Dr. J talks with musician Joshua Leventhal about something Christian often struggles to make room for: honesty. What happens when our songs and subculture leaves little room for anger, grief, doubt, or disappointment? Drawing on Scripture, the Psalms, and his experience as a musician, Joshua explores why honest artistic expression matters—not just for making better art, but for being human and growing in faith.
The conversation considers how church culture can subtly sanitize our emotional lives, rewarding certainty and celebration while leaving lament, confession, and vulnerability at the margins. Justin and Joshua explore the biblical case for bringing the full range of human emotion before God, asking what we lose when worship prioritizes what’s smooth and positive.
They also examine the influence of market forces on Christian music and the pressure to produce art that fits familiar expectations. What happens when the demands of an industry—or the preferences of a congregation—begin to shape what we're willing to sing, say, and feel? Rather than treating art as a decorative addition to spiritual life, Joshua argues that it can be one of our most formative influences, shaping the stories we tell about God and ourselves.
Fortunately, hope doesn't require us to rush past grief; we often have to sit with sorrow before we can discover what hope actually means. For anyone who has struggled to find their own emotional life reflected in Christian worship, wondered whether doubt has a place in faith, or grown weary of spirituality that always seems to put on a happy face, this conversation offers an invitation to embrace a more honest faith—and to make room for the kind of art that helps us get there.
LINKS: