Tony Benjamin (00:14.736) Welcome to the HR Life Podcast, a podcast about the work-life experience of those of us in human resources and business leadership. Your hosts are fantastic Tony Benjamin, owner and founder of the Grange Strategic HR Consulting, and Stephen Big Deals Smith, who is so important that after a year of telling stories about himself, you still don't know all there is to know about him. Hey Steve! Steven Smith (00:40.807) Ain't that the truth? They're learning all kinds of stuff. What's crazy is you're starting to learn it stuff about me that you're just like, where did that come from? My wife is sharing some whoppers. Tony Benjamin (00:54.21) Yeah, well, you know, there's I gotta hit her up again. I have to admit I'm I'm and I'm I'm running low. I'm running low on the list that I have prepared. So but I no it just it strikes me that and I mentioned this at the conference too, but it's been over a year. We've been on the air every single week since that happened, and and I s we still have do you know, there's still stories to come out of it. Steven Smith (01:02.939) Are you out? Steven Smith (01:08.623) That's funny. Steven Smith (01:23.153) There's still stories. Ha I think people just wanna know how you do it. Cause who cares how I do it? I just make stuff up, right? Tony Benjamin (01:24.004) That's right. That's right. Tony Benjamin (01:30.18) Well Yeah Well for a long time that's what I did. I just you know I was like I can make up anything and Steve's got a story, so that's right, that's right. So that's how important you are. Well, Steve, we're here and we're with an empty red seat again today. And we this is Steven Smith (01:40.231) I got some story behind it. It's true. Steven Smith (01:50.169) Yeah. Though on the video it looks like I'm sitting in the red seat, so it's kinda weird, huh? Tony Benjamin (01:54.404) It does look like that. It does, it does. But it's actually behind you, right? Steven Smith (02:00.045) It it is, yeah, I'm I'm in a chair because my back kinda hurts today and so I'm I'm sitting in a chair, but the way I'm sitting in the chair, the red seat is back there and the the just the tip top part is showing over my shoulders and so yeah, it looks like I'm sitting in it. Tony Benjamin (02:16.654) Yeah, so it's maybe it's not quite empty. Maybe it's you know Steve is so famous and such a big deal that now he fills two two roles on the Steven Smith (02:19.334) Yeah. Steven Smith (02:26.213) And Max is not sitting in it. So this is where Max usually sits. So Max is a tuxedo cat that my daughter got when she was well, basically Max was abandoned as a kitten in Texas. And I'll tell you what, this cat is so skittish, like ridiculously skittish. And what's funny is every time there's a rainstorm, yeah, exactly. Every time there's a rainstorm or some type of storm, he goes ballistic. Tony Benjamin (02:46.532) He has attachment issues. Steven Smith (02:54.319) And so I'm wondering if when because he was abandoned in in Texas in a like a paper bag or something or a a bag. And I'm wondering if during the time he had been abandoned before they scooped him up, I bet it was during a storm. There must have been some type of wretched storm going on. And so he it scares him like crazy. The lightning, the thunder, like all of it. The flash of the lightning, all of it just drives him crazy. So So anyway, I don't know but boy boy is he skittish. It is crazy. And that's so that's usually the chair he lays in. He he he'll come in here and lay in 'cause it's kind of away from things, so Tony Benjamin (03:28.568) Gotcha. Tony Benjamin (03:32.548) Does do fireworks get him too? Steven Smith (03:35.513) No, they don't. They don't. It's just the storms. That that's why I think it's really it's truly PTSD. I don't know if cats can have PTSD. I guess they can. But but Tony Benjamin (03:38.66) Wow, see. Tony Benjamin (03:46.04) Yeah, I'm sure. I'm sure. Sometime I'll I'll have to tell everybody the story of the two cats that we have at my house and one of is named Death Cat, DC and he was vicious as a kitten 'cause we rescued him. And but now he's scared of everything and everyone, so it's he's just scared of everything. But okay, well enough about the k yeah. Steven Smith (03:52.134) Mm-hmm. Steven Smith (04:04.079) Wow. Wow. Well, you know what's funny too is Max was really small. He was like the the runt of the litter. But he became the the biggest. This cat is big. I mean I we have our main coon, which is really big, but but he weighs seventeen and a half pounds. And so we just always say things are bigger in Texas. Well let me tell you that the cats are too. So anyway. Tony Benjamin (04:22.798) Well, there you go. Tony Benjamin (04:27.736) The cats are too, right. I was gonna say that just proves the whole thing. That's awesome. That's awesome. All right, for all you for all you dog lovers now, you should all know that my ki one of my cats heals. She'll follow me around. So anyways, that always makes me think of that Chevy commercial where the guy throws the stick out in the lake and he opens up the door on his truck and the cat jumps out and jumps into the lake and goes and fetches the stick and brings it back. Steven Smith (04:33.799) All right, we'll stop talking about cats. Yeah, sorry. Steven Smith (04:43.077) Mm. Steven Smith (04:56.268) What? That has to be done by AI. There's no way. Tony Benjamin (04:57.956) Yeah, for sure. But it's hilarious. It's awesome. So funny. Anyways, so what we wanted to talk to every there's there's several things that are that are out there in the news right now and we want you to know we're following these. one of which was the recent decision about Sherm in in the Torres case. Steven Smith (05:04.839) Cool. Steven Smith (05:12.719) Mm-hmm. Steven Smith (05:18.224) What? Another decision on Sherm? I'm shocked. Tony Benjamin (05:21.804) Yeah. Right, right. So anyways, the we we hinted about this several months ago when we did the original one that came down in December. Steven Smith (05:30.949) Yeah, yeah. Cause we weren't sure if it was going to jury or not, but it did go to jury. And this is a jury verdict. Yeah. Tony Benjamin (05:35.8) did go to jury and the jury right, right. And they awarded four hundred thousand dollars to the plaintiff. we're gonna look at that one. That one's a little bit there's less twists and turns in the case itself, but I think that in my opinion, I think maybe the jury got it wrong. And so I think it's I think it's really good to look at it and and discuss it. Steven Smith (05:50.183) Mm-hmm. Tony Benjamin (06:01.74) And what sort of precedent that this is setting, especially in the press. Especially in the press. So Yeah, yeah, they're appealing. Yeah, they're appealing that one for sure. Steven Smith (06:03.931) Yeah. Well, and they're they're gonna push back, I assume Sherm will. And you know, I'm with you, Tony. I kind of agree on the appeal with this one a little bit. As especially based on Sam now I'm remembering this, especially based on the evidence was presented and and even the doctor, because the doctor testified at this jury at this thing and And even the testimony didn't really support the plaintiff at all. it was more much more supportive of Sherm. So so yeah, there are some things here that that I'm not a hundred percent sure that I agree, but but you know, here here's a good point, right? You take it to a jury, and a jury is mostly gonna decide you like you f first of all, you do, you never know. But think about the this particular individual with the disease and you know things that are happening. Tony Benjamin (06:36.601) Yeah. Tony Benjamin (06:48.482) And you never know. Steven Smith (06:58.831) You're gonna you're gonna your heart's gonna go out as a jury and you're gonna side with the plaintiff, right? So so in a way that part doesn't surprise me. So there you go. I don't know. Tony Benjamin (07:03.982) Yep. Yeah. Tony Benjamin (07:08.246) You you never know, and especially in the southeast of the of the country, right? And this is down there in Atlanta, you never know what a jury's gonna do out there. A jury could say, Yep, you win the case and here's ten bucks or they could say, Yep, you win the case and here's forty million. Like you have no idea. So it's just it's it's a Steven Smith (07:25.105) Well, yeah, the Ledbetter case. I remember when I was out there, if you recall the Leadbetter case, Leadbetter, she she lived in Alabama. And so we would see her at a lot of our conferences back then. And hearing her speak about her story and all that, she was she was a very simplistic Southern girl. Like she was just very simplistic, but she was very adamant that she and and obviously she won her case. And and but but at first she really didn't want to fight. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Tony Benjamin (07:34.188) really? Tony Benjamin (07:47.438) Well, she lost the case and then Congress changed the law. Yeah, yeah. Steven Smith (07:51.877) But listening to her story is fascinating because she wasn't always the she's really intelligent now, but you could tell at the time she only knew what she knew, right? She there wasn't a whole lot of of context for her. And over the years she's become very knowledgeable. But but at the time this was so new and and pr unprecedented that yeah, it it created the precedent. So there you go. Tony Benjamin (08:13.924) Yep. So we're gonna we're gonna dive and that that's just a taste of what we're gonna talk about when we do that episode. But Steve and I will go through that case. We'll we'll talk about all the back and forths with that. There's some of the testimony stuff that I still need to dig into a little bit. some of the stuff that I've seen though is pretty and eye popping to me at least. and so anyways, we're gonna dig into that. But today we're gonna talk about the exciting and wonderful Steven Smith (08:19.611) Yeah. Yeah, we'll we'll dig into it for sure. Steven Smith (08:33.532) Yeah. Tony Benjamin (08:42.242) world of workplace investigations. Steven Smith (08:46.053) Whoa, you got claps. Our live studio audience is like, you know, there's no red velvet rope for them this time. They're probably a little disappointed. Tony Benjamin (08:48.45) Yeah, well, can't you hear I excited there? That's Yay. Right. but no, we're gonna we're gonna talk about workplace investigations and I recently sat through a presentation of this and I wanna give a shout out to Chris Staley and and right, yeah. Steven Smith (09:10.503) Carissa, right? Staley, yeah. Tony Benjamin (09:12.856) This was this was on her what her presentation was on work elevator conference. And she also gave the same presentation to Basin HR, which is a group that I help leave it out here in the UNA Basin. and anyways, she gave this. I am not going to use the examples and everything that she gave. I think you should all ask Carissa to come and do that presentation at your group or whatever. and and and you'll you'll get a lot out of it. Steven Smith (09:34.183) Yeah, come and speak. Yep. Tony Benjamin (09:40.652) With that said, however, I I do think this is a subject we want to talk about. you hear about investigations all the time. You know, speaking of SHERM, the that first SHERM case was an excellent example about how to mess up an investigation and have it cost you. So yeah. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. And some of the in some of the advice today that we're going to give is is in reflection of that case. Now Steven Smith (09:52.583) Ain't that the truth? And they really did mess that one up. I mean, just point blank. So Steven Smith (10:09.073) Yeah. Tony Benjamin (10:09.964) Because of the way the US justice system works, the lessons from that don't necessarily go across to all the districts or the or whatever. They they they don't quite you know, it doesn't quite spread across the whole country, but I think there's some important lessons that we'll talk a little bit about what that means for you. So there you go. is there anything that we have missed talking about in a while, Steve, before we get into this that people want to know? Like we we know now that treetop Yoda is lost. Steven Smith (10:40.391) In the abyss. I think he's in Dagobah, and so I just I gotta go back there and pick him up. Yeah, yeah. Tony Benjamin (10:40.488) that he's lost his way in the force. Is there it go to the swamp. yeah. i okay, well can you think Steven Smith (10:51.503) Not that half our listeners will even know what that means, but but yeah, there you go. So important, so important. Tony Benjamin (10:54.564) All you gotta remember is at at. That's all you gotta remember about Star Wars. So that's that's right. That's right. Well, let's do this then. since we don't have any crazy updates, let's do let's do our first read and then we'll jump into the subject. Looking for a team building experience, your employees will actually talk about Dino Outfitters in Vernal, Utah. offers guided trips on the epic new Ashley Gorge Via Ferrata. Help your team build trust, confidence, and real connection, all while hanging out on the side of a cliff. Reach out to build a custom experience at UtahViaFerrata.com. Shout out to Amber and the wonderful stuff that she's doing and she's incredible. I'm actually going to be meeting with her in the next week or something like that. And talking to her again, but I saw her the other day. But yeah, she's incredible. She's incredible. anyways, okay, let's let's dive into this a little bit and let's talk about workplace investigations. And and here's for many of you that are in small to medium sized businesses, your processes are similar to a large business. The only difference is the formality of it may be smaller because your risk and exposure is smaller. Steven Smith (11:49.489) So fun. Steven Smith (12:09.499) Mm-hmm. Tony Benjamin (12:16.878) than a really big company. So so you don't necessarily have to go through all the detailed things that really big companies do. and and so I want to make sure that that you understand that these things are slightly different. The outline is generally the same, but they can be different. And the first one that that I wanna that I want to mention to everyone here is the first cardinal rule is do not make it bigger than it is. Steven Smith (12:18.481) Yeah. Tony Benjamin (12:46.21) Like trying. I I just you know, I we we used to before we fam formed Base in HR, there was a company here and they would send their office manager to our meetings, right? She wanted to learn about HR, and so she would come and she send out a message to a bunch of us once and said, Hey, I've got this going on. what should I do about it? And it took everybody maybe a day and a half to get back to her, you know, before everybody really responded. Steven Smith (12:46.363) Ha ha Tony Benjamin (13:12.354) And she came back and said, Well, while I was waiting for you all to respond, I initiated an investigation and da-da-da. And the funny part was is that I think two thirds of us told her she didn't need to investigate this situation. She just needed a handle of it because she already knew what had happened. And and she was like, Well, I interviewed five people and I did this and I took notes and I blah blah blah. And now I'm now I think I need to write a conclusion and recommendations. And I'm just like, Okay, you guys got like thirty employees, just let's all calm down here just for a minute. Steven Smith (13:26.769) Really? Interesting. Tony Benjamin (13:42.368) And you know, anyways, it so the first rule is don't make it bigger than it is. if you don't need to do an investigation, don't do an investigation. that's that's the first thing. and and along with that, and this is this is something I've discovered over the course of my career, and Steve, you'll find this kind of funny, but I think that eighty percent of the time there's no disagreement. Well, let me back up. There's no disagreement on about eighty percent of the facts. Anytime you do an investigation, everybody agrees on about eighty percent of the facts. There's no back and forth, there's no no now I tend to think if if you know the accused person in any situation or in somebody that might have done wrong or whatever, if they really wanted to defend themselves, they'd just go, I never did that. I don't know what you're talking about. Prove it. Just lie straight out. Yeah, that's what are you t I don't even know Beck Becky. What what are you talking about? Steven Smith (14:31.207) I just leave it leave it as is. What? What? That's that's not true. Steven Smith (14:39.941) What? I don't even know Becky. Tony Benjamin (14:40.772) Who was that? Yeah. but anyways, the and and of course you gotta have no morals to do that sort of stuff. But anyways, the point is is that that yeah, for saying that particular line maybe, yeah. but you be you just have to you just have to say the most of the facts everybody agrees on. you know, Frank and Debbie worked, you know, together for five years, they've known each other a long time. Steven Smith (14:48.231) is that a prerequisite? Steven Smith (15:01.479) Mm-hmm. Tony Benjamin (15:09.784) They were in this one area of the building alone together on this day. Like all that is stuff that people can agree on, right? And everybody knows and all that sort of stuff. And there's common knowledge that goes around about all these things. Or or if you you know, I I investigated something once where these two employees had gotten into a fist fight and the only thing that all of them disagreed on was who pushed who first. That was it. Steven Smith (15:20.539) Yeah. Steven Smith (15:38.97) Nice. Tony Benjamin (15:39.684) Yeah, yeah. It was everything else they agreed on. It was just Steven Smith (15:42.245) Which doesn't really matter at the end of the day. yeah. Okay. Fair enough. So fun. Well, okay, so so I want to bring up one question or maybe comment, and then maybe we can explore this a little bit before we delve into it. When should you or must you investigate? Is the question. And you know, and and when I think about this. Tony Benjamin (15:45.39) Yes. Yep. Exactly. It doesn't really matter who pushed two first. Tony Benjamin (16:06.452) Okay. Steven Smith (16:09.927) You know, it's interesting. Sherm actually talks a little bit about this in a recent article because I remember reading this where that make sure that you're not requiring written complaints. In other words, tips that you get, exit interviews that reveal things, things a supervisor overhears, those basically all count as a potential trigger. But again, like you said, it doesn't mean that we should investigate, but it does mean that okay, something's going on if if if these things are starting to be brought up in these types of situations. So so what I'm trying to say is, and and what Sherma is actually saying there too, is it doesn't have to be a formal written complaint where somebody called the hotline and actually formally reported something. It could simply be something that's discovered in the exit interview or is discovered during a certain process or is overheard by somebody that doesn't seem to make sense or wait a minute, why would they say that or do that? So anyway, those are those are, you know, some things to be aware of that it's it's a trigger, right? but anyway. Tony Benjamin (16:57.038) Yes. Tony Benjamin (17:14.84) Yeah, no, that's and no, that's exactly right. That that is exactly right. So let's say that your CEO's walking down the hall and he overhears two female female employees saying, you know, Jimbo, that guy harasses me and slaps me on the butt all the time. It's terrible. And if he just walks along and pretends he doesn't hear or ignores it or whatever else, yeah, the company knows. At at that point, the company knows. So anytime it's a C suite or executive overhearing it, especially for quote unquote officers of the company. If they are aware of it, the company is aware of it. And it doesn't matter if something formal was lodged. And this is something that like Utah Charter schools have this problem. They all think they're public schools and so they have a quote unquote grievance process. And my aunt and they're like, well she never filed a grievance or he never filed a grievance. And my answer, it doesn't matter. Doesn't matter. Steven Smith (17:49.639) Correct. Steven Smith (18:05.841) that's it doesn't matter. You're absolutely right. It doesn't matter. Well, and and here's the thing, you know, typically if you're gonna actually, if it's going to trigger an actual investigation, it has to fall under some of the legal issues, right? So harassment, discrimination, retaliation, safety issues, wage complaints, theft, fraud, violence, you know, policy violations, you know, legal stuff. So so so those types of things obviously will trigger an investigation. Pretty much bar none, right? Because it falls within those parameters. Tony Benjamin (18:39.417) Well I Right, right. So but here's the question to ask yourself. Why do we investigate something? We investigate because we don't know what happened. Okay. Steven Smith (18:50.183) Correct. Yep. Tony Benjamin (18:51.192) But if you know exactly what's happened, you don't really have to do that. Now, you could say that the person bringing the complaint to you or whoever initially talked to you that that is your investigation, right? But if you pretty much know what's going on, you don't have to do a formal investigation where you inv- you know you you interview 10 people and corroborate this and that and blah, blah, blah. Like you don't, you don't have to the the Steven Smith (19:10.33) Yeah. Tony Benjamin (19:14.21) I I just want to point that out to people. If you know what's happening, you don't have to quote unquote investigate. you do, however, want to document how you found out about it, right? The situation, right, that sort of stuff. But you don't and that and that goes back to what I was saying. Don't make a bigger deal out of this than it is. I I think I think a lot of us early in our careers, and I'll admit that I was probably guilty of this, a lot of us early in our careers are like, cool, this is what I'm for. An investigation. Aha, I get to go do this. Steven Smith (19:21.809) Document, always document. Yep. Tony Benjamin (19:43.452) And so you're you wanna go out and start interviewing. Well, it's because you like to feel important, like you're doing something more than shuffling paper around, right? That you wanna feel like you're doing something important. And and and I I and I'll say this Steven Smith (19:44.623) Is it because we were bored or something back then? I I'm curious why HR would do that because Steven Smith (19:56.45) okay. Okay. Is this when they were still begging for a seat at the table? Pretty much. Tony Benjamin (20:04.656) Yeah, yeah, probably. Yeah. This was during the era of keep me out of court, right? So and if that's your whole purpose, then an investigation is the pinnacle of your purpose. But you know, it's i just don't make a bigger deal out of it out of it than it is. Investigate when you need to, don't when you don't. You you do want to write down things that you learn and all that. and I would say this as well, that depending upon the size of your company and the severity of the accusation, Steven Smith (20:08.988) Yeah, yeah. Tony Benjamin (20:33.666) You don't always have to write some formalized report. Okay. Let's just let's you the more the more bigger of a deal it is, or the more your liability exposure, the bigger your company, the more formal you need to be. But you don't have to. You know, section in your twenty page report. that's that's not how that stuff works. So Okay, so go ahead. Steven Smith (21:05.585) Well, I was gonna say when I when I was researching this a little bit, there were three legal wise that were established by a a court case, I think Farragor Elert in nineteen ninety eight. And basically if if a supervisor's harassment ends in some type of tangible action, like firing demotional loss of pay, then the employer's liable. There's no defense. if it creates a hostile work environment, then the employer has to avoid liability, they have to prove that it reasonably tried to prevent and promptly correct it, or the employee unreasonably failed to use the complaint process, which that's I think this is where some companies fail a little bit, where they they think always that the process has to be followed. but again, the formal process, but it it can depend, right? Tony Benjamin (21:49.388) The formal process, yeah. Steven Smith (21:54.495) how gra how grave the the actual incident is. And then obviously for coworkers and and and if I th you brought this up with the whole leadership knowing something. If if coworkers and non-employees are aware, then the employer is now liable because and it's liable based on the fact that if it knew or should have known And then failed to think prompt action. And so in this case they should have known, right? Because it was it was overheard or or at least brought to the attention of somebody important in the organization. So Tony Benjamin (22:18.039) Right, right. Tony Benjamin (22:23.778) Meaning every employee in the building knows about it, but for some reason the supervisor doesn't, then they should have known. Right. And that and that's what that's what they're trying to say. Now now there is a defense for a company to say we were not made aware of this, right? There is a way to do that. But what I would tell you in my experience of doing this for a long time is generally before leadership knows, a bunch of employees know. Steven Smith (22:29.073) Yeah, yeah, yeah. And that's the point. Yep. That's exactly the point. Yep. Tony Benjamin (22:52.29) So usually this these things aren't happening in secret. Usually. Okay. So people people know about Steven Smith (22:56.103) Yeah. Well, there were there were two things that the the EEOC brought up too. They said it has to be prompt and adequate. And then they define it. So prompt, prompt was basically the way they described it, I love this, reasonably soon after the notice, right? And and all they could do is is is describe an example of waiting two months without a good reason very very likely isn't, you know, reasonably soon. Tony Benjamin (23:13.164) Right, right. Tony Benjamin (23:22.468) Right, right. Steven Smith (23:23.525) Two weeks of doing nothing after a physical test complaint likely isn't either. And so prompt would be like one to two days, you know, within the week type thing. That w that would be considered prompt in their eyes, based on a lot of the court cases that they've that I've seen. Tony Benjamin (23:38.187) If if a case yeah, yeah. If somebody comes into you and complains at four thirty on Friday And by the time they're done giving you the complaint and everything and they're crying in your office and all that. And by the time they're done, it's five ten. It's pretty reasonable to wait until Monday to deal with it. it it doesn't mean you have to start calling people at home and tracking people down and all that sort of stuff over the weekend. that that is it's a it there's a reasonability thing here in a day or two, three, four, maybe not don't you know, it doesn't matter depending upon the case. But by the time you get to a week it probably does. So and unless, of course, Steven Smith (23:52.999) Correct. Yep, correct. Tony Benjamin (24:13.57) you don't have anyone in you know no one in leadership is in that region or area or whatever you gotta travel along space. But anyways, that yes, no, that that's a very good point. But I I want to touch on this really quick because we're talking a lot about discrimination, harassment, and other things. So I want to talk and we should probably have a podcast just on these items, but let's just throw this out there so everybody understands this. The definition of discrimination is an unfair disadvantaged Steven Smith (24:17.061) Yeah. Yeah. Tony Benjamin (24:39.916) An unfair disadvantage based upon one of those protected classes that we all know about that I mentioned in our last episode. So, anyways, you want to you want to make sure that you know it's it's an unfair disadvantage. That's the definition of discrimination. now there are two kinds of discrimination. The first one is disparate treatment, meaning I meant to do that based upon that that protected class. Right, right. I'm treating you differently because right. Steven Smith (25:02.277) Yeah, purposeful or resentful. Yeah. The intent was there. Yeah. Tony Benjamin (25:08.674) The second kind is disparate impact, meaning what I'm doing has the same effect as if I meant to discriminate, even if I didn't mean to do it. The New York Firefighter Department is the example I always give with that. Now, with that said, harassment is a form of discrimination. Under the law, harassment is a form of disparate treatment. You're saying I'm treating you differently because of discovery. Steven Smith (25:16.817) Yeah. Tony Benjamin (25:33.95) w one through another. But it's a it's a negative fill in the blank. Great. So now most time we think of sexual harassment, but sexual harassment is just a form of harassment. Okay. And usually, okay, just like there's two forms of discrimination, there are two kinds of harassment. And the first is quid pro quo. That's a Latin phrase. It means this for that. Okay. So you do this for me and I'll do that for you. Steven Smith (25:35.301) Yeah, fill in the blank, right? Yeah. Tony Benjamin (26:00.779) If you don't do this for me, I'll do that to you. Okay, and again quid proques Latin this for that. And this is the sort of stuff that, you know, the the the boss chases his secretary around the desk over and over until she finds something heavy enough to knock him out with. that sort of thing. Steven Smith (26:16.945) Wait, did you just describe that movie nine to five? I I feel like that Tony Benjamin (26:19.716) And what is the other one where where Demi Moore preys on Kurt Russell or whatever that was? That was one too. I can't remember that one. Anyways, but the point is, is that's the one we we used to think about all the time. In mo and for most of you young folk, because you're not as old as I am, the what you normally think of and what we hear about most in the press about harassment now is the second kind, and that's hostile work environments. Steven Smith (26:26.884) gall, I don't even know. Tony Benjamin (26:46.104) Now, I just want to say a hostile work environment is not the the guy in the cubicle next to me looks at me funny, okay? That's not hostile work environment. Okay? There has there's a two-tier test for this as well. So in order for it to be a hostile work environment, number one, it has to significantly interfere with your ability to do your job. And number two, it has to permeate the workplace. So I want to make sure that everyone understands that. It has to interfere with your ability to do your job. And the reason for that is is because someone's harassing you or treating you differently based upon one of those protected classes, and it is affecting your ability to do your job. So in other words, they're getting you fired. That is, and we can talk about the threshold about how big that is or whatever. The second state is it has to permeate the workplace. That means it cannot be isolated to one place in time or space and and you claim a hostile work environment. Tony looked at me funny on Tuesday, then that's not a hostile work environment. That's Tony probably ate something that disagreed with him and you misunderstood. So Steven Smith (27:48.455) I mean Tony looks at me weird every Monday, so w obviously Tony Benjamin (27:52.549) Every time we get on the podcast. That's right. So, but yeah, so you you you're kind of understanding, and we could spend a lot a lot of time in those. Now, you're saying to yourself, Hey, wait a minute, this isn't what I've been taught. I've been taught if I'm in a room with ten people and someone tells a dirty joke and nine of them are fine with it and one isn't, that could be considered a hostile work environment. The answer to that is probably not, but We as HR people have been taught to eliminate risk. We are risk adverse. And so we try to eliminate those things and get rid of them before they become technically a hostile work environment. Now, I have never seen a case, although I bet they're out there, that says we looked into this matter and this was not technically a hostile work environment. We did we worked on it and we tried to eliminate it, but it was not technically harassment. And I can't wait to see that in a court somewhere. Steven Smith (28:29.903) Problem. Yeah. Tony Benjamin (28:48.42) I'll have to ask an attorney. We'll have to ask Mark Coleman sometime if if Mark Tolman, if if that's a you know, what his make of that defense would be. But generally speaking, there you go. I wanted to put those out there so everybody understands that and we could spend an hour just on those definitions and what they really mean. my purpose in saying this is that hostile work environment and sexual harassment or harassment rarely happen full blown in a company. It is usually the problem is that it's escalating. Someone has reported it and the company does not do what you said, Steve. They don't take action adequate to correct it. And so so it's Steven Smith (29:27.431) Correct. Well, even appropriate corrective action, which is how the EEOC defines it basically. And what that means is it the the way they describe that is they say that it must be reasonably calculated to prevent further harassment and proportionate to whatever the offense might be. So so so that's that's where you know some people may try to, I don't know, fudge it a little bit. Tony Benjamin (29:49.026) Right. Steven Smith (29:56.773) But think about that, reasonably calculated to prevent further harassment. So was the prompt action helping to prevent further issue? And if it wasn't, it may not have been the appropriate corrective action. And that's where some people fail sometimes. So Tony Benjamin (30:13.9) Right, right. So let's say that Grover, 'cause he's my favorite example in all this. Grover doesn't like Yolanda, who's you know, I'm mixing my childhood meta my childhood domains here, but Grover and Yolanda from Dr. Seuss, you know, he he's bothering her or whatever, and he doesn't know he's bothering her. So you go up and you say, Hey Grover, what you're doing really bothers Yolanda. Don't do that anymore. And he's like, crap, okay. That is sufficient. That is sufficient, right? Now Steven Smith (30:18.811) Grover. Tony Benjamin (30:43.254) If it happens again, it was not sufficient, and that means the company needs to move forward with doing something differently. back in the day we used to write people up for stuff like that a lot more, and I found it doesn't help. All it does is demoralize people. So do what is appropriate. You have to do something sufficient to make the behavior stop that someone finds to be hostile. So that's all you're required to do. Steven Smith (31:09.447) Yeah. Tony Benjamin (31:12.246) you're not required to search it all out, you're not required to report it to the press. You're not required to say, you know, how mean the boss is, all that. Steven Smith (31:18.491) Well and here's a here's a question that comes up often when I talk with people. Just because I think it's hostile doesn't mean it is hostile. So how would you actually define that? Because, you know, I I I re I had somebody come to me and said, Yeah, I I was told that I couldn't talk about with another person of my same religion. I'll just use this example. I was talking with with this other person about religion, and then HR came and told me that I can't do that anymore. But yet I was talking with somebody of the same religion with them and just somebody happened to overhear it and that was the person that filed the complaint. How is that hostile, you might ask, right? And so so that's where it gets a little tricky is how do you def define what hostility actually looks like in that sense? Tony Benjamin (32:05.101) Right, and that's a g that's a great example of your rights conflicting over time, right? Your personal rights conflicting with other people's rights and those sorts of things. And private organizations have a lot of leeway in that. So the answer is is you can say you're not allowed to talk about religion and politics on company time. Okay, that's perfectly fine. But if I'm not clocked in, you have no control over me. Steven Smith (32:11.099) That's correct, yeah. Steven Smith (32:18.993) Mm-hmm. Tony Benjamin (32:30.41) whether or not I'm in your building or not, that's something different. on the flip side of that, if you're gonna prevent me, say as a Baptist from talking about my religion, then you better prevent the Mormon or the Buddhist or the Muslim from talking about theirs. Or else I'm gonna say you singled me out. Yes. Then because Yep, yep. If but if someone says we never talk about religion or politics in the office, which by the way is a bad policy. Steven Smith (32:30.471) Correct. Steven Smith (32:46.641) Yeah. Be consistent. Yeah. There needs to be a level of consistency. Tony Benjamin (32:58.68) But if if that's what you say, then then you have to treat everybody that same way. Everybody's gotta gotta have the same thing. And as long as you treat everybody the same, you're okay. You can say, Hey Billy, stop talking about stop talking about harassment. Okay. Steven Smith (33:09.201) Mm-hmm. Steven Smith (33:13.595) Yeah, because you took the appropriate corrective action based on a policy that already existed within the company that probably everybody signed off on. So there you go. Tony Benjamin (33:21.26) Yeah, yeah. Or in look, we very few of us have s lines in our employee handbook that says don't be an obnoxious jerk in the office, right? Like we have some code of conduct and stuff like that. Steven Smith (33:32.923) I thought yours did have that, Tony. Wait a minute. Tony Benjamin (33:35.877) No. I don't even really like codes of conduct in my in my employee handbook. because then I think you get into this area. but okay, with with all that in mind, a complaint comes to you and let's just pick this up. Let's just say that I'm trying to think of something off the top of my head that will seem that won't be too hard. Let's do this. Let's in my training, this is the example I always give. And then and then let's talk about Steven Smith (33:40.827) Ha ha ha. Tony Benjamin (34:03.651) the specifics of this example and then let's talk about how we would investigate it, okay? So, we've got Grover and he just he lives there in the office, he's doing okay and he works in a cubicle. Yolanda, she's on the back side of the cubicle. She works there and Yolanda's pregnant and let's say that she is talking to her friend about her pregnancy and all the fun changes that are going on with her body. But she's doing it in a very graphic and detailed way. Steven Smith (34:08.199) Okay. Tony Benjamin (34:33.388) And it makes Grover feel uncomfortable. Okay. Poor Grover. So that's right. But you know, she's right, she's literally on the other side of the cubicle wall from him. So one of these days he stands up and he yells at her and says, Stop talking about this. I can't stand it. You know, and then he never talks to Yolanda again and he he just avoids her any chance he gets and he runs away. And anytime she says anything about being pregnant, Steven Smith (34:36.423) Poor Grover Near Far That's where he needs to get far. Steven Smith (34:48.731) Yeah. Tony Benjamin (35:03.48) He shouts her down and and tells her to shut up. So and and that's the complaint you're getting. Let's say you're getting this from Yolanda, okay? That that's where you're getting this. Steven Smith (35:12.881) She's complaining that Grover is having his outbursts. Tony Benjamin (35:16.322) Yeah, he's having his outbursts, he's yelling at me, all that sort of stuff. And this is the complaint. So I I want to start I want to start here. And whether this is in writing or not, the first person that you talk to is the person making the complaint. Okay? Because you have to understand the complaint before you can get into anything else. Okay. That's that's what you want to do. Now here's what I here's the advice that I always give people. I never go into any of these meetings without a note taker with me. And that's another person. Now, in our modern world, we're getting to the point where we can do AI. I think AI note taking is fine as long as well, hold on. AI note taking is fine as long as one, you make sure that you have their private information locked down, it's never ever shared. Number two, I would still have a person in there with me. And I would have them jotting down notes too. Steven Smith (36:10.481) Witness. Tony Benjamin (36:12.726) A they're a witness so that you can't be accused of doing something in there that you didn't. And number two, Steven Smith (36:16.965) Yep. A witness is always important. I cannot emphasize that. I just it's just important, so Tony Benjamin (36:23.02) Right, right. And number two, yeah, yeah, yeah. And number two, that person's gonna notice things that you don't. Okay. So so this is how it goes. Now, we've had guests on in the past that have talked to us about how you find out if someone's lying to you and all that sort of stuff. And and what I wanna say here is I would not go into any meeting that you go into with the assumption that people are lying, okay? Steven Smith (36:30.215) Correct. Yep. Tony Benjamin (36:47.522) So that means even the person who's being accused, I recommend you not go into that assuming that they're lying to you. you may find that out during the interview, but I think it's very important that you don't you don't do that. and then Steven Smith (37:02.247) Well, and that that kind of follows the conflict of interest test that the EEOC requires or at least looks at when investigations come in. Are you familiar with that? Tony Benjamin (37:12.728) Go ahead. Go ahead. Steven Smith (37:14.041) So the conflict of interest test basically says that the accused should not have supervisory authority over the investigator or any control over the investigation. So that that's that's one of the tests. and so you have to know your limits. So there's you know obviously common triggers and things like that that come in. But if the accusations are against a VP or higher, or against HR or or involving multiple incidents, then you you have to be careful about who you bring in for part of that investigation. Right? There there can't be any connection, I guess might be the best way to describe that. because that they call it a conflict of interest. And the EEOC looks at that pretty heavily. Like the I know a lot of the cases that that they've revealed where there were issues, there was a conflict of interest. In fact, I had a a client came come to me the other day complaining about something and The reason why they were complaining is is well I can't make any complaint because the person I I can that I'm supposed to go to to complain is actually the husband of my manager. Like half that that is not a good reporting hierarchy, if you will. it doesn't work at all. but sometimes when you're in a small business like that, you know, small business owners, that gets really tough. You know, especially when it's the owner's relative or there's some type of connection there. So Tony Benjamin (38:22.722) Right, right. Yeah, yeah. Tony Benjamin (38:31.246) Yeah. This yeah Tony Benjamin (38:37.72) No, that's exactly right. And and those are places where the company can turn to consultants like Steve and I and we can come in and help 'cause we don't Steven Smith (38:43.217) Correct. And they should turn to consultants. They should get a third party mascare. I remember years ago I investigated a lady who was being accused of abusing some children in this particular volleyball club. And so they brought me in as a third party because the HR person right away realized that I can't do this on my own. I have too many connections here. We're we're only so many employees. Everybody knows everybody. So I need to have a third party present. There's just no way I can do this otherwise. And so I was brought in for that. very purpose so that it could be discussed and I became the second witness as part of the investigation and making sure there wasn't a conflict of interest because you had me there that I have nothing to do with any of the parties. Right. So that's important. Yeah. Tony Benjamin (39:27.158) Right, right. So the test right, the test of that conflict of interest is whether or not you will gain a reward or suffer a punishment based upon your decision in the matter. And if the answer is yes either direction, then you should not be the person investigating it. Steven Smith (39:45.425) Well, think about it. If you're investigating your own boss and then you involve HR, that puts undue pressure on HR because now HR still has to report to the boss and talk to the boss, right? So and so there can be a conflict there too. Again, this conflict of interest test I think is really important. So if you're going to start an investigation, verify in your s you know, verify is there a conflict of interest here in any way. And if there is, third party. Absolutely. Full stop. Tony Benjamin (40:12.962) Yeah, yeah. If you can't if you can't find somebody qualified to do the investigation within the organization that does not have a qual a conflict of interest, then yes, that's exactly what you should do. And and I want to point out this and what you're th what we're all thinking here is bosses, friends, relatives, or boyfriend, girlfriend. Right, right. Steven Smith (40:30.321) Well and I'm thinking more in smaller employer context as well, 'cause that's where this becomes a real challenge at times. Tony Benjamin (40:36.27) But but let's also think about this. This is what this was part of the problem in the Scherm case that we discussed last year, be was because they they he was not impartial. He had a conflict of interest because he was being asked to f find a way to manage her out. Steven Smith (40:54.513) Correct. Tony Benjamin (40:54.86) At the same time he was supposed to be investigating. So it's a conflict of interest, meaning there's no way that he the company is qualified in that instance to determine if if something's actually going on, because the person tasked to find out is on one side or the other already. So but that's a that's a great example. And there has to be at least an an a modicum of impartiality. You you at least for lack of a better phrase, right, a fig leaf of mo of impartiality. But you w you want to make sure that's the case. Steven Smith (41:29.029) Just waiting for all this all this old Latin words coming out of ya. I mean in here I thought it was a dead language. I mean, gee. Tony Benjamin (41:33.217) Tony Benjamin (41:38.68) Yeah you you all knew posts of Robeskin Latin. You you Vrobesca and Roman Este. I dn I don't speak Latin, I speak Romanian. So there you go. I don't even know how to say Latin. Steven Smith (41:49.211) Well, and I I know there are there are times too where you should absolutely involve an employment attorney. And again, this doesn't have to be the attorney direct. It could be somebody on their staff. It could be somebody like yourself, Tony, that consults with, you know, as part of the legal firm and can do that. And that's usually when there's allegations that involve like the senior leadership or the owner, if there's possible criminal conduct like assault, theft, fraud, things like that, threatened or you know, pending legal action, agency charges, and then obviously termination of like a long-tenured or high profile employee. and then anything involving a union, but a union is rare here in Utah. But outside of Utah there might be those of you who are listening who do have unions involved and so that's when I would definitely recommend having a an employment attorney. So Tony Benjamin (42:26.69) Yeah, yeah. Tony Benjamin (42:34.944) On my website there's a an article about when to call an attorney and when to call an HR consultant and eighty percent of the time it's the HR consultant. right, right. Steven Smith (42:43.739) Yeah. It's cheaper. It it's it you yeah, it and and usually the HR consultant has enough experience and background and have been through enough cases that they can give you some really good feedback, right? So Tony Benjamin (42:56.962) Yeah, yeah. And that's and that's just it. You can usually get the really good advice that direction. okay, so you then what you want to do is you're gonna talk first to the person making the accusation, then you're gonna talk to the person who has been accused. And the reason I say you want to go there first is because you want to make sure that you understand both angles of this, because it puts a beginning and an end on the investigation. Like it it's gonna bookmark your information. Now Steven Smith (43:10.279) Mm-hmm. Tony Benjamin (43:25.076) Then you want to make sure that any discrepancies that those two people do not agree on, that you have to find a way to find out what is true and what isn't. And here's the cardinal rule with this: interview as few people as possible. Okay? Look. We all say we all look when you're in this meeting and you're talking to people and you're gonna get information from them, the first thing you do is you say, Hey, keep this confidential. Please don't go around telling everybody about this. It's just gonna cause people embarrassment. It's not gonna be good. I I'll tell you this, nine out of ten employees walk right out of there and tell your best friend what's going on. So just you know, yes. And thanks to the Steven Smith (44:04.687) All the time. All the time. Or or they'll come and tell me. I was I was like a third party vendor. I can't tell you how many times my clients would just come talk to me because they needed to vent and get it out. As weird as that sounds. Tony Benjamin (44:18.062) Yeah, yeah. But there people are not you c you should tell them, you should advise them not to talk about it, but in the end you can't legally prevent them from doing it. so anyways, you're gonna go in, but you want to talk to as few as people as possible so you spread the information. You spread the information as narrowly as possible. 'Cause you only want enough to be able to do that. here's some advice on how to do those interviews. I would start by asking them generic questions, what happened, and then I would zero in on specifics. I would not start with did you pinch Yolanda's butt? Right? That or or did you did you ever Steven Smith (44:58.631) Grover, what were you thinking? Tony Benjamin (45:00.372) Yeah, Grover, did you ever did you ever make lewd comments about her body parts or or whatever, right? that sort of thing. Or did you ever scream? She said you screamed at her, did you? I would not start there. I would start with generic things that it's easy for them to to do and are not a threat to them, which by the way, is and we've talked about all this, it sends your it sends a person you're interviewing into a relaxed state, which is base, and then you can watch them to find out when they become nervous or not. Steven Smith (45:29.607) Yeah. Tony Benjamin (45:29.88) And that's how you'll know who's telling you the truth or not. But just do that. Then I would say get the general story. And then I would go back to specific details throughout the the conversation and try to zero in on those that are important. Try to get those. Watch not only for how they for the information they give you, but I you also need to watch for what changes in between their explanations. And they can say the same information in different words, and you should note the differences each time. So just to just to put that out there, you're gonna talk to some Steven Smith (46:01.383) Well, I loved what was it, Derek that that told us in in his little heat principle is have them describe it backwards, you know? I I thought that was a yeah, I thought that was a really interesting take on it as well, because when you're telling it backwards, not only do you have to think a little bit harder, but you it's hard to mi stuff up when you're going backwards. Tony Benjamin (46:09.218) Yeah, yeah. Tell you the story backwards. Yeah. Tony Benjamin (46:24.32) I exactly. It's hard to keep all the facts straight. So and and it's harder for everybody to keep all the facts straight anyways, but by doing that it's harder if they're lying to you. but anyways, yeah, there's there's a whole episode there. If you guys didn't hear that episode, that's an incredible episode. You should go listen to that. Yeah, it really gets into it. but you want to talk to as few people as possible. You want to have someone in there with you, and every time you want to make notes. Steven Smith (46:26.62) Yeah. Steven Smith (46:41.115) It's a great one. Tony Benjamin (46:50.656) about what happened. And here's one of the things that I would tell you, advise you when you're taking notes. Not only write down the information about what happened, but also about the quirky ways in which they tell it to you. So for example, if you law if if you're interviewing Grover and he keeps using the word disgusting, that was disgusting. That was disgusting. That was I'm going to jot down the word disgusting. And I'm going to remember that that was his description of stuff. And so And so, anyways, just know about the person, know what their tells are, know what know what's going on, know what they keep coming back to. If they keep repeating the same accusation in a w you know a split second of time, you know that in their mind at least, that's the most important fact that they want you to understand. Have the person with you after every interview, you and the other person talk and say, What did you get out of this? What did I get out of it? And again, not just about information. When were they nervous? When were they worried? And jot those notes down. Once you get done interviewing everybody, then you need to make a a a decision. And you know, Krissa, Krissa had a great point in her thing. She said, you know, before you start investigating, look at your policies. Make sure you know what your policies are, which I think is a great idea. And I would say at this point, you want to apply what you have discovered against your policies. And you wanna find out, is this really a problem? Is it not? Is it a legal problem? Is it not? Is it discriminatory? Whatever else. You're gonna start and and what you wanna do is you wanna say at face value, just what I know, if I only take the facts that everybody agrees on, which is eighty percent of if if I only know those, does is this a problem? Is this harassment? Is this something I have to write? If I just accept the facts that everyone agrees on, what does that mean? And then you can start to build your way through the disputed facts. And and you're gonna have to decide how you do it. you're gonna have to decide what the legal definition of it is and what the best way to handle it is. Chris had a g this great idea of jotting down or having a record of all your precedents, right? So Tom got fired because he made a $100,000 mistake on the ledger. He just got fired for that because it was so egregious. Tony Benjamin (49:13.656) But Billy over there just made a $200,000 mistake and for some reason we're not filing firing him. What's the difference? Right? So anyways, beware of those things, and then I would say draw conclusions and come to a an agreement on what you want to do. I believe that sometimes writing a conclusionary report is not a good thing. Just telling you, it's not. All your notes should have everything about your logic and what you learned and all your interviews, but I you do not have to write a conclusion or determine certain things on paper. You don't have to. Especially if you're a small company. What when you want to document those things is when you are finding specific reasons A for termination and you're worried that the person may come back and you're Your interpretation might be misinterpreted. So your actions might be misinterpreted as going against somebody for their protected class. So I'm gonna side with Yolanda in this case, or no, I'm gonna side with Grover in this case, but Yolanda may come back and say, Hey, I'm the one that said I was being harassed, not him. And your answer is gonna be, okay, but here here's what I found. And you In that case, because she may sue you saying, I'm the one that was harassed and you're siding with him, if that is the case, you better have why. You better have something in writing that says what your thought process was. But that's right, that's right. And look, I make these things very easy. I write down all the agreed upon facts of what happened. I have another section in my notes that say facts in dispute, and then I try to keep my conclusion to as short as possible. Steven Smith (50:48.815) Yeah, like how you came to that conclusion. Tony Benjamin (51:06.004) I believe so and I believe this happened. I believe this happened. And you don't have to get in again. In in most cases, you don't have to get into, you know, ten reasons why you believe it. You just say, I believe this happened, this happened, and this happened after these interviews. And as a result, this is my determination what I'm going to do. And what then is because if you do get sued, you've got something in hand that says this is my logic and my thought process. And by the way, it had nothing at all to do with discrimination or So, anyways, then what you're gonna do is then you're gonna have to take action on it. And sometimes that involves disciplinary action and sometimes it does not. So again, what Steve said a long time, that's the right thing, is really you wanna look at that and you want to say what is sufficient to make whatever behavior it is stop. Now here's what I would tell you people. Let's say that you get investigating and it's not technically harassment, right? That's a misunderstanding or whatever it happens to be, but it's not technically harassment or hostile work environment. That's okay, but you still have to do something about the situation to lower the temperature for everybody involved. So I'm not a big fan of giving written warnings just to make for that purpose, but I am a big fan of saying. Of going to person being accused, okay, I've looked at this, I don't think you did this intentionally, but I'm gonna verbally tell you not to do that again because it gets misunderstood. And the person making the accusation, I totally understand why you took it that way. That's not how it's intended. Here's what we can do to correct all that. And you lay out some parameters. Problem fixed, that's easy to do. is there something else you wanted to add in there? Go ahead. Steven Smith (52:49.575) Yeah. Steven Smith (52:55.375) One of my f yeah, one of my favorites here is the involuntary transfer. I have seen this on occasion where the organization will say, Well, we went ahead and transitioned Yolanda to the night shift so that she wouldn't have to see or sit next to Grover anymore. She didn't ask for that, but we just we changed her role. Tony Benjamin (53:16.856) Yeah. Steven Smith (53:20.837) Because she complained. That that is known as an in voluntary transfer. And and when you do that, that is unlawful retaliation. That is retaliation right there. So so don't don't go just transferring people around simply because, well, if they're not around each other, that'll help solve the problem. That doesn't solve the problem. And in fact, you could be held liable as an organization for that. It's it's a very common practice that I've seen, especially with smaller companies. Tony Benjamin (53:32.344) Yes. Uh-huh. Steven Smith (53:49.637) And they don't realize that what they're doing is actually it's unlawful. It's retaliation. Yeah. Yeah. And they don't they don't see it that way, but but it is. It's exactly what it is. Tony Benjamin (53:53.637) Retaliating. Yeah, Yolanda Yolanda, you work in an office with five bigoted dudes, and so we're gonna move you out of that office and get you away from them. You're gonna go to this other place and it pays fifty cents less an hour, but that's better than having you there. Yeah, yeah. Steven Smith (54:12.891) Or it's a different location altogether, and now you have to drive, you know, further than what you would initially like there there's just too many things there. The only other things I would adverse action. There you go. Yeah. So the only other things that that I would potentially add to the process. Tony Benjamin (54:18.403) Yeah. Adverse adverse action is what that is called. Steven Smith (54:39.855) And don't promise total secrecy. Just listen. Just listen. That's your role as the interviewer is to just listen, right? So don't promise any outcomes or anything like that. Because some people, especially small business owners, they they try to say, well, you know, this, you know, we're we're just trying to make sure we have all our ducks in a row. And but d don't do any of that. Just listen. And then One of my favorite questions that I ever heard from the EOC was asking the accuser, how would you like to see this resolved? Get their take on it. Where are they at? What is it that they want to actually see happen? that that's a that's a big one. b and and I don't I can't remember all the reasoning behind that. I'm sure there's some really good reasons behind that, which I knew. But I always thought that was a fascinating question to me. It was well, how would you like to see it resolved? Because once you ask them that question, they're responding, you're now understanding how they perceive it. And therefore, that might be sufficient enough that the investigation could potentially stop and you can now issue a prompt action to rectify it, or or to at least make it so it's no longer happening. So Tony Benjamin (55:30.392) Well here's Tony Benjamin (55:54.689) So two notes on that, yes. And and working in the legal field like I do, there's a lot of people there who want justice. There's no such thing as justice in these things. That's not what this is. This is making the behavior stop so that it's not a hostile work environment or not a bad environment where you work. There's no justice. Right? I can fire Grover and he has to go, but When I when I fire him, that's not justice. That's just removing him out of the situation. you know, you you're not punishing anybody. the other thing about that too is what you will find in most cases that most employees don't want the Grover fired. They don't want Grover fired. and right, right. Steven Smith (56:38.917) Yeah. He's probably a top producer. I mean his ability to run back and forth and say near far is impeccable. So that's right. Tony Benjamin (56:46.136) Yeah. Or avoid the monster at the end of the book. right. So, anyways, it it's it's it's it tak it usually takes a lot of pressure off HR departments and it helps you to say, Well Betty said she never wanted to work with him again and never would. So I had to transfer him out of the department. Okay? And now Betty can't accuse me of causing her more problems. Because, you know, gro let's go back, Grover, I can't be accused of causing Yolanda more problems because Grover now i you know it's somehow it's made him angry and that made it worse, even though nothing interacted between the two of you know, that sort of thing. That that's the sort of thing, right? So I I do think it helps in those instances. I think it also gives you an insight into their reasonability. Here's what I would say. In in terms of not promising, you do not want to say, I promise you we'll get this guy or we'll get rid of him or whatever else. You can say, however, that really sucks that you're going through this. So therefore, I'm going to fix this however this works to the best of my ability. I can't promise what that looks like, but I'm going to fix this situation so you enjoy working here again. And I don't know, we can get into the whole, you know. Steven Smith (58:08.507) Y you know what you know what's funny to me, Tony? When when we were talking about this, I went back to Tony Benjamin (58:10.027) Scorned lover thing. Steven Smith (58:15.705) to Scherm and reviewed this because especially because they were in the spotlight recently for their own workplace investigation. And so the way they describe it, they actually describe it differently than what you do in regard to the order. So they say obviously interview the complaint at first. So the one making the complaint, but then the second people they say to go see are the witnesses and then the respondent. And and I'm with you, Tony. I disagree with that. I I think Sherm misses the Tony Benjamin (58:37.986) No. Yeah, no. Yeah. Steven Smith (58:44.709) this here and and obviously in in their own court case they missed it right that this this really missed it as well and so so anyway I I'm with you I I prefer the order of talk to the complainant or the respondent first because those two may reveal all the information that you need to resolve it quickly without having to go to witnesses or or additional follow-up interviews and now it's resolved and you're everything is good to go. Tony Benjamin (58:49.582) Yeah, yeah. Tony Benjamin (58:54.477) No, I Tony Benjamin (59:10.478) Ding. Yep, yep. Steven Smith (59:13.051) Why would you involve witnesses and other people when that may not even be necessary? Tony Benjamin (59:15.84) if you don't need to, when you have all the information by talking to the two of them that you need to make a decision. Yeah, no, you're you're exactly right. In addition to that, I'm not a big fan of witch hunts. So i I'm I so it was a no, it was Harvard Business Review. So when I worked at O Vivo, I read this article by Harvard Business Review and they talked about why people don't report harassment at work and specifically women. Steven Smith (59:28.219) Right? Tony Benjamin (59:43.618) And you know what the the number one answer was they didn't want to get other people in trouble. They just wanted the behavior to stop. Okay, no, so stop and think about this. Steven Smith (59:43.772) Mm-hmm. Steven Smith (59:52.571) Okay, that's a noble thing, but yeah. Tony Benjamin (59:55.053) Right, right, right. Stupid but noble. Right, right. But but here's here's the thing about that. Why don't they want the person to get in trouble? Because they don't want it to be perceived that they have weaponized the the system. Because this is what a lot of us think, and we've all seen it, so we all know what happens. People weaponize this system. Okay, they weaponize it, and when they do that, they turn it into detrimentally harming other people. Steven Smith (01:00:03.931) Right. Tony Benjamin (01:00:22.486) And and especially women do not want to be seen as weaponizing a process. Okay? They they they just don't. And so here's the problem though. I go around, I start interviewing people, and w we j we said it a few minutes ago, no matter what, somebody that person's gonna find out you're investigating it. There's no way they're not. Even if it only takes you an hour, I promise you there's a very good chance that that person will find out what you're looking into before you do. And it before you get to them. And and I and I'll I'll tell you this, never go around and interview a bunch of people without talking to the accused person first. Just straight up don't do it. get the accusation, get the response, and then find out what additional information you need and who you need to go to to do it. And if it's just if it's you know, Yolanda and Grover having their thing and and Betty was there next to when this happened, I'm gonna go talk to Betty. after I talked to Grover. But I'm only g I'm just gonna ask her, did this happen or not? Like and I keep it to as minimum as possible. Yeah. Steven Smith (01:01:29.531) Yeah, keep it simple. And and and the thing is, is is you're not gonna really know who the witnesses are until you've talked with both the complainant and you know you're not gonna know anyway. And and you can't just go base off of the witnesses of just the complainant because the they might have handcraftedly, you know, picked, selected those particular witnesses for certain reasons. Tony Benjamin (01:01:37.454) Ding ding. Yep. Yep. Tony Benjamin (01:01:48.184) Let's let's look Tony Benjamin (01:01:52.709) Yes. No, th that's that is exactly it. And I it happens in the workplace where somebody makes up a rumor about somebody else and then they go around and they tell fifteen people because they know if you start looking into it, she told me that. So of course it's credible. She's been talking about that since the day it happened, since the moment it happened. And and they build coalitions to get rid of people. And I Steven Smith (01:01:57.039) I hate to say that, but that's but it happens. Steven Smith (01:02:14.535) Yeah. Tony Benjamin (01:02:20.842) I you can all say that never happens, it does, I think. Steven Smith (01:02:21.073) Which is why I would say, is this just what you've heard or did you actually witness this? That's the other thing. If they're gonna be a true witness, they they better have actually witnessed it and not just heard it through the work grapevine. Tony Benjamin (01:02:35.18) Right, because otherwise they're just gonna all you learn from them is Yolanda told them. Right? And and and look, I'm I'm saying this in a very stereotypical manner, but all this could be reversed. but anyways, the the point I'm I'm getting at here, if you think about this, you do not want to enable in your workforce the place where a click can get somebody else fired. Think about that. Steven Smith (01:02:39.098) Yeah, they're ju and they're just gonna mimic what Yolanda said. Tony Benjamin (01:03:00.844) You do not want a workplace where a group of friends can get another group of people fired by spreading rumors and saying bad things about them. And I promise you it happens. I promise you it happens. Yes, that's exactly the burn book. It's the burn book. Yep, it's the burn book. And and I and I just and I and I want to stress that to everybody. Now Steven Smith (01:03:11.066) Yeah. It's like that it's like that mean girls mentality and I hate or the good old boys' club mentality. I mean, both of those things are Yeah. Yep, there you go. Tony Benjamin (01:03:26.37) So then you make a decision and then we can talk later about how you deal with those things and all that. There's there's two last pieces that I kinda wanna touch on with this that that I think are important. number one is that I have a strict policy that anyone who weaponizes the harassment reporting process or the the employee relations reporting process, anyone who weaponizes it gets fired. Now in my entire career I've never fired somebody for weaponizing stuff even There's been a couple of times, but I don't want to go down that road unless I absolutely have to. But if I find out for sure that somebody is lying about something and just making it up, I will get rid of you. And you have to do that for that very reason I was talking about the Harvard Business Review research. What they did not understand is that people are sure that the system is rigged against the person who was responding. That all it takes is an accusation to get you fired. That's the assumption on employees' parts. And as a result, anybody who anybody who reports to that system, they view as weaponizing the system. But if I make a point of explaining to everybody that I will not allow the system to be weaponized, you lower barriers barriers into entry, and hopefully you get reports of behavior that take care of so you can take care of it before it becomes a hostile work environment. So that's number one. Number two. Steven Smith (01:04:28.443) Yeah. Tony Benjamin (01:04:53.123) I want to point out that in the example we gave about Grover and Yolanda, who's actually doing the harassing? This is this is important. Who in that case, I want you to sit and think about that. Grover's there, he's minding his own business. Yolanda's on the other side. She's talking about explicit things that make him uncomfortable. She knows he's there. He he will even explode or not, but the moment he says something to her about it, she should say, Okay, I'm sorry. Look, we'll tone this down or go somewhere private. Steven Smith (01:04:57.203) huh. Steven Smith (01:05:12.561) He then explodes. Yeah. Tony Benjamin (01:05:24.085) and that's and to be courteous in that, okay? But she continues to do it even after he has exploded at her. So who is harassing whom at this point? I think it's a great question to sit and ponder about because I sho I go this I show this to students in classes a lot of the time, and their first thing is they'll jump on Yolanda's side and say to Yolanda, that's terrible. Let's fire Grover. And then I say, But are you sure? Are you sure? Because Grover is you can say that Yolanda's creating a hostile work environment. And now, probably what you end up doing this is writing them both up or or getting rid of both of them. But I I think it's important to point those those things out. These things are never easy. The way you know, a matter of fact I said this the other night when I was at Rachel Child's class. I said that harassment is a very thick gray line. You're never sure when you enter the line, but you always know when you come out, 'cause someone gets fired or gets sued. poor is in big trouble, right? So i it just that's why you have to investigate. Hopefully this has given you guys a very broad outside. Is there anything else you want to add before we get out of that? Steven Smith (01:06:25.521) Yeah. Steven Smith (01:06:37.775) There is, but I think you should do do do our second read. Let's do our second read. And then I all I have is just a few comments about the actual interview questions and then we can yeah, and then we can go from there. So Tony Benjamin (01:06:47.877) Perfect. Good, good, good. Excellent. Okay. Running a business is hard. HR shouldn't be. Megastar HR is here to save you from bad HR. With expert support in everything from hiring to handbooks, compliance to culture. Need payroll help or recruiting power? We do that too. Fractionally and flexibly, no overhead, just results. Visit megastarHR dot com and let's grow your business together. Shout out to Becca. Can't wait. It's a countdown now to when she's on the show. Steven Smith (01:07:19.143) Shout out to Becca. Okay, so th this is really important to me because we need to be better at asking the questions when we're going through this, because this is where I see a lot of mistakes creep in. And the first thing you have to sit down and think to yourself is I am a fact finder, not a jury. Okay. And and the reason that's important is because every single person you talk to or interview, they're going to want to know your opinion. Tony Benjamin (01:07:40.687) Ding. Steven Smith (01:07:53.861) They always want to know your opinion. What's your opinion on this? What do you never ever offer your opinion during interviews? Ever. Again, you are a fact finder, and that's it. Stick to the facts, find the facts. And so this is why you can't ask leading questions. So so leading is where you basically tell them what. Actually happened. You've already led it. You've already literally filled in the answer to the open-ended question you should be asking. Like, walk me through what happened, what exactly was said, who else was there? Did you tell anyone at the time? Are there any text, emails, or message evidence that that you know shows that? and when you're talking to the respondent, you know, what what is your response to these allegations? Why might they have said this about you? Who else should I talk to? Right? And when when you're talking to witnesses, you know, what did you see or hear? What did the complainant tell you? Or or or and when did they tell that to you? was it much later, or you know, later on down the road? But again, never offer opinions and make sure that your questions are always open-ended and that they are not leading. I have been in too many. complaints like this where their questions are so leading. Well so and so said that you slapped her in the face and so I just need to understand why you would do that. Or I need to right that that's not that's not open ended at all. Tony Benjamin (01:09:23.335) That's like asking a man right, right. That's like asking a man when did you stop beating your wife? Right? I mean because because the assumption is you're guilty. You did it. Yeah. Steven Smith (01:09:29.137) So ridiculous, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah. So so so just that that is that is the one thing that I think from an HR professional perspective, especially if you are the one involved in the investigation, brush up on your questions that you're actually going to ask during the process. this is an example where potentially using AI can be helpful because you can say, Hey, AI, I've got to do this investigation, but I cannot ask leading questions and I cannot ask yes-no type questions. So please help me. Word them differently and l and make them open-ended. What should I ask? How should I ask this? Those are those are some good examples of of potentially using AI to kind of help facilitate that. But again, walk me through what happened, what exactly was said, who else was there? Did anyone, did you tell anyone at the time, or is this the first time, right? Are are there any trails, text messages, emails, messages, etc.? Those are important things because I I've seen too often where they lead and or it's just simple yes nos and they get nowhere. worst kind of questions you can ask, period. So so anyway, so I wanted to bring that up because those are really important elements when it comes to the investigation piece. And and unfortunately, some of us out there are not the greatest of interviewers. We're just not. And so you probably need to prepare a little bit if that's the case. Tony Benjamin (01:10:56.077) And well let me just say this. And you can to your point, Steve, if you want better advice on this, go back to episode forty nine. That's the one that we did with Derek Clark. And and go with him. Yeah. Uh-huh. And dive into that and and kind of learn. Now mostly what he's trying to tell you there is how to evaluate whether or not someone's telling you the truth or not. And I th which I think is very important. But he's gonna give you some real techniques about Yeah, yeah. And watching body language and the way people do things. Steven Smith (01:11:02.853) Yeah. Yep. The heed principle, yeah. Steven Smith (01:11:19.441) There's some good pointers in there, yeah. Yeah. Tony Benjamin (01:11:25.817) Now look, I will tell you there are a point in there where yes-no questions are appropriate. I always like to give somebody who's accused the opportunity to say, I did not do that. Did okay, I understand everything you've told me. I'm going to ask point blank at this point, did you do X? And they're going to go, nope, didn't do that. And then usually they rant for a minute, too. but I like to give everyone the opportunity to say flat out, I did or did not do that. You know you've stumbled into something then at that point when they equivocate in their answers. And lots of people, by the way, do. Lots of people equivocate in those things. And it and it's it's really sad. But yeah, no, you're right, Steve. We're gathering information and you solicit information. Now, I think it's perfectly fine then to drill down on some of that information and try to find, but you are still trying very hard not to limit the scope of what they can answer. Steven Smith (01:12:16.944) I agree. Steven Smith (01:12:23.591) Correct. And like I said, if you're leading, you're already giving them the answers. Don't do that. Don't do that. That that will be to your detriment every time. And and like I said, I love Derek's idea with his heed concept of have him explain it backwards. So before before Grover stood up and started yelling at you, what was going on right before he yelled? Okay, what were you discussing? Tony Benjamin (01:12:23.621) That's dangerous. So Tony Benjamin (01:12:29.775) Yes, yes. Yep. Steven Smith (01:12:53.499) What kind of words did you use when you were discussing it? Was this the first time Grover blew up, or was this the second time? Tell me about it before the first time. Like, like that's an example of taking the same situation and going backwards and having them really explain the the story, because again, that'll probably catch a few things that that are out of order, or or at least things that maybe didn't come out the first time when you had them just explain the story itself. And it Tony Benjamin (01:13:19.509) Exactly. And I and I think yeah, yeah, no, I th that's that's beautiful advice. I think that's really, really good advice. and and again, you're there to find out information, not plant it. And you want to find out, and you need to have if we learned anything from Sherm, you need to have a modicum of independence and making sure that you're actually doing it. Now let me tell you something. If your If you have a manager that has just put a subordinate on on a pip, those stupid pips, and then the subordinate comes to you and says, the manager is d discriminating against me or is retaliating against me for X, yes, you must look into it. Okay. Just now you could do some cursory stuff to look into it really quick first to see if there's any there there or look for smoke. Steven Smith (01:14:14.929) Yeah. Tony Benjamin (01:14:15.363) But you still have to now of course the one of my f one of my longest running investigations I'd ever done was somebody who had acc she was saying that somebody had done something to her a year before. He had asked her to lift his shirt he had asked her to lift her shirt for him when they were together alone. And in the nine or ten months since that time she had told everybody in the warehouse about it, except the poor guy that she was accusing, had no idea she had told everybody about it. And you know when she reported it? When she got a not great performance review. Okay? Because she was convinced. Yeah, nearly a year later, right. So, anyways, the the point and you can obvious you can say, Well, blow her off because she's obviously only doing this because she got a bad whatever. Well, that may be the case. It might also be the case that he really did it though, right? Steven Smith (01:14:48.633) 'Cause and that was what, a year later? Steven Smith (01:15:05.957) Yes. Steven Smith (01:15:10.245) Yeah. Well and and he may have asked multiple times. Like there could have been other times, right? So yeah, that would warrant an investigation in my mind, for sure. Tony Benjamin (01:15:13.689) Yes, yes. Tony Benjamin (01:15:19.341) Yeah, yeah, but but here even though yes, she look, there's no way around it. She reported it because she got a bad performance review. But that doesn't necessarily mean it's not true. So, anyways, and in in that case, th my guess is th in in the long run of that stuff, there was some truth to what she was saying and not others. but her performance was really bad. So Steven Smith (01:15:29.255) Correct. Steven Smith (01:15:43.621) Okay, so so my final question on this, and the this that we can end here. Where does AI fit in investigations today? Because obviously people are gonna start using AI and to you know record and and you know brainstorm or investigate or what have you. And I've got some really good insights into this because I've been researching this for quite some time now with with a lot of the AI stuff that I do. Tony Benjamin (01:15:46.629) Uh-huh. Yep. Tony Benjamin (01:16:10.009) Then go ahead, give us your answers, Steve, because I'm curious. Steven Smith (01:16:11.771) But but here's the answer to that question where AI fits. You you cannot let AI decide how credible the findings are or decide what the discipline is. You can't let it just simply make that decision. At the end of the day, the individual investigator is the one who has to make the decision, right? Those involved in the actual investigation process, they're the ones that have to decide. So you can't let AI judge. Yeah. Tony Benjamin (01:16:24.453) Mm-hmm. Tony Benjamin (01:16:37.753) Because AI will always make the dis right AI will always make the decision that it thinks you want it to make. Steven Smith (01:16:44.205) Exactly. Especially if it knows you well enough and you've used it enough that that it it knows what you want to hear type thing. So that that better be th that's just something to be aware of. Another thing is you be you better not use an AI tool that's that's public facing, where you haven't made things, you know, private. You know, use a tool that is a paid tool that is not public and free. that's going to be really critical because you don't want that type of information being available to the non-pub or to the public, right? That it this should be an investigation that is internal and therefore should be recorded on those those areas that can be proven that it won't be read by other people. Now here's an important thing to understand from a cyber cybersecurity perspective. I talked with Kate Marshall about this. Sometimes with AI models, the IT team can still see it all. They can see, they can actually look into and read all these investigations. So that's another thing to be aware of. How truly private is your AI tool and who actually has access to it? Yeah, yeah. Who actually has access to it? This is a big deal. So that's the other thing. If you're going to choose to use an AI tool, you better make sure that the people that have access to the data are not the wrong people. Tony Benjamin (01:17:47.257) This is the Alexa thing. Yes, this is what happened with Alexa. Steven Smith (01:18:06.961) people, right? They have to be the right people in essence. Very, very important. And and another thing is is the accuracy risk for the transcript. What I've seen sometimes with AI is AI doesn't know how to transcript certain phrases like uh-huh. you know, like like things like that where the transcript doesn't always tr transcribe. Yeah, yeah. Prime example, we transcribe all of our podcast episodes, just so you know. And I'll tell you, I have to look at it when AI pulls it because when it pulls the transcript, some of those just little things, the filler, I call them fillers, some of those fillers are detrimental. They're they are not Tony Benjamin (01:18:27.311) Just look at our transcripts here. Yeah. Steven Smith (01:18:47.623) They're they're not helpful in the episode and sometimes it confuses in between sentences and AI gets it wrong. And so can you imagine that being part of like this accuracy risk, if you will, as part of the transcript of the recording of the interview and and and the accusation itself? So very, very important that if if you're gonna consider using AI. Make sure the appropriate guardrails are in place. Make sure the appropriate tool is actually being used. And then make sure that if you're going to use the tool to summarize or anything, that it is checked and double checked and triple checked. To make sure that it's not making the decision for you. I I cannot emphasize that enough because we're starting to see states like California, Colorado, New York City, they now have regulations for AI decisions, especially employment practice. and I can totally see this happening with investigations. And I I get it, right? Recording the interviews is so much easier, so I don't have to take notes. It makes it simpler so I can refer to it later, and I make sure I don't miss something. I I get that. The the need for that is absolutely great. Just be a be aware of the things that I mentioned. Tony Benjamin (01:20:03.427) No, that's exactly right. And and as a conclusion I'll say this. So today I was looking into granola, which is a famous transcribing note taking thing, and I've decided to experiment a little with it. I started to dive into granola to find out if granola was safe and I could put client information or have it, you know, do the things for meetings for client information. And it says, yes, we encrypt everything we do. We keep it on a server. No one has access to it but you. They said, but our our partners who work with us to write plugins or attach to us have the ability to to have computers look at transcripts so that they understand the diction and stuff like that. Number one. And number two, we warn you do not put any personal health information on do not mention any personal health information. You know what that and and by the way, that's the same restrictions. Ding. Yes. Yep. Yep. Yeah, yeah. Steven Smith (01:20:55.431) They're already telling you that no, we don't. That that's the answer. It's not safe in that sense. Yeah. Tony Benjamin (01:21:04.554) And so and so I do granola for things that I don't have to worry about getting out near the public. Sometimes Steve and I will have to tell everyone if we haven't already told the story about AI thinking that I never make a mistake. it's an awesome we'll have to do that sometime. We'll tell that story. Mm-hmm. Yes. I don't I that's not hallucination. Dang it, that's right. Okay. Steven Smith (01:21:16.857) Right? Prime example. It totally hallucinates now. Steven Smith (01:21:27.131) That is absolute hallucination. And I've had to tell it multiple times. Tony Benjamin (01:21:32.224) That's right. But we'll tell that story sometime. That's a hilarious story. Okay, here we go. now we're going into the the segment on the HR in life. Tony Benjamin (01:21:58.668) All right, all right, all right, all right, here we go. Steve hit us with it. Steven Smith (01:22:02.159) Okay, so so so this was a common one I would get at Applicant Pro. And I noticed a post this week, I think it was on Reddit, or maybe it was Facebook, but they were asking about employee assessments, employment assessments, right? So you apply for the job, you get a call back from the organization. The organization says, in order for us to continue further, we need you to take this assessment. And so they send you a link, and then now you're prompted to go ahead and take this assessment. Obviously in the back of your mind, you know that passing this assessment is really important because if you don't pass, you can now become part of the rejection list instead of the acceptance list. And you may not even be called in for the interview at that stage. So so this can be Nerve-wracking for candidates, right? Job seekers, when they see this, because they're like, they get nervous, they they get worried about, well, do I need an answer a certain way? How do I prepare for it? How do I, you know, what do I do? How how do I approach this? How do I take care of this assessment to ensure that I move on to the next thing? So so Tony, I want your take on this before I delve into this, but but I'm just curious what your response would be to somebody asking about. Assessment advice because it happened a lot when I was an Appan Pro. We had lots of assessments our clients would use, all kinds of varieties of assessments, some integrated, some not. But inevitably you get the link, you see it, you know the assessment's going to take 15 to 45 minutes or more. it's important. This is an important part of the process. And if you don't pass, you don't get through. So what do I do? Tony Benjamin (01:23:43.605) I'm not a I'm not a big fan of assessments until you're into the interview process and until you've already been screened and all that sort of stuff by AI and everything else. I'm not a fan until then. The answer at that point is do your best and see how it goes. But be honest, be straightforward, do your best. don't cheat. And look All cheating does on stuff like that is is qualify you for something that you're probably not qualified for. Meaning if you can't do it yourself and you have to resort to cheating, you shouldn't have that job because you're not qualified to do the job. But yeah, that but I don't really I don't love assessments. I love personality assessments and those sorts of things and strength finders and all that after you make an offer to somebody so it gives you insight into how to best manage them, but not not before. Steven Smith (01:24:31.323) Yeah. Yeah, not the pre employment assessment. And what I'm referring to specifically are the pre employment assessments. There's a lot of pre employment assessments out there. Some are good, some not so good. Some have been validated, some have not been validated, right? They should be validated. That should be required everywhere. There's only certain states that require it, but but but I'm with you on this, Tony. I don't think an assessment really should enter the picture until you've actually met with the the candidates and at least narrowed down your pool. Tony Benjamin (01:24:34.861) Yeah. Tony Benjamin (01:24:45.134) Yeah, yeah. Steven Smith (01:25:00.143) Right. You shouldn't be giving everybody an assessment just just to give them an assessment. You should have already interviewed and and gone through a a part of your process to the point now that we've got three of our top candidates and now an assessment might help. facilitate in in the decision making process. And so let's go ahead and do the assessment. Even then I think an assessment should be objective, should test for skills and things like that. And if you're gonna benchmark it, because a lot of people like to benchmark assessments, you better make sure that the benchmarks are appropriate. And not bias and all that. That's why the validation studies are so important. So if you're if you use some type of assessment tool, ask your assessment provider: has this been validated? Has it gone through a validated study to you know eliminate bias and discrimination and things like that? Because they by law they should they should be able to provide that stuff to you, even if you have a have to sign an NDA. But in our in my world, when we were applicant with applicant tracking, we always had to provide the bias. Tony Benjamin (01:25:36.802) Yeah, yeah. Steven Smith (01:26:01.755) Like the actual assessments, l are not the assessments, the validation studies. And that was just we had to provide it. you didn't even have to sign anything. We just are we are obligated to provide it if you're gonna use that as a service. And so Tony Benjamin (01:26:08.323) Mm-hmm. Tony Benjamin (01:26:13.462) And if you don't, you turn into work day. So yeah. Steven Smith (01:26:16.547) That's exactly correct. So so my my advice though for the candidate, because you know it's usually the job seeker, the applicant that's asking this question. First of all, you shouldn't ever feel nervous or or and it and it shouldn't you shouldn't feel like you have to game the system. Because here's what most of these assessments do. Most of these assessments are designed to catch liars. And what that means is when they're looking at the answers and it's looking at how you respond to certain things, you'll notice in most assessments, some of the questions are exactly the same. They're just written differently. Because what it's trying to measure is if you're going to answer this question a certain way, then this other question should be very similar, the way you respond to it. And so it's measuring whether or not you're just trying to game the system or lie. And most assessments, if not all of them, have some type of mechanism in place to catch liars or catch somebody who's attempting to try to game the system, which makes you even worse off because now you can't even qualify for another position in the organization at all. Like Tony had mentioned, maybe you qualify for something else. Nope. It'll eliminate you entirely and you'll never see a job at that organization because you tried to game it, period. Tony Benjamin (01:27:27.534) The the other piece of that too is that a lot of those tests aren't and they're the skill ones are different, but a lot of those tests aren't necessarily designed to find out you know how fast I can put a bolt in a hole or something. Many of them are designed to look for personality traits. And all you're doing right, right, and you have no you have no idea what the employer is actually looking for. Steven Smith (01:27:48.128) Mm. And some of your cognitive abilities. Yeah. Tony Benjamin (01:27:57.025) They may not want certain types of personalities. They may want personalities in their program that you would not that you would think was stupid to have in your organization, but that's all they'd look for. and and just by gaming it, just let it do its thing. Now, now I yeah. We're talking about making your house payment. I understand that. I get it. Steven Smith (01:28:09.819) Yeah. That's why you should never try to game it or think that you should answer a certain way. Yep. Be honest with yourself. Yeah. Tony Benjamin (01:28:23.714) But yeah, you're you're exactly right. And don't use AI to fiddle with that stuff. Steven Smith (01:28:29.211) Yeah. And and at the end of the day, if you're not honest with yourself, you're gonna get a job that you are going to be miserable in. You will be miserable because you you decided to answer a certain way to try to get in and show them that you're somebody that you're absolutely not. And that all that's gonna do is make you miserable. So so that that would be my recommendation to this when it comes to to to job application assessments and things like that. Don't put yourself in the misery. Just just be honest, be yourself, answer what absolutely what you think, 100%. Usually what you think first is the right answer. And just get through it. If they don't hire you, then obviously there was something there that didn't match and you just need to move on. Again, I know sometimes we're desperate, like Tony said. We gotta get work. We've been out of work for months and months and months, sometimes years in some cases now. But but yeah, it's not worth it. It's not worth it. Tony Benjamin (01:29:23.672) Yeah. No, no, I agree. I and there's ways to cheat and get around all that sort of stuff nowadays. There's people out there who will interview for you and all that. Just lug don't please don't go there. we should do a whole episode on the arms race between applicant tracking systems and applicants. Like we should do do some big stuff on that on that arms race. Yeah, 'cause Steven Smith (01:29:45.777) That would be a fun one. That'd be a fun one. Tony Benjamin (01:29:48.741) I'll I'll be honest, my son called me a few nights ago and he's like, Dad, help me with my resume. And I was like, okay, I can help with your resume. But I said, look, the truth of the matter is, I don't know right now the best way to find a job because I don't think anybody does. 70% of 70% of companies out there are doing it the old way, and that's perfectly fine. For those companies, the old methods that I'm very good at work really well. Steven Smith (01:30:02.969) No, yeah. Tony Benjamin (01:30:13.614) But especially his age, most of the companies applying for in that they're not doing it that way. And I don't know what the best way I I'm coming to quickly to the conclusion the best way to find a job is networking. It's and you can't do that all at once. It takes a long time but it pays off. Yes. And Steven Smith (01:30:26.139) Yeah. It still it still works. It still works. It it'll always work. Yeah, it'll always work. And you know, even for s yeah, and I'm assuming your son is in the boat that a lot of people are that that I would consider entry level type jobs. And maybe your son's already graduated college and that's no longer the case, but for a lot of these entry level applicants The reality is this first come, first serve in a lot of those industries. If you were the first applicant within the first 24 hours, chances are you might get the interview and get the job. And they'll never interview the 500 other applicants that applied because they're going to make the decision with the first 50 applicants and then go on to the next 50, go on to the next 50. That's how a lot of these companies do it now because they just don't have the capacity to literally sift through that many applications. And so Tony Benjamin (01:31:16.3) If you're not part of the my my rollout is somewhere around sixty five. If you're not in the top sixty five, then yeah. Steven Smith (01:31:21.115) Yeah. Yeah. So so what I would recommend is is you know you have the ability and indeed and some of these job words, set the alert in motion so that you get alerted as soon as a new job posts that that is is associated with a keyword or phrase or something that's applicable to you and be one of the first ones to ever apply. But that is going to get you quicker in the door if if that's the game you want to play and you decide not to do the networking game. Tony Benjamin (01:31:46.595) Right. But let's let's talk about that sometimes. That's a good that's a good overall subject. We probably ought to get some people on. and I 'cause it's either gonna be all networking or it's gonna be your bot talking to my bot and they're negotiating out whether or not I'm a good fit and whether or not their bot wants to talk to me and my bot determining whether or not it's going to allow them to talk to me because it might be a job I'm interested in. Steven Smith (01:32:01.372) Mm-hmm. Steven Smith (01:32:11.335) Wow, you were going all into the bot thing right away, huh? Tony Benjamin (01:32:15.07) I'm I'm I'm I'm very convinced there's a very good chance that's where it ends up. The way to get a Yeah, yeah. Yeah, but the way to get around that the way to get around that is networking. So yep, yep. All right. I think we've done a pretty good job on investigations today. Talked a little bit about some frustrating stuff. Yeah. Steven Smith (01:32:19.121) The future is bots talking to bots. Steven Smith (01:32:26.373) Networking. Yep. Steven Smith (01:32:33.465) Lots of intense stuff. Which I'm kind of excited because tomorrow I'm speaking at the Payson Chamber of Commerce. We're doing the Garage to Great series. It's it's like a it it's kind of funny they call it that because Applicant Pro when Ryan and I started it, know, it it it was basically like we were in a garage. It was a little, you know, room on on not even a room, it was like this b old Tony Benjamin (01:32:41.795) yeah, yeah. Steven Smith (01:32:54.119) dilapidated building on Lehigh Main Street. But Taleo used to make fun of us that, yeah, those guys are from a garage, right? And so this garage to great is i it's just a fun name because I it resonates with me really well. So Tony Benjamin (01:33:04.952) How does that feel to get your butt kicked to Layo by a garage company? Yeah, yeah. Steven Smith (01:33:09.113) I know, right? Because they used to make fun of us all the time. I you know, I'm ex I'm excited about it because I get to talk to a lot of business owners and I know investigations are probably something that they c run into sometimes. and so, you know, share this episode with your friends. If you have somebody that needs help about investigations, there's probably things that have resonated for you. But share it with your friends, especially your small business owner people that you know where they may not have the HR department to do this kind of stuff and and they've may not even have the experience or the capabilities. and so so please share. That this is this is exactly why Tony and I are starting to do some of these types of episodes to really give organizations something that they can, you know, l rely on a little bit and then use for future reference. So Tony Benjamin (01:33:58.541) Yep, exactly. And hey, you know, send us send us some ideas about stuff you want to talk about. Or some reactions. Look, I I some of the stuff I said on this podcast is not the typical answer. So I'm fine if you disagree. Get on and tell us why. Steven Smith (01:34:02.949) Yeah, some subjects. Are there are there things that you want to talk about? Steven Smith (01:34:12.241) Yeah. Yeah, if you guys throw it into AI, I'm sure you guys will probably get some interesting answers. But like I said, if you throw it in if you throw it in Sherm and you c look up Sherm's order of the investigation, I just don't agree with it. I don't think the second person you interview are the actual witnesses. Because I don't think you know all the witnesses up to that point. Tony Benjamin (01:34:18.372) That's right. Tony Benjamin (01:34:25.421) Right, right. Tony Benjamin (01:34:29.186) Yep, no. No, I agree. I agree. Hey, and if you put it into AI you may find out that I never make mistakes. So just saying. Steven Smith (01:34:37.531) Ha ha. Which would make Tony's day. If you could maybe get a screenshot of that and send that to him, I think that would be really important to him. Tony Benjamin (01:34:47.18) I've got some screenshots of that answer already, so it's really funny. Anyways, we'll tell that story sometime. Steven Smith (01:34:51.867) Wow. He literally has them framed on his wall behind him. That now I get it. Now I get it. Tony Benjamin (01:34:55.66) Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Never made a mistake. Once thought I did. Yep. All right. Well, thanks everybody. We really appreciate you joining with us. And again, thanks for sharing the podcast with everybody. We're really appreciative of that. And we're we're we're grateful for for everything that you do in sharing the podcast, letting people know. we're gonna do our charity read next. When a child faces a serious illness, the entire family feels the impact. Thrive Life Project steps in to lighten the load, delivering nutritious meals and engaging STEM kits directly to families' homes, completely free of charge. It's more than support, it's a community of care. Learn more at ThriveLife Project. dot org. That's ThriveLifeproject.org. Shout out to Brock and the wonderful things that he's doing there. We're very appreciative. I got to see online some of his handiwork today. It was really cool. So there you go. Steven Smith (01:35:52.204) So cool. I love Brock. I love Brock. Tony Benjamin (01:35:54.22) Me too. Great guy, great guy. Okay, everybody. Well, I guess that we'll go out the same way we came in. Thank you for listening to today's podcast. Don't forget to subscribe and leave a five star review on your favorite podcast app. Comments or questions for us? Email the podcast at the HRlife Podcast at gmail.com and we'll talk again soon.