WEBVTT

NOTE
This file was generated by Descript 

00:00:00.049 --> 00:00:04.460
Adam Crockett: It's an industry where
94% of clubs last year made a loss.

00:00:05.090 --> 00:00:09.890
29% of clubs couldn't survive more than
30 days if the owner pulled their funding.

00:00:10.370 --> 00:00:15.080
60% of clubs in the EFL and the National
League are technically insolvent.

00:00:15.650 --> 00:00:18.980
If you make an investment, your
expected return in the last five

00:00:18.980 --> 00:00:21.230
years has been a loss of 41%.

00:00:21.751 --> 00:00:26.227
It's an industry on any reasonable
metric that has financial challenges.

00:00:27.813 --> 00:00:31.073
Ralph Grayson: Welcome to The Boardroom
Path by Sainty Hird & Partners.

00:00:31.418 --> 00:00:35.308
I'm your host, Ralph Grayson, a
partner in the board practice.

00:00:35.677 --> 00:00:40.237
In this series, we'll offer practical
steps and useful perspectives for

00:00:40.237 --> 00:00:42.577
aspiring and newly appointed NEDs.

00:00:42.982 --> 00:00:46.852
This week we're continuing with our
focus on opportunity for listeners to

00:00:46.852 --> 00:00:50.422
consider board roles in football clubs.

00:00:50.932 --> 00:00:54.382
So if you were invited to join the
board of a football club, what would

00:00:54.382 --> 00:00:56.212
you want to know before saying yes?

00:00:56.812 --> 00:00:59.752
Who really makes the decisions
and how secure is the funding?

00:01:00.292 --> 00:01:02.452
And would you be able to challenge
the owner when the pressure

00:01:02.452 --> 00:01:03.982
to win becomes overwhelming?

00:01:04.732 --> 00:01:07.972
These are all familiar boardroom
questions, but in football they come

00:01:07.972 --> 00:01:09.832
with some unusual complications.

00:01:10.372 --> 00:01:14.476
Promotion and relegation, transfer
windows, generations of supporter

00:01:14.476 --> 00:01:19.012
loyalty, and the possibility of the
club's financial security rests on one

00:01:19.042 --> 00:01:21.206
person continuing to write the cheques.

00:01:22.024 --> 00:01:25.751
The independent football regulator's
licensing regime brings those

00:01:25.852 --> 00:01:27.832
questions into much sharper focus.

00:01:28.442 --> 00:01:31.742
The question for today is what
effective oversight looks like

00:01:32.132 --> 00:01:33.662
and who's equipped to provide it?

00:01:34.502 --> 00:01:38.852
My guest is Adam Crockett, as a
senior official at the Department for

00:01:38.852 --> 00:01:43.142
Culture, Media and Sport, Adam helped
design the new football regulatory

00:01:43.142 --> 00:01:47.762
framework and led work on the Football
Governance Act and its implementation.

00:01:48.302 --> 00:01:51.842
He subsequently advised the IFR's
chair and the chief executive.

00:01:52.592 --> 00:01:56.312
Before football, Adam worked in
economic regulation, competition

00:01:56.312 --> 00:02:00.361
policy and enforcement, including
at Ofgem and on the government's

00:02:00.452 --> 00:02:02.428
response to digital market power.

00:02:03.072 --> 00:02:06.847
He now leads Game Plan Strategic
Advisory and is a senior

00:02:06.847 --> 00:02:08.690
advisor at Alvarez and Marsal.

00:02:09.347 --> 00:02:12.872
He also advises Football Beyond
Borders and serves on its audit and

00:02:12.872 --> 00:02:17.972
risk committee and that gives him an
unusually useful perspective on the gap

00:02:17.972 --> 00:02:21.872
between writing a regulatory framework
and making it work in a boardroom.

00:02:22.592 --> 00:02:26.162
Through his Substack and recent
podcast appearances, he's also

00:02:26.162 --> 00:02:29.552
been explaining what this change
means for clubs and investors.

00:02:30.242 --> 00:02:31.172
So Adam, welcome.

00:02:31.645 --> 00:02:32.425
Adam Crockett: Thank you for having me.

00:02:33.475 --> 00:02:37.135
Ralph Grayson: You're joining us in a
personal capacity, I should start with,

00:02:37.285 --> 00:02:41.965
drawing on your experience of designing
and implementing the IFR framework.

00:02:42.355 --> 00:02:47.365
So let's start by exploring what
football boards will actually need to

00:02:47.365 --> 00:02:51.745
do differently and why people listening
who've never worked in football might

00:02:51.745 --> 00:02:53.455
actually have something valuable to offer.

00:02:54.475 --> 00:02:59.173
Adam Crockett: Yeah, so the place to
start here, I think, is looking at what's

00:02:59.173 --> 00:03:04.243
happened to football finance over the
last few decades, really, where we've

00:03:04.243 --> 00:03:09.643
seen instances of clubs getting into
financial distress, and football has

00:03:09.643 --> 00:03:13.453
responded to that by bringing in its
own sets of rules to try and address

00:03:13.453 --> 00:03:19.183
those issues and to a degree, some of
that has worked, but equally, and there

00:03:19.183 --> 00:03:23.637
was a report out by the new independent
regulator just last week, we've seen

00:03:23.641 --> 00:03:28.723
instances of clubs not performing very
well, even within those frameworks.

00:03:29.343 --> 00:03:33.703
So after the European Super League, the
government kicked off an independent

00:03:33.703 --> 00:03:37.753
review to decide how could football's
governance be reformed to be as

00:03:37.753 --> 00:03:42.943
effective as possible and that concluded
that essentially the self-regulatory

00:03:42.943 --> 00:03:48.574
frameworks we see at the moment are
an inefficient and imprecise way to

00:03:48.574 --> 00:03:50.794
try and tackle some of those problems.

00:03:51.284 --> 00:03:54.674
The problems you typically see are
owners coming in, spending lots and

00:03:54.674 --> 00:04:00.292
lots of money getting the club into a
distressed position, and then walking

00:04:00.292 --> 00:04:04.174
away and the club being in financial
distress and what football's own

00:04:04.174 --> 00:04:08.967
regulatory rules are inadequate at
dealing with is trying to manage some

00:04:08.967 --> 00:04:10.767
of that and then try to address it.

00:04:10.767 --> 00:04:14.037
So the government
introduced the legislation.

00:04:14.097 --> 00:04:17.967
What that's done is said, rather
than trying to constrain how clubs

00:04:17.967 --> 00:04:24.047
spend money or trying to curb, making
clubs profitable, as existing rules

00:04:24.047 --> 00:04:28.577
try to do, it set out a framework
that you see in financial services.

00:04:28.577 --> 00:04:32.657
So looking at the business plan,
trying to assess risk within that

00:04:32.657 --> 00:04:35.627
business plan, and where there are
risks, trying to mitigate that.

00:04:36.239 --> 00:04:39.227
And I think you're going to see some
big changes if you're on a board.

00:04:39.747 --> 00:04:42.957
The first place to start is rather
than this being a black and white

00:04:42.999 --> 00:04:49.421
rules-based system and a clear compliance
or non-compliance position, the IFR's

00:04:49.445 --> 00:04:51.925
regime is a more principles-based regime.

00:04:51.933 --> 00:04:56.217
So the IFR will be taking a look
in the round, is the club complying

00:04:56.217 --> 00:04:58.016
with the obligations that it has?

00:04:58.499 --> 00:05:01.694
It will assess the risk within
the business plan, and it can then

00:05:01.694 --> 00:05:04.702
apply its judgement  to assess
whether intervention is needed.

00:05:04.703 --> 00:05:09.094
So there will be more uncertainty and it
will be a different way of doing things.

00:05:10.094 --> 00:05:13.077
Ralph Grayson: I think it's interesting
that I know you're an ardent Everton

00:05:13.084 --> 00:05:17.104
fan, but you come at this not as a
football supporter, but as somebody

00:05:17.104 --> 00:05:22.604
steeped in regulatory understanding and
a regulatory background within government

00:05:22.994 --> 00:05:26.244
and you've just touched on there some
of the analogies there are with the

00:05:26.244 --> 00:05:31.294
establishment of the FCA and comply or
explain as we use in governance language.

00:05:31.594 --> 00:05:37.714
So just maybe touch on a little bit
how somebody who sits in a non-football

00:05:37.714 --> 00:05:42.005
board might recognise what this
regulatory regime is going to look like.

00:05:42.005 --> 00:05:47.194
How much are they going to feel at
home in football that this is a normal

00:05:47.254 --> 00:05:49.314
governance and board environment?

00:05:50.094 --> 00:05:53.124
Adam Crockett: Yeah, so I think
probably two main ways into that.

00:05:53.124 --> 00:05:57.527
So every club going forward in the top
five tiers of men's English football

00:05:57.527 --> 00:06:01.526
will need a licence to operate and
within that, there's the first, this

00:06:01.602 --> 00:06:03.677
financial regulation part of this.

00:06:03.677 --> 00:06:07.787
So an assessment of the business plan
and an assessment of the risks, where

00:06:07.787 --> 00:06:10.967
the regulator perceives risks, it
will put conditions on top of that.

00:06:10.967 --> 00:06:15.807
So if you work in financial services,
it is a prudential style of regulation,

00:06:16.017 --> 00:06:20.887
stress testing, looking at forecasts and
trying to mitigate that and then the other

00:06:20.887 --> 00:06:23.407
aspect of it is non-financial resources.

00:06:23.407 --> 00:06:28.867
So does the business have
systems, processes, does it have

00:06:29.047 --> 00:06:30.637
adequate corporate governance?

00:06:30.637 --> 00:06:34.267
And where clubs don't have those
sorts of things, again, conditions

00:06:34.267 --> 00:06:37.562
can be put in place as part of
the licensing process to make the

00:06:37.657 --> 00:06:40.354
club more financially sustainable.

00:06:40.754 --> 00:06:44.892
So yeah, the model that's being applied
here is every club will need to show how

00:06:45.034 --> 00:06:49.067
on an comply or explain basis it complies
with  the football governance statement.

00:06:49.067 --> 00:06:53.417
So how is it taking the corporate
governance code the IFR will produce,

00:06:53.777 --> 00:06:58.067
assess what the club is doing
against that, and then give a view

00:06:58.067 --> 00:06:59.477
on whether that's adequate or not.

00:06:59.507 --> 00:07:03.027
That's obviously quite typical of
lots of more mature industries.

00:07:03.838 --> 00:07:07.258
Ralph Grayson: How much of a mindset
change do you think owners or the

00:07:07.352 --> 00:07:10.545
establishment in football at the
moment, how much are they going to

00:07:10.545 --> 00:07:14.174
have to change their mindset to this
new regime and for a non-footballing

00:07:14.264 --> 00:07:17.635
NED coming and joining a board, how
much are they going to have to change

00:07:17.638 --> 00:07:19.044
their mindset to fit in with football?

00:07:19.364 --> 00:07:21.213
Adam Crockett: Yeah, I think
there will be a big change

00:07:21.216 --> 00:07:22.824
actually for a couple of reasons.

00:07:22.824 --> 00:07:25.734
The first is the move away
from a rules-based system.

00:07:25.734 --> 00:07:28.254
So this more principles-based.

00:07:28.656 --> 00:07:32.796
It's a much more proactive regime than
you might see in football at the moment.

00:07:32.796 --> 00:07:37.356
It tends to be what we would call
in regulation ex post regulation,

00:07:37.358 --> 00:07:38.496
how it's done at the moment.

00:07:38.706 --> 00:07:42.516
This will be more about pre-empting
problems and putting in place plans

00:07:42.696 --> 00:07:47.016
pre-emptively to solve that rather than
waiting for a problem to happen, waiting

00:07:47.016 --> 00:07:48.816
for detailed enforcement to happen.

00:07:48.816 --> 00:07:54.186
So it will be a big change, more
onus on the board to take ownership

00:07:54.186 --> 00:07:58.693
of the decisions, not just to go for
a tick-box exercise, but actually

00:07:58.697 --> 00:08:02.646
strategically own that, fit what is
being asked of them to their business

00:08:02.646 --> 00:08:06.646
model and take some ownership of
compliance is the vision for this.

00:08:07.456 --> 00:08:10.636
Ralph Grayson: And I guess one of the
big practical differences between a

00:08:10.636 --> 00:08:16.456
PLC board and a football board at the
moment is probably the football club

00:08:16.996 --> 00:08:22.696
is owned by the executive chair, i.e.,
the chair is executive chair, not

00:08:22.696 --> 00:08:27.689
non-exec chair, and probably owns the
majority of the shares in the company.

00:08:28.320 --> 00:08:32.576
So if a chair says, "Well, we
already comply with the League's

00:08:32.582 --> 00:08:37.636
financial rules, so we should be
fine," what have they misunderstood

00:08:37.636 --> 00:08:39.076
about what's coming down the road?

00:08:39.623 --> 00:08:43.272
Adam Crockett: I mean, I would say that is
a fundamental issue if that is the case.

00:08:43.272 --> 00:08:45.972
They are potentially two
very separate things.

00:08:45.972 --> 00:08:51.532
So if you take football's current
rules, squad cost ratio, so a football

00:08:51.549 --> 00:08:55.875
club has limits on what it can spend
on players, whether it's the transfer

00:08:55.875 --> 00:08:58.935
fees that they pay and the wages they
pay and the agents' fees they pay.

00:08:59.355 --> 00:09:03.795
That is entirely separate from
essentially an assessment of, is this

00:09:03.795 --> 00:09:06.158
football club financially sustainable?

00:09:06.945 --> 00:09:10.305
Has it properly thought through
a range of different scenarios?

00:09:10.575 --> 00:09:13.605
Has it stress tested them and
does it have a plan to manage

00:09:13.605 --> 00:09:15.285
any risks within the business?

00:09:15.615 --> 00:09:19.695
So just because you are, by the letter
of the law, complying with squad cost

00:09:19.695 --> 00:09:24.395
ratio as you know, a Premier League club
CFO or board would be assessing, you

00:09:24.395 --> 00:09:28.235
are doing something entirely different
there where you're saying, "Are there

00:09:28.235 --> 00:09:33.318
more fundamental stresses within this
business model? Have we properly thought

00:09:33.328 --> 00:09:36.845
through what we would do if there was
a bad turn of events and do we have a

00:09:36.845 --> 00:09:41.015
plan to manage that?" And I think that
would be a complete mindset change.

00:09:41.305 --> 00:09:45.645
I think one is looking reasonably
reactively and one is taking a more

00:09:45.705 --> 00:09:48.165
holistic long-term view of the situation.

00:09:49.306 --> 00:09:51.765
Ralph Grayson: And as you've already
touched on, Adam, the State of the

00:09:51.765 --> 00:09:55.935
Game report describes a very successful
industry with a, should we call

00:09:55.935 --> 00:09:58.155
it, a fragile financial foundation?

00:09:58.875 --> 00:10:03.097
So how do you think this chair or
executive chair is going to have to change

00:10:03.097 --> 00:10:07.137
the way they think about the use of the
board to address some of these issues?

00:10:08.137 --> 00:10:10.897
Adam Crockett: Yeah, so I think it
is just worth starting by touching on

00:10:10.897 --> 00:10:14.773
the State of the Game report and for
those that haven't seen the headlines

00:10:14.773 --> 00:10:20.383
on this, it's an industry where
94% of clubs last year made a loss.

00:10:21.013 --> 00:10:25.813
29% of clubs couldn't survive more than
30 days if the owner pulled their funding.

00:10:26.293 --> 00:10:31.003
60% of clubs in the EFL and the National
League are technically insolvent.

00:10:31.573 --> 00:10:34.903
If you make an investment, your
expected return in the last five

00:10:34.903 --> 00:10:37.153
years has been a loss of 41%.

00:10:37.724 --> 00:10:43.124
Debt is very high, I think at five billion
of a nine billion pound industry and

00:10:43.154 --> 00:10:48.824
interest and agent fees at the moment
are over a billion pounds and the implied

00:10:48.824 --> 00:10:51.104
interest rate people are paying is 11%.

00:10:51.104 --> 00:10:56.279
So on any number of issues and in addition
to that, a lot of things have been factor

00:10:56.287 --> 00:10:59.650
invoiced and so longevity is challenged.

00:10:59.653 --> 00:11:04.739
So it's an industry on any reasonable
metric that has financial challenges.

00:11:05.459 --> 00:11:09.749
I think an important part of this process
then is to look at that context and

00:11:09.749 --> 00:11:15.599
look at those numbers, to look at their
own business and look at how is that

00:11:15.599 --> 00:11:17.789
football club performing on those things.

00:11:17.789 --> 00:11:20.609
And the IFR has been reasonably
clear there, the types of

00:11:20.609 --> 00:11:21.959
things that it's worried about.

00:11:21.959 --> 00:11:26.199
It's worried about liquidity, it's worried
about debt, it's worried about solvency.

00:11:26.199 --> 00:11:30.309
So I think the first place for any
board to start here would be to take

00:11:30.309 --> 00:11:35.289
a step back, to properly scrutinise
and put some internal challenge on

00:11:35.679 --> 00:11:39.219
how are we as a football club and a
business performing on those areas?

00:11:39.909 --> 00:11:44.316
Do we have a plan if the
situation deteriorates?

00:11:44.976 --> 00:11:48.546
Is this something where it's football
and we'll just have to see it through

00:11:48.546 --> 00:11:51.966
and it's always been this way or do
we have a plan to try and correct it?

00:11:52.266 --> 00:11:55.373
Those are the sorts of things I think
the IFR is going to want to see.

00:11:55.717 --> 00:11:59.988
I think the IFR's also been reasonably
clear that change is going to have

00:11:59.988 --> 00:12:03.966
to happen here and in fact, the
legislation's clear, if it's not

00:12:03.966 --> 00:12:07.686
delivering its statutory objectives of
making sure the industry's financially

00:12:07.686 --> 00:12:09.726
sustainable, it will have to take action.

00:12:09.726 --> 00:12:14.346
So I think every club should be really
scrutinising that report, scrutinising

00:12:14.346 --> 00:12:18.066
their own business, thinking about how
do they respond to that and I think

00:12:18.426 --> 00:12:21.726
the clubs that do that and have a
proactive plan, whether it's through

00:12:21.726 --> 00:12:24.936
their business model or through the
other structural changes they can put in

00:12:24.936 --> 00:12:29.683
place, stands a good chance of navigating
this process in a really good way.

00:12:30.255 --> 00:12:31.783
Ralph Grayson: I just want to
bring that to life a little bit.

00:12:31.843 --> 00:12:34.771
So it's the role of every board
member to oversee strategy.

00:12:35.491 --> 00:12:40.291
To what extent do you think boards,
existing football boards, lack the

00:12:40.291 --> 00:12:45.241
capacity to write a multi-year business
plan, which is actually based on financial

00:12:45.258 --> 00:12:47.005
projections rather than unfounded hope?

00:12:47.782 --> 00:12:50.450
Adam Crockett: I've heard some statistics
before from one of the leagues.

00:12:50.450 --> 00:12:53.810
I think it was one of the lower leagues
that the average predicted finish

00:12:53.810 --> 00:12:55.574
for clubs in that division was sixth.

00:12:55.950 --> 00:12:58.730
So everyone thinks they're going to
get in the playoffs or get promoted,

00:12:58.730 --> 00:13:00.890
and clearly that can't be the case.

00:13:01.940 --> 00:13:06.080
But there are some really serious
people at every football club.

00:13:06.440 --> 00:13:10.010
There is nothing about writing a business
plan that is beyond the industry.

00:13:10.370 --> 00:13:14.513
I think one of the things though that
does come through is moving away from

00:13:14.806 --> 00:13:19.460
the view, I think, when you've got an
independent statutory regulator, that

00:13:19.460 --> 00:13:22.850
this is just the way that football's
always done it, because the IFR has

00:13:22.850 --> 00:13:27.350
come out with its report, said that the
industry is at a financial precipice.

00:13:27.770 --> 00:13:30.590
I think you can't just be of the
mindset that this is the way that

00:13:30.590 --> 00:13:35.060
football works, because if you do, you
can probably expect some intervention

00:13:35.060 --> 00:13:38.990
and potentially really significant
intervention on how much liquidity

00:13:38.990 --> 00:13:43.130
you have to hold in the business, what
your debt pile needs to look like.

00:13:43.520 --> 00:13:47.515
If you don't act on this and think and
put yourself some challenge, you're

00:13:47.515 --> 00:13:49.479
probably going to fall foul of the regime.

00:13:50.811 --> 00:13:54.099
Ralph Grayson: A lot of what we talked
about so far has been financial stability

00:13:54.099 --> 00:13:58.760
and liquidity, but there's a heck of a
lot more to running or being involved

00:13:58.760 --> 00:14:01.122
in the running of a modern sports team,
whether that's football or anything else.

00:14:01.122 --> 00:14:03.829
I mean, we all talk about sport
as an asset class now and that's

00:14:04.014 --> 00:14:07.614
as much about the off-field
stability as the on-field success.

00:14:07.614 --> 00:14:12.235
So the number of stadia that are doing
other things beyond just hosting the

00:14:12.235 --> 00:14:16.593
match on the Saturday and you think about
Spurs with a go-kart track at the bottom

00:14:16.594 --> 00:14:18.068
and a venture capital lab at the bottom.

00:14:18.398 --> 00:14:21.338
The number of stadia now I
see with hotels on the side.

00:14:21.338 --> 00:14:26.208
So this is much about a real
estate play as it may also be

00:14:26.238 --> 00:14:29.328
about digital media, entertainment.

00:14:29.508 --> 00:14:34.278
So what do you think the skill gaps are
more broadly beyond finance that somebody

00:14:34.458 --> 00:14:38.250
who's interested in joining a football
board may bring particular expertise on?

00:14:39.500 --> 00:14:42.668
Adam Crockett: Yeah, I think that is
a very good, if challenging question.

00:14:42.668 --> 00:14:46.111
I think, you know, you look at the Premier
League, I think half of the clubs have

00:14:46.111 --> 00:14:48.001
a big infrastructure project planned.

00:14:48.001 --> 00:14:52.291
My football club, Everton, I think it only
probably avoided administration because

00:14:52.291 --> 00:14:56.109
it had a brand new stadium coming along
and Spurs Stadium has been transformative.

00:14:56.201 --> 00:15:00.821
So clearly the property play and
the real estate play is important.

00:15:01.091 --> 00:15:05.771
I know as well, a big part of where growth
is expected is the fact that these clubs

00:15:05.771 --> 00:15:10.260
have huge international fan bases, but
they're basically only making a pound

00:15:10.260 --> 00:15:11.924
per fan over their global fan base.

00:15:11.924 --> 00:15:16.797
So people who can mine the data and reach
those international fans are  going to

00:15:16.805 --> 00:15:18.638
potentially see a lot of the upside.

00:15:19.054 --> 00:15:22.984
I think the question a board should
ask itself is, do we need all of

00:15:22.984 --> 00:15:26.524
those skills on the board or are
there actually third parties that

00:15:26.524 --> 00:15:28.204
can give us the best advice on that?

00:15:28.265 --> 00:15:32.338
And maybe given the dynamic nature of
the business, the way that the industry's

00:15:32.338 --> 00:15:37.228
evolving so quickly, a more external
recruitment to some of those skills might

00:15:37.228 --> 00:15:40.228
be a better way to do this than just
getting it simply through the board.

00:15:41.228 --> 00:15:44.754
Ralph Grayson: So if I just back up on
that a little bit, when we first met you

00:15:44.754 --> 00:15:48.986
made the point to me quite robustly that
a football club doesn't behave like a

00:15:48.993 --> 00:15:51.400
conventional profit-maximising business.

00:15:52.011 --> 00:15:55.221
Through your eyes, how should
a board define success?

00:15:55.571 --> 00:15:58.391
Because it's a combination of
winning, financial resilience,

00:15:58.391 --> 00:16:00.839
we've touched on fan engagement.

00:16:01.212 --> 00:16:03.762
There's a lot of different ambitions
pulling in different directions here.

00:16:04.782 --> 00:16:07.591
Adam Crockett: Yeah, and I think,
you know, you can see examples of

00:16:07.591 --> 00:16:11.461
football clubs that have been run
super financially prudently and what

00:16:11.461 --> 00:16:15.301
that does to the relationship with
fans and we do have to remember, we

00:16:15.301 --> 00:16:20.293
all love sport because we want to see
a successful on-pitch product and we

00:16:20.293 --> 00:16:22.771
want success and glory for our clubs.

00:16:23.471 --> 00:16:27.641
One thing I would say though is that
generally, if you look at, say, football,

00:16:27.641 --> 00:16:32.431
a lot of the most well-run football clubs,
Paul Barber and what he's done at Brighton

00:16:32.431 --> 00:16:37.441
or Matthew Benham and how he's used
data at Brentford, those football clubs

00:16:37.441 --> 00:16:43.141
that are well run, you often then see a
huge uptick in performance on the pitch.

00:16:43.141 --> 00:16:45.541
They're not necessarily
always contradictory.

00:16:46.145 --> 00:16:49.975
I think that the mindset change
here though is actually one of time.

00:16:50.815 --> 00:16:56.205
So rather than just thinking about
short-run, short-term outcomes,

00:16:56.252 --> 00:17:00.125
which I think is where solely looking
through a sporting lens will take you.

00:17:00.125 --> 00:17:03.695
I think part of the success of what,
say, Brighton and Brentford have done

00:17:04.145 --> 00:17:07.805
is they've built to the success over a
number of years and it took them time

00:17:07.805 --> 00:17:11.405
to build and I think football clubs
that do think on a longer timeframe

00:17:11.765 --> 00:17:13.745
will probably see better results.

00:17:13.745 --> 00:17:17.135
And you can see examples to the
contrary for that, people that chase

00:17:17.315 --> 00:17:22.025
success and clubs that have chased
success have not always had the success

00:17:22.025 --> 00:17:25.751
that they've wanted because they've
sacrificed long-term strategic decisions.

00:17:26.321 --> 00:17:28.841
I think the only other thing I
would say as well is I've read

00:17:28.841 --> 00:17:31.781
Moneyball, which is a fantastic book.

00:17:32.021 --> 00:17:35.771
One of the points that Billy Beane
pointed out was at the end of the

00:17:35.771 --> 00:17:40.631
process, they had amazing success for
a relatively low budget, but what they

00:17:40.631 --> 00:17:45.741
did was, they didn't win anything,
but they got every last dollar out of

00:17:45.741 --> 00:17:50.541
that team that they could and they had
a plan and they stuck to that plan.

00:17:51.352 --> 00:17:54.781
When they took a step back and why
they didn't get all of the results

00:17:54.781 --> 00:17:58.281
that they wanted, it came down to
the randomness and the luck that

00:17:58.281 --> 00:18:00.021
comes with professional sport.

00:18:00.501 --> 00:18:04.521
But what they could do and say with
a genuine hand on heart was we stuck

00:18:04.521 --> 00:18:07.661
to the plan and we did as much as we
could with the resources that we have

00:18:07.661 --> 00:18:12.281
and I think that sort of mentality is
one that I think could traverse these

00:18:12.371 --> 00:18:14.471
potentially competing priorities.

00:18:15.623 --> 00:18:18.248
Ralph Grayson: I think that
mindset's quite interesting.

00:18:18.248 --> 00:18:21.198
When you were writing the report
and helping with setting up the

00:18:21.198 --> 00:18:23.082
IFR, did you talk to the owners?

00:18:23.087 --> 00:18:26.862
Was it a two-way process or did
you pull the FCA report off a shelf

00:18:26.862 --> 00:18:28.122
and say, "Well, we'll copy that?"

00:18:28.722 --> 00:18:31.076
Adam Crockett: Yeah, I mean, when
we did the original independent

00:18:31.081 --> 00:18:35.610
fan-led review, I think there were
over a hundred hours of hearings.

00:18:35.616 --> 00:18:39.842
So everyone, whether it's an owner
or a fan or executives got to make

00:18:39.892 --> 00:18:43.402
their representations and as we
were developing the legislation,

00:18:43.452 --> 00:18:44.832
we saw owners throughout.

00:18:45.012 --> 00:18:48.462
You would, in fairness, get a different
story from different owners at different

00:18:48.462 --> 00:18:53.922
levels where they were relative in their
performance cycle, those sorts of things.

00:18:53.922 --> 00:18:55.962
But we absolutely consulted with everyone.

00:18:56.232 --> 00:18:58.932
There was never a consensus or
a consistent view, and I think

00:18:58.932 --> 00:19:02.368
you probably can't just say
owners were of one view here.

00:19:02.998 --> 00:19:05.997
But there are some consistent
messages coming out.

00:19:05.997 --> 00:19:10.748
I think certainly in the EFL, there's
a widely held view now that the current

00:19:10.748 --> 00:19:15.668
business model is unsustainable and change
is needed and I think there is potentially

00:19:15.668 --> 00:19:19.921
some consensus in that sense that more
sanity might be needed in the industry.

00:19:20.911 --> 00:19:24.947
Ralph Grayson: So without personalising
it or mentioning examples, did you get

00:19:25.007 --> 00:19:28.667
the sense that the owners recognise
they've got a governance problem?

00:19:29.217 --> 00:19:30.747
Adam Crockett: Hand on
heart, probably not.

00:19:31.257 --> 00:19:35.427
I think one thing that I would probably
also take away that some owners are a

00:19:35.427 --> 00:19:37.357
lot more engaged in this than others.

00:19:37.357 --> 00:19:40.477
So obviously there's a lot of
foreign owners in the game now.

00:19:41.072 --> 00:19:44.691
They're potentially based in the
States or other parts of the world.

00:19:44.691 --> 00:19:48.441
So their ability to be across all
of this all of the time is not easy,

00:19:48.441 --> 00:19:54.188
but there are other people who are
very wealthy and would be involved

00:19:54.188 --> 00:19:56.223
with all of the minutiae of detail.

00:19:56.273 --> 00:20:00.441
I won't name the person, but a billionaire
who knew the legislation back to front.

00:20:00.441 --> 00:20:03.278
So there are different stories
about different owners.

00:20:03.894 --> 00:20:06.221
Ralph Grayson: And to what extent do
you think the owners need educating

00:20:06.581 --> 00:20:11.285
that board members are going to answer
back and ask challenging questions

00:20:11.285 --> 00:20:14.424
of them and saying, "We can't afford
to do that." Is that an issue?

00:20:14.484 --> 00:20:20.424
Are people realistic as to the whole point
of an independent board is to challenge?

00:20:20.695 --> 00:20:23.215
Adam Crockett: From the conversations
I've had over the last five years,

00:20:23.215 --> 00:20:27.656
including the last few months, I think
there still probably is a mentality

00:20:28.316 --> 00:20:33.323
and an education piece to go on across
the board, frankly, that significant

00:20:33.325 --> 00:20:34.729
change is going to happen here.

00:20:34.734 --> 00:20:38.722
So there is now an independent
regulator, each club's going to have

00:20:38.723 --> 00:20:43.128
a supervisor, and they are going to
want to see that decision-making is

00:20:43.140 --> 00:20:48.395
being taken in a sensible way with the
club's long-term interests in place.

00:20:48.905 --> 00:20:53.195
I don't think everyone has
potentially clocked that and clubs

00:20:53.195 --> 00:20:56.375
that can demonstrate there is
the types of model you've set out

00:20:56.375 --> 00:20:59.615
there, Ralph, where there is proper
independent challenge and scrutiny.

00:20:59.915 --> 00:21:02.595
And that doesn't mean that
the owner can't still make the

00:21:02.595 --> 00:21:05.985
decisions that they want to, but
that it's properly thought through.

00:21:06.345 --> 00:21:09.156
They are the types of things that
the IFR is going to want to see

00:21:09.158 --> 00:21:13.935
that decisions are taken in a very
considered way and I think a bit of

00:21:13.935 --> 00:21:15.885
an education piece there for everyone.

00:21:17.148 --> 00:21:21.065
Ralph Grayson: So it leads into the
obvious question before accepting a

00:21:21.065 --> 00:21:26.445
role, what would you want an owner to
commit to when your advice, perhaps

00:21:26.445 --> 00:21:27.945
shall we say, is inconvenient?

00:21:29.248 --> 00:21:30.298
Adam Crockett: I know this personally.

00:21:30.298 --> 00:21:33.904
So I spent 15 years in the civil
service and telling secretaries

00:21:33.904 --> 00:21:37.024
of state they couldn't do what
they wanted to do is a hard skill.

00:21:38.285 --> 00:21:41.075
I think that this is where
the IFR will be helpful.

00:21:41.673 --> 00:21:46.233
So the first thing to say is, if I was
building my perfect board, first of

00:21:46.233 --> 00:21:50.026
all, one of the things that needs to
happen, I think, is a cultural change.

00:21:50.476 --> 00:21:54.896
One of challenge and one of support.

00:21:54.986 --> 00:21:58.076
So you need to be all
strategically aligned.

00:21:58.136 --> 00:21:58.856
What is your goal?

00:21:58.856 --> 00:21:59.516
What is your plan?

00:21:59.516 --> 00:22:00.596
Where are you trying to get to?

00:22:00.986 --> 00:22:06.476
Have a cultural piece about the ability
to ask some of the challenging questions

00:22:06.476 --> 00:22:10.326
and say, someone who's prepared to
say, "Have we thought about this?"

00:22:11.616 --> 00:22:18.036
And I think boards that have that are
then likely to land well with the IFR.

00:22:18.726 --> 00:22:22.546
Boards that don't do that, where it is
command and control and decision-making

00:22:22.559 --> 00:22:28.716
can quickly diverge from the business
plan or areas where a statutory regulator

00:22:28.716 --> 00:22:31.236
like the IFR quickly gets nervous.

00:22:32.616 --> 00:22:38.986
What I think though is also important
is, you can have an owner that either

00:22:38.997 --> 00:22:45.240
says explicitly to a non-executive
director that they won't pay much

00:22:45.240 --> 00:22:49.081
attention to what they've got to
say or the actions that they take,

00:22:49.136 --> 00:22:51.022
that's effectively what happens.

00:22:51.049 --> 00:22:54.170
But this is where it would come
back to the IFR and its role.

00:22:54.170 --> 00:22:56.300
So every club now has a supervisor.

00:22:56.870 --> 00:23:04.160
Clubs that do diverge from the plan and
end up in sets of circumstances that are

00:23:04.160 --> 00:23:06.440
detrimental to the club's sustainability.

00:23:06.710 --> 00:23:09.986
The supervisor is going to be all
over that sort of information.

00:23:09.986 --> 00:23:16.571
So really there is an inbuilt mechanism
that effectively owners and boards are

00:23:16.571 --> 00:23:19.466
going to have to be open to more scrutiny.

00:23:19.526 --> 00:23:22.826
If you don't have that, you can
probably expect more scrutiny from

00:23:22.826 --> 00:23:25.586
the IFR, which might mean things
happen to you that you don't want to.

00:23:26.285 --> 00:23:29.208
Ralph Grayson: And is the
supervisor going to vet an incoming

00:23:29.211 --> 00:23:31.286
new board member or NED then?

00:23:31.376 --> 00:23:34.367
I mean, you, I was a bit facetious with
you before we started the recording.

00:23:34.371 --> 00:23:37.858
I said, "Well, what stops an owner
just appointing the vicar and then

00:23:37.858 --> 00:23:39.056
saying, well, now I've got a NED."

00:23:39.606 --> 00:23:42.492
Adam Crockett: Well, there's a
new regime set called the Owners,

00:23:42.492 --> 00:23:45.324
Directors, and Senior Executives regime.

00:23:45.339 --> 00:23:51.161
So any new owner or senior official
within a club will need approval by

00:23:51.161 --> 00:23:54.951
the IFR and lots of clubs have already
gone through that process so far.

00:23:55.485 --> 00:23:58.267
In fairness, there is nothing to
say that a vicar couldn't be a

00:23:58.370 --> 00:24:01.592
person who's suitable to that, but
there will be tests that apply to

00:24:01.596 --> 00:24:03.110
decide whether people can do that.

00:24:03.140 --> 00:24:07.730
So on the ownership side, there's a
fit and proper persons test that most

00:24:07.730 --> 00:24:09.470
people would just be able to understand.

00:24:09.834 --> 00:24:13.225
Ralph Grayson: We hope the vicar
would pass the society test.

00:24:13.232 --> 00:24:16.513
But maybe not the financial ratios test.

00:24:16.658 --> 00:24:19.564
Adam Crockett: Exactly and the other
aspect of it, as you say, do you have

00:24:19.564 --> 00:24:23.243
the adequate finances and is that money
from an illicit source they're checked?

00:24:23.627 --> 00:24:28.294
But on the senior execs and the directors,
there is an assessment, again, of fitness

00:24:28.504 --> 00:24:31.444
and propriety, but also suitability.

00:24:31.444 --> 00:24:34.910
Essentially, do you have the requisite
skills to do this job and if you

00:24:34.910 --> 00:24:38.210
don't have that, then you wouldn't
be approved by the IFR to do that.

00:24:39.290 --> 00:24:41.360
Ralph Grayson: So in, I was going
to say normal, that's a little

00:24:41.360 --> 00:24:42.320
unfair to the football world.

00:24:42.540 --> 00:24:46.622
In regular corporate governance we talk
about the skills matrix on the board.

00:24:47.091 --> 00:24:50.274
Is that something when you were helping
write the IFR report and setting

00:24:50.274 --> 00:24:54.787
it up, was there a formal approach
to thinking what a skill assessment

00:24:54.787 --> 00:24:56.647
looks like on a football board?

00:24:56.647 --> 00:25:00.618
And I guess my follow on question to that,
because I haven't seen much evidence of

00:25:00.618 --> 00:25:04.458
it, but we do formal board evaluations
here and we've done them with a number of

00:25:04.938 --> 00:25:08.488
regulatory bodies in and around football,
which I probably better not name.

00:25:09.038 --> 00:25:12.578
But I don't see much evidence, if
any, of the football clubs that

00:25:12.578 --> 00:25:18.768
we've talked to here doing any sort
of formal skill assessment or board

00:25:18.768 --> 00:25:22.618
evaluation of what have we got when
we put in our licensing application.

00:25:23.159 --> 00:25:26.849
Adam Crockett: So the answer to that
is no, we didn't, and I would come

00:25:26.849 --> 00:25:31.719
back to my first question, which was
about how the regime works in practice.

00:25:32.238 --> 00:25:36.329
So this more principles-based
system where it's not black

00:25:36.329 --> 00:25:38.819
and white has pros and cons.

00:25:39.029 --> 00:25:42.059
One of the cons is people aren't
entirely certain about exactly what

00:25:42.059 --> 00:25:46.379
is required in all instances, but what
it also allows is a club to look at

00:25:46.379 --> 00:25:51.089
its own circumstances, look at what
the regulation sets out, and try to

00:25:51.089 --> 00:25:53.129
apply that to their own circumstances.

00:25:53.849 --> 00:25:57.239
Why I think that's important, so we
didn't want to dictate exactly what does

00:25:57.239 --> 00:25:59.009
the skillset need to be on the board.

00:25:59.549 --> 00:26:03.569
We've tried to delegate that to the IFR to
help guide the industry and the industry

00:26:03.569 --> 00:26:05.099
to take ownership of some of that.

00:26:05.099 --> 00:26:08.614
But that's, I think, the types of
skills and services that you guys

00:26:08.617 --> 00:26:12.579
offer, Ralph, are exactly, I think,
what is needed here for a club to, if

00:26:12.579 --> 00:26:15.249
they don't have the skills in-house,
to come and speak to people like

00:26:15.249 --> 00:26:18.479
you and take a bit of an assessment
of what we're trying to achieve?

00:26:18.479 --> 00:26:19.409
What are our skills?

00:26:19.409 --> 00:26:21.239
What are our competitive advantages?

00:26:21.449 --> 00:26:22.529
What are our gaps?

00:26:23.159 --> 00:26:28.649
And then do that skills matrix exercise
to try and identify gaps and fill that.

00:26:28.649 --> 00:26:34.013
So I think the framework was deliberately
non-prescriptive for a series of those

00:26:34.013 --> 00:26:39.593
types of examples to try to empower
the industry and try to empower the

00:26:39.593 --> 00:26:43.193
regulator to try and get to a better
solution rather than parliament trying

00:26:43.193 --> 00:26:46.403
to pre-emptively design something
and almost certainly get it wrong.

00:26:47.403 --> 00:26:52.687
Ralph Grayson: And if the clubs don't
take this seriously, do you think

00:26:52.687 --> 00:26:56.153
the IFR and the people at the top of
the IFR are going to show some teeth?

00:26:57.067 --> 00:26:57.697
Adam Crockett: I think so.

00:26:57.697 --> 00:27:02.287
So David's a man I've known for probably
18 months now, David Kogan, the chair.

00:27:02.647 --> 00:27:07.167
He is a force of nature, but he
also is a big football man, and he

00:27:07.167 --> 00:27:09.076
will want this industry to succeed.

00:27:09.826 --> 00:27:12.447
He just put out a report that
basically said the industry's

00:27:12.447 --> 00:27:14.067
at the financial precipice.

00:27:14.457 --> 00:27:18.462
So I just don't see a world where
both because of the statute he now has

00:27:18.462 --> 00:27:22.856
ownership of and him as a person is going
to want to do anything other than try

00:27:22.870 --> 00:27:24.643
to get the industry into a good place.

00:27:25.032 --> 00:27:28.457
So I think clubs that bury their heads
in the sand and don't do anything

00:27:29.057 --> 00:27:35.917
can probably expect severe scrutiny,
potentially conditions that in part

00:27:35.917 --> 00:27:40.207
govern how their business is going to
be run and the other aspect of this

00:27:40.207 --> 00:27:41.947
is part of that is non-financial.

00:27:41.947 --> 00:27:45.491
So you might have controls, financial
controls or risk controls, put on you

00:27:45.491 --> 00:27:47.261
as part of your licence application.

00:27:48.281 --> 00:27:52.271
The other side of it as well is part of
the regime and a lot of the focus is on

00:27:52.271 --> 00:27:54.131
the financial regulation of the business.

00:27:54.131 --> 00:27:58.121
So if you don't have good governance and
you don't give the IFR confidence that you

00:27:58.481 --> 00:28:03.101
have good structures in place, I think you
can probably expect more severe financial

00:28:03.101 --> 00:28:07.991
regulation intervention from the IFR in
the short term and that's more tangible.

00:28:08.601 --> 00:28:11.751
There are a lot of people within
the IFR who have come from the FCA.

00:28:12.111 --> 00:28:16.020
I think that they probably would
think that significant financial

00:28:16.021 --> 00:28:20.023
intervention is needed if you don't
take significant non-financial

00:28:20.023 --> 00:28:22.033
intervention proactively as a club.

00:28:23.719 --> 00:28:24.579
Ralph Grayson: I love your view on this.

00:28:24.629 --> 00:28:26.315
So other podcasts are available.

00:28:26.350 --> 00:28:30.119
I'm an avid listener on my dog walks on a
Saturday night of the Business of Sport.

00:28:30.749 --> 00:28:35.128
Charlie Stebbings on that last week who
was a director of Oxford and was involved

00:28:35.128 --> 00:28:38.278
with Sunderland, if I remember, and knows
more about football than I ever will.

00:28:39.058 --> 00:28:44.008
He was making the point that while the
IFR doesn't have statutory teeth, that

00:28:44.008 --> 00:28:50.638
if they don't act when they see a problem
and Kogan suddenly finds himself up in

00:28:50.646 --> 00:28:53.608
front of the Department for Culture,
Media and Sport to say, "Why didn't

00:28:53.608 --> 00:28:56.578
you do something?" He'll just say,
"'Cause you didn't give me the powers.

00:28:56.668 --> 00:28:59.728
Now I'd like some more powers, please."
And he'll get them pretty quickly.

00:29:00.228 --> 00:29:02.927
Adam Crockett: I probably think
that's unrealistic actually.

00:29:02.927 --> 00:29:06.797
I think it was quite a bruising process to
take the legislation through parliament.

00:29:06.797 --> 00:29:11.087
So I think, I'm not sure Andy Burnham
with his grand list of things he wants to

00:29:11.087 --> 00:29:15.368
change, another go at football governance
is something where he would want to go to.

00:29:15.398 --> 00:29:19.081
But Kogan's got a pretty big toolkit
there to act already, so I'm not sure

00:29:19.081 --> 00:29:22.364
he definitely needs additional powers
would be my own view of the matter.

00:29:23.489 --> 00:29:26.762
Ralph Grayson: So what other due
diligence do you think a prospective

00:29:26.762 --> 00:29:30.122
NED should be doing before he
or she joins a football board?

00:29:30.672 --> 00:29:33.312
Adam Crockett: My own view is I don't
think you need to have a football

00:29:33.312 --> 00:29:37.252
background and be a huge football
fan to be successful in this.

00:29:37.252 --> 00:29:41.792
And in fact, I personally found all the
people who worked for me in the five

00:29:41.792 --> 00:29:46.336
years of working on this in government,
the people who weren't football fans were

00:29:46.336 --> 00:29:51.866
often the most objective and strategic
on thinking through some of this stuff.

00:29:51.866 --> 00:29:55.000
So I don't think you necessarily have
to have a big football background

00:29:55.000 --> 00:29:56.740
or even be a huge football fan.

00:29:57.310 --> 00:30:01.505
But I think you want to probably
know you're going to be listened to.

00:30:02.273 --> 00:30:07.000
I think you want to know that there
is a commitment to being challenged.

00:30:07.550 --> 00:30:12.068
I think they're two of the immediate
things I would want to see and then I

00:30:12.069 --> 00:30:15.710
would also want to get a sense of what
is the plan for the business, what's

00:30:15.710 --> 00:30:20.540
the vision for the business, how are
they planning to get to their goals?

00:30:21.440 --> 00:30:24.080
And then really what is the
role that they can bring?

00:30:24.116 --> 00:30:25.739
Given your skillset, what would you bring?

00:30:26.739 --> 00:30:29.461
Ralph Grayson: And if you're not a
football fan, what are you going to have

00:30:29.461 --> 00:30:33.441
to learn about football pretty quickly
to be effective and add value on a board?

00:30:34.042 --> 00:30:36.922
Adam Crockett: You don't have to
have a football background and be a

00:30:36.922 --> 00:30:40.312
huge football fan, but you do have to
understand the business and the economics

00:30:40.312 --> 00:30:42.142
of football and they are very different.

00:30:42.532 --> 00:30:45.742
As you said before, Ralph, I
did economics at university.

00:30:45.742 --> 00:30:48.563
The first, very first, thing that
we learned in any lecture was that

00:30:48.563 --> 00:30:50.056
all firms are profit-maximising.

00:30:50.149 --> 00:30:53.722
Well, that goes out the window and
there would be riots before clubs

00:30:53.722 --> 00:30:55.252
started to try and make a profit.

00:30:56.032 --> 00:30:59.422
They're not necessarily
overly complex businesses.

00:30:59.572 --> 00:31:04.462
So I think spending the time though
understanding where the money's coming in,

00:31:04.462 --> 00:31:09.412
where the money goes out, the structures,
the governance, the relationships, I

00:31:09.463 --> 00:31:13.222
think if you can understand that, you'll
get a good sense of the basics of the

00:31:13.222 --> 00:31:19.150
industry and then I think from there
you can probably then start to identify

00:31:19.180 --> 00:31:22.416
potential risks that come in because
there's probably only four or five

00:31:23.166 --> 00:31:25.416
revenue lines and four or five cost lines.

00:31:25.417 --> 00:31:27.696
So trying to understand that
you get to a good place.

00:31:27.816 --> 00:31:31.146
And then you can start trying to think,
"Where's this heading? How would I add

00:31:31.146 --> 00:31:33.006
some value?" Those sorts of things.

00:31:34.174 --> 00:31:37.674
Ralph Grayson: So what do you think
the balance is between the ability

00:31:37.674 --> 00:31:43.677
to read a spreadsheet and think about
the numbers, but actually having the

00:31:43.677 --> 00:31:47.690
judgement and the intuition to stand
up to the sporting director who says,

00:31:47.693 --> 00:31:48.956
"I want to buy a new centre forward."

00:31:49.479 --> 00:31:52.149
Adam Crockett: There's a nuance
to this in my view, which is

00:31:52.329 --> 00:31:54.039
you need people who can do both.

00:31:54.346 --> 00:31:59.506
For all NEDs, I think, it's not your
job to go in and say, "I wouldn't

00:31:59.506 --> 00:32:03.976
sign that player." Because you almost
certainly don't have the background

00:32:03.976 --> 00:32:08.246
unless you've actually come from
working in football on the pitch

00:32:08.276 --> 00:32:09.926
to make those sorts of judgments.

00:32:10.476 --> 00:32:14.941
But equally, there is, and I think
the State of the Game report lays

00:32:14.943 --> 00:32:19.266
this bare, a short-termism to how
certain decisions can get taken.

00:32:19.476 --> 00:32:21.597
Certainly in certain circumstances.

00:32:22.317 --> 00:32:26.007
Potentially when clubs are at risk of
relegation in the January transfer window.

00:32:26.037 --> 00:32:31.737
So I think sometimes it's not necessarily
though about having a huge knowledge

00:32:31.737 --> 00:32:36.117
of football or even being a spreadsheet
geek to be able to make those judgments.

00:32:36.357 --> 00:32:40.979
Sometimes it's about just knowing
the good strategic questions to ask.

00:32:42.712 --> 00:32:47.427
What the IFR, for example,
would be wanting to see is why

00:32:47.427 --> 00:32:48.507
have you made that decision?

00:32:49.647 --> 00:32:51.387
What happens if that doesn't come off?

00:32:51.687 --> 00:32:54.027
Do you have a plan if
this doesn't come off?

00:32:54.027 --> 00:32:58.317
And they're just common sense
basic questions you can ask.

00:32:58.317 --> 00:33:01.227
Now you can apply similar
frameworks as a NED, I think.

00:33:01.617 --> 00:33:06.057
You can just ask some fairly
rudimentary basic questions to try and

00:33:06.057 --> 00:33:09.807
understand the decision, how it fits
within the strategic plan that you

00:33:09.807 --> 00:33:12.357
have in place, where this gets you.

00:33:13.077 --> 00:33:15.905
I think they're all sensible
things a NED can do.

00:33:16.937 --> 00:33:19.053
Ralph Grayson: And of course in the
boardroom, what we talk about all the time

00:33:19.053 --> 00:33:21.423
is stakeholders as well as shareholders.

00:33:21.423 --> 00:33:24.850
And what we haven't touched on is
the whole area of the fan base.

00:33:25.103 --> 00:33:32.459
To what extent is the fan integral
within the IFR's raison d'être and North

00:33:32.459 --> 00:33:36.873
Star, and how should a prospective board
member joining a football board think

00:33:36.873 --> 00:33:41.673
about fans and the duty to them as well
as the duty to financial stability as

00:33:41.673 --> 00:33:43.563
well as the duty to the shareholders?

00:33:44.268 --> 00:33:47.356
Adam Crockett: I mean they are incredibly
important and I think as soon as a

00:33:47.357 --> 00:33:52.698
club or a board loses its fans, you're
in real trouble and it's very, very

00:33:52.698 --> 00:33:58.158
difficult to turn that round and
they are the lifeblood of the club.

00:33:58.158 --> 00:34:01.878
They are the people that
spend their money, help the

00:34:01.878 --> 00:34:03.888
club through thick and thin.

00:34:04.728 --> 00:34:10.618
The legislation has specific requirements
on clubs which give the fans more power.

00:34:10.708 --> 00:34:17.758
So each football club will need to
consult as part of its licence with

00:34:17.758 --> 00:34:19.978
their fans on key strategic decisions.

00:34:19.978 --> 00:34:24.718
So that might be, and tickets are in fact
named on the face of the legislation,

00:34:24.718 --> 00:34:28.888
but clubs are under pressure, they
need to grow revenue, they might

00:34:28.888 --> 00:34:30.508
need to put up their ticket prices.

00:34:30.838 --> 00:34:34.542
What the legislation has said
is you need to engage with your

00:34:34.542 --> 00:34:36.402
fans in a meaningful way on this.

00:34:37.152 --> 00:34:42.582
So what that might mean in practice is
you're thinking about putting prices up,

00:34:42.634 --> 00:34:46.727
you might have held them at the same level
for 10 years, going out and consulting

00:34:46.727 --> 00:34:51.407
on what the change is, explaining the
change, listening to the feedback, where

00:34:51.407 --> 00:34:56.051
you can act on that and where you don't
make a decision to change your decision.

00:34:56.621 --> 00:34:59.141
Explain that and explain why
you've reached that decision.

00:34:59.141 --> 00:35:02.951
So I think meaningful engagement
is central to how this will work.

00:35:03.461 --> 00:35:06.671
There are three limbs to
getting a full licence.

00:35:07.181 --> 00:35:11.261
One of the three limbs is the fan
engagement threshold condition.

00:35:11.441 --> 00:35:15.425
Do you engage with your fans
meaningfully on key strategic decisions?

00:35:15.845 --> 00:35:19.146
And then fans will also have a
say on if you're going to move

00:35:19.167 --> 00:35:21.160
ground, fans need to be consulted.

00:35:21.449 --> 00:35:23.823
If you're going to change the
badge, if you're going to change

00:35:23.825 --> 00:35:27.455
the home shirt colour, or if you're
going to change the name, you need

00:35:27.455 --> 00:35:28.955
to also engage with your fans.

00:35:28.955 --> 00:35:33.503
So what some of this does is
the FA already has rules that do

00:35:33.856 --> 00:35:35.365
a light touch version of this.

00:35:35.365 --> 00:35:39.575
This is a sort of statutory
backstop to make sure that happens

00:35:40.025 --> 00:35:43.725
and properly engaging with fans
will be a licence requirement.

00:35:44.725 --> 00:35:47.385
Ralph Grayson: So I don't know whether
we've got our listeners to a point

00:35:47.385 --> 00:35:53.190
where they're either terrified or
thinking, "I'd love to do this." But

00:35:53.521 --> 00:35:57.415
from your perspective and, there's
been nobody closer to the heart of

00:35:57.415 --> 00:36:02.575
this than you, why do you think a board
member, prospective board member, should

00:36:02.575 --> 00:36:03.761
think about joining a football club?

00:36:04.288 --> 00:36:06.718
Adam Crockett: The first thing I
would say is when I first got to

00:36:06.718 --> 00:36:10.918
work on football, I was absolutely
delighted as a very big football fan,

00:36:10.918 --> 00:36:12.898
but that wears off quite quickly.

00:36:13.361 --> 00:36:19.618
this is the best area I've ever worked
in and the reason that I say that

00:36:19.618 --> 00:36:22.138
is, it is like no other industry.

00:36:22.408 --> 00:36:27.448
In many instances, it's bonkers,
but it's also incredibly fun.

00:36:28.078 --> 00:36:30.088
It makes a huge amount of difference.

00:36:30.088 --> 00:36:34.708
So you would be working on something that
makes a huge difference to thousands or

00:36:34.738 --> 00:36:41.188
millions of people, is intrinsic to the
local community, it has huge profile.

00:36:41.188 --> 00:36:44.518
They are brilliant things to
get to work on, and you really

00:36:44.518 --> 00:36:47.338
would be making a difference to
the community that you serve.

00:36:48.015 --> 00:36:51.825
Part of the reason I loved it
as well though, I'm sort of a

00:36:51.855 --> 00:36:54.751
semi-academic economic nerd.

00:36:55.291 --> 00:37:00.211
They are very challenging policy problems
and as some of your questions have laid

00:37:00.211 --> 00:37:07.531
out, Ralph, they are often with lots
of competing tensions in place and for

00:37:07.531 --> 00:37:13.681
people that like big challenges that
matter to millions of people, and by

00:37:13.681 --> 00:37:17.371
the way, it's fun and it's interesting
and you can speak to someone at a

00:37:17.371 --> 00:37:21.481
dinner party or in the pub about it and
they'll get it, you honestly won't get

00:37:21.481 --> 00:37:23.235
a better opportunity than doing that.

00:37:23.260 --> 00:37:28.711
So I really would say it is
one of the best gigs  for your

00:37:28.711 --> 00:37:29.791
clients to get to work on.

00:37:31.066 --> 00:37:31.966
Ralph Grayson: Adam, thank you.

00:37:32.256 --> 00:37:37.026
What I take from all of this is that a
board needs the people, the information

00:37:37.086 --> 00:37:42.807
and the authority, to make difficult
decisions before the pressure in

00:37:42.808 --> 00:37:44.960
football's going to overwhelm the clubs.

00:37:45.336 --> 00:37:49.356
So for anyone considering a role in
football, the question, it seems to

00:37:49.356 --> 00:37:53.436
me, is whether their experience can
help the club make better decisions and

00:37:53.436 --> 00:37:56.016
whether the club will let them use it.

00:37:56.766 --> 00:38:02.016
If they're intrigued by this dichotomy,
how do they follow up with you?

00:38:02.376 --> 00:38:04.956
Where do they read you
on Substack on LinkedIn?

00:38:04.986 --> 00:38:08.183
And I know you've got your own consulting
business now, so if an owner of a

00:38:08.183 --> 00:38:11.862
football club is thinking, "I hadn't
given this the care and attention yet

00:38:11.959 --> 00:38:16.443
and no better person than the one who
helped write the central premise,"

00:38:16.673 --> 00:38:17.753
how do they get in contact with you?

00:38:18.340 --> 00:38:21.904
Adam Crockett: So firstly, I'm on
LinkedIn so people can find me there.

00:38:22.184 --> 00:38:30.014
I am at adamc@gameplan-sa.com if people
want to email me and then I have a

00:38:30.014 --> 00:38:33.464
Substack where I've tried to talk about
some of these issues in more detail, and

00:38:33.464 --> 00:38:37.614
I know, Ralph, as part of your doctorate
you've been looking at some of that.

00:38:37.664 --> 00:38:39.706
I've gone into some of
these issues in more detail.

00:38:39.707 --> 00:38:43.274
So @adamcrockett1 on Substack and I
explain a bit more of these things

00:38:43.274 --> 00:38:46.664
if people want to do a bit more
due diligence and hear about the

00:38:46.664 --> 00:38:48.794
industry and what's coming a bit more.

00:38:49.199 --> 00:38:50.009
Ralph Grayson: Adam, that's amazing.

00:38:50.009 --> 00:38:53.219
I think this story is going to run
and I suspect this won't be the last

00:38:53.339 --> 00:38:54.786
podcast we have on this subject.

00:38:54.786 --> 00:38:57.366
So in the meantime, until the
next time, thank you so much.

00:38:57.441 --> 00:38:57.951
Adam Crockett: Thank you.

00:38:59.048 --> 00:39:02.318
Ralph Grayson: I hope that you've enjoyed
listening to this podcast and have found

00:39:02.318 --> 00:39:06.578
it helpful when thinking about how to
approach your own path to the boardroom.

00:39:07.468 --> 00:39:10.608
If you would like to push this a
little bit further, Sainty Hird

00:39:10.628 --> 00:39:15.418
runs a bespoke one-to-one programme
designed specifically to this end.

00:39:15.752 --> 00:39:20.436
For more information, please visit
our website saintyhird.com, follow

00:39:20.436 --> 00:39:26.291
us on LinkedIn, and subscribe to the
Boardroom Path to receive new episodes.

00:39:26.637 --> 00:39:27.587
Thank you for listening.