Spin It or Bin It

Paul and Josh build a Mount Rushmore of Weezer's 21st century albums - i.e. excluding their most popular Blue and Pinkerton. Of the band's controversial post-Pinkerton output, what rises above the rest? Is there an album that is actually in contention for the best Weezer album of all time? 

What is Spin It or Bin It?

Paul and Josh are exploring the classic rock and metal canon to figure out which albums are forgotten gems or hidden mistakes.