Beijing: Behind the Gates A sound inside the wall: Allison Murray: I am Allison Murray and this is Elsewhere. Allison Murray: A ladle of batter hits a hot iron plate and hisses. The cook spreads it thin, a fistful of scallions scatters across it, and something crisp and folded lands in your hand in a paper sleeve, too hot to hold and too good to wait for. And breakfast is only the beginning. Grey lanes run between courtyard walls. Great red gates rise, and a square lies open to the sky. This is Beijing. Built for emperors, taken by new rulers, claimed by a new state. So who gets to gather in its great spaces now, and how did they change hands? Come along. Let's go. A capital made to measure: Allison Murray: Let that breakfast sizzle fade into something heavier: the knock of mallets on timber and the scrape of stone, as an emperor builds a capital to his own measure. This is Beijing at its turning point. Why here, of all places? Why did Yongle choose it, Hugo? Hugo Carr: Because it had been a capital before, and a mighty one. Kublai Khan established his Yuan capital here, a city called Dadu, whose boundaries first drew the rough lines of what is now Dongcheng District, part of the old core. Then his dynasty fell. The new Ming rulers governed from Nanjing and had the old Mongol palaces razed. Beijing was left a capital with nobody on the throne. Allison Murray: So he wasn't building on empty ground. He was building on rubble. Hugo Carr: Rubble with a past, which suited him beautifully. Zhu Di had spent years up here as Prince of Yan, ruling the Beijing region. In fourteen oh two he seized the throne from his own nephew and became the Yongle Emperor. Nanjing was the court he had just overthrown; the north was where his strength lay. So Yongle made his decision: the Ming capital would move to Beijing, onto his own ground, and closer to the frontier, where the Mongols were still a threat. Allison Murray: Moving the whole court towards the danger. On purpose. Hugo Carr: On purpose, and on a colossal scale. Skilled artisans and labourers were drawn from across China. Precious zhennan timber came out of southwestern jungles; marble blocks were dragged over roads slicked with ice. All of it served the emperor, his court and his officials, and ordinary subjects were forbidden entry. Shichahai's lakes took their name from the temples that once ringed the water. And the trace is the wall: long, crimson, still enclosing the palace, separating the court from ordinary subjects. Breakfast in a wrapper: Allison Murray: An army of labourers built that palace. Now it's one cook, one round griddle, and the hiss of batter hitting hot iron in Dongcheng District. What does that sound promise, Beth? Beth Hartley: Breakfast made for you alone. Dongcheng still holds the Forbidden City and the Temple of Heaven, but it also has hutong lanes of courtyard homes, and that's where the carts sit, making jianbing, a savoury mung-bean crepe, to order. Allison Murray: So when do I need to be standing there? Beth Hartley: Early. The carts typically set up around seven and pack up by mid-morning. Queues of office workers gather by subway entrances or hutongs. Leave it too late and the griddle's gone cold. Allison Murray: Wells, I have no Mandarin. How does an order even start? Wells Harrington: Hold up one finger. That's one jianbing. Point at the eggs if you want an extra. Then the cook ladles batter onto the griddle and spreads it in quick circles, into one thin, even round. Beth Hartley: Then an egg, cracked straight onto the batter and spread across it, with the yolk and the white kept a little apart, so you get both. Wells Harrington: Scallions and cilantro go on next, then a brush of sweet bean sauce and some chili. That smell gets to the queue long before the crepe is finished. Beth Hartley: And here's the Beijing touch. It's a baocui, a thin, crisp cracker laid in the middle. In Tianjin, it's often a fried dough stick. Beijing wanted a snap. Wells Harrington: You make that fold sound so tidy. It's a sheet of glass wrapped in a pancake. That neatness has about one bite to live. Allison Murray: Breakfast engineered for a hand, not a plate. Beth Hartley: Which is exactly what it turned into. Its Tianjin cousin was once a late-night snack for dockworkers, and the carts later returned as breakfast stalls. Now the sides fold over, the bottom tucks up, and the whole packet goes into paper. Allison Murray: Mind your fingers, Wells. It's the only hand-warmer in Beijing with sesame seeds. Wells Harrington: It's warm and a little greasy through the paper. Then comes the first bite. Soft crepe, soft egg, and then the cracker shatters, and that tidy packet is never tidy again. The Forbidden City’s enormous front door: Allison Murray: That jianbing was small enough to juggle; this front door is too big to take in with both eyes. Everyone knows the red walls and golden roofs of the Forbidden City, now the Palace Museum. But in the early sun, what's the first thing that actually stops you, Nora? Nora Larkin: The Meridian Gate, Wumen, the enormous front door. Its towers reach forward on either side like wings, which is why people call it the Five Phoenix. And in that wall of red there's a row of arches, and the middle one belonged to one man alone. Allison Murray: One man. Hugh, that's not a door, that's a velvet rope. Hugh Danner: A very expensive velvet rope. Everyone else took a side passage, graded by rank, so you knew your place before your first step. And it doesn't stop at the gate: bridges, more gates, vast open courts. The distance is the design. Nora Larkin: A design, yes. But a design is somebody's wish, and that's the part I can't stop wondering about. Who wanted to be that far away from everyone? Allison Murray: My guess is someone with something to prove. Nora Larkin: You'd be right. Zhu Di, the Yongle Emperor. He'd taken the throne from his own nephew and ordered this palace begun in fourteen oh six. His builders finished it in fourteen twenty, as the Ming court made its move to Beijing. A man who'd seized a throne, building himself a door nobody else could use. Allison Murray: Hugh, that sounds like swagger in stone. Hugh Danner: Swagger doesn't need this much floor space. These were working courts. When processions went out, bells and drums sounded from those gate towers, and officials filled the open court below the throne hall for the great ceremonies. The palace Yongle ordered could let a whole empire's business in, rank by rank, and still keep him apart. Allison Murray: Did he at least get to enjoy it, Nora? Nora Larkin: Barely. Soon after the court moved in, fire destroyed the three great outer halls and they had to be rebuilt. And the hands that built it belonged to people like Nguyen An, a Vietnamese eunuch who was one of its engineers. The plan outlived them all: emperors of two dynasties kept living behind that door. Allison Murray: A usurper's front door, and two dynasties walked through it. So before anyone today gets near it, what has to be decided, Hugh? Hugh Danner: The day, and a week ahead. If you want your morning here, the dated tickets go on sale online seven days before, through the museum's official channels, in your own name with your passport. Nothing is sold at the gate on the day. Allison Murray: So the emperor strolled in whenever he liked, and you need paperwork. Say you've made it through the arch. Nora, what's waiting in all that stone? Nora Larkin: Marble bridges over a curving stream, enormous gates, and courts so wide that even a morning crowd thins and you hear your own steps. It was a home for emperors; now it's a museum, and the halls are still waiting. Hugh Danner: Waiting, and not getting any closer. That's the design still working, Nora. That great throne hall riding up on its white marble terraces makes an official feel small. The distance was built for them. It works just as well on you. New Year at Ditan: Allison Murray: The palace's long stone hush cracks open into gongs, drums and frying dough at the Ditan Temple Fair, and you can try your luck with scissors, Cooper. Cooper Vale: You can. It's midday in Ditan Park, the Temple of Earth, it's packed, and artisans at the craft stalls often let visitors try paper-cutting. You can snip the character fu, good fortune, out of red paper and hold it up against the old cypress trees. Allison Murray: So I'm cutting my own luck. And those drums, Frances, who are they for? Rev. Frances Calder: For the ceremony, someone playing an emperor. These grounds were where Ming and Qing emperors made sacrifices to the earth for good weather and harvests, and ordinary people weren't allowed in at all. Allison Murray: And now? Rev. Frances Calder: Now dozens of costumed performers re-create the Qing procedure at the Fangze Altar, with a procession and offerings of jade and silk. It's a careful re-enactment of a state rite. Watch it as that, and it's rather moving. Allison Murray: Cooper, the crowd is here for the lion too, isn't it? Cooper Vale: The lion, and everything next to it. The rite is one altar. Out here, lion dancers shove right through the crowd scattering blessings, acrobats flip on the stages, and somebody's pinching your zodiac animal out of coloured dough. Allison Murray: I've traded the emperor for scissors. Cooper Vale: At noon, yes. If the ceremony is the point, come in the morning, in the first days. The fair typically runs the first seven days of the lunar new year, and the rite usually comes early. Allison Murray: Frances, is the fair as old as the altar? Rev. Frances Calder: Not remotely. It came back in nineteen eighty-five, after a long silence that took in the Cultural Revolution, as the city's first official temple fair since the People's Republic began. The altar's tradition is what it chose to borrow. Allison Murray: And it borrowed a lot of braised pork, Cooper. Cooper Vale: Luzhu huoshao, pork and flatbread in one bowl, and tea porridge poured from a kettle with a spout as long as your arm. Eat it with that red fu in your pocket. You cut it on ground the commoners were once kept off. A harvest under blue tiles: Allison Murray: The fair's drums and the New Year crush fall away, and at midday there's only a round roof, three tiers of deep blue glazed tile, blazing above white marble at the Temple of Heaven. What was a round hall for, August? August Mercer: For the harvest. That's the Hall of Prayer for Good Harvests, a wooden hall where, each spring, the emperor came to ask Heaven for an abundant year. When the Yongle Emperor moved his capital north, a place for that rite was part of the plan from the start. Allison Murray: So the round hall is Yongle's design. Gideon? Gideon Thorne: Not quite. Yongle's hall was rectangular. It turned round more than a century later, when the Jiajing Emperor reorganised the rites. Heaven was round and Earth was square, so the whole complex plays that out: round buildings on square platforms, and nine, Heaven's number, turning up again and again. August Mercer: A beautiful diagram, Gideon, but to the man performing the rite it wasn't geometry. He fasted for days beforehand. One wrong note in the music, one misstep in the choreography, and the whole realm read it as a grave omen. Gideon Thorne: Which is why the building had to be right as well. Get the shape wrong and the prayer goes to the wrong address. Allison Murray: Then the roof. Why that blue? Gideon Thorne: Blue faces Heaven. But here's the surprise: the hall's all-blue roof came later, under the Qianlong Emperor. The hall on every postcard is a later emperor's finishing touch. Allison Murray: A Qing paint job on a Ming idea. Is anything here original, August? August Mercer: Not even the timber. The hall was rebuilt after a lightning fire, the old way, beams locked into one another without a single nail. Every joint holds by fit alone. I'd call that a steady pair of hands. Gideon Thorne: And the columns holding it up are a calendar: an inner ring for the seasons, a middle ring for the months, an outer ring for the traditional Chinese hours of the day. The roof rests on time itself. Allison Murray: Practical question, then. How close does a visitor actually get? Gideon Thorne: That's down to your ticket. A park-only ticket gives you the grounds and the old cypresses. The hall's enclosure and the other ceremonial sites need the combined ticket, so if the hall is why you came, buy that one. Allison Murray: And once you're through, August? August Mercer: The white marble terrace rises tier on tier, and the scale tells you this was a stage for one man. In silence broken only by ritual music, the emperor offered jade and silk, kowtowed nine times, then read his prayer and burned it. Allison Murray: An emperor's prayer in smoke, and the same terrace open to anyone with a ticket. Did they keep it up long, Gideon? Gideon Thorne: Nearly five hundred years; later, the grounds became a public park. At noon those blue roofs throw the light back so hard they look freshly glazed. August Mercer: And around all that ceremony, Gideon, ordinary Beijing simply carries on. Under the cypresses people practise tai chi, sing together, slap down playing cards. The rite was once performed for everyone's harvest. The park now belongs to everyone's lunch hour. At hutong speed: Allison Murray: The emperor's enormous open sky narrows here to a strip between grey-brick walls, and the loudest sound is a chain clicking under a driver's pedals. This is the hutong rickshaw tour at Shichahai, the lakes quarter that includes Houhai. Katie, short ride or long? Katie Galbraith: Shichahai is three linked lakes ringed by willows. Old hutong lanes and courtyard homes crowd the shore, and people fish and play chess at the edges. The short ride takes about half an hour. The longer versions add stops, like tea in a local family's courtyard. Allison Murray: And the man with the pedals names the price? Katie Galbraith: Not if you board at an official station. The drivers there wear uniforms and numbers, ride fixed routes and charge set prices for each version, so short or long is settled before you climb in. Freelance drivers are where the overcharging stories start. Allison Murray: A rickshaw with a menu. Iris, what does the first lane feel like from that seat? Iris Marchetti: Close. The lane is too narrow for cars, and the seat puts you level with carved courtyard gates, a chessboard on a stool, a songbird in its cage. The midday shade drops over you like a lid. None of it is a set. People live behind those walls. Allison Murray: So does a moving seat show you enough, Katie? Katie Galbraith: As an overview, yes. The driver takes the turns slowly, and plenty of them talk as they pedal, sometimes in basic English, sometimes in quick local dialect you won't follow but will enjoy. You get the shape of a whole neighbourhood in one sitting. Iris Marchetti: The shape, yes. But notice what eye level does to you. You're close enough to see a man's next chess move and never close enough to be asked in. That's the honest bargain of the ride: you glimpse somebody's home, you don't visit it. Katie Galbraith: Which is exactly what the longer package is selling. That courtyard tea is the arranged, paid way past the gate. The short ride never pretends to be that. Allison Murray: And then the walls just stop. Katie Galbraith: And there's water. That's Yinding Bridge, a narrow stone arch linking the lakes, with views of the Western Hills on a clear day. Allison Murray: Who decided pedicabs belong here? Katie Galbraith: Pedal rickshaws were ordinary transport until cars and the subway took over. Then visitors came looking for the surviving hutongs, and the pedicabs found new work. Yandai Xiejie brings the shop bustle: the old tobacco-pouch street. Allison Murray: Iris, what if I want to stop at a gate? Iris Marchetti: Then the ride has done its job. It gave you the scale of the place quickly. On foot, every pause is yours, and you can linger over a carved gate as long as you like. The lane doesn't charge by the minute. Katie Galbraith: So pick your speed. Ride, and someone else pedals you through the lanes while you just look. Walk, and every stop is yours. Either way the courtyards stay private, unless you've booked that cup of tea. When Beijing heard the hour: Allison Murray: The hutong lanes gave you one neighbourhood at a time; Beijing's Drum Tower and Bell Tower once addressed a whole capital. Walter, who plays the drums today? Walter Davies: Drummers in traditional costume, up in the tower's main hall, at one of the scheduled performances. It opens in quick strikes and settles into slow ones, and you feel it before you've decided whether you like it, through the floor and in the ribs. Gulou, it's called. Simply, drum tower. Allison Murray: A drum that size wasn't built to entertain anyone. Thomas, who was it actually for? Thomas Walker: Everyone outside the palace walls, which is the interesting part. A clock in a courtyard serves whoever owns the courtyard. A drum on a tower gives the whole capital the same time at once: the shopkeeper, the porter, the man hurrying home before the gates shut. Walter Davies: Thomas, it wasn't polite information, though. The drums marked the geng, a night watch of roughly two hours, starting at dusk with a beat nobody could sleep through. Then the bell answered from next door, the largest ancient bronze bell left in China, and that meant the city gates were closing. Allison Murray: So Beijing's great public alarm clock was for bedtime. Thomas Walker: Bedtime, and business. The same bell opened the gates again at dawn, so a trader's day began on its note. Under the Ming, this pair served as the capital's official timekeepers. Neither tower is quite what they built, though: the Bell Tower was remade in brick and stone under the Qing, after its wooden predecessors burned. Allison Murray: Walter, someone turning up at noon. Will the tower just be booming away the whole time? Walter Davies: No. The drums only sound at set performance times, several a day from morning into the afternoon. Plan the climb around one of those slots, or you'll be standing beside some very silent drums. Thomas Walker: And the climb is real: steep stone stairs up to the hall where the drums stand. One great drum stood for the year, and the smaller ones for the solar terms, the old farming calendar of the seasons. Allison Murray: A whole year, racked up and ready to hit. Walter Davies: Which is why that first beat sounds different up there. Fast, then slow: once it meant the watch had changed and the gates were going. Among the copies sits the one original main drum left, its cowhide head scarred by bayonets. That's the voice the city obeyed. Allison Murray: From curfew to curtain call, Thomas. Thomas Walker: And it still keeps a kind of time. Several times a day the drummers take their places in that hall, the first quick strikes roll out over the grey hutong roofs, and the floor hums under everyone standing there. The frontier and the new court: Allison Murray: That drum kept the Ming city's hours. It could not keep its throne. The palace is finished, the frontier is walled, so who comes through the door, Hugo? Hugo Carr: Not who the Ming expected, Allison. The dynasty that finished Yongle's capital spent its later years staring at the northern frontier. This city sat uncomfortably close to the steppe, so the Ming poured men and money into the mountains beyond it, rebuilding the Great Wall along forested ridges at places like Mutianyu. Watchtower after watchtower on the crests, built for defence. Allison Murray: A capital with its back to its own people. Hugo Carr: Which is exactly where the blow landed. In sixteen forty-four, rebels under Li Zicheng took Beijing, and the Chongzhen Emperor, the last Ming ruler here, hanged himself. His family never sat on this throne again. Then a Ming general, Wu Sangui, sided with the Manchus at the Battle of Shanhai Pass, and Manchu forces came on into the capital. Under their commander, Prince Dorgon, the young Shunzhi Emperor was proclaimed in Beijing. The palace and the whole machinery of the capital passed to a new dynasty, the Qing. Allison Murray: Same rooms, entirely new family at the head of the table. Hugo Carr: And a far larger table. The Qing governed a wider empire from Beijing, drawing Mongol and Tibetan networks into the court alongside the Han. For the people who did the hauling and building, one demand remained: the new court commanded labour and resources just as the old one had. What a visitor sees today is the look of that court's city: imperial roofs glazed in yellow, above walls of red. The find at Panjiayuan: Allison Murray: From a court that roofed itself in imperial yellow down to tarps, folding tables and the clink of coins in a tray. Somebody is calling 'cheap, cheap' in English across Panjiayuan Antique Market, out in Chaoyang. What's the first thing a visitor has to get right, Jack? Jack Hadley: The day. Come on a Saturday or a Sunday. The shops trade all week, but the outdoor stalls, the tarps and tables that make this Beijing's biggest flea market, really fill up at the weekend. Turn up on a Tuesday and you get the shops without the full weekend bustle. Allison Murray: And if you arrive at lunchtime, has the treasure gone? Jack Hadley: Serious collectors arrive at dawn with torches, scanning the new stock. That's how it began in the nineteen eighties: a ghost market, people laying family heirlooms on blankets at first light, sometimes quietly, while private trade was restricted. It only became official in nineteen ninety-two. At midday you can take your time. You're browsing. Allison Murray: Browsing what, exactly? Jack Hadley: Porcelain, calligraphy, propaganda posters, and beside them a great many replicas and folk crafts. Nearly everything arrives with a story. And never buy at the first stall: compare the asking prices for the same bead bracelet three times over and you have a feel for its price before you bargain. Allison Murray: Marcus, a visitor picks up one small carved jade pendant. Before they hear a word of the story, what is it telling them? Marcus Hale: Pick it up before you listen to anything. Feel the weight, the coolness, the polish under your thumb. Hold it to the light and look for the natural skin or tiny inclusions you'd expect in Hetian nephrite, the jade that comes out of Xinjiang. Then the carving itself: a peace buckle, perhaps, with the tool's work plain to see. Jack Hadley: And when the pendant comes with a claim of Qing-dynasty origins? Or can a nice pendant just be a nice pendant? Marcus Hale: It can, and nearly always is. What's on these tables is overwhelmingly modern carving, made for today's market. Ancient jade does exist, but it's difficult to authenticate at a folding table surrounded by reproductions. The stone tells you how it was cut and polished. It can't tell you who sat on the throne. Allison Murray: Then the slow part's over. Jack, how fast does the haggling go? Jack Hadley: Fast and cheerful. Open at about a third of the asking price, say it's too expensive, ask for the last price. Take two things instead of one and the figure may drop again. Allison Murray: And if they won't budge? Jack Hadley: You walk away. Slowly. Vendors very often call you back with a lower counter before you've reached the next table. The walk is practically part of the price. Allison Murray: So the dynasty stays at the stall, Marcus, and nobody pays for it. Marcus Hale: Nor should they. Pay in small notes, since many outdoor stalls prefer cash, or by phone where they take it, and ask for any available receipt or basic description. Then it's wrapped and handed over, and you walk out with a carving whose weight and polish you judged yourself, and a haggle worth retelling. The prince’s house becomes a monastery: Allison Murray: Panjiayuan sent us off with a pendant and an argument over its price. Here, at the gate, the incense sticks come free. Everyone pictures the golden roofs of the Lama Temple, the Yonghe Temple, with smoke drifting across them. But under those roofs, Nora, whose house was this? Nora Larkin: A prince's. It was built for a son of the new Manchu dynasty, and that prince's own son was born here, in a wing called the East Academy. The baby grew up to be the Qianlong Emperor. Allison Murray: So the emperor handed the house he was born in to monks? Nora Larkin: He finished something his father had started. When that prince became emperor himself, half the grounds went to Tibetan Buddhist monks and the rest stayed a palace. Then, in seventeen forty-four, Qianlong's edict made the whole place a lamasery. What he privately felt, nobody can tell you. What he signed, we know. Allison Murray: Most of us just turn the old bedroom into a study. Gideon, can you see that decision from the courtyard? Gideon Thorne: In the roofs, yes. When this was a prince's house, the roofs were a blue-green. Qianlong had them retiled in yellow, the glaze kept for imperial buildings. Before you've read a single word anywhere, the roofline tells you about its imperial patronage. Allison Murray: Nora, did anyone put it in words? Nora Larkin: In stone. A stele by the gate records the conversion, carved in four different scripts. One stone, written for readers right across the empire, not just for this city. Gideon Thorne: And those readers came. Qianlong brought in monks from Tibet and Mongolia in large numbers, and the temple became the government's centre for running lama affairs. So that stele isn't decoration. It's a notice addressed to the far edges of the empire. Allison Murray: A monastery and an office. Nora Larkin: And a school. Colleges were set up inside, teaching everything from tantric ritual to medicine and the calendar. Allison Murray: Gideon, where does all of that sit in the buildings? Gideon Thorne: Each hall has its subject: guardian kings, the Buddhas of past, present and future, a great bronze of Tsongkhapa, founder of the order. A prince's courtyards, given a religious life. Allison Murray: And if I've only got the middle of the day, what should I know about getting in? Gideon Thorne: Last entry is an hour before closing. Closing time varies with the season, so leave yourself time rather than counting on a late arrival. Allison Murray: Nora, are the buildings themselves the pleasure? Nora Larkin: Half of it. The other half is that this isn't a museum. Monks live here, chanting fills the halls, and on the big days of the lunar calendar devotees crowd in with incense. Allison Murray: And all that incense hangs in the air. Gideon, what's the great spectacle? Gideon Thorne: The Pavilion of Ten Thousand Happinesses, and inside it Maitreya, the Buddha still to come. A towering figure, carved from a single trunk of white sandalwood sent from Tibet as a gift. Open balconies frame him, with sandalwood scent in the air. Nora Larkin: Monks still chant here. A prince's house became a monastery because an emperor decided it would, and it is one still. A boat on Houhai: Allison Murray: Incense curls under the temple roof; across Shichahai's old lakes, water knocks against a hull beneath a great deal more sky. On Houhai Lake, the boats come out in the warm months. Katie, what does a first-timer actually do at the water's edge? Katie Galbraith: Pick a boat, which is a bigger decision than it looks. There's a four-seat pedal boat, an electric one, or a shared wooden rowboat with a boatman in a bamboo hat. Push off, and the lakeside chatter starts shrinking behind you. Allison Murray: And the money changes hands where? Katie Galbraith: Right at the pier, before you board. A pedal boat is hired whole, by the hour; the rowboat is usually a seat, paid per person. And you needn't come back where you started. Any participating dock will take the boat. Allison Murray: A one-way lake. Sneaky. Katie Galbraith: Very. Out on the water it goes quiet: the slap of pedals or an oar, willow branches trailing into the lake, and maybe a wild duck that has no interest in you whatsoever. Allison Murray: So you're peering into everyone's back yard. Katie Galbraith: Into rooftops, mostly. The siheyuan, the old courtyard houses, show their tiles to the water. Boat rentals developed as the shore opened up to visitors. Allison Murray: My guess: the pedal boat is for people who can't sit still. Katie Galbraith: Partly. Pedal and you're the captain, with a view of Yinding Bridge, the little Silver Ingot Bridge. Take the rowboat and someone else does the work while you watch, and some boatmen tell stories or sing. Allison Murray: Steering, or being serenaded. Katie Galbraith: Neither is the lesser ride. One buys you control, the other buys you the view. Either way, grab a cold drink from a lakeside vendor first; it's allowed aboard. Allison Murray: And then the bank comes back into earshot. Katie Galbraith: You step off at a participating dock, and the roofs disappear behind the walls again. What a watchtower can do: Allison Murray: The lake held a few quiet boats; the Mutianyu Great Wall offers an excursion out of the city, with wind coming up a mountain ridge and nothing to stop it. It's some seventy kilometres from central Beijing in the forested hills of Huairou. What am I actually looking at up there, Gideon? Gideon Thorne: Grey, kiln-fired brick on a granite base, riding the crest of the ridges as if someone had traced the skyline with a pen. Forest falls away on both sides. And towers. Every couple of hundred metres, another one rises straight out of the wall. Allison Murray: That close? It sounds less like a wall and more like a queue of towers. Gideon Thorne: That's exactly where the story starts. The hollow towers have rooms inside, arrow slits, little observation windows. And in places the walkway has notched battlements on both of its edges, not just the one facing outward. Allison Murray: Before I admire any of it, there's a mountain. How much of it am I climbing? Gideon Thorne: As much as you choose. There's a shuttle bus from the visitor centre, and an enclosed cable car or an open chairlift can spare you the climb. A toboggan track offers a way down when weather allows. Allison Murray: Back to those hollow towers. A tower you could live inside isn't what I pictured. Gideon Thorne: That's General Qi Jiguang's doing. Ming commanders kept strengthening the defences beyond their capital, and in fifteen sixty-nine Qi began reinforcing this stretch. He'd made his name fighting pirates on the southeast coast, where he'd built hollow two-storey towers that housed troops and stored weapons. He carried the idea north. Allison Murray: A seaside idea, hauled up a mountain. Gideon Thorne: And rebuilt for it. Gun ports, storage, somewhere for soldiers to sleep, and each tower near enough to support the next. That's your queue. A tower stopped being just a lookout and became a little garrison. Allison Murray: Funny. All that famous scenery, and what shaped it was a staffing plan. Gideon Thorne: And a quality-control plan. Qi's builders worked to precise brick calculations, with specially fired bricks, and bricks were often marked with the makers' names and where they came from. A bad brick had somebody's name on it. Allison Murray: Which leaves the battlements on the inside. Who guards against their own side? Gideon Thorne: Not their own side, the rear. Most of the Great Wall is notched only on the outer face. Qi gave this walkway battlements on the inner face too, so if raiders broke through or came round behind, archers could still fire from cover. Those two notched edges are a plan for the worst day. Allison Murray: Though what people walk between now has been restored, not left untouched since the Ming. Gideon Thorne: Yes. Later restoration preserved Qi's outline, the hollow towers and the double battlements, even where the bricks are newer. Allison Murray: So the floor plan is his, whatever the brick's age. Gideon Thorne: And the floor plan is still being used. All afternoon, people climb the stairs from tower to tower, duck into those hollow rooms out of the wind, and plenty of them finish by sitting on a little sled and rattling down the toboggan track, one hand on the brake. The public capital: Allison Murray: Those towers watched a mountain ridge for armies. In the twentieth century the armies reached the city itself, long after the Qing court had gone. What came through Beijing's gates, Hugo? Hugo Carr: Occupation first. Then, instead of peace, civil war. Beijing had already been stripped of its crown under the Republic, and it spent those years under other people's flags and other people's orders. A punishing passage for the city. Allison Murray: Two wars back to back, and a city with no crown left. Hugo Carr: Which is why the next decision mattered so much. In nineteen forty-nine the Communists won, and someone had to choose a setting for the new state's founding ceremony. Zhou Enlai made that choice: Tiananmen, the Gate of Heavenly Peace, the old imperial gate, picked over the other sites. Rather a theatrical instinct, I'd say. The ground before that gate had been a walled imperial forecourt that ordinary people could scarcely enter. Then, one October afternoon, Mao Zedong stood on the gate and proclaimed the People's Republic of China. Beijing was a capital again, of a state that had never existed before. Allison Murray: An emperor's front door, handed to the people, with a doorstep nowhere near big enough. Hugo Carr: Nowhere near. Over the next decade the state built itself a stage. The square was enlarged for rallies and parades, and the old city in its path came down: the Gate of China, the chessboard streets of a Ming-era market, dozens of hutongs, the old residential lanes. In one push, thousands of houses were demolished within a month, and the families in them were moved out. The state gained room for vast crowds. Those residents lost their homes. The Great Hall of the People rose on that cleared ground, and it still lines one long side of the square. A small sweet thing: Allison Murray: That square was enlarged by moving people out of their homes. Now the scale drops to one small stall in Dongcheng, the old palace district, where bright red skewers glitter under a bare bulb at dusk on Nanluoguxiang. Iris, what's the first bite of tanghulu actually like? Iris Marchetti: It's a bamboo stick threaded with little red hawthorn berries, each one sealed in sugar so thin and glassy you can see the fruit through it. And then there's the pause I love: your teeth are on the shell, nothing's given yet, and then it cracks. Allison Murray: A snack with a drumroll. Beth? Beth Hartley: And the drumroll is for the fruit. Under all that shine, hawthorn is properly sour, a bit dry, almost mealy, with little pips in the middle. In Beijing it's called shanlihong. The sugar's the wrapping; the sourness is why you finish the stick. Allison Murray: But it's sitting next to strawberries and grapes and kiwi, all glistening at me. What do I actually point at? Beth Hartley: Point at the hawthorn if you want that sharp bite. It's the classic, and the sourness cuts the sugar. Strawberry's sweeter and juicier, honestly a different snack. Either way, ask for one freshly dipped, because the ready-made sticks go soft faster. Though Iris will say I've missed the point. Iris Marchetti: You're choosing with your tongue. I'd choose with my ears. A fresh shell cracks loudly enough that the people beside you hear it, and they glance over. You haven't just eaten a berry. You've made a small public announcement. Allison Murray: Has Beijing always been cracking these out in the street? Beth Hartley: On winter nights, mostly. Vendors sold it at temple fairs and in market lanes because cold air keeps the shell hard, and warmth turns it sticky. Under the Qing, the last imperial dynasty, people ate the sweet, crisp, cold snack in the belief that it cleared coal fumes from their heated rooms. Allison Murray: Sugar as a chimney sweep. So when did the strawberries turn up? Beth Hartley: Much later, once it became a year-round favourite with visitors. The fruit multiplied, strawberries, kiwi, even cherry tomatoes, and some hawthorns get stuffed with red bean paste. But hawthorn is still the classic. Allison Murray: From winter treat to holiday snack. Iris, does the bite still do its trick? Iris Marchetti: Every time. It's two tastes queued up. The sweetness arrives first and makes a promise, then the hawthorn breaks it, sharp and sour. So you go back for the next berry to see if this one keeps the promise. It never does. Beth Hartley: And the making happens right in front of you. The vendor threads firm, dry berries on bamboo, rolls them through syrup boiled to the hard-crack stage, twirls off the drips and lays the stick on a tray, where it sets almost at once. There's an old legend about an imperial consort cured by hawthorn and rock sugar. Iris Marchetti: Just a tray of red berries cooling in the dusk, each one under its own glass, and nobody's teeth on them yet. The gate and the crowd: Allison Murray: After a sweet small enough to rattle in one hand, the scale throws itself wide open: wind across pale stone, guides calling their groups together, a slow line edging toward security at Tiananmen Square. Which part of all this was here on the day everyone remembers, James? James Harlow: The gate. Tiananmen, the Gate of Heavenly Peace, with Mao's large portrait on its face, an old palace entrance rebuilt long before the day you mean. Allison Murray: So the gate and the square went up together, Alice? Alice Pemberton: No, and that's the distinction worth bringing with you. The gate is centuries old. The square was much smaller on the founding day and was enlarged afterward to roughly four times its size, so most of the ground you're crossing came later. Allison Murray: James, who stood where that day? James Harlow: Mao Zedong stood on the gate's terrace. The crowd filled that smaller square below him. And on the first of October, nineteen forty-nine, in the afternoon, he proclaimed the People's Republic of China down to them. Allison Murray: In what words? James Harlow: One sentence carried it: It announced a government. The people taking power stood up on that terrace; the public stood beneath it and heard the news. Allison Murray: Then the ground the crowd stood on is the day's real monument, Alice. Alice Pemberton: Except that smaller gathering place isn't the whole square you see now. The later clearing changed its scale completely. Allison Murray: Plan ahead: the square takes a free real-name reservation made at least a day before, and at security foreign visitors show a physical passport while bags go through the X-ray. Alice Pemberton: And once you're through, you meet what all that clearing bought: granite paving running almost to the edges, room for crowds the founding day never imagined. Thousands of workers and student volunteers built it in shifts, racing to finish for the Republic's tenth anniversary. That wind-swept emptiness was a decision. Allison Murray: A square built on a deadline. And James, I'd bet the grand buildings around it were already here in forty-nine. James Harlow: You'd lose. The Great Hall of the People and the building that now houses the National Museum of China were finished for that same anniversary, and the granite Monument to the People's Heroes the year before. The hall holding Mao's preserved body came later still. On the founding day there was the gate, the crowd and one voice. Allison Murray: Which leaves the gate holding that whole afternoon by itself, Alice. Alice Pemberton: And still working. At sunrise an honour guard raises the flag in time with the sun, as it does every single day. The duck reaches the table: Allison Murray: After a square built for a crowd, a table built around one bird. At dusk the fruitwood smoke drifts out of Quanjude Qianmen, carrying the promise of a proper Peking duck. Where does it begin, Margaux? Margaux Delacroix: At the founding branch of the whole chain, and with a poultry trader who'd sold chickens and ducks in the meat market round here. In eighteen sixty-four, Yang Quanren bought a failing dried-fruit shop called Dejuquan, turned its name back to front to read Quanjude, and started roasting duck for the public. Allison Murray: Thrifty. He recycled the sign. Margaux Delacroix: Recycled the sign, then hired a retired palace chef for the recipe. So you order like a banquet: a whole duck, or a half if there are only two of you, with the pancakes and all their trimmings. Allison Murray: And before I get anywhere near a pancake, what do I have to decide? Margaux Delacroix: Whether you'll actually get a seat. It's a hall of several floors that seats hundreds, but advance reservations are recommended, so book ahead for the full sit-down duck meal, especially with a group, rather than gamble on a walk-in table. Allison Murray: Book, order, the tea arrives, and then a chef wheels the whole duck to your table. Thomas, what does that do to the room? Thomas Walker: Speeds it right up. The bird comes in glossy and date-red, and the chef works fast: skin lifted away first, then the breast sliced thin, skin and meat fanned onto separate plates. Nobody at the table talks. Everyone watches the knife. Margaux Delacroix: You're watching the knife. I'm watching the skin. That lacquered crackle is what the oven was working toward all along, and diners are often invited to taste it first, on its own, dipped in a little sugar. That's the reward for waiting. Allison Murray: Sugar. On duck. Thomas Walker: Sweet against that crackle, I can see the appeal. Then the tempo drops, because now the work is yours. Spread sweet bean sauce on a thin pancake, lay the duck on with scallion and cucumber, roll it up. Slower, messier, and far more sociable. Allison Murray: So the grand banquet turns into finger food, Margaux. Margaux Delacroix: Finger food from a very serious oven. The ducks hang in an open-fronted oven over fruitwood, jujube, peach or pear, which leaves a faint fruity note in the skin. Quanjude popularised that method, and this old branch is the one people prize for keeping to it. Allison Murray: All that heritage, and I'll still drop half of it in my lap. Margaux Delacroix: Then eat the skin first, while it still shatters. Thomas will tell you the carving is the show. It isn't. That first slice is the whole point. Thomas Walker: The first slice is the opening bid, Margaux. The deal closes later: the carcass goes back to the kitchen and comes out again as a clear duck-bone soup to finish, and the restaurant hands you a certificate with your duck's serial number. Dinner, with paperwork. Roofs in the last light: Allison Murray: Duck-bone soup and paperwork recede; on one quiet hilltop, a whole palace of roofs turns gold at once. Take us up, August. August Mercer: At the top of Jingshan Park, beside Wanchun Pavilion, the Forbidden City stops being a maze of courtyards. The yellow-glazed roofs lie below in one symmetrical sweep, and in the last light they catch the sun together. Allison Murray: Down inside, it's gate after gate. It's harder to take in that sweep of roofs. August Mercer: Which is this hill's odd gift. It was enlarged with earth dug out for the palace moat and nearby canals. So that rectangle of water around the roofs helped give the hill its height. Allison Murray: A view that brought its own ditch. August Mercer: And for centuries both belonged to the court. This was an imperial garden. Only after the last dynasty fell did its gates open to anyone who cared to climb. Allison Murray: And then the capital left it in peace? August Mercer: Not entirely. In the first years of the new People's Republic, the hill was closed for a while and used as an air-defence position. A garden made to shelter a palace, put to work watching the sky. Allison Murray: From strolling courtiers to sky-watchers. August Mercer: Then it reopened with new paths and plantings, and simply carried on as a public park while the city changed around it. Peonies on the slopes in their season, birds in the trees, the palace still below. Allison Murray: How much of the hill does a visitor actually need? August Mercer: The summit. The standard gate ticket is pocket change. The climb to the central pavilion takes about ten minutes on paths and stone steps, and opening hours vary with the season, so check last entry if you're chasing dusk. Allison Murray: Ten minutes of stairs to shrink an emperor's whole precinct to the size of a tea tray. August Mercer: And that same gold sweep reads differently once you know the hill. An enclosure almost nobody could enter, now seen whole by whoever climbs. It won't tell you what the people inside thought. It only shows you the walls they lived behind. An opera in one night: Allison Murray: Up on that hill the roofs went quiet in the dusk; in here a gong cracks, a fiddle answers, and somebody lifts the lid off a bowl of jasmine tea. This is Peking opera at Liyuan Theatre, and the first decision comes long before the curtain. What does a newcomer actually book, Emma? Emma Cartwright: Not the all-night epic you're picturing. Liyuan does one hour of excerpts, short scenes chosen for people meeting Peking opera for the first time. So you might get a tragedy, a battle and something lighter, and you're out before your attention flags. Allison Murray: Sold. And how do I get a seat? Emma Cartwright: Book ahead, especially for your preferred seats. Curtain is at half past seven. Arrive half an hour early to exchange your ticket in the Qianmen Jianguo Hotel lobby. Allison Murray: Tables. At the opera. Emma Cartwright: It's a teahouse theatre. Eight Immortals tables, jasmine tea in lidded bowls, little Beijing snacks with the better seats, and quiet conversation is allowed. Before the show, visitors can watch the actors paint their faces. Allison Murray: Walter, suppose a man paints his face white. Should I be worried? Walter Davies: A little. The painted face is a code you read before anyone sings: red for sincerity, black for directness, white for cunning. So a white face walking onstage has already told you not to trust him. Allison Murray: Then the lights go down. What's in the orchestra? Walter Davies: The jinghu fiddle, with drum, gongs and clappers. They aren't accompaniment so much as punctuation for the steps, the turns of the head, the strikes. Emma, meanwhile, will be reading the screen. Emma Cartwright: Of course I will. The screens carry lyrics and dialogue in Chinese and English, so the story is right in front of me: who is loyal, who is lying, who is about to lose everything. That's my way in. Walter Davies: And mine is the body. A sleeve flicked up, the stamp of a boot, a painted face turning on a gong stroke. You can follow a scene without a single word. Emma Cartwright: Sometimes you have to. The Crossroads has no dialogue at all. Walter Davies: The fighters are all leaps and near misses. Emma Cartwright: There might be Farewell My Concubine, with Yu's sword dance, and that singing, high and nasal and intense the first time you hear it. Read her lyric, and you risk missing the sword. Walter Davies: That's the art asking for all your senses. It was built to be taken whole. Under the Qing, troupes from Anhui came to the capital for the Qianlong Emperor's birthday, their style mixed with Kunqu and other regional forms, and singing, speech, acting and combat grew up together, for the court and the crowd alike. Allison Murray: There. The gong landed right on the turn of her blade. Emma Cartwright: And the scene's over. Bows, a last gong, applause rolling round the tables, and anyone who wants one can have a photo taken in costume and makeup on the way out. Walter Davies: The music was part of the action all along. What stays open: Allison Murray: The last gong fades, and the teahouse tables empty into the dark. So who gathers in Beijing's great spaces now? Almost anyone with a ticket, a reservation or a free morning, though every opening came at a price. Yongle walled his palace in crimson and kept the middle arch for himself. A new state widened the square for its crowds, and thousands of houses came down to make the room. And at a Qianmen table, someone spreads sweet bean sauce on a thin pancake and rolls up the duck. If you go, notice who walks through each door. If you don't, remember who once couldn't. That's Elsewhere. Wherever you go, look again. I'm Allison Murray.