00:00:00:00 - 00:00:25:33 Speaker 1 Hello. Hello, hello. Hello, everyone. Welcome to the Ball in a cold podcast. I am DJ Johnson. I am the founder and CEO of Baldwin and Co, and we are a bookstore and coffee shop located down here in New Orleans. So make sure you stop by whenever you are in need of intellectual stimulation. Today we have a bonus episode for you. 00:00:26:03 - 00:01:07:27 Speaker 1 One I am especially excited to share with you. Just big, big fan of both of these individuals. So today we have New York Times columnist Jamal Bullying and Tulane law professor Carla La Roche, and together they explore what I would say is the haunting parallels between the reconstruction era and today's political climate. Carla framed reconstruction as a period of profound promises codified in the 13th, 14th, and 15th amendment that were ultimately betrayed by the rise of white supremacy and Jim Crow. 00:01:07:31 - 00:01:35:13 Speaker 1 Jamal argued that the era remains vital because we're currently still grappling with the same existential questions it raised, and that being who counts as an American and what is the nature of our freedom? It is truly a riveting conversation that I'm sure you all will enjoy. So as always, like, subscribe and share with at least one person you know. 00:01:35:17 - 00:01:38:00 Speaker 1 Enjoy. 00:01:39:39 - 00:01:43:34 Speaker 1 We have Carla Laroche, who is? 00:01:43:34 - 00:02:01:05 Speaker 1 Is the Felder fellow associate professor of law at Tulane University. And the Murphy Institute. Her scholarship and teaching focus on access to justice for systemically excluded communities, particularly at the intersections of criminal law, race, gender, voting rights, and family law. 00:02:01:16 - 00:02:24:44 Speaker 1 A former, clinical law professor at Washington and Lee at Florida State University. She founded and led nationally recognized justice clinics advancing civil rights and reentry equity. Her work has appeared in leading law reviews and has been honored by Tulane, the American Bar Association and the National Bar Association. Give it up again for Carla. 00:02:24:48 - 00:02:28:42 Unknown Thank you. Thank you. 00:02:28:46 - 00:02:56:02 Speaker 1 This is this. All right. And for our esteemed guests, here, we have Jamelle Bouie, who is a Charlottesville based columnist for The New York Times, where he covers politics and history. He also co-hosts the Unclear and Present Danger podcast, exploring the political and military thrillers of the 1990s. Yes. Before joining The Times, he was chief political correspondent at slate, with earlier bylines at The American Prospect and The Daily Beast. 00:02:56:12 - 00:03:18:22 Speaker 1 His essays appear in 400 Soles and the 1619 project. Jamal is a recipient of the Hillman Prize, the Karen McWilliams Award and a to Call Alum Prize on the US at the moment. He was elected to the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, a University of Virginia graduate. He's also a photographer whose work can be found online and on social media. 00:03:18:31 - 00:03:24:07 Speaker 1 Y'all give it up one more time for these amazing, amazing people. 00:03:24:07 - 00:03:29:32 Unknown Thank you. Thank you. 00:03:29:36 - 00:03:36:48 Speaker 3 Oh, good. 00:03:37:02 - 00:04:03:18 Speaker 3 Good evening. Hi, y'all. Good evening. We heard we have a lot of people here, interested in hearing what this amazing brain and man has to say. So I want to make sure that he knows that New Orleans is here. New Orleans is here for him, right? As you heard, I am, Carla Laroche. I am a professor at Tulane Law School and at the Murphy Institute. 00:04:03:19 - 00:04:25:03 Speaker 3 I am so excited to be here with you all to have this conversation about reconstruction, about reconstruction in the past and what reconstruction might look like right now or not look like right now. And so, so happy to see you all here. 00:04:25:03 - 00:04:30:36 Speaker 3 We started the introduction or started the conversation thanking some people. And I want to make sure that we thank, 00:04:30:36 - 00:04:52:28 Speaker 3 both within company for hosting this event. It is good to again. See you all here. To be supporting, independent bookstore, but also the community. And this conversation, the way that this night will work or tonight will work, is that I will pose some questions to Jamal. Hopefully he'll like them enough to answer them. 00:04:52:32 - 00:05:22:37 Speaker 3 Maybe. Yeah. And then you all will have an opportunity to answer questions. I mean, to ask questions. I will take monitor's privileges if, it goes on too long. Or if, there is not a question in your question. And so, just think about that. Jamal has said he loves audience questions. And so please feel free, feel empowered to ask your question if you want to know it. 00:05:22:41 - 00:05:46:35 Speaker 3 Again, he's a brilliant mind, so he probably knows random things that you really remember from a previous column that he has written. And would love to talk to you about it. He's like, what? Did you just give me a tip? So let's get started with just just a little bit of framing, so that we are all we start on the same general page. 00:05:46:39 - 00:06:26:47 Speaker 3 What is reconstruction? Right. It's this past event pass era that Jamal will really situate us in terms of the importance of it and why it's relevant today. But at the start, it is it was a period around 1863, 1860 is when, you may have the patient proclamation. The proclamation was signed by Abraham Lincoln. And then it was a period of, about 15, 20 years until 1877 or 1880. 00:06:27:01 - 00:06:54:39 Speaker 3 Where all of these promises, we basically they basically admitted were not going to happen. We go into the Black Codes and into Jim Crow, and the promises, the legal promise. We had the 13th amendment abolishing abolishment of slavery, except for punishment. And, I at this moment, I want to just, lift up the, trial that's going on in Baton Rouge. 00:06:54:43 - 00:07:22:17 Speaker 3 That started today, the Angola, farm line. Case, about, brutal punishment for individuals who are working, in are forced to work in Angola, in agriculture. And the trial is going on in Baton Rouge, started again today and will go until Thursday. The 14th amendment, which had equal protection, which guaranteed equal protection and, birth rights, citizenship. 00:07:22:21 - 00:08:00:22 Speaker 3 The 15th amendment, which banned voting based discrimination based on race, which meant that in theory, that promise black men could vote. It was also a time for voting and political power. The promise of it. Louisiana had its first, black person, governor of the whole nation, right? Black men were in state and federal positions of power. People were able to exercise their political power. 00:08:00:26 - 00:08:44:12 Speaker 3 It was limited. But there was a promise for. There was also a promise for financial freedom, financial mobility. 40 acres and a mule. Being able to enter contracts was a promise. Being able to move without the permission of others was a promise. Rebuilding your families and yourselves was a promise. It was a time of promise. But as we know, it was also a time where white supremacy continued on, where the promises were just that. 00:08:44:12 - 00:08:49:38 Speaker 3 Promises. And so, Jamal. 00:08:49:42 - 00:08:53:06 Speaker 1 Yes. 00:08:53:10 - 00:09:06:19 Speaker 3 You just did what my students did. They're like, oh, you're paying attention. We got it. Why are we with all that is going on right now? Why are we talking about reconstruction? 00:09:06:23 - 00:09:15:13 Speaker 1 First, thank you, everyone, for coming out this evening. And thank you to Bob Walton, and company. 00:09:15:17 - 00:09:36:16 Speaker 1 So in addition to the very, I think the great overview of what reconstruction was, you, you presented, I want to throw out a couple other things, and we'll get to answering the question. Because you can think of reconstruction rewind a bit. You can think of American history at various points as like asking a set of questions about the country. 00:09:36:26 - 00:10:00:25 Speaker 1 What is the United States? Which sounds like, you know, I see a great school, that question. But it's really a question about what is the nature of this polity. Who is an American who counts, in this polity? And what is the nature of American freedom? What exactly do we mean when we say that people have freedom and liberty in this country? 00:10:00:29 - 00:10:20:18 Speaker 1 And these are questions that are always a part of American political life. But there are acute moments in the nation's history when they are very much on the national political agenda. And reconstruction is maybe the most important moment when they are on the national political journey, because that's what I would say. Reconstruction is about. What is the United States? 00:10:20:22 - 00:10:47:44 Speaker 1 Is it just a collection of these weird semi sovereign entities, or is it a singular nation with a singular purpose? Who are Americans? Is it just people who can claim European ancestry? Or should everyone who finds themselves within the borders of the United States? And what is American freedom to begin with? Is it a narrow thing, simply the freedom to make a contract, to earn a wage, which is something much more expansive than than that? 00:10:47:48 - 00:11:14:48 Speaker 1 And I think the reason why reconstruction is relevant today is this is another moment in our history when we're grappling with these questions. What is the United States? Who is an American? What is American freedom? And even more than that, in a very literal sense, the current government has answers to those questions that cuts against the most aspirational answers, that of reconstruction. 00:11:15:10 - 00:11:43:47 Speaker 1 What is the United States? It is just any other country, with no special, with no special or particular, heritage worth honoring. No. You know, no tradition of, democracy, no tradition of maybe egalitarian aspiration. Just another another country. Who are Americans? The very specific people with a very specific heritage, usually racial, also religious, who happen to be in this regular old country. 00:11:44:07 - 00:12:12:34 Speaker 1 And what is American freedom? Well, it's the freedom to dominate everyone outside of those confines. And so this I think I'd say this administration, this government had a very particular answer. I think there very consciously, or at least the people with ideas are very consciously thinking about, or repudiating, the, the more expansive notions. And so I think it's, I think to understand what's happening now, to be able to formulate a response. 00:12:12:34 - 00:12:41:36 Speaker 1 What's happening now? It's it's important to look back to to reconstruction. And I'll say, I mean, in addition to everything else, this is a little abstract. The administration is quite literally trying to overturn the birth of citizenship clause of the 14th Amendment. Right. Like be the president. The president is quite literally president because it's section three. The 14th amendment was effectively invalidated, like in in the most sort of uninteresting based, sort of like a bad screenplay writer put it out. 00:12:41:39 - 00:12:47:08 Speaker 1 Well, like we're just dealing with reconstruction right now. 00:12:47:12 - 00:13:03:49 Speaker 3 Can you tell me more about the tradition and what you think the tradition actually is? So you gave the. What I found interesting is that you talked about domination as the freedom, right? So what is your view of the tradition, whether reconstruction or what it should be today? 00:13:04:03 - 00:13:24:20 Speaker 1 Yeah. So, I mean, you know, one way to think about freedom as a form of domination is to think of it. It's the freedom of the master, right? The master can have a plantation, can have, homestead or whatever, and can, you know, enslaved people can dominate people. Even slaves can dominate the people in the household. Women and children, if you're on the frontier, can dominate the natives, right. 00:13:24:20 - 00:13:46:35 Speaker 1 Like freedom as mastery over others. And then the, the sort of the useful or the natural counterpart to that is like, well, what is the freedom of the dominated? What is the freedom of the enslaved person? It's a freedom from domination of kind of right to personal self-determination. It's a freedom to make your way. It's a freedom. 00:13:46:39 - 00:14:10:35 Speaker 1 As you alluded to, to be able to have a family, to be able to make a life, to be able to own for yourself. It is it is a freedom much more centered on notions of liberation than it really is on notions of domination. Of course, in the, in the, you know, when you when you are disentangling actual people's lives and history, these things can kind of get a little mixed up together, right? 00:14:10:36 - 00:14:36:24 Speaker 1 Like you have, you know, you have during reconstruction, enslaved people who imagine themselves as like building free communities. You have others who are like, well, freedom for me is the ability to, like, have control of my household in a way that would be not dissimilar from someone who imagines freedom as domination. But like, if they can broad strokes, you can say that that those are the those are kind of a two, two competing visions of freedom in this country and the art of reconstruction. 00:14:36:28 - 00:15:13:36 Speaker 1 And if you treat the Reconstruction Amendment as sort of like the, the, the political instantiation of the ideals of reconstruction, then you quite clearly see a vision of freedom as a kind of liberation, Liberation from bondage. Right? Liberate from the narrow parochialism of your particular community a lot of ways. For section one of the 14th amendment, which begins with, you know, if you're born in the United States or subject there within you are a citizen and ends with the equal protection clause is kind of saying there are American citizens in there. 00:15:13:36 - 00:15:39:34 Speaker 1 Everyone who's born here, they have the privileges and immunities of American citizenship, regardless of where they live. They are entitled to due process, regardless of where they live, maybe equal protection, regardless of where they live. It's taking away. It's taking out the individual and like, liberating them in a sense from whatever particular, forms of domination might be in their area and say, the national government will protect and defend you from those things. 00:15:39:34 - 00:16:07:36 Speaker 1 And the 15th amendment is you are you are free to vote political participation. So, you know, I would say that all that stuff you can see in the amendments, you can see in at least the visions of the more, radical politicians and political figures who were trying to push a very expansive idea of reconstruction and kind of be interesting about the period in the tragedy is like how so much of that was never brought into reality. 00:16:07:36 - 00:16:17:32 Speaker 1 But even with text on a page, that didn't really amount to something real for people in the world. 00:16:17:36 - 00:16:47:29 Speaker 3 Okay, so I want to, continue with the discussion of, reconstruction, just for a little bit longer to ask about Louisiana significance. In reconstruction, we have Supreme Court cases that dealt with, that were addressed during reconstruction. We have massacres. We have Louisiana leaving some of its, French and Spanish heritage and becoming more quote unquote, American. 00:16:47:33 - 00:16:51:27 Speaker 3 Why was Louisiana such a bad for all of this? 00:16:51:31 - 00:17:01:36 Speaker 1 That's a great question, but I'm not sure I have any answer to it. It's kind of funny that this that Louisiana was like this crucible for so much of of reconstruction. 00:17:01:47 - 00:17:03:18 Speaker 3 Can you tell us some of the. Yeah. 00:17:03:22 - 00:17:30:40 Speaker 1 Yeah, yeah, yeah. So, so, you you begin your timeline in 1863 with the Emancipation Proclamation. Should following year. For those of you who are Civil War nerds, you'll know that, later in 1863, beginning of 1864, Grant, secures Union victory at Vicksburg, wins control of Mississippi, and splits the Confederacy right in half. And the Union basically at that point has control of New Orleans. 00:17:30:44 - 00:17:52:01 Speaker 1 And so Lincoln, begins Lincoln's already thinking about the postwar world. And, he begins the first reconstruction policies in Louisiana. And they're very lenient. They're sort of like, you know, 10% of the people there have to say an oath to the union. You know, former Confederates, you know, can't hold office necessarily, but they do a couple things. 00:17:52:01 - 00:18:26:37 Speaker 1 You right back in and Republicans in Congress, especially the radicals, called because they were radical. There's not really any more to that. Names. Pretty descriptive. They in they were like, this is this camp. This can't happen. This is too lenient. This doesn't do enough to, account for the damage done. The blood spilled, too many people have died, and so they're pushing Lincoln to have a much more a much harsher, approach to handling reconstruction. 00:18:26:49 - 00:19:09:16 Speaker 1 And unfortunately for Lincoln, he can't. There's no resolution here because he's assassinated in April of 1865, and Andrew Johnson takes over. Andrew Johnson kind of implements Lincoln's plan. And in Louisiana, what that ends up meaning is that you have a lot of former Confederates coming back to power. And again, Louisiana enters the fray is like this place where there's this very, stark conflict between former Confederates coming into power, Unionist, white or otherwise, and then, freed, black Americans who want to participate and get involved in political life as well. 00:19:09:20 - 00:19:38:05 Speaker 1 And so I believe it's an 1868, Louisiana gets some of the first black codes. In 1868, there is, New Orleans, race riot, a massacre of black Americans, in 1873, there's the Colfax massacre in 1874. There is, another riot in New Orleans attempting to depose, the, the a the current is the current government. 00:19:38:06 - 00:20:02:31 Speaker 1 The election happens incoming government. And Louisiana is also this place where you see the emergence of the first set of, like, vigilantes, who are trying to, undermine reconstruction policy. So, like, a lot is happening here. Things pioneered in Louisiana, like the vigilantes would find their way in other places, into why, why, why here? 00:20:02:31 - 00:20:39:49 Speaker 1 I'm not necessarily. I don't have an answer for that. But it is the case that so much of the the new the most dramatic episodes of reconstruction happened. Louisiana. The two of those important court cases. I mean, three of the most important court cases for thinking about the post reconstruction period. The slaughterhouse cases. Cruickshank and, Plessy v Ferguson come out of Louisiana, come out of New Orleans, and the state, it's just it's just like, it's just it's this place where so much of it takes place and so much of it reverberates, throughout the rest of the South and rest of the country. 00:20:40:03 - 00:20:42:45 Speaker 1 Right. 00:20:42:49 - 00:21:09:45 Speaker 3 We're going a little more current in terms of the conversation. So, yeah, Hartman writes about the afterlife of slavery, how emancipation was a nonevent. And essentially that's what we're talking about now, how the promises that reconstruction gave us were only on paper and not actually enforced. For a certain time they were in existence and then removed. 00:21:09:49 - 00:21:19:27 Speaker 3 And so can you talk about how. The law on paper is different from the law in people's lives? 00:21:19:36 - 00:21:23:08 Speaker 1 Yeah. 00:21:23:12 - 00:21:29:36 Speaker 1 I I'll say it. I, I do disagree somewhat with Hartman's view there. 00:21:29:40 - 00:21:31:02 Speaker 3 Tell me to yeah. 00:21:31:06 - 00:22:02:33 Speaker 1 Yeah. So I mean, my my disagreement is actually very concrete. It's right. It's the end of slavery does not mean the end of racial domination. Right. The fact that, you know, efforts to make the law matter were rolled back. So I mentioned two court cases, slaughterhouse cases, dealt with some, workers in the slaughterhouse who were insisting that the privileges and immunities Clause of the 14th Amendment, meant that they could that and a new set of municipal regulations were an infringement on the rights. 00:22:02:37 - 00:22:35:18 Speaker 1 And rather than decide the case narrowly, the Supreme Court decided that what this meant was that the Privileges and Immunities Clause A, the regulations didn't do that, and that privileges and immunities were quite narrow. It didn't really mean much, just sort of like, just fancy language to use. And so that decision renders the Privileges Immunities Clause more or less a dead letter, even though the the drafters of the 14th Amendment really envisioned this being actually something quite expansive is really investing American citizenship with with much more in the way of, rights. 00:22:35:22 - 00:23:26:08 Speaker 1 The US Cruickshank involved, the convictions after the Colfax massacre. I shoot long story short, a bunch of black politicians and their supporters were massacred in a courthouse. And the United States prosecuted this, under what's called the Enforcement Act of 1870, 1871. But the Supreme Court ruled that because the perpetrators in the massacre were not state agents, they were just guys, and that the 14th amendment only applies, or the 14th amendment, promise of equal protection, and due process only really applies when there are state agents involved, that you have to overturn the convictions because you can't prosecute just guys with federal law, in this way. 00:23:26:12 - 00:23:50:01 Speaker 1 And so that ends up kind of opening the door for, you know, always Jim Crow. Right? Plessy kind of determines it. But like, Cruickshank really opens the door for the kind of extralegal violence that makes Jim Crow possible. And then Plessy v Ferguson says, you know, the 14th amendment says nothing about social inequality. It only says that you can't treat people unequally. 00:23:50:09 - 00:24:16:25 Speaker 1 And, hey, separate can still be equal. So you can have segregation. So the court turns back a lot of what happens. But the source of disagreement is that even then there's like a meaningful difference, right, between a world where your children can be sold from you in a world where they can't. Right. There's a meaningful difference, in a world where even if it's difficult, you can, like, make your own way. 00:24:16:29 - 00:25:00:39 Speaker 1 In a world where your labor is stolen from you. And so I think that even if, even if the, you know, what the what the, jurors call the badges, the the badges instance of slavery weren't fully erased in the aftermath of the war and of the amendments, they're still sort of like a real material difference. And you can see quite clearly as well the, the way that the opportunity to build community is to get a measure of independence, even some measure of, distance from, white supremacy would enable kind of the growth of, 00:25:00:43 - 00:25:30:25 Speaker 1 Movement for like, a fuller form of freedom. So, like, I think I like to think about I live in Charlottesville, Virginia, which is right down the street about 20 minutes from Buckingham, Virginia, which is kind of in the boonies. But Buckingham is where Carter G. Woodson, great black historian, was born. And his whole origin story, feeling afraid that way is that he, learned how to read as a young, boy and then would in his parents were enslaved and would read to basically sort of like sharecroppers the news. 00:25:30:29 - 00:25:53:22 Speaker 1 And that's sort of like how he kind of began to figure out himself. And Woodson is he is it can be child of enslaved people. And like, that whole thing isn't possible, before 1865. Right. Like his his life and ability to sort of make change is a product of their very flawed but very real change that comes out of out of reconstruction. 00:25:53:22 - 00:26:22:21 Speaker 1 So I, you know, that my part of my view here is that. I believe that the promises of reconstruction really betrayed. And I like to use the word betrayed or destroyed or undermined because when you see reconstruction failed, it's like, well, the people, you know, ordinary Americans, ordinary black Americans and fail at anything. Right. Reconstruction. And and they were they were fierce and vicious forces trying to undermine reconstruction as well. 00:26:22:21 - 00:26:53:15 Speaker 1 So reconstruction was undermined. It was defeated. But it's still it's still mattered. What was attempted mattered. The there's amendments still mattered, right? They kind of became dead letters for some time. But there was a reason why even now, as I said, you know, people in power want to do as much as they can to, like, nullify the 14th because there's real power in a constitutional guarantee of equal protection and the due process and of citizenship. 00:26:53:19 - 00:27:12:22 Speaker 1 Even as we know, right, that simply having something on paper doesn't guarantee anything. That is still the work of ordinary people, that still the work of political activity. That's still the work of human agency. So for me, it's like get a whole these get a whole both things in mind at the same time. That does nothing. 00:27:12:22 - 00:27:20:21 Speaker 1 Nothing is guaranteed. But these things do they do matter, and they even matter in a very kind of material way. 00:27:20:25 - 00:27:40:08 Speaker 3 Can you break it down more? You said, the historian was Watson. Yeah. Why was he reading to sharecroppers? What was that promise that then was taken away? Who were these sharecroppers? And let's go through our history of the black. Like you mentioned, the Black Codes. What did that look like? Paper. 00:27:40:12 - 00:28:03:32 Speaker 1 So. We've been talking about reconstruction as primarily like a legal thing. But, you know, you you mentioned it in your introduction. This was also a question of economic life. The great book, Black Reconstruction by W.E.B. Du Bois is, it begins, talking about the black worker, by which he means the enslaved person he wants to frame, reconstruct. 00:28:03:32 - 00:28:30:48 Speaker 1 And it's being very much about questions of land and, and economic agency and capital. Who controls what? What is capital? Who is capital, for that matter? And so coming out of the Civil War, there was this push, as I'm sure you all know, for land redistribution. You know, the planters had rebelled against the government. 00:28:31:02 - 00:28:56:35 Speaker 1 We should take their land and we should either distribute it to the people who worked the land or allowed them to buy it. And there was a real push to make this happen, to allow the formerly enslaved to buy it the land. The, the establishment of the Freedman's, Savings and Loan Bank in 1864, I want to say, and there's a great book on that, by the way, called The Rise and Betrayal of the Freedman's Bank, by historian Justine Hill Edwards. 00:28:56:39 - 00:29:24:34 Speaker 1 Wonderful book. You should read it. But part of the theory there was that formerly enslaved people, they just needed a place to have their money. They wanted to save up money to buy land. On the other side, influential figures in the government, Union Army officers, they were so quite prejudiced and, like, didn't imagine that black Americans could engage in that kind of entrepreneurial self-improvement. 00:29:24:34 - 00:29:56:06 Speaker 1 So they they're thinking, well, these people need to work and they need to work for wages. And that's how they'll that's how they achieve freedom. And northern industrialists and northern capitalists were like, well, we need people to start producing agricultural staples again. We need to put these people back to work for wages. It's what ends up happening when I see what ends up happening, the push to sort of redistribute land, which also cuts, again, sort of American ideas of property rights, the emancipation of 4 million people was already kind of an unprecedented transfer of wealth. 00:29:56:10 - 00:30:24:31 Speaker 1 When you remember that these people were actual stores of value were worth more. And David Blight, formulation, David Blight, the Civil War historian, who with more than all the railroads and all the infrastructure and all the banks in the country, that already upset people quite a bit, didn't make them happy. And then the notion of in giving these people land or let them bite on the cheap also was just a bridge too far for many, white Americans in power. 00:30:24:35 - 00:30:53:45 Speaker 1 And so what happens, is that black Americans, in the South are tied once again to the land. And because of Johnson's lenient reconstruction policies and the return of ex Confederates to power, they can legalize this. This is the Black Codes. The black coded this attempt to reimpose conditions of slavery. Literally slavery by just another name. 00:30:53:49 - 00:31:30:14 Speaker 1 And I think we were thinking about Carter. Is someone like someone like Carter G. Woodson, 20 years later, 20 years after all of this. Like, yeah, he is. His family is existing in the aftermath of all of this. In the aftermath of the failed economic revolution and reconstruction, or the non-existent economic revolution and reconstruction, and that that that failure of the economic revolution is as much important to the shape of what we term as the failed or the undermined and, legal revolution. 00:31:30:18 - 00:31:57:22 Speaker 1 It is not just now that there's no federal government enforcing rights on paper or rights written down in statute, the Civil Rights Act of 1866, of the Civil Rights Act of 1875. But then there's also been no change in underlying social relations. So economic historians over the past couple of years have found that more or less the same families that were wealthy in the South, pre-Civil War got their wealth back. 00:31:57:26 - 00:32:15:07 Speaker 1 There was like a there was like a bump. You know, people were unhappy for a little bit, but then they got their money back. And there wasn't the kind of redistribution, that would have changed. I think kind of the basic calculation, of social relations in the South. 00:32:15:11 - 00:32:44:36 Speaker 3 Okay, we focus on the South, where reconstruction, we focus on those who are doing the harm directly. But in your work, you also call out the northern elite who how did they further the loss of reconstruction or the goals of reconstruction? So that, yeah, we can go back, I mean, that so that we are lost, that we missed a promise? 00:32:44:37 - 00:32:46:28 Speaker 3 Yeah. 00:32:46:32 - 00:33:12:34 Speaker 1 That's a combination of a couple things. I mean, it cannot. This isn't this is more this is explanation, not justification. But it's worth remembering, right? That like, the Civil War killed around 750,000, the hundred thousand Americans, and wounded impaired about 2 million more after that. So a close to 10% of the American population of the time was killed or wounded in this war. 00:33:12:38 - 00:33:33:36 Speaker 1 The northern public was already at the end of it, sort of like we just want this to be over. The notion of union soldiers being in the South for a decade or more, the notion of this being kind of the center of national political life for a decade or more was increasingly intolerable to the northern public. 00:33:33:40 - 00:34:04:09 Speaker 1 And so there was just softening political support for the kind of, the kind of intensive work needed to be done to make to make everything stick. That's sure that that's like the overarching, you know, situation. And I'll say, you know, when I read that 15 years ago, ten years ago in a book, I had a hard time understanding it. 00:34:04:09 - 00:34:37:20 Speaker 1 Like, what do you mean? People got tired of it? And then we had, you know, an insurrection. It was January 6th. And the press, you know, the the then president, now president, tried to kill a bunch of Congress and overturn the government. And like, a couple years later, everyone's like, why are we talking about this? So events in the events in the present of help me understand how a public can experience something traumatic and then be like, I don't know what the big deal is anymore, and sort of what happened. 00:34:37:24 - 00:34:58:38 Speaker 1 Part of what happened here, part of what happened here. And I, I just, I just, I just mentioned this is that Northern Capital has also invested a lot of money into the war effort, and they want a return on their investment. And what they want is just to put these people back to work, put the blacks back to work, to produce cotton, to produce tobacco, to produce rice, produce these staples that are going to help us get our return on investment. 00:34:59:00 - 00:35:24:20 Speaker 1 And they begin supporting politicians who want to, you know, wrap this up so we can get back to the production of goods for the sake of, getting our return on investment and 1873, there's a big financial panic that is more or less equivalent to the Great Depression, which even makes this all the more acute for northern capital. 00:35:24:21 - 00:35:47:08 Speaker 1 We got to get our money back. If sweeps a lot of, you know, southern sympathizing Democrats back into office, either in the North or even in the South, you got a lot of Democrats back in office now. Who with political power can put pressure on the federal government to wrap this up as quickly as possible? 00:35:47:12 - 00:36:18:38 Speaker 1 There is, again, a northern public. You know, there are these massacres happening. And news of this reaches northern publics. And part of the attitude of much of the northern public is not no problem anymore. So it's a combination of, like, material things, exhaustion. What what what is happening? With frustration with the Grant administration, there is a whole kind of rebellion in the Republican Party against Grant, who they feel is too focused on the South and a lot of ways, and when the kind of old guard of Radical Republicans start dying. 00:36:18:38 - 00:36:45:25 Speaker 1 So Barry Stevens, Charles Sumner, when they start dying or losing or leaving office there just really isn't the kind of political counterweight anymore to, to press things further. And when control of the presidency ends up hinging on whether or not reconstruction policies can continue, and this is the election of 1876, there's just a general sense that we're done here. 00:36:45:29 - 00:37:10:23 Speaker 1 Now, having said having said that, it remains the case that for like the next 15 years or so, there is still some energy within the Republican Party for kind of basically saying, hey, we can still win elections down there, right? Like we're right. I don't know if we'll get into it. People can ask me about it. But one of the, I think problems with how we think about this period in public memory is we go immediately from the end of Reconstruction to Jim Crow, but there's like 20 years there. 00:37:10:27 - 00:37:31:35 Speaker 1 Between that, between those two events. And so in those 20 years, there's still party competition in the South. There's still Republican parties in the South. And so you still have national Republicans, Republicans in the North who are like, well, we shouldn't completely ignore them because we can still win elections. And this ends up culminating in one last effort to do like a, a federal elections and civil rights bill in 1890. 00:37:31:35 - 00:37:52:26 Speaker 1 That doesn't succeed, but it's kind of a product of all of this. But for the most part, attention is going elsewhere. It's going to the West, you know, all this land again that demands I'm sounding like a Marxist here, but the demand of capital, are are driving am I Marxist? Are driving so much of what's happening here. 00:37:52:26 - 00:38:13:37 Speaker 1 So looking to west, looking out west for land, looking for labor in the south and, and and increasingly looking abroad to, other nations, for, resources. The imperial domination is all shaping the reaction of the northern public to, to this. 00:38:13:41 - 00:38:28:40 Speaker 3 You explained the northern, interests and disinterest and their let's just get to production during reconstruction. Who would you say are today's northern elite? 00:38:28:44 - 00:38:49:32 Speaker 1 That's a good question, because I'm. I'm I'm always hesitant to make 1 to 1 analogies because just like the past is different, different time. I think I'll say this. I'll say this, at the beginning of our conversation, you kind of alluded to maybe we'll think about does reconstruction look like today? Do we need a reconstruction today? 00:38:49:36 - 00:39:13:17 Speaker 1 And I think it's I think one thing it's clear is that there is like a, emerging energy for the kind of, Harsh response to the people responsible for all the chaos. There's a great. I'm going to mention another book. It's a great book, called punish treason, reward loyalty. It's by a law professor. 00:39:13:20 - 00:39:17:04 Speaker 1 So it's not, like, scintillating, but it's good. 00:39:17:06 - 00:39:18:39 Speaker 3 Excuse me. 00:39:18:43 - 00:39:20:35 Speaker 1 No offense. 00:39:20:39 - 00:39:25:14 Speaker 3 But I need to send you my stuff. 00:39:25:18 - 00:39:29:42 Speaker 1 No offense, but I do read a lot of stuff by law professors. 00:39:29:46 - 00:39:33:07 Speaker 3 Looking at me like yours to. 00:39:33:11 - 00:39:49:48 Speaker 1 That's not not you. But the title comes from, how how lawmakers would speak after the war and punish treason, reward loyalty and that kind of energy. You can kind of sense, I think, in the country right now. And so. 00:39:49:48 - 00:39:51:48 Speaker 3 I think that. 00:39:52:02 - 00:40:18:46 Speaker 1 It's not hard to imagine a world where there's going to be a kind of irrepressible political demand to do something about what's happening and to try to make sure it doesn't happen again. I think when we get into questions of like, who is the equivalent of like the the northern elite or the northern Republic, it's going to be, or if there's a point where we get past this, there's going to be this conflict between punish treason and reward loyalty. 00:40:19:02 - 00:40:40:43 Speaker 1 And let's just get back to business. Right? Let's just get back to normalcy, where this is going to come from. It can come from a lot of places, right? Like I remember, after the 2008 election, it came from the white House. We know not great the past eight years, that we can move forward. We're not going to spend any time worrying about the torture program, not going to spend any time worrying about the law breaking. 00:40:40:47 - 00:41:01:02 Speaker 1 We're going to move forward. And that that was not a good decision. It's my opinion, but I thought I thought that was a bad choice. After after after Trump's first term, there was some of this as well. It was a little more because of January 6th, with a little more of an appetite for we got to do something. 00:41:01:02 - 00:41:26:14 Speaker 1 But even there, there was an urgency. On January 7th, you know, I remember, I remember just like watching, you know, the C-Span cameras are still rolling for capture. And God bless those guys. And you have these, like, shellshocked lawmakers who are genuinely shaken by what they've experienced. And then, you know, Democratic leadership is like, well, we should go home, that we need to go home. 00:41:26:18 - 00:41:27:28 Speaker 1 You gotta. 00:41:27:32 - 00:41:28:29 Speaker 3 Impeach that dude. 00:41:28:29 - 00:41:57:05 Speaker 1 Right now, right? Like if I have, you know, my kids clean up now. And there was this desire to kind of let's just. But, hey, everyone knows this is bad. We can move forward. And so there's going to be that energy, it is going to come and it will probably come from, if there is a Democratic majority in Congress, the Democrat presidency, the it'll be coming from elements of the Democratic Party, and then the reverse will be coming from all elements of Democratic Party as well. 00:41:57:05 - 00:42:14:48 Speaker 1 So like the I to me, to my for me, if I'm thinking about like the politics of three years from now, I do think that sort of the big political struggle is going to be okay. Now, what do we do? What do we do about these people? And it's going to be a real conflict between, let's just move forward. 00:42:15:08 - 00:42:26:11 Speaker 1 We don't want to dwell on this. It already happened. And punish treason, reward loyalty. I let you guess where I am on that. On that. 00:42:26:15 - 00:42:44:08 Speaker 3 So then how do we get off of that cycle? Yeah, right. How how? There's probably there will be pushback if we go one way or the other. So how do we get off that cycle to ensure that we don't have to have this conversation in the future? 00:42:44:12 - 00:43:11:14 Speaker 1 I think part of it, it's a political project, right? It's it's part of it is making political demands. Right. And like demonstrating the force of those political demands, of. Making a kind of call for real accountability, like a litmus test for support of a politician. Like, I don't just I don't just want to vote for you because you are you belong to my party or belong to the party I vote for. 00:43:11:18 - 00:43:33:00 Speaker 1 Are you going to do this? Are you going to make sure that we're not going to experience this again? And not like a vague, amorphous sense, but like in a very concrete we're going to investigate. We're going to, you know, take whatever hammer however much time it takes to really, really find who's responsible and punish if necessary. 00:43:33:04 - 00:43:51:20 Speaker 1 So I think, I think it's just that it's going to be that political struggle. I think for someone like me, for what I'm trying to do when I when I say write about like I recently wrote about the absence of, like, meaningful accountability for Confederate leaders, right. Like Jefferson Davis died peacefully in his bed. He was like 82 years old. 00:43:51:31 - 00:44:12:49 Speaker 1 His wife was next to him, and he just died peacefully in his bed, which is insane to think, right, like a guy who, maybe more than anyone else, done more than anyone else, but like up there in responsibilities for like dead Americans got to just like, you know, peacefully expire. And so Alexander Stevens died peacefully in bed like you. 00:44:12:49 - 00:44:36:41 Speaker 1 Sure. Going on the list of Confederate leaders. And no one had to, like, escape to Argentina, right? Les Brown, like, you know, Nazis trying to get away from the hangman's noose. Although there is that weird Confederate like, play town in Brazil. So, I mean, fact check, some of them did escape to South America. But you you get what I'm saying? 00:44:36:43 - 00:44:38:42 Speaker 1 You get you get the you get the point there overall. 00:44:38:43 - 00:44:42:46 Speaker 3 Overall. Well, yes. 00:44:43:00 - 00:45:05:29 Speaker 1 There part of what I'm trying to do is sort of like, say, one of the consequences of not taking accountability seriousness seriously enough is that you just you just you get more. Yeah. More of this. You get you get some version of what you just experienced. I think that was true then. It's certainly true now. And so to my mind, the the political question of the next few years is like, is it going to be true again? 00:45:05:33 - 00:45:24:45 Speaker 3 So we have the political question of, how to address this. My wonderful colleague Robert Wesley, who's right here, is writing a book on reparations. Dismissed with prejudice slavery, white supremacy, and the quest for black reparations. Under the law, it will not be in a boring law. But don't worry. 00:45:24:49 - 00:45:33:12 Speaker 1 And so I want to express my apologies to all of those who may be present. 00:45:33:16 - 00:46:06:38 Speaker 3 Apology accepted on behalf of law professors. He also teaches, 14th amendment at the law school, which is a very popular class. And he's been looking at reparations and the movement to redress some of the social justice issues, the racial justice, issues through reparations. What do you think of that movement and what other options do you think can address, the injustices? 00:46:06:40 - 00:46:07:42 Speaker 3 Yeah. 00:46:07:46 - 00:46:48:22 Speaker 1 I, I, you know, back back 12 years ago now with my, my friend and colleague Thanasi Coates wrote the case for reparations. I remember being persuaded by that, and since then had been, of the view that, like, reparations are a, a worthy goal and a worthy construct. I mean, even if even if something like reparations for slavery or reparations for a sort of like, you know, convict leasing or redlining isn't necessarily politically possible, bringing the construct into public view and saying that this is a legitimate way of thinking about how we respond to the things we've done is important. 00:46:48:26 - 00:47:18:46 Speaker 1 And I do think that looking at right now, right where legal residents, citizens, lawful asylum seekers, people who are, doing everything the right way, and being subjected to brutality, to cruel treatment, to the deprivation of the rights. I think thinking about reparations is all the more important in the context of what's happening now, because 3 or 4 years down the road, you know, let's say, let's say, let's say we apologize. 00:47:19:01 - 00:47:34:39 Speaker 1 That happened. We reorganized the Department of Homeland Security. What do we do about the people who are harmed? Right. What do we do about the people who are running these detention centers? I'm sure that when all of a sudden, then we're going to find very ugly stuff in the we're already finding, are we something interesting that we're gonna find even more ugly stuff in this tension centers? 00:47:35:00 - 00:47:57:04 Speaker 1 What do we do? And I it it it can't be. And in the same way that it cannot be, we're going to look forward with the perpetrators. It can't be sorry. Sorry, sorry for giving you measles. Sorry for traumatizing your children like it has to be. There has to be recompense. There has to be reparations. And so that's that's that's my view. 00:47:57:04 - 00:47:57:10 Speaker 1 Yeah. 00:47:57:13 - 00:48:03:36 Speaker 3 Do you see reparations only in the financial sense? Or what other ways can reparations be defined? 00:48:03:40 - 00:48:29:42 Speaker 1 I mean, I think part of me does, kind of see that in the financial sense, right? Like, you know, hey, the US federal budget is like $4 trillion. You can spare a couple a couple coins. I imagine I mean, I imagine you can think of them. Through this, in the direct sense of we are going to. 00:48:29:46 - 00:48:53:42 Speaker 1 Give you a literal recompense for what we did. We cannot there's no there's no monetary value that can ever make up for what we did to you. But we're going to give you and give you cash, as a way of, acknowledging that we did something wrong. That's what that kind of really is. I think you can imagine recompense in tend, in the sense of we're going to do everything we can to make sure this this doesn't happen again. 00:48:53:46 - 00:49:10:11 Speaker 1 Right? So we're going to make whatever transformation to reforms we need to make to make sure that, like this thing cannot happen again. And then I don't, I don't know, I mean, I don't know, I'd have to I have to think more about it. 00:49:10:15 - 00:49:12:48 Speaker 3 All right. And you should read his book once it comes out, I will. 00:49:13:02 - 00:49:14:38 Speaker 1 Yeah. 00:49:14:42 - 00:49:34:17 Speaker 3 I'm going to skip another question that I have because I want to, open it up soon. And just ask my last question. So we talked about the past. You look a lot to the past for guidance. What do you think future writers and historians will say about the current period? 00:49:34:21 - 00:49:52:02 Speaker 1 Right. I mean, at this moment. Right. Like, if I can, if I can put my self in the mind of, like a grad student 100 years from now, they might just be wondering, how did they let that guy get back in office, right? Like, yeah. Because from us. Yeah. I mean, from from the point of view of today. 00:49:52:03 - 00:50:25:38 Speaker 1 Right. It's sort of like this was very predictable, all the terrible things, quite, quite predictable. So how did this happen again? I think I mean, I think that future historians will be looking at this period not just as the past ten years, but really sort of the entire post, post-Cold War period that we're kind of we're kind of still in post-Cold War America, and that some part of what we're experiencing are the internal fractures and division in American society that's always been there. 00:50:25:42 - 00:50:51:37 Speaker 1 But the absence of a big external enemy of a big ideological crusade, kind of suppressed, someone this is also plug for my podcast, which is, which is unclear and Present Danger, which is all about all about this stuff. This is about, you know, I don't you know, I've listened to it, but it was like, you know, that that I imagine it's going to be like a combination of those things, right? 00:50:51:38 - 00:51:10:28 Speaker 1 In the same way that when I read about the First World War, it's right. Yeah. I can see how the system of alliance is entangled. All the all the, all the combatants of Europe. I can see how kind of the pressures of imperialism begin to, like, make themselves known. The European continent, like, all the big picture stuff. 00:51:10:32 - 00:51:33:49 Speaker 1 Clearly, I can see it. But then you're just sort of like me. It's really dumb with them to do that, right? You know, it was really. It really, someone should have thought twice before committing an entire army to a a land war because some random, you know, inbred monarch got asked, and so I think I think it will be a combination of the two. 00:51:33:49 - 00:52:08:33 Speaker 1 The same kind of impulse, like clear structural, you know, structural explanations and then wondering, just like what? What how did Americans lose their minds in this particular way? And because the story is yet unwritten, we'll we'll see where this goes. Right? Like, there's there's a possibility that this gets worse. There's a possibility that we recognize the, destruction in the chaos and decide to do something about it. 00:52:08:37 - 00:52:24:49 Speaker 1 And then there's the possibility that we just muddle through, and that we make some changes. We find we do some repair. There are ways in which we don't. And we kind of muddle through and see and see what happens. Right. 00:52:25:03 - 00:52:40:07 Speaker 3 While you all are trying to figure out your questions, I am going it's clear that you have read a lot of books, and since we're at a bookstore, I'm going to point to books, and you're gonna tell me if we've read them. If you read them. All right. I'm kidding. All right. 00:52:40:11 - 00:52:47:33 Speaker 1 I was like, I was like, mentally preparing. I was like, let's see if I can do this. I have a. 00:52:47:37 - 00:53:03:10 Speaker 3 Now I want to make sure you all, if you have questions, if there's enough time at the end, we'll play. We'll play. But I do want to make sure that you all, get to ask your questions that you have formulated, throughout here. And thank you all. I only had one cell phone ring, so thank you all for that. 00:53:03:10 - 00:53:31:23 Speaker 3 Yes. And have you got the mic? So if you will call them. All right. And your name, Evie will come to you if you raise your hand. And ask the question, again, it needs to end with a question mark. If it's too long, then I will again take my moderator's privilege, and ask, you to ask the question. 00:53:31:23 - 00:54:06:22 Speaker 3 And we can disagree without being disrespectful. And so, please take that into mind as well. Oh. I'm on the sideline. Thank you. I, am retired faculty of Humanities, but I guess now, I'm anti die world, I can't teach, I couldn't teach if I was still in the classroom, but I was really struck by how you frame the beginning of the conversation about reconstruction. 00:54:06:26 - 00:54:46:12 Speaker 3 And today, in terms of questions around identity, I would say what's resonated actually more with me is questions around power. And when I think about power, I think about the 1850s, and I think about, the slave power. Yeah. Right. That was that was enough to instantiate this was this Republican response to the 1861. So when I am doom scrolling through history in my mind, this is what I want you to to answer for me, because I get bits of this in your columns. 00:54:46:12 - 00:55:12:27 Speaker 3 Anyway. Do you see the birthright citizenship case coming out the way that the administration would like? And if it does, do you see a path whereby and I mean this for us here in Louisiana, whereby Dred Scott, the tenants of the Dred Scott decision, be whipped up as a right. 00:55:12:31 - 00:55:34:19 Speaker 1 Yeah. I don't know how that birthright citizenship case is going to go down. I don't know, I this is this is something where like my my inclination is to be like, yeah, those, those those, those six, you know, conservatives in the court are going to are going to give Trump what he wants. But I really don't know. It's one of those things where. 00:55:34:23 - 00:56:06:01 Speaker 1 The legal case for the legal case against a non traditional understanding of that clause is non-existent. Like it's like it's it's as close the first resistance because for, for good reason. They want it to be clear is as close to absolutely clear as you can get. Right. They're just they're really like if you are born here and if for some reason you're not subject to the law or if you're subject to the laws with the kind of like implicit, if for some reason you're not, but you are, then you're a citizen. 00:56:06:01 - 00:56:31:11 Speaker 1 And then if you read the four debates, right, you have because remember, the Republican Party coalition comprises no, nothing's there, nothing nativist. So you have like nativist Congressman being like, what does this include? The Chinese? And, Senator Jacob Howard of Michigan says, yeah, it does. Does it include gypsies? It it does include, but these are going down the list of like, potentially potential swarthy people. 00:56:31:11 - 00:57:17:32 Speaker 1 It might include it every time. The response is, yes, it obviously includes everyone. So and logically it should be an open and shut case. But I don't know. I will say though that if if you do get basically, you know, a meaningful overturning of the birthright citizenship requires in which like it no longer is absolute, then I to me that is in a sense affirming Dred Scott because b to my my how I understand Dred Scott is that ultimately that is a ruling saying that there are tiers of American right, that there are Americans who count the most, and there are Americans who don't count whatsoever, and they have no rights with respecting. 00:57:17:36 - 00:57:38:33 Speaker 1 And that the section on the 14th amendment is both, historically speaking, but also sort of like legally and philosophically speaking, a direct rebuke to that. It's that there are no tiers of Americans that there only is one type of American citizenship. It belongs to everyone who's born here or naturalized here. It involves due process for all. It requires equal protection for all. 00:57:38:37 - 00:57:53:36 Speaker 1 And as soon as you open up the door to the existence of like a legally recognized subordinate caste, then you've just you're just back in Dred Scott territory. So, Yeah, so I hope I hope they don't. I hope they will. 00:57:53:36 - 00:57:57:46 Speaker 3 Correct that. 00:57:58:00 - 00:58:28:15 Speaker 3 Hi. I'm thinking about your poor hypothetical graduate student 100 years from now. And what the hell is he going to research? Because I'm just worried about, you know, the the books, you know, the censorship. Who's publishing what? The the fact that they, you know, that there's been so little attention placed to how to make the humanities a little sexier is also quite worrying, because a lot of these parents, I mean, I can see instruction and how it affects my life. 00:58:28:15 - 00:58:52:16 Speaker 3 I'm born in Freedman's Hospital in Washington, D.C., when my mom was a medical student. It didn't frames households. And close to 50 years ago, it opened 1863, provided health care for all. Was the charity hospital it. But, you know, with the civil rights issues, I did saw someone colorized some civil rights, some Martin Luther King pictures so the kids would know it wasn't that damn long ago. 00:58:52:20 - 00:59:14:02 Speaker 3 But, you know, with with what we're having, I'm really worried that they'll have to be sort of underground documents for this poor graduate student. How do we how do we, you know, in a time when they're trying to get rid of all of our history, the ministry did seep out. How are we going to protect it? So that grad student has something to find. 00:59:14:06 - 00:59:14:30 Speaker 3 This. 00:59:14:34 - 00:59:40:02 Speaker 1 I'll be honest. This is one of the things I'm not actually that worried about, in part because of the response to efforts to erase history. Right? Like, they they tried to they took down the, in Philadelphia, the the exhibit about slavery, George Washington's enslaved people. Right. They're like, this isn't this is this this isn't relevant to the site where the site exists because George Washington enslaved people there. 00:59:40:06 - 01:00:12:44 Speaker 1 It is literally the reason for the site. But so the the administration removed it and then, like ordinary Philadelphians, came by and put little plaques. Slavery happened here, right? I think one of the things, one of the reasons I think that this administration has been so ferocious about trying to suppress history, why their allies have been so ferocious about trying to suppress books, is because they're fighting, you know, in military terms, a rearguard action. 01:00:12:44 - 01:00:35:45 Speaker 1 They've kind of they kind of lost the war already. Right? There is there is a, I think, a cultural expectation of taking things seriously in history. It's not that every American is like woke or anything, but that enough Americans do say things like, I want to learn about slavery, right? Like I want my kids to learn about slavery. 01:00:35:45 - 01:00:57:17 Speaker 1 I want my kids to learn about Japanese internment. I want my kids to learn about Native Americans. That's that's the norm. My wife's a schoolteacher. Right. And, if we if the school were to somehow. And our governor was Glenn Youngkin for four years, right, who came to office on a kind of like, you know, my teenage son read beloved. 01:00:57:28 - 01:01:26:19 Speaker 1 And it it made him so upset. He was traumatized. Your kid was traumatized. And what happened? Well, but honestly, happened is that the Youngkin administration tried to put out new educational standards and teachers and parents and communities across the Commonwealth were like, we're not having any of it, right? You know, first of all, too many of us living, you know, we we live through massive resistance. 01:01:26:19 - 01:01:48:26 Speaker 1 We remember it experience the loss of education because of people like that. So we're not going to do it again. And the standards just like went nowhere, sort of like no school districts adopted them was kind of a dead letter. And I think that the extent to which the actual public, is committed to something a bit broader, is going to be the thing that safeguards all of this, right? 01:01:48:26 - 01:02:08:30 Speaker 1 Like, you know, the existence of independent bookstores. The the fact that the fact that, you know, young people still like the idea of forbidden knowledge, right? And that's I mean, that's that's half the reason why you can't successfully censor anything. It's like they don't want you to know is is the number one way to get people to want to look. 01:02:08:30 - 01:02:21:21 Speaker 1 It's a it's as someone who used to write headlines for, internet news stories they don't want you to know. Very effective. 01:02:21:25 - 01:02:45:34 Speaker 1 Great discussion. You mentioned the radicals, I guess, the name of the party during construction. And I feel like, like where are the radicals now? Like like, I feel like, particularly the Democratic Party is sort of waiting for even more, worse things to happen to have a better political position. And I'm just kind of curious to know, what were the motivations of the radicals during reconstruction? 01:02:45:34 - 01:03:06:09 Speaker 1 And is there, you know, where does that fit into what we're seeing out there? Any possibility that there will be radicals or they're just kind of focus group everything to figure out the best positions. So the Radical Republicans should do reconstruction. But that's like a particular. All right. I got rewind real quick. So the Republican Party is formed in 1854. 01:03:06:13 - 01:03:32:06 Speaker 1 And it's formed. It's like this weird coalition party, centered around opposition to the expansion of slavery, but comprising of different approaches to that. So you have what was formerly the Liberty Party, which is basically sort of like in today's kind of terms, the most left wing anti-slavery formation. Right? Like they were like immediate abolition. Now, don't, don't compensate the slave owners. 01:03:32:10 - 01:03:54:10 Speaker 1 Can I, can I can I can I curse can I a, support? If they're like, fuck the slave holders. Immediate emancipation. You have the Free Soil Party, which is we don't want to get rid of slavery. We're it is property rights, blah, blah, blah, but it can't expand beyond its borders. You have the no nothing. 01:03:54:10 - 01:04:17:38 Speaker 1 So we're like, we don't like immigrants. And we don't like black people, and we don't like the people who get power from black people either. So no slaveholders, because of course, the, prefix compromise and apportionment meant the slave owners were quite powerful. So now that brings liberty, free soil, and then anti-slavery Democrats who some of them, were genuinely anti-slavery. 01:04:17:42 - 01:04:55:06 Speaker 1 Some of them were more along the lines of the basically the barnburner Democrats, they said we would be empowering the Democratic Party if not for the slave holders. And so we don't like them very much. And then you have the remnants of the Whig Party or the anti-slavery way. So that's the Republican Party, all these people and the radicals are basically the former Liberty Party men, and they're the ones who a guy like John Bingham from Ohio, who wrote much of the 14th and 15th amendment, he was, a lawyer for fugitive slaves in Ohio, salmon Chase as well, who was Lincoln's secretary of the Treasury and then Supreme Court 01:04:55:06 - 01:05:23:45 Speaker 1 justice, also was a lawyer for, fugitive slaves. He was known as a lawyer for fugitive slaves. You have these various guys who they get into politics because they want to end slavery. Like, that's that's the reason why they're doing this, and they're the ones Charles Sumner is, you know, who has a young lawyer helped, tried to integrate Boston schools, and, you know, lived he lived in a black neighborhood in Boston and was like a very staunch, egalitarian and anti-slavery guy. 01:05:23:45 - 01:05:45:27 Speaker 1 So you have all these, these figures who they they are basically abolitionists. And but they involved in regular party politics and they were like the core of the Radical Republicans. They're the ones who, during the war, are constantly badgering Lincoln about, you need to make this a war for emancipation. You need to take a harder line against the slave owners. 01:05:45:31 - 01:06:08:05 Speaker 1 Charles Sumner, who was a very good friend of Mary to have. Lincoln would basically sort of like be like tiger husband to, to be better. And that's so another way putting this in maybe attracted a bit is the radicals were like a specific social formation, like they came from particular communities in, in the Midwest and, the north western Massachusetts. 01:06:08:09 - 01:06:31:41 Speaker 1 They they were distance wise, they were some distance from places where there were commercial ties to slavery. So New York is in western New York is where you'd find radical Republicans in Pennsylvania, was in western Pennsylvania, was an Ohio. And it was in Maine and Massachusetts. But, you know, away from Boston and, and, they were just sort of committed to almost like the maximal anti-slavery position. 01:06:31:45 - 01:06:52:41 Speaker 1 So the question for if you're thinking about the present day is like, what what what are the social formations? So they're going to be like the most opposed to Trump in the various whatever comes after that. And that's, you know, they're going to be within the Democratic Party because Democrat Party is a coalition party, in the way in, in all ways, in the way the Republican Party was. 01:06:52:41 - 01:07:23:09 Speaker 1 The Democratic Party has become this broad anti-Trump coalition of a lot of different kinds of people. And so what what faction within that coalition is going to be the one that is going to be the most aggressive. And I actually think that this is this is not an obvious thing to figure out, because part of why the radicals were the way they were is that they were traded into politics at a time when the slaveholding, the slave power, the slave power was, becoming all the more extreme. 01:07:23:09 - 01:07:45:16 Speaker 1 Right? So they are witnessing slaveholders saying, you know, if the federal government doesn't ban personal liberty laws, we're going to secede. If the federal government doesn't mandate that states give us back our slaves, we're going to secede. It's really polarizing against what they're witnessing. I think you got to think about all of this in terms of political acculturation. 01:07:45:26 - 01:08:12:24 Speaker 1 Who are the what are the factions in the Democratic Party that that their understanding of politics is more shaped from, by the last 20 years, in the previous 20 years before that. Right. And so, that's someone's it that's young people. It is some young people, it is some, it is some older members of Congress who maybe only got into politics in, in the, in the 2020 tens. 01:08:12:28 - 01:08:34:17 Speaker 1 But I'm thinking of like, particular people. Right. Like, if you have younger members like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. In the House, I can never name senators because they'll kind of blur in my mind, but it's, you know, Ruben Gallego from Arizona who was a very moderate Democrat. Right. But is is also quite kind of like we got to punish these people. 01:08:34:17 - 01:08:53:38 Speaker 1 So I think the thing you want to look for is that, like, when are they like, how do they understand the political moment. And it's it's the Democrats whose understanding of the political moment or who's understanding of politics feels like out of a different age, that the who are the ones who I think are uniquely unequipped from the moment. 01:08:53:42 - 01:09:14:20 Speaker 1 For those of you who watched The Wire, way back when, it's that scene when, it's, it's season four and Marlo Stanfield goes into that convenience store, and he, like, he steals a lollipop. And the security guard, he's like, come on, man, you know I can't let you do that. And then Amal looks in. It looks him in the eye and says, you wanted to be one way, but it's the other way. 01:09:14:23 - 01:09:32:28 Speaker 1 And for some of these Democrats, they really want it to be one way, but it is in fact, the other way. And you got to look for the Democrats to understand if it is the other way. I love that scene. Are you I referenced that scene all the time. I feel like it is. It is such a yeah. 01:09:32:31 - 01:09:57:06 Speaker 3 It's like I, I got moved to the front of class from our question, but much great chat. So whenever you're talking about identity and reconstruct and I was thinking about the press and the emergence of the black press and its role in shaping black identity, we have Louisiana Weekly here, which is, a long running black newspaper. 01:09:57:06 - 01:10:11:20 Speaker 3 But can you talk about any through lines that we may be seeing between then and now with the press? It's very poignant right now. Very loud, and very disturbing. So I would love to hear your thoughts. 01:10:11:23 - 01:10:37:05 Speaker 1 That's really interesting question, because the the nature of the press in the, in the late 19th century is very different. Right? There were the New York Times existed, but it wasn't the kind of big national, you know, agenda setting paper that it is now. It was just another New York paper, a particularly large one. But like the New York paper and the media was like much more partizan in a way that actually be, I think, quite familiar to us. 01:10:37:09 - 01:11:07:28 Speaker 1 There were Republican newspapers. There were Democratic newspapers. I mentioned Jefferson Davis. Thank you. So in his bed after he died, you know, obviously there are obituaries everywhere. And basically, if it was a Democratic newspaper, especially in the South, it was like Jefferson Davis. What what a what a guy. You know, what, what a champ. What a gee, and then no other newspapers, Republican newspapers were like, you know, I hope he's burning in hell right now. 01:11:07:31 - 01:11:34:10 Speaker 1 And so that that kind of partizan divide was, like, characteristic of the press, the divide between news and opinion didn't quite exist in the same way. Which is also that that it's hard to draw a direct analogy. If anything, I feel like that be you got to look for analogies in ways of thinking about. But the role of alternative presses, and the role of the mainstream press, it's the civil rights era where the mainstream press really dropped the ball a lot. 01:11:34:14 - 01:11:57:03 Speaker 1 In terms of coverage of what was happening. And it was the black press that really pioneered a lot of important stories about the civil rights movement, about what was happening in the South even before it, even before the, the via the late civil rights movement in the 50s and 60s. It's the black press that's doing it to kind of investigative work, the reporting work to be like, this is what is happening. 01:11:57:06 - 01:12:07:43 Speaker 1 And the mainstream press is like kind of nowhere to be found. And in the present, I would say that the mainstream press struggles with what the story is now. 01:12:07:43 - 01:12:12:06 Speaker 1 you can't call Donald Trump a fascist because that's insulting to Americans. 01:12:12:10 - 01:12:35:42 Speaker 1 And it's like, are you are you stupid? Like, are you dumb? I, I don't understand what what would drive you to make this claim, but it's like, it's that that attitude that we can't say these things because of what it might say about the American people. It's actually a little more common than, than I would like, to think. 01:12:35:46 - 01:13:04:18 Speaker 4 Good evening. Oh, thanks for being here. My name is Jerome. And I1I yeah, we talk about education, law. You know, I was born here in New Orleans, and, you know, our education system was known as, school to prison pipeline. And so I want to speak about the 13 amendment. And actually, your thoughts on how prevalent was, you know, being duly convicted and our past, present and future? 01:13:04:27 - 01:13:08:03 Speaker 4 Yeah. 01:13:08:07 - 01:13:24:18 Speaker 1 I have this, I can say, of course I own this. I have this these two big volumes of, like, all the documents from the Reconstruction amendments drafting on the floor of Congress. It cost a lot of money. And I was like to my boss, I'm going to buy this, and you guys are going to pay for it. 01:13:24:22 - 01:13:48:27 Speaker 1 And if you read through, the four debates have been collected over the 13th amendment, no one talks about that phrase. It's it's not it's not really in the I believe Charles Sumner at one point says, you know, maybe people might try to, you know, and unfairly arrest people, but it's sort of quickly dismissed out of hand, like it's no one's talking about it when you look at. 01:13:48:31 - 01:14:09:40 Speaker 1 So there, the color conventions, if people know about those, there's a black American, those who are gathering in places like Baltimore and Philadelphia and Boston and kind of like debating the issues of the day and talking about them. And you we have, there are current conventions that are talking about the 13th amendment, and we have sort of like their notes and even their there's not much discussion of this clause, at the time. 01:14:09:40 - 01:14:33:40 Speaker 1 There's a very good book by, historian Stephen Hahn called A Liberal America, which kind of he talks about some of this at the time, the idea of prison labor was considered to be progressive. Right. We're not just going to like, we're not going to throw you into a dungeon. We're not going to make you rot. If you go to prison, you will work and you'll be brought into work. 01:14:33:40 - 01:15:11:35 Speaker 1 You will, you know, rehabilitate. And so the the except for punishment is a crime. One way to read this is it's sort of a nod to a kind of like, more progressive vision of punishment. And you don't want to rule that out. We want to make sure that that can still happen. The other way to read it is, that phrase you can find in the northwest Ordinance of 1787, which is a law passed under the Articles of Confederation, which banned slavery from what is now Ohio in Michigan and sort of what was the Northwest Territory, the United States. 01:15:11:39 - 01:15:39:01 Speaker 1 And when they were writing the 13th amendment, they kind of just copied the language from that law and made just like, you know, copy paste it. And so one argument is that it's just boilerplate. It's just sort of something that's there. And he didn't really think about it. I in either case, it's there. And there is this interesting historical question of how much did it matter that language to the emergence of convict leasing, to the emergence of a century later mass incarceration? 01:15:39:05 - 01:16:06:46 Speaker 1 I say my own view is that it didn't matter that much. Not that the language isn't important, but still, both with the larger political and cultural environment is what mattered the most. So if there were, if the northern public was gung ho about seeing reconstruction through to the end, whatever it took to reconstruct the South, and there was a political coalition for the protection of the rights of blacks that was powerful and strong, then it wouldn't matter what the language was, right? 01:16:07:00 - 01:16:31:17 Speaker 1 Who cares? Because it would have been like a political will to make sure that convict leasing couldn't emerge, that something like Jim Crow couldn't emerge. The equal Protection clause of the First Amendment is very clear. You know, all Americans, all the equal protection of the laws. It was kind of that kind of dead for 80 years. So I, I'm not sure that the language mattered all that much. 01:16:31:17 - 01:17:06:17 Speaker 1 I think what mattered was that, you know. After a brief period out of power, white supremacists got power back that in the late 19th century, the white public throughout the nation kind of just had to reconcile with itself on this basis of, like, white supremacy. There's a connection between America looking to Cuba and to Hawaii and to the Philippines for new territory and all of the national reconciliation, civil war stuff that's happening. 01:17:06:17 - 01:17:24:42 Speaker 1 At the same time, it's part of the same thing. White America will come together. Brown. You know, unfortunate that war, brother against brother. Too bad. And this is where all that red, all that language comes to, all those narratives that the war wasn't about slavery. It was a big misunderstanding. It was the abolitionists fault, that kind of thing. 01:17:24:46 - 01:17:52:48 Speaker 1 All emerges in this period of trying to reconcile the nation under white supremacy, so that that that's what that's what determines the direction and the language in the 13th amendment, to my mind, is just sort of, you know, not great, but I'm not sure how much it mattered either. And even mass incarceration in the 20th century is as much about deindustrialization and the emergence of, like, surplus labor in the cities. 01:17:52:48 - 01:18:13:32 Speaker 1 And what are we going to do about all these young men who don't have jobs? We're going to go to jail, which will provide jobs to other young men who don't have jobs. Right. Like, well, the the, the people at the bottom of the race hierarchy, they'll go in prison. And the people who normally benefit from that kind of stuff, well, they can be guards. 01:18:13:36 - 01:18:17:08 Speaker 1 So, yeah, I mean. 01:18:17:12 - 01:18:51:24 Speaker 3 This will be the last question. Hi. My name is Tim. And my question is, as someone trained in history, when you look at this moment, what do you think students, especially those moving toward law or policy, need to recognize as a potential breaking point? Like, what kinds of questions should we be training ourselves to ask right now? And what does history suggest about when, like, this collective commitment feels more like an individual's own idea of progress rather than what you're that like for us? 01:18:51:28 - 01:18:57:21 Speaker 3 Not just the law, but the movement. Thank you. 01:18:57:25 - 01:19:22:37 Speaker 1 I think in terms of what it's important for students, especially people going into law right now, going into politics right now. I think one thing that may have caught many people are aware over the past few years is this idea that everyone thought, like the checks and balances were like self-executing. They're like, oh, you can't do that because there's checks and balances. 01:19:22:41 - 01:19:41:36 Speaker 1 But the truth is, of course, and this might be maybe a theme of this conversation that like, ultimately, the Constitution is just words on paper, just words on paper. And if there's no one there to execute anything, it doesn't, doesn't happen. Which means I think one of the things it's important to cultivate is a recognition of the importance of power. 01:19:41:40 - 01:20:15:30 Speaker 1 Right? I don't think I think Americans are actually with the uncomfortable thinking about power. You know, thinking about acquiring it, wielding it, the uses of it, like, be important to power and understanding why things happen the way they do, is, to my mind, like the thing you need to cultivate the most to you don't necessarily to be like a legal realist here, but you can you can see you can see that what laws are enforced, what structures survive. 01:20:15:34 - 01:20:39:49 Speaker 1 You know, who who is affected, what is effected. It's very much a function of who holds power. And so in terms of everyone, it's, you know, for my to my mind, you have to if you want meaningful change out of this period, then the paramount goal is the acquisition of political power. All right. That is that is the end. 01:20:40:03 - 01:21:04:31 Speaker 1 And there are many paths to that end, right? There are many ways to go about that, to accomplish that. But that is ultimately the strategic goal, the acquisition of the power of the state to change things. Whether that's to change laws, whether to change structures, because one of the lessons of reconstruction is that losing the power of the state, will set you back and can set you back, for 100 years. 01:21:04:35 - 01:21:10:10 Speaker 1 So that's a really dark way to end this conversation. 01:21:10:14 - 01:21:15:13 Speaker 3 But just like with concert, where they say the last song and then there's an encore. Yeah. We have one more question. 01:21:15:13 - 01:21:18:06 Speaker 1 Okay, good. Okay. 01:21:18:10 - 01:21:37:33 Speaker 3 Well, I appreciate that. I feel like that was probably the place to stop. I'm not gonna say who I am. I'm just. I'm going to ask two questions quickly, if that's possible. They're ones historic ones. Right. So, given the promises of reconstruction, what would have been different if, what can we imagine would be different if Lincoln was still in the picture? 01:21:37:35 - 01:22:01:42 Speaker 3 That's the first question. Second question is you addressed the role of media. In the moment. And I'm really curious, given your experience, what you think about the independent media, I think there's a case to be made that the media environment is so balkanized now that maybe it doesn't foment division, but there are so many divisions, and you can just slot yourself into one and never have to listen to anything else. 01:22:01:42 - 01:22:04:33 Speaker 3 So just curious what you think about the media moment. 01:22:04:38 - 01:22:05:18 Speaker 1 Yeah. 01:22:05:22 - 01:22:07:07 Speaker 3 Thank you. 01:22:07:11 - 01:22:26:42 Speaker 1 Okay. Lincoln. No idea. Is is so as I said earlier, you know, he he began with a sort of lenient approach to all this. He really wanted to reconcile the nation quite quickly. You can see that in the second inaugural, the very end, where he is kind of urging the country to we have to finish this war. 01:22:26:42 - 01:22:43:43 Speaker 1 But then once the war is over, we have to recognize that we're one country again. We have to get back together again. So that's I think that's where his heart is. The interesting thing about Lincoln, the really I think makes him like a, an unusual president is he was just capable of changing his mind. And he could do it all the time. 01:22:43:47 - 01:23:01:14 Speaker 1 And so the path from this is a war for Union to this is a war for emancipation. It's very much a case of Lincoln being pressured by people within his administration, outside of his administration, by events on the ground, and rather than digging in and saying, no, this is what I want it to be, him recognizing that the ground change and I have to change with it. 01:23:01:18 - 01:23:24:08 Speaker 1 And so he changes his mind. Let's say Lincoln doesn't get assassinated. John Wilkes Booth, you know, it doesn't make it, to Ford's Theater. The Lincoln's don't go. Whatever happens. And he pursues the lenient policies. And then we get the black codes and we get the normal progression of our history, I think. And that it to in our history that happened. 01:23:24:08 - 01:23:54:25 Speaker 1 Andrew Johnson, who hates black people, is a terrible racist and imagined himself to be the leader of a new party formation. Of all the whites who hate black people in that world, Andrew Johnson doubles down. He's like, yeah, I want this. When the Congress passes the Civil Rights Act of 1866, he vetoes it and he says, when are we going to stop giving all of these favors to the blacks, which is a which is a crazy thing to say in 1866. 01:23:54:29 - 01:24:20:13 Speaker 1 But he says it and, what are we going to do stuff for the white man? Really, dude? So that's what happens in our world. It's not hard for me to imagine that over Lincoln experiences the Black Codes and says, oh, I've been too lenient. Right. Because this is the same Lincoln who, when Grant is sending 1020, 30,000 Union soldiers to die in single engagement, he is like, all right, if that's what it takes. 01:24:20:13 - 01:24:43:47 Speaker 1 Right. So I'm the way I the way I understand Lincoln's psychology. I think there's a real chance that in the face of recalcitrant confederates and white supremacist vigilantes, I think he might have taken like it even harder line than the Radical Republicans, in part because of a recognition that, like, you know, these sacrifices can't happen for not they have to they have to be for something so that structure would be different. 01:24:44:06 - 01:25:09:04 Speaker 1 Yeah, yeah. In his. Yeah, yeah. So, that's that's how I maybe see how things work out with Lincoln in, media today. Balkanized. I said earlier, right, that like a lot in a lot of ways the media environment today is like not actually all that different from the media environment. 100 years ago. It's very different from the middle of the 20th century, when there were the big newspapers and big conglomerates, and it was sort of consensus. 01:25:09:08 - 01:25:29:10 Speaker 1 But prior to that, which itself was sort of just an accident of like radio spectrum, right? Like the government monopolized it. And so in order to get access to it, you had to, promise to, you know, share all perspectives. And so it was like a business decision. But prior to that, it was more of a free for all right. 01:25:29:12 - 01:25:49:38 Speaker 1 People were balkanized in their understanding. So I don't necessarily see that as like an obstacle. I see it as like an opportunity for all kinds of, you know, political entrepreneurs, you might say. Because the other thing about the period. This is somewhat true now, is that like political movements, parties, they had newspapers, right? Like they wanted to inform their audiences, inform their supporters. 01:25:49:42 - 01:26:13:42 Speaker 1 And so I think there's a real opportunity today, you know, if I were, if I had $1 billion to just, like, hand around, if I had $1 billion and it didn't, hadn't driven me insane, which is certainly what $1 billion does. But, if I somehow escape that curse, I would 100% fund lots of, like, local, you know, newspapers that do local news for my particular political perspective. 01:26:14:04 - 01:26:38:23 Speaker 1 And the editorials represent my particular political perspective. I think there's an opportunity for the people with money in this country to stop thinking about influencing politics in terms of think tanks or like, you know, funding, you know, some random dude with a new book and more in terms of how do we cultivate the kind of public that we want to exist? 01:26:38:27 - 01:27:05:15 Speaker 1 And part of that is like the media question. And even if there's going to be a lot of different publics, you can cultivate a couple big ones with like, you know, media investment. So that's that's sort of how I see things right now that the the separation and the balkanization. Is probably a return to sort of like the base state of American, the American media landscape, but that that provides an opportunity for whoever wants to try to try their hand at creating new publics. 01:27:05:15 - 01:27:14:17 Speaker 1 And I do think that one thing the media does is it creates new publics, like that's and that's a whole other conversation. But yeah. 01:27:14:21 - 01:27:27:26 Speaker 3 Please join me in thanking. 01:27:27:26 - 01:27:55:01 Speaker 1 Thank you for spending time with us and for being a part of the Baldwin Co community. Every listen helps to keep the conversation alive. So thank you for listening. And if you believe in the work that we're doing, building literacy, nurturing curiosity and investing in our city, please, please, please consider supporting to the Bone and Co Foundation. You can go on to that Bco foundation at org. 01:27:55:01 - 01:28:14:35 Speaker 1 You can make a donation or you can just go to WW Baldwin or call books.com. You can follow us on our socials just at Baldwin and Company. So make sure you follow us. Check us out, subscribe. If you want to watch the video portion of this podcast and all of our podcasts, definitely check out our YouTube channel. 01:28:14:37 - 01:28:36:03 Speaker 1 It's just Baldwin and co on YouTube. Put it in the search and it'll come right up. So thank you so much. Please. Your donations, a few, programs that open doors our kids and our neighborhoods. And, when you're ready for your next great read, make sure to visit us online at Baldwin and Co. Every book you buy to help us just keep the movement going. 01:28:36:12 - 01:28:54:26 Speaker 1 If you're in New Orleans, make sure to stop by. Our address is 1030 Legion Fields Avenue. Come by and check us out. Get a good book, hang with us, get a good cup of coffee, and, look forward to seeing you. Have a good one.