WEBVTT

NOTE
This file was generated by Descript 

00:00:03.104 --> 00:00:06.364
Welcome to The Boardroom Path
by Sainty Hird & Partners.

00:00:06.709 --> 00:00:10.599
I'm your host, Ralph Grayson, a
partner in the board practice.

00:00:10.968 --> 00:00:15.528
In this series, we'll offer practical
steps and useful perspectives for

00:00:15.528 --> 00:00:17.868
aspiring and newly appointed NEDs.

00:00:18.216 --> 00:00:21.896
Throughout its 30 year history,
Sainty Hird has recruited senior

00:00:21.896 --> 00:00:27.791
board members across the City,
Industry, the Public Sector and NGOs.

00:00:28.681 --> 00:00:33.351
We're now also evaluating those boards,
as well as coaching and mentoring

00:00:33.561 --> 00:00:38.021
those seeking to transition from an
executive career into the boardroom.

00:00:38.189 --> 00:00:40.819
So we'll be speaking to some
leading figures in the board

00:00:40.819 --> 00:00:42.269
advisory and NED world.

00:00:42.934 --> 00:00:47.284
Specifically, we'll seek their
counsel about how and where to spend

00:00:47.284 --> 00:00:51.454
time and energy to make an effective
transition into the boardroom.

00:00:52.654 --> 00:00:59.004
The goal is to equip recent and aspiring
NEDs with tips, tactics and strategies

00:00:59.344 --> 00:01:04.754
to be most effective and build a
successful career as a board director.

00:01:05.684 --> 00:01:09.594
In the process, we aim to help you
to think more about who you are,

00:01:10.054 --> 00:01:14.014
how you operate and how you can
make this work in the boardroom.

00:01:14.556 --> 00:01:17.085
I'm delighted today to
welcome Kieran Moynihan.

00:01:17.462 --> 00:01:21.747
Kieran is the managing partner of
Board Excellence, a specialist board

00:01:21.747 --> 00:01:25.487
practice supporting and enabling
boards of directors and individual

00:01:25.487 --> 00:01:30.797
directors in Ireland, the UK, Europe
and internationally, excelling in the

00:01:30.797 --> 00:01:33.027
areas of effectiveness and performance.

00:01:33.937 --> 00:01:38.657
Kieran has over 25 years serving on
boards as a CEO and an executive director,

00:01:39.027 --> 00:01:41.677
non executive director and board chair.

00:01:42.337 --> 00:01:45.267
Kieran is an internationally
recognised thought leader in the area

00:01:45.267 --> 00:01:49.747
of board dynamics, effectiveness,
performance and corporate governance.

00:01:50.397 --> 00:01:54.157
He's a regular contributor to
leading board publications and

00:01:54.157 --> 00:01:58.087
has developed ground breaking new
approaches to optimising the so

00:01:58.087 --> 00:02:00.067
called people equation of the board.

00:02:00.577 --> 00:02:05.237
The partnership between executive and non
executive board members and enabling the

00:02:05.247 --> 00:02:08.197
board to excel as a high performing team.

00:02:08.473 --> 00:02:12.108
He's the chairman and non executive
director of a number of high growth,

00:02:12.188 --> 00:02:16.778
globally focused companies across
sectors such as technology and health.

00:02:17.010 --> 00:02:20.880
Providing strong support and independent
strategic thinking to the overall

00:02:20.910 --> 00:02:23.690
board team and the CEO executive team.

00:02:24.130 --> 00:02:27.820
Leveraging his deep international
expertise in business development,

00:02:28.130 --> 00:02:31.250
sales, finance, operations and M&A.

00:02:31.694 --> 00:02:36.134
Kieran also has a deep expertise in
technology and supporting boards in

00:02:36.134 --> 00:02:41.439
key areas such as cyber security,
big data, digital transformation

00:02:41.739 --> 00:02:43.299
and artificial intelligence.

00:02:44.139 --> 00:02:45.639
Kieran, hi and welcome to London.

00:02:46.014 --> 00:02:46.954
Thanks very much, Ralph.

00:02:46.974 --> 00:02:48.054
Delighted to be here.

00:02:48.479 --> 00:02:53.339
Perhaps we can start with some background
on you as a Technology Founder CEO and

00:02:53.339 --> 00:02:57.799
your journey into the world of board
evaluation and the advisory services that

00:02:57.809 --> 00:03:01.149
align with that and perhaps introduce
yourself a little more formally.

00:03:01.388 --> 00:03:01.918
Thanks, Ralph.

00:03:01.938 --> 00:03:03.928
So, my name is Kieran Moynihan.

00:03:03.928 --> 00:03:05.908
I'm the managing partner
of Board Excellence.

00:03:06.294 --> 00:03:11.438
By background, I'm an electrical
engineer, and in the late nineties,

00:03:11.498 --> 00:03:16.528
got the entrepreneurial start up
bug founded a telecommunications

00:03:16.528 --> 00:03:21.688
software company and we raised about
30 million euros investment funding

00:03:21.688 --> 00:03:23.338
from venture capitalists at the time.

00:03:23.908 --> 00:03:27.065
Had a fantastic, but very
quite challenging, tough

00:03:27.065 --> 00:03:28.885
journey over the eight years.

00:03:29.245 --> 00:03:34.145
We ended up getting acquired by IBM,
which is a great outcome in 2007.

00:03:34.849 --> 00:03:39.817
But the genesis of why an electrical
engineer has ended up leading an

00:03:39.817 --> 00:03:44.767
international board consulting practice
was laid there and that I was blessed

00:03:44.767 --> 00:03:46.617
with a fantastic board of directors.

00:03:47.467 --> 00:03:51.037
So on my board, I had four
investor nominee directors from

00:03:51.037 --> 00:03:52.817
various venture capital firms.

00:03:53.237 --> 00:03:57.317
Our lead investor was HG Capital
here in London, and I had two

00:03:57.357 --> 00:03:59.287
independent non exec directors.

00:04:00.267 --> 00:04:03.787
And in terms of the six non exec
directors, one was better than the other.

00:04:03.837 --> 00:04:09.287
And collectively, they were a huge factor
in us making it, and that gave me a great

00:04:09.287 --> 00:04:13.777
interest in the whole areas of boards
and governance and particularly how

00:04:13.777 --> 00:04:16.237
executive teams and boards work together.

00:04:16.877 --> 00:04:21.897
At the time, I was a rookie CEO, had
no board experience, no governance

00:04:21.897 --> 00:04:29.029
experience, was a decent engineer, but no
real serious, management, expertise, and

00:04:29.499 --> 00:04:34.520
it was a real shot to the system in some
respects, having raised the investment

00:04:34.530 --> 00:04:38.210
to suddenly realize that you are now
accountable to a board of directors.

00:04:38.784 --> 00:04:42.444
From the very outset, they were
quite challenging and tough,

00:04:42.864 --> 00:04:44.674
but extremely supportive.

00:04:44.875 --> 00:04:49.045
In some respects, it was like having six
owls around the table, one wiser than

00:04:49.055 --> 00:04:55.094
the next, but very thoughtful and, really
had a brilliant chair at the time, a

00:04:55.114 --> 00:04:59.314
fantastic gentleman called Ian Armitage,
who was the CEO of HG Capital at the time.

00:04:59.844 --> 00:05:04.014
And he was just incredible in terms
of his guidance and that just gave me

00:05:04.024 --> 00:05:07.391
great interest in the area of boards.

00:05:07.584 --> 00:05:13.334
After serving for three years as a vice
president in IBM, I decided to actually

00:05:13.334 --> 00:05:18.534
take a step back from the executive
world and became a board chair myself for

00:05:18.544 --> 00:05:22.779
Venture Capital, a private equity backed
companies based in Ireland, in various

00:05:22.799 --> 00:05:28.209
technology, in particular sectors, and in
the health medical devices area as well.

00:05:28.683 --> 00:05:33.299
Really enjoyed the chair, role, and
I still do that today, 14 years on.

00:05:33.359 --> 00:05:39.591
But I suppose in that time, I just had
a great, interest and probably around

00:05:39.591 --> 00:05:44.690
2015, 2016, a number of board investment
firms and board of directors were

00:05:44.690 --> 00:05:46.399
asking me for my help and guidance.

00:05:46.399 --> 00:05:50.305
And that was the genesis then of
Board Excellence starting in 2016.

00:05:50.980 --> 00:05:55.325
So, Board Excellence, as with all
good businesses has its mission

00:05:55.325 --> 00:05:56.915
and its purpose clearly stated.

00:05:56.978 --> 00:06:02.508
Yours is empowering boards to excel in
effectiveness, governance and performance.

00:06:02.838 --> 00:06:06.498
Perhaps you can just talk a little bit
about what that actually means for you and

00:06:06.498 --> 00:06:09.858
a little bit more about Board Excellence
in terms of type of clients you work

00:06:09.858 --> 00:06:14.078
with, the sort of missions and mandates
that you're given, and how you're trying

00:06:14.078 --> 00:06:15.438
to make an impact in the boardroom.

00:06:15.662 --> 00:06:21.298
The key thing for us is just given
the critical responsibility that

00:06:21.358 --> 00:06:27.258
the board directors collectively and
individually have been entrusted with from

00:06:27.618 --> 00:06:32.478
particularly obviously the shareholders
as the providers of capital, but also

00:06:32.548 --> 00:06:37.038
in quite a strong way their employees,
their stakeholders, their customers,

00:06:37.678 --> 00:06:43.059
that the effectiveness, decision
making, and ultimately performance

00:06:43.199 --> 00:06:48.100
of the board of directors and the
executive team together, dictate the

00:06:48.118 --> 00:06:50.726
future of organizations and companies.

00:06:51.198 --> 00:06:56.932
Our key mission is to really help
them be at their best, to get the

00:06:56.942 --> 00:07:02.777
best out of each other, and to truly
excel for their shareholders, but also

00:07:02.837 --> 00:07:04.777
their employees, their stakeholders.

00:07:05.117 --> 00:07:10.267
We would have very much, a focus on a
kind of servant leadership type model

00:07:10.297 --> 00:07:15.447
for board of directors that we set the
bar really high for them in terms of

00:07:15.817 --> 00:07:21.227
how they function, their effectiveness,
and ultimately the quality of their

00:07:21.237 --> 00:07:23.257
decision making, their performance.

00:07:23.403 --> 00:07:27.760
Then in terms of how we help boards we
have kind of four areas that we focus on.

00:07:28.154 --> 00:07:31.428
The biggest area that we
particularly specialize in is

00:07:31.438 --> 00:07:33.478
in external board evaluations.

00:07:33.948 --> 00:07:38.608
So that's where for a lot of
companies and organizations they

00:07:38.608 --> 00:07:42.298
would have a requirement normally
every three years to do a fully

00:07:42.328 --> 00:07:44.618
independent external board evaluation.

00:07:45.214 --> 00:07:49.793
We would be known, I suppose, as a
very thorough and very honest evaluator

00:07:49.793 --> 00:07:52.283
of boards and we set the bar high.

00:07:52.663 --> 00:07:56.900
We really examine the effectiveness
of the board and the committees and

00:07:56.900 --> 00:07:58.570
how they work with the executive team.

00:07:59.040 --> 00:08:03.640
We look at that and assess 20 different
areas and we put it all in together

00:08:03.870 --> 00:08:08.180
to give an overall assessment of
the board and we're effectively

00:08:08.210 --> 00:08:10.140
doing three things in each area.

00:08:10.610 --> 00:08:12.990
We're giving a very honest
assessment of where we see the

00:08:12.990 --> 00:08:14.630
board and executive team today.

00:08:15.425 --> 00:08:20.325
We compare them with the best that we see
for comparable peer type boards, if it

00:08:20.325 --> 00:08:22.725
was a FTSE or AIM company, for example.

00:08:23.405 --> 00:08:27.505
And finally, in some respects, the
most important part is we lay out

00:08:27.505 --> 00:08:30.945
a set of recommendations to help
them drive improvement in the board

00:08:30.945 --> 00:08:32.375
effectiveness and performance.

00:08:33.025 --> 00:08:35.865
The second area then that
we focus on is training.

00:08:36.105 --> 00:08:40.055
So we do quite a lot of training for
boards of directors, for groups of

00:08:40.055 --> 00:08:42.775
directors, for groups of chairs, CEOs.

00:08:43.260 --> 00:08:48.080
We do a lot of work with founder CEOs,
for example, just yesterday, I gave a

00:08:48.110 --> 00:08:54.002
workshop to 30 founder CEOs a leading
international venture capital firm.

00:08:54.227 --> 00:08:57.607
And the workshop will really just help
them how to work with their boards.

00:08:57.817 --> 00:09:01.056
Because it's an area founders, CEOs
in particular, find quite challenging.

00:09:01.666 --> 00:09:06.086
The third area then for us is where we do
a lot of advisory services and boards and

00:09:06.086 --> 00:09:11.373
governance, helping them develop committee
terms of reference, chair succession

00:09:11.403 --> 00:09:13.313
planning, board diversity planning.

00:09:13.808 --> 00:09:17.838
All different guidance on this, both the
technical aspects of corporate governance,

00:09:17.838 --> 00:09:21.818
another popular area that we do quite
a lot of helping the board in terms of

00:09:21.818 --> 00:09:23.928
CEO succession planning, for example.

00:09:24.608 --> 00:09:30.158
The final area then that we provide
support on is in board dispute mediation.

00:09:30.528 --> 00:09:34.599
So around the world, we mediate
quite a lot of board disputes.

00:09:34.979 --> 00:09:39.219
Most of the time it's where the
relationship has broken down between

00:09:39.219 --> 00:09:40.749
the executive team and the board.

00:09:40.827 --> 00:09:46.397
Trust has been broken and in many cases
it's getting close to literally having

00:09:46.397 --> 00:09:51.195
to go to the courts and we often get
asked to come in just to help to see can

00:09:51.195 --> 00:09:55.108
we rebuild the relationship and trust
between the executive team and the board.

00:09:55.928 --> 00:09:56.618
Fascinating.

00:09:57.068 --> 00:10:00.978
One of the things we've dwelled on
with some other guests in the past is

00:10:01.298 --> 00:10:06.648
the fact that the title NED isn't all
encompassing and boards aren't generic.

00:10:06.708 --> 00:10:10.838
I know you've worked in the UK,
you've worked in Europe, you've

00:10:10.848 --> 00:10:12.028
worked in Africa, I think.

00:10:12.058 --> 00:10:17.193
Whether it's public, private, Geographical
domain, perhaps regulatory environment,

00:10:17.634 --> 00:10:20.283
how does that perhaps change the
way you think about a board, the

00:10:20.283 --> 00:10:25.163
constituent members of the board, its
mission, its purpose, its added value?

00:10:25.443 --> 00:10:28.543
It's a very interesting, point,
Ralph, that at this stage we've

00:10:28.553 --> 00:10:32.323
helped boards in over 35 countries
internationally and growing.

00:10:32.943 --> 00:10:36.373
And what's really interesting is that
whether it's a publicly listed company,

00:10:36.423 --> 00:10:41.953
a charity, private equity backed company,
a not for profit membership body.

00:10:42.471 --> 00:10:45.881
Ninety percent of the responsibilities
of a board director are quite

00:10:45.881 --> 00:10:48.301
similar for a non executive director.

00:10:48.351 --> 00:10:52.141
When we think about the role and
responsibilities of a non executive

00:10:52.141 --> 00:10:57.281
director, we always think of in kind of
two sets or buckets of responsibility.

00:10:57.664 --> 00:11:02.874
And the first kind of core foundation
set of responsibilities is oversight,

00:11:03.399 --> 00:11:08.479
and governance and a key role for the
non exec director individually and

00:11:08.479 --> 00:11:13.199
then collectively together is to hold
the CEO and executive teams feet to

00:11:13.199 --> 00:11:16.639
the fire in their performance, their
decision making, their behaviors.

00:11:17.105 --> 00:11:20.355
That oversight and that
structure and that level of

00:11:20.355 --> 00:11:22.955
accountability,  that's a fundamental.

00:11:23.055 --> 00:11:26.995
With that then comes ensuring the highest
standards of corporate governance, risk

00:11:26.995 --> 00:11:31.375
management, internal controls, quality
of external, internal audit, et cetera.

00:11:31.796 --> 00:11:37.066
But on that set of responsibilities then
is then balanced by the responsibilities

00:11:37.066 --> 00:11:42.551
of the non exec director to actually help
support and encourage the executive team.

00:11:43.271 --> 00:11:48.694
Because one of the benefits of having a
board of non exec directors is you have

00:11:48.694 --> 00:11:50.734
a lot of experience around the table.

00:11:51.084 --> 00:11:55.584
The vast majority of non exec directors
were senior executives themselves.

00:11:56.124 --> 00:12:01.064
So there's a wealth of experience
around the table that the

00:12:01.064 --> 00:12:02.734
executive team can tap into.

00:12:03.389 --> 00:12:06.449
And that's where you get the
real, magic in a boardroom.

00:12:06.869 --> 00:12:12.159
When you get a fantastic partnership
between the executive team and the non

00:12:12.159 --> 00:12:17.329
exec directors, that kind of balance,
strong oversight and excellence and

00:12:17.329 --> 00:12:22.281
governance, but with a lot of value
add and support to the executive team.

00:12:22.751 --> 00:12:27.481
One of the other interesting aspects
about the definition of non executive

00:12:27.481 --> 00:12:32.441
director is that they're not in the
machine day to day, hour to hour.

00:12:33.091 --> 00:12:39.121
And that brings incredibly valuable
independence of mind and objectivity.

00:12:39.771 --> 00:12:44.031
That when the non exec directors are
sitting at the table and the CEO and

00:12:44.031 --> 00:12:48.277
the executive team are laying out some
serious challenges, potential decisions

00:12:48.297 --> 00:12:50.220
that they want the board to support.

00:12:50.723 --> 00:12:54.890
They're at this 90 hours a week, seven
days a week, and they are so close to

00:12:54.890 --> 00:12:58.540
it, but sometimes they're so close that
they can't see the wood from the trees.

00:12:59.320 --> 00:13:04.400
And the value of non executive
directors bring in that objectivity

00:13:04.530 --> 00:13:08.863
and honesty is incredibly valuable,
to help an executive team.

00:13:09.193 --> 00:13:14.683
When you look at the role of non executive
directors and how it's evolved, there

00:13:14.683 --> 00:13:19.703
was always the bias towards the first
part around governance and oversight.

00:13:20.075 --> 00:13:23.545
But as the years have gone by, I
think when you look at a modern board

00:13:23.545 --> 00:13:26.335
of directors now, and it doesn't
matter whether it's a FTSE board

00:13:26.395 --> 00:13:31.545
or a charity board, there's a lot
more expected of non exec directors.

00:13:32.060 --> 00:13:37.270
You absolutely always need to do your
job of oversight and governance because

00:13:37.270 --> 00:13:40.806
you've been entrusted, to safeguard
the health of the organisation.

00:13:41.536 --> 00:13:45.576
But what distinguishes the really good
non exec directors from the average

00:13:46.046 --> 00:13:49.666
is the amount of value and support
they provide to the executive team.

00:13:50.206 --> 00:13:54.542
And if you have an environment where the
executive team are doing really well, And

00:13:54.582 --> 00:14:00.258
they actually welcome the board stretching
them, really setting ambitious targets,

00:14:00.268 --> 00:14:04.638
obviously helping them and where needed,
hauling them over the coals, giving them

00:14:04.638 --> 00:14:06.528
a dose of salts for poor performance.

00:14:07.368 --> 00:14:10.758
That's where you get exceptional
boards and executive teams together.

00:14:11.069 --> 00:14:14.809
A lot of our listeners will
be new, or aspiring NEDs.

00:14:15.289 --> 00:14:18.109
For those who haven't been in the
heat of battle in the boardroom,

00:14:18.586 --> 00:14:21.586
let's turn to what I know you talk
about the iceberg of dysfunction.

00:14:22.156 --> 00:14:25.646
Why do you think so many boards
struggle with their performance?

00:14:26.016 --> 00:14:28.946
And for you what are the key
signs of a poor performing board?

00:14:29.851 --> 00:14:36.098
For me, Ralph, I always come back to
that 90 percent of serious problems

00:14:36.098 --> 00:14:38.738
on impact boards are people related.

00:14:39.015 --> 00:14:41.245
There's no shortage of
experience around the table.

00:14:41.365 --> 00:14:46.195
There's a lot of experience, non execs
and executives with very impressive CVs.

00:14:47.105 --> 00:14:52.495
But the reality of getting a group of
board directors and executives to be able

00:14:52.495 --> 00:14:58.205
to build a working relationship and to
trust together, to be able to function and

00:14:58.205 --> 00:15:00.255
to be able to really stretch each other.

00:15:00.473 --> 00:15:03.653
That's where then you start to
get all types of challenges.

00:15:04.033 --> 00:15:08.783
We often say that the best boards
and executive teams, they have

00:15:08.793 --> 00:15:14.003
this virtuous cycle of challenge,
debate, respect, and trust.

00:15:14.455 --> 00:15:17.860
We find really good boards
and executive teams are very

00:15:17.900 --> 00:15:19.520
comfortable stretching each other.

00:15:19.860 --> 00:15:23.680
So the quality and level of robust
debate is quite significant.

00:15:24.244 --> 00:15:27.874
But when you have a situation, and
I suppose, give an example, the

00:15:27.874 --> 00:15:32.784
most common problematic board of
directors is where you have an overly

00:15:32.784 --> 00:15:38.154
dominant CEO and the CEO doesn't
really want to challenge and debate.

00:15:38.484 --> 00:15:41.234
They don't appreciate their
feet being held to the fire.

00:15:41.874 --> 00:15:45.004
Obviously, when you're in the stock
market or corporate board, in a lot

00:15:45.004 --> 00:15:49.269
of cases, they know they have no
choice and they'll get along with it.

00:15:49.359 --> 00:15:52.259
That doesn't change the fact
that they don't really welcome

00:15:52.349 --> 00:15:53.549
the challenge and debate.

00:15:54.269 --> 00:15:59.829
And in those particular cases
where a CEO who on paper works

00:15:59.839 --> 00:16:03.549
for the board of directors, but is
really dominating the boardroom.

00:16:04.109 --> 00:16:07.309
The first person I always looked in
that situation and is the board chair.

00:16:07.769 --> 00:16:10.389
The board chair leads
the board of directors.

00:16:10.519 --> 00:16:13.529
The CEO works for the board
chair and the board of directors.

00:16:14.049 --> 00:16:15.979
So when you see that type of dynamic.

00:16:16.419 --> 00:16:20.489
You'll often recognize then that either
the chair is too close to the CEO

00:16:21.079 --> 00:16:24.649
or that the chair just isn't strong
enough to actually lead the board.

00:16:25.199 --> 00:16:30.429
And what happens, of course, in that
type of situation is that the non exec

00:16:30.429 --> 00:16:32.349
directors get more and more frustrated.

00:16:32.779 --> 00:16:35.469
That they can't really
challenge the CEO properly.

00:16:35.769 --> 00:16:38.999
CEO and the other executives
don't really respect their role.

00:16:39.669 --> 00:16:44.759
And you start to get then a vicious
cycle of a lot of unhealthy tensions

00:16:44.949 --> 00:16:49.739
and conflict, and sometimes when you
see board directors step down from

00:16:49.739 --> 00:16:53.259
a board and you say, God, they're
only on that board four years.

00:16:53.429 --> 00:16:54.929
They have another five years to go.

00:16:55.079 --> 00:16:56.069
Why are they leaving?

00:16:56.529 --> 00:16:59.070
Sometimes it's they've just
given up at that stage.

00:16:59.410 --> 00:17:01.335
So that's a particularly common problem.

00:17:01.727 --> 00:17:06.167
Other types of problems then
are where you just don't have

00:17:06.497 --> 00:17:08.007
the firepower on the board.

00:17:08.397 --> 00:17:12.727
So you have non exec directors
who on paper have the experience,

00:17:12.967 --> 00:17:14.607
CVs look very impressive.

00:17:15.004 --> 00:17:18.906
But the caliber that's there,
the mix of expertise around the

00:17:18.906 --> 00:17:23.366
table,  the amount of value that
they have to add, isn't good enough.

00:17:23.676 --> 00:17:27.036
What often happens then is the executive
team starts to get very frustrated.

00:17:27.591 --> 00:17:30.611
That we don't have a board who's
strong enough for added value.

00:17:31.101 --> 00:17:34.521
Sometimes you see boards that,
haven't been refreshed in a long

00:17:34.571 --> 00:17:36.391
time and have gone very stale.

00:17:37.311 --> 00:17:40.361
And one of the other interesting things
that happens, Ralph, and this is just

00:17:40.361 --> 00:17:46.046
human nature, is I've seen over the
years, some really strong, independent,

00:17:46.056 --> 00:17:51.765
non exec directors who start on a board
and the first couple of years the fire

00:17:51.815 --> 00:17:55.885
really is in the belly in terms of
challenge, debate and it's suddenly

00:17:55.885 --> 00:18:00.045
over the years to just start building a
really good relationship with the CEO and

00:18:00.055 --> 00:18:05.655
the executive team and they've suddenly
been in the trenches five, six years and

00:18:05.765 --> 00:18:10.875
suddenly then the blade of independent,
robust challenge starts to dull a bit.

00:18:11.601 --> 00:18:14.849
That's where we just find where
sometimes the non exec directors have

00:18:14.849 --> 00:18:16.999
gone native a bit with the board.

00:18:17.439 --> 00:18:22.709
And that's why one of the recent trends
is you're starting to see boards being

00:18:22.719 --> 00:18:26.279
refreshed and people not waiting for
someone to have served their nine years

00:18:26.339 --> 00:18:28.339
on a FTSE or AIM board, for example.

00:18:28.849 --> 00:18:32.139
And a very wise board chair
recognising that there's times

00:18:32.139 --> 00:18:34.369
where you generally need new blood.

00:18:34.989 --> 00:18:40.049
And you use that opportunity sometimes
to add specific expertise onto the board,

00:18:40.049 --> 00:18:45.759
whether that's technology and AI and ESG
and HR and all of those type of areas.

00:18:46.292 --> 00:18:52.703
so it's interesting that there is quite
a wide range of, problematic type boards.

00:18:53.153 --> 00:18:56.583
We've evaluated hundreds of boards
at this stage and when we look at

00:18:56.583 --> 00:19:01.883
the research around the world, we
actually find that only one in five

00:19:01.913 --> 00:19:06.343
boards fall into the category of
high performing and strong boards.

00:19:07.003 --> 00:19:10.403
There's about a third that would
be average, functional, and there's

00:19:10.403 --> 00:19:15.543
probably about 20 percent that are
mediocre, dysfunctional, in any case,

00:19:15.733 --> 00:19:17.653
do not excel for the shareholders.

00:19:18.193 --> 00:19:23.803
And another interesting thing we find is
that the experience of non exec directors

00:19:23.833 --> 00:19:25.763
is no guarantee of their performance.

00:19:25.823 --> 00:19:30.253
Some of the boards that we've
evaluated and we've given a very

00:19:30.253 --> 00:19:32.793
challenging rating of ineffective.

00:19:33.188 --> 00:19:38.568
or dysfunctional, for example, have
had incredibly experienced non exec

00:19:38.568 --> 00:19:42.358
directors on the board, and a lot
of the non exec directors find that

00:19:42.498 --> 00:19:44.188
feedback quite challenging to get.

00:19:44.815 --> 00:19:49.120
Let's bring that into today's boardroom
then so we've got Trump with yet

00:19:49.120 --> 00:19:53.185
another series of executive orders,
with the old bonfire of the acronyms,

00:19:53.195 --> 00:19:58.485
so DEI, ESG, what's driving that
agenda and what impact do you think

00:19:58.635 --> 00:20:02.645
that's having on what board members are
having to think about at the moment?

00:20:02.666 --> 00:20:05.716
Let's try and imagine ourselves in the
BP boardroom at the moment with Elliot

00:20:05.736 --> 00:20:10.060
as an activist, suddenly going on
the cap table and the share register.

00:20:10.110 --> 00:20:13.179
How should that change the way
a NED thinks about their role.

00:20:13.999 --> 00:20:18.099
To be honest, Ralph, I think any of
us who've, worked in the board and

00:20:18.099 --> 00:20:23.344
governance area over the last couple of
years and have seen just how hard it was

00:20:23.724 --> 00:20:30.354
to progress the ESG, DEI agendas, you
know, there was a lot of regulators and

00:20:30.684 --> 00:20:37.534
governments and institutional investors
really had to work hard to change the kind

00:20:37.534 --> 00:20:42.454
of makeup of a lot of boards and really
push the critical, important agendas

00:20:42.484 --> 00:20:48.760
in climate change, in DEI, in gender,
diversity and representation on boards.

00:20:49.390 --> 00:20:54.939
It's absolutely frightening how many
corporate boards in the U. S. have

00:20:54.939 --> 00:21:02.544
suddenly, literally overnight, abandoned
all the incredible DEI and ESG commitments

00:21:02.544 --> 00:21:05.724
and initiatives that they had made to
great fanfare over the last couple of

00:21:05.734 --> 00:21:10.252
years and suddenly overnight literally
have thrown them all out the window.

00:21:10.792 --> 00:21:16.252
For me, when I see that, I immediately
think about the moral compass of that

00:21:16.252 --> 00:21:19.282
board of directors and its core values.

00:21:19.743 --> 00:21:25.851
While at times, the whole area of ESG
and DEI did become overhyped and was a

00:21:25.851 --> 00:21:28.681
bit, probably too puritanical at times.

00:21:29.081 --> 00:21:33.588
At its core, the values in there are
really important and decent, it doesn't

00:21:33.608 --> 00:21:35.398
matter what country you are in the world.

00:21:36.058 --> 00:21:40.738
But I think the fact that so many
corporate boards, unfortunately, which

00:21:40.738 --> 00:21:45.508
surprised me all the more, aided and
abetted by some of the world's largest

00:21:45.508 --> 00:21:51.348
institutional investors,  aligning with
the Trump sentiment about, let's get rid

00:21:51.348 --> 00:21:53.378
of all of these, they're holding us back.

00:21:53.714 --> 00:21:58.398
I think what a lot of Trump is doing
ultimately is trying to undermine

00:21:58.438 --> 00:22:02.998
regulators, undermine the standards
of corporate governance, ultimately

00:22:03.068 --> 00:22:09.008
with this mission of, really
bringing capitalism back to where

00:22:09.008 --> 00:22:10.558
Trump and others think it should be.

00:22:10.783 --> 00:22:15.566
And that's an extremely free unregulated
markets where the commitment to

00:22:15.566 --> 00:22:19.976
do the right thing and decency and
values like that, are out the window.

00:22:21.031 --> 00:22:25.850
I'm just thinking about Goldman Sachs
announcing that hitherto they'd said

00:22:25.850 --> 00:22:29.260
we won't advise or list any company
that doesn't have a diverse board

00:22:29.760 --> 00:22:33.140
and now they've turned around said
well that race is largely won, right?

00:22:33.149 --> 00:22:37.651
The mission is done, it's got a
momentum, it doesn't need any more

00:22:37.751 --> 00:22:39.571
help from us or lends from us.

00:22:39.591 --> 00:22:43.211
You've been doing this a long time, what's
changed in terms of that North Star,

00:22:43.231 --> 00:22:45.091
the mission that you alluded to there?

00:22:45.417 --> 00:22:46.977
Let's just touch on diversity.

00:22:47.217 --> 00:22:48.367
Where do you think that has got to?

00:22:48.367 --> 00:22:50.707
Is it now embedded in
every boards thinking?

00:22:50.722 --> 00:22:53.754
Is it like, B Corp certification
was the thing that a board

00:22:53.764 --> 00:22:55.264
wanted to have two years ago.

00:22:55.664 --> 00:22:59.829
Now, I turn to younger board members
and I'll say, no, no, no, everybody

00:22:59.829 --> 00:23:01.629
should be B Corp certified now.

00:23:01.629 --> 00:23:02.447
That's a given.

00:23:02.447 --> 00:23:04.617
There's no need to push
that agenda anymore.

00:23:04.637 --> 00:23:07.897
So are Goldman reflecting the
way boards are now thinking?

00:23:08.117 --> 00:23:12.177
Or are they reacting perhaps, shall
we say, more commercial influences?

00:23:13.032 --> 00:23:18.352
Yeah, it is fair to say that in terms
of you look at board diversity and

00:23:18.352 --> 00:23:23.302
DEI and ESG, there has been a lot
achieved in the last couple of years.

00:23:23.802 --> 00:23:25.822
So we work all across the world.

00:23:26.452 --> 00:23:31.762
And now  it's really unusual to see
boards that are not diverse, right?

00:23:32.402 --> 00:23:38.188
I suppose what I would worry about
is that I still don't think they're

00:23:38.188 --> 00:23:42.517
fully embedded yet to the point
where what's happened with the likes

00:23:42.517 --> 00:23:44.757
of Goldman could undermine that.

00:23:45.567 --> 00:23:49.658
I was really dismayed to see
Goldman's statement, because they're

00:23:49.658 --> 00:23:53.528
going to encourage a lot of other
institutional investors and leading,

00:23:53.578 --> 00:23:56.395
world financial and corporate entities.

00:23:56.975 --> 00:24:02.517
While their statement is, on the
surface, almost celebrating the progress

00:24:02.677 --> 00:24:05.157
of ESG and DEI and things like that.

00:24:05.857 --> 00:24:09.757
I think it's an extremely clever
way of masking what's really

00:24:09.757 --> 00:24:14.777
driving  their approach is to
really align with the prevailing

00:24:14.777 --> 00:24:16.807
strong winds in the U. S. market.

00:24:17.293 --> 00:24:24.073
We here in Europe, I think we all feel
that Trump 2.0 is just fundamentally

00:24:24.073 --> 00:24:31.450
going to change the order of how
public life, business life, politics,

00:24:31.985 --> 00:24:36.085
and people all work together in
the US and I think unfortunately

00:24:36.085 --> 00:24:39.065
in a very troubling direction.

00:24:39.437 --> 00:24:41.157
It's a huge pity to be honest.

00:24:42.127 --> 00:24:45.187
People, Purpose and Profits, right?

00:24:45.227 --> 00:24:46.197
Getting that balance right.

00:24:46.197 --> 00:24:46.457
Yeah.

00:24:46.527 --> 00:24:51.977
and just coming back, Ralph, as well
to, I always think that when you look

00:24:51.977 --> 00:24:56.487
at all the various efforts that have
been made in ESG and DEI over the years,

00:24:56.487 --> 00:25:03.452
and at times there's very sophisticated
kind of descriptions of those, but

00:25:03.472 --> 00:25:07.692
ultimately you can boil it all down to
what I always say to boards of directors

00:25:07.692 --> 00:25:10.532
about ESG and DEI in all these areas.

00:25:11.239 --> 00:25:14.672
It's ultimately just decency
to do the right thing.

00:25:15.622 --> 00:25:20.600
and that's where you come back to, the
true moral and compass of a board of

00:25:20.600 --> 00:25:24.940
directors and the executive team who
are driving the organisation day to day.

00:25:25.510 --> 00:25:29.275
For them as individuals being able
to look in the mirror to say that,

00:25:29.368 --> 00:25:34.058
we have a really highly ethical,
decent organisation that does the

00:25:34.058 --> 00:25:38.258
right thing in terms of our employees,
our customers, our stakeholders,

00:25:38.258 --> 00:25:39.908
our suppliers and shareholders.

00:25:40.298 --> 00:25:43.581
Let's just examine that from an
individual or personal perspective.

00:25:43.611 --> 00:25:48.791
So, when we meet aspiring NEDs who perhaps
left very senior, successful executive

00:25:48.791 --> 00:25:54.146
careers and say, for whatever reason,
I now want to be a NED or join a board

00:25:54.146 --> 00:25:58.701
or have a plural career going forward,
we begin with a psychometric assessment

00:25:59.181 --> 00:26:04.876
and we use that to force people to look
themselves in the mirror and say, not

00:26:04.876 --> 00:26:11.311
only why do you want to be a NED but are
you really cut out to be in a boardroom?

00:26:11.784 --> 00:26:14.394
Just touch on this theme of
personal and boardroom behaviour

00:26:14.394 --> 00:26:15.124
a little bit more, will you?

00:26:16.109 --> 00:26:20.399
Yeah, one of the interesting things I
find, when I see first time non exec

00:26:20.399 --> 00:26:25.694
directors who in many cases have been
quite senior and experienced executives.

00:26:26.409 --> 00:26:30.393
One of the first, I suppose,
challenges they find is suddenly to

00:26:30.393 --> 00:26:32.953
realize that they are non executive.

00:26:33.423 --> 00:26:39.493
And sometimes for a lot of quite strong
executives, they sometimes find it takes

00:26:39.493 --> 00:26:44.183
a little bit of time to calibrate, and we
always talk about the kind of golden rule

00:26:44.183 --> 00:26:47.323
for boards of nose in and fingers out.

00:26:48.048 --> 00:26:52.468
And first time non exec directors
suddenly realize what that means.

00:26:52.703 --> 00:26:54.923
The Goldilocks scenario I think I've
heard you talk about in the past.

00:26:54.923 --> 00:26:59.128
Yeah, and that understanding that
they are not executive, right?

00:26:59.647 --> 00:27:02.747
The other thing then that
they find as well is finding

00:27:02.747 --> 00:27:04.177
your voice in the boardroom.

00:27:04.847 --> 00:27:07.027
Because it's an intimidating place.

00:27:07.387 --> 00:27:12.787
That if you join a board of directors and
say, for example, there are six or seven

00:27:13.047 --> 00:27:15.677
existing non exec directors on the board.

00:27:15.717 --> 00:27:19.977
There's a couple of executive directors
on the board and some of the other

00:27:19.977 --> 00:27:23.717
management team are in there and you
suddenly have 12, 14 people around

00:27:23.727 --> 00:27:26.887
the table and just finding your voice.

00:27:27.547 --> 00:27:32.107
And I always guide inexperienced non
exec directors, particularly when they're

00:27:32.107 --> 00:27:38.327
joining kind of a larger type board, to
just for the first meeting or two, just

00:27:38.337 --> 00:27:42.547
to really listen and just get a feeling
for who they have around the table.

00:27:43.187 --> 00:27:44.667
And they'll see that there's a mix.

00:27:44.667 --> 00:27:49.617
There's always a mix in boards of
the more louder kind of people who

00:27:49.617 --> 00:27:51.487
will always get their views in first.

00:27:51.487 --> 00:27:55.007
You'll see some quieter non exec
directors who sometimes are the sharpest

00:27:55.007 --> 00:27:56.927
people in the room, who are quiet.

00:27:57.207 --> 00:28:00.507
And you'll often find a board chair
would ask them, that Ralph, I'd really

00:28:00.507 --> 00:28:02.337
appreciate your perspective on that.

00:28:02.907 --> 00:28:07.610
So, there's an interesting kind of
people equation in a board as well of

00:28:07.610 --> 00:28:10.020
all the different personalities and egos.

00:28:10.770 --> 00:28:14.110
After that first one or two
meetings, where you've really

00:28:14.110 --> 00:28:17.590
been in listening mode, it's
time then to start contributing.

00:28:17.851 --> 00:28:20.281
So if you're on a board,
you need to contribute.

00:28:20.641 --> 00:28:23.351
It's not that you need to
contribute on every single topic

00:28:23.351 --> 00:28:27.551
and agenda item, but you really
need to be an active board member.

00:28:28.141 --> 00:28:31.861
And I suppose another key piece
of guidance then for new non exec

00:28:31.881 --> 00:28:37.361
directors is it's so important to be
really well prepared for the board

00:28:37.361 --> 00:28:38.891
meeting or the committee meetings.

00:28:39.391 --> 00:28:42.581
So in terms of the board packs, the
committee packs, and sometimes you're

00:28:42.581 --> 00:28:46.361
looking at a board pack and it's 300
pages and you're thinking, my God, today's

00:28:46.381 --> 00:28:48.381
going to take me five hours to read that.

00:28:48.701 --> 00:28:50.021
But it's really important.

00:28:50.369 --> 00:28:54.339
When you're joining the board, then
that first couple of months, you work

00:28:54.379 --> 00:28:58.979
hard to build an understanding of
the company, the organisation, and in

00:28:58.979 --> 00:29:01.119
particular, what's really important.

00:29:01.224 --> 00:29:04.404
And in time then building the
relationships both with your fellow

00:29:04.684 --> 00:29:09.334
non executive directors and the chair,
but also with the CEO, the CFO and

00:29:09.334 --> 00:29:10.804
the other executive team members.

00:29:11.234 --> 00:29:15.154
So, that first couple of months,
six months in particular, are an

00:29:15.154 --> 00:29:19.904
important time just to find your
feet, but also build towards a point

00:29:19.904 --> 00:29:21.654
where you need to start contributing.

00:29:22.544 --> 00:29:23.534
It's a blunt question.

00:29:23.824 --> 00:29:26.984
How often when you're doing an
appraisal do you think, that NED

00:29:26.984 --> 00:29:28.854
just shouldn't be in the boardroom?

00:29:28.854 --> 00:29:32.124
They just don't have the
right DNA to be here.

00:29:32.234 --> 00:29:37.454
And follow up question to that is,
what can a new or aspiring NED do to

00:29:37.454 --> 00:29:41.384
make sure that they've done the right
personal training and development

00:29:41.904 --> 00:29:43.314
to make themselves ball ready?

00:29:43.646 --> 00:29:48.971
So sometimes we see, either first time
or inexperienced non executive directors

00:29:49.219 --> 00:29:53.138
who haven't sat with them and interviewed
them and just watched them in action when

00:29:53.138 --> 00:29:57.903
we just come to a view that we don't see
them being a strong non exec in time.

00:29:58.553 --> 00:30:02.953
Because you can see the attributes
of a strong non exec director and you

00:30:02.953 --> 00:30:08.233
can see the kind of foundation even
in an inexperienced non exec director.

00:30:08.263 --> 00:30:12.853
You just can see the foundation there
that over time they will grow into it.

00:30:13.573 --> 00:30:16.868
And I suppose a big thing that we
always think about when we think about

00:30:16.888 --> 00:30:22.198
non exec directors as well it's just
their overall judgment, and their

00:30:22.198 --> 00:30:25.658
overall sense of where things are at.

00:30:25.752 --> 00:30:29.062
Really having a good feel for where
the performance of the company is at.

00:30:29.612 --> 00:30:34.032
And I always think a very interesting
question that we pose to non exec

00:30:34.032 --> 00:30:38.195
directors is, what are the three
vital few items for this company?

00:30:38.205 --> 00:30:42.975
If you were to cut down to three things
right now that are the most critical

00:30:43.005 --> 00:30:44.815
for this company, what would they be?

00:30:45.715 --> 00:30:50.892
And I think that overall judgment, is
absolutely critical because when you

00:30:50.892 --> 00:30:55.772
understand those, that's then where
your value that you can add both in

00:30:55.772 --> 00:31:00.442
terms of really intelligent and at
times robust debate and challenge with

00:31:00.442 --> 00:31:04.692
the executive team, but also helping
them with your guidance and expertise.

00:31:04.692 --> 00:31:09.552
And we always think of non exec directors
as well having, two sets of expertise.

00:31:10.002 --> 00:31:14.527
One is the sector expertise that
they have, and some non execs have

00:31:14.527 --> 00:31:17.520
worked across multiple sectors
and are very good generalists.

00:31:17.520 --> 00:31:21.990
But there's a second set of softer
skills then, and influencing and

00:31:22.000 --> 00:31:25.870
listening and getting that tempo right.

00:31:26.050 --> 00:31:31.787
You can ask a CEO who's under serious
pressure a question in two different ways.

00:31:32.207 --> 00:31:35.217
One could be just absolutely
really aggressive.

00:31:35.597 --> 00:31:40.097
That's going to make a CEO who's stubborn
to begin with even more defensive.

00:31:40.727 --> 00:31:45.257
Or asking a question a different way
where you say, listen, we can really

00:31:45.257 --> 00:31:47.397
see that you're struggling in this area.

00:31:47.497 --> 00:31:49.247
It's really difficult and complex.

00:31:49.527 --> 00:31:52.017
We as a board are struggling
to get our head around as well.

00:31:52.027 --> 00:31:56.517
So, can you walk us through your sense of
what are the kind of underlying factors?

00:31:56.918 --> 00:32:00.358
What could we as a board and
executive team, how can we help you

00:32:00.448 --> 00:32:02.088
just to identify a path forward?

00:32:02.658 --> 00:32:06.608
That whole judgment, listening
skills, and just feeling.

00:32:07.048 --> 00:32:11.348
We always talk as well about non exec
directors today, and particularly when

00:32:11.348 --> 00:32:14.828
they're starting, we really highlight
to them the importance of emotional

00:32:14.828 --> 00:32:20.068
intelligence, because it's a people
environment around the table and the

00:32:20.078 --> 00:32:26.048
best boards will have a lot of healthy
tension because this is serious business.

00:32:26.108 --> 00:32:29.918
Everyone in there in the board table
has their role and responsibilities.

00:32:30.308 --> 00:32:34.978
It's a tough, challenging environment,
but we find even inexperienced non

00:32:34.978 --> 00:32:38.638
exec directors who have very good
people intelligence, emotional

00:32:38.638 --> 00:32:41.108
intelligence, are able to adapt.

00:32:41.648 --> 00:32:44.478
And that helps them then
grow in their contribution.

00:32:44.928 --> 00:32:47.663
I think I've heard you talk in the
past about the partnership model.

00:32:47.993 --> 00:32:51.026
So let's move from the individual
to the team how does that

00:32:51.066 --> 00:32:52.996
orchestra get the right tune?

00:32:53.066 --> 00:32:58.765
Yeah, I was given an analogy, I was given
a workshop recently to a large bank,

00:32:58.785 --> 00:33:02.035
an international bank, and their board
of directors and the executive team.

00:33:02.665 --> 00:33:06.935
And I gave them the analogy, actually
and I put up a big picture on the

00:33:06.935 --> 00:33:13.485
screen of Torvill and Dean doing their
Bolero routine in Sarajevo in 1984,

00:33:13.785 --> 00:33:19.575
which is just over 40 years ago, when
they became absolutely the world's

00:33:19.575 --> 00:33:23.185
best with the highest ever score in
the figure skating Olympic final.

00:33:23.362 --> 00:33:28.127
And I explained to them that in that
routine, the two of them there, how

00:33:28.167 --> 00:33:32.822
they achieved that brilliant outcome,
is that they were brilliant individually

00:33:32.822 --> 00:33:37.052
in their parts of the routine, but
when they came together, they were

00:33:37.052 --> 00:33:39.022
just exceptional and phenomenal.

00:33:39.752 --> 00:33:44.262
And I often laugh when one time I saw that
Torvill and Dean had been interviewed,

00:33:44.772 --> 00:33:47.682
and they're talking about how at times
you drive each other crazy in training.

00:33:47.977 --> 00:33:49.477
Just trying to get the best.

00:33:50.297 --> 00:33:56.197
And for me, it's an exact analogy for
a board and an executive team that what

00:33:56.197 --> 00:34:01.087
you want is for them individually as an
executive team to be exceptional, for the

00:34:01.087 --> 00:34:05.777
board to be exceptional, but for the two
of them, then how they work together, and

00:34:05.777 --> 00:34:07.617
how they get the best out of each other.

00:34:08.327 --> 00:34:13.467
And what I find is that at the core
of that partnership model is when

00:34:13.467 --> 00:34:17.427
you have a CEO and the executive team
who really understand the role of the

00:34:17.427 --> 00:34:22.187
board, who really respect the board and
want to get the best out of the board.

00:34:22.627 --> 00:34:25.787
Not to say at times the board
doesn't drive them crazy, right?

00:34:25.837 --> 00:34:28.007
And really,  hold their feet to the fire.

00:34:28.947 --> 00:34:32.297
But when you have that at the
foundation, that allows the board

00:34:32.297 --> 00:34:34.057
then to do their jobs properly.

00:34:34.732 --> 00:34:38.912
And again, come back to that balance
of really strong oversight and

00:34:38.912 --> 00:34:42.202
challenge and holding their feet to
the fire and excellence and governance

00:34:42.212 --> 00:34:43.762
and risk and internal controls.

00:34:44.434 --> 00:34:48.434
But when the executive team are
incredibly open and honest, brilliant

00:34:48.444 --> 00:34:52.704
reporting, so that the board for
better or for worse know exactly where

00:34:52.704 --> 00:34:57.384
everything is, that then frees up the
board's energy and time to add a lot

00:34:57.384 --> 00:34:59.724
more value, and it inspires the board.

00:35:00.064 --> 00:35:03.754
So as part of our board evaluation
process, we observe the board and

00:35:03.754 --> 00:35:07.674
committee meetings, and when we see
the best boards and committees in

00:35:07.674 --> 00:35:09.515
action, by God, do they get at it.

00:35:09.945 --> 00:35:12.095
There's a real spirited give and take.

00:35:12.335 --> 00:35:16.485
They really stretch each
other, very healthy tensions.

00:35:17.325 --> 00:35:21.415
But what you can see around the table
is that nobody's taking it personal.

00:35:22.005 --> 00:35:25.765
All that matters right now in
this boardroom table is how do

00:35:25.765 --> 00:35:29.685
we make the best decisions and
they really stretch each other.

00:35:29.735 --> 00:35:32.365
And people's, tensions are quite high.

00:35:32.775 --> 00:35:36.195
but sometimes for a lot of complex
decisions, such as business models,

00:35:36.215 --> 00:35:40.785
strategy shift, and things like that, the
board and the executive team really need

00:35:40.795 --> 00:35:47.000
to go deep into the well to really figure
out, explore, challenge assumptions,

00:35:47.240 --> 00:35:51.680
have contrarian, left field thinkers,
devil's advocates and things like that.

00:35:52.390 --> 00:35:57.110
And that's when we see boards and
executive teams at their very, very best.

00:35:57.660 --> 00:36:01.612
And it really is like Torvill
and Dean out on the ice.

00:36:01.612 --> 00:36:05.780
Absolutely brilliant together, getting
the best out of each other, but

00:36:05.790 --> 00:36:10.880
realizing that for them to excel as
a couple, so to speak, both of them

00:36:10.880 --> 00:36:15.580
have to excel in what their part of
the routine is, and then together.

00:36:16.206 --> 00:36:17.985
When we see that, it's just magical.

00:36:17.985 --> 00:36:21.710
So if we pivot the analogy from
Torvill and Dean to an orchestra,

00:36:22.099 --> 00:36:26.096
we'll talk about the Board Skills
Matrix needing the right blend of

00:36:26.106 --> 00:36:28.255
skills, experience, and knowledge.

00:36:28.642 --> 00:36:34.422
What are the key skills you see missing
on boards as of today, and for a new

00:36:34.422 --> 00:36:40.662
and aspiring NED what are the key skill
gaps that people can go, yup, I solved

00:36:40.662 --> 00:36:42.512
for that, I should apply for that role.

00:36:43.049 --> 00:36:48.519
The most topical area at the moment that
a lot of boards are struggling with is

00:36:48.519 --> 00:36:55.249
in the whole area of technology, digital
transformation, cyber risk, artificial

00:36:55.299 --> 00:36:59.409
intelligence has now leapt to the
front of so many board agendas around

00:36:59.419 --> 00:37:05.119
the world that a lot of boards just do
not have any expertise in this area.

00:37:05.718 --> 00:37:10.545
You know, when you think of the vast
majority of large organizations now, their

00:37:10.545 --> 00:37:13.685
entire backbone is digital, is technology.

00:37:14.195 --> 00:37:18.125
And a lot of times you have boards
overseeing executive teams who are making

00:37:18.125 --> 00:37:23.255
major bets on digital transformation, new
products, all sorts of things like that.

00:37:23.605 --> 00:37:26.175
And the board really doesn't
have the depth of expertise.

00:37:26.535 --> 00:37:27.935
I think the second area.

00:37:28.270 --> 00:37:32.836
That we're seeing, interest
in as well is board directors

00:37:33.466 --> 00:37:36.076
who have a strategic mindset.

00:37:36.886 --> 00:37:41.571
So we see a lot of quite good non
executive directors, who are fantastic

00:37:41.621 --> 00:37:45.751
at oversight, really strong in sales,
operations and things like that.

00:37:46.701 --> 00:37:52.041
But when you look at strategy,
business model, innovation, oftentimes

00:37:52.041 --> 00:37:53.481
they're not great at that area.

00:37:54.161 --> 00:37:58.561
And what we're finding at the moment
is that strategy for any company,

00:37:58.561 --> 00:38:02.252
organisation around the world has
never been more difficult to develop.

00:38:02.422 --> 00:38:06.102
And we're seeing a lot of executive
teams, more and more put their hand

00:38:06.112 --> 00:38:08.772
up and say to the board, we need help.

00:38:08.909 --> 00:38:11.269
There's a lot of experienced
people around the table here.

00:38:11.599 --> 00:38:12.599
We're struggling.

00:38:12.649 --> 00:38:14.679
Our competitors are
wiping the floor with us.

00:38:14.709 --> 00:38:18.279
They've changed their pricing model,
their delivery model, whatever it is.

00:38:18.589 --> 00:38:19.889
The ecosystem is changing.

00:38:19.889 --> 00:38:21.369
Our customer requirements are changing.

00:38:21.569 --> 00:38:26.644
We're really struggling strategically, and
we're seeing a lot of boards of directors

00:38:26.774 --> 00:38:29.144
who do not have the strategic firepower.

00:38:29.664 --> 00:38:32.344
And it's not just sector expertise.

00:38:32.771 --> 00:38:38.861
It's actually strategic thinkers who can
actually look at business models and look

00:38:38.861 --> 00:38:43.361
at, say, an adjacent type of business and
say, could we look at this model here?

00:38:43.681 --> 00:38:47.901
So I think that's another interesting
area for aspiring non exec directors.

00:38:48.516 --> 00:38:54.686
We're finding now non exec directors who
are, say, starting off now in their, say,

00:38:54.866 --> 00:38:57.556
forties, for example, and early fifties.

00:38:58.056 --> 00:39:02.656
They're a lot more digital savvy than
say some of the older non exec directors.

00:39:03.016 --> 00:39:07.188
So that brings an important
dimension to their skill set,

00:39:07.638 --> 00:39:12.948
but also that just innovation
strategy business model type area.

00:39:13.498 --> 00:39:18.002
And the third area that we're seeing, an
interest in as well is board directors

00:39:18.002 --> 00:39:22.270
who understand people, employees, culture.

00:39:22.481 --> 00:39:27.401
And can help organizations with, in
some cases, transforming their culture,

00:39:28.151 --> 00:39:35.438
and having non execs on the board who
really have a deep, progressive view to

00:39:36.168 --> 00:39:39.740
employee retention and areas like that.

00:39:39.740 --> 00:39:44.740
So that's another interesting, set of
softer type skills that we're seeing, new

00:39:44.740 --> 00:39:47.510
non exec directors can bring to the table.

00:39:48.230 --> 00:39:52.440
Because we see so many non exec
directors, you know, who have a standard

00:39:52.660 --> 00:39:56.520
financial services background skill
set, which is great and important.

00:39:56.997 --> 00:39:59.237
But that's not going to help
them stand out from the crowd.

00:39:59.561 --> 00:40:05.678
I had a conversation two days ago with,
a very experienced, CEO, whose company

00:40:05.678 --> 00:40:09.208
was acquired has now kind of retired
from executive role and is looking for

00:40:09.208 --> 00:40:11.908
their first non exec director roles.

00:40:12.268 --> 00:40:15.678
And we were having a conversation, I
was saying to him that the amount of

00:40:15.688 --> 00:40:19.938
non exec directors now looking for
each position has never been greater.

00:40:20.488 --> 00:40:26.618
So the competition to be a professional
NED You have a lot of other people in

00:40:26.618 --> 00:40:31.275
the lanes alongside you, and if you're
going to really differentiate, it's not

00:40:31.275 --> 00:40:36.302
only in skill set, in that your sector
expertise in financial services, or

00:40:36.302 --> 00:40:41.522
engineering technology background, but
it's also a lot of those softer type

00:40:41.537 --> 00:40:47.277
skill sets, I think could be the key for
a lot of aspiring non exec directors.

00:40:47.307 --> 00:40:50.127
I think it's really interesting,
certainly I'm seeing our NOMS committees

00:40:50.127 --> 00:40:53.977
in particular, people coming from more
of an HR background who understand that

00:40:54.047 --> 00:40:56.580
emotional, part, and often culture.

00:40:56.980 --> 00:40:59.920
So I think that opens a lot
of opportunities, for people.

00:41:00.100 --> 00:41:02.112
Similar to the composition
of a risk comittee.

00:41:02.218 --> 00:41:03.898
We should maybe touch
on that for a second.

00:41:03.908 --> 00:41:08.728
So risk has come very much to the fore,
risk defined in its broadest sense.

00:41:09.102 --> 00:41:12.356
How has the interpretation and
the management of risk changed,

00:41:12.356 --> 00:41:15.597
both from a corporate governance
perspective, as well as an individual

00:41:15.607 --> 00:41:16.957
perspective over the last few years?

00:41:17.542 --> 00:41:23.650
Yeah, I think it was interesting how
prior to COVID 19 risk management was

00:41:23.650 --> 00:41:28.520
a very, steady conservative approach of
a typical approach for organizations.

00:41:28.910 --> 00:41:32.750
You built your risk matrix, you did
your assessment and you monitored

00:41:32.750 --> 00:41:35.970
and you had your mitigation
plans and things like that.

00:41:36.720 --> 00:41:42.247
I think COVID 19 actually, has
brought in a whole new era of risk

00:41:42.287 --> 00:41:46.857
management, where the risks now
being considered are far broader.

00:41:47.497 --> 00:41:53.507
And what were considered risks before
that had such a low level of probability,

00:41:54.147 --> 00:41:55.937
there's a different mindset to those now.

00:41:56.320 --> 00:41:59.090
So in recent board
evaluations I've been doing.

00:41:59.486 --> 00:42:04.846
One of the biggest risks up that the board
is thinking about is geopolitical risk.

00:42:05.096 --> 00:42:05.836
Trade wars.

00:42:05.956 --> 00:42:07.046
Trump 2.0.

00:42:07.426 --> 00:42:11.176
I'm now seeing on risk
registers Trump 2.0.

00:42:11.459 --> 00:42:16.689
But what also then people are suddenly
thinking about people risk, employee

00:42:16.689 --> 00:42:21.679
retention risk in a far more sophisticated
way than they did previously.

00:42:22.359 --> 00:42:26.569
Obviously, another big risk area at
the moment is artificial intelligence.

00:42:27.169 --> 00:42:31.663
There's a lot of, organizations
now suddenly thinking about the

00:42:31.663 --> 00:42:35.984
risks of us lagging behind our
competitors in terms of AI adoption.

00:42:36.302 --> 00:42:41.142
Have we employees and departments in
our company who are using very advanced

00:42:41.142 --> 00:42:46.542
artificial intelligence that we don't know
about and suddenly are putting in biases

00:42:46.542 --> 00:42:51.772
towards certain ethnic backgrounds, all
sorts of things, and creating a whole

00:42:51.782 --> 00:42:54.647
new type of risk for the organisation.

00:42:55.157 --> 00:42:59.297
What we're finding is that risk
committees themselves are starting

00:42:59.297 --> 00:43:03.337
to evolve and they're looking
for different type thinkers.

00:43:03.809 --> 00:43:08.079
Before what you would normally see on
the risk committee is the best finance

00:43:08.099 --> 00:43:12.199
people, basically, because they were
all primarily financial related risks.

00:43:13.039 --> 00:43:16.299
But we're seeing now the best risk
committee is being far broader.

00:43:16.614 --> 00:43:19.994
Far more holistic, and they're
thinking about all different

00:43:20.004 --> 00:43:23.824
dimensions of risk in a way that you
wouldn't have seen five years ago.

00:43:24.342 --> 00:43:27.900
Clearly we're seeing a trend
of public companies delisting.

00:43:28.080 --> 00:43:31.770
Private companies staying
private longer and, being much

00:43:31.770 --> 00:43:33.390
larger in terms of market cap.

00:43:33.918 --> 00:43:37.438
Perhaps in many ways, taking
on the manifestations of public

00:43:37.438 --> 00:43:41.368
companies whilst remaining in
either P.E or private ownership.

00:43:41.758 --> 00:43:46.348
How does an aspiring NED think about
the difference of, should I join

00:43:46.348 --> 00:43:48.558
a Private board or Public board.

00:43:48.568 --> 00:43:51.438
Historically, it was very much
a presumption that I would

00:43:51.968 --> 00:43:54.798
join a Public board if I've
come from an executive career.

00:43:54.818 --> 00:43:56.918
I think that dynamic's completely changed.

00:43:57.371 --> 00:44:04.051
We're seeing some outstanding non
exec directors now who, if they have a

00:44:04.051 --> 00:44:09.447
choice, would join a private board far
quicker than a publicly listed board.

00:44:10.347 --> 00:44:13.647
And I think both here in the UK
for the FTSE and AIM, and then

00:44:13.657 --> 00:44:15.527
stock exchanges around the world.

00:44:16.257 --> 00:44:22.441
I think there's a dawning realisation
for both the existing non exec

00:44:22.441 --> 00:44:27.391
directors on PLC boards and aspiring
non execs who want to join PLC boards.

00:44:28.221 --> 00:44:33.449
That the role and responsibilities
has just increased to such a level

00:44:34.009 --> 00:44:38.759
that no matter how much compensation
you're getting, there's some public

00:44:38.759 --> 00:44:43.153
list and non exec director said it's
not worth it because the regulation

00:44:43.163 --> 00:44:44.673
has increased significantly.

00:44:45.483 --> 00:44:50.023
A lot of very good board directors,
very conscientious board directors who

00:44:50.053 --> 00:44:55.883
in some respects are suffering a bit
from increasingly onerous levels of

00:44:55.883 --> 00:45:01.443
regulation in response to all different
scandals and destruction of shareholder

00:45:01.443 --> 00:45:05.913
value and all what's happened over the
years, both here and across the world.

00:45:05.943 --> 00:45:10.573
In every country, a lot of boards have
failed, a lot of listed company type

00:45:10.573 --> 00:45:12.633
boards and had all type of scandals.

00:45:13.158 --> 00:45:18.758
So that has really changed, the
environment to be a PLC board director.

00:45:19.032 --> 00:45:23.232
And I suppose I always highlight
to non exec directors that a good

00:45:23.232 --> 00:45:26.572
non exec director could work in any
environment, whether it's a PLC or a

00:45:26.572 --> 00:45:32.384
large PE type environment, but just the
understanding that serving on a listed

00:45:32.414 --> 00:45:37.024
company board, there is a whole extra
set of dimensions that come with that.

00:45:37.599 --> 00:45:41.137
And it's not just things like
market abuse rules or insider

00:45:41.137 --> 00:45:42.827
information and things like that.

00:45:43.297 --> 00:45:49.047
It's just the realization as well that,
as a listed company, you have a very

00:45:49.047 --> 00:45:53.342
wide shareholder base and you have
some very large institution investors.

00:45:53.642 --> 00:45:57.042
And you have pension funds
and you have small investors.

00:45:57.802 --> 00:46:03.743
And there, is an additional layer
of responsibility to all of those

00:46:03.743 --> 00:46:07.673
shareholders for how the company acts
and behaves and its decision making

00:46:08.403 --> 00:46:14.518
that is different compared to an
extremely mature, PE backed company,

00:46:15.488 --> 00:46:21.368
very strong board of directors, executive
team, very clear operating model.

00:46:21.651 --> 00:46:26.103
And while the role, in many respects,
is quite similar, I often would say

00:46:26.103 --> 00:46:30.823
to aspiring non exec directors, if
they could, I would advise them,

00:46:31.393 --> 00:46:35.733
to focus their first roles on
private type organizations, to build

00:46:35.873 --> 00:46:37.973
their capabilities and experience.

00:46:38.513 --> 00:46:43.738
Because I think the bar for serving as
a listed company director board in the

00:46:43.738 --> 00:46:46.881
UK and internationally has gone higher.

00:46:47.471 --> 00:46:50.582
Certainly when I'm talking to people, I
try and impress on them, have you thought

00:46:50.582 --> 00:46:53.632
about the reputational risk, particularly
if this is your first board role?

00:46:53.882 --> 00:46:56.972
And quite often people blink at me and
say, I don't quite know what that means.

00:46:57.432 --> 00:47:01.172
Second question then is, have you
asked about what the DEI insurance is?

00:47:01.602 --> 00:47:03.022
And that gets an even bigger blink.

00:47:03.162 --> 00:47:03.432
Yeah.

00:47:03.782 --> 00:47:08.792
I always explain to non exec directors
as well, is that in the digital world

00:47:08.802 --> 00:47:14.432
we're now living in, that once you sign
your name to be a company director,

00:47:15.142 --> 00:47:19.262
no matter whether it's a PLC or a
private equity, a family business, or a

00:47:19.262 --> 00:47:24.652
charitable organisation, you are forever
going to be connected to that company.

00:47:25.577 --> 00:47:31.166
And God forbid, there is a serious
scandal or collapse or that organisation

00:47:31.166 --> 00:47:36.577
has lost its way or whatever like that,
then you are inextricably linked to

00:47:36.577 --> 00:47:38.947
that organisation and to the reputation.

00:47:39.427 --> 00:47:44.867
And I've seen cases where a board of
director was just unlucky in one of

00:47:44.867 --> 00:47:46.937
their first or second board roles.

00:47:47.327 --> 00:47:53.012
There was a serious scandal or collapse
at that organisation and it did influence

00:47:53.012 --> 00:47:55.172
or impact on future board roles.

00:47:55.212 --> 00:47:57.422
And it took a while for
them to recover from that.

00:47:57.792 --> 00:48:01.292
Yeah, I think this is something
that a lot of people don't

00:48:01.592 --> 00:48:03.312
give enough due diligence to.

00:48:03.322 --> 00:48:05.162
It's a bit like when we tell
our kids, careful what you put

00:48:05.162 --> 00:48:06.742
on your social media, right?

00:48:06.742 --> 00:48:09.092
A lot of first time NEDs think,
well, I could just resign, I

00:48:09.092 --> 00:48:09.902
could just leave the board.

00:48:10.382 --> 00:48:14.122
In the NED world, the board
world, everybody is going to take

00:48:14.142 --> 00:48:15.762
references everywhere on you.

00:48:16.132 --> 00:48:21.012
And that's going to come back, and
whether it was on your watch or not, and

00:48:21.012 --> 00:48:25.142
whether you were in the heat of battle
or not, the reputational risk will link,

00:48:25.302 --> 00:48:29.680
Absolute, and, you kind of mentioned
for first time NEDs one advice that

00:48:29.680 --> 00:48:33.510
I would always give them as well, and
you've alluded to it there, Ralph, is the

00:48:33.510 --> 00:48:35.600
importance of their own due diligence.

00:48:36.240 --> 00:48:39.800
At times, particularly for a first time
NED, they're really excited that they

00:48:39.800 --> 00:48:44.210
have an opportunity to secure a board
role that they feel would be a great

00:48:44.210 --> 00:48:46.090
foundation for future board roles.

00:48:47.150 --> 00:48:50.710
But I was really impress upon them,
the importance of really doing their

00:48:50.710 --> 00:48:55.925
homework, of really understanding, both
the organisation, who's serving on the

00:48:55.925 --> 00:49:00.645
board, and I always say to aspiring non
exec directors, you always need to meet

00:49:00.685 --> 00:49:02.505
at least the following three people.

00:49:02.855 --> 00:49:05.845
One is the chair of the board
who you're going to be working

00:49:05.845 --> 00:49:07.185
for as part of their team.

00:49:07.505 --> 00:49:12.425
Second is the CEO and third is one
of the other non executive directors,

00:49:12.535 --> 00:49:14.865
ideally as independent as possible.

00:49:15.495 --> 00:49:19.495
And you just sit down and ask
them, what's this board like?

00:49:19.980 --> 00:49:20.720
How does it work?

00:49:21.040 --> 00:49:22.010
What's the relationship?

00:49:22.010 --> 00:49:23.810
The dynamics or whatever like that.

00:49:24.310 --> 00:49:27.210
But the other thing as well
is to really do your research

00:49:27.280 --> 00:49:31.350
on the company or organisation
itself in terms of its values.

00:49:31.920 --> 00:49:35.420
And that if you bumped into people
in the street and asked them, listen,

00:49:35.420 --> 00:49:38.860
you're a customer of this organisation
or whatever, how do you find them?

00:49:39.485 --> 00:49:42.938
Because sometimes non exec directors
who do that properly suddenly

00:49:42.948 --> 00:49:47.288
realize that, listen, I met the
chair and I met the CEO and I was

00:49:47.288 --> 00:49:49.258
doing my kind of desktop research.

00:49:49.298 --> 00:49:53.318
And to be honest, I'm not sure
my value set is a good fit

00:49:53.368 --> 00:49:54.838
here with this organisation.

00:49:55.143 --> 00:49:58.246
And I always say in that particular
case, you're better to pass it because

00:49:58.246 --> 00:49:59.966
there will be other opportunities.

00:50:00.310 --> 00:50:01.100
I couldn't agree more.

00:50:01.390 --> 00:50:04.533
Whilst we've been touching on private
companies, I can't resist just coming

00:50:04.533 --> 00:50:11.383
back to one of the great slides you have
in your presentation, is Yoda sitting

00:50:11.383 --> 00:50:15.233
there with a young Skywalker in the swamp.

00:50:15.423 --> 00:50:17.833
So a picture tells a thousand words.

00:50:17.853 --> 00:50:20.743
Sadly, we're on a podcast and we
probably don't have time for a thousand

00:50:20.743 --> 00:50:24.973
words, but just touch on what that
means in terms of the role of a board

00:50:24.973 --> 00:50:29.403
member with perhaps a Series A, Series
B scale up company and the founder.

00:50:29.823 --> 00:50:34.933
Yeah, it's, we spend a lot of time
helping, series A, B, C type companies.

00:50:35.407 --> 00:50:39.694
You know, we've done board evaluations for
the likes of Revolution here in London and

00:50:39.884 --> 00:50:42.044
Stripe in Europe and other organizations.

00:50:42.044 --> 00:50:44.194
So, we work with founders quite a lot.

00:50:44.744 --> 00:50:48.569
And the reality is, Founders
find their boards challenging.

00:50:49.139 --> 00:50:53.329
It's such a switch to suddenly have
to be accountable to the board, the

00:50:53.329 --> 00:50:56.489
board hauling you over the coals for
your mistakes, suddenly have to get

00:50:56.489 --> 00:51:00.419
the board approval for everything,
that it can be really challenging.

00:51:00.839 --> 00:51:06.229
And I suppose when they highlighted
kind of Yoda giving a dose of salt to

00:51:06.229 --> 00:51:11.899
the young Jedi, Luke Skywalker, it was
really highlighting as well the chair CEO

00:51:11.909 --> 00:51:14.129
relationship in a growth type company.

00:51:14.939 --> 00:51:19.142
And that, the chair in that particular
environment, you know, does give a lot

00:51:19.142 --> 00:51:21.732
of support to the CEO and encouragement.

00:51:22.242 --> 00:51:27.582
But there's times as well where the
chair has to be tough and be brutally

00:51:27.582 --> 00:51:32.592
honest with the CEO, particularly in
helping them work well with the board.

00:51:33.062 --> 00:51:37.577
Because sometimes I see founders, CEOs
who really struggle with their attitude

00:51:37.597 --> 00:51:41.707
to the board and they're in the board
meeting and the non exec directors are

00:51:41.707 --> 00:51:47.117
really asking the hard questions and
they find it very difficult and just

00:51:47.117 --> 00:51:49.427
incredibly stubborn and defensive.

00:51:49.837 --> 00:51:52.277
You know, in a lot of cases,
they're young, they have very

00:51:52.277 --> 00:51:53.647
little management experience.

00:51:53.947 --> 00:51:57.467
The boardroom is a completely different
type of environment or whatever like that.

00:51:57.777 --> 00:52:02.337
But I suppose when I look at the growth
companies, that have made it and have

00:52:02.337 --> 00:52:06.397
really grown and attracted multiple
financing rounds and had great exits.

00:52:06.847 --> 00:52:12.765
They had boards with Yoda type figures
on them, both the chair, but other non

00:52:12.765 --> 00:52:18.995
execs as well, who really were able to
build the trust and the relationship with

00:52:18.995 --> 00:52:23.665
the founders and the executive team to
be able to have those at times brutally

00:52:23.705 --> 00:52:28.825
honest discussions and help the founder
and the executive team to realize that

00:52:29.730 --> 00:52:34.052
all of the investors around the table,
all the non exec directors, they're only

00:52:34.052 --> 00:52:35.972
going to win if the executive team wins.

00:52:36.432 --> 00:52:43.342
And while that might seem blindingly
obvious to a founder CEO who finds it

00:52:43.352 --> 00:52:46.492
difficult to work with their board,
it is not as obvious as you think.

00:52:47.312 --> 00:52:53.009
And that's for us, the key that anytime
we see, growth companies that seem to

00:52:53.009 --> 00:52:57.819
be stuck at series A and they're doing
5 million revenue, 10 million revenue

00:52:57.819 --> 00:53:01.939
and it looks a very promising company
and you come back 15 months later,

00:53:02.169 --> 00:53:03.699
they're still doing 10 million revenue.

00:53:04.119 --> 00:53:06.159
They really haven't attracted new capital.

00:53:06.639 --> 00:53:08.975
Oftentimes I slap the executive team.

00:53:08.975 --> 00:53:09.615
I look at the board.

00:53:10.310 --> 00:53:14.680
And say, how strategic, how strong is
this board and how much value are they

00:53:14.730 --> 00:53:16.500
adding to help this executive team?

00:53:17.190 --> 00:53:24.560
Because the reality Ralph, I find is in
growth type companies, the board does

00:53:24.570 --> 00:53:28.990
have a bit more of a hands on role than
a traditional corporate type board.

00:53:29.760 --> 00:53:33.966
The executive team are still driving
the bus, but they're so inexperienced

00:53:33.976 --> 00:53:37.966
from a management point of view,
brilliant technology, brilliant experts

00:53:37.966 --> 00:53:42.066
in their areas, but they need a lot
of support and guidance as well.

00:53:42.376 --> 00:53:47.896
And the founders who I think have
the wisdom to build really good

00:53:47.896 --> 00:53:51.526
boards and attract the type of
people who are going to stretch them,

00:53:52.156 --> 00:53:53.416
they're the founders who make it.

00:53:54.151 --> 00:53:56.191
there's some great work on this,
particularly by one of the partners

00:53:56.191 --> 00:54:00.187
at Mercia, about the link between
valuation, the quality of advice a

00:54:00.187 --> 00:54:03.657
founder has, and actually how many board
meetings a founder's going to have,

00:54:04.017 --> 00:54:05.337
before they're thinking about an exit.

00:54:05.377 --> 00:54:06.787
I think 80 is the magic number.

00:54:07.117 --> 00:54:12.942
So it's interesting that, historically,
aspiring NEDs were often advised,

00:54:12.962 --> 00:54:16.022
go and join a school board,
join a not for profit charity.

00:54:16.022 --> 00:54:17.742
That's the way you learn about governance.

00:54:18.142 --> 00:54:22.702
We're going to do a future podcast with,
the founder of Connected and for founders

00:54:22.732 --> 00:54:24.292
seeking capital on the Connected platform.

00:54:24.342 --> 00:54:28.527
They have a large bank of Advisors,
NEDs, Board Advisors, whatever

00:54:28.527 --> 00:54:29.407
title we want to give them.

00:54:29.727 --> 00:54:32.967
And it's becoming much more of an
integrated, I think offering now for

00:54:32.967 --> 00:54:37.327
pre Series A companies, to really
think about first time and aspiring

00:54:37.337 --> 00:54:41.597
NEDs cutting their teeth and learning
how to give good advice in the right

00:54:41.597 --> 00:54:44.337
way, influence, not management, right?

00:54:44.707 --> 00:54:49.882
As a way to learn about governance and
learn to be an effective board advisor.

00:54:50.172 --> 00:54:51.352
You're nodding furiously.

00:54:51.352 --> 00:54:55.744
So, so you see that as a as a good way
to cut your teeth and learn your trade.

00:54:55.869 --> 00:54:56.629
No, absolutely.

00:54:56.629 --> 00:55:01.019
Because particularly for experienced
executives, they have so much value

00:55:01.049 --> 00:55:05.059
to bring to a young, inexperienced
funding management team.

00:55:06.029 --> 00:55:11.836
I do think it's important at the same
time that they're careful around the stage

00:55:11.846 --> 00:55:13.466
of the company in which they're joining.

00:55:13.971 --> 00:55:16.881
If you're a kind of first time non exec,
the last thing you want to be doing

00:55:16.881 --> 00:55:21.581
is joining a growth company board, and
they've run out of cash four months later.

00:55:22.351 --> 00:55:26.831
So, just coming back to the due diligence
part as well, you know, and I always

00:55:26.831 --> 00:55:31.131
say to aspiring NEDs that, I would be
a great advocate for joining a growth

00:55:31.141 --> 00:55:35.871
company board, but they should have a
minimum of 12 to 18 months cash runway,

00:55:36.194 --> 00:55:40.894
and that, again, you spend serious
time with the CEO and the founder.

00:55:41.269 --> 00:55:43.409
To get a real sense of,
could I work with them?

00:55:44.299 --> 00:55:48.829
And I always think a very interesting
question when an aspiring NED should

00:55:48.829 --> 00:55:53.069
meet with the CEO is the single biggest
question they should be looking to

00:55:53.069 --> 00:55:55.959
answer is, will this founder take advice?

00:55:56.384 --> 00:55:57.894
Yeah, in particular, I'd also.

00:55:58.283 --> 00:56:01.253
encourage listeners to think about
joining advisory boards, which

00:56:01.313 --> 00:56:04.856
perhaps don't go with the same
reputational risk and, governance

00:56:04.856 --> 00:56:06.806
issues, as a formal board member.

00:56:07.056 --> 00:56:10.469
And if anybody's interested, Ollie
Cummings at New Roll, on his podcast

00:56:10.469 --> 00:56:15.049
has been developing a theme of the idea
of pop up boards and advisory boards

00:56:15.049 --> 00:56:19.659
to solve for a particular issue for a
particular founder at that moment of time.

00:56:19.659 --> 00:56:23.119
So, so again perhaps a bit
of wider perspective people

00:56:23.129 --> 00:56:24.029
might want to think about.

00:56:24.319 --> 00:56:25.369
So let's try and pull this together.

00:56:25.739 --> 00:56:29.779
What's the listener take from our
discussion, and how does our aspiring NED

00:56:30.244 --> 00:56:32.164
maximise their chance of a board seat?

00:56:32.934 --> 00:56:35.933
Every day, literally
both myself and my team.

00:56:36.298 --> 00:56:39.258
We're observing board and
committee meetings in action.

00:56:39.658 --> 00:56:45.398
And I think the key thing, is for aspiring
non execs is to really understand your

00:56:45.398 --> 00:56:47.783
role and what makes for a great non exec.

00:56:47.952 --> 00:56:52.399
It's that balancing of holding the CEO
and the executive team's feet to the

00:56:52.399 --> 00:56:55.949
fire, even sometimes when they don't
want their feet held to the fire, and you

00:56:55.949 --> 00:57:00.269
can have very strong characters in the
executive team, but being steadfast and

00:57:00.269 --> 00:57:05.664
resolute that's my role, as an individual
and as a collective board to oversee

00:57:05.664 --> 00:57:10.034
the performance of the organisation, its
health, its finances, its risk management.

00:57:10.574 --> 00:57:14.804
But then balancing that with really
adding value, support and helping

00:57:14.804 --> 00:57:16.204
the executive team to excel.

00:57:16.824 --> 00:57:21.894
Because if your executive team excels,
then the board and the executive team

00:57:21.904 --> 00:57:27.094
together are in a great position as the
stewards and drivers of that company.

00:57:27.464 --> 00:57:32.314
At the end of the day, around the board
table, you have 11 or 12 individuals

00:57:32.314 --> 00:57:37.174
between the non execs and the executive
team and how they work together, how

00:57:37.194 --> 00:57:38.834
they get the best out of each other.

00:57:39.309 --> 00:57:41.149
And at times, that's going to be tough.

00:57:41.169 --> 00:57:44.089
You're going to be in The Zone of
Uncomfortable with a lot of healthy

00:57:44.089 --> 00:57:48.719
tensions and sometimes conflict,
but sometimes that's what's needed

00:57:49.039 --> 00:57:52.519
to make the very best decisions
and what often are complex choices.

00:57:53.029 --> 00:57:54.459
Fantastic summary, thanks Kieran.

00:57:54.785 --> 00:57:57.695
I know you've written some
great content on LinkedIn and

00:57:57.695 --> 00:57:58.845
you've got a fantastic blog.

00:57:59.292 --> 00:58:02.152
So if anybody wants to follow
up with you or find out a bit

00:58:02.152 --> 00:58:03.482
more about Board Excellence,

00:58:03.512 --> 00:58:08.272
Yeah, if you go to our website,
board-excellence.com, or if you look

00:58:08.572 --> 00:58:13.002
for me on LinkedIn, I love sharing,
I suppose, our experiences of helping

00:58:13.002 --> 00:58:18.629
boards, and, celebrating positives, what
the best boards like, but also, I suppose,

00:58:18.629 --> 00:58:23.212
sharing a lot of the challenges we see, in
boards and directors that, that struggle.

00:58:23.222 --> 00:58:26.585
So, delighted for any of the
listeners to follow up with me and,

00:58:26.635 --> 00:58:28.435
or follow up with any of the articles.

00:58:29.055 --> 00:58:31.725
Kieran, thanks so much for
putting us into your hectic

00:58:31.725 --> 00:58:32.845
schedule while you were in London.

00:58:33.175 --> 00:58:34.905
It's been an absolute
pleasure, thank you so much.

00:58:35.135 --> 00:58:35.515
Thank you.

00:58:35.798 --> 00:58:39.198
I hope that you've enjoyed listening
to this podcast and have found it

00:58:39.208 --> 00:58:43.328
helpful when thinking about how to
approach your own path to the boardroom.

00:58:44.218 --> 00:58:47.358
If you would like to push this a
little bit further, Sainty Hird

00:58:47.378 --> 00:58:52.168
runs a bespoke one to one programme
designed specifically to this end.

00:58:52.502 --> 00:58:57.186
For more information, please visit
our website, saintyhird.com, follow

00:58:57.186 --> 00:59:03.041
us on LinkedIn, and subscribe to the
Boardroom Path to receive new episodes.

00:59:03.387 --> 00:59:04.337
Thank you for listening.