Alice Pemberton: In nineteen eleven, Cornwall’s Doom Bar wrecks two ships in a single day, the Island Maid and the Angele. Alice Pemberton: In nineteen fifty-five, William F. Buckley Junior launches National Review, giving the American conservative movement a national platform. Alice Pemberton: In nineteen ninety-nine, John Carpenter becomes the first top-prize winner on Who Wants to Be a Millionaire? Alice Pemberton: This is The Long Echo for the nineteenth of November. I'm Alice Pemberton. History doesn't repeat itself — but it echoes. Alice Pemberton: In this edition: Edmund Cavendish catches the almanacs out on Saint Peter's Basilica; Arthur Nightingale opens Franz Schubert's last letter; Judge Marion Calloway on the one sentence that made Afghanistan a member; Rufus McCrae on the Jay Treaty; and Eleanor Shaw, Hugo Carr and Beth Hartley on the Moon, a penalty and a man sued by his own name. Let's begin. Alice Pemberton: Every almanac says the new Saint Peter's Basilica in Rome was consecrated on this day in sixteen forty-six. For the front page, our professor of history, Edmund Cavendish, says the almanacs are wrong. Edmund? Professor Edmund Cavendish: Wrong by twenty years and a day. The surviving records put the consecration of Saint Peter's on the eighteenth of November, sixteen twenty-six, under Pope Urban the Eighth. On the vigil, Urban ordered a fast. Then the clergy and religious of Rome walked in solemn procession from the church of San Marco to the new basilica. Alice Pemberton: More than a century in the making — what had they built? Professor Edmund Cavendish: Pope Julius the Second laid the first stone in fifteen-oh-six. The site was already sacred: Constantine's basilica, raised in the fourth century over the tomb tradition holds is Peter's own. Bramante, Michelangelo and Maderno shaped its replacement, and it is still the largest church in the world by interior measure. Alice Pemberton: And why the eighteenth? Professor Edmund Cavendish: Because it was already Saint Peter's birthday. The old basilica's dedication feast fell on that day — written into its service books around the year one thousand, and credited by tradition to Pope Sylvester, in Constantine's own time. Rome swept Constantine's church away. It kept the birthday. Alice Pemberton: On this day in eighteen twenty-eight, Franz Schubert died in his brother's flat in Vienna. He left over a thousand works that only a small circle had ever heard. For the biographical sketch, our storyteller, Arthur Nightingale. Arthur? Arthur Nightingale: A small circle — and Franz Schubert's last surviving letter went to one of them, his friend Franz von Schober, received a week before the end. 'Lieber Schober! Ich bin krank.' Dear Schober, I am ill. 'I have eaten nothing and drunk nothing for eleven days, and I wander, weak and unsteady, from chair to bed.' Arthur Nightingale: He began as the twelfth child of a parish schoolmaster in a Vienna suburb. His father taught him violin, his elder brother piano, and the boy soon outplayed them both. At eleven he won a place at the Stadtkonvikt school, where he met Haydn, Mozart and Beethoven on the music stand. Later he studied with Salieri — while training, dutifully, to be a schoolteacher. Alice Pemberton: And Vienna noticed him? Arthur Nightingale: Barely. Schubert poured out more than six hundred songs — the Erlkönig, the Winterreise cycle — and the Unfinished Symphony. Yet he gave a public concert of his own works only once, in the March of his final year, to real acclaim. Eight months later he was gone. Alice Pemberton: Gone of what? Arthur Nightingale: Officially typhoid; some historians suspect syphilis. The death register wrote 'nervous fever'. His father's notice ran two days later: 'my beloved son Franz Schubert, artist and composer, died after a short illness.' It took Mendelssohn, Schumann, Liszt and Brahms to dig out what Vienna had missed. Franz Schubert was given one concert. History has been playing the encore ever since. Alice Pemberton: On this day in nineteen forty-six, the Kingdom of Afghanistan joined the United Nations — not by a vote, but by a letter. From the archive, our jurist, Judge Marion Calloway. Marion? Judge Marion Calloway: By a letter, because the vote was only half of it. The Security Council recommended Afghanistan that August, alongside Iceland and Sweden. The General Assembly admitted all three early in November. But under the Assembly's provisional rules, membership began only on the day a state handed the Secretary-General its instrument of adherence. Alice Pemberton: And what did Afghanistan's say? Judge Marion Calloway: Its Minister in Washington delivered it, and the heart of it is one sentence: 'The Kingdom of Afghanistan hereby states that it accepts the obligations contained in the Charter of the United Nations.' No ceremony. A kingdom bound itself to the world's rulebook in a single line. Alice Pemberton: And the kingdom? Judge Marion Calloway: Its monarchy lasted almost half a century, until a coup in nineteen seventy-three. Then came the Soviet invasion, civil war, the Taliban, an American-led invasion, and the Taliban again. The kingdom that signed is gone, and the government in Kabul is one most of the world refuses to recognise. In law, a state's promise outlives its rulers. Nobody has settled who is entitled to keep it. Alice Pemberton: On this day in seventeen ninety-four, in London, John Jay and Lord Grenville signed the Jay Treaty — keeping America out of a war with Britain and starting a fight at home. For the chamber, our resident sceptic, Rufus McCrae. Rufus? Rufus McCrae: A fight that began with a covering letter. Jay, then Chief Justice of the United States, wrote home the same day: 'The long expected Treaty accompanies this letter.' The talks, he admits, 'frequently had the appearance of being insurmountable,' and the two men were reconciled to 'an unusual degree of Trouble and Application.' That is diplomatic prose for: we nearly threw the inkwell. Alice Pemberton: And what did all that trouble buy? Rufus McCrae: Britain agreed to quit the Northwest forts it had clung to since the peace that ended the Revolution. American merchants got a foot in the British West Indies. And the quarrels over war debts and the border went to arbitration — one of the first great uses of it in modern diplomacy, and a precedent other nations took up. Alice Pemberton: And the fight? Rufus McCrae: France was furious, and Americans split: Hamilton's Federalists for the Jay Treaty, the Democratic-Republicans against — the seed of the country's first party system. The Senate ratified it twenty votes to ten. Not one vote to spare. One senator changes his mind, and the peace goes with him. Alice Pemberton: On this day the record runs from a Pennsylvania graveyard to the Ocean of Storms. At the table: our narrative historian, Hugo Carr; our diplomacy hand, former ambassador Eleanor Shaw; and our culture correspondent, Beth Hartley. Hugo — the graveyard. Hugo Carr: A graveyard with a headliner. In eighteen sixty-three they dedicated the Soldiers' National Cemetery at Gettysburg, and the star was Edward Everett. He spoke for two hours. The organiser, David Wills, asked Abraham Lincoln for just 'a few appropriate remarks.' Those remarks became the Gettysburg Address. Everett, nobody quotes. Eleanor Shaw: Every diplomat should frame that invitation. In nineteen thirty-three, Spanish women voted in a general election for the first time, after Clara Campoamor fought her own allies for it, reportedly asking: 'Have they not already fought for the Republic?' A right-wing coalition won. You hand people a vote; you don't get to choose how they use it. Beth Hartley: Samuel Goldwyn chose his own name — sort of. Born Szmuel Gelbfisz in Warsaw, he was Samuel Goldfish, ex-glove salesman, when he founded a studio with the Selwyn brothers in nineteen sixteen: Gold from Goldfish, wyn from Selwyn. He then took the company's name as his own. Within a few years, Goldwyn Pictures was in federal court against Samuel Goldwyn. Hugo Carr: Out-branded by his own letterhead. Eleanor Shaw: Mine's further off. In nineteen sixty-nine, Apollo Twelve set Pete Conrad and Alan Bean down in the Ocean of Storms. Conrad, coming in: 'Hey, there it is! There it is! Son-of-a-gun!' They became the third and fourth humans on the Moon. They'd parked within walking distance of an unmanned probe, Surveyor, so they strolled over and brought pieces of it home. Beth Hartley: Lunar litter-picking. Very tidy. Hugo Carr: Same day, same year, in Rio's Maracanã: Pelé of Santos was fouled in the box against Vasco da Gama. He took the penalty himself and scored his thousandth goal. The keeper, Edgardo Andrada, guessed right and got a hand to it. His memory of it: 'The noise was deafening.' Alice Pemberton: A short speech that outlived a long one, a vote that surprised its champion, a name that sued its owner — history does love an understudy. Thank you, all three. Alice Pemberton: Well, that was the day that was — the nineteenth of November — where in nineteen forty-four President Franklin Roosevelt opened a war-bond drive aimed at fourteen billion dollars to pay for the war; where in eighteen sixteen the University of Warsaw was founded, giving the Polish capital a university of its own; and, more recently, where in nineteen seventy-nine Ayatollah Khomeini ordered the women and the Black Americans among the hostages in Tehran set free. The echo never stops. Neither do we. See you tomorrow. Humphrey Thwaite: What they didn't tell you: on this day in four sixty-one, a Sardinian called Hilarius was consecrated Pope. Twelve years earlier, as a papal envoy at a council in Ephesus, he blocked the condemnation of Flavian of Constantinople with one Latin word — 'Contradicitur' — then slipped past guards watching the roads and the docks. Mortimer Finch: One word and a getaway. And with a name like Hilarius, I was hoping for jokes. Humphrey Thwaite: He spent his papacy enforcing canon law in Gaul and Spain. Mortimer Finch: So — no.