WEBVTT

00:00.000 --> 00:19.280
Hey everyone, it's Mikki here, you're listening to Mikkipedia and this week on the podcast I speak to Dr. Tony Boutagy about cutting through noise in exercise science, particularly when it comes to training women and really just the rise of the unqualified coach.

00:19.280 --> 00:38.400
Tony talks about the growing trend towards sex-specific training recommendations, exploring what the research actually tells us about differences in muscle fibre types, fat oxidation, strength adaptations and responses to interval training, and why these differences don't necessarily warrant different training programmes.

00:38.680 --> 00:49.260
We also discuss what matters for women navigating menopause, the importance of resistance training for bone and muscle health, and how little training is actually needed to build and maintain strength.

00:50.160 --> 01:00.380
Tony shares practical recommendations for endurance athletes, considerations for those using GLP-1 medications, and why meeting people where they are is essential for long-term success.

01:01.100 --> 01:12.780
We also tackle the dangers of over-interpreting research, and why evidence-based practice matters more than ever in an increasingly complicated health and fitness landscape.

01:13.180 --> 01:17.760
So, really enjoyed this conversation with Tony, just a frank conversation really.

01:18.100 --> 01:19.260
And, you know, he's got such a...

01:19.280 --> 01:26.900
He's got such a wealth of information in all of these areas that we chatted about, and I really enjoy hearing how he frames it.

01:27.260 --> 01:31.860
So, Tony is a strength coach and an exercise physiologist based in Sydney, Australia.

01:32.600 --> 01:40.740
His undergrad degree was in human movement, and he holds a PhD in exercise and sports science from Charles Darwin University in far north Australia.

01:41.140 --> 01:49.260
So, his coaching career has spanned close to 30 years, and he has written over 70,000 training programmes across a wide range of disciplines.

01:49.280 --> 01:58.880
So, he's got a wide range of populations, including the general public, athletes, Olympians, special populations, and those needing rehabilitation from injuries.

01:59.300 --> 02:13.980
He's also been involved in education since 1999, and he has his own educational programmes, in addition to holding various educational positions at several universities in exercise science, physiotherapy, and personal training.

02:13.980 --> 02:16.980
You can find Tony over on...

02:19.280 --> 02:28.700
And I will pop a link to his website and also his Instagram feed where he shares super practical information for us.

02:29.020 --> 02:29.940
And I'll also...

02:29.940 --> 02:31.880
This isn't Tony's first time on Mikkipedia.

02:32.320 --> 02:38.900
Those long-time listeners will know I've had Tony on a couple of times now, so I'll pop links to those episodes in the show notes as well.

02:39.240 --> 02:47.260
All right, guys, before we crack on into the interview, I would like to remind you that the best way to support Mikkipedia is to hit the subscribe button

02:47.460 --> 02:48.840
wherever you're listening to this.

02:49.020 --> 02:49.260
And leave a comment.

02:49.260 --> 02:50.280
And leave a five-star review.

02:50.860 --> 02:56.280
That increases the visibility of Mikkipedia and it makes literally thousands of other podcasts out there.

02:56.520 --> 03:01.280
So, more people get to hear from experts that I have on the show, like Dr. Tony Boutagy.

03:01.840 --> 03:03.540
All right, guys, enjoy this conversation.

03:08.920 --> 03:10.300
Chat type thing.

03:10.420 --> 03:13.700
I love your music of your podcast.

03:13.800 --> 03:14.640
I've always loved it.

03:15.060 --> 03:15.360
Have you?

03:15.460 --> 03:17.020
Do you know, you could have used it yourself.

03:17.020 --> 03:18.300
I think that we just...

03:18.300 --> 03:18.760
I think it's...

03:18.760 --> 03:19.000
You can...

03:19.000 --> 03:25.860
Not that you need it because you've obviously got your own music, but I like it too, thankfully, because it's been close to six years at this point.

03:26.200 --> 03:27.100
Oh, has it?

03:27.100 --> 03:27.260
It's great.

03:27.780 --> 03:28.760
I think it has.

03:29.040 --> 03:29.960
Amazing, isn't it?

03:30.520 --> 03:31.160
Time flies.

03:31.680 --> 03:32.080
It is.

03:32.140 --> 03:32.620
It does.

03:32.900 --> 03:35.320
Now, Tony, firstly, so nice to see your face.

03:35.520 --> 03:39.060
It's been possibly just over a year since...

03:39.060 --> 03:41.600
Or maybe even more since you were last on Mikkipedia.

03:42.400 --> 03:42.980
Can't remember.

03:43.200 --> 03:45.640
I have a feeling it's definitely over a year.

03:46.220 --> 03:47.440
Time flies, right?

03:47.680 --> 03:47.880
Right.

03:47.880 --> 03:48.480
That's crazy.

03:49.000 --> 03:49.240
Right.

03:49.900 --> 03:56.500
I was just in a WhatsApp chat with a couple of friends of mine who are in adjacent industries to ours.

03:56.500 --> 04:02.480
And we were talking about just the rise of the coach out there.

04:02.780 --> 04:15.640
And not necessarily exercise coach or even nutrition coach, but I'm thinking cortisol coach, menopause coach, ADHD coach.

04:15.940 --> 04:17.800
I think that's also a thing.

04:17.800 --> 04:18.800
And this...

04:19.000 --> 04:20.740
I don't know, mental health coach.

04:20.860 --> 04:21.320
I don't know.

04:21.780 --> 04:25.760
And it's like, are people in this space?

04:25.820 --> 04:32.480
It feels like these people have almost this overconfidence in knowledge, but very little

04:32.480 --> 04:34.000
sort of behind a certification.

04:34.720 --> 04:38.460
Because, you know, people can get certifications from everywhere at this point.

04:39.100 --> 04:41.800
I think the idea of a coach is great.

04:41.800 --> 04:48.300
If you have expertise in a subject and combined with a lot of experience,

04:48.300 --> 04:56.400
you can help other people navigate the challenges of menopause, of growing older, of mindset.

04:57.500 --> 04:58.720
But you're right.

04:58.800 --> 05:00.460
The issue is not in the coach.

05:00.700 --> 05:03.320
It is in, well, I like this.

05:03.600 --> 05:04.980
So I went through it.

05:05.720 --> 05:06.900
This worked for me.

05:07.460 --> 05:09.480
And I'm now going to be a coach.

05:09.660 --> 05:17.920
And the issue with this, because social media is the world, that if you've got a big following or you sound compelling,

05:18.300 --> 05:22.180
people will think that you must know what you're talking about when in actual fact,

05:22.180 --> 05:28.520
you might not have the necessary training to really understand the complexities of what somebody is going through.

05:29.200 --> 05:30.880
A hundred percent agree.

05:31.020 --> 05:39.240
And I feel like if people see that someone is certified in a certain area and they don't understand,

05:39.820 --> 05:43.160
I guess, what the certification process might necessarily look like,

05:43.420 --> 05:48.280
then this person is afforded this level of expertise that they may not have.

05:48.300 --> 05:51.160
Like, I know so many people in this space.

05:51.700 --> 05:54.160
And it's not that I don't like these people.

05:54.240 --> 05:56.320
It's not a character assassination on them.

05:56.400 --> 06:03.660
But there's just nothing behind this really base level of knowledge that is all well and good if things are going well.

06:04.160 --> 06:11.760
But if there is something that goes wrong, that's when the rubber should really hit the road and things can fall apart.

06:12.400 --> 06:14.460
It's consumer protection, isn't it?

06:14.460 --> 06:18.020
This is not character assassination, as you said.

06:18.300 --> 06:26.240
Well, how does the public know whether this person is really skilled to walk me through the complexities of whatever I'm facing?

06:26.540 --> 06:30.140
Now, sometimes the complexities is not terribly difficult.

06:31.020 --> 06:37.300
Personal training for the general public, it's my field, but it's not terribly complex.

06:39.860 --> 06:47.360
Understanding bone fractures, risks of fall, training when you're on 16 different medications,

06:47.360 --> 06:49.260
and their interactions with nutrition.

06:49.400 --> 06:52.360
And you think, well, I've read that this was good for inflammation and aging.

06:52.680 --> 06:53.740
You should take this.

06:53.980 --> 06:56.300
It's like, right, but they're already on a blood thinner.

06:56.480 --> 06:59.100
And that's where the consumer has to be protected.

06:59.680 --> 07:01.060
Yeah, 100%.

07:01.060 --> 07:06.460
And I've got a lot of thoughts in my mind, actually, well before I come to the set of questions that I sort of sent you through.

07:07.400 --> 07:11.600
I was listening to another podcast this morning.

07:12.140 --> 07:15.720
Doctors were just discussing people on GLP-1s.

07:15.720 --> 07:16.640
I mean, it's their specialty.

07:16.640 --> 07:26.700
And then one of their listener questions was someone was getting pushback from friends of theirs because they were taking a GLP-1.

07:27.240 --> 07:30.400
And the pushback was, you're supporting Big Pharma.

07:30.660 --> 07:37.520
Yet the person giving pushback was taking like a peptide bought from a Medispa company.

07:37.700 --> 07:44.760
You know, clearly that's not, you know, because it's some sort of black market peptide, then they're not in support of Big Pharma.

07:44.760 --> 07:46.620
Or be it this person who was.

07:46.640 --> 07:51.920
You know, getting the pushback, they had a BMI of 45 and had PMOS.

07:52.680 --> 08:00.520
So, you know, if there was any, if any time there was a clinical case for a medication that would help support them, surely this would be it.

08:00.600 --> 08:03.300
But isn't it crazy the perceptions that are out there?

08:03.920 --> 08:05.260
We all have blind spots.

08:05.500 --> 08:11.160
And I think we look into a situation like that as outsiders and go, right, there's a blind spot there.

08:11.300 --> 08:12.440
But we all have them.

08:12.540 --> 08:13.620
We've got cognitive biases.

08:13.620 --> 08:15.480
We see the world in one way.

08:15.560 --> 08:16.600
And we forget that other.

08:16.680 --> 08:19.400
People come to it from a different background and perspective.

08:19.960 --> 08:25.360
I think as I get older, the younger, brasher me would have said, are you kidding?

08:25.900 --> 08:32.300
Look at what you're saying as to now, you might consider this.

08:33.460 --> 08:33.700
Yeah.

08:33.700 --> 08:33.800
Yeah.

08:33.960 --> 08:46.600
It's just, I think there's a lot of overwhelm of information, or at least there's just so much information out there that we could all be experts in a particular.

08:46.640 --> 08:49.460
Or feel like we're an expert in some particular area.

08:49.540 --> 08:56.160
And you must get this with your clients too, like who might come to you and they've already diagnosed themselves with something.

08:56.380 --> 09:04.780
And they've decided to take this sort of course of action, which feels very well informed because the information is out there for them to grab.

09:04.940 --> 09:13.020
But in fact, they don't really have a sense of, they just don't have that background knowledge to actually make good decisions around it.

09:13.540 --> 09:14.960
It must be so hard.

09:14.960 --> 09:16.420
I just think when, I don't know.

09:16.420 --> 09:17.280
I don't know anything about cars.

09:17.400 --> 09:20.320
I don't know anything about my tax and accounting.

09:20.820 --> 09:27.820
I just rely on the people doing my car and doing my accounts that they're real experts.

09:28.860 --> 09:35.440
And the same must be of our clients and the public who are bombarded with information.

09:35.560 --> 09:42.740
But the thing is, you don't go to social media and follow an accountant who tells you everything of how to do your accounts.

09:43.440 --> 09:44.740
We just trust them.

09:44.740 --> 09:44.860
Right.

09:44.860 --> 09:44.880
Right.

09:44.880 --> 09:44.900
Right.

09:44.900 --> 09:44.920
Right.

09:44.920 --> 09:44.940
Right.

09:44.940 --> 09:44.960
Right.

09:44.960 --> 09:44.980
Right.

09:44.980 --> 09:45.000
Right.

09:45.000 --> 09:45.020
Right.

09:45.020 --> 09:45.040
Right.

09:45.040 --> 09:45.060
Right.

09:45.060 --> 09:45.080
Right.

09:45.080 --> 09:45.100
Right.

09:45.100 --> 09:45.120
Right.

09:45.120 --> 09:45.140
Right.

09:45.140 --> 09:45.160
Right.

09:45.160 --> 09:45.180
Right.

09:45.180 --> 09:45.280
Right.

09:45.280 --> 09:45.320
Right.

09:45.320 --> 09:45.380
Right.

09:45.380 --> 09:45.400
Right.

09:45.400 --> 09:45.480
Right.

09:45.480 --> 09:45.920
Right.

09:45.920 --> 09:46.400
Right.

09:46.420 --> 09:47.420
Right.

09:47.420 --> 09:48.700
Right.

09:48.700 --> 09:48.720
Right.

09:49.500 --> 09:49.600
Right.

09:49.600 --> 09:49.800
Right.

09:49.800 --> 09:49.820
Right.

09:49.820 --> 09:50.140
Right.

09:50.140 --> 09:50.320
Right.

09:50.320 --> 09:52.280
Right.

09:52.280 --> 09:52.440
Right.

09:52.440 --> 09:52.620
Right.

09:52.780 --> 09:53.260
Right.

09:53.360 --> 09:53.420
Right.

09:53.800 --> 09:53.900
Right.

09:53.900 --> 09:54.040
Right.

09:54.040 --> 09:54.360
Right.

09:54.400 --> 09:54.720
Right.

09:56.880 --> 09:57.240
Right.

09:57.860 --> 09:57.920
Right.

09:58.060 --> 09:58.720
Right.

09:59.740 --> 09:59.880
Right.

10:00.160 --> 10:00.940
Right.

10:12.680 --> 10:12.760
Right.

10:12.760 --> 10:18.240
hopefully today we can provide a framework of evaluating whether something is more likely to

10:18.240 --> 10:25.640
be correct than all the kind of opinions and even slop that's out there? 100%. And I really like

10:25.640 --> 10:31.720
that analogy to the sort of the finance perspective as well, right? Because I don't know anything

10:31.720 --> 10:38.140
about investment, for example. And I immediately just think, well, I've never been trained in it,

10:38.140 --> 10:43.840
so why would I know about it? Yet, of course, everyone eats. So everyone feels like they're

10:43.840 --> 10:48.740
some sort of, they've got that sort of base knowledge. Albeit what I will say is I have

10:48.740 --> 10:53.580
started following a lot of these sort of mum and dad investor type pages on Facebook. Man,

10:53.620 --> 10:57.960
you learn a lot and from podcasts, but I would by no means think that I'm an expert in it.

10:59.180 --> 11:04.820
But yeah, I guess it's what you do with that information in your context. And I think

11:04.820 --> 11:07.880
that's the thing. Yeah. I can remember when I was

11:07.880 --> 11:14.200
I give a lot of leeway to content creators in their 20s because I think, well, we didn't have

11:14.200 --> 11:22.360
this in our 20s. But if I was around in my 20s now, I would be insufferable. And I can remember

11:22.360 --> 11:26.480
talking about something to do with medicine with a friend who is a doctor. And he goes,

11:27.060 --> 11:33.400
Tony, that doesn't happen in Australia. That's a different law. It's like, oh, I learned that

11:33.400 --> 11:37.780
on something I had seen from an American doctor. And those rules,

11:37.880 --> 11:43.180
didn't apply here. I didn't know. I just was young and 20. And I think this is part of the

11:43.180 --> 11:48.960
problem. I'm sure there's great content creators in their 20s. But in another 20 or 30 years of

11:48.960 --> 11:55.960
doing one subject, you're going to realize that world is really big and really complex. And

11:55.960 --> 12:01.020
it's often beyond what we understand when we're in our 20s.

12:01.020 --> 12:07.800
It is interesting, isn't it? With the years of experience and working with people in different,

12:07.880 --> 12:14.160
different contexts and having to consider what we think of as rules or guidelines within that

12:14.160 --> 12:19.220
person's own sort of lived experience, that is where you get that level of understanding and

12:19.220 --> 12:22.920
knowledge. And you can't fake that. You can't just, you can't fast forward that either. That

12:22.920 --> 12:27.060
is actually just time spent doing things. Right. Absolutely.

12:27.540 --> 12:32.800
Yeah. Nice one, Tony. So one last thing before we crack on into the conversation,

12:32.800 --> 12:37.820
had enjoyed a lovely glass of red wine last night. And as,

12:37.880 --> 12:42.920
as Hubster was getting down the wine glasses, I said, Hey, put that wine glass on the scales.

12:42.920 --> 12:51.360
Right. Yeah. And I'm like, I want to see how much your usual pour is compared to what is deemed a

12:51.360 --> 12:58.040
standard pour. And actually, actually, so he normally pours about a hundred mils.

12:58.860 --> 13:06.260
Okay. So he's a light hand. He is a light, I mean, it is, it is, let's, I will be very

13:06.260 --> 13:07.720
transparent. It is multi,

13:07.880 --> 13:14.180
there's multiple pours. Yes, of course. Now more envious, I could not be that you had a tipple last

13:14.180 --> 13:20.600
night. I, I find, and I don't know if your listeners are the same, but the best intervention

13:20.600 --> 13:27.120
I can do for my sleep is to bring eating and drinking as far away from going to bed as possible

13:27.120 --> 13:33.280
because I can't dissipate the heat. I just cannot get rid of it. And I, if I go to bed at, I'm up at

13:33.280 --> 13:37.460
four. So if I go to bed at eight, I know that's, I know I go to bed at eight.

13:37.460 --> 13:38.160
I love it.

13:38.440 --> 13:45.740
But if I eat at six with my friends, then I don't sleep well because I'm just too hot. And if I eat

13:45.740 --> 13:52.860
at four or five and drink then, then I sleep better. So it's just this dissipation of heat.

13:53.420 --> 13:57.120
So, I mean, again, another solid case for day drinking in Tony's example.

13:58.740 --> 14:03.660
I do my best writing. So I, Saturdays, Sundays, it's my PhD days. I'm doing a second PhD and,

14:03.660 --> 14:07.200
uh, and I spent all day in this library.

14:08.000 --> 14:12.060
Just writing. And with a little bit of alcohol, I write a lot better.

14:12.600 --> 14:16.640
I'm sure. I don't, I'm going to say, I don't doubt it. And I shouldn't say that because it

14:16.640 --> 14:21.680
sounds like, well, cause you're so shit. So something's got to be better. This is not what

14:21.680 --> 14:28.700
I mean at all. Um, but okay. So now I'm curious. Well, one, I'm sounds ridiculous. And, um, so

14:28.700 --> 14:33.440
Barry, as you know, does edit the podcast. He'll be going, oh my God, don't even, you should not

14:33.440 --> 14:36.520
have mentioned that because that makes me slightly envious that you're doing a PhD. Like,

14:36.840 --> 14:37.420
oh, I'm sick.

14:37.420 --> 14:40.280
Second PhD, man, I'd love it. What is it on?

14:40.940 --> 14:47.860
It's in a different field. It's in ancient history, which is my second love. And, uh, I, I think one,

14:47.920 --> 14:54.200
I've always wanted to do it, but, but to my aging mother, she has dementia and just seeing that and

14:54.200 --> 14:59.500
its impact on the family. I just want to really push my brain in a different, completely different.

14:59.500 --> 15:06.700
It's not like learning more physiology, which I love. It has to be something quite different and

15:06.700 --> 15:12.000
learning and writing in a different discipline is very challenging.

15:13.760 --> 15:17.180
And that's what I decided to do for the next, however long it takes me.

15:17.180 --> 15:24.240
I mean, that is amazing, Tony. I had no idea. Like I applaud you to go down that path because

15:24.240 --> 15:30.920
as you and I both know, a PhD is, of course you need a level of intellect, but actually you need

15:30.920 --> 15:36.280
that tenacity and that perseverance to really stick at it. When the last thing that you want to be doing

15:36.280 --> 15:43.200
is, is answering one particular question and the series of questions for years on end, like well

15:43.200 --> 15:48.860
done. Right. Thank you. Yeah. Yeah. Well, so to get into what we want to talk about today. So I,

15:48.860 --> 15:53.120
I think I sent you a post. So part of this will of course be about me because I'm

15:53.120 --> 15:59.200
quite selfish in that regard. Why we do podcasts. That's why we do podcasts. Um, and, and sort of

15:59.200 --> 16:05.100
chat a little bit about strength training, um, and running, but of course, you know, you're very

16:05.100 --> 16:06.260
outspoken. Um, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and,

16:06.280 --> 16:11.780
on social media about just like training modalities for, uh, people at different life

16:11.780 --> 16:17.660
stages and, and how different or otherwise that they need to be, um, or not. So, I mean, let's

16:17.660 --> 16:23.440
just cut straight to the chase really Tony and start there. So if we strip away all of the noise

16:23.440 --> 16:30.360
on social media, do men and women actually need to train differently? The short answer is no.

16:30.620 --> 16:35.500
Sex doesn't dictate your sets and your reps and your exercise selection and your training

16:36.280 --> 16:43.620
or anything like that. The individual needs do. If you had two females sitting together in a room

16:43.620 --> 16:48.400
and one was 30 and one was 60 and one had not been training and the other had been training for 30

16:48.400 --> 16:58.620
years, those individual goals and needs and background drive the particulars and not a male

16:58.620 --> 17:03.480
sitting next to them. Who's again, 30 and 60 with a different training experience. It's one's

17:03.480 --> 17:05.900
background. It's one's training goals.

17:06.280 --> 17:16.540
Okay. So there, you know, there are physiological differences obviously between men and women,

17:16.540 --> 17:23.720
but should these not drive training decisions or track? Yeah. Yeah. Training or programming

17:23.720 --> 17:31.180
decisions, I suppose. It's a really great question because the new thought of training

17:31.180 --> 17:35.380
should be sex specific. And, and it's actually even more emotional than that.

17:36.280 --> 17:38.580
Yeah. sex is the third until you're out and things are tomatoing and plastic or something like

17:38.580 --> 17:42.220
that. And no, everyone who's trained male or female has had found things that have worked for them,

17:42.220 --> 17:46.460
things that haven't things that they got injured with those that reached a plateau and they just

17:46.460 --> 17:50.040
couldn't get past it. And the coach would always problem solve. Where have you been? Where do you

17:50.040 --> 17:55.860
want to go? What else is going on in your life? And they take all of that and then put a solution

17:55.860 --> 18:00.880
together. Oh, you've completely missed this and you've been doing too much with that. And maybe

18:00.880 --> 18:05.540
you need to sleep a bit more. On and on in the last several years, an emotional perspective from

18:05.540 --> 18:06.120
your perspective is inherited back into the experience of women and men and there's a lot that is not

18:06.120 --> 18:13.360
has come about, that is the reason why you have plateaued or you didn't get the results you wanted

18:13.360 --> 18:20.480
is because you followed a program that was written by men, based on studies by men, and you as a

18:20.480 --> 18:25.400
female got the leftovers. And you were working against your physiology because females have

18:25.400 --> 18:30.380
different physiology. So there's this really emotional drive. And I think a lot of people

18:30.380 --> 18:36.400
really relate to that going, yeah, I couldn't lose weight. And yes, my injuries occurred. And

18:36.400 --> 18:43.380
no one gave me the solution. And here is the answer. It is because you are following the wrong

18:43.380 --> 18:49.940
program. And when we strip away that and look at the actual question, it's based on sex differences.

18:50.860 --> 18:55.560
Now, there's two things that can't coexist together, of course. You can't know that

18:55.560 --> 19:00.360
there's sex differences and have no studies on women. So those two

19:00.360 --> 19:06.820
things are opposite. So we know that there's sex differences in fuel use, in muscle fiber type.

19:07.740 --> 19:13.940
There's disputed differences, which we can talk about. But you are either then basing a program

19:13.940 --> 19:23.060
on physiological differences, or you're basing a program on the way sets and reps and exercises

19:23.060 --> 19:29.760
and programs have been delivered to males and females and looked at an outcome. And there has

19:29.760 --> 19:30.340
been studies on that. And I think that's a really important thing to look at. And I think that's

19:30.340 --> 19:34.840
that have compared males and females. Let's just take resistance training. Endurance training goes

19:34.840 --> 19:42.100
back decades. But males and females were really robustly tested in the early 1970s. By the 1980s,

19:42.120 --> 19:47.580
there were position stands that were able to compare males and female outcomes when they're

19:47.580 --> 19:52.680
given programs to look at the differences and to give recommendations and conclusions. And in 1989,

19:53.280 --> 19:59.420
the conclusion of the NSCA, which is the governing body, said that males and females respond similarly

19:59.420 --> 19:59.760
and respond differently. And that's a really important thing to look at. And I think that's

19:59.760 --> 20:02.780
a really important thing to look at. And therefore should follow the same kinds of programs if you

20:02.780 --> 20:09.240
want to improve strength and power and muscle mass and bone. That was revised and then revised again.

20:09.460 --> 20:15.160
And the new position stand, which is now in its third iteration, came out recently and concluded

20:15.160 --> 20:21.940
exactly the same. That is when males and females are given a good program, goal specific program,

20:22.180 --> 20:28.720
they respond the same. So we should be leaning on the human data that has compared males and females

20:28.720 --> 20:36.400
and not on sex differences. And if you wonder whether that's correct, you can speak to any

20:36.400 --> 20:41.100
high performance coach who trains men and women and say, do you have a men's squad or a women's

20:41.100 --> 20:49.280
squad? And they will politely smile and say, no, we just have goal specific programs. You do 200

20:49.280 --> 20:55.720
meters, you do 800 meters. So we train to the goal, but not to your sex. And you mentioned

20:55.720 --> 20:58.540
sort of fiber type differences, fuel.

20:58.720 --> 21:03.900
Substrate use differences between men and women. And I'm, I'm, you know, you know, that I'm

21:03.900 --> 21:10.560
interested in, in fuel substrate use and stuff thinking about, you know, training wise, but also

21:10.560 --> 21:15.520
metabolic health wise, because that's an area that I've been sort of deep involved with throughout

21:15.520 --> 21:23.780
my career. And I always, I understand that women are better fat burners than men, you know, like,

21:23.780 --> 21:28.400
like as a, you know, if we had to, not that we do, but what we do, you know,

21:28.720 --> 21:36.300
like general man versus women, women will burn more fat, but we are a product of our environment.

21:36.440 --> 21:40.560
And this is the thing which I, which, which I do struggle with actually, because I hear that women

21:40.560 --> 21:46.760
are more metabolically flexible. And that is like just a feature of us. And so we don't have to

21:46.760 --> 21:51.420
worry as not, I don't know how it's often couched, but the cat, the thing is, is that women are

21:51.420 --> 21:56.760
better fat burners than men, but we are only better in a particular environment that lends itself that

21:56.760 --> 22:03.060
way. So, you know, I, I don't know, actually, I remember looking a couple of years ago at studies

22:03.060 --> 22:09.300
on metabolic flexibility in women, particularly as we, as we get older and head into perimenopause

22:09.300 --> 22:14.440
and menopause. And, um, I didn't see a lot in that training space, I suppose.

22:14.560 --> 22:19.900
No, there's two follow on questions and this changes everything. What is your training status?

22:20.460 --> 22:26.440
What kind of habitual training do you do and how fit are you? And what is your habitual diet?

22:26.760 --> 22:34.620
That changes everything. And I get concerned when these physiological differences at rest in the

22:34.620 --> 22:40.800
untrained are then used as some form of defense. Well, see, because you are a better fat burner

22:40.800 --> 22:48.340
and because males have 51% fast twitch and females have 51% slow twitch, you're,

22:48.340 --> 22:51.900
you're an endurance queen. You should be doing, you should be more sprint training

22:51.900 --> 22:56.740
because you've already got the endurance. Like that's a really simplistic view of,

22:56.760 --> 23:00.820
of how physiology works. And it's taking a small snippet of untrained people,

23:00.820 --> 23:09.040
because if you take you versus a sprint, you versus completely untrained, you,

23:09.180 --> 23:15.500
you will have different fiber types. This is an adaptation to training. And I get really

23:15.500 --> 23:20.460
concerned when these, and they know what they're doing, right? They know this stuff,

23:20.460 --> 23:26.380
but they take a very small area and then push it as a training rule. Would it not be better

23:26.760 --> 23:32.280
to look at studies that compare males and females on the same program and then look at the training

23:32.280 --> 23:37.280
outcomes? Now, if you give males and females aged match and they do the same endurance training and

23:37.280 --> 23:42.760
men really respond well, or they don't, and women respond really well, they go, ah, well, now we've

23:42.760 --> 23:47.100
got grounds to say, perhaps men need to do a little bit more base work because women, they

23:47.100 --> 23:52.940
respond really quickly. This work has been done and there is no difference. And we can talk across

23:52.940 --> 23:55.240
the different intensity domains.

23:56.760 --> 24:02.200
It speaks to the point that women have been told that they are massively underrepresented

24:02.200 --> 24:09.180
and they have been ignored. Well, how would we know that these outcomes are similar if they

24:09.180 --> 24:15.280
haven't been studied? I guess my other question around this, Tony, is, you know, science has never

24:15.280 --> 24:24.120
settled, right? Of course not. And equally, like how much, what studies would need to be done in

24:24.120 --> 24:26.040
order to, I don't know, be...

24:26.760 --> 24:32.120
I mean, you're very certain, but other people are very certain as well. So what studies still need to be

24:32.120 --> 24:38.140
done to sort of, it's not even about convincing, but to sort of test that hypothesis and go, okay, I was

24:38.140 --> 24:38.460
wrong.

24:38.980 --> 24:48.440
Well, certainty is certainly a way of looking at it. I think it's better to phrase it as, what is

24:48.440 --> 24:55.720
probabilistically correct? Because we need to do something. Who is more probable to be correct?

24:56.060 --> 24:56.740
Based on what we've done.

24:56.760 --> 25:01.060
Based on what we currently understand. And I think it's, if we just take one of the big advice,

25:01.260 --> 25:07.320
and that is, let's follow the framework. Women have been underrepresented and they're following

25:07.320 --> 25:13.120
advice from men, written by men and women get leftovers. I mean, that's virtually a quote.

25:13.900 --> 25:20.440
And females have more slow twitch fiber. They've got more mitochondria and therefore they're built

25:20.440 --> 25:25.620
for endurance and should do more sprint training. Well, let's have a look at how certain you are

25:25.620 --> 25:26.520
on that statement.

25:26.760 --> 25:32.860
Is that from a study or a meta-analysis that has compared males and females with the set

25:32.860 --> 25:42.920
frequency, intensity, duration, or does that come from a biopsy of a liver in a mouse to show that

25:42.920 --> 25:49.520
females have more mitochondria? It does. So yeah, you can be very certain in a different species

25:49.520 --> 25:55.180
that females have more mitochondria, but in human studies, they've done this work.

25:55.280 --> 25:56.740
Capillary density is the same.

25:56.760 --> 26:01.360
Mitochondrial density is the same. Small differences in fiber type, which don't mean

26:01.360 --> 26:06.820
anything. Your fuel metabolism changes, as we've just said, based on your training history and

26:06.820 --> 26:12.160
your training status and what kind of training you're doing. And let's look at the studies that

26:12.160 --> 26:18.420
compare. So I look at that database in humans and think there really isn't a difference that

26:18.420 --> 26:25.440
would make me give you as a female versus age matched, same goals, a different program based

26:25.440 --> 26:25.980
on sex.

26:26.760 --> 26:30.460
And it's like, oh, I'm going to be aged on goal. Whereas somebody who else is certain, it's like,

26:30.460 --> 26:34.360
well, right. But you're using a different species to make that claim.

26:34.360 --> 26:46.340
Yeah. No, I guess it is a really contested area, isn't it? And I suppose-

26:46.340 --> 26:52.640
Can I just say, Mikki, that it's not contested by anyone in the field. It's only contested

26:52.640 --> 26:55.380
by people selling you something.

26:55.380 --> 26:56.720
Social media.

26:56.720 --> 27:01.160
Yeah. And that is, you can't trust any information that's out there because it's

27:01.160 --> 27:08.100
written by men for men based on male data. You can follow my stuff because I am the scientist

27:08.100 --> 27:13.460
who knows this. And that kind of wording is actually used in promos. Like I'm the sex

27:13.460 --> 27:18.920
difference scientist. Okay. Well, why are you using a different species and ignoring all the

27:18.920 --> 27:24.860
human data? And I think this is really important for the public to understand that there can't be

27:24.860 --> 27:26.400
two views that are polar differences.

27:26.720 --> 27:27.720
Yeah.

27:27.720 --> 27:28.720
And that can be correct.

27:28.720 --> 27:35.920
Yeah. Do you know, it's my, so I follow, do we follow Adam from Four Weeks to the Beach?

27:35.920 --> 27:36.920
I do not.

27:36.920 --> 27:37.920
Oh, you would like him. He's great.

27:37.920 --> 27:38.920
I'm sure.

27:38.920 --> 27:47.400
And he's very, and he's really, he's in the more sort of the diet and nutrition and training

27:47.400 --> 27:52.160
side of things. And he's very, a lot of his clients are in that perimenopause, menopause

27:52.160 --> 27:55.160
space. And he was recently on SIAT Fitness podcast with Jordan SIAT. And he was talking,

27:55.160 --> 27:56.160
he was talking about, he was talking about, he was talking about, he was talking about,

27:56.160 --> 28:03.680
and he got absolutely slammed talking about menopause because he's not a woman, a woman

28:03.680 --> 28:08.780
going through menopause essentially. And, and if you follow, like he's a, he's sort

28:08.780 --> 28:14.340
of like a gruff looking man, if you like, but he's got a lot of empathy and he, but

28:14.340 --> 28:19.960
he's a straight talker too. Like he's not going to sugar coat anything, you know? And

28:19.960 --> 28:25.160
so you'll see it in his content. And I think sometimes the person saying something,

28:26.160 --> 28:33.340
I don't know, he was slammed because he's not a woman. And sometimes I wonder if some

28:33.340 --> 28:38.480
of the pushback that you might get is because you're not a woman.

28:38.480 --> 28:44.800
Oh, most certainly, but you just have to ignore those. That's not an argument. If you really

28:44.800 --> 28:53.740
think that a coach or a muscle physiologist like myself is not allowed to comment on a

28:53.740 --> 28:56.160
sex or a stage of life.

28:56.160 --> 28:57.160
Yeah.

28:57.160 --> 29:02.320
Because I am a male, not a female, and I have not gone through menopause, then you're also

29:02.320 --> 29:09.120
welcome to not listen to what we have to say. And I'm happy with that. That that's, it's

29:09.120 --> 29:13.940
not an argument. So we, I ignore those things, but if you come with a, a question, a legitimate

29:13.940 --> 29:18.100
question, and that is what do I need to do differently going through menopause? We can

29:18.100 --> 29:23.000
answer that. We can do it based on studies. We can do it based on physiology. We can also

29:23.000 --> 29:24.480
do it based on my experience.

29:24.480 --> 29:25.480
Yeah.

29:26.160 --> 29:28.700
We can do it based on what we've done with people through the menopause transition, both

29:28.700 --> 29:34.940
who used hormones and both that did not. And we've also got DEXs twice a year, every year

29:34.940 --> 29:40.320
through that transition. Now there's not many people in the world who do that and have done

29:40.320 --> 29:45.560
that so diversely across the disciplines, but if you don't care, cause you're a male,

29:45.560 --> 29:47.680
that's also fine. That's okay.

29:47.680 --> 29:54.700
Okay. So on that then, what should we do for a woman? I mean, people probably know, but

29:54.700 --> 29:56.120
I just want to ask that question.

29:56.160 --> 29:57.160
Yeah.

29:57.160 --> 30:01.080
There is a woman in her forties or fifties. So let's actually, yeah. So, and I think actually

30:01.080 --> 30:05.780
a lot of women who have gone beyond menopause now are like, what about me? Because a lot

30:05.780 --> 30:09.740
of the argument is, well, argument, but you know, a lot of the discussion is around that

30:09.740 --> 30:16.340
perimenopause time, but you know, if they just want to be strong, fit and healthy for

30:16.340 --> 30:18.400
life, what are the training non-negotiables?

30:18.400 --> 30:24.700
Yeah. And, and what are the differences between an aged matched male? Because a lot of these

30:24.700 --> 30:29.980
women, if they are partnered, they'll be going through it with somebody presumably of similar

30:29.980 --> 30:36.020
age and do, do they therefore need to do very different things? It's a great question and

30:36.020 --> 30:42.460
it's not a new question and there's great data on this, but it comes down to the adaptations.

30:42.460 --> 30:47.500
Well, what are we trying to get from a training program? What's going on physiologically

30:47.500 --> 30:53.100
through that transition and for the decades after, and what is training trying to do to

30:53.100 --> 30:54.680
those, uh,

30:54.700 --> 31:00.300
changes that are happening physiologically. Again, this is where a lot of the hormonal changes

31:00.300 --> 31:07.760
are driven as this is why you need to do more strength training, as in heavy loaded strength

31:07.760 --> 31:13.220
training, because you lose fast twitch fibers. We're both males and females lose fast twitch

31:13.220 --> 31:19.840
fibers. So that's not sex specific. There's a hormonal change. This is true. Men only have a

31:19.840 --> 31:24.820
slight decline in testosterone, same with females. But we understand that that's not really a key

31:24.820 --> 31:31.260
driver anymore. That certainly was a key driver of what was going on muscular wise in the 1980s

31:31.260 --> 31:37.320
and 1990s. But now with another 20 years of data, we know that that's not really a big deal. That's

31:37.320 --> 31:41.620
not driving the sets and the reps and the exercise. And that again, is really comforting to know.

31:42.260 --> 31:47.000
So what is the difference? Well, probably urgency, that if you've not lifted weights,

31:47.520 --> 31:49.740
and you're in your 40s, just as an

31:49.740 --> 31:49.820
arborist,

31:49.840 --> 31:58.160
age, then we know that bone is more likely to be impacted negatively through that transition

31:58.160 --> 32:03.360
compared to a male. But males still have bone issues, but not to the same

32:03.360 --> 32:11.100
severity and speed that a female does through the transition. But luckily, the solution is

32:11.100 --> 32:17.140
resistance training. And resistance training can cover a wide range of attributes that we want.

32:17.140 --> 32:19.640
It can impact muscle mass.

32:19.840 --> 32:25.960
It can impact muscle strength, impact muscle power. And a good program would be designed to hit all of

32:25.960 --> 32:33.480
those three capacities. Plus, to use a phrase, bulletproof tendons or injury potential. And we'll

32:33.480 --> 32:41.240
therefore look at adding balance and stability and tendon loading as well. Would that differ to a

32:41.240 --> 32:46.240
male? Nope. Those programs could you a male and female could go in together age match and do

32:46.240 --> 32:49.800
the same thing. Because it's the adaptations we want.

32:50.000 --> 32:56.160
We want you to be able to recruit your muscle fibers and place a large amount of tension on them.

32:57.020 --> 33:03.140
Yeah. Do you know, one thing which I know in a gym that really frustrates me is some gyms you

33:03.140 --> 33:12.560
walk into in the equipment fits like a 90 kilo, six foot male, and not a 50 kilo, five foot three

33:12.560 --> 33:18.720
women. And that's, that's the thing that like, grinds my gears, but which is a complete tangent

33:18.720 --> 33:19.720
from that.

33:19.960 --> 33:20.120
Definitely.

33:20.120 --> 33:25.800
But that's, I suppose, a difference. And people just need to think more about the adjustable

33:25.800 --> 33:28.260
features of equipment.

33:29.520 --> 33:36.440
It's certainly getting better. I think, I think that has been a really legitimate and something

33:36.440 --> 33:41.420
I've really struggled with as a coach of over 30 years is like the back pad is longer than the

33:41.420 --> 33:46.460
torso and the legs on some of my clients, but it is getting better. I mean, adjustable back pads,

33:46.480 --> 33:49.820
adjustable leg pads and up and down, and clearly free weights.

33:49.840 --> 33:56.220
it doesn't matter but the machines we love machines machines gets rid of the balance

33:56.220 --> 34:00.740
component we want a balanced component at times and at other times we don't want the brain thinking

34:00.740 --> 34:06.220
of stabilizing and bracing and this and that and we just want the brain to think the muscle we're

34:06.220 --> 34:11.860
trying to do to get more out of that so we'd love a combination of both but often the machines like

34:11.860 --> 34:18.280
you're not going to fit on that yeah i exactly and i and i do really like a machine because

34:18.280 --> 34:26.100
if for example because i often find myself in a gym after a harder run or a or it's the end of a

34:26.100 --> 34:30.760
sort of a week if you like and it's and i've just finished a run so that run itself might not be

34:30.760 --> 34:36.140
hard but there's fatigue and so i don't trust that my body is able to with i've been sort of like

34:36.140 --> 34:42.660
turn on all of the the muscles and the tendons in a way that keeps me safe i suppose so exactly

34:42.660 --> 34:46.700
yeah it's a real safety feature absolutely and as long as the brain is perceiving

34:46.700 --> 34:48.260
injury

34:48.280 --> 34:54.860
just like you've described you will absolutely have the brakes on how many muscle fibers will

34:54.860 --> 35:00.400
be available to you in that session so tony if i think then sort of shift the conversation to

35:00.400 --> 35:06.100
cardio like i really don't think and i think unless you are actually training for something

35:06.100 --> 35:12.880
cardiovascular like a cyclist a triathlete like a runner like a swimmer do we even need to care

35:12.880 --> 35:17.640
if we're doing zone 2 training do we have to think have i've got my 45 minutes of zone 2 like

35:17.640 --> 35:18.260
a lot of people don't know that they're doing zone 2 training so i think it's a really good

35:18.280 --> 35:18.340
thing to do and i think it's a really good thing to do and i think it's a really good thing to do

35:18.340 --> 35:22.580
people are talking like this and i just i just think it's over complicating it like can you

35:22.580 --> 35:27.360
not just get out and go for a run does it really matter how high your heart rate is or otherwise

35:27.360 --> 35:33.560
like people do they don't mean to but they catastrophize these small details in their

35:33.560 --> 35:40.900
training which is just so inconsequential to your goal and even and i dare i say it like i try you

35:40.900 --> 35:45.560
know i train i'm currently training for a marathon and i've i've got specific intervals and stuff i'm

35:45.560 --> 35:48.260
trying to hit and i'm wanting to do it i'm basing it on my body and i'm trying to hit it and i'm

35:48.280 --> 35:55.780
pace um and effort actually more so than anything i'm basing it on my perceived effort but i could

35:55.780 --> 36:02.100
go real into the weeds and go well my heart rate's too high or you know and i just i feel like there

36:02.100 --> 36:06.840
are things that we over complicate that are so unnecessary for the general person wanting to

36:06.840 --> 36:13.200
live a fitness lifestyle where do zones come from they come from athletes so they can control

36:13.200 --> 36:18.240
intensity distribution across the week and not do too much and burn out or do too

36:18.240 --> 36:26.420
too little and under adapt these were then taken into the fitness industry if you train every day

36:26.420 --> 36:31.160
or you take your training seriously just understanding hard and easy is absolutely

36:31.160 --> 36:38.980
good enough the issue we have of course is how do you define hard and easy but that's just a

36:38.980 --> 36:44.980
simple conversation being able to talk during your running that's easy can you back up and do it

36:44.980 --> 36:47.480
every day could you keep going great that's easy

36:47.480 --> 36:48.180
we

36:48.240 --> 36:53.120
love that because you can accumulate a lot of time training because a lot of time training

36:53.120 --> 36:57.880
or training volume is a key driver of many of the adaptations that we're after

36:57.880 --> 37:04.720
to promote marathon running or endurance or healthy aging cardiovascular wise but it does

37:04.720 --> 37:09.280
something slightly different to when you really rev the engine and you go hard as long as you

37:09.280 --> 37:14.660
understand i've got easy and i can talk and i've got hard where i want to stop and don't want to

37:14.660 --> 37:18.100
keep going then that's probably what the

37:18.100 --> 37:18.220
the

37:18.240 --> 37:21.680
majority need for most of the time

37:21.680 --> 37:31.880
yeah so i don't know that i'd be able and i mean i'll be honest i can't i mean i do intervals with

37:31.880 --> 37:36.880
with running but if i like getting on a bike or something like i've only really learned in the

37:36.880 --> 37:43.080
last few months how to get my cadence up on 85 and over yeah yeah uh who knew that if you just

37:43.080 --> 37:47.580
lowered that level down that would actually work it takes a lot actually for my brain to really

37:47.580 --> 37:48.220
click in and say i'm not going to be able to do this i'm going to be able to do this i'm going to

37:48.240 --> 37:54.760
stay dialed into it and that does lift my heart right but but i i a lot of the conversation isn't

37:54.760 --> 38:00.120
just about zones it's about hit and sit and getting that right and and i don't i'm not

38:00.120 --> 38:04.900
confident that unless you've got about five people if i if i had five people around me

38:04.900 --> 38:10.400
really telling me to absolutely go for it i don't think i'll ever be able to reach the intensities

38:10.400 --> 38:18.020
that a sit session um is sort of set out to achieve i don't know like i probably i personally

38:18.240 --> 38:25.940
right running sprinting is a skill in itself that is highly injurious yeah which means this idea of

38:25.940 --> 38:31.080
women through the menopause transition when they're more likely to have tendon ruptures

38:31.080 --> 38:35.820
kind of muscular tendon injury and telling them to do sprinting without giving really clear

38:35.820 --> 38:43.840
caveats around it is just a recipe for disaster can you do it on a bike sure can you do it on an

38:43.840 --> 38:47.420
assault bike sure absolutely what's your chance of injury

38:48.240 --> 38:54.380
little can i tell you on an assault bike i want you to go 20 seconds all out so you can't do 25

38:54.380 --> 39:01.080
seconds within a few you'll be able to understand what you need to do to do 20 seconds of work

39:01.080 --> 39:08.420
really safely but i would never do it running unless you were a sprinter it's too skill oriented

39:08.420 --> 39:15.800
and these are where we need coaches to read past all the headline grabs women should do this

39:15.800 --> 39:17.180
perimenopausal should do that

39:17.180 --> 39:17.460
so

39:18.240 --> 39:23.520
okay how does that work for you in your life in your fitness with your background

39:23.520 --> 39:29.180
and then firstly why would that be any different to a male as well and this is where the science

39:29.180 --> 39:34.720
underneath it is really very shaky because the rules apply to both let's just look at that for

39:34.720 --> 39:43.160
one second studies have looked at men and women aged matched across hit and sit and continuous

39:43.160 --> 39:48.200
we'll rule that aside and have looked at training outcomes and they conclude a 20

39:48.240 --> 39:53.620
24 meta-analyses that looked at more than 126 studies that looked at men and women so that

39:53.620 --> 39:59.280
answers the question in this specific field women haven't been studied well we've got 126 of them in

39:59.280 --> 40:05.820
a meta-analysis compared evenly matched males and females and they found identical responses in

40:05.820 --> 40:12.480
vo2 max change in threshold change in performance outcome change males and females respond the same

40:12.480 --> 40:17.980
so it's sex agnostic but will you get something out of sprinting that you won't get from just

40:18.240 --> 40:23.420
intensity work and the answer is maybe a little bit of muscle fiber recruitment but would you

40:23.420 --> 40:30.620
really know the answer is no so can you do sprinting safely yep bike yeah assault bike i

40:30.620 --> 40:35.800
love the assault bike but other than that you can just do high intensity interval training and still

40:35.800 --> 40:41.900
reap most of the benefits yeah i like i remember listening to ronda patrick i believe um this is

40:41.900 --> 40:47.740
years ago now and she was talking about how she was doing tabata tabata and you know tabata um

40:47.740 --> 40:52.420
for people who are listening is that the you'll have to correct me if i'm wrong but is it 20

40:52.420 --> 40:57.620
seconds with 10 seconds rest times four and that is it like times eight times eight times eight

40:57.620 --> 41:03.460
times eight so it's your best 50 second effort yeah so yes let's call it just under a minute

41:03.460 --> 41:09.420
that on one day after a good warm-up you do your best if it's you probably wouldn't do it running

41:09.420 --> 41:13.960
because it's too much start stop and that deceleration becomes injury but what do you do

41:13.960 --> 41:16.980
on a bike sure assault bike absolutely

41:16.980 --> 41:25.100
i really do think for this on off on off work like a tabata now tabata is only four minutes

41:25.100 --> 41:29.980
it's eight lots of them and you're meant to reach task failure at the end if you do them on a bike

41:29.980 --> 41:33.780
or an assault bike because there's no risk of injury it's just so easy but it's your best 50

41:33.780 --> 41:40.000
second power okay so that's what that's what that is i remember ronda saying she did like i don't

41:40.000 --> 41:45.640
know five lots of them or something yeah which is not tabata yeah that's just yeah yeah that's what

41:46.980 --> 41:53.440
it is and you know as try as i might i don't think i'm i don't have the skill to actually execute

41:53.440 --> 41:59.340
properly a um sprint interval type training and of course i could train i'm sure i could

41:59.340 --> 42:04.000
train myself to some extent but but there are just some things that you can you really teach

42:04.000 --> 42:07.640
an old dog new tricks and i don't know i think that this dog is just a little bit too old yeah

42:07.640 --> 42:12.720
but i think you're no exception i think you're the majority and let's ask ourselves what benefit

42:12.720 --> 42:16.960
would we get from this versus other modalities that are safer and i think that's a good question

42:16.980 --> 42:22.380
the point of sprinting is that you're going to preferentially use your fast twitch muscle fibers

42:22.380 --> 42:27.840
can you get the same muscle fiber recruitment when you do a set of leg press or leg extensions

42:27.840 --> 42:34.260
absolutely but this is also the problem when women have been told you've got to do max strength

42:34.260 --> 42:37.320
lifting and you've got to do sprint training and then you start doing them on each day

42:37.320 --> 42:41.700
monday is your weights training tuesday is your sprint training wednesday is your weight training

42:41.700 --> 42:46.080
sprint you're doing the same muscle fibers every day there is no recovery there

42:46.980 --> 42:51.840
and because it might be different to what you've done high rep training a lot of continuous

42:51.840 --> 42:57.680
training when you do high intensity training you've got a fresh stimulus introduction to the

42:57.680 --> 43:02.460
program you're going to get results for the next little while but two things will happen you'll

43:02.460 --> 43:06.620
either burn out and get injured because you're doing the same muscle fibers every day recipe

43:06.620 --> 43:14.240
for disaster or you will just hit a plateau and then you go well oh i thought i'd found the

43:14.240 --> 43:16.920
solution like well it's a new program it's just something different

43:16.980 --> 43:22.080
and that's the concern that i have that ultimately let's have this chat in three months once you've

43:22.080 --> 43:28.500
found what you think is the best thing then let's talk when it's going to plateau but worse you could

43:28.500 --> 43:34.520
get injured yeah you know i remember um this is related but a bit of a tangent like some of the

43:34.520 --> 43:39.460
running coaches that i used to have conversations with when i was a more serious runner maybe

43:39.460 --> 43:46.240
20 years ago now and they would set up programs so if i'm thinking about sort of age you know

43:46.980 --> 43:53.540
for me as a young well 30 youngish adult right um i had the same program as someone else i knew who

43:53.540 --> 43:59.180
was more of a master's athlete she was like 39 uh but her program was extended over 10 days

43:59.180 --> 44:03.880
and my program was seven days you know and i really liked that as an approach and i think

44:03.880 --> 44:10.200
it really spoke to the you know that recovery piece that you're talking about which is which

44:10.200 --> 44:16.600
is really important right well aging changes the neurology there is less high threshold motor units

44:16.980 --> 44:22.220
brain to muscle they they die the essentially the nervous system that's activating high threshold

44:22.220 --> 44:29.720
threshold motor units or fast which muscle fibers they decay and die and that's why part of the

44:29.720 --> 44:37.220
reason why there needs to be more protracted recovery after those activities that is reliant

44:37.220 --> 44:44.160
on a lot of fast which muscle fibers there's also studies that have shown that the recovery from

44:44.160 --> 44:46.720
muscle damage a lot of hitting the ground a lot of

44:46.980 --> 44:53.700
centric actions or downhill running that that's also delayed in older individuals not just training

44:53.700 --> 44:58.820
naive those people have been training for a long time and that speaks to the point that recovery

44:58.820 --> 45:07.960
as we age from really high fast twitch activities max strength power sprinting

45:07.960 --> 45:16.500
require longer recovery yeah okay well that and that is absolutely um uh

45:16.980 --> 45:26.240
gels with my experience as well yeah um so tony if we switch gears if you're happy to um i sent you

45:26.240 --> 45:32.680
that post about that um resistance training piece for strength endurance runners and you know i was

45:32.680 --> 45:38.100
really interested to get your take on it because i'm trying to you know i've always been a fan of

45:38.100 --> 45:44.100
the gym and i've never quite navigated how to fit training in and around my strength training in and

45:44.100 --> 45:46.960
around my training but now i'm following a program and they sort of just do it for me and i'm trying to

45:46.980 --> 45:52.180
and it's working really well although i believe that their sort of strength training beliefs may

45:52.180 --> 45:58.440
be different from the posts that that i've sent you so i guess what well i guess my first question

45:58.440 --> 46:03.480
is and i'll pop the review in the show notes for people who are interested who will be the runners

46:03.480 --> 46:08.400
around us so like you know the paper that i'm discussing like what was your biggest takeaway

46:08.400 --> 46:16.540
from it well firstly i think it applies to everyone because as we age or what we want to age

46:16.980 --> 46:25.960
is to have both strength power muscle mass and endurance it's not an either or and this paper

46:25.960 --> 46:31.440
is essentially answering that question but from an endurance perspective and it's talking about

46:31.440 --> 46:36.940
trade-offs and the trade-offs essentially are if you do a certain type of weight training

46:36.940 --> 46:43.640
you will build muscle mass and for those who already start with larger muscle mass males

46:43.640 --> 46:46.520
that could be a problem for

46:46.980 --> 46:53.440
weight it could be a problem for interference and it could be a problem for locomotion so if

46:53.440 --> 46:57.840
you've got more mass around your calves for example you've got to swing that when you're

46:57.840 --> 47:05.200
training and that changes your economy then the question is if you are a female and you've got

47:05.200 --> 47:10.260
40 kilos of muscle mass versus 80 kilos of muscle mass and you both right because males and females

47:10.260 --> 47:14.800
will respond the same for hypertrophy you do the same program you'll respond the same as me

47:14.800 --> 47:16.780
given all individual differences

47:16.980 --> 47:22.780
but you're starting at 40 kilos and i'm starting at 70 kilos so my five percent will be different

47:22.780 --> 47:27.640
to your five percent in absolute terms that's a problem i go running up a hill i'm carrying more

47:27.640 --> 47:36.100
mass so that's another consideration but if you are recreationally trained and of low mass then

47:36.100 --> 47:41.840
you really kind of go after the weight training because the trade-offs are not great there's

47:41.840 --> 47:46.900
really only positives but if you are a larger male there's more trade-offs

47:46.980 --> 47:50.860
and that's what you've got to consider and you've got to probably be more selective with your

47:50.860 --> 47:57.420
loading and maybe your frequency but i think the ultimate take-home is how do you distribute this

47:57.420 --> 48:03.360
all in the week and how do you get the sets and reps that give you what you want which is

48:03.360 --> 48:11.840
strength and tendon resilience and not interfere with too much mass or interfere with your quality

48:11.840 --> 48:16.800
sessions and that's where the coach comes in yeah yeah and you know i do i i

48:16.980 --> 48:23.300
struggle a little bit with in my brain because you know i'm i'm very i'm all about um muscle

48:23.300 --> 48:29.820
preservation and strength relative strength and making sure that i'm robust and resilient as i

48:29.820 --> 48:35.420
age within my frame right uh but of course i love running and right now i'm going through a block

48:35.420 --> 48:40.480
of marathon running but soon after i'll switch back to my low slung training for my low slung

48:41.480 --> 48:46.940
events um got a couple of them coming up next year and i guess you know i

48:46.980 --> 48:53.720
i do want you know is what i'm trying to achieve with my running is that in competition to the

48:53.720 --> 49:00.760
goals that i'm trying to achieve as a woman almost 50 who is still trying to be all those

49:00.760 --> 49:05.360
things about health like you know with when it comes to strength like am i am i doing myself

49:05.360 --> 49:11.220
a disservice because i'm not interested in building muscle like i'm like it's not really

49:11.220 --> 49:15.860
the thing i'm going after i'm not going after building muscle at this point right and let's

49:15.860 --> 49:16.700
be honest with you

49:16.980 --> 49:22.760
of energy output with running building muscle is energy expensive so you would have to become

49:22.760 --> 49:29.580
a full-time eater and a full-time recoverer to actually see some gains in muscle tissue

49:29.580 --> 49:35.560
yeah of course but the gains in strength are largely neurological they're largely brain to

49:35.560 --> 49:41.580
muscle and connective tissue is a different adaptation again you want tendon resilience

49:41.580 --> 49:45.840
or tendon strength that protects your patella tendon and protects your achilles tendon

49:45.840 --> 49:46.160
um

49:46.160 --> 49:55.180
they are essentially strain driven that is you can develop strength working say between

49:55.180 --> 50:00.380
four to six repetitions but maybe with a weight that you could do for eight

50:00.380 --> 50:06.800
and that is enough strain to induce all the positive benefits we want for strength but also

50:06.800 --> 50:13.080
for the tendon which is great now why did i say not eight reps why stop at six and this just

50:13.080 --> 50:16.000
essentially has to do with knock-on fatigue when you are

50:16.160 --> 50:21.540
training for endurance we have to be really mindful that what we do today how will it

50:21.540 --> 50:26.060
impact what we do either that afternoon or what we're doing the next day and training to failure

50:26.060 --> 50:32.740
won't give you extra benefits for strength power muscle mass quit clearly not pal different

50:32.740 --> 50:40.200
topic but it won't give you any extra benefit but it will protract your recovery so we like

50:40.200 --> 50:45.340
keeping reps in reserve and for runners i would typically work in the four to six rep range for

50:45.340 --> 50:46.000
primary

50:46.000 --> 50:50.740
muscles that we're going after, i.e. the lower limb, the gluteals, the quads, the hamstrings,

50:50.900 --> 50:57.220
the calves. We do a weight four to six times that you could probably do for eight, but we stop short,

50:57.560 --> 51:03.480
we don't sacrifice any benefit, and we don't have the fatigue knock on. The other thing we watch for

51:03.480 --> 51:08.740
is too much marked eccentric work, either really kind of slowing down the eccentric or super

51:08.740 --> 51:13.720
maximal eccentrics. We just want to keep the weight moving up, down, up, down, and not one,

51:13.720 --> 51:20.600
two, three, four. Because again, eccentric actions also create muscle damage and protract

51:20.600 --> 51:26.360
the recovery. That just simply means we get the best out of the weights in the four to six rep

51:26.360 --> 51:31.900
range without the fatigue, and you'll try and distribute that at minimum of twice a week.

51:32.380 --> 51:35.780
Then the next day, just to be sure, it's an easy session.

51:36.100 --> 51:43.380
Yeah. Okay. Because I really like a 10 to 12 rep range, but that sounds like I'm

51:43.380 --> 51:50.080
and could I achieve what you've just described with that? Or actually, I'm just curious,

51:50.300 --> 51:56.160
could I get the same benefit by having the same perceived effort that I would have otherwise

51:56.160 --> 52:01.040
gotten from four to six or no? You will adapt to whatever you give them. This is why we train.

52:01.360 --> 52:09.600
If I give unexposed Mikki the 10 to 12, eight to 12 rep range, and you've never done it before,

52:09.600 --> 52:12.020
you're going to be sore, your next day is going to be dreadful,

52:12.360 --> 52:13.360
and you would-

52:13.380 --> 52:16.860
Conclude, well, I'm not going to do weight training because my running sucks and I'm sore.

52:17.620 --> 52:23.260
But the repeated bad effect tells us that the more often you do the same thing,

52:23.820 --> 52:28.660
the body puts in all the adjustments in place physiologically so that you don't get the fatigue

52:28.660 --> 52:32.700
and you don't get the damage and you don't get that protracted recovery. You've got to go through

52:32.700 --> 52:39.020
that. Can you get the benefit in the 10 to 12 rep range that the four to six rep is giving you?

52:39.020 --> 52:42.860
They are slightly different. You get more-

52:43.380 --> 52:48.500
This is slightly contentious, but at least the body of data would suggest that the heavier loads

52:48.500 --> 52:54.020
have more benefit for tendon. There's more tendon strain. That has been questioned recently,

52:54.580 --> 53:00.340
but at least there's a strong signal for that being likely to be correct. Secondly,

53:00.340 --> 53:05.060
if you don't want muscle, then doing two sets in the four to six rep range,

53:05.940 --> 53:12.660
that's not enough training volume to drive muscle mass, but you get the neurological signals for

53:12.660 --> 53:17.980
improving strength. It's a tick in the box for tendon resilience. It's a tick in the box for

53:17.980 --> 53:24.080
strength. What you're probably missing is that volume, which means you could probably do that

53:24.080 --> 53:30.680
more moderate rep range for ancillary exercises, but maybe not for your primary locomotive muscles

53:30.680 --> 53:41.140
that you want to improve running. Let's say I do squats and I do Bulgarian split squats and I do

53:41.140 --> 53:42.140
some sort of-

53:42.660 --> 53:47.440
One-legged deadlift thing, and I've just told you exactly almost what I do almost every time I walk

53:47.440 --> 53:52.580
into the gym. That's where I would do my four to six. Then when I hit a lat pull-down machine

53:52.580 --> 54:00.680
or do a bent-over row or do some sort of overhead press, that's when I could still continue to do

54:00.680 --> 54:06.760
my 10 to 12s. You could. That would be an option. I'm going to be slightly controversial and say for

54:06.760 --> 54:07.160
runners- Go on.

54:07.160 --> 54:11.860
Runners who don't live and breathe in the gym, I probably wouldn't do a squat

54:11.860 --> 54:12.640
because the-

54:12.660 --> 54:19.160
The amount of technique to get the most out of the squat is not- If I put you on a leg press,

54:19.540 --> 54:25.320
it's the same thing. I give you a few warm-up sets and I get you to work with true effort,

54:25.400 --> 54:30.520
but not to failure for six reps of a leg press. How much do you lift there versus doing the

54:30.520 --> 54:35.560
comparable effort on six reps of a back squat? The answer is it's going to be an eighth.

54:36.620 --> 54:42.620
It's going to be way off. I have two 50-kilogram ladies who are 70 years old. They can leg

54:42.660 --> 54:48.460
press 250 kilos. Their best back squat is 50. By order of magnitude, it's hugely different.

54:48.800 --> 54:51.960
There's lots of things going in. Am I going to hurt my back? Can I stand back up again?

54:52.540 --> 54:57.720
What would I do if you're not there? All of those things, as we said before, put the brakes on.

54:58.540 --> 55:02.920
Does that mean that the squats are terrible exercise? No, but it is individualized for you

55:02.920 --> 55:09.540
as a runner. You've only got so much time in the weights room. I would spend it on a leg press.

55:09.540 --> 55:12.640
I'd spend it on a leg extension. I'd spend it on a seated leg curl.

55:13.380 --> 55:19.760
Absolutely on a hip thrust. Those things, the brain doesn't go, I'm going to put the brakes on.

55:20.000 --> 55:26.120
You get the most out of them. There's also very little time there in eccentric actions or stretch

55:26.120 --> 55:30.980
there that would make you sore into the next day. Do we like the Bulgarian split squat?

55:31.740 --> 55:37.860
It's fine. Could you get more out of a single leg leg press? Yeah.

55:38.500 --> 55:42.620
Okay. Now, this is good because I do actually use a leg press machine. I do like it, but again,

55:42.620 --> 55:48.540
I'm on 15 reps. It tells me I need to load those plates up a bit more and take up. Yeah, I know.

55:48.860 --> 55:57.560
I think, do you know what? It really speaks to that old volume. Volume is better. That's probably

55:57.560 --> 56:04.380
what that speaks to. Volume will drive persistent fatigue, both in the session. Once you do 15 reps

56:04.380 --> 56:11.500
of something, whatever else you do will be impaired. The goal of a runner is to

56:11.500 --> 56:19.020
improve adaptations that will help you run and stop you from breaking down. We know what those

56:19.020 --> 56:24.900
adaptations are. You're better to do that without the knock-on effect of fatigue by lifting heavier

56:24.900 --> 56:30.540
loads. Look, I'm advocating heavy loads for females, but it's very context specific.

56:31.120 --> 56:36.100
Yeah. No, I love it. You didn't have an opinion on my upper body stuff because it doesn't really

56:36.100 --> 56:41.480
matter, does it? No, but the one thing I would be concerned with a runner is if you are,

56:41.500 --> 56:47.000
hitting it with more volume, okay, that's not going to affect the fatigue of your lower body

56:47.000 --> 56:53.300
running. Okay. Some people argue that your brain will perceive that effort and it's unpleasant and

56:53.300 --> 57:01.040
everything else is worse. I think that's greatly overstated, but if you're doing 10, 12, 15 reps

57:01.040 --> 57:08.120
in the upper body, you're more likely to increase muscle mass. Is that a problem? Probably not,

57:08.120 --> 57:11.040
for a few grams. If it was for me, that's a problem.

57:11.500 --> 57:18.240
Because now I add kilos that I have to carry with me. So it's based on the individual.

57:18.940 --> 57:24.000
So basically, so for Hubster, he wouldn't want to be doing that, but I'm probably all right because

57:24.000 --> 57:29.100
my potential to increase muscle mass, I mean, I just want to really preserve what I've got more

57:29.100 --> 57:32.500
than anything else. Yeah. Yeah. But I probably would consider

57:32.500 --> 57:40.680
doing some heavier work because the neurological signals are different between four to six,

57:40.680 --> 57:51.520
10 to 12, 15 to 20. And it's the neurological signals that die as we age. And I do like the idea

57:51.520 --> 57:57.380
of different velocities of contraction. So working with either fast intent or actually moving

57:57.380 --> 58:03.740
quickly and mixing up the rep ranges because no one rep range has the monopoly across the

58:03.740 --> 58:09.160
neuromuscular adaptations. And a good program would include a little bit of all of them.

58:09.560 --> 58:10.660
Okay. That makes sense.

58:10.680 --> 58:15.720
That makes total sense. And I guess if I were to have one more question,

58:16.320 --> 58:20.420
a couple of warmup sets, then the two working sets, is that what you'd do?

58:20.420 --> 58:25.220
Yeah, absolutely. This is where the coach comes in. There's a lot of talk about warmups and

58:25.220 --> 58:30.620
are they necessary? And actually people argue about a lot of things. You put your coach's hat

58:30.620 --> 58:35.380
on and it's load dependent. So if you're going to do a hip thrust or a leg press, and it's going to

58:35.380 --> 58:40.340
be a hundred, 150, 200 kilos, you're going to go in straight to 200 kilos.

58:40.680 --> 58:45.700
Then you might do a hundred, then you might do 150, and then you do your work set.

58:46.160 --> 58:50.760
But the difference is the rep range. The rep range is my warmup sets are typically

58:50.760 --> 58:59.200
three to four repetitions. You're not warming up the muscle. There's no way in a set of 10 that

58:59.200 --> 59:03.760
your temperature of your quad increases. So you're doing it for the brain to go, oh, all right,

59:04.180 --> 59:09.560
I finished my kids drop off and I've finished my work meeting. I'm now combining ankle, knee, hip,

59:09.800 --> 59:10.360
and I'm...

59:10.680 --> 59:15.200
Expressing force this direction. And I'm not on my phone and I'm not thinking, and I'm doing this.

59:15.580 --> 59:20.360
Okay, now I'm going to add another 50 kilos. That's what I'm doing. And I'm all in. And then

59:20.360 --> 59:26.120
off I go. So the warmup is your preparation for the task you're about to do. Weight training is

59:26.120 --> 59:33.060
a cruel mistress. It demands your entire focus. You cannot go from a meeting from your phone to

59:33.060 --> 59:37.380
whatever, and then do your work. You're leaving so many muscle fibers on the table if you're

59:37.380 --> 59:40.660
multitasking. Okay. Now that makes perfect sense.

59:40.680 --> 59:45.920
Yes. This is great. I'm getting so much info. Thank you, Tony. And this is one of the reasons

59:45.920 --> 59:52.040
why I wanted to bring that sort of paper to you and just get us discussing it. Because I know that

59:52.040 --> 59:56.460
you've worked with so many people over the years that you are like a perfect person to chat to

59:56.460 --> 01:00:02.260
about the endurance piece as much, because I obviously know a ton of people in the strength

01:00:02.260 --> 01:00:07.920
space, but not a lot of them are also well-versed in strength work for endurance, really.

01:00:08.240 --> 01:00:10.640
And when people look at my program,

01:00:10.680 --> 01:00:15.100
for endurance athletes, whether they're recreational or whether they're national

01:00:15.100 --> 01:00:22.140
champions or Olympians, the programs are ridiculously simple. What adaptations am I

01:00:22.140 --> 01:00:28.660
trying to increase to help their triathlon, their running, their swimming, you name it.

01:00:29.400 --> 01:00:35.400
And once you look at tendon resilience and strength, improving that capacity of that muscle

01:00:35.400 --> 01:00:40.280
to express force and to resist fatigue and injury prevention,

01:00:40.680 --> 01:00:44.020
the programs are very simple. They're very low volume. There's a reduced,

01:00:44.600 --> 01:00:49.300
it's called a dose response to sets. The more you do, the less you get out of it. So if we just want

01:00:49.300 --> 01:00:54.440
a minimum dose to increase strength a little bit, we typically do one or two sets and we move on.

01:00:55.020 --> 01:00:59.660
A few warm-up sets get you there and then one or two sets and we're on. We're absolutely not doing

01:00:59.660 --> 01:01:03.720
three, four, five sets per exercise and then multiple exercises for the same thing.

01:01:04.140 --> 01:01:09.660
It's going to give you so little for what you get out with the knock-on effect of fatigue,

01:01:09.660 --> 01:01:14.160
impacting negatively everything else you do in the week. So that doesn't make sense. So we need

01:01:14.160 --> 01:01:18.980
to realize this is the program designed for somebody just wanting to increase muscle mass

01:01:18.980 --> 01:01:25.440
and not doing any other cardio. Or are they a runner, endurance athlete, that we're doing

01:01:25.440 --> 01:01:31.220
weight training to help that. Very different context. Yeah. And then I guess my last question

01:01:31.220 --> 01:01:37.900
with that is, even if my weight training is geared towards assisting my running, be it marathon,

01:01:37.900 --> 01:01:39.500
be it the ultra marathon stuff, which I...

01:01:39.660 --> 01:01:46.180
I love doing in our multi-stage stuff, am I doing myself a disservice from not training in a

01:01:46.180 --> 01:01:52.080
different way because of how important it is for strength work? Am I slowly degrading my muscle

01:01:52.080 --> 01:01:58.760
over time because I'm not doing other stuff, I suppose? There's other bigger enemies and they're

01:01:58.760 --> 01:02:05.320
often available energy as the large one. And that is an endurance athlete, you will know that it's

01:02:05.320 --> 01:02:09.640
very easy to be within the day or just full stop in low energy.

01:02:09.660 --> 01:02:14.980
That's the enemy of muscle mass. Even if you're lifting two days a week, even if your protein is

01:02:14.980 --> 01:02:19.720
there, if you're sitting in daily energy expenditure that is massively exceeding your

01:02:19.720 --> 01:02:24.580
input, there's nothing you can do to your muscle mass. You will absolutely penalize that. And

01:02:24.580 --> 01:02:31.600
that's a problem. And once we understand the energy demands of training with what we're trying

01:02:31.600 --> 01:02:37.060
to accomplish to perhaps stay weight stable, then you are absolutely not compromising. I would say

01:02:37.060 --> 01:02:39.560
that they're complimentary because your quality of muscle,

01:02:39.660 --> 01:02:47.220
stays high, even though your main training is very oxidative, slow-twitch oriented.

01:02:47.980 --> 01:02:55.000
Yeah. And I have a conversation about muscle mass with my friends. We talk a lot about it and I've

01:02:55.000 --> 01:03:00.300
got a lot of friends who don't really love strength. I enjoy being in a gym and I enjoy

01:03:00.300 --> 01:03:07.100
lifting weights and I find it fun. Whereas they do not enjoy it and it's quite a task for them.

01:03:07.100 --> 01:03:09.540
They're very fit and they're out in the mountains and they're

01:03:09.540 --> 01:03:16.280
hiking and whatnot and doing some stuff. And energy availability is no concern.

01:03:17.960 --> 01:03:28.720
Tony, I'm curious. I sometimes wonder how much we have almost over-indexed on protein,

01:03:29.060 --> 01:03:36.800
over-indexed on strength training for you to be truly healthy until you're in your 80s.

01:03:36.800 --> 01:03:39.340
And how much just living a life that is active,

01:03:39.540 --> 01:03:44.300
and that you're outside and you're moving and you're eating well. I don't know. Do you have

01:03:44.300 --> 01:03:47.060
any thoughts on stuff like that? That's quite a big question, but I'm...

01:03:47.780 --> 01:03:51.680
It's an important question because weight training is not everyone's cup of tea.

01:03:52.360 --> 01:03:56.180
And the same stretch, believe it or not, some people don't like doing

01:03:56.180 --> 01:03:58.420
aerobic and cardiovascular training.

01:03:58.920 --> 01:04:00.160
Who are these crazy people?

01:04:00.160 --> 01:04:08.720
Right. And this is where minimum dose comes in. And we often confuse the advice that's given to

01:04:08.720 --> 01:04:09.520
experts. Now, I don't know if you've heard of it. I don't know if you've heard of it. I don't know

01:04:09.540 --> 01:04:13.760
I'm a cyclist, which means that when we think about what's a good training program, we think,

01:04:13.860 --> 01:04:18.060
well, what is Tadej Pogacar doing? Let's just do what he's doing. And in the muscle world,

01:04:18.120 --> 01:04:23.120
we think, well, what are bodybuilders doing? These are not the right questions to ask.

01:04:23.460 --> 01:04:29.520
They are, what is... If I don't like weight training, what's the minimum dose I need to do

01:04:29.520 --> 01:04:34.580
to either preserve muscle, don't want to grow any more muscle, but I don't want to go downward. So

01:04:34.580 --> 01:04:38.740
the minimum to maintain it, or to give me slow...

01:04:39.540 --> 01:04:45.400
Growth over the many years, but not megadosing. So kind of a minimalist approach. Minimum dose,

01:04:45.740 --> 01:04:49.600
minimalist approach, and then a maximalist approach. I want to grow as much muscle as

01:04:49.600 --> 01:04:56.060
my genetic ceiling will let me. They are very different frequencies, volumes, splits, you name

01:04:56.060 --> 01:05:02.080
it. They are so different. And for most people, training, if you want to maintain, you do one

01:05:02.080 --> 01:05:09.520
session total body a week. That will maintain you. If you do two sessions, total body, and you do,

01:05:09.520 --> 01:05:15.300
two sets per muscle group, eight to 10 repetitions, and you push, you pull, you push, you pull,

01:05:15.400 --> 01:05:21.180
you leg press, you eight for everything, then you will have this slow increase going upwards.

01:05:21.980 --> 01:05:26.840
And then clearly, the more you do, the more you get within reason. You add another day,

01:05:26.940 --> 01:05:31.820
you add more sets, you add more exercises. And that's for somebody who wants to maximize that.

01:05:32.000 --> 01:05:36.460
And you need to decide where you fit, but there'll only be those three. You have to choose which

01:05:36.460 --> 01:05:39.500
those three are. And the same rule applies to cardio. For those people who don't know,

01:05:39.540 --> 01:05:43.320
people who never want to do it, well, okay, you're going to devote 10 minutes at the end

01:05:43.320 --> 01:05:47.040
of your weights, and you're going to do kind of some interval training just for 10 minutes.

01:05:49.140 --> 01:05:52.580
What about like, if you never want to even step into a gym?

01:05:53.400 --> 01:06:00.400
There's no way around it. Muscle will decay. And you can't get what weight training does by

01:06:00.840 --> 01:06:07.960
mimicking hard exercise outside. Muscle adaptations are muscle specific. That is,

01:06:08.100 --> 01:06:09.380
running up a hill or hiking.

01:06:09.520 --> 01:06:15.240
We use different fibers to what you're doing in a hip thrust, to a squat, to a Bulgarian squat.

01:06:15.860 --> 01:06:21.000
And we create adaptation, not at a muscular level, but at a muscle fiber level. And that's

01:06:21.000 --> 01:06:24.920
really important to understand because people will say, I don't like the gym, but I'm really

01:06:24.920 --> 01:06:31.220
active outdoors. How are you working your gluteus medius? How are you working your soleus? You

01:06:31.220 --> 01:06:37.020
can't. You have to do that in a gym. So use minimum dose. Okay, I'm hearing you. So press

01:06:37.020 --> 01:06:39.140
up somewhere in your house is not going to cut it.

01:06:39.520 --> 01:06:45.320
Oh, I'll tell you. I'll tell you a good news story. I'm a twin. I think you knew that. And

01:06:45.320 --> 01:06:50.620
she has just gone on this health journey this year and she has lost 17 kilos. She's now stabilized at

01:06:50.620 --> 01:06:57.980
this really great place for her. And she's just started in the gym, maybe about 10 weeks ago at

01:06:57.980 --> 01:07:04.240
this point. And it took her, she was always, her job is quite physical and she would always get

01:07:04.240 --> 01:07:09.200
10,000 steps because she has dogs and she walks them, et cetera. But I then sort of,

01:07:09.520 --> 01:07:13.920
and I, when we begun together, I said, Hey, look, you don't, I don't know what you think about this,

01:07:13.920 --> 01:07:17.100
but I said, you don't need to worry about the gym right now. Let's not even think about

01:07:17.100 --> 01:07:22.120
that because she was quite overwhelmed at that. Just the idea. And she's like, I don't think I'll

01:07:22.120 --> 01:07:26.940
ever get into the gym. So I just said, no problem, no problem. Let's, you know, so she just got

01:07:26.940 --> 01:07:32.000
started on her journey. And then at about six or eight weeks. And I said, you know, laws, I think

01:07:32.000 --> 01:07:36.140
you will need to start doing strength training at some point, if we really want to make sure that

01:07:36.140 --> 01:07:39.160
you, um, you just are protecting, you know,

01:07:39.520 --> 01:07:44.840
using your muscle, you're building some strength and you're, you're not just losing a lot of what

01:07:44.840 --> 01:07:50.580
you've got in terms of muscle mass. And so we're sort of targeting fatness more, um, not with the

01:07:50.580 --> 01:07:55.700
goal of looking ripped, but just to protect the muscle. And so she started with, with the press

01:07:55.700 --> 01:08:01.880
ups on the wall and the squats, et cetera. And then about six weeks after that, she got into

01:08:01.880 --> 01:08:06.100
the gym with a friend of hers, and now she's going three times a week. And she said it is

01:08:06.100 --> 01:08:11.900
the best thing for her mental health. Absolutely. And she also said that she, at the start, she's

01:08:11.900 --> 01:08:17.180
like, I'll never, she was very determined. She'd never go to a gym and now she absolutely loves it.

01:08:17.180 --> 01:08:22.040
So people can change too. I think that experience is the experience of the majority, not the

01:08:22.040 --> 01:08:27.340
minority. And that's also the sequence I would do. We, we, as trainers think let's do it all. Let's

01:08:27.340 --> 01:08:33.980
do it all now. Let's do it based on studies that did it all now. Whereas in reality, you, it's a

01:08:33.980 --> 01:08:36.020
journey. That's the word you use.

01:08:36.100 --> 01:08:40.300
And that journey for many people starts with just becoming more regular with their activity

01:08:40.300 --> 01:08:47.400
and dialing in their nutrition and then adding new behavior upon new behavior that 12 weeks ago

01:08:47.400 --> 01:08:53.420
would seem absolutely foreign to go to the gym. And then, all right, my identity has changed and

01:08:53.420 --> 01:09:00.760
yeah, I can do that. You're at it. Yeah, it's, it is, it's so great. And I just think I,

01:09:00.760 --> 01:09:05.860
because obviously I see a lot of people in my programs who are at the place that she was at

01:09:05.860 --> 01:09:11.760
and they're beginning with me for that eight weeks. And of course I encourage them to, we talk

01:09:11.760 --> 01:09:15.620
a lot about the importance of strength training, but I totally understand why some of them go

01:09:15.620 --> 01:09:19.680
through my entire program first time without really embarking on it. And I have a lot of

01:09:19.680 --> 01:09:26.240
empathy for them because there's a lot of change initially. So, and I guess this is, you know,

01:09:26.280 --> 01:09:31.280
obviously strength is extremely important and I, my hope for them is that they get onto it and they

01:09:31.280 --> 01:09:34.160
do do it eventually, but everyone's got their own pace, right?

01:09:35.320 --> 01:09:35.720
Absolutely.

01:09:35.860 --> 01:09:42.420
The question of ideal versus what you're going to do. Everyone in the field understands that

01:09:42.420 --> 01:09:48.380
your consistency with an exercise habit is everything, which is a slightly separate

01:09:48.380 --> 01:09:54.960
question to saying, well, what physical attributes are going to detrain when you're losing weight

01:09:54.960 --> 01:10:00.160
and you will lose muscle tissue, which means you will lose resting metabolic rate and your

01:10:00.160 --> 01:10:05.740
ability to move around and carry things because it's already declining as we age anyway,

01:10:05.860 --> 01:10:12.180
but calorie deficit will expedite that. And that's where we explain the importance of resistance

01:10:12.180 --> 01:10:16.680
training at some stage. Of course we have a preference. You just do everything all at once,

01:10:16.680 --> 01:10:20.040
but that's not everyone's reality. And you meet the person where they're at

01:10:20.040 --> 01:10:26.820
and prescribe the program that they look at and go, yeah, I can do that. That's workable in my day

01:10:26.820 --> 01:10:31.580
and I can buy in. Then we can have the conversation about resistance training.

01:10:32.300 --> 01:10:35.740
Yeah. Tony, off the cuff, are you seeing a lot of GLP?

01:10:35.740 --> 01:10:35.820
Yeah.

01:10:35.860 --> 01:10:39.440
Ones in your work with your clients or adjacent to your clients or anything?

01:10:39.720 --> 01:10:40.420
Yeah. Yeah, absolutely.

01:10:42.100 --> 01:10:48.320
And any comments, thoughts, anything you want to share with the listeners about?

01:10:48.320 --> 01:10:57.000
I am of the belief that these are really valuable tools in the right place, i.e. where many people

01:10:57.000 --> 01:11:02.380
have tried lifestyle interventions and have worked with dietitians and have tried it on their own

01:11:02.380 --> 01:11:05.740
and found over the long term that

01:11:05.860 --> 01:11:11.060
the food noise and their appetite and their desire to eat was too great and they might lose

01:11:11.060 --> 01:11:16.740
weight and then rebound back again. And in other words, it's not first attempt. It is I've tried

01:11:16.740 --> 01:11:22.140
and I've tried and I've tried. And in those instances, the newer generation seem to be

01:11:22.140 --> 01:11:28.060
working better. I have clients who use the available doctor prescription second generation,

01:11:28.480 --> 01:11:35.140
but most of my clients have already moved to third generation great market and find that even better.

01:11:35.860 --> 01:11:42.540
And obviously, this is all done with other people other than me because I'm not a medico. But

01:11:42.540 --> 01:11:46.660
it's been a great tool that we did not have in our toolbox.

01:11:47.300 --> 01:11:53.460
Yeah. So the gray market in Australia is because it's not that I don't know if it's not talked

01:11:53.460 --> 01:11:58.340
about, but I just don't think it's as accessible here in New Zealand. I know actually a friend of

01:11:58.340 --> 01:12:05.400
mine said a friend of hers shipped in a bunch of peptides from China. I don't know what it's like

01:12:05.400 --> 01:12:05.800
in Australia.

01:12:05.860 --> 01:12:12.440
It all comes from China, but it's just the compounding pharmacists who batch test them

01:12:12.440 --> 01:12:13.800
and then make them.

01:12:14.840 --> 01:12:21.920
Yeah. It's changing the game, I feel, for our industry. And probably I might have even started

01:12:21.920 --> 01:12:28.280
the podcast up with this, but my brain has even forgotten what we discussed. But I feel like

01:12:28.280 --> 01:12:34.600
there's a bit of a lag, actually, in terms of people are seeing these as a magic bullet,

01:12:35.000 --> 01:12:35.800
which of course...

01:12:35.860 --> 01:12:42.100
Because everything is. And you see any of my content, I'm very supportive of GLPs. I think

01:12:42.100 --> 01:12:48.660
they are, in fact, so helpful for so many people. But I feel like for some, they'll latch onto it

01:12:48.660 --> 01:12:56.180
like a magic bullet, knowing that they need the support of diet and of exercise, et cetera.

01:12:56.780 --> 01:13:02.840
But knowing is different from knowing. And in a couple of years' time, there's going to be some

01:13:02.840 --> 01:13:05.400
sort of, I don't know, shift.

01:13:05.400 --> 01:13:05.580
Yeah.

01:13:05.860 --> 01:13:12.800
And we have complementary roles in this. And your work is to provide a framework for healthy

01:13:12.800 --> 01:13:19.760
eating. Mine is to anticipate what will happen from a muscle and bone perspective because of

01:13:19.760 --> 01:13:25.640
the lower energy intake, but also lower protein intake. And that's where we kind of double down

01:13:25.640 --> 01:13:31.360
on the resistance training. And because appetite changes, we'll probably use more protein drinks

01:13:31.360 --> 01:13:35.840
around training just to... I saw you have it. So I know that you have it. So I know that you have it.

01:13:35.860 --> 01:13:36.820
I know that you have it. So I know that you have it. So I know that you have it. So I know that you have it.

01:13:36.820 --> 01:13:37.800
I know that you have it. So I know that you have it. So I know that you have it. So I know that you have it.

01:13:37.800 --> 01:13:41.640
Because I don't know what will happen the rest of the day. And I don't pretend I know anything

01:13:41.640 --> 01:13:47.620
about nutrition. But in terms of the weight training, I usually get people three times a week

01:13:47.620 --> 01:13:54.000
to make sure that they're chronically stimulating muscle. And with that protein interaction,

01:13:54.340 --> 01:13:59.420
that's really the best we can do. And yeah, sometimes we still even see loss of muscle when

01:13:59.420 --> 01:14:04.380
people have lost a lot of weight. And it's just surprising. I can't give them any more weight

01:14:04.380 --> 01:14:04.700
training.

01:14:05.860 --> 01:14:11.640
But sometimes the loss of mass is so great. I mean, I've seen the loss of 70 kilos in one

01:14:11.640 --> 01:14:12.000
individual.

01:14:12.680 --> 01:14:17.820
Wow. And I guess the thing is, it's not all muscle is bad. Not all muscle loss is bad. There is that

01:14:17.820 --> 01:14:20.420
the muscle that...

01:14:20.420 --> 01:14:26.760
How much muscle do you need if you're... I have seen in one individual 120 kilos of lean mass.

01:14:27.380 --> 01:14:29.220
Whoa. Holy moly.

01:14:29.480 --> 01:14:33.940
Yeah. Well, if you think about it, if someone weighs 200 kilos and they're 50% body fat,

01:14:33.940 --> 01:14:35.500
they've still got 100 kilos of muscle mass.

01:14:35.860 --> 01:14:36.500
Yeah. Good point.

01:14:36.500 --> 01:14:41.140
And not many people are 50%. So let's say 40% and there's your 110, 120 kilos.

01:14:41.660 --> 01:14:42.640
Your knees don't need that.

01:14:43.240 --> 01:14:49.880
No, 100%. And I think also just that low energy availability with these drugs. We don't talk

01:14:49.880 --> 01:14:54.360
often enough about how important carbohydrate is for energy. If you have no energy to get in and

01:14:54.360 --> 01:15:00.680
do your workouts, this is where I'm finding myself recommending foods and beverages that I would not

01:15:00.680 --> 01:15:05.400
always recommend. I wouldn't recommend a usual usually, but they're almost like functional

01:15:05.400 --> 01:15:05.840
products.

01:15:06.500 --> 01:15:13.240
They're contact specific and intra-training carbohydrate is a game changer for people on

01:15:13.240 --> 01:15:17.700
GLPs. No question. And my clients bring, they squeeze their own orange juice so that they know

01:15:17.700 --> 01:15:23.360
they're doing it well and they bring it in like a 150 mil and they just drink it. And their work

01:15:23.360 --> 01:15:27.760
output is, I'm not going to exaggerate, it's 50% better.

01:15:28.340 --> 01:15:33.280
Yeah. Amazing. Yeah. Yeah. And so that's, and I think this is, that's, I'm pleased that we're

01:15:33.280 --> 01:15:35.700
just chatting about it. So people listening, if they're in the...

01:15:35.860 --> 01:15:39.080
In this situation and they haven't discussed or thought about that, they're like, oh, actually,

01:15:39.160 --> 01:15:44.420
maybe I'll try that because yeah, it's totally worth it. And, and I think the things that people

01:15:44.420 --> 01:15:50.600
misunderstand about GLPs is that you're still not, you're not after like accelerated fat loss.

01:15:51.140 --> 01:15:53.820
You know, you don't want to lose weight as quickly as possible, even though that

01:15:53.820 --> 01:16:00.880
appears to happen. Like that's not the goal. The goal is to lose weight and, and, and find ways

01:16:00.880 --> 01:16:05.280
and find and change your behaviors. You can keep it off medication or not. It's not

01:16:05.280 --> 01:16:12.800
a race to the bottom. Couldn't agree. Yeah. Yeah. Nice one, Tony. So now I guess I'm looking

01:16:12.800 --> 01:16:17.680
at the time. Our time is sort of coming up. Obviously you've got a PhD that you're writing

01:16:17.680 --> 01:16:23.000
right now, but, but tell the listeners just sort of what's, what you've got going on in terms of

01:16:23.000 --> 01:16:28.060
how they may be able to work with you or from a practitioner perspective or from a client

01:16:28.060 --> 01:16:32.040
perspective, if you're still got a lot of that going on, that would be really helpful. And of

01:16:32.040 --> 01:16:34.880
course your podcast. Yeah, it's a great,

01:16:35.280 --> 01:16:42.140
uh, diverse work schedule that I have. I still coach three days a week, all day. So Tuesday,

01:16:42.220 --> 01:16:48.320
Wednesday, Thursday, I am on the tools from morning to night. And then the other four days

01:16:48.320 --> 01:16:54.300
in the week, uh, weekends are overrated. I, yeah, I'm, I'm doing a completely different field,

01:16:54.320 --> 01:16:59.760
but I have the podcast stronger with time where I try and bring people who social media have no,

01:16:59.760 --> 01:17:05.260
never heard of because they're usually leading in the field and often don't know what social,

01:17:05.280 --> 01:17:11.460
so I interview these people and try and bring, uh, them and give them a platform because I think

01:17:11.460 --> 01:17:16.680
they need to be heard. Uh, I run my own courses designed mainly for personal trainers and general

01:17:16.680 --> 01:17:22.200
public individuals on everything from fat loss to menopause to, uh, resistance training program

01:17:22.200 --> 01:17:29.580
design. And I do a lot of academic writing, some meta-analyses reviews, um, those kinds of things

01:17:29.580 --> 01:17:34.800
as well. Uh, we're editing a book on personal training, which you are involved in as well.

01:17:35.280 --> 01:17:38.740
Right. A matter of fact, do you know what? I forgot about that. I cannot wait. That'll be

01:17:38.740 --> 01:17:45.220
great. It's exciting. And, uh, and just wrapping up a major review, uh, with an all-star team of

01:17:45.220 --> 01:17:52.420
writers on resistance training for women across the lifespan, uh, that looks at bone and muscle

01:17:52.420 --> 01:17:58.440
and strength and power, menopause transition, older individuals, adolescence, menopause,

01:17:58.440 --> 01:18:04.340
I think I said menopause and the menstrual cycle. So who's who in each field is contributing that

01:18:04.340 --> 01:18:05.260
section and that,

01:18:05.280 --> 01:18:08.680
it's going to be all wrapped up by the, hopefully by the end of this month.

01:18:09.440 --> 01:18:12.460
Amazing. And then of course it goes to peer review and then it will be published.

01:18:12.960 --> 01:18:13.440
Yeah, that's right.

01:18:13.800 --> 01:18:18.580
Cannot wait. Tony, thank you so much for your time. Um, I always enjoy chatting to you. You're

01:18:18.580 --> 01:18:21.880
such a wealth of information and for the information that you're putting out there,

01:18:21.960 --> 01:18:26.100
just adding some clarity. Um, it's really well appreciated. So thanks so much.

01:18:26.100 --> 01:18:26.700
Thanks, Mikki.

01:18:35.280 --> 01:18:45.360
Alrighty. Hopefully you enjoyed that. As I said, I always enjoy chatting to Tony. It's like catching

01:18:45.360 --> 01:18:51.320
up with a mate and he really has a great perspective on all things in this field. So I'm

01:18:51.320 --> 01:18:56.740
always curious as to sort of hear what he's working on and, and how he's updated any of his

01:18:56.740 --> 01:19:02.820
sort of thinking as, you know, new science emerges as he does. So, um, that's it from me this week,

01:19:02.880 --> 01:19:03.500
guys. Hit me up over on Instagram and I'll see you in the next one. Bye.

01:19:03.500 --> 01:19:03.520
Bye.

01:19:03.520 --> 01:19:03.580
Bye.

01:19:03.580 --> 01:19:03.600
Bye.

01:19:03.600 --> 01:19:03.640
Bye.

01:19:03.640 --> 01:19:03.700
Bye.

01:19:03.700 --> 01:19:03.720
Bye.

01:19:03.720 --> 01:19:03.740
Bye.

01:19:03.740 --> 01:19:03.760
Bye.

01:19:03.760 --> 01:19:03.820
Bye.

01:19:05.280 --> 01:19:05.360
Bye.

01:19:05.780 --> 01:19:05.900
Bye.

01:19:05.920 --> 01:19:06.000
Bye.

01:19:06.800 --> 01:19:06.860
Bye.

01:19:06.860 --> 01:19:07.120
Bye.

01:19:08.700 --> 01:19:08.800
Bye.

01:19:08.800 --> 01:19:08.840
Bye.

01:19:09.580 --> 01:19:09.660
Bye.

01:19:09.660 --> 01:19:09.680
Bye.

01:19:09.680 --> 01:19:09.700
Bye.

01:19:09.700 --> 01:19:09.720
Bye.

01:19:10.020 --> 01:19:10.160
Bye.

01:19:10.160 --> 01:19:10.320
Bye.

01:19:10.320 --> 01:19:10.360
Bye.

01:19:10.360 --> 01:19:10.540
Bye.

01:19:10.600 --> 01:19:10.800
Bye.

01:19:11.120 --> 01:19:11.260
Bye.

01:19:11.260 --> 01:19:11.400
Bye.

01:19:11.400 --> 01:19:11.520
Bye.

01:19:11.520 --> 01:19:11.980
Bye.

01:19:11.980 --> 01:19:12.200
Bye.

01:19:12.200 --> 01:19:12.400
Bye.

01:19:12.400 --> 01:19:16.460
And if you are short on inspiration, why not sign up to my recipe portal?

01:19:16.820 --> 01:19:22.380
12 bucks a month, you get access to a thousand or more recipes, actually.

01:19:22.740 --> 01:19:27.720
Huge number of recipes that I've collated over the years and it's constantly being updated.

01:19:28.120 --> 01:19:32.700
You know, just for some nice macro-friendly, high-protein, moderate to low-carb meals.

01:19:33.340 --> 01:19:33.940
Why don't you do it?

01:19:34.200 --> 01:19:34.940
Love that.

01:19:35.080 --> 01:19:35.260
Bye.

01:19:35.280 --> 01:19:36.820
All right, guys, you have the best week.

01:19:37.040 --> 01:19:37.440
See you later.