WEBVTT

00:00:00.010 --> 00:00:03.730
<v Stu>I'm just trying to work out how much I would sell you out for in a three-year contract.

00:00:03.930 --> 00:00:06.010
<v Chas>I think it would be very cheap, sadly.

00:00:06.410 --> 00:00:07.090
<v Stu>$8,000?

00:00:18.150 --> 00:00:19.410
<v Chas>Hi, I'm Chas Fisher.

00:00:19.590 --> 00:00:20.670
<v Stu>And I'm Stu Willis.

00:00:20.830 --> 00:00:24.790
<v Chas>And welcome to DraftZero, a podcast where two aspiring filmmakers try to work

00:00:24.790 --> 00:00:27.330
<v Chas>out what makes great screenplays work.

00:00:27.330 --> 00:00:31.190
<v Stu>Emerging filmmakers. Sounds a little bit better, don't you think?

00:00:31.370 --> 00:00:36.830
<v Chas>Than aspiring. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Fine. So what are we talking about,

00:00:37.010 --> 00:00:39.350
<v Chas>Stu? What are these two emerging filmmakers talking about?

00:00:40.390 --> 00:00:45.330
<v Stu>What we are going to be doing today is kind of picking up on previous episodes

00:00:45.330 --> 00:00:47.930
<v Stu>that we have done looking at choices and decisions.

00:00:48.090 --> 00:00:53.390
<v Stu>And we've done quite a few episodes going right back to like episode four with

00:00:53.390 --> 00:00:58.610
<v Stu>catharsis, which we kind of revisited with a later episode on agnoresis.

00:00:59.050 --> 00:01:02.890
<v Stu>And we're kind of be looking at what we kind of sometimes have been calling

00:01:02.890 --> 00:01:05.730
<v Stu>the hero's choice or the final choice, right?

00:01:05.830 --> 00:01:12.030
<v Stu>Which is this decision, this big decision that our hero, and I'm using that

00:01:12.030 --> 00:01:15.670
<v Stu>as a broad term to cover whether it's the protagonist, our main character,

00:01:15.850 --> 00:01:18.370
<v Stu>our point of view character, they're all interesting questions,

00:01:18.530 --> 00:01:20.430
<v Stu>has to make at the end of the film.

00:01:20.430 --> 00:01:25.430
<v Stu>And our three main examples, which all kind of subvert the traditional way of

00:01:25.430 --> 00:01:29.650
<v Stu>thinking about this, this is what's interesting, are going to be Michael Clayton,

00:01:29.970 --> 00:01:31.850
<v Stu>promising young woman, and talk to me.

00:01:32.320 --> 00:01:35.440
<v Stu>And we're doing Talk to Me last, because I actually think it's the film that

00:01:35.440 --> 00:01:38.000
<v Stu>kind of got us interested in finally doing this episode.

00:01:38.200 --> 00:01:40.940
<v Stu>We've been talking about doing this episode for a while, but both of you,

00:01:41.020 --> 00:01:45.360
<v Stu>when we saw it, were a little disappointed in the ending, right?

00:01:45.680 --> 00:01:49.040
<v Stu>It's a great horror film. The sequel's coming out. It deserves a sequel.

00:01:49.380 --> 00:01:54.360
<v Stu>But both of us kind of had to unpack why that ending was a problem for us.

00:01:54.360 --> 00:02:00.200
<v Stu>And then recently kind of revisited it in the context of like horror films and

00:02:00.200 --> 00:02:05.080
<v Stu>talking about like the catharsis of that film and why it didn't work for us.

00:02:05.580 --> 00:02:09.660
<v Stu>So the parts to pick up on our choices and decision episode.

00:02:10.320 --> 00:02:14.420
<v Stu>What we kind of came to is this language is that the choices that we are talking

00:02:14.420 --> 00:02:19.600
<v Stu>about are the options presented to the character that they could choose between.

00:02:19.920 --> 00:02:25.260
<v Stu>A decision is a knowing act. There is a knowing them. We're kind of separating

00:02:25.260 --> 00:02:29.100
<v Stu>the distinct, there is a distinction we're drawing between someone just being

00:02:29.100 --> 00:02:32.320
<v Stu>reactive and someone making a knowing act.

00:02:32.520 --> 00:02:32.640
<v Chas>Yep.

00:02:32.980 --> 00:02:36.120
<v Stu>And then we're going to add a new thing, which I think we kind of talked about

00:02:36.120 --> 00:02:38.440
<v Stu>in those episodes. I didn't re-listen to them.

00:02:38.540 --> 00:02:41.240
<v Chas>Oh, we absolutely did if you're about to talk about narrative point of view.

00:02:41.500 --> 00:02:44.240
<v Stu>No, I'm going to talk about, I'm going to add consequences to it.

00:02:44.320 --> 00:02:48.280
<v Chas>Oh, no, no, we did talk about consequences, but it was kind of a mind bomb that

00:02:48.280 --> 00:02:52.080
<v Chas>occurred to you during recording, having re-listened to them recently.

00:02:52.420 --> 00:02:52.960
<v Stu>Oh, really?

00:02:53.120 --> 00:02:53.260
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:02:53.260 --> 00:02:56.800
<v Stu>Where I was like, oh, why are we not talking about the consequences of the decision?

00:02:56.940 --> 00:03:01.180
<v Chas>Because we were talking, we were trying to distinguish between decisions versus choices.

00:03:01.340 --> 00:03:06.860
<v Chas>And the language we developed is a choice is where the character is presented with options.

00:03:07.080 --> 00:03:13.300
<v Chas>Like there's a selection from an array of options that the audience can or cannot be made aware of.

00:03:13.480 --> 00:03:18.400
<v Chas>The character makes their selection, makes their knowing decision or choice.

00:03:18.720 --> 00:03:23.140
<v Chas>And then we talked about the consequences flowing on from that choice.

00:03:23.260 --> 00:03:29.260
<v Chas>And what we noticed is that there was different power in the narrative point of view of

00:03:29.450 --> 00:03:32.090
<v Chas>Because to the character, that's all happening in real time.

00:03:32.250 --> 00:03:34.130
<v Chas>They're presented with their options, they make their choice,

00:03:34.210 --> 00:03:35.330
<v Chas>and then there's consequences.

00:03:35.690 --> 00:03:41.250
<v Chas>And then each of these three films in particular, in the hero's choice moment,

00:03:41.930 --> 00:03:46.050
<v Chas>has changed the narrative point of view, the relationship between the audience

00:03:46.050 --> 00:03:49.050
<v Chas>and seeing the order of those things.

00:03:49.310 --> 00:03:54.070
<v Chas>Whether they see the choices being presented, and then the actual character

00:03:54.070 --> 00:03:58.730
<v Chas>making the choice, and then the consequences of that choice.

00:03:58.730 --> 00:04:03.610
<v Chas>They all happen not necessarily in real time in all three of these films.

00:04:03.830 --> 00:04:06.870
<v Stu>I don't think the character's always going to experience the consequences immediately.

00:04:07.030 --> 00:04:09.910
<v Stu>But as you say, it's kind of real time.

00:04:10.390 --> 00:04:12.710
<v Stu>And in the case of Promising Young Woman,

00:04:12.950 --> 00:04:16.750
<v Stu>she doesn't even get to see the consequences of her decision at all.

00:04:17.070 --> 00:04:17.550
<v Chas>Spoilers.

00:04:18.510 --> 00:04:21.670
<v Stu>Spoilers. So obviously, given we're talking about the endings and writing better

00:04:21.670 --> 00:04:24.270
<v Stu>endings, there are going to be lots of spoilers.

00:04:24.270 --> 00:04:29.110
<v Stu>And look, we've already used this in our writing before where we wanted to kind

00:04:29.110 --> 00:04:31.990
<v Stu>of beef up the character because I think what's the important thing about decision

00:04:31.990 --> 00:04:36.630
<v Stu>making, giving a character's decisions is its action.

00:04:36.870 --> 00:04:37.270
<v Chas>Right?

00:04:37.370 --> 00:04:41.890
<v Stu>It's a way of making your character more active and connecting to like the adolescence

00:04:41.890 --> 00:04:44.690
<v Stu>discussion around stillness of characters.

00:04:44.690 --> 00:04:51.070
<v Stu>So if you've got characters that are powerless or there's a high cost to rebellion,

00:04:51.630 --> 00:04:54.570
<v Stu>right, then you can still give them the choice.

00:04:54.870 --> 00:04:59.830
<v Stu>In adolescence, Jamie could tell his father the truth that he did kill this

00:04:59.830 --> 00:05:05.310
<v Stu>girl and he has chosen not to, right? And that's something that we realize later.

00:05:05.490 --> 00:05:10.910
<v Stu>I'm just saying that because it's those little decisions that are creating choices

00:05:10.910 --> 00:05:16.910
<v Stu>that the audience are aware are choices. right and seeing our character make a knowing,

00:05:18.200 --> 00:05:22.040
<v Stu>making a knowing decision is going to make a character feel more active,

00:05:22.200 --> 00:05:23.480
<v Stu>which is obviously very important.

00:05:23.700 --> 00:05:27.380
<v Stu>And this kind of sets us up to a larger, you know, at some point this year,

00:05:27.480 --> 00:05:30.720
<v Stu>we're going to be doing, looking at character arcs and this kind of,

00:05:30.840 --> 00:05:33.520
<v Stu>the character arc discussions springboarded off this.

00:05:33.620 --> 00:05:37.220
<v Stu>So this is kind of in some way setting the, combining a few ideas,

00:05:37.740 --> 00:05:43.420
<v Stu>the agnoresis as part of it, but through the lens of decisions and choices.

00:05:43.720 --> 00:05:47.680
<v Chas>Yeah. The main reason we're looking at final choices and hero's choices is, as you say,

00:05:48.200 --> 00:05:56.320
<v Chas>they are often, if you're following the guru formula for these things,

00:05:56.520 --> 00:06:02.040
<v Chas>is that it should dramatize the entire character's kind of journey, if you can.

00:06:02.240 --> 00:06:07.320
<v Chas>Not should is a didactic word, but I think that is certainly present in these

00:06:07.320 --> 00:06:11.060
<v Chas>three heroes choices we're looking at in these three films.

00:06:11.240 --> 00:06:16.080
<v Chas>So, what I'm hoping to do in all our explorations of character arcs is look

00:06:16.080 --> 00:06:21.300
<v Chas>at better tools for dramatizing the internal, dramatizing the character's journey,

00:06:21.460 --> 00:06:24.740
<v Chas>not just the plot that the character is going through.

00:06:25.080 --> 00:06:30.520
<v Chas>But to your point about agency and kind of active versus still,

00:06:31.200 --> 00:06:33.400
<v Chas>you know, I've been going through the back catalog of episodes,

00:06:33.560 --> 00:06:36.580
<v Chas>like listening to myself is like the most narcissistic thing I'm doing,

00:06:36.680 --> 00:06:40.420
<v Chas>but sometimes I just forget stuff that we learned like two years ago and I have

00:06:40.420 --> 00:06:43.680
<v Chas>to go back and re-listen to it and go, oh, yeah, that's what it was.

00:06:43.880 --> 00:06:47.640
<v Stu>Look, as long as you're listening to the finished episode with both of our sides

00:06:47.640 --> 00:06:51.220
<v Stu>of the conversation and just not your original recording.

00:06:51.480 --> 00:06:55.700
<v Chas>Unfortunately, I haven't taught AI to say, can you please just mute Stu?

00:06:57.280 --> 00:07:01.180
<v Stu>If you would like that feature, you should sign up for a big cover of Patreon and we'll look into it.

00:07:03.300 --> 00:07:07.140
<v Chas>We'll do the Stu edit and the Chaz edit. We did two other episodes.

00:07:07.140 --> 00:07:12.460
<v Chas>One was on splitting character function between the characters that are driving

00:07:12.460 --> 00:07:15.300
<v Chas>the plot versus the main characters, the point of view characters.

00:07:15.480 --> 00:07:20.340
<v Chas>And one of the things we identified particularly in The Fighter was we often

00:07:20.340 --> 00:07:25.480
<v Chas>didn't see the Mark Wahlberg character, Mickey, the act of him making decisions

00:07:25.480 --> 00:07:27.160
<v Chas>or act of him making choices.

00:07:27.160 --> 00:07:31.360
<v Chas>We would see the options being presented to him and then the consequences of

00:07:31.360 --> 00:07:34.300
<v Chas>those, but they would often cut away from him making the choice to make him

00:07:34.300 --> 00:07:39.520
<v Chas>feel more kind of at the expense of his brother and less in charge of the plot.

00:07:39.520 --> 00:07:45.600
<v Chas>And then the other thing that we did was, I didn't realize we did two Game of Thrones episodes.

00:07:45.720 --> 00:07:49.780
<v Chas>We did one in season six and one in season eight.

00:07:49.940 --> 00:07:55.840
<v Chas>But the second one in season eight, we were particularly looking at how Sansa

00:07:55.840 --> 00:08:02.520
<v Chas>and Cersei making two enormous decisions that impacted hugely on two different episodes on the plot.

00:08:03.230 --> 00:08:07.670
<v Chas>Were experienced completely differently by the audience of them as characters

00:08:07.670 --> 00:08:13.270
<v Chas>because one we got to see Cersei making the choice and Sansa was largely absent

00:08:13.270 --> 00:08:17.410
<v Chas>from the we saw the consequences of her choice but we didn't see her making

00:08:17.410 --> 00:08:20.190
<v Chas>the choice we didn't see her presented with the options it's.

00:08:20.190 --> 00:08:23.950
<v Stu>A great callback and and and oh man I should really listen to that episode but

00:08:23.950 --> 00:08:26.630
<v Stu>I remember it kind of came out of like a argument.

00:08:26.630 --> 00:08:28.190
<v Chas>On the internet because.

00:08:28.190 --> 00:08:30.810
<v Stu>Someone was on on the internet and are complaining about Sansa.

00:08:30.990 --> 00:08:35.230
<v Stu>And I was just like, it feels like, because we don't get to see her decision-making,

00:08:35.430 --> 00:08:39.290
<v Stu>it's about her coming in at the Battle of the Bastards to save Jon.

00:08:39.530 --> 00:08:43.190
<v Stu>And she arrives in the nick of time and then it's played as a surprise.

00:08:43.190 --> 00:08:46.830
<v Stu>We don't know whether, and we don't know whether she's like belted her soldiers

00:08:46.830 --> 00:08:50.450
<v Stu>to get there in time or that she's been holding back to the moment.

00:08:50.610 --> 00:08:54.870
<v Stu>All these things which can reveal character, right? And they've chosen to align

00:08:54.870 --> 00:08:56.750
<v Stu>us with Jon's experience of it.

00:08:56.810 --> 00:08:56.930
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:08:57.170 --> 00:09:02.890
<v Stu>Right. But then there's no kind of real exploration of her decision making there,

00:09:02.990 --> 00:09:07.190
<v Stu>which I think we consider as a character because we quite literally do not get

00:09:07.190 --> 00:09:08.750
<v Stu>access to her as a character.

00:09:08.890 --> 00:09:11.150
<v Stu>And I think I, and then the comparison, correct me if I'm wrong,

00:09:11.210 --> 00:09:14.050
<v Stu>you've obviously listened to it more recently. And then the comparison with

00:09:14.050 --> 00:09:16.870
<v Stu>Cersei was her blowing up the sept, right?

00:09:17.130 --> 00:09:20.970
<v Stu>And us sitting in that decision and seeing the consequences of that decision.

00:09:21.170 --> 00:09:21.290
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:09:21.490 --> 00:09:23.950
<v Stu>Those are both decisions at the climax of the season.

00:09:24.190 --> 00:09:24.330
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:09:24.530 --> 00:09:27.870
<v Stu>Right? Right. And so we are talking about this hero's journey.

00:09:28.250 --> 00:09:33.150
<v Stu>Michael Arndt also kind of talks about it as the decisive act in his excellent,

00:09:33.310 --> 00:09:36.270
<v Stu>insanely great endings, right?

00:09:36.390 --> 00:09:38.690
<v Stu>And he's got this whole beat by beat breakdown.

00:09:38.910 --> 00:09:43.430
<v Stu>And then he kind of puts the decisive act as smack bang in the middle of the climax.

00:09:43.830 --> 00:09:47.250
<v Excerpts>So then you get to your decisive act and your decisive act is positive, right?

00:09:47.350 --> 00:09:51.150
<v Excerpts>It's surprising and it's meaningful. And it's meaningful because, and this is crucial,

00:09:51.550 --> 00:09:56.050
<v Excerpts>the decisive act speaks to and is an embodiment of the underdog values of your

00:09:56.050 --> 00:09:59.410
<v Excerpts>story so your hero doesn't have to get up at the climax of your story and give

00:09:59.410 --> 00:10:02.790
<v Excerpts>a big speech right that's just bad writing the underdog values are embedded

00:10:02.790 --> 00:10:06.990
<v Excerpts>in the decisive act itself and that's the thing that again is going to turbocharge

00:10:06.990 --> 00:10:10.690
<v Excerpts>the emotion at the end of your story and give your story an insanely great ending.

00:10:10.690 --> 00:10:13.410
<v Stu>But as i think as you can see when we

00:10:13.410 --> 00:10:16.970
<v Stu>get to michael clayton and promising young woman they're not

00:10:16.970 --> 00:10:19.870
<v Stu>in the in the two minute climax but an

00:10:19.870 --> 00:10:22.850
<v Stu>example um that i

00:10:22.850 --> 00:10:25.670
<v Stu>think we can use to kind of give a i mean

00:10:25.670 --> 00:10:28.350
<v Stu>you can watch his videos for his examples including a new

00:10:28.350 --> 00:10:32.450
<v Stu>hope and i think part of the reason we've actually put new hope into our character

00:10:32.450 --> 00:10:36.290
<v Stu>arcs is because michael did such a great job of breaking it down as a traditional

00:10:36.290 --> 00:10:40.850
<v Stu>ending i think dungeons and dragons does this kind of treat is it traditional

00:10:40.850 --> 00:10:44.570
<v Stu>i don't know the michael aren't kind of approach the decisive act being in the

00:10:44.570 --> 00:10:46.670
<v Stu>moment in this big climax i.

00:10:46.670 --> 00:10:54.390
<v Excerpts>Should start by giving you some context so she unleashed hell on earth so i

00:10:54.390 --> 00:10:57.310
<v Excerpts>built the perfect team with magic and.

00:11:12.200 --> 00:11:16.000
<v Stu>So, we're talking about the excellent Dungeons and Dragons film,

00:11:16.020 --> 00:11:20.100
<v Stu>and it is excellent. If you haven't seen it, it's actually one of my favorite fantasy films.

00:11:20.220 --> 00:11:23.000
<v Stu>It nails a fantastic tone.

00:11:23.260 --> 00:11:25.260
<v Chas>I have now seen it four times.

00:11:25.420 --> 00:11:25.560
<v Stu>Wow.

00:11:25.620 --> 00:11:29.220
<v Chas>There are so few films that I've seen four times. Part of it is because my kids love it.

00:11:29.300 --> 00:11:32.480
<v Chas>I took them to see it in cinemas, and it pops up on Netflix,

00:11:32.580 --> 00:11:35.000
<v Chas>and now we're just like, yeah, let's watch Dungeons and Dragons.

00:11:35.220 --> 00:11:39.080
<v Chas>But yeah, it is so easy to watch. It's so delightful.

00:11:39.900 --> 00:11:45.400
<v Stu>So, Chris Pline plays Edgen Darvis, a bard, right? And a member of the harpist.

00:11:45.580 --> 00:11:50.720
<v Stu>His wife was murdered, and he's raised his daughter with the help of his friend

00:11:50.720 --> 00:11:56.880
<v Stu>Holger, who's played by Michelle Rodriguez, right? They basically run a party and doing heists.

00:11:57.260 --> 00:12:00.900
<v Stu>Edgen and Holger are caught. They're in a prison. They escape.

00:12:01.360 --> 00:12:07.920
<v Stu>And Edgen's quest is to gain this powerful MacGuffin to get this- Tablet of

00:12:07.920 --> 00:12:12.460
<v Stu>reawakening. And his goal is to bring back his wife from the dead.

00:12:12.640 --> 00:12:15.340
<v Excerpts>But then Forge told me that among the relics in Khorne's Keep,

00:12:15.440 --> 00:12:20.020
<v Excerpts>there was a tablet of reawakening, capable of bringing back a single deceased

00:12:20.020 --> 00:12:23.360
<v Excerpts>person, even one killed by a red wizard's blade.

00:12:23.860 --> 00:12:25.920
<v Excerpts>You can probably see where this is going.

00:12:26.360 --> 00:12:32.580
<v Stu>The tablet has one use, and he plans to use it to resurrect his dead wife.

00:12:32.580 --> 00:12:37.020
<v Stu>And that's pretty much the driving quest of the film.

00:12:37.220 --> 00:12:44.000
<v Stu>And it culminates in the third act where our adventurers, a party of our adventurers,

00:12:44.180 --> 00:12:50.260
<v Stu>are going on this elaborate heist to break in and steal the tablet from under

00:12:50.260 --> 00:12:55.400
<v Stu>the noses of the big bad, the red wizard, Safina.

00:12:56.160 --> 00:13:01.540
<v Stu>The final battle, they manage to retrieve the tablet and end up in a final battle

00:13:01.540 --> 00:13:03.820
<v Stu>with Safina, who's a very powerful wizard,

00:13:04.120 --> 00:13:11.600
<v Stu>and she stabs, fatally wounds Holger with this blade that means the normal heal spell can't work.

00:13:11.780 --> 00:13:16.000
<v Stu>They end up defeating the Red Wizard, and then Holger is dying.

00:13:17.320 --> 00:13:24.220
<v Stu>And Darvis is basically there with his daughter. His daughter is like mourning

00:13:24.220 --> 00:13:27.160
<v Stu>the loss of, of her, effectively her step-mom.

00:13:27.400 --> 00:13:27.920
<v Chas>Right.

00:13:28.120 --> 00:13:33.020
<v Stu>And in that moment, and they've dramatized it with this interesting blue, um.

00:13:33.420 --> 00:13:33.940
<v Chas>Dragonfly?

00:13:34.560 --> 00:13:38.980
<v Stu>Dragonfly. They've dramatized it with this blue dragonfly to show this idea

00:13:38.980 --> 00:13:40.180
<v Stu>that he's beginning to let go.

00:13:40.360 --> 00:13:45.800
<v Stu>And then he makes the decision in consultation with his daughter, right?

00:13:46.300 --> 00:13:50.840
<v Stu>He basically says, I can only use this tablet once to his daughter who nods

00:13:50.840 --> 00:13:57.220
<v Stu>his head. and he uses the tablet to save Holger, meaning that he can no longer resurrect his wife.

00:13:57.400 --> 00:13:57.580
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:14:38.590 --> 00:14:42.650
<v Stu>So, that is the decision that he is giving, right? We can see the choice,

00:14:42.890 --> 00:14:46.750
<v Stu>which is clearly save Holger or save his wife.

00:14:48.150 --> 00:14:53.430
<v Stu>We understand it's a choice because he actually talks to his daughter about it, right?

00:14:53.630 --> 00:14:58.430
<v Stu>And then he knowingly, he has to recite words. So, this is not just an instinctive

00:14:58.430 --> 00:15:00.930
<v Stu>reaction to bring her back, right?

00:15:01.250 --> 00:15:03.890
<v Stu>And then Holger comes back and is like, why did you waste that onto me?

00:15:03.990 --> 00:15:10.190
<v Stu>And it's a powerful ending. The agnoresis, I think, is him realizing that his

00:15:10.190 --> 00:15:13.110
<v Stu>daughter's mother effectively is Holger, right?

00:15:13.230 --> 00:15:17.570
<v Stu>And so it's got a really big uplifting emotion. I rewatched it this afternoon

00:15:17.570 --> 00:15:21.150
<v Stu>and I cried even though I literally just watched the last couple of minutes, right?

00:15:21.870 --> 00:15:25.090
<v Stu>It is almost into catharsis territory.

00:15:25.550 --> 00:15:29.410
<v Stu>But to me, when you think of that being a classic, what I would go,

00:15:29.530 --> 00:15:31.410
<v Stu>ah, the hero's journey is a choice like that.

00:15:31.590 --> 00:15:36.170
<v Stu>I can save this character. I have to get what I, you know, it's giving up what

00:15:36.170 --> 00:15:38.450
<v Stu>you want for what you need, that kind of thing.

00:15:38.610 --> 00:15:42.330
<v Stu>What he wanted was to bring his wife back. What he actually needed to was realize

00:15:42.330 --> 00:15:46.270
<v Stu>that Holger was really the family unit.

00:15:46.430 --> 00:15:50.810
<v Stu>And I love the fact that it's actually, he doesn't have a romantic relationship with Holger.

00:15:50.870 --> 00:15:51.830
<v Chas>No, no. Right.

00:15:52.070 --> 00:15:57.590
<v Stu>Not at all. I know, but I love that, that they can be good parents together for this child.

00:15:57.590 --> 00:16:05.850
<v Chas>I think you can phrase the choice even clearer than that, because Edgen,

00:16:06.070 --> 00:16:07.890
<v Chas>from the beginning of the film,

00:16:09.310 --> 00:16:15.810
<v Chas>everything comes from him wanting to bring his wife back, but even he knows

00:16:15.810 --> 00:16:18.730
<v Chas>that he's responsible for his wife's death because he stole some treasure,

00:16:18.850 --> 00:16:20.850
<v Chas>he broke Harper's oath, right?

00:16:20.850 --> 00:16:27.370
<v Chas>That brought the Thayans into his home, they killed his wife.

00:16:27.450 --> 00:16:32.050
<v Chas>So he's responsible because he was wanting more for himself, right?

00:16:32.350 --> 00:16:35.410
<v Excerpts>I lost everything that ever mattered to me and it was all my fault.

00:16:37.310 --> 00:16:41.630
<v Excerpts>Wouldn't it have really killed my wife? I did.

00:16:43.190 --> 00:16:47.490
<v Excerpts>I decided we deserved a better life than a Harper's Oath would allow us.

00:16:49.490 --> 00:16:51.910
<v Excerpts>But i didn't know that red wizards marked their treasure,

00:16:55.010 --> 00:16:56.370
<v Excerpts>i led them right to our door,

00:16:59.430 --> 00:17:02.170
<v Excerpts>i didn't even have the good luck to be home when when they got there.

00:17:02.170 --> 00:17:07.330
<v Chas>He keeps saying it's for his wife for his family for his daughter he keeps telling

00:17:07.330 --> 00:17:14.690
<v Chas>his daughter that he's trying to steal the the tablet of reawakening for her to bring her mother back.

00:17:14.690 --> 00:17:18.670
<v Excerpts>Here look at me look at me i swear to you it was a tablet of reawakening.

00:17:19.330 --> 00:17:22.190
<v Excerpts>I was doing it for mom, for all of us. You have to trust me.

00:17:23.130 --> 00:17:24.870
<v Excerpts>You told me to trust you when you left.

00:17:26.680 --> 00:17:31.880
<v Chas>But it's still for him. And he's finally confronted with, do I make a choice

00:17:31.880 --> 00:17:35.960
<v Chas>with this tablet between what's good for me or what's good for my daughter?

00:17:36.220 --> 00:17:37.460
<v Stu>And he chooses his daughter.

00:17:37.600 --> 00:17:37.720
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:17:38.200 --> 00:17:44.260
<v Stu>To the kind of structural stuff, this is all experienced with the audience and

00:17:44.260 --> 00:17:47.060
<v Stu>character's point of view absolutely aligned.

00:17:47.080 --> 00:17:50.480
<v Chas>Yeah. And pretty much in real time. Yeah.

00:17:50.840 --> 00:17:55.220
<v Stu>Right? So, it really aligns us with his character and that maybe is what kind

00:17:55.220 --> 00:17:57.120
<v Stu>of gives us this upswell of emotion.

00:17:57.480 --> 00:18:00.140
<v Chas>I mean, you were talking about Catharsis. Like, there's Catharsis beats.

00:18:00.280 --> 00:18:04.840
<v Chas>There's a reversal of fortune. We see that Holger's dead. It throws us back

00:18:04.840 --> 00:18:06.120
<v Chas>to the beginning of the film.

00:18:06.220 --> 00:18:10.440
<v Chas>She's actually stabbed with the same weapon that his wife was stabbed with.

00:18:10.860 --> 00:18:15.180
<v Chas>You know, then he's- I can't remember off the top of my head what the beats

00:18:15.180 --> 00:18:20.060
<v Chas>were for Catharsis were. But it would not surprise me if we went through them

00:18:20.060 --> 00:18:21.520
<v Chas>in order and they would be right there.

00:18:21.960 --> 00:18:25.440
<v Stu>Yes. If you want to give us a moment, I can actually look it up.

00:18:25.620 --> 00:18:28.900
<v Chas>I mean, this isn't an episode about catharsis necessarily.

00:18:28.900 --> 00:18:34.340
<v Chas>We're looking at heroes' choices and how these good, I think,

00:18:34.400 --> 00:18:42.500
<v Chas>or interesting or subversive heroes' choices actually, through their craft tools that they've used,

00:18:42.800 --> 00:18:49.880
<v Chas>are better or more interestingly dramatizing the character's entire arc, the entire journey.

00:18:50.780 --> 00:18:54.980
<v Stu>While I look up the catharsis beats, because it would be interesting to see

00:18:54.980 --> 00:18:59.780
<v Stu>if they also apply to Finding Nemo, you brought up Finding Nemo as another example

00:18:59.780 --> 00:19:02.560
<v Stu>of exactly this kind of real-time,

00:19:02.920 --> 00:19:07.240
<v Stu>really tightly aligned narrative point of view with character point of view.

00:19:07.380 --> 00:19:10.720
<v Stu>So you do want to kind of talk through the net scene from Finding Nemo?

00:19:12.020 --> 00:19:13.800
<v Excerpts>I've got to find my son Nemo!

00:19:18.420 --> 00:19:24.840
<v Excerpts>Fish are friends, not food. Grab shell, dude. Grab...

00:19:26.600 --> 00:19:33.940
<v Excerpts>No hurling on the shell, dude, okay? Just waxed it. Duck! That's not a duck, it's a pelican!

00:19:37.140 --> 00:19:44.320
<v Excerpts>Everybody hold up! A little help over here. Some way.

00:19:46.450 --> 00:19:53.070
<v Excerpts>Beyond the sea how's it going bub you know i speak whale just as well he might

00:19:53.070 --> 00:19:56.350
<v Excerpts>be hungry don't worry whales don't eat clown fish they eat krill,

00:20:01.310 --> 00:20:01.830
<v Excerpts>yeah.

00:20:01.830 --> 00:20:04.470
<v Chas>Sure i mean look i wanted to bring up

00:20:04.470 --> 00:20:07.590
<v Chas>you wanted to bring up dungeons and dragons and i wanted to bring up finding nemo

00:20:07.590 --> 00:20:12.010
<v Chas>as like these classic relatively recent

00:20:12.010 --> 00:20:15.270
<v Chas>examples of the hero's choice being

00:20:15.270 --> 00:20:18.090
<v Chas>pulled off and i didn't even necessarily say finding nemo in

00:20:18.090 --> 00:20:21.290
<v Chas>particular i just said i think we should talk about the pixar

00:20:21.290 --> 00:20:24.630
<v Chas>formula of the character has

00:20:24.630 --> 00:20:27.590
<v Chas>learned their their choice they've gone through their low point they've

00:20:27.590 --> 00:20:33.810
<v Chas>changed and then they put those characters they test the change how much has

00:20:33.810 --> 00:20:38.970
<v Chas>it stuck how much have they learned their lesson and um i re-watched just the

00:20:38.970 --> 00:20:45.450
<v Chas>ending of finding nemo uh just before recording and i am surprised about how immediate it is.

00:20:45.710 --> 00:20:48.470
<v Chas>So Marlin thinks Nemo is dead.

00:20:49.390 --> 00:20:57.970
<v Chas>Nemo and Dory track Marlin down and Marlin meets, like is reunited with Nemo.

00:20:58.090 --> 00:20:59.430
<v Chas>It's amazing. It's wonderful.

00:20:59.590 --> 00:21:04.310
<v Chas>And as they're hugging, like it's within 10 seconds of them seeing each other,

00:21:04.890 --> 00:21:08.530
<v Chas>a net swoops them all up and Marlin

00:21:08.530 --> 00:21:11.550
<v Chas>and Nemo are small enough to be outside the

00:21:11.550 --> 00:21:17.370
<v Chas>net but dory is caught in the net with a whole lot of other fish and marlin

00:21:17.370 --> 00:21:21.430
<v Chas>like nemo knows he's learned in the fish tank that if all the fish swim down

00:21:21.430 --> 00:21:30.010
<v Chas>together they can break the net and escape and save dory and marlin the whole thing the whole.

00:21:31.650 --> 00:21:34.670
<v Chas>Movie it opens with marlin losing his

00:21:34.670 --> 00:21:37.670
<v Chas>wife and every single egg that they had except for

00:21:37.670 --> 00:21:40.610
<v Chas>one and it posits his like

00:21:40.610 --> 00:21:43.270
<v Chas>you know want versus need you know

00:21:43.270 --> 00:21:45.950
<v Chas>he wants to keep nemo safe and what he

00:21:45.950 --> 00:21:51.790
<v Chas>needs to do is learn to let nemo go and look uh craig mazen has got uh it's

00:21:51.790 --> 00:21:56.750
<v Chas>it's an episode on script notes uh i saw him do this lecture live at austin

00:21:56.750 --> 00:22:01.190
<v Chas>it's just an he does an incredible narrative breakdown of finding nemo through

00:22:01.190 --> 00:22:05.090
<v Chas>the lens of theme so i'm not gonna steal his thunder or repeat it,

00:22:05.210 --> 00:22:07.750
<v Chas>but Marlin literally says to Nemo.

00:22:07.990 --> 00:22:13.750
<v Excerpts>No, I am not going to lose you again! Dad, there's no gun! It's the only way we can save Dory!

00:22:15.010 --> 00:22:16.470
<v Excerpts>I can do this!

00:22:18.090 --> 00:22:21.230
<v Excerpts>You're right. I know you can.

00:22:27.350 --> 00:22:32.750
<v Chas>And Marlon chooses to let his son go to save Dory.

00:22:32.910 --> 00:22:36.790
<v Chas>He doesn't say, no, screw Dory, I'm going to keep you safe.

00:22:37.610 --> 00:22:42.410
<v Chas>They test the lesson that Marlon has learned, which is, I mean,

00:22:42.430 --> 00:22:46.710
<v Chas>there's plenty of ways to look at these, plenty of structures and formulas and

00:22:46.710 --> 00:22:49.350
<v Chas>different guru lessons about these lessons.

00:22:50.110 --> 00:22:54.350
<v Chas>I hope that we do actually come back to the Michael Arndt great endings and

00:22:54.350 --> 00:22:58.670
<v Chas>apply it to other movies, uh, recent movies with great endings to see if how

00:22:58.670 --> 00:23:00.870
<v Chas>they stack up against it.

00:23:01.210 --> 00:23:04.590
<v Stu>Yeah. So in that, what's interesting is that we see the choice,

00:23:04.750 --> 00:23:09.150
<v Stu>which is either he, he doesn't risk Nemo's life. He loses Dory. Right.

00:23:09.670 --> 00:23:14.510
<v Stu>Or he risks his son life, potentially saving Dory.

00:23:14.770 --> 00:23:17.790
<v Stu>Right. And there is a consequence, which is they save Dory. And then there's

00:23:17.790 --> 00:23:22.750
<v Stu>this moment where they milk it at the end where Nemo is under the net and he may be injured.

00:23:23.330 --> 00:23:30.110
<v Stu>Right. So, we've kind of learned that he's kind of got to see that these things do come with risks.

00:23:30.290 --> 00:23:30.410
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:23:30.710 --> 00:23:35.170
<v Stu>And it is a powerful ending, and it is kind of dramatizes this theme.

00:23:35.350 --> 00:23:38.570
<v Stu>What is interesting, because I found the catharsis beats, but in my notes I've

00:23:38.570 --> 00:23:43.690
<v Stu>also found, it connects to the adolescence episode, I found Will Dunn's,

00:23:43.770 --> 00:23:48.070
<v Stu>his articulation of this idea is he calls it the crisis decision.

00:23:48.330 --> 00:23:48.510
<v Chas>Okay.

00:23:48.650 --> 00:23:54.170
<v Stu>Right? And it says that a character has to make the most difficult decision

00:23:54.170 --> 00:24:00.450
<v Stu>of their life, and it becomes the crisis because each alternative poses a loss as well as a gain.

00:24:00.950 --> 00:24:04.970
<v Stu>And so, therefore, characters have to weigh what really matters most to them.

00:24:05.110 --> 00:24:10.710
<v Stu>I think you saw that in Dungeons & Dragons. He can resurrect his wife but loses

00:24:10.710 --> 00:24:13.550
<v Stu>Holger, or he saves Holger and loses his wife.

00:24:13.690 --> 00:24:19.010
<v Stu>You don't see that in Finding Nemo. The decision, he's risking something.

00:24:19.450 --> 00:24:19.450
<v Chas>Right?

00:24:20.830 --> 00:24:25.810
<v Stu>But he's not definitely losing something and definitely gaining something, right?

00:24:25.890 --> 00:24:28.810
<v Stu>And I just think that's an interesting idea I wanted to float because I think

00:24:28.810 --> 00:24:34.210
<v Stu>you kind of do see that a little bit in the other films, but not as,

00:24:34.690 --> 00:24:36.330
<v Stu>like, I think it's a really cool idea.

00:24:36.330 --> 00:24:39.130
<v Stu>I just don't think most stories are going to have this crisis idea of,

00:24:39.270 --> 00:24:42.250
<v Stu>like, I mean, rom-coms definitely do it.

00:24:42.250 --> 00:24:45.170
<v Stu>Like when Harry met Sally is the example one of Will Dunn gives,

00:24:45.570 --> 00:24:49.570
<v Stu>which is giving up, Harry giving up his friendship with Sally in order to pursue

00:24:49.570 --> 00:24:51.710
<v Stu>the romantic relationship and risking it.

00:24:52.640 --> 00:24:58.840
<v Stu>The catharsis beats are a twist, a change of fortune, and this kind of sets

00:24:58.840 --> 00:25:00.880
<v Stu>up the circumstances, surprises the audience.

00:25:01.040 --> 00:25:03.180
<v Stu>Dory getting in the net, Hulk getting stabbed.

00:25:03.420 --> 00:25:07.560
<v Stu>There is a revelation, a plot revelation that throws you back to the beginning of the story.

00:25:08.020 --> 00:25:09.680
<v Stu>Surprising, but inevitable.

00:25:10.320 --> 00:25:16.060
<v Stu>And I think in both cases, I think Finding Nemo is connecting it quite literally

00:25:16.060 --> 00:25:20.640
<v Stu>back to what Nemo in the first place in the very opening. And there is a flashback

00:25:20.640 --> 00:25:23.740
<v Stu>to him as an egg, reminding us of that opening scene.

00:25:23.920 --> 00:25:26.180
<v Chas>And in Dungeons of Dragons, there's a flashback as well.

00:25:26.420 --> 00:25:31.460
<v Stu>Yeah. And they've used the blue dragonfly to connect us because it's basically

00:25:31.460 --> 00:25:33.540
<v Stu>a symbol of his wife. So, they've used that in order.

00:25:33.600 --> 00:25:34.540
<v Chas>It's a talisman.

00:25:35.220 --> 00:25:40.160
<v Stu>It's a talisman, right? And then in the Catharsis Beats, the protagonist has

00:25:40.160 --> 00:25:41.100
<v Stu>a moment of understanding.

00:25:41.300 --> 00:25:45.180
<v Stu>They get it. They get it before the audience, which is a narrative point of view, think.

00:25:45.400 --> 00:25:49.740
<v Stu>So, they understand something before we do. And then when we catch up to them

00:25:49.740 --> 00:25:53.460
<v Stu>understanding it, then we feel the emotion in Dungeons & Dragons.

00:25:53.680 --> 00:25:58.120
<v Stu>We understand just slightly after him that he's gone, oh shit,

00:25:58.240 --> 00:26:01.780
<v Stu>Holger is actually my daughter's mother.

00:26:01.980 --> 00:26:02.140
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:26:02.440 --> 00:26:07.680
<v Stu>Right? And I miss my wife, but I've been saying that I want to bring back her

00:26:07.680 --> 00:26:09.860
<v Stu>mother. But the thing is, I miss my wife.

00:26:10.320 --> 00:26:14.340
<v Stu>She wasn't a mother to her. Right? Which is a very powerful idea.

00:26:15.040 --> 00:26:18.020
<v Stu>And that's want versus need very well. articulated in

00:26:18.020 --> 00:26:22.200
<v Stu>finding nemo i think that upswell

00:26:22.200 --> 00:26:25.160
<v Stu>is a little bit um doesn't isn't as powerful

00:26:25.160 --> 00:26:29.340
<v Stu>right because you're not sitting in there but that's i mean that's me i mean

00:26:29.340 --> 00:26:33.700
<v Stu>it's i i don't have kids i don't have young kids i know finding nemo hits stiff

00:26:33.700 --> 00:26:37.420
<v Stu>if you've got young young children and then there's a moment which we talked

00:26:37.420 --> 00:26:40.600
<v Stu>about in our episode on catharsis which you haven't listened to possibly the

00:26:40.600 --> 00:26:43.820
<v Stu>one and only episode of draw zero everyone should listen to in the entire our world,

00:26:44.060 --> 00:26:46.820
<v Stu>except for the first 20 minutes, because we haven't actually moved that,

00:26:46.940 --> 00:26:47.900
<v Stu>re-edited this episode.

00:26:48.180 --> 00:26:51.560
<v Stu>And there's a separation where we separate from what the characters experience

00:26:51.560 --> 00:26:53.840
<v Stu>to reflect upon our own lives.

00:26:54.000 --> 00:26:58.040
<v Stu>So, there's meant to be an aesthetic distance to allow us to reflect on those

00:26:58.040 --> 00:27:01.660
<v Stu>people with us. And I certainly think Dungeons and Dragons did that for me.

00:27:01.920 --> 00:27:06.500
<v Stu>Can't remember what moment. I think they just sit in the spectacle of it, right?

00:27:07.800 --> 00:27:10.360
<v Chas>Well, I guess maybe it's that line from Holger.

00:27:10.760 --> 00:27:12.140
<v Stu>Why did you waste it on me?

00:27:12.340 --> 00:27:12.620
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:27:13.880 --> 00:27:17.720
<v Stu>Yeah, it is. Because it's even... I'm getting emotional about it now.

00:27:17.760 --> 00:27:20.220
<v Stu>It's even Holger not understanding her value.

00:27:20.320 --> 00:27:20.500
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:27:20.760 --> 00:27:22.600
<v Stu>Right? And there's actually something...

00:27:23.850 --> 00:27:27.950
<v Stu>Yeah, I'm getting emotional about it. There's something powerful in her realizing

00:27:27.950 --> 00:27:32.150
<v Stu>the power of her relationship with their kid.

00:27:32.650 --> 00:27:33.910
<v Chas>Right? Yeah, definitely.

00:27:34.010 --> 00:27:37.250
<v Stu>That she kind of took it for granted. And I know we've just spent a lot of time

00:27:37.250 --> 00:27:42.590
<v Stu>laying the groundwork with these two examples that aren't our three hero examples.

00:27:42.910 --> 00:27:43.090
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:27:43.190 --> 00:27:48.430
<v Stu>But I think that's going to be really useful. So, should we jump into Michael Clayton? Finally.

00:27:48.430 --> 00:27:53.090
<v Chas>If nothing else, I think that groundwork that we've laid is to go,

00:27:53.270 --> 00:27:59.630
<v Chas>and surely anyone can conceive of this, but in the hero's journey,

00:27:59.850 --> 00:28:06.930
<v Chas>that final choice, that hero's choice is so pivotal to making a good ending.

00:28:07.110 --> 00:28:12.810
<v Chas>It not just presents the arc, it resolves the plot, it can be strongly thematic,

00:28:12.990 --> 00:28:15.150
<v Chas>all these things. So that's what we want.

00:28:15.150 --> 00:28:19.450
<v Stu>Indiana Jones closing his eyes. That's a very clear choice.

00:28:19.890 --> 00:28:20.070
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:28:20.210 --> 00:28:24.950
<v Stu>And you say it's Hero's Journey. I don't think it's necessarily comes from the Hero's Journey.

00:28:25.350 --> 00:28:28.030
<v Stu>Hero's Journey is finding the elixir and returning it. But anyway,

00:28:28.250 --> 00:28:30.790
<v Stu>we'll talk about that when that comes to character arcs.

00:28:30.910 --> 00:28:31.170
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:28:31.510 --> 00:28:36.230
<v Stu>Because I think the Hero's Journey is actually often more a steadfast character

00:28:36.230 --> 00:28:40.750
<v Stu>arc where the hero changes those around them rather than themselves changing.

00:28:41.290 --> 00:28:42.250
<v Chas>I would agree.

00:28:44.310 --> 00:28:46.530
<v Chas>So, Michael Clayton.

00:28:47.470 --> 00:28:51.150
<v Excerpts>Michael, thank God. Look, I got a situation.

00:28:52.230 --> 00:28:56.430
<v Excerpts>Arthur Edens just stripped down naked in a deposition room in Milwaukee.

00:28:57.310 --> 00:29:00.230
<v Excerpts>You are the senior litigating partner of one of the largest,

00:29:00.350 --> 00:29:03.250
<v Excerpts>most respected law firms in the world. You are a legend.

00:29:03.450 --> 00:29:05.490
<v Excerpts>I'm an accomplice. Romantic, depressive.

00:29:06.250 --> 00:29:08.570
<v Excerpts>I am Shiva, the god of death.

00:29:11.240 --> 00:29:15.800
<v Excerpts>Hi, I'm Michael Clayton. You're late. This is a $3 billion class action lawsuit.

00:29:16.180 --> 00:29:20.800
<v Excerpts>The architect of our defense has been arrested for running naked through a parking lot.

00:29:21.260 --> 00:29:24.500
<v Excerpts>He's building a case against you, North. Nobody's going to let him do that.

00:29:24.620 --> 00:29:26.360
<v Excerpts>Let him? Who the hell's going to stop him?

00:29:26.720 --> 00:29:30.580
<v Excerpts>I spent 12% of my life defending the reputation of a deadly weed killer.

00:29:30.780 --> 00:29:33.300
<v Excerpts>Arthur. No way! They killed the Michael.

00:29:33.900 --> 00:29:36.520
<v Excerpts>You, North, need to know he's under control. They've been shook up.

00:29:36.660 --> 00:29:40.160
<v Excerpts>They need to be reassured. What are you telling me? That I'm counting on you.

00:29:41.240 --> 00:29:46.320
<v Excerpts>I don't want to say exactly what it was. Just that it was something that would win the whole case.

00:29:47.320 --> 00:29:50.120
<v Excerpts>I'm not the enemy. Then who are you?

00:29:52.000 --> 00:29:55.380
<v Excerpts>You got all these cops thinking you're a lawyer. You got all these lawyers thinking

00:29:55.380 --> 00:29:57.220
<v Excerpts>you're some kind of cop. You got everybody fooled, don't you?

00:29:57.480 --> 00:29:58.860
<v Excerpts>You know exactly what you want.

00:29:59.960 --> 00:30:04.280
<v Excerpts>Get out. Get out of the car now. I'm not the guy that you kill.

00:30:04.420 --> 00:30:07.420
<v Excerpts>I'm the guy that you buy. Are you so blind you don't even see what I am?

00:30:08.380 --> 00:30:10.440
<v Excerpts>Do I look like I'm negotiating?

00:30:12.520 --> 00:30:20.040
<v Chas>Written and directed by Tony Gilroy, as we are reveling in Andor season two

00:30:20.040 --> 00:30:22.660
<v Chas>right now at the time of recording.

00:30:22.940 --> 00:30:28.180
<v Stu>And we're going to be doing this same film for our episode on subtext being overrated.

00:30:28.480 --> 00:30:31.420
<v Chas>But a very different moment in the film.

00:30:31.520 --> 00:30:35.460
<v Stu>Yes, but it's motivation for everyone. If you're in the Gilroy hype train of

00:30:35.460 --> 00:30:38.060
<v Stu>like, oh, Andor's pretty good, you should go and watch Michael Clayton.

00:30:38.060 --> 00:30:42.160
<v Stu>Because you're like, everything that Andor does right, you can see it in Michael

00:30:42.160 --> 00:30:44.160
<v Stu>Clayton and, you know, the Bourne movies.

00:30:45.060 --> 00:30:52.220
<v Chas>So, Michael Clayton is a legal thriller where there is a big evil corporation.

00:30:52.580 --> 00:30:53.340
<v Stu>Evil lawyers.

00:30:53.660 --> 00:30:59.220
<v Chas>Yeah, and evil lawyers or amoral lawyers. How do you think we pay the rent, Michael?

00:31:02.800 --> 00:31:05.960
<v Chas>Uh uh and in into this uh

00:31:05.960 --> 00:31:08.780
<v Chas>falls michael clayton the fixer of a law firm that is

00:31:08.780 --> 00:31:11.940
<v Chas>defending the the big weed killer company that's subject

00:31:11.940 --> 00:31:15.440
<v Chas>to a class action lawsuit particularly around

00:31:15.440 --> 00:31:18.280
<v Chas>and this is important background because it's framed around the

00:31:18.280 --> 00:31:21.580
<v Chas>choice so one of their key litigators

00:31:21.580 --> 00:31:25.220
<v Chas>Arthur discovers a document

00:31:25.220 --> 00:31:27.940
<v Chas>that basically proves the guilt of

00:31:27.940 --> 00:31:30.720
<v Chas>the company but he's working for that company he's

00:31:30.720 --> 00:31:34.200
<v Chas>retained by that company he's supposed to act in their best interest but

00:31:34.200 --> 00:31:37.280
<v Chas>he actually possibly for a

00:31:37.280 --> 00:31:40.060
<v Chas>range of reasons but really falling for

00:31:40.060 --> 00:31:45.160
<v Chas>one of not falling in love like not in not romantic love but cherishing the

00:31:45.160 --> 00:31:52.060
<v Chas>innocence of one of the witnesses that he's He is going to reveal this smoking

00:31:52.060 --> 00:31:57.140
<v Chas>gun document that's a report that has been printed with a red cover.

00:31:57.440 --> 00:31:58.720
<v Chas>They killed them, Michael.

00:31:59.440 --> 00:32:01.920
<v Excerpts>Those small farms are family farms.

00:32:03.310 --> 00:32:06.430
<v Excerpts>Did you meet Anna? No.

00:32:06.870 --> 00:32:09.810
<v Excerpts>Oh, you gotta see her. You gotta talk to her. She's a miracle,

00:32:09.970 --> 00:32:11.670
<v Excerpts>Michael. She's God's perfect little creature.

00:32:12.430 --> 00:32:17.690
<v Excerpts>And for $50 million in fees, I've spent 12% of my life destroying perfect Anna

00:32:17.690 --> 00:32:19.910
<v Excerpts>and her dead parents and her dying brother.

00:32:20.050 --> 00:32:22.750
<v Excerpts>When was the last time you took one of these? No, no, no. I'm not losing this.

00:32:22.870 --> 00:32:24.490
<v Excerpts>Everything is now finally significant.

00:32:24.610 --> 00:32:27.170
<v Excerpts>The world is a beautiful and radiant place. I'm not trading that for this.

00:32:27.170 --> 00:32:30.690
<v Excerpts>If it's real, the pill won't kill it. I have blood on my hands.

00:32:30.750 --> 00:32:33.210
<v Excerpts>You are the senior litigating partner of one of the largest,

00:32:33.350 --> 00:32:36.230
<v Excerpts>most respected law firms in the world. You are a legend.

00:32:36.410 --> 00:32:38.470
<v Excerpts>I'm an accomplice. You're a manic depressive.

00:32:39.290 --> 00:32:41.550
<v Excerpts>I am Shiva, the god of death.

00:32:42.190 --> 00:32:48.210
<v Chas>He's going to reveal it. And the company whose key counsel is played by Tilda Swinton.

00:32:48.430 --> 00:32:48.750
<v Stu>Karen.

00:32:48.990 --> 00:32:54.010
<v Chas>I love that she's called Karen. Yeah. She arranges for Arthur to be killed.

00:32:54.610 --> 00:32:58.110
<v Chas>And Michael comes across the report.

00:32:58.330 --> 00:33:01.250
<v Chas>Now, it's interesting. you we've got

00:33:01.250 --> 00:33:06.790
<v Chas>this wonderful snow piercer moment that we'll talk about uh but that's not actually

00:33:06.790 --> 00:33:11.370
<v Chas>here's my my hand grenade is the snow piercer moment the left versus right michael's

00:33:11.370 --> 00:33:19.350
<v Chas>got literally the red covered report in one hand and a check clearing his debts for in the other hand,

00:33:20.150 --> 00:33:26.390
<v Chas>that is the low point of the movie it's not the final it's not the hero's choice because.

00:33:26.390 --> 00:33:30.330
<v Stu>I think this is really interesting because i think we've talked about this two minute climax.

00:33:30.330 --> 00:33:30.870
<v Chas>And look.

00:33:30.870 --> 00:33:33.350
<v Stu>The the shiva the god of death.

00:33:33.350 --> 00:33:35.170
<v Chas>Speech holy.

00:33:35.170 --> 00:33:37.990
<v Stu>Fucking shit like i mean you know.

00:33:37.990 --> 00:33:44.350
<v Chas>Which one the michael one or the uh the arthur one well look.

00:33:44.350 --> 00:33:47.790
<v Stu>There's lots of great speeches in andor and there's great speeches in this film

00:33:47.790 --> 00:33:52.310
<v Stu>if you're like a really good monologue we should finally and do that monologue.

00:33:52.310 --> 00:33:52.670
<v Chas>Episode.

00:33:53.050 --> 00:33:57.830
<v Excerpts>Now, that's just not the way to go here, Karen. For such a smart person,

00:33:57.910 --> 00:33:59.070
<v Excerpts>you really are lost, aren't you?

00:33:59.950 --> 00:34:04.490
<v Excerpts>This conversation is over. I'm not the guy that you kill. I'm the guy that you

00:34:04.490 --> 00:34:07.330
<v Excerpts>buy. Are you so fucking blind you don't even see what I am?

00:34:07.570 --> 00:34:10.630
<v Excerpts>I'm the easiest part of your whole goddamn problem, and you're going to kill me?

00:34:11.450 --> 00:34:16.610
<v Excerpts>Don't you know who I am? I'm a fixer. I'm a bag man. I do everything from shoplifting

00:34:16.610 --> 00:34:19.170
<v Excerpts>housewives to bent congressmen, and you're going to kill me?

00:34:20.970 --> 00:34:25.190
<v Excerpts>What do you need, Karen? Lay it on me. You want a carry permit?

00:34:25.310 --> 00:34:29.110
<v Excerpts>You want a heads-up on an insider trading subpoena? I sold out Arthur for 80

00:34:29.110 --> 00:34:31.590
<v Excerpts>grand and a three-year contract and you're going to kill me?

00:34:33.330 --> 00:34:37.250
<v Excerpts>What do you want? What do I want? I want more.

00:34:38.370 --> 00:34:43.250
<v Excerpts>I want out. And with this, I want everything.

00:34:44.450 --> 00:34:49.350
<v Stu>But I think what is interesting, because it dramatizes what his choices are.

00:34:49.550 --> 00:34:50.670
<v Chas>Yes, so clearly.

00:34:50.850 --> 00:34:54.850
<v Stu>But I don't think it's when he makes the decision. So, what we're seeing here

00:34:54.850 --> 00:34:59.230
<v Stu>is we're experiencing, we are learning what his choices are with him,

00:34:59.390 --> 00:35:01.850
<v Stu>which is, I've got the report or I can just take the money.

00:35:02.190 --> 00:35:07.430
<v Stu>But they're not compressing the relationship between, here's the choice and

00:35:07.430 --> 00:35:11.230
<v Stu>you've got to make a decision, like in Dungeons and Dragons and Finding Nemo, right?

00:35:11.390 --> 00:35:15.830
<v Stu>In the Michael art, this is a two-minute climax, we're going to compress it

00:35:15.830 --> 00:35:17.790
<v Stu>and it's going to have this intensity of emotion.

00:35:17.950 --> 00:35:25.450
<v Stu>This is actually pulling it out, right? He is going to be wrestling with that decision.

00:35:25.850 --> 00:35:29.330
<v Stu>It's that anxiety that I think Michael Clayton does a good job because when

00:35:29.330 --> 00:35:33.990
<v Stu>you compress it, it's kind of a different experience. I'm like, oh, fuck, let's do this.

00:35:34.630 --> 00:35:39.650
<v Stu>As opposed to, oh, I have to really weigh these choices. But I agree because

00:35:39.650 --> 00:35:41.990
<v Stu>something else happens in between.

00:35:44.070 --> 00:35:46.450
<v Stu>They attempt to kill him with a car bomb.

00:35:49.550 --> 00:35:50.350
<v Excerpts>Give me the cell.

00:35:53.610 --> 00:35:54.570
<v Excerpts>That signal's good.

00:36:03.280 --> 00:36:06.420
<v Chas>Quite a significant plot development happens in between

00:36:06.420 --> 00:36:09.240
<v Chas>the uh i'm calling it the snow piercer moment

00:36:09.240 --> 00:36:12.580
<v Chas>but it you you brought it up because you were re-watching

00:36:12.580 --> 00:36:15.300
<v Chas>michael clayton for this other episode that we're going

00:36:15.300 --> 00:36:18.020
<v Chas>to do on subtext and you noticed that there

00:36:18.020 --> 00:36:21.360
<v Chas>was literally a still shot where he's holding the the

00:36:21.360 --> 00:36:24.960
<v Chas>the two different items in his hand and

00:36:24.960 --> 00:36:29.480
<v Chas>there couldn't be a clearer you know dramatization of

00:36:29.480 --> 00:36:36.780
<v Chas>what his choice is do i take the money or do i you know do what is quote unquote

00:36:36.780 --> 00:36:42.920
<v Chas>right um i mean it but it's it's you know talking about other great speeches

00:36:42.920 --> 00:36:46.200
<v Chas>the sydney pollock speech is great you know it's like what.

00:36:46.200 --> 00:36:48.960
<v Excerpts>If arthur was on to something what do

00:36:48.960 --> 00:36:51.860
<v Excerpts>you mean on to what you north what if he wasn't crazy

00:36:51.860 --> 00:36:54.620
<v Excerpts>what if he was right right about what that

00:36:54.620 --> 00:36:57.820
<v Excerpts>we're on the wrong side wrong side wrong way everything

00:36:57.820 --> 00:37:00.560
<v Excerpts>all of it this is news this case reeked from

00:37:00.560 --> 00:37:03.240
<v Excerpts>day one 15 years in i gotta tell you how we pay

00:37:03.240 --> 00:37:05.980
<v Excerpts>the rent but what would they do what would they do if he went

00:37:05.980 --> 00:37:09.360
<v Excerpts>public what would they do are you fucking soft they're doing

00:37:09.360 --> 00:37:12.740
<v Excerpts>it we don't straighten the settlement out in the next 24 hours they're going

00:37:12.740 --> 00:37:15.540
<v Excerpts>to withhold nine million dollars in fees then they're going to pull out the

00:37:15.540 --> 00:37:18.900
<v Excerpts>video of arthur doing his flash dance in milwaukee they're going to sue us for

00:37:18.900 --> 00:37:22.100
<v Excerpts>legal malpractice except there won't be anything from the wind because by then

00:37:22.100 --> 00:37:27.560
<v Excerpts>the merge you with london will be dead we'll be selling off the goddamn furniture that's 80,

00:37:28.820 --> 00:37:30.160
<v Excerpts>we'll call on it a bonus.

00:37:30.160 --> 00:37:32.920
<v Chas>He's just like michael of course we're

00:37:32.920 --> 00:37:36.180
<v Chas>wrong we're lawyers right that's essentially the gist of of

00:37:36.180 --> 00:37:40.700
<v Chas>what he's saying but while we'll get to the car bomb the reason why i think

00:37:40.700 --> 00:37:47.260
<v Chas>the the hero's choice is another choice between the money and doing the right

00:37:47.260 --> 00:37:54.400
<v Chas>thing but it's not this choice right here because we see him straight afterwards cashing the cheque.

00:37:54.560 --> 00:37:58.560
<v Chas>Like he hands it over to the loan shark to pay his debts.

00:37:58.600 --> 00:38:03.240
<v Chas>He's still got the report in his pocket. So it hasn't, they're not mutually

00:38:03.240 --> 00:38:07.360
<v Chas>exclusive. He's still got, he's still living with that choice as you say,

00:38:07.580 --> 00:38:09.740
<v Chas>but he has taken the money.

00:38:10.000 --> 00:38:14.300
<v Chas>He hasn't shown the report to his boss and,

00:38:15.210 --> 00:38:20.070
<v Chas>And he's spent the money. And he literally, you know, you're talking about Shiva,

00:38:20.190 --> 00:38:21.290
<v Chas>the goddess of death speech.

00:38:22.230 --> 00:38:28.210
<v Chas>Part of his, one of the lines that he says that convinces her to betray herself

00:38:28.210 --> 00:38:31.570
<v Chas>is, I sold out Arthur for 80 grand in a three-year contract.

00:38:31.770 --> 00:38:34.610
<v Chas>And that line works in that moment because it's true.

00:38:35.170 --> 00:38:40.950
<v Chas>His low point is he sold, he sells out Arthur for 80 grand in a three-year contract.

00:38:41.770 --> 00:38:45.250
<v Stu>In that speech, when he ultimately confronts the architect,

00:38:45.610 --> 00:38:53.130
<v Stu>Karen, well, not the architect, she's the, what is it, the general counsel for

00:38:53.130 --> 00:38:57.830
<v Stu>the evil corporation, and she is playing dirty tricks.

00:38:57.950 --> 00:39:01.990
<v Stu>She is the one who orders the hit, and that's the scene we're going to be talking about in subtext.

00:39:02.950 --> 00:39:08.310
<v Stu>She orders the hit on Michael Clayton, but also on Arthur. Yeah. Right?

00:39:08.870 --> 00:39:15.810
<v Stu>But clearly, she knew this memo existed and has gone out of her way to suppress it during discovery.

00:39:16.390 --> 00:39:20.130
<v Stu>Isn't that part of it? It was that effectively, she knew they had the smoking

00:39:20.130 --> 00:39:24.350
<v Stu>gun and kind of effectively tried to dispose of evidence.

00:39:24.490 --> 00:39:26.610
<v Chas>Well, she's killing everyone who knows about it.

00:39:26.810 --> 00:39:31.690
<v Stu>Well, I mean, that's one way to dispose of evidence. I hope things don't get

00:39:31.690 --> 00:39:33.330
<v Stu>messy like that in food regulation.

00:39:33.330 --> 00:39:36.490
<v Chas>Better uh the um but

00:39:36.490 --> 00:39:40.670
<v Chas>the big moment what they what they do so beautifully is

00:39:40.670 --> 00:39:43.970
<v Chas>they combine uh an actual character

00:39:43.970 --> 00:39:46.930
<v Chas>moment with michael wrestling with

00:39:46.930 --> 00:39:50.810
<v Chas>the consequences of his decision because he was presented with an option he

00:39:50.810 --> 00:39:55.010
<v Chas>was holding them in two hands and he spent one of them right he spent the check

00:39:55.010 --> 00:40:00.790
<v Chas>and he's driven out and he's in the early morning and he sees some horses on

00:40:00.790 --> 00:40:04.030
<v Chas>a hill and he's compelled to go out and connect with these horses and it's just this,

00:40:05.190 --> 00:40:11.050
<v Chas>quiet moment where you can feel all the things like it's not talking it's not

00:40:11.050 --> 00:40:15.490
<v Chas>verbalized it's just a very internal moment of sitting of michael sitting in

00:40:15.490 --> 00:40:17.830
<v Chas>the consequences of the decision he made at the low point.

00:40:17.830 --> 00:40:22.170
<v Stu>As as someone who has stopped what they're doing for both cats and horses.

00:40:22.170 --> 00:40:27.310
<v Chas>Totally get it i mean your cat slaps you if you don't so i think there's some stakes to that choice.

00:40:27.670 --> 00:40:28.110
<v Stu>Yeah.

00:40:31.190 --> 00:40:36.530
<v Stu>Random cats. There's a lot of, I take, I'm definitely someone who stops and pats the cat.

00:40:37.340 --> 00:40:42.680
<v Chas>But then the car explodes, and the next time we see Michael,

00:40:42.960 --> 00:40:49.800
<v Chas>he is confronting and essentially extorting, blackmailing the general counsel.

00:40:49.800 --> 00:40:57.100
<v Chas>He's saying, unless you pay me $10 million, I will release this report.

00:40:57.420 --> 00:41:01.480
<v Stu>And we believe him in the moment.

00:41:01.660 --> 00:41:02.120
<v Chas>Oh, yeah.

00:41:02.380 --> 00:41:03.280
<v Stu>It's consistent.

00:41:03.440 --> 00:41:07.160
<v Chas>We are not presented so. So leading

00:41:07.160 --> 00:41:10.840
<v Chas>up in between the car bomb and this confrontation, we're not with Michael.

00:41:11.000 --> 00:41:14.560
<v Chas>We're actually with other characters being told that Michael's been killed in a car bomb.

00:41:14.740 --> 00:41:18.180
<v Chas>We know he, as an audience, we know he survives, but we're not with him when

00:41:18.180 --> 00:41:20.740
<v Chas>he's going, what am I going to do next?

00:41:21.060 --> 00:41:24.320
<v Chas>Right? He's not planning his strategy. He's not talking to any other characters.

00:41:24.480 --> 00:41:29.680
<v Chas>He's not laying out the options that he's choosing between. There's not a Snowpiercer

00:41:29.680 --> 00:41:32.440
<v Chas>envelope versus report, right?

00:41:32.440 --> 00:41:40.360
<v Chas>What we are seeing as he confronts the Tilda Swinton character is the strategy

00:41:40.360 --> 00:41:44.260
<v Chas>or the implementation of the choice. We're seeing the choice in effect.

00:41:45.180 --> 00:41:48.960
<v Chas>And we think the choice is to extort her for money.

00:41:49.140 --> 00:41:54.140
<v Chas>That goes back to that low point decision, money or doing the right thing.

00:41:54.560 --> 00:41:59.540
<v Chas>And he's very convincing. He's so convincing that she agrees to pay him.

00:42:00.320 --> 00:42:06.360
<v Chas>And turns out he was wearing a wire and that is the confession that the police

00:42:06.360 --> 00:42:10.700
<v Chas>need to arrest her and her boss.

00:42:11.860 --> 00:42:15.420
<v Excerpts>You have a deal. You're so fucked. What?

00:42:16.480 --> 00:42:21.180
<v Excerpts>You're fucked. What do you mean? Take a wild guess. Is there a problem?

00:42:21.240 --> 00:42:23.240
<v Excerpts>I don't understand. Here, let me get a picture while I'm at it.

00:42:24.100 --> 00:42:27.100
<v Excerpts>You don't want the money? No, you keep the money. You're going to need it.

00:42:27.100 --> 00:42:29.300
<v Excerpts>Is this fellow bothering you? Am I bothering you?

00:42:30.200 --> 00:42:33.100
<v Excerpts>Karen, I've got a whole board waiting in there. What the hell's going on?

00:42:33.160 --> 00:42:36.080
<v Excerpts>Who are you? I'm Shiva, the god of death.

00:42:37.100 --> 00:42:40.420
<v Stu>Well, yeah, arrest her for one, because she owns up to effectively...

00:42:40.420 --> 00:42:41.100
<v Chas>Killing Arthur.

00:42:42.240 --> 00:42:44.480
<v Stu>Arthur trying to attempt murder on him.

00:42:44.660 --> 00:42:44.800
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:42:45.220 --> 00:42:48.820
<v Stu>And all the other stuff around the company. Like, effectively,

00:42:49.120 --> 00:42:50.680
<v Stu>them admitting their guilt.

00:42:51.020 --> 00:42:55.080
<v Stu>And yes, you're right. Because what is interesting is this is really decoupled.

00:42:55.280 --> 00:42:55.620
<v Chas>Right?

00:42:55.620 --> 00:42:59.480
<v Stu>We presented a choice that he actually resolves early, right?

00:43:00.220 --> 00:43:03.340
<v Stu>Yeah. I mean, that is a great, not hand-graded, it's a great carbon.

00:43:06.500 --> 00:43:09.260
<v Stu>Maybe that should be, in the same way that we're talking about Snowpiercer.

00:43:09.260 --> 00:43:12.460
<v Stu>Oh, it's the Snowpiercer moment. And everyone's like, what the fuck is that?

00:43:13.020 --> 00:43:15.440
<v Stu>The Snowpiercer moment is not just a reference to the movie,

00:43:15.520 --> 00:43:19.780
<v Stu>it's a reference to every frame of painting's video essay on the movie about

00:43:19.780 --> 00:43:22.740
<v Stu>dramatizing the choices between two things that's left or right.

00:43:23.020 --> 00:43:24.780
<v Stu>And we've talked about it before.

00:43:24.780 --> 00:43:29.340
<v Excerpts>In fact, this is one of the oldest traditions in cinema. How do you show character choice?

00:43:34.120 --> 00:43:36.100
<v Excerpts>Left or right? That's it.

00:43:36.830 --> 00:43:40.010
<v Excerpts>We often forget that screen direction is a tool and that character choices can

00:43:40.010 --> 00:43:41.610
<v Excerpts>be presented simply by having them look.

00:43:43.830 --> 00:43:48.970
<v Stu>It's really just the clear, like, the path, you know, you're in the fairy tale. Do I go the left?

00:43:49.210 --> 00:43:55.170
<v Stu>You know, do I go this path or do I go this path? Do I go forward or back in terms of Snowpiercer?

00:43:55.450 --> 00:43:57.430
<v Chas>It's reducing options to a binary.

00:43:57.730 --> 00:44:02.890
<v Stu>Yeah, it's about reducing options to a binary that can be very visually explained.

00:44:02.890 --> 00:44:10.290
<v Stu>The red cover report, right, versus the check in my hand is very visual.

00:44:11.510 --> 00:44:15.510
<v Stu>The Mass Effect, which is one of the great game trilogies, but the first one

00:44:15.510 --> 00:44:19.330
<v Stu>has a very powerful choice that echoes over the whole trilogy.

00:44:19.410 --> 00:44:22.030
<v Stu>We have to choose which of your companions survive.

00:44:22.290 --> 00:44:25.190
<v Stu>And it's literally, do you run left and rescue Ashley?

00:44:26.190 --> 00:44:30.990
<v Stu>Do you run right and rescue Kanan? I'm going to look up if that's the actual

00:44:30.990 --> 00:44:32.330
<v Stu>directions you've got to run.

00:44:34.170 --> 00:44:39.210
<v Stu>But it is that very clear, here's the binary, and that's what we mean by the

00:44:39.210 --> 00:44:41.730
<v Stu>snowpiercer moment. Are you dramatizing it?

00:44:41.950 --> 00:44:49.670
<v Chas>So, what we actually see in this moment is because we weren't presented with

00:44:49.670 --> 00:44:54.470
<v Chas>the choices before Michael goes into this meeting, right?

00:44:54.550 --> 00:45:00.390
<v Chas>We don't know what he's choosing between at that point. We assume he's good for his word, right?

00:45:00.530 --> 00:45:03.530
<v Chas>That he's the guy you buy, not the guy you kill.

00:45:03.770 --> 00:45:04.370
<v Stu>Right?

00:45:04.510 --> 00:45:09.650
<v Chas>And it turns out that he had already made the choice off camera before coming

00:45:09.650 --> 00:45:13.210
<v Chas>into this scene, and it was other than what we think it is, and then they reveal

00:45:13.210 --> 00:45:14.890
<v Chas>the consequences of that.

00:45:15.750 --> 00:45:21.410
<v Chas>And it's powerful and it works because it is the same choice dramatically and

00:45:21.410 --> 00:45:24.890
<v Chas>thematically, and from a character perspective as that choice in the low point.

00:45:24.890 --> 00:45:27.470
<v Chas>It's like, do you take the money or do you do the right thing?

00:45:28.050 --> 00:45:28.270
<v Stu>Yeah.

00:45:28.970 --> 00:45:32.950
<v Chas>He is definitely going to, his law firm is definitely going to get sued for malpractice now.

00:45:33.150 --> 00:45:37.650
<v Chas>He is throwing everything away in his life to do the right thing.

00:45:37.890 --> 00:45:41.490
<v Stu>But they don't actually spend time in the consequences of that.

00:45:41.690 --> 00:45:41.910
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:45:42.250 --> 00:45:42.510
<v Stu>Right?

00:45:42.630 --> 00:45:42.990
<v Chas>That's true.

00:45:43.210 --> 00:45:48.850
<v Stu>That, like, I mean, he's kind of won both worlds. He didn't gain and lose in the context of the film.

00:45:48.950 --> 00:45:51.670
<v Stu>He both was able to pay off his debts, right?

00:45:51.990 --> 00:45:56.530
<v Stu>And he was able to do the right thing. What happened in between was that they

00:45:56.530 --> 00:46:01.370
<v Stu>nearly, like, they had to have the car bomb to kind of motivate him to go,

00:46:01.450 --> 00:46:04.810
<v Stu>these are very bad people. And look, he could have let them think he was dead.

00:46:05.010 --> 00:46:06.750
<v Chas>A more cynical version of this.

00:46:07.350 --> 00:46:11.550
<v Chas>Is that he waits until he actually gets the money and then reveals the report anyway.

00:46:12.230 --> 00:46:12.590
<v Stu>Yes.

00:46:13.010 --> 00:46:14.670
<v Chas>Right? And they chose not to do that.

00:46:14.870 --> 00:46:19.590
<v Stu>No, no, no. He has kind of done a deal with his brother who talked to him earlier

00:46:19.590 --> 00:46:22.850
<v Stu>and was like, you know, you're not a cop and you're not a lawyer,

00:46:23.030 --> 00:46:25.030
<v Stu>you know, like is in this in between.

00:46:25.610 --> 00:46:29.610
<v Stu>So, it is interesting because I think the point of view structure makes it a powerful ending.

00:46:29.790 --> 00:46:29.910
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:46:29.910 --> 00:46:36.250
<v Stu>Whereas I think if we had gone into that scene knowing he was trying to entrap,

00:46:36.710 --> 00:46:42.830
<v Stu>it's not even trap, but bait Karen, it would have been a lot less powerful.

00:46:43.030 --> 00:46:43.190
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:46:43.330 --> 00:46:50.170
<v Stu>Because what it's doing is actually playing the experience of his choice from her perspective.

00:46:50.450 --> 00:46:53.850
<v Stu>We're actually getting aligned into her perspective. So, we see her getting

00:46:53.850 --> 00:46:55.410
<v Stu>ready for her big presentation.

00:46:55.770 --> 00:46:55.910
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:46:55.910 --> 00:47:02.390
<v Stu>We see how nervous she is and they're doing a really good job of like humanizing her.

00:47:02.530 --> 00:47:02.650
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:47:02.870 --> 00:47:05.930
<v Stu>You know, coming back to, you know, just Andor, I think the most,

00:47:06.010 --> 00:47:11.110
<v Stu>what's so great about Tony Gilroy is he's, in some ways he's a humanist.

00:47:11.250 --> 00:47:15.590
<v Stu>In many ways he's a humanist. He tries to present his characters as humanistically

00:47:15.590 --> 00:47:20.090
<v Stu>as possible from, you know, we kind of feel sympathy for them.

00:47:20.310 --> 00:47:20.410
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:47:20.550 --> 00:47:27.350
<v Stu>Right? Whether they're an imperial intelligence officer or the general counsel

00:47:27.350 --> 00:47:30.390
<v Stu>for an evil corporation who herself has done evil things.

00:47:30.510 --> 00:47:33.930
<v Stu>In that moment, you're kind of with her desperation.

00:47:34.070 --> 00:47:37.390
<v Stu>And it actually works from a plot point of view because we understand why she

00:47:37.390 --> 00:47:39.810
<v Stu>is like, just take the fucking bribe.

00:47:40.070 --> 00:47:42.490
<v Stu>Please just take the fucking bribe. This is nearly over.

00:47:42.790 --> 00:47:43.230
<v Chas>Right.

00:47:43.330 --> 00:47:46.110
<v Stu>And we've seen how much stress it's caused her throughout the whole film.

00:47:46.210 --> 00:47:49.150
<v Stu>They do a good job of that. But we experience it through her.

00:47:49.150 --> 00:47:50.910
<v Stu>We experience his decisions through her.

00:47:51.090 --> 00:47:55.750
<v Chas>But I think part of what makes us realise the power of that choice is that they

00:47:55.750 --> 00:47:59.590
<v Chas>have dramatised, from a thematic and character perspective, the same choice

00:47:59.590 --> 00:48:01.850
<v Chas>earlier in a subtly different context.

00:48:02.510 --> 00:48:05.150
<v Chas>So that- So where I think-

00:48:05.480 --> 00:48:08.200
<v Chas>what you're saying is that it's the same choice delayed. I think you're actually

00:48:08.200 --> 00:48:13.200
<v Chas>right in some ways, but they, from a narrative perspective, that cheat works

00:48:13.200 --> 00:48:15.340
<v Chas>because they kind of have resolved that choice.

00:48:15.360 --> 00:48:20.020
<v Chas>And it makes you think he is corrupted himself. He has chosen the money.

00:48:20.480 --> 00:48:20.960
<v Stu>Right.

00:48:21.140 --> 00:48:27.700
<v Chas>And that, that version of Michael is the one that sells both Karen and us as

00:48:27.700 --> 00:48:29.460
<v Chas>the audience on that climax.

00:48:29.820 --> 00:48:34.000
<v Stu>Yes. So what do you think? I'm just curious, like you mentioned is the thematic

00:48:34.000 --> 00:48:36.140
<v Stu>ending what makes it a thematic ending for you.

00:48:36.140 --> 00:48:39.400
<v Chas>Uh because i think michael

00:48:39.400 --> 00:48:42.800
<v Chas>clayton is all about the uh

00:48:42.800 --> 00:48:46.640
<v Chas>the cost of making the moral moral decision

00:48:46.640 --> 00:48:49.420
<v Chas>right and and they're in a world where

00:48:49.420 --> 00:48:55.080
<v Chas>no one makes moral decisions there's there's a whole lot of subplots like around

00:48:55.080 --> 00:49:01.360
<v Chas>michael forgiving his drug addicted brother or not who's put michael in this

00:49:01.360 --> 00:49:06.840
<v Chas>position where he's financially insecure anyway and has lost his dream restaurant.

00:49:07.260 --> 00:49:11.240
<v Chas>Arthur is murdered for making a moral decision.

00:49:11.440 --> 00:49:15.780
<v Chas>He's actually seen as mentally unwell for making a moral decision.

00:49:17.400 --> 00:49:22.380
<v Excerpts>As good as this feels, you know where it goes. No, no, no, no.

00:49:22.440 --> 00:49:25.340
<v Excerpts>You're wrong. I mean, what makes this feel good is that I don't know where it goes.

00:49:27.000 --> 00:49:33.320
<v Excerpts>How do I talk to you, Arthur? so you hear me like a child like a nut like everything's

00:49:33.320 --> 00:49:38.160
<v Excerpts>fine what's the secret because i need you to hear me.

00:49:38.160 --> 00:49:40.920
<v Stu>I mean exploring the cost of moral compromise i

00:49:40.920 --> 00:49:44.280
<v Stu>mean that is and all yeah oh yeah you know

00:49:44.280 --> 00:49:48.180
<v Stu>what is the cost of rebelling and smear i mean it's everything to

00:49:48.180 --> 00:49:51.640
<v Stu>use that speech and in some ways this is exploring similar territory

00:49:51.640 --> 00:49:54.540
<v Stu>it's just interesting that we don't see the

00:49:54.540 --> 00:49:57.280
<v Stu>complete she she's told us we are

00:49:57.280 --> 00:50:01.140
<v Stu>given a speech earlier about the cot

00:50:01.140 --> 00:50:04.020
<v Stu>like the malpractice etc these are the of going

00:50:04.020 --> 00:50:07.280
<v Stu>public this will destroy the firm blah blah blah blah yeah we

00:50:07.280 --> 00:50:09.980
<v Stu>don't actually see that in the in the what we're told what it

00:50:09.980 --> 00:50:14.480
<v Stu>is but we don't see it yeah because i guess they're making they could have they

00:50:14.480 --> 00:50:19.080
<v Stu>could have tony gilroy knows what he's doing and i think it's really because

00:50:19.080 --> 00:50:23.160
<v Stu>he's actually wanting her to leave us with this the victory of like he is hanging

00:50:23.160 --> 00:50:29.080
<v Stu>on i love the fucking last shot we're hanging on michael clayton walking out having,

00:50:29.800 --> 00:50:31.920
<v Stu>fucking won this mm-hmm,

00:50:32.500 --> 00:50:37.960
<v Stu>Right. And him going, shit, I actually feel pretty good about who I am.

00:50:38.140 --> 00:50:44.080
<v Chas>And look, maybe I'm saying theme because I think an expertly resolved character

00:50:44.080 --> 00:50:48.880
<v Chas>arc, if you've watched that play out, then as an audience member,

00:50:49.000 --> 00:50:50.980
<v Chas>I tend to go, what was that all about?

00:50:51.480 --> 00:50:57.400
<v Chas>And, you know, Dungeons and Dragons is about a man learning how to live for

00:50:57.400 --> 00:50:59.080
<v Chas>his family as opposed to for himself.

00:50:59.360 --> 00:51:04.540
<v Stu>Oh, yeah. Yeah, and also the family of the people you choose around you and all that kind of stuff.

00:51:04.760 --> 00:51:11.080
<v Chas>You know, I take a narrower view of theme than you do where I am more about

00:51:11.080 --> 00:51:15.680
<v Chas>the, you know, I guess the philosophical argument that's being dramatized with

00:51:15.680 --> 00:51:17.280
<v Chas>these character journeys.

00:51:17.420 --> 00:51:22.860
<v Chas>So, for me, they're kind of somewhat connected if you've got a character arc

00:51:22.860 --> 00:51:26.580
<v Chas>that resolves in a very clear binary hero's choice.

00:51:26.580 --> 00:51:33.120
<v Chas>Where that hero's choice is a dramatization of what has been the thematic conflicts

00:51:33.120 --> 00:51:39.280
<v Chas>that these characters are playing out as it is in all of these three films yeah

00:51:39.280 --> 00:51:42.720
<v Chas>i guess that's why i find it thematically powerful as well.

00:51:42.720 --> 00:51:47.560
<v Stu>Yeah and look i'm just connecting it to our immediately previous episode but

00:51:47.560 --> 00:51:52.200
<v Stu>kind of the revelation to that character and theme character questions are theme

00:51:52.200 --> 00:51:54.260
<v Stu>questions, the theme questions are character questions.

00:51:54.420 --> 00:52:01.120
<v Stu>I absolutely do think this is a good example of that, that is dramatized in the ending, right?

00:52:01.380 --> 00:52:01.580
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:52:01.920 --> 00:52:07.840
<v Stu>You know, what does the price of morality or the price of immorality,

00:52:08.600 --> 00:52:13.100
<v Stu>you know, because she's bought, the whole company has bought,

00:52:13.180 --> 00:52:17.480
<v Stu>it's all about a company that knows that they have done the wrong thing,

00:52:20.000 --> 00:52:25.300
<v Stu>choosing to work out what is the cost, what are they, the literal cost for them

00:52:25.300 --> 00:52:26.680
<v Stu>in the settlement. Yeah.

00:52:26.860 --> 00:52:32.360
<v Chas>I mean, yeah, yeah, exactly. I mean, the Tilda Swinton character and your humanist

00:52:32.360 --> 00:52:36.740
<v Chas>observation is she is the mirror journey to Michael, right?

00:52:37.700 --> 00:52:43.500
<v Chas>She does end up selling her soul for the money and for the prestige and for the position.

00:52:43.540 --> 00:52:49.340
<v Chas>And he does that at the low point, sells out Arthur for 80K in a three-year

00:52:49.340 --> 00:52:52.360
<v Chas>contract, but comes out the other side of that.

00:52:53.020 --> 00:52:55.540
<v Chas>So, do we want to move on to Promising Young Woman?

00:52:55.880 --> 00:53:00.080
<v Stu>Yeah. I'm just trying to work out how much I would sell you out for in a three-year contract.

00:53:00.180 --> 00:53:02.440
<v Chas>I think it would be very cheap, sadly.

00:53:02.880 --> 00:53:03.540
<v Stu>$8,000?

00:53:06.280 --> 00:53:08.880
<v Stu>No, there's a lie, a green light.

00:53:11.360 --> 00:53:14.160
<v Stu>I'll sell Chaz out for a green light in a three-year contract.

00:53:16.780 --> 00:53:22.120
<v Excerpts>Whisper something in your ear Good God Almighty.

00:53:22.960 --> 00:53:28.860
<v Excerpts>You know, they put themselves in danger, girls like that. There was a perverted

00:53:28.860 --> 00:53:34.400
<v Excerpts>thing to say You'd think you'd learn by that age, right? I need to let go.

00:53:36.140 --> 00:53:40.180
<v Excerpts>What are you doing? It's okay, Kate. You're safe. What are you doing?

00:53:42.380 --> 00:53:45.920
<v Excerpts>Hey, I said, what are you doing?

00:53:53.190 --> 00:53:59.770
<v Excerpts>Every week I go to a club I act like I'm too drunk to stand,

00:54:02.030 --> 00:54:14.710
<v Excerpts>And every week a nice guy comes over to see if I'm okay You're so pretty I'm a nice guy Are you?

00:54:15.110 --> 00:54:20.790
<v Excerpts>One, two, three, four I thought we had a connection Okay. How old am I?

00:54:22.110 --> 00:54:23.230
<v Excerpts>What are my hobbies?

00:54:24.630 --> 00:54:25.770
<v Excerpts>What's my name?

00:54:27.210 --> 00:54:28.530
<v Excerpts>Sorry, maybe that one's too hard.

00:54:28.790 --> 00:54:31.530
<v Chas>Just like we've actually looked at Michael Clayton, I believe,

00:54:31.670 --> 00:54:37.450
<v Chas>before and will again, we've looked at Promising Young Woman before and maybe again.

00:54:37.650 --> 00:54:40.590
<v Chas>It's one of those examples recently, I think it felt so

00:54:40.590 --> 00:54:43.730
<v Chas>different to me that it's something that I keep narratively

00:54:43.730 --> 00:54:46.750
<v Chas>wanting to come back to but in

00:54:46.750 --> 00:54:50.350
<v Chas>the previous context that we looked at it was in our

00:54:50.350 --> 00:54:53.610
<v Chas>keeping genre fresh episode which we

00:54:53.610 --> 00:54:58.130
<v Chas>also were looking at get out and the invisible man with reference to parasite

00:54:58.130 --> 00:55:06.430
<v Chas>john wick taken knives out and more and in that i felt that promising young

00:55:06.430 --> 00:55:11.050
<v Chas>woman the had two very different storylines that were shot differently.

00:55:11.390 --> 00:55:16.730
<v Chas>And those two storylines were what created both the character tension and the dramatic tension.

00:55:16.930 --> 00:55:18.910
<v Stu>Which is an excellent observation.

00:55:19.390 --> 00:55:24.110
<v Chas>Well, thank you. So, it's about a young woman,

00:55:24.350 --> 00:55:33.290
<v Chas>Cassie, whose friend was raped in college and the fallout from her friend's

00:55:33.290 --> 00:55:35.830
<v Chas>rape, her friend ended up killing herself.

00:55:36.070 --> 00:55:39.250
<v Chas>And Cassie has, we're introduced to

00:55:39.250 --> 00:55:42.850
<v Chas>her at the beginning of the movie is going on a mission

00:55:42.850 --> 00:55:45.990
<v Chas>to basically reveal to nice

00:55:45.990 --> 00:55:49.690
<v Chas>guys their own monstrosity by

00:55:49.690 --> 00:55:52.930
<v Chas>basically putting herself in the position of uh

00:55:52.930 --> 00:55:56.170
<v Chas>being appearing to them as being

00:55:56.170 --> 00:55:59.010
<v Chas>uh too drunk to consent and showing

00:55:59.010 --> 00:56:01.950
<v Chas>them that they will cross that line

00:56:01.950 --> 00:56:04.930
<v Chas>and and not seek her or not care about her

00:56:04.930 --> 00:56:07.650
<v Chas>consent and so she's got

00:56:07.650 --> 00:56:10.890
<v Chas>a book she's got a tally she's trying to uh target

00:56:10.890 --> 00:56:16.870
<v Chas>these nice guys and it's it's holding the the film posits that it's holding

00:56:16.870 --> 00:56:21.890
<v Chas>her back in life from you know she left her medical career she's working in

00:56:21.890 --> 00:56:27.870
<v Chas>a cafe it's stopping her from having intimate or close friendships or relationships

00:56:27.870 --> 00:56:30.270
<v Chas>but she ends up falling for a guy,

00:56:30.550 --> 00:56:32.910
<v Chas>a nice guy, played by Bo Burnham.

00:56:32.970 --> 00:56:37.530
<v Chas>The casting of this movie is sublime, particularly all the nice guys and their casting.

00:56:37.890 --> 00:56:41.710
<v Chas>And so, as she becomes more...

00:56:42.670 --> 00:56:46.290
<v Chas>Connected with him it it reduces her need

00:56:46.290 --> 00:56:50.090
<v Chas>and efficacy for her sort of revenge addiction

00:56:50.090 --> 00:56:53.650
<v Chas>right and the flip side is her revenge addiction causes

00:56:53.650 --> 00:57:01.050
<v Chas>problems in her relationship and ultimately it comes to a head when the she

00:57:01.050 --> 00:57:08.070
<v Chas>finds out that her nice guy boyfriend actually witnessed her friends rape and

00:57:08.070 --> 00:57:10.470
<v Chas>did nothing and did not tell her and.

00:57:10.470 --> 00:57:11.710
<v Stu>He's denied it.

00:57:11.710 --> 00:57:12.290
<v Chas>Yeah like.

00:57:12.290 --> 00:57:17.250
<v Stu>Knowledge earlier so it wasn't just that he was present and did nothing.

00:57:17.250 --> 00:57:19.790
<v Chas>And he's and he's gaslighting her yeah.

00:57:19.790 --> 00:57:25.570
<v Stu>And and there's a sense of in of self-preservation in the video it's like don't film me don't film me.

00:57:25.570 --> 00:57:26.450
<v Chas>It's.

00:57:26.450 --> 00:57:31.530
<v Stu>It's that thing that he knows what is being seen as wrong in that he doesn't

00:57:31.530 --> 00:57:35.430
<v Stu>want to be associated with it but he doesn't have the moral fortitude to actually intervene.

00:57:35.430 --> 00:57:40.110
<v Chas>Yeah i mean and And he even has these great lines when she confronts him with the video.

00:57:40.250 --> 00:57:44.230
<v Excerpts>Like, I don't remember. I don't.

00:57:45.090 --> 00:57:48.610
<v Excerpts>Didn't make an impact, huh? I was a kid.

00:57:51.610 --> 00:57:57.670
<v Stu>And then she blackmails him with the, I have this video that shows you were

00:57:57.670 --> 00:58:03.310
<v Stu>there and, and was, you know, and that you were there and did nothing and everyone

00:58:03.310 --> 00:58:04.470
<v Stu>else was there and did nothing.

00:58:04.470 --> 00:58:09.750
<v Stu>And she goes for, kind of reputation, like, did he do anything criminal?

00:58:10.050 --> 00:58:15.870
<v Stu>Probably not, but it's not going to be a good look, given that he's a pediatric surgeon.

00:58:16.410 --> 00:58:21.130
<v Stu>And she uses that to extort information about-

00:58:21.130 --> 00:58:27.650
<v Chas>Al Monroe's bachelor party. Al Monroe being her friend Nina's rapist.

00:58:28.070 --> 00:58:32.130
<v Stu>So, and she gets that information. That sets up the third act.

00:58:32.130 --> 00:58:38.110
<v Stu>And what is interesting about this is this is definitely one of those POV things

00:58:38.110 --> 00:58:40.430
<v Stu>where we know that she's got a plan.

00:58:40.590 --> 00:58:40.750
<v Chas>Yeah.

00:58:40.850 --> 00:58:44.790
<v Stu>Because, I mean, she effectively says, I am going there. We turn up, she sees.

00:58:44.990 --> 00:58:48.850
<v Stu>And this kind of does connect to the beginning because we see her putting on

00:58:48.850 --> 00:58:53.310
<v Stu>this makeup and practicing things when she goes and picks up these nice guys,

00:58:53.510 --> 00:58:55.310
<v Stu>picks up, she doesn't pick, they pick her up.

00:58:55.530 --> 00:59:00.390
<v Stu>Right. And then she kind of turns the tables onto them. So, we know that she's

00:59:00.390 --> 00:59:03.950
<v Stu>got a plan, but we don't know what the plan is, right?

00:59:04.190 --> 00:59:08.830
<v Stu>Is it the same as, is she just going to confront them? Is she going to make them look at the video?

00:59:09.250 --> 00:59:16.210
<v Stu>She could just release the video. So, we are absolutely behind her in what's going on.

00:59:16.410 --> 00:59:20.930
<v Chas>Yeah. From a narrative perspective, she has the choice of-

00:59:21.340 --> 00:59:26.060
<v Chas>She's made her choice to choose revenge addiction, but we don't know how,

00:59:26.060 --> 00:59:30.620
<v Chas>like you say, we don't know how that's going to play out. We haven't seen her

00:59:30.620 --> 00:59:31.920
<v Chas>planning what she's going to do.

00:59:32.140 --> 00:59:36.320
<v Chas>We know that she's made a choice. We don't know what options she was considering.

00:59:36.680 --> 00:59:39.580
<v Chas>And again, we're into the implementation of it.

00:59:39.580 --> 00:59:42.440
<v Chas>We are behind her in the same way

00:59:42.440 --> 00:59:48.980
<v Chas>that we were behind michael in weirdly in the same way like in michael clayton

00:59:48.980 --> 00:59:54.160
<v Chas>where we're put into karen's point of view we're almost in al monroe's point

00:59:54.160 --> 01:00:01.040
<v Chas>of view in this uh confrontation do.

01:00:01.040 --> 01:00:05.120
<v Excerpts>I know you i'm not sure you remember me al you were so popular,

01:00:11.100 --> 01:00:12.100
<v Excerpts>you're nina's friend,

01:00:14.100 --> 01:00:18.060
<v Excerpts>fuck you're nina's friend so you did notice me after all.

01:00:18.060 --> 01:00:22.880
<v Stu>Yeah and look it's it's an interesting end sequence because there's this rule

01:00:22.880 --> 01:00:27.040
<v Stu>of thumb that we've talked about before which is if they tell you the plan in

01:00:27.040 --> 01:00:28.740
<v Stu>the heist movie it's all going to go wrong.

01:00:28.740 --> 01:00:29.160
<v Chas>Yeah they.

01:00:29.160 --> 01:00:32.020
<v Stu>Don't tell you the plan, it's going to go right.

01:00:32.180 --> 01:00:32.300
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:00:32.420 --> 01:00:36.120
<v Stu>Because it's where you get the dramatic power from. If you know what the plan

01:00:36.120 --> 01:00:42.300
<v Stu>is, the story is how do they adapt to the changes, the diversions from the plan.

01:00:42.660 --> 01:00:48.160
<v Stu>If you don't know what the plan is, then it's like about enjoying the revelations.

01:00:49.160 --> 01:00:54.120
<v Stu>It doesn't mean these things are not tense. Things kind of can go wrong in these

01:00:54.120 --> 01:00:56.260
<v Stu>heights, but this is a simple thing. We're not told her plan.

01:00:56.560 --> 01:00:58.380
<v Stu>So we think it's kind of working.

01:00:58.600 --> 01:00:58.700
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:00:58.700 --> 01:01:04.220
<v Stu>She gets all the guys, she gets Al Munro upstairs in the bedroom, handcuffed to the bed.

01:01:04.360 --> 01:01:07.960
<v Chas>She drugs all the guys like they're all unconscious.

01:01:08.580 --> 01:01:12.220
<v Stu>She seems like she has all the power, right?

01:01:14.860 --> 01:01:23.200
<v Excerpts>So when I heard your name again, your filthy fucking name, I wondered when was

01:01:23.200 --> 01:01:25.080
<v Excerpts>the last time anyone had said hers?

01:01:26.760 --> 01:01:32.660
<v Excerpts>Or thought it even, apart from me. And it made me so sad because,

01:01:33.160 --> 01:01:39.000
<v Excerpts>Al, you should be the one with her name all over you.

01:01:40.480 --> 01:01:41.120
<v Excerpts>No.

01:01:42.480 --> 01:01:47.880
<v Stu>So, it's a scene that's kind of similar to me to the scene in Girl with Dragon

01:01:47.880 --> 01:01:52.960
<v Stu>Tread 2 where Elizabeth Salander confronts her rapist.

01:01:52.960 --> 01:01:57.640
<v Stu>And is going to basically carve her name into it.

01:01:57.840 --> 01:02:01.380
<v Stu>The difference is, it's not Nina.

01:02:01.800 --> 01:02:05.020
<v Stu>Cassie's using the name Nina in the moment, in this moment.

01:02:05.360 --> 01:02:11.460
<v Stu>She reveals who she is. She reveals she knows Al's everything she goes to to

01:02:11.460 --> 01:02:17.460
<v Stu>carve it and then Al manages to get her hand free and kills her.

01:02:17.660 --> 01:02:17.880
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:02:18.240 --> 01:02:24.140
<v Stu>And this is what we think was meant to be her moment of victory and it seems like a moment of defeat.

01:02:24.300 --> 01:02:28.380
<v Stu>I mean, then talking about a low point in a story, there's like the other low

01:02:28.380 --> 01:02:31.440
<v Stu>point is her learning that her boyfriend and she's getting her life back on

01:02:31.440 --> 01:02:35.140
<v Stu>track is actually, turns out he's just a piece of shit like everyone else.

01:02:36.060 --> 01:02:36.460
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:02:36.640 --> 01:02:38.660
<v Stu>And that spurs her onto this.

01:02:39.080 --> 01:02:39.240
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:02:39.380 --> 01:02:44.240
<v Stu>And then we kind of sit in the consequences of that.

01:02:44.580 --> 01:02:49.240
<v Stu>We sit. So it's not really presented as a decision. It's something that happens to her.

01:02:49.500 --> 01:02:49.660
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:02:49.860 --> 01:02:52.760
<v Stu>Right. we see um her parents fire

01:02:52.760 --> 01:02:56.120
<v Stu>a missile missing persons report bo burnham

01:02:56.120 --> 01:02:58.960
<v Stu>get a visit from the cops he's at first and i

01:02:58.960 --> 01:03:02.020
<v Stu>really like that they play the reality of that which is like oh shit

01:03:02.020 --> 01:03:07.700
<v Stu>did cassie actually release the video and then you kind of see him relax that

01:03:07.700 --> 01:03:10.520
<v Stu>it's actually about cassie being a missing person him actually also seeming

01:03:10.520 --> 01:03:15.140
<v Stu>relieved right and i think part of what it works is the police like is she someone

01:03:15.140 --> 01:03:19.200
<v Stu>that's likely to self-harm and he's like yes because Cassie is someone that

01:03:19.200 --> 01:03:21.980
<v Stu>has kind of self-harming behaviours.

01:03:22.200 --> 01:03:26.360
<v Stu>She isn't going out and actually getting drunk, but she is definitely putting

01:03:26.360 --> 01:03:29.380
<v Stu>herself in, let's say, risky situations.

01:03:29.700 --> 01:03:29.840
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:03:30.020 --> 01:03:34.740
<v Stu>Right? And the film certainly portrays it as kind of risky behaviour on her behalf.

01:03:34.960 --> 01:03:35.220
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:03:35.360 --> 01:03:40.260
<v Stu>Right? And this is the scene where that risky behaviour, she paid the price for it.

01:03:40.260 --> 01:03:49.040
<v Chas>So, we think we've seen her make a choice and act on the choice and be murdered

01:03:49.040 --> 01:03:54.040
<v Chas>or killed, and then that's the consequences of the choice.

01:03:54.180 --> 01:03:57.920
<v Chas>And now, suddenly, we're sitting in other characters' POV.

01:03:58.340 --> 01:04:02.460
<v Stu>Yeah. And then we get to Al Munrud's wedding-

01:04:03.810 --> 01:04:07.330
<v Stu>And then Ryan gets a text message from Cassie that he's scheduled.

01:04:07.590 --> 01:04:11.910
<v Stu>At the time, I was like, eh, scheduled text messages. Now I'm someone that uses

01:04:11.910 --> 01:04:14.670
<v Stu>them all the time. They've just scheduled emails.

01:04:15.510 --> 01:04:20.350
<v Stu>I'm like, hey, Chaz, we're recording Giraffe Zero, schedule for 3 a.m.

01:04:20.890 --> 01:04:24.550
<v Stu>Completely by it now. At the time, I was like, hmm, really?

01:04:24.770 --> 01:04:28.370
<v Chas>So she's sent a scheduled text message.

01:04:28.550 --> 01:04:29.450
<v Stu>To Ryan.

01:04:29.730 --> 01:04:29.950
<v Chas>Yep.

01:04:29.950 --> 01:04:40.010
<v Stu>There is an envelope, a package goes to a lawyer, right, who, was he on Nina's case?

01:04:40.490 --> 01:04:45.190
<v Chas>I think he defended Al Monroe or other people.

01:04:45.490 --> 01:04:51.590
<v Chas>Anyway, she was on, he was on the revenge list, but actually showed contrition.

01:04:51.990 --> 01:04:54.970
<v Chas>So didn't get Cassied, but yeah.

01:04:55.070 --> 01:05:00.450
<v Stu>Yeah. Yes. So his name is Jordan and yeah, he's shows that he's deeply like he is.

01:05:00.850 --> 01:05:07.170
<v Stu>Yeah. Contrition is the right word for it. Um, and explains how the whole thing works.

01:05:07.390 --> 01:05:11.750
<v Excerpts>I got a bonus for every settlement out of court. I got another bonus for every

01:05:11.750 --> 01:05:14.970
<v Excerpts>charge dropped. We all did. There was a guy.

01:05:16.290 --> 01:05:22.350
<v Excerpts>His only job was to comb through all their social media accounts for any compromising

01:05:22.350 --> 01:05:26.150
<v Excerpts>information. He contacted old friends, past sexual partners.

01:05:26.510 --> 01:05:29.870
<v Excerpts>Oh, you'd be amazed how much easier it is now with the internet to dig up dirt.

01:05:30.590 --> 01:05:33.590
<v Excerpts>In the old days, we had to go through a girl's trash.

01:05:33.870 --> 01:05:39.130
<v Excerpts>Now, one drunk photo at a party. Oh, you wouldn't believe how hostile that makes a jury.

01:05:43.290 --> 01:05:44.430
<v Excerpts>You gotta help me.

01:05:46.730 --> 01:05:51.510
<v Excerpts>I can't sleep. I can't sleep.

01:05:52.450 --> 01:05:58.910
<v Stu>And she sends him a package incriminating his clients right his client in the

01:05:58.910 --> 01:06:02.530
<v Stu>event of my disappearance please let her and package to the police right which

01:06:02.530 --> 01:06:05.070
<v Stu>i think actually kind of does a lot of heavy lifting so.

01:06:05.070 --> 01:06:10.810
<v Chas>What what we we've now seen is that is the additional what happens in the in

01:06:10.810 --> 01:06:15.750
<v Chas>the in the climax of the film is that we actually see the consequences of decisions

01:06:15.750 --> 01:06:18.890
<v Chas>that we didn't even know choices that we didn't even know she had made right.

01:06:18.890 --> 01:06:22.210
<v Stu>Yeah because what happens is basically this incriminating video is given to

01:06:22.210 --> 01:06:24.030
<v Stu>the police. We see them arrest Al.

01:06:24.190 --> 01:06:31.170
<v Stu>We see Joe run off. We're assuming that Joe is going to ultimately also be tracked down, right?

01:06:31.310 --> 01:06:32.610
<v Chas>For burning her body.

01:06:32.950 --> 01:06:36.170
<v Stu>I mean, Al is totally going to fucking flip on him.

01:06:38.250 --> 01:06:42.810
<v Chas>But from a hero's journey or from a final choice perspective,

01:06:43.170 --> 01:06:50.010
<v Chas>we are, again, we were not with her. we didn't see her mail that package to the lawyer,

01:06:50.780 --> 01:06:55.200
<v Chas>or schedule some text messages, right? We cut straight from her saying she's

01:06:55.200 --> 01:06:59.980
<v Chas>going to Al Monroe's bachelor party to seeing her outside the bachelor party

01:06:59.980 --> 01:07:04.620
<v Chas>doing the final finishing touches on her makeup and hearing that amazing Britney

01:07:04.620 --> 01:07:07.280
<v Chas>Spears cover as she's wandering up.

01:07:07.420 --> 01:07:10.400
<v Chas>So we haven't seen her make the choice.

01:07:10.980 --> 01:07:14.560
<v Chas>We're only learning that she made the choice to go, you know,

01:07:14.620 --> 01:07:16.140
<v Chas>and she's been reckless the whole film.

01:07:16.240 --> 01:07:20.120
<v Chas>Like you said, she's put herself in dangerous situations. So we as the audience totally buy.

01:07:20.780 --> 01:07:26.540
<v Chas>That her plan was working perfectly until it wasn't and then she died as a consequence

01:07:26.540 --> 01:07:28.160
<v Chas>and that that might be it.

01:07:28.240 --> 01:07:34.120
<v Chas>And maybe we're sitting in this film that is talking about thematically about

01:07:34.120 --> 01:07:38.160
<v Chas>good guys getting away with it, right, with hurting women.

01:07:38.400 --> 01:07:40.720
<v Chas>Maybe that's what we're sitting with.

01:07:40.960 --> 01:07:46.320
<v Chas>But ultimately, we learned that her choice was to prepare better,

01:07:46.540 --> 01:07:49.840
<v Chas>I guess, prepare a contingency plan for her own death.

01:07:50.000 --> 01:07:54.940
<v Stu>Yeah. And so they play the whole thing as a surprise. Cassie's kind of come

01:07:54.940 --> 01:07:58.440
<v Stu>back from the dead to get justice.

01:07:59.080 --> 01:08:02.340
<v Stu>Right. And so what is interesting is, as you've talked about,

01:08:02.600 --> 01:08:04.660
<v Stu>we're not really shown her as having the choice.

01:08:04.820 --> 01:08:08.520
<v Stu>What were her choices to go or not to? Well, I guess her choice was just to

01:08:08.520 --> 01:08:10.560
<v Stu>give the information to the police.

01:08:10.860 --> 01:08:13.560
<v Stu>Right. She kind of talked about, I could just turn this over.

01:08:13.740 --> 01:08:18.500
<v Chas>She could have not sought revenge. She could have not put herself and her life

01:08:18.500 --> 01:08:23.380
<v Chas>at danger for the opportunity to carve Nina's name into Al Monroe.

01:08:24.150 --> 01:08:26.690
<v Stu>And what was her decision? Well, she went.

01:08:26.890 --> 01:08:27.070
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:08:27.390 --> 01:08:32.650
<v Stu>Right? Do you think it was a decision of hers to effectively let herself be

01:08:32.650 --> 01:08:37.570
<v Stu>killed a la Gran Torino, where Clint Eastwood basically mired us himself?

01:08:37.810 --> 01:08:42.910
<v Chas>This is an interesting question, I think. I, you know, does she let herself be killed?

01:08:43.790 --> 01:08:48.330
<v Chas>I think there is a read of this where she deliberately lets herself be killed to set up Al Monroe.

01:08:48.990 --> 01:08:54.090
<v Chas>My preferred read is that she was recklessly indifferent to her own demise.

01:08:54.310 --> 01:08:55.950
<v Stu>And she knew it was a possibility.

01:08:56.250 --> 01:09:03.510
<v Chas>Yeah. She was only an avenging angel of death and that she had one way of seeking her revenge.

01:09:03.610 --> 01:09:06.150
<v Chas>But if that failed, she had another.

01:09:06.590 --> 01:09:06.770
<v Stu>Yeah.

01:09:07.010 --> 01:09:11.250
<v Chas>Yeah. I mean, whichever way you look at it, while it would make you look at

01:09:11.250 --> 01:09:13.490
<v Chas>Cassie differently as a character,

01:09:13.670 --> 01:09:18.310
<v Chas>as an audience member, what makes this ending so confronting and so powerful

01:09:18.330 --> 01:09:20.970
<v Chas>powerful you totally buy just the way that you

01:09:20.970 --> 01:09:23.990
<v Chas>totally buy that michael is going to take the 10 million

01:09:23.990 --> 01:09:27.930
<v Chas>you totally buy that cassie has recklessly

01:09:27.930 --> 01:09:33.170
<v Chas>put herself in the path of death and has failed in her justice mission now we

01:09:33.170 --> 01:09:40.790
<v Chas>kind of get i think as an audience a an emotional bump that she's triumphed

01:09:40.790 --> 01:09:46.650
<v Chas>you know that text message from cassie and nina with a wink emoji.

01:09:46.650 --> 01:09:47.990
<v Stu>So

01:09:47.990 --> 01:09:54.210
<v Chas>It feels triumphant but i i still think that the film is a deliberately a tragedy.

01:09:54.210 --> 01:09:57.250
<v Stu>Yeah i think it is a tragedy and i'm

01:09:57.250 --> 01:10:00.150
<v Stu>glad you found that connection with michael clayton because both of

01:10:00.150 --> 01:10:03.370
<v Stu>them are withholding our experience

01:10:03.370 --> 01:10:06.450
<v Stu>with the characters to speak in a way more towards theme

01:10:06.450 --> 01:10:09.530
<v Stu>and i'm using theme in a broad sense there

01:10:09.530 --> 01:10:12.490
<v Stu>you know it does make a sit in this

01:10:12.490 --> 01:10:15.450
<v Stu>idea of like oh he's gonna

01:10:15.450 --> 01:10:19.050
<v Stu>what he's al's gonna get away with this too fuck

01:10:19.050 --> 01:10:24.610
<v Stu>of course right and then he doesn't and look there is possibly an interpretation

01:10:24.610 --> 01:10:31.330
<v Stu>of the film where it's like a death dream i think that's a pretty weak interpretation

01:10:31.330 --> 01:10:35.510
<v Stu>i think the only thing that makes it feel like a decision that she's chosen

01:10:35.510 --> 01:10:37.230
<v Stu>to go in there and let herself be sacrificed,

01:10:37.510 --> 01:10:40.970
<v Stu>is the fact that it repeats the motive of the one, two, three,

01:10:40.990 --> 01:10:44.790
<v Stu>and the four, where it writes the numbers from her book, and we see four get

01:10:44.790 --> 01:10:47.270
<v Stu>crossed out, that she has achieved,

01:10:47.450 --> 01:10:53.390
<v Stu>you know, what she's after with him, but I think she would have crossed him out had she lived.

01:10:53.730 --> 01:10:57.790
<v Stu>I do think she probably would have given that information to the police, right? Yeah.

01:10:58.030 --> 01:11:01.090
<v Chas>Whether she would have done that or not, or whether she would have been satisfied

01:11:01.090 --> 01:11:08.530
<v Chas>with his wife-to-be seeing, going, why is there the name Nina carved all over your skin?

01:11:09.330 --> 01:11:12.350
<v Chas>Whether that would have satisfied her or not, I don't know.

01:11:12.550 --> 01:11:16.590
<v Stu>Yes, because there's no reason that Hasse believes that the justice system will

01:11:16.590 --> 01:11:19.390
<v Stu>work because it clearly failed Nina, right?

01:11:19.550 --> 01:11:19.670
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:11:19.850 --> 01:11:22.610
<v Stu>And that's why she's doing these things in her own hands. In a way,

01:11:22.890 --> 01:11:26.070
<v Stu>maybe all she's just trying to do is embarrass Al.

01:11:26.870 --> 01:11:31.050
<v Stu>We don't know whether they actually get away with it or not. Yeah.

01:11:31.330 --> 01:11:36.130
<v Chas>I mean, they might. You know, Al might retain a lawyer similar to the Alfred

01:11:36.130 --> 01:11:38.770
<v Chas>Molina character and actually get away.

01:11:39.130 --> 01:11:42.450
<v Chas>If they hadn't burnt the body, he would have a strong self-defense argument.

01:11:42.450 --> 01:11:45.710
<v Chas>She was coming at him with a scalpel while he was handcuffed to a bed.

01:11:46.090 --> 01:11:51.270
<v Stu>Yeah, yeah. I mean, yes. It's letting us enjoy the sense of justice.

01:11:51.730 --> 01:11:56.250
<v Stu>Right. And in a way, what's interesting is they've chosen to play it from Ryan's

01:11:56.250 --> 01:12:01.070
<v Stu>point of view, as opposed to from Al's. So, there's some interesting point of

01:12:01.070 --> 01:12:04.970
<v Stu>view stuff about who we're shifting. And the fact is, we're still talking about this film.

01:12:05.270 --> 01:12:10.430
<v Stu>The ending being not necessarily emotionally powerful, but I definitely think

01:12:10.430 --> 01:12:15.010
<v Stu>thematically powerful is part of the reason we're still talking about it.

01:12:15.050 --> 01:12:19.070
<v Stu>And yet, it is so different from the Michael Arndt, you know,

01:12:19.250 --> 01:12:22.810
<v Stu>insanely great ending. I mean, it's got like some of those things,

01:12:22.930 --> 01:12:25.210
<v Stu>like it's got the Judas moment, which Michael Arnn talks about.

01:12:25.650 --> 01:12:29.110
<v Stu>Yeah. Okay. It turns out Bo Bannon is, is again, you know, um,

01:12:29.590 --> 01:12:31.530
<v Stu>betrays her, but does this happen?

01:12:31.690 --> 01:12:34.650
<v Stu>Does it, is there a decisive act in this two minute climax? No.

01:12:34.930 --> 01:12:39.450
<v Chas>I mean, the decisive act doesn't happen. It's revealed to us that it was made

01:12:39.450 --> 01:12:41.550
<v Chas>in that two minute climax.

01:12:41.870 --> 01:12:42.170
<v Stu>Yeah.

01:12:42.370 --> 01:12:47.170
<v Chas>Like the decisive act happens at some point in between her confronting Ryan

01:12:47.170 --> 01:12:52.850
<v Chas>and getting Al Monroe's bachelor party address and her showing up at that bachelor party.

01:12:53.050 --> 01:12:56.010
<v Stu>And what's kind of interesting is that you've got two choices here.

01:12:56.190 --> 01:12:59.270
<v Stu>She is actually, she actually gives Ryan the choice.

01:12:59.530 --> 01:12:59.850
<v Chas>Mm-hmm.

01:13:00.030 --> 01:13:01.650
<v Stu>Give me, give up your friend.

01:13:01.870 --> 01:13:02.250
<v Chas>Mm-hmm.

01:13:02.540 --> 01:13:06.380
<v Stu>Right? Because you know I'm, at this point, Ryan knows what she has done.

01:13:06.540 --> 01:13:12.020
<v Stu>So, when he says, when she's like, I can go after your friend or I can go after

01:13:12.020 --> 01:13:14.040
<v Stu>you, who do you choose? Of course, he throws his friend.

01:13:14.180 --> 01:13:16.360
<v Stu>So, it's interesting that she's actually given him the choice.

01:13:16.500 --> 01:13:19.520
<v Stu>I'm not saying he's making the heroic decision here. No.

01:13:19.860 --> 01:13:21.640
<v Chas>It's entirely self-preservation.

01:13:21.980 --> 01:13:26.540
<v Stu>Oh, yeah. What I mean is like the hero's choice or the decisive act or the crisis point.

01:13:27.040 --> 01:13:31.200
<v Stu>Whatever you want to do it in a way is interestingly kind of in his point of

01:13:31.200 --> 01:13:35.440
<v Stu>view at this moment. not that he's involved in the back half of the story.

01:13:35.620 --> 01:13:40.940
<v Stu>But it is pretty clever filmmaking in terms of manipulating our point of view.

01:13:41.240 --> 01:13:45.240
<v Stu>And it definitely has frigologic problems, like we've talked about,

01:13:45.340 --> 01:13:48.120
<v Stu>because you get to that moment and go, wait, did she plan to die?

01:13:48.120 --> 01:13:49.760
<v Stu>What happens if she didn't die?

01:13:49.860 --> 01:13:54.740
<v Stu>And that's why I was like, oh, the letter's saying in the event of my disappearance, right?

01:13:54.860 --> 01:13:59.200
<v Stu>And I personally possibly would have liked a little bit more hinting that this was,

01:13:59.200 --> 01:14:04.640
<v Stu>she accepted that it was a possibility but didn't think it wasn't her plan to

01:14:04.640 --> 01:14:10.160
<v Stu>go and die you know but whatever whatever that's the kind of the logic the climactic

01:14:10.160 --> 01:14:11.700
<v Stu>logic of of pushing through.

01:14:11.700 --> 01:14:14.340
<v Chas>Yeah i mean if you do a

01:14:14.340 --> 01:14:20.080
<v Chas>timing thing the odds of the police actually showing up to arrest al at the

01:14:20.080 --> 01:14:25.900
<v Chas>wedding is just as she's sending the scheduled text messages she would have

01:14:25.900 --> 01:14:33.860
<v Chas>no control over when the cops would actually show up to arrest Al on which day or what time of day.

01:14:34.020 --> 01:14:39.140
<v Stu>Yeah. Oh, yeah. Like, Jared, the lawyer, having to get that signature to the police.

01:14:39.160 --> 01:14:44.560
<v Stu>The police have to look at it, find her body, determine that Al is the person

01:14:44.560 --> 01:14:46.520
<v Stu>that they're going to have, a person of interest.

01:14:47.120 --> 01:14:53.220
<v Stu>Like, that whole timeline, they just kind of push, use the power of cinema.

01:14:53.460 --> 01:14:56.640
<v Chas>Yeah. for emotional and wonderful emotional effect.

01:14:56.800 --> 01:15:00.880
<v Chas>But again, like, it should be so obvious to everyone listening,

01:15:01.160 --> 01:15:09.880
<v Chas>but they managed to successfully pull off a powerful hero's choice after the character is dead.

01:15:10.980 --> 01:15:15.520
<v Chas>And yes, it's done through scheduling and flashbacks, but it is powerful.

01:15:15.740 --> 01:15:21.480
<v Chas>It feels from Nina. Like, it would have felt very different if Nina hadn't scheduled

01:15:21.480 --> 01:15:23.200
<v Chas>those text messages, right?

01:15:23.200 --> 01:15:28.160
<v Chas>If Al is just, sorry, if we're in Ryan's point of view, he's at the wedding

01:15:28.160 --> 01:15:33.220
<v Chas>and suddenly the cops show up with the lawyer waving the package that...

01:15:34.440 --> 01:15:39.960
<v Chas>That Cassie has sent, right? That is much less powerful and gives Cassie much

01:15:39.960 --> 01:15:44.720
<v Chas>less agency than her talking directly to Ryan through scheduled text messages.

01:15:44.920 --> 01:15:45.840
<v Stu>Yes. Yeah.

01:15:45.960 --> 01:15:53.240
<v Chas>So they've set all this up to be a character choice, a hero's choice, a final choice.

01:15:54.060 --> 01:15:59.220
<v Stu>All of those things. And here's a crisis decisions. I mean, she had something

01:15:59.220 --> 01:16:00.340
<v Stu>to lose and something to gain.

01:16:00.340 --> 01:16:07.040
<v Stu>I mean, she gained justice, like hours, possibly going to jail for murder,

01:16:07.240 --> 01:16:11.920
<v Stu>but she feels that he's responsible for killing for Nina, but all it cost her was her life.

01:16:12.220 --> 01:16:17.240
<v Chas>I do think what the film sets up and what leaves your question open as to whether

01:16:17.240 --> 01:16:24.600
<v Chas>she chose to die or not is that she certainly had nothing else in her life that she cared about.

01:16:25.160 --> 01:16:29.880
<v Chas>She didn't care about a job, a relationship, her parents. there was nothing

01:16:29.880 --> 01:16:32.660
<v Chas>else in her life other than getting revenge on Al Monroe.

01:16:33.120 --> 01:16:33.220
<v Stu>Yep.

01:16:33.740 --> 01:16:36.640
<v Chas>All right. Well, now that we've done two very juicy examples,

01:16:37.040 --> 01:16:39.840
<v Chas>slash four, if we include Dungeons and Dragons and Finding Nemo,

01:16:40.060 --> 01:16:42.800
<v Chas>shall we end with Talk To Me?

01:16:43.560 --> 01:16:47.620
<v Excerpts>Huh? Do it. Do it. Do it. Do it.

01:16:47.920 --> 01:16:51.640
<v Excerpts>Do it. Do it. Do it. Who's up? I'll do it.

01:16:54.900 --> 01:16:58.980
<v Excerpts>Cannot go for more than 90 seconds. Am I clear? What happens after 90 seconds?

01:17:02.700 --> 01:17:03.740
<v Excerpts>Don't want to stay.

01:17:06.040 --> 01:17:09.680
<v Chas>Look, I think both of you, we don't often do...

01:17:10.360 --> 01:17:17.440
<v Chas>Uh examples that don't work for us in this podcast so i think we both want to be very clear that,

01:17:18.060 --> 01:17:24.400
<v Chas>we greatly admire talk to me it was an incredible low budget australian horror

01:17:24.400 --> 01:17:29.160
<v Chas>feature that i would recommend anyone watch i think it's great it was in fact

01:17:29.160 --> 01:17:34.340
<v Chas>one of my picks for uh i'm a patron of the contrarians podcast and i got to

01:17:34.340 --> 01:17:37.600
<v Chas>make them watch the babadook and talk to me i.

01:17:37.600 --> 01:17:42.860
<v Stu>Was working I haven't ever published on it. I was working on a Shot Zero post

01:17:42.860 --> 01:17:46.260
<v Stu>about the physical intimacy between the characters.

01:17:46.420 --> 01:17:51.220
<v Stu>And one of the things it so beautifully does as an ensemble is kind of the casualness of touch.

01:17:51.560 --> 01:17:51.680
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:17:51.760 --> 01:17:56.420
<v Stu>The power of touching this film. I mean, the whole idea is about touching this

01:17:56.420 --> 01:17:58.020
<v Stu>hand and being able to speak to the dead.

01:17:58.220 --> 01:18:02.940
<v Stu>Touch is this very powerful idea. I'm not sure whether the brothers were conscious

01:18:02.940 --> 01:18:05.020
<v Stu>of it when they were writing it and making the film.

01:18:05.020 --> 01:18:07.500
<v Stu>It doesn't really fucking matter because it still works, right?

01:18:07.500 --> 01:18:12.080
<v Stu>Touches it like there's a lot of films that can feel really dead because physical

01:18:12.080 --> 01:18:14.920
<v Stu>intimacy isn't part of it. And this is, they use all the time.

01:18:15.180 --> 01:18:18.420
<v Stu>Um, there's lots of really amazing things.

01:18:18.600 --> 01:18:23.460
<v Stu>This film does, which I guess was why the ending stood out as something that didn't work for us.

01:18:23.520 --> 01:18:26.700
<v Stu>And we wanted to unpack it because we're like, there's so much here that we

01:18:26.700 --> 01:18:28.580
<v Stu>had like fucking admire.

01:18:28.860 --> 01:18:29.040
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:18:29.360 --> 01:18:33.740
<v Stu>Right. We, I have mentioned referenced this in a, in, in director's notes for

01:18:33.740 --> 01:18:37.240
<v Stu>a project about how amazing I think that ensemble is. Yeah.

01:18:37.500 --> 01:18:44.400
<v Chas>And just to be clear up front, we came out of this film wondering what the film

01:18:44.400 --> 01:18:49.040
<v Chas>was about because the film withholds the final choice.

01:18:49.040 --> 01:18:52.580
<v Chas>So, I'm just setting that as groundwork before we explain how the film is structured

01:18:52.580 --> 01:18:57.420
<v Chas>and then how that final choice is or is not presented on screen.

01:18:57.780 --> 01:19:02.840
<v Stu>Yes. We came out of it. We both, you and I, we saw it with a bunch of our writers

01:19:02.840 --> 01:19:05.000
<v Stu>group and you and I were kind of like, yeah, it didn't work for us.

01:19:05.180 --> 01:19:10.000
<v Stu>Yeah, blah, blah, blah. What was it trying to say? And we kind of quickly reversed engineered it.

01:19:10.120 --> 01:19:13.220
<v Stu>It's not like we both- I mean, maybe we came to a conclusion in the cinema,

01:19:13.400 --> 01:19:18.520
<v Stu>but I think it was more like just quick discussion kind of narrowed it to this

01:19:18.520 --> 01:19:23.560
<v Stu>particular moment, which is the absence of the decisive act, right?

01:19:23.700 --> 01:19:24.480
<v Chas>For the audience.

01:19:24.760 --> 01:19:25.100
<v Stu>Yes.

01:19:25.320 --> 01:19:32.160
<v Chas>Because it happens in the film. We just- it's just withheld from us as to what the act is.

01:19:32.160 --> 01:19:36.300
<v Stu>And unlike Michael Clayton and unlike Promising Young Woman,

01:19:36.540 --> 01:19:39.780
<v Stu>we never, never learn what it is.

01:19:39.780 --> 01:19:45.460
<v Chas>Explain to us afterwards. So, as a broad summary, I think Talk To Me is really

01:19:45.460 --> 01:19:49.280
<v Chas>a horror film, but there's a hand,

01:19:49.580 --> 01:19:55.420
<v Chas>like a supernatural hand, that if you hold and you say, talk to me,

01:19:55.600 --> 01:20:03.300
<v Chas>you can invite either dead spirits or demons, depending on your interpretation,

01:20:03.640 --> 01:20:06.420
<v Chas>to possess your body temporarily.

01:20:07.220 --> 01:20:08.680
<v Excerpts>That's where you get it from anyway.

01:20:09.620 --> 01:20:12.280
<v Excerpts>I'll tell you what it is right it's the hand of

01:20:12.280 --> 01:20:15.200
<v Excerpts>a psychic got cut off and embalmed legit it's

01:20:15.200 --> 01:20:19.820
<v Excerpts>a medium joss not a psychic yeah this isn't an embalmed hand yes it is danny

01:20:19.820 --> 01:20:23.720
<v Excerpts>boy see look the ceramic shit is put over it but if you smash it there's an

01:20:23.720 --> 01:20:28.260
<v Excerpts>actual a hand in there you're full of shit i'm serious apparently it was the

01:20:28.260 --> 01:20:31.080
<v Excerpts>hand of someone who could connect with the dead right so everyone around him

01:20:31.080 --> 01:20:34.420
<v Excerpts>thought let's just cut his hand off white people shit man i tell you.

01:20:34.420 --> 01:20:42.100
<v Chas>What is so incredible about the first half of this movie is it's like a perfect parable for like,

01:20:42.800 --> 01:20:45.900
<v Chas>teenage risk-taking right uh

01:20:45.900 --> 01:20:48.780
<v Chas>the when the contrarians were discussing it i thought it was an interesting

01:20:48.780 --> 01:20:51.780
<v Chas>thought experiment is would this film have worked because they're

01:20:51.780 --> 01:20:54.440
<v Chas>filming this group of teenagers they're all doing it in like

01:20:54.440 --> 01:20:57.260
<v Chas>a basement like uh and it's like a

01:20:57.260 --> 01:21:00.240
<v Chas>drug or alcohol or something like that and

01:21:00.240 --> 01:21:03.520
<v Chas>they're all filming it and posting these that

01:21:03.520 --> 01:21:06.720
<v Chas>themselves getting possessed and it's just

01:21:06.720 --> 01:21:09.580
<v Chas>so delightfully real and

01:21:09.580 --> 01:21:12.740
<v Chas>you wonder if would this film have worked like

01:21:12.740 --> 01:21:15.740
<v Chas>the contrarians asked the question would this film have worked before social

01:21:15.740 --> 01:21:21.900
<v Chas>media where there's this kind of feedback incentive to uh publishing your risk-taking

01:21:21.900 --> 01:21:27.880
<v Chas>behavior but i i i was just thinking um yes it would work because people used

01:21:27.880 --> 01:21:34.840
<v Chas>to do seances and ouija boards and all that kind of stuff and drugs in placements.

01:21:36.560 --> 01:21:37.340
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:21:38.420 --> 01:21:43.540
<v Stu>I mean, I'm looking at your office pot at the moment with the Frosthaven board in the back.

01:21:44.580 --> 01:21:49.100
<v Stu>One of your kids is going to be smoking bongs in there when they're a teenager.

01:21:50.520 --> 01:21:51.020
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:21:51.400 --> 01:21:55.780
<v Stu>And Chaz is just going to be bringing out a platter of munchies for them.

01:21:56.540 --> 01:21:56.900
<v Chas>Sure.

01:21:57.020 --> 01:22:04.920
<v Stu>You'll be like, I just happen to slow cook this six-hour brisket if you want some.

01:22:05.800 --> 01:22:06.740
<v Chas>I am a feeder.

01:22:06.920 --> 01:22:09.380
<v Stu>I'm just going to say it because I still think it's cool. One of my friends,

01:22:09.580 --> 01:22:15.880
<v Stu>Kush, his mom used to make, I mean, she was born in India, made amazing curries.

01:22:17.140 --> 01:22:21.140
<v Stu>Her, and her name was Nina. She would always keep food on the stove,

01:22:21.320 --> 01:22:22.220
<v Stu>like his amazing curries.

01:22:22.340 --> 01:22:26.340
<v Stu>And her whole thing was like, I just wanted to meet my son's friends.

01:22:27.300 --> 01:22:30.440
<v Stu>And by having food on the stove that just can be kept on the stove,

01:22:30.660 --> 01:22:32.080
<v Stu>they would always come over.

01:22:33.780 --> 01:22:36.160
<v Stu>And it was great i love it.

01:22:36.160 --> 01:22:37.440
<v Chas>Oh that's awesome good.

01:22:37.440 --> 01:22:40.620
<v Stu>Reason to learn how to cook curry stew uh anyway.

01:22:40.620 --> 01:22:43.640
<v Chas>But the the midpoint of the film uh so

01:22:43.640 --> 01:22:46.540
<v Chas>the the leads are this group of teenagers like

01:22:46.540 --> 01:22:50.300
<v Chas>you say it's a true ensemble but the main character and

01:22:50.300 --> 01:22:53.260
<v Chas>possibly protagonist is mia played by

01:22:53.260 --> 01:23:01.340
<v Chas>sophie wilde who has her mother's died by suicide she has a strained almost

01:23:01.340 --> 01:23:07.100
<v Chas>estranged relationship with her father and kind of seeks intimacy and familiarity

01:23:07.100 --> 01:23:11.120
<v Chas>with a neighboring family where a mother,

01:23:11.400 --> 01:23:15.900
<v Chas>a single mother, a daughter her age called Jade and her younger brother Riley.

01:23:16.740 --> 01:23:23.260
<v Excerpts>It was mom's two years. That was today? Yeah.

01:23:25.460 --> 01:23:27.280
<v Excerpts>I just want to forget about it.

01:23:30.900 --> 01:23:33.980
<v Excerpts>And I need Daniel to come give my Gucci some attention.

01:23:37.140 --> 01:23:40.760
<v Excerpts>Daniel's not touching your Gucci. Why? It was my boyfriend before he was yours.

01:23:40.760 --> 01:23:44.260
<v Excerpts>Oh my god, you guys held hands once three years ago. That doesn't mean anything. Jade!

01:23:45.740 --> 01:23:47.180
<v Excerpts>It's my mom's remembrance day.

01:23:54.580 --> 01:23:59.260
<v Excerpts>Daniel can come too, yeah? If he's touching my Gucci, yes.

01:24:00.880 --> 01:24:09.600
<v Chas>And the midpoint of the film is Riley being possessed by a spirit or demon so violent that he...

01:24:09.600 --> 01:24:16.740
<v Chas>It's a really spectacular scene, but just injures himself so badly that he gets put into a hospital.

01:24:21.820 --> 01:24:24.720
<v Excerpts>Oh my God. Okay.

01:24:29.780 --> 01:24:33.080
<v Excerpts>I finally... Ah! My lips! Ah!

01:24:35.460 --> 01:24:41.200
<v Excerpts>I'm fucking out, man! I can't help you! I can't help you!

01:24:42.780 --> 01:24:48.780
<v Chas>They stop using the hand temporarily, but every time he regains consciousness,

01:24:49.080 --> 01:24:54.020
<v Chas>he once again keeps trying to kill himself by, and because he's restrained by usually,

01:24:54.580 --> 01:24:58.120
<v Chas>uh banging his head into things in spectacular fashion.

01:24:58.120 --> 01:25:03.600
<v Stu>I would say concurrently mia is getting more and more interested in the imbound

01:25:03.600 --> 01:25:07.960
<v Stu>and as a way to contact her mom yes i.

01:25:07.960 --> 01:25:14.100
<v Excerpts>Can't believe i spoke to her i think that was your mom mia no it was at first

01:25:14.100 --> 01:25:20.820
<v Excerpts>she used to call me me all the time i mean how would the spirits know that i

01:25:20.820 --> 01:25:23.520
<v Excerpts>feel like they read what we think you know i mean,

01:25:25.160 --> 01:25:29.200
<v Excerpts>they were in us they could know everything about us,

01:25:32.400 --> 01:25:36.640
<v Excerpts>maybe mum was there because she was trying to reach out.

01:25:38.500 --> 01:25:44.680
<v Stu>So you've got these parallel storylines that are definitely not parallel they're

01:25:44.680 --> 01:25:47.740
<v Stu>intertwined which is Riley's in hospital,

01:25:48.300 --> 01:25:52.480
<v Stu>absolutely possessed with this demon and then Mia's contacting her mother through

01:25:52.480 --> 01:25:56.320
<v Stu>the hand and then says, it wasn't a suicide,

01:25:57.180 --> 01:25:59.460
<v Stu>and you need to go and help Riley.

01:25:59.660 --> 01:25:59.940
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:26:00.180 --> 01:26:02.720
<v Stu>Right? And you need to do these things to help Riley.

01:26:02.980 --> 01:26:03.080
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:26:03.260 --> 01:26:05.440
<v Stu>And part of it is that-

01:26:05.850 --> 01:26:11.790
<v Stu>Part of the law is that you can't trust the people that you're seeing through

01:26:11.790 --> 01:26:14.630
<v Stu>these visions that they may be demons, right?

01:26:14.850 --> 01:26:24.630
<v Stu>And so, you don't know- So, you fear that Mia may be- And this is classic possession movie trope.

01:26:24.730 --> 01:26:24.850
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:26:25.050 --> 01:26:27.510
<v Stu>Right? You can't trust the possessive demon.

01:26:27.690 --> 01:26:31.730
<v Chas>I mean, she is seeing stuff without using the hand, right?

01:26:31.850 --> 01:26:35.490
<v Chas>So, Riley is like- They've taken the hand away.

01:26:35.490 --> 01:26:38.230
<v Chas>Riley is still possessed he exceeded the

01:26:38.230 --> 01:26:41.270
<v Chas>90 seconds safe time right so Riley is

01:26:41.270 --> 01:26:44.350
<v Chas>still possessed and she's also still seeing things

01:26:44.350 --> 01:26:47.090
<v Chas>and sort of gradually she becomes a very

01:26:47.090 --> 01:26:50.630
<v Chas>clear unreliable narrator and one

01:26:50.630 --> 01:26:53.790
<v Chas>of the things that I do like about the film early early

01:26:53.790 --> 01:26:57.370
<v Chas>on is that Mia is clearly not popular

01:26:57.370 --> 01:27:00.690
<v Chas>and it's the popular crowd have the hand and

01:27:00.690 --> 01:27:03.590
<v Chas>we don't know what she wants but she really desperately wants to

01:27:03.590 --> 01:27:06.810
<v Chas>get into this party with the cool kids and she's

01:27:06.810 --> 01:27:12.890
<v Chas>prepared to humiliate herself to get into that party and so it is seated quite

01:27:12.890 --> 01:27:17.590
<v Chas>early on that she really wants to like the reason she wants the hand is and

01:27:17.590 --> 01:27:21.350
<v Chas>keeps using it and going again and again and again is she wants to find her

01:27:21.350 --> 01:27:25.450
<v Chas>mother as the spirit so there is this sort of underlying story

01:27:25.470 --> 01:27:33.030
<v Chas>like you said an intertwined storyline about mia being unable to accept that

01:27:33.030 --> 01:27:36.930
<v Chas>her mother killed herself and wanting to talk to her mother and.

01:27:36.930 --> 01:27:44.170
<v Stu>So we're leading up to the climax of the film which is mia breaking into the hospital to take riley.

01:27:44.170 --> 01:27:44.990
<v Chas>Right.

01:27:44.990 --> 01:27:52.010
<v Stu>Because she well she she's kind of listening to the spirit of her mother.

01:27:52.010 --> 01:27:57.710
<v Chas>She has already killed her father by this point Just to be clear as a plot development. Yeah.

01:27:57.850 --> 01:28:03.910
<v Stu>And her mother has told her that Riley needs to die in order to be set free from his possession.

01:28:33.780 --> 01:28:40.580
<v Stu>And so the climax is Mia kidnapping Riley and then basically going towards a highway.

01:28:40.820 --> 01:28:46.580
<v Stu>If you've seen the film, I want you to just remember, because I've used this test before.

01:28:46.820 --> 01:28:51.440
<v Stu>When you think of the moment when they come to the highway, what do you think

01:28:51.440 --> 01:28:55.420
<v Stu>happened? We see a close-up of Rhea speaking to Mia. What do you think happened?

01:28:55.420 --> 01:29:01.680
<v Chas>So, just to be clear, Riley is in a wheelchair and she's wheeled him up to the

01:29:01.680 --> 01:29:09.260
<v Chas>edge of a highway with the understanding that she's thinking about tipping him

01:29:09.260 --> 01:29:12.540
<v Chas>over in front of oncoming traffic.

01:29:12.820 --> 01:29:13.040
<v Stu>Right.

01:29:13.200 --> 01:29:15.940
<v Chas>So, are you using the test on me? Because I have seen it just about,

01:29:15.940 --> 01:29:17.600
<v Chas>you know, 20 minutes ago.

01:29:17.600 --> 01:29:22.000
<v Stu>Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Because I will tell you when I've asked people this,

01:29:22.320 --> 01:29:27.060
<v Stu>they're all like, oh, Mia jumps into the on-carving traffic.

01:29:27.300 --> 01:29:27.440
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:29:27.600 --> 01:29:30.880
<v Stu>Right? So, you see her mother whisper in her ear and then she jumps.

01:29:31.020 --> 01:29:32.120
<v Stu>But if you actually look at what.

01:29:32.120 --> 01:29:38.540
<v Chas>We see in the film- His- Riley's sister Jade is running after them to try and stop them. Yeah.

01:29:38.540 --> 01:29:44.380
<v Stu>And then we see the very kind of grossy, great prosthetics of the mother whispering

01:29:44.380 --> 01:29:47.660
<v Stu>into Mia's ear, Mia's hands clasped.

01:29:47.800 --> 01:29:51.420
<v Stu>This is all real ECU, very close up, right?

01:29:51.640 --> 01:29:54.960
<v Stu>Kind of very decompressed filmmaking with Riley.

01:29:55.220 --> 01:29:58.520
<v Stu>We see, we do see her let go, right?

01:29:58.620 --> 01:29:59.560
<v Chas>Of the wheelchair.

01:29:59.560 --> 01:30:06.960
<v Stu>And then we cut to the inside of a car driving along the highway and out of

01:30:06.960 --> 01:30:11.380
<v Stu>focus, we see something hit the car, right?

01:30:11.500 --> 01:30:15.600
<v Stu>So they're keeping it as a surprise, right? We actually spend some time with

01:30:15.600 --> 01:30:20.740
<v Stu>the kind of stunt of the car and then we cut to wide overhead shot showing that it was Mare.

01:30:20.880 --> 01:30:25.560
<v Stu>So this is what the very nitty gritty of the text is showing.

01:30:25.580 --> 01:30:26.520
<v Stu>And I think it's important.

01:30:27.140 --> 01:30:30.220
<v Stu>The nitty gritty here is important because I've actually sat there and slot

01:30:30.220 --> 01:30:33.740
<v Stu>motioned through it because people, I think a few people are saying,

01:30:34.040 --> 01:30:38.300
<v Stu>oh, it's like even the Wikipedia summary saying Mia jumps, right?

01:30:38.500 --> 01:30:42.320
<v Chas>Because there's two different, the film is positing to my mind,

01:30:42.540 --> 01:30:44.820
<v Chas>two different things that could have happened in that moment.

01:30:45.060 --> 01:30:45.280
<v Stu>Yeah.

01:30:45.460 --> 01:30:50.200
<v Chas>One is that Mia jumps and the other is that Jade pushes her.

01:30:50.360 --> 01:30:53.580
<v Chas>Is there any other potential scenarios that-

01:30:53.920 --> 01:30:56.140
<v Chas>could have resulted in mia being on the.

01:30:56.140 --> 01:30:59.420
<v Stu>I mean her sister not sister

01:30:59.420 --> 01:31:02.580
<v Stu>her mother somehow coming in and

01:31:02.580 --> 01:31:05.400
<v Stu>possessing her yes okay yeah

01:31:05.400 --> 01:31:08.260
<v Stu>right not not possessing her like pushing her and that's

01:31:08.260 --> 01:31:12.880
<v Stu>how we're going to dramatize it or fucking riley pushes her yeah okay but i

01:31:12.880 --> 01:31:17.160
<v Stu>think the most common things because i will say if you stop motion if you stop

01:31:17.160 --> 01:31:23.820
<v Stu>through it you actually see jade reaching Mia before Mia's in front of the vehicle,

01:31:24.480 --> 01:31:25.820
<v Stu>right? It's out of focus.

01:31:26.180 --> 01:31:29.300
<v Stu>I'm just saying like, it feels like that, I'm using that not to be like,

01:31:29.400 --> 01:31:32.940
<v Stu>here's the gotcha, but it feels like that may have been an intention of this

01:31:32.940 --> 01:31:37.740
<v Stu>film, that it was actually Jade pushing Mia in front of the car, right?

01:31:37.840 --> 01:31:41.900
<v Stu>And they've decided to not cut to anything that suggests that because they went,

01:31:42.000 --> 01:31:45.140
<v Stu>no, that's not what we want to make the film about.

01:31:45.440 --> 01:31:50.540
<v Stu>But the difficulty for me, right, is that otherwise what they're saying is Mia

01:31:50.540 --> 01:31:55.520
<v Stu>has chosen to die by suicide, then confront her problems.

01:31:55.680 --> 01:31:57.060
<v Chas>So is to save Riley.

01:31:57.240 --> 01:32:01.040
<v Stu>But no, Riley's not going anywhere if she doesn't push him.

01:32:01.180 --> 01:32:04.480
<v Chas>I think when I say to save Riley, to save Riley from herself.

01:32:04.740 --> 01:32:05.100
<v Stu>Yes.

01:32:05.340 --> 01:32:08.540
<v Chas>Or from the spirits that are possessing her.

01:32:08.780 --> 01:32:13.260
<v Stu>Yeah. And I guess the thing that annoys me about the film is I still think that

01:32:13.260 --> 01:32:18.520
<v Stu>it's a very problematic idea when dealing with mental health and teenagers to say,

01:32:18.680 --> 01:32:24.820
<v Stu>I have to kill Sacrifice myself to save people from the danger that I am putting them in.

01:32:26.120 --> 01:32:30.660
<v Stu>Very problematic idea. And I think, I don't know.

01:32:30.900 --> 01:32:34.760
<v Stu>I have to say this is all speculation, but I think if you saw a close-up of

01:32:34.760 --> 01:32:38.520
<v Stu>Mia going, I'm going to jump in front of a car, people would have been like,

01:32:38.580 --> 01:32:40.800
<v Stu>that's a fucking bad thing to put in a movie.

01:32:41.240 --> 01:32:45.920
<v Stu>Right? And that Jade pushing there is a more complex idea, but also confronting,

01:32:45.920 --> 01:32:51.320
<v Stu>which is I am going to kill you or hurt you in order to save my brother.

01:32:51.680 --> 01:32:51.800
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:32:51.980 --> 01:32:53.300
<v Stu>I, but we-

01:32:54.150 --> 01:33:00.510
<v Stu>don't know most people like as i said in wikipedia people say it's mia a few people say it's mia,

01:33:00.970 --> 01:33:04.930
<v Stu>and then i'm like don't you think that's a really bad idea to say that mia's

01:33:04.930 --> 01:33:12.210
<v Stu>solution to her depression and running away from her is to die by suicide and people like yeah so.

01:33:12.210 --> 01:33:15.650
<v Chas>That's so let's let's play this out right like this is why we were frustrated

01:33:15.650 --> 01:33:19.170
<v Chas>because we came out going what is this film about a film that initially starts

01:33:19.170 --> 01:33:23.290
<v Chas>out being kind of a a parable about the risk-taking of teenagers,

01:33:23.730 --> 01:33:29.250
<v Chas>then in the second half becomes very much about Mia being unable to come to

01:33:29.250 --> 01:33:31.790
<v Chas>terms with her mother's suicide.

01:33:32.090 --> 01:33:36.850
<v Chas>So are we saying that, you know, like you've said, Mia's inability,

01:33:37.110 --> 01:33:40.830
<v Chas>the only way Mia could come to terms with her mother's suicide is to kill herself.

01:33:41.010 --> 01:33:44.950
<v Chas>Is that what we're, is that what the film is saying thematically?

01:33:45.190 --> 01:33:48.170
<v Chas>And this is where we get to is because we are taken

01:33:48.170 --> 01:33:51.210
<v Chas>we don't have access to either jade's

01:33:51.210 --> 01:33:54.190
<v Chas>agency or mia's agency to your point we don't

01:33:54.190 --> 01:34:00.630
<v Chas>even know if it's mia let's say mia's body is hulls itself we don't even know

01:34:00.630 --> 01:34:05.270
<v Chas>is that mia making the decision or is it the spirits or the demons making the

01:34:05.270 --> 01:34:10.890
<v Chas>decision we are not given agency and so by that we're not given the choice we

01:34:10.890 --> 01:34:12.870
<v Chas>know what the options presented to her word,

01:34:12.970 --> 01:34:16.590
<v Chas>but we don't know what choice Mia may or may not have made.

01:34:16.850 --> 01:34:25.550
<v Chas>What would have been fascinating is if, to me, is if Mia let go of the wheelchair and managed to cast off,

01:34:26.040 --> 01:34:31.980
<v Chas>the possession, right? Manage to say no to the spirits and then Jade comes along

01:34:31.980 --> 01:34:34.700
<v Chas>and pushes her into the traffic, right?

01:34:34.820 --> 01:34:39.840
<v Chas>Like that would have been a depressing, terrifying, powerful.

01:34:40.520 --> 01:34:44.100
<v Chas>Cathartic thing, right? But we're not given to any access to that.

01:34:44.240 --> 01:34:46.260
<v Stu>We don't know what the moment is.

01:34:46.480 --> 01:34:46.620
<v Chas>Right?

01:34:46.820 --> 01:34:52.960
<v Stu>And I'm curious to why they've chosen, the filmmakers have chosen the ambiguity, right?

01:34:53.140 --> 01:34:56.120
<v Stu>They have chosen to play the moment from inside this

01:34:56.120 --> 01:34:59.520
<v Stu>car right knowing that they've hit someone and

01:34:59.520 --> 01:35:02.340
<v Stu>then it's played as a reveal right is it

01:35:02.340 --> 01:35:07.780
<v Stu>mia is it you know is it riley i guess maybe is it jade is the third thing right

01:35:07.780 --> 01:35:11.680
<v Stu>and then it's played as the shock but to me what is interesting about this moment

01:35:11.680 --> 01:35:16.380
<v Stu>is the as as we've explored is these choices and as you say it makes us get

01:35:16.380 --> 01:35:20.720
<v Stu>in the way and maybe we're over intellectualizing it well right you.

01:35:20.720 --> 01:35:23.780
<v Chas>Could say we're over intellectualizing it but emotionally we came out of that

01:35:23.780 --> 01:35:28.500
<v Chas>film going what was it about because, and we've managed to pinpoint that if

01:35:28.500 --> 01:35:33.300
<v Chas>we had seen that choice, we would have had a firmer grip of what the film was trying to tell us.

01:35:33.640 --> 01:35:37.860
<v Stu>Maybe the sequel that comes out very soon will tell us what happened in that

01:35:37.860 --> 01:35:42.880
<v Stu>moment and their idea was to make it more ambiguous because there are people

01:35:42.880 --> 01:35:46.540
<v Stu>that see it as her sacrificing her life to save Riley, right?

01:35:46.760 --> 01:35:51.220
<v Stu>But I think, then why not show us that?

01:35:51.500 --> 01:35:56.940
<v Chas>Yeah. like if it was about if it was self-sacrifice i mean the the one thing

01:35:56.940 --> 01:36:02.420
<v Chas>that i think leads a lot of people to that is as she's hearing the spirit version

01:36:02.420 --> 01:36:04.520
<v Chas>of her mother whispering in her ear,

01:36:05.200 --> 01:36:11.300
<v Chas>she said the mother says character says uh we will have him forever and i think

01:36:11.300 --> 01:36:17.320
<v Chas>that's supposed to be a moment of realization for mia that killing riley is

01:36:17.320 --> 01:36:24.420
<v Chas>not saving his soul from eternal torment it is condemning him to eternal torment.

01:36:24.680 --> 01:36:28.560
<v Chas>So it feels like it's given her that realization.

01:36:28.940 --> 01:36:32.460
<v Chas>I mean, what we're missing is the aftermath. We do come in the consequences

01:36:32.460 --> 01:36:38.000
<v Chas>of that decision and it's really awesome consequences, which is basically we see Mia going through-

01:36:39.370 --> 01:36:42.250
<v Chas>Experiencing the afterlife to the point where

01:36:42.250 --> 01:36:45.110
<v Chas>she sees a candle and sees the hand and goes and touches

01:36:45.110 --> 01:36:48.390
<v Chas>the hand and then suddenly some greek guy is

01:36:48.390 --> 01:36:51.510
<v Chas>saying talk to me right so it

01:36:51.510 --> 01:36:54.790
<v Chas>is awesome it's like the the actual end end

01:36:54.790 --> 01:36:58.030
<v Chas>sequence of the film i think is really cool it's just

01:36:58.030 --> 01:37:01.910
<v Chas>i don't have anything other than coolness to

01:37:01.910 --> 01:37:04.590
<v Chas>hold on to i don't have a theme to hold on to i

01:37:04.590 --> 01:37:07.690
<v Chas>don't know what was the film exploring or

01:37:07.690 --> 01:37:14.690
<v Chas>saying about either teenage risk-taking is it like drugs are bad okay or what

01:37:14.690 --> 01:37:20.010
<v Chas>is it saying about grief or youth suicide or any of the myriad of other things

01:37:20.010 --> 01:37:26.510
<v Chas>that it's raised it hasn't told us what its position as a piece of art is on those things.

01:37:26.510 --> 01:37:30.010
<v Stu>Well and and look daily who's one

01:37:30.010 --> 01:37:32.830
<v Stu>of the kind of had the idea was like this was for him was

01:37:32.830 --> 01:37:36.130
<v Stu>a metaphor about addiction and that even

01:37:36.130 --> 01:37:39.150
<v Stu>to me doesn't quite work and

01:37:39.150 --> 01:37:42.210
<v Stu>look this maybe because i'm old unfortunately there

01:37:42.210 --> 01:37:44.950
<v Stu>are a few people in my life like you know

01:37:44.950 --> 01:37:48.370
<v Stu>i've known people who have died by suicide i have

01:37:48.370 --> 01:37:51.450
<v Stu>known people who have died from the

01:37:51.450 --> 01:37:54.510
<v Stu>self-destruction of their addiction and i've

01:37:54.510 --> 01:37:58.110
<v Stu>known people who have overcome these addiction and all

01:37:58.110 --> 01:38:01.390
<v Stu>of that i look at this and go i don't and

01:38:01.390 --> 01:38:04.950
<v Stu>this may just be a personal reaction because i don't

01:38:04.950 --> 01:38:07.670
<v Stu>want maybe maybe i'm completely wrong about the

01:38:07.670 --> 01:38:11.670
<v Stu>filmmakers here but i this feels like they've chosen cool over

01:38:11.670 --> 01:38:16.610
<v Stu>wise yeah for lack of a better word and it's frustrating because there's so

01:38:16.610 --> 01:38:21.710
<v Stu>much of this film that is beautifully observed yeah it actually feels like teenagers

01:38:21.710 --> 01:38:25.390
<v Stu>hanging out with teenagers right like there is so much of this that actually

01:38:25.390 --> 01:38:30.970
<v Stu>feels really youthful and and emotionally intelligent i guess that's why it's so confronting,

01:38:31.530 --> 01:38:34.790
<v Stu>the film for like particularly the first half seems really emotionally intelligent

01:38:34.790 --> 01:38:38.830
<v Stu>and then that kind of unravels in this moment oh.

01:38:38.830 --> 01:38:45.170
<v Chas>I i feel like a lot of films do that like pick a genre and a lot of films the

01:38:45.170 --> 01:38:49.870
<v Chas>setup is really great and then the rollout the consequences might not be as

01:38:49.870 --> 01:38:52.690
<v Chas>powerful or as mind-blowing or as good.

01:38:52.690 --> 01:38:56.330
<v Stu>But to me this is not a like i guess what i'm just bumping on,

01:38:56.430 --> 01:38:59.430
<v Stu>and I know we've been talking about it, is why didn't they show us?

01:38:59.650 --> 01:39:05.570
<v Chas>Yeah. Yeah. And I think you possibly, like you said, they couldn't think of

01:39:05.570 --> 01:39:09.830
<v Chas>a way to show us that resonated with them or they may have felt that they could pull off.

01:39:09.890 --> 01:39:13.150
<v Chas>I mean, I'm purely speculating here because this is, to be clear,

01:39:13.550 --> 01:39:16.070
<v Chas>an incredible debut film by-

01:39:16.980 --> 01:39:22.980
<v Chas>Two very experienced filmmakers who hadn't made a narrative feature before.

01:39:24.040 --> 01:39:29.760
<v Chas>And we say that our feeling is they chose cool over clarity,

01:39:29.760 --> 01:39:35.260
<v Chas>I guess, or theme or potentially resonance.

01:39:35.480 --> 01:39:37.800
<v Chas>But they pulled off cool, right?

01:39:38.660 --> 01:39:42.260
<v Stu>Yeah. And look, other people might go, no, it's very obvious.

01:39:42.260 --> 01:39:47.260
<v Stu>These are the things that you are missing. and I would love to hear that evidence.

01:39:47.700 --> 01:39:50.440
<v Stu>And I'm saying evidence because I'm talking about in the combination of the

01:39:50.440 --> 01:39:53.300
<v Stu>text. When we talk about techniques, I'm looking at the tools that they're using.

01:39:53.460 --> 01:39:58.140
<v Stu>And what is interesting compared to the other films that we're getting at is

01:39:58.140 --> 01:40:07.620
<v Stu>that the decisions in Michael Clayton and Promising Young Woman were also made

01:40:07.620 --> 01:40:12.420
<v Stu>by characters off screen and we learned what their decisions were after the fact.

01:40:12.880 --> 01:40:18.720
<v Stu>But this is a decision that is played off screen. So it's not that it's off screen, right?

01:40:19.080 --> 01:40:23.800
<v Stu>It's that I've given no further information about what that decision was.

01:40:24.200 --> 01:40:27.140
<v Stu>We're meant to be filling in the blank. And as you.

01:40:27.140 --> 01:40:31.660
<v Chas>Say- We're presented with the options, not the choice, and then the consequences.

01:40:31.960 --> 01:40:35.220
<v Stu>And I actually have to say, I don't think it's me watching the shot in slow motion.

01:40:35.440 --> 01:40:39.560
<v Stu>Maybe it's just my editor's eye. I just look at it and go, Jade reached her

01:40:39.560 --> 01:40:41.200
<v Stu>before there's an impact on the car.

01:40:41.320 --> 01:40:44.200
<v Stu>Jade pushed her. And then everyone else was like, what do you mean Jade pushed

01:40:44.200 --> 01:40:46.980
<v Stu>her? I can't remember the exact moment. It was 2022, right?

01:40:47.960 --> 01:40:51.460
<v Stu>But they could have done visual effects or cut around that particular moment

01:40:51.460 --> 01:40:53.220
<v Stu>if they're worried about that misinterpretation.

01:40:53.400 --> 01:40:57.500
<v Stu>So, to me here, it is a question of what interpretation do they want us to have?

01:40:57.880 --> 01:41:00.200
<v Stu>Because that impacts, it's the ending of the film.

01:41:00.460 --> 01:41:00.740
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:41:01.620 --> 01:41:03.760
<v Stu>It's going to interpret my whole meaning.

01:41:03.760 --> 01:41:08.140
<v Chas>Because we don't have an anchor to hold on to as to what the character resolution

01:41:08.140 --> 01:41:12.100
<v Chas>was, was Mia self-sacrificing?

01:41:12.200 --> 01:41:14.180
<v Chas>Was she free of the spirits or not?

01:41:14.820 --> 01:41:18.580
<v Chas>Was she a victim just like Riley, right?

01:41:18.680 --> 01:41:24.860
<v Chas>Because we don't have answers to those questions, we are flailing around for

01:41:24.860 --> 01:41:27.580
<v Chas>what is the meaning of the film.

01:41:29.450 --> 01:41:33.150
<v Chas>That said, I was surprised that neither, on the contrary, neither Julio or Alex

01:41:33.150 --> 01:41:34.170
<v Chas>had even heard of the film.

01:41:34.290 --> 01:41:38.550
<v Chas>Like, it's so huge here in Australia. I just assumed it was huge everywhere.

01:41:38.610 --> 01:41:46.130
<v Stu>I mean, it took $50 million at the US box office. It was pretty freaking big, Julio.

01:41:46.350 --> 01:41:50.470
<v Chas>It's on Netflix here in Australia. I presume it's on Netflix fairly worldwide.

01:41:51.970 --> 01:41:56.450
<v Chas>So, what have you, what has been your key learnings from this exercise?

01:41:57.090 --> 01:42:01.050
<v Stu>Okay, I'm going to separate this into two things. There's the kind of confirmation

01:42:01.050 --> 01:42:03.470
<v Stu>and bias of like, we were right.

01:42:05.070 --> 01:42:09.950
<v Chas>We came into this with a very clear sort of thesis and understanding and lens

01:42:09.950 --> 01:42:12.750
<v Chas>that I don't think their homework dissuaded us from.

01:42:13.010 --> 01:42:19.510
<v Stu>Yeah, we haven't had any kind of car bombs that have changed our understanding

01:42:19.510 --> 01:42:20.910
<v Stu>of that thesis, right? Right.

01:42:20.990 --> 01:42:25.890
<v Stu>If anything, it's just like, it is really interesting on a, like,

01:42:26.010 --> 01:42:29.590
<v Stu>we haven't deep dive in the emotional experience of it.

01:42:30.090 --> 01:42:34.390
<v Stu>Other than, I guess the talk to me thing is like choices, decision,

01:42:34.590 --> 01:42:38.610
<v Stu>consequence, the audience understanding all three has the emotional impact for us.

01:42:38.710 --> 01:42:43.010
<v Stu>That's what's important to us. And missing one of those things possibly will

01:42:43.010 --> 01:42:45.110
<v Stu>affect the impact of the ending.

01:42:47.590 --> 01:42:56.210
<v Stu>I guess maybe because our work tends to be more thematic that the more distancing

01:42:56.210 --> 01:43:04.510
<v Stu>of Michael Clayton and Promising Young Woman where the audience catches up to

01:43:04.510 --> 01:43:07.470
<v Stu>the character is kind of an interesting thing to explore.

01:43:08.030 --> 01:43:11.510
<v Stu>I don't think we can retroactively apply it to anything,

01:43:12.250 --> 01:43:15.030
<v Stu>we've worked on but maybe on something we're future

01:43:15.030 --> 01:43:17.830
<v Stu>developed that we can kind of look at and go if you want an ending that's kind

01:43:17.830 --> 01:43:24.990
<v Stu>of more uh intellectual intellectual is the wrong word more thinky than feely

01:43:24.990 --> 01:43:28.650
<v Stu>uh then then playing around with his point of view stuff maybe the way to do

01:43:28.650 --> 01:43:33.050
<v Stu>that versus like the finding the immediacy and that's what it really is the

01:43:33.050 --> 01:43:36.230
<v Stu>emotional immediacy of like Dungeons and Dragons and and Finding Nemo.

01:43:36.230 --> 01:43:36.990
<v Chas>I'm.

01:43:36.990 --> 01:43:41.290
<v Stu>Going to palm it to you to see if there's any kind of like unforeseen little insights.

01:43:41.290 --> 01:43:44.810
<v Chas>I think it really did reaffirm

01:43:44.810 --> 01:43:47.910
<v Chas>the power of of that interaction

01:43:47.910 --> 01:43:50.650
<v Chas>with narrative pov like think about when are

01:43:50.650 --> 01:43:53.390
<v Chas>the options presented to the character when does the character make

01:43:53.390 --> 01:43:57.470
<v Chas>the choice and when are the consequences of that and deciding what

01:43:57.470 --> 01:44:00.530
<v Chas>you're going to choose to reveal to the audience

01:44:00.530 --> 01:44:03.390
<v Chas>when uh we've seen

01:44:03.390 --> 01:44:06.490
<v Chas>the power of that um i think

01:44:06.490 --> 01:44:09.910
<v Chas>in all three of these examples like there there

01:44:09.910 --> 01:44:12.810
<v Chas>is power in that in the ending of of talk

01:44:12.810 --> 01:44:15.890
<v Chas>to me you know we are talking about it still we did come

01:44:15.890 --> 01:44:19.610
<v Chas>out of the the cinema thinking about it but

01:44:19.610 --> 01:44:22.490
<v Chas>the setup is what

01:44:22.490 --> 01:44:25.490
<v Chas>i've noticed in doing this exercise like those final

01:44:25.490 --> 01:44:28.570
<v Chas>choices are such clear so easy

01:44:28.570 --> 01:44:31.770
<v Chas>to dramatize as a to to describe as

01:44:31.770 --> 01:44:34.870
<v Chas>a binary for those character arcs and

01:44:34.870 --> 01:44:37.890
<v Chas>part of that is about all the groundwork that have been done before

01:44:37.890 --> 01:44:41.270
<v Chas>like it's no accident that there were

01:44:41.270 --> 01:44:44.250
<v Chas>in dungeons and dragons that it was the exact same

01:44:44.250 --> 01:44:46.990
<v Chas>red blade that killed his

01:44:46.990 --> 01:44:50.010
<v Chas>wife and killed holger that we've got

01:44:50.010 --> 01:44:54.570
<v Chas>the talisman of the blue dragonfly coming back like they do they're putting

01:44:54.570 --> 01:45:01.670
<v Chas>in so much work earlier in the film so that when we're in that decision it gains

01:45:01.670 --> 01:45:08.190
<v Chas>more power like michael We saw the Snowpiercer moment at the low point and we're.

01:45:08.810 --> 01:45:16.990
<v Chas>Misled into thinking that that decision had been resolved by the by the filmmakers yeah i i think.

01:45:17.730 --> 01:45:23.210
<v Chas>Oh fuck if if every learning i'm just like oh it's actually the the stuff they

01:45:23.210 --> 01:45:27.110
<v Chas>pulled off is earlier in the film but that that seems to be my learning with

01:45:27.110 --> 01:45:31.670
<v Chas>almost every craft tool is uh is the the power of setup and.

01:45:31.670 --> 01:45:35.570
<v Stu>Look maybe that's why people are thinking that mia sacrificed herself.

01:45:35.570 --> 01:45:36.150
<v Chas>Because.

01:45:36.710 --> 01:45:40.470
<v Stu>You know, we've seen her kill her dad because she listened to the spirit and

01:45:40.470 --> 01:45:43.130
<v Stu>she's realizing that the spirit has lied to her.

01:45:43.270 --> 01:45:49.530
<v Stu>I just, you know, I just would have liked to see that moment with the character

01:45:49.530 --> 01:45:51.290
<v Stu>having her moment of agnoresis.

01:45:51.670 --> 01:45:58.650
<v Chas>Yeah. Of her saying no to her mother. And I think the film is fairly clear that

01:45:58.650 --> 01:46:03.350
<v Chas>it's not her mother, that it is some trickster ghost or demon.

01:46:03.570 --> 01:46:03.690
<v Stu>Yeah.

01:46:03.690 --> 01:46:07.990
<v Chas>And why did we not get the moment where Mia can actually see that?

01:46:08.330 --> 01:46:15.470
<v Chas>Yeah. I don't know. And that Mia realizes that the cost of her grief is potentially Riley and Jade.

01:46:16.130 --> 01:46:20.090
<v Chas>Like that dynamic, one of the things that Contrarians observed is in the second

01:46:20.090 --> 01:46:26.890
<v Chas>half of the movie, Jade really gets lost as a character and they were a bit sad that that happened.

01:46:26.890 --> 01:46:31.850
<v Chas>I mean, we literally don't spend any time with her in the second half,

01:46:31.890 --> 01:46:35.650
<v Chas>whereas in the first half of the movie that relationship between Mia

01:46:35.650 --> 01:46:38.770
<v Chas>and Jade is almost as sisters yeah so yeah

01:46:38.770 --> 01:46:42.590
<v Chas>those are those are my my main learnings I

01:46:42.590 --> 01:46:47.970
<v Chas>mean taking this into the context of a piece of work that I did so I've just

01:46:47.970 --> 01:46:53.110
<v Chas>recently written a beat outline that I brought to our writers group and the

01:46:53.110 --> 01:46:57.830
<v Chas>main piece of feedback is I've set up all these juicy confrontations and then

01:46:57.830 --> 01:47:02.510
<v Chas>I'm not actually having them play out in the, in the climax of the movie.

01:47:02.630 --> 01:47:06.110
<v Chas>It's like, why haven't they had an argument about this that you've set up before?

01:47:06.250 --> 01:47:10.850
<v Chas>Why aren't they then these other two characters arguing about that? That is the key thing.

01:47:11.090 --> 01:47:13.010
<v Chas>You know, you're telling us that this is what your film is about,

01:47:13.070 --> 01:47:16.730
<v Chas>but you're not showing those scenes that are so easily there.

01:47:16.890 --> 01:47:20.970
<v Chas>And I don't know what my instinct was in, in the structuring of the film that

01:47:20.970 --> 01:47:22.130
<v Chas>I was avoiding that stuff.

01:47:22.250 --> 01:47:27.670
<v Chas>I mean, And maybe it was, yeah, avoiding digging into the emotions of it or

01:47:27.670 --> 01:47:29.070
<v Chas>trying to play it more grounded.

01:47:29.650 --> 01:47:31.790
<v Stu>Look, sometimes you're also dealing with characters-

01:47:32.650 --> 01:47:36.990
<v Stu>I mean, obviously, I've read that. This is something for people that are like,

01:47:37.290 --> 01:47:41.370
<v Stu>Chaz is talking about this project in the abstract, and now what the fuck?

01:47:41.570 --> 01:47:45.310
<v Stu>But I think you're also talking about characters who are conflict avoidant.

01:47:45.450 --> 01:47:51.390
<v Stu>They're so diplomatic. They're so politically astute that they don't do direct conflict.

01:47:51.630 --> 01:47:51.750
<v Chas>Yeah.

01:47:52.350 --> 01:47:57.350
<v Stu>And so then you have to find, create circumstances in which direct conflict

01:47:57.350 --> 01:48:00.490
<v Stu>is the only tactic that they have.

01:48:00.610 --> 01:48:02.190
<v Chas>Or they run out of tactics, but yeah.

01:48:02.190 --> 01:48:05.930
<v Stu>Or that they run out of, I mean, direct conflict, I mean, retreat is always,

01:48:06.110 --> 01:48:10.110
<v Stu>so you have to just, as you say, run out, but you kind of have to, there is no retreat.

01:48:10.450 --> 01:48:14.110
<v Stu>There is no this. The only way to get what you want is direct confrontation. Yeah.

01:48:14.230 --> 01:48:19.150
<v Chas>And I know I'm talking in the abstract, but applying it to this is what I'm

01:48:19.150 --> 01:48:25.330
<v Chas>realizing is those two powerful scenes that I've avoided bringing out are decisive

01:48:25.330 --> 01:48:27.010
<v Chas>acts in the climax. Yeah.

01:48:27.010 --> 01:48:30.510
<v Stu>I mean, and we've talked about it before, but I think plotting what your final

01:48:30.510 --> 01:48:35.270
<v Stu>decision is at the outline stage or knowing what that kind of is, is really useful.

01:48:35.470 --> 01:48:38.530
<v Stu>I mean, we're going to talk about in character arcs, but I wouldn't be surprised

01:48:38.530 --> 01:48:45.330
<v Stu>if George Lucas kind of knew that Luke, particularly Luke, was going to trust

01:48:45.330 --> 01:48:46.650
<v Stu>the Force from blowing up the Death Star.

01:48:46.790 --> 01:48:51.250
<v Stu>Maybe we can find that very versed version of Star Wars where it's like the

01:48:51.250 --> 01:48:54.550
<v Stu>Bogan side of the Force or whatever the fuck it was, all the crazy stuff with

01:48:54.550 --> 01:48:56.050
<v Stu>Starkiller and all that.

01:48:56.050 --> 01:49:00.470
<v Stu>And I reckon there's a version of that because it's such a clear crystallization

01:49:00.470 --> 01:49:02.890
<v Stu>of what that character's journey is meant to be.

01:49:03.070 --> 01:49:07.190
<v Stu>And that's why it's going to connect character arcs because articulating your

01:49:07.190 --> 01:49:12.250
<v Stu>character decisions, how they change the context of a story or don't is going

01:49:12.250 --> 01:49:14.850
<v Stu>to be how you're going to build a sense of journey.

01:49:15.490 --> 01:49:18.650
<v Chas>Cool. Thank you, Stu, for making this.

01:49:19.180 --> 01:49:22.280
<v Chas>Episode happen and uh

01:49:22.280 --> 01:49:25.320
<v Chas>sue was actually suggesting like

01:49:25.320 --> 01:49:28.280
<v Chas>i've got this tagline that i trot out if you want more draft

01:49:28.280 --> 01:49:31.600
<v Chas>zero more often uh you too can become uh amazing

01:49:31.600 --> 01:49:34.280
<v Chas>patreons uh and she was like maybe that's a

01:49:34.280 --> 01:49:37.200
<v Chas>disincentive people might not be signing up to the patreon because

01:49:37.200 --> 01:49:43.460
<v Chas>they don't want more draft zero more often but what our patreons do get is personalized

01:49:43.460 --> 01:49:51.500
<v Chas>channel to to talk to us and one of the things that I feel our patrons seem

01:49:51.500 --> 01:49:55.180
<v Chas>to get most out of it is their ability to choose our homework.

01:49:55.500 --> 01:49:58.760
<v Chas>So what we often do when we're brainstorming ideas is we go,

01:49:58.960 --> 01:50:03.700
<v Chas>we've got this lens and this one example and then we're trying to think of what

01:50:03.700 --> 01:50:08.240
<v Chas>the other two examples should be and we end up with lists of like 20 or 30 amazing

01:50:08.240 --> 01:50:10.720
<v Chas>films that our patrons vote from.

01:50:10.900 --> 01:50:15.360
<v Stu>And then much like the Australian election, you'll have a bunch of voting that you will ignore.

01:50:17.620 --> 01:50:24.400
<v Chas>Preferential system, baby. But jokes aside, particular thanks to our top tier

01:50:24.400 --> 01:50:30.540
<v Chas>patrons, Alexandra, Jen, Jesse, Krob, Lily, Malay, Paolo, Randy,

01:50:31.240 --> 01:50:34.120
<v Chas>Sandra, Thies, and Thomas.

01:50:34.560 --> 01:50:39.800
<v Chas>It's nice that that list is getting so long to say, but really means a lot to us. Thank you.

01:50:39.960 --> 01:50:44.200
<v Stu>Thank you. Stay tuned. We got episodes coming up on subtext being overrated,

01:50:44.680 --> 01:50:47.180
<v Stu>character arcs, but we're going to do an arc,

01:50:47.710 --> 01:50:54.330
<v Stu>Per episode, or an episode per arc, we're looking at hopefully doing something on monologues.

01:50:54.550 --> 01:50:56.070
<v Chas>A one-shot on Sinners?

01:50:56.190 --> 01:50:59.890
<v Stu>Oh, no, I don't want it to be a one-shot. I want it to be other horror films.

01:51:00.070 --> 01:51:05.230
<v Stu>It's just an excuse for me to claim buying the RPG Mothership Against Tax,

01:51:05.690 --> 01:51:10.090
<v Stu>because the RPG of Mothership has a thing they call the tomb system,

01:51:10.310 --> 01:51:14.830
<v Stu>which is transgression, omens, manifestations, banishment, slumber,

01:51:14.870 --> 01:51:16.330
<v Stu>as a way of structuring horror.

01:51:16.330 --> 01:51:20.170
<v Stu>And I'm like, that's just a five-act hero film. What the fuck?

01:51:20.510 --> 01:51:22.590
<v Stu>And, you know, also Sinners.

01:51:22.930 --> 01:51:26.550
<v Chas>Also, we can debate the, you know, speaking of final choices,

01:51:26.730 --> 01:51:31.910
<v Chas>debate the wonders of that final, that post-credit scene in Sinners.

01:51:32.010 --> 01:51:37.190
<v Stu>It's slumber. That's why it needed to be there. It's the S in tombs.

01:51:37.710 --> 01:51:40.170
<v Stu>It's not tomb. It's tombs.

01:51:42.630 --> 01:51:46.150
<v Chas>And thank you, dear listeners. Any feedback? Always welcome.

01:51:46.330 --> 01:51:48.990
<v Stu>Tell us why we're wrong and talk to me. Talk to us.

01:51:49.130 --> 01:51:52.970
<v Chas>Go and watch Talk To Me if you haven't. We're just assuming that you've watched

01:51:52.970 --> 01:51:54.570
<v Chas>Michael Clayton and Promising Young Woman.

01:51:56.650 --> 01:52:00.490
<v Excerpts>I hope you all feel like arguing with either Stu or myself about anything on

01:52:00.490 --> 01:52:02.110
<v Excerpts>this episode or anything in general.

01:52:02.290 --> 01:52:08.910
<v Excerpts>And you can find many ways of getting in touch with us at our website at draft-zero.com.

01:52:09.170 --> 01:52:13.270
<v Excerpts>At the website, you'll also find the show notes for this and all our other episodes,

01:52:13.270 --> 01:52:18.770
<v Excerpts>as well as links to support us and spread the word for free via a rating and

01:52:18.770 --> 01:52:21.810
<v Excerpts>review on Apple Podcasts. Very important for spreading the word.

01:52:22.030 --> 01:52:26.890
<v Excerpts>Or if you think that what we do here is worth a dollar or preferably more than

01:52:26.890 --> 01:52:32.610
<v Excerpts>a dollar, then you can also find links to our Patreon page to support us getting

01:52:32.610 --> 01:52:34.470
<v Excerpts>these episodes to you quicker.

01:52:35.030 --> 01:52:37.710
<v Excerpts>Thanks. And thanks for listening.