WEBVTT

00:00:00.102 --> 00:00:04.893
And Microsoft's Copilot is really an
interesting play, uh, because it's now no

00:00:04.893 --> 00:00:09.424
longer, uh, that coded environment that
you have for, for developers anymore.

00:00:09.454 --> 00:00:12.969
It's just, "Oh, tell me what I
want," and, and there you go.

00:00:12.969 --> 00:00:15.746
You got this program and code
that can do exactly what you want.

00:00:16.002 --> 00:00:20.043
I wanna go scrape 1,000, uh,
websites for price points to compare

00:00:20.044 --> 00:00:21.437
it to what my price point is.

00:00:21.984 --> 00:00:24.730
Here you go, uh, and, and
just by asking the question.

00:00:25.029 --> 00:00:28.115
And that's the kind of thing that
I think is gonna start changing

00:00:28.370 --> 00:00:31.973
the work environments for, uh,
retail, uh, employees as well

00:00:31.973 --> 00:00:33.449
as other businesses as well.

00:00:33.449 --> 00:00:36.409
But m- mostly you're gonna see a
lot of the impact on the retail side

00:00:37.427 --> 00:00:41.660
Welcome to the Retailgentic podcast,
where we explore the intersection

00:00:41.663 --> 00:00:47.380
of retail, e-commerce, and AI
agents, which we call retailgenic.

00:00:48.000 --> 00:00:49.133
Our mission is simple.

00:00:49.146 --> 00:00:52.531
We are shining a bright light on
the new agentic AI shopping mega

00:00:52.532 --> 00:00:56.686
trend, which will disrupt the
trillion-dollar digital retail market.

00:00:57.024 --> 00:00:58.366
The stakes are high.

00:00:58.692 --> 00:01:06.441
Google, OpenAI, Microsoft,
Perplexity, Amazon, Apple, Meta, and

00:01:06.442 --> 00:01:10.487
Anthropic are all fighting to be the
consumer AI shopping agent winner.

00:01:10.788 --> 00:01:13.962
There are gonna be some tough decisions
for online brands and retailers to make.

00:01:14.493 --> 00:01:16.079
What happens to checkouts?

00:01:16.534 --> 00:01:17.957
How should payments work?

00:01:18.604 --> 00:01:21.151
Should you continue to invest
in retail media networks?

00:01:21.735 --> 00:01:24.692
What does the world look like when
over half of your traffic is not

00:01:24.696 --> 00:01:27.481
from humans, but from AI agents?

00:01:28.252 --> 00:01:30.917
These existential questions
are the tip of the iceberg.

00:01:31.233 --> 00:01:35.359
On this podcast, we're talking to industry
experts, analysts, and influencers

00:01:35.648 --> 00:01:40.310
to get answers to these questions,
identify trends and best practices.

00:01:40.915 --> 00:01:45.631
This is Retailgentic, your
podcast partner in navigating

00:01:45.631 --> 00:01:47.539
our AI shopping agent future.

00:01:47.778 --> 00:01:52.626
And now here's your host, Scot Wingo.

00:01:53.253 --> 00:01:55.482
Welcome to the Retailgentic podcast.

00:01:55.901 --> 00:02:00.402
IDC is a leading global provider of
market intelligence and advisory services.

00:02:01.290 --> 00:02:05.033
They work with a wide range of
businesses from B2B to consumer

00:02:05.115 --> 00:02:06.870
and across all different sectors.

00:02:07.398 --> 00:02:10.545
In today's episode, I'm excited
to welcome Andy Chaurtia.

00:02:10.678 --> 00:02:14.840
He is the vice president of research
for IDC's Retail Insights group.

00:02:15.841 --> 00:02:19.041
Andy has a report out titled
"Win-Win Product Discovery: A

00:02:19.043 --> 00:02:21.284
Retail Agentic AI Use Case."

00:02:21.894 --> 00:02:26.078
In this report, Andy goes very deep
into what agents are, how do you

00:02:26.079 --> 00:02:29.933
orchestrate them, and how retailers can
leverage agents internally to improve

00:02:29.934 --> 00:02:31.646
their product catalog discoverability.

00:02:32.332 --> 00:02:33.558
I thought it was a great example.

00:02:33.559 --> 00:02:38.169
He uses baseball bats, which is, uh,
a category that is inherently hard to

00:02:38.170 --> 00:02:42.661
have a great shopping experience for
in today's filtered navigation user

00:02:42.661 --> 00:02:44.184
interface that most retailers have.

00:02:45.120 --> 00:02:48.257
After reading this awesome report,
I thought, "We have got to get Andy

00:02:48.281 --> 00:02:51.784
onto the Retailgentic pod," and he
graciously accepted that invite.

00:02:52.580 --> 00:02:57.409
In this discussion, we hear all about
Andy's long and amazing career, where

00:02:57.409 --> 00:03:00.262
he was on both sides of the coin.

00:03:00.273 --> 00:03:04.054
He has worked for many retailers,
then also on the vendor side as well.

00:03:05.016 --> 00:03:09.070
It would not be a Retailgentic podcast
if we didn't cover agentic shopping.

00:03:09.182 --> 00:03:13.938
Andy shares his point of view and
thoughts on where we are today and where

00:03:13.946 --> 00:03:16.319
agentic commerce is going in the future.

00:03:17.122 --> 00:03:21.219
Finally, Andy, in his role, Andy
talks to hundreds of retail clients a

00:03:21.220 --> 00:03:24.859
month and has some really interesting
viewpoints he's gathered from the

00:03:24.862 --> 00:03:26.937
summation of those conversations.

00:03:27.503 --> 00:03:31.138
Uh, so we get to hear what are retailers
thinking about, what's motivating

00:03:31.138 --> 00:03:37.893
them, and where is agentic commerce on
their, their priority list right now.

00:03:39.107 --> 00:03:44.459
I really enjoyed this conversation with
Andy and hope you enjoy it as well Ananda,

00:03:44.488 --> 00:03:47.048
welcome to the Retailgentic Podcast.

00:03:47.659 --> 00:03:49.849
Oh my gosh, I'm, I'm excited to be here.

00:03:50.029 --> 00:03:50.605
Thanks, Scott.

00:03:51.612 --> 00:03:51.953
Yeah.

00:03:51.984 --> 00:03:56.096
You and I, uh, have, uh, we
just really officially met.

00:03:56.096 --> 00:03:57.824
I think we bumped into each
other at some trade shows.

00:03:57.826 --> 00:03:59.836
You've been in the, the
industry for quite a while.

00:04:00.171 --> 00:04:04.113
Um, and I was drawn to you
because you wrote a really good

00:04:04.114 --> 00:04:05.216
paper that we'll talk about.

00:04:05.277 --> 00:04:10.085
Um, and you're, you're, you know, VP of
research at IDC, but before we go into

00:04:10.085 --> 00:04:12.009
what that means, let's go, let's go back.

00:04:12.056 --> 00:04:15.579
Let's talk about, uh, I think
it's interesting, I learned in a

00:04:15.610 --> 00:04:18.328
little pre-conversation you have
an engineering degree like I do,

00:04:18.330 --> 00:04:19.532
so we, we share that in common.

00:04:19.832 --> 00:04:22.256
Not a lot of engineers in
the, in the retail world.

00:04:22.257 --> 00:04:23.821
So let's, let's start there.

00:04:23.822 --> 00:04:26.553
What, what, um, what'd you study
in school, and then let's, let's

00:04:26.554 --> 00:04:29.550
draw a path from there to how
you ended up pontificating on

00:04:29.800 --> 00:04:31.154
agentic commerce here today.

00:04:31.445 --> 00:04:34.270
So I went to Clemson University
as a engineering student,

00:04:34.280 --> 00:04:35.230
electrical engineering.

00:04:35.232 --> 00:04:36.536
I wanted to get into computers.

00:04:36.778 --> 00:04:39.818
Was really excited about parallel
processing, which is really a cool

00:04:39.819 --> 00:04:41.843
space in the eng- engineering space.

00:04:42.352 --> 00:04:46.809
I, uh, graduated there, got a master's
in, um, uh, electrical engineering from,

00:04:46.809 --> 00:04:48.500
uh, University of Massachusetts in Lowell.

00:04:48.906 --> 00:04:53.233
And then, uh, went off to Northeastern
for my MBA later on when I realized

00:04:53.354 --> 00:04:54.922
this isn't quite what I wanted to do.

00:04:54.930 --> 00:04:58.553
The engineering is great for a
background, it sets the stage, but I

00:04:58.553 --> 00:05:00.041
wanted to get into the business side.

00:05:00.043 --> 00:05:03.958
It was so much more important, and it
actually drives the value, uh, for a lot

00:05:03.959 --> 00:05:08.361
of, uh, especially in the retail side,
uh, but in general across the market

00:05:08.728 --> 00:05:13.372
around applying that engineering into,
uh, real-time settings, which with some

00:05:13.373 --> 00:05:15.087
real dollar values associated with it.

00:05:15.307 --> 00:05:18.657
So that was the exciting thing about, um,
me moving in one direction or another.

00:05:19.471 --> 00:05:19.644
Yeah.

00:05:19.659 --> 00:05:21.313
How'd you end up at Clemson of all places?

00:05:21.313 --> 00:05:23.947
I'm, I'm from South Carolina
and I, I'm gonna hazard a guess

00:05:23.947 --> 00:05:24.911
you're not from South Carolina.

00:05:25.629 --> 00:05:27.507
But how did you end up in
Clemson, South Carolina?

00:05:27.763 --> 00:05:30.529
My whole family went there,
uh, like five cousins of mine.

00:05:30.833 --> 00:05:34.445
My aunt and uncle both were professors
there of physics and math, so it was

00:05:34.446 --> 00:05:38.358
all one of those things where family
connection that really brought me there.

00:05:38.520 --> 00:05:42.461
But Clemson's a great football school,
it's got great, uh, programs as well

00:05:42.461 --> 00:05:43.933
in agriculture and other stuff too.

00:05:43.933 --> 00:05:49.194
So, um, I, I truly enjoyed my time
there and, um, you know, of all places,

00:05:49.506 --> 00:05:52.810
uh, South Carolina was not one of
the places that I expected to go.

00:05:52.810 --> 00:05:56.275
I was thinking about, you know,
California, Texas, uh, even,

00:05:56.340 --> 00:05:58.626
uh, Northeast, but I wanted
to get away from my parents.

00:05:58.628 --> 00:05:59.450
That was part of it too.

00:06:00.022 --> 00:06:00.270
So

00:06:01.313 --> 00:06:03.757
You can, you can do that at Clemson,
you get away from everybody.

00:06:03.809 --> 00:06:05.637
It's just like this little isolated city.

00:06:05.710 --> 00:06:05.925
Yeah.

00:06:07.420 --> 00:06:07.700
Yeah.

00:06:07.792 --> 00:06:09.954
Did you get your MBA
straight out of school?

00:06:09.956 --> 00:06:14.353
Uh, so you did undergrad, masters, MBA, or
like, did you go something in the middle?

00:06:14.515 --> 00:06:15.111
No, no.

00:06:15.161 --> 00:06:17.667
So, uh, actually it was well Yeah.

00:06:17.667 --> 00:06:20.203
So I was actually going for a doctorate
in, uh, electrical engineering.

00:06:20.368 --> 00:06:24.488
That was my plan at the time,
and I realized that, um, uh, this

00:06:24.489 --> 00:06:26.165
wasn't exactly what I wanted to do.

00:06:26.183 --> 00:06:29.868
It was too much on the side of really,
uh, getting into really detailed

00:06:29.897 --> 00:06:33.957
function and understanding, and it
wasn't about, uh, computers anymore.

00:06:33.960 --> 00:06:37.959
It actually moved into acoustics
and other types of, uh, mechanical,

00:06:37.987 --> 00:06:42.066
electromechanical engineering, which did
not, uh, suit me at all, and I actually

00:06:42.066 --> 00:06:46.109
went and attended a seminar a- about
business, and it totally changed my

00:06:46.109 --> 00:06:48.117
viewpoint on what I wanted to do next.

00:06:48.516 --> 00:06:52.278
Um, it pushed me towards entrepreneurship,
pushed me towards, uh, you know,

00:06:52.366 --> 00:06:55.795
starting my own firm, building
out a, a different type of, uh,

00:06:55.900 --> 00:06:57.813
uh, focus on where I wanted to go.

00:06:57.981 --> 00:07:01.300
And it was a, a, I think, a great
change in, in the direction.

00:07:01.783 --> 00:07:04.436
Um, so a few years later,
after I joined a couple of…

00:07:04.514 --> 00:07:07.123
and did some, uh, some work,
I went back to Northeastern

00:07:07.123 --> 00:07:08.661
as an executive MBA program.

00:07:08.663 --> 00:07:11.652
So, um, that was, that
was true- truly worth it.

00:07:12.253 --> 00:07:12.660
Very cool.

00:07:12.712 --> 00:07:16.770
And then, uh, so you finished
your MBA, and what was your first

00:07:16.770 --> 00:07:18.348
job out of, out of that program?

00:07:18.705 --> 00:07:20.012
Oh, af- after my MBA.

00:07:20.087 --> 00:07:23.607
Oh, well, yeah, uh, I
worked at monster.com.

00:07:23.708 --> 00:07:26.961
I don't know if you, that means much to
you, but everybody's probably heard of it.

00:07:27.224 --> 00:07:28.110
There's two Monsters.

00:07:28.112 --> 00:07:29.409
There's recruiting and cables.

00:07:29.441 --> 00:07:31.514
I'm assuming, uh, you did recruiting.

00:07:31.809 --> 00:07:33.370
Yeah, this was, uh, recruiting.

00:07:33.384 --> 00:07:37.119
This was basically all online and,
uh, I was, uh, the coolest part

00:07:37.119 --> 00:07:41.091
of the job was, uh, I was brought
in as a senior manager of, uh,

00:07:41.136 --> 00:07:42.687
e-commerce and e-business innovation.

00:07:43.027 --> 00:07:44.247
That was the title actually.

00:07:44.251 --> 00:07:46.967
So it was really, uh,
an exciting space to be.

00:07:47.305 --> 00:07:50.175
It was at the time when Monster
was really growing rapidly.

00:07:50.189 --> 00:07:52.854
It had some, uh, uh, super
people working there.

00:07:53.193 --> 00:07:58.403
Um, uh, we had, uh, a, a lot of open
dollars and availability of resources

00:07:58.646 --> 00:08:00.322
to build whatever we wanted to build.

00:08:00.718 --> 00:08:05.179
And, um, uh, you get to see, you
know, kind of the intricacies of how,

00:08:05.221 --> 00:08:08.746
um, you know, an internal e-commerce
site really operates and works.

00:08:09.159 --> 00:08:12.876
We learned all about, you know, uh, uh,
the business analyst side of things,

00:08:12.886 --> 00:08:16.868
the, the understanding the metrics, all
the different pieces that go into job

00:08:16.883 --> 00:08:18.639
hunting and, and that whole piece of it.

00:08:18.926 --> 00:08:22.436
I moved at, at Monster a couple
ranks up, uh, became a product

00:08:22.437 --> 00:08:24.688
dir- a product manager, and
then a product director there.

00:08:24.808 --> 00:08:25.946
So that was a load of fun.

00:08:26.347 --> 00:08:30.415
Um, uh, and I do miss little bits
of it, pieces of it, uh, but it,

00:08:30.464 --> 00:08:33.419
it was also, uh, just a stepping
stone to where I wanted to go.

00:08:33.840 --> 00:08:39.066
Um, I did, and you know, after Monster,
I left to, uh, move on to other types of

00:08:39.066 --> 00:08:40.638
things, and I started getting into retail.

00:08:40.976 --> 00:08:45.812
After a few other steppingstones in
between, uh, I joined Talbots, got, I

00:08:45.812 --> 00:08:50.462
got involved with, uh, Staples as well,
um, and both all on the e-commerce

00:08:50.462 --> 00:08:52.470
and, uh, you know, side of things.

00:08:52.683 --> 00:08:55.827
But it gave me an understanding of what
is needed from a digital perspective

00:08:55.840 --> 00:08:56.914
for a lot of these companies.

00:08:56.943 --> 00:09:00.487
At the time, they were all starting to
go through digital, initial stages of a

00:09:00.487 --> 00:09:04.425
digital transformation, and that was so
critical for retailer at that time, right?

00:09:04.425 --> 00:09:07.571
I mean, it was such a big change
and big stepping, and many retailers

00:09:07.572 --> 00:09:08.878
hadn't even gone through that yet.

00:09:09.303 --> 00:09:13.540
Um, so those were really nice steps to go
through and understand the space better.

00:09:14.018 --> 00:09:18.483
When you were at Talbots and Staples,
were you, um- Involved in, you know, that,

00:09:18.499 --> 00:09:20.518
that's kind of the era of re-platforming.

00:09:21.422 --> 00:09:24.487
Did, did you get involved in some of
those big re-platforming kind of things?

00:09:24.533 --> 00:09:24.779
Yeah.

00:09:25.127 --> 00:09:28.117
Yeah, there was a lot of that Yep.

00:09:28.402 --> 00:09:31.205
There was, there was s- several of those
projects that we, we were going through.

00:09:31.207 --> 00:09:34.267
We were also, you know, at Staples,
uh, head of personalization, which

00:09:34.267 --> 00:09:37.753
was an interesting space to be in
because they needed, they needed to

00:09:37.753 --> 00:09:41.115
kind of figure out what is, what is
this whole world of recommendations

00:09:41.115 --> 00:09:43.076
and online, uh, engagement all about.

00:09:43.404 --> 00:09:47.797
Um, uh, it, it gave me a different
perspective on what to think about

00:09:47.877 --> 00:09:51.430
when a company is really looking
to connect with the customer.

00:09:51.817 --> 00:09:55.248
And that was the biggest challenge for
a lot of retailers, figuring out what

00:09:55.248 --> 00:09:59.084
is that digital connection piece that
really makes it worth their while.

00:09:59.418 --> 00:10:01.007
And at the time they really didn't have…

00:10:01.083 --> 00:10:04.089
I mean, it was just at the beginning
and start of the omni-channel

00:10:04.089 --> 00:10:07.089
revolution, if you will, and where
everybody's looking at everything

00:10:07.089 --> 00:10:08.989
from a single, uh, single perspective.

00:10:09.367 --> 00:10:12.981
Um, and what I got out of that was,
you know, the average customer,

00:10:13.219 --> 00:10:15.192
when they're looking for a sweater,
they're looking for a sweater.

00:10:15.214 --> 00:10:16.693
They don't really care how they buy it.

00:10:16.751 --> 00:10:20.433
It doesn't matter if they're buying it in
store or online, through BOPIS, through

00:10:20.433 --> 00:10:24.618
whatever other tools that they have, BOPIS
being buy online, pick up in store, right?

00:10:24.902 --> 00:10:29.117
So, um, that was a, that was a
kind of a, a revelation, if you

00:10:29.117 --> 00:10:30.574
will, for the industry as a whole.

00:10:30.786 --> 00:10:34.300
And, and for me, just looking and
talking with the customers, engaging

00:10:34.300 --> 00:10:38.057
at that level, uh, changed my
perspective as well, uh, about what

00:10:38.057 --> 00:10:39.416
retail really needs to think about.

00:10:39.724 --> 00:10:40.282
It's kind of funny.

00:10:40.282 --> 00:10:41.655
They're, they're very much…

00:10:41.666 --> 00:10:45.313
All the omni-channel guys were
very resistant to, to marketplaces.

00:10:45.355 --> 00:10:49.835
Uh, and then suddenly Walmart and Target
ha- helped crack it up, crack it open.

00:10:49.835 --> 00:10:52.257
But then they've all become
obsessed with retail media

00:10:52.258 --> 00:10:53.801
networks, as you, as you know.

00:10:53.846 --> 00:10:56.442
And marketplaces are an unlock for that.

00:10:56.446 --> 00:11:00.404
So, so it's kind of come full circle
that the shiny bulb of getting some of

00:11:00.404 --> 00:11:04.198
these like pure margin ad dollars is
bringing them back into the marketplace

00:11:04.477 --> 00:11:06.181
conversation, a lot of these retailers.

00:11:06.503 --> 00:11:07.146
Absolutely.

00:11:07.170 --> 00:11:07.590
Absolutely.

00:11:07.593 --> 00:11:09.497
I, I think that's, that was a, you know…

00:11:09.499 --> 00:11:12.243
Retail media networks right
now I think are on such a tear.

00:11:12.609 --> 00:11:14.312
Um, they, you know, uh…

00:11:14.342 --> 00:11:17.172
I just saw this little article, I think
it's Kerry Masters, I believe, who was

00:11:17.172 --> 00:11:22.617
writing it, and she's i- in ar- up in arms
with another expert in this space, uh,

00:11:22.855 --> 00:11:24.766
about whether it matters or not, right?

00:11:26.348 --> 00:11:26.713
Yeah.

00:11:26.713 --> 00:11:29.167
It's this, uh, annoying
guy named Jason Goldberg.

00:11:29.482 --> 00:11:30.580
Oh, yes, exactly.

00:11:30.583 --> 00:11:30.969
That's right.

00:11:31.025 --> 00:11:33.076
I knew, I knew, I knew
there was something.

00:11:33.076 --> 00:11:34.799
He's kind of the grumpy
old man of e-commerce.

00:11:35.401 --> 00:11:37.023
I thought it was a cool argument, though.

00:11:37.065 --> 00:11:39.642
And, and he, and, you know, Jason
makes some good points, but I,

00:11:39.696 --> 00:11:40.834
I don't agree with him at all.

00:11:40.834 --> 00:11:44.873
I think, uh, retail media is
at its infancy, nascent stages.

00:11:44.890 --> 00:11:48.616
It's got a long, uh, you know, road
ahead, and I think it's gonna permeate

00:11:48.647 --> 00:11:53.057
not just retail media, but also AI and
other things that are really gonna change

00:11:53.351 --> 00:11:56.775
how programmatic works, how everything
will, will start operating in the future.

00:11:57.160 --> 00:11:59.953
People are gonna, you know, kind
of assume that it's gonna work.

00:12:00.003 --> 00:12:01.339
They're not gonna even see it happen.

00:12:01.339 --> 00:12:01.646
It's…

00:12:01.811 --> 00:12:02.881
That's the cool thing about AI.

00:12:02.881 --> 00:12:04.105
It's so embedded, right?

00:12:04.105 --> 00:12:07.595
It's almost invisible, uh, once
it's working properly, right?

00:12:07.661 --> 00:12:09.224
That's where, where I think it's headed.

00:12:09.295 --> 00:12:12.583
And people aren't even gonna think
about AI as something different and

00:12:12.583 --> 00:12:14.856
new and a shiny object down the road.

00:12:14.858 --> 00:12:18.062
It's all gonna be part of, oh, well,
you know, just like the internet

00:12:18.062 --> 00:12:19.416
or connecting to something, right?

00:12:19.416 --> 00:12:21.249
It's gonna be kind of routine.

00:12:21.657 --> 00:12:23.914
Uh, back to your bio, and then
we'll, we'll definitely wanna talk

00:12:23.916 --> 00:12:25.010
more about retail media networks.

00:12:25.262 --> 00:12:28.156
Uh, so you did a stint at
retailers, so you were on the,

00:12:28.187 --> 00:12:29.350
on that side of the house.

00:12:29.413 --> 00:12:31.063
Uh, and then you did some pontificating.

00:12:31.063 --> 00:12:33.967
I saw you were at Forrester,
and then you did a vendor.

00:12:33.980 --> 00:12:34.897
You were at Oracle.

00:12:35.269 --> 00:12:38.680
I, I was at, uh, Forrester for a
while, and then I went to, uh, yeah,

00:12:38.687 --> 00:12:40.426
and I was a retail analyst there.

00:12:40.460 --> 00:12:41.296
That was fun to do.

00:12:41.299 --> 00:12:42.211
I enjoyed that work.

00:12:42.239 --> 00:12:44.246
Uh, Forrester has actually
a great team of folks.

00:12:44.672 --> 00:12:47.169
Uh, not as good as IDC, of course,
but they're, they're there.

00:12:47.251 --> 00:12:53.243
I mean, uh, more importantly, um,
uh, the, the thing was, uh, uh, after

00:12:53.244 --> 00:12:56.526
that, I got a chance to go into the
vendor side, which was really exciting.

00:12:56.540 --> 00:13:00.085
Uh, Oracle and, and their RGBU,
their Retail Global Business Unit.

00:13:00.472 --> 00:13:03.839
Um, and we had some fantastic people
working on that side of the coin.

00:13:03.841 --> 00:13:07.723
I really got to see how these vendors
really opened up the doors, especially

00:13:07.729 --> 00:13:11.575
a company like Oracle, which has
end-to-end solutions, complete, um,

00:13:11.615 --> 00:13:15.194
you know, opportunities for people
to kind of, uh, register different

00:13:15.330 --> 00:13:18.939
parts of what they need, uh, and
then build that into their solutions.

00:13:19.221 --> 00:13:22.340
Now, there's lots of, uh, uh,
opportunities in, in vendors,

00:13:22.365 --> 00:13:23.587
in the vendor side anyway.

00:13:23.950 --> 00:13:27.028
Um, but, uh, Oracle kind of gave
me that opening and understanding

00:13:27.149 --> 00:13:30.479
a little bit better and, and,
and the problems that these, uh,

00:13:30.521 --> 00:13:34.031
companies had with implementation,
deployment, rolling out solutions.

00:13:34.508 --> 00:13:36.916
Um, so that was, that was
a great experience as well.

00:13:37.193 --> 00:13:39.095
That was 2018 to 2020.

00:13:39.162 --> 00:13:40.882
Um, the…

00:13:41.346 --> 00:13:44.346
Yeah, so that's post a,
a good bit of ATG, right?

00:13:44.346 --> 00:13:45.841
So they had integrated ATG.

00:13:45.861 --> 00:13:48.995
They kind, kind of turned it from
on-prem into hosted or at least an

00:13:49.002 --> 00:13:50.369
option to host, that kind of thing.

00:13:50.690 --> 00:13:53.182
Yeah, everything was all about,
at that time, it was all about

00:13:53.183 --> 00:13:54.046
moving to the cloud, right?

00:13:54.048 --> 00:13:56.180
I mean, that was the big play at the time.

00:13:56.216 --> 00:14:00.205
So that migration to the cloud, it was
talked about almost every other call

00:14:00.205 --> 00:14:03.581
that I was on and, um, you know, how
to, how to actually make that work.

00:14:03.999 --> 00:14:07.456
Uh, I think they did an okay job in
pulling that off at the end of the day,

00:14:07.456 --> 00:14:09.218
but it's a long-term process, right?

00:14:09.218 --> 00:14:12.344
I mean, every, every one of these
retailers that go down this path

00:14:12.441 --> 00:14:15.771
are putting a lot of money, effort,
time, resources into building that

00:14:15.771 --> 00:14:18.845
out and, you know, some of them
just don't quite get there because

00:14:18.847 --> 00:14:20.109
they didn't plan it out properly.

00:14:20.434 --> 00:14:23.867
Or they don't know or have the
understanding of what's coming, right?

00:14:23.867 --> 00:14:26.235
I mean, they don't understand
what they need to p-prepare for,

00:14:26.506 --> 00:14:27.815
the flexibility and agility.

00:14:27.822 --> 00:14:31.379
So those things, uh, I think
are all pieces of that puzzle.

00:14:31.965 --> 00:14:34.965
Went from there to Diebold
Nixdorf, uh, which was a real

00:14:34.966 --> 00:14:36.319
cool place to work as well.

00:14:36.319 --> 00:14:40.682
I was there as a, a pricing strategy,
uh, guy who, uh, instead of just on the

00:14:40.682 --> 00:14:44.062
strategy team in general, I was more on
the pricing strategy, uh, side of the

00:14:44.062 --> 00:14:46.111
equation, which was really exciting.

00:14:46.179 --> 00:14:50.854
Uh, went back to MIT to get a certificate
for that, uh, for pricing, which was fun.

00:14:51.292 --> 00:14:55.810
Um, and then, uh, uh, be- being able
to actually apply it in the market

00:14:56.162 --> 00:14:59.789
was even more exciting because, uh,
in the retail sector, that's such

00:14:59.790 --> 00:15:01.076
a critical piece of the puzzle.

00:15:01.481 --> 00:15:05.669
Um, both, uh, you know,
merchandising pricing as well as, uh,

00:15:05.727 --> 00:15:07.163
business-to-business pricing is…

00:15:07.218 --> 00:15:11.804
Yeah, so it, it was a, a great experience
to understand, uh, how Diebold Nixdorf,

00:15:11.804 --> 00:15:14.886
a point-of-sale vendor, was really
driving value across the board.

00:15:15.318 --> 00:15:19.200
A- and I also got to see a lot of really
new, uh, and cool innovations that they

00:15:19.200 --> 00:15:23.057
were putting out with their, uh, you know,
just their general point-of-sale tools.

00:15:23.470 --> 00:15:26.458
Self-service capabilities that they
were working with, and I don't know if

00:15:26.458 --> 00:15:31.083
you know anybody from there, but folks
like Matt Redwood and, and, uh, um, uh,

00:15:31.867 --> 00:15:35.737
a few others, uh, that were kind of,
uh, driving the show, um, were really

00:15:35.737 --> 00:15:39.882
driving and betting on self-service to
continue to grow, grow across the board.

00:15:39.897 --> 00:15:42.373
Scale was kind of the, the
name of the game at the time.

00:15:42.430 --> 00:15:44.942
And you get to, uh, go to the
bigger booths at NRF when you're,

00:15:45.042 --> 00:15:45.974
when you're with that vendor.

00:15:46.005 --> 00:15:47.203
Well, Oracle has one too.

00:15:47.239 --> 00:15:47.850
Yeah, you're in the…

00:15:48.049 --> 00:15:50.123
You're playing with the big
boys at, at the big show, yeah.

00:15:51.597 --> 00:15:54.085
But you also have to go on the whole
weekend when you're with those guys too.

00:15:56.550 --> 00:15:58.893
When you're a retailer, you can kind of
show up whenever you want, but, like,

00:15:58.893 --> 00:16:01.560
when you're a vendor at, in the big booth,
you gotta be there for the whole weekend.

00:16:02.782 --> 00:16:04.533
Um, and then how'd you land at IDC?

00:16:04.913 --> 00:16:09.683
So, uh, uh, so my former boss, Leslie
Hannah, she called me up and said,

00:16:09.722 --> 00:16:13.175
"Hey, Nada," or, you know, well, I don't
know if she called me up or I called

00:16:13.175 --> 00:16:14.962
her first or whatever, but we talked.

00:16:14.962 --> 00:16:18.414
I knew Leslie from before 'cause,
uh, she was-- she's just a smart

00:16:18.414 --> 00:16:22.180
person in the space, and she's, she's
been with us for such a long time

00:16:22.202 --> 00:16:25.381
in the, in the industry, and she
knows just about everything about it.

00:16:25.716 --> 00:16:29.627
Um, uh, but, uh, I tried to impress
her and did my best to do that.

00:16:29.792 --> 00:16:32.048
But whatever I did, it
seemed to have worked.

00:16:32.055 --> 00:16:34.847
She decided to bring me on,
on her team, which was great.

00:16:35.326 --> 00:16:35.622
Uh-

00:16:35.869 --> 00:16:37.825
There were no other candidates,
so you won by default.

00:16:38.376 --> 00:16:39.487
Maybe, maybe that was it.

00:16:40.065 --> 00:16:40.916
Won by default.

00:16:41.225 --> 00:16:44.811
Uh, but in any case, I'm just happy
that she, she brought me on the team.

00:16:44.867 --> 00:16:47.355
And that was the, that was the
kind of the s- the starting point.

00:16:47.692 --> 00:16:50.769
Um, uh, just recently I
took over, uh, her role.

00:16:50.769 --> 00:16:53.171
She retired from, from the,
the company just recently.

00:16:53.180 --> 00:16:57.594
So, um, I kind of, uh, now am, uh,
running, running our IDC retail

00:16:57.594 --> 00:16:59.320
intelligence team, which is, is a blast.

00:16:59.320 --> 00:16:59.780
It's fun.

00:17:00.108 --> 00:17:04.575
We have a super group of smart people, uh,
in just about every single aspect of the

00:17:04.577 --> 00:17:07.001
business, uh, when we think about retail.

00:17:07.032 --> 00:17:10.779
And what I really like about it is it has
a full-fledged team, and it's not just

00:17:10.779 --> 00:17:13.288
one or two people, uh, taking on retail.

00:17:13.300 --> 00:17:15.005
They really understand the retail space.

00:17:15.058 --> 00:17:17.814
Many of them have been there, worked
with retailers for so many years.

00:17:18.247 --> 00:17:23.196
Uh, and, um, uh, you know, that
alone gives a, uh, a very different

00:17:23.198 --> 00:17:25.327
perspective than some of our competitors.

00:17:25.372 --> 00:17:30.309
And not to dis- you know, uh, uh,
to plug, give myself a plug, but I

00:17:30.316 --> 00:17:34.780
think IDC is one of the best, uh,
retail, uh, research groups ever

00:17:34.894 --> 00:17:36.169
that I've met, that I've engaged.

00:17:36.614 --> 00:17:40.343
Um, that said, uh, you know,
uh, that's just a self plug.

00:17:40.855 --> 00:17:42.901
So that's really all
that, that really means.

00:17:43.290 --> 00:17:45.548
But, uh, it is a, it's a good team.

00:17:45.615 --> 00:17:47.624
Yeah, I do think it's
good to get it out there.

00:17:47.625 --> 00:17:52.177
So like, so retailers mostly, I imagine,
you know, in my mind, IDC goes way back.

00:17:52.178 --> 00:17:52.524
It's been…

00:17:52.536 --> 00:17:57.208
It's like one of the old, you know,
almost like, yeah, pr- precedes Gartner

00:17:57.208 --> 00:17:59.371
and Giga and For- all these things.

00:17:59.713 --> 00:18:03.990
Um, and you know, in my mind, it was
really tied to the computer industry for

00:18:03.990 --> 00:18:08.252
a long time, where IDC was kind of like,
you know, covering Dell and like the

00:18:08.254 --> 00:18:11.333
computer industry seems to be-- I think
that's my memory of how it was born.

00:18:11.750 --> 00:18:15.899
Um, and so I guess your customers
are very large, you know, you know,

00:18:16.339 --> 00:18:18.017
probably tend to be on the larger side.

00:18:18.063 --> 00:18:21.951
IDC's always been kind of like blue
chip, Fortune 500 type kind of thing.

00:18:22.213 --> 00:18:25.524
So you have the larger retailers,
which kind of implies omni-channel,

00:18:25.642 --> 00:18:27.080
'cause they tend to be the larger ones.

00:18:27.425 --> 00:18:32.398
And, and they, they pay you guys a
monthly fee to get research and to meet

00:18:32.400 --> 00:18:35.521
with you, and maybe they're thinking
about re-platforming or they want to

00:18:35.524 --> 00:18:39.549
talk about retail media networks, or do
you guys even go into, you know, being,

00:18:39.811 --> 00:18:42.354
you know, there's probably a physical--
you probably have pr- people on your

00:18:42.354 --> 00:18:46.101
team that are good at the point of sale
systems and, you know, all these things.

00:18:46.102 --> 00:18:47.438
Is that, is that how it works?

00:18:48.509 --> 00:18:49.129
Yeah, absolutely.

00:18:49.129 --> 00:18:51.557
So w- our team is kind of broken
out into different groups.

00:18:51.557 --> 00:18:56.486
We have Margot and Filippo working on
technologies and, uh, strategies inside

00:18:56.486 --> 00:18:59.951
the store, as well as, uh, you know,
experiential operations inside the store.

00:19:00.236 --> 00:19:03.495
Point of sale systems, for instance,
those are all part of, uh, their group.

00:19:03.669 --> 00:19:07.772
Uh, um, they also cover things like
technologies inside the store like,

00:19:07.778 --> 00:19:12.858
uh, you know, network systems, uh,
IT, uh, uh, capabilities, RFID.

00:19:12.881 --> 00:19:17.212
All of that is kind of covered
on that side Uh, digital pricing

00:19:17.215 --> 00:19:18.466
kind of falls under my bucket.

00:19:18.467 --> 00:19:21.381
I'm still also an analyst even
though I'm running the team.

00:19:21.381 --> 00:19:21.962
I'm still active.

00:19:22.290 --> 00:19:22.584
Yeah.

00:19:23.591 --> 00:19:26.823
Uh, the tags, uh, so ESL tags, um, okay.

00:19:26.823 --> 00:19:30.108
So those are kind of me and, uh,
Filippo are kind of covering that.

00:19:30.108 --> 00:19:30.993
I don't want to say it's all me.

00:19:31.421 --> 00:19:34.150
Uh, yeah, tag- we tag
team them, literally.

00:19:34.476 --> 00:19:37.761
Um, but more importantly, um, uh,
I think we have some great people

00:19:37.761 --> 00:19:39.129
on the supply chain side, too.

00:19:39.171 --> 00:19:41.659
Uh, Jo- Jordan, uh, Spear.

00:19:41.659 --> 00:19:46.678
We have Dorothy, who kind of, uh, runs
our, um, hospitality, travel, and dining.

00:19:46.969 --> 00:19:49.709
And then we have folks on media
and entertainment, Alex Holtz, who

00:19:49.711 --> 00:19:51.294
kind of covers that entire space.

00:19:51.646 --> 00:19:55.348
Um, so it, it, you know, really a
talented team just here in the US.

00:19:55.393 --> 00:19:59.994
And then we have folks in Europe, uh,
uh, Filippo and Ornella both, uh, working

00:19:59.994 --> 00:20:02.611
out of, uh, uh, Milan and, and UK.

00:20:02.967 --> 00:20:07.006
Uh, Ornella is covering, um, you know,
customer service, customer experience,

00:20:07.008 --> 00:20:12.528
as well as, uh, uh, CDPs, channels,
uh, and also, um, uh, loyalty programs.

00:20:12.849 --> 00:20:17.199
Uh, and then, um, uh, we have myself,
who covers merchandising, marketing,

00:20:17.245 --> 00:20:20.384
analytics, and specifically artificial
intelligence and retail media.

00:20:20.392 --> 00:20:23.402
So those are, uh, kind
of some of the team.

00:20:23.402 --> 00:20:27.310
There's some more team members as
well in Asia-Pac, but that's, uh,

00:20:27.342 --> 00:20:28.386
that just rounds out the team.

00:20:28.505 --> 00:20:30.891
And that's-- the thing about
it is it's a team, right?

00:20:30.893 --> 00:20:34.557
I mean, it's we all kind of interface
with, with our customers as needed,

00:20:34.906 --> 00:20:38.987
as opposed to kind of locking into
one particular rep who's-- or one

00:20:38.988 --> 00:20:43.017
particular analyst who's working with
a retailer or a vendor for that matter.

00:20:43.219 --> 00:20:43.440
Yeah.

00:20:43.441 --> 00:20:45.902
And retail used to be
kind of like a taxonomy.

00:20:45.909 --> 00:20:49.256
Like, you would talk about topic A or
B or C, and then it's quickly become

00:20:49.257 --> 00:20:50.896
a graph where it's all interconnected.

00:20:50.896 --> 00:20:55.278
And, you know, especially being the AI
guy, you, you could talk about digital

00:20:55.290 --> 00:20:58.454
price tags, point-of-sale systems,
and, you know, what we're gonna talk

00:20:58.465 --> 00:20:59.762
about, which is agentic shopping.

00:20:59.769 --> 00:21:01.355
The, it, yeah, yeah.

00:21:01.837 --> 00:21:02.849
All in the same conversation.

00:21:02.849 --> 00:21:06.395
So that's, that's one of the challenges
I think a lot of, uh, retailers

00:21:06.395 --> 00:21:08.030
are just starting to get a hang of.

00:21:08.362 --> 00:21:11.784
Um, they need to have to make
those conversations work.

00:21:11.819 --> 00:21:14.014
They need to have the data
in the same, same way.

00:21:14.221 --> 00:21:15.929
They need to have their
structure, their organizational

00:21:15.929 --> 00:21:17.386
structure operating the same way.

00:21:17.386 --> 00:21:19.993
They need to have, um, uh,
the resource structure for the

00:21:19.993 --> 00:21:21.590
technology to work the same way too.

00:21:21.852 --> 00:21:25.576
So all of those things make it that much
more difficult to kind of fit in to give

00:21:25.576 --> 00:21:27.997
a holistic view of the retail business.

00:21:28.361 --> 00:21:31.899
And I think that that's a, a great
stepping stone for anybody who's

00:21:31.899 --> 00:21:35.769
really, uh, who wants to understand
and, and get into the AI side of things.

00:21:36.075 --> 00:21:40.800
You know, when I started AI, it was-
wasn't in, you know, when I was doing my

00:21:40.800 --> 00:21:45.044
first job at Monster or, or anything like
that, or even before, uh, when I was in

00:21:45.319 --> 00:21:46.919
the defense contracting indus- industry.

00:21:47.316 --> 00:21:52.110
It was when I was in ninth grade, and I
wrote a, a, uh, a paper, uh, basically

00:21:52.112 --> 00:21:54.456
an essay about artificial intelligence.

00:21:54.937 --> 00:21:57.388
Those things at the time was
all about things like the

00:21:57.388 --> 00:21:58.923
Turing test and stuff like that.

00:21:58.931 --> 00:22:00.781
What, what really constitutes AI?

00:22:01.126 --> 00:22:03.603
Um, what, what does a
Bayesian model look like?

00:22:03.605 --> 00:22:05.326
What's a Markov model chains and stuff?

00:22:05.877 --> 00:22:10.073
These were things that were, uh, really
cool to read about and stuff, but it was

00:22:10.086 --> 00:22:12.363
almost like a, a future vision, right?

00:22:12.363 --> 00:22:13.120
A sci-fi vision.

00:22:13.305 --> 00:22:15.342
You can't actually achieve
that in that time period.

00:22:15.715 --> 00:22:17.892
This is 40 years ago
or something like that.

00:22:17.893 --> 00:22:18.834
I don't know how old I'm now.

00:22:19.121 --> 00:22:22.931
Don't wanna date myself on the
call, but it was a long time ago.

00:22:23.234 --> 00:22:27.871
Uh, and the main thing was, uh, you
know, the things that I had kind of hoped

00:22:27.919 --> 00:22:31.782
and wished for at the time when I was
writing that paper are coming true now.

00:22:31.790 --> 00:22:32.899
They're actually happening.

00:22:32.920 --> 00:22:38.491
You have real live LLMs that can actually
do the things that, uh, that were, you

00:22:38.491 --> 00:22:40.302
know, kind of imagined in those days.

00:22:40.632 --> 00:22:43.955
Um, and it's almost magical because,
uh, you know, it's new, it's

00:22:43.958 --> 00:22:46.021
technology, it's kind of cutting edge.

00:22:46.385 --> 00:22:49.573
Uh, and that's what makes it really
exciting to be in this space right now.

00:22:49.973 --> 00:22:52.422
So you were, you were into
this since ninth grade.

00:22:52.437 --> 00:22:53.119
When did…

00:22:53.485 --> 00:22:56.196
Did you raise your hand at IDC
and say, "I wanna do that?"

00:22:56.200 --> 00:22:59.799
Or like when ChatGPT dropped,
that's kind of-- To me, that's

00:22:59.799 --> 00:23:00.836
like when this really started.

00:23:01.176 --> 00:23:01.796
Yeah.

00:23:01.853 --> 00:23:04.430
Leslie asked me the question,
said, "Do you like AI?"

00:23:04.435 --> 00:23:05.045
I said, "Love it."

00:23:05.095 --> 00:23:07.681
And I said-- And she said, "Okay,
I'm gonna put you in charge of that."

00:23:07.748 --> 00:23:10.201
That's kinda how it worked,
and she was very good about it.

00:23:10.438 --> 00:23:13.311
But, uh, the thing is, uh, IDC
actually has put together a lot

00:23:13.311 --> 00:23:14.264
of effort behind it, though.

00:23:14.303 --> 00:23:17.885
We have other groups, uh, that
are more horiz- horizontal rather

00:23:17.885 --> 00:23:21.140
than vertical teams that are
dedicated specifically to AI.

00:23:21.189 --> 00:23:26.317
You know, Ritu Jyoti works a whole
team of AI-specific experts that

00:23:26.317 --> 00:23:27.847
really understand the space well.

00:23:28.171 --> 00:23:32.460
Uh, and they understand almost, uh, not
just the technology and the capabilities,

00:23:32.475 --> 00:23:35.899
but from that horizontal perspective
across all industries, if you will.

00:23:36.253 --> 00:23:40.115
Uh, and from technology companies that are
really pushing really hard to make sure

00:23:40.116 --> 00:23:42.385
that their AI gets to the top of the coin.

00:23:42.385 --> 00:23:45.325
You're talking about companies
like OpenAI, Microsoft,

00:23:45.333 --> 00:23:47.327
Google, Amazon, you name them.

00:23:47.726 --> 00:23:49.489
Um, they're all trying to push for that.

00:23:50.368 --> 00:23:51.642
ownership of this space.

00:23:51.714 --> 00:23:55.597
And I don't think it's gonna be that
easy to, uh, to say that, uh, that

00:23:55.672 --> 00:23:57.413
any one company will really dominate.

00:23:57.896 --> 00:24:01.112
Uh, matter of fact, I think it's going
to become a mix and then eventually

00:24:01.112 --> 00:24:04.743
it'll fade out into the points where,
um, there are many different players

00:24:04.753 --> 00:24:06.545
that are kind of, uh, contributing to it.

00:24:06.748 --> 00:24:06.971
Yep.

00:24:06.971 --> 00:24:09.916
So you, you probably have, I don't know
how many conversations a week, but a

00:24:09.917 --> 00:24:12.320
lot with big brands and manufacturers.

00:24:12.321 --> 00:24:14.777
What, what are some of
the top of mind topics?

00:24:14.777 --> 00:24:18.157
Like obviously I think AI, but let,
let's dig a little bit, like we

00:24:18.158 --> 00:24:19.707
mentioned retail media networks.

00:24:19.736 --> 00:24:22.915
Um, what, what are like maybe the
top three or four things that, that

00:24:22.916 --> 00:24:24.325
are on people's minds these days?

00:24:24.611 --> 00:24:28.775
If you just go to an NRF con- you know,
event, you'll see exactly what's going on.

00:24:28.776 --> 00:24:31.217
And they, they basically
all talk about AI obviously.

00:24:31.608 --> 00:24:33.959
Uh, AI is one of the big deal items.

00:24:34.001 --> 00:24:35.557
There's also retail media networks.

00:24:35.558 --> 00:24:37.717
I think that is also a
very hot topic right now.

00:24:38.026 --> 00:24:41.281
Um, but a lot of it also goes
back to some of the basics, the

00:24:41.281 --> 00:24:42.664
fundamentals of retail, right?

00:24:42.872 --> 00:24:45.702
How do you keep a store clean and make
sure that people come in the store?

00:24:45.870 --> 00:24:48.117
How do you, uh, you know,
drive traffic to a website?

00:24:48.153 --> 00:24:52.592
These things are still essential
components of retail and a lot

00:24:52.592 --> 00:24:54.982
of, uh, retailers, they're,
they're looking at that.

00:24:55.327 --> 00:24:58.301
The other piece that I think is
really important is, uh, data and

00:24:58.301 --> 00:25:02.733
data manipulation and I wouldn't call
it just manipulation, but also, uh,

00:25:02.789 --> 00:25:06.258
leveraging data to, to be able to
make decisions and good decisions.

00:25:06.667 --> 00:25:09.910
Decision-making data, which is a
different, uh, you know, context than

00:25:09.910 --> 00:25:13.213
just collecting data and then having it
sit there in some database someplace.

00:25:13.237 --> 00:25:17.139
It's the actual, uh, action-based
data that you can actually use to

00:25:17.139 --> 00:25:20.589
make good decisions that translate
into dollar value for the companies.

00:25:20.886 --> 00:25:24.298
That is where I think a huge amount
of effort is also placed, and that

00:25:24.299 --> 00:25:28.614
ties back right into retail media,
right into AI, right into some of

00:25:28.617 --> 00:25:31.949
the needs that come from the new
technologies that are out there.

00:25:32.113 --> 00:25:34.856
But yeah, it's still running a
business and operating it well.

00:25:35.265 --> 00:25:39.532
Let's talk about, um, so one of the
reasons that it kind of like spurred me

00:25:39.533 --> 00:25:44.226
to, to reach out to you was you wrote this
amazing paper, um, called "Win-Win Product

00:25:44.227 --> 00:25:47.182
Discovery: A Retail Agentic AI Use Case."

00:25:47.203 --> 00:25:50.310
And this is near and dear to my
heart because part of my theory

00:25:50.312 --> 00:25:53.810
here is, uh, so I, I have a
theory, so I'm a marketplace guy.

00:25:54.101 --> 00:25:57.293
I have a theory that, you know,
number one, I feel like e-commerce

00:25:57.295 --> 00:26:00.923
has really slowed down and not really
innovated on the user experience.

00:26:01.304 --> 00:26:02.443
That's theory number one.

00:26:02.494 --> 00:26:07.429
Theory number two is there's all this
activity of people using the, the LLMs.

00:26:07.682 --> 00:26:11.374
I think that's gonna spill over into
commercial, which is gonna spill over

00:26:11.396 --> 00:26:14.666
into commerce, and I think they're
looking to monetize, and I think

00:26:14.681 --> 00:26:16.455
commerce is the lowest hanging fruit.

00:26:16.458 --> 00:26:19.682
When you, you read all the surveys,
consumers are increasingly saying,

00:26:20.073 --> 00:26:23.383
"This thing's helping me research,"
and then I think they'll increasingly

00:26:23.387 --> 00:26:25.347
research, find, and buy products.

00:26:25.697 --> 00:26:30.677
Um, and then I think the other thing
I think a lot about is, and I learned

00:26:30.677 --> 00:26:35.162
this at Channelyzer, is our, our
product discovery engines are not great

00:26:35.195 --> 00:26:39.741
because, um, we, we have the lowest
common denominator problem that, uh,

00:26:39.764 --> 00:26:43.020
goes all the way down the, the whole
tech stack to the product catalog.

00:26:43.032 --> 00:26:47.094
It's, it's kind of, you know, the way it's
put together from different systems, the

00:26:47.151 --> 00:26:52.290
attributes it has and lacks are gonna be
a bit of a, uh, a challenge for retailers.

00:26:52.614 --> 00:26:53.988
So, so you're, you're, you're…

00:26:54.086 --> 00:26:57.245
Talk a little bit about the, what
led you to write this white paper

00:26:57.245 --> 00:27:00.205
and some of the things you discovered
or recommendations you're making.

00:27:00.663 --> 00:27:04.659
And yet I also discovered, I also
learned from this paper you, uh, you

00:27:04.660 --> 00:27:07.769
either play a lot of baseball or you
have sons that play baseball 'cause,

00:27:07.773 --> 00:27:11.246
uh, you have a, you go really-- I
was also shocked how deep you go.

00:27:11.247 --> 00:27:14.124
You go, like, way into
databases and retrieval.

00:27:14.348 --> 00:27:15.031
You go deep.

00:27:15.150 --> 00:27:18.551
Uh, so, so that's when I was kinda
like, "This guy has to be, like, an

00:27:18.552 --> 00:27:21.499
engineer or something because it's,
this is not surface level stuff."

00:27:21.991 --> 00:27:22.315
Yeah.

00:27:22.316 --> 00:27:22.571
Yeah.

00:27:22.571 --> 00:27:26.572
Well, the, uh, so the engineering, um,
background definitely helped a-and,

00:27:26.582 --> 00:27:29.753
and I appreciate that, and thank you
for the compliments about the report.

00:27:29.753 --> 00:27:34.280
I think it, um, more importantly, uh,
it came from above saying, you know,

00:27:34.280 --> 00:27:38.143
"We need something that's deeper than
just that s- you know, top level stuff.

00:27:38.143 --> 00:27:41.195
We need something that really goes into
how these things are working, what is

00:27:41.195 --> 00:27:46.104
the real value add that they're bringing
to the table, and then the benefits of

00:27:46.447 --> 00:27:48.688
bringing in understanding of that space."

00:27:48.974 --> 00:27:51.557
I think that was w- uh, the, the
question that was asked from one of

00:27:51.557 --> 00:27:52.913
my senior leaders at our company.

00:27:53.268 --> 00:27:58.510
Um- And, um, uh, more importantly, I think
the, the second piece to that was how do

00:27:58.511 --> 00:28:01.089
you apply it to, uh, a vertical, right?

00:28:01.124 --> 00:28:03.876
That was the question that was being
asked at, at this company meeting.

00:28:04.248 --> 00:28:08.150
And, um, uh, so I said, "You know,
there's some key use cases we've

00:28:08.150 --> 00:28:10.053
already put together for gen AI.

00:28:10.320 --> 00:28:13.340
Why don't we see what-- how that
fits in for agentic AI too?"

00:28:13.440 --> 00:28:16.351
And that's really what kind of
spurred me on to write the paper.

00:28:16.639 --> 00:28:21.497
Um, uh, it was also because I think
agentic AI is a, uh, is something

00:28:21.498 --> 00:28:24.977
that is gonna be overtaking the
market in the, in the future.

00:28:25.045 --> 00:28:27.804
I mean, without a doubt, it,
it will dominate eventually.

00:28:28.064 --> 00:28:31.106
And the problem for most people
to under- is the understanding

00:28:31.106 --> 00:28:32.262
of what it means, right?

00:28:32.341 --> 00:28:34.095
What is agentic AI in the first place?

00:28:34.313 --> 00:28:38.973
What is that concept of an agent, um,
uh, really doing the work for you?

00:28:39.326 --> 00:28:44.013
Uh, and I think there's some key pieces in
there that I talk about, such as, um, you

00:28:44.017 --> 00:28:45.943
know, reasoning and, and thinking engines.

00:28:46.012 --> 00:28:47.193
What do those really mean?

00:28:47.193 --> 00:28:49.555
What does that really, uh,
uh, you know, compose of?

00:28:49.847 --> 00:28:53.892
Um, the ability to con-constrain those
engines with RAG, for instance, or

00:28:53.893 --> 00:28:57.928
retrieval augmented generation, for
instance, or, um, uh, build-building

00:28:57.928 --> 00:29:01.415
in, uh, capabilities that actually take
it to the next level of where you have

00:29:01.585 --> 00:29:05.215
multi agents or a sequence of agents
that are actually doing multiple problems

00:29:05.215 --> 00:29:08.147
at a time to come up with, "Here's
the sequence of what you need to do."

00:29:08.453 --> 00:29:10.563
And lastly, probably, uh, orchestration.

00:29:10.574 --> 00:29:14.333
That's a key component to the, to
the whole concept of agentic AI,

00:29:14.623 --> 00:29:17.411
where you're orchestrating several
different pieces together, and the

00:29:17.411 --> 00:29:18.820
tool is doing that orchestrating.

00:29:18.820 --> 00:29:21.890
It's just like it's doing, uh, you
know, the probability-based, uh,

00:29:22.243 --> 00:29:25.673
uh, estimation of, uh, the next
sentence it's gonna talk back to

00:29:25.673 --> 00:29:28.148
you about whatever topic you ask it.

00:29:28.485 --> 00:29:31.424
Uh, it has to do the same thing for
here's the sequence of actions that

00:29:31.424 --> 00:29:34.393
you need to take to accomplish this
goal or whatever that task might be.

00:29:34.735 --> 00:29:38.439
Um, so, uh, and, and I should
probably add one more thing, and

00:29:38.439 --> 00:29:39.688
then it's the execution, right?

00:29:39.733 --> 00:29:41.930
It has to be connected to
something that's then running

00:29:41.932 --> 00:29:43.276
that program and executing on.

00:29:43.549 --> 00:29:46.933
So once you have all those pieces-
So, uh, and that makes it a real

00:29:47.028 --> 00:29:50.722
function as opposed to just a, a
theoretical, uh, a theoretical one.

00:29:51.009 --> 00:29:55.036
And I think, um, uh, uh, that was
what I tried to, uh, explain here and

00:29:55.038 --> 00:29:58.422
to show in the form of a use case,
and I took this one use case here.

00:29:58.795 --> 00:30:02.331
Uh, but I'm gonna-- we're gonna see this
happen across many different retail use

00:30:02.331 --> 00:30:04.506
cases down the road, not just one or two.

00:30:04.861 --> 00:30:08.631
Even our gen AI taxonomy that
we've developed, um, really covers

00:30:08.643 --> 00:30:11.740
something like, uh, you know, 20
different use cases that are, are

00:30:11.741 --> 00:30:14.002
primary, uh, uh, use cases out there.

00:30:14.221 --> 00:30:18.147
And to your point, uh, Scott, a lot
of them are in the space of digital

00:30:18.229 --> 00:30:22.982
eCommerce product, uh, you know, uh,
descriptions and, and similar, uh, that

00:30:22.984 --> 00:30:26.456
are, uh, in many cases, productivity
related right now and efficiency

00:30:26.456 --> 00:30:30.541
related, but in the future, they will be
revenue and sales growth related, right?

00:30:30.555 --> 00:30:35.364
It's gonna change and shift in time, uh,
towards something far more, um, important

00:30:35.386 --> 00:30:37.889
to the retailer I shouldn't say important.

00:30:38.135 --> 00:30:41.206
I think cost saving is just as
important, but, uh, you're gonna see

00:30:41.206 --> 00:30:44.856
it become more, uh, real for, from a
dollar and bottom line point of view,

00:30:45.380 --> 00:30:46.769
um, from profitability point of view.

00:30:46.878 --> 00:30:48.230
So that's, that's gonna be cool to see.

00:30:48.623 --> 00:30:52.330
So when you're talking about agents,
sometimes I, I hear people kind of use

00:30:52.330 --> 00:30:55.770
these interchangeably, and I think as an
industry we need a little clarification.

00:30:56.248 --> 00:31:00.072
I kinda think there's, there's kind of
meta agents that are gonna look across

00:31:00.260 --> 00:31:03.794
sites, and then there's like intra
agents that are gonna look inside a site.

00:31:03.795 --> 00:31:08.355
So Rufus and Sparky are examples of,
of agentic shopping that lives, you

00:31:08.355 --> 00:31:12.746
know, they're within the, the walled
garden of an Amazon or a Walmart.

00:31:13.101 --> 00:31:14.753
Um, and then you all…

00:31:14.781 --> 00:31:17.081
You know, there's another one
that's kind of more like, you know,

00:31:17.188 --> 00:31:20.087
Perplexity Buy with Pro, which
is looking across all retailers.

00:31:20.113 --> 00:31:21.473
Do you, do you…

00:31:21.636 --> 00:31:23.751
Or are you, are you generally
talking about either of those,

00:31:23.751 --> 00:31:26.949
or are you specifically talking
about retailers should be

00:31:26.949 --> 00:31:28.896
implementing the Sparky-like thing?

00:31:28.896 --> 00:31:30.145
Or what, what's your
point of view on that?

00:31:30.741 --> 00:31:33.546
There's, there's conditions and
different use cases for both.

00:31:33.546 --> 00:31:33.810
Yeah.

00:31:33.810 --> 00:31:36.556
And both of those things will be
adopted over time by retailers.

00:31:36.569 --> 00:31:38.158
You can't just stick
with one or the other.

00:31:38.511 --> 00:31:41.404
Uh, sometimes you need to have
that constraining structure

00:31:41.406 --> 00:31:42.759
behind, uh, what you're doing.

00:31:42.759 --> 00:31:46.815
You need to have the, the blocks to,
to get answers quickly and to have more

00:31:46.815 --> 00:31:50.933
relevant answers anyway to whatever you're
asking for, uh, whether it's execution,

00:31:50.944 --> 00:31:54.293
whether it's actual question, uh, a
generic question that you're asking.

00:31:54.623 --> 00:31:58.625
Uh, so Rufus, Sparky, these guys are gonna
be very important, but just as much as,

00:31:58.684 --> 00:32:01.375
uh, you know, all the models that come
with Perplexity, and they've, they've

00:32:01.425 --> 00:32:03.164
worked with Claude, with Gemini, with…

00:32:03.454 --> 00:32:06.122
You know, they, they got all of these
different models already built in.

00:32:06.456 --> 00:32:08.042
Um, ChatGPT of course.

00:32:08.092 --> 00:32:10.814
And, and so you'll see,
see a lot of that as well.

00:32:11.078 --> 00:32:15.530
I think, um, uh, the example I wanted
to give here was where do you start?

00:32:15.653 --> 00:32:17.988
Kind of here's one example
case that makes sense.

00:32:18.288 --> 00:32:22.785
Um, it's, it's a, a fundamental case for
retail anyway, which is product discovery.

00:32:22.796 --> 00:32:24.953
How do you actually go about
finding the products you want?

00:32:25.336 --> 00:32:28.671
Uh, and then what are the tools and
capabilities that help you as a consumer

00:32:28.673 --> 00:32:30.510
in some cases, and then also the retailer?

00:32:30.887 --> 00:32:33.681
One of the interesting things
about this, um, this particular

00:32:33.681 --> 00:32:36.595
use case is it's a win-win for
both the retailer and the consumer.

00:32:36.992 --> 00:32:40.508
Consumer can find the things that they
want faster and more effectively, uh,

00:32:40.546 --> 00:32:43.890
and the retailer is able to push and
upsell and cross-sell items that are

00:32:43.890 --> 00:32:48.118
more relevant to the consumer as well,
um, allowing for both, uh, parties to

00:32:48.120 --> 00:32:52.196
become, uh, you know, uh, get that,
uh, value add at the end of the day.

00:32:52.456 --> 00:32:55.219
I think that's an important
component to keep in mind, uh, when

00:32:55.219 --> 00:32:57.383
they're thinking about what types
of stuff they wanna build out.

00:32:57.591 --> 00:33:02.832
If it's just, uh, you know- value for one
group or the other, it's, um, it's gonna

00:33:02.842 --> 00:33:06.965
have some challenges in becoming adopted,
becoming, uh, you know, uh, driven as a,

00:33:07.031 --> 00:33:09.099
as a major value add across the board.

00:33:09.181 --> 00:33:09.364
Yeah.

00:33:09.367 --> 00:33:10.551
Let's, let's dig into that.

00:33:10.564 --> 00:33:12.997
That, that's interesting 'cause a
lot of the retailers I've talked to,

00:33:12.997 --> 00:33:16.460
there's a fear that they're gonna be
disintermediate- disintermediated, right?

00:33:16.460 --> 00:33:16.858
So this…

00:33:17.168 --> 00:33:20.424
The-- they want a, they want a human to
come to the website and then upsell them

00:33:20.427 --> 00:33:24.574
stuff, and you're, you're kind of making
it sound like if you can get good at

00:33:24.597 --> 00:33:28.868
your agent talking to the, the buyer's
agent, then there still will be upsells.

00:33:28.881 --> 00:33:30.503
Is that, uh, kinda what
you think is gonna happen?

00:33:30.775 --> 00:33:34.202
Actually, I think in the future,
the agents are not gonna be, uh,

00:33:34.216 --> 00:33:35.782
recognizable, uh, from a human.

00:33:35.957 --> 00:33:38.180
You know, they're gonna have
almost the same capabilities.

00:33:38.180 --> 00:33:41.255
They're gonna have almost the same
figuring-- ability to figure out

00:33:41.255 --> 00:33:42.843
something like, "Oh, that's a promotion.

00:33:42.851 --> 00:33:46.151
Maybe I should take advantage of that
now because it's, you know, it's up

00:33:46.152 --> 00:33:49.202
there for 15 seconds," or whatever
amount of time they're gonna give you.

00:33:49.534 --> 00:33:54.503
Um, because, uh, my, my human
overlord, uh, is saying that they

00:33:54.503 --> 00:33:57.698
want the best, you know, product
at the lowest possible cost, right?

00:33:57.698 --> 00:34:01.104
So, uh, there, there's gonna be
a lot of that as well, uh, and

00:34:01.105 --> 00:34:02.530
that's gonna take experimentation.

00:34:02.532 --> 00:34:06.322
That's gonna take, you know,
exploration of, of these places, spaces.

00:34:06.717 --> 00:34:09.880
But there's no doubt that those
things are gonna evolve over time,

00:34:09.973 --> 00:34:11.403
uh, to become more human-like.

00:34:11.406 --> 00:34:14.312
I think that's just inherent to,
uh, the nature of our business.

00:34:14.423 --> 00:34:18.549
Do you see a day where agentic
traffic exceeds human traffic?

00:34:18.843 --> 00:34:20.183
And it's like, can you…

00:34:20.509 --> 00:34:21.572
Do you have, do you have a prediction?

00:34:21.572 --> 00:34:24.166
Is that like, are we 12 months
away from that or like five years?

00:34:24.511 --> 00:34:27.078
Oh, I don't have a date, but
I, I know it's gonna happen.

00:34:27.094 --> 00:34:27.567
It's, uh…

00:34:27.615 --> 00:34:29.297
And it'll happen sooner than later.

00:34:29.380 --> 00:34:33.477
We're-- We don't know right now, but
because it's an exponential trend, uh,

00:34:33.504 --> 00:34:34.958
I think it'll be adopted very quickly.

00:34:34.984 --> 00:34:38.526
People will start seeing more and
more of this- All they need is one,

00:34:38.526 --> 00:34:42.644
just like ChatGPT shot through the
roof, uh, in November 20th, 2022.

00:34:42.989 --> 00:34:44.881
Um, same thing is gonna happen here.

00:34:44.890 --> 00:34:48.881
You're just gonna see one or two examples
or one, two use cases, and then people

00:34:48.883 --> 00:34:51.392
will start adopting like never before.

00:34:51.695 --> 00:34:52.631
Oh, there's my agent.

00:34:52.632 --> 00:34:53.274
I've got one.

00:34:53.313 --> 00:34:54.608
I got my own personal agent.

00:34:54.901 --> 00:34:57.498
People with more money will, uh,
you know, have their own fleets of

00:34:57.498 --> 00:34:59.453
agents and, and they'll use them.

00:34:59.497 --> 00:35:02.862
I mean, it'll be a lot easier for
them to go out and, "Oh, I love

00:35:02.862 --> 00:35:05.959
that coat that that celebrity
was wearing online," you know.

00:35:06.072 --> 00:35:08.602
"Let me, let me see where I can
get that for a low cost," right?

00:35:08.667 --> 00:35:09.976
Click, there you go.

00:35:10.052 --> 00:35:10.943
A few days later, like…

00:35:11.120 --> 00:35:15.663
Or maybe not days, maybe the same day the,
the coat is arriving at your door, right?

00:35:15.689 --> 00:35:19.543
So that's the kind of thing that I
think is, uh, is, is gonna be inherent

00:35:19.578 --> 00:35:21.582
to the mo- models of, of the future.

00:35:21.948 --> 00:35:23.902
Um, but that's still a ways away.

00:35:23.928 --> 00:35:26.909
We still have some work to do to
get that working to that level.

00:35:27.291 --> 00:35:30.045
But, uh, yeah, it's all gonna
be, it's all about human nature.

00:35:30.045 --> 00:35:33.435
We're all greedy for stuff and we're
still materialistic in a lot of ways.

00:35:33.883 --> 00:35:36.949
When retailers-- I'm sure this report
stimulated a lot of discussions.

00:35:36.949 --> 00:35:38.751
When retailers say, "Okay, I get it.

00:35:38.794 --> 00:35:40.989
This, these shopping agents
are gonna be coming to my site.

00:35:41.491 --> 00:35:42.465
What should I do today?"

00:35:42.465 --> 00:35:43.278
What, what's your…

00:35:43.306 --> 00:35:45.069
Do you have some tactical recommendations?

00:35:45.313 --> 00:35:49.273
What they have to do, start thinking
about is, um, uh, setting up sites

00:35:49.299 --> 00:35:52.434
that are able to cater to both
humans as well as non-humans, right?

00:35:52.446 --> 00:35:54.111
I mean, as well as to
agents for that matter.

00:35:54.504 --> 00:35:58.787
Uh, and, uh, that doesn't mean, uh,
necessarily changing everything nes-

00:35:58.872 --> 00:36:02.281
uh, you know, from the start, but it
has to be easy for, uh, agents and

00:36:02.292 --> 00:36:03.982
humans to be able to operate on those.

00:36:04.280 --> 00:36:06.555
Um, it may still use
the same types of stuff.

00:36:06.555 --> 00:36:10.306
The whole, uh, concept of gen AI
and, and, you know, that I think

00:36:10.307 --> 00:36:14.453
is really, uh, has been the major
change is that it now understands

00:36:14.455 --> 00:36:16.232
things at the human level, right?

00:36:16.513 --> 00:36:19.248
So, um, an agent should
be able to do that too.

00:36:19.286 --> 00:36:22.329
The only distinction there is it'll
be able to do it faster, right?

00:36:22.332 --> 00:36:27.190
It'll be able to figure out stuff in two
seconds other, rather than 30 seconds that

00:36:27.190 --> 00:36:30.694
it takes for a human being to con- you
know, conceptualize a page and figure out

00:36:30.694 --> 00:36:34.693
what's on it and, and do what- whatever's,
uh, you know, uh, associated with it.

00:36:34.707 --> 00:36:38.430
So I think, um, uh, you're gonna be
able-- You're gonna have to have tools

00:36:38.432 --> 00:36:40.562
that are able to capture it very quickly.

00:36:40.563 --> 00:36:42.321
You'll have to have
real-time capabilities.

00:36:42.638 --> 00:36:46.247
You'll have to have, um, the ability
to think like a human first and

00:36:46.248 --> 00:36:48.049
then like a hu- and an agent second.

00:36:48.385 --> 00:36:51.457
Agents are still have, maybe may
have one or two purpose points.

00:36:51.754 --> 00:36:54.416
Uh, and the initial set of agents
are still gonna be a little slower

00:36:54.426 --> 00:36:58.682
at being able to capture, let's say,
uh, sentiment or, um, uh, what a

00:36:58.682 --> 00:37:02.716
picture might be representing for,
for a, a juicy hamburger on the

00:37:02.716 --> 00:37:03.980
screen or something like that, right?

00:37:04.253 --> 00:37:07.411
But, um, ultimately those agents
are gonna understand that too.

00:37:07.620 --> 00:37:10.512
I mean, that's not gonna be
difficult for or challenging for

00:37:10.512 --> 00:37:11.706
them in the not-too-distant future.

00:37:11.782 --> 00:37:12.023
Okay.

00:37:12.023 --> 00:37:13.115
So you need, you know…

00:37:13.124 --> 00:37:17.663
What, what, w- we're having conversations
with retailers too, and you know,

00:37:17.664 --> 00:37:20.766
what, what we have found is looking
at the current agents that are out

00:37:20.767 --> 00:37:22.970
there, they, they love context.

00:37:22.994 --> 00:37:25.847
It's just like that's their- You
know, context window and everything.

00:37:26.115 --> 00:37:29.055
So the more attributes you can give
them, like you normally wouldn't show…

00:37:29.127 --> 00:37:31.236
Y-you know this being an
engineering person, right?

00:37:31.236 --> 00:37:34.582
Like, you're not gonna show someone
the, you, you're gonna give them…

00:37:34.798 --> 00:37:37.615
Humans are looking maybe for three
or four bullet points, but the

00:37:37.648 --> 00:37:39.713
LLM wants like 1,000 data points.

00:37:39.713 --> 00:37:43.406
You know, it, the more it can learn
about the product and it, you know,

00:37:43.419 --> 00:37:46.699
it's makes, it's life, life easier
if they could just all be on the PDP.

00:37:46.711 --> 00:37:47.912
So they're, you know, the…

00:37:48.061 --> 00:37:50.610
W- I think one way it's gonna be
different is the human PDP is gonna

00:37:50.610 --> 00:37:53.865
be this beautiful, very imagey thing,
and I think the other one's gonna

00:37:53.866 --> 00:37:55.414
look like a spec sheet basically.

00:37:55.608 --> 00:37:58.528
That, you know, I think the LLM
would like much prefer a spec sheet.

00:37:58.579 --> 00:38:02.004
Like, you know, give me some images
and stuff, but any content and image,

00:38:02.004 --> 00:38:05.398
just like give it to me in text and,
and I'll, I'll gobble that up, and I'll

00:38:05.402 --> 00:38:06.950
be able to make recommendations up.

00:38:07.578 --> 00:38:08.279
What do you think about that?

00:38:08.955 --> 00:38:10.415
Yeah, that's a, that's a good theory.

00:38:10.418 --> 00:38:13.941
I think that's how it'll start for sure,
but I don't think that's how it'll end up.

00:38:14.057 --> 00:38:17.397
I think, uh, what'll happen is, um,
uh, and, and here's the reason why.

00:38:17.826 --> 00:38:20.397
The agent will go and find that
information elsewhere, right?

00:38:20.442 --> 00:38:23.009
They're not gonna look at your
site necessarily to find that, the

00:38:23.010 --> 00:38:26.026
specs on that particular product
or how well people adopt it.

00:38:26.230 --> 00:38:28.705
They'll find stuff and data points
that are associated with that

00:38:28.705 --> 00:38:32.124
product that you never even knew
were associated with that product.

00:38:32.543 --> 00:38:36.713
Um, an example might simply be I'm
going to the site, I see, uh, let's

00:38:36.744 --> 00:38:38.368
take baseball bats for s- for instance.

00:38:38.717 --> 00:38:40.571
I, I have 1,000 baseball bats.

00:38:40.571 --> 00:38:41.259
Here's, uh, uh…

00:38:41.532 --> 00:38:44.083
It's gonna go out and find out
which baseball players, Major

00:38:44.083 --> 00:38:46.929
League baseball players actually use
that bat, and it'll come back and

00:38:46.929 --> 00:38:48.858
use that as a crit- criteria now-

00:38:48.927 --> 00:38:49.080
Yeah

00:38:49.085 --> 00:38:52.851
to identify which bat is best for
this particular client, and it doesn't

00:38:52.852 --> 00:38:54.081
need to do that from your site.

00:38:54.098 --> 00:38:55.297
It'll actually do it on its own.

00:38:55.298 --> 00:38:58.282
It'll figure out how to do it on, on its
own and where to find that information on

00:38:58.292 --> 00:38:58.549
its own.

00:38:58.549 --> 00:38:58.569
Good point.

00:38:58.806 --> 00:39:00.935
So I think that's really
where it'll eventually get to.

00:39:00.936 --> 00:39:01.182
Yeah.

00:39:01.659 --> 00:39:03.479
Uh, but to start off, yes, absolutely.

00:39:03.481 --> 00:39:04.654
The spec sheet is important.

00:39:04.724 --> 00:39:08.881
It's gonna be, uh, it'll make it
easier for, um, uh, the retailer…

00:39:08.905 --> 00:39:10.792
I'm sorry, uh, whoever's using it.

00:39:10.836 --> 00:39:11.708
It's not just retailers.

00:39:11.708 --> 00:39:12.810
I think it'll be beyond that.

00:39:13.234 --> 00:39:16.060
Uh, and more importantly, it,
it's around the metadata, right?

00:39:16.074 --> 00:39:20.572
It's all about that metadata set that is
describing what you're looking at, that

00:39:20.572 --> 00:39:22.041
context that you just mentioned here.

00:39:22.400 --> 00:39:26.287
I think that's such a cr- key
component, um- Because it's the

00:39:26.288 --> 00:39:30.198
main piece that's, uh, been eluding
much of our past technology.

00:39:30.686 --> 00:39:33.177
Um, and, uh, we just haven't
been able to capture that.

00:39:33.179 --> 00:39:36.888
Now that we can and we have the compute
power to, compute power to do it,

00:39:37.322 --> 00:39:39.079
uh, it changes the game completely.

00:39:39.155 --> 00:39:42.466
Since you're the broader AI guy, I could
talk about this agentic shopping forever,

00:39:42.466 --> 00:39:43.940
but let, let's mix it up a little bit.

00:39:44.349 --> 00:39:47.829
Um, I think it's interesting too to
think through, you know, so, so if

00:39:47.829 --> 00:39:50.897
you think about the foundation retail
is built on, there's this product

00:39:50.908 --> 00:39:53.186
catalog and inventory and supply chain.

00:39:53.645 --> 00:39:57.195
There's also, you've talked about pricing,
you obviously have a passion for that.

00:39:57.519 --> 00:40:01.761
Um, and then there's like loyalty and,
and you mentioned that, uh, as we were

00:40:01.768 --> 00:40:03.825
chatting, um, and personalization.

00:40:04.494 --> 00:40:08.779
In, in a-- You know, it's gonna be
interesting, do you think those, those

00:40:08.809 --> 00:40:13.261
elements of the foundation have an
agentic flavor and a human flavor as well?

00:40:13.261 --> 00:40:17.335
Because you could see this agent-agent
protocols being developed that, you

00:40:17.335 --> 00:40:21.752
know, to your point, you say maybe
your agent says, "Hey, I know," you

00:40:21.754 --> 00:40:25.671
know, maybe part of your prompt is, "I
kind of need this baseball bat today."

00:40:25.728 --> 00:40:29.691
So that's gives me the context that
Andy's son has a game today and he broke

00:40:29.692 --> 00:40:31.370
a bat, now he needs a new one or whatever.

00:40:31.634 --> 00:40:33.915
You know, and, and maybe I
make you a special offer if you

00:40:33.917 --> 00:40:34.903
buy in the next five minute.

00:40:35.120 --> 00:40:35.635
So there's gonna be…

00:40:35.810 --> 00:40:38.921
But then on, on the retailer side,
there's gonna be this calculus of,

00:40:38.948 --> 00:40:42.320
you know, maybe I'm swimming in this
one baseball bat and I say, "If you

00:40:42.320 --> 00:40:46.319
buy this one Easton bat, I'll, I,
I'd be happy to give you 10% off."

00:40:46.644 --> 00:40:50.485
It's a little bit, you know, you, you
told me $100 price point, I'm gonna

00:40:50.494 --> 00:40:53.281
get you to $150 with a discount and
maybe get a little bit more out of

00:40:53.282 --> 00:40:54.879
you because I'm swimming in this.

00:40:54.901 --> 00:40:58.574
I've got a lot of inventory on this
bat or a better margin or whatever.

00:40:58.851 --> 00:41:00.382
Do you-- Yeah.

00:41:00.556 --> 00:41:01.478
Is that, is that a…

00:41:01.947 --> 00:41:04.084
How are all, how are all, some of
these things gonna play out, you think?

00:41:05.325 --> 00:41:05.647
Wow.

00:41:05.688 --> 00:41:07.707
That's a, that's a deep
question there, Scott.

00:41:08.163 --> 00:41:10.280
You asked me to predict the
future for the next, uh-

00:41:10.542 --> 00:41:11.302
That's your job.

00:41:11.312 --> 00:41:12.099
You're, uh, you're…

00:41:12.485 --> 00:41:14.555
It says there ri- retail insights.

00:41:14.912 --> 00:41:15.615
It's right there in your title.

00:41:15.628 --> 00:41:16.959
That doesn't mean I know it all.

00:41:17.085 --> 00:41:17.269
Oh,

00:41:17.826 --> 00:41:18.524
we know you don't know it all.

00:41:18.524 --> 00:41:18.701
That's the

00:41:18.701 --> 00:41:19.845
whole fun part of it,
like- Just this is my job.

00:41:20.257 --> 00:41:23.900
So what I, I, I'll give you my
thinking on it, and, and, and you

00:41:23.901 --> 00:41:25.042
can take it the way you want, right?

00:41:25.062 --> 00:41:25.978
I mean, maybe that's, uh…

00:41:26.167 --> 00:41:28.112
So I'll, I'll give you my thinking on it.

00:41:28.133 --> 00:41:33.565
So I think there's going to be a, um, uh,
so yes, there is that connectivity between

00:41:33.565 --> 00:41:37.234
the agent and agent, uh, onga- ongoing,
and I think that's gonna become more

00:41:37.234 --> 00:41:40.033
and more, um, uh, important over time.

00:41:40.346 --> 00:41:44.003
There's gonna be, um, uh,
agents of agents, if you will.

00:41:44.332 --> 00:41:47.413
Literally an agent who's operating on
the behalf of several other agents in

00:41:47.413 --> 00:41:51.244
the, in the, in the background who's
doing their task, and it's not gonna be

00:41:51.290 --> 00:41:55.043
kind of like an orchestration agent, but
an agent who's just like a travel agent

00:41:55.043 --> 00:41:57.078
would on beha- on somebody else's behalf.

00:41:57.421 --> 00:42:00.620
Um, the same type of functionality,
but it's on behalf of other agents.

00:42:00.644 --> 00:42:03.646
So the overlord's no longer human,
they're an agent of some sort.

00:42:04.010 --> 00:42:07.917
So I think that's gonna also be, uh,
the kind of that multi-structure, if

00:42:07.920 --> 00:42:10.244
you will, of, uh, being able to engage.

00:42:10.393 --> 00:42:13.089
What I think is gonna happen over
time though is, uh, there's gonna

00:42:13.089 --> 00:42:14.768
be a level of authenticity, right?

00:42:14.768 --> 00:42:18.998
You're gonna have to find out where is
that human in that loop, and, uh, how,

00:42:19.037 --> 00:42:23.300
uh, you know, and put more prioritization
and, and engagement with that human side

00:42:23.301 --> 00:42:25.449
of it wherever they are in that process.

00:42:25.676 --> 00:42:28.699
Whether they're the ones who say, "Oh,
go find me a bat," or whether they're

00:42:28.699 --> 00:42:32.455
the ones say, um, uh, that ha- kind
of gave the initial instruction of,

00:42:32.767 --> 00:42:35.928
uh, "Let's get this done in a day," or
whether they have a problem that they

00:42:35.928 --> 00:42:39.248
just don't know how to solve, and the
agent is then re- representing that,

00:42:39.500 --> 00:42:43.027
uh, that particular human in trying
to get something in a day, the broken

00:42:43.030 --> 00:42:44.294
bat or whatever example you give.

00:42:44.580 --> 00:42:49.078
So I think, um, we're gonna see a lot
of, uh, of, uh, experimentation up to

00:42:49.079 --> 00:42:53.084
the point where, um, then there, uh,
there will be eventually a prioritization

00:42:53.085 --> 00:42:56.631
of what's most important versus what's
second most important, third, et cetera,

00:42:56.862 --> 00:42:57.892
and they have to figure that out.

00:42:57.939 --> 00:42:59.494
The, the agents themselves will do that.

00:42:59.853 --> 00:43:02.843
We had a problem like this
before with IoT, if you remember.

00:43:02.866 --> 00:43:04.859
Uh, we've been talking about
that in the past, right?

00:43:05.162 --> 00:43:08.572
Where, uh, you know, all these internet
c- you know, computers would be talking

00:43:08.573 --> 00:43:11.847
to each other, and there is some
of that that goes on, uh, for sure.

00:43:11.847 --> 00:43:14.755
But it didn't expand and explode
like everybody thought it would.

00:43:15.081 --> 00:43:16.808
I think agents are gonna
be a little bit different.

00:43:16.819 --> 00:43:19.505
There will be a little bit of an
explosion there, and people will

00:43:19.538 --> 00:43:21.860
devise, uh, tools to do some of that.

00:43:22.268 --> 00:43:25.239
And to the point of, uh, you
made before where, uh, you know,

00:43:25.268 --> 00:43:26.449
does this fit into pricing?

00:43:26.449 --> 00:43:27.746
Does it fit into loyalty?

00:43:27.747 --> 00:43:29.158
Does it fit into
personalization and stuff?

00:43:29.667 --> 00:43:32.767
I think that is very much where
you'll see different use- types

00:43:32.767 --> 00:43:36.872
of use cases come out, um, that,
uh, literally will look for, and

00:43:36.873 --> 00:43:38.516
pricing is a great example of that.

00:43:38.819 --> 00:43:42.435
You'll see many different variations
of that in the marketplace, and they're

00:43:42.435 --> 00:43:44.055
gonna test out these models on their own.

00:43:44.292 --> 00:43:47.394
So you're gonna have agent- You
know, groups of agents that are

00:43:47.397 --> 00:43:52.649
working together, uh, to kind of
find ways of, uh, of getting the best

00:43:52.896 --> 00:43:56.924
opportunity for the consumer as well
as for the, the retailers as well.

00:43:57.255 --> 00:43:57.441
Yeah.

00:43:57.788 --> 00:44:01.077
We could see group buying actually become
a thing, but it's gonna be agentic.

00:44:01.193 --> 00:44:01.373
Yeah.

00:44:01.447 --> 00:44:01.829
Interesting.

00:44:02.393 --> 00:44:02.709
Yeah.

00:44:02.817 --> 00:44:03.747
That's pretty cool to see.

00:44:03.748 --> 00:44:07.131
I mean, it's, it's, it's gonna change,
uh, how we think about doing business,

00:44:07.132 --> 00:44:08.500
how we think about shopping too.

00:44:08.527 --> 00:44:10.519
I mean, that's a, it's a big change.

00:44:10.929 --> 00:44:14.395
Have you, uh, I didn't see it in the
paper, and this may be off-script, but

00:44:14.413 --> 00:44:19.474
did you, have you looked at MCP and A2A
and some of those, those, those protocols?

00:44:19.621 --> 00:44:21.160
I, I have looked at MCP.

00:44:21.237 --> 00:44:21.825
I think that's a…

00:44:22.045 --> 00:44:23.996
Yeah, I've seen some of
the standards around that.

00:44:24.191 --> 00:44:27.037
I think that's a, that's a great
step, I think, in the right direction.

00:44:27.353 --> 00:44:31.694
Um, you know, uh, just because
it's, it's starting to establish

00:44:31.694 --> 00:44:34.164
a standard, but I think those
standards are gonna change too.

00:44:34.201 --> 00:44:37.361
I mean, just because of how,
uh, you know, agents are gonna,

00:44:37.521 --> 00:44:38.881
uh, are gonna be developed.

00:44:39.157 --> 00:44:42.695
Matter of fact, I think in the not too
distant future, uh, you're gonna have

00:44:42.776 --> 00:44:46.723
agents develop the new standards for
that matter, uh, as opposed to what we do

00:44:46.725 --> 00:44:49.176
today, where we have a broad scale scope.

00:44:49.178 --> 00:44:52.051
And, and those agents are gonna
kinda condense it to just the things

00:44:52.053 --> 00:44:53.894
that they need at the time, right?

00:44:53.894 --> 00:44:57.336
It's, it's gonna be very much
unique to that particular agent's

00:44:57.368 --> 00:45:00.512
particular, uh, needs that they
have at that moment, and that's how

00:45:00.512 --> 00:45:01.449
they're gonna actually function.

00:45:01.450 --> 00:45:04.117
It's, it's a very, uh,
interesting world in that sense.

00:45:04.415 --> 00:45:08.061
Um, I mean, just, uh, you know, two
days ago, just I think two or three days

00:45:08.061 --> 00:45:13.008
ago, um, uh, uh, Google came out with
their Google IO conference, and they

00:45:13.008 --> 00:45:14.211
had a whole bunch of stuff going on.

00:45:14.213 --> 00:45:16.385
Microsoft had another conference
going on at the same time.

00:45:16.746 --> 00:45:20.372
All of this stuff is now tying
back to retail and what we're

00:45:20.372 --> 00:45:22.987
doing in the shopping world,
and that's a very big deal.

00:45:23.035 --> 00:45:29.479
Um, uh, Microsoft's Copilot is really an
interesting play, uh, because it's now no

00:45:29.479 --> 00:45:34.052
longer, uh, that coded environment that
you have for, for developers anymore.

00:45:34.052 --> 00:45:37.563
It's just, "Oh, tell me what I
want," and, and there you go.

00:45:37.563 --> 00:45:40.334
You got this program and code that
can do, do exactly what you want.

00:45:40.585 --> 00:45:44.632
I wanna go scrape 1,000, uh,
websites for price points to compare

00:45:44.632 --> 00:45:46.059
it to what my price point is.

00:45:46.582 --> 00:45:49.319
Here you go, uh, and, and
just by asking the question.

00:45:49.621 --> 00:45:52.699
And that's the kind of thing that
I think is gonna start changing

00:45:52.966 --> 00:45:56.560
the work environments for, uh,
retail, uh, employees as well

00:45:56.560 --> 00:45:58.036
as other businesses as well.

00:45:58.036 --> 00:46:00.702
But m- mostly you're gonna see a
lot of the impact at the retail

00:46:00.702 --> 00:46:04.255
side, just because that has the
widest reaching impact overall.

00:46:04.496 --> 00:46:04.735
Yeah.

00:46:04.749 --> 00:46:07.416
I was excited to see Copilot
put out product cards.

00:46:07.427 --> 00:46:10.479
So we're, we're starting to see the, the
intersection of what you and I would call

00:46:10.479 --> 00:46:16.139
comparison shopping with the agent, with,
with the LLM, which is the first big step.

00:46:16.139 --> 00:46:20.186
So now that it understands product
catalog and buyer intent, then we're

00:46:20.186 --> 00:46:21.570
gonna get into that agentic flow.

00:46:21.571 --> 00:46:23.496
Whereas Google went all the way in.

00:46:23.507 --> 00:46:26.884
They, they went from
product cards to buy for me.

00:46:26.947 --> 00:46:27.857
Um, so they're already…

00:46:28.360 --> 00:46:32.023
They, they're, they're kind of almost at
the furthest, you know, out, you know,

00:46:32.143 --> 00:46:34.064
uh, of the maturation scale of this.

00:46:34.329 --> 00:46:35.615
Uh, I don't wanna say that.

00:46:35.641 --> 00:46:39.503
I, I, I've seen, you know, a lot of
these, like I said, Microsoft, Amazon,

00:46:39.508 --> 00:46:41.863
these guys are also doing just as much.

00:46:41.864 --> 00:46:44.317
If you look at some of the stuff
that they're working on now, they

00:46:44.318 --> 00:46:47.172
have almost the same level of
capabilities that they're building out.

00:46:47.517 --> 00:46:51.848
Um, uh, you know, uh, and I think that
those things are gonna be the real,

00:46:51.934 --> 00:46:53.813
uh, real drivers in, in the long term.

00:46:53.911 --> 00:46:56.144
I don't think there's gonna be
one owner, let's put it that way.

00:46:56.359 --> 00:46:59.448
I think there's gonna be many different
players in this space, and the agents

00:46:59.449 --> 00:47:03.675
are gonna be unique and almost as many,
uh, different types of agents as you

00:47:03.675 --> 00:47:04.984
have different types of models, right?

00:47:05.476 --> 00:47:08.201
And you can expand on
that as well if you want.

00:47:08.263 --> 00:47:12.051
Uh, you know, not just models, but also
how those models are implemented and

00:47:12.395 --> 00:47:13.876
applied to different types of use cases.

00:47:13.887 --> 00:47:16.833
So, um, there, there's a
wide world ahead of us.

00:47:16.836 --> 00:47:18.513
I mean, that, that's
the cool thing about it.

00:47:18.892 --> 00:47:20.980
Um, and a lot of opportunities too.

00:47:21.018 --> 00:47:22.727
Sounds like job security for analysts.

00:47:22.771 --> 00:47:23.444
So that's good.

00:47:23.806 --> 00:47:27.701
Lots of, lots of change and chaos
then, uh, it'll be good for you guys.

00:47:28.408 --> 00:47:30.713
Some people are saying things like
we're gonna be replaced by these

00:47:30.715 --> 00:47:32.656
AI agents too so I don't know.

00:47:33.415 --> 00:47:35.958
I don't know how much job security
there is, but definitely there's

00:47:35.960 --> 00:47:38.675
a, there's a job security for those
who are working in the analyst

00:47:38.676 --> 00:47:40.336
space and working with agentic AI.

00:47:40.637 --> 00:47:45.555
They definitely have some job security
coming up, uh, at least for a, a decade.

00:47:45.908 --> 00:47:46.345
So…

00:47:46.571 --> 00:47:47.013
Well, awesome.

00:47:47.320 --> 00:47:51.043
I, uh, I promised we wouldn't go, uh,
too much past your time there, so I

00:47:51.044 --> 00:47:52.729
wanna be, uh, I wanna honor your time.

00:47:52.729 --> 00:47:54.160
I know you're a busy, busy person.

00:47:54.162 --> 00:47:55.075
So this is good.

00:47:55.075 --> 00:47:58.103
We-- I definitely wanna have you back on
in like, you know, three to six months,

00:47:58.103 --> 00:48:02.279
so to kinda keep getting a pulse or if
you have any other awesome papers that

00:48:02.279 --> 00:48:03.671
you write, uh, I think that'd be great.

00:48:03.886 --> 00:48:06.696
If, if folks wanna follow
you, where do you pontificate?

00:48:07.074 --> 00:48:09.429
Um, so you can certainly go to idc.com

00:48:09.431 --> 00:48:11.887
and, and click on analysts
and type in my name and stuff.

00:48:11.888 --> 00:48:13.584
That's the easiest way, uh, probably.

00:48:13.940 --> 00:48:18.150
But, um, uh, just look me up online,
you'll find my name somewhere out there.

00:48:18.152 --> 00:48:19.855
I got a bunch of different
reports coming out.

00:48:20.111 --> 00:48:20.249
Yeah.

00:48:20.290 --> 00:48:24.703
Um, and, um, uh, you know, if you go
to the IDC retail section and, and

00:48:24.703 --> 00:48:28.292
look at some of the other players in
the market, not just myself, but all

00:48:28.292 --> 00:48:30.111
of us talk about and think about AI.

00:48:30.123 --> 00:48:33.339
Even though I'm kind of focused on
that, um, every single one of our

00:48:33.363 --> 00:48:38.251
analysts really focus a lot on AI
today, uh, and in- including agentic AI.

00:48:38.277 --> 00:48:42.044
So, um, uh, great place to connect
with us, and appreciate this, uh,

00:48:42.086 --> 00:48:44.030
opportunity to talk with you, Scott.

00:48:44.046 --> 00:48:44.806
I mean, this was great.

00:48:45.305 --> 00:48:45.647
Absolutely.

00:48:45.647 --> 00:48:47.263
And I, I'll give a personal shout-out.

00:48:47.318 --> 00:48:48.951
Um, your LinkedIn feed is very good.

00:48:48.951 --> 00:48:51.764
So I, you know, if you're
gonna … I'm sure, I'm sure the

00:48:51.784 --> 00:48:54.942
IDC path is awesome, but I've,
I've enjoyed your, your LinkedIn.

00:48:54.977 --> 00:48:57.608
'Cause you, you give us some
snippets of what you're, what you're

00:48:57.609 --> 00:49:00.134
putting out there and, and that's
been a, been a great read as well.

00:49:00.433 --> 00:49:01.106
Yeah, absolutely.

00:49:01.109 --> 00:49:01.894
I appreciate that.

00:49:02.176 --> 00:49:02.340
Yeah.

00:49:02.341 --> 00:49:03.001
Thanks for coming on.

00:49:03.001 --> 00:49:03.623
Appreciate it.

00:49:03.647 --> 00:49:06.753
And I'm sure, uh, we'll have you
back on, or I'll see you at one

00:49:06.754 --> 00:49:07.803
of the trade shows here soon.

00:49:08.050 --> 00:49:08.977
Oh, I'm sure we will.

00:49:09.624 --> 00:49:10.255
I can't wait.

00:49:10.665 --> 00:49:11.457
Have a good one, Scott.

00:49:12.074 --> 00:49:17.861
Follow, rate, and share to stay up
to date with RetailGenic, your guide

00:49:17.875 --> 00:49:21.262
to the future of AI shopping agents.