:22:54,345 --> 00:22:55,345
Sure, sure.

569
00:22:55,254 --> 00:22:59,465
nothing special about us. It's just often
I'm carrying multiple devices and

570
00:22:59,113 --> 00:23:00,113
Yeah.

571
00:22:59,666 --> 00:23:00,716
mo often that's

572
00:23:00,918 --> 00:23:03,500
couple times a year going back and forth
between an Android phone and

573
00:23:03,500 --> 00:23:06,382
a and it's very nice that I can just take
my main iPhone,

574
00:23:06,382 --> 00:23:12,606
put a selection of things on a Google f on
an Android device and use it with

575
00:23:12,606 --> 00:23:15,468
all of my information on it. That's super
helpful.

576
00:23:15,468 --> 00:23:19,411
I don't know how many people use this
because they're like,

577
00:23:19,411 --> 00:23:21,522
I've finally done it. I've given up the
iPhone.

578
00:23:21,522 --> 00:23:23,454
I'm going to Android or the other way
around.

579
00:23:24,500 --> 00:23:27,583
Yeah, I don't I mean you would use it once
and then probably

580
00:23:27,623 --> 00:23:29,555
not switch platforms again for a long
time,

581
00:23:29,555 --> 00:23:31,967
but yeah. I don't know. It's it's good
that it's there.

582
00:23:31,967 --> 00:23:36,551
I'm sure after like Apple did all this
work or whatever,

583
00:23:36,551 --> 00:23:40,195
Google also slides the invoice across the
table for Gemini powering Apple

584
00:23:40,195 --> 00:23:41,806
intelligence. It's like, yeah,

585
00:23:41,806 --> 00:23:43,117
by the way, don't forget to pay your bill.

586
00:23:43,117 --> 00:23:46,841
But you know, it's a it's a friendemyship.

587
00:23:46,841 --> 00:23:49,073
Frenemyship. Friendship

588
00:23:48,812 --> 00:23:49,812
They're

589
00:23:49,163 --> 00:23:51,197
they're even better of best of frenemies.

590
00:23:51,197 --> 00:23:52,860
Well that's open AI on Apple, but yeah.

591
00:23:53,245 --> 00:23:54,876
Well, I I think they're just straight
enemies now,

592
00:23:54,876 --> 00:23:56,758
Jason. I don't I don't know if there's any
friend of me.

593
00:23:56,704 --> 00:23:57,994
They need each other, Stephen.

594
00:23:56,758 --> 00:23:57,758
That

595
00:23:58,199 --> 00:23:59,470
that integration is going away,

596
00:23:59,470 --> 00:24:02,743
I'm sure. The open AI one. But so that's
that.

597
00:24:02,743 --> 00:24:04,644
A couple of things on the cameras.

598
00:24:04,644 --> 00:24:07,427
So the cameras have improved hardware in
the pixel devices,

599
00:24:07,427 --> 00:24:10,149
but some really cool software features.

600
00:24:10,149 --> 00:24:13,491
And they're really gearing towards
creators with a couple of them.

601
00:24:13,491 --> 00:24:19,797
One is called Magic Capture. And this is a
feature where in the demo

602
00:24:19,917 --> 00:24:22,577
it shows that you can just hold the Pixel
phone and

603
00:24:23,091 --> 00:24:25,603
And it's basically it looks like it's
capturing a video and has

604
00:24:25,603 --> 00:24:26,794
a couple basketball players doing it.

605
00:24:26,794 --> 00:24:32,199
And the Pixel is just going to choose
moments that are that would make great
photos

606
00:24:32,519 --> 00:24:38,844
and capture those photos. And this is not
the same as pulling still frames from

607
00:24:38,844 --> 00:24:42,257
a video. And in the demo, they zoom into
the photos to show like this

608
00:24:42,257 --> 00:24:45,369
is a high-quality photo. This is not just
a screen grab from a video.

609
00:24:45,369 --> 00:24:49,973
And you don't even like the person demoing
it wasn't even looking at the phone.

610
00:24:49,973 --> 00:24:51,735
Like you're just kind of holding it at
chest height.

611
00:24:52,137 --> 00:24:55,037
Kind of like how your parents or
grandparents hold something when they're
trying

612
00:24:55,037 --> 00:24:57,338
to like capture something in a in the
school,

613
00:24:57,338 --> 00:25:00,039
whatever. They're just kind of like
holding the phone randomly and pointing

614
00:25:00,039 --> 00:25:04,801
it in random directions. But the magic
capture will then just pull great photos
from

615
00:25:04,801 --> 00:25:07,891
moments it decides is really good and you
can decide which ones to keep.

616
00:25:07,891 --> 00:25:10,322
That's a cool feature built in.

617
00:25:10,322 --> 00:25:12,910
Again, it's software, not necessarily,

618
00:25:12,910 --> 00:25:14,733
I don't know if you need the latest
hardware to do it,

619
00:25:14,733 --> 00:25:19,135
but that's a cool feature. And then the
creator focused features,

620
00:25:19,135 --> 00:25:20,455
these are things that

621
00:25:20,618 --> 00:25:22,569
You know, I would love see on an iPhone
too.

622
00:25:22,569 --> 00:25:26,370
Things like you can have a teleprompter
right there while you're recording

623
00:25:26,370 --> 00:25:32,923
in the camera. It has social media safe
lines so you can see what how like frame

624
00:25:32,923 --> 00:25:35,474
it up for vertical video and horizontal.

625
00:25:35,474 --> 00:25:39,865
You can see like what is going when you
crop it to that vertical nine by sixteen,

626
00:25:39,865 --> 00:25:43,637
what it's gonna look like. These are nice
little features that are just added in.

627
00:25:43,637 --> 00:25:48,169
You know, I feel like many times Apple has
started down this path,

628
00:25:48,169 --> 00:25:49,309
like with the Clips app.

629
00:25:49,949 --> 00:25:53,350
And was like, we're gonna make an an app
where you can edit short form video,

630
00:25:53,350 --> 00:25:56,222
but it's gonna be square, and then we're
gonna forget about this app forever.

631
00:25:56,222 --> 00:26:01,594
And it's like if they had if Apple had
just pushed on that for a couple years

632
00:26:01,594 --> 00:26:05,726
and innovated, like that could have been a
useful creator tool.

633
00:26:05,726 --> 00:26:08,066
And Apple is doing some of that,

634
00:26:08,066 --> 00:26:11,828
like into Final Cut, they added the
ability to do captions and overlay it,

635
00:26:11,828 --> 00:26:13,309
but there's not a lot of style.

636
00:26:13,309 --> 00:26:18,161
So just credit to Google actually building
features that I think would help

637
00:26:18,161 --> 00:26:19,161
creators.

638
00:26:19,184 --> 00:26:20,659
If any of them use pixel phones,

639
00:26:20,659 --> 00:26:21,659
but I don't know if they do.

640
00:26:22,188 --> 00:26:27,560
Two things. One, I think like I always
feel very weird,

641
00:26:27,560 --> 00:26:30,020
especially when Google releases camera
features,

642
00:26:30,020 --> 00:26:33,621
because I'm like I don't want to get into
the like what's a photo thing.

643
00:26:33,621 --> 00:26:35,802
But it's like y okay.

644
00:26:34,451 --> 00:26:35,961
We'll we'll touch on that. We'll touch on
that.

645
00:26:36,602 --> 00:26:40,703
But I also think the reality is they just
know how most normal people

646
00:26:41,524 --> 00:26:43,154
how many terrible photos they take.

647
00:26:43,154 --> 00:26:45,995
And st I don't know, have you ever I'm
sure you've had this experience,

648
00:26:45,995 --> 00:26:49,056
but like people will send you photos and
you're like how

649
00:26:49,416 --> 00:26:52,247
How is it possible you took such a
terrible photo of this moment?

650
00:26:52,247 --> 00:26:54,538
Like, do you n do you not

651
00:26:52,568 --> 00:26:53,895
W were you running away?

652
00:26:54,538 --> 00:26:56,338
know how to point your phone correctly?

653
00:26:56,338 --> 00:27:00,030
Like it's like do you not understand
things like maybe I mean,

654
00:27:00,030 --> 00:27:02,020
I understand that the teenagers like
taking pi one,

655
00:27:02,020 --> 00:27:04,661
you point five pictures of their foreheads
and so they do that on purpose.

656
00:27:04,125 --> 00:27:05,354
Yes, yes.

657
00:27:04,661 --> 00:27:05,661
But like, I

658
00:27:05,430 --> 00:27:07,442
don't think that our parents are trying to
do that,

659
00:27:07,442 --> 00:27:09,813
right? And actually I'm not picking on my
parents because my mom

660
00:27:09,873 --> 00:27:11,366
was a photographer and does a great job.

661
00:27:11,366 --> 00:27:12,534
The point is, like

662
00:27:13,430 --> 00:27:14,881
People will look at a photo and be like,

663
00:27:14,881 --> 00:27:16,452
your photo for is so much better.

664
00:27:16,452 --> 00:27:20,495
I'm like, I just pointed the phone at it
and pushed the button.

665
00:27:20,495 --> 00:27:22,276
Like I didn't do it, like I don't I don't
know.

666
00:27:22,143 --> 00:27:26,317
The w the one habit I see is so many that
yeah.

667
00:27:22,276 --> 00:27:25,858
Stop stop pinging to Zoom, stop all that
stuff,

668
00:27:25,858 --> 00:27:27,910
just tap the button. And I think but

669
00:27:26,317 --> 00:27:27,793
Yeah.

670
00:27:27,910 --> 00:27:29,321
Google knows, like, no no no no.

671
00:27:29,321 --> 00:27:30,962
People are terrible at taking photos.

672
00:27:30,962 --> 00:27:32,203
So we're gonna do all this work because

673
00:27:31,839 --> 00:27:32,839
Gorgeous.

674
00:27:32,203 --> 00:27:36,005
what they really want is just to have a
good end result and we can argue about

675
00:27:36,005 --> 00:27:38,287
all of those details and and that's fine.

676
00:27:38,287 --> 00:27:40,739
The other thing I was just gonna say is
like the creator,

677
00:27:40,739 --> 00:27:42,080
like all these tools and stuff,

678
00:27:42,080 --> 00:27:43,080
that's great.

679
00:27:43,713 --> 00:27:45,804
I you I'm sure have this experience.

680
00:27:45,804 --> 00:27:50,005
But like right now, if you took a vertical
video on your phone and you're like,

681
00:27:50,005 --> 00:27:52,350
this would be cool. I want to add
captions.

682
00:27:52,350 --> 00:27:56,433
I want to do this. There isn't actually
like AI should have solved this problem

683
00:27:56,433 --> 00:27:58,635
by now. I mean cap cut, whatever.

684
00:27:58,635 --> 00:27:59,635
Like it's it's

685
00:27:58,834 --> 00:27:59,834
Yeah, yeah.

686
00:27:59,515 --> 00:28:04,890
but it's still like dialing that stuff in
is not super easy anywhere.

687
00:28:04,890 --> 00:28:09,663
And so I actually think the more that pe
the Google and Apple could build these

688
00:28:09,663 --> 00:28:12,445
features in in a way that's really
accessible,

689
00:28:12,445 --> 00:28:13,445
because

690
00:28:13,216 --> 00:28:14,776
That's what people want to do with this
stuff.

691
00:28:14,776 --> 00:28:15,776
They're taking

692
00:28:14,974 --> 00:28:15,974
Yeah.

693
00:28:15,447 --> 00:28:19,489
these short videos so that they can post
them on Instagram or TikTok or whatever.

694
00:28:19,489 --> 00:28:21,510
So I think that's actually a positive,

695
00:28:21,510 --> 00:28:25,323
even though I'm still in the camp of like
people should just be able

696
00:28:25,323 --> 00:28:27,814
to take better photos. The cameras should
stop trying to do so much.

697
00:28:28,786 --> 00:28:32,227
Well, sure. I think you know, the pinching
and zooming is one thing.

698
00:28:32,227 --> 00:28:38,179
I'm also usually I cringe when someone
like moves

699
00:28:38,179 --> 00:28:41,010
the phone so quickly after hitting the
shutter button.

700
00:28:41,010 --> 00:28:44,626
Like so often I see someone like hit the
shutter button and the camera's down.

701
00:28:44,626 --> 00:28:49,093
And like for me, I always like give it a
second just to make sure it's like
captured

702
00:28:49,093 --> 00:28:50,293
and still, you know what I mean?

703
00:28:50,293 --> 00:28:52,094
I don't know if you you see that kind of
stuff,

704
00:28:52,094 --> 00:28:53,094
but

705
00:28:52,214 --> 00:28:53,214
Yeah,

706
00:28:52,404 --> 00:28:56,476
also, honestly, you should just turn off
all the camera control features

707
00:28:56,476 --> 00:28:57,896
and you should use it as a shutter button.

708
00:28:57,896 --> 00:28:59,377
It's the best way to use your camera.

709
00:28:59,377 --> 00:29:04,069
A hundred percent. Just hold it there and
just hit the camera control button

710
00:29:04,069 --> 00:29:05,339
constantly. And that's

711
00:29:04,242 --> 00:29:05,242
Yeah. Yeah.

712
00:29:05,339 --> 00:29:06,840
the people don't do that though.

713
00:29:06,840 --> 00:29:08,781
They're tapping the thing and yeah.

714
00:29:08,168 --> 00:29:09,771
This should I still tap the shutter
button,

715
00:29:08,781 --> 00:29:10,101
No, no, no.

716
00:29:09,771 --> 00:29:10,771
but

717
00:29:10,101 --> 00:29:11,382
Don't do the don't tap the shutter button.

718
00:29:11,504 --> 00:29:15,731
see, I like to do it because pressing the
camera control button I feel like moves

719
00:29:15,731 --> 00:29:18,336
the phone a little too much, even if I try
really hard to hold it still.

720
00:29:18,336 --> 00:29:21,742
Whereas tapping the shutter button I could
do so lightly it doesn't move the phone.

721
00:29:22,806 --> 00:29:24,664
We had this entire conversation once.

722
00:29:24,167 --> 00:29:25,337
I know we had this entire conversation.

723
00:29:24,664 --> 00:29:25,678
Okay. Okay.

724
00:29:25,337 --> 00:29:27,568
I'm just reiterating my habit and

725
00:29:27,748 --> 00:29:28,949
we won't get we won't have to get into it.

726
00:29:28,949 --> 00:29:31,530
But we will say one other thing about the
camera stuff:

727
00:29:31,530 --> 00:29:37,232
Pixel is adding these cam Pixel camera
looks is the feature.

728
00:29:37,232 --> 00:29:41,294
And in the Google Pixels are giving you
more control.

729
00:29:41,294 --> 00:29:44,295
It's not just filters on top of the photo.

730
00:29:44,295 --> 00:29:48,616
This gives like photo gen like photo
styles on iPhone,

731
00:29:48,616 --> 00:29:52,258
where when you decide the look or how you
want the photo

732
00:29:53,448 --> 00:29:59,450
composed, it's actually affecting the
entire photo process on the camera,

733
00:29:59,450 --> 00:30:02,420
like from the sensor, the processing of
HDR,

734
00:30:02,420 --> 00:30:05,041
all of that. So it's not just a filter on
top of a photo.

735
00:30:05,041 --> 00:30:07,302
It will affect how the photo is taken.

736
00:30:07,302 --> 00:30:11,423
And they are giving users more granular
control over these looks.

737
00:30:11,423 --> 00:30:16,314
And for instance, if you look at this
example and it's in the Verge article,

738
00:30:16,314 --> 00:30:17,545
a link in the show notes as well,

739
00:30:17,545 --> 00:30:19,401
you can choose like, you know what,

740
00:30:19,401 --> 00:30:21,446
don't crush the highlights so much.

741
00:30:21,446 --> 00:30:22,696
I kinda want

742
00:30:22,910 --> 00:30:26,151
kind of the more natural look where this
is what it looked like when I

743
00:30:26,151 --> 00:30:30,312
was there in real life. Or you just don't
want the HDR crank so much.

744
00:30:30,312 --> 00:30:33,613
And if you want a ~ the shadows to
actually be shadowy,

745
00:30:33,613 --> 00:30:35,753
or if you want the grain because it's low
light,

746
00:30:35,753 --> 00:30:40,735
it's giving users the option to have less
processing or at least process

747
00:30:40,735 --> 00:30:43,956
it differently. So it doesn't look so much
like a smartphone photo.

748
00:30:43,956 --> 00:30:49,137
And like I've seen a lot on social media
and TikTok people using like

749
00:30:49,137 --> 00:30:52,168
old cameras because it has cool looks

750
00:30:52,530 --> 00:30:56,062
But basically the cool look is just minus
all the computational photography.

751
00:30:56,062 --> 00:30:57,062
Like the

752
00:30:56,640 --> 00:30:57,640
Right.

753
00:30:56,973 --> 00:30:59,684
the cool look is this is an old camera
that all it did was capture what

754
00:30:59,684 --> 00:31:02,936
was in front of it and there were no
settings and no processing.

755
00:31:02,936 --> 00:31:05,287
And especially younger generations are
like,

756
00:31:05,287 --> 00:31:08,459
hey, this is cool. Like I actually want
pictures that look like this.

757
00:31:08,459 --> 00:31:11,761
And so the Pixel is actually doing that
and giving users more control.

758
00:31:11,761 --> 00:31:14,562
Again, photogenic styles gives you some
control on the iPhone,

759
00:31:14,562 --> 00:31:16,523
but the Pixel is going even further,

760
00:31:16,523 --> 00:31:20,375
giving more granular control and being
able to make it look like not

761
00:31:20,375 --> 00:31:21,636
as processed of a photo.

762
00:31:21,810 --> 00:31:22,964
Which I think is good. I mean,

763
00:31:22,964 --> 00:31:24,912
yeah. Nice.

764
00:31:24,672 --> 00:31:25,672
I agree.

765
00:31:25,052 --> 00:31:28,028
I agree. Yeah. And I do think that the
headline of that story is great.

766
00:31:28,028 --> 00:31:30,673
Google's making pixel cameras better by
making them worse.

767
00:31:30,789 --> 00:31:32,280
Exact exactly.

768
00:31:31,555 --> 00:31:32,898
Good job. Good job, David.

769
00:31:33,160 --> 00:31:35,842
Exactly. All right. A couple of last quick
things.

770
00:31:35,842 --> 00:31:37,983
~ I just closed a tab. no.

771
00:31:38,988 --> 00:31:39,988
Show's over.

772
00:31:39,944 --> 00:31:43,045
The show is over. I inadvertently closed a
tab.

773
00:31:43,045 --> 00:31:48,218
No, the Pixel Tag. So Google did announce
a and yeah,

774
00:31:48,218 --> 00:31:49,769
announce because it doesn't come out till
November,

775
00:31:49,769 --> 00:31:52,230
an air tag style tracking tag.

776
00:31:52,230 --> 00:31:55,052
It's called the Pixel Tag. It's gonna be
$29 for one.

777
00:31:55,052 --> 00:31:59,094
It's gonna be $99 for four. It is oblong.

778
00:31:59,376 --> 00:32:01,567
It's not like a perfect circle like an air
tag.

779
00:32:01,567 --> 00:32:05,988
It is a kind of a oval shape. It is still
a coin battery,

780
00:32:05,988 --> 00:32:09,733
year of battery life. Google says it will
be able to ping

781
00:32:09,753 --> 00:32:14,606
the entire Android network. So it seems
like maybe any Android phone doesn't have

782
00:32:14,606 --> 00:32:16,917
to be a Pixel, will be a part of the
network,

783
00:32:16,917 --> 00:32:18,918
the find hub network for Google.

784
00:32:18,918 --> 00:32:21,420
So yeah, if you are in the Pixel universe,

785
00:32:21,420 --> 00:32:23,081
you can have an AirTag like thing.

786
00:32:23,081 --> 00:32:24,322
There you go.

787
00:32:24,192 --> 00:32:25,192
I

788
00:32:24,622 --> 00:32:29,885
I do think this is a perfect example of
how good Apple

789
00:32:29,885 --> 00:32:34,307
is at designing the form of a product
around its limiting factor,

790
00:32:34,307 --> 00:32:36,948
which is the little CR whatever,

791
00:32:36,948 --> 00:32:38,129
twenty thirty two battery.

792
00:32:37,406 --> 00:32:38,542
Twenty thirty two battery. Yeah,

793
00:32:38,542 --> 00:32:39,542
yeah, yeah.

794
00:32:38,909 --> 00:32:40,870
Because this looks like

795
00:32:41,366 --> 00:32:44,798
This actually looks a lot like the one of
the versions of the Google

796
00:32:44,798 --> 00:32:48,731
TV Chromecast remote. Looked a lot like
that.

797
00:32:47,376 --> 00:32:48,507
Yeah, it does, yeah.

798
00:32:48,766 --> 00:32:52,694
It's like this is this is weird in the
sense that like the air tag

799
00:32:52,694 --> 00:32:54,205
is the perfect form factor for this.

800
00:32:54,205 --> 00:32:56,417
And people are like, well, you can make it
smaller if you made it rechargeable.

801
00:32:56,417 --> 00:32:58,112
No, no, no. It's perfect that you can just
twist it,

802
00:32:58,112 --> 00:32:59,139
take out a battery every year,

803
00:32:59,139 --> 00:33:00,339
put it in. I don't have to recharge it.

804
00:33:00,339 --> 00:33:02,641
I don't have to you the battery won't
degrade over time.

805
00:33:02,641 --> 00:33:04,314
It'll just die and I put a new one in.

806
00:33:04,314 --> 00:33:05,314
But I I just

807
00:33:04,594 --> 00:33:05,594
Yeah, yeah.

808
00:33:05,073 --> 00:33:09,386
think not throwing any shade at this thing
other than I have no use for it.

809
00:33:10,206 --> 00:33:14,163
I just think it should we should
appreciate for all of our criticisms of
Apple,

810
00:33:14,163 --> 00:33:16,547
the air tag is actually such a perfect
example of like,

811
00:33:16,547 --> 00:33:19,242
no, the limiting factor of this is the
size and shape of the battery

812
00:33:19,623 --> 00:33:21,556
and they built the perfect device around
that.

813
00:33:21,520 --> 00:33:22,520
Yeah.

814
00:33:21,860 --> 00:33:24,923
And I'm curious like the range of
something like this Pixel One.

815
00:33:24,923 --> 00:33:28,035
I'm sure Lexi Civides, who was on the show
a few weeks ago,

816
00:33:28,035 --> 00:33:32,679
she actually did a whole find my
comparison with the current products.

817
00:33:32,679 --> 00:33:35,981
And so I hope she does a an updated video
with this specifically.

818
00:33:35,981 --> 00:33:37,062
It doesn't come out till November,

819
00:33:37,062 --> 00:33:38,663
but I will be curious the range,

820
00:33:38,663 --> 00:33:41,465
because AirTag two range is insane.

821
00:33:41,465 --> 00:33:45,168
I remember I did a short video and it got
over two hundred feet,

822
00:33:45,168 --> 00:33:48,961
I think, and I still had to precision find
my arrow on screen,

823
00:33:48,961 --> 00:33:50,991
which was pretty wild. So yeah.

824
00:33:51,601 --> 00:33:53,272
That's pretty cool. All right.

825
00:33:53,272 --> 00:33:54,272
Well, that was the Pixel event.

826
00:33:54,263 --> 00:33:58,887
There was also the Pixel Watch 5 that has
breathing emergency detection

827
00:33:59,368 --> 00:34:02,750
and also insulin resistance trends.

828
00:34:02,750 --> 00:34:04,992
Not so much like individual measurements,

829
00:34:04,992 --> 00:34:06,674
but that's there in blood pressure trends.

830
00:34:06,674 --> 00:34:09,408
So you got Pixel Watch 5, which I do I
think it looks nice.

831
00:34:09,408 --> 00:34:10,587
I mean it's a nice circle face.

832
00:34:10,587 --> 00:34:13,239
That's cool. Also, tap to share is going
to be updated,

833
00:34:13,239 --> 00:34:16,952
so you'll be able to just tap two Android
phones together as long

834
00:34:16,952 --> 00:34:19,675
as they're a Galaxy 8, the Z Fold 8,

835
00:34:19,675 --> 00:34:20,675
the Fold 8.

836
00:34:20,593 --> 00:34:22,385
And a Pixel Six series of newer,

837
00:34:22,385 --> 00:34:23,957
which actually going back pretty far.

838
00:34:23,957 --> 00:34:26,610
Shout out Bump. You remember the Bump app,

839
00:34:26,610 --> 00:34:27,741
Jason? Yeah.

840
00:34:26,784 --> 00:34:27,784
Yep, I do.

841
00:34:27,901 --> 00:34:30,865
That was on iPhone too. Like the Bump app
existed on both platforms,

842
00:34:30,865 --> 00:34:31,865
I feel like.

843
00:34:31,040 --> 00:34:32,040
And

844
00:34:31,170 --> 00:34:34,403
it was a big deal before you could just
have those contact posters that

845
00:34:34,403 --> 00:34:36,315
you could share by putting the phone next
to each other.

846
00:34:36,315 --> 00:34:38,748
But in this I mean, bump was like what it
was like,

847
00:34:38,748 --> 00:34:40,490
two thousand ten, eleven maybe.

848
00:34:40,490 --> 00:34:43,110
I can just remember going to conferences
and it's like,

849
00:34:43,110 --> 00:34:45,765
Here you go, wanna bump? Which is a weird
thing to say to someone,

850
00:34:44,391 --> 00:34:45,391
Bump. What a

851
00:34:45,765 --> 00:34:46,765
but

852
00:34:46,102 --> 00:34:48,072
bump. Maybe the name. If it was a better
name,

853
00:34:48,072 --> 00:34:50,322
it might have been better. But anyway.

854
00:34:50,322 --> 00:34:53,183
Alright, Zuck had this huge AI manifesto I
want to get into.

855
00:34:53,183 --> 00:34:55,584
Claude is gonna watermark text that it
generates.

856
00:34:55,584 --> 00:34:56,904
I have some interesting feelings about
that.

857
00:34:56,904 --> 00:34:59,985
And yeah, Spotify is ~ maybe trying to
kill podcasting.

858
00:34:59,985 --> 00:35:01,653
We'll get into it. But before we get to
all that,

859
00:35:01,653 --> 00:35:04,006
we're gonna take a break and thank today's
sponsor,

860
00:35:04,006 --> 00:35:07,087
which is Decagon. Listen, Decagon,

861
00:35:07,087 --> 00:35:10,118
if you have a team and you're dealing with
tons of support tickets,

862
00:35:10,118 --> 00:35:13,089
multiple channels, your customers have
high expectations.

863
00:35:13,393 --> 00:35:16,534
You might have thought about using AI for
customer support and you might

864
00:35:16,534 --> 00:35:20,195
be limited in time and how time consuming
those options are and training it.

865
00:35:20,195 --> 00:35:22,336
Well, that's why Decagon is here for you.

866
00:35:22,336 --> 00:35:27,297
Dekagon helps companies create
personalized concierge-style customer
experiences

867
00:35:27,417 --> 00:35:29,798
with AI agents across chat, email,

868
00:35:29,798 --> 00:35:32,999
voice, and SMS. They're available 24-7,

869
00:35:32,999 --> 00:35:36,890
they feel natural to talk to, and can
resolve customer requests on their

870
00:35:36,890 --> 00:35:41,381
own so businesses can keep up with
requests without losing that personal
touch.

871
00:35:41,798 --> 00:35:46,462
And Dekagon plugs directly into your
existing teams so agents can get live
quickly.

872
00:35:46,462 --> 00:35:49,644
And because workflows can be updated using
natural language,

873
00:35:49,644 --> 00:35:53,788
teams can make changes themselves without
long engineering cycles.

874
00:35:53,788 --> 00:35:57,301
That's huge. You don't need to be a
programmer to affect how it responds

875
00:35:57,301 --> 00:36:00,463
and do you update it. You can just your
team can do it today.

876
00:36:00,463 --> 00:36:03,816
That means less time spent managing
workflows and more time focused

877
00:36:03,816 --> 00:36:05,838
on customers and ROI in weeks.

878
00:36:05,838 --> 00:36:08,520
And once live agents can pull up to date
information,

879
00:36:08,520 --> 00:36:09,671
take action on requests.

880
00:36:09,851 --> 00:36:12,342
And understand the context behind any
conversation.

881
00:36:12,342 --> 00:36:16,765
Also, Decagon gives your team full
visibility into why agents make decisions

882
00:36:16,885 --> 00:36:19,406
and what's happening across every
conversation.

883
00:36:19,406 --> 00:36:23,098
Decagon helps power millions of
conversations every day for brands

884
00:36:23,098 --> 00:36:24,409
you already know and love like Avis,

885
00:36:24,409 --> 00:36:26,610
Affirm, Fanatics, and Aura, like the Aura
Ring.

886
00:36:26,610 --> 00:36:28,901
So if you're ready to transform your
customer support,

887
00:36:28,901 --> 00:36:34,835
go to Decagon.ai slash primary to get a
personalized demo and see what Decagon

888
00:36:34,835 --> 00:36:37,976
can do for your team. So check out Decagon
at Decagon.ai.

889
00:36:37,976 --> 00:36:38,977
~

890
00:36:39,087 --> 00:36:41,178
slash primary. That link's also in the
show notes.

891
00:36:41,178 --> 00:36:44,000
That's decagon.ai slash primary.

892
00:36:44,000 --> 00:36:46,961
Thanks to Decagon for sponsoring this
episode.

893
00:36:46,961 --> 00:36:49,943
And also thanks to all of our members who
support the show,

894
00:36:49,943 --> 00:36:52,504
which just a quick plug, you can become a
member.

895
00:36:52,504 --> 00:36:54,926
There's a link down in the show notes if
you're not already a member.

896
00:36:54,926 --> 00:36:59,328
$2.50 a month or $25 a year. You get an
ad-free version of the show.

897
00:36:59,328 --> 00:37:01,990
You get the bonus episode, you get the
unedited feed,

898
00:37:01,990 --> 00:37:03,491
which also includes a pre-show,

899
00:37:03,491 --> 00:37:05,151
you get primary tech daily, you get all
the things.

900
00:37:05,151 --> 00:37:06,412
So we'd appreciate your support.

901
00:37:06,412 --> 00:37:07,853
Thank you for all those who already do
that.

902
00:37:08,076 --> 00:37:09,076
You

903
00:37:08,217 --> 00:37:10,343
get a sneak peek into something I'm
working on.

904
00:37:10,801 --> 00:37:13,283
That is true. We talk about Jason's next
app,

905
00:37:13,283 --> 00:37:15,444
which is pretty exciting. So, you know,

906
00:37:15,444 --> 00:37:17,586
it's right there. All right, Jason,

907
00:37:17,586 --> 00:37:23,110
I read Mark Zuckerberg's entire AI
manifesto.

908
00:37:23,110 --> 00:37:27,292
It is very long. It's like over 6,500
words.

909
00:37:27,292 --> 00:37:29,534
I have just a quick question for you.

910
00:37:29,534 --> 00:37:32,036
How it's okay if you did. Did you read any
of this?

911
00:37:32,036 --> 00:37:34,377
Okay, you read the whole thing.

912
00:37:32,448 --> 00:37:35,245
I read the whole thing. I even made notes,

913
00:37:35,245 --> 00:37:36,849
Stephen, incontextually.

914
00:37:38,360 --> 00:37:39,360
I made notes too.

915
00:37:39,654 --> 00:37:43,560
I made notes. One, the title is The Future
Is For Everyone.

916
00:37:43,560 --> 00:37:47,787
Subhead The Path to a Positive AI Future.

917
00:37:47,787 --> 00:37:51,103
I don't like that there's the in the title
and the in the subtitle.

918
00:37:51,103 --> 00:37:52,535
I think you should drop one of the the's.

919
00:37:52,535 --> 00:37:53,535
You know what I mean?

920
00:37:55,010 --> 00:37:58,473
Sure, but the Yeah.

921
00:37:55,399 --> 00:37:57,293
That's a that's a joke. That's a social
network joke.

922
00:37:57,293 --> 00:37:58,545
Just throwing

923
00:37:58,545 --> 00:38:01,071
that out there. Do you think you're a
writer,

924
00:38:01,071 --> 00:38:03,445
Jason? I think our listeners know that.

925
00:38:03,445 --> 00:38:05,179
Is Zuck a good writer?

926
00:38:08,551 --> 00:38:11,372
I don't know that it would be fair to say
that Zuck wrote this.

927
00:38:11,372 --> 00:38:14,774
I mean, I don't this is like how many
words was this thing?

928
00:38:13,479 --> 00:38:16,505
Sure. Sixty five hundred? About sixty five
hundred.

929
00:38:14,774 --> 00:38:15,774
A lot.

930
00:38:16,735 --> 00:38:21,767
The guy running the largest advertising
platform in the world doesn't have time

931
00:38:21,767 --> 00:38:23,048
to write sixty five hundred words,

932
00:38:23,048 --> 00:38:24,048
does he?

933
00:38:24,847 --> 00:38:29,158
Well, that's a good question. So high
level,

934
00:38:29,158 --> 00:38:34,860
this is like Zuck trying to I guess make a
call like who do you who is this for?

935
00:38:34,860 --> 00:38:38,831
It seems like maybe this is a call to the
governments and also other

936
00:38:38,831 --> 00:38:44,553
AI companies and also trying to tell the
people that he is he thinks AI

937
00:38:44,553 --> 00:38:47,564
is for the people and needs to be
available to all people,

938
00:38:47,564 --> 00:38:50,745
free and open, and the only way we all
succeed is everybody gets AI.

939
00:38:51,141 --> 00:38:53,334
on their own terms and I'm gonna talk
about the personal agent

940
00:38:53,334 --> 00:38:56,508
he talks about several times. Who who is
this for,

941
00:38:56,508 --> 00:38:57,508
do you think?

942
00:38:57,108 --> 00:38:58,850
Okay, this is helpful context.

943
00:38:58,850 --> 00:39:03,044
Do you wanna start by c going through it
and then we can we can talk about

944
00:39:03,084 --> 00:39:06,808
why this exists? Okay. Okay.

945
00:39:04,935 --> 00:39:06,787
Sure. Let's do that. Let's do that.

946
00:39:06,968 --> 00:39:09,931
'Cause I think that the why it exists is
the only part that matters,

947
00:39:09,931 --> 00:39:12,134
but if we start talking about that we'll
never get to the other part,

948
00:39:12,134 --> 00:39:13,134
so

949
00:39:12,305 --> 00:39:13,305
Okay,

950
00:39:12,695 --> 00:39:14,325
all right. So I'll I'll quickly jam
through this.

951
00:39:14,325 --> 00:39:15,917
I made a bunch of notes, I'm not gonna go
through all of it,

952
00:39:15,917 --> 00:39:19,318
but he does make a call to Steve Jobs
talking about like all

953
00:39:19,318 --> 00:39:20,749
the revolutions in technology,

954
00:39:20,749 --> 00:39:25,041
and he mentions in a line the kid in a
garage who thought personal computer
should

955
00:39:25,041 --> 00:39:27,332
be for everyone. And that I don't know.

956
00:39:27,332 --> 00:39:28,662
I was a little bit like, All right,

957
00:39:28,662 --> 00:39:31,624
all right. You d don't don't invoke the w
he never said Steve Jobs,

958
00:39:31,624 --> 00:39:32,814
but everybody knows what he's talking
about.

959
00:39:32,505 --> 00:39:33,961
but he's always wanted to be Steve Jobs.

960
00:39:34,075 --> 00:39:39,067
Always want to be Steve Jobs. So a couple
poll quotes from this manifesto.

961
00:39:40,241 --> 00:39:43,442
First of all, he's trying to make
superintelligence the term.

962
00:39:43,442 --> 00:39:46,704
And I think he and Meta are the only ones
using that term,

963
00:39:46,704 --> 00:39:49,465
superintelligence. He has the
superintelligence labs,

964
00:39:49,465 --> 00:39:51,686
but fine. He's really trying to make that
a thing.

965
00:39:51,686 --> 00:39:55,927
Some of the bold claims that he has about
the near future of AI.

966
00:39:55,927 --> 00:40:02,550
He says everyone will have an
exceptionally capable personal agent that
understands

967
00:40:02,550 --> 00:40:06,572
you, your goals, and everything you care
about.

968
00:40:06,572 --> 00:40:09,433
That's a bold claim. Like,

969
00:40:09,691 --> 00:40:10,921
Sure, there are agents right now,

970
00:40:10,921 --> 00:40:12,822
but he's saying very personal.

971
00:40:12,822 --> 00:40:15,263
He also believes that everyone will have
one.

972
00:40:15,263 --> 00:40:19,264
He says the economy will become more
entrepreneurial because of this.

973
00:40:19,264 --> 00:40:24,765
Adults will have a superintelligent
learning assistant that knows exactly

974
00:40:24,765 --> 00:40:27,036
how to teach you new job skills,

975
00:40:27,036 --> 00:40:30,807
new languages, new hobbies, or anything
else you're interested in.

976
00:40:30,807 --> 00:40:36,139
Side question: if the superintelligence
can teach me all of that,

977
00:40:36,139 --> 00:40:37,139
why do I need to learn it?

978
00:40:37,590 --> 00:40:38,891
Well, hold on, let's pause.

979
00:40:39,056 --> 00:40:40,056
Okay, sure, please.

980
00:40:40,913 --> 00:40:42,334
Go back to the first thing you said.

981
00:40:42,334 --> 00:40:44,446
Everyone's gonna everyone's gonna

982
00:40:43,057 --> 00:40:44,408
The capable person Yeah.

983
00:40:44,446 --> 00:40:46,948
have a capable This is written by someone
who probably

984
00:40:46,948 --> 00:40:50,521
has fifteen personal assistant type
people,

985
00:40:50,521 --> 00:40:52,002
right? And

986
00:40:50,617 --> 00:40:51,885
~ sure, for sure.

987
00:40:52,002 --> 00:40:56,145
~ also I'm pretty sure that none of them
know everything about him.

988
00:40:56,861 --> 00:40:57,872
Sure, sure.

989
00:40:57,418 --> 00:40:58,418
And I'm pretty

990
00:40:57,899 --> 00:41:01,403
sure he doesn't want that. And I
definitely don't want all of my personal,

991
00:41:01,403 --> 00:41:04,787
everything deep personal, everything about
me living on a server somewhere

992
00:41:05,088 --> 00:41:06,950
so that an AI agent can get to it.

993
00:41:06,950 --> 00:41:09,724
Because what happens when the other agent
breaks into it?

994
00:41:09,724 --> 00:41:11,536
Because it's not like that ever happened
before.

995
00:41:11,536 --> 00:41:16,082
Right? Like i this is a I don't think this
is a future people actually want.

996
00:41:16,935 --> 00:41:18,886
I don't think it's feature people actually
want.

997
00:41:18,886 --> 00:41:23,398
And he also I I think he talks out of both
sides of his mouth because throughout

998
00:41:23,398 --> 00:41:28,801
this entire manifesto, he is trying to
make the plea that AI needs

999
00:41:28,801 --> 00:41:34,184
to not be centralized to a few specific
powerful companies,

1000
00:41:34,184 --> 00:41:35,735
slash people, slash governments.

1001
00:41:35,735 --> 00:41:39,957
It needs to be democratized. But then in a
different breath,

1002
00:41:39,957 --> 00:41:45,340
he says, quote, We Meta will offer free
versions that will be accessible

1003
00:41:45,340 --> 00:41:46,521
to billions of people.

1004
00:41:46,983 --> 00:41:50,215
So it's we want, we don't want a
centralized anything of power,

1005
00:41:50,215 --> 00:41:52,527
but also we will be the one that gives
everyone this power.

1006
00:41:52,527 --> 00:41:55,609
And it's like, I feel like that's a little
contradictory.

1007
00:41:55,609 --> 00:42:01,963
Fine. He also has this wild example of
trying to prove this point

1008
00:42:02,423 --> 00:42:08,307
that if one person had a AI
superintelligent lawyer

1009
00:42:08,607 --> 00:42:11,809
in the courtroom, but the other person
didn't,

1010
00:42:11,809 --> 00:42:13,490
that would be an unfair advantage.

1011
00:42:13,490 --> 00:42:16,232
So the future we need is that everyone
has.

1012
00:42:16,622 --> 00:42:19,814
A superintelligence lawyer on their side,

1013
00:42:19,814 --> 00:42:23,326
and then these superintelligence lawyers
will argue,

1014
00:42:23,326 --> 00:42:28,430
I guess, and do the case. And it's like
recently on Movies on the Side,

1015
00:42:28,430 --> 00:42:31,692
we reviewed the movie Mercy, which is
exactly this situation,

1016
00:42:31,692 --> 00:42:34,283
and it doesn't go well. Just throwing that
out there.

1017
00:42:34,283 --> 00:42:37,092
But just seems like a weird, I don't know,

1018
00:42:37,092 --> 00:42:39,567
it's a weird example. But these are the
kind of examples that he pulls

1019
00:42:39,567 --> 00:42:41,188
to try and prove his point.

1020
00:42:42,184 --> 00:42:47,317
Yeah, I feel like there's this is I think
that didn't they talk about this

1021
00:42:47,317 --> 00:42:52,920
on ~ The Verge cast recently because
Zuckerberg wrote about like what a

1022
00:42:53,241 --> 00:42:55,442
I think it's Neely who talks about
software brain.

1023
00:42:55,442 --> 00:42:56,442
There's

1024
00:42:55,717 --> 00:42:56,717
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1025
00:42:56,422 --> 00:42:58,043
so much software brain in this.

1026
00:42:58,043 --> 00:43:01,315
There's so much. Also,

1027
00:42:58,598 --> 00:42:59,777
There's a lot of software brain.

1028
00:42:59,777 --> 00:43:01,330
Lot of software brain. ~

1029
00:43:01,315 --> 00:43:02,315
like

1030
00:43:01,515 --> 00:43:04,207
you could have the most super intelligent
lawyer in the entire world.

1031
00:43:04,207 --> 00:43:07,089
Fine. Could be an AI agent, fine.

1032
00:43:07,089 --> 00:43:09,452
But you know who decides cases?

1033
00:43:10,496 --> 00:43:12,588
Just randos off the street, twelve of
them,

1034
00:43:10,928 --> 00:43:13,496
Yeah. That is true.

1035
00:43:12,588 --> 00:43:13,849
sitting in a box, listening

1036
00:43:13,849 --> 00:43:15,891
to those super intelligent AIs for days.

1037
00:43:15,891 --> 00:43:16,891
Or a

1038
00:43:16,252 --> 00:43:17,252
That is true.

1039
00:43:16,771 --> 00:43:21,595
judge who has very little patience already
for AI written briefs that just make

1040
00:43:21,595 --> 00:43:23,157
cra like this

1041
00:43:22,362 --> 00:43:23,362
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

1042
00:43:23,157 --> 00:43:26,840
is like I'm sure this sounded good to him
when he wrote it,

1043
00:43:26,840 --> 00:43:28,471
but his persp you just have to understand,

1044
00:43:28,471 --> 00:43:31,214
like the perspective of the guy who owns
an island in Hawaii is

1045
00:43:31,214 --> 00:43:33,866
not the perspective of what most of us are
experiencing.

1046
00:43:34,177 --> 00:43:36,338
That's a good data point to keep in mind.

1047
00:43:36,338 --> 00:43:37,856
This dude owns an island in one.

1048
00:43:38,209 --> 00:43:41,411
I just and he and he just keeps up buying
a property and pushing people out.

1049
00:43:41,411 --> 00:43:44,443
Like cause in his mind, like the world
just revolves around.

1050
00:43:44,443 --> 00:43:47,285
Okay, can we just cut to why this exists
and then I'll let you keep going.

1051
00:43:47,285 --> 00:43:49,146
I'm sorry. Okay.

1052
00:43:48,314 --> 00:43:49,847
No no okay, go ahead. Yeah, why does this
exist?

1053
00:43:49,907 --> 00:43:53,700
Cause you said it. His core thesis here is
that it should

1054
00:43:53,700 --> 00:43:58,012
not be that superintelligence should not
be controlled by a few powerful companies.

1055
00:43:58,012 --> 00:44:00,154
Who are those powerful companies?

1056
00:44:00,154 --> 00:44:04,108
Yep. That's it.

1057
00:44:01,102 --> 00:44:04,339
It is OpenAI, Anthropic, Google.

1058
00:44:04,108 --> 00:44:06,068
Well, it's those two, really, right?

1059
00:44:04,339 --> 00:44:06,424
Sure.

1060
00:44:06,464 --> 00:44:08,145
I mean Google Sure, fine, whatever.

1061
00:44:08,145 --> 00:44:10,196
They've already won search, like all that
stuff.

1062
00:44:10,196 --> 00:44:14,437
So what do you say if you are not one of
the companies that is currently

1063
00:44:14,437 --> 00:44:15,999
in the race to control everything?

1064
00:44:15,999 --> 00:44:19,411
You say no one should control everything,

1065
00:44:19,298 --> 00:44:20,369
Exactly. Yes.

1066
00:44:19,411 --> 00:44:20,592
right? It should all

1067
00:44:20,592 --> 00:44:22,913
be open and everyone should have access to
it.

1068
00:44:22,913 --> 00:44:25,684
He thinks superintelligence should be a c
commodity.

1069
00:44:25,684 --> 00:44:30,507
And what do you do when one of your
competitors controls a scarce commodity?

1070
00:44:30,507 --> 00:44:33,348
You argue that the commodity should be
free.

1071
00:44:33,348 --> 00:44:36,070
And the other reason that this is
important is

1072
00:44:36,392 --> 00:44:38,794
Is that his entire business well,

1073
00:44:38,794 --> 00:44:43,248
first of all, I think there is definitely
a I want to be seen as cool.

1074
00:44:43,248 --> 00:44:45,109
This is what's cool.

1075
00:44:43,870 --> 00:44:45,026
~ for sure.

1076
00:44:45,469 --> 00:44:47,021
So I have to be in this space.

1077
00:44:47,021 --> 00:44:51,364
But there is actually an argument for why
artificial intelligence

1078
00:44:51,364 --> 00:44:55,417
is important to Facebook, and it is
because generative AI is capable

1079
00:44:55,417 --> 00:44:58,140
of infinity advertising. Right?

1080
00:44:57,404 --> 00:44:58,404
Correct.

1081
00:44:58,460 --> 00:45:00,652
And I've I've heard people talk about this
before.

1082
00:45:00,652 --> 00:45:03,654
I think maybe it's the VerchCast where
they talk about like a YouTube video,

1083
00:45:03,654 --> 00:45:06,036
every single pixel is mod maybe it's
actually Ben Thompson.

1084
00:45:06,366 --> 00:45:08,066
Every single pixel should be monetizable.

1085
00:45:08,066 --> 00:45:12,188
You hold up a product, right? We're people
looking at our video feed right

1086
00:45:12,188 --> 00:45:13,308
now should be able to be like,

1087
00:45:13,308 --> 00:45:14,778
where did that frame come from?

1088
00:45:14,778 --> 00:45:15,949
Where did this lamp come from?

1089
00:45:15,949 --> 00:45:17,029
Where did this book come from?

1090
00:45:17,029 --> 00:45:19,990
Like there should be able to everything
single pixel should be monetizable.

1091
00:45:19,990 --> 00:45:22,571
That is not possible without AI,

1092
00:45:22,571 --> 00:45:24,011
right? Infinity

1093
00:45:23,024 --> 00:45:24,024
Right, right.

1094
00:45:24,011 --> 00:45:26,892
ad content is what what Facebook wants.

1095
00:45:26,892 --> 00:45:30,543
Infinity and so, but they cannot they've
been through the experience.

1096
00:45:30,543 --> 00:45:33,274
It's kind of like people talk about Apple
never wanting to be beholden

1097
00:45:33,274 --> 00:45:34,444
to someone else because like

1098
00:45:34,645 --> 00:45:36,777
Adobe and Microsoft had them over the
barrel,

1099
00:45:36,777 --> 00:45:41,791
right? Zuckerberg just never wants to be
beholden to someone else's platform
because

1100
00:45:41,791 --> 00:45:44,343
that's been the case with Apple for for
decades.

1101
00:45:44,343 --> 00:45:50,277
And so they cannot have a world where all
of this capability

1102
00:45:50,277 --> 00:45:51,949
is controlled by someone else.

1103
00:45:51,949 --> 00:45:52,949
So it has

1104
00:45:52,283 --> 00:45:53,283
Right.

1105
00:45:52,850 --> 00:45:54,921
to be open. So when you read this,

1106
00:45:54,921 --> 00:45:58,174
it sounds super altruistic and super good
for the good of humanity.

1107
00:45:58,174 --> 00:45:59,385
Just understand

1108
00:45:58,545 --> 00:45:59,545
Right.

1109
00:45:59,385 --> 00:46:03,388
that the actual reason is it is an
existential threat to meta.

1110
00:46:04,590 --> 00:46:08,002
It's exactly that. And we've mentioned
before,

1111
00:46:08,002 --> 00:46:11,344
but Zuck missed the mobile revolution.

1112
00:46:11,344 --> 00:46:13,775
Facebook never got to be in the hardware,

1113
00:46:13,775 --> 00:46:18,168
make a phone there. They missed the search
revolution.

1114
00:46:18,168 --> 00:46:22,401
Google got that. And now it feels like
they are missing the AI revolution.

1115
00:46:22,401 --> 00:46:26,333
I mean, I have never heard a soul say,

1116
00:46:26,333 --> 00:46:30,215
I asked the meta AI app about this or
that.

1117
00:46:30,215 --> 00:46:31,356
It is

1118
00:46:32,100 --> 00:46:35,012
90% of the time ChatGPT. Just normal
people,

1119
00:46:35,012 --> 00:46:36,904
not techie people, just normal people,

1120
00:46:36,904 --> 00:46:39,205
they're like, Chat GPT, ChatGPT,

1121
00:46:39,205 --> 00:46:43,248
this and that. And then when you move a
little bit into the nerdier space,

1122
00:46:43,248 --> 00:46:46,391
you'll hear Claude, maybe some Gemini.

1123
00:46:46,391 --> 00:46:49,754
And like there was other news this week
where Gemini reached a billion users,

1124
00:46:49,754 --> 00:46:54,327
and it's like, Google, if you're counting
every Google search as a Gemini user,

1125
00:46:54,327 --> 00:46:58,150
because that's what it is. Right.

1126
00:46:54,432 --> 00:46:55,693
They are because that's what it is.

1127
00:46:55,693 --> 00:46:57,525
So most people are using Gemini,

1128
00:46:57,525 --> 00:46:58,525
they just don't think about

1129
00:46:58,316 --> 00:47:00,779
it as using AI yet because they aren't
going

1130
00:47:00,368 --> 00:47:01,368
Right.

1131
00:47:00,779 --> 00:47:01,950
intentionally into a chat bot.

1132
00:47:02,229 --> 00:47:06,561
Right. But when any I I would argue that
ninety percent of people when they think

1133
00:47:06,561 --> 00:47:09,472
of AI or an AI chat, it's Chat GPT.

1134
00:47:09,472 --> 00:47:14,864
And so I think it's becoming increasingly
clear Meta is losing this battle as well.

1135
00:47:14,864 --> 00:47:17,255
And it feels like that was probably the
impetus for this,

1136
00:47:17,255 --> 00:47:21,657
where Mark Zuckerberg is trying to wave
his arms around and on one hand

1137
00:47:21,657 --> 00:47:24,778
try to be not doomsday-ish,

1138
00:47:24,778 --> 00:47:27,779
but then he also talks about a lot of
other doomsday-ish scenarios that I'll

1139
00:47:27,779 --> 00:47:29,510
get to in a second. And

1140
00:47:30,148 --> 00:47:34,672
Like you're saying, feigning altruism in
the hopes that he could be

1141
00:47:34,933 --> 00:47:37,275
in the room again. And like on one level,

1142
00:47:37,275 --> 00:47:40,959
I almost feel a little bad because it
feels like he's the guy that keeps getting

1143
00:47:40,959 --> 00:47:44,552
left out of the cool kids group because he
got left out of the phone thing,

1144
00:47:44,552 --> 00:47:45,944
got left out of this. But also,

1145
00:47:45,944 --> 00:47:48,297
he has built some of the biggest
companies,

1146
00:47:48,297 --> 00:47:50,468
the most profitable companies in the
world.

1147
00:47:50,468 --> 00:47:53,269
I just don't think he's proud of them.

1148
00:47:54,050 --> 00:47:55,491
Well he built one and he bought two.

1149
00:47:55,491 --> 00:48:01,134
And he in and I I do hear people talk.

1150
00:47:56,879 --> 00:48:01,756
Fair point. Fair point. And the one he
built is dying,

1151
00:48:01,134 --> 00:48:04,276
Yeah, that's good. That's a hundred
percent true,

1152
00:48:01,756 --> 00:48:04,821
just to be clear. Like Facebook the one he
built is dying.

1153
00:48:04,276 --> 00:48:05,276
right?

1154
00:48:05,036 --> 00:48:08,938
Yes. And the one that he the one that he
bought that is doing really well

1155
00:48:09,159 --> 00:48:12,641
is literally just Snapchat, all the good
ideas stolen.

1156
00:48:12,641 --> 00:48:14,912
And TikTok, all the good ideas stolen.

1157
00:48:12,997 --> 00:48:14,942
~ and TikTok 'cause of reels. Yeah,

1158
00:48:14,912 --> 00:48:15,912
Right. And

1159
00:48:14,942 --> 00:48:15,942
exactly.

1160
00:48:15,652 --> 00:48:20,495
so yeah, he's the exactly. They they they
are dominant purely because

1161
00:48:20,495 --> 00:48:22,076
of their network effect that they already
have.

1162
00:48:22,432 --> 00:48:26,785
Right, and that's ~ and in Instagram's
entire user base was built on Twitter.

1163
00:48:26,785 --> 00:48:28,225
Let's not forget that at the time.

1164
00:48:28,225 --> 00:48:32,068
So I 'cause it was a filters app.

1165
00:48:29,061 --> 00:48:32,889
Sure. Yeah. Right.

1166
00:48:32,068 --> 00:48:33,068
The feed wasn't

1167
00:48:32,958 --> 00:48:36,370
the thing in Instagram. You shared your f
Instagram photos on Twitter.

1168
00:48:36,370 --> 00:48:40,813
And then you could and when you you could
also can take all of your Twitter users

1169
00:48:41,033 --> 00:48:43,555
and create your social graph on Instagram
at the beginning.

1170
00:48:43,555 --> 00:48:46,336
So all of these things, like the
innovation here,

1171
00:48:46,336 --> 00:48:47,917
it's not really happening.

1172
00:48:49,010 --> 00:48:50,010
In y the cool

1173
00:48:49,533 --> 00:48:50,533
Yeah.

1174
00:48:49,861 --> 00:48:53,514
kid thing, you're right. He he also
changed the name of his company because

1175
00:48:53,514 --> 00:48:56,766
of his big bet on a thing that no one is
using,

1176
00:48:56,766 --> 00:48:58,418
the metaverse. It's not real.

1177
00:48:57,871 --> 00:48:58,871
Which

1178
00:48:59,752 --> 00:49:05,764
and which feels like the most like he
keeps trying to make big bet after big
bet,

1179
00:49:05,764 --> 00:49:11,276
hoping one of them pays off. It's like the
it's like the guy who either you know,

1180
00:49:11,276 --> 00:49:13,727
at the craps table or behind the lottery
tick,

1181
00:49:13,727 --> 00:49:16,178
he's like, This time I'm gonna hit it big.

1182
00:49:16,178 --> 00:49:19,170
And the thing is like you I don't feel bad
for him because he's filthy rich.

1183
00:49:19,170 --> 00:49:21,561
He owns an island in Hawaii, like he has
successful companies,

1184
00:49:21,561 --> 00:49:26,423
but I also get he's the things that he
built and have bought are

1185
00:49:26,423 --> 00:49:27,483
not the cool things.

1186
00:49:28,155 --> 00:49:31,133
And everyone's talking about AI right now
and no one's talking about meta

1187
00:49:31,133 --> 00:49:32,133
in that conversation.

1188
00:49:32,203 --> 00:49:37,268
Right. And it's because I mean Lama is
maybe a very capable frontier model.

1189
00:49:37,268 --> 00:49:38,839
That's great. And it's not open source.

1190
00:49:38,839 --> 00:49:41,592
It's open weight. There's a there's an
important difference between difference

1191
00:49:41,592 --> 00:49:45,495
there, right? But I think that you're yes,

1192
00:49:45,495 --> 00:49:47,717
the this is not Zuck's manifesto,

1193
00:49:47,717 --> 00:49:49,439
this is Zuck's complex. Right.

1194
00:49:49,439 --> 00:49:51,000
And it's like he

1195
00:49:49,739 --> 00:49:50,739
That's right.

1196
00:49:51,000 --> 00:49:52,722
just you're right, he doesn't want to feel
left out.

1197
00:49:52,722 --> 00:49:54,183
He's he's got the Hamilton complex.

1198
00:49:54,183 --> 00:49:55,525
He wants to be in the room where it
happens,

1199
00:49:55,525 --> 00:49:56,525
right?

1200
00:49:56,037 --> 00:49:57,037
Yes,

1201
00:49:57,100 --> 00:49:58,100
yes, said

1202
00:49:57,116 --> 00:49:58,116
And there was two

1203
00:49:57,816 --> 00:50:00,557
quotes right at the beginning that set the
stage for this.

1204
00:50:00,557 --> 00:50:04,808
He says, historically, hoping that an
absolute power will benevolent benevolent

1205
00:50:04,808 --> 00:50:09,549
benevolently provide for humanity if
sufficiently enlightened has not led

1206
00:50:09,549 --> 00:50:11,730
to safe or positive outcomes. Right?

1207
00:50:11,730 --> 00:50:15,361
Historically, hoping that an absolute
power will be good for us has not

1208
00:50:15,361 --> 00:50:17,692
led to safe outcomes. And then he says,

1209
00:50:17,692 --> 00:50:20,132
as everyone gains more powerful tools,

1210
00:50:20,132 --> 00:50:21,873
this is your super lawyer thing,

1211
00:50:21,873 --> 00:50:25,284
each person will become more capable of
shaping the future,

1212
00:50:25,284 --> 00:50:26,284
not less.

1213
00:50:26,538 --> 00:50:31,755
Has he met people? Do you want to give
everyone more powerful tools?

1214
00:50:31,755 --> 00:50:36,632
Because sometimes being more capable of
shaping the future is not a great thing.

1215
00:50:36,632 --> 00:50:41,559
Do you know what happens when people who
can afford infinity lawyers start hiring

1216
00:50:41,559 --> 00:50:43,641
lawyers? It's not a good thing.

1217
00:50:44,237 --> 00:50:49,859
Yeah. And he also has some awkward like
caveats where he says

1218
00:50:49,859 --> 00:50:51,639
we need to democratize you know,

1219
00:50:51,639 --> 00:50:53,710
AI needs to be in the hands of everyone.

1220
00:50:53,710 --> 00:50:56,971
But that's also gonna create questions of
like,

1221
00:50:56,971 --> 00:51:03,002
well, what laws and what systems do we
lean on as we build this personal

1222
00:51:03,002 --> 00:51:09,224
AI revolution? And he talks about mainly a
Western democratized version

1223
00:51:09,224 --> 00:51:11,454
of economy and government. And I like,

1224
00:51:11,454 --> 00:51:12,847
so

1225
00:51:13,711 --> 00:51:19,254
By everyone, you mean the West Because
those are just like and I don't even know

1226
00:51:19,254 --> 00:51:24,618
if he understands the weirdness of that
those kind of caveats that he's saying.

1227
00:51:24,618 --> 00:51:27,039
So that's why I wonder, like, maybe he did
write this,

1228
00:51:27,039 --> 00:51:29,230
because that's I don't know. I feel like a
PR person would like,

1229
00:51:29,230 --> 00:51:34,584
you know, you just kinda like dissed a
large You just you just slammed like half

1230
00:51:30,400 --> 00:51:33,017
You shouldn't say that out loud.

1231
00:51:33,017 --> 00:51:35,948
Yeah.

1232
00:51:34,584 --> 00:51:35,584
the globe

1233
00:51:35,965 --> 00:51:38,446
while you're trying to say you're making
this for the globe.

1234
00:51:38,446 --> 00:51:39,767
So okay.

1235
00:51:40,708 --> 00:51:42,970
And anyway, I'll just throw out a couple
details because we don't have

1236
00:51:42,970 --> 00:51:44,170
to spend too much time on this,

1237
00:51:44,170 --> 00:51:47,993
but he talks about the good that Meta is
doing.

1238
00:51:47,993 --> 00:51:52,316
And obviously, data centers are a huge
pain point right now here in the States.

1239
00:51:52,316 --> 00:51:55,918
And he talks about that Meta is building a
data center in Louisiana,

1240
00:51:55,918 --> 00:52:00,241
and teachers in that area received a fifty
thousand dollar bonus because

1241
00:52:00,241 --> 00:52:02,382
of the increased tax revenue from our
investment.

1242
00:52:02,382 --> 00:52:05,605
Gruber quoted that and linked to another
article.

1243
00:52:05,605 --> 00:52:09,027
Apparently that is real. Like teachers did
get a fifty thousand dollar bonus.

1244
00:52:09,463 --> 00:52:11,425
in that town because of the data center.

1245
00:52:11,425 --> 00:52:14,327
Great for those teachers. That's a tough
gig.

1246
00:52:14,327 --> 00:52:16,809
Underpaid, like more power to them.

1247
00:52:16,809 --> 00:52:19,631
I don't see how that's going to change
anybody's opinion on data centers

1248
00:52:19,631 --> 00:52:22,023
as a whole and whether they want it in
their backyard,

1249
00:52:22,023 --> 00:52:24,549
because they're not giving fifty thousand
dollars to every resident of this town.

1250
00:52:24,549 --> 00:52:26,400
They're giving it to the teachers of this
town.

1251
00:52:26,400 --> 00:52:27,868
So that's I don't know. Again,

1252
00:52:27,868 --> 00:52:32,682
feels like a weird justification kind of
like I don't know.

1253
00:52:32,682 --> 00:52:33,682
Whatever that is.

1254
00:52:33,504 --> 00:52:36,556
Well, no, what it is is a is a let's like
let's be clear.

1255
00:52:36,556 --> 00:52:41,539
It's just you find a sympathetic group of
h humans and you and you just it's

1256
00:52:41,539 --> 00:52:43,810
a bribe. I'm not saying that the teachers
were the people that made

1257
00:52:42,605 --> 00:52:45,333
It's right, right, right.

1258
00:52:43,810 --> 00:52:45,571
the decision about it, but like you find a
sympathetic

1259
00:52:45,571 --> 00:52:47,923
group of people, you give them a huge
amount of money,

1260
00:52:47,923 --> 00:52:51,054
and then it makes you look good so that
you can do this other thing.

1261
00:52:51,054 --> 00:52:53,676
Like this is that outcome great?

1262
00:52:53,676 --> 00:52:56,448
Sure. But let's just be clear about what's
happening here.

1263
00:52:56,448 --> 00:52:57,448
You're just gonna

1264
00:52:56,763 --> 00:52:57,763
Right, like

1265
00:52:57,268 --> 00:52:59,414
throw money at people to get them to do
what you want.

1266
00:52:59,414 --> 00:53:00,414
It's called a bribe.

1267
00:53:00,653 --> 00:53:03,185
It is thank you. That is what it's called.

1268
00:53:03,185 --> 00:53:06,988
And then he go even goes on to talk about
bioweapons,

1269
00:53:06,988 --> 00:53:11,352
cybersecurity. He talks about China and
how they're bringing online

1270
00:53:11,352 --> 00:53:14,814
one gigawatt plus of nuclear capacity
every other week.

1271
00:53:14,814 --> 00:53:17,296
The US needs to catch up in the
development.

1272
00:53:17,296 --> 00:53:22,801
That the American government needs to
allow AI companies to run and not

1273
00:53:22,823 --> 00:53:26,634
h hold them back. Otherwise we won't be
competitive on the global scale when

1274
00:53:26,634 --> 00:53:30,137
it comes to AI models. And which

1275
00:53:30,723 --> 00:53:33,644
Not surprising, he's very
pro-distillation.

1276
00:53:33,644 --> 00:53:39,427
He said, you know, we need to allow
companies to distill from each other.

1277
00:53:39,427 --> 00:53:42,529
And to ~ I think a fair point,

1278
00:53:42,529 --> 00:53:45,881
AI is was learned from all of human
knowledge.

1279
00:53:45,881 --> 00:53:50,383
Like it was distilled from the the raw
material of what humans have done

1280
00:53:50,383 --> 00:53:54,345
for hundreds of years. And so we should be
able to distill other models.

1281
00:53:54,345 --> 00:53:57,470
But again, it's because he wants his
models to be good too.

1282
00:53:57,470 --> 00:53:59,818
So he's like, I would love to distill from
fable.

1283
00:54:00,118 --> 00:54:01,649
and soul five point six or whatever.

1284
00:54:01,649 --> 00:54:06,973
And so anyway. And then his final promise
is we will build a fully private mode

1285
00:54:06,973 --> 00:54:10,365
where even Meta cannot see or grant access
to your information.

1286
00:54:10,365 --> 00:54:14,288
Hard sell on that, Meta. I don't know if I
believe that.

1287
00:54:14,288 --> 00:54:18,131
And that he says open source is a positive
and important force

1288
00:54:18,131 --> 00:54:23,034
for empowering people. Again, it just
feels like he is wanting things that would

1289
00:54:23,034 --> 00:54:24,955
benefit him and Meta in general,

1290
00:54:24,955 --> 00:54:27,007
like being able to distill other models,

1291
00:54:27,007 --> 00:54:28,378
claim things are open source,

1292
00:54:28,824 --> 00:54:31,908
not have centralized power among anthropic
and open AI,

1293
00:54:31,908 --> 00:54:33,659
although he never mentions them in this
article.

1294
00:54:33,659 --> 00:54:36,933
And so he can be part of this whole thing.

1295
00:54:36,933 --> 00:54:39,326
And it's just I don't know. It fell very
well.

1296
00:54:39,830 --> 00:54:43,433
Well yeah, and it's the whole point,

1297
00:54:43,433 --> 00:54:45,215
it's just important to remember this,

1298
00:54:45,215 --> 00:54:49,439
is that w what Mark Zuckerberg is afraid
of,

1299
00:54:49,439 --> 00:54:54,824
one, there is the I want to be a part of
the cool thing and I cannot beat these

1300
00:54:54,824 --> 00:54:56,686
companies and I need them to not win.

1301
00:54:56,686 --> 00:55:01,651
And two, he needs them to not win because
it is an existential threat threat

1302
00:55:01,651 --> 00:55:04,633
to his business. Right? He even s talks
about like

1303
00:55:05,314 --> 00:55:06,915
He doesn't say this outright, but it's
like,

1304
00:55:06,915 --> 00:55:10,857
yeah, these other guys, their j their goal
is to essentially replace workers.

1305
00:55:10,857 --> 00:55:14,757
But what we want to do is turn everyone
into an entrepreneur by giving them these

1306
00:55:14,757 --> 00:55:18,422
like it's like, I mean, I don't think any
of either of these things are

1307
00:55:18,742 --> 00:55:23,795
are gonna be the case because just bec
just what it what exactly kind

1308
00:55:23,795 --> 00:55:27,527
of an entrepreneur do you want just
generating AI slap videos to put into your
feed

1309
00:55:27,527 --> 00:55:29,959
so that more people will watch them so you
can sell more ads?

1310
00:55:29,959 --> 00:55:32,200
Like let's just be clear about what we're
actually talking about.

1311
00:55:32,536 --> 00:55:35,361
Yeah. Yeah. So anyway, that was his
manifesto.

1312
00:55:35,361 --> 00:55:36,513
You don't have to read it everybody.

1313
00:55:36,513 --> 00:55:38,226
We we we tried to sum it up for you,

1314
00:55:38,226 --> 00:55:39,226
so but we'll

1315
00:55:38,646 --> 00:55:39,646
We didn't do a

1316
00:55:39,247 --> 00:55:41,934
very good job, but that's because it's a ~

1317
00:55:41,851 --> 00:55:44,212
It's hard to summarize. He said a lot of
words.

1318
00:55:42,616 --> 00:55:44,360
it's yeah. It's

1319
00:55:44,360 --> 00:55:45,360
a lot of words.

1320
00:55:45,312 --> 00:55:46,323
We'll link it in the show notes.

1321
00:55:46,323 --> 00:55:48,944
~ but I I'm gonna skip a go things because
I do want to get

1322
00:55:48,944 --> 00:55:53,695
to the anthropic watermarking text that it
generates.

1323
00:55:53,695 --> 00:55:57,537
And I will link to one, an article from
The Economist,

1324
00:55:57,537 --> 00:56:02,058
which I saw Gruber link to. They did this
huge study on how to spot AI writing.

1325
00:56:02,058 --> 00:56:05,350
And they tested ChatGPT, Claude,

1326
00:56:05,350 --> 00:56:09,941
Gemini, and Grok. They had it write
versions of articles and they compared

1327
00:56:09,941 --> 00:56:11,492
it to actual human writing.

1328
00:56:12,126 --> 00:56:14,838
And they've had some surprising findings.

1329
00:56:14,838 --> 00:56:15,999
I'll just read one poll quote.

1330
00:56:15,999 --> 00:56:17,980
It says Our findings are surprising.

1331
00:56:17,980 --> 00:56:22,153
AI prose is distinguishable by word and
punctuation choice,

1332
00:56:22,153 --> 00:56:24,855
as well as sentence and paragraph
structure,

1333
00:56:24,855 --> 00:56:27,056
but its hallmarks are not what you might
expect,

1334
00:56:27,056 --> 00:56:30,078
partly because its writing style has
changed with the updates.

1335
00:56:30,078 --> 00:56:33,160
That does not mean that LLMs are great
writers.

1336
00:56:33,160 --> 00:56:37,864
Their prose lacks lucidity and elegance
and is often formulaic.

1337
00:56:37,864 --> 00:56:41,156
So those aspiring to be impressive human
storytellers

1338
00:56:41,466 --> 00:56:44,508
should avoid the following peculiarities
in their own prose.

1339
00:56:44,508 --> 00:56:47,189
I think I have yet to read this whole
study.

1340
00:56:47,189 --> 00:56:51,431
It is behind the Economist. You have to do
like a free trial if you want to read it.

1341
00:56:51,431 --> 00:56:53,913
The gift link ~ expired already.

1342
00:56:53,913 --> 00:56:58,205
But I'm very curious fascinating that they
did this study and I think

1343
00:56:58,205 --> 00:57:03,958
to no surprise, there is formulas to how
AI writes content and text.

1344
00:57:03,958 --> 00:57:09,221
And so that in light of because of
pressure from the EU,

1345
00:57:09,221 --> 00:57:11,142
Anthropic is introducing

1346
00:57:11,634 --> 00:57:17,639
A text watermarking to all text generated
by Claude.

1347
00:57:17,639 --> 00:57:22,964
And so it's saying that new models will
mark AI generated content from day one.

1348
00:57:22,964 --> 00:57:28,548
Claude models launched in the EU on or
after August 2nd will support machine

1349
00:57:28,548 --> 00:57:34,734
readable marking at launch. So this sounds
like the older models or models that have

1350
00:57:34,734 --> 00:57:37,006
already existed, they're still working on
them the marking,

1351
00:57:37,006 --> 00:57:39,798
but any new models going forward will have
this from day one.

1352
00:57:40,269 --> 00:57:44,641
Old models, it's coming soon. And this
watermarking that Claude is going

1353
00:57:44,641 --> 00:57:47,503
to use will apply to all output,

1354
00:57:47,503 --> 00:57:49,504
whether you're using the Claude app,

1355
00:57:49,504 --> 00:57:52,685
Claude Code, Cowork, or even the API,

1356
00:57:52,685 --> 00:57:55,497
which made me think, just curious.

1357
00:57:55,497 --> 00:57:59,209
Like I have a bunch of shortcuts that use
the Anthropic API to

1358
00:57:59,209 --> 00:58:00,669
do things like summarize stuff.

1359
00:58:00,669 --> 00:58:05,352
I am very curious. Like, is that text
watermarked coming through my shortcuts?

1360
00:58:05,352 --> 00:58:07,383
I thought that was very curious.

1361
00:58:07,383 --> 00:58:09,534
And I it seems like the answer is yes.

1362
00:58:09,826 --> 00:58:11,907
according to this Claude support article.

1363
00:58:11,907 --> 00:58:15,029
They're also going to help users detect
Claude marks.

1364
00:58:15,029 --> 00:58:18,371
And they say that existing models are in
progress of being watermarked.

1365
00:58:18,371 --> 00:58:25,325
And the they specify like detecting a
Claude watermark tells

1366
00:58:25,325 --> 00:58:28,036
you that the content may have been
processed by Claude,

1367
00:58:28,036 --> 00:58:31,258
but it doesn't confirm whether it was
fully generated,

1368
00:58:31,258 --> 00:58:33,069
whether it just went through Claude.

1369
00:58:33,069 --> 00:58:37,621
Like for instance, if you write a
newsletter and you just ask Claude

1370
00:58:37,621 --> 00:58:38,692
to proofread it,

1371
00:58:39,414 --> 00:58:44,666
It will mark it. And someone on the
receiving end might have tools from Claude

1372
00:58:44,666 --> 00:58:48,557
to see that it is watermarked and could
assume that you just generated this

1373
00:58:48,557 --> 00:58:53,038
newsletter, but it's you have to
understand,

1374
00:58:53,038 --> 00:58:57,259
like it might just be that someone used it
to proofread or you know,

1375
00:58:57,259 --> 00:58:59,120
process some small part of the text.

1376
00:58:59,120 --> 00:59:02,901
So I find this interesting. Like we've
talked about on this show,

1377
00:59:02,901 --> 00:59:06,362
we do need tools, especially when it comes
to photo.

1378
00:59:06,788 --> 00:59:10,620
video and audio generation that when
something is AI generated.

1379
00:59:10,620 --> 00:59:12,501
And while Spotify is trying to kill
podcasts,

1380
00:59:12,501 --> 00:59:15,213
it's also going to do things to try and
label AI music,

1381
00:59:15,213 --> 00:59:16,213
which I'll get to in a minute.

1382
00:59:16,183 --> 00:59:20,866
But I find this fas is the first time that
I've seen like a text marked,

1383
00:59:20,866 --> 00:59:25,458
a watermark on text. It's still like I
it's hard for me to wrap my mind around
like

1384
00:59:25,458 --> 00:59:30,531
what exactly this is. Is this like
markings on the literal pixels of

1385
00:59:30,531 --> 00:59:34,623
the text that's generated? Is it hidden
metadata behind like I'm

1386
00:59:34,623 --> 00:59:36,134
not exactly sure what it is.

1387
00:59:36,846 --> 00:59:40,589
But it means that whether you just process
or proofread with Claude,

1388
00:59:40,589 --> 00:59:45,283
your content might be marked as AI not
generated,

1389
00:59:45,283 --> 00:59:47,696
but just watermarked that Claude had
something to do with it.

1390
00:59:47,696 --> 00:59:48,837
What what are your thoughts on this?

1391
00:59:48,837 --> 00:59:49,837
I mean you're

1392
00:59:49,662 --> 00:59:52,905
Yeah, a couple of things. I d
congratulations,

1393
00:59:52,905 --> 00:59:55,357
EU, you get to regulate tech across the
world.

1394
00:59:55,357 --> 00:59:57,388
This is what you wanted. So good job.

1395
00:59:57,388 --> 01:00:02,252
Nice nice work. You you know, and so in
his daily update,

1396
01:00:02,252 --> 01:00:06,025
Ben Thompson I this is like the fourth
time w we should get a

1397
01:00:06,025 --> 01:00:08,087
cut of every subscription to Stratekery.

1398
01:00:08,087 --> 01:00:10,219
So ~ the

1399
01:00:11,755 --> 01:00:12,755
Sure.

1400
01:00:12,561 --> 01:00:16,944
anyway, he explains sort of how this
works.

1401
01:00:16,944 --> 01:00:17,944
No well

1402
01:00:17,324 --> 01:00:18,324
Okay.

1403
01:00:17,715 --> 01:00:19,286
no, he explains a his

1404
01:00:19,446 --> 01:00:21,117
how he thinks it works, right?

1405
01:00:20,854 --> 01:00:21,854
Right, right.

1406
01:00:21,117 --> 01:00:22,178
And

1407
01:00:22,178 --> 01:00:26,131
'cause and it has to do with tokens and it
has to do with like lists

1408
01:00:26,131 --> 01:00:31,194
of tokens of how like different things
work and how instead

1409
01:00:31,194 --> 01:00:33,355
of being purely probabilistic,

1410
01:00:33,355 --> 01:00:36,818
the generation becomes somewhat
deterministic in that it chooses from

1411
01:00:36,818 --> 01:00:39,960
a green list more often than it chooses
randomly between the two lists.

1412
01:00:39,960 --> 01:00:44,563
And that somehow that that's detectable by
other tools that are like right.

1413
01:00:44,563 --> 01:00:47,895
Like it's it's it doesn't it supposedly
doesn't change the output,

1414
01:00:47,895 --> 01:00:48,895
but it actually

1415
01:00:49,154 --> 01:00:51,636
Kind of does because of like what you were
just saying,

1416
01:00:51,636 --> 01:00:53,806
like word structure, sentence structure
and stuff.

1417
01:00:53,806 --> 01:00:56,830
So I think it's the reason that this
survives things like copy paste,

1418
01:00:56,830 --> 01:01:00,053
whatever, is it's actually the structure
of the output.

1419
01:01:00,053 --> 01:01:03,216
This is what he says. He says Claude
doesn't explain how watermarking would
work

1420
01:01:03,216 --> 01:01:07,239
beyond that. But the general concept for
text watermarking is described

1421
01:01:07,239 --> 01:01:11,542
in a white paper. In brief, LLMs don't
produce the next token
determinalistically.

1422
01:01:11,542 --> 01:01:15,746
The the model produces a probability
distribution over possible next tokens

1423
01:01:15,746 --> 01:01:18,158
and one is selected with some degree of
randomness.

1424
01:01:18,391 --> 01:01:21,883
the watermark uses a keyed hash to
classify all of those tokens into

1425
01:01:21,883 --> 01:01:24,835
a green list and a red list. And the green
list gets a slight boost

1426
01:01:24,855 --> 01:01:27,837
to its probabil probability, I cannot talk
today,

1427
01:01:27,837 --> 01:01:32,060
of being picked. What that means is that
while an unmark watermarked output would

1428
01:01:32,060 --> 01:01:34,982
choose from the green list and the red
list roughly equally,

1429
01:01:34,982 --> 01:01:39,915
the watermarked output would have a
statistically meaningfully higher
percentage

1430
01:01:39,915 --> 01:01:41,116
of tokens from the green list.

1431
01:01:41,116 --> 01:01:42,346
So there's some like

1432
01:01:42,168 --> 01:01:43,168
Okay.

1433
01:01:42,607 --> 01:01:45,418
it's like a code built into the the
writing,

1434
01:01:45,418 --> 01:01:47,070
literally, but the the problem

1435
01:01:46,351 --> 01:01:47,351
Interesting.

1436
01:01:47,070 --> 01:01:48,070
here is like

1437
01:01:48,744 --> 01:01:51,235
If you're using it for things like
proofing,

1438
01:01:51,640 --> 01:01:52,640
Right.

1439
01:01:52,056 --> 01:01:54,937
that is not the same as if you just
generated text.

1440
01:01:54,937 --> 01:02:01,527
Also, I feel like d AI generated text is
significantly less problematic than

1441
01:02:01,527 --> 01:02:03,342
AI generated video and photos.

1442
01:02:04,565 --> 01:02:09,128
It's less press problematic at scale,

1443
01:02:09,128 --> 01:02:13,190
maybe, but when it's passed as human
writing,

1444
01:02:13,190 --> 01:02:18,443
I think it's problematic and it's easier
to pass it as human writing to most
people.

1445
01:02:18,806 --> 01:02:24,031
But the the the problem with AI generated
text past as human writing

1446
01:02:24,031 --> 01:02:28,335
is different than the problem of AI
generated videos and photos past as real,

1447
01:02:28,335 --> 01:02:31,978
because an AI generated photo and an AI
generated video is being passed

1448
01:02:31,978 --> 01:02:35,081
off as though it is a real capture of a
real thing that happened.

1449
01:02:35,081 --> 01:02:38,043
And anytime you read text about a thing,

1450
01:02:38,043 --> 01:02:40,175
you're one level removed from it,

1451
01:02:40,175 --> 01:02:44,229
right? AI generated fiction, like stories,

1452
01:02:43,289 --> 01:02:44,289
Sure.

1453
01:02:44,509 --> 01:02:45,509
fine.

1454
01:02:45,462 --> 01:02:48,145
The fact that it wasn't generated by a
human might mean that it's

1455
01:02:48,145 --> 01:02:50,627
not an interesting story, it might mean
that it's not a good story,

1456
01:02:50,627 --> 01:02:53,920
it might mean that someone is just using
AI to generate their

1457
01:02:53,920 --> 01:02:55,282
own version of Gulliver's travels,

1458
01:02:55,282 --> 01:02:58,845
like whatever. Like that's different
though than I post a photograph

1459
01:02:58,845 --> 01:03:01,588
of Steven breaking into the back of my car
and stealing my walk.

1460
01:03:02,487 --> 01:03:04,399
Which I did in fact do. The

1461
01:03:03,647 --> 01:03:04,647
Yes, twice.

1462
01:03:04,939 --> 01:03:10,204
So like my my initial concern was the way
I use ALLMs,

1463
01:03:10,204 --> 01:03:12,306
like when I make a YouTube video,

1464
01:03:12,306 --> 01:03:15,649
I don't use AI until the end of the
process.

1465
01:03:15,649 --> 01:03:19,432
I give it my transcript and I ask it for
title and description ideas.

1466
01:03:19,432 --> 01:03:22,495
I A B title test pretty much every video.

1467
01:03:22,495 --> 01:03:26,178
I usually have some titles that I
brainstormed throughout the process.

1468
01:03:26,178 --> 01:03:28,941
I'll use one or two of those. I'll ask
Claude

1469
01:03:29,882 --> 01:03:33,495
For some other title ideas, and sometimes
I'll just copy and paste one in

1470
01:03:33,495 --> 01:03:37,008
the A B test. Sometimes I'll copy one and
change a word or two.

1471
01:03:37,008 --> 01:03:42,092
And so does that mean once this
watermarking is live in all the models,

1472
01:03:42,092 --> 01:03:47,496
will YouTube think that my content is AI
generated?

1473
01:03:47,496 --> 01:03:52,981
Because Anthropic admits in this sport
article that it is not to assume that even

1474
01:03:52,981 --> 01:03:56,494
if something has the watermark that it's
wholly generated,

1475
01:03:56,494 --> 01:03:58,062
but we can't like

1476
01:03:58,435 --> 01:04:03,639
tell you that. Like it won't be
immediately available that this

1477
01:04:03,639 --> 01:04:07,201
was either completely AI generated or this
was processed by AI.

1478
01:04:07,201 --> 01:04:09,873
That that distinction does not exist in
this first iteration.

1479
01:04:09,873 --> 01:04:12,915
So all that to say, me personally,

1480
01:04:12,915 --> 01:04:15,456
I'm probably gonna not copy and paste
stuff anymore.

1481
01:04:15,456 --> 01:04:20,140
Even just simple things like titles for my
YouTube videos.

1482
01:04:20,140 --> 01:04:24,392
I will probably just just literally type
the few words I might see

1483
01:04:24,392 --> 01:04:27,625
in Claude because it feels like I don't
know.

1484
01:04:27,625 --> 01:04:28,625
I don't know.

1485
01:04:28,545 --> 01:04:31,749
I d it it's I'm glad that there's a system
for it,

1486
01:04:31,749 --> 01:04:36,125
but I also I don't know, I've just been
thinking about the Hank Green thing that

1487
01:04:36,125 --> 01:04:39,330
we talked about last week. I listened to a
whole Colin and Samir episode about it.

1488
01:04:39,330 --> 01:04:41,042
I'm gonna link it in top five tech
tomorrow,

1489
01:04:41,042 --> 01:04:45,628
but I don't know. I think people getting a
little weird about stuff.

1490
01:04:45,628 --> 01:04:46,628
That's all.

1491
01:04:46,784 --> 01:04:52,988
Yeah, I just think I understand the the
reasoning behind it.

1492
01:04:52,988 --> 01:04:58,051
The the the thing is is it there's a
difference of what is useful to know

1493
01:04:58,051 --> 01:05:03,704
is AI generated. And I I use AI to I use
like ChatGPT and Claude to proof things

1494
01:05:03,704 --> 01:05:06,145
for me. I use it to fact check things for
me.

1495
01:05:06,145 --> 01:05:09,647
But when I do that, like I've written
something over here,

1496
01:05:09,647 --> 01:05:13,450
I put it in and I say fact check this and
it gives me back information.

1497
01:05:13,450 --> 01:05:14,450
I'm not just

1498
01:05:14,624 --> 01:05:16,317
than publishing that. I'm using it.

1499
01:05:16,161 --> 01:05:17,161
Right.

1500
01:05:16,317 --> 01:05:17,317
So like

1501
01:05:16,638 --> 01:05:18,500
that's fine. That's not gonna be
watermarked.

1502
01:05:18,500 --> 01:05:21,736
Right. But it's it's it's just kind of
like it's weird.

1503
01:05:21,736 --> 01:05:23,158
I don't know. I don't know how I feel
about it,

1504
01:05:23,158 --> 01:05:26,684
except for I don't think that the EU
should be determining how people

1505
01:05:26,684 --> 01:05:28,877
use these tools in this in this way.

1506
01:05:29,793 --> 01:05:32,959
Well, yeah, and it's not necessarily how
you use it,

1507
01:05:32,959 --> 01:05:34,621
but how the tool marks itself,

1508
01:05:34,621 --> 01:05:36,425
I guess. So

1509
01:05:36,576 --> 01:05:40,776
Right, but the the tool marking itself is
not distinguishing between

1510
01:05:40,776 --> 01:05:41,776
how you're using it.

1511
01:05:42,444 --> 01:05:45,295
Right. And that's that's I think the core
the core crux of it.

1512
01:05:45,295 --> 01:05:47,697
And I just I I think I'm pretty clear.

1513
01:05:47,697 --> 01:05:50,138
I mean, I talk pretty openly about what I
use AI for,

1514
01:05:50,138 --> 01:05:52,679
like I just said, like giving me title and
description ideas.

1515
01:05:52,679 --> 01:05:58,431
And I don't want I've I do feel like
people's you know,

1516
01:05:58,431 --> 01:06:00,383
the the internet is always polarizing.

1517
01:06:00,383 --> 01:06:03,945
And so and just seeing what happened to
Hank Green,

1518
01:06:03,945 --> 01:06:07,847
it's like, we're gonna put him in this box
because he apparently used Chat

1519
01:06:07,847 --> 01:06:10,478
GPT for something. And I think there was
confusion about how much

1520
01:06:10,478 --> 01:06:11,478
he actually used AI

1521
01:06:11,661 --> 01:06:14,262
to create his content, but people still
jumped on him and it was like,

1522
01:06:14,262 --> 01:06:16,504
Sheesh. And I understand the
consternation.

1523
01:06:16,504 --> 01:06:22,777
Like I totally get if you what if you read
articles that someone

1524
01:06:22,777 --> 01:06:27,459
was writing for months to years and then
found out that seventy percent

1525
01:06:27,459 --> 01:06:28,890
of their writing was AI generated,

1526
01:06:28,890 --> 01:06:30,391
that would feel like a betrayal.

1527
01:06:30,391 --> 01:06:35,074
I totally get that. And I just don't I
don't want to do anything that might

1528
01:06:35,414 --> 01:06:37,095
instigate the feeling of betrayal,

1529
01:06:37,095 --> 01:06:40,737
even if it's not really n like applicable.

1530
01:06:40,737 --> 01:06:41,737
So

1531
01:06:41,497 --> 01:06:44,529
I don't know. I'm just thinking about how
I might change my habits using that stuff

1532
01:06:44,529 --> 01:06:45,759
going forward. And maybe that's a good
thing.

1533
01:06:45,759 --> 01:06:48,741
I don't know. That's claude. Text
watermarking.

1534
01:06:48,741 --> 01:06:51,182
All right. I wanted to I keep mentioning
the Spotify thing.

1535
01:06:51,182 --> 01:06:53,253
This is a great article from Pod News.

1536
01:06:53,253 --> 01:06:57,246
James Cridland, a friend of Metam at many
podcast movement conferences.

1537
01:06:57,246 --> 01:07:01,228
Spotify is testing a feature in its app.

1538
01:07:01,228 --> 01:07:03,499
It's called the Skip Ahead feature,

1539
01:07:03,499 --> 01:07:10,233
available to premium Spotify users that
will allow you to skip ads in podcasts.

1540
01:07:11,005 --> 01:07:15,086
And even skip over things like membership
plugs.

1541
01:07:15,086 --> 01:07:17,387
So like what I just did earlier in this
episode,

1542
01:07:17,387 --> 01:07:21,438
talking about how you could support the
show and you can get an ad free version

1543
01:07:21,438 --> 01:07:24,989
and all that. This tool from Spotify would
skip even that stuff.

1544
01:07:24,989 --> 01:07:29,470
And allowing Spotify users just to like
totally skip over all the things.

1545
01:07:29,470 --> 01:07:34,752
And Spotify is a large player in the
podcast game as far as how many people use
it.

1546
01:07:34,752 --> 01:07:39,673
Like people use YouTube, and there is
YouTube does have like jump ahead.

1547
01:07:40,065 --> 01:07:41,766
As far as like when an ad starts,

1548
01:07:41,766 --> 01:07:45,028
sometimes you'll see the jump ahead button
show up on the player,

1549
01:07:45,028 --> 01:07:49,371
and it's basically skipping the ad because
it is following the behavior

1550
01:07:49,371 --> 01:07:53,464
of all the viewers before it and assuming
that people jump ahead during this part

1551
01:07:53,464 --> 01:07:55,235
and you can jump forward and skip the ad.

1552
01:07:55,235 --> 01:07:59,718
But this feature specifically built in to
skip ads,

1553
01:07:59,718 --> 01:08:02,399
to even skip the membership plugs,

1554
01:08:02,399 --> 01:08:08,834
feels like ~ you must really not care
about how podcasters make money because
this

1555
01:08:08,834 --> 01:08:09,834
is

1556
01:08:09,420 --> 01:08:14,151
Bypassing all of that. And now our
audience on Spotify is very small.

1557
01:08:14,151 --> 01:08:18,582
A majority of our audience is on Apple
Podcasts and then Overcast and then
YouTube.

1558
01:08:18,582 --> 01:08:20,743
So this is not something that would affect
us specifically,

1559
01:08:20,743 --> 01:08:24,584
but there are some shows where Spotify is
the main one,

1560
01:08:24,584 --> 01:08:26,925
especially like more cross platform shows.

1561
01:08:26,925 --> 01:08:29,986
Spotify had the deal exclusive deals for a
long time,

1562
01:08:29,986 --> 01:08:31,486
and so a lot of people moved to Spotify,

1563
01:08:31,486 --> 01:08:35,627
like once the Joe Rogan show was and Call
Her Daddy was on Spotify exclusively

1564
01:08:35,627 --> 01:08:38,678
for a long time. And a a button that just
by

1565
01:08:39,084 --> 01:08:43,513
default just lets you skip all the
advertising and also the membership
please.

1566
01:08:43,513 --> 01:08:48,322
That doesn't feel great and feels a little
bit anti podcast landscape,

1567
01:08:48,322 --> 01:08:50,587
anti podcast creator kind of thing.

1568
01:08:50,587 --> 01:08:51,587
So

1569
01:08:51,168 --> 01:08:52,168
Yeah,

1570
01:08:51,468 --> 01:08:54,761
and I mean, just to be clear, I know it's
like you're listening to guys

1571
01:08:54,781 --> 01:08:57,553
on a podcast talk complaining about
someone trying to make it harder

1572
01:08:57,553 --> 01:09:00,336
to make money podcasting. I understand
that like fine,

1573
01:09:00,336 --> 01:09:02,087
we're not trying to just be navel gazing
here.

1574
01:09:02,087 --> 01:09:05,650
I do think it's like worthwhile just
mentioning that what's there

1575
01:09:05,650 --> 01:09:10,504
is a inherent conflict between what's
great for the user who doesn't want

1576
01:09:10,504 --> 01:09:13,647
to listen to ads and great for the person
making the content that they

1577
01:09:13,647 --> 01:09:15,919
do want to listen to. There is a tension
there.

1578
01:09:15,919 --> 01:09:19,872
And unless every podcast is going to
become paid.

1579
01:09:20,321 --> 01:09:21,812
You only get to listen to it if you pay
for it.

1580
01:09:21,812 --> 01:09:23,973
Ads are going to be a part of that,

1581
01:09:23,973 --> 01:09:26,115
right? And we like we have ads on our
show.

1582
01:09:26,115 --> 01:09:29,097
We don't make a ton of money on on ads.

1583
01:09:29,097 --> 01:09:31,969
That's just the only way to monetize this,

1584
01:09:31,969 --> 01:09:34,941
other than our members. Now, if all of you
listening want to become members,

1585
01:09:34,941 --> 01:09:37,442
we'll just stop doing ads. That's great.

1586
01:09:36,056 --> 01:09:37,470
Right? Sir.

1587
01:09:37,442 --> 01:09:38,442
If if

1588
01:09:37,943 --> 01:09:39,644
we have zero downloads that are not
members,

1589
01:09:39,644 --> 01:09:40,955
there's no reason for us to do ads.

1590
01:09:40,955 --> 01:09:41,955
That's totally fine.

1591
01:09:41,356 --> 01:09:42,356
Right. Right.

1592
01:09:42,506 --> 01:09:47,789
I think that I just think that Spotify
should not be putting itself in that
position

1593
01:09:48,396 --> 01:09:49,396
Yeah.

1594
01:09:48,710 --> 01:09:49,710
to

1595
01:09:48,970 --> 01:09:49,970
do that.

1596
01:09:50,060 --> 01:09:52,795
Correct. That it would be and yeah,

1597
01:09:52,795 --> 01:09:55,300
it would be like as if YouTube would
introduce a feature like this.

1598
01:09:55,300 --> 01:09:56,893
That would be terrible.

1599
01:09:56,982 --> 01:09:58,233
Well, because d and the reason

1600
01:09:58,233 --> 01:10:02,556
I say that is Spotify benefits from we
give Spotify our content for free.

1601
01:10:02,556 --> 01:10:03,556
They don't pay us

1602
01:10:03,041 --> 01:10:04,041
Right.

1603
01:10:03,487 --> 01:10:06,489
to let you listen to this show in their
app.

1604
01:10:06,489 --> 01:10:10,833
We are giving that to them for free and
they are monetizing

1605
01:10:10,833 --> 01:10:15,336
it through subscriptions. And then w the
people who pay them for that subscription,

1606
01:10:15,336 --> 01:10:19,469
they are going to give those people the
ability to skip the thing that monetizes

1607
01:10:19,469 --> 01:10:22,982
this show, but they will not be sharing
any of that subscription with us.

1608
01:10:23,272 --> 01:10:27,933
Exact exactly. That. And that's the
differen like YouTube,

1609
01:10:27,933 --> 01:10:29,094
which we'll talk about in a second.

1610
01:10:29,094 --> 01:10:32,995
Like YouTube premium allows you to not
have the YouTube ads,

1611
01:10:32,995 --> 01:10:36,175
but creators get paid from that.

1612
01:10:36,175 --> 01:10:40,137
And actually get paid a little more from
premium subscribers viewing their content

1613
01:10:40,137 --> 01:10:44,688
than the ads anyway. And like that is how
you do that system right.

1614
01:10:44,688 --> 01:10:48,999
That's how you do it both for the user's
experience and for the creator.

1615
01:10:48,999 --> 01:10:52,610
So that's so that's a thing. But on

1616
01:10:52,790 --> 01:10:56,891
The complete opposite side, Spotify is
also introducing tools that

1617
01:10:56,891 --> 01:11:00,592
are going to label AI music, which is very
necessary.

1618
01:11:00,592 --> 01:11:04,023
And I talked to my oldest son and he'll
use Spotify and he's like,

1619
01:11:04,023 --> 01:11:08,334
Man, I just get these playlists and
there's just a ton of AI generated music

1620
01:11:08,334 --> 01:11:10,555
in there. And like it's very clear it's AI
generated.

1621
01:11:10,555 --> 01:11:12,425
It's just not labeled as such.

1622
01:11:12,425 --> 01:11:16,727
And so Spotify is going to introduce AI
persona labels.

1623
01:11:16,727 --> 01:11:19,847
So if an entire artist only produces
AI-generated music,

1624
01:11:19,847 --> 01:11:21,788
you'll see that AI persona label.

1625
01:11:22,209 --> 01:11:25,110
And also in playlists and on tracks and in
search,

1626
01:11:25,110 --> 01:11:27,811
they're going to label AI generated
content.

1627
01:11:27,811 --> 01:11:32,333
Artists could appeal if somehow it's
labeled incorrectly.

1628
01:11:32,333 --> 01:11:37,675
But for as bad as the the podcast ad
skipping feature would be,

1629
01:11:37,675 --> 01:11:41,396
kudos to Spotify for this feature because
I do think this is needed.

1630
01:11:41,396 --> 01:11:42,747
And like, yeah, let's be clear,

1631
01:11:42,747 --> 01:11:46,888
AI generated. I know that almost feels
antithetical to I was just talking about

1632
01:11:46,888 --> 01:11:49,239
the text watermarking and I have mixed
feelings about that.

1633
01:11:49,239 --> 01:11:51,320
But for this I don't know

1634
01:11:51,776 --> 01:11:54,589
I don't know, I can Yeah.

1635
01:11:51,852 --> 01:11:54,734
Well, there's a there's a there's a degree
here because what

1636
01:11:54,734 --> 01:12:00,319
we're saying is that if you ran your text
through Claude and you asked

1637
01:12:00,319 --> 01:12:03,542
it to correct all your grammar or your
typos or whatever.

1638
01:12:03,542 --> 01:12:06,454
You created all the content, you're just
asking it to do that piece,

1639
01:12:06,454 --> 01:12:08,636
it's gonna get labeled as AI. Right?

1640
01:12:08,342 --> 01:12:09,342
Right.

1641
01:12:08,736 --> 01:12:12,360
That's different than I just had Suno make
a song and I uploaded it

1642
01:12:12,360 --> 01:12:14,241
to Spotify and I'm gonna collect
royalties.

1643
01:12:14,241 --> 01:12:16,372
I don't think those two things are the
same.

1644
01:12:14,998 --> 01:12:17,295
Right. Yes.

1645
01:12:16,372 --> 01:12:17,372
I don't think it's like

1646
01:12:17,604 --> 01:12:20,076
contradictory to s hold both of those
beliefs.

1647
01:12:20,258 --> 01:12:22,069
Thank thank you, Jason. Thank you.

1648
01:12:22,198 --> 01:12:26,549
Right. As opposed to if AI if Spotify was
marking like you're an indie artist

1649
01:12:26,549 --> 01:12:30,551
and you were just using AI to create a
drum loop and they mark that as AI,

1650
01:12:30,551 --> 01:12:32,600
then I feel like that's that's a little
bit different because like,

1651
01:12:32,600 --> 01:12:34,722
no, this is a real person, this is a real
artist,

1652
01:12:34,156 --> 01:12:35,432
Right. Right, right, right.

1653
01:12:34,722 --> 01:12:35,722
they really

1654
01:12:35,633 --> 01:12:41,244
r made this song, they just needed to use
like in logic the whatever

1655
01:12:41,244 --> 01:12:43,425
fe thing that would generate a drum loop
for

1656
01:12:43,382 --> 01:12:44,392
Right, right, right, right, right,

1657
01:12:43,425 --> 01:12:44,696
you. That's I feel

1658
01:12:44,392 --> 01:12:45,392
right.

1659
01:12:44,696 --> 01:12:45,916
like that's different.

1660
01:12:46,175 --> 01:12:47,747
I think it's different too. I think it's
different too.

1661
01:12:47,747 --> 01:12:48,747
You know it when you see it.

1662
01:12:50,475 --> 01:12:51,475
Or hear it.

1663
01:12:51,220 --> 01:12:54,938
or hear it. OpenAI says they had a really
powerful model and it's putting

1664
01:12:54,938 --> 01:12:58,088
the brakes on it because it has critical
cybersecurity capabilities.

1665
01:12:58,088 --> 01:12:59,789
Just wanna point this up because hey
again,

1666
01:12:59,789 --> 01:13:04,995
let's just n let's not. Let's just not
have the velociraptors while stop.

1667
01:13:02,722 --> 01:13:04,525
Stop breeding the Velociraptors.

1668
01:13:04,525 --> 01:13:05,938
What what

1669
01:13:04,995 --> 01:13:05,995
Stop.

1670
01:13:05,938 --> 01:13:08,893
is the one in like Jurassic Park three
that's like bigger than the T Rex?

1671
01:13:08,928 --> 01:13:09,928
It's the

1672
01:13:09,648 --> 01:13:12,650
~ ultra mega don. It's the

1673
01:13:12,192 --> 01:13:13,192
Yeah.

1674
01:13:12,790 --> 01:13:15,711
there's another one too in the the
Jurassic World things.

1675
01:13:15,711 --> 01:13:19,373
Jurassic World, big monster. That's what
I'm googling right now.

1676
01:13:19,373 --> 01:13:25,036
Distortus Rex the Distortus Rex is the one
that has like the weird head in the

1677
01:13:24,650 --> 01:13:26,131
Gigantosaurus

1678
01:13:26,131 --> 01:13:28,192
is the one in Jurassic World Dominion.

1679
01:13:28,192 --> 01:13:30,573
Indominus Rex, that's what I'm thinking
of.

1680
01:13:28,616 --> 01:13:33,398
Okay. Indominus Rex. The Indominus Re
Don't make Don't make that.

1681
01:13:30,573 --> 01:13:33,814
They specifically

1682
01:13:33,814 --> 01:13:36,686
genetically engineered a hybrid designed
to be bigger,

1683
01:13:36,686 --> 01:13:38,677
smarter, and more dangerous than a T-Rex.

1684
01:13:38,677 --> 01:13:40,778
That's literally what OpenAI is doing.

1685
01:13:40,790 --> 01:13:41,981
That is what they're doing. Stop it.

1686
01:13:41,981 --> 01:13:46,708
Stop it. Don't do that. You you you know
the the Bob Newhart stop it skit from SNL?

1687
01:13:46,228 --> 01:13:47,228
We do n

1688
01:13:46,719 --> 01:13:50,017
yeah. But all I know is I don't need an
Indominus Rex in my computer.

1689
01:13:50,113 --> 01:13:52,484
That's right. Stop it. Just stop it.

1690
01:13:52,484 --> 01:13:54,395
And you know that have you seen that skit
though?

1691
01:13:54,395 --> 01:13:55,395
You know what I'm talking

1692
01:13:54,475 --> 01:13:55,475
Yes.

1693
01:13:54,983 --> 01:13:55,983
Yeah, it's pretty, it's pretty.

1694
01:13:55,936 --> 01:13:58,648
It's a good one. Stop it or I'll bury you
alive in a box.

1695
01:13:58,648 --> 01:14:01,409
~ last thing before personal tech.

1696
01:14:01,409 --> 01:14:03,130
That's from the skit, by the way.

1697
01:14:03,130 --> 01:14:09,684
YouTube is increasing the requirements to
become monetized

1698
01:14:09,684 --> 01:14:11,615
or become part of the YouTube partner
program.

1699
01:14:11,615 --> 01:14:17,158
Previously, up until now, and until I
think it's February first

1700
01:14:17,158 --> 01:14:18,158
of twenty twenty seven.

1701
01:14:18,645 --> 01:14:22,036
It's 1,000 subscribers and 4,000 watch
hours.

1702
01:14:22,036 --> 01:14:26,077
They are changing that for long form
videos on YouTube.

1703
01:14:26,077 --> 01:14:28,958
Same subscriber count, 1,000 subscribers,

1704
01:14:28,958 --> 01:14:33,699
but it's doubling the amount of watch
hours to 8,000 in the calendar year

1705
01:14:34,019 --> 01:14:37,980
to become monetized. And if you want to be
monetized specifically on shorts,

1706
01:14:37,980 --> 01:14:44,342
you need twenty million qualified shorts
views in the last ninety days

1707
01:14:44,802 --> 01:14:47,623
to become monetized as a shorts creator.

1708
01:14:48,311 --> 01:14:52,564
Now there's a lot of dust up about this
because if you have ever tried

1709
01:14:52,564 --> 01:14:55,196
to build a YouTube channel and get
monetized,

1710
01:14:55,196 --> 01:14:57,877
the 1,000 subscribers is a challenge,

1711
01:14:57,877 --> 01:15:03,351
but attainable. The 4,000 watch hours
feels like an insurmountable task

1712
01:15:03,351 --> 01:15:07,964
as a creator because you look at that
count day after day and you're like,

1713
01:15:07,964 --> 01:15:12,507
this number barely moves. And I understand
it can be very disheartening.

1714
01:15:12,507 --> 01:15:15,219
And so to double that to 8,000 hours,

1715
01:15:15,219 --> 01:15:17,811
total like I understand.

1716
01:15:18,772 --> 01:15:23,715
I understand that could be very ~
discouraging and maybe even discourage
some

1717
01:15:23,715 --> 01:15:28,337
creators to try. I will also here's the
thing about all of that.

1718
01:15:28,337 --> 01:15:32,640
Whether you are monetized or not,

1719
01:15:32,640 --> 01:15:35,841
if you just make those requirements,

1720
01:15:35,841 --> 01:15:39,663
even the 8,000 hours, you're still making
almost no money.

1721
01:15:39,663 --> 01:15:44,246
As an example, I don't think a lot of
YouTube channels do this.

1722
01:15:44,246 --> 01:15:47,728
I am going to show what this channel
makes.

1723
01:15:48,204 --> 01:15:49,245
The primary technology channel,

1724
01:15:49,245 --> 01:15:50,767
what we make on YouTube in a month.

1725
01:15:50,767 --> 01:15:52,448
Are you ready for that? Are you ready?

1726
01:15:51,978 --> 01:15:53,229
I didn't even know we made anything.

1727
01:15:54,190 --> 01:15:58,425
Well, yeah. I mean, I've basically
included in what I've sent you because
it's it's

1728
01:15:57,568 --> 01:15:59,546
No I'm not I'm not questioning you,

1729
01:15:58,425 --> 01:16:02,479
nothing. I know. But so

1730
01:15:59,546 --> 01:16:01,675
Steven. I'm just like, okay.

1731
01:16:02,619 --> 01:16:04,401
this is a channel that is monetized.

1732
01:16:04,401 --> 01:16:06,543
We get well, I'll just show you.

1733
01:16:06,543 --> 01:16:08,325
This way, I'm gonna share my screen.

1734
01:16:08,325 --> 01:16:09,656
And for those listening, don't worry,

1735
01:16:09,656 --> 01:16:10,656
I'm going to

1736
01:16:10,838 --> 01:16:13,583
And we probably have higher than average
watch hours,

1737
01:16:13,583 --> 01:16:17,510
I would assume, because people probably
watch all fourteen hours of this show

1738
01:16:18,071 --> 01:16:19,113
as opposed to like

1739
01:16:18,454 --> 01:16:19,454
Rights.

1740
01:16:19,113 --> 01:16:21,718
people who only watch the first three
minutes of a YouTube video.

1741
01:16:21,975 --> 01:16:27,355
Correct. So this channel has made $72 in
the last month.

1742
01:16:28,128 --> 01:16:29,825
That's way more than I thought.

1743
01:16:29,825 --> 01:16:31,573
I just kidna

1744
01:16:30,369 --> 01:16:31,369
Seventy two dollars.

1745
01:16:32,100 --> 01:16:37,884
So and that is for in the last month we've
had two point five thousand watch hours.

1746
01:16:37,884 --> 01:16:42,107
So that means we probably make five
thousand watch hours every two months,

1747
01:16:42,107 --> 01:16:46,319
and it would take us over three months it
to get monetized on this

1748
01:16:46,319 --> 01:16:48,851
new eight thousand hour thing.

1749
01:16:49,142 --> 01:16:51,509
But we're two whatever, almost three years
into this.

1750
01:16:51,927 --> 01:16:52,927
Correct.

1751
01:16:52,492 --> 01:16:56,543
So you'd have to be doing it for that long
and then in one of those years

1752
01:16:56,543 --> 01:16:57,543
hit that number.

1753
01:16:57,623 --> 01:17:02,656
Correct. So I understand the
discouragement of it might take longer

1754
01:17:02,656 --> 01:17:04,848
to get monetized from YouTube,

1755
01:17:04,848 --> 01:17:10,031
but in order for YouTube AdSense revenue
to be anything significant,

1756
01:17:10,031 --> 01:17:12,553
you need way more hours anyway.

1757
01:17:12,553 --> 01:17:13,553
Like

1758
01:17:12,673 --> 01:17:13,673
Yeah.

1759
01:17:13,834 --> 01:17:16,496
if you want to actually make a YouTube
channel a thing,

1760
01:17:16,496 --> 01:17:20,609
you need what you just need way more watch
hours for it to amount to any number.

1761
01:17:20,609 --> 01:17:23,771
And so I understand the discouraging side
of that,

1762
01:17:23,771 --> 01:17:26,333
meaning like if you were like if you're
right now,

1763
01:17:26,333 --> 01:17:27,333
you have like

1764
01:17:27,032 --> 01:17:30,474
3,000 watch hours and now you're like
stressing because you want to

1765
01:17:30,474 --> 01:17:33,676
hit it before February. So you get into
the YouTube partner program.

1766
01:17:33,676 --> 01:17:35,937
I totally get that. I was there.

1767
01:17:35,937 --> 01:17:39,018
I was there, like trying to get those
4,000 watch hours.

1768
01:17:39,018 --> 01:17:44,672
But I also made almost no money from
YouTube bec even in after I was monetized,

1769
01:17:44,672 --> 01:17:49,694
because it just takes time. Part of it is
like if I look at any one of

1770
01:17:49,694 --> 01:17:53,666
my videos in the last month, no one video
makes a significant amount of money.

1771
01:17:53,666 --> 01:17:54,666
But

1772
01:17:54,857 --> 01:17:57,928
I have now 1,000 videos uploaded on my
channel,

1773
01:17:57,928 --> 01:18:00,389
which is a wild number. I didn't even
realize it was that many.

1774
01:18:00,389 --> 01:18:02,829
But I have like 1,000 videos uploaded,

1775
01:18:02,829 --> 01:18:07,571
and the collective watch time across all
those videos over the course

1776
01:18:07,571 --> 01:18:09,911
of a month generates some income.

1777
01:18:09,911 --> 01:18:12,772
Still not a ton, still not the main source
of income.

1778
01:18:12,772 --> 01:18:17,193
I still make more from pretty much every
other revenue stream in my business,

1779
01:18:17,193 --> 01:18:20,764
but it's just is it takes time and it
takes a lot of watch hours.

1780
01:18:20,764 --> 01:18:23,265
So totally identify because I was there.

1781
01:18:23,647 --> 01:18:28,040
wanting to get monetized, but I also get
like even if you attain

1782
01:18:28,040 --> 01:18:30,832
the YouTube partner program, you're not
gonna make significant money anytime soon.

1783
01:18:30,832 --> 01:18:33,514
So that's all. I just want to point that
out.

1784
01:18:33,514 --> 01:18:36,356
And but yeah, I think still go for it.

1785
01:18:36,356 --> 01:18:38,567
You know, I think if people are wondering
like is it too late to start

1786
01:18:38,567 --> 01:18:40,298
a YouTube channel? I don't think so.

1787
01:18:40,298 --> 01:18:42,940
You know, if I I started fairly recently,

1788
01:18:42,940 --> 01:18:45,442
like three or four years ago, I started
putting a sort of effort.

1789
01:18:45,442 --> 01:18:46,823
And I still think there's room today.

1790
01:18:46,823 --> 01:18:49,856
I still see like Christian Sealig.

1791
01:18:49,856 --> 01:18:50,856
Are you familiar with him?

1792
01:18:51,190 --> 01:18:52,190
Yes.

1793
01:18:51,687 --> 01:18:52,687
Maker of

1794
01:18:53,527 --> 01:18:56,638
~ the Apollo Reddit app, which is now
defunct because of Reddit,

1795
01:18:56,638 --> 01:19:02,971
but Christian Sealig, he last year he he
releases like

1796
01:19:02,991 --> 01:19:06,292
one video a year, okay, on his YouTube
channel.

1797
01:19:06,292 --> 01:19:09,494
And he knocks it out of the park every
time.

1798
01:19:09,494 --> 01:19:12,595
And so I'll put a link to his YouTube
channel.

1799
01:19:12,595 --> 01:19:15,176
But he released a video last year.

1800
01:19:15,176 --> 01:19:20,238
It's a gaming piece. It's like I built I
made the PC I couldn't buy.

1801
01:19:20,238 --> 01:19:22,209
Short title, here's the thumbnail.

1802
01:19:22,823 --> 01:19:28,627
8.4 million views, and it got him like
over 200,000 subscribers with that one
video,

1803
01:19:28,627 --> 01:19:33,210
and it is an excellent video, it is
incredibly well done.

1804
01:19:33,210 --> 01:19:36,011
He is an engaging narrator and
storyteller.

1805
01:19:36,011 --> 01:19:37,953
Not once is his face on screen,

1806
01:19:37,953 --> 01:19:39,634
it is a faceless YouTube video,

1807
01:19:39,634 --> 01:19:41,935
but his visuals are super fun and
interesting,

1808
01:19:41,935 --> 01:19:47,459
and so you can totally go viral on a
long-form YouTube video

1809
01:19:47,899 --> 01:19:52,362
and probably make that 8,000 watch hours
and 1,000 subscribers.

1810
01:19:52,562 --> 01:19:54,434
In one video. Like it's very possible.

1811
01:19:54,434 --> 01:19:56,156
He did it. Like Christian Sealy.

1812
01:19:55,710 --> 01:19:56,710
I mean it

1813
01:19:56,172 --> 01:19:59,848
did help that he had an incredibly popular
app that people loved.

1814
01:19:59,848 --> 01:20:01,173
In a name right I'm just

1815
01:20:01,396 --> 01:20:06,121
Yes, but that does not g like none of that
matters on YouTube,

1816
01:20:06,121 --> 01:20:07,615
honestly. Because if you

1817
01:20:07,146 --> 01:20:08,146
You don't think

1818
01:20:07,827 --> 01:20:11,613
him being able to post on to his hundreds
of thousands of followers

1819
01:20:11,613 --> 01:20:13,555
on Twitter and threads that I made a
video,

1820
01:20:13,555 --> 01:20:14,777
there's no carryover?

1821
01:20:15,498 --> 01:20:19,726
His Goodbye Apollo video got thirty eight
thousand views,

1822
01:20:19,726 --> 01:20:23,313
which is not bad, but also nothing.

1823
01:20:23,313 --> 01:20:25,378
F five years ago,

1824
01:20:23,490 --> 01:20:25,162
Sure. Okay. I mean and by the way,

1825
01:20:25,162 --> 01:20:26,162
I

1826
01:20:25,555 --> 01:20:26,778
I still have Apollo on my phone,

1827
01:20:26,778 --> 01:20:28,196
I just want you to know I won't delete it.

1828
01:20:27,974 --> 01:20:28,974
Sure

1829
01:20:28,214 --> 01:20:31,046
I'm sure. But like he posted lots of
videos before this.

1830
01:20:31,046 --> 01:20:32,997
Like he has an M1 MacBook Air video,

1831
01:20:32,997 --> 01:20:39,441
six thousand views. So that's the weird
thing about YouTube is like just because

1832
01:20:39,642 --> 01:20:42,764
you have tons of followers elsewhere
doesn't necessarily mean they're gonna
come

1833
01:20:42,764 --> 01:20:47,487
over and watch. And this gaming like this
gaming video has nothing to

1834
01:20:47,487 --> 01:20:50,329
do with Reddit or Apollo or the apps he
made.

1835
01:20:50,329 --> 01:20:52,290
He's just talking about building a PC.

1836
01:20:53,054 --> 01:20:56,416
And he did like great work. He like 3D
printed the casing and

1837
01:20:56,416 --> 01:21:00,229
he like customized pieces. Like it is a tr
incredible video.

1838
01:21:00,229 --> 01:21:02,821
Totally makes sense why. And he did it
again.

1839
01:21:02,821 --> 01:21:05,593
He just released or or or two years ago,

1840
01:21:05,593 --> 01:21:09,615
he released a video about I built the my
dream keyboard from scratch.

1841
01:21:09,615 --> 01:21:11,146
That video got two point four million
views.

1842
01:21:11,146 --> 01:21:13,841
So all I'm saying is even today,

1843
01:21:13,841 --> 01:21:16,670
a year ago, Christian Sealag did this with
one video.

1844
01:21:16,670 --> 01:21:20,573
And so part of one of the things as if you
want to be a creator,

1845
01:21:20,573 --> 01:21:22,034
you have to reconcile with is like

1846
01:21:22,955 --> 01:21:25,677
Do I have the chops? Do I have the ideas?

1847
01:21:25,677 --> 01:21:28,259
And do I have the execution to be able to
do this?

1848
01:21:28,259 --> 01:21:31,101
And if those three things are true,

1849
01:21:31,101 --> 01:21:35,395
you can still do it today. And even if the
watch time requirement is

1850
01:21:35,395 --> 01:21:38,307
to 8,000 hours versus 4,000, you can still
do it today.

1851
01:21:38,307 --> 01:21:40,809
That's all I'm saying. So be encouraged.

1852
01:21:40,809 --> 01:21:44,302
That's all. Okay, my my app,

1853
01:21:44,302 --> 01:21:47,805
Jason. Personal tech is app cornered this
week.

1854
01:21:48,148 --> 01:21:49,148
It

1855
01:21:48,269 --> 01:21:50,046
just says in our in our rundown,

1856
01:21:50,046 --> 01:21:51,753
Knightmare.

1857
01:21:53,355 --> 01:21:54,846
I did that because I thought it was a fun
plan.

1858
01:21:54,846 --> 01:21:57,979
It's not been a nightmare. Thank you all
for supporting Can Do,

1859
01:21:57,979 --> 01:22:02,928
my task management app. It hit number one
in the Mac App Store and iOS App Store.

1860
01:22:02,928 --> 01:22:04,704
I got a lot of positive feedback,

1861
01:22:04,704 --> 01:22:07,707
t a lot of downloads. Really appreciate
it.

1862
01:22:07,707 --> 01:22:11,119
I just wanted to share a couple things
about the development process that

1863
01:22:11,119 --> 01:22:12,831
I feel like you will identify with.

1864
01:22:12,831 --> 01:22:19,176
And ~ yeah. So one, I've received infinite
feature requests

1865
01:22:19,176 --> 01:22:21,318
and bug fix reports, which

1866
01:22:21,824 --> 01:22:24,166
Totally understand. Thank you all.

1867
01:22:24,166 --> 01:22:27,388
I'm implementing some. There's just so
many feature requests.

1868
01:22:27,388 --> 01:22:28,799
There's no way I would be able to build
them all.

1869
01:22:28,799 --> 01:22:31,551
Maybe if I have Codex and Cloud working on
it simultaneously.

1870
01:22:31,551 --> 01:22:35,313
We'll see. But probably not. But I just
wanted to talk a little bit about

1871
01:22:35,313 --> 01:22:40,307
the actual troubleshooting process because
there was one night,

1872
01:22:40,307 --> 01:22:42,508
Jason. It was a dark night of the soul for
me.

1873
01:22:42,508 --> 01:22:48,543
And that was last Friday. I was receiving
emails

1874
01:22:48,543 --> 01:22:50,514
and bug reports that iCloud sync.

1875
01:22:50,996 --> 01:22:54,747
was not working properly. And I would
test.

1876
01:22:54,747 --> 01:22:56,728
Sometimes it would work, sometimes it
wouldn't.

1877
01:22:56,728 --> 01:22:58,128
So I knew there were problems.

1878
01:22:58,128 --> 01:23:01,239
And I will reiterate again, I'm not a
developer,

1879
01:23:01,239 --> 01:23:04,050
so I can't read the code. I don't know
what it's doing.

1880
01:23:04,050 --> 01:23:08,471
And iCloud also feels like a black box of
what's happening here.

1881
01:23:08,471 --> 01:23:12,772
So I was up till 3 a.m.

1882
01:23:12,772 --> 01:23:16,053
Friday, just going back and forth with
Claude,

1883
01:23:16,053 --> 01:23:18,654
Fable, burning tokens all night long,

1884
01:23:18,654 --> 01:23:20,224
saying

1885
01:23:20,939 --> 01:23:24,060
Here's what's happening. The sync is not
working.

1886
01:23:24,060 --> 01:23:28,941
I'll send screenshots. I'll send screen
recordings to Claude of the various
devices.

1887
01:23:28,941 --> 01:23:30,781
It's running stuff on the Mac.

1888
01:23:30,781 --> 01:23:34,922
And I will send it to Claude. Sometimes it
would work for 20 minutes.

1889
01:23:34,922 --> 01:23:38,563
It would just go. And I'm like,

1890
01:23:38,563 --> 01:23:41,064
I see the token count going. And I'm just
sitting here.

1891
01:23:41,064 --> 01:23:44,845
I'm just staring at it because it's two in
the morning and I have nothing else

1892
01:23:44,845 --> 01:23:47,075
to do. And I'm like watching it go.

1893
01:23:47,075 --> 01:23:49,146
And then it'll come back, Jason.

1894
01:23:49,146 --> 01:23:50,186
And Claude will be like,

1895
01:23:51,156 --> 01:23:53,107
I got it. This was the problem.

1896
01:23:53,107 --> 01:23:55,869
This was a ~ issue with the sync engine.

1897
01:23:55,869 --> 01:23:58,430
This was a thing with the app writing the
boards.

1898
01:23:58,430 --> 01:24:01,732
Fixed it all. Committed the build to
GitHub.

1899
01:24:01,732 --> 01:24:04,633
You're ready to deploy. I said,

1900
01:24:04,633 --> 01:24:06,834
great, Claude. That sounds good.

1901
01:24:06,834 --> 01:24:11,457
So I go in, I go straight to a test flight
build.

1902
01:24:11,457 --> 01:24:14,819
I understand you can deploy the app
directly on your iPhone and Mac.

1903
01:24:14,819 --> 01:24:18,263
I do that as well to test. But with the
iCloud Sync specifically,

1904
01:24:18,263 --> 01:24:20,572
I wanted to test it on the test flight.

1905
01:24:20,936 --> 01:24:25,027
install because that uses the production
iCloud sync,

1906
01:24:25,027 --> 01:24:29,629
not the developer iCloud Sync paradigm in
iCloud Developer Console.

1907
01:24:29,629 --> 01:24:33,870
Anyway, so I would wait for it to hit my
personal test flight.

1908
01:24:33,870 --> 01:24:35,480
I would update my Mac, my iPhone,

1909
01:24:35,480 --> 01:24:37,491
my iPad, I would try it again,

1910
01:24:37,491 --> 01:24:40,112
and inevitably it would still be broken.

1911
01:24:40,112 --> 01:24:43,893
And I would the same process, it was like
Sisyphus rolling up

1912
01:24:43,893 --> 01:24:46,834
the iCloud the mountain, like just trying
to figure this out.

1913
01:24:46,834 --> 01:24:47,904
And it was

1914
01:24:48,744 --> 01:24:52,295
It boggled my mind how often Claude just
is gaslighting me.

1915
01:24:52,295 --> 01:24:55,967
And I understand like it is thought it
found the problem and fixed

1916
01:24:55,967 --> 01:24:58,098
the problem and is very confident.

1917
01:24:58,098 --> 01:25:02,230
I finally understood your take on like
Claude just being the overconfident,

1918
01:25:02,230 --> 01:25:06,981
whatever. And it would probably a dozen or
more times that night,

1919
01:25:06,981 --> 01:25:10,143
it'd be the same process. I would tell
Claude the issue be like,

1920
01:25:10,143 --> 01:25:13,604
~ I missed this one thing, it's fixed now,

1921
01:25:13,604 --> 01:25:16,705
no problem. I would do the whole test
flight process,

1922
01:25:16,705 --> 01:25:18,066
still broken.

1923
01:25:18,943 --> 01:25:21,974
And it was maddening. And at one point,

1924
01:25:21,974 --> 01:25:26,185
Jason, I almost lost it. Because it was
about 2 a.m.

1925
01:25:26,185 --> 01:25:30,086
And I sent the thing to Claude.

1926
01:25:30,086 --> 01:25:31,275
It was thinking. And it came back.

1927
01:25:31,275 --> 01:25:33,867
It said, We've done a lot of good work
today.

1928
01:25:33,867 --> 01:25:36,048
I think I just fixed the iCloud bug.

1929
01:25:36,048 --> 01:25:39,809
It's it's almost 2 A.m. Let's call it a
night.

1930
01:25:39,809 --> 01:25:41,890
This is what Claude this is what Claude
told me.

1931
01:25:41,890 --> 01:25:42,890
Like, this is what Claude told me.

1932
01:25:42,850 --> 01:25:45,941
And I I was like.

1933
01:25:46,443 --> 01:25:48,767
I couldn't whisper flow 'cause it was two
in the morning and my office

1934
01:25:48,767 --> 01:25:53,625
is close to my kids. But just imagine me
typing furiously Don't tell me what to do,

1935
01:25:53,625 --> 01:25:56,360
Claude. You don't tell me it's late.

1936
01:25:56,360 --> 01:25:58,904
Okay? Don't tell me what time it is.

1937
01:25:58,904 --> 01:25:59,956
I know what time it is.

1938
01:25:59,990 --> 01:26:02,320
Time is a human construct and you are a
robot,

1939
01:26:02,320 --> 01:26:03,404
so you just stop.

1940
01:26:03,774 --> 01:26:05,544
And I d I didn't say all that to Claude,

1941
01:26:05,544 --> 01:26:09,255
but I did say, Claude, don't make any
judgment calls about the time

1942
01:26:09,255 --> 01:26:12,096
I'm working or what don't don't tell me
when we're done.

1943
01:26:12,096 --> 01:26:14,137
I tell you when you're done, okay?

1944
01:26:14,137 --> 01:26:16,467
And like it almost sent me over the edge,

1945
01:26:16,467 --> 01:26:19,938
I'll be honest. Kept working, thought it
was fixed.

1946
01:26:19,938 --> 01:26:24,620
It's mostly fixed. I'm still been fixing
issues this entire week.

1947
01:26:24,620 --> 01:26:26,900
And I'm at a point now where I'm also
installing Codex.

1948
01:26:26,900 --> 01:26:29,221
I'm gonna see may let's let's put it to
the test.

1949
01:26:29,221 --> 01:26:31,181
Let's see clo if codex can fix this.

1950
01:26:31,181 --> 01:26:33,312
I did get a very nice email.

1951
01:26:33,642 --> 01:26:39,085
From Phil. He sent me a markdown file with
instructions for LLMs

1952
01:26:39,165 --> 01:26:41,286
on building iCloudSync into the app.

1953
01:26:41,286 --> 01:26:44,818
I gave that markdown file to Claude and I
said,

1954
01:26:44,818 --> 01:26:46,990
please compare this to what you've been
doing and see if there's

1955
01:26:46,990 --> 01:26:49,221
any improvements here. And once I clan,

1956
01:26:49,221 --> 01:26:50,682
I don't know if Claude's gaslighting me or
not,

1957
01:26:50,682 --> 01:26:56,195
but it's like, this part I totally didn't
know about this part about pushing

1958
01:26:56,655 --> 01:26:58,276
something when changes are made.

1959
01:26:58,276 --> 01:27:01,838
I got it now. When it made a bunch of
changes.

1960
01:27:02,376 --> 01:27:03,970
Again, still not for totally fixed,

1961
01:27:03,970 --> 01:27:06,015
but my thank you to Phil. It did help.

1962
01:27:06,015 --> 01:27:08,261
It is more reliable. Still working on the
fix.

1963
01:27:08,261 --> 01:27:11,710
But man, I almost I almost lost it on
Claude Jason.

1964
01:27:12,342 --> 01:27:15,825
There was two two things that happened for
me recently that are similar

1965
01:27:15,982 --> 01:27:17,947
d in building this second app.

1966
01:27:17,947 --> 01:27:19,558
Actually I guess it's the third app,

1967
01:27:19,558 --> 01:27:23,331
but the sec the first there's one that
won't you won't no one'll see it,

1968
01:27:23,331 --> 01:27:28,674
but it's fine. the I s I got to a point
where I was basically the

1969
01:27:28,674 --> 01:27:31,398
to the token window was like nine hundred
thousand tokens and the tok

1970
01:27:31,398 --> 01:27:33,089
the the limit is a million and I was like,

1971
01:27:33,089 --> 01:27:35,221
Okay, simple problem to solve.

1972
01:27:35,221 --> 01:27:36,382
I'm just gonna start a new chat.

1973
01:27:36,382 --> 01:27:39,344
Right? I don't so I said I said,

1974
01:27:39,344 --> 01:27:40,625
Great, you fixed that problem.

1975
01:27:40,625 --> 01:27:41,625
Awesome.

1976
01:27:41,847 --> 01:27:44,918
I'm gonna start a I'm gonna start over in
a new chat because the context window

1977
01:27:44,918 --> 01:27:47,318
is almost full. What info do I need to
bring with me?

1978
01:27:47,318 --> 01:27:49,649
So it'll make a claude.markdown file for

1979
01:27:49,300 --> 01:27:50,300
Right.

1980
01:27:49,649 --> 01:27:52,810
you and it puts it in the project so that
the next chat can just see

1981
01:27:52,810 --> 01:27:55,850
all that kind of stuff. And its response
was,

1982
01:27:55,850 --> 01:27:58,911
Congratulations on shipping exclamation
point.

1983
01:27:58,911 --> 01:28:02,092
I'm like, dude, no,

1984
01:28:02,092 --> 01:28:05,823
we didn't and then it goes through this
whole list of here are your
accomplishments.

1985
01:28:05,823 --> 01:28:08,533
You did this. I'm like, dude, we've only
been working on this for four hours.

1986
01:28:08,533 --> 01:28:10,594
Like, we are nowhere near shipping.

1987
01:28:10,594 --> 01:28:11,594
I just

1988
01:28:11,848 --> 01:28:14,700
I just am telling you like we're gonna
keep this conversation going,

1989
01:28:14,700 --> 01:28:17,062
but I need to start a new chat and I just
need to

1990
01:28:16,660 --> 01:28:17,660
Yes.

1991
01:28:17,923 --> 01:28:23,757
s succinctly tell what it what it has
because it's like it it has no no idea.

1992
01:28:23,757 --> 01:28:29,611
It's just completely crazy. ~ and then it
was the number

1993
01:28:29,611 --> 01:28:31,813
of times where just like you're saying,

1994
01:28:31,813 --> 01:28:36,996
it will it will tell you that it's figured
something out.

1995
01:28:36,996 --> 01:28:39,178
And it goes, I guarantee it's fixed.

1996
01:28:39,562 --> 01:28:42,764
And I just take a screenshot of of what it
thinks is fixed

1997
01:28:42,089 --> 01:28:43,089
Ha ha.

1998
01:28:43,165 --> 01:28:45,036
and I send it and I go, This is ugly,

1999
01:28:45,036 --> 01:28:47,448
bro. And it's like, Yeah, fair.

2000
01:28:47,448 --> 01:28:50,380
It's pretty ugly. And it's like it's

2001
01:28:49,341 --> 01:28:50,511
See. And that that

2002
01:28:50,511 --> 01:28:53,963
was another time where after I gave it
that markdown file about iCloud Sync,

2003
01:28:53,963 --> 01:28:57,985
it said, Yeah, this is definitely helps.

2004
01:28:57,985 --> 01:28:59,605
We should definitely implement it.

2005
01:28:59,605 --> 01:29:03,667
But it's pretty late. We can implement
this in the next iteration.

2006
01:29:03,667 --> 01:29:05,668
I think you should ship it as is.

2007
01:29:05,668 --> 01:29:08,889
That's what it told me. And and to add
insult to injury,

2008
01:29:08,889 --> 01:29:12,410
it put a little cruise ship emoji in its
message.

2009
01:29:12,410 --> 01:29:16,212
I kid you not. I kid you not. And when I
saw that again,

2010
01:29:16,212 --> 01:29:18,293
that cruise ship emoji, I almost

2011
01:29:18,535 --> 01:29:21,388
I almost flipped a table. It was I was
like,

2012
01:29:21,388 --> 01:29:25,352
No, I'm not gonna ship if there are still
more improvements that need to be done.

2013
01:29:25,352 --> 01:29:28,425
Like why are you tired of working?

2014
01:29:28,425 --> 01:29:32,549
Like are you are you saying like so
anyway,

2015
01:29:32,549 --> 01:29:34,491
that was that was just maddening and I
couldn't deal.

2016
01:29:34,039 --> 01:29:35,039
Well, and there

2017
01:29:34,539 --> 01:29:37,742
was a point where it was having a hard
time solving a particular problem.

2018
01:29:37,742 --> 01:29:40,864
And I'm thinking, You're Fable Five,

2019
01:29:40,864 --> 01:29:43,967
the most capable LLM in the world for
doing this.

2020
01:29:43,967 --> 01:29:47,229
Figure it out. And it did.

2021
01:29:48,200 --> 01:29:54,598
It did. Okay, well good. Now you have not
you have not like been tempted

2022
01:29:54,598 --> 01:29:56,431
to try Codex for anything yet?

2023
01:29:56,938 --> 01:30:03,291
Not on this app, no. I mean I've used it
in X code for contextually this

2024
01:30:03,291 --> 01:30:05,331
was before Fable exist existed,

2025
01:30:05,331 --> 01:30:08,283
but when there were s issues that I felt
like it just kept going around

2026
01:30:08,283 --> 01:30:11,224
in circles and was not getting any new
pers and part of that could be because

2027
01:30:11,224 --> 01:30:13,004
I was sending the whole context window
back,

2028
01:30:13,004 --> 01:30:16,126
so it's just continuing on the same train
of thought or thread.

2029
01:30:16,126 --> 01:30:18,887
So there was times when I would just bump
into X code,

2030
01:30:18,887 --> 01:30:21,858
go over to the AI chat thing, load codecs
there and be like,

2031
01:30:21,858 --> 01:30:22,909
Could you look at this problem?

2032
01:30:22,909 --> 01:30:24,489
And it'd be like, Yeah, it looks like it's
probably this,

2033
01:30:24,489 --> 01:30:25,770
this, and this, and be like, Sweet.

2034
01:30:25,770 --> 01:30:26,770
And then

2035
01:30:26,634 --> 01:30:29,146
I would get to a point where that couldn't
figure it out anymore and

2036
01:30:29,146 --> 01:30:30,179
I'd just switch back to Claude.

2037
01:30:30,179 --> 01:30:32,102
But mo this entire app has been Claude.

2038
01:30:32,605 --> 01:30:35,536
Okay. And mine has been clawed up until
now completely.

2039
01:30:35,536 --> 01:30:38,218
I am going to share I just want to show
you this conversation.

2040
01:30:38,218 --> 01:30:40,449
I just need to prove it and I'll put this
as the chapter artwork.

2041
01:30:40,449 --> 01:30:41,570
Look at look at this, look at this.

2042
01:30:41,570 --> 01:30:43,451
Ship it.

2043
01:30:42,082 --> 01:30:45,225
Ship it. Ship this Claude.

2044
01:30:45,992 --> 01:30:48,414
I said, I'm not shipping without these
improvements.

2045
01:30:48,414 --> 01:30:50,775
Make the changes per this document and I
will retest.

2046
01:30:50,775 --> 01:30:55,838
Agreed. Let's do it properly. Like listen.

2047
01:30:55,502 --> 01:30:56,502
Ha ha ha

2048
01:30:56,878 --> 01:30:59,129
Merlin Mann was a guest on MacPower Users
recently.

2049
01:30:59,129 --> 01:31:01,261
He's a very divisive figure. People have
strong feelings.

2050
01:31:01,261 --> 01:31:02,261
We had

2051
01:31:02,171 --> 01:31:03,582
Literally the polar opposite comments.

2052
01:31:03,582 --> 01:31:05,564
Like, this was the best episode in a
while.

2053
01:31:05,564 --> 01:31:07,746
And people are like, I couldn't listen to
five seconds of this episode.

2054
01:31:07,746 --> 01:31:12,129
Totally understand. But the one thing from
that episode that Merlin gets into

2055
01:31:12,250 --> 01:31:17,934
is all the instructions that he has built
into his Claude and of like MD file

2056
01:31:18,295 --> 01:31:21,017
on how to talk. I understand it now.

2057
01:31:21,017 --> 01:31:26,422
I underst I understand why you would be
that particular because sometimes

2058
01:31:26,422 --> 01:31:29,224
it is absolutely maddening, especially
when you're trying to fix a problem.

2059
01:31:29,224 --> 01:31:30,355
And I understand

2060
01:31:30,730 --> 01:31:32,461
People are gonna say, like, this is a vibe
coded app,

2061
01:31:32,461 --> 01:31:35,114
you're not fixing anything. Sure,

2062
01:31:35,114 --> 01:31:38,516
I guess, but I am part of this testing
process.

2063
01:31:38,516 --> 01:31:41,139
Like, I am the one like dealing

2064
01:31:39,146 --> 01:31:40,146
Yeah.

2065
01:31:41,139 --> 01:31:43,891
with data. I'm using the can do app for my
own video planning.

2066
01:31:43,891 --> 01:31:46,803
And so as stuff is breaking, like my own
data is breaking.

2067
01:31:46,803 --> 01:31:50,016
And so, like, this is like we're in it
together,

2068
01:31:50,016 --> 01:31:52,828
whether or not I'm actually writing the
code with my fingers or not.

2069
01:31:52,828 --> 01:31:55,630
Like, this is it is a whatever process.

2070
01:31:55,630 --> 01:31:58,483
And like it was the way Claude talks
sometimes just makes me insane.

2071
01:31:58,483 --> 01:31:59,483
So.

2072
01:31:58,604 --> 01:31:59,604
Well,

2073
01:31:58,844 --> 01:32:02,276
and here two things. We I wanna have this
conversation at some point about

2074
01:32:02,636 --> 01:32:05,247
the stigma ~ the perception of vibe coded
apps,

2075
01:32:05,247 --> 01:32:07,158
whether they're less valuable because of
that.

2076
01:32:07,158 --> 01:32:10,569
But I I really like the way Mark Armin was
talking about it recently when

2077
01:32:10,569 --> 01:32:13,631
he was talking about the number of things
he was able to get fixed in

2078
01:32:13,631 --> 01:32:17,102
his app and like how he spun up some new
stuff

2079
01:32:17,161 --> 01:32:18,161
Yeah.

2080
01:32:17,563 --> 01:32:21,254
entirely based and he was thinking of
himself as a director of AI,

2081
01:32:21,254 --> 01:32:22,645
and I actually think that's super useful.

2082
01:32:22,645 --> 01:32:25,066
That's the first thing. Second thing is

2083
01:32:26,120 --> 01:32:32,035
Every single piece of software you're
using today is being written in some part

2084
01:32:32,115 --> 01:32:34,197
at this point by either Codex or Claude.

2085
01:32:34,197 --> 01:32:37,900
Every single thing, whether it's coming
from the largest,

2086
01:32:37,900 --> 01:32:40,623
especially when it's coming from the
largest companies in the world.

2087
01:32:40,623 --> 01:32:41,623
Now,

2088
01:32:41,041 --> 01:32:42,041
yeah.

2089
01:32:41,684 --> 01:32:43,565
they didn't like have one guy sit down and
be like,

2090
01:32:43,565 --> 01:32:45,367
make me a Kanban board app, right?

2091
01:32:45,367 --> 01:32:47,179
That's not but that's what we think of as
vibe coded,

2092
01:32:47,179 --> 01:32:51,292
but these are the tools that are being
used by the smartest developers in the
world.

2093
01:32:51,326 --> 01:32:52,326
Yeah, yeah.

2094
01:32:51,693 --> 01:32:53,334
And they are just very good directors.

2095
01:32:54,129 --> 01:32:56,231
Exactly. And that is what yeah,

2096
01:32:56,231 --> 01:32:58,473
that's what it is. So I just want to get
that off my chest.

2097
01:32:58,473 --> 01:33:01,395
I thought hopefully that was entertaining
and ship it.

2098
01:33:01,395 --> 01:33:04,538
Listen, Claude. I wanted to ask Jason
about Offred.

2099
01:33:04,538 --> 01:33:05,979
So we're gonna go record a bonus episode.

2100
01:33:05,979 --> 01:33:07,150
You can get the unedited feed,

2101
01:33:07,150 --> 01:33:10,452
which I'm sure is over two hours this week
and usually is close to two hours.

2102
01:33:10,452 --> 01:33:12,194
You can listen to that, our daily show,

2103
01:33:12,194 --> 01:33:14,466
get an ad-free version, click that link
down in the show notes.

2104
01:33:14,466 --> 01:33:16,999
We'd appreciate a five-star rating and
review in Apple Podcast.

2105
01:33:16,999 --> 01:33:20,572
We are extremely close to ~ five hundred
ratings there.

2106
01:33:20,572 --> 01:33:21,572
I'm gonna check it real quick.

2107
01:33:21,422 --> 01:33:22,422
We are at

2108
01:33:22,527 --> 01:33:26,488
494. So we only need six more five-star
ratings.

2109
01:33:26,488 --> 01:33:27,509
So if you haven't done that yet,

2110
01:33:27,509 --> 01:33:30,193
head over to Apple Podcasts, give us a
five-star rating and review there.

2111
01:33:30,193 --> 01:33:32,224
Appreciate it. And thanks for tuning in.

2112
01:33:32,224 --> 01:33:33,325
We'll catch you next time.