WEBVTT

NOTE
This file was generated by Descript 

00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:04.233
Marianne Macdonald: I remember one chair
saying to me that he had asked somebody

00:00:04.473 --> 00:00:08.883
why they wanted to join his board, and
they didn't have an immediate answer

00:00:08.913 --> 00:00:12.583
and he thought, "Well, we might as
well stop the interview right there."

00:00:13.921 --> 00:00:17.181
Ralph Grayson: Welcome to The Boardroom
Path by Sainty Hird & Partners.

00:00:17.526 --> 00:00:21.416
I'm your host, Ralph Grayson, a
partner in the board practice.

00:00:21.784 --> 00:00:26.344
In this series, we'll offer practical
steps and useful perspectives for

00:00:26.344 --> 00:00:28.684
aspiring and newly appointed NEDs.

00:00:28.910 --> 00:00:32.360
My guest today is someone who has
built one of the most influential

00:00:32.360 --> 00:00:35.390
and best connected communities
in the boardroom landscape.

00:00:35.935 --> 00:00:40.375
Marianne Macdonald is the founder of
the 350 Club, an exclusive community

00:00:40.375 --> 00:00:45.325
bringing together chairs, non-executive
directors, and executive leaders from

00:00:45.325 --> 00:00:47.215
many of the world's largest companies.

00:00:47.995 --> 00:00:52.075
Alongside it, she has created Boardhouse
for the next generation of board

00:00:52.075 --> 00:00:56.065
leaders and the board directory,
a platform connecting senior board

00:00:56.065 --> 00:00:58.405
talent with the board search market.

00:00:59.205 --> 00:01:03.405
Through Non Executive Directors
Consulting, she's also advised hundreds

00:01:03.405 --> 00:01:09.045
of senior executives, CEOs, and partners
as they develop their portfolio careers.

00:01:09.502 --> 00:01:13.462
What makes Marianne's perspective so
valuable is her view of the market

00:01:13.792 --> 00:01:15.412
that produces our board leaders.

00:01:15.952 --> 00:01:21.562
She understands how reputation, judgement,
relationships, and capability, all

00:01:21.592 --> 00:01:25.732
combine to shape who is ultimately
chosen to sit around the board table

00:01:26.332 --> 00:01:30.532
and has studied the development of
portfolio careers for over two decades.

00:01:30.952 --> 00:01:34.912
So today, we're going to explore
the hidden board market, how great

00:01:34.912 --> 00:01:39.052
board careers are really built,
what search firms and chairs are

00:01:39.052 --> 00:01:43.552
looking for today, how candidates
can influence their outcome, and what

00:01:43.552 --> 00:01:45.682
good board directors really look like.

00:01:46.162 --> 00:01:48.112
So Marianne, welcome
to The Boardroom Path.

00:01:48.134 --> 00:01:49.008
Marianne Macdonald:
Thank you for having me.

00:01:49.612 --> 00:01:52.822
Ralph Grayson: Perhaps you could
just start and set the scene and

00:01:52.822 --> 00:01:58.402
the context here on how your own
career has developed into this space.

00:01:58.712 --> 00:02:02.952
The evolution of your career from
the search firm Zygos, other search

00:02:02.952 --> 00:02:07.962
firms are available, and then into
Non Executive Directors consulting.

00:02:08.472 --> 00:02:09.012
Marianne Macdonald: Sure.

00:02:09.142 --> 00:02:13.792
I read English at Oxford and
that took me into a 20-year

00:02:14.422 --> 00:02:15.892
broadsheet journalist career.

00:02:16.412 --> 00:02:21.137
Then broadsheet journalism became
really impossible to continue

00:02:22.115 --> 00:02:23.825
with the advent of the internet.

00:02:23.825 --> 00:02:29.177
So then I had a big career change,
my first big one, and moved into

00:02:29.177 --> 00:02:33.717
non-executive headhunting with somewhere
called the Zygos Partnership, which

00:02:33.767 --> 00:02:38.147
had a very prominent reputation in
the non-executive space at the time.

00:02:38.147 --> 00:02:44.327
It's now become the core of the Russell
Reynolds UK board practice through M&A and

00:02:44.387 --> 00:02:51.727
I spent seven years there before going on
to found various things, a career advisory

00:02:51.727 --> 00:02:56.947
really focused on senior leaders creating
non-executive careers, and then my board

00:02:56.947 --> 00:02:59.347
community and one or two other things.

00:02:59.817 --> 00:03:03.747
Ralph Grayson: So let's maybe
just get into all of these highly

00:03:03.747 --> 00:03:07.557
accomplished people with significant
influence you've met over the years.

00:03:08.157 --> 00:03:14.126
What have those encounters really taught
you about the attraction of people

00:03:14.126 --> 00:03:16.036
into a board and a portfolio career?

00:03:16.836 --> 00:03:20.053
Marianne Macdonald: Well, very
accomplished people have done a lot.

00:03:20.623 --> 00:03:24.563
They are often very
curious, often quite global.

00:03:25.223 --> 00:03:30.993
They really don't want their career
to end at 55 or 60, which is often

00:03:30.993 --> 00:03:36.563
built in kind of obsolescence almost
from an executive point of view.

00:03:37.026 --> 00:03:40.096
Or they get a bit tired of being
an executive at a higher level,

00:03:40.096 --> 00:03:42.646
actually, for a whole range of reasons.

00:03:42.886 --> 00:03:46.486
And, then, of course, if you're a big
four partner or so on, you have to leave

00:03:46.996 --> 00:03:51.228
at 55 to 60 in that phase of your career.

00:03:51.618 --> 00:03:56.658
And so what they want to do is
carry on working in some form, being

00:03:56.658 --> 00:04:02.198
active, contributing, and what they
want to continue having is access

00:04:02.198 --> 00:04:05.528
to really interesting companies
and really accomplished people.

00:04:05.961 --> 00:04:10.911
So the non-executive career is a
perfect way to solve all of that.

00:04:11.361 --> 00:04:14.991
Obviously, some people want to stop
altogether, but I think a great many

00:04:14.991 --> 00:04:19.941
people do like the idea of a plural
career with different parts to it,

00:04:19.941 --> 00:04:24.861
as advisory, the actual sort of more
formal non-executive work, investment

00:04:24.861 --> 00:04:27.441
can play a part, mentoring and so on.

00:04:27.841 --> 00:04:31.262
So for them, I think it is
a very powerful attraction.

00:04:31.262 --> 00:04:33.902
It's something they're often
very, very keen to do and it's

00:04:34.022 --> 00:04:35.642
actually not very easy to do.

00:04:35.702 --> 00:04:37.322
So there's a bit of a tension there.

00:04:38.122 --> 00:04:41.490
Ralph Grayson: So we're going to pick
apart a lot of those different aspects

00:04:41.490 --> 00:04:45.750
but let's maybe just start with the
three different, I think it is verticals.

00:04:45.750 --> 00:04:50.430
You've got the 350 Club,
Boardhouse, and the Board Directory.

00:04:50.430 --> 00:04:53.370
So what's distinctive and
distinct about each of those?

00:04:53.420 --> 00:04:57.380
And how are they valuable to
aspiring and established NEDs as

00:04:57.380 --> 00:04:58.642
they build their portfolio careers?

00:04:59.250 --> 00:05:03.630
Marianne Macdonald: Those three all
came from the same root, actually, which

00:05:03.630 --> 00:05:10.021
was the non-executive career advisory
business I set up after I left Zygos,

00:05:10.026 --> 00:05:15.491
10 years ago, there was no place in the
market for very senior leaders to get

00:05:15.911 --> 00:05:21.731
really hands-on, knowledgeable advice
that was completely focused on creating

00:05:21.731 --> 00:05:23.561
a non-executive career at a high level.

00:05:24.018 --> 00:05:28.728
So I set up my advisory firm in
non-executive directorships consulting

00:05:29.068 --> 00:05:35.176
partly because the URL was easily
available and I just started working with

00:05:35.176 --> 00:05:39.586
people who I'd typically met as a head
hunter, actually, and then increasingly

00:05:39.586 --> 00:05:40.846
through word of mouth, others.

00:05:40.876 --> 00:05:46.186
We've now worked with about 350
senior leaders across all sectors

00:05:46.186 --> 00:05:48.706
and sort of roles and functions.

00:05:49.126 --> 00:05:53.766
That is really just a three-month
intervention where we press every possible

00:05:53.766 --> 00:05:58.816
lever to increase their chances of
success and accelerate their trajectory.

00:05:59.266 --> 00:06:05.110
And I was five years into that when COVID
happened and that led me as a project

00:06:05.110 --> 00:06:07.420
initially, actually, to start my 350 Club.

00:06:08.020 --> 00:06:13.270
That is a community for the most
senior board members and leaders.

00:06:13.660 --> 00:06:17.500
It was called the 350 Club, because it was
originally intended for people who were in

00:06:17.500 --> 00:06:20.910
the top 350 listed businesses in the UK.

00:06:21.260 --> 00:06:23.510
Six years on, it's
grown very considerably.

00:06:23.510 --> 00:06:25.340
It has about 1,200 members.

00:06:25.790 --> 00:06:28.290
It is really quite international now.

00:06:28.290 --> 00:06:32.940
We have quite a number of members
from other major indices and it's for

00:06:32.970 --> 00:06:40.170
those who sit on FTSE 100 or FTSE 250
or equivalent boards or FTSE 100 or

00:06:40.170 --> 00:06:42.720
equivalent ex-executive committees.

00:06:43.210 --> 00:06:45.490
We have quite a lot of people
from private businesses and

00:06:45.520 --> 00:06:47.530
private equity businesses as well.

00:06:48.115 --> 00:06:50.905
The point of that is really to
bring people together so that

00:06:50.905 --> 00:06:54.985
they can connect much more easily,
share learnings across sector.

00:06:55.502 --> 00:06:59.432
Because often this group of people
are trying to solve the same problems,

00:06:59.432 --> 00:07:03.902
but they don't have any kind of
inherent ways to connect and share

00:07:03.902 --> 00:07:08.638
information other than on a rather ad
hoc basis if they happen to meet each

00:07:08.638 --> 00:07:12.515
other at an event or something and
they're often very siloed by sector.

00:07:12.515 --> 00:07:15.065
So I was wanting to solve
all of those things.

00:07:15.605 --> 00:07:20.555
Now at this point in its evolution, it's
really focused on the connection part.

00:07:20.675 --> 00:07:21.935
You can message any member.

00:07:21.935 --> 00:07:27.103
It's full transparency over who's on
the club and right through to FTSE

00:07:27.103 --> 00:07:32.250
five chairs through to those who are
earlier in their non-executive careers,

00:07:32.250 --> 00:07:39.067
and indeed those who sit on FTSE 100
executive committees as a CFO for example.

00:07:39.497 --> 00:07:41.964
The other part of it is
career advancement, actually.

00:07:41.964 --> 00:07:45.564
So there's a piece around mentoring
that we can put our more senior members

00:07:45.564 --> 00:07:47.574
together with our more executive members.

00:07:47.904 --> 00:07:52.734
We get access to the best commercial
non-executive vacancies and there's

00:07:52.734 --> 00:07:54.084
a whole piece around learning.

00:07:55.054 --> 00:07:58.564
Some of our most accomplished
members in their fields will do

00:07:58.564 --> 00:08:00.394
events for our other members.

00:08:00.394 --> 00:08:05.064
We've got one coming up on Quantum,
which is proving of enormous interest,

00:08:05.064 --> 00:08:09.124
for example, and then we also work with
some of the best blue chip advisory

00:08:09.124 --> 00:08:15.794
firms such as Egon Zehnder or Latham
and Watkins, Capgemini, who themselves

00:08:16.314 --> 00:08:22.084
host events and contribute content and
knowledge from the market, as it were.

00:08:22.601 --> 00:08:23.557
Ralph Grayson: So that's 350.

00:08:23.737 --> 00:08:24.697
Marianne Macdonald: That's 350.

00:08:24.697 --> 00:08:26.977
So then and I'll be quicker now.

00:08:27.007 --> 00:08:32.797
Boardhouse is a subgroup of 350 or
sub-club, I should say, and that

00:08:32.797 --> 00:08:34.297
is actually for next-gen leaders.

00:08:34.357 --> 00:08:37.967
So it's a really interesting,
again, unique community for

00:08:37.967 --> 00:08:43.397
those who are on a FTSE 100 ExCo
minus one is how I think of them.

00:08:43.397 --> 00:08:46.937
So they report to a FTSE 100 ExCo member.

00:08:47.337 --> 00:08:50.187
So often run very large
businesses in their own right.

00:08:50.547 --> 00:08:54.507
Or people who sit on a FTSE
250 ExCo, but not on the board.

00:08:54.867 --> 00:08:59.947
And again, we have very many
members with the same club taxonomy.

00:08:59.947 --> 00:09:01.207
They can see who else they are.

00:09:01.207 --> 00:09:02.407
They can message each other.

00:09:02.407 --> 00:09:03.397
They can share learnings.

00:09:03.397 --> 00:09:04.537
They can attend events.

00:09:05.007 --> 00:09:09.117
And they can get some mentoring
from the main club members as well.

00:09:09.375 --> 00:09:13.225
Both of these are sort of online
communities with a physical component.

00:09:13.715 --> 00:09:15.253
The Board Directory is a bit different.

00:09:15.253 --> 00:09:16.723
So the Board Directory is newer.

00:09:16.723 --> 00:09:23.296
It's six, seven months old now, and
it arose from my experience of both

00:09:23.296 --> 00:09:28.636
running the club and continuing to
work with clients in my advisory

00:09:28.636 --> 00:09:34.696
business, Non Executive Directorships,
and that is really trying to be

00:09:34.796 --> 00:09:38.306
another thing that fills a gap in
the board space, because it seems to

00:09:38.306 --> 00:09:39.836
me at this level, it's full of gaps.

00:09:40.316 --> 00:09:46.006
This is a directory where you can have
a profile which you control and create

00:09:46.306 --> 00:09:51.986
and that profile will be seen by all
of the board headhunters en masse.

00:09:52.456 --> 00:09:55.576
So the Board Directory, in a
way, is the inverse of the club.

00:09:55.576 --> 00:10:01.646
It's nothing more than a closed database
that currently around 80 of the best board

00:10:01.646 --> 00:10:04.706
headhunters search for candidate ideas.

00:10:05.216 --> 00:10:07.196
So that's different in itself.

00:10:07.196 --> 00:10:09.716
That doesn't exist or didn't exist before.

00:10:10.136 --> 00:10:13.226
It's very inexpensive to have
a profile in the directory.

00:10:13.466 --> 00:10:17.214
You have to be of a certain
seniority to have a profile.

00:10:17.214 --> 00:10:18.747
So there is a curated element.

00:10:18.807 --> 00:10:21.627
You can be a professional services
partner or a leader in effect.

00:10:22.107 --> 00:10:25.947
And the other part of it is that
the filters are comprehensive and

00:10:25.947 --> 00:10:28.342
state-of-the-art and somewhat AI-driven.

00:10:28.702 --> 00:10:32.572
So you can be found right
across all of your skill sets.

00:10:32.872 --> 00:10:37.102
So this, the three, four things all come
together in different ways to help people

00:10:37.102 --> 00:10:40.772
create and advance non-executive careers.

00:10:41.572 --> 00:10:42.257
Ralph Grayson: All makes sense.

00:10:42.277 --> 00:10:48.085
So just so I'm clear, you have
to apply to join each separately?

00:10:48.155 --> 00:10:51.365
Costs involved, how does the process work?

00:10:51.755 --> 00:10:54.019
Marianne Macdonald: So it's
all quite visible online.

00:10:54.019 --> 00:10:55.789
You can Google the 350 Club.

00:10:56.299 --> 00:10:58.039
You can Google the Board Directory.

00:10:58.039 --> 00:10:58.879
They'll come up.

00:10:59.159 --> 00:11:02.909
And there's a way to apply
on the landing page of them.

00:11:03.359 --> 00:11:05.989
And you just fill in the small form.

00:11:06.449 --> 00:11:11.399
For the 350 Club, it is obviously
quite an exclusive community.

00:11:11.399 --> 00:11:14.833
But if you qualify, you can
have a place at no charge.

00:11:15.393 --> 00:11:16.893
The Board Directory's
a little bit different.

00:11:16.893 --> 00:11:20.763
That's a subscription service, but
we've kept the price point really low.

00:11:21.133 --> 00:11:26.593
If you sit on a FTSE 100 or 250 board,
then there's no charge to be on that

00:11:26.593 --> 00:11:30.823
directory and actually, we have many
very senior chairs and non-execs who are.

00:11:31.253 --> 00:11:35.924
If you don't, but you are senior,
maybe you're part of a major

00:11:35.924 --> 00:11:40.044
professional services firm, maybe you
chair a Remco of an Oxford College

00:11:40.044 --> 00:11:44.214
or maybe you sit on the board of an
AIM company or something like that.

00:11:44.434 --> 00:11:48.454
Then you can join for £250 a
year or a little bit more if

00:11:48.454 --> 00:11:49.894
you want a fuller profile.

00:11:50.244 --> 00:11:51.724
Ralph Grayson: One of the
things I'm fascinated by.

00:11:51.814 --> 00:11:56.114
Some of the more far-sighted Heads of
Talent and Head of HR are looking at

00:11:56.114 --> 00:12:01.484
their executive teams, and particularly
to develop some of the younger cohort

00:12:01.484 --> 00:12:07.014
and faster track cohort, and are
seeing the benefits of their executive

00:12:07.014 --> 00:12:10.494
team members being on external
boards, and that's part of their

00:12:10.494 --> 00:12:12.054
personal growth, personal development.

00:12:12.394 --> 00:12:15.004
An HR person who's listening to
this or talent person who listens to

00:12:15.004 --> 00:12:18.904
this should also be thinking about
potentially connecting with you in terms

00:12:18.904 --> 00:12:23.764
of how they can develop their existing
teams by taking external board roles.

00:12:23.926 --> 00:12:25.684
First of all, I mean, what do
you think about that premise?

00:12:26.454 --> 00:12:28.352
And secondly, how do people go about it?

00:12:28.686 --> 00:12:31.116
Marianne Macdonald: Yeah, so
I wholly endorse that premise.

00:12:31.196 --> 00:12:37.966
I think the development is really clearly
apparent when someone takes an external

00:12:37.966 --> 00:12:41.886
board role, very often, you're looking
at executives, and this won't surprise

00:12:41.886 --> 00:12:47.959
any HR director, obviously, who have
spent their career entirely or at least

00:12:47.959 --> 00:12:49.849
significantly in one organisation.

00:12:50.192 --> 00:12:54.212
Consequently, there's a sort of
narrowness perhaps of sector of board

00:12:54.212 --> 00:12:58.219
experience, of business model experience,
and sometimes quite simply geography.

00:12:58.219 --> 00:13:04.069
I was talking about an executive who's
based in a certain area of England and

00:13:04.339 --> 00:13:09.619
how that was probably limiting that person
in terms of their ability to run a large

00:13:09.739 --> 00:13:15.829
company because they did not necessarily
have so strongly a global perspective and

00:13:16.539 --> 00:13:20.892
that perhaps a US board would be a really
interesting addition for that person.

00:13:21.172 --> 00:13:23.662
So, yes, I think it can
be enormously helpful.

00:13:23.662 --> 00:13:25.222
Also, obviously, retention.

00:13:25.472 --> 00:13:29.309
Quite often, you get the executives
who you very much don't want to lose.

00:13:29.669 --> 00:13:33.149
Perhaps they don't have a chance
at the top job, and they may

00:13:33.149 --> 00:13:36.689
not necessarily want it, but you
are working hard to retain them.

00:13:37.076 --> 00:13:40.526
Giving them the opportunity to have a
non-executive role, which it won't be

00:13:40.526 --> 00:13:44.586
lost on most of them, that if you take
one while you're still executive, it will

00:13:44.586 --> 00:13:50.074
move you greatly further forward if you
then want a plural career in due course.

00:13:50.174 --> 00:13:53.834
It is a very useful lever all
round, really, and there aren't

00:13:53.834 --> 00:13:59.654
many CEOs who will stand against
it and say that they don't want

00:14:00.224 --> 00:14:01.964
their senior leaders to have them.

00:14:02.114 --> 00:14:04.454
I think in general, it's
viewed as a positive.

00:14:04.853 --> 00:14:07.883
Ralph Grayson: Interesting observation,
I'm not sure most people listening

00:14:07.883 --> 00:14:10.253
to this would necessarily think that.

00:14:10.503 --> 00:14:15.093
It segues beautifully into some
of the myths that I want us to

00:14:15.573 --> 00:14:18.420
hopefully explode and address.

00:14:18.600 --> 00:14:21.400
First of which, and the most
important, the elephant in the room,

00:14:21.400 --> 00:14:23.680
how board careers really happen.

00:14:24.170 --> 00:14:29.690
So I'd just like to get your perspective
on some of these myths versus reality,

00:14:29.690 --> 00:14:33.098
if you like, common perceptions
and what you're actually seeing.

00:14:33.898 --> 00:14:37.438
First myth, you can't be
a  NED until you've been a NED.

00:14:37.808 --> 00:14:41.858
From what you've observed,
what separates those who are

00:14:41.858 --> 00:14:43.658
appointed from those who aren't?

00:14:44.228 --> 00:14:47.656
And what does that mean on that
most important first NED position?

00:14:48.319 --> 00:14:52.243
Marianne Macdonald: This chicken
and egg idea, I totally accept that.

00:14:52.783 --> 00:14:55.813
And in fact, I just had lunch with a
chair who was saying the same thing.

00:14:55.813 --> 00:15:00.163
The first non-executive role, at
least commercial non-executive role,

00:15:00.163 --> 00:15:02.248
is generally the hardest to get.

00:15:02.638 --> 00:15:08.368
Although, I had a call this morning
from a CTO who said, "Yes, I decided

00:15:08.368 --> 00:15:09.947
I wanted a non-executive role.

00:15:09.947 --> 00:15:11.027
I was still serving.

00:15:11.417 --> 00:15:14.297
I worked out which
businesses I wanted to join.

00:15:14.657 --> 00:15:16.337
I got some introductions.

00:15:16.337 --> 00:15:19.817
I went off to see the chair, and
in the same breath, he offered me a

00:15:19.817 --> 00:15:24.682
role on the board." So sometimes it
can follow quite easily, but that's

00:15:24.682 --> 00:15:28.882
usually for people who have tremendous
experience, which is tremendously in

00:15:28.882 --> 00:15:33.562
sync with the zeitgeist, and usually
that's coupled with a very good style.

00:15:33.862 --> 00:15:38.622
For those who don't, yes, the
first one will be usually a bit of

00:15:38.622 --> 00:15:40.662
a campaign and a mission to get.

00:15:41.082 --> 00:15:48.172
Once you have got it, actually, I don't
think the difficulty ends because you

00:15:48.202 --> 00:15:52.522
need your chair to give you a really good
reference in order to get the next one.

00:15:52.962 --> 00:15:58.462
I don't agree that you won't
get your first NED unless you

00:15:58.462 --> 00:16:01.042
have non-executive experience.

00:16:01.642 --> 00:16:06.352
There's this age-old debate that seems
to come up again and again, "Oh, well, I

00:16:06.352 --> 00:16:09.202
should sit on a charity board, and then
I'm more likely to get my commercial

00:16:09.202 --> 00:16:13.392
non-executive role, which is what I
really want." And actually that, to

00:16:13.392 --> 00:16:16.332
me, as a non-executive headhunter,
is completely irrelevant, really.

00:16:16.642 --> 00:16:21.112
It's more about what is the breadth
and depth of your experience?

00:16:21.112 --> 00:16:24.322
What are you going to bring to a
board that a board would want or

00:16:24.322 --> 00:16:25.612
a particular business would want?

00:16:26.412 --> 00:16:30.212
Ralph Grayson: Yeah, I think there's
also a lack of appreciation for those

00:16:30.212 --> 00:16:31.772
who are thinking tactically like that.

00:16:31.772 --> 00:16:36.392
That that lack of authenticity won't
come through when you're applying for

00:16:36.392 --> 00:16:38.342
a charity role or a public sector role.

00:16:38.592 --> 00:16:41.472
They're too competitive and just
thinking that you can tick that

00:16:41.472 --> 00:16:44.824
box to then move on to a commercial
role, I just don't think is valid.

00:16:45.315 --> 00:16:48.630
Marianne Macdonald: I think it's
anathema actually to too many chairs.

00:16:48.660 --> 00:16:54.305
What they hate is, being used, their board
being used as a stepping stone and that

00:16:54.305 --> 00:16:56.815
will absolutely turn them off immediately.

00:16:56.865 --> 00:17:02.505
I remember one chair saying to me
that he had asked somebody why they

00:17:02.505 --> 00:17:06.315
wanted to join his board, and they
didn't have an immediate answer and

00:17:06.365 --> 00:17:09.695
he thought, "Well, we might as well
stop the interview right there."

00:17:10.292 --> 00:17:12.832
What is useful though, I think,
when you're going to see board

00:17:12.832 --> 00:17:17.182
headhunters who are very tough breed,
is having something to talk about.

00:17:17.182 --> 00:17:22.432
So it is quite useful if you have
already retired and come out of your

00:17:22.432 --> 00:17:29.362
executive career, then you do need to
evidence that you are doing things.

00:17:29.395 --> 00:17:34.045
Whether it's advising a startup or
you're very focused on investing in a

00:17:34.045 --> 00:17:38.515
certain area or actually that's where
the charity board can become quite

00:17:38.515 --> 00:17:42.085
useful, because you could start to talk
about the kind of learnings you've had

00:17:42.085 --> 00:17:47.345
from it, the kind of board issues that
you have been dealing with and some

00:17:47.345 --> 00:17:50.728
people will certainly take the view
that, yes, you've started to make that

00:17:50.728 --> 00:17:55.498
transition into the non-executive mindset,
which is quite a big consideration.

00:17:55.658 --> 00:17:57.118
Ralph Grayson: Yeah, I
think it's a great point.

00:17:57.458 --> 00:18:00.088
I'm going to turn it on its head
as well, because you and I have

00:18:00.088 --> 00:18:05.088
both seen many people over the
years who've said, "Look at my CV.

00:18:05.118 --> 00:18:06.258
Look at my experience.

00:18:06.288 --> 00:18:07.728
I'm a proven CEO.

00:18:08.478 --> 00:18:10.518
Obviously, I'm going to walk
straight into a NED role."

00:18:10.992 --> 00:18:12.252
Marianne Macdonald: Gosh,
do people still think that?

00:18:12.528 --> 00:18:13.108
I don't know.

00:18:13.612 --> 00:18:14.402
Ralph Grayson: Depressingly
in my experience.

00:18:14.502 --> 00:18:14.892
Yes.

00:18:16.868 --> 00:18:18.998
Marianne Macdonald: I mean, it's
so difficult to get these roles.

00:18:18.998 --> 00:18:24.038
There just aren't enough to go round
and there are many very, very able,

00:18:24.038 --> 00:18:26.108
determined people wanting to get them.

00:18:26.678 --> 00:18:33.275
They probably need to work on their style
and approach because ego and humility

00:18:33.365 --> 00:18:36.275
do play quite a big role in all of this.

00:18:36.455 --> 00:18:38.705
Ralph Grayson: So let's just touch
on that in a bit more detail.

00:18:38.762 --> 00:18:41.432
What role in your mind
does reputation play?

00:18:42.042 --> 00:18:47.172
And how does a strong executive
reputation perhaps fail to translate

00:18:47.232 --> 00:18:48.552
into relevance for a board seat?

00:18:49.186 --> 00:18:52.126
Marianne Macdonald: Clearly what
works as an executive, which you

00:18:52.126 --> 00:18:56.026
could very bluntly characterise as
command and control, obviously, won't

00:18:56.566 --> 00:18:59.326
work in the non-executive sphere.

00:18:59.836 --> 00:19:05.306
So there is a piece around, if you
are moving onto a decent kind of

00:19:06.056 --> 00:19:11.196
commercial board role, any, you would
hope, board or indeed search firm

00:19:11.226 --> 00:19:17.197
or both would be trying to pick up
information about the likelihood of

00:19:17.197 --> 00:19:20.617
success in making that transition.

00:19:20.987 --> 00:19:27.257
I think if there are enough star points
that suggest that you are unlikely

00:19:27.257 --> 00:19:35.567
to be able to move to a sort of
oversight, hands-off, non-executive,

00:19:36.367 --> 00:19:42.507
literally non-executive role, then
you are likely to find some difficulty

00:19:42.507 --> 00:19:45.207
actually moving forward in a process.

00:19:46.027 --> 00:19:48.626
There's a piece about track
record, of course, as well.

00:19:48.836 --> 00:19:50.756
So there's reputation more broadly.

00:19:50.786 --> 00:19:54.236
If you have been perceived as
failing at things, that's going

00:19:54.236 --> 00:19:55.616
to work against you, clearly.

00:19:56.116 --> 00:19:58.636
And then there's a piece
around just general style.

00:19:58.736 --> 00:20:03.146
Headhunters absolutely notice
how people manage things.

00:20:03.146 --> 00:20:06.536
They actually get to know candidates
much better through a process.

00:20:06.866 --> 00:20:11.306
So whilst they've picked them to
run in the process, they are also

00:20:11.306 --> 00:20:13.076
getting to know them at the same time.

00:20:13.376 --> 00:20:16.946
So if you're difficult to deal with,
if you're quite peppery, if you seem

00:20:16.946 --> 00:20:21.956
incredibly unavailable, if you're quite
displeased about being signed off for a

00:20:21.956 --> 00:20:26.276
role, that will all be noted by the board
headhunter, and it'll probably stay in

00:20:26.276 --> 00:20:29.186
their head for the next 10 or 15 years.

00:20:29.186 --> 00:20:30.798
So people need to be a bit careful.

00:20:31.379 --> 00:20:32.739
Ralph Grayson: I think
that's great wisdom.

00:20:33.428 --> 00:20:37.118
I think the maths of the search
process for a board member is,

00:20:37.118 --> 00:20:40.758
I will say, something not many
people take into consideration.

00:20:40.758 --> 00:20:43.278
I think I've seen some data that
would suggest if you make it on a

00:20:43.278 --> 00:20:46.638
long list for an executive role,
you probably got a one in six, one

00:20:46.638 --> 00:20:48.584
in seven chance of getting the job.

00:20:49.184 --> 00:20:51.824
I think if that's a NED role,
probably half it, you've

00:20:51.824 --> 00:20:53.924
probably got a one in 15 chance.

00:20:54.614 --> 00:21:00.274
Headhunters will approach a lot more
potential board candidates, because

00:21:00.274 --> 00:21:03.424
there are conflicts of interest, there's
time availability, there's all the

00:21:03.424 --> 00:21:05.444
fit stuff we'll maybe get into later.

00:21:05.984 --> 00:21:11.554
But the maths of being approached
as a candidate for a board is a

00:21:11.554 --> 00:21:14.236
lot tougher than the maths of being
approached to be an executive.

00:21:14.684 --> 00:21:15.764
Marianne Macdonald:
That's absolutely right.

00:21:15.764 --> 00:21:19.884
I think so and I think the
odds are lengthening, actually.

00:21:20.454 --> 00:21:22.764
Shortlists themselves
have got much longer.

00:21:23.334 --> 00:21:26.924
So whereas before there were three
or four people, they might now be

00:21:27.484 --> 00:21:29.734
considerably more than that as well.

00:21:30.064 --> 00:21:32.914
And those shortlists are typically
regarded as people who are

00:21:32.914 --> 00:21:35.224
all appointable, as it were.

00:21:35.704 --> 00:21:38.704
Whether the style is a fit,
that's a different question.

00:21:38.704 --> 00:21:43.354
So yeah, I think people are very
taken by surprise, I think, by

00:21:43.354 --> 00:21:45.604
this and it is very bruising.

00:21:45.997 --> 00:21:50.937
It's quite hard to watch sometimes
because people have often succeeded

00:21:51.737 --> 00:21:53.747
completely in their executive career.

00:21:53.747 --> 00:21:56.177
They've not really maybe
even had a setback.

00:21:56.177 --> 00:22:00.527
They've just risen through a large
organisation or several of them and

00:22:00.527 --> 00:22:04.334
then suddenly, they're getting knocked
back left, right, and centre and you

00:22:04.334 --> 00:22:08.084
have to have a bit of stamina and
just be aware you need a thick skin.

00:22:08.884 --> 00:22:11.224
Ralph Grayson: And learn
to take rejection well.

00:22:11.624 --> 00:22:13.244
Because it's not really rejection, right?

00:22:13.244 --> 00:22:15.194
It's just you didn't
happen to get that one.

00:22:15.584 --> 00:22:17.444
Marianne Macdonald: But people
do get quite discouraged.

00:22:17.444 --> 00:22:19.454
They feel like they're
continuously the bridesmaid.

00:22:19.454 --> 00:22:22.244
And actually, that's discouraging
as well for the headhunters, because

00:22:22.244 --> 00:22:25.244
they don't want to keep running
them and then saying no to them.

00:22:25.244 --> 00:22:28.065
So it can be a bit of a
vicious cycle, actually.

00:22:28.329 --> 00:22:30.939
Ralph Grayson: So let's use this
as an opportunity just to step into

00:22:31.059 --> 00:22:32.929
what I call the hidden board market.

00:22:33.798 --> 00:22:38.778
What I say to a lot of people is,
you've got to appreciate somewhere

00:22:38.778 --> 00:22:43.458
between a half and two-thirds of all
the board appointments don't involve an

00:22:43.458 --> 00:22:45.258
intermediary, don't involve a headhunter.

00:22:45.738 --> 00:22:47.118
They're private networks.

00:22:47.578 --> 00:22:51.988
The recommendations of a recommendation
of somebody who sits on a similar board

00:22:51.988 --> 00:22:54.658
or may have been approached for that role.

00:22:54.808 --> 00:22:58.121
So let's just drill into a little
bit the world of such informal

00:22:58.121 --> 00:23:03.401
networks, the role of chairs, the
role of sponsors and recommendations

00:23:03.401 --> 00:23:05.561
within that informal network.

00:23:05.561 --> 00:23:08.404
Just give me your 20,000
feet view on this, would you?

00:23:08.831 --> 00:23:12.204
Marianne Macdonald: I mean, this
is quite a complex question.

00:23:12.684 --> 00:23:19.034
So I guess the transparent board
market in a way, or actually

00:23:19.034 --> 00:23:21.734
to some degree transparent, is
the executive search market.

00:23:22.584 --> 00:23:27.224
I tend to work in the larger
business board space, if you like.

00:23:27.224 --> 00:23:31.804
So I'm not so good on the kind
of AIM small cap side of things.

00:23:32.194 --> 00:23:37.191
So in kind of the area I know well, the
first hurdle people have is, yes, the

00:23:37.191 --> 00:23:39.021
search firms are themselves visible.

00:23:39.501 --> 00:23:44.571
But that doesn't mean to say it's
easy to identify who they are actually

00:23:44.571 --> 00:23:48.831
comprehensively and that's one of
the things that I was very keen

00:23:48.891 --> 00:23:51.081
to solve in my advisory business.

00:23:51.421 --> 00:23:55.301
The second part is that you don't know
which headhunters are in those firms.

00:23:55.691 --> 00:23:57.481
They're also very hard to get to.

00:23:57.721 --> 00:24:00.241
So that's a real problem.

00:24:00.721 --> 00:24:03.891
Informal networks, these are
undoubtedly very powerful.

00:24:04.311 --> 00:24:09.051
Really the more chairs and board
members you have got to know in your

00:24:09.051 --> 00:24:12.171
executive career, and some people do
get to know a lot, particularly if

00:24:12.171 --> 00:24:16.862
they move around between companies,
that's going to help you enormously.

00:24:17.172 --> 00:24:21.302
That goes to formal referencing, but
also informal referencing, a whole

00:24:21.302 --> 00:24:24.092
load of advice, and then connections.

00:24:24.432 --> 00:24:27.777
Some people might view this, I think
the old boy network is actually such

00:24:27.777 --> 00:24:32.213
an outdated term, but I think there
is an element of being hidden in all

00:24:32.213 --> 00:24:36.353
of that, because that just won't work
to the advantage of the people that

00:24:36.353 --> 00:24:41.183
have been based in Asia or the people
that don't have those ready-made

00:24:41.183 --> 00:24:43.313
kind of PLC or other networks.

00:24:43.417 --> 00:24:46.507
That doesn't mean that they don't
have a great deal to offer a board.

00:24:47.017 --> 00:24:49.327
There's a piece around that
which is quite important.

00:24:49.327 --> 00:24:50.317
Can you build a network?

00:24:50.317 --> 00:24:51.007
You can.

00:24:51.697 --> 00:24:53.947
Most people aren't very good at
it, and they're not very good at

00:24:53.947 --> 00:24:56.857
maintaining it because networks
are quite fragile, actually.

00:24:56.857 --> 00:24:59.587
They don't really last
that long, generally.

00:24:59.947 --> 00:25:01.627
Sponsors, very important.

00:25:01.657 --> 00:25:03.877
Dare I say it for women
in particular, I think.

00:25:03.877 --> 00:25:05.227
They're still very powerful.

00:25:05.617 --> 00:25:06.727
Most people don't have them.

00:25:07.267 --> 00:25:11.427
Recommendations, again, that goes
back to networks and then it goes

00:25:11.427 --> 00:25:13.377
back to broader people skills.

00:25:13.697 --> 00:25:17.657
In a way, if the world is a marketplace,
people are continually forming views of

00:25:17.657 --> 00:25:23.327
you and your ability and your capability,
your ability to contribute and that's all

00:25:23.327 --> 00:25:28.397
kind of hidden stuff that will actually
start to work for you or against you.

00:25:28.397 --> 00:25:33.757
So some of this stuff you can control,
some of it's harder to control, and some

00:25:33.757 --> 00:25:37.057
of it I think is impossible to control
because it's stuff that's in your past.

00:25:37.357 --> 00:25:41.577
Your career is largely created by the
time you're thinking about this stuff.

00:25:42.477 --> 00:25:45.721
Ralph Grayson: I think the key moral
to that is there's no shortcuts here.

00:25:46.121 --> 00:25:49.451
It takes a lot of time and effort,
particularly to get that first board

00:25:49.601 --> 00:25:54.851
role, but then to keep that continuity
and that network fresh and relevant

00:25:55.481 --> 00:25:59.054
to what boards may be looking like or
looking for at that particular moment.

00:25:59.347 --> 00:26:03.157
I'd love just your perspective, because
I don't want to lead the audience on

00:26:03.307 --> 00:26:08.027
how a listener should be thinking about
their interaction with a search firm.

00:26:08.027 --> 00:26:10.607
In the context of search
firms are transactional.

00:26:11.027 --> 00:26:12.467
Searches are London buses.

00:26:12.467 --> 00:26:16.547
They come and they go, and headhunters
can be looking for very different things

00:26:16.547 --> 00:26:20.437
on very different days, and there's got
to be a certain amount of serendipity.

00:26:20.657 --> 00:26:24.861
The chances of you approaching
as a prospective NED, a search

00:26:24.861 --> 00:26:29.281
firm or a headhunter at any
one moment, and them having the

00:26:29.281 --> 00:26:31.861
right job for you at that moment.

00:26:32.191 --> 00:26:34.441
It is, as I say, it's two
bullets meeting in the air.

00:26:34.601 --> 00:26:37.611
It's a beautiful explosion when it
happens, but you don't see it very often.

00:26:38.086 --> 00:26:39.116
Marianne Macdonald: That's
such a good analogy.

00:26:39.116 --> 00:26:40.406
I think that's absolutely right.

00:26:41.036 --> 00:26:45.676
Obviously you would hope, and to some
degree it's true, I think very true, that

00:26:45.706 --> 00:26:48.766
you go in to see the search and they don't
have anything for you and it's something

00:26:48.766 --> 00:26:50.506
that, frankly, board headhunters lament.

00:26:50.536 --> 00:26:53.596
They don't like having what they
call generals or drop-ins and

00:26:53.596 --> 00:26:57.046
not having anything to offer, but
that's usually inevitably the case.

00:26:57.076 --> 00:27:00.696
So then they should code you
properly, put you on their system,

00:27:00.696 --> 00:27:02.706
maybe even use our board directory.

00:27:02.706 --> 00:27:06.366
There should be ways that they can
find you again when something does

00:27:06.606 --> 00:27:08.016
come up that matches with you.

00:27:08.016 --> 00:27:11.136
And on that, the good news of this
is that board headhunters want to

00:27:11.136 --> 00:27:14.796
help, and by and large, they'll be
carrying around your profile in their

00:27:14.796 --> 00:27:16.356
head along with thousands of others.

00:27:16.666 --> 00:27:19.096
And if they like you and were
impressed by you, they're trying

00:27:19.096 --> 00:27:21.946
to find the matching brief for you.

00:27:22.276 --> 00:27:27.836
So it's not all bad, but you do
have to be proactive by yourself.

00:27:27.886 --> 00:27:31.354
I remember a board, the head of a
board practice at one of the SHREK

00:27:31.354 --> 00:27:34.504
firms saying to me that someone had
said to him, "What are you doing for

00:27:34.504 --> 00:27:37.414
my career?" And he said, "Well, what
are you doing for your career?" "It's

00:27:37.414 --> 00:27:41.447
not my job to help your career." People
often sort of slightly misunderstand.

00:27:41.447 --> 00:27:43.748
Their headhunters are
working for their clients.

00:27:44.097 --> 00:27:46.887
The candidates are
actually not their clients.

00:27:46.977 --> 00:27:49.257
They're simply there to fulfil the brief.

00:27:49.432 --> 00:27:51.792
Ralph Grayson: Well at the risk of
putting myself on the naughty step here,

00:27:51.852 --> 00:27:55.992
headhunters also aren't there to give
prospective NEDs free career advice.

00:27:56.087 --> 00:27:59.021
Marianne Macdonald: Oh, gosh, absolutely
and I think they do find themselves

00:27:59.021 --> 00:28:03.431
doing that an awful lot, as do
chairs, and they don't have the time.

00:28:03.891 --> 00:28:06.291
Ralph Grayson: Yeah, much as
they might want to or like to.

00:28:06.381 --> 00:28:07.211
Marianne Macdonald: Yes, indeed.

00:28:07.576 --> 00:28:10.426
Ralph Grayson: Before we leave search
firms, because you've been a practitioner,

00:28:11.026 --> 00:28:15.646
I think a lot of prospective NEDs
misunderstand how search firm actually

00:28:15.646 --> 00:28:20.596
works and the partner doesn't have
their Black Book, rolodex, whatever

00:28:20.596 --> 00:28:21.856
the expression is in their head.

00:28:22.306 --> 00:28:26.656
A lot of this is delivered by the
research department and I'd love

00:28:26.656 --> 00:28:31.396
just to get your advice to listeners,
for listeners, as to the role of a

00:28:31.396 --> 00:28:35.276
research department and actually the
importance of getting your CV in front

00:28:35.276 --> 00:28:37.736
of the researcher, not necessarily
the most senior partner in the firm.

00:28:37.901 --> 00:28:38.516
Marianne Macdonald: That's right.

00:28:38.530 --> 00:28:42.436
I kind of see it as two twin entities
that interact to make a decision.

00:28:43.858 --> 00:28:47.788
Let's say that the partner side of
things, it will generally be their

00:28:47.788 --> 00:28:53.748
judgement on kind of style and fit
that will carry the day and probably

00:28:53.748 --> 00:28:56.988
make the difference between making
the long list or shortlist or not.

00:28:57.318 --> 00:29:00.948
But the research department, as you
say, are the ones that are doing the

00:29:00.948 --> 00:29:04.648
hard yards, combing through thousands
of names, and it really is thousands of

00:29:04.648 --> 00:29:10.100
names, and coming up with the right fit
on behalf of the partner and sometimes

00:29:10.100 --> 00:29:14.510
working very closely with them so that
they're also a pair of eyes and ears

00:29:14.510 --> 00:29:18.275
and that they're sitting there in the
interviews and they're also absorbing.

00:29:18.545 --> 00:29:20.555
Because to be a board headhunter,
you really have to get to know

00:29:20.555 --> 00:29:23.500
thousands of people and remember their
background and style in your head.

00:29:23.550 --> 00:29:27.360
Yes, the researcher is really
important, and I say this, I think

00:29:27.360 --> 00:29:31.932
one of my jobs as a career advisor
is to kind of educate clients about

00:29:31.932 --> 00:29:35.962
how search works because they really
are the gatekeepers in so many cases.

00:29:36.292 --> 00:29:40.522
So they are quite powerful, a
very powerful force in the market.

00:29:40.732 --> 00:29:43.642
You don't want to go and do an
interview and talk only to the

00:29:43.642 --> 00:29:46.402
partner and completely ignore the
researcher, because to be honest,

00:29:47.002 --> 00:29:48.232
the partner might well notice.

00:29:48.232 --> 00:29:51.872
The researcher will certainly notice
and one day the researcher will

00:29:51.872 --> 00:29:53.232
probably be running that board.

00:29:53.278 --> 00:29:54.568
You know, they probably won't forget it.

00:29:55.194 --> 00:29:57.098
Ralph Grayson: And the role of LinkedIn?

00:29:57.368 --> 00:30:00.668
Has it democratised and made
the process more transparent?

00:30:00.988 --> 00:30:04.958
And how should people think about
the LinkedIn summary as part of

00:30:04.958 --> 00:30:08.708
their board proposition and actually
stating, "Here's what I'm looking for

00:30:08.708 --> 00:30:09.878
and here's what I'm available for."

00:30:10.800 --> 00:30:12.240
Marianne Macdonald: Look,
this is just my personal view.

00:30:12.300 --> 00:30:14.760
I think LinkedIn is just
a tool in the process.

00:30:14.760 --> 00:30:19.804
I don't think it's certainly the
higher levels, it's that material.

00:30:19.804 --> 00:30:24.182
However, it does do something really
important because I'm quite often

00:30:24.182 --> 00:30:28.802
asked by headhunters if I have
any thoughts about candidates, for

00:30:28.802 --> 00:30:33.232
example, for search they're doing
and if I suggest a name, I'll hear

00:30:33.232 --> 00:30:35.180
the keys tapping on their keyboard.

00:30:35.450 --> 00:30:37.070
They will be looking at LinkedIn.

00:30:37.460 --> 00:30:41.240
So it's very powerful in terms
of providing what is generally

00:30:41.240 --> 00:30:45.350
regarded as the most up-to-date
snapshot of what someone is up to.

00:30:45.740 --> 00:30:47.810
That's quite important, because
obviously, that goes to things

00:30:47.810 --> 00:30:49.280
like capacity and conflicts.

00:30:49.380 --> 00:30:53.370
It is really worth paying attention to
your LinkedIn profile and making sure

00:30:53.420 --> 00:30:58.040
it's really quite well filled in, at
least for the later more senior roles.

00:30:58.480 --> 00:31:01.938
Ralph Grayson: Yeah, I know and it
goes without stating that LinkedIn

00:31:01.938 --> 00:31:05.198
isn't a social media platform.

00:31:05.948 --> 00:31:08.078
Just be careful about your photograph.

00:31:08.138 --> 00:31:09.608
Be careful what you say.

00:31:10.035 --> 00:31:11.295
Marianne Macdonald: I completely agree.

00:31:11.295 --> 00:31:12.615
Yes, exactly.

00:31:12.675 --> 00:31:14.965
So there's a piece around messaging.

00:31:14.965 --> 00:31:18.430
I mean, sometimes when I was a board
headhunter, very rarely, but on occasion,

00:31:18.460 --> 00:31:22.180
I would message people on LinkedIn because
it was the only way to get hold of them.

00:31:22.180 --> 00:31:27.000
So there's something about the
360-degree kind of ability to get

00:31:27.000 --> 00:31:29.010
in touch, which can be useful.

00:31:29.010 --> 00:31:31.380
But that will be, you know, a
whole bunch of other messages

00:31:31.380 --> 00:31:32.580
you probably don't want to get.

00:31:32.880 --> 00:31:36.830
I once persuaded someone to go on
LinkedIn and it was a disaster, because

00:31:36.883 --> 00:31:41.033
he was very powerful on an honours
committee and he then got a flood of

00:31:41.033 --> 00:31:44.443
emails from people that he probably
didn't want to hear from again.

00:31:45.433 --> 00:31:47.757
It can be a bit of a double-edged sword.

00:31:48.117 --> 00:31:51.507
The other thing about LinkedIn is,
I think it's most useful at the

00:31:51.507 --> 00:31:52.887
beginning of your non-executive career.

00:31:52.887 --> 00:31:55.197
You can then start to
come off it as people do.

00:31:55.557 --> 00:32:00.627
It gets awkward if you're being contacted
by employees of a board on which you sit.

00:32:01.107 --> 00:32:02.247
That can be a bit awkward.

00:32:02.577 --> 00:32:06.567
For headhunters, they do on occasion,
obviously, even in the non-executive

00:32:06.567 --> 00:32:08.877
space, use it to identify candidates.

00:32:08.877 --> 00:32:11.817
But it's not really designed
for that and it's not really

00:32:11.817 --> 00:32:13.347
very effective at that either.

00:32:14.147 --> 00:32:17.417
Ralph Grayson: So just before we leave
this segment, what for you is effective

00:32:17.497 --> 00:32:23.352
networking as opposed to wasted miles on
a pavement and medium dry Chardonnays?

00:32:23.764 --> 00:32:26.783
Marianne Macdonald: And this obviously
is not going to surprise anybody, but

00:32:26.783 --> 00:32:30.473
I guess, obviously, you don't really
want to be networking with others at

00:32:30.473 --> 00:32:35.453
your level if you are trying to enter
the non-executive board space, because

00:32:35.453 --> 00:32:37.223
that probably won't get you so far.

00:32:37.703 --> 00:32:39.113
What is effective networking?

00:32:39.113 --> 00:32:43.733
I think it's really thinking through
who you do know and if you want to be

00:32:43.733 --> 00:32:45.893
super tactical, frankly, who they know.

00:32:46.283 --> 00:32:48.933
And you can do that in
quite a strategic way.

00:32:48.933 --> 00:32:50.473
I mean, I have a tool that will do that.

00:32:50.573 --> 00:32:52.583
I think you probably have
access to the same one.

00:32:52.793 --> 00:32:56.993
I know most people don't, but
it's then getting to them.

00:32:57.423 --> 00:33:00.303
Obviously not asking them for things,
but you can ask them for advice,

00:33:00.303 --> 00:33:02.493
which people will generally give.

00:33:02.613 --> 00:33:05.523
And then I think it's
about compounding it.

00:33:06.183 --> 00:33:09.263
Then it's saying, "Okay, is there
anyone else I should meet?" And trying

00:33:09.263 --> 00:33:14.223
to get additional introductions from
them and then keeping up with that

00:33:14.223 --> 00:33:15.963
person and then it's like the basics.

00:33:16.013 --> 00:33:17.843
Thanking them for their time.

00:33:18.203 --> 00:33:22.163
Going back to them when you then meet
the person they've mentioned to thank

00:33:22.163 --> 00:33:25.423
them for that and just, that kind of
politeness goes a long way, actually.

00:33:25.768 --> 00:33:29.728
Ralph Grayson: Politeness does go a long
way, particularly in the board space.

00:33:29.788 --> 00:33:33.418
Again, shouldn't need to say, but does
need reminding every now and again.

00:33:33.688 --> 00:33:37.228
Say, Marianne, you've spent probably
as much time with the leading

00:33:37.228 --> 00:33:41.018
search firms and in particular the
board practice as anybody I know.

00:33:41.388 --> 00:33:47.538
So I'd love just to get your thoughts
on what makes a NED candidate stand out.

00:33:48.078 --> 00:33:52.339
What mistakes do aspiring NEDs
make when presenting themselves

00:33:52.344 --> 00:33:54.578
to such firms and chairs?

00:33:55.238 --> 00:33:55.899
Let's go from there.

00:33:56.214 --> 00:33:56.434
Marianne Macdonald: Okay.

00:33:56.563 --> 00:34:01.263
Well, I could talk about this for
hours, but what makes a NED stand out?

00:34:02.223 --> 00:34:08.393
At the end of the day, and on occasion,
I think this is sometimes lost on people,

00:34:08.693 --> 00:34:14.213
it's going to be about the strength and
quality of your experience and that is

00:34:14.213 --> 00:34:15.593
what you're going to bring to a board.

00:34:15.920 --> 00:34:18.380
In truth, that's something
you can't change either.

00:34:18.710 --> 00:34:23.060
Although, you can do a lot to
change how you present it, i.e.

00:34:23.060 --> 00:34:24.704
effectively or not effectively.

00:34:24.704 --> 00:34:27.300
So it's a bit of a kind of nuanced answer.

00:34:27.750 --> 00:34:32.370
So I think what makes them stand out is
something around the experience they've

00:34:32.370 --> 00:34:38.840
gathered and then the other piece
usually is around their style and EQ.

00:34:38.930 --> 00:34:41.120
Those are usually the two things.

00:34:41.920 --> 00:34:44.020
You can then start to slice and dice it.

00:34:44.020 --> 00:34:47.110
So do they have experience
that's super relevant for what

00:34:47.110 --> 00:34:48.490
boards are concerned about?

00:34:49.060 --> 00:34:50.920
But that's not really
something you can make up.

00:34:50.920 --> 00:34:53.740
You can certainly try and keep
up, but that's very different.

00:34:53.740 --> 00:34:57.310
You can't become a CTO if
you've come up the CMO route.

00:34:57.670 --> 00:34:58.690
So that's one thing.

00:34:58.960 --> 00:35:02.890
Mistakes they make in terms
of how they come across.

00:35:03.690 --> 00:35:08.070
So there's a huge piece around
preparation, and I think

00:35:08.070 --> 00:35:10.140
people routinely under-prepare.

00:35:10.560 --> 00:35:15.390
I think they fail to realise that if
you're going up to meet a headhunter in

00:35:15.390 --> 00:35:20.100
relation to an non-executive role, that
is an interview which is just as important

00:35:20.130 --> 00:35:22.080
almost as the one with the chair.

00:35:22.080 --> 00:35:25.914
In fact, arguably more important because
that headhunter could run you for multiple

00:35:26.123 --> 00:35:30.443
processes where the chair is probably only
meeting you against one, you'd imagine.

00:35:30.743 --> 00:35:36.163
So it's something around how well do you
know the business you're going to discuss?

00:35:36.493 --> 00:35:38.473
Oddly, how well do you
know your own career?

00:35:38.473 --> 00:35:41.637
Cause people can be quite odd sometimes.

00:35:41.637 --> 00:35:45.267
They seem to have forgotten
the people they worked for or

00:35:45.597 --> 00:35:47.037
the years they worked for them.

00:35:47.377 --> 00:35:50.287
That can get quite hazy in their
head, but that doesn't really induce

00:35:50.287 --> 00:35:53.977
confidence if you're a headhunter
kind of interviewing them and then

00:35:53.977 --> 00:35:55.777
there's something around enthusiasm.

00:35:56.077 --> 00:36:02.150
So people can often seem as though they're
out really for themselves rather than

00:36:02.660 --> 00:36:07.460
coming at something from, "I want to
contribute this to a board. I want to help

00:36:07.790 --> 00:36:11.960
build and grow this business." So there's
something about approach there as well.

00:36:12.555 --> 00:36:13.605
Ralph Grayson: I think
that's a crucial point.

00:36:13.635 --> 00:36:21.385
This whole area of moving from executive
authority to boardroom influence.

00:36:21.715 --> 00:36:26.155
That is a style that you can
train in yourself in terms

00:36:26.155 --> 00:36:27.235
of the way you articulate it.

00:36:28.035 --> 00:36:29.143
Marianne Macdonald: That you can train?

00:36:29.800 --> 00:36:30.140
Yeah.

00:36:30.856 --> 00:36:32.116
Ralph Grayson: You can be more self-aware.

00:36:32.176 --> 00:36:34.936
Maybe you can't train yourself,
but you can be more aware of

00:36:35.146 --> 00:36:36.466
the nuances and the subtleties.

00:36:36.616 --> 00:36:38.746
If you're not aware of that,
you'll probably not cut out

00:36:38.746 --> 00:36:39.548
to be a good board member.

00:36:39.691 --> 00:36:42.891
Marianne Macdonald: I hear this debated
and it was being debated by a chair the

00:36:42.891 --> 00:36:46.641
other night at a dinner I was at whether
people really can change themselves.

00:36:47.071 --> 00:36:51.092
If someone joins a board, they're
probably going to be the way they are

00:36:51.662 --> 00:36:55.832
and either you accept that or you try
and ease them out at the end of their

00:36:55.832 --> 00:36:59.822
first term, which is what was part
of the problem we were discussing.

00:37:00.103 --> 00:37:04.040
This came up in the context of what do
you do when most people around the board

00:37:04.040 --> 00:37:08.270
table are nine out of 10, was the way it
was put, and there, there's a passenger

00:37:08.270 --> 00:37:10.130
who's sort of six or seven out of 10.

00:37:10.676 --> 00:37:12.806
How does that affect the board dynamic?

00:37:13.110 --> 00:37:15.202
To what degree should
they be allowed to stay?

00:37:15.502 --> 00:37:16.882
Those sorts of questions.

00:37:17.092 --> 00:37:20.392
That's not quite what we're talking
about, but I think it's about, can

00:37:20.392 --> 00:37:24.112
people really change in terms of
their contribution, their style?

00:37:24.112 --> 00:37:25.372
I'm not sure they can.

00:37:25.622 --> 00:37:28.426
And usually, to be fair,
they self-select out.

00:37:28.686 --> 00:37:33.876
Having been involved in quite a lot
of search processes for boards you

00:37:33.876 --> 00:37:36.096
do see a lot of similar mistakes.

00:37:36.126 --> 00:37:40.416
Someone who just talks too much to
the point that the chair doesn't get

00:37:40.506 --> 00:37:44.556
the answers they need to even decide
whether they want them around the

00:37:44.556 --> 00:37:48.006
board table and then they just decide
they're probably on transmit and

00:37:48.006 --> 00:37:50.076
that's going to be a bit of a pain.

00:37:50.473 --> 00:37:52.461
Ralph Grayson: Well, this
whole area of board behaviour.

00:37:52.461 --> 00:37:56.234
I mean, this is a theme that runs
through every podcast I have.

00:37:56.804 --> 00:37:59.972
That's different to the skills,
experience, knowledge that we all talk

00:37:59.972 --> 00:38:02.314
about as being the expertise on the board.

00:38:02.556 --> 00:38:06.437
Let's turn to that sector expertise,
because I think people talk now

00:38:06.437 --> 00:38:08.297
about this VUCA environment.

00:38:08.297 --> 00:38:11.507
Where is that changing this
emphasis and balance between

00:38:11.687 --> 00:38:12.947
skills, experience, knowledge?

00:38:13.747 --> 00:38:19.493
Marianne Macdonald: Well, a few hours
ago, I had a debate about whether the pure

00:38:19.493 --> 00:38:24.083
non-executive career even had any future.

00:38:24.623 --> 00:38:29.503
Because if things are changing so
rapidly in the tech space, to what

00:38:29.503 --> 00:38:34.743
degree can non-executives really
contribute other than, which by the

00:38:34.743 --> 00:38:38.973
way, I don't remotely underestimate,
but other than wisdom and judgement.

00:38:39.423 --> 00:38:44.193
Because if some of the most meaningful
and existential and strategic and business

00:38:44.193 --> 00:38:50.823
model questions facing a business are
really related to technology issues and

00:38:51.413 --> 00:38:56.023
the non-executive around the table is
quite out of date with those things,

00:38:56.023 --> 00:39:03.293
assuming they are digital at all, then
it does raise the question of what

00:39:03.293 --> 00:39:05.333
should the board of the future look like?

00:39:05.693 --> 00:39:09.653
So I think there's a piece around the
kind of geopolitics and people who

00:39:10.493 --> 00:39:15.743
really have that bigger picture and
understanding and actually curiosity.

00:39:16.043 --> 00:39:20.243
I think there's a piece, massive piece,
around technology and being able to

00:39:20.243 --> 00:39:25.763
even, at some level, weigh in on those
big decisions that every board is

00:39:25.763 --> 00:39:28.313
grappling with including data, actually.

00:39:29.113 --> 00:39:30.330
Ralph Grayson: Gosh, there's
a lot to unravel there.

00:39:30.758 --> 00:39:35.798
How does that lead you onto your
perception on this balance between

00:39:36.548 --> 00:39:43.268
good judgement, self-awareness, the
ability to influence rather than manage?

00:39:43.752 --> 00:39:48.901
How does somebody put forward as
best they can those soft skills?

00:39:49.701 --> 00:39:53.931
Marianne Macdonald: Well, remember that
the chairs and the headhunters will be

00:39:53.931 --> 00:39:56.511
taking up soundings on those, I think.

00:39:57.311 --> 00:40:01.301
Obviously, whenever you're in front
of somebody, that's going to be part

00:40:01.301 --> 00:40:03.551
of the assessment that's going on.

00:40:04.051 --> 00:40:07.501
Not to state the obvious,
but, it doesn't begin in the

00:40:07.501 --> 00:40:09.541
interview room, whatever that is.

00:40:09.591 --> 00:40:14.801
We, at my search firm, we had a very
kind of powerful receptionist who's

00:40:14.801 --> 00:40:20.351
actually still working today and he
would form extremely strong views of

00:40:20.351 --> 00:40:23.351
candidates as they arrived, whether he
felt they were smart enough, whether

00:40:23.351 --> 00:40:26.351
he felt they were nice enough, whether
he felt they were courteous enough,

00:40:26.351 --> 00:40:31.061
and he would have no hesitation in
conveying them to the headhunters

00:40:31.061 --> 00:40:32.471
who were involved in the search.

00:40:32.761 --> 00:40:37.721
So there's a piece around, that,
which is quite interesting.

00:40:38.411 --> 00:40:43.084
I think there's actually, it depends
on the board and the chair, you know,

00:40:43.084 --> 00:40:47.194
I spoke to one chair, he's actually an
executive chair, so he's slightly unusual,

00:40:47.194 --> 00:40:50.944
but he really didn't want his non-execs
either to have sector experience or

00:40:50.944 --> 00:40:57.434
indeed to weigh in on most of the kind
of day-to-day or operational decisions

00:40:57.624 --> 00:40:59.184
even when they got to the board table.

00:40:59.184 --> 00:41:04.784
Really, what he just wanted was those
non-execs to come in a really effective

00:41:04.784 --> 00:41:07.364
and strategic way on the really big calls.

00:41:07.784 --> 00:41:12.414
Do we sell half the business ahead of what
appears to be a financial crisis in 2008?

00:41:13.134 --> 00:41:15.274
And I saw where he was
coming from you, you know.

00:41:15.844 --> 00:41:19.374
His view was we have a business full
of people with sector experience.

00:41:19.864 --> 00:41:22.324
I don't need that in my non-execs.

00:41:22.514 --> 00:41:25.724
Other chairs will differ, and they
will say, "What good is a board without

00:41:25.724 --> 00:41:30.006
people with at least two members who
understand the sector very well?"

00:41:30.254 --> 00:41:32.384
Ralph Grayson: This is a question
I'm being asked a lot, which

00:41:32.384 --> 00:41:36.944
is, how do I demonstrate I'm a
fit as a member of the board?

00:41:37.634 --> 00:41:40.754
But to the same extent, I'm
going to add diversity, either

00:41:40.754 --> 00:41:42.494
of thoughts, perspective.

00:41:42.957 --> 00:41:45.734
Increasingly, I'm asked how
somebody balances those two.

00:41:46.134 --> 00:41:49.954
Marianne Macdonald: I question how much
you can control that, because at the end

00:41:49.954 --> 00:41:54.634
of the day, there's a chemistry thing,
isn't there, between you and the chair?

00:41:54.964 --> 00:41:58.564
And yes, they might have liked your
background on paper, but when you get

00:41:58.564 --> 00:42:03.244
in the room, to be honest, and this is
probably due to a thousand invisible

00:42:03.484 --> 00:42:06.544
pieces of experience and things to
do with your upbringing and who knows

00:42:06.544 --> 00:42:09.524
what, but the chemistry won't be there.

00:42:09.881 --> 00:42:14.881
That will probably mean you don't get
the role, but maybe also means that

00:42:14.881 --> 00:42:16.441
you probably don't want the role.

00:42:16.831 --> 00:42:22.689
So I don't know how much you can
influence that and I'm not even sure

00:42:22.689 --> 00:42:27.009
you can influence your level of EQ
and if it's not that great, then I

00:42:27.009 --> 00:42:28.989
think you are going to have a problem.

00:42:28.989 --> 00:42:32.409
You might just make it,
but it will be much harder.

00:42:32.859 --> 00:42:34.099
Ralph Grayson: Yeah, I think
that's a really pragmatic.

00:42:34.099 --> 00:42:35.479
It was rather an unfair question.

00:42:35.723 --> 00:42:40.493
I default back to don't try and overthink
it and don't overgame it because if you're

00:42:40.493 --> 00:42:42.053
not authentic, you will get found out.

00:42:42.537 --> 00:42:46.093
Marianne Macdonald: I mean, what I do
say to clients a lot is think about the

00:42:46.093 --> 00:42:50.597
headhunter, because these are the really
powerful gatekeepers almost always.

00:42:50.740 --> 00:42:52.180
They get tired.

00:42:52.480 --> 00:42:55.390
They get tired of giving, because
it's almost like you're continually

00:42:55.390 --> 00:42:59.590
giving in that role and people are
wanting things from you all day,

00:42:59.590 --> 00:43:01.060
essentially, career advancement.

00:43:01.360 --> 00:43:04.510
Just think about asking them
questions, showing an interest

00:43:04.510 --> 00:43:06.010
in them, thanking them.

00:43:06.243 --> 00:43:09.243
Things where you're just actually
being thoughtful as a human being,

00:43:09.532 --> 00:43:12.718
asking about their family and
then remembering what they said.

00:43:12.988 --> 00:43:16.028
These are things that do make
a really good impression.

00:43:16.328 --> 00:43:20.888
Being aware of the researcher who is
asking maybe not such a good question, and

00:43:20.888 --> 00:43:23.848
just being incredibly nice in your answer.

00:43:24.133 --> 00:43:27.793
Ralph Grayson: And if I just interject,
when the researcher rings you for

00:43:27.793 --> 00:43:30.763
something you're not a candidate for,
but they want your advice on, take

00:43:30.763 --> 00:43:34.003
the call and give it some thought
because they'll remember the people

00:43:34.003 --> 00:43:35.293
who are nice on the phone to them.

00:43:35.338 --> 00:43:37.938
Marianne Macdonald: Well, more than that,
they'll keep a log on the database that

00:43:37.938 --> 00:43:42.938
will stay there forever and it will say
something like, "Yes, always refuses to

00:43:42.938 --> 00:43:46.858
be sourced," or, "As usual, really nice,
came up with some really good ideas."

00:43:47.383 --> 00:43:47.857
Ralph Grayson: There you go.

00:43:48.657 --> 00:43:52.133
I'm fascinated to hear your thoughts
from the conversations you're

00:43:52.133 --> 00:43:56.633
having with other headhunters
around board cadence, priorities,

00:43:57.173 --> 00:43:59.363
where the recruitment hotspots are.

00:43:59.523 --> 00:44:01.713
We've all talked about AI and Cyber.

00:44:02.133 --> 00:44:04.563
Geopolitics is coming more to the fore.

00:44:04.623 --> 00:44:05.763
Private capital.

00:44:06.333 --> 00:44:08.523
ESG, Trump, non-Trump.

00:44:08.631 --> 00:44:10.243
The list goes on, right?

00:44:10.243 --> 00:44:14.408
So is this the natural ebb and
flow of board recruitment or is

00:44:14.408 --> 00:44:17.498
there something more structural or
what are you seeing and hearing?

00:44:18.113 --> 00:44:20.153
Marianne Macdonald: In terms
of sort of changes in board

00:44:20.153 --> 00:44:21.623
trends, board composition?

00:44:21.743 --> 00:44:21.803
Ralph Grayson: Yeah.

00:44:22.203 --> 00:44:22.983
Marianne Macdonald: Technology.

00:44:23.783 --> 00:44:25.583
It just feels like a really big one.

00:44:25.773 --> 00:44:27.273
So I think that is a change.

00:44:27.513 --> 00:44:31.053
There was a period about 15 years ago
where overnight, every board seemed to

00:44:31.053 --> 00:44:34.503
wake up and say, "Oh, we need a digital
NED." And that was the start of it.

00:44:35.013 --> 00:44:41.253
But now, I think it's so
overwhelmingly important.

00:44:41.373 --> 00:44:44.373
So I think that's
something that's going on.

00:44:44.733 --> 00:44:47.463
We had CSR, sadly, it's come and gone.

00:44:47.513 --> 00:44:53.573
I think geopolitics, as I've mentioned,
I do think people who have that kind of

00:44:53.573 --> 00:44:56.663
insight are going to come up the track.

00:44:56.663 --> 00:44:59.573
I'm not quite sure it's happening
yet, but I think that's probably

00:44:59.573 --> 00:45:00.983
something we'll see more of.

00:45:01.433 --> 00:45:05.603
So that kind of plays, to people
like the ambassadors who haven't

00:45:05.603 --> 00:45:08.723
been perhaps so sought after to date.

00:45:09.496 --> 00:45:13.806
The diversity trends
have actually gone away.

00:45:14.310 --> 00:45:16.096
They're much less sharp than they were.

00:45:16.096 --> 00:45:19.886
We had a period where, frankly, men
felt they didn't have much of a chance

00:45:20.306 --> 00:45:21.716
of a commercial non-executive role.

00:45:21.716 --> 00:45:25.676
Now, those big listed boards,
these are pretty much equalised.

00:45:26.006 --> 00:45:30.116
So I think we're back to
level pegging on that front.

00:45:30.516 --> 00:45:33.817
It's often, it seems to me, the
bigger economic environment is a

00:45:33.817 --> 00:45:35.797
big kind of influencer of this.

00:45:35.797 --> 00:45:41.657
So in the last financial crisis,
almost 20 years ago now the boards

00:45:41.657 --> 00:45:43.007
all went back to their knitting.

00:45:43.037 --> 00:45:47.657
They were like, "Okay, we're not going
to take any chances now on the left field

00:45:47.657 --> 00:45:52.857
candidate, the sort of slightly more
fun, creative, less obvious candidate.

00:45:52.917 --> 00:45:56.347
No, what we're going to do is we're
going to take frankly, at the time,

00:45:56.347 --> 00:46:01.687
it was the guy who was 66, who served
on 15 boards, who totally gets our

00:46:01.687 --> 00:46:06.697
sector and he just has so much board
experience and wisdom and judgement.

00:46:07.087 --> 00:46:11.617
And I think today, you're starting
to see some of that coming back in.

00:46:11.692 --> 00:46:12.112
Ralph Grayson: Yeah.

00:46:12.112 --> 00:46:13.522
I think it's very contextual.

00:46:13.522 --> 00:46:14.152
Couldn't agree more.

00:46:14.302 --> 00:46:18.692
We went through this wave, everybody
wanted ex-CEOs then they wanted ex-CFOs.

00:46:19.298 --> 00:46:20.838
No, I think that's very insightful.

00:46:21.378 --> 00:46:25.778
Tell me a little bit about your thoughts
of how early and whether an aspiring

00:46:25.778 --> 00:46:31.288
NED should start thinking about the
ladder, first board role, multiple

00:46:31.288 --> 00:46:35.578
board roles, chair of subsidiary
committee to being chair of the board.

00:46:35.638 --> 00:46:37.972
How should they, or should
they not overthink it?

00:46:38.412 --> 00:46:41.181
Marianne Macdonald: I don't think you
can start planning your non-executive

00:46:41.181 --> 00:46:45.561
career too early and then obviously, for
a period of time, that will run alongside

00:46:45.561 --> 00:46:48.321
your executive career, you hope, because
you probably don't want to come up too

00:46:48.321 --> 00:46:53.001
early, otherwise you'll lose your currency
and that'll be a problem potentially.

00:46:53.331 --> 00:46:57.591
But then you are on the front foot
when you have your full plural career.

00:46:57.951 --> 00:47:03.034
So I quite often work with serving
execs, they might be CEOs, but they

00:47:03.034 --> 00:47:09.254
might not necessarily be at all and for
example, I'm working with somebody where

00:47:09.254 --> 00:47:11.114
they have quite a technology focus.

00:47:11.411 --> 00:47:17.331
So we were just discussing how that
person could enhance their executive

00:47:17.511 --> 00:47:21.861
credentials for the board space whilst
they still have the ability to do that.

00:47:21.861 --> 00:47:25.011
In other words, the executive career
is still going and so I think there's

00:47:25.011 --> 00:47:26.451
a whole range of things you can do.

00:47:26.691 --> 00:47:30.911
You can sit on committees that you might
have done your best to avoid previously.

00:47:31.271 --> 00:47:35.751
You could actually create work streams,
projects, committees which might be

00:47:35.751 --> 00:47:41.031
around some of the really important
issues that the board is wrestling with.

00:47:41.301 --> 00:47:43.431
So it might be AI, it might be quantum.

00:47:43.791 --> 00:47:48.591
If you do things like that, that
is enormously helpful and you

00:47:48.591 --> 00:47:50.031
can do that quite tactically.

00:47:50.281 --> 00:47:53.731
Quite often, I think with people about
how they might change or amend their

00:47:53.731 --> 00:47:59.351
role title so that it's either extended
or changed completely so that it's more

00:47:59.351 --> 00:48:03.461
differentiated or it's more spot on
to either reflect what they've done,

00:48:03.461 --> 00:48:07.811
but more importantly, perhaps reflect
something that's really important in

00:48:07.811 --> 00:48:10.151
the board's sort of mind collectively.

00:48:10.421 --> 00:48:14.141
So there's a lot you can do
there and then we've talked a bit

00:48:14.141 --> 00:48:16.091
about, do you take on the charity?

00:48:16.091 --> 00:48:17.921
Do you take on something alongside?

00:48:18.431 --> 00:48:19.391
You can if you want to.

00:48:19.721 --> 00:48:23.681
I'm not sure school governor will get
you that much further, to be honest.

00:48:24.011 --> 00:48:27.401
People often think, "Oh, well, maybe
I'll do some training around being

00:48:27.401 --> 00:48:30.371
a NED." I'm not sure that will get
you much further, frankly, either.

00:48:30.641 --> 00:48:32.621
I think that's possibly
a bad use of your money.

00:48:33.101 --> 00:48:38.831
Once you are actually thinking more
actively about retirement, then I think

00:48:39.041 --> 00:48:44.651
it becomes a campaign where you are
trying to harness, which is also, frankly,

00:48:44.651 --> 00:48:49.241
easier often when you're still serving,
you're trying to harness your network.

00:48:49.541 --> 00:48:54.827
You're trying to burnish your credentials
and you're trying to go out to the

00:48:54.827 --> 00:48:58.577
headhunters and just start to get
that first while you still have the

00:48:58.577 --> 00:49:01.847
currency of the executive career.

00:49:02.697 --> 00:49:03.467
Ralph Grayson: Marianne, thank you.

00:49:03.722 --> 00:49:08.012
This has been a fascinating insight into
how board careers are really built, the

00:49:08.012 --> 00:49:12.842
importance of reputation, relationships,
and judgement we've touched on, and

00:49:12.842 --> 00:49:17.132
why an impressive executive career
maybe does not automatically translate

00:49:17.672 --> 00:49:20.112
into a credible portfolio career.

00:49:21.192 --> 00:49:25.092
You've also certainly reminded me
that the board market is not simply

00:49:25.092 --> 00:49:27.252
about access, but about relevance.

00:49:28.052 --> 00:49:32.932
Before approaching somebody like
you, I think listeners should ask

00:49:32.932 --> 00:49:34.522
themselves some honest questions.

00:49:34.972 --> 00:49:37.852
What's the distinctive
value I bring to a board?

00:49:38.332 --> 00:49:40.732
How can I explain it clearly?

00:49:40.972 --> 00:49:43.882
Do I really understand the
responsibilities of a NED?

00:49:44.392 --> 00:49:47.332
And perhaps most importantly, am
I genuinely ready to contribute?

00:49:47.902 --> 00:49:53.402
Or am I just attracted by the
title or the stature or status?

00:49:53.812 --> 00:49:58.812
So for those listening who believe they
have the experience, the credibility,

00:49:58.812 --> 00:50:02.802
and the commitment to begin or further
develop their portfolio career,

00:50:03.162 --> 00:50:06.282
how should they decide whether it's
appropriate to connect with you?

00:50:06.702 --> 00:50:07.962
What's the best way to do so?

00:50:07.962 --> 00:50:11.286
And what information should they
provide to make that initial

00:50:11.346 --> 00:50:13.166
approach relevant and worthwhile?

00:50:13.616 --> 00:50:14.306
Marianne Macdonald: Thank you.

00:50:14.820 --> 00:50:16.560
It's not hard to get ahold of me.

00:50:17.093 --> 00:50:20.873
If you Google Marianne Macdonald
non-executive or something, you'll

00:50:20.903 --> 00:50:27.933
probably find me somewhere and my
career advisory firm has my email there.

00:50:28.323 --> 00:50:31.953
People also connect with me quite
often on LinkedIn, and I do look at

00:50:31.953 --> 00:50:33.843
LinkedIn, I do read those messages.

00:50:34.093 --> 00:50:35.893
Feel free to connect with me.

00:50:36.103 --> 00:50:40.353
But for the Board Directory, anyone
who's really been a partner of a

00:50:40.353 --> 00:50:43.123
big professional services firm,
anyone that's been involved with the

00:50:43.123 --> 00:50:48.803
business of small cap and upwards
I'm sure I could potentially help

00:50:48.803 --> 00:50:52.509
them through the Board Directory
and would be delighted to do that.

00:50:53.309 --> 00:50:53.949
Ralph Grayson: Thank you for your time.

00:50:54.269 --> 00:50:57.600
I hope we've shone a bit of a
light into somewhat of an opaque

00:50:58.200 --> 00:51:00.180
industry, if we can call it that.

00:51:00.300 --> 00:51:02.200
Thank you for your insights
and it's been a pleasure.

00:51:02.342 --> 00:51:03.712
Marianne Macdonald: Thank
you so much for having me.

00:51:04.036 --> 00:51:07.306
Ralph Grayson: I hope that you've enjoyed
listening to this podcast and have found

00:51:07.306 --> 00:51:11.566
it helpful when thinking about how to
approach your own path to the boardroom.

00:51:12.456 --> 00:51:15.596
If you would like to push this a
little bit further, Sainty Hird

00:51:15.616 --> 00:51:20.406
runs a bespoke one to one programme
designed specifically to this end.

00:51:20.741 --> 00:51:25.425
For more information, please visit
our website saintyhird.com, follow

00:51:25.425 --> 00:51:31.280
us on LinkedIn, and subscribe to the
Boardroom Path to receive new episodes.

00:51:31.626 --> 00:51:32.576
Thank you for listening.