Transformative Principal

Victor Karkar of Scrible gives principals a test for AI in student writing: does it build a skill or bypass it? Learn where AI helps students and where it hurts.

Show Notes

Victor Karkar, the brains behind the research and writing platform Scrible, gives principals one test for AI in education: does a tool help a student develop a skill, or bypass it? Teachers can use AI to save time. Students are in learning mode, and that changes the rules.

Karkar uses the calculator as his model. Students still learn long division by hand, then move on to calculators and spreadsheets. He applies the same order to writing and citations. He also tells how he challenged a chief academic officer in Texas to stop teaching math and just hand out calculators.

What you'll learn

  • Ask of any AI use whether it helps students develop a skill or bypasses the skill before they have it.
  • Separate teacher productivity use from student learning use before your staff argues about whether to embrace AI.
  • Map each activity in the writing process to the skill it builds, then decide where automation fits.
  • Teach citations by hand in late elementary so students see the value of attribution, then let tools take over.
  • Look at your homework: busy work pushes students toward shortcuts, so make the work worth doing.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Why embrace AI needs a clearer meaning
  • 4:49 Teacher productivity versus student learning
  • 6:06 Does AI build a skill or bypass it
  • 9:22 Calculators as a model for writing
  • 13:52 Teach citations by hand, then automate
  • 17:04 Learning mode versus working mode
  • 23:30 Lived experience bias in the AI debate
  • 28:28 Students must learn what good looks like

Times are for the episode without ads. Your player may be off by the length of any ads.

Questions this episode answers

Should schools just embrace AI because it is here to stay?
Karkar says it is true that AI is here to stay, but embrace it is too vague. A teacher using AI for lesson plans is not a student having it write a paper. His test: does it help develop a skill or bypass it? Bypassing a skill not yet learned is the problem.

Can we stop teaching writing now that AI can write a first draft?
Karkar says no. Calculators did not end teaching long division, and spell check did not end spelling. Students need foundational skills to know what good writing looks like and to catch AI output that is wrong but sounds confident.

When is it fine for students to automate citations?
Karkar would have students write citations by hand in late elementary, maybe early middle school, so they understand attribution. After that, tools can handle it so they focus on source quality, paper structure and the strength of their arguments.

About Victor Karkar

The brains behind Scrible, a web-based research and collaboration startup, with a background in Internet and biotech product management and business development.

Links and resources

Working on this at your school? Get a free preview of a 10-week leadership pathway built from episodes like this one at transformativeprincipal.com/start.


Thanks to our Sponsor Broadcast Made Easy who help you start a news broadcast at your school by having everything you need in one easy-to-download place. Check it out today and get your kids creating. 

We’re proud to be sponsored by IXL. 

IXL’s comprehensive teaching and learning platform for math, language arts, science, and social studies is accelerating achievement in 95 of the top 100 U.S. school districts. Loved by teachers and backed by independent research from Johns Hopkins University, IXL can help you do the following and more:
  • Simplify and streamline technology
  • Save teachers’ time
  • Reliably meet Tier 1 standards
  • Improve student performance on state assessments

🚀 Ready to see why leading districts trust IXL for their educational needs? Visit IXL.com/BE today to learn more about how IXL can elevate your school or district.

Creators and Guests

Host
Jethro Jones

What is Transformative Principal?

Jethro Jones interviews instructional leaders from around the nation to learn and teach what it takes to become a transformative principal. Episodes address topics like Response to Intervention (RTI), Multi-Tiered System of Support (MTSS), Positive Behavior Interventions and Supports (PBIS), the latest advances in educational research, standards-based grading, and interviews with industry leaders like Bill Daggett, Rick Wormeli, Todd Whitaker and even people outside the education like Seth Godin, JeVon McCormick, Liz Wiseman, and more.

If you've been thinking about news broadcast, but don't know where to start and don't want to have that lift, use broadcastmadeeasy.com to make it super easy for yourself. I am really excited about our sponsor, Broadcast Made Easy. As a principal, I created a daily news show at all of my schools, but you know what? It took a ton of work. Broadcast Made Easy makes it super simple for you to get started.

They provide templates, scripts, job descriptions, applications, the whole nine yards. You buy it once, no subscription, and it makes getting started so much easier. Another thing they have is specific videos for every holiday you could possibly imagine. So that as part of your news broadcast, you can share what holidays are coming up, less than a minute, and very simple, straightforward, just the facts that makes it really easy to start conversations about those holidays.

So go check it out at broadcastmadeeasy.com and let them know that you heard about it on Transformative Principle. That's broadcastmadeeasy.com. This B Podcast Network show is presented by IXL. IXL's all-inclusive online teaching and learning platform simplifies edtech needs and accelerates achievement in 95 of the top 100 U.S. school districts. IXL delivers personalized learning across a comprehensive pre-K-12 curriculum, including math, language arts, science, and social studies, and helps you assess student performance through actionable, real-time insights at every level of your school or district.

This one solution performs work that typically requires dozens of tools. Want to find out why so many leading districts trust IXL? Visit IXL.com slash B-E. That's IXL.com slash B-E. Welcome to Transformative Principle. Today I'm excited to have Victor Karkar on the program. He's the brain behind Scribble, a game-changing startup that's shaking up the way we do web-based research and collaboration. He is also one of the sponsors of this Summer of AI series, and we're grateful to have Scribble as a sponsor here.

He was an instrumental part of the early team at insuranceorder.com, a startup that got bought by a Fortune 500 giant, Marsh, and McLennan. McLennan, excuse me. And he's also done some venture work, and he's been done a lot of different things. Designer, product developer, tester, marketer. He's also a tech nerd, a debate person, and loves dreaming about good things and creating ways for people to change the world.

So, Victor, welcome to Transformative Principle. Happy to have you here. Thank you. It's great to be with you. So, you and I talked a few weeks ago about a lot of different things, and we've been doing all these interviews about artificial intelligence, and we've had a lot of different ideas about we don't need to teach writing anymore. Like, we can just have the computer do it. We've talked about banning AI.

We've talked about all these different things. And you have two perspectives that I think are important. One is the idea of embracing AI because it's here to stay and using it myself, and that's great. And so, can you talk about those two ideas of how we should approach that and why those phrases are, like, maybe not the best for what we're trying to do with the rising generation?

Yeah, sure. And maybe a little context will be helpful as well. I think in your introduction, you described Scribble as a kind of research and collaboration platform, which it is. But the reason why I think the work we're doing and the conversation we're having now is relevant in a sharp way with the AI stuff going on in schools right now is that beyond research, we are in the writing process, right?

So, research and writing oftentimes go together for evidence-based writing. And so, we're thinking deeply about the impact of AI on writing. And as most folks who are listening to this probably already heard and know, there's a lot of sort of anxiety and opportunity around AI, right? So, the opportunity is, there's this amazing technology that can do all these amazing things. And the anxiety part is worrying about student misuse around AI and AI plagiarism is kind of like the key thing that really is holding people back and causing some concern.

So, just a little bit of context for why, you know, we've got something to say about the writing process. The work that we do very much spans across research and writing. So, it's through that lens that I've been having lots of conversations with district leaders in K-12, as well as, you know, college leaders, which community college presidents, for example, VPs of academic affairs, et cetera, in higher ed as well.

And, you know, I've been having these conversations, honestly, since about January of this year, so 2023, to try to understand what people's reactions are to both the positive and negative or like the benefits and the potential risks around AI. And I've managed to kind of like boil those down as some sort of profiles that I see that when somebody's saying something to me, why are they saying it?

And what is their frame of reference when they're talking about the pluses and the minuses of this new AI era that we're entering into? And so, to address kind of the first thing that you mentioned, which is we've just got to embrace it because it's here to stay. I've heard a lot of people say that. And, you know, my view on that, having listened to that and listened to the supporting statements around that, is that that's not wrong.

Actually, saying that it's here to stay, that the genie's not going to go back in the bottle, this is out in the consumer market, students have access to it, everybody's using it, is true. And I think saying that we've got to embrace it because it's here to stay is, I would say, yes, but, you know, yes, but what are we actually talking about when we say we've got to embrace it, right?

What do we actually mean when we say embrace it? Because there's different ways to use it. And when you say just embrace it, that's a catch-all term. And so, what I've been saying is that the folks that typically are in a school or a district that are having disagreements about what to do with the AI, I've sort of seen at least two camps emerge, right? There's the folks that are really focused on the risk, which is sort of like, just as an example, English teachers that are worried about students actually using chat GPT, for example, to write the papers for them instead of doing the work themselves.

And then at the other end of the spectrum, you have early adopters that are teachers, let's say, that might be using chat GPT to generate lesson plans, which saves them a ton of time. Or I've had superintendents say that they're using it to write graduation speeches or reference letters, right? And what's interesting to me is that I think actually both camps are actually right. The problem is we're not all talking about the same thing.

So when we say we have to embrace AI, it's here to stay, my response is yes, but what does that actually mean, right? And, you know, a teacher using it for lesson planning is not the same thing as a student potentially misusing the same technology to do the work for them. And so oftentimes we talk about teaching and learning together. It just goes together. But actually, I think what's part of what's happening here is that actually teaching and learning sort of diverge a little bit here where teacher use and student use are different things.

And to have an administrator or a teacher use it for their work to be productive, to save time, et cetera, is probably not just okay. It's actually probably recommended a great idea because you're in sort of a productivity mode as an adult in the workplace. But that's very, very different from a student whose primary role is to develop cognitive skills and to learn and to develop their own sort of mental abilities.

And so my clarification really is that when we say we've got to embrace it because it's here to stay, I say, yes, but what are we actually talking about? And one of my concerns is that in that sort of catch-all term, people are conflating the two and we're actually talking past one another. The folks that are actually concerned about the downside risks when it comes to student misuse are not talking about the same thing as the administrators and the teachers that are saying, here are all the potential benefits that even I've experienced.

And so I think it's really important to be very clear about what we're talking about, if that makes sense.

If the AI can help. If you've been listening to Transformative Principle for any amount of time, you know that I have a love-hate relationship with ed tech. We have the ability to personalize learning for every single one of our students. And yet, so many of our ed tech tools fall short. We need our technology to do more for us. That's why it's so important for me to know that IXL provides true personalized learning across the entire pre-K-12 curriculum and that it's proven to benefit all student populations, including English language learners and students in special ed programs.

As a principal, I've used this in my school. As a parent, I've had my children use it as well. And let me tell you, this is a tool that definitely helps students learn and practice better. IXL is research proven to accelerate achievement. Studies across 45 states show the IXL schools outperform non-IXL schools on state assessments. And independent research from Johns Hopkins University verifies the IXL meets ESSA Tier 1 standards.

With those results combined with IXL's teacher-friendly reputation, what more could you ask for? Now, you also know that I don't care so much about test scores, but I know that they are legislatively convenient and something that we have to deal with and manage on a day-to-day basis. If you can implement something that is easy and effective, why wouldn't you do it? If you have a goal to increase achievement for all students, make sure to find out what IXL can do for you.

Visit IXL.com slash B for a demo. That's IXL.com slash B E. If you need to develop those cognitive skills, then yes, you should be using it. If the AI is hindering those cognitive skills, then you should not be using it. And so that's where this idea of there's a very real difference between having the AI write a paper for you and having the AI help you write a paper.

And those are two different things. And one of them, the AI writing the paper for you is not helpful with your cognitive skills because it's doing all of the work and you're going to copy and paste it and put it in. The AI helping you write a paper is actually helping with your cognitive skills if it's actually doing that. And if it's not, so for an example, in my doctoral program right now, I'm taking classes after I write papers and I'm using the AI in different ways in a couple of different things.

Number one, I'm having it help me find, go through things that I've written previously and connect them to what I'm talking about now so that it's not just me only being able to remember what I've written and I've written a lot. It's about helping me phrase things in a way that are better. And so if I were to just copy and paste straight from the AI into my submission, that would not make, that would not be helpful to me, except in the fact that I'm just trying to get it done and check off a box.

And in school, there is some of that also, right? So that's a reality. But if I'm really trying to improve the way that I'm thinking, then it's just as helpful for me to use the AI as a coach as it is for me to email back and forth with another classmate or professor and figure out how to reframe my argument so that it actually makes sense. That's the kind of thing that I hear you saying perfectly clear is doing the work for you is not helping the cognitive skills develop.

100%. So I agree with that 100%. And actually, I, similar to what you said, I've actually kind of been talking about kind of a litmus test for automation, the use of automation in education, right? And so AI is, at the end of the day, just another automation. It's a mind-blowingly next-level automation, but at the end of the day, it's a type of automation. And we've had other automations in education before, right?

All kinds. The internet calculators come up all the time. We're talking to people about what happens with AI in the writing process because they kind of reference, oh, remember when calculators came in? And we freaked out about that, destroying math education, but it didn't do that. We figured out how to incorporate it. So I think what's interesting to me is the litmus test I've kind of developed mentally for kind of using automations in education are, does it basically help develop or bypass the development of a skill?

And my way of thinking about it is, if it helps basically bypass the development, that could be problematic. But if you've already developed the skill so that you can basically bypass that now so you can focus on developing something else, then that's okay, right? And so I think math actually provides a pretty good example of how we can maybe think about this for writing. I think at the end of the day, it's really just a question of the right amount of automation at the right time in the journey.

And it's okay to have increasing levels of automation as skills are mastered as you go through that process. And so, again, going back to the calculator example, which, again, if I had, you know, a dollar every time somebody mentioned the math and calculator example, when I've had these AI conversations, it would be great. But we sort of say, like, just because we have the calculator doesn't mean that we stop teaching kids how to do long division by hand when they're in elementary school, right?

But then it's sort of like they learn that skill, and then it's okay to give them a calculator to move on to other things. So you save time on doing things that will be really hard and time-consuming to do manually, and you can move on to developing other cognitive skills that are important, that are more sophisticated. And so there's a progression where, at the beginning, you do things by hand, then you have a calculator, and at some point, you use a spreadsheet, and then you move on to software, like maybe you're in graduate school or you're in college and you're using SAS and R and things like that for statistical software.

So I think there's a really interesting analogy there that we could potentially think about as a model for what happens now going forward for writing. And I'd argue it's actually, we've already been down, started down this path, we just didn't know it in a way. The AI stuff now, and its impact on the writing process, is bringing it into focus, and it's really challenging the way we've always done things.

And in some way, it may be a good forcing function to think about what's important and when we do things and why we do things. But I think the math analogy, there's already the start of it in writing. And the example I give is that just because we have spell check doesn't mean we don't teach students how to spell it properly. Just because we have grammar check doesn't mean that we gave up on teaching them grammar.

And I think just because we have ChatGPT that can literally write a decent first draft doesn't mean that we don't teach the skills that are really important and foundational for how to do essentially original content creation for the first draft. So anyway, it's a long sort of extension of what you were saying, but I think at the end of the day, it really is about skills development.

And it's okay to use technology, and you probably should. You just have to be careful and make sure that for the particular activity you're doing, it's not actually essentially outsourcing the thinking and outsourcing the skill development and bypassing it as a result. Does that make sense? Yeah, it totally does. And I think a good example of that is citations and bibliographies. Like, why in the world would you type all of that out by hand when you can put it in something like EasyBib and say, here's the source.

Give me a bibliography using these sources. It makes no sense to do anything other than that. And because once you know how to do that, you know how tedious and slow it is, and it's a formulaic thing, you might as well have a computer do it because that's what computers are really good at. And, you know, I think that as we talk about these things more and more, we really have to get granular about what it is that we're actually talking about.

And we can't just say, oh, yeah, let's use AI or let's not use AI. We have to say, what's the purpose? What's the intent that we're trying to get at? And how is this helping the goal of what we're trying to accomplish? And if it's not helping the goal, then we should ditch it. State assessments are a good example of that. State assessments really don't help with our goal of educating kids.

Everybody agrees about that. And yet we still do them. We don't stand up and say, no, I'm not going to do this anymore. We just go along with it because it's quote unquote required. And there needs to be some civil disobedience around things that are bad for our kids. And we're not at a point where we have the courage to do that just yet. Yeah. And I think the granularity piece, I actually think is, is totally right.

Because I think with this, like a lot of things, the devil's in the details, right? If you're not being specific about what it is that the technology is doing and what, what learning outcome or what learning goal it's supporting or, or undermining, then you're likely to just apply it and not be aware of like what it's negative or positive impacts really are. So one of the things that I'm excited about that I think we're going to be doing in the future is that really trying to map activities in the writing process to specific skills that will be developed along the way.

Once you do that, then you can know that if I apply an automation to this part of the writing process or to this activity, that it's actually, then you kind of know like, okay, is it actually developing this or is it bypassing this? If they've already developed the skill because we did it without automation, now it's okay to automate that because we've already learned that skill. Doing that mapping of what's the skill or the, sorry, of what's the activity to the skill is something that we're, I think, going to be doing in the future to help kind of make that granularity more clear.

Then it becomes much easier to sort of say, okay, it's okay to use it for this. It's not okay to use it for that because this is where the student is in the journey. And just because you mentioned easy video, I will tell you that we also in our work allow for, you know, automated citation stuff happening inside of the, inside of our product. But one of the things that is really interesting to me is because we have conversations all the time with librarians and sometimes we'll get an old school librarian that'll be like, oh, you're making it too easy, right?

Like you're doing this automated citation extraction stuff. And I sort of say, look, I get it. And I would say that I don't disagree, but I think we're logically consistent. We sort of say, look, we, if you feel like, again, automating the citation stuff is somehow hurting the student's ability to understand the value of that, then I'd say, yes, you should do it the old school way, you know, by hand, probably in late elementary, maybe even early middle school, but hopefully late elementary.

So they understand the value of what attribution is and what are all the different components that go into it. The question becomes, do you want them to continue then having to do that throughout middle school, high school, college, et cetera? And the answer is most people would say no, because once they've understood what the purpose of that is, what the value of a citation is, the value of attribution and giving credit to original author, they've learned that lesson.

And now the question is, do you want them to have to reinvent the wheel every time they write a paper? And most people, I think, would agree that no, that's not the best use of time. Once they've learned that lesson, then give them technology like we have in Scribble or other citation tools that are out there to help them bypass that so they can focus on other things that are more important, like the looking at the quality of the sources, the structure of the paper, the strength of the arguments, those kinds of things, right?

So I think in that way, we are actually logically consistent in what we preach, that you should probably do things the old school, non-technology way at a certain point in the journey. But the question is, at what point do you then switch, like in the calculator example, to doing things that allow students to focus their time and effort on other skills? Yeah, exactly. And going back to the idea of the mapping the activities to the skills that are being developed, what I love about that approach is that you're saying, you're not just saying, here's a task to do, you're saying, here's the skill that you need to learn.

And in education, we often are like posting learning objectives and saying, this is what we want you to learn. But if you can be really particular about the reason why you're writing this paper by hand is to learn this skill of transferring thoughts from your brain to your hand, you can't do that any other way than by writing it out. And so we're intentionally going to slow everything down and force you to write by hand so that you can see what this process is like.

Once you see what that process is like, then it's OK to start typing on the computer because you're understanding how difficult it is to get things from your brain down onto paper. And short-circuiting that would be unwise because that's the skill we really want you to develop. And I think that that is really a powerful approach to that. Here's the truth. School leadership is demanding. It's rewarding, but it can also feel lonely and so overwhelming sometimes.

That's why we created Linked Leaders, to make sure great leaders keep leading and good leaders get the support to become great. At Linked Leaders, you're never on your own. Whether you're building culture, navigating board relations, or tackling special education challenges, you'll find solutions from leaders who've been in your shoes. And the best part, you don't have to wait months for a big conference or spend thousands of dollars hoping to make the right connection.

With Linked Leaders, you can log in today, get straight answers from experienced mentors, and walk away with a playbook that works right when you need it. Linked Leaders is efficient, personalized support that keeps you moving forward. Sign up for free at LinkedLeaders.com. The second piece that you mentioned is this idea of, I use this for myself, therefore, we should have schools adopting it. And why is that not a good approach for the rising generation?

So, it's connected to what I said earlier about the example of a teacher using it for lesson planning or an administrator using it for other things like we talked about, versus a student using it, you know, in schooling. But I'll go a little further than that. Let me kind of do the first part first. I've had so many people say, I use it for work, it's great, right?

And what I sort of say is that what I see happening is a bit of conflating of what I call learning mode with working mode, or cognitive development mode with productivity mode. And that is that our students that are going through the K-12 system, going through schooling, even in higher ed to some extent, or maybe to a great extent, their goal and our hope and goals for them is cognitive development, skills development, self-development, training yourself to be able to think critically, to be down the road, a good employee and a good citizen, right?

As a result of that, optimizing learning. That is very different from what we expect of people and what we want, how they want, we want them to be when they're an employee, when they're, you know, even an adult kind of in the workplace or in society. In those environments, you're a team member, you're trying to support your team and your organization and their development. Maybe you're trying to contribute to your employer, to society.

And in that environment, you are trying to optimize your productivity to serve those goals as best as you can. And to that extent, and to that end, essentially any tool you use, as long as it's sort of ethical and doesn't break any laws, is going to help you get that work done, right? And I think what I see happening is adults, whether they be in the work environment, but particularly in education, let's say administrators and teachers that are saying, this thing is amazing.

It's helping me be more productive. And so they sort of, I think I've seen folks sort of make sort of a blanket statement that we need to embrace this. And I sort of say, well, you got to be careful. You have to draw a line between that kind of learning mode and working mode. We can't conflate the two, right? You should certainly be using it to do what you need to do.

If that approach then makes it so that students aren't actually getting that cognitive development, that's the problem. And so drawing that line, I think, is very, very important between what a student does and what their goal is and what we hope for them to develop versus what, you know, an employee or a team member does in the working environment. So that's part one. Does that make sense?

Yeah. And I want to pause there for just a second because I think it's so powerful because schools are not about productivity. They're about learning, or at least they should be. And yet a lot of what we do is about productivity. All these assignments that need to be done, homework every day, all that stuff is not about learning. It's about productivity. And so if that is the goal of the school, which may be the unstated and unintended goal, then, yeah, maybe it makes sense to bring in more AI stuff so that things can be automated more.

But if you really sat down and said, is the goal productivity or learning, teachers would say the goal is learning, but their actions may not show that. And that's an important thing for teachers to discuss and say, what is our goal? What are we really trying to do? I'm really glad you brought that up, that reframed it in a different way for me in my mind. That is really powerful.

Go on. Yeah, no problem. And just to add on that before I go to part two, I would say it's not that homework and all these things don't meet that goal or can't meet that goal. I think obviously students doing work, doing homework, doing other project-based learning, whatever it is that they're doing, those things hopefully do and are intended to support cognitive development and learning. But again, the devil's in the details, right?

You really have to ask, are you designing homework and work that is actually doing that or does it feel like busy work? And actually, as a tangent, I'll just mention something we can come back to later. I think when the student feels like it's actually just busy work to cross off the list, that's when you get folks wanting to take the shortcuts because they don't see it as actually adding value to their rights or to their development.

And I think in that arena, that's when they're more likely to take a shortcut, like using technology to do the work for them. So it's a separate topic we can come back to about motivation and making sure that the work is actually relevant and they can see the value in the work you're assigning to them, frankly. And that's a lesson I think that a lot of people kind of learned during the pandemic.

Sorry, I'm going further down this tangent, but maybe this is worth mentioning because it is still 2023 and we're just out of the pandemic. One of the things I learned and I saw happening during the pandemic was so many educators saying, well, we're on remote learning and the kids are at home, but they've turned out their cameras and I don't really know if they're there, if they're paying attention, etc.

And that was a lesson during the pandemic that I feel like we should have taken and internalized to actually change a lot of what we're doing going forward. Because what the pandemic and that remote learning environment that showed us is historically we relied heavily on compliance, right? The students are in front of me in the class, they're captive audience, they have to listen to what I'm saying.

And if they're not being engaged, if they're not doing the work, I can use sort of social group techniques, not in a malicious way, but just to kind of try to get them engaged. I can say, hey, cold call on somebody and the peer pressure of having them be there and have to say something kind of keeps them on their toes and gets them engaged and whatnot.

Well, when all that falls away during the pandemic and they're at home and you can't rely on the compliance model because they're not a captive audience in front of you, all you have that you can rely on is inspiration and motivation. That's it, right? All you can do is sort of give them something that you think will get them interested to actually want to do the work and engage in the content.

And I think that's a lesson that we should, that unfortunately I feel like we may forget, but I really feel like we should not. We should really sort of say that should have been a lesson that going forward, you know, we'll have compliance because that's the world. But the primary goal should be to try to inspire and motivate because that will yield stronger results and actually yield authentic learning in a way that compliance doesn't.

And I'd argue in writing, that's also true. Yeah, totally. The way that I have phrased that so many times on this podcast is when the pandemic happened, kids realized that everything was made up and it was all fake. And that's what we told them and they figured it out and they knew they'd been lied to for their whole entire lives. And that's really what happened because when we didn't have all those structures in place, all that compliance, then so many kids checked out and, and chose to, and for, in some situations, very good reason.

All right. I've talked about that a lot. So let's move on to part two of this. I use it myself. Yeah. Yeah. So part two is, and it's connected to part one, but it's a little bit different is that when I've seen. Adults, I probably put this in the realm of education administrators and some teachers, but mostly administrators that I've talked to that have tried ChatGPT and are actually using it.

And again, have embraced it because they like it. I've sort of noticed sort of two profiles that are kind of like two sides of the same coin where you've got folks that are good writers and folks that are not good writers, right? So the folks that are good writers say, this thing is amazing. Like I'm, I'm a fine writer, but this thing saves me so much time.

And the flip side of that coin is somebody that's embraced ChatGPT because they acknowledge that they're not a strong writer. And this thing is a godsend because basically it helps them sound so much better. And, you know, what they produce is so much better than what they could have done on their own. And what's interesting to me is in both cases, they're saying, let's embrace it because this thing has had a positive impact on their lives.

Either time savings or actually being transformative in how they, how their writing is received by other folks. And what I say is that's fine that it's helping you, right? But I think it's important not to let what it does for you necessarily strongly influence or shape what we ought to be doing for the next generation that's coming up. And the reason for that is what you're expressing to me when you say that we have to embrace it in our schools.

What you're showing to me is what I've been calling kind of a lived experience bias, which is that, hey, I was not, you know, I was not a great writer growing up and I'm still not a great writer now. And maybe that's because you don't have that natural ability to a certain extent, or maybe what we're more likely scenario is that you just weren't taught it well.

Because unfortunately, there's data that shows that when our teachers go through, you know, the certification and training programs in this country, there's very little of that time that they're spending on writing instruction and assessment. So the reality is that's a broader problem that we could talk about another time. But the reality is that you're probably not a great writer, partly because it was never taught to you well, right?

And so whatever your reason is, either you were in that situation or you were not naturally talented or interested in that, or on the flip side of the coin, if you are a great writer, maybe you were naturally talented, or maybe you were one of the lucky few that actually had a great teacher that taught you how to write well and spent a lot of time on it, emphasized that and gave you feedback and all that stuff that we hope is happening.

But whatever that is, regardless of which bucket you're in, the point is, that was your experience, right? And you right now, as an adult, if you're sort of saying, well, we just need to kind of throw AI into the classroom, you're not looking at it from a clean slate perspective, right? What you have to think about is what is a 15-year-old student or a 12-year-old student who doesn't have either one of those lived experiences, what's best for them, right?

And we need to be able to provide them the experiences and the tools and the support to be able to learn those skills and to be able to become great writers independent of whatever your lived experience is. And so I sort of say we need to come at it from a first principles perspective and be very careful not to let our lived experience bias influence too strongly what we ought to be doing for the next generation.

I don't know if that makes sense. I've kind of explained that a couple of different ways, but does that make sense? Yeah, that totally does. And what I'm hearing you say is a good writer or a poor writer knows how ChatGPT is helping because they've already had those experiences. But if a student comes in and starts using it and doesn't know what those experiences are, they're actually not going to see the value in the tool either because they haven't had those experiences or they don't know what good writing looks like or they don't know how to comprehend that this is any different.

Like the people taking this to a different thing of technology, which is cell phones and iPads and things like that, that people say that kids are digital natives. I've hated that word for a long time. The difference is, is that kids really just aren't afraid of breaking something. They, like you and I probably, haven't grown up with technology that they actually could break. Like I started using MS-DOS and I could type the wrong thing in and I could destroy my whole entire computer and have to start over.

And, and I could download viruses off the internet when the internet came about. Those things, they can still happen, but it's a lot less likely for a kid to be able to ruin their iPhone by, by going to a malicious website. They can install spyware and things like that for sure, but they, they, a lot more difficult to break it. And so that's really the difference. So we have this experience of, if I don't know and understand how to use this, then I'm afraid of it.

Whereas kids are like, I don't know what this is. I'm just going to tap things until I get what I want. They're, they're just not afraid of breaking stuff. And that's really my version of what you're talking about here.

Interesting. I think that what you just said, I think kind of played off of what I was saying earlier that I'd like to respond to is that you said, you know, they, they're not necessarily going to know what good looks like. And to me, that's actually really, really important. I think that if we don't give them the ability to sort of learn the foundational skills without technology or with minimal technology or with, again, scaled up scaffolded technology over time, we kind of take the shortcut and let them just use it to kind of create the first draft from a very early age without those foundational skills being developed first.

We run into a, we run into a situation and we will over time have a world in which people won't know what good looks like, right? Because they weren't taught that we kind of, we kind of bypass that skill. And I think that's personally, I think that's a problem and that's not what I want to see happen. I think it's really important that folks have some basic understanding of what's happening under the hood when they're using automation and technology, right?

And that's why I like the idea that even though we have calculators, we do teach students how to do foundational stuff without the calculator to start with. And I remember having this conversation with a kind of a high profile chief academic officer of a very large district in Texas. And they made the analogy of this. So said, well, essentially he didn't use the words like we don't need to teach writing anymore, but he sort of gave this analogy of like, well, I've got this phone in my hand.

When I was a student, I had to used to go to the library and all that. I don't have to do that anymore. I can just use this. Isn't that really what we ought to be doing now going forward with this chat GPT stuff? And I sort of said, look, we can have a long discussion about it, but if you really kind of believe what you're telling me now, I challenge you to stop teaching kids how to do math by hand.

You know, and just give them calculators. And I think when you make it that crisp and clear and you sort of say, like, if you really believe what that, if you really kind of believe that this technology is going to obviate the need for that foundational skill development in a way. Okay. We hold your feet to the fire. You actually stop teaching math, just give them calculators.

And he kind of took a step back and he's like, okay, I see what you're saying. But I think that's the point is that we want them to know what good looks like. And if you don't develop the foundational skills, it's really hard to know when you get an output out of whatever the automation or the technology is that is, that is problematic. And I'd argue it's actually more important with the chat GPT and writing stuff than it is for math.

Because with the calculator, it's discreet. It's probably very unlikely you're going to get a wrong output. You just may not know what's happening inside the black box. With chat GPT and the other AI, we know from at least what we know so far that it is possible for actually to produce incorrect things and tell you that very confidently. And for you to believe that it's right because it's maybe right most of the time, right?

Because maybe the training data doesn't cover certain topics or maybe there are other issues with it, right? We've heard of this concept of them hallucinating. So I think even more than in math and calculator analogy for this writing and chat GPT stuff, I think it's really important that we make sure they understand to have a certain level of skepticism and to know that like you have to double check your facts and you have to be able to kind of think critically about this because not everything it tells you, at least at this point in time, is going to be believable.

And so that's why I think teaching them what good looks like and teaching them the foundational skills to think critically about it and not just accept it as being correct all the time is really, really important. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, this, this, I think you're right on this. I think it's great. Appreciate you saying that. The real thing with calculators is kids still need number sense. And that's really, that's why we teach the base.

So they have a number sense. They need a sense of literacy with writing as well. They need to understand what they're saying and what things are. So this is really good. Once again, Victor, it's the Scribble.com, S-C-R-I-B-L-E, one B, not two Bs, .com. Be sure to go and check that out. Thank you again for being part of Transformative Principle. This has been awesome. Is there any other way you want people to connect with you besides just going to Scribble.com?

No, that's pretty good. We have an increasing sort of presence on LinkedIn. So that's always good. But yeah, connect with us. We'd love to help you as best we can make this transition to this whole AI era. We're thinking very deeply about both the risks as well as the transformational benefits of AI. And I think that one of the things that I can say is that we're thinking deeply about how to integrate AI into what we've done for the writing process going forward.

And that's stuff people see from us going forward. But what we've been able to do and what we can help with right now is actually help mitigate some of the downside risks that people are freaking out about because we're really able to shift assessment for writing from the end work product to the process. And I think that's kind of an emerging best practice for assessment in the AI era.

So we can help you with that now and you'll see good stuff from us that's more AI infused going forward. Very cool. Hey, man, I appreciate you being here and thanks so much for your time and for your deep thoughts about this. It's been a different interview than what we've done already. So I appreciate you being so thoughtful and sharing that with us. Happy to do it.

It's an engaging conversation. And these are all the important conversations we need to have right now in this transition period. So happy to do it.

Edited by Gage Sanderson. Do you want to simplify your school's technology, save teachers time, improve students' performance on state assessments? You can do it all. But don't waste another minute. Head straight to IXL.com slash BE to learn how IXL's research-proven teaching and learning platform can help you achieve all these goals. That's IXL.com slash BE. When I was a principal at a Title I elementary school, we had Playworks and it dramatically changed how our school functioned.

Kids show up to school when they want to be there and that's the whole idea behind Playworks. What they do is they train staff to build belonging and connection right into recess so the kids feel connected and want to come back. They have tons of games that they teach the kids that are fun, enjoyable, and games where either everybody wins or the loss gets you back in the game very quickly.

One principal put it, when the teacher hops in the game and everyone's playing together, that builds camaraderie between students and adults. And the research backs it up. There was a UC Berkeley study that found that Title I schools partnering with Playworks had significantly lower chronic absenteeism. If you're thinking about attendance this year, and we all are, visit Playworks.org slash podcast to get the 30-day attendance reset and additional helpful resources that you can implement today.

Don't wait on this.