WEBVTT

NOTE
This file was generated by Descript 

00:00:00.018 --> 00:00:03.348
Joanna Meager: I don't think you can
ever rely on a technology to replace

00:00:03.348 --> 00:00:05.628
your understanding of a business.

00:00:05.884 --> 00:00:08.674
Use the technology as much as
you want, but you've got to

00:00:08.674 --> 00:00:09.694
understand the business first.

00:00:11.384 --> 00:00:14.644
Ralph Grayson: Welcome to The Boardroom
Path by Sainty Hird & Partners.

00:00:14.989 --> 00:00:18.879
I'm your host, Ralph Grayson, a
partner in the board practice.

00:00:19.248 --> 00:00:23.808
In this series, we'll offer practical
steps and useful perspectives for

00:00:23.808 --> 00:00:26.148
aspiring and newly appointed NEDs.

00:00:27.033 --> 00:00:30.003
When you've spent your career
making things happen, leading

00:00:30.003 --> 00:00:34.503
people, transforming businesses, and
taking responsibility for delivery.

00:00:35.163 --> 00:00:38.373
What changes when you join a
board as a non-executive director?

00:00:39.243 --> 00:00:43.503
Your experience remains valuable,
but how you use it must evolve.

00:00:44.343 --> 00:00:48.363
You need to establish credibility,
exercise independent judgement,

00:00:48.693 --> 00:00:52.473
and help the executive team succeed
while recognising that running the

00:00:52.473 --> 00:00:54.243
business is their responsibility.

00:00:55.173 --> 00:00:58.503
My guest today, Joanna Meager,
brings a particularly relevant

00:00:58.503 --> 00:01:00.093
perspective to that transition.

00:01:00.753 --> 00:01:04.953
Joanna's executive career has encompassed
international financial services,

00:01:05.313 --> 00:01:09.153
including capital markets, prime
brokerage and asset management, with

00:01:09.153 --> 00:01:14.193
substantial experience in operations,
technology, regulatory governance,

00:01:14.493 --> 00:01:18.543
mergers and acquisitions, and major
global transformation programmes.

00:01:19.683 --> 00:01:24.033
At Royal Bank of Canada, her leadership
responsibilities included global head

00:01:24.033 --> 00:01:29.343
of client operations and CEO of investor
and treasury services in the UK.

00:01:30.363 --> 00:01:33.513
Those roles placed her close to
the connections between commercial

00:01:33.513 --> 00:01:38.673
ambition, client service, technology,
people, and operational risk.

00:01:39.393 --> 00:01:42.633
She subsequently developed a
portfolio spanning non-executive

00:01:42.633 --> 00:01:44.460
and advisory responsibilities.

00:01:44.980 --> 00:01:49.108
For listeners contemplating the first
board appointment, Joanna's experience

00:01:49.108 --> 00:01:51.268
opens up several practical questions.

00:01:51.801 --> 00:01:56.271
How do you translate an executive
career into a clear board proposition?

00:01:56.961 --> 00:01:59.991
How do you contribute beyond
your particular specialisation?

00:02:00.561 --> 00:02:04.461
How do you challenge management without
becoming an alternative management team?

00:02:04.971 --> 00:02:09.111
And how do you decide whether the
chair, culture, and expectations of a

00:02:09.111 --> 00:02:11.301
prospective board are right for you?

00:02:12.021 --> 00:02:16.177
We'll also explore technology and
AI, diversity, risk, and the REM

00:02:16.182 --> 00:02:21.171
committee, assessing where questions
about performance, behaviour, fairness,

00:02:21.411 --> 00:02:23.571
and long-term success come together.

00:02:24.175 --> 00:02:25.645
Joanna, welcome to The Boardroom Path.

00:02:26.045 --> 00:02:26.945
Joanna Meager: Thank you very much.

00:02:27.535 --> 00:02:31.975
Ralph Grayson: So, before we discuss
the mechanics of becoming a NED,

00:02:32.515 --> 00:02:33.775
what made you want to do this?

00:02:34.135 --> 00:02:37.945
What were you hoping to contribute and
I guess most importantly, what did you

00:02:37.945 --> 00:02:39.805
want from this next stage of your career?

00:02:41.425 --> 00:02:46.122
Joanna Meager: So it was both an informal
and a formal process that I went through.

00:02:46.122 --> 00:02:52.552
So when I left my executive career, I
really tried to work out what it was

00:02:52.552 --> 00:02:54.802
I enjoyed about my executive career.

00:02:54.842 --> 00:02:59.852
Not in the detail of the job,
but did I enjoy the strategy,

00:02:59.852 --> 00:03:04.802
the direction of the company,
joining the dots, mentoring people?

00:03:04.922 --> 00:03:08.852
I went through a long list in my head
to try and work out what my next step

00:03:08.852 --> 00:03:13.862
was and I think that's really important
for anyone leaving an executive career.

00:03:14.223 --> 00:03:16.969
There will be things that you loved
about it and there will be things

00:03:16.969 --> 00:03:21.649
that you loved not quite so much about
it and once you've listed those out

00:03:21.722 --> 00:03:26.869
for yourself, it will be clear as to
whether that adds up to a NED portfolio.

00:03:27.169 --> 00:03:30.202
Some people just aren't cut
out for a NED portfolio.

00:03:30.601 --> 00:03:36.799
If the aspects of your exec career
that you loved were the control and the

00:03:36.799 --> 00:03:42.362
accountability and doing the execution
yourself, don't take on a NED portfolio.

00:03:43.405 --> 00:03:45.045
Ralph Grayson: Great advice to start with.

00:03:45.345 --> 00:03:48.435
Were there things you consciously
thought about wanting to retain

00:03:48.435 --> 00:03:52.395
from your executive life and things
you particularly wanted to change?

00:03:52.395 --> 00:03:55.715
And I guess within that, was
this a deliberate plan or just

00:03:55.715 --> 00:03:58.445
an evolving opportunity and a
certain amount of serendipity?

00:03:59.017 --> 00:04:00.956
Joanna Meager: There was a
certain amount of serendipity.

00:04:01.106 --> 00:04:06.112
But one of the biggest things as I've
changed roles through my executive career

00:04:06.472 --> 00:04:11.512
is I've made a conscious decision never
to do the same job for a competitor.

00:04:12.093 --> 00:04:14.733
That doesn't give you a
great learning experience.

00:04:14.733 --> 00:04:18.622
You learn how to answer the phone with
a different corporate title, but you're

00:04:18.622 --> 00:04:20.332
doing the same thing for somebody else.

00:04:20.572 --> 00:04:24.652
So I've always swapped around and
when you read the intro, and thank you

00:04:24.652 --> 00:04:28.702
for that glorious intro, you told of
all the different parts of financial

00:04:28.702 --> 00:04:32.212
services I've worked in and that
was absolutely a conscious decision

00:04:32.242 --> 00:04:33.802
because I like learning new things.

00:04:34.462 --> 00:04:40.072
So when I took on the various NED
roles that I've done, one of my key

00:04:40.072 --> 00:04:43.894
lenses that I was looking through was,
was I going to learn something new?

00:04:44.932 --> 00:04:47.529
Ralph Grayson: So is there a tipping
point at which you woke up one morning

00:04:47.534 --> 00:04:51.208
and thought now's the time to be a
NED tomorrow, but at least now is the

00:04:51.208 --> 00:04:52.378
time to start thinking about this?

00:04:52.976 --> 00:04:54.428
Joanna Meager: I should have
thought about it earlier.

00:04:56.904 --> 00:05:02.196
I should have thought about it earlier
purely to build the transition but I had

00:05:02.319 --> 00:05:06.868
quite a clean break from my executive
career because we sold a business.

00:05:07.170 --> 00:05:10.800
And I thought initially that I was
going to take on another exec role.

00:05:11.160 --> 00:05:17.010
It was only when I had the pause and
I actually could think about what

00:05:17.010 --> 00:05:22.110
I really wanted to do, that the NED
route seemed more logical for me.

00:05:23.220 --> 00:05:27.450
Ralph Grayson: And the question I always
love asking is, what was the distinction

00:05:27.450 --> 00:05:32.352
between being attracted to a board
appointment as opposed to enjoying the

00:05:32.365 --> 00:05:34.924
work that you thought it would entail?

00:05:35.887 --> 00:05:40.087
Joanna Meager: For me, it was very much
looking at the company as the first point.

00:05:40.141 --> 00:05:44.581
Could I learn something from
that company that I would be

00:05:44.648 --> 00:05:47.571
sitting as a non-exec director on?

00:05:47.751 --> 00:05:50.571
And then as I went through the
interview process, and you know

00:05:50.571 --> 00:05:54.051
better than most, those interview
processes can be quite long.

00:05:54.691 --> 00:05:58.291
You got to learn a lot about the company
and the people that you were working with.

00:05:58.421 --> 00:05:59.981
That was a key decision point for me.

00:06:00.911 --> 00:06:04.291
Ralph Grayson: And was there a
particular experience, conversation,

00:06:04.294 --> 00:06:07.991
somebody you spoke to, a mentor or
a coach, that helped you decide?

00:06:08.505 --> 00:06:12.360
Joanna Meager: I speak to a lot of
people, and I did have help from

00:06:12.363 --> 00:06:18.191
people that had already taken that NED
transition and gave me advice more on

00:06:18.371 --> 00:06:23.631
what not to accept and making sure that
I didn't put myself in a conflicted

00:06:23.635 --> 00:06:25.420
situation right from the get-go.

00:06:25.961 --> 00:06:28.551
So that was exceedingly helpful.

00:06:29.511 --> 00:06:32.481
Ralph Grayson: And was there anything
you wished you'd asked yourself at that

00:06:32.505 --> 00:06:35.422
point in your career or that pivot moment?

00:06:35.997 --> 00:06:39.756
Is there something that you would
advise somebody to ask themselves

00:06:39.756 --> 00:06:44.076
before concluding that a NED role
is the right next step for them,

00:06:44.346 --> 00:06:45.826
crucially for the right reasons?

00:06:47.316 --> 00:06:52.886
Joanna Meager: I think it's really
being clear on what a NED role

00:06:52.886 --> 00:06:57.866
entails and whether that is something
that you are truly interested

00:06:57.866 --> 00:07:02.428
in because it's a very different
aspect than your executive career.

00:07:02.788 --> 00:07:06.058
There are parts of your executive
career that are completely

00:07:06.058 --> 00:07:12.338
applicable, but it's things like,
are you prepared to wade through

00:07:12.788 --> 00:07:16.478
quite lengthy tomes of board papers?

00:07:16.478 --> 00:07:17.798
Does that interest you?

00:07:18.188 --> 00:07:23.438
That preparatory work that you do on your
own and joining the dots and asking the

00:07:23.438 --> 00:07:25.928
right questions, does that interest you?

00:07:26.438 --> 00:07:33.158
And being able to coach and mentor and
direct in a nudging kind of way rather

00:07:33.158 --> 00:07:35.378
than a controlling directive way.

00:07:35.973 --> 00:07:39.873
If that's not something in your
executive career that you enjoy doing,

00:07:40.198 --> 00:07:43.203
you're not miraculously going to
enjoy doing it in your NED career.

00:07:44.333 --> 00:07:48.363
Ralph Grayson: And as we touched on,
your background has a huge breadth to it,

00:07:48.363 --> 00:07:52.953
operations, technology, transformation,
regulated financial services.

00:07:52.953 --> 00:07:57.294
So I guess it would be quite simple to say
there are a lot of things here I solve for

00:07:57.694 --> 00:08:01.988
but is the reality of the NED roles that
you've now got are you solving for what

00:08:01.993 --> 00:08:03.496
you thought you were going to solve for?

00:08:04.187 --> 00:08:05.943
Joanna Meager: Yeah,
for the most part yes.

00:08:06.078 --> 00:08:12.928
I do think that when you look at
your previous executive career, the

00:08:12.928 --> 00:08:16.628
breadth of different things that
I've done, and even the breadth of

00:08:16.628 --> 00:08:20.318
the different week or month that you
may have, especially if you've done

00:08:20.318 --> 00:08:23.018
international executive roles like I did.

00:08:23.468 --> 00:08:26.108
One week was nothing like the next week.

00:08:26.588 --> 00:08:30.158
One board meeting is very similar
to the next board meeting.

00:08:30.188 --> 00:08:31.748
That's the good thing about it.

00:08:31.771 --> 00:08:37.088
You're building on foundations of work
that you've done for the April board

00:08:37.088 --> 00:08:40.568
meeting and the June board meeting
and in the October board meeting.

00:08:40.868 --> 00:08:47.258
But you do not have the variety doing a
NED portfolio in the actual role aspect

00:08:47.288 --> 00:08:49.388
that you had in an executive career.

00:08:49.748 --> 00:08:55.478
You get the variety by having a portfolio
of NED jobs across different companies.

00:08:56.072 --> 00:08:57.485
Ralph Grayson: And I really want
to touch on here the difference

00:08:57.578 --> 00:09:04.338
between an executive CV and a board
proposition because delivery I think

00:09:04.338 --> 00:09:07.548
is a constant theme in your executive
CV, which I know fairly well.

00:09:07.680 --> 00:09:13.380
Yes, any board role is all about
good judgement and that difference

00:09:13.380 --> 00:09:15.180
between influence and authority.

00:09:15.904 --> 00:09:18.994
For somebody who was stereotypical
delivery, did you find it

00:09:18.994 --> 00:09:20.044
tough to make that decision?

00:09:20.044 --> 00:09:21.454
Did it come naturally to you?

00:09:21.454 --> 00:09:23.454
What did you have to learn and unlearn?

00:09:24.096 --> 00:09:25.601
Joanna Meager: A really good question.

00:09:26.021 --> 00:09:32.621
Yes, my career up to executive had
been all about delivery, absolutely,

00:09:32.621 --> 00:09:34.391
across multiple different things.

00:09:34.631 --> 00:09:39.461
But once you get to a certain level,
you're not doing the delivery yourself.

00:09:39.461 --> 00:09:42.521
You're coaching the people
that are doing the delivery.

00:09:43.055 --> 00:09:47.835
I think as I got older, it's not a
maturity thing, but as I got older, I

00:09:47.835 --> 00:09:53.259
realised that coaching was much more
about getting the best out of those people

00:09:53.469 --> 00:09:55.539
than stepping in and doing it yourself.

00:09:55.569 --> 00:10:00.099
So that very much aligned to
moving over to a NED role.

00:10:00.819 --> 00:10:07.059
The one thing that I didn't do very
well at the outset is reposition

00:10:07.059 --> 00:10:12.849
my resume and my resume was
written as an executive resume.

00:10:13.479 --> 00:10:21.195
I spent all of the time on the
areas of work that I'd done most in.

00:10:21.255 --> 00:10:23.055
That's how we all write our resumes.

00:10:23.055 --> 00:10:26.925
We go, "I did 13 years in this
job, so that's better take half the

00:10:26.925 --> 00:10:32.415
page." And that's not how you need
to write your resume for a NED role.

00:10:32.509 --> 00:10:37.549
You need to write your resume
based upon the skills and the

00:10:37.549 --> 00:10:41.179
competencies that you have that
will translate into the NED role.

00:10:41.389 --> 00:10:45.949
So you may end up writing not very
much about that big executive job

00:10:45.949 --> 00:10:52.462
that you did and don't try and make
your resume equal the years of effort.

00:10:52.749 --> 00:10:57.792
It needs a complete 180 rethink and
that I didn't do right from the get-go.

00:10:58.409 --> 00:11:02.903
I did learn how to do it and it felt a
bit like you were giving something up.

00:11:02.963 --> 00:11:06.443
It's like, "Oh my goodness, that
job that I did for 10 years has only

00:11:06.443 --> 00:11:11.123
got three lines on my resume now."
But it makes it much more relevant

00:11:11.123 --> 00:11:12.533
for somebody looking for a NED.

00:11:12.953 --> 00:11:15.423
Ralph Grayson: Yeah, I think
this labelling point is really

00:11:15.423 --> 00:11:18.273
interesting that you touch on there
and it's both sides of the table.

00:11:18.513 --> 00:11:21.738
It's how you as the candidate label
yourself, but also how somebody on

00:11:21.739 --> 00:11:23.612
the Nominations committee labels you.

00:11:23.614 --> 00:11:29.405
And I guess in your context, Joanna, it
would be very lazy but easy for people to

00:11:29.405 --> 00:11:33.815
label you as the operations person or the
delivery person or the technology person.

00:11:34.360 --> 00:11:37.170
Did you consciously try
and deconstruct that?

00:11:37.570 --> 00:11:40.307
Or was that something that came out
of practice of doing interviews?

00:11:40.821 --> 00:11:44.511
Joanna Meager: I deconstructed it on my
LinkedIn and I deconstructed it on my

00:11:44.511 --> 00:11:50.051
resume which then led to the interviews
being conducted in a different way

00:11:50.345 --> 00:11:54.376
because most of the interviews are led
by what you've written on your resume.

00:11:55.576 --> 00:12:01.126
What was important and useful for me
is if I look back over my career, I

00:12:01.186 --> 00:12:06.676
was around when operational risk was
first being formed and talked about.

00:12:07.039 --> 00:12:11.569
So the elements I could put into my resume
around what I'd done around operational

00:12:11.569 --> 00:12:16.429
risk, what I'd done around looking at
target operating models and driving

00:12:16.429 --> 00:12:21.653
strategy, it was just pulling those themes
out rather than pulling the jobs out.

00:12:22.587 --> 00:12:26.685
Ralph Grayson: So if you're going to
advise a listener to think about how

00:12:26.685 --> 00:12:30.244
to structure their board proposition
in kind of three sentences or three

00:12:30.244 --> 00:12:34.504
lines, what do you think it's crucial
that those sentences establish?

00:12:35.135 --> 00:12:40.115
Joanna Meager: They've got to establish
the competencies and the skills that

00:12:40.115 --> 00:12:44.945
you will bring to the board table,
not the jobs that you have done.

00:12:45.945 --> 00:12:48.285
Ralph Grayson: And how does somebody
rationalise that when they're reading

00:12:48.285 --> 00:12:49.935
their own CV and looking in the mirror?

00:12:49.935 --> 00:12:49.945
It's.

00:12:49.995 --> 00:12:52.455
Joanna Meager: It's actually
really difficult to do yourself.

00:12:52.605 --> 00:12:53.385
Ralph Grayson: That's
why I asked the question.

00:12:53.671 --> 00:12:56.701
Joanna Meager: You can make
a stab at it, but the best

00:12:56.701 --> 00:12:58.771
thing is to find a trusted ear.

00:12:58.871 --> 00:13:03.711
Someone that knows you relatively well
but also somebody that understands the

00:13:03.711 --> 00:13:08.721
board and the NED space, and they will
be able to put the turn on it for you.

00:13:09.711 --> 00:13:11.181
Ralph Grayson: Yeah, I think
that's really good advice.

00:13:11.721 --> 00:13:14.536
Take us into your early
experience as a NED then.

00:13:14.623 --> 00:13:19.764
What surprised you about the
reality of the role even after

00:13:19.764 --> 00:13:23.286
you've had such a substantial
and successful executive career?

00:13:24.276 --> 00:13:30.646
Joanna Meager: I think what surprised me
in a good way was the accountability and

00:13:30.646 --> 00:13:33.341
the responsibility right from the get-go.

00:13:33.799 --> 00:13:34.876
It's kind of good and bad.

00:13:35.386 --> 00:13:40.216
So you think if you take on an executive
role and you take on a new job, a new

00:13:40.216 --> 00:13:43.941
executive role in the same company or
even in a different company, you have

00:13:45.907 --> 00:13:51.848
some help, you have a team of people
that work for you that will make sure

00:13:51.848 --> 00:13:56.244
that you are brought into the firm
in the right way, that you're brought

00:13:56.244 --> 00:14:00.294
into that new role in the right way,
and you've got a lot of people to

00:14:00.294 --> 00:14:04.374
lean on that you don't necessarily
have to make any of the decisions

00:14:04.374 --> 00:14:06.281
on your own right from the get-go.

00:14:07.066 --> 00:14:14.364
When you join a board or any subcommittee
of a board, you have no team of people to

00:14:14.364 --> 00:14:19.374
go to and validate a question or validate
something that you are looking at.

00:14:19.831 --> 00:14:23.188
You are thrown in at the deep end a
little bit and this is nothing to do

00:14:23.188 --> 00:14:26.546
with the companies I work for, it's
the nature of going into a board.

00:14:27.467 --> 00:14:32.308
You've got to use your experienced
NEDs that have been there a while.

00:14:32.508 --> 00:14:35.628
There is the adage of no
question is a stupid question.

00:14:35.958 --> 00:14:37.578
There are stupid questions.

00:14:37.958 --> 00:14:43.298
Make sure you ask those in private
and then when you can turn up to the

00:14:43.298 --> 00:14:46.968
board meeting, and the great thing
is you get a lot of prep time, you

00:14:46.968 --> 00:14:51.658
can deal with all of those qualifying
questions with your co-board members.

00:14:52.075 --> 00:14:54.723
But the accountability you get
right from the get-go, that was

00:14:54.724 --> 00:14:56.515
the biggest surprise for me.

00:14:57.475 --> 00:14:58.585
Ralph Grayson: There's
a lot to unpick there.

00:14:59.125 --> 00:15:03.205
So how do you teach yourself how to be
efficient going through some board papers?

00:15:03.591 --> 00:15:07.671
Joanna Meager: I have a prep model
that I've evolved over the last couple

00:15:07.671 --> 00:15:09.681
of years that really works for me.

00:15:10.701 --> 00:15:13.401
Doesn't necessarily work for
everybody, but it works for me.

00:15:13.731 --> 00:15:19.311
So I read all of the papers and I write
no notes and I write no questions.

00:15:19.341 --> 00:15:24.861
I just read them as soon as they've
come out and then two days before

00:15:24.861 --> 00:15:29.211
the meeting, I read them again, and
that's when I write my questions.

00:15:29.271 --> 00:15:29.991
Why?

00:15:30.321 --> 00:15:34.881
I learned really early on that I used
to write lots and lots of questions that

00:15:34.881 --> 00:15:37.851
all got answered 15 pages on in the deck.

00:15:38.781 --> 00:15:40.161
So I don't do that anymore.

00:15:40.491 --> 00:15:45.321
I also learned really early on that if you
do all your prep, the minute the papers

00:15:45.321 --> 00:15:49.311
come out, you've probably forgotten it
by the time the meeting comes around.

00:15:49.551 --> 00:15:51.231
So that's why I split it in two.

00:15:51.541 --> 00:15:55.127
I've taught that model to quite a few
people now, and it works very well.

00:15:55.622 --> 00:15:57.205
There are great tools out there as well.

00:15:57.301 --> 00:16:01.771
Lots of the board tools allow you
to write Post-it notes on them,

00:16:02.081 --> 00:16:06.161
electronically, and of course,
there's all of the AI enablement now

00:16:06.161 --> 00:16:08.351
that allows you to summarise things.

00:16:08.531 --> 00:16:10.151
So kind of whatever works for you.

00:16:10.151 --> 00:16:14.561
We've all gone through lots and lots
of documents before, so I'm sure

00:16:14.561 --> 00:16:16.331
everyone's got their own way of doing it.

00:16:16.747 --> 00:16:20.137
Ralph Grayson: How did you learn
the difference between management

00:16:20.137 --> 00:16:26.427
engagement as opposed to management in
an executive sense and this key skill

00:16:26.427 --> 00:16:29.307
of observation rather than direction?

00:16:29.705 --> 00:16:31.739
Joanna Meager: That's a really
good question and very tricky.

00:16:32.219 --> 00:16:37.619
Some of it is in the language, so you
have to think about how you're asking

00:16:37.619 --> 00:16:44.459
the question and your question is
always a clarification question, a help

00:16:44.459 --> 00:16:49.809
me understand question, can you give
me some more information around that?

00:16:50.199 --> 00:16:54.452
Whereas when you're an executive, it's
like, "Well, I don't necessarily agree

00:16:54.452 --> 00:16:59.757
with that." You've got to really change
your language and I was very conscious of

00:16:59.757 --> 00:17:05.257
that from the start and it might have even
sounded a little forced to start off with,

00:17:05.257 --> 00:17:06.877
but you soon get into the rhythm of it.

00:17:08.047 --> 00:17:14.887
And then I also, as I went through and
did my prep work, I made sure that I

00:17:14.917 --> 00:17:21.937
went back to basics of you're there to
make sure this is sound, you're there

00:17:21.937 --> 00:17:26.887
to make sure this is appropriately
governed, there's always more than one

00:17:26.887 --> 00:17:29.257
way to do something as an executive.

00:17:29.257 --> 00:17:31.477
You're not there to
tell them how to do it.

00:17:31.957 --> 00:17:36.687
I challenged myself as I was going
through my prep and then when I went

00:17:36.687 --> 00:17:41.007
back and read my questions, if any of
my questions sounded executive-like,

00:17:41.307 --> 00:17:44.947
and believe me they did, I used to take
a red pen to them and cross them out.

00:17:46.467 --> 00:17:48.755
Ralph Grayson: Yeah, learning to ask
open questions as opposed to closed

00:17:48.778 --> 00:17:51.564
questions is something I've certainly
learned in 12 months doing podcasts.

00:17:52.027 --> 00:17:57.417
And without being specific as to
your roles but more of a generic open

00:17:57.417 --> 00:18:03.779
question what could people do better in
terms of induction onto the board and

00:18:03.959 --> 00:18:05.639
having you prepared before you arrive?

00:18:05.773 --> 00:18:08.834
If a chair's listening and thinking,
have I got my induction right for a new

00:18:08.834 --> 00:18:10.664
board member, what would you stress?

00:18:11.894 --> 00:18:15.184
Joanna Meager: I think a
number of the boards do the

00:18:15.184 --> 00:18:16.714
induction really well, right?

00:18:16.714 --> 00:18:20.164
So they do the induction of
getting you into the company and

00:18:20.164 --> 00:18:22.125
onto the board exceedingly well.

00:18:22.126 --> 00:18:26.044
It's a well-trodden path
and a well-oiled machine.

00:18:26.824 --> 00:18:33.119
The bit that I would encourage is
that the new NED themselves doesn't

00:18:33.215 --> 00:18:36.005
just take that as exhaustive.

00:18:36.095 --> 00:18:38.045
I would suggest that's the minimum.

00:18:38.435 --> 00:18:42.695
So that's being put to you as
this is the path that we've always

00:18:42.965 --> 00:18:47.822
used in order to get new board
members into the organisation.

00:18:48.242 --> 00:18:51.062
That doesn't mean that
that's all you need to do.

00:18:51.572 --> 00:18:55.502
So as you go through that induction,
work out what else you need to do.

00:18:56.012 --> 00:19:01.322
You may be sitting on a board of a company
and a business that you know really well

00:19:01.322 --> 00:19:03.934
and you did that business as an executive.

00:19:04.259 --> 00:19:07.802
You're going to need a different level
of induction to if you're sitting on the

00:19:07.802 --> 00:19:13.476
board of a part of a business or a part
of financial services that you don't know.

00:19:14.296 --> 00:19:18.256
Don't feel that you can't go back and go,
"Can I have this extra meeting?  Can I

00:19:18.256 --> 00:19:24.386
have this extra report?" And I think the
biggest learning is you as the new board

00:19:24.386 --> 00:19:27.416
member, your induction is in your hands.

00:19:27.596 --> 00:19:32.582
The CoSec or the chair of the
board is helping you, but you have

00:19:32.582 --> 00:19:34.712
to own that induction yourself.

00:19:36.016 --> 00:19:39.340
Ralph Grayson: And I think most
new NEDs that I talk to have some

00:19:39.384 --> 00:19:43.942
combination of imposter syndrome  or
they worry about their credibility.

00:19:44.952 --> 00:19:49.122
So how do you get the balance
right between feeling you must

00:19:49.242 --> 00:19:55.512
demonstrate your expertise at the
first few meetings, but also knowing

00:19:55.722 --> 00:19:57.132
when to listen and when to speak?

00:19:58.002 --> 00:20:00.132
Joanna Meager: Yeah, definitely
more listening than speaking.

00:20:00.262 --> 00:20:04.132
In all meetings, no matter how good
you've become, because that's the

00:20:04.132 --> 00:20:06.682
nature of being a board member.

00:20:07.372 --> 00:20:12.232
I found that the best thing was,
especially as I was learning, was to

00:20:12.232 --> 00:20:17.062
have the meetings with the other board
members before and after the board.

00:20:17.092 --> 00:20:20.722
So I would ask my questions
to them beforehand.

00:20:21.262 --> 00:20:24.952
Probably that meant that half of them
got taken off and I didn't need to ask

00:20:24.952 --> 00:20:29.662
them in the board meeting and then after
the board meeting, I would circle back

00:20:29.662 --> 00:20:34.352
with them on anything that I didn't
understand or I wanted clarification

00:20:34.352 --> 00:20:36.092
on why we went a certain route.

00:20:36.642 --> 00:20:40.364
That's the best way to build up
your confidence because you're

00:20:40.366 --> 00:20:43.752
doing it in the board meeting
and outside of the board meeting.

00:20:43.842 --> 00:20:47.832
As time goes on, the outside of
the board meeting just drops away

00:20:48.162 --> 00:20:49.662
and it's all in the board meeting.

00:20:50.042 --> 00:20:53.213
Ralph Grayson: Did you spot somebody
on the board, may have been the chair,

00:20:53.213 --> 00:20:57.066
may have been the SID, may have been
just an old, wise, more experienced NED.

00:20:57.486 --> 00:21:01.416
But is there somebody that you picked
out to say, "Okay, should I create a

00:21:01.416 --> 00:21:04.386
relationship with this person to be able
to have those offline conversations with?"

00:21:04.430 --> 00:21:05.554
Joanna Meager: I did it with everyone.

00:21:05.614 --> 00:21:07.054
I probably was a pain in the neck.

00:21:07.454 --> 00:21:11.099
So depending upon the question
kind of depended where I went.

00:21:11.149 --> 00:21:15.199
I thought about what is it that I've
got a gap on that I need some help with?

00:21:15.608 --> 00:21:19.009
If it was something risk-related, I
might go to the chief risk officer.

00:21:19.009 --> 00:21:20.779
I used all the executives as well.

00:21:20.779 --> 00:21:24.239
As I say there, I probably was a pain
in the neck as I'm looking back on it.

00:21:24.649 --> 00:21:28.656
So yes, I just went to the person
that I thought had the most expertise.

00:21:29.119 --> 00:21:30.349
Ralph Grayson: Okay, makes a lot of sense.

00:21:30.889 --> 00:21:32.929
Joanna Meager: And probably built
a great network as a result.

00:21:33.019 --> 00:21:35.919
Ralph Grayson: Yeah, which is
not to be underestimated, right?

00:21:36.639 --> 00:21:40.598
And as somebody, going back to your
delivery  running through you like

00:21:40.601 --> 00:21:45.139
a stick of rock, how did you learn
to check yourself when you saw a

00:21:45.139 --> 00:21:46.999
problem which you knew how to solve?

00:21:47.999 --> 00:21:48.779
Joanna Meager: It's tricky.

00:21:48.959 --> 00:21:53.309
I can't honestly say I've
completely solved for that one.

00:21:53.879 --> 00:21:57.779
But the way I do it, rightly
or wrongly, is to offer help.

00:21:57.779 --> 00:22:02.989
So if I see a problem coming up that
I've seen a variety of, I offer coffee.

00:22:03.672 --> 00:22:07.009
I jokingly say for the price of
a cup of coffee, I can probably

00:22:07.095 --> 00:22:08.415
give you some advice on that.

00:22:08.955 --> 00:22:12.735
So I take it out of the board meeting,
out of the risk committee, out of

00:22:12.735 --> 00:22:16.305
whatever meeting it is, and then I'll
just spend time with the executive

00:22:16.305 --> 00:22:21.385
and say, "Look, you can use this if
you want or feel free to throw it away

00:22:21.385 --> 00:22:24.808
with the coffee cup. But this is what
I've done when I've seen one of these

00:22:24.808 --> 00:22:26.728
before." You don't do it in the meeting.

00:22:27.268 --> 00:22:29.638
Ralph Grayson: And what might
tell you you're getting too close

00:22:29.638 --> 00:22:32.538
to executive territory, even if
it's the executive asking for it?

00:22:33.393 --> 00:22:38.307
Joanna Meager: You can only really spend
the time that you've got available,

00:22:38.307 --> 00:22:43.034
and if you've got a portfolio that time
is quite precious and quite juggled.

00:22:43.034 --> 00:22:48.421
One of the things that I would advise
anybody taking on a NED portfolio is

00:22:48.437 --> 00:22:53.124
when you worked for one company as
an executive, you had one diary, and

00:22:53.124 --> 00:22:57.624
even though your diary might have felt
full, it was full with one company.

00:22:57.984 --> 00:23:00.804
There's a lot more juggling to do
when it's more than one company.

00:23:01.177 --> 00:23:04.927
I don't find I have the
capacity to overstep the mark.

00:23:05.497 --> 00:23:09.430
You also don't get all of the
information to be able to overstep the

00:23:09.430 --> 00:23:14.050
mark, because you're getting summary
papers, you're not getting detailed

00:23:14.050 --> 00:23:18.561
project plans or… it's pretty easy
to stay on the right side of the line.

00:23:19.025 --> 00:23:23.998
I also work with some great executives
that would clearly push me back

00:23:23.998 --> 00:23:25.858
across the line if I overstepped it.

00:23:26.668 --> 00:23:28.498
Ralph Grayson: So let's try and
bring that to life a little bit.

00:23:28.618 --> 00:23:31.013
Transformation is one of
your key subject matters.

00:23:31.024 --> 00:23:35.405
So let's say you're being told by the
executive a transformation programme's

00:23:35.447 --> 00:23:40.098
on track, but just something in your
experience is making you a little

00:23:40.098 --> 00:23:41.928
queasy, uneasy, whatever it may be.

00:23:42.458 --> 00:23:45.068
What would you ask, what
evidence would you seek, and

00:23:45.488 --> 00:23:47.588
how and when might you escalate?

00:23:48.308 --> 00:23:50.798
Joanna Meager: So one, be careful
what you ask, because once you've

00:23:50.798 --> 00:23:53.588
got the information, you probably
need to do something with it.

00:23:54.048 --> 00:23:59.488
I would probably coach them because
they've been given that information

00:23:59.488 --> 00:24:04.271
probably by people in the organisation
that are actually directly running it.

00:24:04.601 --> 00:24:09.221
So I would coach them on the questions
to ask, "So next time you come and

00:24:09.221 --> 00:24:14.691
present, it would be great if we
could see, da da, da." I wouldn't step

00:24:14.691 --> 00:24:16.807
in and go and get the data myself.

00:24:17.012 --> 00:24:21.051
You've got to work through the
executives, not around the executives.

00:24:22.011 --> 00:24:24.081
Ralph Grayson: And you've worked in
some big international businesses.

00:24:24.081 --> 00:24:28.693
How does an international context
make that different if maybe some of

00:24:28.693 --> 00:24:32.893
the important strategic decisions are
shaped elsewhere in the organisation?

00:24:33.378 --> 00:24:36.613
Joanna Meager: That's the nature of
international business, isn't it?

00:24:36.673 --> 00:24:42.230
I've never, until very recently, worked
in organisations where the head office has

00:24:42.230 --> 00:24:47.650
been in the UK and I've worked outside of
the UK as much as I've worked in the UK.

00:24:48.040 --> 00:24:55.269
So I completely understand how you
have to balance local priorities with

00:24:55.400 --> 00:24:57.598
global strategic decision-making.

00:24:57.951 --> 00:24:59.451
It's second nature to me.

00:24:59.791 --> 00:25:02.851
I'm more surprised when
everything's in one location.

00:25:03.431 --> 00:25:08.562
I think it just gives you a better
appreciation of the nuances, either

00:25:08.652 --> 00:25:14.382
of how to work with different types of
people who care about different types of

00:25:14.382 --> 00:25:19.332
things, but also to understand what you
really can influence and what you can't.

00:25:19.774 --> 00:25:21.649
Ralph Grayson: Just love to pick up
on that word nuance there, because I

00:25:21.649 --> 00:25:24.689
think that's so interesting because
it raises the question about cultural

00:25:24.689 --> 00:25:29.009
norms and how do you challenge and
how do you use judgement and what do

00:25:29.009 --> 00:25:30.749
people understand by independence?

00:25:31.027 --> 00:25:32.632
Have you felt that experience?

00:25:33.206 --> 00:25:35.859
Joanna Meager: Definitely, and it depends
on how you mean the word cultural.

00:25:35.859 --> 00:25:39.129
So cultural doesn't have
to attach to a country.

00:25:39.489 --> 00:25:44.649
Cultural can attach to a type of company
and how they would like to be challenged

00:25:44.649 --> 00:25:46.029
and don't like to be challenged.

00:25:46.329 --> 00:25:51.771
It can also attach to just an individual
person, like how somebody reacts

00:25:51.771 --> 00:25:53.545
to a different type of challenge.

00:25:53.935 --> 00:25:59.575
For me, the analogy I always use is
it's like giving birthday cards and

00:25:59.575 --> 00:26:03.235
I know you're giving me that scowly
face, but when you send a birthday

00:26:03.235 --> 00:26:08.605
card, you send a birthday card, the
card the person wants to receive,

00:26:08.815 --> 00:26:11.275
not the card that you want to send.

00:26:11.705 --> 00:26:14.075
Otherwise everyone would get
the same birthday card from me.

00:26:14.525 --> 00:26:22.575
So I always try and think, how would the
person like to hear this ask, not just

00:26:22.575 --> 00:26:25.035
how does Joanna want to say this ask?

00:26:25.955 --> 00:26:28.635
Ralph Grayson: Gosh, that's so
interesting and where does AI,

00:26:28.635 --> 00:26:30.165
the dreaded AI, fit into all of

00:26:30.255 --> 00:26:31.425
Joanna Meager: Oh, I love AI.

00:26:31.489 --> 00:26:34.690
I was one of the earliest
proponents of AI.

00:26:35.170 --> 00:26:39.490
But in my personal life as well as in
my work life, and I've got children of

00:26:39.490 --> 00:26:45.160
a certain age that should be teaching
me, and it's the other way round.

00:26:45.544 --> 00:26:50.174
I have friends that have sent
me hilarious little cartoons.

00:26:50.174 --> 00:26:56.077
One of them says when your kids are
teaching you how to use tech and getting

00:26:56.077 --> 00:27:01.727
frustrated, just remind them that you
taught them how to use a knife and fork.

00:27:02.357 --> 00:27:07.317
But I am the one teaching my kids
because I've just got so into it.

00:27:07.387 --> 00:27:08.857
I find it so helpful.

00:27:09.247 --> 00:27:14.047
My biggest tip is AI will
write the prompts for you.

00:27:14.107 --> 00:27:19.237
You can ask AI, "What prompt should
I tell you to do this?" And it

00:27:19.237 --> 00:27:20.677
will write the prompt for you.

00:27:21.757 --> 00:27:23.947
AI is all about having the right prompts.

00:27:24.307 --> 00:27:27.517
So for your personal life, it's
about having the right prompts.

00:27:27.517 --> 00:27:30.667
For your personal productivity,
it's about having the right prompts.

00:27:31.057 --> 00:27:36.500
And then using AI more broadly in
the business in order to make things

00:27:36.750 --> 00:27:41.550
more effective, better quality,
time to market, all of those things.

00:27:41.920 --> 00:27:44.920
It's just changing and
evolving every week.

00:27:45.010 --> 00:27:51.130
So it's not like running projects
of past eras where you could have

00:27:51.370 --> 00:27:55.630
multiple quarters or even multiple
years to implement something.

00:27:55.870 --> 00:28:01.280
If you take that long, the technology
will have evolved too many times over.

00:28:02.060 --> 00:28:04.944
Ralph Grayson: As somebody who is
technologically much savvier than me,

00:28:04.944 --> 00:28:05.934
I'd love to ask you this question.

00:28:06.187 --> 00:28:09.792
I was on a panel earlier this
week about AI in the boardroom.

00:28:10.002 --> 00:28:14.002
Seems to be every panel I seem to be
invited to join these days and it was

00:28:14.002 --> 00:28:17.542
fascinating because we were talking
about the demographics of who should be

00:28:17.542 --> 00:28:21.512
on the board and whether we need younger
board members who actually understand the

00:28:21.512 --> 00:28:27.140
technology that goes around AI and the
balance with perhaps more seasoned people,

00:28:27.141 --> 00:28:29.767
should we say, who understand its context.

00:28:29.875 --> 00:28:33.775
And one person made a really interesting
observation, said, "I'm of a certain age.

00:28:33.775 --> 00:28:38.965
I haven't grown up in the AI generation,
but I am old enough to remember Y2K and

00:28:38.981 --> 00:28:43.135
I remember all the palaver we got in
about tech being the disruptor as we

00:28:43.135 --> 00:28:47.351
came into Y2K, and planes were going to
drop out of the sky and how it fitted

00:28:47.351 --> 00:28:51.865
into the risk register." And she said,
"I find it enormously valuable now

00:28:51.865 --> 00:28:56.494
just to be able to go back 26 years and
remember that thought process and remember

00:28:56.495 --> 00:28:58.075
how we put it in the risk register."

00:28:58.306 --> 00:28:59.624
What's your perspective on that?

00:28:59.624 --> 00:29:01.934
I mean, you smiled, so
I hope it resonates.

00:29:01.934 --> 00:29:03.464
But I'd love your perspective on that.

00:29:03.896 --> 00:29:06.204
Joanna Meager: See, I'm going to go
back to one of your first comments,

00:29:06.204 --> 00:29:09.384
which is about the demographics and
the age of the people on the board.

00:29:09.444 --> 00:29:10.704
I don't think it's about that.

00:29:10.884 --> 00:29:16.234
I think it's about mindset, and
it's that most adaptable to change

00:29:16.234 --> 00:29:18.304
mindset and that growth mindset.

00:29:18.974 --> 00:29:23.954
The reason I have adopted AI quite
so broadly is because it helps.

00:29:25.135 --> 00:29:29.329
If you can find a reason to
do something that gives you

00:29:29.329 --> 00:29:33.169
personal gain and productivity,
I think most of us would do it.

00:29:33.679 --> 00:29:38.689
So for me, having the right
mixture of mindsets on the board

00:29:39.049 --> 00:29:44.329
is probably far more helpful than
a different level of demographics.

00:29:44.989 --> 00:29:49.688
I also think that you've got to understand
a business first before you can apply

00:29:49.688 --> 00:29:51.518
technology to it of whatever type.

00:29:52.478 --> 00:29:57.198
I remember years ago, and I'm talking a
long time ago, a system on the trading

00:29:57.198 --> 00:30:02.028
floor stopped and it stopped being
able to calculate accrued interest

00:30:02.028 --> 00:30:07.609
on bonds  and I looked across the
trading floor and the suggestion was

00:30:07.609 --> 00:30:12.052
that we stopped trading bonds for the
afternoon because the booking system

00:30:12.082 --> 00:30:13.822
couldn't calculate accrued interest.

00:30:14.272 --> 00:30:15.502
And I said, "Don't be ridiculous.

00:30:15.502 --> 00:30:19.342
We'll just manually calculate the
accrued interest,' until I realised

00:30:19.342 --> 00:30:23.362
that I was the only person on the
trading floor that remembered how

00:30:23.362 --> 00:30:25.282
to calculate accrued interest.

00:30:25.552 --> 00:30:31.178
So after a very quick lesson in one of
the meeting rooms, I suddenly taught 20

00:30:31.178 --> 00:30:33.368
people how to calculate accrued interest.

00:30:33.368 --> 00:30:34.658
We were back up and running.

00:30:35.288 --> 00:30:38.888
I don't think you can ever rely
on a technology to replace your

00:30:38.888 --> 00:30:40.898
understanding of a business.

00:30:41.535 --> 00:30:44.325
Use the technology as much as
you want, but you've got to

00:30:44.325 --> 00:30:45.345
understand the business first.

00:30:46.635 --> 00:30:48.345
Ralph Grayson: And what's the
balance of reliance there?

00:30:48.345 --> 00:30:52.160
Is the danger we all become overly
reliant and therefore you're abrogating

00:30:52.162 --> 00:30:56.382
your responsibility as a board member by
saying, "Well, what does the AI tell us?"

00:30:58.238 --> 00:30:58.734
Joanna Meager: You know what?

00:30:58.734 --> 00:31:02.865
We can all still add up and
Excel's been around for a while.

00:31:03.555 --> 00:31:05.085
So I won't worry about that too much.

00:31:05.585 --> 00:31:09.016
Ralph Grayson: What are the three
questions then that any new NED should

00:31:09.017 --> 00:31:12.445
feel comfortable asking about an AI
proposal at their next board meeting?

00:31:13.032 --> 00:31:13.992
Joanna Meager: Oh, that's a tricky one.

00:31:14.752 --> 00:31:17.691
I think it depends what
kind of AI proposal it is.

00:31:17.691 --> 00:31:22.551
If it's just a plain personal productivity
proposal, that's simple and easy.

00:31:23.151 --> 00:31:25.541
There's less risk involved there.

00:31:25.852 --> 00:31:33.765
If it's taking out of activity, processes,
et cetera, I always ask the fallback.

00:31:33.864 --> 00:31:36.564
If this isn't working,
what's the fallback?

00:31:36.594 --> 00:31:38.514
Back to my accrued interest example.

00:31:39.094 --> 00:31:44.712
I always ask about how we are
sense-checking that it's still working

00:31:44.712 --> 00:31:46.572
and not hallucinating, et cetera?

00:31:46.902 --> 00:31:49.662
So what does that continuous
activity look like?

00:31:49.754 --> 00:31:50.645
Ralph Grayson: Lots to think about there.

00:31:51.112 --> 00:31:55.672
Let's turn on to REM committees, because
I think they're very misunderstood.

00:31:56.534 --> 00:32:00.014
You may or may not want to speculate
on the balance of risk and reward of

00:32:00.014 --> 00:32:03.914
being a board member these days and
the amount of published days there

00:32:03.914 --> 00:32:07.094
are, the actual days you spend doing
it and what you get rewarded for.

00:32:07.094 --> 00:32:10.506
But what do most people underestimate
about the work of a REMCO?

00:32:11.155 --> 00:32:15.271
Joanna Meager: I think when you
look at REMCO responsibilities, it's

00:32:15.271 --> 00:32:20.941
probably not quite as defined as
some of the other board meetings.

00:32:20.941 --> 00:32:26.881
So different companies want the REMCO
to do different things, and that's fine.

00:32:27.264 --> 00:32:28.044
Ralph Grayson: Bring that to life for me.

00:32:28.681 --> 00:32:32.126
Joanna Meager: If you look at what's
expected from a risk committee, I think

00:32:32.126 --> 00:32:36.296
the reporting might be slightly different,
but the expectation of what's covered

00:32:36.296 --> 00:32:39.776
in a risk committee is fairly standard.

00:32:40.056 --> 00:32:46.073
When you look at what's included in a
REMCO, there are different perceptions

00:32:46.073 --> 00:32:53.403
of whose compensation should be reviewed,
what the risk process should be, how much

00:32:53.583 --> 00:32:56.313
detail should you go into on conduct.

00:32:56.523 --> 00:33:00.496
So it doesn't quite have the
same defined parameters around

00:33:00.496 --> 00:33:02.206
it, which makes it interesting.

00:33:02.806 --> 00:33:06.526
What I would say is always go
back to your terms of reference.

00:33:06.736 --> 00:33:11.146
So go back to your terms of reference and
make sure that you're covering everything

00:33:11.176 --> 00:33:13.816
in your REMCO that you should be covering.

00:33:14.296 --> 00:33:19.696
Sometimes terms of reference can be
written and put to one side, and like

00:33:19.696 --> 00:33:23.566
objectives, they should be a living
document and reviewed on a regular

00:33:23.566 --> 00:33:27.226
basis, and you should be reviewing them
against the agenda to make sure that

00:33:27.226 --> 00:33:28.636
you're covering everything in there.

00:33:29.726 --> 00:33:33.289
Ralph Grayson: Where's your personal
north star as a good member of a REMCO

00:33:33.289 --> 00:33:37.092
in terms of, I mean, let's take a
hugely successful trader whose behaviour

00:33:37.096 --> 00:33:38.350
perhaps is not what it could be.

00:33:38.460 --> 00:33:39.480
Where's the balance there?

00:33:39.480 --> 00:33:41.507
Where's the responsibility
of a REMCO member?

00:33:41.813 --> 00:33:46.013
Joanna Meager: So the company will
have its own processes and procedures.

00:33:46.013 --> 00:33:49.793
It will have documented
disciplinary and conduct activity.

00:33:50.421 --> 00:33:55.157
As the REMCO, you're there to
make sure that they have followed

00:33:55.203 --> 00:33:57.337
those processes and practices.

00:33:57.610 --> 00:33:58.900
You're not there to change them.

00:33:58.960 --> 00:34:02.710
You're there to make sure that they're
followed and interpreted appropriately.

00:34:03.273 --> 00:34:04.318
Ralph Grayson: Data, data, data then.

00:34:04.365 --> 00:34:05.104
Joanna Meager: Absolutely.

00:34:05.247 --> 00:34:10.577
Ralph Grayson: Okay, and same rules
apply when it comes to diversity, ESG?

00:34:12.077 --> 00:34:14.597
Joanna Meager: So for me, I have
a slightly different view of

00:34:14.597 --> 00:34:16.637
diversity and I'm old, right?

00:34:16.637 --> 00:34:24.898
So I remember when we weren't even talking
about diversity as a particular aspect.

00:34:26.068 --> 00:34:30.778
I know that it's easy to measure
certain aspects of diversity

00:34:30.778 --> 00:34:33.178
because they are obvious.

00:34:33.268 --> 00:34:38.608
But to me, the most important thing
is diversity of thought and making

00:34:38.608 --> 00:34:42.885
sure that you've got people who
are across those board meetings,

00:34:42.888 --> 00:34:47.308
across those subcommittees, yes,
have got different experiences, but

00:34:47.308 --> 00:34:49.618
think in a slightly different way.

00:34:49.888 --> 00:34:53.155
That is the biggest safety
net any company can have.

00:34:53.673 --> 00:34:57.298
Now sometimes we short-circuit that
by going, "Let's pick someone with

00:34:57.298 --> 00:35:00.328
a different experience. Let's pick
someone from a different gender.

00:35:00.568 --> 00:35:04.952
Let's pick someone from a different
background." But that really is just  a

00:35:04.954 --> 00:35:09.608
short-circuit to get a different type of
thinking, and that's just so important.

00:35:10.050 --> 00:35:13.230
Ralph Grayson: And what might tell you
that we've got outward diversity, but

00:35:13.230 --> 00:35:15.231
not inward diversity if I can express it

00:35:15.231 --> 00:35:15.385
Joanna Meager: like that?

00:35:16.008 --> 00:35:19.290
If you end up with a whole load of
questions that are all looking exactly

00:35:19.290 --> 00:35:24.145
the same around a narrow field, you know
that you've got groupthink going on.

00:35:25.096 --> 00:35:29.940
I know on the boards that I sit on,
we have a full spectrum of questions.

00:35:30.060 --> 00:35:33.840
And if you've read the same documents,
you've read the same documents, you

00:35:33.840 --> 00:35:38.627
sit in the same room, and you can
come at questions from left field and

00:35:38.627 --> 00:35:42.450
right field, you know that you've got
the right kind of thinking going on.

00:35:42.950 --> 00:35:46.550
Ralph Grayson: But how do you
make space for that disagreement?

00:35:46.600 --> 00:35:50.513
Murray Steele, who runs the FT
NED programme, he calls it the

00:35:50.513 --> 00:35:52.313
Zone of Uncomfortable Debate.

00:35:52.882 --> 00:35:55.522
You're not adding value if it's
not uncomfortable, but it can't

00:35:55.522 --> 00:35:59.602
be so uncomfortable that it
leads to bad boardroom behaviour.

00:35:59.635 --> 00:36:01.988
How would you recommend people steer that?

00:36:02.105 --> 00:36:06.257
Joanna Meager: A good friend of
mine and a former boss always used

00:36:06.257 --> 00:36:12.077
to say to me, "We like to disagree,
but we're not disagreeable." And

00:36:12.077 --> 00:36:14.417
I think that's absolutely true.

00:36:14.447 --> 00:36:15.977
You've got to be able to challenge.

00:36:15.977 --> 00:36:19.817
One challenge on data, I
think that's really important.

00:36:20.417 --> 00:36:23.567
You're challenging on an issue,
you're not challenging a person.

00:36:24.134 --> 00:36:25.844
Disagree, but don't be disagreeable.

00:36:26.577 --> 00:36:29.487
Ralph Grayson: Let's turn that
scrutiny around the other way perhaps.

00:36:29.487 --> 00:36:33.927
So when you now look at a board
opportunity, how do you decide

00:36:33.927 --> 00:36:37.773
whether the organisation deserves
the commitment you would have to

00:36:37.775 --> 00:36:38.833
give it if you joined the board?

00:36:38.877 --> 00:36:40.407
Joanna Meager: Oh, that's a good question.

00:36:40.747 --> 00:36:43.567
Well, obviously, first of all, you've
got to get over the conflict thing.

00:36:43.627 --> 00:36:48.637
So making sure that it's not a conflict
with the portfolio you already have.

00:36:49.027 --> 00:36:51.007
For me, personally, it's interest.

00:36:51.234 --> 00:36:54.774
I've been asked to join a number
of boards because of my executive

00:36:54.774 --> 00:36:59.514
background that were very aligned
to things I did as an executive,

00:36:59.874 --> 00:37:01.704
not so interested in doing those.

00:37:02.164 --> 00:37:07.674
Also just looking at where that
particular company is in its journey.

00:37:08.094 --> 00:37:09.204
Is it growing?

00:37:09.204 --> 00:37:11.433
Is it trying to diversify?

00:37:11.880 --> 00:37:14.940
What's its footprint across the world?

00:37:15.350 --> 00:37:17.210
All of those things are really important.

00:37:17.662 --> 00:37:21.402
Ralph Grayson: And who might you
ask to meet from the employer's

00:37:21.402 --> 00:37:23.690
side rather than who the Nominations
committee want to put in front of you?

00:37:24.963 --> 00:37:26.909
Joanna Meager: You normally get
a good cross-section because I

00:37:26.922 --> 00:37:30.625
think, as I mentioned before, the
process can be a little long-winded.

00:37:31.105 --> 00:37:34.825
One of my personal tips… I'm
giving away all of my tips now.

00:37:34.825 --> 00:37:39.595
One of my personal tips is
you're normally collected from

00:37:39.625 --> 00:37:42.265
reception by a more junior person.

00:37:43.465 --> 00:37:47.335
I tend to grill them on the
way to the meeting room in a

00:37:47.335 --> 00:37:49.825
very nice way, I hasten to add.

00:37:50.665 --> 00:37:53.605
But you get a lot of
information out of that person.

00:37:53.605 --> 00:37:56.785
"How long have you worked here?
What's it like to work here?" That's

00:37:56.785 --> 00:37:58.765
my top tip, is speak to that person.

00:37:59.335 --> 00:38:04.765
If for any reason you are not
meeting a number of the executives,

00:38:04.825 --> 00:38:06.325
that would be a red flag for me.

00:38:06.463 --> 00:38:08.893
You need to be meeting
a few of the executives.

00:38:09.803 --> 00:38:11.453
Ralph Grayson: What's the role
of the headhunter in all of this?

00:38:11.807 --> 00:38:14.655
Two-thirds of board positions
don't use a headhunter.

00:38:14.761 --> 00:38:16.801
What's your experience of
the role of the headhunter?

00:38:16.991 --> 00:38:21.301
Joanna Meager: Well, I've done both and
I actually think it's really valuable

00:38:21.301 --> 00:38:25.801
as a candidate having a headhunter there
because you've got a sounding board,

00:38:26.592 --> 00:38:31.321
you've got insight, you're better prepared
going into your interviews because

00:38:31.321 --> 00:38:35.401
you've got insight from that headhunter
and then when you've come out of the

00:38:35.401 --> 00:38:39.654
interviews, let's face it, we don't
all walk out of interviews high-fiving

00:38:40.052 --> 00:38:41.598
and going, "That went brilliantly."

00:38:41.998 --> 00:38:46.711
You get much better feedback if
you've got a headhunter in the space.

00:38:47.194 --> 00:38:53.189
Plus, if there are things that you then
reflect on, I'm not the best reflector,

00:38:53.189 --> 00:38:54.719
but I'm trying to get better at it.

00:38:54.749 --> 00:39:00.839
If there's things that you then reflect on
and go, "I'm not 100% sure that I really

00:39:00.839 --> 00:39:04.529
understood the answer to that question
or the implication of the answer to that

00:39:04.529 --> 00:39:06.359
question," you've got somewhere to go.

00:39:07.019 --> 00:39:11.959
So I much prefer having
headhunters in the process.

00:39:12.546 --> 00:39:15.927
Ralph Grayson: And once you've read
the job spec, you've read the brief and

00:39:15.936 --> 00:39:21.114
you've asked the right questions, how do
you move beyond the job spec to the fit?

00:39:22.114 --> 00:39:24.034
Joanna Meager: I'm a touch
it and feel it person.

00:39:24.567 --> 00:39:30.057
If I thought it looked about right and
it looked interesting, I would go through

00:39:30.057 --> 00:39:34.377
the interview process because I think
you learn more in the interview process

00:39:34.617 --> 00:39:37.257
than you'll ever learn theoretically.

00:39:37.790 --> 00:39:40.827
To me, and you've got to remember when
you're doing the interview process,

00:39:41.338 --> 00:39:44.697
you're interviewing them as much as
they're interviewing you, maybe not

00:39:44.697 --> 00:39:50.237
with 200 questions, but you at least are
getting a great feel for the organisation

00:39:50.243 --> 00:39:51.178
that you're going to be joining.

00:39:52.117 --> 00:39:56.469
Ralph Grayson: And when you look back now,
is there a particular board discussion

00:39:57.279 --> 00:40:01.893
or something that's made you think,
"Gosh, my presence made a difference

00:40:01.989 --> 00:40:04.102
there. It's been worth all the angst."

00:40:05.102 --> 00:40:08.882
Joanna Meager: I don't have much
angst, which I'm quite lucky about.

00:40:09.542 --> 00:40:12.152
I think for me, it's
not one in particular.

00:40:12.536 --> 00:40:16.895
What was a lightbulb moment for me is
when I first became a NED, every company

00:40:18.384 --> 00:40:23.942
talks in such a variety of acronyms,
and there was a period in one particular

00:40:23.955 --> 00:40:27.383
meeting where I was like, "I think
I'm understanding every fourth word."

00:40:27.963 --> 00:40:31.923
It's now that I've gone, as you say,
seasoned and through a cycle, I sit in

00:40:31.923 --> 00:40:36.126
the meetings, I'm like, "I understand
all of this." I did exactly what I would

00:40:36.126 --> 00:40:39.636
encourage everybody to do is if you
don't understand something, either ask

00:40:39.636 --> 00:40:42.645
in the meeting or ask outside of the
meeting, because that's the only way

00:40:42.645 --> 00:40:46.266
you're going to end up like me and now
understanding everything in the meeting.

00:40:46.960 --> 00:40:47.800
Ralph Grayson: Joanna, thank you.

00:40:48.070 --> 00:40:53.020
For anyone considering their first
NED role, this transition raises

00:40:53.020 --> 00:40:56.770
questions we've touched on here
around preparation, judgement,

00:40:57.310 --> 00:41:00.040
relationships, personal motivation.

00:41:00.460 --> 00:41:04.260
I think your experience has given
everybody a really practical way

00:41:04.680 --> 00:41:08.910
to think about the contribution
they would make and the conditions

00:41:09.000 --> 00:41:11.100
in which they could make it well.

00:41:11.790 --> 00:41:16.230
Any one last piece of advice,
wisdom you would give?

00:41:17.187 --> 00:41:18.717
Joanna Meager: Don't
feel you have to do it.

00:41:19.137 --> 00:41:24.697
Just because you're semi-retiring
as an executive doesn't mean

00:41:24.697 --> 00:41:26.317
that you have to become a NED.

00:41:26.687 --> 00:41:33.127
Think about whether your particular
characteristics and charm would lead you

00:41:33.127 --> 00:41:36.757
to being a good NED or not, because if
you're not a good one, you won't enjoy it.

00:41:37.777 --> 00:41:41.324
Ralph Grayson: That's really good advice
when people come to see me and say, "I

00:41:41.324 --> 00:41:45.847
want to be a NED." The first thing I ask
is, "Have you looked in the mirror first?"

00:41:46.017 --> 00:41:47.030
Joanna Meager: I think you asked me that.

00:41:49.183 --> 00:41:51.475
Ralph Grayson: Joanna, thank you so much
for joining me on The Boardroom Path.

00:41:51.895 --> 00:41:52.285
Joanna Meager: Thank you.

00:41:52.285 --> 00:41:53.035
It's been a pleasure.

00:41:54.448 --> 00:41:57.718
Ralph Grayson: I hope that you've enjoyed
listening to this podcast and have found

00:41:57.718 --> 00:42:01.978
it helpful when thinking about how to
approach your own path to the boardroom.

00:42:02.868 --> 00:42:06.008
If you would like to push this a
little bit further, Sainty Hird

00:42:06.028 --> 00:42:10.818
runs a bespoke one-to-one programme
designed specifically to this end.

00:42:11.153 --> 00:42:15.836
For more information, please visit
our website saintyhird.com, follow

00:42:15.836 --> 00:42:21.691
us on LinkedIn, and subscribe to the
Boardroom Path to receive new episodes.

00:42:22.037 --> 00:42:22.987
Thank you for listening.