This is a Physician in the Loop special topic. The cut Congress wrote Most of next year's Medicare cut to doctors is written into law. Congress should tie the yearly update to what practices pay, and the new same-day cut will move appointments more than money. Medicare will cut its standard base rate for physicians' services by about 2.3 percent next year, more than it proposed in July. The final fee schedule, released on Nov. 4, lowers the conversion factor, the dollar amount Medicare multiplies by the value it assigns each service. Every $100 Medicare paid this year becomes about $97.70 in January, unless the service's own value changes. “We are changing what Medicare pays for to change what our health system delivers,” said the health secretary, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Most of that cut was written in advance. Congress gave doctors a one-year raise of 2.5 percent for 2026, which ends on Jan. 1. The yearly increase the law provides, a quarter of a point, replaces only a sliver, so the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, CMS, says current law requires a cut. Doctors who qualify through Medicare's advanced payment models lose 1.8 percent. The cut grew after July because a balancing adjustment turned slightly negative. Medicare's yearly update has fallen far behind the cost of running a practice. A cut built into the law costs doctors as a group more than anything CMS decided, and Congress should tie the update to those costs. The cut CMS chose on visits billed the same day as a minor procedure is likelier to move appointments than to save money. Medicare's own figures show the gap. In July CMS projected that the Medicare Economic Index, its yardstick for practice costs, would rise 2.5 percent in 2027. The base rate will fall 2.3 percent. Costs and price will move nearly five points apart in one year. The American Medical Association calculates that Medicare's payment to physicians, adjusted for inflation in practice costs, has fallen about a third since 2001. In July its chief executive, John Whyte, wrote that “physicians remain the only Medicare provider type that does not receive an annual payment update tied to inflation.” CMS's same-day cut is narrower. When a doctor bills an office visit as a distinct service on the same day as a minor procedure, one with no follow-up days built into its price, Medicare will pay the cheaper of the two at 80 percent. Its reasoning is that there are efficiencies when the same physician does both, and that it is “likely duplicating payment under the current payment methodology.” Patients pay part of that duplication too, the agency says. Opposing the July proposal, the AMA wrote that the procedures most affected were already priced to cover only the work and costs beyond the visit. Dermatologists, ear, nose and throat surgeons and podiatrists take the largest hits from it. A procedure moved to another day is paid in full, and so is the visit. The American Academy of Family Physicians warned in September that CMS's proposal, a 50 percent cut, would encourage practices “to turn patients away for same-day procedures and have patients return another day to have the procedure performed.” Delayed or specialist care, it added, “could cost the agency more money” than paying for both at once. The final version is gentler. It points the same way. The academy said that is especially hard on patients of limited means or limited mobility. For them a second appointment is another ride and another lost afternoon, and the discount on their share of the bill is gone. Medicare's advisers see little sign of a crisis. The Medicare Payment Advisory Commission found this year that, in some surveys, the share of clinicians accepting Medicare is comparable with the share accepting private insurance, and that very few opt out. Physician pay, in survey data it cited, rose 6 percent in one recent year, about twice the rate of inflation. Dr. Mehmet Oz, the CMS administrator, says fee-for-service payment has “rewarded volume over value, fueling a reactive system of sick care.” None of this defends the update. The commission asked Congress to raise 2027's update above current law, and a year earlier recommended an update equal to the cost index's projected rise, less a point. A flat cut rewards nothing. Congress should stop patching. The Patients First Act, from Reps. John Joyce, Greg Murphy and Kim Schrier, two Republicans and a Democrat, all physicians, would set a permanent yearly update at the Medicare Economic Index minus one point, held between a quarter and three-quarters of the index's rise. At July's projection that is about one and a half points, short of costs but six times current law's quarter point. Rural doctors take the same national cut, and the bill would extend and raise the floor under Medicare's geographic adjustment for their work, which the AMA says helps physicians in many rural areas and 34 entire states. Practices have less than eight weeks to load the new modifier, B1, which replaces the add-on for the complexity of ongoing care and adds 16 percent to the visit's payment. The same-day cut reaches only procedures with no follow-up days, so check the global period of those done most. The harder choice concerns patients. Where a procedure can safely be done that day, it should be, rather than sending people home to avoid a 20 percent cut on one of two services. CMS should publish within a year how often same-day procedures moved to a second visit. Mr. Kennedy is right that what Medicare pays for changes what the health system delivers. From January it will pay less for each unit of work, and less again for two things in one visit. Doctors will fall further behind their costs, and some patients, as family physicians warned when the cut was proposed, may be asked to come back another day. Congress can fix the update before Jan. 1, and it should. This special topic was read by an AI voice. Its sources are linked at physicianintheloop.org.