First Principles

1 · Summary

Rajiv Kaul runs the company that fills about one in every two ATMs outside India's bank branches, and he says the business was never really about logistics. In Part 1 of 2, he walks Rohin Dharmakumar through a CMS cash van's day, explains why he thinks cash and UPI are growing side by side, and recalls the night demonetisation was announced, which he spent in a hospital where his father was due for surgery the next morning. He sets out the 2x2 he uses to decide when to act in a crisis and when to wait. Then the story goes back: a father who set up the National Highways Authority of India, a summer internship at Nestlé where his research killed two products and cost him a job offer, becoming Microsoft's India MD at 33 with imposter syndrome, and leaving Microsoft for private equity in London. Part 1 ends as he decides he doesn't want to work for anyone again. Part 2 picks up with how he came to own a large piece of CMS.

2 · Chapters

0:00 "You don't think of backups"
0:15 Introduction
3:16 Everyone was surprised except his family
5:55 One van, 70,000 ATMs, one day
9:03 A risk business, and "trust infrastructure"
10:03 Who uses cash? Why cash isn't dying
15:17 Rural ATMs, urban retail
19:18 Demonetisation night, from a hospital
24:29 A 2x2 for handling a crisis
28:19 One price per ATM, and outspending rivals on tech
31:50 What AGS Transact did that CMS refused to do
33:43 "Don't look at P&Ls": the cash book
36:01 AI cameras and lakhs of alerts a day
39:49 A father who set up NHAI, and killing two Nestlé products
43:51 Microsoft India MD at 33, and imposter syndrome
48:20 Why Microsoft picked him
51:39 Why he left India, then Microsoft
55:20 Private equity in London, four risks at once
57:16 Buying CMS with Blackstone

3 · Memorable quotes

[0:08] "You don't think of backups when you do this."
[8:48] "We are not a cash logistics firm. We're a risk management company."
[25:54] "I don't know what to do, so let's do something."
[43:00] "Doing the right thing is going to cost you at times."
[47:23] "You learned loneliness at a very young age."

4 · Frameworks & mental models
  • The crisis 2x2: sort a crisis by whether you understand it and whether waiting costs you. The financial crisis: understood, act now. Demonetisation: not understood, act anyway. COVID: not understood, wait and survive. Acquisitions: understood, take your time.

  • A risk business, not a logistics one: within a year of buying CMS, Kaul decided the company should be paid for the risk it carries, not for moving vans.

  • Cash, not P&L: a mentor's advice before he bought CMS was to read the cash book every day. Earn what you spend and keep some for a rainy day.

  • Scale, then tech, then the next category: chase market share, outspend competitors on technology to cut cost, reinvest the margin, and use the cash to enter a new category.

5 · Credits & sharing

This episode was produced by Rohin Dharmakumar and mixed and mastered by Rajiv CN.
Write to us at fp@the-ken.com with your feedback, suggestions, and guests you would want to see on First Principles.
If you enjoyed this episode, please help us spread the word by sharing and gifting it to your friends and family.

What is First Principles?

First Principles is a weekly interview podcast comprising authentic, candid, and insightful conversations between some of India’s most accomplished founders and business leaders, and Rohin Dharmakumar, The Ken’s CEO & co-founder.

From personal philosophies, mental models and decision making frameworks, to reading habits, parenting styles or personal interests, each episode will delve into what makes each of these leaders unique.