Welcome back everybody to another exhilarating episode of of energy bites. Rad dad here, John Calfan. Bobby is is out today. It is the last Friday of school before uh Christmas. And so I think pretty much every school district in town has a half day. So he's he's playing dad this afternoon. So it's just going to be me today, but today I've got Scott Paper. Um Excuse me. [snorts] I've got Scott, our our field CTO at Ansys. Thanks for for joining us today, man. John, thanks for having me. And thanks for the warning about traffic when I leave you today. There's going to be a little bit more traffic, I guess. Oh man, I mean I I actually posted on Twitter. I put in I always put in work on my Google or Apple CarPlay this morning when I come in and it was only 17 minutes from Katy. And I was like, "Oh, wow." Miracles do happen. [laughter] Yeah, that's normally a Got to love Waze. 30-45 minute commute time. So it's you've got definitely got 980 Fridays that you can definitely tell where traffic slows down, but then you've got kids not going to school today as well. So that's going to be a a good one. So Appreciate you coming on. You've got a You've got a really cool kind of history, experience, career-wise, and stuff. And so I kind of want to jump in. Both mechanical engineers, but kind of tell us, you know, how you got into the energy and or tech space kind of going up to where you're at today at at Ansys. Sure. Um Well, look, engineering is one of those things I think you discover it quite young. I was always quite curious about how things worked. And I had a habit of taking things apart. Not necessarily all the screws came back in when I put the toaster back or the air popper. But it would it was that kind of a childhood, right? You always kind of which which led me more to the mechanical side. Um only because I did an experiment with electricity and it didn't work out very well. [laughter] And I said, you know, that may be a little too dangerous for me. So anyway, I ended up in mechanical engineering. And then uh really because, you know, of that that curiosity and how things worked. And then to be honest with you, my my favorite topic in college and high school was really physics. Yeah. And I So, as much as I didn't go into electrical engineering, I really was curious about how everything worked. Electromagnetics and and so forth. Material science was very interesting. So, I kind of I kind of fell into it that way and I think it affected my curiosity in science and and engineering for my entire career. So, even as I would, you know, became a CTO at whether it was GE, or Baker Hughes in different roles, I stayed very curious technically. And um, I'm not saying I could go deep with each of you know, all these PhDs and scientists, but in especially in technology development, I found it to be and you and I talked a little bit about this before, I I found it to be uh, very enlightening in terms of where that tech may end up. Right. Uh, globally in a product space. I mean, you think glass is not that interesting. Bulletproof glass gets more interesting. And glass that can be used as a solar panel is even more interesting, right? So, even something is maybe as simple as that uh, can evolve into products all over the world. So, that that kind of curiosity to me was what would lead me into engineering. And uh, you know, I started with a undergraduate degree, then realized, or at least my professor made me believe uh, after doing a summer internship at a paper mill with Bechtel in Maine, um, I I realized I wanted to be on the design side, not the field installation side. Uh, and he said, "Look, you got Didn't enjoy your time at the paper mill? Well, you know, [laughter] paper mills can be quite dangerous. Not as dangerous as they used to be. But they used to be one of the more dangerous industries. Oh, for sure. The amount of engineer mechanical engineers specifically that I know that have worked at a paper mill in some form or fashion is pretty crazy actually. Yeah, it is. It is. And none of them work at paper mills because of that experience. I am from Maine. So, paper mills are important, but but to the economy up there. But but ultimately, yeah, it it was a you know, it became more and more automated, too. They were one of those industries where they became because of the hazard. Right. Looked at automation differently. It wasn't just about penny saved on the pound. It was It was about pound saved on the body. Yeah. And so, I think that that always made paper industry. But But I after that went to graduate school Penn State, did my master's degree in aerospace engineering, and started using frankly the ANSYS product again. You know, started doing computational work and in acoustics and structural mechanics and vibration space trust dynamics and these kinds of things. And I thought I would end up uh you know, looking at satellites when I was done. Instead, really uh you know, I ended up working for companies like GE uh at the time the aerospace was a little bit in a slump. This was late uh mid early early '90s. So, I ended up in automation and robotics for compact disc and DVD manufacturing, which dates me. I mean, that stamps me pretty good uh in terms of tech. But that's a fascinating time though, right? Like Cuz it was. It was because we didn't then have tools and we didn't have the connectivity. Yeah. But what was interesting about our equipment is cuz they were all automated, we did have all the sensing and equipment in one place. So, that one brain real time we could do a lot of things. It was quite interesting. Even from like a product perspective, right? Like uh man, I'm going to forget the name of that book, but there's a a really good product book out there. Um and you again, I'll remember that probably at the end and I'll put it in the show notes, but he talks a lot about like it's about the evolution of products and how they like generally speaking will spin out of a major like why can't the whole thesis of the book is why can't these giant GE style companies or you know, IBM back in the day, why can't those companies innovate as quick or as fast as like the new companies and stuff. And one of the the examples they use in the book is they were talking about like early days of computer storage with the hard like hard drives, right? And so like you know, whoever it was, Seagate or one of those old school players, you know, they were highly focused on just uh making the desktop computer hard drives smaller, more efficient, etc. Well, in that project, this small group of guys developed this really small hard drive that couldn't store as much, but it was very performant and low power consumption. Seagate didn't want it or whoever it was. and I don't remember, but they spun off a company that then started targeting the new laptop market, which, you know, was still very young, and a lot of people didn't know what that was going to be. And then they, you know, step change, jumped Right. their prior company, started their own company cuz they didn't want anything to do with it, and now they got bought back but, you know, 10 years later [clears throat] from that company, right? And so even like in that space, like I remember back then, right? We went from the OG floppy disks to hard floppy disks to CDs, and then I remember wanting a zip drive so bad just because of the storage capacity, right? [laughter] I don't remember what it was. I don't know if any company would let you use a zip drive [laughter] because I think you're going to take the data home with you, and then probably, you know, so so it's funny how you say that. I mean, technology's get get adopted and then obsoleted. Mhm. Well, yeah, like HD DVD is another one, right? Like the the whole Blu-ray DVD HD DVD kind of saga, right? All of that. It's always fascinating to see that like over time how all that plays out, and why one wins over the other, and all of those different kind of knobs that turn, so. And I I actually that would be one of the things that from a career standpoint, uh, really helped me define where I would go next because I I realized that in this very small company, you know, when I joined it was like 20 of us. When I left I was running it, and about 300 of us. Um, but at the end of the day, that company came in wet with the tech. Right. And, you know, we tried to leverage it into other kind of capab- and it just didn't work. And I think one of the things I learned in in going to GE was if you're in all these spaces, first of all, the pace and and to your description in terms of how how do you move quicker in the innovation space? Sometimes you got to carve people out Mhm. and let them focus. Um, and other times you've got to give them the support that is only a scaling large company can give. Not just financial support, but maybe it's manufacturing know-how, lean know-how, whatever it might be, uh, to help them move more assuredly with less risk. They're still going to have risk in maybe the tech and in know-how of the development of the product or the market isn't ready. But, you have the leverage of scale in terms of how you get there right with with some level of confidence that you're going to make it. Yeah, now that's like I think that's probably one of the most interesting dynamics in like the energy tech space specifically, right? Is you've got you know, every startup looks at all the big publicly traded companies and they're like, you've got all the resources in the world. How can't How come you can't Right. innovate faster or how come you don't want to adopt our new thing or technology or whatever. And then the flip side of that is it's like, you've got all this innovation and you can move very quickly, but you don't have those processes and structures to go scale, to manufacture, to support. Like, big companies do certain things very well and that's why they got so big, right? But, smaller companies do the other thing really well, but then they can't you know, the there's that dichotomy of them where it's like them trying to bring a product to market is very different at a small startup than at a GE or IBM big huge model. working on profitability. Right. the backside of that curve, right? It's kind of interesting, you know, I had a stint I had a couple of stints where I I ran and operated like a COO role and I had manufacturing and engineering together. And I remember I So, I reported both to the senior leader of engineering at GE and the senior leader of manufacturing at GE at one point. And in those conversations, you know, they were typically not together when we had [laughter] Right, so I would talk to one guy one day and the next guy. And I remember the manufacturing leader said, "Listen, we can't overthink this. We're knuckle draggers." And I I I stopped the mid-sentence and said, "Don't ever call me a knuckle dragger because there isn't any role in any big company where you shouldn't be" And I I look in in good faith, he was a good friend of mine. So, it it was not he didn't mean it as an insult. But, the reality is a lot of times the opportunity innovate is in the white space between functions still today. We see, you know, you a lot of verticalized and we decentralized engineering in most companies. I don't know whether it was uh which of the, you know, consultancy company told [laughter] everybody to do that 10 years ago. You know, but it almost killed innovation. Because now we've taken engineers that used to work collectively together and we've separated them all and put them in little boxes and said, "Don't talk to each other, right?" So, moving around the cabin in in in manufacturing at at a company like GE or any of the other large industrial companies, um is in fact, you know, a science around how do we get this product safely and quality control and all those things you probably don't have to worry as much about it like you when you're patching a a software that, you know, is showing you how to do Tik Tok dances. I mean, that's that isn't even comparable to the level of safety, right? And we thank God uh that we have in the big industrial space. So, it does change, and I think a lot of those small companies, wide-eyed, pretty bright, but at the same time don't understand that piece. You have to live through a product failure. Oh, yeah. Uh at that at scale, you know, at the hundreds of millions of dollars of scale. Uh hopefully you don't have too many of those in your career, but when you do, uh it changes the way you think about that stage gate design process and why it's so important to get as much as you know on the table early, Yeah. tested, and and verified before you ship. But, those are different business models. For sure. Yeah. [clears throat] Well, tell me so cuz like I said, so you've got a very kind of interesting background both on the tech, energy tech, and product space, but what are some things, you know, that that you see companies do well, you know, so continue this conversation on, right? A lot of times what happens is those smaller players they innovate, they move fast, they have something unique, proprietary, etc., and then they get bought by, you know, uh a large publicly traded Yeah. whether that be, you know, on the oil field services side like a Haliburton, Schlumberger, Baker, or, you know, on the industrial manufacturing side, whether that be GE, IBM, whoever, right? Like they get bought, and sometimes those companies buy them, and then that technology goes to die Yeah. a lot of in some of these companies like notoriously. And then another company's they're actually incredibly good, even like with uh well, I guess operator MMA or M&A, right? Like when Exxon bought XTO, Mhm. right? Like XTO kept their office and they they allowed them to operate as two separate companies but with the support of and the resources of the big company instead of forcing the innovative little company that we bought because they were innovative and they had a new thing or they had a different approach but then forcing that into you know the monolith archaic or not archaic but just rigid structure of a super major type thing, right? So what what are some things you see you've seen people do well as far as that either with product or you know acquisition or what are some areas where you've seen like very common mistakes that you know you might not think. Yeah, you know I've lived through both of them, right? So I've been acquired and then and it many times and with my small startup company was acquired by a German company. And that first run of that experience was you know the German company came in and said okay, who's who's running the engineering? You run the company. It was almost that start kind of a decision. And you know processes were what they were. We were a much more we would say a cultural western startup. Now we weren't we weren't a west coast startup. We were an east coast startup. And the the difference is you didn't know if you were getting paid that week. Right? [laughter] Today you know it's a little different. These guys get big series of funding. But anyway from that standpoint having been acquired by a German company very similar at the time I think when Daimler and Chrysler were getting together and I was reading about some of the cultural issues. We were a much smaller company and yet at the same time going through a lot of that same cultural issues. So to to me it comes down to people. And I've I've been on the acquiring where I'm doing the acquiring or been part of whether it's GE or Baker Hughes where we've acquired companies in the energy space specifically. And we've recognized that financially you know the mothership can't afford to have a compliance issue, right? So that quickly gets lined up. Um HR then follows that same stretch. For the for kind of the same reason, you know? And at the same time you know where some of these companies the leadership and the understanding who knows what is becomes important. So HR and and finance typically very quickly I I support that. I think when you get down to the next level, especially in engineering and in science space, I think there's way too many folks who don't have enough experience to know what they're doing in terms of how quickly they're crushing Right. innovation. And and it's hard to see sometimes. I mean it depends where you come out of engineering. You come out of field services, you come from research institution, and I don't think there's any right answer there, but but what I would say, what I do see works well is some level of recognizing we bought this company for a value, let's let the engineering teams in the and let's say the mothership, I'll keep going with the mothership, get some experience with that tech. Right. Under and you will find usually a great balance of floating some people across into that company for the right reasons. Right. Not to be there to knuckle whack in the dictator and crush everything down. And I I've I've done that a number of times. We bought a technology from when I was with General Electric in the clean coal gasification space here in Houston. And Exxon and Chevron were just kind of coming together and Chevron said, "Look, you can take this technology." We thought clean coal was going to be the thing. At the time natural gas was $15 a BTU, right? And so fracking wasn't even in the conversation at that time. And so General Electric having gas and steam turbines recognized if we could decarbonize coal Right. and at the coal's price point as a fuel, and we could use that syngas to turn gas turbines, we had a solution that would be unique in the market. When I came down, I really I I inherited like five or six chemical engineers. And and what was interesting about that was those chemical engineers really had never made anything. Right. They'd done heat mass balances, they understood the the petrochemical processes, but they hadn't made anything. Yeah. And General Electric came in as a company that makes things, right? Big heavy things. Anyway, we one of the things we had to go do was a a syngas cooler and a syngas reactor. And and I remember bringing in people from GE research. Uh I brought a lot of young engineers in. That's a risk. So, I brought in professors, right, to coach them. Uh, and the topic very quickly became, "How do we create algorithms for all of this empirical stuff that we've been doing for years that would that tells us we understand what's going to come out of the other end of the the cooler after the reaction, but but what do we have to do to design a cooler?" Yeah. And the first strike at this thing was something the size of a Statue of Liberty that cost $50 million apiece and we all just looked at each other and said, "Is that what we have to do?" And uh, you know, but that's a long story, but ultimately I can like envision this in my head, right? Like, "Hey, you gave the engineers the constraints and the problem and they solved it. They didn't pay attention to the budget or the feasibility of that solution." time back. So, and and this was going back to your startup piece, that to me worked because we brought in people that weren't just General Electric people. Right. And if we did some of them come from the research center, so they were a little bit more open to experimenting and remodeling or whatever it might be. But I thought, you know, where you come in and you don't recognize people and culture, it's it's obviously a catastrophe. And and those integration leaders are often, unfortunately, some companies pick people who are just ripe for a promotion versus somebody who's ripe for the hard work because it's it's a lot of work. It's like any other startup, right? So, anyway, I I think those are those are lessons learned for me and and uh, but I you know, I'm not shy and it's just in this today buys, you know, we were really a 50 million a 50-year-old company and we were about a billion dollars maybe five eight years ago. We're about just over $2 billion company today and we do a lot of acquisitions in the software space. And typically, you know, we've done some in material science, we've done some in systems optimizations that are agnostic to any tool that you might be using. Um, but what's really exciting is we typically recognize that it's a niche. Right, it may be very very small. Maybe 10 physicists who have figured out a new way to model the tear of material. Yeah. Right? The cracking of it. And so that particular science is so valuable and so important in so many industries, we can provide that algorithm a place to a home that allows them to scale that business. Uh and at the same time we know what the value of that predictive crack is. Yeah. In so many industries. So I think we the answer is we we typically uh we acquire about one company a quarter in in this acquisition space. And it's all in physics. Most most often. We do a little platforming, but not really much. We we we do platforming where it makes sense for computational solutions. Right. Right. But in those cases and I've been, you know, connected to a few of those, uh you know, we we always stew around whether it should be a partnership. Right. Is it, you know, is it something we need to be, you know, ownership of or is it something that could just be a partnership with us? And that then leads us to leaving those people where they are and doing what they're doing and putting a very very limited amount of and again, mostly financing HR HR kind of I won't say auditing, but compliance and that kind of thing. Yeah. No, I mean it it makes a lot of sense like when you break it down like that, right? Like people would be like, why is this billion-dollar company buying these like super niche kind of focused things, but Yeah. to your point, right? Like metal cracking or materials cracking literally applies to every correct industry from Yeah. Corro- yeah, corrosion's another one, right? Like I think there's all these universalities that like Yes, it's a very small subset of every single market, but it's of every single market. Therefore, it has broad appeal Absolutely. and applicability instead of hyper focusing on one niche that is only that thing and then being like, well, how do we grow this? Right? Like not having that visionary kind of mentality of like, hey, this is not only applicable here cuz that happens all of the time, right? Across industries. It's like, hey, we've got this really cool thing. We're going to [snorts] go to market and we're going to build this company around it. It's like you and you can do that, but you can also, like if you really want to build a huge company, understanding where those things apply outside of your expertise or industry can be such a huge Well, it's a value multiplier, too, right? I mean, cuz if if you're looking in one sector and you don't have access to these other sectors, you're you're you're in fact um not getting the scale quick enough. And and ultimately sometimes that's what kills these startups. But the other thing I mean, just not to be too salesy, but what I was rem- you know, just remarked at um when I joined Ansys, you know, 93% customer approval rating Yeah. and on the top 10 list of companies most like to work for in the United States, it's really not that difficult to find people that want to come work for you, right? That culture's a winning culture, but it's also a culture where uh our employees are very very I mean, it's very flat. Our CEO is very accessible, remarkably bright uh man, of course, as you would expect. Um but what's what's really nice is the there's a a lack of I would say politics. Right. And, you know, I having been in mostly heavy industrial businesses for I would say I would say 28 of my um working working in a data software-ish, although most of our company is physicist or scientist uh before they're software engineers. Uh but in that space, it's really the the whole place is curious. Yeah. All the time. The level of questioning and asking and learning uh I I've never had a role in all these big companies where where I would have thousands of employees. Today I have none. And I am learning at a rate Right. like I was in college. Yeah. And I think, you know, depending on and again, this is kind of important, too, cuz a lot of the companies we acquire in our space aren't pure software companies. Right. And they are physicists. So, they find a home here pretty quick, and I think you know, any any M&A activity, you've got to make sure that culture piece Yeah. If it's not the same, how is it different? And let's talk about it. Let's make sure that's on the table. Oh, for sure. I mean, I've worked I've worked with a number of companies, whether it was overseas developers or uh I worked for a French company for a while um that did actually Bayesian modeling, which is another Okay. That's the only uh simulation professional experience that I have, but outside of all the stuff, you know, I did in undergrad with all my SolidWorks and 3D modeling stuff, but uh even that, right? Like within the same company, just cultural differences from True. geo, you know, uh from their their locations can be like a crazy thing. No less, okay, now we have that within the company that we're buying and now we're having to figure that out and our company's culture on top of that kind of scenario. So, it's it's a huge thing, right? Like even to the like down to, you know, certain countries just generally speaking, not that I want to make any generalizations, but like you know, super and even with the personality types, right? Like engineers like really highly technical engineers tend to be hard to get like information, like concise information out. Just like me right now babbling on. Well, we we're not very concise, right? Like and so being able to understand like the personality type and how they communicate and how to extract that information that you're trying to get out of them is is a huge factor in whether they have, you know, like a lot of developers I work with historically hard to get emotion out of some of them, right? And you're like, I have no idea if this person likes me or hates me, right? Like just completely impossible to read in in some situations, but that culture piece I completely agree with you is like the foundation of a lot of that M&A and even partnerships, right? Like just being able to make that that work because if it doesn't, it just just innovation in general. Yeah. If you just talk about the innovation, people like to talk about diversity. I I'm very I'm a, you know, supporter of diverse work forces, but I I my my slant on that from from experience is if you have a diverse workforce, but they're not connected to each other, Right. who cares? Yeah. There's no value. But what I've what I've seen is when you have a global workforce and you do have differences of culture and behavior in terms of how people work and like to work, um, you can actually use that as a multiplier. Yeah. And I used the example earlier the white space between functions. I mean I can't say this enough. I go into companies and you know engineering and manufacturing folks, you know the engineering leaders sitting over here in the manufacturing I mean those desks should be put together. Right. And and even inside engineering. Mhm. So when you go inside engineering, you know I I tell people today I think multi-physics simulation is being limited by organizational structure. Yeah. And people look at me what do you mean by that? Well, I mean you got a mechanical engineer is working on this problem and I I'll give you an example. I won't tell you what company but we were working on an on oxygen sensor. And uh we already had flow sensing and so forth but we wanted to make it more accurate and ultimately migrated to a hydrogen sensing which pretty small stuff hydrogen. So you've got to you've got to have the sensitivity. We had never run a multi-physics model of the flow of uh you know using computational flow dynamics with the electromagnetic field that was being created by the power supply. Mhm. And the reason we hadn't done it is first of all we weren't a simulation first culture in that equal part of the business yet. But when I asked the folks listen before you go do any experiments, I want to see a model that basically describes how the system works. Our physicist, not mechanical engineer, quickly realized oh but wait wait we're getting interference here Right. from the electromagnetic field. Long story short the sensor turns out to be orders of magnitude better in the first pass because we've taken two different engineering disciplines, not forced them together but recognized in the real world doesn't care that you're a mechanical engineer, right? These things don't separate themselves. We may try to from a from a system standpoint. Right. But anyway, I find that's true too in innovation and I think one of the things that kind of a pet peeve of mine is is early I would say 2015 onward and I again I don't know which consultancy company I'm pretty sure I know but started talking about blueprints and everywhere I'd go from Baker to BP and back to GE, everybody wanted to start to decentralize engineering. Yep. And and um I I had this conversation with a number of the CEOs ahead of time. I said would you decentralize finance? [laughter] And and that they would say well no, no, no, yeah, we I really? Okay." Cuz everybody turns in a different spreadsheet on Friday, the closing day. How are you going to put all that together? So, of course you wouldn't. But engineering, when you break it up into bits, small bits, right? You take this one brilliant material scientist and you he's over there with saying Germany and you've got a group here in the US that's working on a high temperature electronics for downhole tools. Why aren't they talking? Right. Well, because uh he works for this guy and he works for this guy. It's just It's amazing how innovation is stifled by poor leadership. Yeah. And I I sit with a lot of CTOs just because Ansys has that reach. I mean, we've got 45,000 or more customers around the world and almost anybody that makes anything is using We're about 50% of the world's simulation market. And so I when I sit with these CTOs, I ask them really basic questions. And it's not Look, if you're really good in digital, you're going to want to use simulation. It's not really that. It's what are your aspirations for innovation, your engineering workflows, how your engineers what they do, how they think, how they behave. How do you want to accelerate that pace with digital? And you know, it surprises me sometimes you'll get a CTO who really has no strategy. They may have a thousand, two thousand, three more more engineers and they really don't have a strategy. They want to go They want to chase productivity cuz that makes sense. And so I learn a lot from the different folks I meet with and Ansys and I we all try to kind of help as an adviser with 93% customer We're We're kind of partners with almost everybody that we work with. And we guard their information and their data very carefully, but ultimately we we think we help them innovate uh better if we can partner with them in terms of getting more engineers on the table working together. I don't regardless of work structures, you know, and but work structures kind of can can be a problem just like any M&A. No, I mean, that's uh that's probably one of my biggest complaints about the oil and gas side of it like out of the gate, right? To your point, you've got some of the most highly technical engineering staff in the world working at these companies. Correct. And then it's like, oh, well, there's the R&D group over here. There's the reservoir engineers over here. Also, if you're a reservoir engineer, now we're going to split you up by basin because surely there are no lessons that we can learn from other basins or other fields and that we're working in as well. Also, production engineers, we're going to do the same thing with you. Completion, you're going to be over here and drilling, you're going to be over here. And it's like this is all part of the same product, which is a well, which it is all tied to revenue, which is the oil coming out of that well. So, the faster the oil comes out of that well, the faster we get a return on our investment and the faster we can keep moving down the line. And yet that's that is such like a novel concept to most operators. And I think a lot of it comes from like the disconnect going back to our earlier conversation, right? Like when I was an industrial as an intern doing industrial engineering and manufacturing and everybody's focused on the problem like you wouldn't go build a a widget and go sit it on the shelf for 9 months and then go sell it. Like that's a very hard business plan and model and that's exactly what we do in oil and gas where it's like we go acquire an asset. Okay, we come up with all these plans and engineering and then we drill it and then by the time it starts producing, it's 9 months later. All of the money is up, you know, due upfront and super expensive, super risk, all you know, all these things and then hopefully we'll make money on it at the end. It's like if you can accelerate the time to revenue, you accelerate your ROI. Like it's basic, you know, basic math and and just business sense. one steps on the gas when they're lost. So, if you're lost and you you you you you feel you're risking it. I say this a lot, but but ultimately, you know, I won't drive 5 miles in Houston. I won't even drive out of my neighborhood without putting Waze on. Yeah. And yet what I can be in parts of the world and and everybody agrees, okay, well, that's it. That's a model, guys. That's a model. Pretty accurate. I mean, it had me here within 30 seconds essentially of when I left my house, you know, 30 miles away through traffic and, you know, ex- accidents and toll booths. And so, people believe confidently in those kinds of models to go base their, you know, stepping on the gas. I find it it's just remarkable. We have big customers good customers like Cummins a good customer of ours that that I can speak to that that is their CTO is simulation first. Yep. And whether it's simulation first or we're going to do systems engineering or whatever that's going to be, having what I find the hybrid organization that works really well is having a few people at a center of excellence. Not a lot of people cuz that can become a more of a researchy kind of, you know, we're just going off and studying our navel. When when in fact what we want to do is we still solve a problem and we want to be in directionally doing this. Yeah. But if you don't have if you want to put all your engineering leaders under business unit leaders, some of which are not technical at all, and you want to call yourself a technology company, and that business unit leader really can't fall over a soapbox and understand the difference between soap and acid, uh then you then you probably have the wrong structure. And ultimately it's it's not that it will necessarily fail, it's the things you just described, but it's suboptimized. Right. I mean, it's people. Suboptimized. And this is your most in most technical companies this is the most valuable group you've got in the room. And not allowing them I mean we will we will have this discussion about well, should we you know, get the chief engineers together once a year. Well, it's too expensive. And I'm like, "Hey, what are you talking about?" The finance guys just got back and they just did a three-day session with ice sculptures out there at wherever it was. Yeah. And and well, of course they did because we got to make our numbers. [laughter] You got to make your products work if you want to make your numbers, right? So, I I always find engineering in in unfortunately or fortunately, and I'm going to be too outspoken about it, but but I think engineering leaders and one of one CEO told me this. He said, "Look, engineering needs to push back more." And that's a fair that's a fair In fact, I'll share it with you cuz I have a lot of respect for him, Lorenzo Simonelli who runs Baker Hughes. You know, you technical guys got to You got to sit at the table use it, right? I mean Right. And so, I think you know, even if you have a group that doesn't know that, it's your job as a technical leader to say, "Look, we have to have We have to do We have to do it this way or we need to be organized in a way that allows us to share." Yeah. And if that means you can do it because the business unit leaders are all lined up around the fact that technology is going to get together one afternoon on a Friday, have a few pizzas, and look at technology together, then you you can make it work. Yeah. Yeah, they don't have to be restructured, but uh I find that to be the globally, industry independent, the biggest thwart to innovation. Yeah. No, I mean, it makes it makes a ton of sense, too. And like, you see it on the software side, you see it in so many of these different fields, right? Where it's like, "Oh, well, you know, we'll have we'll hire a developer to do it." It's like, "Okay, well, if you're deploying an enterprise-ready software product, you need a back-end developer, you need an architect, you need a front-end developer, you probably need a database guy. You like, there's all these Right. specialties that follow un- or that fall under that. And it's the exact same thing with engineering. And for whatever reason, no one not many people think about it that way, where it's like, "Hey, just because you're a petroleum engineer and I'm a mechanical engineer, that's actually a good thing if we're working together because we bring completely different perspectives to the problem that will make it better because we're not thinking in the same box." Yeah. And like, that's another big issue, right? diversity, right? I mean, that And that's that's where And I And I do think, you know, gender falls in that and other things fall in that, too, because people think differently. They come from But it's a zip code thing to me. Um and and if people are from one of the country have gone to these types of schools, uh then you mix them. You mix them up a little bit. And you mix the scientists. And there's a good book um I'm going to forget the name. It's IDEO is the name of the company. And the the writer it it was an amazing story about how he was doing innovation. And And I It's called the Innovation Handbook or something. I I you have to give it to you later. Uh but it's the company is a San Francisco-based company, IDEO. And these guys had come out of uh [clears throat] uh Stanford Design School. And again, independent of whatever industry you were in, they gave examples of where when they would want to figure out why people have stopped fishing for the fishing reel company. Um you know, they were all going down the they tell the story in the book. They're all they they take their scientist, their engineer, their fisherman, their psychologist, and they put that team together because they wanted this kind of very different kind of thinking. They sent them down to the lake to watch people fish. Mhm. And it was a psychiatrist about 30 minutes in. He said, "Wait a minute, this isn't where the problem is. These guys are already fishing. We need to go find out why people [laughter] aren't fishing. We need to go to Walmart and see what they sell this stuff for." And and so that diversity of thinking, to your point, is really exciting because a lot of times what we would do is we if we had a good idea, and we'd kind of quarterly look at it and say, "Geez, you know, this is this is something we ought to put a patent on. It's that good." We would say, "Okay, well, wait a minute. If we think it's a good idea now, Right. let's take the four guys that came up with the idea. Let's put them in a room with a whole bunch of pizza and a bunch of other disciplines, and let them go after this and ring fence this to make a better patent. Yep. Cuz if you it doesn't cost you more to have a crappy patent than have a good one, right? I mean, you're still going to pay lawyers and all these guys to go do the work. So, that was one of those things again where diversity was critically important to getting not a couple guys that look like me going, "That's an answer. Let's go with it." And and actually Ansys leverages that today because with simulation, you're able to put a bunch of different variables and run a number of not one solution and done, but I can run thousands, tens of thousands of of iterations parametrically on this design or that design. And you can have different people in the team too because they have different assumptions or inputs and all that stuff, right? it costs you very little. Right. You're not building a physical model. It's not taking you a a test cell. You're not building breaking. You're not testing tweaking. You're going in knowing this it's this one or this one are 10 times better than the the other 50. Which one is going to win? Well, this might be a little bit more expensive. This might be a little bit more reliable. We'd see how those things play out, right? That's a much more intelligent conversation, and uh it brings more people in the room. Yeah. Yeah. I remembered the name of the the book I was talking about. It's called Innovate Innovator's Dilemma. You made me think about it when you said Innovator's Handbook. I knew what happened. That's just That's okay. Yeah, I'm I'm glad it came back. [laughter] Um no, I completely agree cuz that's, you know, like Frac interference is a big kind of trend in the oil and gas space and I mentioned to you at one point the longest I've ever worked at any company actually. I was working for this gauge company [snorts] and right when I started there was a lot of work. People were moni- you know, it was beginning of kind of frac interference monitoring, right? So, people throwing pressure gauges on these offset wells and just monitoring the pressure to see if they saw any pressure increases from the offsets. And uh I'm sitting here thinking as a mechanical engineer, I'm like, I remember all the stress and strain and the brittleness like all of that mechanical failure stuff from undergrad. And then I'm sitting here thinking like how why has no one backed out like Like this is basic physics. It's a distributed load. I've got a well bore. It is it's got this much feet exposed to the the rock itself in this cluster with this many perfs. I am putting this much force on that length of the well over here. I've got a microphone over here essentially and I know the distance between them. So, I should be able It's a It's velocity and accept like it's just basic calculus, right? And I'm like, this is like physics one stuff that I did in undergrad and yet no one in the oil field is thinking about it in that way at all because they're so in the weeds of well, you know, the rock is heterogeneous and it changes and all that stuff and it's like at the end of the day all the models don't care because it's nano Darcy rock anyway. It's just a brittle piece of rock regardless of how heterogeneous it is or not. Like that's the other part of a lot of engineers, right? It's like they get so in the weeds of it that they can't back out and be like, hey, yeah, their their hardnesses or their brittleness slightly different but the bottom line is they're not accepting of the accuracy, right? So, there's a difference between right? The [laughter] difference between discovery and, you know, I don't want to fall off this bridge and versus okay, I want to make it across the bridge in 20 minutes. Those are very different objectives. [clears throat] But, I think to your point, especially material science, what we try to do is we we work at, you know, sort of the micro scale very very accurately, me me meso scale, and then sort of the macro scale in these problems. And maybe you come up with an equivalency based upon you've done a couple of tests in that that basin. You've characterized that material by doing just what you said back into it. We actually did that in my Oklahoma lab with Baker Hughes a few years back. And we started working commercially with customers and they said, "Listen, this I wouldn't put it there. I would move it, you know, right, left." And and and effectively over time demonstrated that, "Hey, this is a pretty dang good tool. This this is giving us very quick runs, very quick what if scenarios." And to your point, the level of accuracy was more than good enough to make a dent in something that was getting no help there. Well, it didn't have to be from like a reservoir model that had every single piece of rock perfectly mapped and all of that stuff, right? Like it's a block. It has these general properties. You put a force on it and you can see the response over here after whatever, right? That's what we That's what we call physics informed. And and we find, you know, a lot of times folks say, "Well, we're going to do big data." And and I said, "Look, you you know, first of all, you have to know the subject to know what data to collect." And I've heard many AI folks, the minute they lose credibility with me and anybody who's an OEM is when they said, "Oh, no, no, we we just need enough data." And and the reality is these models are learning from failure. And you and I are not accepting failure at 32,000 ft. I'm sure they're not interested in in being part of that experiment. And so, you know, at the end of the day, what we what we think is we know and we've demonstrated is that you can you know most of the physics. There is a couple of variables or even constants to those variables. And where you might have the problem is, you know, in the non-linearities. That's typically where your error, whether it's experiment that you're doing or simulation you're doing. So, that's engineering know-how applied to a problem recognizing that, you know, I I was I was sitting here at the nuclear summit Opera E had one on nuclear heat. So, using uh small modular reactors and or fusion for heat for cement, steel, refineries, and so forth those applications. And I'm sitting in the back of the room and I hear one of the you know nuclear is very conservative, but these folks are using a lot of simulation. A lot of a lot of simulation. And I'm hearing somebody one of the EPCs kind of say, "Well, you know, we're going to scale up this heat exchanger five times." And nobody in the room blinked. And I said and I I wanted to get up in the back um you know, this is a this is a kid show, so I don't want to you know, be using an expletive, but I wanted to say, "What don't we know about the physics?" On a heat exchanger for gas-to-gas exchange. I mean, what what are we Now, if you're trying to I don't know what you'd be trying to study. I mean, you want to study material science and corrosion? We can go there, too, but I I find that to be ridiculous. And not only is it going to be expensive and time-consuming, but it's the lack of understanding that these methodologies have evolved. They're sitting on platforms that running 10,000 times faster computational fluid dynamics today in many applications, whether it's combustion or aerodynamics, from where they were 10 years ago. 10 So, if you haven't touched some of those new methodologies, you're not going to get there fast enough. And I think you know, one of the things I see is organizationally that can be a stump, too. If you if you think about it, if you've broken up to all those engineers and all those groups and they're not talking and some guy over in the corner figures out you can do it this way better, and doesn't share it with everybody else, that idea goes from an interesting idea to not scalable. The my favorite companies to work with in the in the inner or at least in the upstream space is generally speaking tend to be the companies that have some kind of innovate it's and it's not an innovation like how can we bring outside tech in? It's an internal innovation group that is focused on optimizing best practices from across all of the assets. And that's how like that makes so much sense, right? Like hey, these guys why why is you know, the Eagleford faster at our frac turnarounds and has less MPG than the permit. Like it's it's so basic and again it's like back to this industrial engineering mindset of like optimize everything and as you optimize distribute the learnings of that across the organization. What a novel concept. listen 9/10 of the safety you get in the aviation space is because people have a checklist. Mhm. A common checklist. Oh, you forgot to close the door. Right. Or you forgot to fill the tank. And it irritates people when when you're on a plane because you hear them say, "Well, you know, we got a little something with the fuel gauge and tapping it doesn't seem to fix it." And I remember [snorts] being on a flight from Boston to I don't know where it was. I maybe it was Pittsburgh and you know, person behind me is like, "Well, let's go anyway." And I'm like, "Are you serious?" I mean so So [laughter] at the end of the day, did you come Of all the places to have a problem. one drinks, right? I mean but at the end of the day, right? Standard work, best practices, lean principles. Th- These are fundamental and I call management. Yeah. I mean you you could say, "Well, I don't you know, I'm not I Well, no one has to hire some of those people and make sure you're spreading them around the organization because if you're not, you you are absolutely not capitalizing on the scale opportunity. And that's what big companies should do well. Right. Right. Right. Yeah, that's their differentiator, right? They don't have the new innovative thing. They've got the scalability Correct. and distribution, right? Yeah, and resources, right? Well, so tell me tell me a little bit more about, you know, kind of Ansys and some of the tools you guys have that fit in kind of the energy space and and how people use them, success stories, failures, etc. Sure. Well, I mean you you know, so from wind I mean it was kind of the talk of the energy space. So when I think of the energy space and I have to correct people my own team sometime, um it's everything from upstream, midstream, downstream. It's inclusive of the OEMs, the gas turbines, wind turbines, steam turbines, whatever it might be that's rotating uh or the solar cell or whatever. And and now that is including things like storage and batteries and so forth. So when I think of energy systems, um an integrated energy system. All the way down to the electronics, too. All the way down to the circuit, right? So you know, we're our our tools are being used and I you think about high temperature electronics for downhole drilling. I mean uh all of our tools we are we are best in class in the semi space. And we'd probably surprise folks that even with a few customers in the semi space and you and I were talking a little bit about this without getting into you know, calling people out because it's it is what it is. Um but because we are 50% of the simulation market, we kind of have a view of where companies are and in the in in and you can digest this one for a second. The largest energy customer not including the Department of Energy the largest energy customer usage of simulation hang on to your hats is 1 30th the size of an average company in semi connected that's using our product or aerospace. Right. 1 30th the spend. And we go in many times and where I'm talking to somebody across the table who's going to go do a bunch of experiments and going to spend 10 20 30 million dollars and they've convinced their boss that's the way. Of course, we're going to go spend 20. We have to spend the money on testing. Right. And when we come in and say, "Look, it's going to be you know, half a million dollars in software." And somebody swallows hard. I look at the cross table and I just go, "Oh my god, you folks you know, you're decades behind." Yep. So, you know, in the energy space we provide products uh from that are used in all those other industries too, right? So, computational fluid dynamics that you would use for everything from drilling mud Mhm. uh to applications in biogas Right. um bio algae going to say any kind of fluid flow, right? anywhere you want to optimize heat, you know, so I just look we were just looking at a project the other day where we're using um what we've done in modeling of an aircraft sub 77 and run run it into the side of a nuclear reactor that's being proposed uh as a you know, as an anti-terrorist what what So, here you got two different industries very When did you ever think those two would meet, right? So, on this application uh through regulatory people were trying to do certification of uh integrity through accidents. And so, a combination of models and space that really uh is interesting. In the energy space we use those same technologies. So, I talked to you a little bit earlier about crash testing which is not all eliminated in the auto industry but great great greatly reduced. Um and now they do all of that and there's some great stuff on YouTube where we do it with LEGOs for kids. It's really fun to watch. That's awesome. I'm going to look at that. Yeah, yeah, we take a LEGO Bugatti and run it into the side of a LEGO Ferrari. And uh My 4-year-old's going to love that. well, all these little discreet LEGOs go flying around, right? And we have the actual in the video and it's it's quite cool. But but that's being used. And and now in the energy space because what if I have a hydrogen car on a rail car? What happens when that Do I have a cash truck failure? Um what do I do to contain batteries? Yeah. structurally, right? So, in in the oil and gas space, we sit with a lot of the sensor development. Um we do computational fluid dynamics with some of uh the customers I've talked about before, working with some of the majors to look at what do we do on emissions mitigation. So, greenhouse gas or methane or flare optimization. Um hydrogen embrittlement, right? What are we doing in terms of at the macro? We talked a little bit about materials and macro, micro, and meso scale to recognize time, temperature, and and constituency of hydrogen, how we think this storage tank pipeline Right. Because historically, you know, we're working with the lowest carbon solution out there in oil and gas. Most of the pipelines, 90% of them are are low carbon uh solution. So, bringing these tools to to basically simulate uh any aspect in the energy space. You can just imagine electromagnetics, uh antenna even even 5G antenna interference out on a rig. Yeah. Uh so, technologies, as you said earlier, that it show up in other industries, show up in this industry, for sure, even if we're not the first adopters. Uh we work with a company, this is kind of cool. We work with a FLIR. A FLIR is a Teledyne company that do thermal cameras on the West Coast. I was up with their CTO a few weeks back, brilliant guy. And their product is is being used on cars and trains and plane and offshore because people are able to do that to signal some level of corrosion, actually. And so, anyway, long story short, these guys have embedded their application in our libraries. So, if you were to if you were one of these companies that wants to put a thermal camera camera in in their market-leading technology, you now not only have the physics, but you don't have to go do the simulation. They've already done it for you. And now you can do a systems-level integration of that thermal camera into your solution at a much higher level of of fidelity. Right. Without having to do anything from scratch on your own. Correct. And why shouldn't you? In labs. Yeah. No, I think that's that's the uh like I we've been talking about it since you got here, but you know, the the cross-learnings from other industries, especially those like aerospace and automotive and industrial manufacturing who have incredible standards for these things. Who are literally maybe take automotive out because we all know lots of things on cars are designed to fail after the warranty, but Mhm. uh Who is here? you know, for automotive and in in manufacturing, things are designed to last and be as robust as they possibly can for as long as they possibly can because that's where all your money ends up, right? It's all the capex spent into that equipment that runs the entire operation that makes you money. Which sounds a lot like the oil field, right? Where you've got all this heavy equipment in these remote locations in the middle of nowhere with no resources and all this stuff. And then it's like yeah, but they're still doing, you know, non-destructive testing in a lab somewhere without a any kind of simulations on it. Or it's like, "Yay, we've got this new downhole, you know, tool gauge, plus perf gun, whatever." And but we're trying to we have to go test it in a lab. Yeah. Why don't you simulate that? Or like, you know, even on a on a drilling site or a frac site or anything like that, right? Like, you have to turn your phones into airplane mode because of the radio interference and stuff with all the the charges and stuff on a perf gun. Why don't we modeling those things? Like, if you've got a perf gun that you're worried about, instead of having to do destructive physical testing with that, simulate it. [laughter] And then we're seeing the same thing with wind farms, right? With electromagnetic interference with radar with with uh wind farms. And so, these technologies play across multiple industries, which interestingly enough, I mean, one of the tools that we have is called SCADE. Um and it was a French acquisition about a decade ago that we made, and they were deep in the French nuclear industry. Now, the French are out there ahead of everybody else in nuclear. They just have been doing it longer, and they have standardized designs, which had made it much safer, right? And if you get trained in one, you can work on another one. Brilliant idea. We've made them all uniquely different. The Southwest model. Yeah, it's like the steering wheel this time is in the back. So, you know, you the training for Anyway, so that makes it more difficult. So, we this software company basically had developed certifiable logic that you could tie together. If-then kind of control. Very for very important safety systems, right? Where you want to keep the code clean and simple. Industrial control system type of system. Industrial control system, yeah. Right. And it is the standard for aerospace uses it, and then the standard for nuclear as well, which is embedded software that we have used this tool for that gives you a certified to standard for that industry. Interesting. Code. So, after you're done with the the kind of the modeling and a a bunch of what-ifs and optimization and so forth, then it will drop you the certified code. That could be used in any industry, health care, and so forth, and so on. So, I I think there's some places what happens is, just like the startups that we acquire, they may be focused in one particular industry. We We've got this technology that's really cool. You've heard of the DART mission. Yeah. Right? And so, first time we knocked a celestial body out, Ansys was behind that. A lot of that simulation, right? And that same technology can be applied to the hydrogen car we talked about that you want to run into the side of a or or a geothermal drilling device that's going to be coming through and pounding through bedrock. So, I I it's what's what's it's almost limitless what people can do. I think what we see the migration to now is a lot more of that automated workflow. Where where people are saying, "Listen, now that we've done this engineering six times, and we have it in the tool, why are we still doing that one? Why don't we be doing other optimizations?" So, so we do we you know, and as as far as digital engineering goes, we get into that automation space with our partners, like Right. You You mentioned some of the CAD companies. We don't We're not a CAD company, we're a simulation company. And so that and IoT has made what used to be digital assets that were primarily used for design now fungible enough. Right. Because you're getting real-time data, you can use them to steer your operation. Yep. So you put them out on the edge and you you make a reduced order model and you're collecting real-time data and you're you're basically tuning that model to the variables Right. that are unique. Yeah. And and what's cool about really what's kind of what's cool about the oil and gas space, really what I share back to the folks I talked to in aerospace so I don't beat up on I don't want people to beat up on gases. You know, by zip code we talked about, you know, the geology's different. Aerospace, you know, 3 mi up is Right. Right. 5 mi up, 10 mi up, it gets really simple. I say simple, I'm not saying the systems are simple. Right. Systems and the products are complex. Plus variables. But there's less variables. Yeah. It's more uniform, it behaves more uniformly. You don't have that volatility. So where we should be using this industry more is in testing the boundaries of the control volume of understanding against the variability and and it might be geoscience or might be offshore wind or offshore platforms, right? Road waves and hydraulics and all all this hydrodynamics and so forth. Yeah, I know. I mean, I remember in undergrad before I graduated I think it was Hal I think it was Halliburton came or maybe it was BP. Somebody came and gave a you know, presentation or what like a it wasn't during class, it was just a side thing, but uh on all the simulation that went into like these uh floating offshore platforms, right? And like a deep water platform, right? Where it's truly floating you've got not only is the platform basically just like a you know, lunar module or where it's got jets and motors on all sides so that it it can stabilize itself, but then you've got the actual pipe coming from the platform down to the ocean floor that has to deal with the waves and the current and all this stuff and it was just like, man. And that's the thing that like we always talk about is just the energy workforce is got is is some of the most technical in like incredible in my mind because of all of the problems that they face regardless of which side of it it is. And yet you still have like you you get all these knobs that get twisted or what I you know, corporate structure is politics etc. And then yet we still can't solve some of the most like basic issues with some of the things that we have and it's like or like we're not you know, there's so much rotating equipment and in every industry but no less oil and gas. And it's like hey, if you're a manufacturer of a compressor, a pump, you know, a turbine etc. Yeah, literally or even the circuit board like you were talking about like why aren't you modeling that because everyone that tries to optimize for costs especially when prices are low and all that stuff but it's like hey, if your equipment can last twice as long because you [laughter] run these models and you design it properly, that saves you a ton of money and time because that's the biggest cost in the oil field is time and money, you know. Well, think but think about electronics in a downhole tool. You've got a bit on the front that's banging that tool around. Worst conditions in the world for most of our equipment. But you have that actuator right there and you're sensing what's going on in the vibration. Did you take that vibration and the circuit if you A, did you do the circuit board analysis for the would say the the resistivity tool? Mhm. Uh or the acoustic tool. Did you do the analysis on that circuit board temperature, time, vibration PDT stuff, yeah. And then has test against it. Nope. Okay. And where did you put it in the tool? Uh well, we wrapped it in foam. I didn't ask you if you wrapped it in foam. I asked you where did you put it in the tool? Uh we put it over here cuz that's where we had room for it. Uh-huh. Well, you just put grandma on the end of the diving board. [laughter] Okay? I mean, you know, so at the end of the Why would you see this in design? And I I I really had the privilege of being in so many different products that we as you and I talked about, it just keep coming back. Right? It's and it's basic physics in some cases. And why would you not and the excuse can't be well, we can't run those systems. No, you can. Yeah, you absolutely can. And when you do and I've seen us do it with customers who say you can't and very quickly they become adopters. Um but ultimately too, it may be because the electrical engineer and the mechanical engineer he he gave me this hole over here to put my stuff in and that's what I'm going to do and I I don't know. What have I got to say about it? So, you know, I think when you get all those folks in a room and you have a leader that is willing to let people and I always my favorite phrase is and I I just adopted it cuz I travel all the time. You have the freedom to move around the cabin. Yeah. You have got to give engineers and scientists and I say 10% of their time. Not five, not two, not after hours, not you've got to give them time to connect and if you don't you're intellectually thwarting Yeah. that organization. Full stop. And people will say you know I I you talk with folks and say well you know no we don't do that. We don't we we you know engineers aren't you know they'll they'll waste they'll fritter their time away and you look at them and I say you know why did you hire that person? Right. Did you hire them to to put a you know a fill a hole with a screw or did you hire these folks to figure out I don't need the hole or the screw? Right. Right. [laughter] I mean Use glue. That's the Anyway. The No, that's the that's absolutely correct, right? Like at the core engine we love to solve problems. It doesn't matter what type of problem it is. Like I will spend an inordinate amount of time trying to solve some random ass problem because I am motivated by solving problems that a normal person would have just quit on Yeah. you know, five minutes later, right? Like You want [snorts] to say something to you about engineers which I really and I thought I want to put all scientists in that box, too. Um and doctors and anybody that's curious. Um but what found and I've I've had the opportunity to lead companies commercial folks, sales folks and I've had CEOs say well don't you want to go run this business over here? And I look at them and say no. Yeah. And they said well why is that? I said cuz I know how to run engineering and science. And the difference in engineering side cuz I have run those other organizations is the motivation factor is very different. Now I'm not going to say engineers don't want to get paid and I I think sometimes we we allow ourselves not to get paid like some of the other folks do. But at the end of the day the engineering community is a community that can be inspired and motivated and multiplied by the right leadership. Yep. And with these tools can be accelerated and multiplied in productivity and capability in terms of what they can go solve. Right. Right? And how how accurate, how quickly. So I To me, what's exciting what I really enjoy about this company and in the kinds of spaces we're in, um is it is uniquely engineering Yeah. and science. And I'm not having a conversation about a sales guy about a spiff or a tiff. Look, I mean you got to motivate people somehow, right? But then you know, bonus on this excel and bonus. That That would do That would exhaust me intellectually, right? And so what's kind of all coming all these kind of things we've been talking about this morning about the oil and gas space is because we have such a cyclic nature to the hiring and reducing, we be we beat that culture up big time. It becomes dog eats dog. I'm going to lose my job. I better just do what I'm told and I better stay in this box and and Bob over there, let's hope he goes before I do and it's not personal, Bob, but I needed your Well, nobody wants to put their name out there on a project that fails and then they'll never get another project approved, which is the complete opposite mentality of of most other industries. Right. Right. Like and it's and you know, to your point, it a lot of that comes from the sick sick loud or whatever cyclical nature of the industry where it's like, well, there's a layoff, you know, prices are bad, layoff just happened or it's coming or whatever. And so it's like, I don't want to be the one that gets laid off because I, you know, stepped outside the box and did something trying to be innovative and save us money that cost Sure. And it And then we scrap the project completely because it cost money even though we didn't see it all the way out to the end to see if there was a different way of doing it or you know, whatever. Um those are the things like, yeah, I mean, I can't tell you how much how many times I've been a part part of projects where, you know, works at small scale on a well, a pad, a field, whatever. But then the minute they go to try and scale it out across either multiple wells or outside of the the field or whatever, there's some nuance and it doesn't work exactly how it worked in the other one, and then they just scrap it all together, and it's like Or we just take like the scientific method, and we keep iterating on this thing, right? Like, there's so many things there to it, but But you know, I mean, that's why I ended up with ANSYS, because of the years I spent at GE Research, and then all these different products at these different companies, there was one common weapon that worked every time. And we every every leader now, it's a new thing we book and say I embrace failure. I have not met a CEO that the next question you should ask is to what extent. Right. How big a box can I fail in? $5? $500? $500,000 box? Is it a failure in time? You surely don't want to hurt people, right? There's Once you put all those constraints on it, and the engineer who lives by specification sits there and goes, "So, I can fail if I meet all of that criteria?" I don't think so. Yeah. And so, what what's what's exciting, and I'll use this example, cuz I think it's a phenomenal example of using computational simulation to to basically radically change an industry. And this was aerospace, and it go back about 20 years ago. And everybody you you get on a plane today, and you look out, what do you see? You see these little winglets. Mhm. And that those were derived computationally. Yeah. So, somebody didn't go out to a 777 and go staple some wooden things on, or even go to a wind tunnel. Well, tell people, for those who don't know, you're talking about the little at the very tip of the wing that come up, right? And they're on pretty much every plane now. Every plane, yeah. Tell people, like, I I don't remember the stat, but reduction in drag. Which is $10 billion a year in fuel, depending on what the fuel price is, right? And because it's at altitude, and I'm somebody's going to correct me on this, but it's somewhere between 1 and 3% of total greenhouse gas emissions eliminated by that, in terms of effect at altitude. By the By another foot of 5% reduction in drag. Just huge numbers. I I literally I was with a one of our good cut company called Grundfos, Denmark company, number one in the water pump space. Water pumps are 10% of the world's electricity. That's insane. 10%, right? Motors are 45%. They have in two turns of a dial, and and they'll they'll I I'm I'm going to say it, but they'll they would say it if you were here. It's because of simulation. I mean, they've simulated a subcomponent, then they move that to the system level and so forth. And they're vertically integrated, so they have all the parts and all the assembly and they've optimized it. And reality is they knocked out 80% That's an have improved their efficiency 80% two turns of the dial. And here's a company 10% of the world's water's electricity. So, think about what that is. I mean, you can measure that. Right. And you know, everybody's getting caught in the axle around what new technologies are we going to bring? And that's really important. And we we're part of that. I mean, some of our newest biggest customers are startups in the energy space. And you know, they'll be important 2050 or the end of the century, for sure. But in the meantime efficiency is the winner. Half a gigaton of CO2, which is what? 50 gigaton is what we're sitting on. So, it's not 10%, but maybe it's give it a 1% greenhouse effect on combustion gas turbines land-based. So, 1% improvement in combustion efficiency before you move to hydrogen Yeah. is half a gigaton estimated across the world. So, these this is where our tools are can be used immediately because we're already with a lot of these companies. They're not focused as much on that. They used to not be as focused on that because it was really just a fuel savings. Right. But now they can draw that one level out and get a greenhouse gas emission savings you talked about. So, you get two wins for the Yeah. the dollar. Well, that's the other thing, too, is it's like we had that conversation earlier where it's like, oh, yeah, it saved 1%. 1% becomes, you know, at scale. And that's the thing that a lot of people don't like grasp, especially energy across the board, right? You've got extremely expensive, high-risk assets that are, you know, like the the pricing on those is volatile. Like it goes up and down, but then you've got this uh like we're seeing it more and more now where you've got this hyperfocus on once things get so expensive, you can start really optimizing those efficiencies on them or if there's so much pressure from whatever perspective Right. of the table. And so, like I've seen a number of just like waste heat companies spinning up, whether that be waste heat off of a compressor or a pump or whatever that be on site or a full power plant, right? Like And that's the crazy part, the physics is the same. Yeah. Right? It's just how much value or efficiency does that bring you and what does that scale out to be? And so I think that's to me like the future of you kind of energy is as you know we we say energy addition not transition because that's kind of where we we sit, but we all know that the source of energy is going to change over time. But I see the near term there's all this pressure and focus and incentive now finally for people to decarbonize, to reduce emissions, to increase efficiencies. And those are you know they most people think of things like operational efficiency. So how do we spend less time doing X or whatever, but then they don't think about it down a layer where it's like, okay, what is the efficiency of my motor? What is the you know CO2 emissions of that motor? How do I make that up like start we I see my thought is I see the future where near term we really start gaining a lot of ground on those efficiency metrics. And and we need to. I mean 65% of the energy produced converted into and consumed on planet is tossed. Mhm. Right? I mean just let that soak in. Yeah. 65%. And that's only improved 5% in the last 50 years. Right. So And then you compare that to like the compute efficiencies, right? Right. There's and there's no reason for it other than what you just described. And maybe maybe what's what's kind of interesting about that is if efficiency is looked at at a systems level. Right? I used this example the other day with a with a customer. I said, look and we we're having a nuclear discussion in the UK. And I said, look, here's the problem with not running an integrated systems model of whatever it is. You don't care if it's an offshore rig, whatever it is. If you're bringing equipment in from all of these different OEMs, Cummins, GE, everybody has to put margin Mhm. on their components and their systems. And usually they try to get rid of the component level and they put it at the system level. And so, if this guy's got 5% margin, and this guy's got 5% and 10% so forth, and I start to load those into a systems model, and I sub-optimized around all of those extra margin, you've padded this thing. And it's cost, and it's inefficient. Because you've sized this part thinking he's going to be 5% less power, and so you've gone ahead and cut the penny and said, "Look, I'm going to make sure we don't have an ounce more heat exchanger I need." Because I didn't do a systems-level integration of these assets, right? So, I think what I'm seeing is, and this water pump company was a good example of that, is they started with the impeller, that made it improvement, right? And they moved away on, but but in materials, which we we have an awful lot of software in the material science space, we have a customer I was with in Israel about a month back just before the the fighting started, large printer company, and they have these large drums. And you would think this is low-tech, it's not low-tech. These are high-resolution images, and they're printing out thousands of them very quickly. And they sell these machines all over the world. And I'm sitting with a mechanical engineer who points me to this drum, this large metal drum that's spinning, and he says, "Look, my boss says I need you to take dematerialize this machine." And so, there's two pieces there. I want to dematerialize, but I also want to put circularity in so I can recycle, right? But ultimately, he looked at me and said, "Well, what do you think we can do in terms of reduction of weight?" And I'm just looking at this thing spinning, it's got to be going at least 1,000 RPM or more. And the machine starts and stops and starts and stops. And I look at it, and I said I said to him, I said um 65%. And he looked at me and said, "No way." I said, "I'll I'll I'll give you my paycheck for 50%." Because I you know, I'm not going to do the problem myself. But but ultimately, every time we see people go in that have never done a physics kind of that level of analysis at that level, 50%. And you say, "Okay, that steel that would have had to have been shipped." Right. Right? That's material that would have had been kiln, mined. And when you start doing the full carbon footprint on what 50% material is, why additive is so exciting, because you're only putting the material where you need it. Right. Um and and so, when you look at that kind of thing and you see that kind of I'll call it waste and I'm not I'm not uh, I don't want to offend the company cuz it's it they're a good company. Yeah, yeah. But that kind of waste on the table, you know why we're at 65%. Yep. And we got a long way to go to take the engineering to a level what people would say is over-engineered. Well, that's way over-engineered. Look at all the metal. That's under-engineered today, right? You don't put more metal in something you don't need to put in more metal. Right. But that's it's it's very true though, right? Like cuz historically speaking as engineers we're taught factors of safety and you want to over like Toyota, right? Like Toyota is a huge international brand and major car company because people have or faith that it is over-engineered or they have been historically at least, right? And so like it's funny because the historical like definition or context of what that means is completely different now than it was Absolutely. 10 years ago, right? Absolutely. Because what you want to do if you haven't done the analysis uh, and we do something as simple as these glasses Mhm. and recognize that the hinge is the fail point most of the time. Right. Sometimes it's these little things, but most times So if I put more in the hinge and I do that in a calculated way, that's engineered. Mhm. And that's not over-engineered. That's just engineered properly. If I put more metal anywhere in this and I haven't done the analysis, that's over-engineered or under-engineered in my opinion. Right. So I'm really screwing up with the the terminology on this, but I do think people need to reflect on that. You know, elevators they can afford a high uh, level of safety. Right. But aircraft can't. Mhm. Frankly. So they have to be engineered because I've got to only afford to lift that metal five times a day and drop it back down safely. I can't afford uh, you know, extra metal. Right. And you know, we were working on a project one time where we were taking out one fan blade out. It was 65 lb. That meant something because you had two engines and that's 120 lb which is the weight of an average passenger. Well, not North America anymore. Anyway. [laughter] So anyway, so it's just kind of an interesting thought about I get to that system. No, for sure. I think that's a like I said, I I and to your point like there's so much that has changed on the material side and the manufacturing side of those materials, right? Like, printed material, whether that's metal or plastic now, to your point, like, not only is there no waste, but then you can put things exactly where they need to be without that incremental cost of, you know, uh honing it on the like post-manufacturing work, right? Like, And you And you see the dance of that laser and melt pool that it's creating. Uh it's it's mesmerizing, actually. Now they have four lasers, five and eight lasers working at the same time on some of these machines. But, what's interesting is we can we pre-model that. So, we have tools to to pre-model every, you know, 25,000 print layers for thermal distortion and or uh if you or stress that would be induced in the print, so you can optimize the print they dance to minimize that thermal People aren't using it. Yeah. So, they're like, "Well, you know, additive is too expensive." Well, it's too expensive cuz you're throwing a lot of stuff away because you're not doing a pre-print analysis and letting the printer decide what orientation uh to put it at. But, we're we're out I mean, I'm I'm I'm very bullish. I go on for hours. I won't on additive, but I'll leave it at this. Um this is where simulation and math are going to be just incredibly important to mature additive. Additive is replacing castings in a lot of ways, right? And we had a machine here at Rankin Road when I was with Baker when I had the additive team where we could print three four materials at the same Now they have eight. So, you're essentially able to print your own alloys, right? And and we've been as Ansys, we've been buying libraries of these alloys from the different aerospace companies like a Siemens and a GE and putting them into our libraries so people can use them uh where it's not a competitive threat for the I mean, it's a commercial agreement. But, ultimately, what's what's really pretty interesting about that is we started putting graded materials. So, think about thing you know, I remember when I started to design, we had engineers that were everything was in 2D. And I just couldn't think in 2D. So, I as a department lead, I said, "You're all going to go to 3D. I don't want to hear about it. We're not designing in 2D. This half a whole stuff not lining up. We're done with it. And and so we went we started using 3D CAD. This is going way back. But anyway, the the point is uh you're able to optimize that print on a three-dimensional matrix of material. So you might like an M&M. I could print it soft in the middle and hard on the outside. And there is no cladding layer, there's no welded layer, there's no joint, there's no And today when we want to change materials like this cup, we have plastic on the top and paper at the bottom. We make two separate parts. So we can do a homogeneous manufacturing. Well, in fact it's much more efficient in many aerospace applications if I want to combine parts to actually be able to change that alloy to be spring at the bottom or hard at the surface. Yeah. And that is going to revel And that that is not going to be done. No engineer is going to be able to think in three-dimensional material non-homogeneous you Is that material science is is already hard hard enough out of the gate. That was my worst subject in undergrad. this will this will this will mature and we're partner with a company called Materialise and a couple of other companies here. Um we're going to mature this process. And I my my my brain says we got it in less than five years, but um it maybe it takes a little longer, but ultimately people are trying to certify every part for NACE or who whatever your governing body is in whatever industry you're in. And what we really need to do is is certify a smart process. Yeah. And because we've got in situ measurement and it's all digital and it's all tied together, there's no reason this machine can't figure out it screwed up. Yeah. Right? And tune itself in the next print. And uh there's just no excuse for it. And I I think we can get there. And I think that's going to revolutionize additive almost overnight as soon as we can get this kind of workflow worked. Because today your design engineer is going to optimize this cup on strength, temperature, and so forth, whatever it might be. He's not optimizing for manufacturing. He might think he is. Right. But can you imagine if you had a fit for print part and the machine determined and threw another variable into the optimization routine after one print learning about temperature or time or or anything and and absolutely optimizing the design again Yeah. Against what would be an optimized print. This is phenomenally it's fundamentally doable. Yeah. And will be phenomenally powerful. No, I think that's uh we're running out of time, but we didn't get to talk about it, but that's one of the things I was going to actually ask about with AI in your space. AI is on everybody's Yeah. uh tongue this year, but I I've already seen some stuff. Um I don't remember what it was for or what, but it was essentially that, right? Where you know, they uh they had a part Mhm. then they threw it at they did the model everything, and then they started essentially letting an AI try and optimize the part by itself. Jared design. Right. Yep. And uh and it optimized a part that looked completely different, and of course it's got new additive manufacturing and all the new like here's the old part that we designed 20 years ago. What would that look like today, right? And like the difference is crazy, and then you start getting into the math behind it, and like manufacturing time, the cost, and all these things. You're like, holy [ __ ] this is it's going to be crazy. It is. [laughter] And in in our industry, oil and gas be a really good candidate for it. And what and why Baker had been investing in it is cuz really sometimes you're not selling your product. Like the downhole tools, right? And or your wireline tools, and you are our drill bits. We're going to print those in in full uh disclosure. I mean, we disclose that uh publicly through patents and so forth. But ultimately um the low volume sometimes. Unique alloy. Mhm. I mean, this this is a play Or just a manufacturing process, right? Yeah. Yeah, the manufacturing So, it's a niche it's a niche for the auto for the for the oil and gas space for sure. And I I I found it kind of interesting. I still ask the question cuz I'm I'm super curious, but I'll ask a company, "Hey, look, do you do anything in additive?" And very quickly they'll come back with an answer that was probably founded 10 years ago. Yeah. Well, you know, it's too expensive, or you know, we make too much volume. And I'm I'm thinking I don't you have no idea what's going on in health care right now. In health care is we're all unique. Our bones are different. Right. I mean, it's just a This is going to be revolutionary. It already is revolutionizing health care. And aerospace. and I think you know ultimately oil and gas might be a later adopter but it's going to have fundamentally an opportunity it makes a ton of sense right like again oil and oil and gas most of the issues are kind of problems that we run into are stem from the the materials right like so there's always salt water so corrosion and metal are not always the big fans of each other and they don't work really well over time and it doesn't help the the part and all of that stuff and then again you're also moving all of these materials that have whether it's LNG CNG hydrogen to your point like that change the way the metallurgy is over time and also change under pressure and temperature like there's so many little things and I get but again it sounds complicated cuz it is because that's always changing there's always different states but it is physics and they fit into a PVT model they all have their own curves and all this stuff and so and so many and so many modeled that pipeline regionally probably probably if there was any kind of service at all you'd want to model it and so why wouldn't you now have that as a not as a digital asset that's monitor your point monitoring all the conditions that are coming over time in that product and over time I can then project predict not just disclose where I think I'm going to have a problem but predict that I'm going to have a corrosion problem in 10 years out 5 years out so yeah it's it's how do we how do we kind of use an IoT investment in the last couple of decades have really advanced that opportunity I think many people are still in a different paradigm believing that this stuff doesn't work and we can't [snorts] do digital and I mean I mean I was in Europe a couple weeks back with a large hydro turbine producer and their customer took our tools designed and re re reverse engineered all of the turbines with a third party supplier who did the engineering work to create digital twins on erosion and of their of their hydro blades based upon rain and silt and all this stuff in the in the lakes and they've got 130 hydro plants and you know I had a customer tell me you know well you know the models don't work and why why are they doing this? Because you have the mindset that models don't work and they have the IoT connected and so they're just creating a digital asset that you should have given them if you wanted to help them get there about a year sooner. But ultimately we have found the value in that. So these these assets in our energy space, some of them, many of them are done well before the dawn of digital and are being even nuclear plants around the world are being recast for another 50 years, recertified, whether it's in Paris or the United States. It's the same discussion cuz we can't afford to have all that base load come off right now. And so, you know, they're using the tools differently than they did in the past, but if you're not sharpening that knife between cuts, you've made a mistake in the engineered world anyway. Now, that's awesome. We are we're out already, which is crazy. I feel like we could sit here and chat up all week, but all afternoon, but we're we'll wrap it up on the the speed round. So I'll just pepper you some questions, some short quick answers. Uh couple books either on the technology or um innovation or product side that you would recommend some people check out. One of my one of my favorites There's a lot of talent books. I won't get into it a lot of that discussion, but but certainly on innovation, one of my one of my favorite ones is actually fast innovation. And uh I was talking to somebody the other day and he picked one off his desk and I used to have my staff read it. It was a good combination of lean, Six Sigma, and design. And everybody out there says, "Oh, it's always a GE guy. We're going to hear about Six Sigma again." That's not what I'm going to talk about, but ultimately it's a means of solving a problem and knowing it's solved. Uh you know, define, measure, analyze, improve, and control. It doesn't get any more straightforward. It's really the scientific method if you would with with tools and ways to measure your way through. This book does a nice job. It's written by a couple of young ladies here in Texas, I think, in the Dallas area. And uh it is I bought I don't know how many ver- versions that That's That's a great book. The the innovation development, you mentioned that one. Crossing [clears throat] the Chasm was another good one. One of the one of my favorites actually even for engineers is Jack Stack's great game of business and this is an old book. This goes back maybe 30 or 40 years and basically everybody should understand what how they tie out to the financials of the company. Mhm. And so I've talked a lot about innovation and how engineers are underutilized and so forth. At the same time there's a discipline in the finance community that frankly is useful for engineers to understand, right? Cuz it lets them think for themselves, hey you you wait a minute. I'm going to spend an hour doing this task. Mhm. What would it save the company if I spent a half an hour doing this task and I did it better Right. or three times better. So that Jack Stack's book's really good for that purpose and there's a number of other good books out there but um I think you know my boss just wrote a book on on innovation, Prith Banerjee, really really interesting. He does case studies um of different companies that have worked their way through both technology innovation and stage gate processes and and kind of going to where you were a little bit John about what's worked, what's not worked and it's really quite a quite a good read. But you know those are those are the kinds of things I think today podcasts and YouTube Yep. are a real valuable source of data and information and opinions Yeah. that are testing my own point of view on different things over time and changing it based upon that that input. Uh Yeah, no I think it it never ceases to amaze me. It's like oh well whatever I certain the breaker at my house keeps tripping. Yeah. Google it and find a YouTube video on how to fix it, right? Like Right. There is literally no reason It's so much easier for you to ever not know how to do something if you want to try and do it, right? And you don't have to necessarily the way search engines work, we talked about this earlier. You don't have to read the entire body of knowledge on Moby Dick to know that the whale was really big and [laughter] dangerous. Right. Uh you can get that pretty quick in the title but anyway. Um what uh I was going to ask you, what are some what are some of your favorite Normally it's just your favorite kind of software tools but I'll ask [clears throat] you, what are some of your favorite Ansys tools on the software side that you uh are either excited about or see people really turning out really interesting like valuable results with. Yeah, boy, that's a high one for me because because it's a whole gamut. I won't take it all the time. What we're doing in optics is is pretty exciting because where optics are going in augmented reality and and virtual reality and these, you know, the metaverse and when you immerse yourself in those environments, we create that physics, right? Water flowing over here, wind blowing over there. How that and then translate that physics into optics, which is what you and I see. Uh that's really kind of curious and creative and incredible. We we've got a a number of products that I I mentioned LS-DYNA, which I really find. We just had a users conference here in in Detroit a few weeks back and thousands of people there. And that tool being used we brought it out of Lawrence Livermore Lab. It was originally used to to as as a way of measuring damage on nuclear detonation. Uh and we've, you know, applications over time have developed and we've used it for this crash test capability, but you can use it for anything. I mean, we used it in in this industry recently to look at what would happen if a if a ship collided into the side of an offshore rig. We've used it to see what would happen if an anchor catches a pipeline. We we we've used it to see what happens when you drop the reactor. Uh when you're doing a reactor refueling, what happens to the reactor vessel if you Good thing to good thing to model. Yeah, all all kinds of So, I like that one and that's the one I talked to you about on YouTube you go, you know. Um last thing, where can where can people find you? How do they get in touch with you if they're interested in learning more? Sure. Uh well, it's scott.parent@ansys.com recognizing there'll be some spam today that comes out of that, but but but ultimately that's where they they can get me and Yeah, I'm on LinkedIn, too. And I'm on LinkedIn and and I'm much more customer focused than I've been in any job I've had before. I spend all my time with customers. So, I treat anybody that calls me as a customer. Awesome. Yeah. Scott, I appreciate it, man. This has been a ton of fun. Great. Excited to have you back. Guys, if you like this episode or any of the other ones, please uh give us a review, give us a like, subscribe. Um Scott, thanks again, man. Appreciate it. Yeah. Give us a like and maybe my emotional fragility I got to have the the thumbs. You know, I do I got to tell you, John, I have a stuffed thumb that I use because when the thumb's all you could do was give thumbs up and I would be in these telepresence and I I'm a nice guy. I like to have a lot of fun. So, I have a foam thumb that I can go this way with [laughter] and uh it always gets a laugh and and and yet you're still sending a message. But but [laughter] ultimately it's a thumbs up on this. I enjoyed my time with you. A lot of fun. Appreciate it. Uh and everybody out there that's manufacturing stuff, please talk to these guys cuz we all know that our stuff could last longer and be better designed. So, appreciate everybody. Um, Christmas is in a couple little over a week away. So, I'll also say Merry Christmas and happy holidays everybody and we'll see y'all after after the break. Thanks.