1
00:00:00,195 --> 00:00:01,787
Coming up on The Thin Veil

2
00:00:02,106 --> 00:00:04,277
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: I
was part of the DEI industry, and

3
00:00:04,277 --> 00:00:05,815
I was ousted from my position.

4
00:00:06,066 --> 00:00:10,344
I kept seeing this Palestine
exception we talk about human rights

5
00:00:10,344 --> 00:00:12,569
for everyone except Palestinians.

6
00:00:12,999 --> 00:00:19,965
how do you feel about Jewish identity
being weaponized for the state of

7
00:00:19,965 --> 00:00:25,633
Israel When we think of people as
monsters, we fail to understand that

8
00:00:25,658 --> 00:00:30,642
ordinary human beings are capable
of extraordinarily horrible things.

9
00:00:30,928 --> 00:00:35,938
Like what happened in the Nazi
Holocaust of Jews is being repeated

10
00:00:36,263 --> 00:00:38,106
Ezra Lipp: I did wanna talk
about armed resistance,

11
00:00:38,275 --> 00:00:40,998
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: we're
talking about Israeli society at large.

12
00:00:41,018 --> 00:00:43,636
what do we do with a society like this?

13
00:00:44,130 --> 00:00:44,470
Ezra Lipp: Well,

14
00:00:45,132 --> 00:00:45,913
do you have an answer?

15
00:00:52,064 --> 00:00:57,476
Well, hello and welcome back to
The Thin Veil with Ezra Lipp.

16
00:00:57,509 --> 00:00:59,551
I am your host, Ezra Lipp.

17
00:01:00,104 --> 00:01:07,224
I am a musician and Jewish-born
anti-Zionist advocate and activist,

18
00:01:08,158 --> 00:01:11,771
always on a continuous journey
of learning and unlearning.

19
00:01:12,213 --> 00:01:15,495
if you're a first-time listener,
thank you for being here.

20
00:01:15,557 --> 00:01:18,066
If you're coming back,
thank you for coming back.

21
00:01:18,081 --> 00:01:21,165
Uh, I'm not much of an analytics guy.

22
00:01:21,445 --> 00:01:26,694
I just try to do what I do and get it out
there and hope, uh, it lands with people.

23
00:01:26,694 --> 00:01:32,918
But I will say, I was digging into
some of the, uh, backend podcast stats

24
00:01:32,931 --> 00:01:42,903
and, turns out, as far as podcasts
go that focus on Palestine, hosted

25
00:01:42,903 --> 00:01:51,926
by Jewish anti-Zionists based in
Sacramento, that also are musicians,

26
00:01:52,276 --> 00:01:58,136
that create in multiple genres but most
established in improvisational rock,

27
00:01:58,634 --> 00:02:02,680
The Thin Veil is number one, and
that's because of listeners like you.

28
00:02:02,682 --> 00:02:06,301
So thank you so much for getting
us, uh, number one in the charts

29
00:02:06,301 --> 00:02:07,967
of that highly niche genre.

30
00:02:08,608 --> 00:02:11,321
And, um, we're just gonna
keep, keep rolling here.

31
00:02:11,322 --> 00:02:12,509
So thank you for your support.

32
00:02:12,515 --> 00:02:15,881
please leave a rating, a review
wherever you're listening.

33
00:02:15,899 --> 00:02:20,614
hit the notification, share, and please
sign up for the Patreon or leave a

34
00:02:20,616 --> 00:02:23,171
one-time donation or tip on Ko-fi.

35
00:02:23,506 --> 00:02:27,386
We'd also like to draw attention
in this episode to Al-Tuffah

36
00:02:27,488 --> 00:02:30,132
School and Kindergarten in Gaza.

37
00:02:30,433 --> 00:02:34,461
and later on in the episode, you will
hear more about that, as well as a

38
00:02:34,462 --> 00:02:38,629
special message prepared just for "Thin
Veil" listeners from the school in

39
00:02:38,630 --> 00:02:44,918
Gaza My guest today is an award-winning
public speaker, sociologist, media

40
00:02:44,919 --> 00:02:47,122
commentator, and social justice advocate.

41
00:02:47,912 --> 00:02:51,793
She has spent much of her career studying
and speaking about identity, culture,

42
00:02:51,808 --> 00:02:54,258
colonialism, and systemic inequality.

43
00:02:54,897 --> 00:02:58,449
She formerly taught sociology and
criminology at Sheridan College

44
00:02:58,450 --> 00:03:02,433
in Canada, where she also served
as a senior advisor on DEI.

45
00:03:03,105 --> 00:03:07,311
However, following her advocacy for
Palestinian rights, she was forced

46
00:03:07,312 --> 00:03:11,454
to resign from her advisory position
and later lost her teaching position.

47
00:03:12,612 --> 00:03:17,991
That experience helped inspire her new
book, called "DEI Undone: The Rise,

48
00:03:18,081 --> 00:03:22,831
Fall, and Rebirth of Diversity, Equity,
and Inclusion," which examines how

49
00:03:22,831 --> 00:03:27,306
institutional DEI initiatives can become
disconnected from the very movements

50
00:03:27,313 --> 00:03:29,502
for justice they claim to support.

51
00:03:30,067 --> 00:03:35,870
Of course, I am talking about the one
and only Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar Saddiqui.

52
00:03:36,376 --> 00:03:41,446
Dr. Sabreena has also launched a brand
new independent documentary series

53
00:03:41,470 --> 00:03:45,603
called "The Rest," which explores
culture, history, and identity through

54
00:03:45,604 --> 00:03:49,950
the personal stories and everyday
experiences of people whose voices are

55
00:03:49,951 --> 00:03:52,119
too often overlooked or marginalized.

56
00:03:52,684 --> 00:03:53,879
I love Dr. Sabreena.

57
00:03:53,937 --> 00:03:56,016
It was such a pleasure getting
to know her for this show.

58
00:03:56,018 --> 00:03:58,004
We got to speak multiple times.

59
00:03:58,587 --> 00:03:59,562
she's brilliant.

60
00:03:59,850 --> 00:04:03,844
we did not get to speak, about
"The Rest," her new series, but I

61
00:04:04,109 --> 00:04:05,756
highly recommend checking it out.

62
00:04:05,781 --> 00:04:10,706
It is, something you can learn from,
but it is not too heavy like some,

63
00:04:11,111 --> 00:04:14,561
programs that look at the history
of, uh, you know, colonialism

64
00:04:14,561 --> 00:04:16,125
through people's life stories are.

65
00:04:16,386 --> 00:04:21,012
It's something I could watch with my wife,
at nighttime, which I'm grateful for.

66
00:04:21,379 --> 00:04:25,836
anyway, this conversation leaves
me wanting more and leaves

67
00:04:25,838 --> 00:04:27,799
me with unresolved questions.

68
00:04:27,825 --> 00:04:31,682
But like good conversations,
I, I think that's indicative

69
00:04:31,688 --> 00:04:34,100
of, the terrain we navigated.

70
00:04:35,155 --> 00:04:39,298
We start off by discussing the movie
"Naza," a controversial new documentary

71
00:04:39,551 --> 00:04:43,865
by Israeli filmmakers featuring anonymous
testimony from Israeli soldiers just

72
00:04:43,865 --> 00:04:45,426
in case you didn't know what that was.

73
00:04:45,813 --> 00:04:51,300
Anyway, without further ado, please enjoy
my conversation with the one and only Dr.

74
00:04:51,315 --> 00:04:53,187
Sabreena Ghaffar-Saddiqui

75
00:04:58,892 --> 00:05:05,447
Ezra Lipp: last time we spoke, you were
about to see the movie "Naza," and we

76
00:05:05,447 --> 00:05:11,263
were on the subject of this idea of
dehumanization relating to indoctrination.

77
00:05:11,876 --> 00:05:13,194
how was that experience for you?

78
00:05:13,545 --> 00:05:15,600
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui:
so I had initially decided that I

79
00:05:15,601 --> 00:05:17,261
wasn't gonna watch the film Naza.

80
00:05:17,355 --> 00:05:24,182
I had been seeing all this online
discourse around it, and, I really,

81
00:05:24,762 --> 00:05:29,266
appreciate this idea that, the attention
shouldn't be taken away and the mic

82
00:05:29,267 --> 00:05:33,480
shouldn't be taken away from those who are
on the receiving end of the oppression.

83
00:05:34,320 --> 00:05:42,681
And also, giving the mic to Israelis
and Jewish Zionists, you're basically,

84
00:05:42,816 --> 00:05:48,854
legitimizing their perspective and
delegitimizing the perspective of

85
00:05:48,856 --> 00:05:50,547
Palestinians at the same time, right?

86
00:05:50,547 --> 00:05:55,429
by constantly uplifting the voices
and opinions of Israelis and

87
00:05:55,569 --> 00:05:57,504
even anti-Zionist Jews, right?

88
00:05:57,506 --> 00:06:01,597
There's this whole process of,
delegitimizing, the voices of the

89
00:06:01,597 --> 00:06:03,322
people who are facing the oppression.

90
00:06:03,549 --> 00:06:08,098
So, in line of that kind of
criticism, I had decided I

91
00:06:08,098 --> 00:06:09,354
wasn't gonna watch this film.

92
00:06:10,163 --> 00:06:14,892
and then you and I had a conversation,
and, uh, y- you know, we started talking

93
00:06:14,904 --> 00:06:21,479
about this concept of, like, groupthink,
group psychology, dehumanization, and

94
00:06:21,480 --> 00:06:26,615
we even shared notes on this, episode of
Black Mirror that I have always shown in

95
00:06:26,617 --> 00:06:30,645
my classes, which is called Men Against
Fire, and it's basically all about this

96
00:06:30,645 --> 00:06:38,270
idea of brainwashing people into thinking
of entire groups of people as animals

97
00:06:38,308 --> 00:06:41,129
and just dehumanizing people, right?

98
00:06:41,172 --> 00:06:43,008
And turning them into the enemy.

99
00:06:44,094 --> 00:06:48,687
And so, you know, after that conversation,
I was like, "I want to be able to

100
00:06:48,687 --> 00:06:52,749
pa- participate in this conversation
from a place of I've seen this film."

101
00:06:52,754 --> 00:06:55,991
let me-- Even if it's a critical
analysis, let me watch this film to

102
00:06:55,993 --> 00:06:58,290
give my critical analysis of this film.

103
00:06:58,670 --> 00:07:04,146
So I went to watch it last week, organized
by our mutual friend, Rabbi David Mivasir.

104
00:07:04,159 --> 00:07:08,272
He-- It was actually his,
organization that was screening it.

105
00:07:08,461 --> 00:07:16,967
And I have to say, going in, I was really
expecting it to, to, to just piss me off.

106
00:07:16,981 --> 00:07:17,750
Ezra Lipp: Yeah

107
00:07:17,960 --> 00:07:24,011
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui:
yes, I would say, 98% of the film,

108
00:07:24,412 --> 00:07:27,813
I sat there just with, anger.

109
00:07:27,813 --> 00:07:31,505
Like I… There was a
physiological response to the film.

110
00:07:31,505 --> 00:07:36,411
I just sat there, my arms like this,
like clenched fists, and just I felt very

111
00:07:36,411 --> 00:07:42,223
upset and angry, like very angry as I was
watching these, soldiers having committed

112
00:07:42,223 --> 00:07:47,462
such heinous crimes and then talk a-
talk about it in somewhat a casual way.

113
00:07:47,747 --> 00:07:51,242
I almost was expecting more remorse,
and I didn't see that remorse.

114
00:07:51,988 --> 00:07:57,014
and I say 98% because, or 95% because
the last few minutes of that film

115
00:07:57,499 --> 00:08:04,401
is where, like I just, I couldn't
stop crying because it took us to

116
00:08:04,402 --> 00:08:07,525
a moment where a father was looking
for his children under the rubble.

117
00:08:08,681 --> 00:08:14,476
And, and there was like absolute silence
in the entire… I mean, throughout

118
00:08:14,476 --> 00:08:15,950
the film, there was absolute silence.

119
00:08:15,952 --> 00:08:17,942
people were just mesmerized by this film.

120
00:08:18,337 --> 00:08:21,981
But in that moment, that last moment,
you could just hear people crying,

121
00:08:22,049 --> 00:08:23,879
and nobody got up from their seats.

122
00:08:24,408 --> 00:08:27,885
afterwards for a good 10 minutes, people
just sat there, and they were crying.

123
00:08:27,888 --> 00:08:32,151
And then I got up, and I looked around,
and the thing that really impacted me

124
00:08:32,151 --> 00:08:35,773
was, I didn't notice this when I was
watching the film, but when I got up

125
00:08:35,775 --> 00:08:41,574
and I looked around, the people around
me, they were, I could tell, were mostly

126
00:08:42,085 --> 00:08:45,612
non-Arabs, non-Muslims, non-Palestinians.

127
00:08:46,399 --> 00:08:52,606
and you know, a part of me just felt
like some, some hope in the future.

128
00:08:52,622 --> 00:08:58,664
You know, if, if all these people sat
here to bear witness and to listen, and

129
00:08:58,667 --> 00:09:03,825
hopefully take this and do something
with it, then it gave me somewhat hope.

130
00:09:04,711 --> 00:09:09,767
Ezra Lipp: seeing a theater full of,
white people, non-Arab, non-Palestinian,

131
00:09:09,768 --> 00:09:13,526
non-Muslim Did anything change in
you about your perspective of the

132
00:09:13,526 --> 00:09:16,269
value of that sort of narrative?

133
00:09:18,441 --> 00:09:21,576
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: Well,
I think that there is no denying the

134
00:09:21,576 --> 00:09:28,418
fact that different people, different
advocates, different filmmakers, different

135
00:09:28,455 --> 00:09:31,674
creators will attract different audiences.

136
00:09:31,854 --> 00:09:33,665
They speak to different audiences.

137
00:09:33,971 --> 00:09:41,120
So in that sense, a film that was
created by Israelis and it features

138
00:09:41,168 --> 00:09:47,434
Israelis, I feel like Maybe it
attracted a different audience.

139
00:09:47,519 --> 00:09:53,824
I can imagine that many of the people
who were sitting there may have,

140
00:09:54,110 --> 00:09:59,740
at one point in their life, had an
association to Israel, or may consider

141
00:09:59,740 --> 00:10:04,721
themselves Jewish, or may have at one
point considered themselves Zionists.

142
00:10:05,126 --> 00:10:10,265
So I feel like that film attracted
a crowd that maybe a film that

143
00:10:10,265 --> 00:10:14,371
was made by a Muslim or by a
Palestinian may not have attracted.

144
00:10:14,587 --> 00:10:20,627
So this is the reason why, even though
I vehemently disagree with so many,

145
00:10:21,040 --> 00:10:25,398
people who have the pulpit and who are
speaking about Palestine or speaking

146
00:10:25,399 --> 00:10:29,475
about Iran, let's say, you know, like
there are journalists or there are people

147
00:10:29,475 --> 00:10:34,902
in positions of, uh, like media power
who talk about these political issues

148
00:10:35,304 --> 00:10:40,181
and, in a broad stroke, I would say
that these people are liberals, okay?

149
00:10:40,181 --> 00:10:43,820
So these are liberal progressives,
these are people who fall under

150
00:10:43,820 --> 00:10:49,520
that liberal camp, and their way
of approaching these issues is very

151
00:10:49,522 --> 00:10:55,383
different to someone who is radical and
revolutionary and very leftist, right?

152
00:10:55,393 --> 00:11:03,224
So I tend to disagree with a lot of
them, but at the same time, I see value

153
00:11:03,301 --> 00:11:07,829
in, in the work that they're doing
because their audience is different.

154
00:11:08,387 --> 00:11:14,734
And now I say this with, you know, I have
to preface this with, the fact that I

155
00:11:14,737 --> 00:11:23,136
have also said that people like them also,
create barriers in the ultimate revolution

156
00:11:23,136 --> 00:11:29,753
and liberation of, uh, Palestine and
other, regions and areas that are impacted

157
00:11:29,756 --> 00:11:35,415
by imperialism and colonialism and,
Zionist expansionism in that region.

158
00:11:35,792 --> 00:11:39,508
because what they do is they e- end
up being like controlled opposition

159
00:11:39,509 --> 00:11:42,776
or, you know… the whole idea of
controlled opposition is that they are

160
00:11:42,824 --> 00:11:45,784
participating in like the lie, right?

161
00:11:45,784 --> 00:11:49,976
Like that they are part of the,
the opposition, but they're just,

162
00:11:50,155 --> 00:11:55,120
they're, sent there to control, the
liberatories and the revolutionaries.

163
00:11:55,302 --> 00:11:59,386
But some of these people, I, I
think they end up playing the role

164
00:11:59,387 --> 00:12:02,353
of controlled opposition, even
their, if their intentions are good.

165
00:12:02,551 --> 00:12:06,495
Even if they think they're doing
revolutionary work, that they still end

166
00:12:06,497 --> 00:12:09,240
up functionally having the same impact

167
00:12:09,610 --> 00:12:14,135
Ezra Lipp: they're not necessarily
a, a controlled PSYOP operation but

168
00:12:14,151 --> 00:12:16,099
they end up serving that function.

169
00:12:16,887 --> 00:12:22,665
can you give some examples of, the sort of
advocacy you feel that fulfills that role

170
00:12:22,682 --> 00:12:27,985
of, this sort of unintentional controlled
opposition and the limitations of that

171
00:12:27,987 --> 00:12:30,053
worldview you feel, come through that?

172
00:12:30,973 --> 00:12:34,215
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: So the
kind of people I talk about when I say,

173
00:12:34,240 --> 00:12:40,193
they end up functionally serving that
role, it's people who promote that liberal

174
00:12:40,201 --> 00:12:45,291
fe- feminist ideology, liberal feminist
position when it comes to women's rights.

175
00:12:45,291 --> 00:12:53,529
And so the type of people who are
promoting narratives that have

176
00:12:53,537 --> 00:13:01,388
historically been used to invade
countries and, where they give this

177
00:13:01,388 --> 00:13:05,717
impression that their goal is to go
there to protect these women and help

178
00:13:05,717 --> 00:13:09,537
these women and to f- you know, fight the
oppression and get rid of these horrible,

179
00:13:09,545 --> 00:13:12,213
misogynistic, patriarchal systems.

180
00:13:12,640 --> 00:13:16,935
but what has been proven, and obviously,
I'm speaking about Afghanistan here, as

181
00:13:16,937 --> 00:13:24,467
being like the main, I would say, example
of where women's rights, the niqab,

182
00:13:25,132 --> 00:13:33,622
women's education has been, you know, this
very legitimate and real and important

183
00:13:33,637 --> 00:13:39,085
topic has been weaponized by liberal
feminists and people who promote that

184
00:13:39,088 --> 00:13:47,546
liberal feminist, narrative to justify
the imperial invasion of Afghanistan.

185
00:13:48,187 --> 00:13:53,099
And the reason why I say that it is
rooted in this kind of like false

186
00:13:53,522 --> 00:13:59,992
human rights, position is that,
where were they when the country was

187
00:13:59,992 --> 00:14:01,456
handed right back to the Taliban?

188
00:14:02,120 --> 00:14:02,130
Ezra Lipp: Mm-hmm.

189
00:14:02,265 --> 00:14:05,155
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: Where
are these people now, now that they

190
00:14:05,157 --> 00:14:10,048
don't really have, a fight there, or
they don't really care about that place?

191
00:14:10,073 --> 00:14:15,160
Now all the attention is on Iran, and now
the same talking points are being used for

192
00:14:15,181 --> 00:14:19,132
Iran, where we're talking about women's
rights, we're talking about oppression.

193
00:14:19,210 --> 00:14:20,795
and it's so muddied.

194
00:14:20,904 --> 00:14:27,022
It's so muddied to the point where you
have people who are with, a straight face

195
00:14:27,087 --> 00:14:33,992
lying and saying that, women can't go to
school in Iran or women a- are oppressed.

196
00:14:34,353 --> 00:14:39,249
Iran has one of the highest, educational
attainment stats when it comes to

197
00:14:39,250 --> 00:14:44,287
women, one of the highest in the
world, like the most PhDs per capita

198
00:14:44,458 --> 00:14:46,806
compared to a lot of other places.

199
00:14:46,974 --> 00:14:50,959
so It's a bold-faced lie when
people are saying that women

200
00:14:50,974 --> 00:14:52,773
in Iran can't go to school.

201
00:14:53,048 --> 00:14:58,937
You know, women are in positions of
leadership there and have got, positions

202
00:14:58,938 --> 00:15:05,066
in government and, places that even in
America women haven't achieved that level

203
00:15:05,255 --> 00:15:09,598
of, uh, leadership and equality, right?

204
00:15:09,598 --> 00:15:16,079
So the focus seems to be on the things
that, like the measure of progress

205
00:15:16,099 --> 00:15:20,898
in terms of feminism is usually
how many clothes women are wearing,

206
00:15:20,926 --> 00:15:24,318
how much they are covering up, and
how much they're not covering up.

207
00:15:24,569 --> 00:15:30,514
That's, that seems to be the only
measure of how progressive a society is

208
00:15:30,922 --> 00:15:33,180
Ezra Lipp: How immodest the women

209
00:15:34,179 --> 00:15:36,311
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui:
like honestly, it just, that--

210
00:15:37,432 --> 00:15:39,723
look, I clearly don't wear a hijab.

211
00:15:40,269 --> 00:15:42,316
I clearly don't wear a niqab, right?

212
00:15:42,370 --> 00:15:45,066
I'm a Muslim woman, but I, I show my hair.

213
00:15:45,383 --> 00:15:50,821
So why am I sitting here and
advocating for women, for a woman's

214
00:15:50,821 --> 00:15:54,689
right to be able to wear the niqab
or to be able to wear the hijab?

215
00:15:55,165 --> 00:15:59,949
It's because at the core of my,
principles, like my core principles

216
00:15:59,950 --> 00:16:02,930
when it comes to human rights, is
that, you know, women should be able

217
00:16:02,930 --> 00:16:05,429
to choose what they wanna wear, right?

218
00:16:05,462 --> 00:16:06,199
And not wear.

219
00:16:06,922 --> 00:16:12,571
And if we're going to talk about
countries where, yes, you do have

220
00:16:12,911 --> 00:16:17,104
governments and people telling women
that they have to cover up, then can we

221
00:16:17,105 --> 00:16:23,213
talk about governments that also tell
women that they can't wear the hijab?

222
00:16:23,591 --> 00:16:29,416
I mean, just in Canada, in Quebec, women
who wear hijab can't, work in schools.

223
00:16:29,543 --> 00:16:30,829
They've lost their jobs

224
00:16:30,833 --> 00:16:31,761
Ezra Lipp: S- really?

225
00:16:31,923 --> 00:16:32,823
I had no idea.

226
00:16:33,470 --> 00:16:34,915
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: Yeah,
so there was, you know, there's

227
00:16:34,915 --> 00:16:40,187
a law in Quebec where religious
symbols are not-- It's part of the

228
00:16:40,188 --> 00:16:42,603
secularism law, same as France.

229
00:16:43,325 --> 00:16:49,689
so technically the law applies to,
all religious symbols, but the people

230
00:16:49,689 --> 00:16:56,215
who are inadvertently or advertently
targeted the most are Sikh men

231
00:16:56,574 --> 00:16:58,844
with their turbans and Muslim women

232
00:16:59,094 --> 00:17:03,561
Ezra Lipp: I'm curious what your
perspective is as a Muslim woman, which is

233
00:17:04,209 --> 00:17:11,847
not the hijab, but when a girl or a woman
is fully covered besides, like, her eyes.

234
00:17:12,303 --> 00:17:13,696
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui:
So that would be a niqab?

235
00:17:13,807 --> 00:17:14,838
Ezra Lipp: A niqab, Yeah,

236
00:17:14,907 --> 00:17:16,404
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui:
Yeah, that would be a niqab

237
00:17:17,698 --> 00:17:20,758
Ezra Lipp: I, and maybe this is like,
I'll, I'll just name, like, I'm--

238
00:17:21,065 --> 00:17:26,148
this is a cultural difference, it's
a Western difference, but, like, it

239
00:17:26,148 --> 00:17:31,676
is really hard for me to see that,
particularly when it's a young girl or

240
00:17:31,676 --> 00:17:39,459
woman, and just, my orientation to the
world and as someone who would consider

241
00:17:39,460 --> 00:17:44,017
themselves, uh, a feminist or being,
you know, for women's liberation and

242
00:17:44,017 --> 00:17:45,505
rights and full equality, all that.

243
00:17:46,383 --> 00:17:48,178
Like I get uncomfortable when I see that

244
00:17:48,889 --> 00:17:49,286
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: Mm-hmm.

245
00:17:49,623 --> 00:17:52,705
And I, and I, you know, like I
appreciate your honesty here, and

246
00:17:52,705 --> 00:17:56,875
I think you've actually touched
on something really important

247
00:17:57,172 --> 00:17:59,391
with using the word uncomfortable.

248
00:17:59,984 --> 00:18:06,028
And the truth is that there
are like cultural practices or

249
00:18:06,029 --> 00:18:11,882
religious practices that will
make people uncomfortable, right?

250
00:18:11,915 --> 00:18:15,029
Like certain people who are just not
accustomed to it, haven't seen it

251
00:18:15,030 --> 00:18:20,221
before, it's not part of their worldview
or what they've grown up with, and it

252
00:18:20,221 --> 00:18:22,038
would make you uncomfortable naturally.

253
00:18:22,139 --> 00:18:26,129
I'll be honest, it has also
always made me uncomfortable.

254
00:18:26,828 --> 00:18:31,037
I, as a Muslim woman, can say to you
that it's al- also made me uncomfortable.

255
00:18:31,672 --> 00:18:38,982
But human rights or, freedom,
the freedom to choose isn't based

256
00:18:38,993 --> 00:18:44,045
on my discomfort, what makes me
comfortable or not comfortable, my

257
00:18:44,045 --> 00:18:45,890
discomfort isn't the point here.

258
00:18:46,318 --> 00:18:51,911
We don't make laws based on people's
comfort or discomfort, otherwise we

259
00:18:51,911 --> 00:18:57,620
wouldn't have laws that allow people to
marry people from the same sex, right?

260
00:18:57,620 --> 00:19:02,227
We wouldn't have abolished laws
that prevented gay people from, from

261
00:19:02,327 --> 00:19:07,731
getting married if it was based on
comfort, 'cause most people at the

262
00:19:07,732 --> 00:19:09,523
time were still uncomfortable by that.

263
00:19:09,864 --> 00:19:13,673
So I appreciate, that you are being
honest in that sense that, you

264
00:19:13,673 --> 00:19:14,944
know, it makes you uncomfortable.

265
00:19:15,313 --> 00:19:19,760
I'll tell you something anecdotal,
but, for what it's worth, it

266
00:19:19,760 --> 00:19:21,129
might help you understand.

267
00:19:21,557 --> 00:19:29,321
I have actually only met and spoken
to, I would say about 10 niqabi

268
00:19:29,595 --> 00:19:37,153
women in my lifetime, women who, wear
niqab And much to my surprise, all

269
00:19:37,156 --> 00:19:42,167
of them, underneath the niqab were
very different to what I expected.

270
00:19:42,705 --> 00:19:46,224
And of course, there was a lot of
preconditioning that made me imagine

271
00:19:46,576 --> 00:19:50,910
that the woman under the niqab would
be an immigrant woman or a woman

272
00:19:50,911 --> 00:19:55,595
who's really meek and docile and,
all of the things like that you

273
00:19:55,597 --> 00:19:57,929
just imagine based on stereotypes.

274
00:19:58,201 --> 00:20:04,894
And the women who I met under the
niqab were like very educated, bold

275
00:20:04,902 --> 00:20:10,276
women who all said to me that the
niqab was their choice, that it was

276
00:20:10,276 --> 00:20:11,894
something that they chose to do.

277
00:20:12,152 --> 00:20:15,004
And obviously, that's not something
I would choose to do, but I

278
00:20:15,004 --> 00:20:16,722
defend their right to choose.

279
00:20:17,363 --> 00:20:21,974
And now one might argue and say, "Okay,
you're in Canada or you're in UK or

280
00:20:21,977 --> 00:20:24,282
whatever, this, these places, fine.

281
00:20:24,612 --> 00:20:27,306
Uh, there aren't any young
children wearing niqab.

282
00:20:27,306 --> 00:20:31,656
It's all women who are adults who
are choosing to or not choosing to.

283
00:20:31,656 --> 00:20:34,401
So fine, I'll give you that.

284
00:20:34,622 --> 00:20:39,494
But what about young girls and children
in countries where they're wearing the

285
00:20:39,498 --> 00:20:45,166
hijab or they're wearing, uh, you know,
the niqab or something, and, you know,

286
00:20:45,341 --> 00:20:51,378
how is that a choice?" Now, this is where
I would stop someone, and this is where I

287
00:20:51,388 --> 00:21:01,255
would say, what gives Westerners a moral
authority to speak about what's happening

288
00:21:01,256 --> 00:21:04,011
in countries in other parts of the world?

289
00:21:05,061 --> 00:21:08,066
This is at the root of a lot
of the advocacy work that I do.

290
00:21:08,434 --> 00:21:14,177
What gives the West moral authority
over the Global South, where they are

291
00:21:14,180 --> 00:21:22,039
lecturing, criticizing, commenting on
the way people live their lives in other

292
00:21:22,040 --> 00:21:28,240
countries, often as a pretext to wars and
invasions and imperialism and colonialism,

293
00:21:28,716 --> 00:21:34,722
Ezra Lipp: So to speak more about this
idea of dehumanization, I just wanna

294
00:21:34,889 --> 00:21:38,929
mention a little more about this "Black
Mirror" episode, because I think it's

295
00:21:38,929 --> 00:21:42,087
such a poignant example of how this works.

296
00:21:42,540 --> 00:21:45,926
and just to give-- try to give a brief
synopsis, basically in this episode,

297
00:21:45,926 --> 00:21:47,521
"Men Against Fire,"  spoiler alert.

298
00:21:48,052 --> 00:21:53,277
there are these soldiers of this army,
and they think they're fighting these,

299
00:21:53,313 --> 00:21:57,270
human roaches they're literally like
the embodiment of these, horrific

300
00:21:57,288 --> 00:21:59,297
monster human-sized cockroaches.

301
00:22:00,001 --> 00:22:05,052
And they, go about and they're
gunning them down with machine guns.

302
00:22:05,102 --> 00:22:10,342
and then you learn that actually this
is just a computer chip, through this

303
00:22:10,348 --> 00:22:12,014
example of this protagonist soldier.

304
00:22:12,014 --> 00:22:15,515
It's this computer chip that's
implanted in the brain, and, as the

305
00:22:15,527 --> 00:22:20,763
software begins to malfunction, he
realizes that, he's actually just--

306
00:22:21,006 --> 00:22:24,490
they're just murdering human beings,
children and regular human beings.

307
00:22:24,981 --> 00:22:30,686
it really does serve as this really
poignant metaphor, of I feel like

308
00:22:30,688 --> 00:22:35,661
what we're seeing now, for sure in
Palestine, although it's this sort of

309
00:22:36,044 --> 00:22:39,950
dehumanization has been used in all,
all sorts of, wars in, in history.

310
00:22:39,950 --> 00:22:43,614
and we saw this in the film "Naza,"
like the way that these soldiers

311
00:22:43,616 --> 00:22:46,538
are speaking about Palestinians,
they're not seeing them as human.

312
00:22:47,671 --> 00:22:52,366
But when you show this to your
students, what is the message

313
00:22:52,628 --> 00:22:54,075
you're trying to articulate?

314
00:22:54,284 --> 00:22:57,550
And then I also know you've gotten
pushback in the pro-Palestinian

315
00:22:57,555 --> 00:23:00,935
community about speaking, to
this sort of dehumanization.

316
00:23:00,948 --> 00:23:02,639
So can you speak to those things?

317
00:23:02,716 --> 00:23:03,227
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: Yeah.

318
00:23:03,363 --> 00:23:05,340
Um, Ezra you know what?

319
00:23:06,154 --> 00:23:12,552
When I speak about dehumanization and
dehumanization being a terrible thing, I

320
00:23:12,562 --> 00:23:19,640
think what- is really important that I'm
trying to push is not just the fact that,

321
00:23:20,002 --> 00:23:25,298
those who are being oppressed are being
dehumanized, but also those who are doing

322
00:23:25,299 --> 00:23:26,945
the oppressing are being dehumanized.

323
00:23:26,959 --> 00:23:33,707
I think dehumanization happens
on all sides, So dehumanization

324
00:23:33,712 --> 00:23:35,402
can be very effective.

325
00:23:36,266 --> 00:23:41,441
And so what I mean by this i- idea of
dehumanization and it being wrong, right?

326
00:23:41,443 --> 00:23:45,423
So in this case with Men Against Fire,
we see the dehumanization of these,

327
00:23:45,455 --> 00:23:50,808
this community that, the, the group
wants to target them, and then these

328
00:23:50,808 --> 00:23:54,111
soldiers are, like, made to think
that they are, like, these roaches and

329
00:23:54,112 --> 00:23:55,860
they have completely been dehumanized.

330
00:23:56,346 --> 00:24:01,808
But the reason why it's really important
for us to also not dehumanize, the

331
00:24:01,808 --> 00:24:06,693
people doing the oppressing, the people
doing the killing, is that it's very

332
00:24:06,765 --> 00:24:11,394
easy for us to fall into this trap when
we say things like, "These people are

333
00:24:11,405 --> 00:24:20,060
monsters. These people are, like, evil
monsters out of this world." The reason

334
00:24:20,060 --> 00:24:25,701
why I don't like that language is that
human beings are the ones doing this.

335
00:24:26,568 --> 00:24:30,548
Like, when you watch the film Naza,
the reason why it was so important

336
00:24:30,557 --> 00:24:37,910
for me, that film, was that it
humanized the IOF soldiers, but not

337
00:24:37,919 --> 00:24:42,103
in the way that you might think, not
humanizing them in the sense that,

338
00:24:42,605 --> 00:24:44,787
oh, we should empathize with them.

339
00:24:45,246 --> 00:24:49,894
It humanized them in the sense that
it makes you realize that these are

340
00:24:49,907 --> 00:24:56,511
very real human beings, not some
evil monsters who are doing this.

341
00:24:57,159 --> 00:25:00,664
Do you remember there was a scene,
there was a scene in the film where

342
00:25:01,055 --> 00:25:09,132
he says, "My platoon is the most
leftist, most liberal of, from Tel Aviv.

343
00:25:09,207 --> 00:25:10,985
We are the most liberal,

344
00:25:11,035 --> 00:25:12,500
We're not Arab haters."

345
00:25:12,651 --> 00:25:12,967
Ezra Lipp: Right.

346
00:25:12,971 --> 00:25:13,253
Yeah.

347
00:25:13,288 --> 00:25:16,623
That's exactly the scene I wanted to
bring up where he says, in the context

348
00:25:16,639 --> 00:25:20,630
of this platoon that's killed hundreds
if not thousands of Palestinians, he's

349
00:25:20,631 --> 00:25:23,403
like, "Nobody in my platoon hates Arabs."

350
00:25:23,690 --> 00:25:25,303
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: and
then the interviewer very rightly

351
00:25:25,308 --> 00:25:31,386
turns around and says, "But, but you've
killed the most Arabs of any Israeli."

352
00:25:31,576 --> 00:25:34,410
Ezra Lipp: and the response, the
response is I don't fu- fully

353
00:25:34,410 --> 00:25:37,945
remember, but I feel like he's
just almost like, "Oh, yeah." like,

354
00:25:38,348 --> 00:25:39,222
like, it's

355
00:25:39,223 --> 00:25:39,346
like

356
00:25:39,348 --> 00:25:41,730
he hadn't even thought it through.

357
00:25:41,875 --> 00:25:44,061
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui:
that's a good point." That his, his

358
00:25:44,062 --> 00:25:45,824
face looked like he was like, Yeah

359
00:25:46,586 --> 00:25:46,923
True.

360
00:25:47,621 --> 00:25:47,927
True.

361
00:25:47,958 --> 00:25:53,804
Yeah, we have killed them." And so this
idea that, when we think of people as

362
00:25:53,807 --> 00:25:59,269
monsters, we fail to understand that
ordinary human beings are capable

363
00:25:59,402 --> 00:26:01,841
of extraordinarily horrible things.

364
00:26:02,127 --> 00:26:08,604
Like what happened in the Nazi
Holocaust of Jews is being repeated

365
00:26:08,929 --> 00:26:10,401
Ezra Lipp: Yes

366
00:26:10,656 --> 00:26:13,154
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: And
that was done by ordinary human beings.

367
00:26:15,032 --> 00:26:19,361
And you know, when you hear of some of
the stories even of, the Nazi Holocaust

368
00:26:19,361 --> 00:26:24,888
of Jews, like it's shocking to hear
that the Germans who participated were

369
00:26:24,889 --> 00:26:28,423
just ordinary people, ordinary families.

370
00:26:28,438 --> 00:26:32,713
Like they'd kill children and then
they'd go home to their own children

371
00:26:33,540 --> 00:26:37,753
in their homes with their wives so,
you know, this, this whole idea of like

372
00:26:37,755 --> 00:26:43,537
humanizing the oppressors is important
because I say that is the only way

373
00:26:43,718 --> 00:26:47,643
for us to prevent something like this
happening again, for us to understand

374
00:26:47,655 --> 00:26:51,667
the psychology of group behavior
and group psychology and groupthink.

375
00:26:51,739 --> 00:26:57,492
So people could be individually very moral
people, very good people, but once you're

376
00:26:57,492 --> 00:27:03,024
part of a group, your individual morality
gets overtaken by a group morality, and

377
00:27:03,024 --> 00:27:08,823
you become part of groupthink, and your
behaviors are impacted by the group.

378
00:27:08,823 --> 00:27:12,877
So a lot of times, somebody might
be like, "Well, no one else has said

379
00:27:12,879 --> 00:27:17,001
anything, so I won't either." Like
there are all these justifications

380
00:27:17,001 --> 00:27:20,337
and things that happen in your head,
but only because you're part of this

381
00:27:20,705 --> 00:27:20,925
Ezra Lipp: Yeah.

382
00:27:21,540 --> 00:27:23,682
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: so
the reason why this whole concept of

383
00:27:23,682 --> 00:27:27,389
group psychology is really important,
when it comes to, what we're seeing

384
00:27:27,655 --> 00:27:33,473
happen in Palestine is, and, when you
watch this film Nazha, Some of these

385
00:27:33,473 --> 00:27:36,913
soldiers were asked, like, "Well, did
you say anything? Did you do anything?"

386
00:27:36,913 --> 00:27:41,671
Like, some of them expressed that
they knew it was wrong, that they

387
00:27:41,672 --> 00:27:45,578
knew it was wrong when it was
happening, and yet they did nothing.

388
00:27:45,842 --> 00:27:49,738
And I think one of the responses
of the soldiers was, "Well,

389
00:27:50,131 --> 00:27:51,024
I couldn't say anything.

390
00:27:51,025 --> 00:27:52,101
I was just doing my job.

391
00:27:52,605 --> 00:27:53,873
My job was to do this.

392
00:27:53,873 --> 00:27:55,999
I was just fulfilling
my mission and my…"

393
00:27:56,492 --> 00:28:00,227
But then at the same time admitting that
these people would then later go party and

394
00:28:00,462 --> 00:28:06,115
go to clubs and bars and, you know, kill
people and then just go live their lives.

395
00:28:06,670 --> 00:28:10,290
Ezra Lipp: so the-- I think this
raises, this question if the idea

396
00:28:10,290 --> 00:28:16,479
isn't to dehumanize the dehumanizers,
the people that are involved in grave

397
00:28:16,666 --> 00:28:23,208
horrendous atrocities and, unimaginable
violence, what do we do with that?

398
00:28:23,221 --> 00:28:24,036
how do you stop it?

399
00:28:26,746 --> 00:28:31,253
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: one of
the problems that I see that I'm trying

400
00:28:31,254 --> 00:28:37,069
to fight at the moment is, turning
the atrocities or the things that

401
00:28:37,069 --> 00:28:43,261
we're seeing into, like, individual
issues or human, catastrophes that

402
00:28:43,308 --> 00:28:45,017
are beyond human control, right?

403
00:28:45,017 --> 00:28:51,299
So for example, this flooding that's
happening in Gaza right now, right?

404
00:28:52,713 --> 00:28:57,102
Now, when you hear that there are
floods in Gaza, and people are dying,

405
00:28:57,104 --> 00:29:01,583
and they're drowning, and there are
diseases that are being spread, the

406
00:29:01,584 --> 00:29:07,598
first thing that people think of is rain,
natural disaster, But the only reason

407
00:29:07,598 --> 00:29:14,173
why there's flooding is because the
infrastructure has been destroyed for

408
00:29:14,174 --> 00:29:20,563
people in Gaza to, to be able to deal with
natural things like raining or snowing.

409
00:29:21,187 --> 00:29:23,200
You know, why are people in tents?

410
00:29:23,280 --> 00:29:23,511
Ezra Lipp: Yeah.

411
00:29:24,347 --> 00:29:25,557
Why is there no drainage?

412
00:29:25,558 --> 00:29:25,994
Why is there

413
00:29:26,086 --> 00:29:26,826
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui:
why is there no

414
00:29:26,828 --> 00:29:27,517
drainage?

415
00:29:27,622 --> 00:29:31,180
Ezra Lipp: is the sewage
mixing with the rainwater?

416
00:29:32,058 --> 00:29:33,909
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: Why
is there no clean drinking water?

417
00:29:33,946 --> 00:29:36,392
Why are there these diseases
that are being spread?

418
00:29:36,760 --> 00:29:45,903
So the systemic structural problems,
the deep rot that's inside the system

419
00:29:47,349 --> 00:29:50,073
gets n- nobody wants to talk about that.

420
00:29:50,122 --> 00:29:58,327
It's easier or it's, it's safer for people
to talk about Palestine, Palestinians, and

421
00:29:58,328 --> 00:30:06,220
what's happening in Gaza as a human rights
issue or like a, like a human disaster.

422
00:30:06,742 --> 00:30:10,649
give charity, give
money, help these people.

423
00:30:11,491 --> 00:30:14,003
And yes, of course, all of
that is really important.

424
00:30:14,034 --> 00:30:17,392
It's important for us to like,
help Palestinians by funding

425
00:30:17,401 --> 00:30:18,930
campaigns and things like that.

426
00:30:19,697 --> 00:30:21,371
It's such a Band-Aid solution

427
00:30:21,742 --> 00:30:25,840
Ezra Lipp: th- there's also the rhetorical
trick that happens is, well, if it weren't

428
00:30:26,035 --> 00:30:27,727
for Hamas, they wouldn't be intense.

429
00:30:27,973 --> 00:30:29,330
You know, victim blaming.

430
00:30:29,381 --> 00:30:30,346
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui:
Victim blaming.

431
00:30:30,597 --> 00:30:31,888
Yeah, of course.

432
00:30:32,043 --> 00:30:36,475
And so the reason why I, I say all this
is that, you know, when you say, "What

433
00:30:36,477 --> 00:30:41,867
is it that we can do?" One of the first
things that we need to do is get to

434
00:30:41,867 --> 00:30:50,347
the rot at the core of it, which is a
system that's built on Jewish supremacy.

435
00:30:51,839 --> 00:30:56,434
A- another topic that people don't
really want to talk about, That we

436
00:30:56,435 --> 00:31:03,994
have a country, we have a system that
favors one group of people over others.

437
00:31:04,009 --> 00:31:08,292
Not just favors them, but discriminates.

438
00:31:08,345 --> 00:31:13,944
that's what an apartheid system is,
where there's such inequality, not just

439
00:31:13,945 --> 00:31:18,050
in, thinking Palestinians are terrible
people, but when it comes to housing,

440
00:31:18,055 --> 00:31:22,292
they can't buy houses, they can't rent,
they can't live in certain places,

441
00:31:22,292 --> 00:31:23,982
they can't shop in certain places.

442
00:31:23,982 --> 00:31:26,270
their movement is impacted.

443
00:31:26,476 --> 00:31:30,798
Their lives are impacted in every single
way, where you buy, where you live, where

444
00:31:30,802 --> 00:31:34,460
you go to school, Palestinians don't
ha- have access to healthcare the way

445
00:31:34,460 --> 00:31:36,731
that Israelis have access to healthcare.

446
00:31:36,952 --> 00:31:37,165
Ezra Lipp: And

447
00:31:37,166 --> 00:31:42,363
you're just talking about in Israel,
the green line, not, you're not talking

448
00:31:42,363 --> 00:31:43,958
about the occupied territories of

449
00:31:44,358 --> 00:31:46,204
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: I'm
not even talking about those places.

450
00:31:46,255 --> 00:31:51,022
even in Israel, which is apparently,
like, the only democracy in the Middle

451
00:31:51,022 --> 00:31:58,527
East, and, is such a progressive European
utopian place, system of Jewish supremacy

452
00:32:00,394 --> 00:32:03,289
in, that's in housing and, it's everywhere

453
00:32:04,375 --> 00:32:09,182
Ezra Lipp: How do you see this play
out in your work in the West, in the

454
00:32:09,185 --> 00:32:11,525
DEI industry that you were part of?

455
00:32:11,699 --> 00:32:14,972
where do you see the Jewish
supremacy or exceptionalism show up?

456
00:32:15,855 --> 00:32:18,892
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: So
I, as you know, I wrote a book, DEI

457
00:32:18,892 --> 00:32:22,182
Undone, because I was part of the
DEI industry, and I lost my job.

458
00:32:22,420 --> 00:32:23,958
I was ousted from my position.

459
00:32:24,209 --> 00:32:28,926
And the reason why was because, there were
contradictions and inconsistencies in the

460
00:32:28,927 --> 00:32:35,204
sense that, you know, everything that I
was taught over my entire academic career

461
00:32:35,205 --> 00:32:41,105
and also, the work that I've been doing
in DEI for, like, 10, 15 years, everything

462
00:32:41,105 --> 00:32:46,564
that I thought was, were the, was the rule
book that we're following just somehow

463
00:32:46,579 --> 00:32:51,632
didn't apply when it came to Palestine.

464
00:32:52,016 --> 00:32:55,661
And so there was this Palestine
exception that I kept seeing

465
00:32:55,933 --> 00:33:00,482
where we talk about human rights
for everyone except Palestinians.

466
00:33:01,027 --> 00:33:06,013
we talk about, abuses, human rights abuses
taking place in other parts of the world

467
00:33:06,030 --> 00:33:10,110
because let's face it, we talked about
Ukraine, we talked about, you know, we

468
00:33:10,111 --> 00:33:15,151
talk about Iran, we talk about everything
except, we can't talk about, Palestinians.

469
00:33:15,153 --> 00:33:19,520
We can't talk about Israel, We
can't talk about them being the

470
00:33:19,521 --> 00:33:23,105
perpetrators of oppression or violence.

471
00:33:23,677 --> 00:33:28,408
And so there was this, exception that
was very clear, and this has been spoken

472
00:33:28,408 --> 00:33:33,040
about before, the Palestine exception
But what became very interesting to me

473
00:33:33,186 --> 00:33:37,544
in my world and in the, you know, with
me losing my job and everything else that

474
00:33:37,590 --> 00:33:46,841
unfolded post October 2023, was how I
saw the Palestine exception paired with

475
00:33:47,075 --> 00:33:53,849
Jewish exceptionalism, Jewish identity
is co-opted, weaponized by Zionists And

476
00:33:53,913 --> 00:34:01,540
there was this, institutional power being
exerted where there was this exception

477
00:34:01,542 --> 00:34:09,972
being applied to Zionists, where they
were able to exert power in the sense that

478
00:34:09,972 --> 00:34:20,345
they were able to weaponize DEI and claim
antisemitism falsely, and have people lose

479
00:34:20,345 --> 00:34:26,901
their jobs, and have people lose their
livelihoods or be demoted or, students

480
00:34:26,901 --> 00:34:32,260
lose their, status and being suspended and
like, you know, we've seen it all over and

481
00:34:32,261 --> 00:34:34,852
I've, noted all of these cases in my book.

482
00:34:34,873 --> 00:34:37,754
But you know, what I talk about
is this kind of pairing of the

483
00:34:37,754 --> 00:34:42,153
Palestine exception with Jewish
exceptionalism and Jewish supremacy.

484
00:34:42,633 --> 00:34:47,215
and how, it's not just that people
were losing their jobs because

485
00:34:47,231 --> 00:34:49,281
they were speaking about Palestine.

486
00:34:50,244 --> 00:34:55,359
there was an institutional power
that was being exerted by people

487
00:34:55,527 --> 00:35:01,015
where they were able to weaponize
their identity and antisemitism to

488
00:35:01,017 --> 00:35:06,567
have people removed, because that
wasn't applying on the other side.

489
00:35:06,927 --> 00:35:11,355
Like, a Muslim wasn't able to say
that, "I'm experiencing Islamophobia.

490
00:35:11,357 --> 00:35:15,474
I'm experiencing anti-Palestinian
racism here. I'm being targeted."

491
00:35:16,468 --> 00:35:22,740
Like, where are the cases of, of
Zionists being ousted from their jobs?

492
00:35:22,742 --> 00:35:27,379
And, you know, we've got people
who were in the Epstein files,

493
00:35:27,873 --> 00:35:29,727
and they didn't lose their jobs.

494
00:35:30,254 --> 00:35:32,713
You know, in terms of like
Zionists with connections to

495
00:35:32,737 --> 00:35:35,007
Israel who didn't lose their jobs.

496
00:35:35,014 --> 00:35:44,652
So when are we going to talk about this
weaponization of antisemitism, and how

497
00:35:45,000 --> 00:35:54,531
power is exerted, And how the safety,
the lives, the comfort of Jews is "Jews".

498
00:35:54,866 --> 00:36:00,335
I always say that because it's Zionists
who are using the, the Jewish identity

499
00:36:00,771 --> 00:36:04,182
to, to claim antisemitism, right?

500
00:36:04,228 --> 00:36:10,083
And it's, and their safety and comfort
is prioritized over every other group

501
00:36:12,661 --> 00:36:17,557
Ezra Lipp: I know you've spoken
about this idea of Judaism or

502
00:36:17,557 --> 00:36:23,490
Jewishness as an ethnicity that
differs from, I'd say, most religions.

503
00:36:24,277 --> 00:36:26,780
how do you understand that
phenomenon and can you speak to that?

504
00:36:28,148 --> 00:36:32,698
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: So what
I say, and what I have spoken about is

505
00:36:33,167 --> 00:36:40,372
how problematic this term ethno-religion
is, and how Jewishness described

506
00:36:40,468 --> 00:36:47,292
as an ethnicity is problematic When
someone doesn't even believe in God

507
00:36:48,541 --> 00:36:56,393
can be completely, atheist Will claim
Jewishness and then say that this is

508
00:36:56,394 --> 00:37:00,332
because it's an ethnic racial category.

509
00:37:00,530 --> 00:37:02,990
There are Black Jews,
there are Ethiopian Jews.

510
00:37:03,262 --> 00:37:06,667
There are people who,
convert to Judaism later.

511
00:37:06,686 --> 00:37:09,415
There are Arab Jews, right?

512
00:37:09,416 --> 00:37:10,873
Sephardic Jews, right?

513
00:37:10,875 --> 00:37:18,191
So it's a very strange phenomenon
to me, And the reason why I'm

514
00:37:18,192 --> 00:37:21,193
pushing back on this, right, because
someone might turn around and be

515
00:37:21,194 --> 00:37:22,208
like, "Well, what's it to you?

516
00:37:22,220 --> 00:37:27,020
Why do you care so much that, that
people call themselves Jewish if they're

517
00:37:27,020 --> 00:37:32,972
not practicing Jews?" Because what
it does is it distorts numbers, data,

518
00:37:33,359 --> 00:37:41,387
experiences, If someone was born into
a Muslim family and then they decide to

519
00:37:41,387 --> 00:37:44,888
not be Muslim, they're called ex-Muslims.

520
00:37:44,909 --> 00:37:45,920
There's a word for it.

521
00:37:46,774 --> 00:37:49,150
They actually call themselves ex-Muslims.

522
00:37:49,181 --> 00:37:51,760
People will describe them as ex-Muslims.

523
00:37:53,203 --> 00:37:54,507
That's their identity.

524
00:37:54,887 --> 00:37:56,147
They don't believe in God.

525
00:37:56,300 --> 00:37:57,269
They're not Muslim.

526
00:37:57,279 --> 00:37:58,563
They're not practicing Muslim.

527
00:37:58,796 --> 00:38:03,849
But it also doesn't take away from the
fact that they grew up in a household

528
00:38:03,849 --> 00:38:09,252
that was Muslim, Or they come from
grandparents who were practicing Muslims.

529
00:38:10,409 --> 00:38:16,984
My argument for like people who say,
even anti-Zionists, Who say that

530
00:38:19,275 --> 00:38:23,268
There's no other way for me to describe
myself other than say that I'm Jewish

531
00:38:23,268 --> 00:38:25,008
even though I don't believe in Judaism.

532
00:38:25,056 --> 00:38:29,245
Well, why can't someone just
say that I grew up in a Jewish

533
00:38:29,246 --> 00:38:31,021
household, but I'm not Jewish?

534
00:38:32,215 --> 00:38:35,893
My grandparents were survivors of
the Holocaust, but I'm not Jewish.

535
00:38:35,932 --> 00:38:36,828
I don't practice.

536
00:38:37,561 --> 00:38:40,476
I'm anti-Zionist, but I'm not Jewish

537
00:38:40,787 --> 00:38:45,453
Ezra Lipp: Well, I guess where I would,
not necessarily push back, but just ask

538
00:38:45,454 --> 00:38:50,267
questions because I'm still trying to…
But like while I'm not, don't consider

539
00:38:50,267 --> 00:38:55,487
myself a religiously, observant Jew in any
way and haven't been my whole adult life,

540
00:38:56,483 --> 00:39:06,283
Jewish cultural identity and specifically
Ashkenazi, identity and also Zionism,

541
00:39:06,867 --> 00:39:11,854
as it's expressed in Western Jewish
circles were a big part of my upbringing.

542
00:39:12,260 --> 00:39:16,944
I'm obviously rejecting the Zionist
component of that and pushing, fighting

543
00:39:16,955 --> 00:39:21,419
back against that in my own community
or the community of which I was raised.

544
00:39:21,429 --> 00:39:27,349
but I do feel like it would cheapen
something about my identity to disown the

545
00:39:27,350 --> 00:39:33,392
Jewish cultural practice, which was a big
part of my identity growing up, and still

546
00:39:33,409 --> 00:39:39,706
is something that I, I do still celebrate
Jewish holidays in, not in a religiously

547
00:39:39,707 --> 00:39:41,444
meaningful way, but in a cultural way.

548
00:39:41,811 --> 00:39:47,295
to just say I'm ex-Jewish or, formerly
Jewish or just was raised Jewish, like

549
00:39:47,296 --> 00:39:52,146
I do think there is even for me, there
would be something lost there or something

550
00:39:52,146 --> 00:39:54,878
that wouldn't fully encapsulate, not

551
00:39:54,881 --> 00:39:56,269
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui:
I can appreciate that.

552
00:39:56,659 --> 00:40:02,608
But then, how do you feel
about Jewish identity being

553
00:40:02,817 --> 00:40:06,304
weaponized for the state of Israel

554
00:40:06,840 --> 00:40:07,214
and,

555
00:40:07,566 --> 00:40:07,921
and

556
00:40:07,924 --> 00:40:14,254
for, and it to be used as a
justification for the colonial, project?

557
00:40:14,281 --> 00:40:21,272
Because it rests on this idea that
you don't have to be a practicing Jew.

558
00:40:21,319 --> 00:40:25,373
Like, God has promised you this
land, but you don't have to believe

559
00:40:25,373 --> 00:40:29,201
in God to come to this land.

560
00:40:30,403 --> 00:40:38,309
And that- that's where I feel like
it's not a benign, identity category,

561
00:40:38,313 --> 00:40:39,922
or it's not a benign conversation.

562
00:40:39,922 --> 00:40:40,566
Do you know what I mean?

563
00:40:40,567 --> 00:40:45,966
Like, if, if, let's say, my Pashtun
identity or my Pashtun heritage was

564
00:40:45,973 --> 00:40:54,572
being used to basically kill people
and take over their land and, you

565
00:40:54,573 --> 00:40:58,797
know… Then, then it becomes very
important to make distinctions and

566
00:40:59,265 --> 00:41:03,523
talk about it in a way that it doesn't
allow for it to get weaponized.

567
00:41:04,247 --> 00:41:10,041
Ezra Lipp: I think maybe where the
contradiction is, or is that it's Zionist

568
00:41:10,205 --> 00:41:17,453
ideology and identity being fused with
Jewish identity, be it cultural or

569
00:41:17,471 --> 00:41:20,521
ethnic, where the real danger comes in.

570
00:41:21,790 --> 00:41:25,816
I understand how Jewish identity
and the way it's characterized as an

571
00:41:25,829 --> 00:41:31,972
ethnic group is being weaponized and
utilized for harm and for Zionist cover.

572
00:41:31,972 --> 00:41:34,584
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: this
is the thing that I'm pointing to.

573
00:41:34,660 --> 00:41:39,165
And, I guess I'm just trying to
put a spotlight on something that

574
00:41:39,172 --> 00:41:46,169
I feel like we have overlooked,
but it is critical to the, not just

575
00:41:46,169 --> 00:41:50,517
the conversation, but the material
impact on the lives of Palestinians.

576
00:41:51,113 --> 00:41:58,104
You know, we can't deny the fact that
it is Jewishness… It's actually this

577
00:41:58,104 --> 00:42:05,353
idea of Jewish identity that is used for
the apartheid and the ethnic cleansing,

578
00:42:05,794 --> 00:42:07,757
the creation of the state of Israel.

579
00:42:09,199 --> 00:42:11,926
Like, it is Jewishness, right?

580
00:42:11,928 --> 00:42:19,321
So even though I have tried my best,
and succeeded, to never conflate

581
00:42:20,097 --> 00:42:24,667
Judaism and Zionism and claim that,
you know, all Jews are responsible

582
00:42:24,668 --> 00:42:27,256
for the acts of Zionists, right?

583
00:42:28,486 --> 00:42:35,333
At the end of the day, we need to have
a conversation about how Jewishness

584
00:42:35,961 --> 00:42:38,500
successfully has become weaponized.

585
00:42:40,396 --> 00:42:45,840
And if it is being weaponized to the
point where we are seeing the complete

586
00:42:45,869 --> 00:42:52,330
erasure, like genocide of an entire
people, then we need to talk about this.

587
00:42:52,336 --> 00:42:58,409
It's not just a matter of, "Oh, it's my
culture, and, you know, like I, I feel

588
00:42:58,415 --> 00:43:03,279
Jewish, I celebrate the holidays, I feel
like there's a cultural Jewish identity

589
00:43:03,280 --> 00:43:05,376
even though I'm not a practicing Jew."

590
00:43:05,376 --> 00:43:09,953
And like, all of this would have
been a conversation that would've

591
00:43:09,953 --> 00:43:15,224
been lovely if it wasn't happening
at the same time as genocide

592
00:43:15,884 --> 00:43:15,894
Ezra Lipp: Yeah.

593
00:43:15,894 --> 00:43:16,129
Yeah

594
00:43:16,287 --> 00:43:17,962
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui:
in the name of Jewishness

595
00:43:18,624 --> 00:43:21,019
Ezra Lipp: I'm glad you
said all that, and I I think

596
00:43:23,256 --> 00:43:29,300
I think whatever, confusion I might
have that I still need to work out or

597
00:43:29,300 --> 00:43:35,832
anyone, I think it's good to keep the
focus on how this is being weaponized to,

598
00:43:36,642 --> 00:43:38,120
commit genocide and, harm Palestinians

599
00:43:38,453 --> 00:43:41,202
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: And,
a- and not just like the genocide,

600
00:43:41,202 --> 00:43:47,063
but also in sucking up all the oxygen
in the room in the West, right?

601
00:43:47,066 --> 00:43:48,615
So I'll give you an example.

602
00:43:48,617 --> 00:43:51,668
I was speaking to someone over the
weekend, and they were just like telling

603
00:43:51,669 --> 00:43:56,097
me how they're a schoolteacher, who's
this lovely old lady, and she teaches in

604
00:43:56,097 --> 00:43:59,837
this like very predominantly Arab school.

605
00:44:00,088 --> 00:44:01,840
she's Jewish background.

606
00:44:02,421 --> 00:44:07,402
and she is just scared all the time,
and she's expressed how she's always

607
00:44:07,404 --> 00:44:11,741
worried that she's gonna be attacked,
that she's gonna be attacked, right?

608
00:44:11,759 --> 00:44:13,176
Or that she's gonna be harmed.

609
00:44:13,582 --> 00:44:17,149
And I even asked, I even asked this
person, you know, I was like, "Has

610
00:44:17,149 --> 00:44:22,689
she ever been attacked? Has there ever
been an incident in her life where

611
00:44:22,689 --> 00:44:31,419
she has experienced harm?" and no, but
this constant like projection of fear

612
00:44:31,498 --> 00:44:37,032
and again, it's weaponized, and it
sucks up all the oxygen in the room.

613
00:44:37,313 --> 00:44:42,221
When you have Palestinians, Muslims,
Arabs, people who are pro-Palestine

614
00:44:42,466 --> 00:44:48,567
literally being physically attacked,
harmed, and then you've got people

615
00:44:48,567 --> 00:44:53,275
saying, "But I'm Jewish, and I'm
scared," and for the attention

616
00:44:53,318 --> 00:44:55,881
to go to you and to your safety.

617
00:44:57,018 --> 00:45:04,841
so here we see this stereotype again
being used, this narrative of the

618
00:45:04,845 --> 00:45:11,524
violent terror that comes from Arabs,
inherently violent Arabs exist in

619
00:45:11,524 --> 00:45:14,694
this school, even though there's never
been an incident, even though these

620
00:45:14,694 --> 00:45:20,029
are children, but I as a teacher, I'm
scared because this is who they are.

621
00:45:20,206 --> 00:45:25,014
Ezra Lipp: but I think that is the s-
the intent of Zionism to perpetuate and,

622
00:45:25,187 --> 00:45:32,293
call to the constant, imaginary threat
of antisemitism, the weaponization of it,

623
00:45:32,333 --> 00:45:35,828
in order to justify its colonial project.

624
00:45:36,323 --> 00:45:40,084
I did wanna bring up, I did wanna
talk about armed resistance,

625
00:45:42,897 --> 00:45:43,256
Okay.

626
00:45:43,284 --> 00:45:47,818
I wanted to just take a moment to talk
about the Al Tuffah School in Gaza.

627
00:45:48,436 --> 00:45:54,802
I had the privilege earlier this
week to do a Zoom call and I got

628
00:45:54,807 --> 00:45:57,467
to, say hello to so many students.

629
00:45:57,467 --> 00:46:02,543
They have, uh, few hundred students at
this school, and I also got to speak

630
00:46:02,543 --> 00:46:05,789
with some of the teachers and they showed
me some of the mass infrastructural

631
00:46:06,111 --> 00:46:10,084
problems and repairs needed and the
lack of supplies that the kids have.

632
00:46:10,652 --> 00:46:12,298
the kids were so sweet and adorable.

633
00:46:12,495 --> 00:46:15,592
Anyway, they prepared a special
video message for us if you wanna

634
00:46:15,593 --> 00:46:17,141
contribute and support the school.

635
00:46:17,653 --> 00:46:21,715
There's a link to donate below and
here's a message from the school and then

636
00:46:21,715 --> 00:46:23,314
we'll get right back to our conversation

637
00:47:26,706 --> 00:47:30,467
Ezra Lipp: I did wanna bring up, I
did wanna talk about armed resistance,

638
00:47:31,059 --> 00:47:31,413
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: Mm-hmm.

639
00:47:31,713 --> 00:47:37,575
Ezra Lipp: Palestinian armed resistance
And I wanna approach it in, in a way that

640
00:47:37,637 --> 00:47:45,701
Maybe is a little more relevant to, how
we can think about how we practice, as

641
00:47:45,713 --> 00:47:49,213
activists, as advocates for Palestine.

642
00:47:49,861 --> 00:47:51,002
how do we resist?

643
00:47:52,875 --> 00:47:58,522
And, and I know our, I know our, our
circumstances are so, so different

644
00:47:58,530 --> 00:48:02,288
from people experiencing violence
on the ground in Palestine, in

645
00:48:02,288 --> 00:48:04,308
Gaza or the West Bank or anywhere.

646
00:48:05,420 --> 00:48:07,282
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: you
know, I've, I've spoken about this

647
00:48:07,293 --> 00:48:11,885
topic many times, and I always say
that, violence comes in different

648
00:48:11,885 --> 00:48:17,180
forms, There is physical violence that
we are aware of that, when people talk

649
00:48:17,190 --> 00:48:21,564
about violence, you know, they often
are talking about, physical violence,

650
00:48:21,565 --> 00:48:23,097
like getting physically attacked.

651
00:48:24,382 --> 00:48:30,218
But there's also, like, psychological
violence that people experience, I've

652
00:48:30,218 --> 00:48:37,247
had a Zionist write me a message saying
that, they're gonna come to my house

653
00:48:37,253 --> 00:48:41,401
and hang my children off the trees
in my backyard and lynch us, right?

654
00:48:41,437 --> 00:48:47,351
And it was one of the worst messages
I've ever received, and I remember

655
00:48:47,368 --> 00:48:55,043
having a very visceral reaction to
that one particular message And it felt

656
00:48:55,070 --> 00:48:58,425
like a form of psychological violence
because obviously what they're doing

657
00:48:58,427 --> 00:49:02,221
is they're trying to scare me, but then
the imagination of it happening, right?

658
00:49:02,241 --> 00:49:04,001
Like it's… It was very hard.

659
00:49:04,041 --> 00:49:04,296
So

660
00:49:04,387 --> 00:49:05,340
Ezra Lipp: that's awful.

661
00:49:05,340 --> 00:49:05,360
I'm so

662
00:49:05,726 --> 00:49:06,266
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: thank you.

663
00:49:06,525 --> 00:49:08,211
But, this happens all day, every day.

664
00:49:08,211 --> 00:49:13,085
So, you know, violence comes in
so many different forms, and what

665
00:49:13,109 --> 00:49:18,372
Palestinians are living through
is all of the forms of violence.

666
00:49:18,463 --> 00:49:23,829
It's the physical violence, the,
the violation of their human rights,

667
00:49:23,831 --> 00:49:25,958
their dignity, their movement.

668
00:49:26,341 --> 00:49:27,342
They're trapped.

669
00:49:27,767 --> 00:49:29,621
They can't live dignified lives.

670
00:49:29,671 --> 00:49:31,791
they can't live a life.

671
00:49:31,792 --> 00:49:34,619
They can't do the things that
ordinary people can do in terms of

672
00:49:34,619 --> 00:49:38,138
just go to school and have a career
or get married and have children.

673
00:49:38,140 --> 00:49:42,263
Like, there's this constant threat of
physical violence, and then that itself

674
00:49:42,923 --> 00:49:47,111
becomes a form of psychological violence
because the threat is consistently there.

675
00:49:47,513 --> 00:49:51,125
I remember one of my friends, a
Palestinian friend, told me about

676
00:49:51,194 --> 00:49:58,178
her cousin, this 10-year-old girl who
was shot by an IOF soldier in, Gaza

677
00:49:58,467 --> 00:50:02,762
because she crossed, she was playing
in the backyard, and she crossed

678
00:50:02,763 --> 00:50:09,291
an imaginary line that they had
created as to where their home ends.

679
00:50:10,787 --> 00:50:12,278
And she was just shot, right?

680
00:50:12,318 --> 00:50:12,976
just like that.

681
00:50:13,021 --> 00:50:17,851
And she experienced violence, but what
would you call the violence experienced

682
00:50:17,852 --> 00:50:22,048
by every other child watching that
and realizing, "Now I can't even play

683
00:50:22,353 --> 00:50:24,272
because I could get shot," right?

684
00:50:24,274 --> 00:50:27,248
So there's so many different
forms of violence out there.

685
00:50:28,059 --> 00:50:31,331
going back to this question of
like, what can we do in terms of

686
00:50:31,331 --> 00:50:35,914
like resisting, right, and armed
resistance and this idea of resistance.

687
00:50:37,456 --> 00:50:42,564
What we go through, what I go through,
and people who are especially racialized,

688
00:50:42,588 --> 00:50:49,402
Muslim, Arab, Palestinian, obviously,
we are constantly living through a

689
00:50:49,402 --> 00:50:54,240
threat of physical violence, actual
psychological violence, violence

690
00:50:54,240 --> 00:50:57,324
on our careers, our livelihoods.

691
00:50:57,718 --> 00:51:03,499
You know, so there's this constant
violent environment that we exist in

692
00:51:05,792 --> 00:51:10,824
And we are resisting it by speaking
out, by not being silenced, by

693
00:51:10,840 --> 00:51:16,565
continuing to do the advocacy and do
the work, and that is resistance, right?

694
00:51:16,675 --> 00:51:18,218
Existence, resistance.

695
00:51:19,100 --> 00:51:27,215
So for me, that is, It's a form
of resistance as we're fighting

696
00:51:27,215 --> 00:51:29,013
that psychological violence.

697
00:51:30,596 --> 00:51:35,921
But, you know, we are also resisting
physically as well, through

698
00:51:35,921 --> 00:51:38,690
our bodies and our livelihoods.

699
00:51:39,499 --> 00:51:42,813
there are people who have
been physically harmed.

700
00:51:43,103 --> 00:51:47,452
You know, I know Palestinians,
Arabs, people who are racialized,

701
00:51:47,479 --> 00:51:53,189
Black, Indigenous, Jewish
anti-Zionists who have been physically

702
00:51:53,189 --> 00:51:56,144
assaulted at rallies and protests.

703
00:51:57,290 --> 00:51:59,967
And, you know, they have experienced
physical violence, and they've

704
00:51:59,967 --> 00:52:04,840
resisted by continuously showing up,
by continuously being in those spaces.

705
00:52:06,090 --> 00:52:12,224
So there are many ways for us to
resist, and, my only, thing that I

706
00:52:12,227 --> 00:52:17,235
would say is that it doesn't matter
how you resist the oppression that

707
00:52:17,235 --> 00:52:22,206
we're seeing, the suppression,
The silencing, the gaslighting.

708
00:52:23,010 --> 00:52:26,233
It doesn't matter how you show up,
but just don't stop showing up, and,

709
00:52:26,384 --> 00:52:35,009
and don't stop fighting, not just
for, you know, like a ceasefire.

710
00:52:35,091 --> 00:52:38,561
And I always say this, there are
people who are fighting for the

711
00:52:38,627 --> 00:52:42,206
end of the most obvious violence.

712
00:52:43,158 --> 00:52:48,470
But to be fighting for Palestinians
to be able to live lives of dignity

713
00:52:48,471 --> 00:52:53,582
like everyone else, to not have to
live the, in this constant threat,

714
00:52:54,569 --> 00:52:58,388
and being controlled, like everything
about your life being controlled.

715
00:52:58,439 --> 00:53:04,446
to, the fact that the electricity is
the water is controlled, what comes

716
00:53:04,447 --> 00:53:06,371
in and what goes out is controlled.

717
00:53:08,510 --> 00:53:15,151
To live a life like that, you know,
it-it's, it's a horrible existence, and

718
00:53:15,505 --> 00:53:20,260
we need to fight for that rot at the
core of these systems that uphold that,

719
00:53:20,318 --> 00:53:26,479
So it's not just about sending money
and charity and asking for a ceasefire.

720
00:53:27,089 --> 00:53:31,925
yes, obviously we want, to
end arms sales to Israel.

721
00:53:31,930 --> 00:53:36,943
We want to like stop arming them
so that physical violence can end.

722
00:53:37,670 --> 00:53:42,723
But what I always say is that there
needs to be a dismantlement of Israel

723
00:53:43,741 --> 00:53:49,533
so that the violence that is every
day, that psychological and physical,

724
00:53:49,544 --> 00:53:51,572
the occupation, so that that can end

725
00:53:53,996 --> 00:53:54,954
Ezra Lipp: I fully agree.

726
00:53:56,317 --> 00:54:03,634
And I think where I struggle is, when
you said the idea is just to, you

727
00:54:03,634 --> 00:54:06,897
know, simply don't stop resisting,
and there's many forms it can take.

728
00:54:07,642 --> 00:54:15,044
but I think where I personally struggle,
because I am in community, at least

729
00:54:15,463 --> 00:54:19,419
peripherally through family connections,
through people I grew up with, like

730
00:54:20,107 --> 00:54:23,378
through a, a Zionist community, And
I think speaking to this idea of

731
00:54:23,378 --> 00:54:28,082
dehumanization that we touched on
earlier, like I don't think these are

732
00:54:28,436 --> 00:54:35,399
inherently evil people, even though
they're supporting materially or through

733
00:54:35,444 --> 00:54:40,793
emotional support or at least, these
systems, the-- these incredibly violent

734
00:54:41,583 --> 00:54:43,741
and arguably evil systems, you know?

735
00:54:44,799 --> 00:54:50,245
and I know it's a, cultural
indoctrination that I experienced

736
00:54:50,245 --> 00:54:52,148
that many Jewish people do.

737
00:54:53,089 --> 00:54:55,514
it's a ignorance, it's
a lack of understanding.

738
00:54:55,514 --> 00:55:00,638
It's, it-- and that was deliberately
imposed on our community through decades

739
00:55:00,638 --> 00:55:04,150
of psyops, you know, propaganda campaigns.

740
00:55:04,200 --> 00:55:07,789
but, you know, I really struggle with
like, you know, and I've had conversations

741
00:55:07,790 --> 00:55:12,091
with friends that are like, "Oh, well,
you just have to, you have to be soft,

742
00:55:12,092 --> 00:55:17,257
and it's a, and it's a, and it's a slow
process, and maybe you'll reach some of

743
00:55:17,258 --> 00:55:21,871
them, maybe you won't, but you just gotta
keep trying." And, but I'm like, "Okay,

744
00:55:21,871 --> 00:55:26,449
but there's people in Palestine that, you
know, we are, I guess I feel like there's

745
00:55:26,450 --> 00:55:33,457
this urgency in this crisis and, and it's
hard to sit here in my comfortable house

746
00:55:33,457 --> 00:55:35,560
and put out this podcast every week.

747
00:55:35,562 --> 00:55:37,927
And yes, I think, I think it's important.

748
00:55:37,928 --> 00:55:39,709
I think these conversations are important.

749
00:55:40,079 --> 00:55:44,923
I've learned so much from other people's
conversations, from my own conversations.

750
00:55:45,652 --> 00:55:51,207
But like, when the material reality
is so horrible and so violent, I

751
00:55:51,210 --> 00:55:55,899
feel like there's this impatience
and this kind of despair that comes

752
00:55:55,900 --> 00:55:58,681
up when I feel like it's not enough.

753
00:55:58,681 --> 00:56:03,578
is there more that we can be doing
that, that maybe is even more,

754
00:56:04,439 --> 00:56:10,662
um, more provocative, more, um…

755
00:56:12,676 --> 00:56:14,633
I just wonder if like, what we're doing,

756
00:56:15,509 --> 00:56:15,870
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: isn't

757
00:56:15,931 --> 00:56:16,423
Ezra Lipp: enough

758
00:56:17,564 --> 00:56:19,052
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: I
think, you know, when I say that

759
00:56:19,098 --> 00:56:24,039
we need to, resist and we need to
get to the core and, the rot at the

760
00:56:24,040 --> 00:56:26,106
core of the systems and all of that.

761
00:56:26,958 --> 00:56:31,632
And when we talk about systems, sometimes
it sounds like such a, vague term, right?

762
00:56:31,656 --> 00:56:35,466
Like there's some system out
there that's controlling us.

763
00:56:35,514 --> 00:56:41,706
And the thing is that the system is made
up of all these, isms that have become

764
00:56:41,707 --> 00:56:44,546
part of our everyday existence, right?

765
00:56:44,668 --> 00:56:46,034
One of them is capitalism.

766
00:56:46,528 --> 00:56:47,854
The other is individualism,

767
00:56:49,876 --> 00:56:51,043
and the other is liberalism.

768
00:56:51,825 --> 00:56:55,970
There are lots of isms that have
become a part of, who we are and

769
00:56:55,980 --> 00:56:57,592
how we function in the world.

770
00:56:58,815 --> 00:57:06,157
And part of the fight is against
these systems that, stop us from

771
00:57:06,158 --> 00:57:15,415
actually being liberated, So, you
know, look, I, I used to have a job

772
00:57:15,416 --> 00:57:17,309
that paid really, really good money.

773
00:57:17,686 --> 00:57:21,864
Do you think that when I was doing
my PhD, that my life's goal was

774
00:57:21,883 --> 00:57:26,715
to not make any money and to be
unemployed and to not have a career?

775
00:57:27,163 --> 00:57:34,673
one of the reasons why I was willing to
lose my job and I was willing for that

776
00:57:34,685 --> 00:57:40,299
to be a price that I pay for my advocacy,
is that was also rejecting capitalism

777
00:57:42,748 --> 00:57:48,402
It was like I was fighting Zionism,
but I was also fighting this idea of

778
00:57:48,402 --> 00:57:53,449
capitalism, that I'm like a cog in the
wheel, you know, that I'm like both

779
00:57:53,466 --> 00:57:56,318
product and producer within this system.

780
00:57:56,735 --> 00:58:02,080
I'm being exploited, I'm being…
So, you know, part of my resistance,

781
00:58:02,525 --> 00:58:08,438
I feel, was against this capitalist
system and individualism, where it

782
00:58:08,438 --> 00:58:12,670
was like my own comfort and, you know,
things that made me happy in terms

783
00:58:12,672 --> 00:58:15,561
of like buying power and all of that.

784
00:58:16,051 --> 00:58:17,704
It changed completely, right?

785
00:58:17,711 --> 00:58:21,234
So my resistance was
against all of that as well.

786
00:58:21,939 --> 00:58:26,184
And we really should be
fighting all of that.

787
00:58:27,049 --> 00:58:30,013
everything is connected, and this
has been the big epiphany, this

788
00:58:30,014 --> 00:58:35,620
has been the big reali- realization
that I've had since, October 2023.

789
00:58:35,658 --> 00:58:38,609
I just have realized that
everything is connected.

790
00:58:38,935 --> 00:58:44,418
was very loud, and I spent a lot
of time doing advocacy around the

791
00:58:44,418 --> 00:58:47,579
newly released Epstein files last
year as well, and earlier this

792
00:58:47,580 --> 00:58:50,571
year, and everything is connected.

793
00:58:51,075 --> 00:58:53,381
like what's happening
in Iran is connected.

794
00:58:53,382 --> 00:58:56,558
What's happening, what happened
in Venezuela is connected.

795
00:58:56,984 --> 00:58:58,741
Yemen is connected.

796
00:58:59,606 --> 00:59:06,473
We need to educate ourselves and
realize that, we're a part of all,

797
00:59:06,488 --> 00:59:09,685
the system affects all these things,
and all these things are connected

798
00:59:09,689 --> 00:59:15,200
to, to Zionism as well and to
what's happening to Palestinians.

799
00:59:16,316 --> 00:59:22,814
And one thing that I say in terms of
like taking your advocacy to another

800
00:59:22,815 --> 00:59:28,933
level is, I think it's great work to
be doing work online and educating

801
00:59:28,935 --> 00:59:30,355
people and bringing awareness.

802
00:59:30,357 --> 00:59:31,691
Yes, that's excellent.

803
00:59:31,691 --> 00:59:32,251
That's wonderful.

804
00:59:32,253 --> 00:59:36,551
But it's still doing it within some
sort of comfort and safety, right?

805
00:59:36,551 --> 00:59:38,634
Like we're talking to
people who are allies.

806
00:59:38,646 --> 00:59:41,462
We are talking to people who are
on the same wavelength as us.

807
00:59:42,117 --> 00:59:47,049
And I think the really difficult stuff,
the really difficult part, is to confront

808
00:59:47,710 --> 00:59:56,559
Zionists and to confront racists and
capitalists and, people who are, fascist

809
00:59:56,610 --> 01:00:00,753
and at the head of this system, right?

810
01:00:00,792 --> 01:00:05,917
And so making people uncomfortable
and being uncomfortable

811
01:00:05,917 --> 01:00:10,195
yourself in the process is that
next step, which is not easy

812
01:00:10,371 --> 01:00:10,792
Ezra Lipp: Y- right.

813
01:00:10,847 --> 01:00:15,012
and also I think that's where the, the
tension lies for me, 'cause I, I try to

814
01:00:15,014 --> 01:00:21,579
do that in my life, but there's a, there's
this tension of, do you try to speak to

815
01:00:21,579 --> 01:00:27,143
the Zionist, and in a way that, humanizes
them and puts them at ease and just pushes

816
01:00:27,143 --> 01:00:29,814
their, you know, boundaries a little bit?

817
01:00:30,752 --> 01:00:33,745
or do you show up outside
the synagogue and protest?

818
01:00:33,756 --> 01:00:34,323
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui:
All of them.

819
01:00:34,344 --> 01:00:36,061
The, the point is all
of them are important.

820
01:00:36,069 --> 01:00:39,430
Everything that you said is important,
and this is why, bringing it all

821
01:00:39,446 --> 01:00:43,036
back to, like, the film Nazha, which
initially I didn't think that I

822
01:00:43,047 --> 01:00:46,503
wanted to watch, but then realized
that it was an important film.

823
01:00:46,780 --> 01:00:48,118
I'm glad that it was made.

824
01:00:48,447 --> 01:00:53,997
but what some of these IOF soldiers
were revealing were their very intricate

825
01:00:54,120 --> 01:01:01,063
military tactics and processes that
they went through as human beings.

826
01:01:01,108 --> 01:01:07,247
to be able to listen to how they press
these buttons and the process that they

827
01:01:07,247 --> 01:01:13,403
went through, mental, physical, to engage
in the killing of hundreds of people at

828
01:01:13,446 --> 01:01:19,643
a time, It was necessary because I don't
think we would've had that information

829
01:01:19,644 --> 01:01:25,620
at this point of the genocide if it
wasn't talking to them directly, the

830
01:01:25,620 --> 01:01:27,530
people who were pushing the buttons.

831
01:01:28,789 --> 01:01:35,777
And this whole… perhaps one of the
most important parts of this film, Nazar,

832
01:01:35,814 --> 01:01:44,132
that has stuck with me is, there was that
story of how, with the AI systems that

833
01:01:44,133 --> 01:01:49,757
were being used, where they are literally
watching, listening to everything.

834
01:01:49,768 --> 01:01:56,649
The surveillance state, Gaza and
the West Bank and, the territories

835
01:01:56,649 --> 01:02:00,407
where Palestinians are, that
Israel s- has that control over

836
01:02:00,407 --> 01:02:03,121
still, ability to surveil them.

837
01:02:04,333 --> 01:02:10,200
That is the epitome of all of these things
that we've always feared, you know, about

838
01:02:10,232 --> 01:02:13,171
living in a dystopian surveillance state.

839
01:02:13,980 --> 01:02:20,600
They are literally living in what
we have described as dystopia, where

840
01:02:21,298 --> 01:02:26,011
every text message, their locations,
their… Like, you know, Someone's

841
01:02:26,039 --> 01:02:32,965
entire family was killed because the
father bought bread from the same baker

842
01:02:33,970 --> 01:02:39,871
that someone who's a Hamas soldier
bought bread from, and it's just Naza.

843
01:02:40,153 --> 01:02:41,676
It's just collateral damage.

844
01:02:43,184 --> 01:02:44,885
And, entire families wiped out.

845
01:02:44,891 --> 01:02:48,494
the fact that there was a soldier
who literally described listening,

846
01:02:48,732 --> 01:02:56,375
having access to the entire audio
of a home before it was bombed

847
01:02:56,387 --> 01:02:58,040
with several family members in it.

848
01:02:58,078 --> 01:03:06,371
they were able to listen to the screams
before and after the bomb hit them.

849
01:03:06,941 --> 01:03:14,818
it's like they heard the children
dying Again, this coming from them

850
01:03:15,746 --> 01:03:21,346
was very important because what
do we do with a society like this?

851
01:03:23,427 --> 01:03:25,210
Ezra Lipp: Well, do you have an answer?

852
01:03:26,763 --> 01:03:27,931
What do you, what do we do?

853
01:03:28,734 --> 01:03:33,785
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui: I mean,
my answer, my humble opinion and answer

854
01:03:33,785 --> 01:03:41,187
to this question is, what if there was
a society that just gave equal rights to

855
01:03:41,192 --> 01:03:48,371
everyone, where there was no apartheid
system, where there were no residential

856
01:03:48,462 --> 01:03:54,036
housing laws that prevented Arabs from
buying properties or renting in certain

857
01:03:54,039 --> 01:03:56,947
places, that everything was exactly equal.

858
01:03:57,245 --> 01:04:04,428
My suspicion is that the Israelis who
have been enjoying the privilege of

859
01:04:04,429 --> 01:04:09,464
Jewish supremacy, all the privileges
that come with that, and who have

860
01:04:09,464 --> 01:04:13,519
been brainwashed successfully to
the point where they believe that

861
01:04:13,520 --> 01:04:16,475
they are deserving somehow, right?

862
01:04:16,475 --> 01:04:20,473
Like that, that, Jewish people and
Israelis are just more deserving

863
01:04:20,473 --> 01:04:25,512
because they are modern and progressive,
and Arabs are just regressive and

864
01:04:25,860 --> 01:04:28,059
inherently violent, all the tropes.

865
01:04:28,749 --> 01:04:32,650
Like those type of people might
not want to live there anymore.

866
01:04:33,657 --> 01:04:37,765
They will refuse to live equally in a
society with everyone else, and they

867
01:04:37,765 --> 01:04:43,155
might leave So, you know, like in
terms of having an answer to all of

868
01:04:43,156 --> 01:04:47,996
this, I do think that we need to start
talking about like these, this, these,

869
01:04:48,197 --> 01:04:49,794
this is the elephant in the room.

870
01:04:50,377 --> 01:04:54,799
these are not a small group of people.

871
01:04:54,825 --> 01:04:58,623
It's not just extremist settlers
that we're talking about now.

872
01:04:59,682 --> 01:05:02,405
we're talking about
Israeli society at large.

873
01:05:02,425 --> 01:05:05,343
And I know that there are people
who are in Israel who are fighting.

874
01:05:05,363 --> 01:05:08,242
activists within Israel
who try to speak up

875
01:05:09,101 --> 01:05:11,120
Ezra Lipp: I mean, like a tiny fraction.

876
01:05:11,356 --> 01:05:12,030
Like, it's not…

877
01:05:12,708 --> 01:05:14,962
From all accounts, it's, it's small.

878
01:05:15,665 --> 01:05:18,124
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui:
So what do we do with that?

879
01:05:18,212 --> 01:05:25,614
Nazar has exposed the fact that
Israeli society is complicit, that

880
01:05:25,626 --> 01:05:30,092
we can no longer talk about the
violence as being a s- for coming

881
01:05:30,093 --> 01:05:32,303
from a small, proportion of people.

882
01:05:32,961 --> 01:05:36,921
So, I know a lot of people said that
Naza was made for Israelis, right?

883
01:05:37,000 --> 01:05:41,732
I actually think that it was made for
the rest of the world, and I think that

884
01:05:42,735 --> 01:05:44,635
when you hear it from the horse's mouth,

885
01:05:45,367 --> 01:05:49,656
like I told you, I got up in that theater
and I looked around, and it was just

886
01:05:49,656 --> 01:05:56,189
like a sea of white people watching
this documentary, and I could physically

887
01:05:56,200 --> 01:05:58,029
see the effect that it had on them

888
01:06:00,568 --> 01:06:01,449
So it was important

889
01:06:04,003 --> 01:06:08,636
Ezra Lipp: Sabreena, there's so much
more I could-- we could talk about, I--

890
01:06:08,877 --> 01:06:10,538
but I wanna be respectful of your time.

891
01:06:10,544 --> 01:06:12,124
Thank you so much for coming on,

892
01:06:12,156 --> 01:06:13,082
Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui:
Thank you, Ezra,

893
01:06:13,133 --> 01:06:15,528
And I think you're doing
very important work,

894
01:06:15,600 --> 01:06:17,115
So thank you, I appreciate that

895
01:06:22,798 --> 01:06:23,639
And there you have it.

896
01:06:23,762 --> 01:06:25,559
Thank you so much for listening.

897
01:06:25,572 --> 01:06:28,391
Thank you, Dr. Sabreena,
for coming on the show.

898
01:06:28,413 --> 01:06:29,660
It was such a pleasure.

899
01:06:30,053 --> 01:06:34,936
Please check out Sabreena's
book, "DEI Undone." Go watch "The

900
01:06:34,937 --> 01:06:38,267
Rest." Website's linked below.

901
01:06:38,380 --> 01:06:43,568
You can find Sabreena, and she's
also spoken about so many other parts

902
01:06:43,568 --> 01:06:47,655
of her story and her journey on so
many other podcasts and shows, so

903
01:06:47,764 --> 01:06:49,126
she has a lot more to talk about.

904
01:06:49,127 --> 01:06:51,280
So go check her out There's
some great interviews out there.

905
01:06:52,371 --> 01:06:55,718
Thank you for returning to "The
Thin Veil." Like, subscribe,

906
01:06:55,881 --> 01:06:58,607
Support us on Patreon or on Ko-fi.

907
01:06:58,811 --> 01:07:03,483
Please support Al Tuffah Kindergarten
There's a link to donate below too.

908
01:07:03,501 --> 01:07:05,037
They could use our help.

909
01:07:05,334 --> 01:07:07,196
Thank you for doing all you're doing.

910
01:07:07,635 --> 01:07:10,963
I wish you a very free Palestine
and thank you for being here