WEBVTT

00:00:03.104 --> 00:00:06.364
Ralph Grayson: Welcome to The Boardroom
Path by Sainty Hird & Partners.

00:00:06.709 --> 00:00:10.599
I'm your host, Ralph Grayson, a
partner in the board practice.

00:00:10.968 --> 00:00:15.528
In this series, we'll offer practical
steps and useful perspectives for

00:00:15.528 --> 00:00:17.868
aspiring and newly appointed NEDs.

00:00:18.216 --> 00:00:21.896
Throughout its 30 year history,
Sainty Hird has recruited senior

00:00:21.896 --> 00:00:27.791
board members across the City,
Industry, the Public Sector and NGOs.

00:00:28.681 --> 00:00:33.351
We're now also evaluating those boards,
as well as coaching and mentoring

00:00:33.561 --> 00:00:38.021
those seeking to transition from an
executive career into the boardroom.

00:00:38.189 --> 00:00:40.819
So we'll be speaking to some
leading figures in the board

00:00:40.819 --> 00:00:42.269
advisory and NED world.

00:00:42.934 --> 00:00:47.284
Specifically, we'll seek their
counsel about how and where to spend

00:00:47.284 --> 00:00:51.454
time and energy to make an effective
transition into the boardroom.

00:00:51.967 --> 00:00:58.317
The goal is to equip recent and aspiring
NEDs with tips, tactics and strategies

00:00:58.657 --> 00:01:03.624
to be most effective and build a
successful career as a board director.

00:01:04.100 --> 00:01:08.010
In the process, we aim to help you
to think more about who you are,

00:01:08.470 --> 00:01:12.430
how you operate and how you can
make this work in the boardroom.

00:01:12.952 --> 00:01:18.692
It's my great pleasure today to talk
to Dr. Scarlett Brown, Director of

00:01:18.692 --> 00:01:22.622
the Think Tank at Board Intelligence,
where she leads Board Intelligence

00:01:22.622 --> 00:01:26.702
events for business leaders, board
members, and governance professionals.

00:01:27.542 --> 00:01:32.162
Board Intelligence is Europe's largest
board technology and advisory firm with

00:01:32.162 --> 00:01:36.272
a mission to supercharge boards with
the science of board effectiveness.

00:01:37.172 --> 00:01:40.682
Her expertise is in best practice,
corporate governance and board

00:01:40.682 --> 00:01:44.897
effectiveness with a particular
focus on AI and technology in the

00:01:44.897 --> 00:01:49.817
boardroom, responsible business,
board reporting and sustainability.

00:01:50.887 --> 00:01:54.617
Scarlett is a regular speaker and
panelist, including appearances

00:01:54.617 --> 00:01:57.557
on BBC Radio Four and Radio Two.

00:01:57.975 --> 00:02:04.110
In 2023, Scarlett was recognised
as one of HRs most influential

00:02:04.110 --> 00:02:08.940
thinkers for her research with
Professor Veronica Hope Haley on

00:02:08.940 --> 00:02:11.250
leadership through the COVID Crisis.

00:02:12.140 --> 00:02:16.380
Scarlett's book, Gender and Corporate
Boards: The Route to a Seat at the

00:02:16.380 --> 00:02:23.220
Table was published in 2022 based
on her PhD research on the obstacles

00:02:23.220 --> 00:02:25.050
to achieving boardroom diversity.

00:02:26.025 --> 00:02:30.345
Since then, Scarlett has led
research into leadership, boards

00:02:30.345 --> 00:02:34.635
and corporate governance for many
organisations, including Tomorrow's

00:02:34.635 --> 00:02:40.515
Company, Grant Thornton, the CIPD,
the Chartered Institute for Personnel

00:02:40.515 --> 00:02:44.805
and Development, the University of
Oxford and the Forward Institute.

00:02:45.615 --> 00:02:47.925
Scarlett, thank you for
appearing on this podcast.

00:02:48.285 --> 00:02:52.065
It would be great to hear a little
about your backstory, your journey

00:02:52.065 --> 00:02:55.575
into the world of corporate governance
and your path to Board Intelligence.

00:02:56.075 --> 00:02:58.470
Scarlett Brown: Thank you so much
Ralph, a pleasure to be here.

00:02:58.520 --> 00:03:02.060
So I can tell you a long version or
a short version, but, the interest

00:03:02.060 --> 00:03:05.380
in corporate governance and in board
effectiveness started life as for

00:03:05.380 --> 00:03:07.590
many of us it did sort of by accident.

00:03:08.010 --> 00:03:12.900
I accidentally did a PhD looking
at how there are barriers to

00:03:12.930 --> 00:03:15.863
boardroom diversity In about 2012.

00:03:15.923 --> 00:03:20.193
You may remember it was a time when we
were really fascinated in, how do we

00:03:20.193 --> 00:03:23.873
get more women onto boards, women on
boards was the thing at the time and I

00:03:23.873 --> 00:03:28.373
came up into the ranks a young sort of
feminist sociologist really interested

00:03:28.733 --> 00:03:33.443
in those barriers to gender diversity
and sort of week one of my research the

00:03:33.443 --> 00:03:37.913
question was, you know, I was sitting
there on my laptop going, what is a board?

00:03:37.973 --> 00:03:39.713
Why would anybody want to be on a board?

00:03:39.763 --> 00:03:42.362
Why do we care if there's
enough women on boards?

00:03:42.782 --> 00:03:44.167
Why would diversity make a difference?

00:03:44.477 --> 00:03:48.047
And all of those questions led me
to having to, over the course of

00:03:48.047 --> 00:03:52.517
several years, very quickly go from
being a researcher to being what I

00:03:52.517 --> 00:03:55.907
now like to refer to myself as is a
professional corporate governance nerd

00:03:56.307 --> 00:03:57.987
and the career came from that really.

00:03:57.987 --> 00:04:01.917
So I've had the privilege to work with
some amazing organisations over that time,

00:04:01.967 --> 00:04:03.387
many of them you've already mentioned.

00:04:03.817 --> 00:04:09.677
But I became really interested in the role
that the board plays in wider society,

00:04:09.677 --> 00:04:14.052
of course, in the way that businesses
are run and particularly, I think over

00:04:14.052 --> 00:04:18.252
the years, over the sort of last decade,
the changes to the way that we approach

00:04:18.252 --> 00:04:21.312
boards and corporate governance in this
country have been really fascinating.

00:04:21.712 --> 00:04:25.672
So we've seen the rise of things
like expectation that board members

00:04:25.672 --> 00:04:29.422
should have oversight of culture,
should be driving better purpose,

00:04:29.482 --> 00:04:31.342
should be trusted by the wider world.

00:04:31.347 --> 00:04:34.972
All while there's been, you know, major
corporate governance failings happening.

00:04:35.332 --> 00:04:39.042
So it's been a kind of a fascinating
journey, that led me, as you say

00:04:39.074 --> 00:04:41.747
to the door of Board Intelligence
a little over four years ago.

00:04:42.712 --> 00:04:46.513
Ralph Grayson: Fascinating, a lot of
the listeners to this podcast are new

00:04:46.513 --> 00:04:51.573
and aspiring non-executives, maybe some
aren't familiar with Board Intelligence.

00:04:51.823 --> 00:04:55.003
So perhaps we could just spend a
minute on how Board Intelligence

00:04:55.003 --> 00:04:58.553
was set up, what its mission, its
purpose was, and maybe how that's

00:04:58.553 --> 00:04:59.573
evolved over the last few years.

00:04:59.638 --> 00:05:00.538
Scarlett Brown: Yeah, absolutely.

00:05:00.698 --> 00:05:04.188
so Board Intelligence is
a boutique consultancy.

00:05:04.238 --> 00:05:07.933
The founders were sitting
in the back of boardrooms.

00:05:07.987 --> 00:05:11.027
They were strategy consultants initially
and looking at how the organisation

00:05:11.047 --> 00:05:14.527
could be more effective and they sat
in this boardroom, and I think many

00:05:14.527 --> 00:05:17.347
of us will have had this experience
sort of that first day that you're

00:05:17.347 --> 00:05:21.397
going to be either in a board meeting
or being in it for the first time and

00:05:21.397 --> 00:05:24.757
having this expectation about what a
board will be and what they won't be.

00:05:24.857 --> 00:05:28.727
Pippa and Jen who founded the
organisation, were really excited about

00:05:28.877 --> 00:05:32.547
listening in and hearing this, it was
a very big, well-known organisation

00:05:32.567 --> 00:05:36.517
with some very big, well-known
non-executive directors sitting around

00:05:36.517 --> 00:05:40.747
the table, and it was an organisation
that was going through a really,

00:05:40.747 --> 00:05:42.597
really big challenge, at the time.

00:05:42.597 --> 00:05:46.047
One that was very much in the public
eye and there was this kind of, you

00:05:46.047 --> 00:05:49.887
know, excitement about the meeting,
and then they got in, and watched these

00:05:49.887 --> 00:05:54.987
incredibly interesting, brilliant, wise
board members have an incredibly dull

00:05:54.987 --> 00:05:59.427
conversation about the backward looking
information that was in front of them,

00:05:59.837 --> 00:06:03.197
and this realisation that actually a lot
of what board members do when they're

00:06:03.197 --> 00:06:08.387
sitting in a board meeting is to review
past performance and approve some updates.

00:06:08.467 --> 00:06:11.587
This felt like such a missed opportunity
when you speak to board members

00:06:11.587 --> 00:06:13.177
about the value that they bring.

00:06:13.612 --> 00:06:16.942
The things that they want to talk
about are the strategy, are where the

00:06:16.942 --> 00:06:20.782
organisation is going, what's going on
out there in the world, how can we avoid

00:06:20.782 --> 00:06:24.472
these big risks that are maybe coming
down the track and one of the biggest

00:06:24.472 --> 00:06:27.802
barriers to that is the information
that boards have in front of them.

00:06:27.862 --> 00:06:32.412
That when you are reviewing mountains
of past performance, you don't have

00:06:32.412 --> 00:06:33.882
a conversation that really matters.

00:06:34.162 --> 00:06:36.782
And that's what led to the
formation of Board Intelligence

00:06:36.857 --> 00:06:40.907
as it is and as an organisation
we now have a much broader remit.

00:06:40.907 --> 00:06:44.897
We look at almost every
part of board effectiveness.

00:06:44.987 --> 00:06:49.337
But really at our core we are
kind of fascinated with the way

00:06:49.337 --> 00:06:53.657
that the information that board
members have at their fingertips.

00:06:54.137 --> 00:06:58.457
How that drives the kind of conversations
they have and the kind of decisions

00:06:58.457 --> 00:07:02.037
they're able to make and that's a
challenge that has kept us busy for the

00:07:02.037 --> 00:07:05.737
last two decades, and I'm sure we'll
continue to keep us busy looking forward.

00:07:06.467 --> 00:07:10.087
Ralph Grayson: Brilliant, and as head of
the Think Tank, what's your particular

00:07:10.087 --> 00:07:15.180
role in that dynamic and what should
our listeners perhaps take from that?

00:07:15.240 --> 00:07:18.990
You published some really good thought
leadership, and I would encourage

00:07:18.990 --> 00:07:22.360
everybody thinking about, a board
and their role on a board to look

00:07:22.360 --> 00:07:24.970
at the website and look at some of
the content that you've written.

00:07:25.270 --> 00:07:28.050
But maybe you can just talk about
your personal mission in that respect.

00:07:28.110 --> 00:07:29.150
Scarlett Brown: Yeah, absolutely.

00:07:29.150 --> 00:07:32.930
So as head of the Think Tank, I have many
aspects to that, but I have the privilege

00:07:32.930 --> 00:07:37.276
of running many of our event series and
of working with the team on the thought

00:07:37.276 --> 00:07:38.557
leadership that we pulled together.

00:07:38.557 --> 00:07:42.952
So we are always kind of looking to
answer that question around, how can we

00:07:42.952 --> 00:07:46.702
really understand the science of board
effectiveness and how can we support our

00:07:46.702 --> 00:07:52.762
clients and those in our wider audience as
well to be the best directors they can be?

00:07:53.202 --> 00:07:56.542
The main thing that I do as part of
the Think Tank is to run our engagement

00:07:56.542 --> 00:08:01.172
and our community of thousands of
board members, and of governance

00:08:01.172 --> 00:08:05.252
professionals, of those that support
boards, and to really try and bring

00:08:05.402 --> 00:08:10.907
what we know about what makes boards
run really well into the hands of people

00:08:10.907 --> 00:08:14.597
who are really trying to be brilliant
board members and make boards run well.

00:08:14.997 --> 00:08:18.347
So it's not a small mission just, you
know, try and improve the effectiveness

00:08:18.347 --> 00:08:22.017
of every board that we work with
and also every board globally.

00:08:22.327 --> 00:08:25.237
I like to say, you know, compared
to some of my colleagues, you

00:08:25.237 --> 00:08:27.847
know, my job is changing the world
and their job is just, you know,

00:08:27.847 --> 00:08:29.137
working with a handful of clients.

00:08:29.137 --> 00:08:32.799
But yeah, trying to make sure that
every business that has a board is doing

00:08:32.799 --> 00:08:37.010
the best that it can for that board to
drive value for the organisation is key.

00:08:37.529 --> 00:08:41.299
Ralph Grayson: So the front page
of the website clearly states that

00:08:41.359 --> 00:08:46.669
Board Intelligence thinks that board
effectiveness is a science, not an art.

00:08:47.419 --> 00:08:51.515
So what's the particular
approach to that thinking and

00:08:51.515 --> 00:08:52.865
why do boards need this science?

00:08:53.980 --> 00:08:57.000
Scarlett Brown: It's a really great
question and we've toyed with it lots,

00:08:57.050 --> 00:09:01.307
stating that board effectiveness is a
science is not an insignificant statement.

00:09:01.937 --> 00:09:03.707
Many people feel it to be an art.

00:09:03.737 --> 00:09:07.787
I think, you know, there's a real
love of boards and boardrooms, feeling

00:09:07.787 --> 00:09:10.987
like it's an artful place and of
course there's a place for that too.

00:09:11.737 --> 00:09:15.013
But, there's been an incredible
professionalisation of the role.

00:09:15.073 --> 00:09:18.703
The expectation now that a board
should be delivering value for its

00:09:18.703 --> 00:09:21.503
organisation has really increased.

00:09:21.718 --> 00:09:25.048
Board members, and I know many of your
listeners will feel this way, part of the

00:09:25.048 --> 00:09:28.558
reason they'll listen to this podcast is
because they feel that kind of personal

00:09:28.558 --> 00:09:33.681
responsibility, to be adding value, and
we are a long way away from the past where

00:09:33.681 --> 00:09:37.791
perhaps, you know, the only people that
sat on boards were retired chief execs

00:09:37.791 --> 00:09:41.694
who were given it as a sort of a nice
little retirement treat to be taken out

00:09:41.694 --> 00:09:45.311
for lunch every so often and to offer
some wisdom and we've just seen such a

00:09:45.311 --> 00:09:48.837
change in the world of boards since then
over the last, two or three decades.

00:09:49.497 --> 00:09:53.347
So I think there's a kind of an appetite
from boards and from the organisations

00:09:53.367 --> 00:09:58.338
that they lead to be driving more value
from the organisation and a desire

00:09:58.338 --> 00:10:02.578
for the board members themselves to
be doing that, and of course we have

00:10:02.578 --> 00:10:07.828
seen a total shift in the way that
boards are run in a practical sense.

00:10:08.188 --> 00:10:12.072
So, a really basic one is now it's
much more likely that the board

00:10:12.072 --> 00:10:16.297
member will receive their information
through a iPad or an email.

00:10:16.627 --> 00:10:19.927
Which I know sounds really basic to
say, but when we started as a business,

00:10:19.977 --> 00:10:24.807
the team were sitting in the corner of
an office with a ring binding machine.

00:10:24.827 --> 00:10:28.715
I'm just about old enough to
remember making magazines when I

00:10:28.715 --> 00:10:31.390
was in primary school that were
made out of this ring binder.

00:10:31.600 --> 00:10:34.060
But many of the people in our
team are not old enough to

00:10:34.060 --> 00:10:35.740
remember a ring binding machine.

00:10:36.520 --> 00:10:40.730
There was a time when we would send,
you know, an enormous stack of papers

00:10:40.730 --> 00:10:44.860
to a chair on a Friday afternoon, and
it would, you know, get UPS to them.

00:10:45.280 --> 00:10:49.030
Technology has fundamentally changed
every aspect of the way that boards run.

00:10:49.080 --> 00:10:52.320
Even in organisations that are
perhaps a little bit more tech phobic.

00:10:52.910 --> 00:10:57.365
There's this real kind of access to data,
and I suppose that's the final point

00:10:57.365 --> 00:11:02.105
around what we've seen the need for a
kind of scientific approach to this is

00:11:02.165 --> 00:11:06.125
we used to say, that, you know, a lot
of the work that we would do would be

00:11:06.125 --> 00:11:09.035
helping boards get access to information.

00:11:09.455 --> 00:11:11.315
Now the problem is too much data.

00:11:11.405 --> 00:11:12.815
We can't see the wood for the trees.

00:11:12.855 --> 00:11:16.625
We are drowning in data, and board
packs, and board information has

00:11:16.625 --> 00:11:18.867
got longer, and longer and longer.

00:11:19.417 --> 00:11:24.827
So there's a need to also, you know,
to make sense of the data that we have.

00:11:25.177 --> 00:11:28.687
Which means that you can take a much
more scientific approach to how the

00:11:28.687 --> 00:11:30.517
board runs and how it improves itself.

00:11:30.967 --> 00:11:33.927
Ralph Grayson: I think what's so great
about hearing that is having somebody

00:11:33.927 --> 00:11:39.747
in the room who's young and relevant
and leading board thought leadership.

00:11:39.837 --> 00:11:44.688
I think this is just fantastic and
it harks back to previous guests I've

00:11:44.688 --> 00:11:48.808
had Patrick Dunne talking about five
generations in the workforce, Graham

00:11:48.808 --> 00:11:52.888
Duggan, who founded the Non-Executive
Director Association talking about

00:11:53.278 --> 00:11:58.528
Christmas tree lights that NEDs are just
there to look pretty and now you are

00:11:58.528 --> 00:12:04.608
bringing this absolutely as a function
into the 21st century and up to today.

00:12:04.608 --> 00:12:06.933
So let's go right to the
heart of that with AI.

00:12:07.983 --> 00:12:11.253
Because it is totally disrupting
the world of corporate governance.

00:12:11.713 --> 00:12:17.203
I'd love to hear what you think the
impact of AI is on the function of good

00:12:17.203 --> 00:12:19.238
governance and how you see that evolving.

00:12:20.168 --> 00:12:21.162
Scarlett Brown: It's
interesting, isn't it?

00:12:21.192 --> 00:12:25.375
It feels like we can't move for a
conversation without it coming back to

00:12:25.375 --> 00:12:30.305
AI at the moment in the business world,
and your listeners would be forgiven for

00:12:30.305 --> 00:12:32.705
being a bit tired of talking about AI.

00:12:32.755 --> 00:12:36.055
But it is a big part of what we're
thinking about at Board Intelligence.

00:12:36.432 --> 00:12:38.802
I suppose there's kind of two
areas that I think are really

00:12:38.802 --> 00:12:40.092
interesting when it comes to AI.

00:12:40.902 --> 00:12:45.742
So first is, what do boards
themselves do about the challenge

00:12:45.742 --> 00:12:47.062
of AI within their business?

00:12:47.122 --> 00:12:49.072
And this is not a question
limited to boards.

00:12:49.072 --> 00:12:53.122
There is something like 85% of
leaders were saying that it was one

00:12:53.122 --> 00:12:57.742
of a top three priority for them,
and that will have grown, I think.

00:12:57.772 --> 00:13:00.982
Certainly to be considering about
how AI is transforming businesses

00:13:00.982 --> 00:13:03.462
and I think that's a challenge
that probably every organisation

00:13:03.482 --> 00:13:04.652
is grappling with at the moment.

00:13:04.712 --> 00:13:06.332
Is AI a priority for us?

00:13:06.332 --> 00:13:08.072
What problems does it help us solve?

00:13:09.062 --> 00:13:12.062
But at the same time, really interesting
research that came out earlier this

00:13:12.062 --> 00:13:17.422
year, which found that something like
75% of businesses who are using AI

00:13:17.422 --> 00:13:21.377
in some way are not seeing a return
on investment on that use of AI.

00:13:21.797 --> 00:13:24.677
So at the moment, we've got
lots of people holding a hammer,

00:13:24.827 --> 00:13:26.087
looking for a nail, right?

00:13:26.087 --> 00:13:28.007
We've got loads of people
going, right, let's do AI.

00:13:28.007 --> 00:13:28.877
Let's use AI.

00:13:28.877 --> 00:13:32.027
Let's get excited about it, but not
really knowing how to deal with it.

00:13:32.987 --> 00:13:36.058
And then when we speak to boards, we
have a framework we use when we are

00:13:36.058 --> 00:13:39.378
looking at kind of, driving a better
conversation within the boardroom, that

00:13:39.378 --> 00:13:40.998
we call the six conversations model.

00:13:40.998 --> 00:13:44.198
Which I won't go into lots of detail
now, partly cause it's better if

00:13:44.198 --> 00:13:45.608
I've got the visual in front of me.

00:13:45.658 --> 00:13:49.368
The key thing that gets drawn out by the
six conversations model is that often

00:13:49.368 --> 00:13:55.008
boards get pulled into talking about
risk management and tracking performance.

00:13:55.038 --> 00:13:56.248
It's like what I said about earlier.

00:13:56.578 --> 00:14:01.678
We get very, very good at talking
about the risks within AI, how we

00:14:01.678 --> 00:14:06.678
should govern it, what are the ethical
challenges that it presents, and

00:14:06.678 --> 00:14:10.728
getting very nervous about it, and
then boards switch off a little bit.

00:14:10.788 --> 00:14:15.708
So, we ran some research earlier
in the year that found that, 83%

00:14:15.708 --> 00:14:19.788
of directors felt ill-equipped to
harness the opportunities of AI.

00:14:20.388 --> 00:14:24.783
So we've got a real nervousness around
that and a lack of conversation about

00:14:24.903 --> 00:14:28.713
the strategic benefits that AI can have
for our businesses, and I think, you

00:14:28.713 --> 00:14:30.963
know, that's something that perhaps
we'll come back onto it a little bit

00:14:30.963 --> 00:14:36.813
later, around how boards can kind of feel
comfortable talking about AI and knowing

00:14:36.843 --> 00:14:38.463
how to make good decisions about it.

00:14:38.463 --> 00:14:42.813
I think there's a real nervousness among
leadership whilst at the same time being

00:14:42.813 --> 00:14:45.123
very outwardly, you know, enthusiastic.

00:14:45.123 --> 00:14:46.143
We need to change everything.

00:14:46.283 --> 00:14:49.193
It's an interesting debate topic
happening within boardrooms at the moment.

00:14:49.508 --> 00:14:53.138
The second interesting area around AI,
which is where we get really obsessed

00:14:53.138 --> 00:14:59.368
about it, is what role can AI play in the
way that the board does its day-to-day?

00:14:59.518 --> 00:15:03.578
Technology has transformed boardrooms
and AI is doing the same and one of

00:15:03.578 --> 00:15:07.178
the things that we've really observed
is that, again, we've got this kind

00:15:07.178 --> 00:15:10.178
of, everybody's got a hammer and
they're looking for a nail problem.

00:15:10.763 --> 00:15:14.903
There are loads of wizzy tools out
there and lots of things claiming that

00:15:14.903 --> 00:15:18.353
they can make a really big difference,
and actually, partly what we need to

00:15:18.353 --> 00:15:22.943
do when it comes to AI is we need to
understand some of the problems or

00:15:22.943 --> 00:15:27.743
the challenges that boards are facing,
and we need to point AI at those

00:15:27.743 --> 00:15:31.493
problems with a tool that it's actually
designed to solve those problems.

00:15:31.883 --> 00:15:33.923
So I'll give you an
example of what I mean.

00:15:35.018 --> 00:15:39.818
I've already emphasised that one of the
biggest barriers to boards being effective

00:15:39.848 --> 00:15:42.188
is they are drowning in information.

00:15:42.248 --> 00:15:46.778
They're, you know, sent 800 pages on
a Friday evening and the board meeting

00:15:46.778 --> 00:15:49.418
is on Monday morning and they're
going to spend their Sunday afternoon

00:15:49.958 --> 00:15:51.548
digesting all of that information.

00:15:52.028 --> 00:15:53.678
So we know we have a
problem with board packs.

00:15:54.533 --> 00:15:59.423
Board information has been getting weaker
in quality for years, and an obvious start

00:15:59.423 --> 00:16:03.113
point for AI would be, and we've seen
some board members do this, and please

00:16:03.113 --> 00:16:07.103
listeners don't do this, running their
board pack through ChatGPT and getting

00:16:07.103 --> 00:16:08.723
it to summarise the information for them.

00:16:09.203 --> 00:16:12.533
Or at the other end, somebody has to
write a paper for the board and they're

00:16:12.713 --> 00:16:14.723
using ChatGPT to help them write it.

00:16:15.878 --> 00:16:19.208
Apart from there being some
challenges about confidentiality of

00:16:19.208 --> 00:16:20.678
information or that kind of thing.

00:16:21.218 --> 00:16:25.808
The problem with both of those things is
that ChatGPT or Copilot or Gemini, are

00:16:25.808 --> 00:16:31.598
one of those equivalents, is not imbued
with the knowledge about what drives a

00:16:31.598 --> 00:16:33.398
really effective boardroom conversation.

00:16:33.968 --> 00:16:39.718
So what you need to use AI for in
this context is either to have a tool

00:16:39.718 --> 00:16:44.143
that will act as a critical friend
and be able to tell you how to write

00:16:44.143 --> 00:16:47.193
a really good board information that
will drive a good board conversation.

00:16:47.193 --> 00:16:51.363
So we'll sit next to the CEO while
she's writing for the board and say,

00:16:51.813 --> 00:16:57.283
oh, by the way, CEO, you do realise
that your paper is 80% optimistic and

00:16:57.283 --> 00:17:01.633
only 20% pessimistic, and we know that
you've got, you know, a very, very

00:17:01.633 --> 00:17:05.413
pessimistic ex CFO on your board and
we think that she might notice that.

00:17:05.413 --> 00:17:06.493
So why don't you tweak it?

00:17:06.553 --> 00:17:08.323
Are you really sure
that's the right balance?

00:17:08.323 --> 00:17:12.433
So tools that can act as a critical
friend that really understand what

00:17:12.433 --> 00:17:13.458
the board paper needs to have in it.

00:17:14.838 --> 00:17:19.248
Or you have tools that on the
director side, for example, would

00:17:19.248 --> 00:17:23.348
be able to feed it the information
that you've got from the board pack.

00:17:23.348 --> 00:17:25.868
So again, in a safe, secure way,
part of the reason, you know, we

00:17:25.868 --> 00:17:28.658
do a lot of thinking around this is
how do you make it safe and secure?

00:17:29.258 --> 00:17:33.338
But that something that could,
again, sit next to it and help you

00:17:33.338 --> 00:17:36.578
bring in all the things that you
need to drive a good conversation.

00:17:37.418 --> 00:17:40.658
Board meetings are typically that we
don't have enough conversation within

00:17:40.658 --> 00:17:42.578
them about the external factors.

00:17:42.638 --> 00:17:45.848
So actually wouldn't be great if you
could have a board pack that not only

00:17:45.848 --> 00:17:50.228
has the papers that are produced by the
organisation, but also brings in other

00:17:50.228 --> 00:17:53.558
external research factors that says
what else is going on in the market.

00:17:54.143 --> 00:17:54.833
Things like that.

00:17:54.833 --> 00:17:57.403
There's something that could bring
up all of the papers where, a

00:17:57.403 --> 00:17:58.873
particular issue was discussed.

00:17:59.653 --> 00:18:04.123
Something that could point out to you and
point out gaps in thinking or could act as

00:18:04.123 --> 00:18:08.143
a reader of a different kind that could,
you know, put on a cynical hat or put on a

00:18:08.143 --> 00:18:11.973
forward looking hat and tell you what kind
of what may be questions you want to ask.

00:18:12.363 --> 00:18:14.943
So those are the kind of use cases
we're thinking about with AI.

00:18:15.143 --> 00:18:17.723
There's some really kind of
standard approaches right now.

00:18:17.723 --> 00:18:20.813
There's some kind of basic
things coming out, people using

00:18:20.843 --> 00:18:22.563
the kind of the generic tools.

00:18:22.623 --> 00:18:27.603
But actually what we are really excited
about is how much better could you make

00:18:27.603 --> 00:18:31.413
a board if you took the understanding
of what drives brilliant board

00:18:31.413 --> 00:18:34.413
effectiveness and the power that AI has.

00:18:34.683 --> 00:18:37.383
Bring them together and that's
what's going to make the difference.

00:18:38.693 --> 00:18:40.103
Ralph Grayson: Gosh, huge
amount of time unravel there.

00:18:40.583 --> 00:18:41.983
Scarlett Brown: A long
answer to a short question.

00:18:42.058 --> 00:18:44.153
Ralph Grayson: Well, no, I think
it was a great, great answer

00:18:44.153 --> 00:18:46.223
to a hugely complex question.

00:18:46.783 --> 00:18:49.513
If anybody's interested in exploring
this a little bit further, there

00:18:49.513 --> 00:18:54.083
is a brilliant Harvard Business
Review post on the use of AI.

00:18:54.323 --> 00:18:58.633
Particularly around the need
for better scenario planning

00:18:58.633 --> 00:19:00.073
for all boards at the moment.

00:19:00.393 --> 00:19:02.913
Let's just step back a little
bit and think a bit more about

00:19:03.333 --> 00:19:05.968
board effectiveness as a concept.

00:19:06.388 --> 00:19:09.718
So you recently published
the Board Value Index.

00:19:10.068 --> 00:19:14.058
That highlights the challenges
boards have in adding value to their

00:19:14.398 --> 00:19:18.288
organisation and in particular, what
I found very interesting reading it

00:19:18.288 --> 00:19:22.048
was what Board Intelligence called
the blockers of board effectiveness

00:19:22.048 --> 00:19:24.448
and what boards can do to improve.

00:19:24.568 --> 00:19:27.578
So I'd love you to dive into that
a little bit more and maybe just

00:19:27.638 --> 00:19:28.928
give us some of the key findings.

00:19:29.378 --> 00:19:31.913
Scarlett Brown: So the Board Value Index,
as you say, launched early this year.

00:19:32.560 --> 00:19:35.758
We've often been kind of looking at
what are the inputs that drive board

00:19:35.758 --> 00:19:38.218
effectiveness, but we sort of wanted
to start from the point of view

00:19:38.218 --> 00:19:43.168
of how do board members feel about
the way that they are adding value?

00:19:43.218 --> 00:19:46.008
And there's some, you know, little
bit nerve wracking statistics.

00:19:46.008 --> 00:19:51.198
So we found that 41% of board
members feel that they're not adding

00:19:51.198 --> 00:19:53.268
enough value to their organisations.

00:19:53.728 --> 00:19:58.558
33% said they add no value at
all and half of them said that

00:19:58.558 --> 00:20:02.758
they were actively holding the
organisation back from creating value.

00:20:03.036 --> 00:20:04.116
Sobering statistics.

00:20:04.116 --> 00:20:06.086
We found, and again, this
is self-report, right?

00:20:06.086 --> 00:20:08.476
These are directors talking
about the way that they feel

00:20:08.476 --> 00:20:09.706
about the value that they add.

00:20:10.846 --> 00:20:14.694
So we kind of have these sort of, these
blockades, I guess to board members

00:20:14.744 --> 00:20:17.984
adding value, and we are always really
keen to start from the point of view

00:20:17.984 --> 00:20:22.724
that generally speaking, even where we
are seeing what we might call kind of

00:20:22.724 --> 00:20:27.194
failings of boards or failing of corporate
governance in the vast majority of

00:20:27.194 --> 00:20:29.444
cases, board members want to add value.

00:20:29.444 --> 00:20:30.734
They want to do well.

00:20:30.794 --> 00:20:32.954
They want their organisations
to succeed, right?

00:20:32.954 --> 00:20:36.554
I think we can probably say that
about the absolute vast majority.

00:20:37.064 --> 00:20:41.204
But that actually we are not setting
board members up for success.

00:20:41.544 --> 00:20:44.394
Partly that's to do with the way that
they work, and partly that's to do with

00:20:44.394 --> 00:20:46.184
the way that their organisations work.

00:20:46.184 --> 00:20:48.854
So we've been really trying to
think about some of the ways that

00:20:48.854 --> 00:20:50.204
we could kind of unblock that.

00:20:50.204 --> 00:20:52.504
So again, I'll give a
couple of little examples.

00:20:52.944 --> 00:20:55.794
The first I've already mentioned
is around board information.

00:20:55.894 --> 00:20:57.274
Board papers are too long.

00:20:57.304 --> 00:20:58.294
They come too late.

00:20:58.574 --> 00:21:01.184
Sometimes, literally the
night before a board meeting.

00:21:01.306 --> 00:21:04.426
If I could sort of advise everybody
listening in, if you're going to make a

00:21:04.426 --> 00:21:11.056
couple of really key differences, making
some consistency across the information,

00:21:11.056 --> 00:21:15.286
using things like executive summaries and
cover sheets, making sure your board have

00:21:15.286 --> 00:21:17.296
the information a week before the meeting.

00:21:17.626 --> 00:21:21.826
These seemingly small areas can
make a massive, massive difference.

00:21:22.696 --> 00:21:26.356
Couple of maybe bigger things that
we're looking at the moment is we need

00:21:26.356 --> 00:21:30.721
a new way of evaluating the extent
to which our boards are effective.

00:21:30.721 --> 00:21:34.651
So we started thinking a lot more about
the role of innovation in the boardroom.

00:21:34.711 --> 00:21:37.201
The role that the board
has in driving innovation.

00:21:37.684 --> 00:21:40.649
So some really interesting, wider
research, which again, if you're

00:21:40.649 --> 00:21:43.639
interested, it's worth having a
dig into about the kind of the need

00:21:43.639 --> 00:21:47.849
that we have as businesses to be, I
hate the phrase innovate or die, but

00:21:47.849 --> 00:21:51.149
it's always the one that comes up
across my mind when we talk about it.

00:21:51.149 --> 00:21:56.126
But the number of businesses now
that longevity as a business becomes

00:21:56.126 --> 00:22:00.746
less and less expected and that is
partly because the pace of change

00:22:00.776 --> 00:22:03.506
within the business world is so fast.

00:22:04.096 --> 00:22:08.306
We see it a lot with the kind of, you
know, the examples like tech businesses.

00:22:08.306 --> 00:22:10.766
We would never have been able to
think about the transformation that

00:22:10.766 --> 00:22:14.336
things like Airbnb or Uber or, you
know, would make to businesses.

00:22:14.846 --> 00:22:18.846
But actually the transformation that's
needed by almost every organisation

00:22:18.866 --> 00:22:23.696
just to stand still, even if you are not
disrupting a whole market, is massive.

00:22:24.486 --> 00:22:27.246
How do you as a board help your
business be more innovative?

00:22:27.756 --> 00:22:30.906
But it's not about saying, right, we're
going to be the Uber of something.

00:22:30.936 --> 00:22:35.471
It's about testing, experimenting,
encouraging the organisations you

00:22:35.471 --> 00:22:39.671
work with to try new things, to test
whether or not those things work

00:22:39.971 --> 00:22:43.511
and to keep going on things that are
and stop doing things that aren't.

00:22:43.951 --> 00:22:47.581
And it's amazing how afraid we've become
within business of doing that and actually

00:22:47.581 --> 00:22:50.391
as a board just being able to say,
right, we're going to give you space to

00:22:50.391 --> 00:22:55.701
try things, this kind of psychological
safety and safe space to try new things,

00:22:55.701 --> 00:22:57.941
experiment and see where it goes.

00:22:57.941 --> 00:23:01.411
And we've got some amazing examples
of where actually businesses

00:23:01.411 --> 00:23:04.561
have really, really flown when
they've had that approach.

00:23:04.561 --> 00:23:08.221
So yeah, that's another one of the areas
we're looking at is how do we drive a more

00:23:08.221 --> 00:23:09.871
innovative conversation in the boardroom.

00:23:10.099 --> 00:23:11.402
Ralph Grayson: It's a
real enigma, isn't it?

00:23:11.452 --> 00:23:13.732
Boards are becoming
more diverse than ever.

00:23:14.272 --> 00:23:16.762
Recruitment of board
members is more rigorous.

00:23:17.182 --> 00:23:19.762
There's more effective
use of board appraisals.

00:23:20.512 --> 00:23:26.752
So logic suggests that board performance
should be improving, but it's not.

00:23:27.872 --> 00:23:30.537
Not a very scientific question,
but why do you think that is?

00:23:31.601 --> 00:23:34.601
Scarlett Brown: Maybe it's unfair
of both you and I to say that

00:23:34.601 --> 00:23:36.131
board performance isn't improving.

00:23:36.161 --> 00:23:41.373
I think it's just that the standard is so
much higher, the expectation is higher.

00:23:41.456 --> 00:23:45.213
You'll know from being in this space for a
long time that there are some unbelievably

00:23:45.213 --> 00:23:46.443
good people on boards right now.

00:23:46.503 --> 00:23:49.803
Like they really, really are
and it is a difficult job.

00:23:49.903 --> 00:23:52.153
When it all goes wrong,
it's really thankless.

00:23:52.213 --> 00:23:55.783
When it's going well, people don't notice,
you know, I mean, the same is true of

00:23:55.811 --> 00:24:00.461
lots of leadership roles, but we're
seeing I just think a hunger for being

00:24:00.461 --> 00:24:02.801
better, and much more in the public eye.

00:24:03.501 --> 00:24:06.741
As I said already, I think that also some
of the processes that we have just aren't

00:24:06.741 --> 00:24:09.051
setting organisations up to succeed.

00:24:09.451 --> 00:24:15.081
Boards rely on the information that they
can get through the board pack, and I

00:24:15.081 --> 00:24:18.631
guess engagement with the business and
actually setting better expectations

00:24:18.631 --> 00:24:20.461
around that, I think is really important.

00:24:20.831 --> 00:24:22.571
But we need to be setting
them up to do that.

00:24:22.571 --> 00:24:25.051
We need to be setting them
up to succeed and not kind of

00:24:25.051 --> 00:24:26.821
creating barriers for themselves.

00:24:27.461 --> 00:24:31.271
There is an expectation now that
actually perhaps board members

00:24:31.301 --> 00:24:33.281
aren't always the finished article.

00:24:33.691 --> 00:24:36.871
It used to be, as I said, that people
would only really get onto boards at

00:24:36.871 --> 00:24:39.451
the end of their career, and you expect
somebody at the end of their career

00:24:39.451 --> 00:24:42.781
to have kind of reached the pinnacle
or be the person they're going to be.

00:24:43.321 --> 00:24:45.691
But we have younger board members.

00:24:45.691 --> 00:24:47.731
We have board members
earlier on in their career.

00:24:48.001 --> 00:24:51.031
Perhaps they're coming from different
sectors, they're adding different aspects.

00:24:51.031 --> 00:24:55.420
They're coming from different expertise
areas and so I think there's also,

00:24:55.420 --> 00:24:58.340
we need to kind of all be comfortable
that actually boards or board

00:24:58.340 --> 00:25:03.060
members will need different kinds of
upskilling, different kinds of skills.

00:25:03.160 --> 00:25:07.216
They will need to grow and understand
more expertise and we can't just

00:25:07.216 --> 00:25:10.636
fill every gap that we need in a
boardroom with, you know, recruiting

00:25:10.636 --> 00:25:11.836
somebody with a different skill.

00:25:12.226 --> 00:25:16.606
So perhaps it's not fair to say that
board performance isn't improving.

00:25:16.606 --> 00:25:19.346
I think board performance in terms
of what they're delivering for their

00:25:19.346 --> 00:25:21.896
organisations continues to rise.

00:25:22.136 --> 00:25:25.316
It's just that what organisations
need continues to rise faster.

00:25:25.861 --> 00:25:26.951
Ralph Grayson: Yeah, I
think that's a good answer.

00:25:27.291 --> 00:25:33.311
Heidrick & Struggles has done some
great work recently around turnover of

00:25:33.401 --> 00:25:38.268
CEOs and starting to ask some really
smart questions about the breakdown

00:25:38.268 --> 00:25:43.718
of trust between the C-suite and the
board and I think trust is a word that's

00:25:44.318 --> 00:25:46.963
becoming a critical factor for boards.

00:25:47.303 --> 00:25:50.723
The Edelman Trust Barometer, which
some people might be familiar with,

00:25:51.203 --> 00:25:54.593
has reported an accelerating erosion
of trust in business leaders.

00:25:54.693 --> 00:26:00.663
A record number of respondents believing
businesses purposefully mislead people.

00:26:00.963 --> 00:26:05.253
Patrick Dunne again, referencing one of
our earlier guests, has posted a great

00:26:05.253 --> 00:26:09.903
article this week on LinkedIn following up
on this and stating that we've now moved

00:26:09.963 --> 00:26:12.633
from a trust deficit to a trust default.

00:26:13.053 --> 00:26:14.493
Just hold that thought for a moment.

00:26:15.063 --> 00:26:20.373
So your own work references the
PwC Survey, which found only 30% of

00:26:20.373 --> 00:26:25.713
C-suite executives rate their board
as good or excellent, and 49% want

00:26:25.713 --> 00:26:27.813
at least one of their NEDs removed.

00:26:28.493 --> 00:26:30.023
Are we really in that much of a mess?

00:26:30.791 --> 00:26:34.061
Scarlett Brown: Again, I think it could be
easy to get depressed by the statistics,

00:26:34.061 --> 00:26:37.271
and I also don't want to get too bogged
down in it because again, I don't want to

00:26:37.271 --> 00:26:39.041
put anybody off becoming a board director.

00:26:39.101 --> 00:26:41.021
It's one of the coolest jobs in the world.

00:26:41.301 --> 00:26:44.491
My friends don't believe me when
I say that, but it really is and

00:26:44.491 --> 00:26:45.811
we need lots of people doing it.

00:26:45.811 --> 00:26:49.861
So, I would hate to set up to
only pull on the negative sides.

00:26:50.501 --> 00:26:53.611
But I think this piece around
trust is super, super interesting.

00:26:53.895 --> 00:26:56.395
As you mentioned that the piece
that Heidricks have talked about,

00:26:56.395 --> 00:26:59.275
and actually there's been really
interesting academic research about

00:26:59.575 --> 00:27:02.605
improving CEO and board relationships.

00:27:02.685 --> 00:27:06.181
One of the things that we advise a
lot is around seeing the board meeting

00:27:06.361 --> 00:27:09.631
the relationship between executives
and non-executives as a dialogue.

00:27:10.041 --> 00:27:14.001
We encourage all board information to
be written in question answer format.

00:27:14.091 --> 00:27:17.906
We talk a lot about how you should
be spending the board meeting time

00:27:19.026 --> 00:27:24.906
discussing, debating, you should be saving
that meeting space for a conversation that

00:27:24.906 --> 00:27:27.366
couldn't happen outside the boardroom.

00:27:27.366 --> 00:27:29.196
And we need to be seeing
that as a dialogue.

00:27:29.246 --> 00:27:33.191
Whereas I think when you see
boards going really wrong.

00:27:33.611 --> 00:27:38.651
What you have is this kind of checks
and balances or people feeling like they

00:27:38.651 --> 00:27:42.341
need to impress the board and then the
board approving what they do and that's

00:27:42.341 --> 00:27:43.871
where it starts to get really toxic.

00:27:43.871 --> 00:27:47.171
So, you know, one of the things that we
talk about a lot is improving dialogue.

00:27:47.613 --> 00:27:51.723
I think another thing, we interviewed a
really brilliant chair recently, called

00:27:51.783 --> 00:27:56.480
Alison Platt, and we got her interview up
on our website and she said some amazing

00:27:56.480 --> 00:28:01.621
things about trust and about the role that
she as a chair plays and as a non-exec.

00:28:02.061 --> 00:28:04.166
A couple of really great
tidbits I took from her.

00:28:04.166 --> 00:28:07.964
So one is that she really emphasises
the need for board members

00:28:07.964 --> 00:28:09.604
to visit their organisations.

00:28:10.153 --> 00:28:13.309
So she works with a large
financial services organisation.

00:28:13.329 --> 00:28:17.679
She spends a day, a quarter, in
the call center listening to calls,

00:28:17.679 --> 00:28:20.359
talking to people who work in the
call centers, people who are on the

00:28:20.359 --> 00:28:23.689
frontline with customers and she
does that as a matter of course.

00:28:24.159 --> 00:28:26.666
And she says this brilliant
thing about how as a non-exec you

00:28:26.666 --> 00:28:30.116
need to go regularly to avoid it
being a Charles and Diana visit.

00:28:30.361 --> 00:28:34.141
And I think that was really good,
that like we need to break down this

00:28:34.141 --> 00:28:38.341
assumption that the board are here and
everybody has to put out flowers and

00:28:38.341 --> 00:28:42.331
put on their best frock, and I think,
you know, as a board member breaking

00:28:42.331 --> 00:28:45.961
down that barrier and going and just
sitting in the organisation and building

00:28:45.961 --> 00:28:50.011
relationships with people even within
your own employee base, but you know,

00:28:50.011 --> 00:28:53.711
employees, customers and seeing your
stakeholders as being people you should

00:28:53.711 --> 00:28:57.131
engage with, I think just makes a massive
difference for building that trust.

00:28:57.471 --> 00:28:59.631
Because you're all working towards
the same goal, right, which

00:28:59.631 --> 00:29:01.161
is the organisation's success.

00:29:01.471 --> 00:29:04.736
but actually you need to see each other
as human, and I don't think we spend

00:29:04.736 --> 00:29:07.196
enough time seeing board members as human.

00:29:08.286 --> 00:29:10.656
Ralph Grayson: Sadly we probably
don't have time to get too much into

00:29:10.656 --> 00:29:14.316
this, but some of the best chairs
that, that I meet talk about how

00:29:14.616 --> 00:29:20.016
most of the best boards add most of
their value outside of the boardroom.

00:29:20.181 --> 00:29:20.781
Scarlett Brown: A hundred percent.

00:29:21.726 --> 00:29:26.469
Ralph Grayson: Then conversely, it
exacerbates that problem of noses in,

00:29:26.469 --> 00:29:31.799
fingers out, in terms of the board being
perceived sometimes to be overly meddling.

00:29:32.449 --> 00:29:37.514
I think the pros and cons of being
a NED are more under the microscope

00:29:37.514 --> 00:29:41.954
perhaps, and they have been for a long
time, reputational risk, compensation,

00:29:42.324 --> 00:29:44.004
a whole number of variables.

00:29:44.004 --> 00:29:48.454
But one of those is just the,
oh my god, 200 pages of a board

00:29:48.474 --> 00:29:50.244
pack on a Sunday afternoon.

00:29:50.714 --> 00:29:52.964
Is it really worth destroying that?

00:29:52.964 --> 00:29:56.271
And by the time I've read
it, what value can I add?

00:29:56.271 --> 00:29:58.961
So you've touched on some of
those themes, but I'd just love

00:29:58.961 --> 00:30:00.161
a bit more perspective on that.

00:30:00.561 --> 00:30:01.371
Scarlett Brown: Yeah, definitely.

00:30:01.521 --> 00:30:04.611
Whenever I tell anybody what my business
does and I think about when I, you

00:30:04.611 --> 00:30:07.401
know, tried to explain it to my mom
and she sort of looked at me with this

00:30:07.401 --> 00:30:10.491
incredibly blank expression, like she
had no idea what I was talking about.

00:30:10.731 --> 00:30:13.496
And if you say, say it to anybody
who has worked with a board.

00:30:14.006 --> 00:30:15.356
They know instantly.

00:30:15.416 --> 00:30:19.046
They know that feeling that, you know,
getting 600 pages on a Sunday afternoon.

00:30:19.416 --> 00:30:22.156
You know, my mom goes, how can the
lengths of board packs be a problem

00:30:22.156 --> 00:30:24.646
big enough to run 150 person company?

00:30:24.706 --> 00:30:26.056
I'm like, let me tell you something.

00:30:26.456 --> 00:30:29.573
So I mean, I could talk for hours,
Ralph, about how we improve board

00:30:29.573 --> 00:30:32.213
information and there's loads and
loads and loads of tips and tricks

00:30:32.213 --> 00:30:33.443
that we've been using over the years.

00:30:33.443 --> 00:30:37.073
We have a very structured methodology
that we use which encompasses a whole

00:30:37.073 --> 00:30:40.373
bunch of stuff, including question
driven insight, which I've talked about.

00:30:40.606 --> 00:30:44.386
So I won't try and sort of pick out too
many, but I suppose one of the things

00:30:44.386 --> 00:30:47.296
that I wanted to kind of flag that I
think is really interesting in this

00:30:47.296 --> 00:30:53.476
area is that actually the skills that
we teach leaders and organisations about

00:30:53.476 --> 00:30:56.266
how to write well for the boardroom,
cause that's where we always start.

00:30:56.266 --> 00:31:00.076
We don't start necessarily with
solving the board pack when it exists.

00:31:00.076 --> 00:31:02.216
We solve it at the process it's produced.

00:31:03.141 --> 00:31:06.281
Some of the things that we teach
around that and our structured

00:31:06.281 --> 00:31:09.941
approach to that is actually the
basis of what we really see is

00:31:09.941 --> 00:31:11.981
around an effective writing culture.

00:31:12.191 --> 00:31:16.031
And that's something that actually drives
value in the organisation, not just

00:31:16.031 --> 00:31:17.471
for the production of the board pack.

00:31:17.894 --> 00:31:19.484
There's some really cool examples of this.

00:31:19.484 --> 00:31:23.141
I wish I had more public examples than
just Amazon, because they're the most

00:31:23.141 --> 00:31:24.911
well known organisation that does this.

00:31:25.661 --> 00:31:28.944
But things like set an expectation
that every meeting should have a

00:31:28.944 --> 00:31:33.144
structure, an agenda, and a memo
that is sent before that meeting.

00:31:33.534 --> 00:31:36.174
So you shouldn't have a meeting
that isn't sent with information

00:31:36.174 --> 00:31:40.404
beforehand and an expectation that
people should engage with the content

00:31:40.404 --> 00:31:42.384
of a meeting before they come into it.

00:31:42.481 --> 00:31:48.121
One of the most amasing things that we see
in our work is that if you are asked to

00:31:48.121 --> 00:31:53.851
sit down and articulate on just one page
what you want to get out of this meeting,

00:31:53.971 --> 00:31:55.651
this is the thing that we need to discuss.

00:31:55.651 --> 00:31:57.481
This is the proposal I've got.

00:31:57.481 --> 00:31:59.491
This is the challenge we need to solve.

00:31:59.701 --> 00:32:00.931
This is what we know about it.

00:32:00.931 --> 00:32:02.581
This is what I think we
should do as a result.

00:32:03.091 --> 00:32:05.671
And then everybody in the room reads
that same piece of information and

00:32:05.671 --> 00:32:07.291
you are all then on the same page.

00:32:07.621 --> 00:32:11.611
The quality of discussion you have with
the next 40 minutes of your meeting

00:32:11.671 --> 00:32:15.706
is astronomically better and it's
something that we advise almost anybody

00:32:15.706 --> 00:32:17.416
at any level to think about doing.

00:32:17.416 --> 00:32:20.876
So we have some cool stuff on our
website about this and in our book,

00:32:20.876 --> 00:32:23.186
Collective Intelligence, I'll do
a little plug for that as well.

00:32:23.546 --> 00:32:27.346
But we realised when we were working with
boards that we would speak to a chief

00:32:27.346 --> 00:32:30.196
exec and they would say, God, I'm going
to get everybody in my business to do this

00:32:30.556 --> 00:32:34.156
and actually a lot of the things that we
can learn from how we communicate with

00:32:34.156 --> 00:32:38.026
each other, how we make meetings more
effective, how we drive better leadership

00:32:38.026 --> 00:32:40.071
work all the way through the organisation.

00:32:40.481 --> 00:32:43.151
So I suppose to answer your question
about how to improve board packs, I

00:32:43.151 --> 00:32:46.871
would also say it's not just about board
packs, it's about the way that we run

00:32:46.871 --> 00:32:52.091
organisations and making people wade
through mountains of information and

00:32:52.091 --> 00:32:55.871
then have meetings that aren't based on
the things that matter, is not how we

00:32:55.871 --> 00:32:57.821
succeed in business in the modern era.

00:32:57.937 --> 00:32:59.047
We have to solve that problem.

00:33:00.572 --> 00:33:04.142
Ralph Grayson: And that segues
brilliantly, I think, into

00:33:04.712 --> 00:33:08.543
diversity and composition of boards.

00:33:08.543 --> 00:33:12.512
Less from a skillset, but more back to
Patrick Dunne and his five generations.

00:33:13.149 --> 00:33:17.139
I think you and I are aligned in we
need more younger people on boards.

00:33:17.379 --> 00:33:22.529
We need to encourage people to volunteer
and see it as a positive thing to do.

00:33:22.769 --> 00:33:26.429
So how should our younger listeners
think how to position themselves and

00:33:26.429 --> 00:33:30.169
what's the right blend of experience
and enthusiasm in that respect?

00:33:30.579 --> 00:33:31.659
Scarlett Brown: It's a great question.

00:33:32.069 --> 00:33:34.522
I guess as I've already
said, I'm a board member.

00:33:34.522 --> 00:33:37.612
I've been board members a
couple of organisations myself.

00:33:37.792 --> 00:33:40.592
I just think it's the coolest job in
the world and I wish more people did

00:33:40.592 --> 00:33:42.762
it, and I wish people did it earlier.

00:33:42.862 --> 00:33:46.792
There's so many charities and
organisations out there that,

00:33:47.131 --> 00:33:50.461
are crying out for people to
be brilliant board members.

00:33:50.521 --> 00:33:53.131
So, you know, step one is always do it.

00:33:53.251 --> 00:33:55.541
Really, really do it because
it's a really cool thing to do.

00:33:56.171 --> 00:33:58.901
One of the things that I've really
observed actually over the last few

00:33:58.901 --> 00:34:03.491
years is this kind of changing need of
different kinds of expertise and if you'd

00:34:03.491 --> 00:34:07.661
asked me this question five years ago, I
would've said be really, really clear on

00:34:07.661 --> 00:34:11.561
the one area that you are an expert in
and make sure that is front and center.

00:34:11.561 --> 00:34:16.451
Whether that be you come from a finance
background or you are a marketing

00:34:16.451 --> 00:34:18.379
expert or you're an AI expert.

00:34:18.379 --> 00:34:20.419
I'd love your thoughts on this
as well, Ralph, but we are

00:34:20.419 --> 00:34:22.219
seeing certainly that changing.

00:34:22.489 --> 00:34:25.026
That really board members need to
think about themselves as being

00:34:25.026 --> 00:34:27.156
quite T shape in their expertise.

00:34:27.156 --> 00:34:31.566
So yes, you will have an area that you
know more about than other things that

00:34:31.566 --> 00:34:35.226
actually, that breadth across the top
the kinds of experience and expertise

00:34:35.226 --> 00:34:37.595
that you need the T is getting wider.

00:34:37.655 --> 00:34:42.500
So the things you need to have coverage
over is, you know, getting more and more.

00:34:42.500 --> 00:34:46.070
So I think thinking about like
mapping out what your T shape is,

00:34:46.120 --> 00:34:48.910
what is the the dropdown, what is
the things that you know about?

00:34:48.910 --> 00:34:50.980
And then making sure that
the things across the top of

00:34:50.980 --> 00:34:52.510
that T you really are across.

00:34:52.510 --> 00:34:56.260
So of course, being able to read
a P&L, being able to understand

00:34:56.260 --> 00:34:57.850
the finances super important.

00:34:58.270 --> 00:35:01.600
But understanding the market, that
the organisations that you are

00:35:01.600 --> 00:35:05.200
interested in joining are operating
in is probably the number one thing.

00:35:05.480 --> 00:35:09.320
It's that horizon scan what's coming down
the track, and I think if you can get that

00:35:09.320 --> 00:35:10.970
across, that's super, super important.

00:35:11.615 --> 00:35:13.325
Ralph Grayson: There's a ton of
work being done on the idea of

00:35:13.375 --> 00:35:16.275
the T board and I would encourage
anybody to go and look at that.

00:35:16.575 --> 00:35:19.905
It comes back to, I think,
the essence of that is boards

00:35:19.905 --> 00:35:21.315
aren't so one size fits all.

00:35:21.345 --> 00:35:21.835
Scarlett Brown: Exactly.

00:35:22.265 --> 00:35:22.555
Yeah,

00:35:22.926 --> 00:35:25.326
Ralph Grayson: How do you think
a perspective NED should think

00:35:25.326 --> 00:35:26.616
about their fit on the board?

00:35:26.616 --> 00:35:28.536
That's a very unscientific question.

00:35:29.736 --> 00:35:30.576
Scarlett Brown: Yeah, definitely.

00:35:30.596 --> 00:35:33.540
I get it asked a lot because
my PhD research was about how

00:35:33.545 --> 00:35:35.790
non-execs try and get roles.

00:35:35.790 --> 00:35:38.650
So, in theory, it should be something
that I know a huge amount about,

00:35:38.650 --> 00:35:41.510
and again, there's other people who
have better advice than me on this.

00:35:41.510 --> 00:35:45.163
But I got asked recently by a colleague
who was thinking about trying to

00:35:45.223 --> 00:35:49.123
kind of think about non-exec roles or
charity trustee roles, and actually

00:35:49.873 --> 00:35:53.503
knowing where you want to go, I
think is a really, really big step.

00:35:53.563 --> 00:35:55.903
I think when I first started thinking
about it, I was like, oh, I could

00:35:55.903 --> 00:35:57.343
add value in loads of places.

00:35:57.613 --> 00:36:00.073
And then I thought, well, what
are the things that I really,

00:36:00.193 --> 00:36:01.963
I care passionately about?

00:36:02.293 --> 00:36:05.949
What are the things that I know lots
about and where might that lead me?

00:36:06.049 --> 00:36:09.139
That led to one of my first non
exec roles which was working for the

00:36:09.259 --> 00:36:12.819
British Association of Counseling
and Psychotherapy and I was part

00:36:12.819 --> 00:36:14.019
of their research committee there.

00:36:14.439 --> 00:36:17.919
And that was this perfect combination
for me of an organisation doing things

00:36:17.919 --> 00:36:22.059
that I really, really cared about
and them needing research expertise,

00:36:22.059 --> 00:36:23.619
which is something I know a lot about.

00:36:23.619 --> 00:36:27.099
So I think there's something about like
really understanding what are the areas

00:36:27.099 --> 00:36:30.309
that you play well in, whether it's
public sector or charity or private

00:36:30.309 --> 00:36:34.059
organisations, and then trying to work
at actually what are the things that

00:36:34.059 --> 00:36:37.389
they are really struggling for, and
then actually putting yourself forward.

00:36:37.419 --> 00:36:42.549
I think lots of, particularly in
the not-for-profit space, lots of

00:36:42.549 --> 00:36:47.714
organisations there don't have time to
look up and think about the kind of people

00:36:47.714 --> 00:36:51.534
that they would like to be working with
and actually approaching organisations

00:36:51.554 --> 00:36:52.994
and saying, I'd love to help.

00:36:53.264 --> 00:36:54.044
How can I help?

00:36:54.044 --> 00:36:55.724
Do you need these kind of experiences?

00:36:55.724 --> 00:36:58.694
I think is, again, I would
encourage anybody to go for it.

00:36:59.054 --> 00:37:04.384
Ralph Grayson: Try before you buy, I
think is an interesting concept there, and

00:37:04.384 --> 00:37:08.954
how people, a lot of people are put off
making that first board application and I

00:37:08.954 --> 00:37:10.724
can't be one because I've never been one.

00:37:10.844 --> 00:37:14.954
The role of advisory boards,
Ollie Cummings at Nurole talks

00:37:14.954 --> 00:37:16.514
a lot about popup boards.

00:37:16.584 --> 00:37:20.124
Groups of experts that can come together
for a finite period to, to address

00:37:20.124 --> 00:37:22.584
a particular issue in the company,
which I think is a brilliant idea.

00:37:23.046 --> 00:37:26.998
Any general thoughts around the
informality perhaps, of learning

00:37:26.998 --> 00:37:28.258
that board experience and fit?

00:37:28.618 --> 00:37:29.398
Scarlett Brown: Yeah, definitely.

00:37:29.435 --> 00:37:32.905
From a candidate perspective, from
an individual perspective, those kind

00:37:32.905 --> 00:37:34.165
of opportunities can be really good.

00:37:34.915 --> 00:37:38.185
I think when I used to work with an
organisation called Dynamic Boards.

00:37:38.185 --> 00:37:42.535
We would advise organisations a lot
about how you can go about getting

00:37:42.625 --> 00:37:44.835
younger non-execs onto your board.

00:37:45.345 --> 00:37:48.825
And we used to feel very strongly that
if you use kind of shadow boards or

00:37:48.825 --> 00:37:52.815
advisory boards as a way of getting
the kind of young person or the

00:37:52.815 --> 00:37:57.675
inexperienced NED voice, they will
always be relegated to that level.

00:37:57.745 --> 00:38:03.010
If I was advising an organisation, I
would say be braver, and actually there's

00:38:03.010 --> 00:38:07.180
expertise out there that you are not
going to find in an experienced non-exec

00:38:07.240 --> 00:38:10.150
and be brave in appointing a non-exec.

00:38:10.220 --> 00:38:13.460
If you are recruiting and you
need somebody with experience in

00:38:13.460 --> 00:38:16.970
a certain area, recruit for two
roles, and one of them doesn't

00:38:16.970 --> 00:38:18.290
need to have previous experience.

00:38:18.290 --> 00:38:21.170
So I think I would always push
organisations to be braver

00:38:21.650 --> 00:38:22.940
when appointing non-execs.

00:38:23.210 --> 00:38:27.970
At the same time, I think there are
some really cool creative ways that

00:38:27.970 --> 00:38:31.600
boards need to get better at about
engaging with wider stakeholders.

00:38:31.630 --> 00:38:36.850
So popup boards within organisations,
popup boards of external advisors

00:38:36.850 --> 00:38:38.260
for particular challenges.

00:38:38.630 --> 00:38:43.100
It's a really cool, I have to dig it
out, it's a really cool workshop exercise

00:38:43.160 --> 00:38:45.795
called Boardroom 2030, which does this.

00:38:45.795 --> 00:38:50.415
Which kind of encourages people to sit in
the role of a boardroom, and I love that.

00:38:50.415 --> 00:38:55.335
That's really great, like if you can get
people in your business to run a kind of

00:38:55.335 --> 00:38:59.385
board simulation of what they would do,
like some of that stuff is really cool.

00:38:59.595 --> 00:39:02.985
But for me it's about boards being
able to get that viewpoint and

00:39:03.015 --> 00:39:06.475
not about solving the problem of
getting people their first NED role.

00:39:07.750 --> 00:39:12.160
Ralph Grayson: Yeah, I look, this is an
entire new podcast, reverse mentoring.

00:39:12.160 --> 00:39:16.210
Again Dunne in his generation
books, talks about the Gucci board.

00:39:16.240 --> 00:39:18.566
Where they've put a young first
generation board together.

00:39:18.566 --> 00:39:21.266
I can't remember quite what the
expression is, but all of these things

00:39:21.266 --> 00:39:25.201
are such, such great initiatives
to start thinking how we can get

00:39:25.201 --> 00:39:27.341
diversity of thought in the boardroom.

00:39:27.461 --> 00:39:28.821
So look, time is running on.

00:39:29.131 --> 00:39:30.431
You and I could keep talking forever.

00:39:30.821 --> 00:39:39.251
What practical steps does my perspective
aspiring new NED take from this podcast?

00:39:39.261 --> 00:39:43.971
What should they be thinking about
and doing now to best progress

00:39:43.971 --> 00:39:44.936
their path to the boardroom?

00:39:46.016 --> 00:39:46.916
Scarlett Brown: Great question.

00:39:46.976 --> 00:39:50.516
So some of the things I've already said,
know where you add value, know what you

00:39:50.516 --> 00:39:55.051
know better than other people, and find
ways of thinking about what you offer in

00:39:55.051 --> 00:39:58.201
terms of your skills, experiences, and
perspectives and getting that across.

00:39:58.641 --> 00:40:00.171
Go on the websites and look.

00:40:00.301 --> 00:40:03.211
There's some great places that
you can find access to roles.

00:40:03.271 --> 00:40:06.131
Again, I'll plug for Dynamic
Boards because I know them well

00:40:06.191 --> 00:40:09.168
when you're looking for potential
roles and other advertising

00:40:09.228 --> 00:40:10.968
websites are available as well.

00:40:11.318 --> 00:40:14.653
And again, I think particularly
if you're looking for roles in

00:40:14.703 --> 00:40:18.313
sectors that don't advertise, or
perhaps in smaller organisations

00:40:18.993 --> 00:40:22.293
getting to know organisations
that you might want to work with.

00:40:22.293 --> 00:40:25.823
So again, volunteer for
them and get to know them.

00:40:25.873 --> 00:40:28.033
They need people who understand
their businesses, understand their

00:40:28.033 --> 00:40:31.253
organisations, and that can be
particularly in the charity space.

00:40:31.283 --> 00:40:34.793
Really, really important and of
course, get to know the search firms.

00:40:34.883 --> 00:40:36.143
Always a good starting point as well.

00:40:36.415 --> 00:40:39.235
And of course I would say this,
but understand how boards work.

00:40:39.295 --> 00:40:40.735
There's loads of cool stuff out there.

00:40:40.785 --> 00:40:45.465
So really knowing what the board does,
how the board can add value, and that

00:40:45.465 --> 00:40:48.045
strategic horizon scanning piece.

00:40:48.495 --> 00:40:50.861
What's the thing that the
organisation you want to work with

00:40:50.861 --> 00:40:54.534
hasn't thought of yet, and how do
you help them be ready for that?

00:40:55.189 --> 00:40:56.844
Ralph Grayson: So number
one, Am I reading this now?

00:40:57.054 --> 00:41:01.704
Plug for Scarlett, her newsletter
comes out every Monday morning.

00:41:01.704 --> 00:41:06.114
It's brilliant synopsis of stuff
that's been written the week before and

00:41:06.114 --> 00:41:07.734
commented around corporate governance.

00:41:07.794 --> 00:41:13.154
It is along with, Ollie and Nuroles
podcast, which is my Saturday morning,

00:41:13.154 --> 00:41:17.924
walk the dog must do Scarlett's
synopsis on a Monday morning, is great.

00:41:18.254 --> 00:41:20.624
So what else should a
listener take from this?

00:41:20.684 --> 00:41:22.094
How do they follow up with you?

00:41:22.164 --> 00:41:24.294
How can they engage maybe
with Board Intelligence?

00:41:24.519 --> 00:41:24.969
Scarlett Brown: Absolutely.

00:41:24.999 --> 00:41:28.496
In all the usual places on our
website, on LinkedIn, and please

00:41:28.496 --> 00:41:30.116
do, yeah, sign up to the newsletter.

00:41:30.156 --> 00:41:33.306
A lot of what I've referenced today has
come up in the newsletter at some point.

00:41:33.740 --> 00:41:37.430
It's my job to keep across the
latest research, the latest insights,

00:41:37.460 --> 00:41:39.980
and yeah, what people are saying
about the boards, what's going on.

00:41:39.980 --> 00:41:44.305
So please do find me there, and there's
loads of resources we have as well.

00:41:44.305 --> 00:41:47.485
Everything I've mentioned today
is very much in the public domain.

00:41:47.485 --> 00:41:50.069
We have loads of guides, workbooks
and things like that, that are

00:41:50.069 --> 00:41:52.679
all designed to try and help you
tackle some of these challenges

00:41:52.783 --> 00:41:54.142
and anything else, get in touch.

00:41:54.357 --> 00:41:56.434
Ralph Grayson: I've got a long
list of questions I'd love to keep

00:41:56.434 --> 00:41:58.728
asking, but we're going to have
to come back to this another time.

00:41:58.728 --> 00:42:00.588
We have more than run out of time.

00:42:00.888 --> 00:42:02.598
So Scarlett, thank you so much.

00:42:02.598 --> 00:42:04.098
I have so enjoyed this.

00:42:04.493 --> 00:42:05.013
Scarlett Brown: Absolute pleasure.

00:42:05.013 --> 00:42:06.018
Thank you so much for having me.

00:42:06.215 --> 00:42:09.485
Ralph Grayson: I hope that you've enjoyed
listening to this podcast and have found

00:42:09.485 --> 00:42:13.745
it helpful when thinking about how to
approach your own path to the boardroom.

00:42:14.635 --> 00:42:17.775
If you would like to push this a
little bit further, Sainty Hird

00:42:17.795 --> 00:42:22.585
runs a bespoke one to one programme
designed specifically to this end.

00:42:22.920 --> 00:42:27.604
For more information, please visit
our website, saintyhird.com, follow

00:42:27.604 --> 00:42:33.459
us on LinkedIn, and subscribe to the
Boardroom Path to receive new episodes.

00:42:33.805 --> 00:42:34.755
Thank you for listening.