1
00:00:00,010 --> 00:00:03,370
Stu:
I'm waiting for Chaz to start his rapping career very soon.

2
00:00:04,070 --> 00:00:05,390
Chas:
My midlife crisis.

3
00:00:05,850 --> 00:00:08,970
Mel:
I am not coming to your open mic night. I'm putting my foot down.

4
00:00:09,010 --> 00:00:10,150
Mel:
I have to have a boundary somewhere.

5
00:00:10,410 --> 00:00:14,130
Stu:
Beat Zero is just going to be a weekly podcast of Chaz.

6
00:00:15,070 --> 00:00:17,470
Chas:
Oh my God, I couldn't imagine anything worse.

7
00:00:27,990 --> 00:00:30,470
Chas:
Hi i'm chas fisher and.

8
00:00:30,470 --> 00:00:31,310
Mel:
I'm mel killingsworth.

9
00:00:31,310 --> 00:00:32,930
Stu:
And i'm stew willis and.

10
00:00:32,930 --> 00:00:38,170
Chas:
Welcome to draft zero podcast where filmmakers try to work out what makes great screenplays work.

11
00:00:38,170 --> 00:00:41,410
Stu:
And in this episode perhaps the final

12
00:00:41,410 --> 00:00:44,630
Stu:
episode in our what feels

13
00:00:44,630 --> 00:00:47,730
Stu:
like mammoth undertaking for the the year our series

14
00:00:47,730 --> 00:00:50,670
Stu:
on talking directly to the audience we've been

15
00:00:50,670 --> 00:00:53,490
Stu:
focusing on characters speaking to

16
00:00:53,490 --> 00:00:56,190
Stu:
the audience and for this episode to finish off we're getting

17
00:00:56,190 --> 00:01:01,070
Stu:
a little bit more meta and we're looking at films in which the filmmakers talk

18
00:01:01,070 --> 00:01:05,370
Stu:
to the audience so not only are characters breaking the fourth wall but it's

19
00:01:05,370 --> 00:01:09,830
Stu:
actually the writer stepping through and breaking the fourth wall and in the

20
00:01:09,830 --> 00:01:13,570
Stu:
case in one of the films the 40 year old version the character literally breaks

21
00:01:13,570 --> 00:01:16,010
Stu:
the fourth wall in a play to talk directly to the audience.

22
00:01:16,190 --> 00:01:19,290
Stu:
And so the films we are looking at are Adaptation.

23
00:01:19,530 --> 00:01:20,390
Chas:
Stories We Tell.

24
00:01:20,630 --> 00:01:22,270
Mel:
And the 40-year-old version.

25
00:01:22,590 --> 00:01:26,350
Stu:
And all of them, to one degree or another, that we're going to explore,

26
00:01:26,690 --> 00:01:28,930
Stu:
play with communicating directly to the audience.

27
00:01:29,190 --> 00:01:32,950
Stu:
And I think I will say up front that, I mean, it's interesting because it is

28
00:01:32,950 --> 00:01:37,950
Stu:
a spectrum, but you are more or less clear by the end of the film that the filmmakers

29
00:01:37,950 --> 00:01:40,210
Stu:
have been talking to you directly.

30
00:01:40,210 --> 00:01:45,530
Stu:
And I do think it's also worth saying that all these three films are also all autobiographical.

31
00:01:45,870 --> 00:01:50,710
Chas:
So, what we've tackled so far, we've discussed examples where the filmmakers

32
00:01:50,710 --> 00:01:52,430
Chas:
are talking directly to the audience.

33
00:01:52,530 --> 00:01:57,750
Chas:
Fight Club, in particular, that scene where Jack is raving about IKEA furniture.

34
00:01:58,270 --> 00:02:01,350
Stu:
Oh, and then there's the overlaying graphics of the catalogue.

35
00:02:01,370 --> 00:02:03,490
Stu:
So, there's a fourth wall breaking of the text.

36
00:02:03,610 --> 00:02:06,870
Stu:
But I don't know if that's David Fincher speaking to the audience, right? Right.

37
00:02:06,890 --> 00:02:10,410
Stu:
But it's definitely in the playing around with the fact that we're not just,

38
00:02:10,470 --> 00:02:14,270
Stu:
it's not trying to pretend that the camera is invisible and that we are just observing.

39
00:02:14,570 --> 00:02:18,410
Stu:
Right. But I guess there is, what we're talking about is an awareness of the

40
00:02:18,410 --> 00:02:22,310
Stu:
camera and of the edit and of sound and of the artifice of the film production

41
00:02:22,310 --> 00:02:23,790
Stu:
is in actually all three films.

42
00:02:24,030 --> 00:02:27,750
Chas:
Yes, definitely. And I was just going to say in Pain and Gain,

43
00:02:27,790 --> 00:02:32,070
Chas:
which we did for voiceover, we definitely identified that those title cards were,

44
00:02:32,700 --> 00:02:37,680
Chas:
this is still a true story is definitely not from the characters that's not

45
00:02:37,680 --> 00:02:42,080
Chas:
them being aware that they're in a movie and using a title card to communicate

46
00:02:42,080 --> 00:02:47,220
Chas:
to the audience that is the filmmakers saying you know like drawing attention

47
00:02:47,220 --> 00:02:49,900
Chas:
i guess somewhat to themselves providing.

48
00:02:49,900 --> 00:02:52,460
Stu:
Commentary they're commenting on their own film.

49
00:02:52,460 --> 00:02:55,220
Chas:
Yeah i mean one of the big takeaways i've taken from this whole

50
00:02:55,220 --> 00:02:58,120
Chas:
series is i always used to think like you are sensibly sue

51
00:02:58,120 --> 00:03:00,880
Chas:
in the last episode on breaking the

52
00:03:00,880 --> 00:03:03,680
Chas:
fourth wall if we loved it so much when in

53
00:03:03,680 --> 00:03:06,600
Chas:
those three amazing examples that we looked at why don't we do

54
00:03:06,600 --> 00:03:12,640
Chas:
it more often and i think breaking the fourth wall all of these techniques do

55
00:03:12,640 --> 00:03:18,880
Chas:
in some ways uh further distance the audience and i use distance i guess in

56
00:03:18,880 --> 00:03:24,460
Chas:
a wanky artistic brechtian theater point of view but what i mean is just remind

57
00:03:24,460 --> 00:03:26,400
Chas:
us that we're watching a piece of screened entertainment.

58
00:03:26,620 --> 00:03:30,400
Chas:
We can't get, I was going to say that we can't get as lost.

59
00:03:30,620 --> 00:03:33,860
Chas:
And I thought that that distancing would always push us further away.

60
00:03:33,980 --> 00:03:37,860
Chas:
But in Breaking the Fourth Wall, it created more intimacy and created a different

61
00:03:37,860 --> 00:03:42,200
Chas:
relationship between us as the viewer and the characters.

62
00:03:42,900 --> 00:03:46,940
Chas:
And in each of these three films, it's not just the filmmakers talking directly

63
00:03:46,940 --> 00:03:49,220
Chas:
to us. You know, the characters have voiceover.

64
00:03:49,340 --> 00:03:54,860
Stu:
The characters- Speak to the camera. They barrel the camera in all, almost all three films.

65
00:03:55,120 --> 00:03:59,720
Chas:
Yeah. So, these basically still use all the things that we've looked at before

66
00:03:59,720 --> 00:04:06,580
Chas:
from using the characters, but what they do is I guess they take that extra step further and,

67
00:04:07,620 --> 00:04:12,160
Chas:
I'm interested in asking you guys, do you think there's any way that the filmmakers

68
00:04:12,160 --> 00:04:17,580
Chas:
can talk to the audience directly without drawing the audience's attention to

69
00:04:17,580 --> 00:04:20,040
Chas:
the fact that they're watching film or TV?

70
00:04:20,040 --> 00:04:26,240
Mel:
I think that I think that the 40 year old version actually does a couple more

71
00:04:26,240 --> 00:04:32,800
Mel:
subtle things in terms of that, which work on one level as something within the text.

72
00:04:32,880 --> 00:04:39,400
Mel:
And then also, you may or may not realize at the time that it is the filmmaker

73
00:04:39,400 --> 00:04:42,720
Mel:
speaking directly to you. I think if you notice that it's the filmmaker,

74
00:04:42,880 --> 00:04:43,880
Mel:
it might pull you out of it.

75
00:04:43,940 --> 00:04:49,400
Mel:
But there are more subtle things in that film that I don't think necessarily.

76
00:04:49,540 --> 00:04:53,660
Mel:
In fact, the first time I watched it, I don't think really, I did not bump on

77
00:04:53,660 --> 00:04:55,180
Mel:
as many of them for sure. Sure.

78
00:04:55,880 --> 00:05:03,780
Mel:
Most of those are audio cues or like very subtle jokes or uses of color or things

79
00:05:03,780 --> 00:05:05,220
Mel:
like that, which we'll get into.

80
00:05:05,380 --> 00:05:11,660
Mel:
But I think for the most part, you're going to notice partly because it's unusual in the form.

81
00:05:12,120 --> 00:05:17,080
Stu:
I'm going to bounce off that and say, I think it's kind of context dependent

82
00:05:17,080 --> 00:05:20,140
Stu:
because I think what you're talking about is there is a difference between something

83
00:05:20,140 --> 00:05:22,480
Stu:
where we know that the characters know that they're in a film.

84
00:05:22,560 --> 00:05:24,600
Stu:
I mean, that's true of most documentaries, right?

85
00:05:24,780 --> 00:05:28,280
Stu:
Yeah. They know that they're in there and they're acknowledging it.

86
00:05:28,400 --> 00:05:32,740
Stu:
Right. And the question I think is, is the film itself making a commentary on

87
00:05:32,740 --> 00:05:36,980
Stu:
the nature of cinema itself in a broad sense, like adaptation?

88
00:05:36,980 --> 00:05:40,600
Stu:
Or is it actually something that's just a little bit more self-aware?

89
00:05:41,200 --> 00:05:44,820
Stu:
I mean, stories we tell has to be self-aware because it's literally a documentary

90
00:05:44,820 --> 00:05:46,660
Stu:
and everyone knows they're participating in the documentary.

91
00:05:46,820 --> 00:05:49,360
Stu:
So the characters are aware of what's going on.

92
00:05:49,520 --> 00:05:53,500
Stu:
Whereas I think the 40-year-old version, when we get to it, is...

93
00:05:54,220 --> 00:05:58,320
Stu:
On the other end where, like, as much as it's a film about someone creating

94
00:05:58,320 --> 00:06:01,840
Stu:
art, it's not about someone making the film that you're watching, right?

95
00:06:01,960 --> 00:06:04,620
Stu:
It's not kind of that kind of convolutedly meta.

96
00:06:04,780 --> 00:06:07,480
Stu:
And I think there is a difference between all those three things.

97
00:06:07,620 --> 00:06:12,580
Stu:
So, I think you can have something that is very quite formally complex that

98
00:06:12,580 --> 00:06:13,840
Stu:
is speaking directly to the audience.

99
00:06:13,980 --> 00:06:19,960
Stu:
I would guess that some of the most watched content in the world has people

100
00:06:19,960 --> 00:06:22,800
Stu:
talking directly to the camera and that's stuff that people watch on YouTube.

101
00:06:22,800 --> 00:06:26,140
Stu:
And I think the filmmaking that we are seeing on YouTube

102
00:06:26,140 --> 00:06:28,860
Stu:
and obviously because I'm doing more YouTube stuff I'm now watching it

103
00:06:28,860 --> 00:06:31,500
Stu:
but there's just a lot more people that are now watching stuff where people

104
00:06:31,500 --> 00:06:35,140
Stu:
are talking directly to the camera presenting and it's really quite multifaceted

105
00:06:35,140 --> 00:06:40,640
Stu:
and complex in the kind of the way it's using the form a little bit more postmodern

106
00:06:40,640 --> 00:06:45,420
Stu:
or hypermodern and I think we're going to start seeing that infect mainstream

107
00:06:45,420 --> 00:06:46,880
Stu:
storytelling because it has to.

108
00:06:47,020 --> 00:06:53,080
Mel:
I think your thesis is right but I think your example Sample might be superseded by TikTok.

109
00:06:53,980 --> 00:06:54,420
Chas:
Sure.

110
00:06:55,020 --> 00:06:58,540
Stu:
Effectively, they're the same thing. I don't think they're, I mean, the platform, yes.

111
00:06:58,740 --> 00:07:01,460
Stu:
If you're saying that the platform specifically, I mean, you know.

112
00:07:01,520 --> 00:07:05,400
Stu:
But then again, I mean, someone complained that Oppenheimer was a movie for TikTok brain.

113
00:07:05,500 --> 00:07:09,160
Stu:
That was the latest main person on Twitter. And it was just like, what?

114
00:07:09,300 --> 00:07:14,500
Stu:
It was like, this is edited so fast. It's for the TikTok audience. And it's just like, wow.

115
00:07:15,060 --> 00:07:19,800
Chas:
Sorry, just identifying. Look, it feels like we're actually really wanting to get into the,

116
00:07:20,410 --> 00:07:25,570
Chas:
meat and examples of that we've done here so that we can talk less abstractly.

117
00:07:25,630 --> 00:07:30,110
Chas:
But I think it might be useful to restate the levers, the craft tools that we've

118
00:07:30,110 --> 00:07:31,910
Chas:
identified in this series so far,

119
00:07:31,970 --> 00:07:37,490
Chas:
because I think it will probably help us identify what these films might be

120
00:07:37,490 --> 00:07:41,610
Chas:
doing differently and how the filmmakers might be drawing more or less attention

121
00:07:41,610 --> 00:07:43,350
Chas:
to themselves and to what effect.

122
00:07:43,570 --> 00:07:48,290
Chas:
So, the levers that we identified and they've grown as we've done this series.

123
00:07:48,290 --> 00:07:51,150
Stu:
And I've got one more to add. Okay.

124
00:07:51,410 --> 00:07:56,870
Chas:
So, we've got diegetic to non-diegetic. How in-story world to outside the story

125
00:07:56,870 --> 00:07:57,830
Chas:
world is the communication.

126
00:07:58,170 --> 00:08:01,690
Chas:
And I think that will be an interesting one here, because I think that's actually

127
00:08:01,690 --> 00:08:06,190
Chas:
what makes these films feel different is how in-story world or out-of-story

128
00:08:06,190 --> 00:08:09,430
Chas:
world the filmmaker communication direct to the audience is.

129
00:08:09,870 --> 00:08:13,770
Chas:
Who is talking, ranging from storytellers to characters?

130
00:08:14,270 --> 00:08:17,870
Chas:
Whom are they talking to, themselves or directly to the audience?

131
00:08:17,870 --> 00:08:23,050
Chas:
And I think certainly stories we tell really plays with that.

132
00:08:23,850 --> 00:08:28,330
Chas:
From when in time is the communication coming? That was a particularly relevant one to voiceover.

133
00:08:28,890 --> 00:08:32,530
Stu:
In contrast to barrelling to the camera, which we talked about this idea that

134
00:08:32,530 --> 00:08:34,450
Stu:
it was super emotionally present.

135
00:08:34,710 --> 00:08:37,990
Stu:
So, you know, he was putting us in the immediate feeling of the character.

136
00:08:38,190 --> 00:08:38,610
Chas:
Yes.

137
00:08:38,730 --> 00:08:40,690
Stu:
You know, where voiceover can be more reflective.

138
00:08:41,910 --> 00:08:44,690
Chas:
What does the communication want from the audience? And I think that's going

139
00:08:44,690 --> 00:08:46,350
Chas:
to obviously be an important question here. year.

140
00:08:46,550 --> 00:08:51,650
Chas:
And as you guys identified in Fight Club, and we delved into more when we did

141
00:08:51,650 --> 00:08:54,730
Chas:
Breaking the Fourth Wall, how much control does the communicator,

142
00:08:54,830 --> 00:08:58,430
Chas:
and in this instance, the filmmakers, have over the narrative?

143
00:08:59,000 --> 00:09:04,620
Stu:
So, I'm going to build a subset of that because I think what's interesting is

144
00:09:04,620 --> 00:09:08,260
Stu:
that we're doing one film, Stories We Tell Being a Documentary has a whole bunch

145
00:09:08,260 --> 00:09:11,280
Stu:
of people that are interviewed, but they don't have control over the communication.

146
00:09:11,520 --> 00:09:14,020
Stu:
That's Sarah Polley, and we know that. So, they're telling her story,

147
00:09:14,140 --> 00:09:17,960
Stu:
right? But they're aware that they're talking to an audience.

148
00:09:18,100 --> 00:09:21,700
Stu:
So, I'm just going to finish. I would say the other lever is how aware are the

149
00:09:21,700 --> 00:09:26,760
Stu:
supporting characters of the fact that they're in a quote-unquote in a film

150
00:09:26,760 --> 00:09:31,680
Stu:
that they're talking to the audience? because I think that is a spectrum as well. Go on.

151
00:09:31,820 --> 00:09:36,800
Chas:
Because I think what we'll find in 40-year-old version is there's moments when

152
00:09:36,800 --> 00:09:39,920
Chas:
Radha, the character, is talking to us and moments when Radha,

153
00:09:39,940 --> 00:09:46,320
Chas:
the filmmaker, is talking to us and whether the other characters are aware of that or not.

154
00:09:46,540 --> 00:09:50,600
Mel:
I think what makes stories we tell such an interesting one to talk about control

155
00:09:50,600 --> 00:09:53,820
Mel:
is, yes, Sarah Polly is doing the documentary. Yes, she's the director.

156
00:09:54,000 --> 00:09:58,040
Mel:
Yes, she's in control. However, the documentary ends up being about herself,

157
00:09:58,160 --> 00:10:02,540
Mel:
and some of the people within the story have more information about her than

158
00:10:02,540 --> 00:10:07,520
Mel:
she does, in which case there are a couple of scenes in which it feels she has ceded control.

159
00:10:07,700 --> 00:10:10,680
Mel:
Now, again, obviously, because she's in control of the edit and things like

160
00:10:10,680 --> 00:10:12,960
Mel:
that, she's still showing us that, right?

161
00:10:13,460 --> 00:10:19,520
Mel:
She's still making the choice in post and in the construction of it to what

162
00:10:19,520 --> 00:10:21,860
Mel:
to show, what not to, in what order, and how.

163
00:10:21,860 --> 00:10:24,520
Mel:
But it's really fascinating because in a lot of documentaries,

164
00:10:24,800 --> 00:10:27,960
Mel:
obviously, you become personally invested in some way, but that doesn't mean

165
00:10:27,960 --> 00:10:30,700
Mel:
it's about you, whereas this literally is.

166
00:10:30,920 --> 00:10:35,060
Mel:
And so it's fascinating that at certain points, there are characters who have

167
00:10:35,060 --> 00:10:40,580
Mel:
more understanding and more pieces of the puzzle than she does in the immediacy

168
00:10:40,580 --> 00:10:43,460
Mel:
of the scene as she's filming it and talking to them. Hmm.

169
00:10:43,940 --> 00:10:45,740
Chas:
I really want to dive into that,

170
00:10:45,780 --> 00:10:49,220
Chas:
but that is not the order in which we've chosen to attack these films.

171
00:10:49,380 --> 00:10:55,780
Chas:
So I'm going to squash all my thoughts down and hopefully they resurface later on in the podcast.

172
00:10:56,180 --> 00:10:58,600
Stu:
Let's just see how constipated your brain's going to be.

173
00:11:00,840 --> 00:11:08,200
Chas:
So we are going to start with Adaptation written by Charlie Kaufman and directed by Spike Jonze.

174
00:11:10,500 --> 00:11:16,300
Excerpts:
She hates me she's disappointed i could see it in her eyes when we met i've got to stop sweating,

175
00:11:17,120 --> 00:11:21,620
Excerpts:
oh she looked at my hairline she thinks i'm bald she's thinking i would never

176
00:11:21,620 --> 00:11:27,820
Excerpts:
in a million years sleep with this guy we think you're great oh thanks wow that's that's nice to hear,

177
00:11:52,090 --> 00:11:55,110
Excerpts:
like you I'm putting

178
00:11:55,110 --> 00:11:58,130
Excerpts:
in a chase sequence so the killer flees on horseback

179
00:11:58,130 --> 00:12:01,250
Excerpts:
cops after them on a motorcycle and it's like a battle between motors

180
00:12:01,250 --> 00:12:04,450
Excerpts:
and horses like technology versus horse

181
00:12:04,450 --> 00:12:10,630
Excerpts:
Susan we would really like to option this you want to make it into a movie I

182
00:12:10,630 --> 00:12:16,690
Excerpts:
want to know what it feels like to care about something passionately John LaRoche

183
00:12:16,690 --> 00:12:23,270
Excerpts:
is a tall guy sharply handsome the book has no story There's no story. Make one up.

184
00:12:23,410 --> 00:12:25,930
Excerpts:
Okay, we open with LaRoche. No, we open at the beginning of time.

185
00:12:26,050 --> 00:12:31,130
Excerpts:
Okay, we open with LaRoche. Crazy white man. We open our Charlie Kaufman. Fat, bald, ugly. Paces.

186
00:12:33,970 --> 00:12:37,310
Excerpts:
I've ripped myself into my screenplay. That's kind of weird, huh?

187
00:12:38,050 --> 00:12:45,450
Chas:
All right. So, Adaptation was the follow-up to the previous Spike Jonze-Charlie

188
00:12:45,450 --> 00:12:48,470
Chas:
Kaufman collaboration, which was being John Malkovich.

189
00:12:48,470 --> 00:12:52,750
Chas:
And it's important to reference that because that is a kind of important character

190
00:12:52,750 --> 00:12:55,010
Chas:
plot point that is referenced.

191
00:12:55,310 --> 00:12:56,110
Mel:
Right off the bat.

192
00:12:56,270 --> 00:13:04,050
Chas:
Yeah, throughout the film. And it follows Charlie as he struggles to adapt an

193
00:13:04,050 --> 00:13:09,410
Chas:
unadaptable novel called The Orchid Thief by Susan Orleans. Orlan? Orleans?

194
00:13:09,610 --> 00:13:10,830
Stu:
Isn't it The Orchard Thief?

195
00:13:12,110 --> 00:13:13,570
Chas:
Especially at the Denouement.

196
00:13:13,910 --> 00:13:18,210
Stu:
Hey, he says it like me. At least he says it like me.

197
00:13:18,650 --> 00:13:22,290
Excerpts:
Cool, I really like Trestakil. Until the third act of Newyament.

198
00:13:22,930 --> 00:13:23,750
Excerpts:
That's not how it's pronounced.

199
00:13:24,370 --> 00:13:30,010
Chas:
And the other, I guess, main element to this is the relationship between Charlie

200
00:13:30,010 --> 00:13:35,970
Chas:
and his entirely fictional twin brother, Donald, to whom the film is dedicated.

201
00:13:36,410 --> 00:13:38,910
Stu:
How's that for a summary, Mel? Does it pass your approval?

202
00:13:39,430 --> 00:13:40,690
Mel:
I shall allow it.

203
00:13:41,170 --> 00:13:44,750
Stu:
Oh, I have to say, I have to say that I'm going to embarrass everyone involved.

204
00:13:44,930 --> 00:13:49,450
Stu:
I watched this film with my parents and my nephew and his girlfriend,

205
00:13:49,570 --> 00:13:50,690
Stu:
and they were second screening.

206
00:13:50,970 --> 00:13:54,030
Stu:
They're like not even 20. Anyway, they're 19. They're second screening the whole

207
00:13:54,030 --> 00:13:54,930
Stu:
way, but, you know, whatever.

208
00:13:55,450 --> 00:14:00,530
Stu:
But I forgot how much masturbation was in this film. So much masturbation.

209
00:14:00,530 --> 00:14:06,350
Mel:
Did you tell them that masturbating is a very important part of writing? Because it is.

210
00:14:08,010 --> 00:14:09,770
Stu:
That's just the words I put on the page, Mel.

211
00:14:11,210 --> 00:14:16,830
Chas:
So, I'm actually, I'm interested in getting your guys' take as to broadly how

212
00:14:16,830 --> 00:14:20,170
Chas:
the filmmakers, and I think we're mostly, when we're talking about filmmakers,

213
00:14:20,170 --> 00:14:22,730
Chas:
is going to be talking about Charlie Kaufman as the writer.

214
00:14:23,230 --> 00:14:23,650
Stu:
Are we?

215
00:14:24,370 --> 00:14:28,370
Chas:
Communicating, well, okay. How are the filmmakers communicating directly to us?

216
00:14:28,450 --> 00:14:37,450
Chas:
Because I remembered this film being even more kind of revolutionary in its metaness than,

217
00:14:37,530 --> 00:14:42,450
Chas:
I guess, you know, we've moved on 20 years of storytelling and it didn't feel

218
00:14:42,450 --> 00:14:44,270
Chas:
quite so confrontational on this.

219
00:14:44,350 --> 00:14:48,010
Chas:
I think it's my third watching of the film as it did originally when I watched it.

220
00:14:48,010 --> 00:14:51,050
Stu:
I mean, you've done a Robert McKee seminar, haven't you, Chas?

221
00:14:51,070 --> 00:14:55,330
Chas:
Yes, I have. I was watching it with Anna and I'm like, I've done this seminar.

222
00:14:55,530 --> 00:14:59,730
Chas:
And Anna was like, did he yell at you like he does in the movies?

223
00:14:59,790 --> 00:15:01,390
Chas:
I'm like, no, he was not like that at all.

224
00:15:03,680 --> 00:15:07,320
Stu:
The filmmakers thing, I think, is interesting, and it's kind of sad,

225
00:15:07,480 --> 00:15:10,040
Stu:
maybe, that we're doing this first, but there's a reason, because it's probably

226
00:15:10,040 --> 00:15:13,540
Stu:
the one film that most screenwriters have watched, you know,

227
00:15:13,600 --> 00:15:15,700
Stu:
because it's about screenwriting.

228
00:15:15,800 --> 00:15:19,560
Stu:
It's that, oh, it's a film about screenwriting that actually managed to pull it off.

229
00:15:20,500 --> 00:15:25,820
Stu:
I think there is a tension between Charlie Kaufman writing the story and Spike

230
00:15:25,820 --> 00:15:28,060
Stu:
Jonze telling the story, right?

231
00:15:28,140 --> 00:15:31,580
Stu:
We were talking about in our pre-chat that if Charlie Kaufman himself directed

232
00:15:31,580 --> 00:15:33,320
Stu:
this film, it would be a lot more depressing.

233
00:15:33,680 --> 00:15:38,680
Stu:
And I think it's to do with when in time is the communication is happening because

234
00:15:38,680 --> 00:15:43,640
Stu:
you've got a duality of Charlie Kaufman as he writes the story and then Spike

235
00:15:43,640 --> 00:15:49,500
Stu:
Jonze telling the story from a future where he knows that Charlie Kaufman wrote a great script.

236
00:15:49,720 --> 00:15:56,140
Stu:
And so as much as the character is depressed about his inability to adapt this

237
00:15:56,140 --> 00:15:59,600
Stu:
novel, the filmmaker making it knows he succeeded.

238
00:15:59,880 --> 00:16:04,200
Stu:
And so there's a wistfulness to it. So it isn't depressing because he knows

239
00:16:04,200 --> 00:16:07,560
Stu:
there's a way out, whereas I think sometimes depression, part of what makes

240
00:16:07,560 --> 00:16:10,220
Stu:
depression depression is that you don't feel like there's any escape.

241
00:16:10,600 --> 00:16:12,260
Stu:
It's an absolute despair.

242
00:16:13,120 --> 00:16:16,360
Stu:
So I think there is an interesting tension there that it could be the choice

243
00:16:16,360 --> 00:16:18,280
Stu:
of colour palette, could be the choice of music.

244
00:16:18,460 --> 00:16:23,480
Stu:
There's just a sense of play that I think comes from Spike Jonze.

245
00:16:23,480 --> 00:16:26,840
Stu:
I think the Charlie Kaufman version of the third act, when it becomes the thriller,

246
00:16:27,000 --> 00:16:34,000
Stu:
would have possibly been less fun and more that I am not going to enjoy having

247
00:16:34,000 --> 00:16:35,200
Stu:
to do the trope. I don't know.

248
00:16:35,280 --> 00:16:38,580
Stu:
I haven't- I actually did- we could have read the adaptation script, but we did not.

249
00:16:38,840 --> 00:16:45,120
Chas:
So, like, I guess the metaness comes from he has chosen, instead of it to adapt

250
00:16:45,120 --> 00:16:50,180
Chas:
the novel, he has chosen to write about his struggle in adapting the novel.

251
00:16:50,180 --> 00:16:59,280
Chas:
And the the moments when i really became aware of the filmmaking i guess where

252
00:16:59,280 --> 00:17:03,860
Chas:
the meta structure of it because at no point is there uh breaking the fourth

253
00:17:03,860 --> 00:17:10,040
Chas:
wall in this and there's a few title cards but not a lot mostly just to tell you.

254
00:17:10,040 --> 00:17:11,240
Mel:
When and where you are.

255
00:17:11,240 --> 00:17:15,180
Stu:
So no breaking the fourth wall in terms of charlie looking at the camera and

256
00:17:15,180 --> 00:17:16,620
Stu:
directly addressing the camera.

257
00:17:16,620 --> 00:17:17,800
Chas:
Yeah so largely Actually.

258
00:17:17,840 --> 00:17:21,340
Stu:
The communication is diegetic. That's what we're saying. Even the quote-unquote

259
00:17:21,340 --> 00:17:25,560
Stu:
voiceover is either him thinking in his head, so it's not him talking to us,

260
00:17:25,600 --> 00:17:28,080
Stu:
or him talking into a voice recorder.

261
00:17:31,790 --> 00:17:34,650
Excerpts:
Okay, we open with LaRoche. He's funny. Okay, he says, okay,

262
00:17:34,690 --> 00:17:37,050
Excerpts:
he says, I love to mutate plants. He says, mutation is fun.

263
00:17:37,290 --> 00:17:39,950
Excerpts:
Okay, we show flowers and, okay, we have to have the court case.

264
00:17:40,110 --> 00:17:43,730
Excerpts:
Okay, we show LaRoche. Okay, he says, I was mutated as a baby. That's why I'm so smart.

265
00:17:44,110 --> 00:17:46,850
Excerpts:
That's funny. Okay, we open at the beginning of time. No, okay,

266
00:17:46,910 --> 00:17:49,570
Excerpts:
we open with LaRoche driving into the swamp. Crazy white man.

267
00:17:51,570 --> 00:17:56,730
Chas:
Yeah, and at no point do we see the actual Charlie Kaufman. It's not like Martin

268
00:17:56,730 --> 00:17:58,410
Chas:
Scorsese at the end of Killers of the Flower Moon.

269
00:17:58,410 --> 00:18:01,570
Stu:
Or in the other film that we talked about doing for this, which we mentioned

270
00:18:01,570 --> 00:18:04,790
Stu:
right at the beginning, American Splendor, where it moves between the real Harvey

271
00:18:04,790 --> 00:18:07,190
Stu:
Beaker and an actor playing him.

272
00:18:07,250 --> 00:18:10,970
Stu:
And we kind of see that a little bit in stories we tell where it uses reenactors

273
00:18:10,970 --> 00:18:13,730
Stu:
and the real people interchangeably. Yeah.

274
00:18:13,950 --> 00:18:18,990
Chas:
So, I think the reason why I was surprised at this on this viewing is how,

275
00:18:19,170 --> 00:18:22,090
Chas:
I guess, diegetic all the communication is.

276
00:18:22,230 --> 00:18:25,590
Chas:
Like, it feels like it's within a story world.

277
00:18:25,890 --> 00:18:30,270
Chas:
It feels like, like Nicolas Cage never tells us he's Nicolas Cage.

278
00:18:30,530 --> 00:18:34,850
Chas:
It's not in that way drawing our attention to the fact that it's a movie.

279
00:18:34,910 --> 00:18:38,650
Chas:
It's all happening to this character of Charlie Kaufman.

280
00:18:38,650 --> 00:18:41,710
Chas:
And the i and

281
00:18:41,710 --> 00:18:44,910
Chas:
so i guess it's structure is the main way of doing it i mean what i

282
00:18:44,910 --> 00:18:51,350
Chas:
really loved is the film has about three or four different opening scenes and

283
00:18:51,350 --> 00:18:55,870
Chas:
as he goes through his relative crises where he's trying to figure out the story

284
00:18:55,870 --> 00:18:59,770
Chas:
it's like he's throwing out the whole story and starting again but then you

285
00:18:59,770 --> 00:19:03,730
Chas:
realize that the new way in for him the new way of him

286
00:19:03,810 --> 00:19:06,630
Chas:
tackling the story is something that he has already done

287
00:19:06,630 --> 00:19:09,950
Chas:
in the opening of the film so it's kind

288
00:19:09,950 --> 00:19:13,190
Chas:
of teaching us how the the story got

289
00:19:13,190 --> 00:19:16,430
Chas:
crafted as he went through it so he might like

290
00:19:16,430 --> 00:19:20,590
Chas:
just to give you i guess some of the summaries is he's having a meeting with

291
00:19:20,590 --> 00:19:24,270
Chas:
the production company till the swing the executive who owns the rights to the

292
00:19:24,270 --> 00:19:28,450
Chas:
book and it cuts away like he's thinking about flowers and it cuts away to this

293
00:19:28,450 --> 00:19:31,990
Chas:
beautiful it's completely prompted by his voiceover and his thoughts,

294
00:19:32,130 --> 00:19:33,690
Chas:
this time lapse of evolution.

295
00:19:34,710 --> 00:19:38,270
Excerpts:
I've been on this planet for 40 years, and I'm no closer to understanding a

296
00:19:38,270 --> 00:19:42,050
Excerpts:
single thing. Why am I here? How did I get here?

297
00:19:43,090 --> 00:19:46,730
Chas:
And then, you know, several scenes down the track when he's trying to figure

298
00:19:46,730 --> 00:19:48,490
Chas:
it out, he's going, this is how it's about flowers.

299
00:19:48,570 --> 00:19:51,930
Chas:
We'll have a time lapse about everything from evolution, you know,

300
00:19:51,930 --> 00:19:55,850
Chas:
and he'll go, oh, it's LaRoche's story or it's Susan's story.

301
00:19:55,910 --> 00:20:00,150
Chas:
And he'll say, this is our way in, having already shown us that he's given us

302
00:20:00,150 --> 00:20:05,490
Chas:
that way in already. And those were the main moments where I was going,

303
00:20:05,630 --> 00:20:08,710
Chas:
oh, I'm suddenly reminded that this is a film.

304
00:20:08,930 --> 00:20:14,250
Chas:
And I wouldn't have felt quite as struck by those moments if they hadn't already done it.

305
00:20:14,350 --> 00:20:17,750
Chas:
Like if he was genuinely going, oh, this is the new way in.

306
00:20:17,830 --> 00:20:20,990
Chas:
And he just like completely does something new that we haven't already seen,

307
00:20:21,090 --> 00:20:24,510
Chas:
as opposed to referencing something that has already happened in the past and

308
00:20:24,510 --> 00:20:29,170
Chas:
recontextualizing as to why it was in there and in that order and why it was in that moment.

309
00:20:30,070 --> 00:20:34,350
Stu:
It's interesting. I was going to say that this film, unlike the others,

310
00:20:34,450 --> 00:20:39,230
Stu:
has no real people in it because both the other films use some of the real people. But that is not true.

311
00:20:39,910 --> 00:20:44,070
Stu:
Catherine Keener, it's in the film playing herself because she was in Being John Malkovich.

312
00:20:44,410 --> 00:20:47,590
Chas:
John Cusack and John Malkovich are both in there.

313
00:20:47,710 --> 00:20:51,170
Stu:
Yeah, we see Lance Accord, the cinematographer who shot Being John Malkovich

314
00:20:51,170 --> 00:20:55,570
Stu:
and shot Adaptation. I don't think we even see Spike Jonze in it, right?

315
00:20:55,610 --> 00:20:59,930
Stu:
But it's interesting there. The only real people are connected to being John

316
00:20:59,930 --> 00:21:03,430
Stu:
Malkovich, which is, we go to the set of them shooting the film.

317
00:21:03,610 --> 00:21:08,250
Stu:
What is interesting, coming back to my nephew, who was not born when this film came out, right?

318
00:21:08,510 --> 00:21:11,910
Stu:
And that's important, because he had this thing of like, hang on,

319
00:21:11,990 --> 00:21:14,170
Stu:
did any of this, is this real?

320
00:21:14,410 --> 00:21:17,190
Stu:
Did this actually happen? Like, he wasn't sure.

321
00:21:17,270 --> 00:21:21,010
Stu:
There was nothing in the filmmaking that was telling him that it was partially

322
00:21:21,010 --> 00:21:24,050
Stu:
documentary-esque, right?

323
00:21:24,050 --> 00:21:29,130
Stu:
That it was like a docodrama or whatever kind of terminology on that spectrum

324
00:21:29,130 --> 00:21:34,710
Stu:
in a way that I think stories we tell is very clear that it's documentary-esque.

325
00:21:34,910 --> 00:21:39,550
Stu:
And that's a choice that the filmmakers have made, whether it's Charlie or Spike Jonze.

326
00:21:39,750 --> 00:21:43,050
Mel:
I think the opening scene, if you're coming into this completely cold,

327
00:21:43,270 --> 00:21:46,090
Mel:
where they're on the set of being John Malkovich, you're like,

328
00:21:46,170 --> 00:21:47,510
Mel:
oh, is this actually behind the scenes footage?

329
00:21:47,650 --> 00:21:50,510
Mel:
And then Nicolas Cage comes in and they call him Charlie Kaufman.

330
00:21:50,570 --> 00:21:54,830
Mel:
They make that very clear very quickly. But if you're, I do think that like

331
00:21:54,830 --> 00:21:58,290
Mel:
within the first five minutes, they play with that and then they move on from it.

332
00:21:58,410 --> 00:21:58,630
Stu:
Yeah.

333
00:21:58,690 --> 00:22:03,630
Chas:
Yes. But to Stu's point, nothing in the story as presented to us in the movie

334
00:22:03,630 --> 00:22:07,490
Chas:
tells us when reality stops. Right.

335
00:22:07,570 --> 00:22:10,110
Stu:
I do think there is a shift when it becomes the thriller.

336
00:22:10,210 --> 00:22:10,990
Chas:
Yes. Right.

337
00:22:11,090 --> 00:22:14,630
Stu:
That it becomes more heightened. So in the third act after Robert McKee says,

338
00:22:14,710 --> 00:22:17,090
Stu:
you just need to make something up and wow them in the end.

339
00:22:18,510 --> 00:22:22,870
Excerpts:
Wow them in the end. You got to hit. You can have flaws, problems,

340
00:22:23,050 --> 00:22:26,550
Excerpts:
but wow them in the end, and you've got a hit.

341
00:22:28,380 --> 00:22:34,800
Excerpts:
Find an ending, but don't cheat. And don't you dare bring in a deus ex machina.

342
00:22:35,180 --> 00:22:36,420
Mel:
Gotta be a chase scene.

343
00:22:36,720 --> 00:22:40,340
Stu:
The film, just the way it's shot, kind of indicates this is made up.

344
00:22:40,420 --> 00:22:44,420
Stu:
And that, I think, is indicated to the audience that this is completely fictionalized.

345
00:22:44,580 --> 00:22:49,880
Stu:
Right. But I think previously to that, it is kind of like a historical reenactment.

346
00:22:49,960 --> 00:22:54,020
Stu:
It's just that the historical reenactment is about someone trying to write a

347
00:22:54,020 --> 00:22:57,820
Stu:
screenplay as opposed to this is the story of Shakespeare, or this is the story

348
00:22:57,820 --> 00:23:00,380
Stu:
of, You know, there's lots of biopics which are about creation.

349
00:23:00,620 --> 00:23:01,520
Stu:
I mean, you've written one.

350
00:23:01,560 --> 00:23:01,800
Chas:
Chaz.

351
00:23:01,980 --> 00:23:05,220
Stu:
It's just that this film is about the creation of itself.

352
00:23:06,220 --> 00:23:06,620
Chas:
Yes.

353
00:23:07,040 --> 00:23:08,060
Mel:
It's an Ouroboros.

354
00:23:08,500 --> 00:23:11,300
Chas:
Yes. Two nice callbacks at a Romel. Well done.

355
00:23:12,360 --> 00:23:15,380
Excerpts:
Caroline has this great tattoo of a snake swallowing its own tail.

356
00:23:15,880 --> 00:23:18,000
Excerpts:
Ouroboros. I don't know what that means.

357
00:23:18,720 --> 00:23:22,060
Excerpts:
A snake. It's called Ouroboros. I don't think so.

358
00:23:22,200 --> 00:23:25,380
Excerpts:
But anyway, it's cool for my killer to have this modus operandi because at the

359
00:23:25,380 --> 00:23:27,580
Excerpts:
end, when When he forces the woman who's really him to eat herself,

360
00:23:27,780 --> 00:23:30,220
Excerpts:
he's also eating himself to death. I'm insane.

361
00:23:31,000 --> 00:23:36,080
Chas:
I would like, it's very clear that that's the point, like having seen it a few

362
00:23:36,080 --> 00:23:41,980
Chas:
times now, the point where it really departs reality is in that third act.

363
00:23:42,360 --> 00:23:46,740
Chas:
But I still think that anyone who's not read the book, which I have not,

364
00:23:46,760 --> 00:23:50,620
Chas:
and has not seen the film or is watching the film for the first time would really...

365
00:23:51,220 --> 00:23:55,660
Chas:
Struggle to know, did Charlie Kaufman really have a twin brother who died in

366
00:23:55,660 --> 00:24:00,300
Chas:
the trying to write of the story of adaptation where he was murdered by the

367
00:24:00,300 --> 00:24:04,900
Chas:
author of the book as played by Meryl Streep? And it sounds silly and delightful.

368
00:24:05,020 --> 00:24:11,500
Chas:
And I think, you know, the ending does somewhat emotionally save what's gone beforehand.

369
00:24:11,600 --> 00:24:15,500
Chas:
As much as I was kind of riveted throughout, I think the fact that you've got

370
00:24:15,500 --> 00:24:18,100
Chas:
Robert McKee telling him what to do.

371
00:24:18,360 --> 00:24:21,040
Mel:
Shut up. The first time I saw this movie, me, my friend Tim McKinney.

372
00:24:21,160 --> 00:24:26,360
Mel:
It was 2011 and he had heard that this was really good.

373
00:24:26,620 --> 00:24:30,300
Mel:
And we went to his place and sat down on the couch and watched it.

374
00:24:30,360 --> 00:24:33,920
Mel:
And neither of us really knew anything, had not seen Being John Malkovich,

375
00:24:34,100 --> 00:24:36,040
Mel:
did not know who Charlie Kaufman was, et cetera.

376
00:24:36,260 --> 00:24:38,840
Mel:
And our jaws were on the floor.

377
00:24:39,100 --> 00:24:43,840
Mel:
Also being an American, I completely bought all of the, like the alligator stuff.

378
00:24:43,900 --> 00:24:47,260
Mel:
Not only was it like Chekhov's alligator, cause you'd seen it and all,

379
00:24:47,260 --> 00:24:49,760
Mel:
But I'm like, oh yeah, that would absolutely happen.

380
00:24:50,060 --> 00:24:53,420
Mel:
There's no doubt in my mind, people tromping around getting eaten.

381
00:24:53,560 --> 00:24:59,000
Mel:
So in terms of how it read to me, it absolutely read as credible,

382
00:24:59,660 --> 00:25:03,080
Mel:
maybe slightly heightened, like biopics do write short-cutting things.

383
00:25:03,220 --> 00:25:05,440
Mel:
But I was like, this is absolutely batshit insane.

384
00:25:06,440 --> 00:25:09,540
Mel:
And coming back to it, every time I've come back to it since,

385
00:25:09,660 --> 00:25:12,560
Mel:
I still have that little bit of a thrill of an experience, which is quite fun.

386
00:25:13,260 --> 00:25:18,180
Chas:
On this watch, the only point where I recognized it tangibly leaving reality

387
00:25:18,180 --> 00:25:21,100
Chas:
is because they finished the book.

388
00:25:21,180 --> 00:25:21,640
Stu:
Right?

389
00:25:21,720 --> 00:25:26,580
Chas:
So, what you were talking about, Stu, in terms of the kind of felt like dramatizations

390
00:25:26,580 --> 00:25:32,060
Chas:
of what was in the book. And I presume that a lot of the Susan Meryl Streep

391
00:25:32,060 --> 00:25:34,680
Chas:
character's voiceover is directly from the book.

392
00:25:34,760 --> 00:25:39,480
Chas:
At least it felt that way, that like it was her observations of her experiences

393
00:25:39,480 --> 00:25:41,860
Chas:
as it felt like it would have been written in the book.

394
00:25:42,180 --> 00:25:46,000
Chas:
And they, you know, there are bits where Charlie and Donald are like reading

395
00:25:46,000 --> 00:25:49,700
Chas:
out bits of the book to us and talking about, is this the theme of the movie?

396
00:25:49,760 --> 00:25:51,200
Chas:
Is this what we're going to explore? law.

397
00:25:51,620 --> 00:25:57,500
Chas:
And it's when he can't find the ending in the book that they depart.

398
00:25:57,740 --> 00:26:03,380
Chas:
And, you know, Donald creates the spying on Susan. The thriller plot kicks off.

399
00:26:04,140 --> 00:26:09,120
Excerpts:
She's lying. What do you mean? What happened? Nothing. She said everything right.

400
00:26:10,820 --> 00:26:13,620
Excerpts:
Too right. Maybe they're too right because they're true.

401
00:26:15,440 --> 00:26:18,460
Excerpts:
Did you embarrass me? People who answer questions too right are liars,

402
00:26:18,460 --> 00:26:21,320
Excerpts:
and everybody says Jesus and Einstein. That's a prepackaged answer.

403
00:26:22,460 --> 00:26:25,060
Excerpts:
What do you mean, Jesus and Einstein? Listen, Charles, I have an idea.

404
00:26:25,320 --> 00:26:28,860
Excerpts:
I need you to buy me a pair of binoculars. What's Jesus and Einstein?

405
00:26:29,420 --> 00:26:33,740
Stu:
Which is nicely meta, because it's basically he brings his brother in to create

406
00:26:33,740 --> 00:26:38,720
Stu:
the thriller plot, and then his brother literally finds, stumbles upon the thriller plot.

407
00:26:39,000 --> 00:26:43,640
Chas:
What we didn't mention in our summary is the Donald character,

408
00:26:43,640 --> 00:26:48,320
Chas:
Like a subplot is the Donald character is like unemployed,

409
00:26:48,660 --> 00:26:54,360
Chas:
living with Charlie, even though they're twins, Charlie feels much more superior

410
00:26:54,360 --> 00:26:56,120
Chas:
to Donald intellectually,

411
00:26:56,520 --> 00:27:01,260
Chas:
but Donald feels much more, he does not suffer from the same social anxiety.

412
00:27:01,260 --> 00:27:05,680
Mel:
These are clearly two sides of Kaufman, right? That's how we read this.

413
00:27:05,840 --> 00:27:11,580
Mel:
The one side of him that's like, yeah, I've written award-winning Oscar-nominated

414
00:27:11,580 --> 00:27:16,380
Mel:
plays, and then the side of him that has imposter syndrome, and it's the two

415
00:27:16,380 --> 00:27:20,160
Mel:
sides of him at war with each other, right? That's absolutely how I read it.

416
00:27:20,160 --> 00:27:23,840
Stu:
Yeah, I read Donald as a little more idealized. He's the version.

417
00:27:24,900 --> 00:27:28,220
Stu:
It's connected to his imposter syndrome, but I don't think he sees himself as

418
00:27:28,220 --> 00:27:31,480
Stu:
the guy that's going to write a serial killer movie.

419
00:27:31,840 --> 00:27:36,420
Mel:
No, but I think it's fun that he gets the fact that he could be good at it,

420
00:27:36,460 --> 00:27:39,140
Mel:
but then he despises it, but then he realizes it's a real art,

421
00:27:39,220 --> 00:27:40,580
Mel:
but then he thinks maybe he'd make money.

422
00:27:40,680 --> 00:27:43,820
Mel:
But then he was like, but actually, it's kind of hard. But then he's like, no, it's easy.

423
00:27:43,920 --> 00:27:46,620
Mel:
But it's not real art. It's great.

424
00:27:46,620 --> 00:27:49,460
Chas:
I agree with Stu that yes okay to the

425
00:27:49,460 --> 00:27:52,580
Chas:
extent that I think Donald is someone he aspires to

426
00:27:52,580 --> 00:27:58,680
Chas:
be that is a part of himself but Donald's character is in the film not just

427
00:27:58,680 --> 00:28:04,440
Chas:
to justify this third act but to give voice to to create the contrast of Charlie's

428
00:28:04,440 --> 00:28:08,680
Chas:
anxiety because Donald comes home one day and says I'm going to be a screenwriter

429
00:28:08,680 --> 00:28:11,960
Chas:
and then the very first draft of the very first screenplay he

430
00:28:12,000 --> 00:28:15,420
Chas:
writes is this like amazing financial success,

431
00:28:15,620 --> 00:28:21,200
Chas:
even though in Donald's like attempt to create the story,

432
00:28:21,520 --> 00:28:23,360
Chas:
Charlie ridicules it throughout.

433
00:28:23,540 --> 00:28:26,980
Chas:
And it does sound like it would make no sense, but very entertaining.

434
00:28:27,460 --> 00:28:31,260
Excerpts:
It's a little obvious, don't you think? Okay, but here's the twist.

435
00:28:31,400 --> 00:28:36,780
Excerpts:
We find out that the killer really suffers from multiple personality disorder, right?

436
00:28:36,880 --> 00:28:40,380
Excerpts:
See, he's actually really the cop and the girl.

437
00:28:40,500 --> 00:28:43,280
Excerpts:
All of them are him. Isn't that fucked up?

438
00:28:45,180 --> 00:28:49,500
Excerpts:
The only idea more overused than serial killers is multiple personality.

439
00:28:49,920 --> 00:28:54,600
Excerpts:
On top of that, you explore the notion that cop and criminal are really two

440
00:28:54,600 --> 00:28:55,840
Excerpts:
aspects of the same person.

441
00:28:56,000 --> 00:29:00,800
Excerpts:
See every cop movie ever made for other examples of this. Mom called it psychologically taught.

442
00:29:01,760 --> 00:29:05,060
Excerpts:
The other thing is, there's no way to write this. Did you consider that?

443
00:29:05,060 --> 00:29:11,960
Excerpts:
I mean, how could you have somebody held prisoner in a basement and working

444
00:29:11,960 --> 00:29:13,600
Excerpts:
in a police station at the same time?

445
00:29:16,160 --> 00:29:16,740
Excerpts:
Trick photography.

446
00:29:17,060 --> 00:29:20,920
Stu:
So, this connects to the Leavers. I will say the other thing that Donald does

447
00:29:20,920 --> 00:29:23,400
Stu:
is give Charlie someone to talk to.

448
00:29:23,480 --> 00:29:23,780
Chas:
Yes.

449
00:29:23,860 --> 00:29:28,920
Stu:
And I think what we're talking around is that even though the topic of the film is rather meta,

450
00:29:29,140 --> 00:29:34,720
Stu:
I think a lot of what it's doing structurally isn't actually as layered,

451
00:29:34,840 --> 00:29:39,560
Stu:
for a lack of a better word, as stories we tell or even the 40-year-old version.

452
00:29:39,560 --> 00:29:43,240
Stu:
And it's actually, I mean, it's got two timelines because it's intercutting

453
00:29:43,240 --> 00:29:46,920
Stu:
the story of Charlie writing the book with the actual excerpts from the book,

454
00:29:46,940 --> 00:29:49,260
Stu:
the scenes of the book, which serves as the B plot.

455
00:29:49,460 --> 00:29:52,780
Stu:
But largely, the characters, you know, I'm going to go through it.

456
00:29:53,140 --> 00:29:56,040
Stu:
Most of the communication is diegetic. There is at no point that he talks to

457
00:29:56,040 --> 00:29:59,540
Stu:
the camera as Charlie, knowing he's in a film called Adaptation.

458
00:29:59,940 --> 00:30:01,760
Stu:
It is the memoir of it, right?

459
00:30:01,960 --> 00:30:06,540
Chas:
There is voiceover, but it is in-world voiceover.

460
00:30:06,620 --> 00:30:12,300
Chas:
It feels very of the moment that he's in. It's not coming from a different time, usually. Yes.

461
00:30:12,360 --> 00:30:16,300
Stu:
So, it's definitely giving access to inner thoughts, but it's his inner thoughts to himself.

462
00:30:16,720 --> 00:30:20,240
Stu:
It's the audience of his communications himself, right?

463
00:30:20,380 --> 00:30:25,220
Stu:
So, with those voiceovers. So, he basically wants him to fucking solve these story problems.

464
00:30:25,500 --> 00:30:29,420
Stu:
The communication of the film as the whole is actually what he says,

465
00:30:29,540 --> 00:30:32,580
Stu:
which is he wants to share what he learned from reading this book,

466
00:30:32,700 --> 00:30:34,180
Stu:
which is all the stuff he actually says.

467
00:30:34,200 --> 00:30:36,760
Stu:
I want people to, you know, love plants and love life.

468
00:30:36,760 --> 00:30:40,120
Excerpts:
And Orlean makes orchids so fascinating.

469
00:30:40,360 --> 00:30:45,800
Excerpts:
Plus her musings on Florida and orchid poaching, Indians. It's great,

470
00:30:45,920 --> 00:30:47,520
Excerpts:
sprawling New Yorker stuff.

471
00:30:47,800 --> 00:30:52,500
Excerpts:
And I'd want to remain true to that. I'd want to let the movie exist rather

472
00:30:52,500 --> 00:30:55,780
Excerpts:
than be artificially plot-driven. Great.

473
00:30:57,720 --> 00:31:00,720
Excerpts:
I guess I'm not exactly sure what that means. Oh.

474
00:31:02,880 --> 00:31:08,140
Excerpts:
I'm not sure I know what that means either. I just don't want to ruin it by

475
00:31:08,140 --> 00:31:14,580
Excerpts:
making it a Hollywood thing like an orchid heist movie or something or changing

476
00:31:14,580 --> 00:31:19,020
Excerpts:
the orchids into poppies and turning it into a movie about drug running why

477
00:31:19,020 --> 00:31:21,500
Excerpts:
can't there be a movie simply about flowers,

478
00:31:23,020 --> 00:31:29,500
Excerpts:
I guess we thought that maybe Susan Orlean and LaRoche could fall in love but

479
00:31:29,500 --> 00:31:35,220
Excerpts:
I'm saying it's like I don't want to cram in sex or guns or car chases,

480
00:31:35,220 --> 00:31:38,660
Excerpts:
you know, or characters, you know,

481
00:31:39,760 --> 00:31:45,560
Excerpts:
learning profound life lessons or growing or coming to like each other or overcoming

482
00:31:45,560 --> 00:31:47,800
Excerpts:
obstacles to succeed in the end, you know.

483
00:31:47,860 --> 00:31:52,960
Excerpts:
I mean, the book isn't like that and life isn't like that. You know, it just isn't.

484
00:31:57,640 --> 00:31:59,460
Excerpts:
I feel very strongly about this.

485
00:31:59,940 --> 00:32:03,920
Stu:
Because I do think one of the amazing things about this film is that it actually does all that.

486
00:32:03,960 --> 00:32:04,380
Chas:
Right?

487
00:32:04,480 --> 00:32:09,840
Stu:
He succeeds in this roundabout way of making a film about the themes of the

488
00:32:09,840 --> 00:32:12,580
Stu:
book, and he's communicating the way that he has.

489
00:32:12,680 --> 00:32:15,440
Stu:
So, I think the film as a whole is talking directly to the audience,

490
00:32:15,580 --> 00:32:18,200
Stu:
but I don't think any of the characters are, right?

491
00:32:18,300 --> 00:32:18,520
Chas:
Yes.

492
00:32:18,660 --> 00:32:25,220
Stu:
I don't think Charlie has power over the filmmaking as separate from the narrative.

493
00:32:25,220 --> 00:32:29,460
Stu:
Charlie clearly wrote the screenplay, but as indicated by the fact that he's

494
00:32:29,460 --> 00:32:35,980
Stu:
not playing himself, he's being played by Nicolas Cage, is I think there is a separation there.

495
00:32:36,040 --> 00:32:42,160
Stu:
A subtle one, but an important one that I don't think Charlie has complete control over the filmmaking.

496
00:32:42,460 --> 00:32:45,360
Stu:
Right. Charlie the person, not Charlie the character.

497
00:32:45,920 --> 00:32:49,480
Stu:
But I don't even think Charlie the character has power over the filmmaking either.

498
00:32:49,560 --> 00:32:53,080
Stu:
He does over the script, but only in hindsight do we understand that.

499
00:32:53,080 --> 00:32:57,300
Chas:
Over the script he's writing. Like, this is to your earlier point about Spike Jonze.

500
00:32:57,340 --> 00:33:01,300
Chas:
Spike Jonze is dealing with the Charlie Kaufman who's finished the script.

501
00:33:01,460 --> 00:33:05,880
Chas:
The Charlie that we're seeing does not think he's going to ever finish that script.

502
00:33:07,240 --> 00:33:10,960
Stu:
I don't think any of the characters have an awareness, really,

503
00:33:11,240 --> 00:33:15,800
Stu:
that they're going to be in the film, the story of the making of,

504
00:33:15,920 --> 00:33:18,640
Stu:
you know, the screenplay that is about him trying to adapt this book.

505
00:33:18,800 --> 00:33:20,320
Stu:
Right? So there is not- Except LaRoche.

506
00:33:21,240 --> 00:33:23,760
Stu:
Yes. Who's going to play me? Yeah.

507
00:33:24,800 --> 00:33:26,040
Excerpts:
He's that screenwriter.

508
00:33:28,040 --> 00:33:30,980
Excerpts:
What, the guy that's adapting our book? Yeah.

509
00:33:34,830 --> 00:33:37,330
Excerpts:
What's wild? It's nice to meet you.

510
00:33:40,450 --> 00:33:43,470
Excerpts:
Hey, dude, who's going to play me?

511
00:33:44,270 --> 00:33:46,950
Stu:
That's three other levers, don't we have? To who the communication,

512
00:33:47,150 --> 00:33:50,610
Stu:
from when in time, and we kind of hinted to that, which is the script is being

513
00:33:50,610 --> 00:33:54,670
Stu:
written in the present, the communication of the filmmaking is definitely presenting

514
00:33:54,670 --> 00:33:57,850
Stu:
it in kind of like an omniscient hindsight, you know.

515
00:34:00,070 --> 00:34:03,290
Chas:
Like it's structured in that way. They could have structured it differently

516
00:34:03,290 --> 00:34:08,930
Chas:
so that his development of the themes and breakthroughs and the understandings

517
00:34:08,930 --> 00:34:12,090
Chas:
of the material happen as they occur to him.

518
00:34:12,190 --> 00:34:18,670
Chas:
But the structure of the film from the very first scene already has those understandings in them.

519
00:34:18,770 --> 00:34:23,370
Chas:
And it's only as he comes to them that it recontextualizes for us as the audience

520
00:34:23,370 --> 00:34:28,850
Chas:
what the filmmakers were doing beforehand and how they were exploring those

521
00:34:28,850 --> 00:34:31,130
Chas:
themes and choosing those moments.

522
00:34:31,130 --> 00:34:36,630
Chas:
What does the communication want from the audience well i think interestingly

523
00:34:36,630 --> 00:34:42,910
Chas:
the donald charlie relationship is the only way that charlie could have got

524
00:34:42,910 --> 00:34:47,910
Chas:
to a line where someone says like what the whole film is about you are what

525
00:34:47,910 --> 00:34:50,670
Chas:
you love not what loves you she.

526
00:34:50,670 --> 00:34:51,630
Excerpts:
Thought you were pathetic,

527
00:34:56,470 --> 00:34:59,030
Excerpts:
that was her business not mine,

528
00:35:02,770 --> 00:35:06,490
Excerpts:
You are what you love, not what loves you.

529
00:35:10,430 --> 00:35:12,090
Excerpts:
That's what I decided a long time ago.

530
00:35:13,250 --> 00:35:18,490
Chas:
And only through, you know, an alligator chase scene third act with an imaginary

531
00:35:18,490 --> 00:35:22,390
Chas:
twin brother could Charlie- I mean, he did discuss that.

532
00:35:22,470 --> 00:35:27,430
Chas:
Like, there were bits where he was talking about Susan's characters yearning

533
00:35:27,430 --> 00:35:29,950
Chas:
for passion and feeling trapped in her marriage.

534
00:35:29,990 --> 00:35:37,070
Chas:
And that LaRoche was liberated by his near-death experience to follow his passion.

535
00:35:37,070 --> 00:35:42,110
Chas:
Like all these characters are defined by what they love and it's only when charlie

536
00:35:42,110 --> 00:35:45,610
Chas:
embraces what he loves about the material what he loves about screenwriting

537
00:35:45,610 --> 00:35:49,310
Chas:
what he loves about storytelling that he can finish the script it.

538
00:35:49,310 --> 00:35:55,770
Mel:
Is kind of that love letter to the horrific process of writing it's very um

539
00:35:55,770 --> 00:35:57,150
Mel:
it's very stockholm syndrome.

540
00:35:57,150 --> 00:35:58,250
Chas:
Yes this.

541
00:35:58,250 --> 00:36:00,990
Mel:
Is terrible and yet i love it and i must continue to do it.

542
00:36:00,990 --> 00:36:04,050
Chas:
I was just surprised that

543
00:36:04,050 --> 00:36:06,850
Chas:
i thought adaptation and this was an option chosen

544
00:36:06,850 --> 00:36:09,910
Chas:
for us by our patrons like it polled very highly in

545
00:36:09,910 --> 00:36:13,690
Chas:
the in the homework options and and was suggested this

546
00:36:13,690 --> 00:36:17,110
Chas:
is the one that i thought would be most overtly communicating

547
00:36:17,110 --> 00:36:23,670
Chas:
directly to us and i was surprised at how in world and within like these character

548
00:36:23,670 --> 00:36:30,230
Chas:
relationships and how it really is almost only through the structure that we

549
00:36:30,230 --> 00:36:34,930
Chas:
are being communicated directly to by Spike Jonze and Charlie Kaufman.

550
00:36:35,090 --> 00:36:40,510
Stu:
In a way, it's less talking directly to the audience than the 40-year-old version,

551
00:36:40,690 --> 00:36:42,410
Stu:
and certainly more than stories we tell.

552
00:36:43,210 --> 00:36:48,230
Stu:
You know, I think if Charlie and Donald were actually collaborating on a screenplay,

553
00:36:48,330 --> 00:36:49,970
Stu:
you know what software I think they could use?

554
00:36:50,990 --> 00:36:52,250
Stu:
Arc Studio Pro.

555
00:36:53,030 --> 00:36:57,330
FX:
This episode of Draw Zero is brought to you by Arc Studio Pro,

556
00:36:57,550 --> 00:37:00,750
FX:
a modern, fresh app for the screenwriting world.

557
00:37:01,030 --> 00:37:03,910
FX:
Which of course has industry standard formatting which,

558
00:37:04,860 --> 00:37:11,980
FX:
That's the bare minimum. But exciting for us Australians, it has it for both US letter and A4.

559
00:37:12,240 --> 00:37:17,680
FX:
Crazy. And it also lets you cheat the margins, which is one of my favourite little features.

560
00:37:18,620 --> 00:37:23,020
FX:
But it has advanced tools for storytellers that are actually easy to use.

561
00:37:23,160 --> 00:37:27,720
FX:
You can seamlessly move between drag and drop beat cards into a treatment and

562
00:37:27,720 --> 00:37:32,740
FX:
into a screenplay and back and forth at any time. and you can color code your beats.

563
00:37:32,880 --> 00:37:35,620
FX:
Super useful whether you want to tag your beats for characters,

564
00:37:35,800 --> 00:37:39,580
FX:
narrative point of view, thematic sections, or however you want.

565
00:37:39,760 --> 00:37:43,680
FX:
We got to use all of that on a project where we took it back to cards and then

566
00:37:43,680 --> 00:37:45,640
FX:
from cards to outline and from outline to pages.

567
00:37:45,740 --> 00:37:48,440
FX:
The development process was intuitive and powerful.

568
00:37:48,720 --> 00:37:53,740
FX:
All the while, it was the best remote collaboration experience we've had in

569
00:37:53,740 --> 00:37:55,780
FX:
screenwriting software, and we've tried a lot.

570
00:37:55,960 --> 00:38:01,480
FX:
I loved looking at a line of dialogue that Chaz had edited, going to the edit

571
00:38:01,480 --> 00:38:04,460
FX:
history and changing it back to the line that I wrote.

572
00:38:06,620 --> 00:38:10,960
FX:
We used the software to present to our producer and script editor at each of

573
00:38:10,960 --> 00:38:15,740
FX:
those stages, at boards, at outline, and then at pages, who could then leave

574
00:38:15,740 --> 00:38:19,000
FX:
comments in the app, which is both useful and terrifying.

575
00:38:19,300 --> 00:38:23,400
FX:
And we could reply to those comments, tag each other to throw each other under

576
00:38:23,400 --> 00:38:25,500
FX:
the bus, or we could tick them as resolved.

577
00:38:25,780 --> 00:38:30,780
FX:
It really is as easy to use as Google Docs. And this development workflow has

578
00:38:30,780 --> 00:38:34,400
FX:
worked so well that Chaz has decided he doesn't need me anymore.

579
00:38:34,560 --> 00:38:38,820
FX:
And he's using it on a solo project because it's not just from collaboration.

580
00:38:38,900 --> 00:38:42,960
FX:
And I know I'll be using it on one of my own projects because the development

581
00:38:42,960 --> 00:38:47,340
FX:
workflow really is that intuitive. We've noticed Arc Studio Pro is being constantly

582
00:38:47,340 --> 00:38:50,320
FX:
updated and the development team is super approachable and responsive.

583
00:38:50,700 --> 00:38:54,280
FX:
They've now introduced the new notes feature which facilitates that collecting

584
00:38:54,280 --> 00:38:59,120
FX:
of all your scraps of ideas and allowing you to get into the flow of free writing

585
00:38:59,120 --> 00:39:03,020
FX:
and figuring all your structure all within one spot. Arc Studio Pro.

586
00:39:03,440 --> 00:39:07,200
FX:
Join the thousands of screenwriters from amateurs to pros and everyone in between

587
00:39:07,200 --> 00:39:08,980
FX:
who've already made the leap.

588
00:39:09,120 --> 00:39:14,420
FX:
Arc Studio offers a completely free plan because starting to screenwrite shouldn't cost you anything.

589
00:39:14,700 --> 00:39:19,900
FX:
But you can also get $30 off the pro plan if you want some of these pro features.

590
00:39:20,260 --> 00:39:26,120
FX:
If you visit the link in the show notes or go to arcstudio.com slash draft zero,

591
00:39:26,300 --> 00:39:28,020
FX:
that's draft zero without a hyphen.

592
00:39:28,400 --> 00:39:32,440
FX:
And now for the third hour of a screenwriting podcast.

593
00:39:32,860 --> 00:39:35,300
FX:
Except this episode is like 90 minutes.

594
00:39:36,970 --> 00:39:37,850
FX:
All the better for it.

595
00:39:40,210 --> 00:39:45,130
Mel:
I do think that simply by nature of calling him Charlie Kaufman and even just

596
00:39:45,130 --> 00:39:49,390
Mel:
by getting Nicolas Cage to play him right off the bat, it is talking directly

597
00:39:49,390 --> 00:39:52,830
Mel:
to us in a somewhat removed way, right?

598
00:39:52,910 --> 00:39:57,250
Mel:
Like by saying, you know who this person is, you know who that guy is playing him.

599
00:39:57,390 --> 00:40:00,670
Mel:
All right, you kind of see where we're going here with this right at the beginning,

600
00:40:00,790 --> 00:40:05,570
Mel:
which really draws attention to that by mentioning his name in the script multiple

601
00:40:05,570 --> 00:40:07,510
Mel:
times in the the first couple of minutes, et cetera.

602
00:40:07,590 --> 00:40:09,890
Mel:
And that's the writer being like, hey, you see what we're doing?

603
00:40:09,970 --> 00:40:11,970
Mel:
You see what we're doing? You see what we're doing, right? Okay.

604
00:40:12,190 --> 00:40:15,390
Mel:
So I do think you're right. I think I was actually a little bit surprised as

605
00:40:15,390 --> 00:40:19,050
Mel:
well, revisiting it, how much less it did than the other two.

606
00:40:19,150 --> 00:40:23,890
Mel:
But I think that it kind of sets us up for it really clearly with where we're going.

607
00:40:24,030 --> 00:40:28,390
Mel:
And then goes, all right, we've set this up and now we're going to go completely off the rails.

608
00:40:28,910 --> 00:40:33,890
Chas:
I think to phrase this using the craft tools, I thought that a film as aggressively

609
00:40:33,890 --> 00:40:38,930
Chas:
self-aware as this one is, where, like you said, Stu, it is called Adaptation.

610
00:40:38,990 --> 00:40:41,530
Chas:
It is a film about the process of the making of itself.

611
00:40:42,070 --> 00:40:48,230
Chas:
For a film that aggressively self-aware, I was surprised by how diegetic everything was.

612
00:40:48,630 --> 00:40:52,470
Stu:
I think that's a choice. And part of the reason maybe it's successful is because

613
00:40:52,470 --> 00:40:59,150
Stu:
the content is so wild and out there, it's grounding it in quite conventional tools.

614
00:40:59,350 --> 00:41:02,550
Stu:
Yes, we're meant to laugh with the fact that Robin McKee is like, don't use voiceover.

615
00:41:02,550 --> 00:41:06,130
Excerpts:
I have failed. I am panicked. I have sold out. I am worthless.

616
00:41:06,890 --> 00:41:11,010
Excerpts:
What the fuck am I doing here? What the fuck am I doing here? Fuck.

617
00:41:11,230 --> 00:41:15,550
Excerpts:
It is my weakness, my ultimate lack of conviction that brings me here.

618
00:41:15,650 --> 00:41:18,750
Excerpts:
Easy answers, moves to shortcut yourself to success.

619
00:41:18,890 --> 00:41:22,230
Excerpts:
And here I am, because my jaunt into the abyss brought me nothing.

620
00:41:22,330 --> 00:41:25,470
Excerpts:
Well, isn't that just the risk one takes for attempting something new?

621
00:41:25,550 --> 00:41:26,710
Excerpts:
I should leave here right now.

622
00:41:26,850 --> 00:41:30,850
Excerpts:
I'll start over. I need to face this project head on. And God help you if you

623
00:41:30,850 --> 00:41:34,170
Excerpts:
use voiceover in your work, my friends. God help you.

624
00:41:34,640 --> 00:41:36,240
Excerpts:
It's flaccid, sloppy writing.

625
00:41:36,420 --> 00:41:40,640
Stu:
But the voiceover is diegetic, right? It's not him smarmingly talking to the

626
00:41:40,640 --> 00:41:43,360
Stu:
audience. It's him talking to himself for a reason. It's largely motivated.

627
00:41:43,620 --> 00:41:47,240
Stu:
They've invented a character to do it. There is the storyteller cuts.

628
00:41:47,340 --> 00:41:50,120
Stu:
There's the A plot and the B plot. They come together.

629
00:41:50,520 --> 00:41:55,220
Stu:
There's a lot of stuff that's quite conventional storytelling that lets it be a little bit more wild.

630
00:41:55,380 --> 00:41:58,580
Stu:
And that is an interesting contrast to the 40-year-old version,

631
00:41:58,740 --> 00:42:01,100
Stu:
which is in some ways kind of hits the beats.

632
00:42:01,100 --> 00:42:05,360
Stu:
And it's kind of does a great job of like mocking some of those beats that it's

633
00:42:05,360 --> 00:42:09,200
Stu:
hitting about the autobiographical artist's journey film,

634
00:42:09,440 --> 00:42:13,260
Stu:
but because it's got some of that conventionality, it can slip in these moments

635
00:42:13,260 --> 00:42:19,460
Stu:
of breaking the fourth wall of, of talking directly to the audience to be a commentary on things.

636
00:42:19,640 --> 00:42:22,560
Stu:
And I know I'm kind of like anticipating that rather than doing it in wrap up,

637
00:42:22,600 --> 00:42:27,480
Stu:
but I think what's interesting about stories we tell is it's a little bit,

638
00:42:27,480 --> 00:42:30,920
Stu:
neither it's, it's not a conventional story and it's not conventionally told.

639
00:42:31,100 --> 00:42:31,180
Chas:
Yeah.

640
00:42:31,280 --> 00:42:35,000
Stu:
Right. But it's using techniques that I've seen in other projects to deal with

641
00:42:35,000 --> 00:42:36,400
Stu:
similar personal subject matter.

642
00:42:36,660 --> 00:42:37,520
Mel:
Excellent segue.

643
00:42:38,620 --> 00:42:42,420
Excerpts:
Can you describe the whole story in your own words? What?

644
00:42:43,760 --> 00:42:47,700
Excerpts:
The entire story? I guess I better pee first.

645
00:42:49,120 --> 00:42:52,620
Excerpts:
I'm interested in the way we tell stories about our lives, about the fact that

646
00:42:52,620 --> 00:42:55,600
Excerpts:
the truth about the past is often ephemeral and difficult to pin down.

647
00:42:56,180 --> 00:42:59,680
Excerpts:
Well, I guess if you could start by describing Mum in as much detail as possible.

648
00:42:59,680 --> 00:43:05,320
Excerpts:
My memory of mom is she was a fun person at parties, that she laughed loud.

649
00:43:05,760 --> 00:43:13,440
Excerpts:
Michael was a private person, and Diane was not a private person. She yearned for more.

650
00:43:13,860 --> 00:43:17,980
Excerpts:
She was very warm, you know, full of life. But I do think it's really interesting

651
00:43:17,980 --> 00:43:24,340
Excerpts:
to look at this one thing that happened and how it's refracted in so many different ways.

652
00:43:24,340 --> 00:43:30,680
Excerpts:
What I overheard was mom saying that she was pregnant and that she wasn't sure who the father was.

653
00:43:32,800 --> 00:43:38,620
Mel:
Stories We Tell is a documentary by Sarah Pauly, who is an actor.

654
00:43:38,720 --> 00:43:43,880
Mel:
And she starts telling a story about her mother who has passed and ends up sort

655
00:43:43,880 --> 00:43:49,180
Mel:
of stumbling upon her own Mamma Mia situation in terms of literally,

656
00:43:49,460 --> 00:43:52,100
Mel:
wait, which of these guys is my dad?

657
00:43:52,100 --> 00:43:55,200
Mel:
Let's find out question mark

658
00:43:55,200 --> 00:43:59,880
Mel:
and the documentary takes a couple different twists and turns following her

659
00:43:59,880 --> 00:44:04,700
Mel:
journey of yeah finding out is the person who raised me my biological father

660
00:44:04,700 --> 00:44:09,160
Mel:
is this other actor or that other actor she has she has three men who could

661
00:44:09,160 --> 00:44:13,480
Mel:
potentially be her father it's a very personal piece and,

662
00:44:14,910 --> 00:44:20,930
Mel:
is very clearly from the beginning that but it takes some really interesting

663
00:44:20,930 --> 00:44:24,330
Mel:
side tracks along the way.

664
00:44:24,330 --> 00:44:29,910
Stu:
My first thing is because i've worked on a couple of documentaries in editing hardest.

665
00:44:29,910 --> 00:44:31,390
Mel:
Thing in filmmaking feature.

666
00:44:31,390 --> 00:44:34,950
Stu:
Documentary absolutely no question yeah um

667
00:44:34,950 --> 00:44:38,070
Stu:
but and also i've done some you know kind of

668
00:44:38,070 --> 00:44:41,970
Stu:
content and i'm using that term deliberately disparagingly advertising

669
00:44:41,970 --> 00:44:44,850
Stu:
and stuff that's documentary light and one of the questions we asked very

670
00:44:44,850 --> 00:44:47,790
Stu:
early on is this a documentary where we see the camera or

671
00:44:47,790 --> 00:44:50,630
Stu:
is it documentary where we don't is it a documentary where you

672
00:44:50,630 --> 00:44:53,490
Stu:
see the lights and you see the camera or is it one where

673
00:44:53,490 --> 00:44:56,950
Stu:
we try to hide the apparatus of the filmmaking is like a very early decision

674
00:44:56,950 --> 00:45:02,110
Stu:
that that documentary filmmakers often talk about or at least have in my experience

675
00:45:02,110 --> 00:45:07,550
Stu:
and this is a documentary where very clearly in the kind of the first act or

676
00:45:07,550 --> 00:45:11,170
Stu:
first sequence we see them setting up all the equipment right they are We're

677
00:45:11,170 --> 00:45:13,330
Stu:
not trying to hide the fact of the apparatus.

678
00:45:13,710 --> 00:45:16,290
Stu:
You know, when we were trying to decide what films to do for this,

679
00:45:16,370 --> 00:45:19,090
Stu:
I watched The Thin Blue Line for the first time. Errol Morris,

680
00:45:19,250 --> 00:45:21,510
Stu:
absolutely revolutionary documentary.

681
00:45:21,890 --> 00:45:23,870
Stu:
I mean, it's one of those things that you look at and you go,

682
00:45:23,970 --> 00:45:26,710
Stu:
fuck, this really did change everything. So much copies from this.

683
00:45:26,790 --> 00:45:29,130
Stu:
But at no point do you see the existence of the camera.

684
00:45:29,410 --> 00:45:31,830
Stu:
This, we see the existence of the camera right from the beginning.

685
00:45:32,030 --> 00:45:34,970
Mel:
Not only the existence of the camera, in that same sequence,

686
00:45:35,030 --> 00:45:38,630
Mel:
she sets up the fact that they're going and doing voiceover.

687
00:45:38,630 --> 00:45:43,370
Mel:
Like actually having her dad do a voiceover where he's reading and she's saying,

688
00:45:43,410 --> 00:45:44,490
Mel:
oh, take that line again.

689
00:45:44,530 --> 00:45:47,550
Mel:
Oh, can you deliver this a little differently? So they're really she's really

690
00:45:47,550 --> 00:45:51,890
Mel:
pushing the fact that this is a crafted story that you have multiple takes that

691
00:45:51,890 --> 00:45:55,570
Mel:
she has control as an editor and that not all of the things that we are seeing

692
00:45:55,570 --> 00:45:59,150
Mel:
and hearing are as they were delivered the first time.

693
00:46:00,030 --> 00:46:03,410
Stu:
What I like about that is she also makes it very clear that the narration,

694
00:46:03,810 --> 00:46:06,850
Stu:
the voiceover, is written by her father.

695
00:46:07,130 --> 00:46:11,410
Stu:
She's recording it and directing it, and he wrote it. And it sets it up in the beginning.

696
00:46:11,510 --> 00:46:16,010
Stu:
And in the credits, they actually say, Michael's voiceover by Michael Polley.

697
00:46:16,130 --> 00:46:19,450
Stu:
And I think that's really interesting because coming back to who is talking,

698
00:46:19,810 --> 00:46:22,490
Stu:
there's actually the people that are talking to the camera.

699
00:46:22,590 --> 00:46:24,950
Stu:
There's Siri Polley who is editing this film together.

700
00:46:25,270 --> 00:46:28,770
Stu:
There is Michael who's delivering a voiceover. And then there's obviously the

701
00:46:28,770 --> 00:46:32,070
Stu:
quote unquote, the voiceovers of the characters when they go to B-roll or whatever.

702
00:46:32,210 --> 00:46:34,790
Stu:
But the narrator is Michael and not her.

703
00:46:34,950 --> 00:46:39,410
Mel:
That also tells us from when in time, right? Because he's narrating things that

704
00:46:39,410 --> 00:46:40,950
Mel:
she's discovering, which means

705
00:46:40,950 --> 00:46:44,850
Mel:
we know that the narration is happening near the end of this process.

706
00:46:46,050 --> 00:46:51,750
Chas:
Michael in particular has both separate interviews, like to camera pieces,

707
00:46:51,970 --> 00:46:56,970
Chas:
separate to his sitting in the sound recording booth reading his story.

708
00:46:57,370 --> 00:47:00,430
Chas:
His version of the events um but

709
00:47:00,430 --> 00:47:03,270
Chas:
i want to make two comments one is first of

710
00:47:03,270 --> 00:47:07,130
Chas:
all not only do they show the the lights and the setup and the camera at the

711
00:47:07,130 --> 00:47:14,390
Chas:
beginning but they are using footage from who we learn very quickly are her

712
00:47:14,390 --> 00:47:18,370
Chas:
siblings half all of them half siblings actually she thought two of them were

713
00:47:18,370 --> 00:47:23,030
Chas:
not half siblings but it turns out they're all her half siblings and it's them

714
00:47:23,170 --> 00:47:28,970
Chas:
talking about how uncomfortable they feel about the process they're about to go under.

715
00:47:29,030 --> 00:47:31,810
Chas:
They clearly don't think we're rolling yet or being recorded.

716
00:47:31,910 --> 00:47:34,650
Chas:
They're having a discussion with Sarah about how is this going to go?

717
00:47:34,710 --> 00:47:35,890
Chas:
What's this going to be like?

718
00:47:38,410 --> 00:47:43,430
Excerpts:
I just think that I might be sweating through my shirt. Yeah, I'm ready.

719
00:47:46,490 --> 00:47:51,690
Excerpts:
I don't like this. Are you nervous? No. Yeah, it'll get worse.

720
00:47:51,910 --> 00:47:56,790
Chas:
It's not only drawing attention to this is a documentary, like you are watching

721
00:47:56,790 --> 00:48:04,590
Chas:
a filmed process, it's drawing attention to how aware the subjects are to that relationship as well.

722
00:48:04,710 --> 00:48:07,190
Chas:
And like before they've even told us what the story is about,

723
00:48:07,290 --> 00:48:10,690
Chas:
they're telling us they're feeling deeply uncomfortable about engaging in the process.

724
00:48:10,690 --> 00:48:13,550
Mel:
I do wonder that she sets up

725
00:48:13,550 --> 00:48:16,870
Mel:
a level of ambiguity how much of that is with

726
00:48:16,870 --> 00:48:19,850
Mel:
or without their knowledge right she could have prompted them they could

727
00:48:19,850 --> 00:48:24,130
Mel:
know exactly how that will be used etc and she sets that up with us by showing

728
00:48:24,130 --> 00:48:29,350
Mel:
us the audio recording booth and I think that level of ambiguity it's is there's

729
00:48:29,350 --> 00:48:35,030
Mel:
there's nothing unethical about it but it is really interesting to toy with

730
00:48:35,030 --> 00:48:37,150
Mel:
that in in a story like this.

731
00:48:37,150 --> 00:48:42,210
Stu:
So I think it's playing with these things in two ways, right?

732
00:48:42,330 --> 00:48:45,710
Stu:
So we have the ambiguity over what is real, what is not, how,

733
00:48:46,030 --> 00:48:51,110
Stu:
for lack of a better word, ethically sourced or how authentically sourced this material is.

734
00:48:51,270 --> 00:48:51,930
Chas:
Right?

735
00:48:52,070 --> 00:48:56,190
Stu:
So there's a degree of ambiguity there and then the ambiguity around time,

736
00:48:56,350 --> 00:49:01,790
Stu:
right? This isn't a documentary that sets up with title cards for the year.

737
00:49:01,910 --> 00:49:03,170
Stu:
And I've worked on those documentaries.

738
00:49:03,370 --> 00:49:08,070
Stu:
In the Bob Brown doco, The Giants, we had very clear timelines.

739
00:49:08,670 --> 00:49:11,770
Stu:
And when we're editing and cutting the sequences, they're all built around time periods.

740
00:49:11,890 --> 00:49:15,670
Stu:
That is a film that was largely told chronologically to help people grasp the

741
00:49:15,670 --> 00:49:17,330
Stu:
magnitude of what was going on.

742
00:49:18,330 --> 00:49:21,930
Stu:
This, they've kept it ephemeral to make it feel, I guess, more like memory.

743
00:49:22,150 --> 00:49:25,670
Stu:
Yeah. Right? Because, and certainly as I've gotten older, you know,

744
00:49:25,690 --> 00:49:27,550
Stu:
I'm the only one here in their 40s.

745
00:49:28,110 --> 00:49:30,710
Stu:
Not for long, thankfully. Yes.

746
00:49:31,510 --> 00:49:37,470
Stu:
The 40-year-old version. I'm waiting for Chaz to start his rapping career very soon.

747
00:49:37,850 --> 00:49:39,130
Chas:
My midlife crisis.

748
00:49:39,690 --> 00:49:43,070
Mel:
I am not coming to your open mic night. I'm putting my foot down.

749
00:49:43,130 --> 00:49:44,270
Mel:
I have to have a boundary somewhere.

750
00:49:44,510 --> 00:49:48,150
Stu:
Beat Zero is just going to be a weekly podcast of Chaz.

751
00:49:49,170 --> 00:49:55,410
Chas:
Oh, my God. I couldn't imagine anything worse. But we've actually danced around

752
00:49:55,410 --> 00:50:03,610
Chas:
the main craft tool that Sarah uses that draws our attention as the audience,

753
00:50:03,770 --> 00:50:05,590
Chas:
that is her talking directly to us.

754
00:50:05,910 --> 00:50:09,650
Stu:
But she doesn't really talk directly to us. This is what's fascinating about it.

755
00:50:09,650 --> 00:50:11,450
Chas:
Oh, no, this is where I disagree with you.

756
00:50:11,590 --> 00:50:11,670
Stu:
Oh.

757
00:50:11,670 --> 00:50:18,390
Chas:
So, throughout the film, there's a lot of Super 8 footage,

758
00:50:18,650 --> 00:50:23,410
Chas:
which in Michael's opening voiceover from his story that he has written,

759
00:50:23,450 --> 00:50:29,370
Chas:
he references how on his honeymoon, he was an addicted Super 8 footage and he's

760
00:50:29,370 --> 00:50:32,030
Chas:
describing the footage and we're seeing Super 8 footage.

761
00:50:33,580 --> 00:50:37,180
Excerpts:
Let me continue by telling you another from Michael's artistic pursuits.

762
00:50:37,880 --> 00:50:41,640
Excerpts:
At about the time of his marriage to Diane, Michael decided to purchase a movie

763
00:50:41,640 --> 00:50:44,640
Excerpts:
camera and to record their belated honeymoon in England.

764
00:50:45,100 --> 00:50:48,440
Excerpts:
Watching it, several features of his work become apparent.

765
00:50:49,180 --> 00:50:54,120
Excerpts:
Every time you see a group of people in my Super 8 movies, every time you see

766
00:50:54,120 --> 00:50:55,680
Excerpts:
a few people, you get interested.

767
00:50:55,900 --> 00:51:01,020
Excerpts:
The camera goes away and looks at the roof of a house or something or disappears

768
00:51:01,020 --> 00:51:06,060
Excerpts:
in the distance. And so this is my way of filming was not to include people too much.

769
00:51:06,280 --> 00:51:08,560
Chas:
So right at the beginning of the film,

770
00:51:08,660 --> 00:51:15,720
Chas:
it is telling us that these Super 8 dramatizations or moments are real.

771
00:51:15,980 --> 00:51:17,300
Stu:
Are archived. Yeah. Yeah.

772
00:51:17,400 --> 00:51:21,360
Chas:
It's fascinating. I just have to describe it. You guys know what I'm talking about.

773
00:51:21,440 --> 00:51:24,480
Chas:
But for anyone who hasn't seen the film, at the end of the film,

774
00:51:24,600 --> 00:51:29,580
Chas:
she deliberately reveals to the audience that she is shooting all that stuff.

775
00:51:29,580 --> 00:51:34,280
Chas:
She shows us Sarah Polley directing an actor playing her mother.

776
00:51:34,420 --> 00:51:39,200
Chas:
She shows us Sarah Polley with a Super 8 camera shooting this footage.

777
00:51:39,360 --> 00:51:43,780
Chas:
She tells us that everything that we've just seen that we- in terms of the Super

778
00:51:43,780 --> 00:51:47,720
Chas:
8 footage that we thought was archival footage, that was real,

779
00:51:47,800 --> 00:51:51,540
Chas:
like real, like was actually her family members.

780
00:51:51,820 --> 00:51:55,440
Stu:
It was actually documents, like in the sense of the word, this is a documentary.

781
00:51:55,700 --> 00:51:57,900
Stu:
These were- it's a film made of documents.

782
00:51:57,900 --> 00:52:02,400
Chas:
And she could have gone through the whole film having done those reenactments,

783
00:52:02,460 --> 00:52:04,800
Chas:
but just left them as a suggestion.

784
00:52:04,980 --> 00:52:12,140
Chas:
But she tells us as the director of the film, she reveals to us that we've been hoodwinked, as it were.

785
00:52:12,360 --> 00:52:16,780
Chas:
And it's very clever because it's such a deliberate misdirection because she's

786
00:52:16,780 --> 00:52:21,480
Chas:
often returning to the same footage, which feels archival documentary-ish where

787
00:52:21,480 --> 00:52:24,240
Chas:
you're like recontextualizing the same thing over and over again because you

788
00:52:24,240 --> 00:52:26,100
Chas:
don't have a lot of the footage.

789
00:52:26,100 --> 00:52:28,880
Chas:
It's often in the same moments with the same characters to

790
00:52:28,880 --> 00:52:31,860
Chas:
make it feel like oh this was actually shot by

791
00:52:31,860 --> 00:52:38,680
Chas:
people it felt like candid super 8 home video footage and the one point i'd

792
00:52:38,680 --> 00:52:43,540
Chas:
seen this film before but i didn't remember how overt it was there was one shot

793
00:52:43,540 --> 00:52:49,520
Chas:
at her mother's funeral where the camera finds harry her mother's lover and

794
00:52:49,520 --> 00:52:51,840
Chas:
her biological father who she finds out is

795
00:52:51,920 --> 00:52:56,560
Chas:
a biological father through the thing, but it does a focus pull to find him

796
00:52:56,560 --> 00:52:59,600
Chas:
at the back of the thing. And that's when I'm like, that's not real.

797
00:52:59,800 --> 00:53:03,580
Chas:
And I Googled it then and went, yes, this is recreated footage.

798
00:53:03,640 --> 00:53:07,520
Chas:
But what I didn't remember, and this was my second time watching it,

799
00:53:07,580 --> 00:53:11,740
Chas:
I didn't remember that Sarah tells us in the film that she shows us overtly

800
00:53:11,740 --> 00:53:13,120
Chas:
that she's been making that up.

801
00:53:13,180 --> 00:53:17,260
Chas:
And I'm fascinated to you guys, why is she doing that? Why is Sarah Polly the

802
00:53:17,260 --> 00:53:19,680
Chas:
director, revealing that she's misdirected us.

803
00:53:20,560 --> 00:53:22,860
Stu:
So, I'm going to answer that question, but I do want to observe.

804
00:53:23,360 --> 00:53:25,060
Stu:
I was suspicious early on.

805
00:53:25,480 --> 00:53:30,560
Stu:
I was like, there's a consistency to the look of the film stock and stuff.

806
00:53:30,700 --> 00:53:33,900
Stu:
There were changes over this period. I expect more of a differences.

807
00:53:34,200 --> 00:53:37,460
Stu:
There were some shots that didn't fit. It's like, how do you have a shot of

808
00:53:37,460 --> 00:53:41,260
Stu:
this? Why was someone filming this? But I kind of was like, meh.

809
00:53:41,880 --> 00:53:46,020
Mel:
They're actors, right? They're in that world. They're on sets a lot.

810
00:53:46,300 --> 00:53:48,540
Mel:
You kind of glaze over that at first.

811
00:53:48,540 --> 00:53:50,880
Chas:
And she has done stunning casting. Yeah.

812
00:53:51,020 --> 00:53:56,760
Stu:
And she does use real footage as well of her mother. There is stuff that is real with her mother.

813
00:53:57,020 --> 00:54:00,560
Chas:
And her father, because they show her father with a beard. Yeah.

814
00:54:00,640 --> 00:54:02,740
Chas:
That's very clearly him from a different time.

815
00:54:02,980 --> 00:54:06,480
Stu:
When I was talking about this with my mum, she, with Sandra,

816
00:54:06,740 --> 00:54:12,940
Stu:
top tier patron, you too can have these conversations if you sign up and are a biological relative.

817
00:54:14,420 --> 00:54:17,180
Stu:
She was like oh i knew from you know i could tell that there

818
00:54:17,180 --> 00:54:20,100
Stu:
was two different people being the mother so she picked up on it really early

819
00:54:20,100 --> 00:54:23,000
Stu:
so i think it's interesting there's the what is

820
00:54:23,000 --> 00:54:25,980
Stu:
the effect of it as a surprise but as we've talked about many times

821
00:54:25,980 --> 00:54:28,900
Stu:
surprise only works on the first watch what is really interesting

822
00:54:28,900 --> 00:54:31,720
Stu:
is when you start looking at techniques like drama or knowing the

823
00:54:31,720 --> 00:54:34,540
Stu:
outcome what do they mean on the re-watch so she

824
00:54:34,540 --> 00:54:37,280
Stu:
has done that not just for the surprise but she has to

825
00:54:37,280 --> 00:54:40,360
Stu:
be aware that some of the audience are going to be like yeah this is dramatic reenactment right

826
00:54:40,360 --> 00:54:43,300
Stu:
you know i have seen air crash investigations i know

827
00:54:43,300 --> 00:54:46,100
Stu:
what dramatic recreation looks like and so what is

828
00:54:46,100 --> 00:54:49,240
Stu:
to answer your question she's done it for for a reason and

829
00:54:49,240 --> 00:54:52,160
Stu:
i think it's because for me there's two things going on here i

830
00:54:52,160 --> 00:54:56,260
Stu:
think one she's talking about literally the stories we tell ourselves right

831
00:54:56,260 --> 00:55:01,120
Stu:
there's harry's understanding of what happened to him and i think he is inventing

832
00:55:01,120 --> 00:55:05,340
Stu:
or building up a relationship with her mother that may not be true he kind of

833
00:55:05,340 --> 00:55:10,700
Stu:
imagined more of a romance and in the same way he's kind of inflated his relationship with Sarah.

834
00:55:10,800 --> 00:55:11,920
Stu:
He suddenly feels like up to

835
00:55:11,920 --> 00:55:15,560
Stu:
three hours that like he's her dad as opposed to, you know, raising her.

836
00:55:15,840 --> 00:55:19,720
Stu:
Right. So there's on that level, that's what she's trying to do is that these

837
00:55:19,720 --> 00:55:20,440
Stu:
stories are constructed.

838
00:55:20,540 --> 00:55:24,720
Stu:
But I also think for me, my takeaway about the film is on a subconscious level,

839
00:55:24,920 --> 00:55:26,600
Stu:
I think Sarah is kind of doing therapy.

840
00:55:26,940 --> 00:55:27,340
Chas:
Right.

841
00:55:27,880 --> 00:55:32,340
Stu:
She is getting the opportunity to direct her mum, to spend time with her mum,

842
00:55:32,420 --> 00:55:35,260
Stu:
a person who died with her at like 10 or 11.

843
00:55:35,400 --> 00:55:39,440
Stu:
And I think that age of 10 or 11, your parents are still a little bit otherworldly.

844
00:55:39,620 --> 00:55:43,120
Stu:
To me, I don't think you're really, you know, I didn't really begin to think

845
00:55:43,120 --> 00:55:46,660
Stu:
of my parents as people apart from myself until like my late teens.

846
00:55:46,880 --> 00:55:49,940
Stu:
You're angry. You begin to have that moment in your teenagehood when you kind

847
00:55:49,940 --> 00:55:51,120
Stu:
of start fighting with them.

848
00:55:51,460 --> 00:55:54,820
Stu:
Right. And I think for me, I didn't have it, but I think that's true for a lot

849
00:55:54,820 --> 00:56:01,960
Stu:
of people, right? That process of children departing from their parents is like from 12 onwards.

850
00:56:02,340 --> 00:56:05,040
Stu:
I mean, maybe you're the one with kids around this age, Chaz,

851
00:56:05,220 --> 00:56:09,400
Stu:
and I think she hasn't had that moment of going and discovering who her parent

852
00:56:09,400 --> 00:56:13,320
Stu:
was as a person, and I think the film was a way of her doing that.

853
00:56:13,560 --> 00:56:16,700
Mel:
I don't think it was subconscious, though. I think she's quite conscious of

854
00:56:16,700 --> 00:56:19,940
Mel:
the fact that that's what she's doing in a lot of ways,

855
00:56:20,000 --> 00:56:24,020
Mel:
and I think that partly because I've read a lot of other things that she's written

856
00:56:24,020 --> 00:56:30,340
Mel:
about her process about her stuff on film sets and and that sort of thing oh really what is.

857
00:56:30,340 --> 00:56:31,340
Stu:
Her process on film sets.

858
00:56:31,340 --> 00:56:34,240
Mel:
Well a looking back at stuff in terms

859
00:56:34,240 --> 00:56:39,280
Mel:
of what she did as a kid on film sets but then also like for example the actors

860
00:56:39,280 --> 00:56:44,480
Mel:
roundtable after women talking talks a lot about how she encourages therapy

861
00:56:44,480 --> 00:56:49,080
Mel:
encourages people to be doing stuff like that encourages people to deal with

862
00:56:49,080 --> 00:56:52,620
Mel:
their specific trauma and talk through the things as their character,

863
00:56:52,660 --> 00:56:54,040
Mel:
as well as themselves as people.

864
00:56:54,120 --> 00:56:57,620
Mel:
So I think she's quite in touch with and interested in interrogating that on

865
00:56:57,620 --> 00:57:01,160
Mel:
a personal level outside of just this.

866
00:57:01,240 --> 00:57:05,300
Mel:
So obviously, Stories We Tell was maybe like 10 years ago, but that feels like

867
00:57:05,300 --> 00:57:07,240
Mel:
something that she's been doing for quite a long time.

868
00:57:07,360 --> 00:57:11,020
Chas:
I mean, I'm interested in the effect on the audience of this decision.

869
00:57:11,080 --> 00:57:15,360
Chas:
I agree with you that that's what she's doing, like what she's trying to explore,

870
00:57:15,500 --> 00:57:16,700
Chas:
what she's trying to communicate.

871
00:57:16,700 --> 00:57:21,400
Chas:
Kate, I'm interested as to what was the effect on the audience and,

872
00:57:21,420 --> 00:57:26,800
Chas:
you know, on, on Sandra having that reveal or having that exploration,

873
00:57:26,900 --> 00:57:30,240
Chas:
even if you, if you twigged earlier as you both did,

874
00:57:30,480 --> 00:57:32,620
Chas:
what was the effect of that?

875
00:57:32,780 --> 00:57:36,960
Chas:
Some archival footage, some not that, that kind of recreation that.

876
00:57:37,080 --> 00:57:40,660
Stu:
What I liked about it is even though I was kind of suspicious,

877
00:57:40,820 --> 00:57:44,720
Stu:
it was just done so casually, the transition into her directing.

878
00:57:44,800 --> 00:57:46,500
Stu:
And they'd done a really good job of, we definitely had.

879
00:57:46,700 --> 00:57:52,120
Stu:
B-roll or C-roll, really, of her shooting cutaways on her Super 8.

880
00:57:52,220 --> 00:57:56,240
Stu:
So it wasn't a sudden surprise. We knew that she was shooting stuff herself on a film camera.

881
00:57:56,320 --> 00:57:57,200
Mel:
She foreshadowed it.

882
00:57:57,440 --> 00:58:02,100
Stu:
And then they kind of just do it and you're like, oh, right? Yeah.

883
00:58:02,220 --> 00:58:06,080
Stu:
Because you are now wondering, it's kind of like mythologizing.

884
00:58:06,440 --> 00:58:09,960
Stu:
It's the difference between facts and emotional truth, if you know what I mean.

885
00:58:10,160 --> 00:58:10,720
Chas:
Yeah, absolutely.

886
00:58:11,060 --> 00:58:15,120
Stu:
Like there is a difference between these are the facts of what happened and this is the impact of it.

887
00:58:15,160 --> 00:58:19,340
Stu:
And I actually really like Harry's speech about the players and the impact on

888
00:58:19,340 --> 00:58:21,480
Stu:
the people around them and all that kind of stuff.

889
00:58:21,620 --> 00:58:25,780
Stu:
And then her insistence that she's got to explore all sides because really it's

890
00:58:25,780 --> 00:58:29,660
Stu:
people's interpretation of the events that what matters more than the event itself,

891
00:58:29,880 --> 00:58:33,440
Stu:
in particularly in something like this i would say no that's not true it's not

892
00:58:33,440 --> 00:58:37,640
Stu:
i mean obviously what matters is she was born there is quite a literal outcome

893
00:58:37,640 --> 00:58:41,540
Stu:
but the kind of the emotional reality about it is constructed by people's interpretation

894
00:58:41,540 --> 00:58:43,240
Stu:
of what happened not yeah.

895
00:58:43,240 --> 00:58:48,300
Mel:
She makes such notable switches between different

896
00:58:48,300 --> 00:58:51,140
Mel:
techniques and between different styles and between

897
00:58:51,140 --> 00:58:56,460
Mel:
one person saying something and then a person in a different interview re-examining

898
00:58:56,460 --> 00:59:01,000
Mel:
that and i think the effect on the audience the The effect that it has is to

899
00:59:01,000 --> 00:59:06,060
Mel:
make us feel through the story of people that we do not know the same thing

900
00:59:06,060 --> 00:59:08,400
Mel:
that we experience a lot in our lives,

901
00:59:08,520 --> 00:59:11,140
Mel:
which is where, you know, you get to a point where you've told the story a certain

902
00:59:11,140 --> 00:59:12,960
Mel:
number of times and you think,

903
00:59:13,080 --> 00:59:19,460
Mel:
am I lying to myself with air quotes or have I misremembered this and it simply

904
00:59:19,460 --> 00:59:20,620
Mel:
becomes cemented as fact?

905
00:59:20,680 --> 00:59:24,240
Mel:
Or am I telling things that I think the audience wants to hear versus am I telling

906
00:59:24,240 --> 00:59:27,380
Mel:
myself what I want to hear versus do I even know the truth?

907
00:59:27,480 --> 00:59:32,040
Mel:
Am I just guessing? And you have these stories where things are sort of ephemeral

908
00:59:32,040 --> 00:59:36,820
Mel:
and they've become shaped over time and you lose track of where one begins and the other ends.

909
00:59:36,880 --> 00:59:44,260
Mel:
And I think she's literally creating that emotion by mimicking it with visuals.

910
00:59:45,330 --> 00:59:50,210
Mel:
And I think that's a really fascinating, incredible use of documentary.

911
00:59:50,690 --> 00:59:55,610
Chas:
And she, like we said at the beginning, in the summary, that it's all about Sarah, right?

912
00:59:55,850 --> 01:00:01,750
Chas:
But she only appears on screen as the filmmaker, right? Yeah.

913
01:00:01,870 --> 01:00:05,530
Stu:
She's never interviewed. She never talks directly to camera and she doesn't give her voiceover.

914
01:00:05,830 --> 01:00:10,790
Mel:
Nope. You hear her off camera asking questions sometimes and you see her obviously filming.

915
01:00:11,170 --> 01:00:13,350
Chas:
But that's her as the filmmaker. filmmaker it's.

916
01:00:13,350 --> 01:00:19,590
Mel:
Her as filmmaker but sometimes she is clearly asking something as a filmmaker but also as a sister.

917
01:00:19,590 --> 01:00:20,590
Chas:
Yeah but also.

918
01:00:20,590 --> 01:00:23,750
Mel:
As a friend like like there's context to things she's asking which makes her

919
01:00:23,750 --> 01:00:25,270
Mel:
more than just one thing but.

920
01:00:25,270 --> 01:00:29,670
Chas:
She's never the subject of the movie in the way that these other people on screen

921
01:00:29,670 --> 01:00:34,130
Chas:
are the subject of the movie absolutely not the closest she comes to being the

922
01:00:34,130 --> 01:00:38,990
Chas:
subject is almost the most artificial part of the whole movie which is where

923
01:00:38,990 --> 01:00:42,870
Chas:
she does as the reenactment of her first meeting with Harry in that cafe.

924
01:00:43,170 --> 01:00:44,470
Stu:
I was about to bring that up, yeah.

925
01:00:44,650 --> 01:00:50,390
Chas:
Where they've got coverage and they've got her saying in voiceover lines that

926
01:00:50,390 --> 01:00:52,450
Chas:
she's kind of over-performing.

927
01:00:52,510 --> 01:00:54,390
Mel:
Feels like big brother, it's great.

928
01:00:54,630 --> 01:00:58,990
Chas:
Yeah, and that all feels like deliberate choices that she doesn't,

929
01:00:58,990 --> 01:01:03,290
Chas:
as much as this is about her and her discovery about her own parentage,

930
01:01:04,090 --> 01:01:07,070
Chas:
she as the filmmaker is really trying to avoid that,

931
01:01:07,560 --> 01:01:09,100
Chas:
being the subject of the documentary.

932
01:01:09,580 --> 01:01:13,280
Stu:
I mean, I think that scene is great because we know from a storytelling point

933
01:01:13,280 --> 01:01:16,560
Stu:
of view that she's 18 and it's clearly her at her current age.

934
01:01:16,660 --> 01:01:18,040
Stu:
They haven't even tried to young her up.

935
01:01:18,180 --> 01:01:21,520
Stu:
It's Harry as he is, not as he was when they met. And that's what I mean about

936
01:01:21,520 --> 01:01:25,560
Stu:
time being weird because they haven't bothered.

937
01:01:25,780 --> 01:01:28,160
Stu:
They could have recast it. They could have recast someone as her.

938
01:01:28,320 --> 01:01:29,780
Stu:
I mean, she was a public figure.

939
01:01:29,880 --> 01:01:32,780
Stu:
You probably have an idea of what she looked like at 18, but they They could

940
01:01:32,780 --> 01:01:35,300
Stu:
have made some attempt to make it period correct.

941
01:01:35,460 --> 01:01:40,200
Stu:
But what I loved about it is, yeah, it feels a little bit, you know,

942
01:01:40,900 --> 01:01:45,280
Stu:
air crash investigations or, you know, the first 48 or one of those kind of

943
01:01:45,280 --> 01:01:48,480
Stu:
like cable TV shows where it's like, we're going to get the people involved

944
01:01:48,480 --> 01:01:51,220
Stu:
to kind of reenact this crime scene moment.

945
01:01:52,920 --> 01:01:58,000
Stu:
But not trying to make it as it was. And it is a curious effect because I think

946
01:01:58,000 --> 01:02:01,760
Stu:
something that's so personal, she's kind of distancing herself from it, right? Right.

947
01:02:01,800 --> 01:02:05,720
Stu:
So as much as the film was about her story, but she is not the subject of it,

948
01:02:05,760 --> 01:02:07,080
Stu:
even though it's about her.

949
01:02:07,580 --> 01:02:12,540
Stu:
So it's kind of this really interesting thing that a sense of who Sarah is is

950
01:02:12,540 --> 01:02:14,560
Stu:
kind of created in the negative space.

951
01:02:14,900 --> 01:02:18,940
Stu:
The absences of her in front of the camera give us an impression of who she is.

952
01:02:19,100 --> 01:02:23,380
Chas:
And one of the main times that we see her outside of that reenactment is when

953
01:02:23,380 --> 01:02:28,540
Chas:
she's directing her father's reading of his material, of his voiceover.

954
01:02:28,740 --> 01:02:33,940
Chas:
And it is always shooting her in profile. never straight on and it's often just

955
01:02:33,940 --> 01:02:39,720
Chas:
as I was losing myself in the filmmaking it would cut back to her saying please say that line again was.

956
01:02:39,720 --> 01:02:49,920
Excerpts:
It Tom or Wayne or Jeff you could just take back that one line yeah was it Tom or Wayne or Jeff.

957
01:02:49,920 --> 01:02:52,940
Chas:
It's reminding us that this is a construction

958
01:02:52,940 --> 01:02:56,980
Chas:
it's reminding us that this was performative and

959
01:02:56,980 --> 01:03:00,020
Chas:
it does that throughout like that moment where she's deliberately telling us

960
01:03:00,020 --> 01:03:02,880
Chas:
where she's showing us her directing the person we

961
01:03:02,880 --> 01:03:06,220
Chas:
thought was her mother you know it's telling us like

962
01:03:06,220 --> 01:03:08,960
Chas:
you guys said that you know it's called stories we tell

963
01:03:08,960 --> 01:03:12,040
Chas:
and so you've referenced that wonderful speech

964
01:03:12,040 --> 01:03:14,880
Chas:
about harry about how he feels an

965
01:03:14,880 --> 01:03:17,940
Chas:
ownership of this story that she's

966
01:03:17,940 --> 01:03:22,220
Chas:
denying him because it says you know her dad wrote 40 pages or something that

967
01:03:22,220 --> 01:03:27,940
Chas:
he reads out uh sorry her her the person who raised her mick i mean she calls

968
01:03:27,940 --> 01:03:33,120
Chas:
him his dad so yeah and her biological father harry also wrote something that

969
01:03:33,120 --> 01:03:37,500
Chas:
he does not get to read out to us he has interviews so.

970
01:03:37,500 --> 01:03:42,220
Excerpts:
What do you think of the concept of me making this documentary where we're sort

971
01:03:42,220 --> 01:03:48,160
Excerpts:
of giving equal weight to everyone's version of the story i don't like it i

972
01:03:48,160 --> 01:03:51,880
Excerpts:
i i think that that takes us into.

973
01:03:53,640 --> 01:04:00,040
Excerpts:
Into very wooly like I see you can't ever touch bottom with anything then We're

974
01:04:00,040 --> 01:04:01,740
Excerpts:
all we're all over the place.

975
01:04:01,860 --> 01:04:05,720
Excerpts:
I think they can all be heard It's it's giving them equal weight,

976
01:04:05,880 --> 01:04:08,720
Excerpts:
which I find particularly those who are non,

977
01:04:09,360 --> 01:04:14,840
Excerpts:
Players first of all there are the parties to an incident those who are there

978
01:04:14,840 --> 01:04:20,460
Excerpts:
and who are directly affected by it Then there is a circle around that of people

979
01:04:20,460 --> 01:04:25,320
Excerpts:
who were affected acted tangentially because of their relationship to the principal parties.

980
01:04:25,580 --> 01:04:29,040
Excerpts:
And then there's another concentric circle further out there,

981
01:04:29,680 --> 01:04:33,580
Excerpts:
which basically has heard or been told by one of the principal players about

982
01:04:33,580 --> 01:04:36,740
Excerpts:
it. And all of these may have different narratives.

983
01:04:37,020 --> 01:04:42,020
Excerpts:
And these narratives are shaped in part by their relationship to the person

984
01:04:42,020 --> 01:04:44,080
Excerpts:
who told it to them and by the events.

985
01:04:44,400 --> 01:04:48,620
Excerpts:
One does not get the truth simply by hearing what their reactions are.

986
01:04:48,620 --> 01:04:52,240
Excerpts:
People tend to declare themselves in terms of what they saw,

987
01:04:52,360 --> 01:04:55,100
Excerpts:
in terms of what they felt, in terms of what they remembered,

988
01:04:55,280 --> 01:04:56,880
Excerpts:
and in terms of their loyalties.

989
01:04:57,160 --> 01:05:02,960
Excerpts:
The same set of circumstances will affect different people in different ways.

990
01:05:03,120 --> 01:05:04,340
Excerpts:
Not that there are different truths.

991
01:05:04,560 --> 01:05:07,480
Excerpts:
There are different reactions to particular events.

992
01:05:09,100 --> 01:05:11,300
Excerpts:
The crucial function of art is to

993
01:05:11,300 --> 01:05:14,740
Excerpts:
tell the truth, to find the truth in a situation. That's what it's about.

994
01:05:16,060 --> 01:05:20,040
Chas:
Boat and to me that seemed like a very deliberate choice that she didn't invite

995
01:05:20,040 --> 01:05:23,860
Chas:
harry into the sound booth to give a voiceover or.

996
01:05:23,860 --> 01:05:26,860
Mel:
She did and then didn't use it but we'll never know yeah and

997
01:05:26,860 --> 01:05:30,980
Mel:
harry harry's the one who calls this entire exercise

998
01:05:30,980 --> 01:05:34,260
Mel:
he says it's concentric layers and

999
01:05:34,260 --> 01:05:36,980
Mel:
that was like my theme for this whole thing and like when

1000
01:05:36,980 --> 01:05:40,480
Mel:
he's talking about that that is this film it's all concentric layers both in

1001
01:05:40,480 --> 01:05:45,980
Mel:
reality it's all concentric layers of truth and fiction and what we remember

1002
01:05:45,980 --> 01:05:51,360
Mel:
what we don't want to remember what our brains have uh scrubbed and also the

1003
01:05:51,360 --> 01:05:55,580
Mel:
process of making a film is the same look.

1004
01:05:55,580 --> 01:06:00,040
Chas:
This film is also like particularly that third act particularly that debate

1005
01:06:00,040 --> 01:06:03,960
Chas:
that harry is having with sarah you know where the things were getting tense

1006
01:06:03,960 --> 01:06:10,140
Chas:
between them over his desire to celebrate their relationship and her desire

1007
01:06:10,140 --> 01:06:15,240
Chas:
to protect her father from the pain of learning that she is not his biological child.

1008
01:06:15,740 --> 01:06:21,260
Chas:
And in that tension, in those moments, her emails, she reads them out in voiceover,

1009
01:06:21,320 --> 01:06:24,780
Chas:
but she's never on screen when she's reading them out. We're on other things happening.

1010
01:06:25,200 --> 01:06:30,220
Excerpts:
You reacted very, very strongly, very, very strongly to it. You were enraged

1011
01:06:30,220 --> 01:06:32,680
Excerpts:
and you were very upset. Hi there Harry.

1012
01:06:33,260 --> 01:06:36,440
Excerpts:
I suppose I'm confused as to why it's such a pressing issue for you that this

1013
01:06:36,440 --> 01:06:40,600
Excerpts:
story be public, when it is already known by everyone we love and everyone who loves us.

1014
01:06:41,820 --> 01:06:44,620
Excerpts:
As I said, while my dad has had some time to deal with the news,

1015
01:06:44,820 --> 01:06:48,040
Excerpts:
he has not yet had to tell his friends or answer any questions from anyone outside

1016
01:06:48,040 --> 01:06:49,000
Excerpts:
of his immediate family.

1017
01:06:51,040 --> 01:06:54,060
Excerpts:
This space and privacy has been important for him, and I believe strongly in

1018
01:06:54,060 --> 01:06:55,480
Excerpts:
protecting that for as long as possible.

1019
01:06:55,900 --> 01:06:59,740
Stu:
And do we know whether they're actually emails that were contemporary?

1020
01:07:00,200 --> 01:07:04,200
Chas:
Yeah, we don't. And she's deliberately making us question those things.

1021
01:07:04,280 --> 01:07:09,700
Chas:
She's deliberately drawing our attention to the making of this story.

1022
01:07:10,420 --> 01:07:16,280
Chas:
But unlike Adaptation, where I feel like in Adaptation, it was a story about

1023
01:07:16,280 --> 01:07:19,200
Chas:
the telling of itself so that it could allow,

1024
01:07:19,400 --> 01:07:22,660
Chas:
like you said, Stu, for us to get lost in the kind of character moments,

1025
01:07:22,740 --> 01:07:26,080
Chas:
to actually genuinely get lost in Charlie and Donald's moments here.

1026
01:07:26,320 --> 01:07:29,820
Chas:
I feel like this one is deliberately distancing us.

1027
01:07:30,100 --> 01:07:34,300
Chas:
I mean, I find it a very affecting emotional film, so I don't mean distancing emotionally.

1028
01:07:34,900 --> 01:07:38,040
Stu:
I did find it distancing emotionally, which is interesting. Cool.

1029
01:07:38,180 --> 01:07:41,440
Stu:
I wouldn't say cold. I was just like, the film is cool.

1030
01:07:41,440 --> 01:07:46,980
Chas:
But to me, it was deliberately pushing us back so that we start exploring those

1031
01:07:46,980 --> 01:07:51,840
Chas:
intellectual ideas about truth, about storytelling, about family,

1032
01:07:51,920 --> 01:07:54,700
Chas:
about myths, about who we are.

1033
01:07:55,280 --> 01:07:58,920
Stu:
I want to go through these levers again. I'm going to start with the first one

1034
01:07:58,920 --> 01:08:02,200
Stu:
because I think what you've kind of identified is, interestingly,

1035
01:08:02,400 --> 01:08:03,300
Stu:
it's similar to adaptation.

1036
01:08:03,620 --> 01:08:08,060
Stu:
The lever is the communication diegetic. I think pretty much I would define

1037
01:08:08,060 --> 01:08:13,120
Stu:
that the communication in this film is diegetic because we see it being created

1038
01:08:13,120 --> 01:08:14,260
Stu:
in the world of the documentary.

1039
01:08:14,400 --> 01:08:20,220
Stu:
We see him in the voiceover booth. We see him, you know, we see the characters talking to the camera.

1040
01:08:20,300 --> 01:08:24,440
Stu:
We kind of hear Sarah talking in the presence, like off camera,

1041
01:08:24,540 --> 01:08:27,100
Stu:
like she might be off mic, but she's in the room with the actors.

1042
01:08:27,140 --> 01:08:29,260
Stu:
She's literally in the world with these characters.

1043
01:08:29,380 --> 01:08:33,180
Stu:
She is not doing a voiceover that she's written later on.

1044
01:08:33,920 --> 01:08:38,880
Stu:
Over the film, right? So, I think that's interesting in terms of the kind of voice communication.

1045
01:08:39,200 --> 01:08:43,920
Stu:
It is diegetic. Obviously, the film is edited and she has shot stuff to construct it.

1046
01:08:44,000 --> 01:08:45,440
Stu:
So, there's stuff that's there,

1047
01:08:45,500 --> 01:08:48,700
Stu:
but the kind of communication is broadly diegetic within the story world.

1048
01:08:48,880 --> 01:08:52,820
Chas:
Yeah. I mean, in documentary, almost everything is quote-unquote diegetic.

1049
01:08:52,960 --> 01:08:57,780
Chas:
Can we ask that question about in-story world versus not in-story world?

1050
01:08:57,840 --> 01:09:02,120
Chas:
Because I feel like that archival footage, whether it is archival footage and

1051
01:09:02,120 --> 01:09:06,140
Chas:
when it's recreation is presented as the same that to me is then pulling a lever

1052
01:09:06,140 --> 01:09:11,940
Chas:
in this area where we're being made to think these siblings are on camera it's.

1053
01:09:11,940 --> 01:09:15,600
Mel:
Also hard because a documentary is a slightly different beast right.

1054
01:09:15,600 --> 01:09:19,740
Stu:
Yeah but i mean that's what i'm saying is interesting yeah that's why i'm trying

1055
01:09:19,740 --> 01:09:25,080
Stu:
to articulate it that that like she is not yeah doing audio commentary over

1056
01:09:25,080 --> 01:09:29,920
Stu:
reenactment for footage or recording like and i began to think that we should

1057
01:09:29,920 --> 01:09:32,800
Stu:
you know that we literally hear her in the world of the environment.

1058
01:09:32,980 --> 01:09:36,800
Stu:
So, we've talked about they keep on cutting to her in the voice recording booth giving direction.

1059
01:09:37,040 --> 01:09:39,400
Stu:
We see her in the interview spaces.

1060
01:09:39,660 --> 01:09:44,080
Stu:
We see her direct people, but we don't hear as an omniscient third-person narrator,

1061
01:09:44,380 --> 01:09:46,880
Stu:
right? Or later on presenting to camera.

1062
01:09:47,120 --> 01:09:51,120
Stu:
And what is interesting is even compared to a documentary, the kind of presentational

1063
01:09:51,120 --> 01:09:52,840
Stu:
documentaries like Supersize Me, right?

1064
01:09:52,900 --> 01:09:56,680
Stu:
Or the kind of stuff you'd see on TikTok or YouTube, she's not even a presenter, right?

1065
01:09:56,780 --> 01:10:01,020
Stu:
That stuff is also kind of diegetic, but it kind of feels like it's detached

1066
01:10:01,020 --> 01:10:04,460
Stu:
from the moment she is definitely presenting herself as being part of the physical

1067
01:10:04,460 --> 01:10:08,220
Stu:
worlds of these characters the people that we know and.

1068
01:10:08,220 --> 01:10:13,440
Chas:
Maybe that's why the her reading the emails stood out to us because they were

1069
01:10:13,440 --> 01:10:15,560
Chas:
non-diegetic in a way like.

1070
01:10:15,560 --> 01:10:19,980
Stu:
Yeah and we don't see the emails on screen yeah but she still has constructed

1071
01:10:19,980 --> 01:10:23,780
Stu:
them if they are artificial which we've put a question mark over them are they

1072
01:10:23,780 --> 01:10:28,220
Stu:
written as you know in reality tv as interview or a voiceover that they use

1073
01:10:28,220 --> 01:10:31,220
Stu:
to patch something together? Is it something written in the future, right?

1074
01:10:31,300 --> 01:10:33,680
Stu:
Or, you know, one of my favorite films that we've done before,

1075
01:10:33,880 --> 01:10:38,560
Stu:
Sans Soleil, where these letters are completely made up, but they're just a structuring device.

1076
01:10:38,860 --> 01:10:41,780
Stu:
They could be completely made up, but she's chosen to make them feel like they're

1077
01:10:41,780 --> 01:10:42,960
Stu:
part of this story world.

1078
01:10:43,140 --> 01:10:47,740
Stu:
In the same way that she's chosen to do reenactments and has not gone reenactments,

1079
01:10:47,860 --> 01:10:50,080
Stu:
right, until she's chosen to reveal it.

1080
01:10:50,920 --> 01:10:54,580
Stu:
So, the other levers then is how much control do the storytellers have over

1081
01:10:54,580 --> 01:10:59,380
Stu:
the story? What is interesting about this is I think there's definitely Sarah has all the control.

1082
01:10:59,780 --> 01:11:00,320
Chas:
Yes.

1083
01:11:01,300 --> 01:11:06,740
Stu:
But there is a sense that there is a degree of awareness that this relates to

1084
01:11:06,740 --> 01:11:09,400
Stu:
the awareness that the characters are obviously all aware that they're in a documentary.

1085
01:11:09,520 --> 01:11:12,660
Stu:
It's not an odd doc where the characters just get used to the camera.

1086
01:11:13,000 --> 01:11:16,240
Stu:
They're clearly, it's not like she's just tagging around people for two years

1087
01:11:16,240 --> 01:11:19,760
Stu:
and they know the, or that they're doing the hidden cam kind of stuff that is,

1088
01:11:19,820 --> 01:11:23,680
Stu:
you know, another film that we talked about doing for this episode was Zone of Interest.

1089
01:11:23,680 --> 01:11:27,500
Stu:
And Zone of Interest is playing around with kind of the spy camera,

1090
01:11:27,540 --> 01:11:28,480
Stu:
the surveillance aesthetic.

1091
01:11:28,580 --> 01:11:30,960
Stu:
But that's deliberately something they were doing in Zone of Interest.

1092
01:11:30,960 --> 01:11:35,940
Stu:
They literally had all the cameras were remote controlled and Jonathan Glazer

1093
01:11:35,940 --> 01:11:38,260
Stu:
sat in a truck to not be in the space.

1094
01:11:38,500 --> 01:11:42,280
Stu:
He chose to not be in the space with the actors to give it this really detached

1095
01:11:42,280 --> 01:11:45,760
Stu:
observational style. And this is the opposite.

1096
01:11:46,040 --> 01:11:48,640
Stu:
That's why I'm drawing that, that they've made a decision that the filmmaker

1097
01:11:48,640 --> 01:11:52,060
Stu:
is in the physical world of the actors. And they're aware of that.

1098
01:11:52,200 --> 01:11:53,580
Stu:
And they're aware that they're in a doco.

1099
01:11:54,040 --> 01:11:58,820
Chas:
And most importantly, the communication to the audience. We're being made aware of it.

1100
01:11:58,820 --> 01:12:02,760
Chas:
Sarah, not only does she have control of the narrative, not only are the characters

1101
01:12:02,760 --> 01:12:06,340
Chas:
all aware they're in a film, she is making sure and reminding us as the viewer

1102
01:12:06,340 --> 01:12:12,240
Chas:
constantly that this is a movie and that she's in control of how and when it's being presented.

1103
01:12:12,860 --> 01:12:17,760
Mel:
Yeah. Well, for me, and we can use this as a segue, we landed on adaptation.

1104
01:12:18,220 --> 01:12:21,300
Mel:
I really wanted to do Stories We Tell because Stu wanted to do a documentary.

1105
01:12:21,560 --> 01:12:23,800
Mel:
This feels perfect. It's one of my favorite documentaries ever.

1106
01:12:24,180 --> 01:12:28,020
Mel:
It's incredibly meta. But once we picked the two and I started thinking was

1107
01:12:28,020 --> 01:12:29,820
Mel:
when I came with 40 year old version.

1108
01:12:29,880 --> 01:12:36,220
Mel:
I think 40 year old version plays in both of these sandboxes in really interesting ways.

1109
01:12:36,320 --> 01:12:39,660
Mel:
We have on one end of the spectrum kind of we have a narrative fiction.

1110
01:12:39,960 --> 01:12:44,660
Mel:
And on the other end of the spectrum, we have a documentary and 40 year old

1111
01:12:44,660 --> 01:12:49,380
Mel:
version is so interesting and how at first glance, I think Chaz,

1112
01:12:49,460 --> 01:12:52,900
Mel:
maybe like you'd started watching and then you messaged and was like,

1113
01:12:52,980 --> 01:12:56,180
Mel:
I've really I'm not 100% sold on this being,

1114
01:12:56,240 --> 01:12:58,980
Mel:
you know, so the film talking directly to us mel

1115
01:12:58,980 --> 01:13:02,380
Mel:
and i'm like just wait for it but i do think that it's

1116
01:13:02,380 --> 01:13:05,160
Mel:
it's more subtle but part of it is

1117
01:13:05,160 --> 01:13:08,360
Mel:
because rata's just not famous right everyone

1118
01:13:08,360 --> 01:13:11,500
Mel:
knows who sarah paulie is everyone in the filmmaking world

1119
01:13:11,500 --> 01:13:14,260
Mel:
does at least right and she plays with that

1120
01:13:14,260 --> 01:13:17,620
Mel:
and nicholas cage insanely famous

1121
01:13:17,620 --> 01:13:22,420
Mel:
charlie kaufman somewhat famous has done a lot of big things in film and rata's

1122
01:13:22,420 --> 01:13:30,460
Mel:
not so she She both has to push things harder and can do the exact same blatant

1123
01:13:30,460 --> 01:13:34,000
Mel:
techniques without actually feeling as much like she's talking directly to us

1124
01:13:34,000 --> 01:13:37,240
Mel:
as Sarah or Charlie can, which I think is fascinating.

1125
01:13:37,480 --> 01:13:42,040
Mel:
And so as soon as we determined the adaptation stories we tell,

1126
01:13:42,100 --> 01:13:46,780
Mel:
I just felt like 40-year-old version was a really natural fit in terms of playing

1127
01:13:46,780 --> 01:13:50,920
Mel:
with not just all these levers, but the specific techniques that these films play with.

1128
01:13:54,060 --> 01:13:57,620
Excerpts:
Any more thought on what kind of play we want to write? Remember,

1129
01:13:57,900 --> 01:14:00,740
Excerpts:
if you put in nothing, it'll be nothing. Like your career?

1130
01:14:02,840 --> 01:14:07,880
Excerpts:
Remember this face? She was one of Spotlight Magazine's 30 Under 30 playwrights

1131
01:14:07,880 --> 01:14:10,200
Excerpts:
to watch. We watched, but where'd she go?

1132
01:14:12,180 --> 01:14:15,740
Excerpts:
How are you? Archie tells me you're teaching.

1133
01:14:17,300 --> 01:14:20,400
Excerpts:
How's somebody who ain't had no real hit gonna tell me how to write a play?

1134
01:14:20,500 --> 01:14:21,360
Excerpts:
She ain't no Tyler Perry.

1135
01:14:21,960 --> 01:14:25,840
Excerpts:
I did win a 30 Under 30. Yes, it was quite a couple of years ago.

1136
01:14:25,960 --> 01:14:29,040
Excerpts:
What do I got to do? Write a slave musical? An all-white play?

1137
01:14:30,040 --> 01:14:35,520
Excerpts:
This some bullshit. It rang a little inauthentic. I asked myself,

1138
01:14:35,620 --> 01:14:37,320
Excerpts:
did a black person really write this?

1139
01:14:39,340 --> 01:14:44,740
Excerpts:
This some fucking bullshit. Bullshit. Think about me doing hip-hop.

1140
01:14:45,340 --> 01:14:50,580
Excerpts:
Doing what to it? I want to make a mixtape about the 40-year-old woman's point of view.

1141
01:14:52,100 --> 01:15:00,420
Excerpts:
Why my skin so dry why am i yawning right now why them aarp niggas sending shit to my house this is 40.

1142
01:15:03,200 --> 01:15:09,600
Stu:
So nothing suits the themes of the 40 year old version than a middle-aged white

1143
01:15:09,600 --> 01:15:15,560
Stu:
man explaining black culture you know like with all the controversy about break

1144
01:15:15,560 --> 01:15:18,740
Stu:
dancing i started I'm starting to get irritated with all these white people

1145
01:15:18,740 --> 01:15:21,080
Stu:
talking about breakdancing. They actually are awesome, my friend.

1146
01:15:21,100 --> 01:15:24,340
Mel:
White Australians as well. Like, oh my God.

1147
01:15:24,700 --> 01:15:28,640
Chas:
Can we date this so that the future people know that we're talking about?

1148
01:15:28,720 --> 01:15:32,300
Mel:
The Olympics closing ceremonies were yesterday. Olympics 2024.

1149
01:15:33,280 --> 01:15:36,440
Chas:
The first time that breaking has been an Olympic sport.

1150
01:15:36,900 --> 01:15:37,700
Mel:
And likely last.

1151
01:15:38,220 --> 01:15:45,260
Chas:
And the Australian Olympic representative, Reagan, has been memed to fuck.

1152
01:15:45,540 --> 01:15:46,620
Mel:
Verbally excorciated.

1153
01:15:46,760 --> 01:15:51,040
Chas:
Yeah. Well, I mean, a lot of the memes are quite joyful, I think.

1154
01:15:51,140 --> 01:15:52,240
Mel:
Some real good memes.

1155
01:15:52,640 --> 01:15:54,340
Chas:
I'm having a great fun with it.

1156
01:15:54,520 --> 01:15:58,080
Mel:
The Nosferatu candle might be my favorite.

1157
01:15:58,360 --> 01:16:03,400
Chas:
But it has triggered a whole, and I think quite healthy discussion on cultural

1158
01:16:03,400 --> 01:16:08,360
Chas:
appropriation, on whether it's homage or not, or participation,

1159
01:16:08,960 --> 01:16:14,620
Chas:
how Australia picks its Olympic athletes in the the dancing competition,

1160
01:16:14,920 --> 01:16:16,040
Chas:
all this other kind of stuff.

1161
01:16:16,140 --> 01:16:20,980
Chas:
So it's actually quite fitting that we watched this movie right at this time.

1162
01:16:21,120 --> 01:16:24,520
Mel:
Yes, but we are not here for appropriation, but for Stu to give us appreciation.

1163
01:16:26,380 --> 01:16:29,680
Stu:
So it's a kind of a biopic about...

1164
01:16:30,260 --> 01:16:33,320
Stu:
Writer blank who's a teacher approaching 40

1165
01:16:33,320 --> 01:16:36,660
Stu:
living kind of like a very

1166
01:16:36,660 --> 01:16:39,400
Stu:
similar frustration of kind of like a charlie

1167
01:16:39,400 --> 01:16:43,640
Stu:
kaufman like classic frustrated writer living in a small apartment she is in

1168
01:16:43,640 --> 01:16:48,120
Stu:
harlem right teaching kids at a local school she even references dangerous minds

1169
01:16:48,120 --> 01:16:52,680
Stu:
right you know she's teaching struggling kids and there's kind of two parallel

1170
01:16:52,680 --> 01:16:56,260
Stu:
storylines that are going on right can't remember which one triggers which but

1171
01:16:56,260 --> 01:16:58,120
Stu:
one is her kind of selling out writing

1172
01:16:58,200 --> 01:17:03,900
Stu:
a play called Harlem Avenue for a wealthy white theater producer called Jay Whitnum,

1173
01:17:04,000 --> 01:17:07,560
Stu:
who basically wants it to be more authentic and more suffering.

1174
01:17:07,700 --> 01:17:09,820
Stu:
And that's one of the great exchanges that it felt like, man,

1175
01:17:09,900 --> 01:17:13,480
Stu:
I'm sure there are people of color who have had exchanges with people at film

1176
01:17:13,480 --> 01:17:17,200
Stu:
agencies that feel like this, where it's people like, hmm, I had to ask myself,

1177
01:17:17,280 --> 01:17:18,620
Stu:
is this written by a black person?

1178
01:17:19,620 --> 01:17:28,000
Excerpts:
That's it? No, no, no, no. It's about gentrification and how this young couple

1179
01:17:28,000 --> 01:17:33,000
Excerpts:
struggles to you didn't like it. The idea is powerful. But?

1180
01:17:33,400 --> 01:17:36,140
Excerpts:
It rang a little inauthentic.

1181
01:17:37,400 --> 01:17:43,020
Excerpts:
Okay, well thank you for that note. I appreciate it. But there's something there.

1182
01:17:43,200 --> 01:17:46,020
Excerpts:
Okay. I just wish you hadn't shied away from darkness.

1183
01:17:46,240 --> 01:17:50,440
Excerpts:
I mean, if you're gonna call it Harlem Ave, you gotta give me Harlem Ave.

1184
01:17:50,880 --> 01:17:54,940
Excerpts:
I should write in a teen mother. shooting up in an alley. No, no, no.

1185
01:17:57,060 --> 01:18:00,480
Excerpts:
No, you're missing my point. I'm talking about gentrification.

1186
01:18:00,920 --> 01:18:04,820
Excerpts:
A black Harlem shifting under a white hipster land grab.

1187
01:18:05,400 --> 01:18:10,320
Excerpts:
But your play never goes there. I ask myself, did a black person really write this?

1188
01:18:11,500 --> 01:18:16,140
Stu:
And she's just like, what the fuck? And it's her kind of, her story of dealing

1189
01:18:16,140 --> 01:18:20,220
Stu:
with that struggle and it's paralleling her interest in exploring rapping,

1190
01:18:20,540 --> 01:18:22,800
Stu:
which she apparently did as a kid.

1191
01:18:22,900 --> 01:18:25,460
Stu:
And that's it. So it's the story of her putting on the play,

1192
01:18:25,640 --> 01:18:29,800
Stu:
her exploring a rapping career at the kind of the two main, the A and the B plot.

1193
01:18:29,840 --> 01:18:32,260
Stu:
The C plot is her teaching these kids theater.

1194
01:18:32,380 --> 01:18:35,680
Stu:
And there's a kind of like a D plot, which is her romantic escapades.

1195
01:18:36,200 --> 01:18:40,680
Stu:
It does feel like it's hitting these traits. What's fun about it is it is hitting

1196
01:18:40,680 --> 01:18:44,900
Stu:
the traits of both the artistic story and elements of black cinema,

1197
01:18:45,020 --> 01:18:46,220
Stu:
which I wish I knew more about.

1198
01:18:46,220 --> 01:18:50,520
Stu:
But I've seen enough, particularly Spike Lee, to be like the homeless man across

1199
01:18:50,520 --> 01:18:54,020
Stu:
the road who kind of drops science towards the film and the film kind of hangs

1200
01:18:54,020 --> 01:18:56,940
Stu:
shit on that and the kind of references to Dangerous Mind and all that kind of stuff.

1201
01:18:57,040 --> 01:19:01,940
Stu:
He's playing around the cliches of Black Sinatol for a white audience, I think.

1202
01:19:03,320 --> 01:19:04,920
Excerpts:
Seriously, it would mean a lot if you came.

1203
01:19:08,920 --> 01:19:16,580
Excerpts:
Archie. Give a bitch a chance, man. Her desperation's making me nauseous.

1204
01:19:16,600 --> 01:19:20,620
Excerpts:
Although technically, you gotta eat something to throw up. Know what I mean?

1205
01:19:21,330 --> 01:19:25,750
Chas:
Similar to a way how American fiction did, which we were also talking about.

1206
01:19:25,990 --> 01:19:27,970
Mel:
I think it would make a great double feature with Nope.

1207
01:19:28,710 --> 01:19:29,110
Chas:
Okay.

1208
01:19:29,150 --> 01:19:32,570
Stu:
So here's a weird observation. I was like, why did they shoot this film in black and white?

1209
01:19:32,650 --> 01:19:35,890
Stu:
So it's shot on 35 millimeter black and white. I kind of feel like she shot

1210
01:19:35,890 --> 01:19:38,670
Stu:
it in widescreen black and white as a weird Woody Allen reference.

1211
01:19:38,910 --> 01:19:44,310
Stu:
Because this feels like a funny inversion of Woody Allen. This is kind of a film.

1212
01:19:44,490 --> 01:19:45,650
Mel:
She did, by the way.

1213
01:19:45,990 --> 01:19:46,750
Stu:
Oh, okay.

1214
01:19:46,830 --> 01:19:51,030
Mel:
She mentions Manhattan. manhattan she first of all she mentions it but she also

1215
01:19:51,030 --> 01:19:53,950
Mel:
cribs a shot from manhattan near the end ah.

1216
01:19:53,950 --> 01:19:55,250
Stu:
Well there you go yeah yeah.

1217
01:19:55,250 --> 01:19:57,330
Mel:
That's right so there you go like.

1218
01:19:57,330 --> 01:20:02,950
Stu:
The running joke of all the young men wanting to hit on her and how she you

1219
01:20:02,950 --> 01:20:06,150
Stu:
know she's horny all the time and these 19 year olds are hitting on her it felt

1220
01:20:06,150 --> 01:20:08,090
Stu:
like such a piss take of woody allen.

1221
01:20:08,090 --> 01:20:12,730
Mel:
She also did say i listened to an interview with her where she was talking about

1222
01:20:12,730 --> 01:20:16,350
Mel:
because she is a teacher and some of her students show up as her students.

1223
01:20:16,390 --> 01:20:20,870
Mel:
So she does the opposite of Sarah Polly, where her brother is actually played by her brother.

1224
01:20:21,210 --> 01:20:26,670
Mel:
And some of her students are played by her students. And she said that the experience

1225
01:20:26,670 --> 01:20:30,750
Mel:
did come from having some of her students, not the ones that play themselves

1226
01:20:30,750 --> 01:20:35,530
Mel:
in this film, actually attempt to hit on her at some point. And she goes, what?

1227
01:20:36,150 --> 01:20:41,030
Mel:
Those references are intentional. Although the black and white was partly budgetary,

1228
01:20:41,030 --> 01:20:46,170
Mel:
Partly budgetary and partly originally this was meant to be a web series.

1229
01:20:46,270 --> 01:20:51,050
Mel:
When we talk about the Metanus, she had written the web series and it was about her life.

1230
01:20:51,170 --> 01:20:55,750
Mel:
And then her mother died. And basically she rewrote it. And she wrote that into this.

1231
01:20:55,930 --> 01:20:59,850
Mel:
She talks a lot about dead mothers really explicitly. You want to talk about,

1232
01:20:59,850 --> 01:21:01,910
Mel:
you know, Sarah Polly therapizing herself.

1233
01:21:02,290 --> 01:21:06,830
Mel:
I think in a lot of ways that is this it's dealing with and it changed the focus of it a little bit.

1234
01:21:07,510 --> 01:21:14,590
Excerpts:
That's your mom? Yeah. Is she coming? In spirit, I guess.

1235
01:21:18,550 --> 01:21:21,730
Excerpts:
Oh, shit. Yo, why you ain't say nothing?

1236
01:21:23,760 --> 01:21:28,620
Excerpts:
Don't you get tired of adding people to the dead mom club in your head and.

1237
01:21:28,620 --> 01:21:31,200
Mel:
Then she just thought like it's a

1238
01:21:31,200 --> 01:21:35,220
Mel:
feature it should be black and white and there's several

1239
01:21:35,220 --> 01:21:40,560
Mel:
uses of color throughout which i think are part of the techniques of how the

1240
01:21:40,560 --> 01:21:45,120
Mel:
filmmaker talks directly to us which i think is fascinating because there's

1241
01:21:45,120 --> 01:21:51,760
Mel:
multiple uses of color but the main one is where we see suddenly 4.3 imagery

1242
01:21:51,760 --> 01:21:54,780
Mel:
of brightly colored images.

1243
01:21:54,960 --> 01:22:00,480
Mel:
And that is, instead of using voiceover, it's taking us inside of her head and

1244
01:22:00,480 --> 01:22:03,020
Mel:
what she is thinking or what she is picturing.

1245
01:22:03,440 --> 01:22:11,380
Mel:
And so it's just visually giving us a writer talking directly to the audience, which is great.

1246
01:22:11,740 --> 01:22:15,260
Stu:
So it's connected to the play she's writing. And there's even this section where,

1247
01:22:15,320 --> 01:22:18,300
Stu:
so you see her imagining the play and you've got these characters,

1248
01:22:18,380 --> 01:22:21,740
Stu:
actors that we've actually already met in color reenacting the

1249
01:22:21,740 --> 01:22:24,820
Stu:
play but there's even this bit where she's writing this terrible fucking

1250
01:22:24,820 --> 01:22:29,000
Stu:
dialogue and she knows it's terrible she's reading it aloud and the actors on

1251
01:22:29,000 --> 01:22:32,600
Stu:
screen are mouthing it but it's her voice and it's just a really fun playful

1252
01:22:32,600 --> 01:22:36,240
Stu:
thing that makes you know that she kind of knows what she's writing is cringe

1253
01:22:36,240 --> 01:22:41,820
Stu:
but she's trying to do a good job but also trying to embrace the cringeness well.

1254
01:22:41,820 --> 01:22:46,660
Excerpts:
I have ideas too why can't

1255
01:22:46,660 --> 01:22:52,820
Excerpts:
we just make a community garden it's not that simple it is you just have to

1256
01:22:52,820 --> 01:22:58,060
Excerpts:
change your perspective take nothing wrong with my damn perspective excuse me

1257
01:22:58,060 --> 01:23:05,680
Excerpts:
don't take that tone with me ladies ladies stop just stop,

1258
01:23:10,240 --> 01:23:12,000
Excerpts:
This some bullshit.

1259
01:23:13,040 --> 01:23:19,040
Chas:
Can I just interject here to say, I thought Mel had missed the homework brief

1260
01:23:19,040 --> 01:23:24,460
Chas:
and there was a lot of the character Radha talking directly to us.

1261
01:23:24,480 --> 01:23:28,920
Chas:
And, you know, in Mel, in your defense, Radha is also the writer and the filmmaker,

1262
01:23:29,040 --> 01:23:33,980
Chas:
but I felt very much that it was nearly always the character we were seeing.

1263
01:23:33,980 --> 01:23:35,820
Chas:
Like, I was always involved in the story.

1264
01:23:35,920 --> 01:23:42,340
Chas:
I was never had that distancing or reflection on how the film was being made.

1265
01:23:42,480 --> 01:23:46,400
Chas:
She does break the fourth wall a couple of times to great effect.

1266
01:23:47,440 --> 01:23:51,320
Chas:
So, as someone who watched this and still at the end of it, like,

1267
01:23:51,360 --> 01:23:54,600
Chas:
now that I've digested it a bit and I'm hearing some of your guys' examples,

1268
01:23:54,700 --> 01:23:56,040
Chas:
I'm like, oh, yeah, that's how they did it.

1269
01:23:56,060 --> 01:24:00,740
Chas:
And that's how it sits somewhere on the spectrum in between adaptation and stories we tell. Yeah.

1270
01:24:01,290 --> 01:24:04,690
Chas:
When did you really feel Radha

1271
01:24:04,690 --> 01:24:07,490
Chas:
as the filmmaker talking directly to the

1272
01:24:07,490 --> 01:24:12,610
Chas:
audience as opposed to Radha the character that we're following in that story

1273
01:24:12,610 --> 01:24:17,550
Chas:
because to your point they've used this very startling filmmaking technique

1274
01:24:17,550 --> 01:24:20,730
Chas:
where we're cutting to color we're cutting to aspect ratio we're cutting to

1275
01:24:20,730 --> 01:24:27,430
Chas:
actors recreating stuff that as she's writing it but that's to put us in her head as

1276
01:24:27,470 --> 01:24:29,730
Chas:
part of her creative process in that moment.

1277
01:24:29,950 --> 01:24:34,730
Chas:
So I didn't feel like this is Radha, the filmmaker, telling me this is how you

1278
01:24:34,730 --> 01:24:37,350
Chas:
write a movie about my life.

1279
01:24:37,650 --> 01:24:43,050
Stu:
I think there may be an element of you having an expectation of when you're

1280
01:24:43,050 --> 01:24:46,690
Stu:
like, oh, I didn't have the distancing effect, that that's kind of what you

1281
01:24:46,690 --> 01:24:47,990
Stu:
were specifically looking for.

1282
01:24:48,250 --> 01:24:48,690
Chas:
Quite possibly.

1283
01:24:49,010 --> 01:24:54,030
Stu:
I will say I found this the most emotionally effective of the three films that we looked at.

1284
01:24:54,230 --> 01:24:54,690
Chas:
Definitely.

1285
01:24:54,690 --> 01:24:59,590
Mel:
For me, I think just the way that Sarah Polly foreshadows it right by showing

1286
01:24:59,590 --> 01:25:02,210
Mel:
herself like in the mirror with the super eight and things like that.

1287
01:25:02,270 --> 01:25:04,990
Mel:
I think Radha foreshadows it in two ways.

1288
01:25:05,090 --> 01:25:10,190
Mel:
Again, within the first five minutes, because you see her being a voyeur a lot.

1289
01:25:10,370 --> 01:25:13,450
Mel:
You see her eavesdropping on her neighbors having sex.

1290
01:25:13,530 --> 01:25:15,990
Mel:
You see her looking out the window and watching people walking.

1291
01:25:15,990 --> 01:25:17,530
Mel:
You see like pedestrians,

1292
01:25:17,810 --> 01:25:22,690
Mel:
you see her like watching TV and you realize like what we're doing to her,

1293
01:25:22,810 --> 01:25:24,450
Mel:
because this is a very self insert,

1294
01:25:24,590 --> 01:25:29,070
Mel:
is trying to peer into and figure out what her life is like. Right.

1295
01:25:29,250 --> 01:25:35,050
Mel:
And then she also has this commentary like in the like writers group right with

1296
01:25:35,050 --> 01:25:41,070
Mel:
her kids where she's talking about like commentary on art, like commerce versus like cause and emotion.

1297
01:25:41,070 --> 01:25:45,250
Mel:
And you realize, like, they're talking about art within their drama class,

1298
01:25:45,390 --> 01:25:48,310
Mel:
but she's clearly talking about this film that we're watching.

1299
01:25:49,590 --> 01:25:53,210
Excerpts:
Now, the dean said I could kick the both of you out of the class after what

1300
01:25:53,210 --> 01:25:55,250
Excerpts:
happened last week. No. So terrible.

1301
01:25:55,610 --> 01:26:01,390
Excerpts:
But I won't. Why? Because even though we'd all rather be someplace than this terribly lit room.

1302
01:26:01,650 --> 01:26:06,390
Excerpts:
Not me. We committed to telling a story and not some version of Poverty Point either.

1303
01:26:06,530 --> 01:26:10,230
Excerpts:
OK? Okay? So don't think if you don't get what you want, Elaine,

1304
01:26:10,470 --> 01:26:11,810
Excerpts:
that the world should stop for you.

1305
01:26:11,990 --> 01:26:15,790
Excerpts:
Mmm, I like this, Miss B. Or that if someone says something you don't like,

1306
01:26:15,870 --> 01:26:19,170
Excerpts:
Rosa, you get to choke them the fuck out. You're right. My bad.

1307
01:26:20,150 --> 01:26:23,910
Excerpts:
Now, Elaine, your poem was great. Okay?

1308
01:26:24,950 --> 01:26:26,710
Excerpts:
Yeah? Yes.

1309
01:26:29,050 --> 01:26:32,990
Excerpts:
But don't think because you created something that people would appreciate it.

1310
01:26:33,210 --> 01:26:38,830
Excerpts:
Okay? Or you'll end up some washed up 40 year old playwright with some stupid

1311
01:26:38,830 --> 01:26:43,290
Excerpts:
notion to become a rapper and the shits from drinking a diet drink that doesn't

1312
01:26:43,290 --> 01:26:45,810
Excerpts:
quite meet the FDA standards. And do you want that for yourselves?

1313
01:26:47,040 --> 01:26:48,800
Excerpts:
I said, is that what you want? No.

1314
01:26:49,560 --> 01:26:56,400
Mel:
So it's incorporated. But I think where I really felt it defines itself as that

1315
01:26:56,400 --> 01:26:58,480
Mel:
is when she's literally writing a play.

1316
01:26:58,560 --> 01:27:02,520
Mel:
And you have, it's this very Hamlet-esque thing of the play within the play.

1317
01:27:02,660 --> 01:27:07,680
Mel:
And the play is meant to be taking all of these little elements and cranking

1318
01:27:07,680 --> 01:27:11,160
Mel:
them up to 11 to see what the effect is on the audience.

1319
01:27:11,460 --> 01:27:15,620
Mel:
Which is, you know, the place of thing where it's, I catch the conscience of the king.

1320
01:27:15,620 --> 01:27:20,880
Mel:
And I think she's saying, like, I, Radha, the filmmaker.

1321
01:27:21,360 --> 01:27:29,560
Mel:
Am doing this thing as Radha, the character with this play to just shout my

1322
01:27:29,560 --> 01:27:33,360
Mel:
message at you in ways that you cannot possibly miss it.

1323
01:27:33,360 --> 01:27:38,080
Mel:
And as a writer, obviously, I feel all of the things that she's going through

1324
01:27:38,080 --> 01:27:44,300
Mel:
in terms of, you know, the despair and the agony over the ridiculous things

1325
01:27:44,300 --> 01:27:47,340
Mel:
that the funding buddies say to you and like, am I ever going to make it?

1326
01:27:47,380 --> 01:27:51,040
Mel:
And should I just become a teacher and like all those things?

1327
01:27:51,040 --> 01:27:54,900
Mel:
But I think she's talking to a larger audience than just filmmakers.

1328
01:27:55,100 --> 01:27:57,880
Mel:
And she's talking to people who consume art full stop.

1329
01:27:58,120 --> 01:28:02,660
Mel:
And by talking to people who consume art full stop, by using that play,

1330
01:28:02,920 --> 01:28:05,020
Mel:
it's such an explicit device.

1331
01:28:05,420 --> 01:28:10,520
Mel:
And that's the first time I watched it through. And again, I think the third

1332
01:28:10,520 --> 01:28:13,600
Mel:
big thing are the going into her mind.

1333
01:28:13,700 --> 01:28:19,180
Mel:
I think just because she's not saying, she's not taking a break as Roda the

1334
01:28:19,180 --> 01:28:23,540
Mel:
director and giving us a, so when I was doing this and this person was talking

1335
01:28:23,540 --> 01:28:28,300
Mel:
to me, I thought she's giving it to us visually. She's giving it to us in color.

1336
01:28:28,380 --> 01:28:31,500
Mel:
She's giving it to us sometimes in people who are like her real life brother.

1337
01:28:31,580 --> 01:28:35,520
Mel:
I don't think she could be shouting it at us any louder other than like,

1338
01:28:35,600 --> 01:28:40,440
Mel:
you know, doing the Woody Allen thing of pausing and walking in as herself and

1339
01:28:40,440 --> 01:28:43,580
Mel:
and talking directly to the camera, which she does as the film critic.

1340
01:28:43,640 --> 01:28:46,500
Mel:
But it feels like a very similar technique to that.

1341
01:28:47,170 --> 01:28:52,690
Chas:
I think maybe it's just because I didn't know anything about Radha as a person

1342
01:28:52,690 --> 01:28:57,710
Chas:
that everything I was watching felt like I was watching Radha the character.

1343
01:28:58,010 --> 01:29:02,450
Chas:
And yes, it's extremely autobiographical, but like, so you referenced that super

1344
01:29:02,450 --> 01:29:06,190
Chas:
powerful moment where she's at the end of her play, where she starts,

1345
01:29:06,270 --> 01:29:08,950
Chas:
you know, rapping about her experience

1346
01:29:08,950 --> 01:29:12,330
Chas:
of the play and of what she's gone through and why it's garbage.

1347
01:29:12,330 --> 01:29:16,350
Chas:
That felt like something that the character i've just been watching for two

1348
01:29:16,350 --> 01:29:23,790
Chas:
hours would do as well as also being the filmmaker shouting their creed at us i.

1349
01:29:23,790 --> 01:29:31,570
Excerpts:
Got really afraid scared of the choices and the bullshit i made thinking i wouldn't

1350
01:29:31,570 --> 01:29:37,910
Excerpts:
get paid but i'm carol's daughter so that shit don't stain i gotta tell you

1351
01:29:37,910 --> 01:29:42,230
Excerpts:
a nigga was choking tired of selling my soul

1352
01:29:42,330 --> 01:29:44,510
Excerpts:
for these tokens, these coins.

1353
01:29:45,330 --> 01:29:52,250
Excerpts:
But guess what? I made a different choice because it's time to F-Y-O-V find your own voice.

1354
01:29:52,970 --> 01:29:59,150
Excerpts:
F-Y-O-V F-Y-O-V 40 year old version indubitably.

1355
01:30:00,010 --> 01:30:06,630
Excerpts:
F-Y-O-V F-Y-O-V Not telling truth just don't make sense to me.

1356
01:30:07,210 --> 01:30:13,570
Excerpts:
Holding back from who you should be. F-Y-O-V Fund your own vision,

1357
01:30:13,730 --> 01:30:20,750
Excerpts:
fill your own void, find your own voice, fuck you old vultures.

1358
01:30:22,010 --> 01:30:25,010
Excerpts:
40 year old version, that's who I be.

1359
01:30:27,920 --> 01:30:28,340
Excerpts:
I'm out.

1360
01:30:29,700 --> 01:30:32,660
Mel:
And I think she knows that, and I think that's why she does a couple things.

1361
01:30:32,840 --> 01:30:36,140
Mel:
The breaking the fourth wall is, I think, to really draw attention.

1362
01:30:36,360 --> 01:30:40,980
Mel:
And also, literally, you'll notice stuff in the set design and stuff,

1363
01:30:41,040 --> 01:30:42,800
Mel:
like a box that just says, Rotter's shit.

1364
01:30:43,020 --> 01:30:46,880
Mel:
Or like the writing, you know, on the labels of her script and things like that.

1365
01:30:46,940 --> 01:30:48,740
Mel:
I think that's to say, hey, this is what I'm doing.

1366
01:30:49,700 --> 01:30:51,840
Stu:
Okay. So, I'm going to be flippant.

1367
01:30:52,200 --> 01:30:52,560
Mel:
Gasp.

1368
01:30:53,560 --> 01:30:56,780
Stu:
But when did I think the filmmaker was talking to the audience?

1369
01:30:56,780 --> 01:31:00,560
Stu:
The film has credits, if you're watching the screen, Jazz, that says,

1370
01:31:00,760 --> 01:31:03,840
Stu:
starring Ryder Blank, written and directed by Ryder Blank, right?

1371
01:31:04,180 --> 01:31:07,720
Stu:
Why is this distinction between Ryder the character and Ryder the filmmaker

1372
01:31:07,720 --> 01:31:13,140
Stu:
more of an issue for you than Charlie Kaufman, who's played by Nick Cage, in Adaptation?

1373
01:31:13,200 --> 01:31:15,980
Stu:
Is it just your awareness of Charlie Kaufman as a person?

1374
01:31:16,080 --> 01:31:20,640
Stu:
Because I would say this film is actually more talking directly to the audience than Adaptation.

1375
01:31:21,000 --> 01:31:25,400
Stu:
Adaptation is more meta in the sense that it's about the writing process.

1376
01:31:25,400 --> 01:31:30,500
Stu:
But I think this is more directly talking to the audience from the filmmaker's perspective.

1377
01:31:30,840 --> 01:31:36,240
Chas:
I guess if we look at any powerfully autobiographical movie like Past Lives,

1378
01:31:36,580 --> 01:31:39,780
Chas:
I'm like, is that the filmmaker talking directly to us?

1379
01:31:39,820 --> 01:31:45,620
Chas:
Or is that the filmmaker writing a film that is very emotional and powerful and presenting it to us?

1380
01:31:45,760 --> 01:31:50,100
Stu:
Both. I mean, they kind of both talked about how they draws on their own stuff.

1381
01:31:51,000 --> 01:31:53,340
Chas:
Yeah, but then this technique that you guys are experiencing,

1382
01:31:53,520 --> 01:31:57,540
Chas:
where it's the filmmaker talking directly to us, can only be for autobiographical stories.

1383
01:31:58,080 --> 01:32:01,560
Mel:
This takes it to a different level than past lives. I don't think comparing

1384
01:32:01,560 --> 01:32:07,360
Mel:
those quite works in terms of you've got, you know, characters who are more explicitly, again,

1385
01:32:07,440 --> 01:32:08,900
Mel:
named the same thing, going through

1386
01:32:08,900 --> 01:32:13,620
Mel:
the same experiences, using very real documentary-esque techniques, etc.

1387
01:32:13,900 --> 01:32:17,680
Mel:
But you're still identifying something along the same spectrum.

1388
01:32:17,680 --> 01:32:21,500
Stu:
Okay, I'm going to come back to my observation earlier about YouTube and TikTok.

1389
01:32:22,100 --> 01:32:25,820
Stu:
I think you're saying, can this only be used for autobiographical films?

1390
01:32:25,920 --> 01:32:30,420
Stu:
No, but I think we are moving through an era at the moment where there is an

1391
01:32:30,420 --> 01:32:31,200
Stu:
interest in authenticity.

1392
01:32:31,400 --> 01:32:35,980
Stu:
And I think that is only going to grow if we are moving into a world where stuff

1393
01:32:35,980 --> 01:32:41,960
Stu:
is written by AI or AI-assisted or more just driven by the algorithm, right?

1394
01:32:41,960 --> 01:32:46,640
Stu:
Right, then stuff that is truly personal and coming from a weird place has value.

1395
01:32:46,840 --> 01:32:52,100
Stu:
You know, one of my favorite records, and I'm sure I played it for you is, Jackson C.

1396
01:32:52,160 --> 01:32:55,860
Stu:
Frank, this blues guitarist. It's basically a record that sounds like he recorded

1397
01:32:55,860 --> 01:32:59,500
Stu:
it in three hours and it's raw and broken and he ended up getting found dead

1398
01:32:59,500 --> 01:33:02,440
Stu:
three decades later, having only ever recorded the one album, right?

1399
01:33:02,660 --> 01:33:06,900
Stu:
All that tragedy is in the recording and it's really authentic and it stands

1400
01:33:06,900 --> 01:33:09,880
Stu:
out. And I think this kind of filmmaking, right?

1401
01:33:10,740 --> 01:33:15,720
Stu:
Is stuff that one you can borrow techniques from i think documentaries and stuff

1402
01:33:15,720 --> 01:33:19,060
Stu:
that's autobiographical is formally more inventive than the stuff we're seeing

1403
01:33:19,060 --> 01:33:20,820
Stu:
in mainstream cinema right.

1404
01:33:20,820 --> 01:33:24,540
Chas:
Awesome so this is what i want to borrow down to because let's say i'm writing

1405
01:33:24,540 --> 01:33:31,140
Chas:
a story that is not about me but is about things that are powerful and of interest

1406
01:33:31,140 --> 01:33:36,960
Chas:
to me in what way am i talking directly to the audience what tools can i use

1407
01:33:36,960 --> 01:33:40,040
Chas:
to draw their attention to like can i communicate

1408
01:33:40,160 --> 01:33:43,640
Chas:
directly to them other than just by writing a narrative and telling a story.

1409
01:33:43,740 --> 01:33:46,540
Chas:
So this is, I guess what I'm getting to is, is 40 year old version,

1410
01:33:46,640 --> 01:33:48,480
Chas:
just writing a narrative and telling a story.

1411
01:33:48,520 --> 01:33:54,040
Chas:
At what point is it rather the writer and the director talking directly to us?

1412
01:33:54,100 --> 01:33:56,180
Chas:
I didn't feel at any point.

1413
01:33:56,620 --> 01:34:00,200
Stu:
Okay. So, I mean, I think these are interesting questions and I do want to make

1414
01:34:00,200 --> 01:34:02,980
Stu:
sure that we give this proper, this film, it's proper Jew, right?

1415
01:34:03,160 --> 01:34:07,740
Chas:
Oh, I loved the film. Don't get me wrong. I'm just questioning it through this lens.

1416
01:34:08,380 --> 01:34:11,300
Stu:
I think this is like Fleabag plus one on plus two, right?

1417
01:34:11,400 --> 01:34:15,420
Stu:
Like, I think Fleabag feels like it's a part of Phoebe Waller-Bridge, right?

1418
01:34:15,520 --> 01:34:19,580
Stu:
And this feels like it is on that spectrum, that this stuff is a spectrum.

1419
01:34:19,700 --> 01:34:22,200
Stu:
It's not like, oh, the filmmaker's not talking to the audience, filmmaker is.

1420
01:34:22,400 --> 01:34:24,960
Stu:
Because obviously, as we've talked about this whole series, it's always the

1421
01:34:24,960 --> 01:34:26,180
Stu:
filmmakers talking to the audience.

1422
01:34:26,620 --> 01:34:29,780
Stu:
Where the filmmakers in a broad sense, it's the writers, it's the directors,

1423
01:34:29,860 --> 01:34:32,680
Stu:
it's the editors, it's everyone coming together and talking directly to the

1424
01:34:32,680 --> 01:34:36,440
Stu:
audience. it's just to what degree are we made aware of that and.

1425
01:34:36,440 --> 01:34:36,940
Chas:
What is the.

1426
01:34:36,940 --> 01:34:41,800
Stu:
Emotional effect of it and i am like she literally eyeballs the camera multiple points of time.

1427
01:34:41,800 --> 01:34:45,480
Chas:
Yeah but but we've got breaking the fourth wall where that's a character doing

1428
01:34:45,480 --> 01:34:50,900
Chas:
that it's not i just never felt at any point that it was hi i'm writer blank

1429
01:34:50,900 --> 01:34:55,620
Chas:
you know famous rapper writer filmmaker talking to you as opposed to i am the

1430
01:34:55,620 --> 01:34:58,680
Chas:
person you've been watching for two hours but.

1431
01:34:58,680 --> 01:35:04,440
Mel:
If you didn't know who charlie kaufman I think you're confusing fame for knowledge.

1432
01:35:04,920 --> 01:35:08,840
Chas:
No, I'm not. Because the film adaptation tells us who Charlie is.

1433
01:35:09,020 --> 01:35:10,780
Chas:
It opens with him on a film set.

1434
01:35:11,160 --> 01:35:16,000
Chas:
Charlie kaufman in text even if people who have no idea have never heard of

1435
01:35:16,000 --> 01:35:19,740
Chas:
charlie kaufman before can go into adaptation and be told he was the writer

1436
01:35:19,740 --> 01:35:22,880
Chas:
of a famous movie that is struggling with writing uh and so.

1437
01:35:22,880 --> 01:35:27,240
Stu:
How is that different from a film which is starring writer blank written directed

1438
01:35:27,240 --> 01:35:29,520
Stu:
by writer blank playing a character called writer blank who's.

1439
01:35:29,520 --> 01:35:30,580
Mel:
Writing a stage play.

1440
01:35:30,580 --> 01:35:35,260
Chas:
Okay so then you have just said is that not just limiting it only to the scenario

1441
01:35:35,260 --> 01:35:39,980
Chas:
where the writer director and actor is the same person because you you raised

1442
01:35:39,980 --> 01:35:44,780
Chas:
phoebe waller bridge i don't feel that fleabag and phoebe waller bridge are the same person why.

1443
01:35:44,780 --> 01:35:50,320
Stu:
Is that an important distinction how are you so confident that sarah polly in stories we tell.

1444
01:35:50,320 --> 01:35:51,100
Chas:
Is sarah.

1445
01:35:51,100 --> 01:35:52,360
Stu:
Polly the person and not.

1446
01:35:52,360 --> 01:35:56,880
Chas:
I'm not i'm not i think it's the point in stories we tell that she is trying

1447
01:35:56,880 --> 01:36:01,300
Chas:
to very much distance us i think that's the point of the text what i'm trying

1448
01:36:01,300 --> 01:36:02,940
Chas:
to do is find techniques from

1449
01:36:03,160 --> 01:36:08,680
Chas:
where filmmakers clearly talk directly to the audience that we can learn from.

1450
01:36:08,860 --> 01:36:13,380
Stu:
There is two running in parallel in 40-year-old version as far as me.

1451
01:36:13,480 --> 01:36:18,400
Stu:
There's the filmmaking techniques, including but not only to eyeballing the camera, right?

1452
01:36:18,520 --> 01:36:23,280
Stu:
But then the second thing is the meta quality about a particular type of cinema

1453
01:36:23,280 --> 01:36:28,900
Stu:
that he's talking about that to me is as valid as adaptation talking about the

1454
01:36:28,900 --> 01:36:30,120
Stu:
meta quality of writing itself.

1455
01:36:30,380 --> 01:36:35,500
Stu:
She is talking about how do you tell authentic black stories in an industry

1456
01:36:35,500 --> 01:36:37,200
Stu:
that is controlled by white people?

1457
01:36:37,300 --> 01:36:41,620
Stu:
This is my interpretation as a white person, right? And at what we are looking

1458
01:36:41,620 --> 01:36:44,420
Stu:
as signals of authenticity.

1459
01:36:44,720 --> 01:36:50,480
Stu:
And she is hitting the beats. The homeless guy across the road is a trope of

1460
01:36:50,480 --> 01:36:54,180
Stu:
stat that kind of feels like it's out of one of Whitman's notes.

1461
01:36:54,280 --> 01:36:57,560
Stu:
I almost expected him to have a speech about, oh, maybe there's a homeless guy

1462
01:36:57,560 --> 01:36:59,680
Stu:
that ends up being the magical negro.

1463
01:36:59,680 --> 01:37:04,860
Mel:
Well, he's kind of a double trope. Like, he's the homeless guy slash magical Negro trope.

1464
01:37:07,040 --> 01:37:11,240
Excerpts:
So this is the part where I tell you I was an artist who had fallen from grace, right?

1465
01:37:12,180 --> 01:37:18,700
Excerpts:
And I impart some wisdom to you that changes your outlook. Because you gave me a fucking sandwich?

1466
01:37:20,280 --> 01:37:25,660
Excerpts:
Like I'm some fucking magical negro just sitting here with shit in my pants

1467
01:37:25,660 --> 01:37:28,060
Excerpts:
so I can help you make up your mind?

1468
01:37:28,820 --> 01:37:35,420
Excerpts:
Nope. I ain't that nigger. And maybe next time, if it don't kill you,

1469
01:37:35,520 --> 01:37:40,320
Excerpts:
could you put some mayonnaise on both sides of this dry ass bread?

1470
01:37:41,560 --> 01:37:44,360
Excerpts:
I'm trying to cut my throat the slow way.

1471
01:37:47,720 --> 01:37:48,680
Excerpts:
You're welcome.

1472
01:37:49,820 --> 01:37:54,240
Stu:
And then there's the stuff about gentrification. She mentions Daydream's Mind

1473
01:37:54,240 --> 01:37:58,580
Stu:
and the idea of raising these kids and getting them out of the Harlem and all

1474
01:37:58,580 --> 01:38:00,900
Stu:
that kind of stuff feels like it's built into this text,

1475
01:38:01,000 --> 01:38:05,440
Stu:
the way in which, and this connects to kind of Get Out, this kind of commodification

1476
01:38:05,440 --> 01:38:07,180
Stu:
of black culture, right?

1477
01:38:07,320 --> 01:38:09,940
Stu:
Is the stuff I'm getting, and I say this as a white Australian,

1478
01:38:10,080 --> 01:38:13,020
Stu:
so obviously I can only interpret it through what is communicated to me.

1479
01:38:13,020 --> 01:38:17,420
Stu:
So that feels like it's a meta quality of the film that is her talking to the

1480
01:38:17,420 --> 01:38:21,480
Stu:
audience in the same way that having Robert McKee turn up as a character in

1481
01:38:21,480 --> 01:38:23,340
Stu:
your film at the third act turning point,

1482
01:38:23,420 --> 01:38:27,640
Stu:
dropping wisdom is exactly the same kind of beat as the homeless magical Negro

1483
01:38:27,640 --> 01:38:30,060
Stu:
going, what, you expect me to turn you all around?

1484
01:38:30,360 --> 01:38:35,180
Stu:
Like, give you wisdom is the same moment at the same time, right? It is.

1485
01:38:35,870 --> 01:38:38,650
Stu:
Them talking to a self-aware audience, right?

1486
01:38:38,830 --> 01:38:44,750
Chas:
So can you only use that tool when you're talking about the process of making what you're making?

1487
01:38:44,870 --> 01:38:48,070
Mel:
No. Okay. So let me answer, you say, what are the techniques, right?

1488
01:38:48,670 --> 01:38:52,950
Mel:
Rewind 10 minutes and I say, okay, because here's the thing, right?

1489
01:38:52,990 --> 01:38:57,310
Mel:
I talk about, I think she sets us up for this in the first 10 minutes by showing

1490
01:38:57,310 --> 01:38:59,030
Mel:
her being a voyeur, right?

1491
01:38:59,090 --> 01:39:01,950
Mel:
Listening to an eavesdropping on neighbors, watching TV, looking out the window

1492
01:39:01,950 --> 01:39:04,830
Mel:
at pedestrians, three techniques that show her as a voyeur, Right.

1493
01:39:05,010 --> 01:39:08,570
Mel:
So that is a technique that you would write in your action lines.

1494
01:39:08,690 --> 01:39:14,750
Mel:
If you want to say, OK, here's a theme of the character who is doing a certain

1495
01:39:14,750 --> 01:39:19,250
Mel:
thing and I want to talk directly to the audience about this thing later in the script.

1496
01:39:19,370 --> 01:39:21,970
Mel:
OK, you set that up with visuals. There's your action lines.

1497
01:39:21,970 --> 01:39:28,050
Mel:
There's also, for example, when she meets with a producer and he starts commenting

1498
01:39:28,050 --> 01:39:32,190
Mel:
on quote-unquote character types of characters that we've just seen.

1499
01:39:32,250 --> 01:39:37,310
Mel:
He starts rambling about sassy older women and beleaguered teenagers and people

1500
01:39:37,310 --> 01:39:40,310
Mel:
who want to pitch themselves as a director. Okay, there's a technique.

1501
01:39:40,450 --> 01:39:45,590
Mel:
You can have a character who comments directly on things that we've just seen.

1502
01:39:45,630 --> 01:39:49,090
Mel:
It doesn't have to be about, you know, filmmaking.

1503
01:39:49,390 --> 01:39:54,170
Mel:
It can be commenting on, you know, skateboarding ne'er-do-wells or,

1504
01:39:54,270 --> 01:39:58,330
Mel:
you know, single moms or whatever. But you can say, okay, here's a technique.

1505
01:39:58,550 --> 01:40:04,650
Mel:
You have a character who is going to be the commentariat on things that we've

1506
01:40:04,650 --> 01:40:09,930
Mel:
just experienced. There's also one of my favorite little tiny moments is there's

1507
01:40:09,930 --> 01:40:13,070
Mel:
all these actors in rehearsal and they're going back and forth.

1508
01:40:13,190 --> 01:40:17,270
Mel:
And one of the actors is getting frustrated and it's like, all right, fine, call it out for me.

1509
01:40:17,310 --> 01:40:21,010
Mel:
And then someone off screen goes, Radha! Yeah, that's something that you can

1510
01:40:21,010 --> 01:40:23,890
Mel:
write in, whereas you have one character do something and then you have something

1511
01:40:23,890 --> 01:40:28,810
Mel:
completely unconnected that the audience would get, right, as being a joke that

1512
01:40:28,810 --> 01:40:29,950
Mel:
the characters might not.

1513
01:40:30,030 --> 01:40:34,470
Mel:
So those are all techniques that she is using that speak directly to the audience

1514
01:40:34,470 --> 01:40:37,390
Mel:
that are not dependent on it being about filmmaking.

1515
01:40:38,070 --> 01:40:38,510
Chas:
Yes.

1516
01:40:38,830 --> 01:40:43,370
Stu:
And I would add into the flash cuts, right, which we've already hinted to this

1517
01:40:43,370 --> 01:40:47,110
Stu:
flash cuts to the color. But like when she is looking at her mum's paintings,

1518
01:40:47,350 --> 01:40:49,990
Stu:
they literally cut to pictures of her mum's paintings.

1519
01:40:50,190 --> 01:40:54,030
Stu:
And that is a technique that feels like it comes out of documentary, you know.

1520
01:40:54,070 --> 01:40:57,750
Stu:
To mention the thin blue line that I talked about earlier, they talk about evidence

1521
01:40:57,750 --> 01:41:02,670
Stu:
and then the film without audio commentary will just cut to photos or articles

1522
01:41:02,670 --> 01:41:06,510
Stu:
or things that are reflective of that. It is non-diegetic.

1523
01:41:06,750 --> 01:41:12,030
Stu:
It is using a non-diegetic technique. In a pure dramatic film,

1524
01:41:12,390 --> 01:41:14,110
Stu:
you wouldn't do that, you know.

1525
01:41:14,290 --> 01:41:19,090
Stu:
And it's super presentational, right? So obviously adaptation plays around with,

1526
01:41:19,130 --> 01:41:22,490
Stu:
you know, we go in through the evolutionary sequence, which interestingly enough,

1527
01:41:23,010 --> 01:41:27,590
Stu:
Stories We Tell does the same kind of evolutionary sequence. How did I get here?

1528
01:41:27,870 --> 01:41:28,310
Mel:
Big bang.

1529
01:41:28,730 --> 01:41:31,890
Stu:
The thing is, in adaptation, if they're going to have that flash cut,

1530
01:41:32,090 --> 01:41:34,490
Stu:
it would be the painting on a wall.

1531
01:41:34,750 --> 01:41:39,770
Stu:
So when we want to see a photo of Susan, we see her on the dust jacket in a book diegetically.

1532
01:41:40,110 --> 01:41:43,510
Stu:
If they were using the techniques of this film, it would literally just be a

1533
01:41:43,510 --> 01:41:47,250
Stu:
photo scanned in, presented to it outside of a story world.

1534
01:41:47,390 --> 01:41:49,590
Stu:
And in fact, it probably would be the real Susan.

1535
01:41:50,030 --> 01:41:53,090
Stu:
Okay. okay, so this is a technique, but you can play with this,

1536
01:41:53,250 --> 01:41:54,850
Stu:
right? I doubt you have seen it,

1537
01:41:54,910 --> 01:41:57,010
Stu:
and I haven't seen the whole thing either because it's like four hours.

1538
01:41:57,350 --> 01:42:03,290
Stu:
But in 1974, Peter Watkins made a film, a docudrama about Edwin Munch that is

1539
01:42:03,290 --> 01:42:08,530
Stu:
in a mockumentary style that includes sit-down interviews with the characters, right?

1540
01:42:08,950 --> 01:42:11,050
Stu:
And they just take it deadpan serious.

1541
01:42:11,870 --> 01:42:15,490
Stu:
And, I mean, his stuff's really interesting in the way he was kind of explaining documentary and stuff.

1542
01:42:15,510 --> 01:42:19,850
Stu:
And, yes, that is a biographical story, but it's kind of more experimental mental

1543
01:42:19,850 --> 01:42:23,830
Stu:
with techniques we've seen how some of these techniques are also used in fight

1544
01:42:23,830 --> 01:42:28,070
Stu:
club fight club includes like flashes to dicks and all that kind of stuff like

1545
01:42:28,070 --> 01:42:32,650
Stu:
as part of it so i think the idea of saying you can only use it autobiographical

1546
01:42:32,650 --> 01:42:35,490
Stu:
is narrow thinking because i think this film i'm.

1547
01:42:35,490 --> 01:42:39,290
Chas:
Not saying that i'm asking the question of you guys just to be clear.

1548
01:42:39,290 --> 01:42:42,870
Stu:
I mean maybe you're playing devil's advocate but i think to me it feels like

1549
01:42:42,870 --> 01:42:47,570
Stu:
you didn't come into this either knowing or caring too much that this was an

1550
01:42:47,570 --> 01:42:51,350
Stu:
autobiographical film. I came in with that knowledge, right?

1551
01:42:51,410 --> 01:42:54,170
Stu:
Either because it said on Netflix or because of the way that Mel framed it.

1552
01:42:54,250 --> 01:42:58,270
Stu:
So I kind of was already picking up on elements of, they're showing me like

1553
01:42:58,270 --> 01:43:02,110
Stu:
the prom photo of her with her manager. Oh my God, so good.

1554
01:43:02,550 --> 01:43:06,730
Stu:
So you could start, like there is a version of Spontaneous, a film we've mentioned

1555
01:43:06,730 --> 01:43:09,550
Stu:
many times, that could actually play around with some of these techniques to

1556
01:43:09,550 --> 01:43:10,410
Stu:
create a sense of authenticity.

1557
01:43:10,770 --> 01:43:14,630
Stu:
It's got a lot of flash cuts. It's got flash cuts to them. Younger, it could do recasting.

1558
01:43:14,870 --> 01:43:18,790
Stu:
It could do moments that kind of borrow these techniques where she kind of looks

1559
01:43:18,790 --> 01:43:21,410
Stu:
to the camera, right? And in the end...

1560
01:43:21,610 --> 01:43:24,470
Stu:
What we're getting to is what is the effect of this?

1561
01:43:24,590 --> 01:43:28,310
Stu:
I think what's important about this story is the whole thing ends with the whole

1562
01:43:28,310 --> 01:43:29,850
Stu:
speech about finding your own voice.

1563
01:43:30,070 --> 01:43:33,210
Stu:
Right. So it's important for the themes of the film that we understand this

1564
01:43:33,210 --> 01:43:35,450
Stu:
is coming from her personal experience.

1565
01:43:35,610 --> 01:43:39,030
Stu:
And I actually fucking love her rap. I can see why it did so well.

1566
01:43:39,190 --> 01:43:41,550
Stu:
I love that they shot it. Cause you're like, when she does it,

1567
01:43:41,610 --> 01:43:43,110
Stu:
you're like, fuck, she's good.

1568
01:43:43,410 --> 01:43:46,650
Stu:
She is really good. And she is funny. And I love the playing.

1569
01:43:46,710 --> 01:43:48,970
Stu:
Like this film is actually super funny as well.

1570
01:43:49,270 --> 01:43:54,330
Stu:
Right. And all of that is kind of helping me understand it through the lens of authenticity.

1571
01:43:54,870 --> 01:43:58,530
Stu:
Right. In a way, it's the opposite to stories where we tell,

1572
01:43:58,550 --> 01:44:00,550
Stu:
which is stories we tell as much as it's a personal story.

1573
01:44:00,730 --> 01:44:04,890
Stu:
It's about the ephemeral nature of authenticity or the lack of truth,

1574
01:44:05,090 --> 01:44:08,650
Stu:
you know, the difficulty of having a truth or the complexities of truth.

1575
01:44:08,770 --> 01:44:11,770
Stu:
Whereas this is about the opposite, about telling your own truth.

1576
01:44:11,770 --> 01:44:18,430
Stu:
And adaptation is interesting because I feel like it's not so much concerned

1577
01:44:18,430 --> 01:44:25,330
Stu:
about truth with a capital T, as much as it's about expressing a kind of particular kind of feeling,

1578
01:44:25,610 --> 01:44:27,130
Stu:
for lack of a better word.

1579
01:44:27,250 --> 01:44:32,750
Stu:
The feeling, the frustrations of creation and then the power of creation as well.

1580
01:44:32,930 --> 01:44:36,710
Stu:
And I think it does a good job of that. And also how beautiful and amazing flowers are.

1581
01:44:37,310 --> 01:44:41,670
Chas:
I am playing devil's advocate here. Please, I want you guys to convince me and educate me.

1582
01:44:41,810 --> 01:44:44,390
Chas:
And Mel, you particularly highlighted something that I'm like,

1583
01:44:44,470 --> 01:44:47,490
Chas:
oh, yes, that is something I'll pull away in key learnings.

1584
01:44:47,810 --> 01:44:52,410
Chas:
I think my point is that if this had been written and directed by Radha,

1585
01:44:52,410 --> 01:44:55,930
Chas:
but starring someone else, that she was directing another person,

1586
01:44:55,990 --> 01:44:58,010
Chas:
it would have been just as powerful for me.

1587
01:44:58,390 --> 01:44:58,830
Stu:
Yeah.

1588
01:44:58,830 --> 01:45:05,930
Chas:
So at no point was I going that this is more or less authentic because it's

1589
01:45:05,930 --> 01:45:09,910
Chas:
an autobiographical story of the writer, director and star.

1590
01:45:10,090 --> 01:45:14,630
Chas:
So I was trying to look for things that can apply outside of that context.

1591
01:45:14,630 --> 01:45:19,550
Chas:
And look, American fiction really is a fascinating companion piece to this because

1592
01:45:19,550 --> 01:45:25,870
Chas:
it is, for a large part, telling this satirical story about the creation of

1593
01:45:25,870 --> 01:45:29,370
Chas:
a piece of art and doing the same commentary on how,

1594
01:45:29,570 --> 01:45:34,670
Chas:
you know, what are the expectations of the commerce of art and particularly

1595
01:45:34,670 --> 01:45:39,750
Chas:
how white the commerce of art is on black art and what its expectations and

1596
01:45:39,750 --> 01:45:41,310
Chas:
creations and pressures are.

1597
01:45:41,310 --> 01:45:45,330
Chas:
And then at the very end of it, we spoke about how the end of that movie,

1598
01:45:45,450 --> 01:45:50,350
Chas:
it deliberately has three endings and is, you know, intercutting with the conversation

1599
01:45:50,350 --> 01:45:53,930
Chas:
with the director where it becomes like there's a big jump.

1600
01:45:54,710 --> 01:45:59,090
Chas:
In the techniques used in that ending where it's drawing our attention to the

1601
01:45:59,090 --> 01:46:01,430
Chas:
creation of the film itself that you've just watched,

1602
01:46:01,610 --> 01:46:08,230
Chas:
as opposed to just seeing a narrative presented about a person where that person

1603
01:46:08,230 --> 01:46:13,390
Chas:
never tells me that they're kind of aware that they're in a narrative as a real person,

1604
01:46:13,610 --> 01:46:20,190
Chas:
as opposed to the character that they're playing is a long winded way of me discussing the point.

1605
01:46:20,370 --> 01:46:23,550
Mel:
I think if people haven't seen the film, they would be very confused about at

1606
01:46:23,550 --> 01:46:25,430
Mel:
that, but it tracks, right?

1607
01:46:25,530 --> 01:46:27,850
Mel:
Yeah. I'm watching Stu's face, but I was like, oh, right. I've seen it.

1608
01:46:27,890 --> 01:46:28,790
Mel:
I know where you're going with this.

1609
01:46:28,950 --> 01:46:33,850
Chas:
Basically, I would have had just an amazing a time if it wasn't Radha playing Radha.

1610
01:46:33,990 --> 01:46:37,230
Stu:
I mean, all of this stuff exists on inspection. And I think the idea is we're

1611
01:46:37,230 --> 01:46:39,770
Stu:
just categorizing when it clicks over a particular point.

1612
01:46:39,850 --> 01:46:43,250
Stu:
Because I would say that Radha's rapping, right?

1613
01:46:43,370 --> 01:46:46,550
Stu:
It's shot really close up. They're coming close so we can see it her,

1614
01:46:46,730 --> 01:46:49,130
Stu:
but this is her talking directly to the audience.

1615
01:46:49,270 --> 01:46:54,570
Stu:
This is not dissimilar of the moments in High Fidelity when Rob turns to camera

1616
01:46:54,570 --> 01:46:57,010
Stu:
and gives a lecture about what she's feeling, right?

1617
01:46:57,110 --> 01:46:59,950
Chas:
Or Spike Lee, like you talked about, the love and hate speech.

1618
01:47:00,250 --> 01:47:04,230
Stu:
Yeah, right? They're moments where she is talking about her experience as a

1619
01:47:04,230 --> 01:47:06,450
Stu:
40-year-old woman directly to the audience.

1620
01:47:06,810 --> 01:47:10,530
Stu:
They're not her eyeballing because it's not a soliloquy in that sense,

1621
01:47:10,610 --> 01:47:15,530
Stu:
but it belongs to a tradition of spoken word, right, that she is finding a way

1622
01:47:15,530 --> 01:47:18,010
Stu:
to insert into the film authentically.

1623
01:47:18,210 --> 01:47:21,350
Stu:
So I think it could have been played by someone else, But then we're like,

1624
01:47:21,550 --> 01:47:25,950
Stu:
well, depending on who that was, like if it's Nicolas Cage rapping about the

1625
01:47:25,950 --> 01:47:31,770
Stu:
experience of menopause, we're going to understand that it's right or blank speaking through him.

1626
01:47:32,070 --> 01:47:34,930
Stu:
Right? Yes. And I'm using that as an obvious extreme.

1627
01:47:35,410 --> 01:47:38,030
Stu:
Please, Nic Cage, do not blackface.

1628
01:47:38,390 --> 01:47:42,730
Chas:
But like using the levers, right? Everything that's happening is largely,

1629
01:47:42,850 --> 01:47:45,810
Chas:
other than the point that you made about those color cutaways,

1630
01:47:45,910 --> 01:47:49,450
Chas:
are the only things that are non-diegetic to the story.

1631
01:47:49,450 --> 01:47:53,190
Stu:
And she eyeballs the camera at key moments yes.

1632
01:47:53,190 --> 01:47:56,830
Chas:
Twice and both times it was hilarious three times i.

1633
01:47:56,830 --> 01:47:58,250
Stu:
Think it's at least three times.

1634
01:47:58,250 --> 01:48:02,350
Mel:
She's also got um she's also got people the on the street interviews a lot of

1635
01:48:02,350 --> 01:48:04,090
Mel:
them break the fourth wall as well yeah.

1636
01:48:04,090 --> 01:48:07,350
Stu:
And that feels connected to spike lee's work as well yeah yeah.

1637
01:48:07,350 --> 01:48:11,510
Mel:
She's she also toys with diegetic sound quite a bit which you can write but

1638
01:48:11,510 --> 01:48:14,670
Mel:
is a way of talking directly to the audience i'm.

1639
01:48:14,670 --> 01:48:18,750
Chas:
Gonna try and segue this into key learnings because the one thing that I took away from you Mel,

1640
01:48:18,830 --> 01:48:22,750
Chas:
that is something that I could take away and apply to any project as a way that

1641
01:48:22,750 --> 01:48:28,610
Chas:
if I want to get a message that I'm talking about to an audience really clearly

1642
01:48:28,610 --> 01:48:32,990
Chas:
is all three of these films dramatize something,

1643
01:48:33,850 --> 01:48:38,190
Chas:
before they comment on it. They don't comment on it and then dramatize it.

1644
01:48:38,370 --> 01:48:39,450
Stu:
Unpack that a bit more.

1645
01:48:39,710 --> 01:48:48,010
Chas:
So, we have seen in 40-year-old version that writer is being pushed to sell

1646
01:48:48,010 --> 01:48:53,570
Chas:
out before they hang the hat on it and have the discussion in world about what

1647
01:48:53,570 --> 01:48:56,130
Chas:
it is to sell out, like what the compromises are making.

1648
01:48:56,330 --> 01:49:02,030
Chas:
In adaptation, we are seeing those different openings where ones One's from

1649
01:49:02,030 --> 01:49:05,330
Chas:
Charlie's perspective, one's from Susan's perspective, one's from LaRoche's

1650
01:49:05,330 --> 01:49:07,550
Chas:
perspective, one's from the perspective of the flowers.

1651
01:49:07,690 --> 01:49:11,790
Chas:
They've shown all of us, all of those before we get to the crisis where he's

1652
01:49:11,790 --> 01:49:13,770
Chas:
like, oh, we should do it from the flowers perspective.

1653
01:49:14,390 --> 01:49:16,370
Stu:
And you get that great time-lapse shot.

1654
01:49:16,590 --> 01:49:22,070
Chas:
Yeah. And in stories we tell, you know, Mel was talking about the foreshadowing

1655
01:49:22,070 --> 01:49:25,310
Chas:
of Sarah being with the Super 8 camera.

1656
01:49:25,510 --> 01:49:31,230
Chas:
Like, it's the very opening with her siblings commenting on how uncomfortable they feel.

1657
01:49:31,790 --> 01:49:38,070
Chas:
She's talking about the stories and the different versions of something before

1658
01:49:38,070 --> 01:49:42,310
Chas:
the third act, they're actually commenting and that becomes like the source

1659
01:49:42,310 --> 01:49:44,450
Chas:
of the conflict or the drama or the narrative.

1660
01:49:44,830 --> 01:49:50,330
Chas:
So if any of these films had those moments where the dramatization was happening

1661
01:49:50,330 --> 01:49:54,150
Chas:
at the same time or following the commentary, it would feel more,

1662
01:49:54,170 --> 01:49:58,550
Chas:
I guess, from the characters or it's not forcing us as the viewer to recontextualize

1663
01:49:58,550 --> 01:49:59,610
Chas:
what we've already experienced.

1664
01:50:00,070 --> 01:50:05,570
Mel:
I think adaptation, and to some extent, all of them follow up with it as well.

1665
01:50:05,670 --> 01:50:09,790
Mel:
But you're right, which they choose to start with, even if they loop back around,

1666
01:50:09,930 --> 01:50:13,270
Mel:
is crucial in how we feel about it.

1667
01:50:13,530 --> 01:50:17,090
Stu:
There was a moment when I was watching 40-Year-Old Version when they mentioned

1668
01:50:17,090 --> 01:50:21,450
Stu:
John Coltrane, and there's a track that drops, and I'm like, oh, it's John Coltrane.

1669
01:50:21,730 --> 01:50:27,970
Stu:
And then I looked at the credits, and it wasn't. And I had to go back and Shazam it to work out who it was.

1670
01:50:28,090 --> 01:50:29,130
Mel:
Probably couldn't afford it.

1671
01:50:29,130 --> 01:50:33,510
Stu:
It was Courtney Bryan. But it felt like it was the kind of film that would do

1672
01:50:33,510 --> 01:50:38,830
Stu:
something like that, that would talk about the cliche of every vinyl collection has white boy jazz,

1673
01:50:38,970 --> 01:50:43,450
Stu:
has Miles Davis as a kind of blue in it, and then they play a track from a kind

1674
01:50:43,450 --> 01:50:45,490
Stu:
of blue. It's the kind of film that it is.

1675
01:50:45,510 --> 01:50:47,710
Mel:
Which is the How Much Control Lever. Yeah.

1676
01:50:48,190 --> 01:50:52,490
Stu:
And I think the choice to shoot in black and white is them saying that there's

1677
01:50:52,490 --> 01:50:53,690
Stu:
a degree of artifice to this.

1678
01:50:53,770 --> 01:50:57,330
Stu:
I think color now, once upon a time, black and white read as socially real.

1679
01:50:57,470 --> 01:51:02,250
Stu:
I think we use desaturation or we did it for a period of time to do real,

1680
01:51:02,310 --> 01:51:03,270
Stu:
but we wanted some color.

1681
01:51:03,430 --> 01:51:05,650
Stu:
I think that's to do with the difference between cones and rods,

1682
01:51:05,830 --> 01:51:10,390
Stu:
but that's another pose for another time. And I think the choice of shooting

1683
01:51:10,390 --> 01:51:13,930
Stu:
black and white is to go, hey, this is a film that there is a separation here

1684
01:51:13,930 --> 01:51:16,090
Stu:
and obviously referencing Woody Allen.

1685
01:51:17,290 --> 01:51:21,690
Stu:
My question is around emotional effect, because I think this is all about what

1686
01:51:21,690 --> 01:51:23,730
Stu:
effect do you want? What tools do you want to use?

1687
01:51:23,890 --> 01:51:27,490
Stu:
I think it really helps that in the 40-year-old version, what she is talking

1688
01:51:27,490 --> 01:51:33,210
Stu:
about is the kind of tropes around black art and black cinema.

1689
01:51:33,350 --> 01:51:35,250
Stu:
So she is referencing them in the work.

1690
01:51:35,410 --> 01:51:39,570
Stu:
It doesn't feel like it's imposed and it's actually connected deeper thematically

1691
01:51:39,570 --> 01:51:44,090
Stu:
than I imagine how those tropes are used in, say, Deadpool and Wolverine,

1692
01:51:44,110 --> 01:51:47,970
Stu:
right? right, is meta, but I can't imagine they're really talking about it. I haven't seen it yet.

1693
01:51:48,170 --> 01:51:53,630
Stu:
And adaptation is using that metaness is about the internal conflict between

1694
01:51:53,630 --> 01:51:57,730
Stu:
hitting the beats, hitting those moments for audience understanding and try

1695
01:51:57,730 --> 01:51:59,010
Stu:
to go underneath the art.

1696
01:51:59,130 --> 01:52:03,110
Stu:
And I think that is an internal debate because art is about communication and

1697
01:52:03,110 --> 01:52:07,130
Stu:
the further you stray from the conventions, literally the heart of the language

1698
01:52:07,130 --> 01:52:11,450
Stu:
you are talking in, even if that is in cinematic language is for an audience.

1699
01:52:11,630 --> 01:52:15,310
Stu:
And so, therefore, the narrower your audience is, even if it's more authentic.

1700
01:52:15,470 --> 01:52:20,630
Stu:
And I think adaptations about those challenges and stories we tell is about

1701
01:52:20,630 --> 01:52:25,050
Stu:
the ephemerability of truth and how that connects to identity, right?

1702
01:52:25,150 --> 01:52:27,570
Stu:
You thought you're person A, now you thought you're person B.

1703
01:52:27,670 --> 01:52:29,970
Stu:
Does that make you A or B? Are you now C?

1704
01:52:30,110 --> 01:52:32,770
Stu:
And I think the film is about that.

1705
01:52:33,010 --> 01:52:37,250
Stu:
And all three films, I've got my little thesis, but they also tell you quite

1706
01:52:37,250 --> 01:52:40,510
Stu:
directly what they're about. And isn't that why you want to talk to the audience?

1707
01:52:40,690 --> 01:52:44,450
Stu:
Is so you can say, motherfucker, this is what this is about.

1708
01:52:44,610 --> 01:52:48,770
Stu:
And they clearly do that at 40-year-old vision. She stands on a stage, raps into a camera.

1709
01:52:49,430 --> 01:52:52,370
Stu:
Adaptation tells you what he wants your experience of the film to be.

1710
01:52:52,570 --> 01:52:57,090
Stu:
And in stories we tell, she is asked, point great, why are you doing this?

1711
01:52:57,150 --> 01:53:00,430
Stu:
What is the point of all of this? And she can't quite answer it.

1712
01:53:00,970 --> 01:53:04,670
Stu:
And to me, that's why you would want to do these techniques is because you don't

1713
01:53:04,670 --> 01:53:05,350
Stu:
want to be misunderstood.

1714
01:53:05,350 --> 01:53:08,490
Mel:
You want to state your thesis as blatantly as possible. I mean,

1715
01:53:08,510 --> 01:53:13,270
Mel:
people will still fucking misunderstand it, but you will state it as clearly as possible.

1716
01:53:13,270 --> 01:53:16,850
Chas:
I mean, Stuart and you, this is going to be fascinating for us in the project

1717
01:53:16,850 --> 01:53:18,350
Chas:
that we're working on next,

1718
01:53:18,470 --> 01:53:23,210
Chas:
because we're both terrified that because we're wanting to explore stories of

1719
01:53:23,210 --> 01:53:27,110
Chas:
dangerous masculinity and radicalization of young men,

1720
01:53:27,230 --> 01:53:31,250
Chas:
that it's very easy for us to accidentally drift into something that they would

1721
01:53:31,250 --> 01:53:35,390
Chas:
love, as opposed to understand that we're critiquing.

1722
01:53:35,990 --> 01:53:40,070
Stu:
I mean, that's a much broader conversation about the world we're living in now,

1723
01:53:40,150 --> 01:53:43,250
Stu:
where people are like, I don't want characters to kiss on screen because they

1724
01:53:43,250 --> 01:53:44,890
Stu:
characters haven't consented to it.

1725
01:53:45,270 --> 01:53:50,470
Chas:
Well, I guess it's the Fight Club and Starship Troopers. Is it satire?

1726
01:53:50,610 --> 01:53:53,850
Mel:
Or the conversation that I was literally having earlier today where someone's

1727
01:53:53,850 --> 01:53:58,330
Mel:
like, the bear is pro capitalism because it shows Tina having a really hard time.

1728
01:53:58,390 --> 01:54:02,490
Mel:
I'm like, that episode is explicitly about why capitalism is bad.

1729
01:54:02,710 --> 01:54:05,110
Mel:
It's like, what are you watching anyway?

1730
01:54:05,110 --> 01:54:11,410
Chas:
But yeah, so, I mean, that takeaway that these techniques are used,

1731
01:54:11,530 --> 01:54:18,290
Chas:
at least in these three films, to give the writers in particular a chance to

1732
01:54:18,290 --> 01:54:22,370
Chas:
have their characters talk about the theme of the film.

1733
01:54:22,490 --> 01:54:25,930
Mel:
Have their characters talk about it, have their characters write plays about

1734
01:54:25,930 --> 01:54:29,470
Mel:
it, have their characters write books about it, have their characters ask their siblings about it.

1735
01:54:29,570 --> 01:54:32,050
Mel:
You know, it's lots of different ways to explore it.

1736
01:54:32,050 --> 01:54:35,230
Stu:
But other films that we have, I know you're trying to finish there,

1737
01:54:35,350 --> 01:54:37,750
Stu:
but other films that we've talked about in earlier episodes,

1738
01:54:37,950 --> 01:54:41,050
Stu:
such as in our antagonist theories, particularly the, you know,

1739
01:54:41,090 --> 01:54:42,570
Stu:
characters versus the audience.

1740
01:54:42,710 --> 01:54:47,010
Stu:
F is for Fake is about authenticity in cinema and recreation.

1741
01:54:47,130 --> 01:54:51,910
Stu:
And it's very much explicitly about that. And it uses some of these techniques. American Splendor.

1742
01:54:51,910 --> 01:54:56,030
Chas:
But then you've got Orson fucking Wells talking to us. Like there's not been

1743
01:54:56,030 --> 01:54:59,730
Chas:
a film where there is not more about the filmmaker talking directly to us.

1744
01:55:00,070 --> 01:55:00,870
Stu:
Oh, it's great.

1745
01:55:00,870 --> 01:55:04,110
Mel:
I mean, it's Orson Welles. You can't find a bigger ego.

1746
01:55:04,950 --> 01:55:09,270
Stu:
But when I watched Stories We Tell, I was like, wow, this feels really indebted for F is for Fake.

1747
01:55:09,390 --> 01:55:13,850
Stu:
And there's probably films that predate F is for Fake. But that kind of blurring

1748
01:55:13,850 --> 01:55:16,250
Stu:
of meaning and all that kind of stuff.

1749
01:55:16,370 --> 01:55:19,270
Stu:
And I think, you know, this is why you would use these techniques.

1750
01:55:19,470 --> 01:55:23,610
Stu:
And I think, for me, I can't think of a pinpoint, but I'm going to ponder.

1751
01:55:24,330 --> 01:55:26,610
Stu:
These are the things I'm going to be pondering. What techniques,

1752
01:55:26,830 --> 01:55:30,430
Stu:
both in terms of the levers, but also specific techniques such as presenting

1753
01:55:30,430 --> 01:55:34,550
Stu:
photos or talking to camera or voiceover or barreling and, you know,

1754
01:55:34,590 --> 01:55:38,590
Stu:
the kind of structural stuff, where in time this stuff is coming from.

1755
01:55:38,630 --> 01:55:41,830
Stu:
I'm going to be thinking about how all this relates to Thane, you know.

1756
01:55:42,190 --> 01:55:45,970
Stu:
Is a character coming back to a story about dangerous masculinity?

1757
01:55:46,030 --> 01:55:49,850
Stu:
It's the obvious choice. If there's a voiceover, is it coming from the point

1758
01:55:49,850 --> 01:55:51,990
Stu:
in time where he realizes the error of his ways?

1759
01:55:51,990 --> 01:55:55,290
Stu:
Is it coming from the point at the time where he's fully, deeply,

1760
01:55:55,490 --> 01:55:59,730
Stu:
absolutely committed to the cause and then, you know, that all is lost moment

1761
01:55:59,730 --> 01:56:02,370
Stu:
is him realizing it's a disaster and then we have no voiceover.

1762
01:56:02,510 --> 01:56:05,550
Stu:
Right. These are things that you can do that kind of can connect to what we're

1763
01:56:05,550 --> 01:56:08,050
Stu:
trying to say. And I think it's good to kind of think of them through that.

1764
01:56:08,230 --> 01:56:09,190
Chas:
I believe in fitness.

1765
01:56:10,850 --> 01:56:11,730
Stu:
Do you, Chas?

1766
01:56:12,050 --> 01:56:13,730
Mel:
Great callback. Great callback.

1767
01:56:13,730 --> 01:56:15,270
Stu:
You believe in food.

1768
01:56:16,030 --> 01:56:17,110
Mel:
Porque lo nos dos.

1769
01:56:17,910 --> 01:56:19,850
Chas:
I do not believe in fitness. this.

1770
01:56:20,090 --> 01:56:21,790
Stu:
I believe in cheese.

1771
01:56:24,550 --> 01:56:27,290
Chas:
So Mel, what are your key takeaways from this exercise?

1772
01:56:27,690 --> 01:56:28,750
Mel:
I just, I...

1773
01:56:30,260 --> 01:56:32,080
Mel:
Loved it so much they.

1774
01:56:32,080 --> 01:56:36,620
Chas:
Are three wonderful movies to have watched in in a short space of time.

1775
01:56:36,620 --> 01:56:39,500
Mel:
I think because i'm i'm writing something right now

1776
01:56:39,500 --> 01:56:42,420
Mel:
a script that toys a lot with style and structure

1777
01:56:42,420 --> 01:56:46,520
Mel:
and i loved how all three of them did use

1778
01:56:46,520 --> 01:56:50,040
Mel:
diegetic and non-diegetic audio or

1779
01:56:50,040 --> 01:56:52,760
Mel:
audio that we thought was one thing and then turns out

1780
01:56:52,760 --> 01:56:55,420
Mel:
to be another like it sounds like a voiceover but it's actually him

1781
01:56:55,420 --> 01:56:58,780
Mel:
talking to screen through the use of j cuts and l cuts through sarah

1782
01:56:58,780 --> 01:57:02,240
Mel:
polly's talking off camera versus reading

1783
01:57:02,240 --> 01:57:05,020
Mel:
something out versus having someone else perform her

1784
01:57:05,020 --> 01:57:08,900
Mel:
words with rata like having characters talk over

1785
01:57:08,900 --> 01:57:11,700
Mel:
each other i loved a reminder that it is

1786
01:57:11,700 --> 01:57:14,740
Mel:
scripted i mean in documentary it's not quote unquote scripted

1787
01:57:14,740 --> 01:57:17,600
Mel:
so much as written by sarah polly but

1788
01:57:17,600 --> 01:57:21,180
Mel:
all of that how you can really use

1789
01:57:21,180 --> 01:57:24,520
Mel:
your script to establish how

1790
01:57:24,520 --> 01:57:28,160
Mel:
important when audio starts

1791
01:57:28,160 --> 01:57:31,140
Mel:
and how you can use that to play with your audience

1792
01:57:31,140 --> 01:57:33,900
Mel:
um i love that in all three of these i also really

1793
01:57:33,900 --> 01:57:37,460
Mel:
liked the idea of foreshadowing how

1794
01:57:37,460 --> 01:57:40,280
Mel:
much you were gonna fuck with your audience straight up

1795
01:57:40,280 --> 01:57:43,000
Mel:
front which was a lot of fun and i

1796
01:57:43,000 --> 01:57:46,260
Mel:
I think I loved how I just

1797
01:57:46,260 --> 01:57:49,180
Mel:
love the artifice and how all three of them play

1798
01:57:49,180 --> 01:57:51,960
Mel:
with artifice and our authenticity and I think

1799
01:57:51,960 --> 01:57:54,800
Mel:
it's so fascinating that we chose something that used

1800
01:57:54,800 --> 01:58:00,040
Mel:
like 18 layers of artifice like adaptation something that's a documentary and

1801
01:58:00,040 --> 01:58:06,240
Mel:
goes to prove how weird that line is by casting actors as real people and then.

1802
01:58:06,240 --> 01:58:10,820
Mel:
You have something like uh 40 year old version and which gets real people as

1803
01:58:10,820 --> 01:58:12,540
Mel:
actors and toys with those relationships.

1804
01:58:12,740 --> 01:58:17,460
Mel:
And so I think watching all three of these, there's just such a sense of play

1805
01:58:17,460 --> 01:58:20,400
Mel:
with the form and with...

1806
01:58:21,010 --> 01:58:24,190
Mel:
The stories and with the formats that

1807
01:58:24,190 --> 01:58:27,230
Mel:
I literally just have like this took half of

1808
01:58:27,230 --> 01:58:30,090
Mel:
a notebook just my notes on the three of these but

1809
01:58:30,090 --> 01:58:33,450
Mel:
I think the really specific moments of techniques and

1810
01:58:33,450 --> 01:58:37,230
Mel:
things like that like that attention to detail like I said how in 40 old versions

1811
01:58:37,230 --> 01:58:42,070
Mel:
some of it's just a tiny bit of set dressing or in adaptation you reckon that

1812
01:58:42,070 --> 01:58:47,070
Mel:
it probably would have been written how the brothers look quite similar but

1813
01:58:47,070 --> 01:58:51,010
Mel:
are slightly different and things like that I wanted I wanted to mention,

1814
01:58:51,130 --> 01:58:54,390
Mel:
just name drop a couple of other things that I think people should seek out.

1815
01:58:54,490 --> 01:58:58,430
Mel:
So I mentioned before, Nope, I think being a great double feature,

1816
01:58:58,670 --> 01:59:04,750
Mel:
even though it's even further than adaptation, it's certainly not as direct,

1817
01:59:04,850 --> 01:59:09,370
Mel:
but it talks about making movies and making TV and just like 40 year old version, how,

1818
01:59:09,530 --> 01:59:15,730
Mel:
you know, people of certain groups are forced to, you know, sell parts of themselves

1819
01:59:15,730 --> 01:59:18,210
Mel:
and fake authenticity to get somewhere right.

1820
01:59:18,210 --> 01:59:22,750
Mel:
I mentioned Beaches of Agnes, one of my favorite ever documentaries that I think

1821
01:59:22,750 --> 01:59:25,250
Mel:
goes along with this. There's a documentary called Mark My Words.

1822
01:59:25,530 --> 01:59:28,870
Mel:
I don't know how easy it is to find, but if you could find it,

1823
01:59:28,890 --> 01:59:30,070
Mel:
I would absolutely watch it.

1824
01:59:30,110 --> 01:59:35,190
Mel:
It goes along with 40-year-old version, American Splendor, and F is for Fake, we already mentioned.

1825
01:59:36,050 --> 01:59:41,730
Stu:
I think it's been on my list for a long time, and it's probably not a 2024 thing.

1826
01:59:41,850 --> 01:59:45,990
Stu:
God, we're planning for 2025. 25, we should do an episode- I mean,

1827
01:59:46,030 --> 01:59:48,170
Stu:
if we're talking about doing an episode on lessons from musicals,

1828
01:59:48,170 --> 01:59:51,510
Stu:
we should consider doing an episode on lessons from documentaries because I

1829
01:59:51,510 --> 01:59:54,250
Stu:
think there's a lot of stuff that we, as fiction writers,

1830
01:59:54,550 --> 01:59:59,330
Stu:
as this is indicated, but even stuff that is a little bit more straight, like a thin blue line,

1831
01:59:59,490 --> 02:00:02,750
Stu:
that we can sit there and go, fuck, these are techniques we can borrow from,

1832
02:00:02,890 --> 02:00:10,310
Stu:
right, that we can learn from because that form seems to be like- as a friend of the podcaster and,

1833
02:00:11,170 --> 02:00:15,070
Stu:
He basically says that cinema is dominated by naturalism.

1834
02:00:15,150 --> 02:00:20,190
Stu:
The super genre of pretty much modern cinema is naturalism. Very rarely do we get away from that.

1835
02:00:20,310 --> 02:00:24,450
Stu:
So it's kind of interesting to look at stuff that kind of opens up that spectrum. Yeah.

1836
02:00:24,570 --> 02:00:30,150
Chas:
I think those would be two great episodes. I mean, speaking of commentary on

1837
02:00:30,150 --> 02:00:34,370
Chas:
the process of making a product, Stu, I'm actually glad that we've had our first

1838
02:00:34,370 --> 02:00:37,230
Chas:
on-air debate in what feels like a long time.

1839
02:00:37,330 --> 02:00:39,610
Chas:
It feels like we've been agreeing with each other too much for a while.

1840
02:00:39,610 --> 02:00:42,890
Chas:
So it was nice for it to get a bit fiery and spicy there.

1841
02:00:43,030 --> 02:00:47,230
Chas:
And like in the end, you absolutely won and both convinced me.

1842
02:00:47,330 --> 02:00:49,270
Chas:
I was playing devil's advocate.

1843
02:00:49,410 --> 02:00:52,950
Chas:
I very much enjoyed the movie. I wanted to dig in and try and learn with the tools.

1844
02:00:53,010 --> 02:00:55,790
Stu:
Just admit, black women are invisible to you.

1845
02:00:56,750 --> 02:00:57,790
Chas:
He's fucking Christ.

1846
02:00:57,830 --> 02:01:00,610
Mel:
He doesn't see color, especially when it's black and white film.

1847
02:01:01,190 --> 02:01:05,130
Chas:
I mean, this is, I feel like I'm so trapped. It's like, oh my God,

1848
02:01:05,130 --> 02:01:08,950
Chas:
I'm married to a woman of color, but then I'm just doing like the classic politician

1849
02:01:08,950 --> 02:01:10,450
Chas:
thing. like I have a daughter,

1850
02:01:13,050 --> 02:01:15,990
Chas:
anyway thank you both for being late when

1851
02:01:15,990 --> 02:01:18,850
Chas:
life is kind of slamming us on a personal level so

1852
02:01:18,850 --> 02:01:24,830
Chas:
well done on picking and debating these three amazing films a lot of that picking

1853
02:01:24,830 --> 02:01:29,710
Chas:
of the homework was done by our patrons you too can pick our homework for us

1854
02:01:29,710 --> 02:01:34,690
Chas:
and bring if you want more draft zero more often you can join our patrons in

1855
02:01:34,690 --> 02:01:36,490
Chas:
particular thanks to Alexandra,

1856
02:01:36,770 --> 02:01:43,230
Chas:
Jen, Jesse, Crob, Lily Lily, Malay, Paolo, Randy, Sandra, Thies, and Thomas.

1857
02:01:43,430 --> 02:01:47,990
Chas:
See, the list is growing. You guys too can be part of this amazing group.

1858
02:01:48,130 --> 02:01:52,410
Chas:
And as you've seen from hopefully the back matter episodes we've recorded to

1859
02:01:52,410 --> 02:01:57,130
Chas:
this series, our patrons are also posing some pretty awesome questions.

1860
02:01:57,510 --> 02:02:02,330
Stu:
And I'm going to foreshadow it now. We're in the process of setting up a Discord,

1861
02:02:02,550 --> 02:02:04,770
Stu:
so you can argue with us on Discord.

1862
02:02:06,550 --> 02:02:09,770
Chas:
We'll have a channel which will be team chas and a different one for team stew.

1863
02:02:09,770 --> 02:02:15,090
Stu:
It's like the house of the dragon and then it turns out mel is being damon and

1864
02:02:15,090 --> 02:02:21,270
Stu:
she's like oh actually maybe i should rule giraffe zero slow and steady you surface the throne.

1865
02:02:25,630 --> 02:02:29,950
Excerpts:
I hope you all feel like arguing with either stew or myself about anything on

1866
02:02:29,950 --> 02:02:31,550
Excerpts:
this episode or anything in general.

1867
02:02:31,690 --> 02:02:38,230
Excerpts:
And you can find many ways of getting in touch with us at our website at draft-zero.com.

1868
02:02:38,510 --> 02:02:42,650
Excerpts:
At the website, you'll also find the show notes for this and all our other episodes.

1869
02:02:42,830 --> 02:02:48,170
Excerpts:
As well as links to support us and spread the word for free via a rating and

1870
02:02:48,170 --> 02:02:51,250
Excerpts:
review on Apple Podcasts. Very important for spreading the word.

1871
02:02:51,350 --> 02:02:56,330
Excerpts:
Or if you think that what we do here is worth a dollar or preferably more than

1872
02:02:56,330 --> 02:03:01,350
Excerpts:
a dollar, then you can also find links to our Patreon page to to support us

1873
02:03:01,350 --> 02:03:03,810
Excerpts:
getting these episodes to you quicker.

1874
02:03:04,690 --> 02:03:07,150
Excerpts:
Thanks. And thanks for listening.