Most operators who want back into freight brokerage would start a new company. Andrew Silver thinks that's the slow way to do it. Building a carrier network takes years no matter how good you are, and in a post-Montgomery world, a broker that opened two weeks ago has a hard time getting a shipper to take the call.
Andrew co-founded MoLo Solutions in 2017 with the goal of building a top 5 brokerage, ran it on execution rules he learned at Coyote, and sold the company to ArcBest. He's spent the last three and a half years sitting out a non-compete and hosting The Freight Pod. With that non-compete now ending, he's lining up a private equity-backed acquisition of an existing broker. In this conversation, Andrew explains why he'd rather buy than build, why he's open to a company of anywhere from 40 to 1,300 people in any mode, and why he's more confident today than he was in 2017 that he can build a top 5 company.
He also talks about the 360 review that showed him how his perfectionism was landing on his team, how MoLo used one food and beverage account to build its carrier network, why he trusts carriers first knowing he'll sometimes get burned, and why he thinks Montgomery and AI will push a lot of brokerage owners to sell over the next year.
What you'll learn:
- Why buying beats building for Andrew's next brokerage: skipping the two to three years it takes to go from zero to $200M and to build a carrier network you can quote off
- Why new brokers struggle after Montgomery: shippers now weigh compliance, process, and carrier network strength, and a brand-new company rarely has any of them
- What made MoLo grow: clear rules around customer commitments like 95% tender acceptance and 97% on-time, so every RFP was a conversation about growing the account
- Why contract freight builds the network: how MoLo did $25-30M a year with one food and beverage shipper to get density on its lanes, even when individual loads lost money
- Why "just do what Coyote did" usually fails: covering every load is the simple part, and companies that copied it without treating carriers like customers fell apart
- How to get reps to take less margin: using storytelling to tie execution at 13% instead of 18% to growth, promotions, and raises
- Andrew's definition of culture: put a new hire between 10 tenured reps and they'll end up acting like the people on either side of them, whatever you trained them on
- Trust first with carriers: paying over spot on contract lanes to build loyalty, and how to handle a carrier who walks when the market tightens
- Why Andrew expects a wave of brokerage M&A: Montgomery liability and uncertainty about AI are giving owners of 10 to 30-year-old businesses reasons to sell
Time-stamped highlights:
- (
00:02) Intro: Jesse on launching The Freight Show when The Freight Pod already existed
- (
02:42) Three and a half years out of work and why Andrew started The Freight Pod
- (
04:59) The relationships the podcast built that he didn't expect
- (
07:02) Andrew's default operating mode: intense, competitive, and reactive
- (
09:12) The 2020 360 review with his executive coach
- (
10:42) Perfectionist or asshole: how a demand for excellence lands on a team
- (
12:18) Why a brokerage mistake always reaches the customer
- (
14:55) System vs. culture: guardrails and ground rules around commitments
- (
15:53) The asset-based broker that wouldn't cover a load under 20% margin
- (
16:50) The conflict between margin and execution
- (
17:21) Using stories to get reps to accept 13% instead of 18% margins
- (
22:03) The 11th person in the row: Andrew's definition of culture
- (
24:02) Why the real differentiator is what happens on the floor
- (
25:40) What MoLo did right: 95% tender acceptance and 97% on-time
- (
27:39) Why the concept is simple and the execution is hard
- (
29:11) The food and beverage account that was about building a network
- (
30:38) Why "just do what you did at Coyote" often failed
- (
31:29) AI bots don't have throats to choke
- (
34:12) Managing the contract vs. spot split through the cycle
- (
36:06) Why Andrew never called a customer just to raise rates 25%
- (
37:30) Trust first: the LA to Phoenix carrier example
- (
40:04) What to do when a carrier breaks the deal
- (
41:29) What's changed in brokerage over the last 10 to 15 years
- (
42:29) The three customers: carriers, shippers, and employees
- (
44:26) Build from scratch or buy?
- (
46:24) Why a new broker is a hard sell in a post-Montgomery world
- (
47:21) Open to any mode, as long as it can become a top 5 broker
- (
48:43) Why brokerage owners should be scared, and why deals are coming
- (
53:26) "Someone's gotta move the freight": over-investing in protection until there's clarity
- (
55:49) Why no one in brokerage is an AI expert yet, and the coming consolidation
- (
59:00) The Rich Products story: 120 loads in a month at age 22
- (
01:04:05) Buying with private equity, from 40 people to 1,300
- (
01:05:31) What Andrew wants the business to feel like 12 months from now
Guest:
Andrew Silver — Co-founder and Former CEO, MoLo Solutions; Host, The Freight Pod
Andrew co-founded MoLo Solutions in 2017 and grew it into a major contract-focused freight brokerage before selling it to ArcBest. Before MoLo, he spent years at Coyote Logistics, where he started building his book in his early 20s. He now hosts The Freight Pod and is preparing to return to brokerage by acquiring an existing broker with private equity backing.