WEBVTT

00:00:00.240 --> 00:00:12.720
<v David McIlroy>You have to legislate morality. What else can you legislate? I mean, the... It's... What what people mean when they say you can't legislate morality is the particular things where I don't want somebody else to make the moral judgment for me.

00:00:13.265 --> 00:00:17.585
But, yeah, to say that I am not allowed to punch you in the face is to make a moral judgment.

00:00:20.945 --> 00:00:29.280
<v Media Clip>I don't understand. Colonel Jessup said he ordered the code red. I know. Colonel Jessup said he ordered the code red. What did we do wrong?

00:00:29.280 --> 00:00:40.480
It's not that simple. What did we do wrong? We did nothing wrong. Yeah, we did. We were supposed to fight for people who couldn't fight for themselves.

00:00:42.265 --> 00:00:44.585
He was supposed to fight for Willie.

00:00:47.945 --> 00:01:35.060
<v John Dickson>In the classic courtroom drama, a few good men, two US marines stand trial for the death of a fellow marine, and their defense rests on a very simple argument. They were just following orders. But is obeying the rules of an institution enough, or is there some higher moral standard by which those rules themselves can be judged? Written by Aaron Sorkin, this is where Kaylee goes, yay, The movie is best known for that famous line shouted by Jack Nicholson's character, this angry, arrogant colonel. You can't handle the truth.

00:01:36.415 --> 00:02:23.520
Sorry to Americans. It's courtroom drama one zero one, and the performances are incredible. But it's probably the treatment of perennial moral questions that explains the ongoing appeal of this thing. The play, which is the original before the movie, is actually enjoying a Broadway revival with cast members saying that the themes of authority and moral responsibility are what continue to make this piece relevant. They are the same questions raised by the Nuremberg principles at the end of World War two, which established that just following orders isn't really an excuse for international crimes.

00:02:24.080 --> 00:03:05.375
When human laws legalise atrocities, we appeal to a higher court, to a universal standard of justice above any of the particular laws of a state. But where do these concepts of law, authority, and justice really come from? Is the legal system simply there to protect us from harming one another, or is it meant to cultivate a virtuous society? And why do so many of us believe that some moral truths are binding no matter what the particular legislation decrees. So let's look deeper.

00:03:05.375 --> 00:03:07.935
I'm John Dickson, and this is Undeceptions.

00:03:11.820 --> 00:03:48.680
<v David McIlroy>I think what drew me to the law was I like arguing on the one hand. Also, I didn't want to sell a product I didn't believe in. So when I was trying to work out what to do, I think law, the programs on television back in the day that showed lawyers off, plus some premature baldness runs in my family, and I was like, what job can I do

00:03:48.920 --> 00:03:49.560
<v John Dickson>And have a wig?

00:03:49.720 --> 00:03:52.440
<v David McIlroy>That enables me to wear a wig without looking like an idiot.

00:03:52.635 --> 00:04:21.790
<v John Dickson>That's David McGillroy, global distinguished professor of law at the University of Notre Dame or Notre Dame and head of chambers at Forum Chambers in London. David's one of the foremost banking barristers in England, and he has a special interest in the philosophy and theology of law, which is a really big field. He's written a bunch of books, including The End of Law and A Biblical View of Law and Justice.

00:04:22.395 --> 00:04:57.795
<v David McIlroy>I went to that rather, quaint, institution of Cambridge University, and they make you sit at dinner, or at least they did in my college, with all the people who were studying other things. And about a quarter of people studying at my college were studying medicine, and another quarter were studying science. And I had lots of friends who were medics or scientists in training who were like, we are off to discover important stuff that's going to be good for humanity. Wear off to look after people and make people better again. You're just in it for the money, aren't you?

00:04:58.355 --> 00:05:42.950
And there's a verse in the Bible where Jesus talks about the young man seeking to justify himself. And so I got really interested in working out whether there was anything more going on in law than simply providing a means for me to earn a really healthy income. And in my third year at university I discovered the philosophy of law. And that just fascinated me, especially because one of the people who was big in The UK scene at that time was an Australian originally, guy called John Finis. And when you read his stuff, and I was a bit of a nerd at university so I actually did the reading, you would find he kept talking a lot about this guy called Aquinas.

00:05:44.405 --> 00:06:20.905
And then after I finished Cambridge I went to do some more study. I thought I was in it. Went to do some more study in Toulouse which is where Aquinas is buried. So this this guy's name kept cropping up. And then when you read his works you discover how he sees the law, the traffic light stuff, the criminal law stuff, all that sort of stuff that that surrounds us and provides a framework for everyday life in the context of something much bigger.

00:06:21.785 --> 00:06:32.050
<v John Dickson>We'll get back to Aquinas a little later on, and one day we're gonna do a whole episode on him. He's amazing. But first, I asked David about the purpose of law.

00:06:32.050 --> 00:07:20.555
<v David McIlroy>Well, that's a great that's a great question. A really fascinating question. And, actually, like many dilemmas, when you start picking away at it, you think, okay, there are versions of these two sides that aren't quite as far apart as they initially seem. Now if you go back to the people who invented the harm principle, that's John Stuart Mill back in nineteenth century England. And he's dealing with a picture of a society where basically the job of government is probably to provide some roads and to make sure that there's a constable wandering around so that you've got a reduced chance of being beaten up in the street.

00:07:20.555 --> 00:07:39.945
But frankly unless the street lights are decent you had no business being out in the first place. And that's a very, the night watchman state that's called. And harm is really well you know, do what you like inside your own house, it doesn't really matter to me. Now if you come forward to today and what people say is harm, Yeah. Yeah.

00:07:39.945 --> 00:08:01.250
If I if I misgender you, if I commit some sort of microaggression against you, then I've committed harm. We've got governments that are doing a whole load more because if people aren't properly educated, that's harmful. People aren't... Health care isn't taken care of by the state, that's harmful. So Mill would probably come along and look at that today and say, hang on a minute.

00:08:01.250 --> 00:08:58.530
What you guys are trying to do in the name of the harm principle is create a virtuous society. And equally you have somebody like John Finis who I mentioned before who would say, well actually I do think the point of law is to promote the common good, but since an important part of being virtuous is is learning the habits so that you yourself live virtuously without somebody telling you to do it, you know, it's it's... My mom would tell me I needed to go and do my homework until there came a point at which I went and did my homework anyway without her having to tell me. At that point her job as a parent is done. And so Finis would say well you look at the virtuous society because what we want is to bring up people who are properly formed and able to make their own decisions, he can say that makes me still a liberal because I'm over here on that side.

00:08:58.610 --> 00:09:01.170
So it's an interesting So

00:09:01.170 --> 00:09:23.910
<v John Dickson>you're not answering my question. I know it sounds like David's not really answering my question, but he's really saying it's both. Law should protect society from harm, even if the concept of harm is getting harder to define. But law also provides training wheels for doing the right thing. Law teaches virtue.

00:09:24.310 --> 00:09:46.750
Now why does this matter? There's a long standing debate about the purpose of the law. On the one side, law should promote virtue. It encourages good behavior and penalizes vice, and so it helps shape whole communities according to the good. The obvious question, though, is whose morals get to inform the laws?

00:09:46.910 --> 00:10:07.115
On the other side, some argue that law should be completely neutral about what is the good life. Law should be a floor, not a ceiling. It deals with just stopping people harming one another. It's not really about elevating the human soul. Is it one or the other or both?

00:10:07.675 --> 00:10:28.315
<v David McIlroy>Yeah. I think so. And that's because I think even the law, when it says it's not trying to do that, is still promoting virtue. It's just a sort of very short list of virtues rather than a long list of virtues. Liberal society today says you've got be tolerant.

00:10:28.475 --> 00:10:42.830
That's the virtual requirement. And that, if you go to any English school, they will be teaching you that you need to be tolerant. You need to be supportive of the of the rule of law. You need to be in favor of democracy. You need to under...

00:10:42.830 --> 00:10:47.390
That... That's a set of virtues of citizenship that you're being taught.

00:10:47.870 --> 00:11:24.305
<v John Dickson>On 04/22/2020, Richard Pusey was speeding in his Porsche down Melbourne's Eastern Freeway when police pulled him over. As it happens, he had to relieve himself in the nearby bushes. And while he was doing that, a massive truck smashed into the Porsche and the police cars, killing four officers. Pusey emerged from the bushes to find the officers strewn across the road, bloody and dying. And if you can believe it, he didn't call for help.

00:11:24.865 --> 00:11:52.040
Instead, he filmed the scene and made derogatory remarks about the officers. And later, he sent the video to his mates. The public outrage was swift, but it was weirdly difficult to establish whether he'd broken any law after the crash. In the end, Pusey was convicted of outraging public decency. This is an ancient, rarely used common law offense.

00:11:52.565 --> 00:12:22.015
He received just three months in prison for the charge. Dubbed the most hated man in Australia, his behavior prompted the Victorian government to introduce a new offense, grossly offensive public conduct. It's a law about morality. There are other examples as well. Australia has Good Samaritan laws that protect people who help out in emergencies from being sued in the course of helping.

00:12:22.255 --> 00:12:41.190
It's meant to encourage altruism. France goes even further. They've made it a legal duty to help someone in danger. These laws raise that perennial question. Should law be about just preventing harm, or is it actually about elevating the ethics of a society?

00:12:41.430 --> 00:12:51.125
People often say you can't legislate morality, but we sort of already do. And as David says, there's no real alternative.

00:12:52.005 --> 00:13:04.860
<v David McIlroy>You have to legislate morality. What else can you legislate? I mean, the... It's... What what people mean when they say you can't legislate morality is they're particular things where I don't want somebody else to make the moral judgment for me.

00:13:05.100 --> 00:14:02.490
But yeah, to say that I am not allowed to punch you in the face is to make a moral judgment. I think one of the reasons why I've become more insistent on this as I've gotten older is that experience of the banking crisis. So what happened in the banking crisis is there was a systemic failure as a result of a set of salespeople and bank executives who thought that their only obligations were to their shareholders and to their own personal bonuses. And you think, okay, well if these people had been formed differently then they wouldn't have made those short term judgments which the rest of us have ended up paying for. So an awful lot of harm ended up being caused precisely because actually what we'd got in that area of regulation was no attempt to encourage virtue.

00:14:02.970 --> 00:14:14.250
We figured we could do it all with economics. We figured we could do it all with incentives without worrying about the character of the people. And yeah, it's been an extremely costly exercise for everyone.

00:14:20.465 --> 00:14:47.185
<v Media Clip>True law is right reason in agreement with nature. It is of universal application, unchanging and everlasting. It summons to duty by its commands and averts from wrongdoing by its prohibitions. And it does not lay its commands or prohibitions upon good men in vain, though neither have any effect on the wicked. It is a sin to try to alter this law, nor is it allowable to attempt to appeal any part of it.

00:14:47.745 --> 00:15:09.750
And it is impossible to abolish it entirely. We cannot be freed from its obligations by Senate or people, and we need not look outside ourselves for an expounder or interpreter of it. And there will not be different laws at Rome and at Athens, or different laws now and in the future, but one eternal and unchangeable law will be valid for all nations and all times.

00:15:11.135 --> 00:15:47.235
<v John Dickson>That's from book three of Cicero's Dei Republica on the Republic written in the middle of the first century BC. He's describing what would become known as natural law, the idea of a universal moral law governing all of humanity. One of the most recognized symbols of Western law is Lady Justice. She holds a sword in one hand and scales in the other. She stands outside courthouses around the world, from London's Old Bailey to the supreme courts of India, Brazil, and Canada.

00:15:47.715 --> 00:16:06.350
Lady justice draws on ancient Greco Roman motifs, Eustitia, the Roman goddess of justice, and Themias, the Greek goddess of divine order. Lady Justice is meant to be a reminder that there is a law above human laws.

00:16:07.225 --> 00:16:47.485
<v David McIlroy>Natural law revolves around two basic ideas. The idea that there is something called human nature that all of us share, and that because all of us share it there are ways of behaving as a human being that are going to be in accordance with our nature in ways that aren't. And secondly, crucially, that we've got each of us some degree of access through reason to that. So that's what natural law is. Now you can then have to start populating it with content.

00:16:48.525 --> 00:17:25.820
And when you start populating with content you have to start thinking what are human beings like? In an age of transhumanism that's a question that we're confronting all over again. But I mean just to take something really basic, we spend quite a lot of money globally on putting people who've been accused of crimes in front of juries or judges and going through an evidence gathering process to try and work out that they're guilty or innocent. Now that presumes that people have moral responsibility. It presumes that their actions are not simply the result of their brain chemistry.

00:17:26.140 --> 00:18:05.965
That there's a picture of what it's like to be a human being there that is implicit in the whole system of law. And frankly if we abandon it well then let's just hand ourselves over to the chemical conditioners who can try and do what the phrenologist did and measure my head and tell me whether I'm a criminal type or not. So what Finniss does as a way of just getting us into this kind of natural law idea is he says well just imagine why do people do things? Know, why John are you interviewing me? And I can guess that one of the reasons you're interviewing me is you're interested in hearing about natural law.

00:18:05.965 --> 00:18:29.060
Well that's a sort of curiosity for knowledge that Finis says is really one of only just more than a handful of basic reasons why we do anything. That there are only fundamentally a certain number of reasons for doing stuff. And each of those relate to things that it's good for human beings to do. So it is good for human beings within reason to acquire more knowledge. It is good for human beings within reason to play.

00:18:29.060 --> 00:18:53.470
It is good for human beings within reason to get to enjoy beauty, to think about their connection to the divine, all those kinds of things. So he says once you start there then you can begin to build out and think about what then goes on and makes for a good well rounded fully functioning human being and a well rounded human society.

00:18:54.510 --> 00:19:37.285
<v John Dickson>Natural law then suggests there is an objective right and wrong connected to the nature of things. Thomas Aquinas, one of the most influential figures in Western philosophy, is the one who cemented this idea in Western consciousness anyway, but he drew heavily on the ancient Greek philosopher, Aristotle. The idea is that humans have a nature oriented towards certain ends, things like knowledge, relationships, reproduction, raising the next generation. And Aquinas thought, so did Aristotle actually, the search for God. These things are just there in our nature as humans.

00:19:37.960 --> 00:20:06.250
Virtue then is excellence in pursuing these natural human ends. The word he uses, at least in English translation, is inclination, but it doesn't mean whatever feels natural is good. What he means is that there is such a thing as a human nature. It's a fact. And the good is whatever fulfills what it means to be a human completing that human nature.

00:20:06.650 --> 00:20:07.370
So he writes

00:20:10.090 --> 00:20:50.385
<v Media Clip>This is the first precept of law, that good is to be done and pursued, and evil is to be avoided. All other precepts of the natural law are based upon this, so that whatever the practical reason naturally apprehends as man's good or evil belongs to the precepts of the natural law as something to be done or avoided. Since, however, good has the nature of an end and evil the nature of a contrary, hence it is that all those things to which man has a natural inclination are naturally apprehended by reason as being good and consequently as objects of pursuit and the contraries as evil and objects of avoidance. Summa Theologiae.

00:20:52.945 --> 00:21:32.760
<v David McIlroy>And that context of something much bigger for him is well actually are there kind of principles or of design built into nature? Things where we look around the world we go actually if human beings behave like this, things go well for them as individuals, well for them as families, and well for them as societies. And if human beings try and do something different then sooner or later chaos breaks out. So he has that kind of picture and then he says well okay so how do we get a grip on that? And for him it's a bit like looking out at a landscape.

00:21:33.560 --> 00:21:46.045
So somewhere over there in the midst of the hills and every human being can sort of see that they're in the hills but it's all a bit foggy because each one of us sees things differently,

00:21:46.045 --> 00:21:48.685
<v Media Clip>we all have our own blind spots, prejudices, and so on.

00:21:49.260 --> 00:22:03.900
<v David McIlroy>And he says well because the hills were really vague and it wasn't clear where this natural law was, it was really necessary that it could be kind of laid down and set out. And for him he would say well one of the first places we see it laid down and set out is in the 10 Commandments.

00:22:06.285 --> 00:22:27.820
<v Media Clip>All the moral precepts of the commandments belong to the law of nature. Aquinas, Summa Theologiae. The first is the law of nature and that is nothing other than the light of the intellect planted in us by God by which we know what should be done and what should be avoided. Aquinas, Exposition of the 10 Commandments.

00:22:29.645 --> 00:23:33.705
<v David McIlroy>And so that's quite fascinating how he talks about that. And then he says, well there's another problem that we have which is not just that we don't always know what the right thing to do is, it's that sometimes even when we know what the right thing to do is we don't really want to do it. And so for him he says well it wasn't just enough to have the sort of landscape cleared away so that we could see what the right thing to do is more clearly, we needed empowering to do it and we needed some sort of correction coming in to address the fact that you know frankly human beings have been cheating and sleeping with other people they shouldn't be sleeping with and killing one another and all those sorts of things that have messed up human society down the ages. So he goes on and talks about this picture of how that law that's there, that's in creation that's sort of repeated in the 10 Commandments then finds its fulfillment. And the only person that we know of who has managed to live perfectly, and that's Jesus.

00:23:34.265 --> 00:23:55.570
And then he also goes on and says, well, actually, Jesus didn't only just deal with the consequences of us not dealing with the law properly. He also gave us the Holy Spirit which is a sort of internal motive power to assist us. And he puts all this together and it's absolutely... It's a wonderful description. And he says, and you know what?

00:23:56.275 --> 00:24:01.555
The way all of this is folding out is what God's plans were from the beginning of time.

00:24:02.275 --> 00:24:24.210
<v John Dickson>One of the key questions in legal philosophy is the one we've been pursuing. What gives law its authority? Two answers get most of the attention. Natural law, as we've seen, says that law's authority rests on underlying moral principles that are built into the fabric of things. This view was influential for centuries.

00:24:24.675 --> 00:25:12.870
But as Christianity's influence has waned, thinkers increasingly approach law more pragmatically. Jeremy Bentham, for example, argued that laws should be judged by their utility, their consequences for more people. That's utilitarianism. Bentham also helped develop what's called legal positivism, which suggests that a law's validity depends not on its inherent or higher morality, but on whether it was made according to due legal procedure. Natural law theory, though, has received a kind of resurgence in recent decades, especially in our debates about human rights and international law.

00:25:13.270 --> 00:26:02.870
Hardly anyone believes that there's no higher law behind the laws of every land. After all, if a law is simply valid because authorities duly enacted it, what does that mean for the Nazi laws? Speaking still about natural law, was this was this natural law principle at all behind, say, the Nuremberg trials, where really the world had to confront, maybe for the first time in a major situation, is there a law above not only the laws of England, but the laws of Germany? Was there a natural law assumption there? How did people arrive at this concept that there's no law I can say that you've broken, but there is a higher law.

00:26:02.870 --> 00:26:35.980
<v David McIlroy>Okay, so you're absolutely right then. Nuremberg is a high point for natural law, but it's not true to say it's the first time. Aquinas didn't invent natural law. Natural law you can find in Aristotle, can find it in Cicero. It's a way that the Romans are thinking about how do we navigate between us and the barbarians, between the people inside the empire who've got Roman law and the people outside the empire where what they call the Eustentian, the law of nations applies.

00:26:36.460 --> 00:27:23.915
So you see it there. You see it in the Middle Ages at the time that Aquinas is writing the Jewish philosopher Maimonides. So you've got Sir Ibn Rasid who, Averroa is in English, the Muslim philosopher, they're engaging with it because you've got at that time around the Mediterranean different cultures, different religions interacting and trying to work out what they've got in common, it appears again in the seventeenth century where you have the Thirty Years' War. The Thirty Years' War was the bloodiest conflict in Europe before the First World War. And at that point trying to make sense of it Hugo Grotius sits down and writes his Law of War and Peace, and in that he makes these natural law arguments.

00:27:24.235 --> 00:27:47.345
So what's happening in Nuremberg is you've got the situation very similar to what had happened in the seventeenth century when there were mercenaries running around all over the place. It's somebody coming in and retrieving a tradition that says actually yeah, we know that they're the enemy but there are ways you should be treating and not treating even the person who's trying to kill you.

00:27:51.745 --> 00:28:13.405
<v Media Clip>Principles of international law recognized in the charter of the Nuremberg tribunal and in the judgement of the tribunal. Principle four: The fact that a person acted pursuant to order of his government or of a superior does not relieve him from responsibility under international law, provided a moral choice was in fact possible to him.

00:28:16.285 --> 00:28:26.440
<v John Dickson>Let's talk about Christianity and the law. Do you have any reflections on the influence of Christianity on at least the Western law tradition?

00:28:26.840 --> 00:28:56.030
<v David McIlroy>Yes, so I think Christianity is absolutely fundamental to the Western legal tradition. And I think it's fundamental to the Western legal tradition in two interesting ways. Because the Western legal tradition is split between civil law and common law. And in the civil law it is a Christian emperor Justinian who pulls together all the resources of ancient Roman laws. I

00:28:56.270 --> 00:28:58.350
<v John Dickson>have his two volumes on my bookshelf there.

00:28:58.350 --> 00:29:40.835
<v David McIlroy>Yeah. Well, and he spends a lot of money getting the best scholars of his day to try and synthesize what were frankly a couple hundred years of case opinions written by written by people. And when in the Middle Ages, the Catholic church is beginning to develop its canon law, they go back to that source material and rework it and make it work for their circumstances. And that's then the body of learning that gets secularized into, civil law, later on.

00:29:41.875 --> 00:30:09.975
<v John Dickson>Just quickly, the world's two main legal systems are civil law and common law. Civil law traces back to ancient Rome, especially to the sixth century code of Justinian, which is just over there in my library. It's used across much of Europe, South America, and Asia. Now common law developed in medieval England and spread throughout the British Empire. It's used in Britain, The US, Australia, Canada, and so on.

00:30:09.975 --> 00:30:40.695
The basic difference, civil law emphasizes written legal codes. Common law places a greater emphasis on judicial precedent on earlier court decisions. There's much more to it, but that'll do for now. And while I'm here, just a quick word about canon law, which is sort of a different tradition. By the twelfth century, the church had developed a vast legal literature, drawing together centuries of authoritative rulings.

00:30:41.200 --> 00:31:26.815
Two influential works were Gratian's Decretum around 1140 and the Glossa Ordinaria of Johannes Teutonicus around 12/16. The whole canon law tradition helped shape the Western legal tradition. As bizarre as it sounds, church courts dealt with everything from marriage and inheritance to property disputes and lots of other stuff as well. They could even impose penance, withhold communion, or even excommunicate offenders, and people took these courts really seriously. Canon Law had plenty to say about charity and the rights of the poor against the rich.

00:31:26.895 --> 00:31:44.680
And when we eventually do an episode on canon law, which would just be awesome, Kaylee, seriously, I'd love to explain how some of these church laws were actually lifted out of canon law into common law by Elizabeth the first, but that's for another time.

00:31:45.400 --> 00:32:28.675
<v David McIlroy>Now the story is very different in England because in England before the canonists have started that work we have a king called Henry the second, and Henry the second decides that what he's going to do is send his judges on horseback to ride around the country to deliver the king's justice. Now Henry the second, he's thinking quite hard about how he's gonna impose this law. But he is frankly an interesting character. And he had a very good friend, a drinking companion in fact. And he, when the post of Archbishop of Canterbury came up, Henry the second thought, I know what I'll do.

00:32:28.675 --> 00:32:50.300
I'll appoint my mate Tommy to be Archbishop of Canterbury. What could possibly go wrong? Well when Thomas Becket gets appointed as Archbishop of Canterbury he proves to be quite insistent on the rights of the church. So he's insisting against this king who's trying to invent English law, invent the common law. There are limits to your power.

00:32:51.665 --> 00:32:53.505
Henry doesn't like this.

00:32:53.825 --> 00:32:54.385
<v John Dickson>Fair enough.

00:32:54.385 --> 00:33:36.470
<v David McIlroy>So he says probably after dinner, after he had a few, will somebody rid me of this turbulent priest? And four nights take him at his word, jump on the horseback, ride down to Canterbury Cathedral and kill Thomas Becket in the cathedral. Well that then becomes the major site of pilgrimage in the Middle Ages. So you just have hundreds of years of English people walking up and down to Canterbury to remember the point where the king's authority was challenged. And after the king had killed Becket or had Becket killed he was forced by the Pope to do penance, which was a pretty powerful signal of his limitations on his power.

00:33:36.790 --> 00:34:26.785
That's 1178. 12/15 bad King John is behaving in a way that everybody agrees is just inappropriate and lawless. And it's the Archbishop of Canterbury of the day who oversees the signing of Magna Carta which is really the start of common law liberties. So you can't tell the story of Western law whether you're looking at continental law where you have to go back to the canons put forward by the Catholic church or the common law tradition where you see the influence of the Church of England and then we have for hundreds of years after that church judges because largely speaking it's the clerics who can read and write. So they're the ones you want to use for your court proceedings.

00:34:26.865 --> 00:34:38.530
Particularly since for period of time we had the joy in England where court proceedings were conducted in French but written down in Latin. The good old days. Yeah. Absolutely.

00:34:38.530 --> 00:35:18.295
<v John Dickson>The Magna Carta of 12/15 is one of the most influential legal documents in Western history. It was a peace treaty between tyrannical King John of England and his rebellious barons. The Magna Carta solidified the principle of the rule of law, that no one, not even a king, is above the law. Though originally protecting mainly the privileged, it laid the foundations of the revolutionary idea that all people had rights, and that idea has deeper roots as we explored in our episode on the image of God.

00:35:19.575 --> 00:35:59.020
<v David McIlroy>Well, I think I think you can look at it two two ways. I I think... I always think it's a bit dangerous to tell stories about golden eras because when you scratch the surface, you find that golden eras are always a bit more tarnished than, you might expect them to be. But undoubtedly, the Magna Carta is part of a movement that sees slavery and serfdom disappear from England and Northern France at that time hundreds of years before it goes anywhere else. There's this sort, again if we're going back and thinking, what does a flourishing human being look like?

00:35:59.020 --> 00:36:30.720
There is this sort of picture of the yeoman farmer, independent, scale, honest, law abiding, caring for their family as almost the ideal person that is in the imagination of the Magna Carta. Now that doesn't stick immediately. Magna Carta gets reissued by every monarch from 12/15 through to 1297. So it's a period of time of embedding this change that's there. And yeah, but I think it's quite significant.

00:36:30.720 --> 00:36:44.585
<v John Dickson>Because it's sort of saying that the weak actually have rights vis a vis the powerful, Yeah. I mean, that's not a concept that's had three cheers through all of history.

00:36:44.585 --> 00:37:10.895
<v David McIlroy>No, it's not. But it proved enormously powerful, because one hundred and thirty five years after all of that, have the Black Death that sweeps through. And what happens after the Black Death sweeps through is those peasants who are still alive look around and go, well, where are the best wages? And they up and leave and go where the best wages are. Now if you're a surf, you can't get up and leave.

00:37:10.895 --> 00:37:18.735
You're stuck wherever you are. If you've a bad boss, there's nothing you can do about it. So, yeah, it's it's it's a really important document.

00:37:25.390 --> 00:37:46.885
<v John Dickson>Another area of David's interest is the role of law in protecting religious freedom. Now I know this can sometimes sound like Christians just trying to protect their own privileges, but religious freedom really should be thought of as good for everyone regardless of belief or unbelief. I asked David about it.

00:37:47.610 --> 00:38:18.270
<v David McIlroy>Yes. So something odd happens in the seventeenth century again. Whilst the Continental Europe is having its thirty years' war, the British and Irish decided to have their own series of fights called the civil wars. And coming out of the civil wars you sort of get to two visions. One vision is Thomas Hobbes and Thomas Hobbes' vision is look guys you've all been fighting about who's in charge.

00:38:18.990 --> 00:38:57.905
We just need to pick somebody who's in charge and then we'll knuckle under because that's frankly will give us order and order however ugly it is it's gonna be better than war. The other vision, the one that wins out in England and wins out in America is that of John Locke. And what John Locke starts us down a road towards is the idea that all this stuff about the good that we were talking about, about the virtues that we were talking about, well all of that, we're never going to agree about that metaphysics. So let's just park it to one side. Let's just try and start with rights and build from there.

00:38:59.665 --> 00:39:59.605
Well that sets the tone that is born through hundreds of years later where we conduct our political discourse and our legal arguments primarily in terms of rights without talking about social goods. And that is going to make both sides, that if they stick to that language and don't go anywhere else, sound trill, is going to mean that for both sides justice is just us. So you see that. What it's missing when the debate takes place in those terms, particularly in relation to freedom and religion, Is there any sort of standing back and look at the broader contribution that freedom of religion has made to flourishing? If you go back and think about when we see freedom of religion in the West, we see it coming about with the first journals being written and printed for religious purposes and that's what gives us freedom of speech.

00:39:59.925 --> 00:40:47.950
And we see congregations of believers meeting in places, hiding from the police or the predecessors of the police and then actually the right to assemble comes out of there. We see people thinking about well I don't want my children to be indoctrinated with false beliefs over there. So I have the right to educate them and we see that the right to education come out of it. So actually when we sit down a lot of the fundamental freedoms that even if you've got no religious convictions whatsoever you want to enjoy as a trade unionist or somebody who wants to be a member of a bowling club or somebody who wants to be an investigative journalist. All those kinds of things find their origin in freedom of religion.

00:40:49.125 --> 00:41:09.520
And what's really striking for those people who are on the sort of religion is bad and dangerous kind of bandwagon is you can draw a pretty close correlation between the societies that don't have freedom of religion today or have restricted freedom of religion and the societies that are also struggling in terms of all those other freedoms as well. Yes, but

00:41:09.520 --> 00:41:16.320
<v John Dickson>is religious freedom really just good for religious folks? Or do you think there is a sense in which

00:41:17.275 --> 00:41:59.880
<v David McIlroy>religious freedom is good for secular society? I've absolutely no doubt that religious freedom is good for secular society, because the ability for a minority religious group to be free from a majority religious group or a wannabe majority religious group is the ability of somebody who doesn't believe at all to be free from that majority religious group. And as I say, what we've seen is there have been secular analogues to all of those freedoms. If I can have a Christian radio station, well you can have a secular radio station. If I can have Christian school, then you can have a secular school.

00:41:59.880 --> 00:42:01.800
All of those things are possible.

00:42:02.200 --> 00:42:25.170
<v John Dickson>I also asked David about punishment and the law. Is punishment meant to be for deterrence? Is it restoration? Is it retribution? It's a really big topic, but I'm sorry to say producer Kaylee has said this part of the conversation is just exclusively for club members.

00:42:25.330 --> 00:42:32.130
Please send all of your complaints to producer Kayleigh @undeceptions.net.uk.

00:42:36.885 --> 00:42:45.045
<v David McIlroy>Because she's relocating to London after all of the hate mail. You'll never

00:42:45.045 --> 00:43:07.655
<v John Dickson>find me. Wherever you send your email, please head to undeceptions.com/club to get access to all those things Kaylee is hiding. One topic we haven't talked about is punishment. What is punishment? Is it restoration?

00:43:07.655 --> 00:43:24.280
Is it deterrence? Is it retribution? Justice? I mean, are you going to just say yes? But really, how does the law think about philosophically think about punishing?

00:43:24.360 --> 00:43:52.750
<v David McIlroy>Well, the great thing about being British is that the British don't feel the need, the Germans or even the Americans, to be systematic in terms of their thinking about it, don't they? So what end up with is something that is sort of pragmatic. It sort of works. We sort of feel we need to do it, so we're going to do it like this. And inevitably in a democracy you'll get different governments that come in at different times which have different theories of punishment.

00:43:53.150 --> 00:44:09.275
But C. S. Lewis I think was really good in saying, well it can't just be deterrent. Because if it was just deterrent, well a crime has been committed. I as the state wants to send the signal that this crime shouldn't be repeated.

00:44:09.595 --> 00:44:47.260
Well I'll just find somebody and punish them for the crime and whether they were the one who did it or not is really secondary to the message that punishing somebody sends. So it can't just be deterrent. Ideally of course we would like it to be restoration. But the experience of legal systems around the world is you can't restore everybody. It's also the case I think that a Christian understanding of punishment would say that there has to be that moment of truth.

00:44:47.820 --> 00:45:30.755
There has to be that moment where you are confronted with the reality of what it is that you have done. Because anything less does not vindicate the victims. It does not properly restore the moral order in society. And also it doesn't put the offender face to face with the reality of what they've done. So that retribution, as it's often referred to, that view of punishment, the kind of necessary step to then create the conditions in which you might go on and explore restoration.

00:45:30.835 --> 00:45:39.475
<v John Dickson>Has it fallen out of favor though? I mean do your legal boffin types sort of avoid talking about retributive justice and prefer to talk about restorative?

00:45:40.660 --> 00:46:10.575
<v David McIlroy>No, I don't think so. The prisons in England are full. If there was more restorative justice, they wouldn't be overcrowded. There have been all sorts of challenges with restorative justice, but I think to some extent it's still something that hasn't been hasn't been properly explored to the extent it might be. I know it's been proved to be useful in a number of places in youth justice situations, but I think there's more that could be could be done with it.

00:46:11.610 --> 00:46:25.930
<v John Dickson>Let's press pause. I've got a five minute Jesus for you. It's kind of a five minute Moses, actually. There have been many famous legal collections through history. Before Moses, there was the code of Hammurabi.

00:46:26.135 --> 00:47:00.335
That's 282 laws from ancient Babylon. After Moses, there were the 147 maxims of Delphi, stuff like know yourself and stop yourself killing. More recently, Benjamin Franklin came up with his own famous 13 laws, cleanliness, humility, and so on. But frankly, nothing comes close to the fame and impact of the 10 Commandments. This has to be the most famous legal code ever composed.

00:47:01.055 --> 00:47:47.500
And curiously, Moses anticipated this. In Deuteronomy four, just before the 10 Commandments are given, he tells Israel that if they carefully observe these laws he's about to give them, then all the nations will hear about these amazing laws, and they will say, and I'm quoting here, surely this great nation is wise and understanding. Three thousand years later, few people ever talk about the Code of Hammurabi or the Maxims of Delphi. But most people know something about the 10 Commandments. Now there are actually 613 commandments in the Old Testament according to Jewish tradition, but the 10 Commandments aren't just the first 10 in the list.

00:47:47.740 --> 00:48:21.305
They are what Christopher Wright, the Old Testament scholar, calls the essential constitutional core of the covenant. These were the only laws that the Israelites heard directly from God on Mount Sinai, and they're the only ones written on those two stone tablets. The first four of the 10 concern our vertical relationship with the almighty. No other gods, no idols, don't take God's name in vain, and keep the Sabbath rest. The remaining six are social laws.

00:48:21.305 --> 00:48:44.880
They're about the horizontal relationships with human beings. Honor your parents, don't murder, don't commit adultery, don't steal, don't bear false witness, and don't covet your neighbor's stuff. Jesus later just summarized all of this by saying that there are two commandments. Love the Lord your God with all your heart, that's the vertical stuff, and love your neighbor as yourself. That's horizontal.

00:48:45.855 --> 00:49:24.925
But here's the really interesting thing, at least I find it interesting. Christians have always read the Old Testament, including these 10 commandments, through the lens of Jesus Christ and his own teaching. Deuteronomy itself promises that God will one day raise up a prophet just like Moses and that everyone has to listen to that prophet. Jeremiah chapter 31 in the Old Testament says that one day there will be a new covenant that will not be like the old covenant, and this covenant will be written on our hearts. And Jesus explicitly claims to bring this new covenant.

00:49:25.650 --> 00:50:26.130
Now we could get very nerdy at this point, but the thing is, there's some excellent scholarship, particularly by people like Dale Allison and others, showing how Jesus is presented in the New Testament as a new Moses with a new law, and his Sermon on the Mount is kind of like the Sinai Mountain and the 10 Commandments. But Jesus' teaching does something remarkable with the old law. He transposes it into a new key, and this dramatically changed how particular commandments were heard and obeyed throughout history. For example, the prohibition against idols in the Old Testament 10 Commandments was extended in the light of Jesus' teaching to include even pursuing material wealth at the expense of worship. That's a kind of idol worship.

00:50:26.850 --> 00:51:14.195
The command against adultery was interpreted by Jesus, and then in the Western Christian tradition, to even include lusting for another human being. The command against murder was amped up to an extraordinary degree by Jesus and the apostles to include even anger and the failure to love others. I could say much more about this, but the critical thing is that it's the specifically Christian version of the 10 Commandments, the law transposed by Christ into the key of love. That's what profoundly shaped Western ethics and law. You can press play now.

00:51:15.395 --> 00:51:30.240
Obviously, you love legal systems, but I guess I wanna ask you about your Christian faith and the way you think of Christianity. It deserve the criticism that some of my listeners will have that Christianity can just be a little too rules based, a little too legalistic?

00:51:31.600 --> 00:51:55.160
<v David McIlroy>So the way I think about is this. Let me use an example. I've been married for an awful long time to the same woman. And for that relationship to work, there are certain things I am not going to do. There are certain things and you could express those in rule form.

00:51:55.560 --> 00:52:30.700
But I don't spend my life with her thinking about oh yeah, I mustn't go there and I mustn't do that with that person because I love my wife. And so all of that sort of stuff fades into the background. What matters to me is how can I express love to her on a day to day basis? And I think the Christian faith is about a relationship with Jesus. And when you get into that relationship it's about, okay, well what is going to be the way of living my life that is going to honor him and respect him?

00:52:31.845 --> 00:52:54.750
And so, for me it's about pursuing the Christian virtues, which are the ones that everybody would understand in terms of wisdom and courage and temperance and justice, but also faith, hope and love, patience, self control, all those other things that are sometimes described as fruit of the spirit. And those are the things that I spend my time being concerned about, how I'm doing

00:52:55.150 --> 00:53:26.315
<v John Dickson>really. Dave McIlree, thank you so much. No, thank you. Undeceptions is hosted by me, John Dickson, produced by Kayleigh Payne, and directed and edited by Mark Bentham Hadley. Sophie Hawkshaw is on socials and membership.

00:53:26.315 --> 00:53:42.190
Siobhan McGinnis is our online librarian. Lindy Leviston remains my wonderful assistant. Santino DeMarco is chief finance and operations consultant. Our voice actors today were Yannick Laurie and Dakota Love. If you like us, rate and review us on Apple Podcasts.

00:53:42.190 --> 00:54:11.680
Send our algorithm through the roof. You can become a member of the Undeceptions club and access all those special extras that Kaylee is hiding and an exclusive gift and much more by heading to undeceptions.com/club. Becoming a member is the best way to help Undeceptions help many others look deeper. An Undeceptions podcast.
