WEBVTT

NOTE
This file was generated by Descript 

00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:03.683
Lily Elsner: The number one reason
why women have IVF in the UK,

00:00:03.683 --> 00:00:07.313
37%, is due to male infertility.

00:00:07.343 --> 00:00:10.543
So the women are, in most
cases, almost completely fine.

00:00:11.854 --> 00:00:14.924
Susannah de Jager: welcome to Oxford
Plus, the podcast series that takes

00:00:14.924 --> 00:00:18.414
you deep into the myths and truths
of the Oxford investing landscape.

00:00:19.044 --> 00:00:22.154
I'm your host, Susannah de
Jager and I've spent over 16

00:00:22.154 --> 00:00:23.654
years in UK asset management.

00:00:24.604 --> 00:00:28.774
My guest today is Lily Elsner, CEO
and Co Founder of Jack Fertility.

00:00:28.944 --> 00:00:33.112
Jack Fertility is the first postal
sperm kit offering lab grade semen

00:00:33.112 --> 00:00:36.362
analysis results without ever
needing to set foot in a clinic.

00:00:36.902 --> 00:00:40.762
Lily has a background in science herself,
having studied biological sciences

00:00:40.772 --> 00:00:42.482
and philosophy at Wellesley College.

00:00:42.772 --> 00:00:46.872
She then co founded Jack Fertility
after her MBA in Oxford and a

00:00:46.872 --> 00:00:51.419
stint as a head of strategy at a UK
growth drug discovery company after

00:00:51.419 --> 00:00:52.859
starting her career in global M& A.

00:00:53.786 --> 00:00:57.391
I'm so pleased to have Lily here
today because Jack Fertility is a

00:00:57.411 --> 00:01:00.701
consumer facing proposition that
is very different from what people

00:01:00.711 --> 00:01:02.971
think of as a typical Oxford startup.

00:01:03.301 --> 00:01:07.281
She also has a wealth of experience
in Oxford from different perspectives.

00:01:07.281 --> 00:01:10.946
Mishcon de Reya have been an amazing
partner to Jack Fertility through

00:01:10.946 --> 00:01:15.526
their startup journey, helping them
with an Innovate UK IP audit and as

00:01:15.526 --> 00:01:19.056
a personal mentor, Nicola McConville,
who is one of the partners here in

00:01:19.056 --> 00:01:21.556
Oxford, also helping as a mentor.

00:01:22.446 --> 00:01:24.676
Lily, thank you so much for joining today.

00:01:24.821 --> 00:01:25.481
Lily Elsner: My pleasure.

00:01:25.491 --> 00:01:26.691
Thank you so much for having me.

00:01:26.896 --> 00:01:31.486
Susannah de Jager: So you've got
a really useful for listeners

00:01:31.486 --> 00:01:36.391
journey because, you've done Oxford
from many different perspectives.

00:01:36.701 --> 00:01:40.371
So you've been a student, an employee
here, and now you're a founder.

00:01:40.781 --> 00:01:45.611
I'd love to hear from you just a
little bit more about those different

00:01:45.734 --> 00:01:50.594
lenses and how it brought you to where
you are now founding Jack Fertility.

00:01:50.766 --> 00:01:52.496
Lily Elsner: It was an
interesting journey, especially

00:01:52.496 --> 00:01:54.206
being an American doing an MBA.

00:01:54.206 --> 00:01:58.876
I had been recruited by Oxford through
that MBA process, so originally from North

00:01:58.876 --> 00:02:01.616
Carolina and lived in New York and D.

00:02:01.616 --> 00:02:01.986
C.

00:02:02.016 --> 00:02:06.076
prior to coming over, and so it was
really interesting as an American.

00:02:06.136 --> 00:02:12.852
So came in 2019, had six normal months and
then got locked down in Pembroke College.

00:02:12.862 --> 00:02:17.162
So quite a wild experience of,
yeah, it felt like me and the

00:02:17.162 --> 00:02:20.312
ghosts,  during the pandemic.

00:02:20.372 --> 00:02:24.026
But it really solidified my bond
with the city in a lot of ways, both

00:02:24.036 --> 00:02:28.606
through living there in such an extreme
situation, but also at the time I was

00:02:28.606 --> 00:02:30.556
working with Creative Destruction Lab.

00:02:30.606 --> 00:02:35.596
I was a strategy consultant for a
local AI drug discovery company and

00:02:35.726 --> 00:02:37.629
rediscovered my scientific roots.

00:02:37.756 --> 00:02:43.800
I had originally started out in science,
so I really adored being able to translate

00:02:43.865 --> 00:02:49.935
corporate speak and investment speak
into translate that to scientists and

00:02:49.935 --> 00:02:53.115
vice versa and found that was actually
a really interesting and useful skill,

00:02:53.115 --> 00:02:58.535
particularly in Oxford and I was delighted
to be hired by that company and stay in

00:02:58.535 --> 00:03:01.360
Oxford to help them grow the company.

00:03:01.380 --> 00:03:07.360
So, we then went from 2020 to 2021 raising
some investment as well as doing a U.

00:03:07.360 --> 00:03:07.490
S.

00:03:07.490 --> 00:03:10.820
expansion where I was able to bring
my American background and have this

00:03:10.820 --> 00:03:14.866
delightful surprise of something that I
didn't know would be useful, coming back

00:03:14.916 --> 00:03:18.076
as I became an employee in the Oxford
ecosystem, I got to know some of the

00:03:18.076 --> 00:03:19.986
incredible support that we have here.

00:03:20.326 --> 00:03:24.776
Everything from professional services
to some of the ecosystem support.

00:03:25.146 --> 00:03:29.026
I'm thinking, of course, of everything
from the Council to the OxLEPs, to

00:03:29.236 --> 00:03:31.186
the Oxford Trust, Advanced Oxford.

00:03:31.186 --> 00:03:32.036
I mean, name drop.

00:03:32.046 --> 00:03:36.126
But, really seeing everything outside of
the university that I think when you're

00:03:36.126 --> 00:03:41.131
a student, you almost have these blinkers
or blinders on, to just what's available

00:03:41.171 --> 00:03:45.011
in the University of Oxford, completely
forgetting that there's a university up

00:03:45.021 --> 00:03:49.731
Headington Hill and that there are so
many amazing resources and so I'm happy

00:03:49.731 --> 00:03:53.471
to get into more of the story of Jack
Fertility, which is the company that

00:03:53.471 --> 00:03:57.841
we've now built, but I found it a really
empowering experience, to be able to

00:03:57.841 --> 00:04:02.319
sort of see how this ecosystem works and
then choose to build my business here.

00:04:02.379 --> 00:04:04.469
So hopefully that's a little
bit of a helpful overview.

00:04:04.669 --> 00:04:07.529
Susannah de Jager: It's super helpful
and actually you've drawn on some really

00:04:07.559 --> 00:04:13.322
important themes there, which is Oxford
has so much here, but it can sometimes

00:04:13.322 --> 00:04:19.012
be operating adjacent without crossover
and you have this amazing seat where

00:04:19.022 --> 00:04:24.402
you've been able to sit across various
areas of it and benefit from them.

00:04:25.256 --> 00:04:31.726
Do you feel with that perspective that
you bring that more could be done to

00:04:31.776 --> 00:04:36.499
educate people within each sphere or
to run co events or do you think it's

00:04:36.499 --> 00:04:38.579
an area that's evolving pretty well?

00:04:39.019 --> 00:04:41.719
Lily Elsner: I wish I could say that
it's evolving well, and I will say that

00:04:41.719 --> 00:04:46.099
I think there's been so much incredible
movement and there's so many people

00:04:46.099 --> 00:04:49.826
who care so much about this that I've
been impressed in the five years that

00:04:49.826 --> 00:04:51.746
I've been here to see so much progress.

00:04:52.116 --> 00:04:56.286
However, I mean, on every front,
there could be improvements, most

00:04:56.286 --> 00:05:01.026
particularly, even just the fact that
I'm so rare, that I come as an MBA.

00:05:01.541 --> 00:05:05.841
I get hired by a local company in
Oxfordshire and am retained to the point

00:05:05.841 --> 00:05:10.696
that I would be able to start a business
with a high growth trajectory in town.

00:05:10.809 --> 00:05:15.489
I'm one of a very few people over the last
ten years who have been able to do that

00:05:15.529 --> 00:05:18.971
So to bring that to life a little
bit, what what was really significant

00:05:18.971 --> 00:05:23.531
for me was going into, I was head
of strategy for this company, and

00:05:23.531 --> 00:05:26.548
that opened my eyes, especially when
you're an early stage company trying

00:05:26.548 --> 00:05:30.408
to keep budget down, and you're
trying to do so many amazing things.

00:05:30.748 --> 00:05:34.378
You start networking and understanding
the ecosystem, and I was, I just opened my

00:05:34.378 --> 00:05:38.723
eyes massively to all of the opportunities
that were literally, I mean, streets

00:05:38.723 --> 00:05:42.863
away from where I sat, like I lived
on Walton Street and I was like, Oh my

00:05:42.863 --> 00:05:47.103
gosh, I wasn't even aware of some of the
things that, for example, the library's

00:05:47.103 --> 00:05:49.063
doing and some of the resources there.

00:05:49.343 --> 00:05:53.733
Similarly, some of the incredible
ecosystem work that's happening, I

00:05:53.733 --> 00:05:59.044
mean, among OSC and the uni, and I
found so many myths, as well as things

00:05:59.044 --> 00:06:00.614
that just need to be explored more.

00:06:00.614 --> 00:06:05.117
So, for example, there's a perception
that MBAs in particular wouldn't want

00:06:05.117 --> 00:06:09.157
to stay in Oxford and that couldn't
be further from the truth in so many

00:06:09.157 --> 00:06:14.077
cases because, one, Oxford's a great
place to live and so I think a lot of,

00:06:14.117 --> 00:06:18.937
I mean, there's 69 nationalities that
come to the MBA from Saiid and they've

00:06:18.937 --> 00:06:23.947
been intentionally recruited for their
extraordinary backgrounds, yet it's so

00:06:23.947 --> 00:06:27.327
rare that you would ever have someone
say, Oh, I'm working with a company in

00:06:27.327 --> 00:06:32.327
Oxford, full stop and it's such a missed
opportunity because the university

00:06:32.327 --> 00:06:35.707
is actually already recruited so many
extraordinary, I mean, talk about

00:06:35.707 --> 00:06:39.907
thinking now about recruitment fees
and how difficult it is to find talent.

00:06:40.274 --> 00:06:44.994
The university has kindly hand picked 330
extraordinary people from all over the

00:06:44.994 --> 00:06:49.554
world with incredibly niche skillsets,
like usually often many medical doctors,

00:06:49.554 --> 00:06:52.994
like people who've worked in similar
industries, venture capital, all of

00:06:52.994 --> 00:06:56.164
these different things that would
be so beneficial to move the needle.

00:06:56.524 --> 00:07:00.334
For so many companies that are just even
in central Oxford, not to mention the

00:07:00.334 --> 00:07:06.634
greater area and they aren't retained and
people don't even recruit from the MBA.

00:07:06.697 --> 00:07:11.677
There's a sort of endemic perception in
Oxford that I've found and have spoken

00:07:11.677 --> 00:07:16.767
to other folks that have been on this
podcast about where we need to change that

00:07:16.767 --> 00:07:21.257
narrative that Oxford is a great place to
start a business, it is a great place to

00:07:21.507 --> 00:07:25.547
settle down and raise a family or to even
just have a great time and have a base.

00:07:25.557 --> 00:07:27.657
For example, I go to London once a week.

00:07:27.657 --> 00:07:29.027
I go to Bristol once a month.

00:07:29.367 --> 00:07:32.907
I mean, it's an extraordinary place to
be able to take advantage of a lot of the

00:07:32.917 --> 00:07:34.797
UK and I say that even as an American.

00:07:36.619 --> 00:07:38.159
Susannah de Jager: Well thank
you firstly, for saying all

00:07:38.159 --> 00:07:39.519
the things that I agree with.

00:07:39.539 --> 00:07:44.909
So let's call, let's call that, you're
a great guest, Lily,  but it's really

00:07:44.929 --> 00:07:48.909
interesting hearing, as you're talking,
I'm thinking about Sarah Hayward from

00:07:48.919 --> 00:07:53.539
Advanced Oxford, who I know you know, but
absolutely talked about this same thing

00:07:53.539 --> 00:07:58.396
from, their perspective of just not very
good at retaining both our undergrads

00:07:58.396 --> 00:08:03.504
and obviously our MBAs from the business
school and what a loss that is because

00:08:03.504 --> 00:08:07.344
we've got all these brilliant people
and how can we retain more of them?

00:08:07.664 --> 00:08:11.547
And then equally, a slightly different
point, but Irene Tracy spoke about it,

00:08:11.547 --> 00:08:16.611
but also it's in the spin out review
that she co authored that point around

00:08:16.641 --> 00:08:20.501
getting business schools to work really
closely with excellent universities

00:08:20.531 --> 00:08:26.040
because, and you drew it up brilliantly,
but you have amazing academics who quite

00:08:26.040 --> 00:08:30.640
often have operated within an academic
setting for, if not the majority,

00:08:30.990 --> 00:08:35.210
possibly all of their career and it's
very different to go and commercialise

00:08:35.230 --> 00:08:38.380
something to sit in a strategic
seat, how do you grow a business?

00:08:38.460 --> 00:08:44.097
But of course, MBAs will classically
be from purely business backgrounds.

00:08:44.137 --> 00:08:48.830
Anyway, it's such a natural, join up and
so there's both an amazing opportunity

00:08:48.870 --> 00:08:52.530
and I suppose I'm a bit saddened to hear
that you still think there's so far to

00:08:52.530 --> 00:08:55.010
go, but thank you for drawing upon it.

00:08:56.110 --> 00:09:01.283
Coming back to Jack Fertility, I'd love
to hear how you went from your drug

00:09:01.283 --> 00:09:05.763
discovery journey and being head of
strategy there to then deciding you are

00:09:05.763 --> 00:09:11.079
going to do something yourself  and co
founding the amazing Jack Fertility.

00:09:11.099 --> 00:09:12.199
So tell me a bit about that.

00:09:12.284 --> 00:09:16.271
Lily Elsner: Yeah, it was an incredible
journey once again facilitated by COVID,

00:09:16.271 --> 00:09:20.921
which is sort of a bizarre thing to
say, but for myself and my co founder,

00:09:20.921 --> 00:09:26.476
Nick Shipley, we met on the NBA, first
day, he  was such a polite and still is.

00:09:26.476 --> 00:09:27.546
Susannah de Jager: Like a cute meet.

00:09:27.546 --> 00:09:31.486
Lily Elsner: Such a, it is so
cute, it really is, poor thing.

00:09:31.486 --> 00:09:35.066
So we're polar opposites in so many
ways yet we're so values aligned.

00:09:35.066 --> 00:09:37.956
So I'm the extrovert as you can
tell from being on the podcast.

00:09:38.206 --> 00:09:40.736
He is the introvert who's
currently recovering from a

00:09:40.736 --> 00:09:46.266
speaking engagement I forced him
to do yesterday at SIFTED Summit.

00:09:46.266 --> 00:09:53.122
But, truly, I love to do wide stretching
strategy work and he's has the eye

00:09:53.132 --> 00:09:55.062
for details, very content based.

00:09:55.362 --> 00:09:58.542
I mean, on every front we're
perfectly complementary and we saw

00:09:58.542 --> 00:09:59.792
that actually working together.

00:09:59.793 --> 00:10:03.642
So on the MBA course, you have
a study group and we did all of

00:10:03.642 --> 00:10:04.892
our different assessments too.

00:10:04.892 --> 00:10:07.662
We were randomly assigned and
then meanwhile also share the

00:10:07.662 --> 00:10:09.352
same British sense of humour.

00:10:09.372 --> 00:10:14.142
So I grew up watching British television
and absolutely loved all of the comedy

00:10:14.142 --> 00:10:18.872
and he also had seen some rather esoteric
shows, and we truly bonded over that

00:10:18.992 --> 00:10:23.542
and then actually in March 2020, he
and his wife had their first baby.

00:10:23.609 --> 00:10:27.059
So they had to go to the hospital
in the, that first day of, we're

00:10:27.059 --> 00:10:29.199
locked down, do we wear masks?

00:10:29.199 --> 00:10:30.169
We don't know.

00:10:30.179 --> 00:10:31.269
Follow the rules.

00:10:31.319 --> 00:10:35.069
and then they had to take this
baby home and navigate becoming

00:10:35.079 --> 00:10:36.559
parents while locked down.

00:10:36.559 --> 00:10:40.759
So for quite obvious reasons,
he ended up deferring to the

00:10:40.759 --> 00:10:42.129
following year of the MBA.

00:10:42.139 --> 00:10:45.949
So at the time, we weren't really thinking
about what ultimately would become Jack.

00:10:46.289 --> 00:10:50.379
Instead, we, like everyone else, were
contending with the evolving testing

00:10:50.389 --> 00:10:55.129
measures, started getting used to doing
PCR tests through the post and that's how

00:10:55.129 --> 00:10:59.499
this initially came up, is that when Nick
was returning to Oxford to finish the MBA,

00:11:00.012 --> 00:11:04.787
he very vulnerably shared that he wanted
to get his fertility tested because they

00:11:04.787 --> 00:11:09.837
had had some issues with the first, and
also wanted to ensure that especially in

00:11:09.837 --> 00:11:14.484
the, headlines that are happening at the
moment of sperm count is down almost 60

00:11:14.484 --> 00:11:19.634
percent over the last 50 years, one in six
couples will now experience infertility

00:11:19.644 --> 00:11:21.834
and the stats are only getting worse.

00:11:22.259 --> 00:11:25.699
so with that in the back of his mind,
he wanted to proactively get tested,

00:11:25.709 --> 00:11:30.359
yet when he approached first the NHS,
it's almost impossible to get a test.

00:11:30.419 --> 00:11:34.479
You have to actively try to conceive
for a year, you have to tell your GP

00:11:34.479 --> 00:11:38.339
about that, so that's already like
a huge mental block, for most men in

00:11:38.339 --> 00:11:41.459
particular, but also if you're not in
a heterosexual relationship and you

00:11:41.459 --> 00:11:44.819
want your fertility tested, that's a
whole other conversation, but basically

00:11:44.829 --> 00:11:48.859
it's one of these huge barriers and as
we started uncovering these, he also

00:11:48.859 --> 00:11:52.139
just said to me, he was like, it's so
embarrassing, it's so emasculating.

00:11:52.589 --> 00:11:56.459
When he went looking at the private
options, similarly, it has to be in

00:11:56.459 --> 00:11:58.699
person because sperm dies within an hour.

00:11:59.019 --> 00:12:03.629
So you have to go through this incredibly
embarrassing process, to then get results

00:12:03.629 --> 00:12:07.059
that you don't really know what to do with
unless you either pay for an additional

00:12:07.059 --> 00:12:14.316
consultation or you simply sort of say,
okay, well, let's, move on, and have to

00:12:14.316 --> 00:12:17.919
make some really difficult decisions about
whether to pursue fertility treatment

00:12:18.369 --> 00:12:21.699
and all of that said, meanwhile, we're
popping PCR tests through the post

00:12:22.179 --> 00:12:26.594
and that started the conversation of
why can't you just, Pop this in a post

00:12:26.594 --> 00:12:31.944
box, we're able to do everything else
in terms of testing and Nick and I had

00:12:31.944 --> 00:12:34.824
been chatting about this and I'm sort
of the science friend in our friend

00:12:34.824 --> 00:12:36.914
group and he said, why is this the case?

00:12:37.384 --> 00:12:41.517
And in the back of my mind, I was like,
look, artificial insemination is how

00:12:41.517 --> 00:12:45.917
the entire livestock industry works
globally and so many people send all

00:12:45.917 --> 00:12:50.387
sorts of samples through the post for
conception purposes even and I thought,

00:12:50.387 --> 00:12:55.722
for testing, actually, it probably isn't
that complicated and so after sort of

00:12:55.722 --> 00:13:00.952
abusing our Oxford email addresses and
interviewing anyone foolish enough to

00:13:00.952 --> 00:13:06.356
answer our emails over about six months,
we really talked ourselves, first trying

00:13:06.356 --> 00:13:11.126
to talk ourselves out of developing what
became Jack, which is a postal sperm test

00:13:11.496 --> 00:13:16.061
and then back into and really developing
the conviction around the massive market

00:13:16.091 --> 00:13:20.891
that there is for proactive male fertility
testing, as well as all the different

00:13:21.001 --> 00:13:24.651
societal taboos that we could also be
breaking down at the same time to also

00:13:24.661 --> 00:13:28.311
remove the burden on women because so
many times Nick's wife had three or four

00:13:28.311 --> 00:13:32.101
different options of things she could
send through the post, yet for women,

00:13:32.111 --> 00:13:35.291
fertility treatment is so much more
different and there's so much less you

00:13:35.291 --> 00:13:40.159
can do it was very empowering experience
of, it is scary to start something.

00:13:40.159 --> 00:13:44.922
It's massively high risk personally, I
just thought, you know, if not now when

00:13:45.242 --> 00:13:49.752
and especially at the beginning of such
a wave of what ultimately we will be this

00:13:49.752 --> 00:13:56.092
massive market opportunity and also huge
societal need, all of my MBA instincts as

00:13:56.092 --> 00:14:00.059
well as my personal instincts were telling
me it's time to take that leap, and felt

00:14:00.059 --> 00:14:02.109
very empowered and supported to do so.

00:14:03.239 --> 00:14:05.899
Susannah de Jager: It's so exciting
to hear you talk about it because

00:14:06.205 --> 00:14:09.755
you do have an amazing background for
it, you've got all of this experience

00:14:10.085 --> 00:14:14.895
and I really understand on a personal
level that draw towards wanting to do

00:14:14.895 --> 00:14:18.525
something for yourself and something so
important where you can see the market

00:14:18.525 --> 00:14:23.225
need, you've got this great partner,
you've got so much together as well.

00:14:23.235 --> 00:14:27.995
So it's really inspiring firstly and
I like the phrase you use of we try

00:14:27.995 --> 00:14:30.945
to talk ourselves out of it because
I think that's quite a good way of

00:14:30.945 --> 00:14:32.395
like really beating something up.

00:14:32.455 --> 00:14:35.055
If it's still burning a hole
in your head after months and

00:14:35.385 --> 00:14:36.345
you're like, I got to do it.

00:14:36.415 --> 00:14:38.435
I've just got to go for it.

00:14:39.264 --> 00:14:42.924
When you say it out loud, it almost seems
obvious as all the best ideas do, I'm

00:14:43.204 --> 00:14:47.274
not trying to take away, but I'm like,
yeah, sure, why is that not a thing?

00:14:47.544 --> 00:14:49.414
Why is it not a thing?

00:14:49.594 --> 00:14:51.634
Lily Elsner: Yeah, huge question.

00:14:51.634 --> 00:14:54.934
I appreciate you asking it because
this is what took six months.

00:14:55.244 --> 00:14:59.294
It just seems so obvious and of
course, this is also something

00:14:59.294 --> 00:15:00.944
investors ask us all the time.

00:15:00.944 --> 00:15:04.744
But after, I mean, we've interviewed
hundreds of experts at this point

00:15:04.754 --> 00:15:09.564
globally and have become quite embedded
in the Femtech and sort of broader

00:15:09.694 --> 00:15:15.050
reproductive health landscape, because
it seems so ridiculous and I think

00:15:15.060 --> 00:15:17.390
there's sort of two major reasons why.

00:15:17.400 --> 00:15:21.780
The first is technological priorities,
and that's really the innovation

00:15:21.780 --> 00:15:26.340
and what we've done at Jack and kind
of our, the reason why it is novel.

00:15:26.390 --> 00:15:31.890
But the second one is this incredibly
entrenched taboo, both from the

00:15:31.890 --> 00:15:35.580
perspective of fertility clinics
themselves, fertility has always been

00:15:35.580 --> 00:15:37.530
something that people are very ashamed of.

00:15:37.540 --> 00:15:41.050
There's so much pressure on
both male and female sides.

00:15:41.050 --> 00:15:43.960
I mean, of course, for women,
when I normally, when I pitch, I

00:15:43.960 --> 00:15:47.670
say, what gender do you think of
when I say the word fertility?

00:15:48.350 --> 00:15:51.930
People always say women, and then it's
equally likely to be male or female

00:15:51.930 --> 00:15:58.420
factor in infertility and often we find
that there's so much shame associated

00:15:58.420 --> 00:16:00.450
with even investigating the male side.

00:16:00.450 --> 00:16:05.470
So men often will, take up to a year
to even book a test because they don't

00:16:05.470 --> 00:16:10.324
want to contend with the fact that they
may or may not be virile or whatever we

00:16:10.354 --> 00:16:14.304
want to talk about because it's so tied
to masculinity and so even people who

00:16:14.304 --> 00:16:18.574
have a relatively healthy relationship
with masculinity will feel very scared.

00:16:18.574 --> 00:16:22.564
So for example, we trialed a tagline
for Jack of, is your sperm okay?

00:16:22.914 --> 00:16:28.864
With over a hundred people and they all
hated it, I wouldn't say all, but most of

00:16:28.864 --> 00:16:32.899
them felt quite threatened and for me, I
was like, especially as a woman, you're

00:16:32.899 --> 00:16:37.090
constantly worried about your fertility
but for men, I think it's the first time

00:16:37.090 --> 00:16:42.850
and to have it so intensely in your face
of, Oh my God, I may not be okay and

00:16:42.850 --> 00:16:46.970
the fear is interesting, that reaction
to the fear as well, rather than in my

00:16:46.970 --> 00:16:48.860
head and just maybe it's my personality.

00:16:48.860 --> 00:16:51.520
I was like, Oh, well, we'll just
check, like, we'll just find out.

00:16:51.950 --> 00:16:56.375
But similarly, if we take a step back
on the revenue model of fertility

00:16:56.425 --> 00:16:58.255
companies and fertility clinics.

00:16:58.635 --> 00:17:03.455
It's really not necessarily in the revenue
driving interest to investigate the

00:17:03.455 --> 00:17:07.955
male factor because about 90 percent of
cases of male infertility are treatable.

00:17:08.035 --> 00:17:12.615
So it's usually a mix of
lifestyle factors, so identifying

00:17:12.615 --> 00:17:15.845
what is detrimental to the
spermatogenesis process.

00:17:16.135 --> 00:17:19.885
So that's things like heat exposure
can often be really detrimental.

00:17:19.885 --> 00:17:24.925
So long cycling rides in Lycra is
terrible for sperm, I'm afraid to say.

00:17:25.525 --> 00:17:32.975
I know, I know here all, I know
I was like greater Oxfordshire

00:17:33.045 --> 00:17:34.645
on a Saturday, unfortunately.

00:17:34.645 --> 00:17:36.835
Susannah de Jager: The mammals
are just dying right now!

00:17:36.879 --> 00:17:37.659
Lily Elsner: Truly.

00:17:37.964 --> 00:17:41.584
Especially actually followed up
with a too long sauna, I mean, that

00:17:41.594 --> 00:17:44.614
is basically birth control, but
that's a whole other conversation.

00:17:44.614 --> 00:17:45.454
Susannah de Jager: What about ice baths?

00:17:45.874 --> 00:17:46.304
Lily Elsner: I know.

00:17:46.334 --> 00:17:51.464
Ice baths, ice baths that can
report are good, so not, not too

00:17:51.704 --> 00:17:53.044
Susannah de Jager: Sales
are going to go up!

00:17:53.044 --> 00:17:53.214
Lily Elsner: I know.

00:17:53.244 --> 00:17:53.694
I know.

00:17:53.694 --> 00:17:54.394
Susannah de Jager: There's
going to be a bump.

00:17:54.604 --> 00:17:55.774
Lily Elsner: I'm like, buy now.

00:17:56.594 --> 00:17:58.154
This is not investment advice.

00:17:59.769 --> 00:18:03.128
But yeah, I mean, there's so many pieces
that as we started looking at this, you

00:18:03.128 --> 00:18:07.168
just have to think we see the rise of
private equity buying up fertility clinics

00:18:07.528 --> 00:18:12.238
in the US as well as the UK and around
the world because it is so lucrative and

00:18:12.238 --> 00:18:16.518
so what I found and actually there are
definitely clinics that do this, there

00:18:16.518 --> 00:18:20.821
are many that don't, but if you have
a male fertility patient, the number

00:18:20.821 --> 00:18:27.501
one reason why women have IVF in the
UK, 37%, is due to male infertility.

00:18:27.531 --> 00:18:30.731
So the women are, in most
cases, almost completely fine.

00:18:30.731 --> 00:18:33.121
It's just that the sperm
quality is not high enough.

00:18:33.521 --> 00:18:36.551
The issue with that is that usually
that is incredibly treatable.

00:18:36.571 --> 00:18:39.991
So for example, it'll be either
an environmental or a lifestyle

00:18:39.991 --> 00:18:41.971
factor happening that's causing...

00:18:42.091 --> 00:18:43.891
Susannah de Jager: Doesn't
sound lucrative though.

00:18:44.021 --> 00:18:45.401
Lily Elsner: No, it doesn't,
because what do you do?

00:18:45.411 --> 00:18:50.686
Like, how do you make money off of saying
just be healthy for three to six months,

00:18:50.706 --> 00:18:56.806
you know, lay off the booze, start
exercising, or in a couple cases, and this

00:18:56.806 --> 00:18:59.816
is what is so saddening, especially in
sort of the fertility justice area, I've

00:18:59.816 --> 00:19:04.731
been speaking with a number of people,
who ended up having, or either are donor

00:19:04.751 --> 00:19:09.981
conceived children or people who did
not need to have fertility treatment.

00:19:10.251 --> 00:19:14.674
It actually was often either a
blockage in, sort of the parts

00:19:14.674 --> 00:19:16.094
of the reproductive system.

00:19:16.384 --> 00:19:19.914
A varicocell is one of the most common
issues, that's a blood vessel that

00:19:19.914 --> 00:19:25.174
basically the heat of that blood vessel
almost like, to just put it vividly,

00:19:25.174 --> 00:19:29.714
it just sort of cooks the sperm because
of the proximity of the tubes and so

00:19:30.209 --> 00:19:33.929
basically, it's like internal birth
control, but if you remove that blood

00:19:33.929 --> 00:19:37.559
vessel, it's a very simple procedure
and so you can go from being almost

00:19:37.599 --> 00:19:42.779
completely infertile to perfectly healthy
just after that surgery and waiting a

00:19:42.779 --> 00:19:47.709
few months and so, this isn't in all
cases, but it's very frequent and so you

00:19:47.719 --> 00:19:52.852
often see people going into, you know,
they'll spend, between 5, 000 and 10,

00:19:52.853 --> 00:19:57.283
000 pounds per cycle, going through up
to five cycles and to be able to save

00:19:57.283 --> 00:20:01.673
that money by just having a surgery
that you didn't know you needed to have,

00:20:01.683 --> 00:20:04.743
because again, men aren't necessarily
going to the doctor saying, Hey,

00:20:04.743 --> 00:20:08.888
actually something's a bit, a bit wrong
downstairs, I'd love to check or we want

00:20:08.888 --> 00:20:10.538
to have a baby, we're trying for a baby.

00:20:10.578 --> 00:20:14.738
I mean, it's so, so many barriers to
getting this done and so that's why

00:20:15.268 --> 00:20:19.558
on our side, we just saw this massive
opportunity to be able to say, look, it's

00:20:19.568 --> 00:20:24.158
in the heads of so many people to have
a product that comprehensively shows you

00:20:24.158 --> 00:20:28.243
what's going on and then roots you to
the right care and of course has revenue

00:20:28.243 --> 00:20:31.383
generating opportunities of saying, look,
you don't have to do this on your own

00:20:31.423 --> 00:20:34.083
because I think there's also a mental
health component of that, of supporting

00:20:34.083 --> 00:20:38.783
people through this vulnerable process
and that's what we've designed you get

00:20:38.783 --> 00:20:42.153
the same results you would have gotten
at a fertility clinic, you get all of

00:20:42.153 --> 00:20:46.013
the guidance that you would get normally
through a consultation and then also

00:20:46.013 --> 00:20:50.618
concrete next steps on what you need
to do and mitigating a lot of the fear

00:20:50.668 --> 00:20:54.488
that's around that because it can save
people so much, not only money, which

00:20:54.488 --> 00:20:59.438
of course a consumer is interested in
doing, but also so much stress and so

00:20:59.438 --> 00:21:03.691
much heartache, removing that coulda,
woulda, shoulda, just through simple

00:21:03.691 --> 00:21:07.741
education is part of, why we decided
to go direct to consumer rather than

00:21:07.741 --> 00:21:11.931
relying on all of the infrastructure
that we see in the more B2B landscape

00:21:11.931 --> 00:21:13.961
Susannah de Jager: So I want to come
back to that point because I think

00:21:13.961 --> 00:21:15.618
that's really important to cover.

00:21:15.888 --> 00:21:19.488
But before we do, what is
novel about what you're doing?

00:21:19.488 --> 00:21:22.948
What have you created in the kind
of technology that you're using?

00:21:22.948 --> 00:21:24.378
Cause I'd love to understand
that a bit better.

00:21:24.408 --> 00:21:24.818
Lily Elsner: Yes.

00:21:24.828 --> 00:21:29.358
the real differentiator for Jack is
that one, it's entirely postal, which

00:21:29.358 --> 00:21:34.201
is really important point because there
are a few competitors that exist that

00:21:34.201 --> 00:21:38.041
are either handheld devices and what
we found through Nick's background

00:21:38.041 --> 00:21:41.051
is in fast moving consumer goods
marketing and consumer insight, so

00:21:41.051 --> 00:21:44.001
we've done so many different interviews
and different ways of assessing this.

00:21:44.201 --> 00:21:48.491
But basically what people said is that
there's a huge ick factor with testing

00:21:48.541 --> 00:21:50.491
your own sample as you can imagine.

00:21:50.871 --> 00:21:56.951
There's also a big concern around, again,
the quality of the samples necessitating

00:21:57.351 --> 00:22:01.991
there's a competitor that does courier
pickup and as anyone who has ever ordered

00:22:01.991 --> 00:22:07.153
something, Uber Eats or any even just
picking up packages, there's so much

00:22:07.153 --> 00:22:11.123
uncertainty in that timing and the way
that unless you're sort of doing what

00:22:11.123 --> 00:22:15.063
we've done, and I'll get into that in a
moment, the quality of the sample is not

00:22:15.063 --> 00:22:17.623
going to be within the appropriate range.

00:22:17.623 --> 00:22:21.613
So what we've done to mitigate
this and to be able to enable this

00:22:21.623 --> 00:22:25.513
postal aspect is like I mentioned,
normally sperm dies within an hour.

00:22:25.753 --> 00:22:27.463
So the first thing, sperm are just cells.

00:22:27.473 --> 00:22:30.833
So you need to keep them alive, they
need to have enough space to be able to

00:22:30.833 --> 00:22:35.118
move around and so what you give them is
basically food and a little more space.

00:22:35.128 --> 00:22:38.538
So we have a preservation medium
that we have the individual who uses

00:22:38.538 --> 00:22:43.818
the kit just pops in a little bit
of this medium and seals up the tube

00:22:43.818 --> 00:22:45.028
where they collect their sample.

00:22:45.498 --> 00:22:49.568
Then they pop it into our kit, which
has a bunch of temperature controls and

00:22:49.568 --> 00:22:53.428
temperature monitoring so we know that
we can keep it within a certain range.

00:22:53.843 --> 00:22:56.893
It goes through the post tracked
24 and arrives at our lab.

00:22:57.303 --> 00:23:01.173
When it gets to our lab, our embryologist
then assesses the sample as if we were at

00:23:01.173 --> 00:23:05.579
a fertility clinic with a few adjustments,
and then we apply an aging algorithm

00:23:05.589 --> 00:23:09.940
that we have developed based on a huge
research study we did last fall, and

00:23:09.940 --> 00:23:13.760
so there's a sort of complimentary data
strategy that we're developing to be able

00:23:13.760 --> 00:23:17.340
to get a lot of this information that
just doesn't exist in the world, in an

00:23:17.340 --> 00:23:22.747
age where data is king, is gold, that's
another longer term play that we're doing.

00:23:22.892 --> 00:23:25.592
Susannah de Jager: That's really
interesting because obviously most

00:23:25.592 --> 00:23:29.264
people have now heard of Zoe, which
is, a completely different area, but

00:23:29.744 --> 00:23:33.954
always these problems that aren't looked
at, you think, oh, we just need so

00:23:33.954 --> 00:23:38.354
much more data and then you could be
educating people out the front, right?

00:23:38.374 --> 00:23:41.784
Like these are the factors, try
this before you try it for a baby.

00:23:42.694 --> 00:23:46.804
This is what you should be thinking about
and that educational piece predicated upon

00:23:46.934 --> 00:23:50.034
hard, cold data, that's super exciting.

00:23:50.294 --> 00:23:52.274
I hadn't heard you speak
about that element before.

00:23:52.924 --> 00:23:58.154
So moving back to what you said about
direct consumer rather than B2B.

00:23:58.914 --> 00:24:03.894
We've spoken about this quite a lot and
how it's a less familiar model to lots

00:24:03.894 --> 00:24:05.964
of investors, particularly in the UK.

00:24:06.294 --> 00:24:10.964
I'd love to hear a little bit more about
some of the conversations you're coming

00:24:10.964 --> 00:24:16.210
into,   and what mental block appears
to be, because to me it seems like it

00:24:16.210 --> 00:24:18.390
is a natural direct to consumer play.

00:24:18.597 --> 00:24:23.167
Lily Elsner: To our earlier points around
the Oxford ecosystem and thinking so much

00:24:23.177 --> 00:24:29.827
about the genesis of ventures, a lot of
the times B2B does seem the less risky

00:24:29.827 --> 00:24:34.685
route because for us, we analysed all
of our competitors and saw how they went

00:24:34.685 --> 00:24:39.025
to market and saw what was successful
and what wasn't and unfortunately,

00:24:39.325 --> 00:24:43.705
for male fertility in particular, we
haven't known a lot about the customers.

00:24:43.705 --> 00:24:45.255
There are three companies in the U.

00:24:45.255 --> 00:24:45.435
S.

00:24:45.445 --> 00:24:47.495
that have done this
incredibly successfully.

00:24:47.795 --> 00:24:50.749
So they've paved the way in
terms of how this all works.

00:24:51.139 --> 00:24:55.549
But in the UK and in greater Europe,
we've seen one or two companies that

00:24:55.549 --> 00:24:59.729
have entered the market, and have
actually failed on the B2B side and

00:24:59.729 --> 00:25:03.639
part of that was because their results
weren't necessarily what clinicians

00:25:03.639 --> 00:25:07.549
needed and then similarly about
retaining some of these contracts.

00:25:07.549 --> 00:25:10.839
it's a really difficult conversation to
have, particularly in Oxford, where we

00:25:10.839 --> 00:25:15.639
have so many spin outs that are so focused
on areas like drug discovery, or even if

00:25:15.639 --> 00:25:20.079
it's hardware, it's these super deep tech
ventures, it's almost like we've forgotten

00:25:20.079 --> 00:25:23.469
about all the other types of businesses
and for me, I've been quite frustrated

00:25:23.469 --> 00:25:27.749
with that because, especially Nick having
worked at Nestle and Kraft Heinz and these

00:25:27.749 --> 00:25:31.665
huge companies and me being, I mean, I
literally was chief of staff for the U.

00:25:31.665 --> 00:25:31.835
S.

00:25:32.035 --> 00:25:35.882
credit card division of Capital One,
specifically in our data analytics and

00:25:35.882 --> 00:25:40.581
digital marketing area, our margins
are extraordinary and so we don't need

00:25:40.581 --> 00:25:44.151
that many customers to be profitable
and so it's almost like we, in the

00:25:44.151 --> 00:25:50.841
UK, have conditioned ourselves to hear
consumer equals high cap, high failure

00:25:51.701 --> 00:25:55.131
and I think there needs to be a bit
of a correction because especially in

00:25:55.131 --> 00:25:58.801
healthcare for some of these incredibly
important products, there's always

00:25:58.811 --> 00:26:00.231
going to be a willingness to pay.

00:26:00.633 --> 00:26:05.848
But I think when we're talking about the
investment landscape in Oxford, I've seen

00:26:05.848 --> 00:26:11.488
this consistently and it is another area
of flight for potentially extraordinary

00:26:11.488 --> 00:26:16.088
successful Oxford based businesses is
that, it was really shocking when looking

00:26:16.088 --> 00:26:20.368
in databases and looking at who backs
these types of companies, it goes from

00:26:20.368 --> 00:26:25.474
being all the different types of funds
to my options are basically about six

00:26:25.474 --> 00:26:30.228
early stage funds that do consumer and
then a variety of family offices and

00:26:30.228 --> 00:26:35.088
then it's really just angels, um, who I
then have to go and say like, basically,

00:26:35.098 --> 00:26:36.628
do you want to make a lot of money?

00:26:36.778 --> 00:26:38.968
And then, then we can
have the conversation.

00:26:38.968 --> 00:26:42.198
But if I use any of those key words,
consumer, health insurance, you

00:26:42.263 --> 00:26:46.736
Healthcare, e commerce, these have
become almost like dirty words.

00:26:47.034 --> 00:26:49.744
the beauty of Jack is that
it's not too complicated.

00:26:49.754 --> 00:26:53.684
Like, we can just get to market, and
everyone's always so worried about IP.

00:26:53.694 --> 00:26:58.234
The first conversation an Oxford investor
always asks me is, what's your IP?

00:26:58.504 --> 00:27:01.114
And thankfully for us, like, we
have done so much innovation,

00:27:01.124 --> 00:27:02.324
we have a patent pending.

00:27:02.969 --> 00:27:06.639
We have a number of really strategic
moves in terms of our protecting our

00:27:06.639 --> 00:27:09.599
brand as well as licensing opportunities.

00:27:09.969 --> 00:27:13.329
But for me, I'm like, don't
worry about our IP until you've

00:27:13.329 --> 00:27:14.536
heard the business, right?

00:27:14.536 --> 00:27:17.116
Is the IP actually what's important here?

00:27:17.476 --> 00:27:21.356
And I think that's partially the dominance
of spin outs and so many of the other

00:27:21.406 --> 00:27:26.596
types of investments that we see here,
but it does put again, the blinders on of

00:27:26.596 --> 00:27:32.036
saying, you know, why if you are investing
at certain levels, wouldn't you rather

00:27:32.036 --> 00:27:35.016
support something that's going to go to
market and quickly make revenue and have

00:27:35.016 --> 00:27:40.626
an exit opportunity rather than sort of
just being so focused on a patent that may

00:27:40.626 --> 00:27:45.906
not actually be necessary for a long time,
and may not be the first thing that you

00:27:45.906 --> 00:27:48.756
need in terms of developing the business.

00:27:48.786 --> 00:27:51.371
Susannah de Jager: It's really interesting
hearing you say that because there is

00:27:51.371 --> 00:27:55.301
a lot of focus on IP, and of course you
want to moat to protect your business,

00:27:55.611 --> 00:28:01.131
but there are other ways and I think
it probably is quite one dimensional

00:28:01.551 --> 00:28:02.561
in Oxford, from my experience.

00:28:03.131 --> 00:28:06.791
I'd love to hear exactly where you're up
to at the moment, what the raise you're

00:28:06.801 --> 00:28:10.401
currently working on is, because I know
you are currently working on a raise.

00:28:10.611 --> 00:28:13.671
You're speaking to hundreds of
investors, which is why it's so

00:28:13.681 --> 00:28:16.571
useful to have you here to talk to
people about some of that experience.

00:28:16.881 --> 00:28:19.021
Where are you and how is it going?

00:28:19.219 --> 00:28:22.569
Lily Elsner: So we're currently
raising 500, 000 pounds, for

00:28:22.619 --> 00:28:24.879
ostensibly a pre seed raise, which
is really going to take us to market.

00:28:26.474 --> 00:28:31.724
So, we have our MVP, the, I mean,
the whole thing is built out, which

00:28:31.724 --> 00:28:33.754
is extraordinary, super exciting.

00:28:34.141 --> 00:28:37.561
Thanks to, we're based in the Wood Center
for Innovation and have a small lab there.

00:28:37.561 --> 00:28:41.931
So I've done all of our innovating
there and it's ready to go.

00:28:42.401 --> 00:28:46.171
we just need to go through that regulatory
process for a class one medical device

00:28:46.201 --> 00:28:51.221
and then get selling, which is super
exciting to finally actually have

00:28:51.221 --> 00:28:53.131
a business and start doing that.

00:28:53.371 --> 00:28:55.521
So overall, it's been going really well.

00:28:56.001 --> 00:29:00.986
we were able to successfully raised
last summer on a very healthy valuation.

00:29:00.996 --> 00:29:04.829
This time we've also been able to raise
a healthy valuation, but I've been

00:29:04.829 --> 00:29:08.566
floored by some of the feedback, not
from the investors themselves who are

00:29:08.566 --> 00:29:14.036
investing, but actually just advisors in
the ecosystem who just are perpetuating

00:29:14.036 --> 00:29:19.169
this perception of UK companies
having these floor level valuations.

00:29:19.169 --> 00:29:22.399
I mean, I had someone suggest to
me, we raised last summer at 3.

00:29:22.399 --> 00:29:26.404
5 million and someone said to
me, actually, I should probably

00:29:26.404 --> 00:29:28.954
lower that to two and I said, why?

00:29:28.974 --> 00:29:31.634
Like, we have so many assets,
there's so many reasons why

00:29:31.634 --> 00:29:33.604
that valuation was what it was.

00:29:34.344 --> 00:29:36.684
Why in the world would I lower it?

00:29:36.684 --> 00:29:40.964
Just from, I mean, this is showing
my Americanism, but why, from a

00:29:40.964 --> 00:29:45.324
negotiation perspective, why would
I go in with such a low valuation?

00:29:45.324 --> 00:29:51.134
And he was like, that's just how it is
and it really was so shocking to me, and

00:29:51.134 --> 00:29:54.604
of course then had a lot of interesting
cultural conversations about, sort of,

00:29:54.874 --> 00:29:59.894
perception and negotiation in Britain
versus America, but that aside, I

00:29:59.904 --> 00:30:04.634
think I share that too, because in my
experience, like, part of becoming the

00:30:04.634 --> 00:30:09.269
founder that I am and our founding journey
is learning how to take what advice

00:30:09.269 --> 00:30:12.509
is appropriate and also just learning
how to trust your gut and trust your

00:30:12.509 --> 00:30:16.139
instincts because we do know that this is
going to be a really successful business

00:30:16.139 --> 00:30:19.709
and we're backing not only ourselves
but our existing investors and what

00:30:19.709 --> 00:30:21.529
they've supported us to build to date.

00:30:21.529 --> 00:30:25.629
So we've have almost half of the round
committed at this point and we're looking

00:30:26.059 --> 00:30:27.909
still for the right lead investor.

00:30:27.919 --> 00:30:31.149
We've had a number of really exciting
conversations both in the UK and

00:30:31.149 --> 00:30:33.439
in Europe about potential leads.

00:30:33.819 --> 00:30:38.309
But I think that's the other trap that
early stage companies, particularly in

00:30:38.309 --> 00:30:42.549
Oxford and the UK, fall into is taking
the first money that they get rather

00:30:42.549 --> 00:30:46.529
than being incredibly intentional about
their cap table and that's one of the

00:30:46.529 --> 00:30:51.069
biggest lessons that Nick and I have
learned in that even the first time

00:30:51.069 --> 00:30:54.789
that we turned down money, it was one
of the hardest things we've ever done.

00:30:54.789 --> 00:30:57.909
But looking back, it was the
best thing we did because that

00:30:58.584 --> 00:31:00.014
would have killed the business.

00:31:00.104 --> 00:31:02.634
Susannah de Jager: And it's really
interesting because this comes up a

00:31:02.634 --> 00:31:06.671
lot and it always sounds like quite
a privileged position, but actually

00:31:06.911 --> 00:31:11.381
hearing you talk about it, particularly
in an area that is depressingly a bit

00:31:11.391 --> 00:31:14.641
less well understood, there is always
going to be feedback that encourages

00:31:14.661 --> 00:31:18.941
you to shift slightly to meet the
demands of a larger pool of investors.

00:31:19.001 --> 00:31:22.801
But that doesn't mean it's the right
thing to do and it can be so tempting,

00:31:23.291 --> 00:31:27.666
but it's so important to stick to what
you know and you guys do know, you

00:31:27.666 --> 00:31:31.656
come from that background, it's going
to be the correct business model and

00:31:31.656 --> 00:31:36.196
find people that actually support that
and support your vision for how to

00:31:36.196 --> 00:31:40.186
develop it and I know that you've got
kind of Femtech Lab, Founders Factory,

00:31:40.212 --> 00:31:42.625
Moonstone Fund and the Oxford Seed Fund.

00:31:43.949 --> 00:31:48.809
But it is fishing in a smaller pool
and I hear that difficulty, but it

00:31:48.809 --> 00:31:49.979
sounds like you're doing amazingly.

00:31:50.009 --> 00:31:51.369
So that's super exciting.

00:31:52.306 --> 00:31:57.056
You are a female founder in a
male focused company and in a

00:31:57.086 --> 00:32:02.326
predominantly male environment, which
we know venture capital still is.

00:32:03.286 --> 00:32:07.591
Do you see that impacting some of
the responses you're dealing with?

00:32:08.651 --> 00:32:09.731
Lily Elsner: I do.

00:32:10.981 --> 00:32:16.967
put bluntly, I do and it's such a
complicated topic in terms of gender

00:32:16.967 --> 00:32:20.297
and gender perception and we've had
some amazing conversations about this.

00:32:20.971 --> 00:32:24.941
I've had an investor at the
investment committee asked me

00:32:24.961 --> 00:32:27.471
directly, why are you doing this?

00:32:27.786 --> 00:32:31.846
Looking at Nick being like, Oh, it
makes total sense, you're a father, you

00:32:31.956 --> 00:32:36.836
have all of these experiences and then
just looking at me being like, and you?

00:32:36.886 --> 00:32:38.496
Susannah de Jager: Just see
what the response you get.

00:32:38.576 --> 00:32:41.951
Lily Elsner: I do often say that I'm just,
I'm just really passionate about sperm.

00:32:42.331 --> 00:32:44.061
It was a hobby of mine.

00:32:44.111 --> 00:32:46.556
Susannah de Jager: It's so strange
because we know that on the flip

00:32:46.556 --> 00:32:50.956
side, lots of femtech businesses are
still predominantly run by men and I

00:32:50.956 --> 00:32:52.856
wonder if they get that same feedback.

00:32:52.856 --> 00:32:57.126
Lily Elsner: Recently Flow made headlines
because they became the first femtech

00:32:57.136 --> 00:33:01.476
unicorn and they're founded by two men and
it's basically a period tracker and there

00:33:01.476 --> 00:33:06.496
are so many women, including the women
who started Clue and so many of the other

00:33:06.936 --> 00:33:11.412
companies in this space where the really
it was so difficult to contend with that

00:33:11.412 --> 00:33:15.402
because, of course, you don't want to say,
oh, you know, it's just a gender thing,

00:33:15.402 --> 00:33:20.222
but the evidence shows that it actually
really probably is a gender thing in this

00:33:20.222 --> 00:33:22.682
case of just like the privilege and the...

00:33:23.292 --> 00:33:28.862
it's really the trust and it's so
difficult to know that you're approaching

00:33:28.862 --> 00:33:32.752
an investment conversation already
several steps behind and that's

00:33:32.752 --> 00:33:36.552
what I've really realized through,
again, just hundreds of data points

00:33:36.552 --> 00:33:38.042
of the various pitches I've done.

00:33:38.411 --> 00:33:44.831
Interestingly, not when we do explicitly
call out gender, but personally this

00:33:44.831 --> 00:33:49.908
summer I was in a number of pitches where
I realised the difference between pitching

00:33:49.908 --> 00:33:56.668
for an explicitly female founder space
versus just a generic pitch was that I,

00:33:56.688 --> 00:33:59.958
halfway through pitching for a female
founder thing, I realised I was having

00:33:59.958 --> 00:34:03.926
this sort of like, I was almost seizing
up because I was defensive about something

00:34:03.936 --> 00:34:07.911
and I realised it was because I was so
used to being interrupted, even in the

00:34:07.911 --> 00:34:12.468
first minute of whatever time limit stated
pitch, even a pretty high touch, sort

00:34:12.468 --> 00:34:14.705
of regulated type pitching environment.

00:34:14.705 --> 00:34:17.895
I was so used to being interrupted
or questioned or asked.

00:34:18.305 --> 00:34:22.600
I shared with you an anecdote earlier
of an Oxford MBA, I mean, 10 years of

00:34:22.600 --> 00:34:25.810
experience in corporate and all these
different, wearing so many different hats.

00:34:25.810 --> 00:34:30.030
I've been asked to define acronyms
just to make sure that I knew what they

00:34:30.030 --> 00:34:34.770
were and I just about, I'm like, first
of all, would you ask anyone that?

00:34:35.390 --> 00:34:36.600
And how is that appropriate?

00:34:36.600 --> 00:34:37.610
How is that relevant?

00:34:37.910 --> 00:34:42.620
And then I noticed that's an experience
that I just never hear Nick having

00:34:42.690 --> 00:34:48.360
and similar, very rare that my male
counterparts ever have that sort

00:34:48.360 --> 00:34:52.280
of experience, but I think also an
interesting point to share on this

00:34:52.290 --> 00:34:56.100
perspective of being a female founder in
a male space, I actually am the customer.

00:34:56.100 --> 00:34:59.290
We anticipate most of the
Jack kits to be purchased by

00:34:59.290 --> 00:35:01.230
women for their male partners.

00:35:02.094 --> 00:35:06.064
It really is, and I think that's where
it's so, and frankly fun from our

00:35:06.164 --> 00:35:10.584
perspective, especially as a male and
female founding team, is that Nick is

00:35:10.584 --> 00:35:14.254
able to make sure and speak with our
marketing team, of course, both based

00:35:14.254 --> 00:35:17.854
on his expertise, but also being the
target audience in a lot of ways by

00:35:17.854 --> 00:35:21.004
making sure that it's a confident,
approachable, masculine brand.

00:35:21.619 --> 00:35:25.749
But I, on my side, of course, am thinking
about all of the women, and frankly, I

00:35:25.749 --> 00:35:30.859
would say about half of our 2, 000 plus
wait list at this point is women who want

00:35:30.869 --> 00:35:34.569
to buy for their partners because, of
course, the likes of Hertility and so many

00:35:34.579 --> 00:35:40.049
of these other trailblazing companies in
the remote female fertility space have

00:35:40.049 --> 00:35:43.439
raised so much awareness that this is
important and they're looking for this

00:35:43.439 --> 00:35:48.322
male factor side to have their partners
tested and so, for me, I think it's almost

00:35:48.322 --> 00:35:53.052
dangerous to not have that perspective
on your team So especially as a woman, I

00:35:53.062 --> 00:35:56.552
mean, part of it, it is fun, it's really
interesting, I've learned so much about

00:35:56.562 --> 00:36:01.172
the frankly, the male psyche, in the
process of doing this research, but also

00:36:01.292 --> 00:36:06.672
it truly in the spirit of innovation, I
think this is one of the most exciting

00:36:06.732 --> 00:36:11.395
areas that you can possibly be in because
it's one of the last frontiers, and for

00:36:11.405 --> 00:36:15.675
me that's incredibly exciting and then
getting to be the one who's sharing

00:36:15.675 --> 00:36:20.198
this, the facts and the excitement that
I find and hopefully paving the way for

00:36:20.198 --> 00:36:24.608
more people to tackle such an important
issue on the male fertility side.

00:36:25.087 --> 00:36:27.307
Susannah de Jager: It makes a lot of
sense when you talk about bringing

00:36:27.307 --> 00:36:32.997
both perspectives as a team and it's
well documented that diverse teams are

00:36:32.997 --> 00:36:37.253
really good for lots of reasons, but
in your particular business, you can't

00:36:37.263 --> 00:36:39.510
have a perspective that not living.

00:36:39.740 --> 00:36:43.068
You can try and get into the head of
your customers, of course, and, and

00:36:43.068 --> 00:36:47.128
people do that brilliantly, but it's
a clear benefit that both you and

00:36:47.128 --> 00:36:49.508
Nick are founders of this company.

00:36:50.181 --> 00:36:54.946
So Lily, It's really interesting, and
dare I say it, not terribly surprising

00:36:54.946 --> 00:36:58.756
when one looks at the data to hear you
talk about some of those differences that

00:36:58.766 --> 00:37:01.386
you experience as a female co founder.

00:37:01.573 --> 00:37:06.673
Gender inclusivity, a catalyst for
innovation by Hannah Isabel Tornow,

00:37:07.123 --> 00:37:08.923
who was doing her PhD on this.

00:37:09.676 --> 00:37:13.788
It is a bit depressing, to still
see it, but it's also reassuring

00:37:13.788 --> 00:37:18.038
to see the data and the numbers
written down in a dispassionate way.

00:37:19.096 --> 00:37:22.656
You know, 90 percent of companies in
Oxfordshire's science and technology

00:37:22.656 --> 00:37:26.986
sector are led by men, only 18
percent of the technology and IP based

00:37:26.986 --> 00:37:31.455
companies have a woman founder and
women are just underrepresented in

00:37:31.455 --> 00:37:36.085
senior leadership roles with only 19
percent of companies having women.

00:37:36.205 --> 00:37:40.343
In any leadership position,  clearly
this also filters through to

00:37:40.343 --> 00:37:44.363
the experience of investors and
potentially unconscious bias.

00:37:44.413 --> 00:37:48.593
Obviously, nobody is intentionally
bringing any bias into the room, but

00:37:48.593 --> 00:37:54.009
I'd love to hear, perhaps from you
some of what you think could be done

00:37:54.019 --> 00:37:58.219
to mitigate this and this is a problem
that both investors are suffering from

00:37:58.229 --> 00:38:01.229
because they're leaving opportunity
on the table, potentially by not

00:38:01.229 --> 00:38:05.689
recognising other characteristics
of great leaders that maybe are less

00:38:06.009 --> 00:38:10.959
traditionally recognised, but also just
on a personal level, what you would

00:38:10.959 --> 00:38:12.589
like to see when you walk into rooms.

00:38:12.969 --> 00:38:15.553
Lily Elsner: Yeah, I appreciate
that because I think there is so

00:38:15.553 --> 00:38:17.763
much we could talk about with this.

00:38:17.763 --> 00:38:22.393
But I think from my experience
there are two major things.

00:38:22.393 --> 00:38:28.247
The first is there's an incredible
book called the Authority Gap by Mary

00:38:28.247 --> 00:38:32.757
Ann Sieghart I think her last name is,
and she writes beautifully on just how

00:38:32.757 --> 00:38:34.884
women frankly, aren't taken seriously.

00:38:34.894 --> 00:38:37.974
If a woman said something, if a man said
something, it falls very differently,

00:38:37.974 --> 00:38:41.984
even if they use the same words and I've
seen that, I've had to challenge even my

00:38:41.984 --> 00:38:48.384
own unconscious bias in a lot of cases,
over the years and I find even last night

00:38:48.384 --> 00:38:53.521
I was at the wonderful Exit Right panel
talking about Advanced Oxford and about

00:38:53.546 --> 00:38:57.976
Art Innovation Ecosystem and Investment
Landscape and what I found was interesting

00:38:57.976 --> 00:39:02.126
is that we all know that investment is
relationship driven, absolutely, but

00:39:02.126 --> 00:39:07.176
what we don't necessarily talk about is
how we find those relationships and how

00:39:07.176 --> 00:39:10.606
those relationships are built and I've
really struggled, especially as a younger

00:39:10.606 --> 00:39:16.704
woman, developing relationships with
people who are some of those investors.

00:39:17.074 --> 00:39:20.684
It's taken a lot of like people
developing other relationships,

00:39:20.684 --> 00:39:22.774
getting intros and intros and intros.

00:39:22.784 --> 00:39:26.584
Whereas I've found, especially just
given and especially in the UK, often

00:39:26.584 --> 00:39:30.724
it ends up that people went to the same
schools and they were all boys schools

00:39:30.724 --> 00:39:34.667
and you find out so many of these other
things that you can't necessarily, if

00:39:34.667 --> 00:39:39.180
you only have a year or two to develop
your relationships and ecosystems.

00:39:39.204 --> 00:39:42.594
I don't have a solution for that,
but I think just having people think

00:39:42.604 --> 00:39:45.814
about why they know someone and why
they're going to give them their time,

00:39:45.814 --> 00:39:50.524
especially when it is, it's like, is
this a favor to my neighbor or is this

00:39:50.804 --> 00:39:52.774
an exciting investment opportunity?

00:39:53.234 --> 00:39:58.754
The second particularly around gender
investment is that I wish that while team

00:39:58.754 --> 00:40:03.618
is extraordinarily important especially
when you're thinking about investing.

00:40:04.543 --> 00:40:08.963
We're almost on the angel side, but also
in the context of funds, I wish there was

00:40:08.963 --> 00:40:12.486
a way to be gender blind in the same way
that you think of the orchestral example

00:40:12.486 --> 00:40:16.099
of, having people be barefoot so you don't
hear high heels, or some of these things

00:40:16.099 --> 00:40:20.899
where I just feel like I've had so many
discussions where, the perception of a

00:40:20.899 --> 00:40:25.279
venture can be changed so much by hearing
the identity of the founder, and so what

00:40:25.289 --> 00:40:30.583
I wish is that there is a way that you
could remove some of the identity to even

00:40:30.593 --> 00:40:35.093
have some of that assessment conversation
and then find out with a sort of more

00:40:35.093 --> 00:40:40.943
gender aware style of understanding and
then really understanding why you're, we

00:40:40.943 --> 00:40:45.333
know that women are asked the prevention
questions, men are asked the aspirational

00:40:45.333 --> 00:40:49.433
questions and I have to do a lot of
work on my side to pivot those into,

00:40:49.433 --> 00:40:52.663
I'm like, sometimes in an investment
conversation, I'm never asked, I'm never

00:40:52.663 --> 00:40:57.223
asked about my financial model, I'm never
asked about fertility revenues and exit

00:40:57.223 --> 00:41:00.473
opportunities or anything, I'm usually
asked about whether I know what the

00:41:00.473 --> 00:41:05.223
science is, and I'm like, yeah, first
of all, yes, I do and second of all,

00:41:05.223 --> 00:41:08.543
let me tell you how much money we're
going to make that sort of conversation.

00:41:08.543 --> 00:41:11.623
Susannah de Jager: I've heard that before
as well, that thing of being put on a

00:41:11.623 --> 00:41:17.683
defensive stance is a very common female
experience and one that I would really

00:41:17.683 --> 00:41:23.993
encourage anyone listening who is in these
seats or subject to it to read this report

00:41:24.043 --> 00:41:29.283
because there are some really useful
toolkits in there and practical examples

00:41:29.293 --> 00:41:35.938
of how to become more aware, overcome
some of these unconscious biases and as

00:41:35.938 --> 00:41:40.088
you say, they're not just men that have
these biases, women bring these biases

00:41:40.088 --> 00:41:42.278
to conversations with people we meet too.

00:41:42.278 --> 00:41:46.878
So it's something I try and check myself
on regularly we all are subject to

00:41:46.878 --> 00:41:51.928
things that we think are true and that we
stereotype and it's part of being human.

00:41:52.288 --> 00:41:57.505
Lily, thank you, this has been a really,
really interesting conversation from

00:41:57.505 --> 00:41:59.185
my perspective, I've so enjoyed it.

00:41:59.265 --> 00:42:00.525
Thank you for coming on today.

00:42:00.660 --> 00:42:01.860
Lily Elsner: Thank you
so much for having me.

00:42:01.860 --> 00:42:05.390
I love the conversation, you
are such an amazing host.

00:42:05.400 --> 00:42:06.810
Thank you so much!

00:42:07.323 --> 00:42:09.423
Susannah de Jager: Thanks for
listening to this episode of Oxford+

00:42:09.673 --> 00:42:11.553
presented by me, Susannah de Jager.

00:42:11.963 --> 00:42:14.553
If you want to stay up to date
with all things Oxford+, please

00:42:14.553 --> 00:42:17.153
visit our website, OxfordPlus.

00:42:17.153 --> 00:42:17.308
co.

00:42:17.308 --> 00:42:20.413
uk and sign up to our newsletter
so you never miss an update.

00:42:20.813 --> 00:42:23.993
Oxford+ was made in partnership
with Mishcon de Reya and is produced

00:42:23.993 --> 00:42:25.663
and edited by Story Ninety Four.