1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:03,931
Aman: Zubin, picture this.
When Maya was nine,

2
00:00:03,932 --> 00:00:08,748
her best friend was a
cocker spaniel called Roxy,

3
00:00:08,749 --> 00:00:15,433
and her dad called her Peanut.
Twenty-five years later, Roxy's back.

4
00:00:15,434 --> 00:00:21,528
Not on four legs, unfortunately.
In Maya's phone, as her Muse:

5
00:00:21,529 --> 00:00:27,623
a cartoon spaniel who books her
flights, orders her groceries,

6
00:00:27,624 --> 00:00:29,689
and calls her Peanut.

7
00:00:30,000 --> 00:00:33,569
Seven minutes past three, Austin, Texas.

8
00:00:33,570 --> 00:00:39,905
Maya's asleep. Roxy isn't. Maya's
flight has moved, so Roxy rebooks it,

9
00:00:39,906 --> 00:00:44,188
finds a hotel and nudges
her: "Book it, Peanut?"

10
00:00:44,189 --> 00:00:48,739
Half asleep, Maya taps yes.
$1,200. Non-refundable.

11
00:00:48,740 --> 00:00:52,755
Wrong night. Now, Zubin,
Maya is a composite.

12
00:00:52,756 --> 00:00:58,109
The sentence that decides who
pays, and who doesn't, is not.

13
00:00:58,110 --> 00:01:03,999
Meta wrote it, it's eleven words
long, and it sits on a help page.

14
00:01:04,000 --> 00:01:10,309
Zubin: So who pays? And why
does every bot suddenly want to

15
00:01:10,310 --> 00:01:14,800
be your friend? That's today, on A2Z.

16
00:01:22,000 --> 00:01:26,999
Aman: Welcome back to A2Z Fintech.
I'm Aman Narain, here in Singapore.

17
00:01:27,000 --> 00:01:30,332
Zubin: And I'm the Z, Zubin
Vandrevala, in San Francisco,

18
00:01:30,333 --> 00:01:34,999
where my AI agents have bought nothing,
because I have read the terms.

19
00:01:35,000 --> 00:01:37,999
Aman: He reads the terms. That's
why nobody invites him to parties.

20
00:01:38,000 --> 00:01:40,254
Zubin: I get invited. I get my fair share.

21
00:01:40,255 --> 00:01:45,345
I just read the invitation properly,
which kind of takes us to disclaimer time.

22
00:01:45,346 --> 00:01:50,178
Let's jump in. This podcast is for
informational and entertainment purposes

23
00:01:50,179 --> 00:01:54,238
only. It's two dudes riffing.
These views are strictly our own,

24
00:01:54,239 --> 00:01:59,264
not those of our employers, and they are
definitely not financial, investment,

25
00:01:59,265 --> 00:02:04,097
legal or tax advice. Please, please,
please consult licensed professionals,

26
00:02:04,098 --> 00:02:07,254
and definitely read the
terms, because somewhere,

27
00:02:07,255 --> 00:02:11,894
someone is still paying for a gym
membership they signed up for in 2019.

28
00:02:11,895 --> 00:02:14,214
Don't let that bot join one for you.

29
00:02:14,215 --> 00:02:16,469
All right, one ask before we start.

30
00:02:16,470 --> 00:02:21,173
If a bot has ever done something in
your name that you didn't quite mean,

31
00:02:21,174 --> 00:02:24,073
tell us in the comments.
Aman's is coming up.

32
00:02:24,074 --> 00:02:27,810
Let's set the board. Seven weeks,
four bots, and for each,

33
00:02:27,811 --> 00:02:31,999
the only question this show cares
about: can it spend your money?

34
00:02:32,000 --> 00:02:34,755
Aman: So let's start
with the big one, Zubin.

35
00:02:34,756 --> 00:02:39,490
Meta's Muse, launched on the 8th
of September, United States first.

36
00:02:39,491 --> 00:02:44,154
It lives where you already are:
its own app, the web and WhatsApp,

37
00:02:44,155 --> 00:02:47,547
which has more than two
billion people using it.

38
00:02:47,548 --> 00:02:51,999
That's the bet. Not the cleverest
model, but the shortest walk.

39
00:02:52,000 --> 00:02:57,513
Zubin: And, Aman, it has a face: a plush,
rosy-cheeked creature Meta calls Jolly.

40
00:02:57,514 --> 00:03:00,493
Rename it, restyle it, make it your own.

41
00:03:00,494 --> 00:03:04,889
And by December, Meta says,
you can carry it on a keychain,

42
00:03:04,890 --> 00:03:07,050
in a gadget called the Charm.

43
00:03:07,051 --> 00:03:10,999
I have a feeling our daughters
are going to want one.

44
00:03:11,000 --> 00:03:13,999
Aman: Well, it's a Tamagotchi

45
00:03:14,000 --> 00:03:18,845
from our youth. Except the nineties
one died if you ignored it.

46
00:03:18,846 --> 00:03:22,999
Ignore this one, Zubin,
and it carries on without you.

47
00:03:23,000 --> 00:03:28,681
Zubin: Which, Aman, is this
whole episode in one sentence.

48
00:03:28,682 --> 00:03:31,022
Let's roll that clip.

49
00:04:06,000 --> 00:04:09,999
Aman: Zubin, it called him
boss. Roxy says Peanut.

50
00:04:10,000 --> 00:04:14,849
Muse says boss. One makes you feel loved,
the other makes you feel in charge.

51
00:04:14,850 --> 00:04:17,999
The contract, as we'll see,
just calls you liable.

52
00:04:18,000 --> 00:04:22,976
Zubin: To be fair to Meta, the engineering
is more careful than the reputation.

53
00:04:22,977 --> 00:04:26,087
Beside Muse sits a second
AI called Sentinel,

54
00:04:26,088 --> 00:04:31,133
and one review says nothing reaches
the internet until Sentinel approves.

55
00:04:31,134 --> 00:04:32,999
And it asks before it buys.

56
00:04:33,000 --> 00:04:35,806
Aman: Yeah. A creature with a chaperone.

57
00:04:35,807 --> 00:04:40,017
Can it spend? Yes, from
day one. One bot, one face.

58
00:04:40,018 --> 00:04:41,999
Is that where this ends?

59
00:04:42,000 --> 00:04:44,582
Zubin: Not if Musk has his way, right?

60
00:04:44,583 --> 00:04:45,999
Which is bot two.

61
00:04:46,000 --> 00:04:49,480
And it isn't one bot.
It's almost a staff room.

62
00:04:49,481 --> 00:04:54,962
Musk's Grok Bot, in beta since August,
gives you as many bots as you want,

63
00:04:54,963 --> 00:05:00,888
one for each job: a researcher, a sales
bot, a chief of staff to run the others.

64
00:05:00,889 --> 00:05:03,999
Reportedly, you can name each one of them.

65
00:05:04,000 --> 00:05:09,999
Aman: So Meta gives you a pet,
and Musk gives you a payroll.

66
00:05:10,000 --> 00:05:13,717
Zubin: A payroll where nobody
asks for a raise, right?

67
00:05:13,718 --> 00:05:19,016
And one newsletter team says theirs
saved them a day of setup work.

68
00:05:19,017 --> 00:05:23,999
Can it spend? Yes. Stripe names
it. It buys what the job needs.

69
00:05:24,000 --> 00:05:26,262
Aman: And it isn't just Musk's customers.

70
00:05:26,263 --> 00:05:30,011
A friend of mine, and I just
had lunch with him yesterday,

71
00:05:30,012 --> 00:05:33,955
is a product manager at a US
fintech, based out of Singapore.

72
00:05:33,956 --> 00:05:38,932
And he runs an army. Not the kind you'd
think of: the one that involves bots.

73
00:05:38,933 --> 00:05:43,393
He's got one bot that books his travel,
one that bills his customers,

74
00:05:43,394 --> 00:05:48,047
one that fetches industry news. And,
as you said, it's not just one bot.

75
00:05:48,048 --> 00:05:53,090
The travel bot, for example, has sub-bots
of its own, specialising in flights,

76
00:05:53,091 --> 00:05:55,999
hotels and the itinerary.
It's quite amazing.

77
00:05:56,000 --> 00:06:00,695
Zubin: It is, it is. An army
with a travel department, right?

78
00:06:00,696 --> 00:06:01,999
For years we've

79
00:06:02,000 --> 00:06:06,999
been promised a personal assistant. What
arrives is a chief of staff, and it hires.

80
00:06:07,000 --> 00:06:11,763
Aman: Yeah, and it's for everybody.
It's not just for CEOs,

81
00:06:11,764 --> 00:06:14,999
and you can do this from your chair.

82
00:06:15,000 --> 00:06:18,999
Zubin: Every sub-bot that can book is
another pair of hands on your card.

83
00:06:19,000 --> 00:06:21,405
Aman: Yeah. And remember that staff room.

84
00:06:21,406 --> 00:06:26,424
We'll come back to it later. So,
bot three, Zubin, had the biggest stage,

85
00:06:26,425 --> 00:06:29,999
the one you got most excited
about: OpenAI's DevDay.

86
00:06:30,000 --> 00:06:36,463
We covered that last year. The 29th of
September, more than 20 announcements,

87
00:06:36,464 --> 00:06:40,576
to what OpenAI says are
1.2 billion weekly users.

88
00:06:40,577 --> 00:06:46,535
And the headline act was dots:
always-on agents you message in ChatGPT,

89
00:06:46,536 --> 00:06:52,999
Slack or Teams. OpenAI already talks of
teams of them working on your behalf.

90
00:06:53,000 --> 00:06:55,236
Zubin: And, Aman,
a quick plug here, right?

91
00:06:55,237 --> 00:06:58,468
A year ago, we talked about
OpenAI and their DevDay,

92
00:06:58,469 --> 00:07:01,762
and the amount of development
on that day was insane.

93
00:07:01,763 --> 00:07:06,920
I'd love for anyone who wants to see how
fast this industry has grown to go back to

94
00:07:06,921 --> 00:07:12,078
that episode. It gives you a snapshot of
what 12 months can change in the AI space.

95
00:07:12,079 --> 00:07:17,112
But coming back to your point, yes, they
did release a bot, and they're adorable,

96
00:07:17,113 --> 00:07:20,592
right? Fast Company met one
called Todd, a smiling frog.

97
00:07:20,593 --> 00:07:23,824
A week after the industry
asked itself to slow down,

98
00:07:23,825 --> 00:07:25,999
OpenAI gave you a frog called Todd.

99
00:07:26,000 --> 00:07:29,311
Aman: I wonder how much this
has to do with the fact that

100
00:07:29,312 --> 00:07:30,999
Sam Altman just had a kid.

101
00:07:31,000 --> 00:07:32,911
Zubin: Maybe, maybe.

102
00:07:34,000 --> 00:07:36,999
Aman: But, question for
you: can dots spend?

103
00:07:37,000 --> 00:07:39,786
Zubin: Maybe, to answer your first
question: did you slow down, Aman,

104
00:07:39,787 --> 00:07:40,999
once you had a kid? Or two?

105
00:07:41,000 --> 00:07:42,933
Aman: It's all relative.

106
00:07:42,934 --> 00:07:46,157
My at-pace version is probably

107
00:07:46,158 --> 00:07:50,133
Sam Altman's first hour of the week.

108
00:07:53,000 --> 00:07:56,175
Zubin: All right. To answer
your question, can Todd spend?

109
00:07:56,176 --> 00:07:58,916
Not really, and I think
that's the surprise.

110
00:07:58,917 --> 00:08:02,092
Dots are sold for work.
By one detailed comparison,

111
00:08:02,093 --> 00:08:05,082
they can't check out on
a shopping site unaided.

112
00:08:05,083 --> 00:08:07,573
And this is where "Sign in with ChatGPT"

113
00:08:07,574 --> 00:08:10,999
carries your identity and
your allowance. Not your card.

114
00:08:11,000 --> 00:08:15,447
Aman: So the bot with the biggest
audience is the one that can't shop.

115
00:08:15,448 --> 00:08:20,312
Yet. And we talked about OpenAI's
challenges with shopping in the last

116
00:08:20,313 --> 00:08:24,760
episode. Which kind of tells you
where each thinks the money is.

117
00:08:24,761 --> 00:08:28,999
OpenAI thinks it's at work.
Meta seems to think it's at home.

118
00:08:29,000 --> 00:08:33,330
Zubin: And, Aman, there's that fourth one
we wanted to call out in this episode,

119
00:08:33,331 --> 00:08:35,999
and it thinks it lives
in your text messages.

120
00:08:36,000 --> 00:08:39,909
Aman: Yeah. Bot four, and I should
declare an interest: Instinct.

121
00:08:39,910 --> 00:08:42,957
I just started using it.
No app, no interface.

122
00:08:42,958 --> 00:08:45,674
You text it, or you ring it. Invite-only.

123
00:08:45,675 --> 00:08:46,999
Just passed you one.

124
00:08:47,000 --> 00:08:48,911
Zubin: That's right.

125
00:08:49,000 --> 00:08:51,931
Aman: About 100,000 users,
free. I'm one of them.

126
00:08:51,932 --> 00:08:56,635
Actually, if anybody wants an invite,
I'm happy to send you a couple.

127
00:08:56,636 --> 00:08:57,999
I've got a few left.

128
00:08:58,000 --> 00:09:01,499
Zubin: Of course you are. And yes,
since you sent me the invite last week,

129
00:09:01,500 --> 00:09:04,999
as we were researching this episode,
I've started using it as well.

130
00:09:05,000 --> 00:09:06,999
Aman: And it's mostly awesome.

131
00:09:07,000 --> 00:09:09,999
Zubin: "Mostly" is doing some work there.

132
00:09:10,000 --> 00:09:13,999
Aman: Yeah, I agree. So let's hold
that thought and come back to it.

133
00:09:14,000 --> 00:09:15,924
Zubin: Yeah, and let's put
some facts on the table, right?

134
00:09:15,925 --> 00:09:17,999
It raised a billion dollars
at a ten billion valuation.

135
00:09:18,000 --> 00:09:23,789
That's a hundred thousand dollars for
each user, Aman included, me included,

136
00:09:23,790 --> 00:09:25,999
which kind of feels generous.

137
00:09:26,000 --> 00:09:30,999
Aman: Yeah, I could do with
some of that cash right now.

138
00:09:31,000 --> 00:09:35,226
But, you know, it's priced on
what we do, not how many we are.

139
00:09:35,227 --> 00:09:39,931
It books flights and tables, orders
groceries, cancels subscriptions,

140
00:09:39,932 --> 00:09:42,522
which have probably saved me $100,000.

141
00:09:42,523 --> 00:09:47,294
The founder reportedly plans to take
a cut of transactions, not a fee.

142
00:09:47,295 --> 00:09:51,113
That's interesting. It's not
really a software business.

143
00:09:51,114 --> 00:09:54,999
That's a payments business
with a personality, I suppose.

144
00:09:55,000 --> 00:09:57,999
Zubin: Yeah. So,
three yeses and a not yet.

145
00:09:58,000 --> 00:09:59,949
Aman: OK, so now the fine print,

146
00:09:59,950 --> 00:10:05,049
and back to the original story of
Maya and Roxy and the $1,200 room.

147
00:10:05,050 --> 00:10:06,999
Zubin, you read the terms.

148
00:10:07,000 --> 00:10:10,999
Zubin: So nobody else has to.
So let's start with Muse, since Roxy

149
00:10:11,000 --> 00:10:13,335
is one. Meta's own help page says,

150
00:10:13,336 --> 00:10:18,350
"You're responsible for all transactions
your Muse makes on your behalf."

151
00:10:18,351 --> 00:10:19,999
Eleven words. No lawyer.

152
00:10:20,000 --> 00:10:22,999
Aman: Yeah, and Maya clearly
didn't read that, and tapped yes.

153
00:10:23,000 --> 00:10:25,097
Zubin: Well, half asleep, but she did.

154
00:10:25,098 --> 00:10:29,225
Now Instinct, since you're a
customer, goes a little further.

155
00:10:29,226 --> 00:10:34,097
Section three: you appoint it as your
agent to enter into agreements and

156
00:10:34,098 --> 00:10:37,480
transactions on your behalf.
And those are, quote,

157
00:10:37,481 --> 00:10:40,999
"binding on you as if entered
into directly by you."

158
00:10:41,000 --> 00:10:44,999
Aman: Yeah. So I've essentially
signed a power of attorney to my bot.

159
00:10:45,000 --> 00:10:48,239
Zubin: That's right, by tapping
a button that says "Send code".

160
00:10:48,240 --> 00:10:52,404
The terms also reportedly say Instinct
is not a party to any purchase or

161
00:10:52,405 --> 00:10:57,148
transaction, and cap its liability at the
greater of a hundred dollars or whatever

162
00:10:57,149 --> 00:10:58,999
you paid in the last six months.

163
00:10:59,000 --> 00:10:59,999
Aman: And I pay nothing.

164
00:11:00,000 --> 00:11:04,999
Zubin: That's true. So you're covered
to the value of maybe a nice lunch.

165
00:11:05,000 --> 00:11:06,999
Aman: Yeah. In Singapore,

166
00:11:07,000 --> 00:11:08,999
a modest one.

167
00:11:09,000 --> 00:11:11,029
Zubin: Probably in San Francisco as well.

168
00:11:11,030 --> 00:11:12,999
And now, "mostly awesome". Go on.

169
00:11:13,000 --> 00:11:18,057
Aman: OK. I had an important meeting with
a GP the other day, at a venture fund,

170
00:11:18,058 --> 00:11:21,953
just to name-drop. In my head,
Instinct had confirmed it.

171
00:11:21,954 --> 00:11:24,619
It hadn't, and I very nearly missed it.

172
00:11:24,620 --> 00:11:28,721
And here's what struck me.
Nothing went wrong on the screen.

173
00:11:28,722 --> 00:11:32,412
No wrong booking, no charges.
The failure was silence.

174
00:11:32,413 --> 00:11:36,376
And, you know, I've only been
using it for a little while,

175
00:11:36,377 --> 00:11:39,999
and I already read it as a
yes as opposed to a maybe.

176
00:11:40,000 --> 00:11:43,999
Zubin: Yeah. And in payments,
don't we have a word for that? Pending.

177
00:11:44,000 --> 00:11:46,999
Aman: Yeah. The most
expensive word in finance.

178
00:11:47,000 --> 00:11:49,631
Zubin: And, Aman, yours is
the cheap version, right?

179
00:11:49,632 --> 00:11:51,736
Forbes, as we were researching this,

180
00:11:51,737 --> 00:11:56,414
reportedly found a tester whose bot booked
a table with a $200 cancellation fee.

181
00:11:56,415 --> 00:11:58,812
He paid. Even the fans get bitten, right?

182
00:11:58,813 --> 00:12:03,315
Katie Jacobs Stanton, a venture investor,
called Instinct an amazing product,

183
00:12:03,316 --> 00:12:06,999
and then it sent an email on her
behalf without checking first.

184
00:12:07,000 --> 00:12:07,999
Aman: So who pays?

185
00:12:08,000 --> 00:12:09,999
Zubin: On the contract, you.

186
00:12:10,000 --> 00:12:13,127
Aman: And under American
rules, it gets interesting.

187
00:12:13,128 --> 00:12:18,704
Regulation E makes banks investigate and
refund unauthorised electronic transfers.

188
00:12:18,705 --> 00:12:22,853
The regulator hasn't yet said
whether a bot's mistake counts.

189
00:12:22,854 --> 00:12:27,070
So when Maya complains, the party
on the hook may be the bank,

190
00:12:27,071 --> 00:12:31,558
at the end of the day. Poor guys.
Speaking as a recovering banker,

191
00:12:31,559 --> 00:12:35,367
that's the oldest trick in
finance: privatise the charm,

192
00:12:35,368 --> 00:12:36,999
socialise the liability.

193
00:12:37,000 --> 00:12:38,999
Zubin: Right. Say the
whole thing in one breath.

194
00:12:39,000 --> 00:12:44,430
Aman: So. On the contract, you pay.
Under the rules, perhaps your bank pays.

195
00:12:44,431 --> 00:12:47,999
In no version does the
bot pay, interestingly.

196
00:12:48,000 --> 00:12:51,463
Zubin: You know, in fairness
to Muse, Muse does ask first.

197
00:12:51,464 --> 00:12:56,557
Roxy did ask. And Meta says Muse is
covered by Link's purchase protections.

198
00:12:56,558 --> 00:13:01,584
What those cover when the mistake is
the bot's, we really can't establish.

199
00:13:01,585 --> 00:13:05,999
If that was useful, subscribe now.
The rest is about who profits.

200
00:13:06,000 --> 00:13:09,430
Aman: So, Zubin, we know who
signs. Who moves the money?

201
00:13:09,431 --> 00:13:12,999
I think it's time for Prof
Z to go under the bonnet.

202
00:13:13,000 --> 00:13:15,487
Zubin: Let's do it.
Let's do it. So, four steps.

203
00:13:15,488 --> 00:13:17,307
The first step is the request:

204
00:13:17,308 --> 00:13:20,584
the bot tells a wallet what
it wants and for how much.

205
00:13:20,585 --> 00:13:23,011
The second step is approve: you say yes.

206
00:13:23,012 --> 00:13:26,652
The third is issue: the wallet
mints a card that works once,

207
00:13:26,653 --> 00:13:30,778
for that specific amount. And the
fourth step is the actual payment.

208
00:13:30,779 --> 00:13:35,390
The bot types those limited credentials,
or restricted or bound credentials,

209
00:13:35,391 --> 00:13:37,999
into the existing
checkout at the merchant.

210
00:13:38,000 --> 00:13:40,999
Aman: And what does the shop,
or the merchant, see?

211
00:13:41,000 --> 00:13:42,644
Zubin: I think that's the beauty of this.

212
00:13:42,645 --> 00:13:45,015
They just see it as an
ordinary card transaction.

213
00:13:45,016 --> 00:13:46,999
So does the bank that issued Maya's card.

214
00:13:47,000 --> 00:13:49,926
Aman: Yeah. This reminds
me of tokenisation, right?

215
00:13:49,927 --> 00:13:53,308
It took the natural process
and just made it better,

216
00:13:53,309 --> 00:13:55,454
but it still used the same flows.

217
00:13:55,455 --> 00:13:59,552
And let me say what that means
from the chair I used to sit in.

218
00:13:59,553 --> 00:14:02,088
The bank can't tell a bot from a human.

219
00:14:02,089 --> 00:14:05,796
Every fraud model it owns was
trained on how people shop,

220
00:14:05,797 --> 00:14:09,633
and people don't book hotels
at seven minutes past three in

221
00:14:09,634 --> 00:14:10,999
the morning. Bots do.

222
00:14:11,000 --> 00:14:13,103
Zubin: That's right.
And one from my chair,

223
00:14:13,104 --> 00:14:17,369
and this is where the networks are
spending a lot of time working through

224
00:14:17,370 --> 00:14:21,986
this, right? Because a card that works
once is a customer the shop never keeps.

225
00:14:21,987 --> 00:14:24,324
No card on file, no one-click next time.

226
00:14:24,325 --> 00:14:28,999
Every agent purchase is a first date,
which, by the way, not all merchants like.

227
00:14:29,000 --> 00:14:31,999
Aman: Yeah, a first date with a chaperone,
which I don't know we're OK with.

228
00:14:32,000 --> 00:14:35,560
Zubin: Always, always.
And here's the reveal, right?

229
00:14:35,561 --> 00:14:41,337
The wallet is Link, from Stripe.
300 million users, a million businesses.

230
00:14:41,338 --> 00:14:44,740
By the way, these are
all Stripe's numbers.

231
00:14:44,741 --> 00:14:49,805
And Stripe's own announcement
names Muse, Grok Bot and Instinct.

232
00:14:49,806 --> 00:14:53,999
Three rivals using Stripe's
Link product. One wallet.

233
00:14:54,000 --> 00:14:56,914
Aman: You've got to love
those Collison brothers.

234
00:14:56,915 --> 00:14:57,999
What about dots?

235
00:14:58,000 --> 00:14:59,710
Zubin: Not on it,
at least per our research.

236
00:14:59,711 --> 00:15:01,560
And talking about the Collison brothers,

237
00:15:01,561 --> 00:15:04,196
I was at the Stripe office
and got a chance to meet John.

238
00:15:04,197 --> 00:15:05,999
That's my little selfie there with him.

239
00:15:06,000 --> 00:15:10,999
Aman: Yeah, proper fanboy moment.
And he recognised you?

240
00:15:11,000 --> 00:15:12,999
Zubin: Of course. He was like,
"Hi, Zubin." No, he didn't.

241
00:15:13,000 --> 00:15:15,176
Aman: You had an interesting
anecdote about that,

242
00:15:15,177 --> 00:15:16,999
and you asked him what he was doing.

243
00:15:17,000 --> 00:15:19,754
Zubin: You know, this may be
a complete segue, and, Aman,

244
00:15:19,755 --> 00:15:21,241
sorry for bringing this in,

245
00:15:21,242 --> 00:15:25,539
but one of the things we've talked about
a lot in our podcast episodes is this

246
00:15:25,540 --> 00:15:27,302
notion of founder-led companies,

247
00:15:27,303 --> 00:15:30,002
and having those founders
be part of the culture.

248
00:15:30,003 --> 00:15:33,087
You and I got a chance to see
that very early at Google,

249
00:15:33,088 --> 00:15:35,511
where Sergey and Larry
would be in the cafe.

250
00:15:35,512 --> 00:15:40,084
And the anecdote I was telling the person
I was having lunch with was that I always

251
00:15:40,085 --> 00:15:43,886
bumped into either Patrick or John,
and she nudged me to look behind,

252
00:15:43,887 --> 00:15:48,349
and sure enough, there was John, and I
got a chance to interact briefly with him.

253
00:15:48,350 --> 00:15:51,820
And when I brought that up,
to say, "Hey, this always happens,"

254
00:15:51,821 --> 00:15:55,732
he looked at me, deadpan, and said,
"Yeah, we've got to eat lunch too."

255
00:15:55,733 --> 00:15:56,999
Which kind of describes

256
00:15:57,000 --> 00:15:59,999
how they're really in the weeds of stuff.

257
00:16:00,000 --> 00:16:01,540
And yes, they've got to eat lunch too.

258
00:16:01,541 --> 00:16:02,999
But let's come back to this episode.

259
00:16:03,000 --> 00:16:05,517
Aman: Billionaire brunch with the boys.

260
00:16:05,518 --> 00:16:10,706
Going back to the previous point,
this is what we call the Money OS:

261
00:16:10,707 --> 00:16:12,995
the layer that picks the card,

262
00:16:12,996 --> 00:16:16,963
the rail and the limit
before you've seen the price.

263
00:16:16,964 --> 00:16:21,924
The bots fight to be loved.
The Money OS is happy to be invisible.

264
00:16:21,925 --> 00:16:22,924
Zubin: And, by the way,

265
00:16:22,925 --> 00:16:26,276
maybe a silent plug for our
Money OS episode about Stripe.

266
00:16:26,277 --> 00:16:30,495
It's probably in the link below,
and you should definitely click through.

267
00:16:30,496 --> 00:16:33,326
And this is the point
where I'll disagree, right?

268
00:16:33,327 --> 00:16:35,465
You're kind of overrating the middle.

269
00:16:35,466 --> 00:16:37,719
Rails, to some extent, are a commodity.

270
00:16:37,720 --> 00:16:41,129
Whether it's Visa, Mastercard
or even, I would say, Google,

271
00:16:41,130 --> 00:16:45,116
each has agent rails of its own.
Meta could swap Stripe out tomorrow,

272
00:16:45,117 --> 00:16:49,740
and Maya would never know, right? So power
sits at the two ends of that barbell:

273
00:16:49,741 --> 00:16:52,456
the bot you trust,
and the shop with the goods.

274
00:16:52,457 --> 00:16:54,999
The wallet is the middle
that gets squeezed.

275
00:16:55,000 --> 00:16:58,891
Aman: Yeah, that's kind of
annoyingly good of you, Zubin.

276
00:16:58,892 --> 00:17:02,554
The Money OS is rented,
not owned. And actually,

277
00:17:02,555 --> 00:17:08,431
the one person who knows that lesson
from being on the receiving end is Zuck.

278
00:17:08,432 --> 00:17:12,552
Maybe that's why he's so
committed to his cutesy Muse,

279
00:17:12,553 --> 00:17:17,131
because what he saw with Android,
and specifically with iOS,

280
00:17:17,132 --> 00:17:20,488
is that he got locked
out of that last mile,

281
00:17:20,489 --> 00:17:23,999
even though he had the
biggest social network.

282
00:17:24,000 --> 00:17:26,999
Zubin: True fact, true fact. So I'm
going to say: concession one, Vandrevala.

283
00:17:27,000 --> 00:17:27,999
All right, all right.

284
00:17:28,000 --> 00:17:33,158
Aman: Yes. Masterclass, Prof Z.
Even the part where I lost.

285
00:17:33,159 --> 00:17:37,928
OK, and the shop end of
your barbell just flexed.

286
00:17:37,929 --> 00:17:42,893
On the 20th of September,
12 days into Muse's life,

287
00:17:42,894 --> 00:17:47,176
and this is shock horror,
Amazon blocked it,

288
00:17:47,177 --> 00:17:49,999
citing its conditions of use.

289
00:17:50,000 --> 00:17:53,570
Zubin: Of course they did, right?
And when we researched this:

290
00:17:53,571 --> 00:17:56,233
Amazon says Muse doesn't identify itself.

291
00:17:56,234 --> 00:17:59,999
Meta says it can't see your
passwords or cards. Contested.

292
00:18:00,000 --> 00:18:03,553
Aman: Yeah. Follow the money.
If a bot does the buying,

293
00:18:03,554 --> 00:18:08,559
nobody sees the sponsored listing.
Nobody makes the impulse purchase.

294
00:18:08,560 --> 00:18:13,999
Amazon isn't defending a sale. It's
defending the shop window that it owns.

295
00:18:14,000 --> 00:18:16,862
Zubin: And Meta's answer
arrived on the 6th of October.

296
00:18:16,863 --> 00:18:20,978
Sierra, Bret Taylor's company,
announced the Personal Agent Protocol,

297
00:18:20,979 --> 00:18:25,571
built with Meta, which is really an open
standard for how your bot introduces

298
00:18:25,572 --> 00:18:27,599
itself to a business. It signs in,

299
00:18:27,600 --> 00:18:30,999
and you choose whether it gets
read-only or write access.

300
00:18:31,000 --> 00:18:36,736
Aman: Yeah. You know, Meta doesn't have
a fantastic record with building open

301
00:18:36,737 --> 00:18:38,999
standards: Libra. But having

302
00:18:39,000 --> 00:18:43,327
Bret Taylor involved with it,
he's a genuine world-class leader.

303
00:18:43,328 --> 00:18:47,722
I think it's going to be really
interesting to see how that goes,

304
00:18:47,723 --> 00:18:52,794
especially in an era where the US
authorities are saying everybody's got to

305
00:18:52,795 --> 00:18:55,769
build the standards and
regulate themselves.

306
00:18:55,770 --> 00:18:57,528
I'm not a big fan of that,

307
00:18:57,529 --> 00:19:02,938
but I do like the idea of people like
Bret Taylor stepping up with Zuck on this.

308
00:19:02,939 --> 00:19:06,792
So, back to Amazon: it says
your bot won't say who it is.

309
00:19:06,793 --> 00:19:11,999
Sixteen days later, Meta co-writes the
rulebook for bots saying who they are.

310
00:19:12,000 --> 00:19:17,076
Zubin: That's right. And, Aman,
let's read the guest list on this, right?

311
00:19:17,077 --> 00:19:20,999
Walmart, Shopify, Stripe
and Instinct are in there.

312
00:19:21,000 --> 00:19:26,401
Amazon isn't. And nor, yet, are OpenAI,
whose board, by the way, Taylor

313
00:19:26,402 --> 00:19:27,999
chairs, or Anthropic,

314
00:19:28,000 --> 00:19:31,999
though he reportedly expects both to join.

315
00:19:32,000 --> 00:19:36,999
Aman: Yeah, I like it. You know you've got
clout when you expect people to join in.

316
00:19:37,000 --> 00:19:40,293
By the way, that's a seriously

317
00:19:40,294 --> 00:19:44,467
awkward board dinner for Bret Taylor.

318
00:19:45,000 --> 00:19:46,999
And the question this
episode cares about most?

319
00:19:47,000 --> 00:19:49,751
Zubin: Yeah. Payments
aren't in version one.

320
00:19:49,752 --> 00:19:54,214
Liability isn't mentioned.
It tells the shop who's knocking.

321
00:19:54,215 --> 00:19:55,999
It doesn't say who pays.

322
00:19:56,000 --> 00:19:59,964
Aman: Which brings us to the bank.
I've had it two steps back,

323
00:19:59,965 --> 00:20:02,583
behind the bot and behind the wallet.

324
00:20:02,584 --> 00:20:03,999
The complaints desk.

325
00:20:04,000 --> 00:20:06,129
Zubin: Yeah, too early to say, right?

326
00:20:06,130 --> 00:20:09,750
If the bank is writing the
refunds, it wants a say.

327
00:20:09,751 --> 00:20:13,798
And it holds the one power
nobody else in that chain has:

328
00:20:13,799 --> 00:20:15,999
it can say no at the beginning.

329
00:20:16,000 --> 00:20:17,719
Aman: OK, fine. Concession number two.

330
00:20:17,720 --> 00:20:20,999
Zubin, you're on a roll.
Whoever pays gets to make the rules.

331
00:20:21,000 --> 00:20:23,645
Zubin: That's exactly right.
So make them, right?

332
00:20:23,646 --> 00:20:26,983
Visa and Mastercard now have
tokens built for agents.

333
00:20:26,984 --> 00:20:31,960
Now imagine one screen in your banking
app: Roxy may spend fifty dollars a day,

334
00:20:31,961 --> 00:20:34,920
on groceries, nothing else.
The bot is the dog.

335
00:20:34,921 --> 00:20:36,999
The winning bank holds the leash.

336
00:20:37,000 --> 00:20:42,075
Aman: And actually, interestingly,
I just remembered: Revolut, and again,

337
00:20:42,076 --> 00:20:44,196
that's another episode plug,

338
00:20:44,197 --> 00:20:49,802
is reportedly building its own shopping
assistant with AIR, AI by Revolut.

339
00:20:49,803 --> 00:20:51,999
Not many banks are. They are.

340
00:20:52,000 --> 00:20:54,656
Zubin: Good, valid point, valid point.

341
00:20:54,657 --> 00:20:59,799
I should read up about that.
But let's shift gears a little.

342
00:20:59,800 --> 00:21:05,199
There's one country that wants
that leash built into the rails.

343
00:21:05,200 --> 00:21:11,885
We read in Business Standard, in July,
that NPCI, which, by the way, runs UPI,

344
00:21:11,886 --> 00:21:16,256
another plug for an episode
we did, is building the

345
00:21:16,257 --> 00:21:18,999
Unified Agent Protocol. The UAP.

346
00:21:19,000 --> 00:21:21,359
Aman: These all sound, by the way,
like Indian political parties.

347
00:21:21,360 --> 00:21:22,999
I guess it's all part of politics anyway.

348
00:21:23,000 --> 00:21:27,672
Zubin: Probably, right. Every agent
is registered, its authority checked,

349
00:21:27,673 --> 00:21:30,999
its limits set. But it's
planned, not yet live.

350
00:21:31,000 --> 00:21:35,449
Aman: Yeah. I mean, going back to
our Google Pay days helping India,

351
00:21:35,450 --> 00:21:38,680
neither of us, I think,
is surprised by that.

352
00:21:38,681 --> 00:21:40,690
India builds the road first,

353
00:21:40,691 --> 00:21:44,781
while America still argues
over who's got the toll booth.

354
00:21:44,782 --> 00:21:49,662
Now, the second question: why does
every bot want to be your friend?

355
00:21:49,663 --> 00:21:52,247
Look at who gave their agent a face.

356
00:21:52,248 --> 00:21:54,831
Meta, with Jolly. OpenAI, with Todd.

357
00:21:54,832 --> 00:21:59,999
And our example of Maya, with Roxy.
But let's look at who didn't, Zubin.

358
00:22:00,000 --> 00:22:02,601
Zubin: Yeah, let's talk
about Google first, right?

359
00:22:02,602 --> 00:22:06,958
And, by the way, we covered this.
Gemini Spark, announced in May at I/O.

360
00:22:06,959 --> 00:22:09,196
Sundar called it a personal AI agent.

361
00:22:09,197 --> 00:22:11,435
You email it tasks, like a colleague.

362
00:22:11,436 --> 00:22:14,158
No frog. And then let's
talk about Anthropic.

363
00:22:14,159 --> 00:22:18,999
It has Claude doing long jobs at your
desk and in your team's Slack. No mascots.

364
00:22:19,000 --> 00:22:23,424
Aman: And both are in commerce. Google
wrote a payments protocol for agents.

365
00:22:23,425 --> 00:22:26,775
We did Anthropic's commerce
agents in a solo episode.

366
00:22:26,776 --> 00:22:29,999
They built the pipes.
They just didn't build a pet.

367
00:22:30,000 --> 00:22:33,456
Zubin: That's right. And neither
has said why on the record,

368
00:22:33,457 --> 00:22:35,608
so this is maybe our read, right?

369
00:22:35,609 --> 00:22:39,260
Google earns its living when
you look at search results.

370
00:22:39,261 --> 00:22:41,608
A bot that buys for you never looks.

371
00:22:41,609 --> 00:22:44,282
And Anthropic sells mostly to businesses.

372
00:22:44,283 --> 00:22:46,956
Different customers, different instincts.

373
00:22:46,957 --> 00:22:47,999
No pun intended.

374
00:22:48,000 --> 00:22:52,279
Aman: Yeah, and here's mine. With
all my experience working in banking,

375
00:22:52,280 --> 00:22:56,559
what I've learned is that nobody
hands their money to a stranger,

376
00:22:56,560 --> 00:23:01,168
or someone they don't trust.
You hand it to someone you feel you know.

377
00:23:01,169 --> 00:23:03,999
A face isn't decoration.
It's underwriting.

378
00:23:04,000 --> 00:23:07,303
Zubin: Yeah. And cute is a
particular kind of face, right?

379
00:23:07,304 --> 00:23:12,744
Fast Company cites research that cuteness
triggers the urge to look after something.

380
00:23:12,745 --> 00:23:15,659
I guess neither of us
has that cuteness gene,

381
00:23:15,660 --> 00:23:19,999
so that's the reason we're not
looking after each other. Maybe not.

382
00:23:20,000 --> 00:23:21,999
Aman: Yeah, which is why I

383
00:23:22,000 --> 00:23:28,009
think the critics point out that Muse
is for over-18s and wears the face of a

384
00:23:28,010 --> 00:23:32,770
nursery toy, bizarrely. If a
bank printed a plush toy, Zubin,

385
00:23:32,771 --> 00:23:37,999
on a power of attorney, the regulators
would be there before lunch.

386
00:23:38,000 --> 00:23:40,906
Zubin: And it's going social,
man. On the 5th of October,

387
00:23:40,907 --> 00:23:42,534
as we were researching this,

388
00:23:42,535 --> 00:23:46,429
Instinct's founder announced that
its bot can join your group chat,

389
00:23:46,430 --> 00:23:48,813
including friends who've never signed up.

390
00:23:48,814 --> 00:23:52,999
That's a growth loop, right? Each
group chat is essentially a free demo.

391
00:23:53,000 --> 00:23:55,819
Aman: So, Zubin, is AI
going social to grow?

392
00:23:55,820 --> 00:23:58,565
Let me have a shot at answering this.

393
00:23:58,566 --> 00:24:02,499
I think the answer is yes,
and I'd love to get yours.

394
00:24:02,500 --> 00:24:08,065
Chat is where people are. Friends are
the cheapest marketing ever invented.

395
00:24:08,066 --> 00:24:11,999
And trust is the one thing
these companies can't buy.

396
00:24:12,000 --> 00:24:14,904
Zubin: I'm going to take
the middle road here, right?

397
00:24:14,905 --> 00:24:19,452
I'll leave it open, because nobody
has shown that charm causes spending.

398
00:24:19,453 --> 00:24:23,999
But the friend in that chat never
tapped "Send code", right? Whose terms

399
00:24:24,000 --> 00:24:28,274
are they on? And a bot you
like is a bot you don't check.

400
00:24:28,275 --> 00:24:29,999
Charm is not a control.

401
00:24:30,000 --> 00:24:32,999
Aman: Meta literally named
the gadget the Charm.

402
00:24:33,000 --> 00:24:34,999
Zubin: I guess they did the joke for us.

403
00:24:35,000 --> 00:24:38,616
Aman: Yeah. So let's go
back to that staff room,

404
00:24:38,617 --> 00:24:42,061
because there's a thought I can't shake.

405
00:24:42,062 --> 00:24:46,540
Musk has said Grok is headed
towards Optimus, right?

406
00:24:46,541 --> 00:24:52,999
Tesla's humanoid robot. So what happens
the day the staff room gets bodies?

407
00:24:53,000 --> 00:24:56,365
Zubin: I guess your research
bot does the washing-up,

408
00:24:56,366 --> 00:24:58,999
which is what I really want one for.

409
00:24:59,000 --> 00:25:03,603
Aman: Yeah. So, today's assistants,
tomorrow's workforce.

410
00:25:03,604 --> 00:25:07,846
An army of them. And that
film has two endings.

411
00:25:07,847 --> 00:25:11,999
In one, you're on the
sofa while Roxy hoovers.

412
00:25:12,000 --> 00:25:13,999
Zubin: And in the other,
Roxy is on the sofa.

413
00:25:14,000 --> 00:25:19,634
Aman: Yeah. Everything we've said about
who pays is about a bot that can only

414
00:25:19,635 --> 00:25:25,110
click. Give it hands, and a
hundred-dollar cap is no longer a clause.

415
00:25:25,111 --> 00:25:28,999
It's a punchline. Over to
you: sofa, or takeover?

416
00:25:29,000 --> 00:25:30,856
Zubin: So what do you do with that?

417
00:25:30,857 --> 00:25:35,632
Three questions before any bot gets
near your card, or your credentials,

418
00:25:35,633 --> 00:25:39,877
I would argue. One is ask. Does
it ask me before every purchase,

419
00:25:39,878 --> 00:25:41,999
and not at three in the morning?

420
00:25:42,000 --> 00:25:46,999
Aman: Two is cap. What's the limit,
and who set it? Me, or them?

421
00:25:47,000 --> 00:25:51,344
Zubin: And number three is call.
When it gets it wrong, who do I call,

422
00:25:51,345 --> 00:25:52,999
and what did I agree to?

423
00:25:53,000 --> 00:25:55,572
Aman: So, three things: ask, cap, call.

424
00:25:55,573 --> 00:26:01,341
If a bot can't answer all three in
plain English, it doesn't get the card.

425
00:26:01,342 --> 00:26:05,941
The new protocol answers a
fourth question: who's knocking?

426
00:26:05,942 --> 00:26:10,619
These three are still yours to
ask. And tell us your number.

427
00:26:10,620 --> 00:26:14,596
How much would you let a
bot spend while you sleep?

428
00:26:14,597 --> 00:26:15,999
Mine is about $40.

429
00:26:16,000 --> 00:26:19,312
Zubin: I guess mine is the price
of a set of guitar strings,

430
00:26:19,312 --> 00:26:21,874
depending on how expensive I choose them.

431
00:26:21,875 --> 00:26:24,249
Which, to be fair, it would get wrong.

432
00:26:24,250 --> 00:26:28,999
All right, all right, Aman. We started
with a dog and ended with a robot army.

433
00:26:29,000 --> 00:26:29,999
Bring us home.

434
00:26:30,000 --> 00:26:33,194
Aman: OK. We're living
through AI's cute phase.

435
00:26:33,195 --> 00:26:37,947
Meta gave it a plush face.
OpenAI gave it a frog called Todd.

436
00:26:37,948 --> 00:26:43,947
And last month, the White House told
federal agencies to stop saying the word

437
00:26:43,948 --> 00:26:47,298
AI altogether. It's
now Super Intelligence.

438
00:26:47,299 --> 00:26:50,103
SI. From the sublime to the bizarre.

439
00:26:50,104 --> 00:26:55,324
But a new name doesn't retire an
old threat, or an old opportunity.

440
00:26:55,325 --> 00:26:58,596
Roxy is brilliant at three in the morning,

441
00:26:58,597 --> 00:27:01,869
and she's why Maya is $1,200 down as well.

442
00:27:01,870 --> 00:27:05,999
They sell you a friend.
The contract hands you a pet.

443
00:27:06,000 --> 00:27:08,743
Zubin: And look who
skipped the costume party.

444
00:27:08,744 --> 00:27:11,838
Google and Anthropic
never put a face on it.

445
00:27:11,839 --> 00:27:15,989
Microsoft did, briefly.
It gave Copilot a blob called Mico,

446
00:27:15,990 --> 00:27:19,999
and if you tapped it enough
times, it turned into Clippy.

447
00:27:20,000 --> 00:27:21,911
Aman: Not Clippy.

448
00:27:22,000 --> 00:27:25,617
Zubin: Right. For those too old to
know this, Clippy, from Office 97:

449
00:27:25,618 --> 00:27:27,951
"It looks like you're writing a letter."

450
00:27:27,952 --> 00:27:31,628
Clippy took ten years to retire.
Mico managed it in ten months.

451
00:27:31,629 --> 00:27:34,896
Microsoft is getting faster
at learning the same lesson.

452
00:27:34,897 --> 00:27:38,397
So either the three of them
know something, or they're late.

453
00:27:38,398 --> 00:27:40,673
My bet: they've gone to the enterprise,

454
00:27:40,674 --> 00:27:43,999
where somebody reads the
contract before anyone signs it.

455
00:27:44,000 --> 00:27:46,824
Aman: Because the plushies
will meet the lawyers.

456
00:27:46,825 --> 00:27:51,685
When a thousand Roxys book a thousand
wrong rooms, that's not a complaint.

457
00:27:51,686 --> 00:27:52,999
It's a class action.

458
00:27:53,000 --> 00:27:54,999
Zubin: And your robot army?

459
00:27:55,000 --> 00:27:58,453
Aman: That's the deepest
question, I think, Zubin.

460
00:27:58,454 --> 00:28:03,869
A bot with a name, a memory and a
personality is the perfect soul for

461
00:28:03,870 --> 00:28:06,851
something it doesn't have yet: a body.

462
00:28:06,852 --> 00:28:13,209
If Grok gets hands and legs from Optimus
tomorrow, Musk isn't building a chatbot.

463
00:28:13,210 --> 00:28:15,957
He's casting a soul for your robot.

464
00:28:15,958 --> 00:28:20,431
That may be the bet that ties
his companies all together.

465
00:28:20,432 --> 00:28:23,727
That's, in some respects, the irony of AI.

466
00:28:23,728 --> 00:28:27,888
Every hard question it
answers spins up a harder one:

467
00:28:27,889 --> 00:28:31,106
how humans and machines grow up together.

468
00:28:31,107 --> 00:28:36,051
So we stay optimistic. Cautiously.
And my test for Roxy, Jolly,

469
00:28:36,052 --> 00:28:41,153
Todd and whoever turns up in your
group chat next hasn't changed.

470
00:28:41,154 --> 00:28:44,999
Don't tell me you're my
friend. Tell me who pays.

471
00:28:45,000 --> 00:28:48,114
Zubin: All right, so that's
it for A2Z Fintech today.

472
00:28:48,115 --> 00:28:51,702
If this made you want to
check your terms, subscribe,

473
00:28:51,703 --> 00:28:56,306
and send it to that one friend who's
already given a bot their card.

474
00:28:56,307 --> 00:28:57,999
Stay curious, my friends.

475
00:28:58,000 --> 00:29:01,500
Aman: Stay purposeful.
And read section three.