{
  "version": "1.0.0",
  "segments": [
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "0.0",
      "endTime": "16.64",
      "body": "And then you ask, well, why does he hide himself? And Pascal would say something like this. He would say, well, because God isn't interested in being the kind of God that you can just sort of say, okay, I believe in God, take that off, get on with the rest of my life. As if God shows himself in that way."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Joe Weller",
      "startTime": "18.8",
      "endTime": "20.96",
      "body": "Yeah, but what I'm saying is because"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Alex O'Connor",
      "startTime": "20.96",
      "endTime": "23.44",
      "body": "I haven't felt anything like that or I haven't seen that kind of thing."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Joe Weller",
      "startTime": "23.6",
      "endTime": "27.55",
      "body": "The position open to it, have you like gone looking for it, have you ever have you know, gone down that path."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Alex O'Connor",
      "startTime": "27.79",
      "endTime": "36.51",
      "body": "Yeah, you know, like to the extent that I it's difficult to know because a lot of people say, well, you think you're trying, but you're not open enough. And I think I've tried. I really, really think I've tried."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Joe Weller",
      "startTime": "36.59",
      "endTime": "38.35",
      "body": "And how did you try?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "38.75",
      "endTime": "75.11",
      "body": "That's a clip from the Wafflin podcast. We do a lot of wafflin in this one too. It's a comedy talk show hosted by internet personalities Joe Weller, Theo Baker, and Luke Martin. Their guest is another super popular podcaster. Alex O'Connor, also known as the cosmic skeptic. We've mentioned him before because he's one of Gen Z's most prominent atheists. Now that conversation is from late 2025, and towards the end, they start to talk about what it means to open up about God."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Alex O'Connor",
      "startTime": "75.99",
      "endTime": "92.74",
      "body": "You kind of have to be convinced that something exists in order to surrender to it. Like if I said, you know, will you surrender yourself to the police officer outside? and you're like, I don't think there is a police officer outside. I'm like, we'll just surrender to him anyway. You'd be like, I kind of literally can't because if I don't believe he's there, I can't like surrender to him."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Joe Weller",
      "startTime": "93.06",
      "endTime": "106.34",
      "body": "Isn't that everyone who everyone who does start believing or sort of surrenders to God has to come from a place of not surrendering to God. So until you've surrendered and until you've actually done it, you can't go, I know for sure that there is a group."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Alex O'Connor",
      "startTime": "106.66",
      "endTime": "117.08",
      "body": "Yeah, but that for me is the great catch 22, which is that I th I feel like I need to think that the thing exists in order to s to surrender to it, but I'm a caveman surrender to it in order to think that it exists."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Joe Weller",
      "startTime": "117.32",
      "endTime": "131.4",
      "body": "If you were a caveman though and you were told like, mate, there's this like Wi-Fi that's gonna let you FaceTime your friend around the world right now, you'd be like, mate, I can't see what Wi-Fi? I can't see that. That can't exist. I it's not tangible. I can't see it. I don't believe it's there."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Joe Weller",
      "startTime": "131.56",
      "endTime": "146.26",
      "body": "So therefore I'm not even gonna try and like FaceTime my friend because what even is that? It's like that caveman can't comprehend the Wi-Fi concept. So what I wonder is that like because we can't comprehend, or we say we can't comprehend something, because our brain is limited, we can't figure everything out."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Alex O'Connor",
      "startTime": "146.34",
      "endTime": "146.98",
      "body": "Yeah."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Joe Weller",
      "startTime": "147.3",
      "endTime": "151.46",
      "body": "Just shutting off and going, I can't comprehend it, therefore it doesn't exist is that But"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Alex O'Connor",
      "startTime": "151.54",
      "endTime": "153.7",
      "body": "okay, so suppose I do hear what you're saying."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "154.1",
      "endTime": "200.79",
      "body": "O'Connor admits that God might exist, but he can't comprehend exactly what God is, let alone how he might surrender to such a thing. And this lands us squarely at the heavy wooden desk of the 17th century polymath Pascal. Blaise Pascal. Now, if you've heard of Pascal at all, you would have associated it with what's called Pascal's wager. And in the popular imagination, the wager says you might as well bet on God existing, because there's more to gain if you end up being right, and less to lose if you're wrong. So bet on God."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "201.51",
      "endTime": "233.29",
      "body": "And if you can't believe, fake it until you make it. That's Alex O'Connor's problem. He says he can't fake it. Critics mock Pascal's wager because You can't strong arm anyone into believing something. You can't make yourself believe in something. And certainly fear isn't the best reason to believe in anything. Like fear of God being true and you going to hell is not a super good reason to believe in God."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "233.77",
      "endTime": "271.67",
      "body": "But my guest today reckons we've misunderstood both Pascal's wager and Pascal's larger significance and his amazing writings. Blaise Pascal was way more than his wager. He was a groundbreaking scientist, mathematician, physicist, philosopher, polemicist, and theologian. He helped invent probability theory. We'll hear more about that too. He demonstrated the existence of a vacuum, He conducted pioneering scientific experiments and he built one of the earliest mechanical calculators."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "271.91",
      "endTime": "294.28",
      "body": "And he left behind notes, thousands of notes, for what would become one of the most compelling defenses of the Christian faith ever written. The pensei, the thoughts of Blaise Pascal. So let's look deeper. I'm John Dixon and this is Underceptions."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "311.24",
      "endTime": "326.47",
      "body": "Graeme, thanks so much. Tell us about the 17th century. You call it the great century. But what do we need to know about 17th century Europe before we introduce this extraordinary figure?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "326.87",
      "endTime": "336.23",
      "body": "Yeah, well, the 17th century was just a really important hinge century really from the kind of pre-modern to the modern world."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "336.55",
      "endTime": "364.44",
      "body": "That's Graham Tomlin, a British theologian and director of the Centre for Cultural Witness in Oxford. He taught historical theology at the University of Oxford for several years and then served as the Bishop of Kensington from 2015 to 2022. He's the author of several books, including Luther's Gospel, Reimagining the World, and his most recent book, 2025, just called Blaise Pascal, The Man Who Made the Modern World."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "364.76",
      "endTime": "392.51",
      "body": "So if you if you think of the 16th century, you've got these great movements, the Renaissance from the 14th through the 15th, 16th century, the kind of revival of learning in Europe, the kind of emergence from the Middle Ages. You've got the Reformation, the Protestant Reformation, and the great move of kind of Martin Luther and John Calvin and the kind of division of European Christendom in that kind of way and then you get the Catholic response to that in the Council of Trent and others."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "393.15",
      "endTime": "408.17",
      "body": "So you've got a, if you like, a all these changes that are happening in terms of learning and culture. But you've also got at the same time a great growth in scientific exploration that comes at the beginning of the 17th century."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "408.25",
      "endTime": "427.99",
      "body": "So the 17th century is one of those periods where an awful lot is changing in terms of our knowledge of the world, our awareness of our place within it. You've also got the great voyages of discovery because the 16th, 17th century was a period where we were discovering continents that in i from Europe's point of view we didn't know existed."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "428.15",
      "endTime": "447.99",
      "body": "And so it's a it's a kind of era of great expansion of our understanding of ourselves, our understanding of the world, and great religious changes at the same time. And so, you know, Europe in 1650 is very different from Europe in 1500, and that's really part of the background to Pascal's life."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "448.46",
      "endTime": "484.45",
      "body": "I spoke with Graham for almost an hour. It was wonderful. But not everything can fit into a single episode. So dear producer Kaylee has collected a bunch of extras from our conversation and she's locked them in her playbox, otherwise known as underceptions.com forward slash club. If you're already a member, you're gonna get all that seamlessly. If you're not, you know what to do. British historian Tom Holland, friend of the pod, calls Pascal the 17th century's supreme polymath."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "484.93",
      "endTime": "500.77",
      "body": "But strangely, he didn't have any formal schooling. He was educated at home by his dad, and he never went on to a university. He was a child prodigy, particularly when it came to mathematics."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "501.18",
      "endTime": "520.06",
      "body": "But the thing that really sort of got him on the map intellectually, if you like, was a series of experiments that Pascal did in 1648, which were experiments on the existence of a vacuum. One of the big questions around in sort of mathematical philosophical circles at the time was, is there such a thing as a vacuum?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "520.3",
      "endTime": "539.85",
      "body": "And because philosophically, before that, people had tended to think there can't be. There can't be nothing. There can't be a space where there is literally nothing. And on the basis of classical philosophy, even on the basis of sort of Aristotle and Augustine's thought, you might conclude that there is no such thing as a vacuum."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "540.01",
      "endTime": "569.89",
      "body": "But Pascal and Descartes, for example, one of, you know, Pascal's contemporary, Descartes' a little bit older than Pascal, he thought there could not be, in principle, such a thing as a vacuum. But Pascal took a different approach to it. His approach to science was really more experimental. And he believed that what you did is you did experiments and tried to work out what's the best explanation of the of the results you get from an experiment. And so in 1648 he devised this experiment."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "570.69",
      "endTime": "591.89",
      "body": "Descartes thought that he thought of it first, but there was a bit of a despite a bit of a kind of argument between them about it about it. But Pascal devised this experiment, which involved carrying tubes of mercury up a hill, near Claremore where he lived, because there was hills around that, and taking measurements at different levels up the mountain."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "592.69",
      "endTime": "605.65",
      "body": "And, you know, the mercury w mercury would be suspended in a tube, and he they took the measurements, and basically as a result of this experiment, Pascal kind of proved that there was such a thing as a vacuum."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "605.81",
      "endTime": "643.54",
      "body": "And Pascal himself was quite ill at the time, he spent a lot of time sick during his life, wasn't able to participate in the experiment, but he designed it, he tested it out in various places, and this was and he w he published the results, and that was quite again quite a new thing. Sometimes it's been said that this experiment is the first modern experiment, in the sense that it was a carefully designed the results repeated over several times to check accuracy, published for all people to sort of see and check, and then it it's results tested to see whether they were accurate or not."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "643.7",
      "endTime": "656.58",
      "body": "And so that was the thing that really brought him to public attention, these experiments on the vacuum. Then he published them in a series of treaties around that time and that got him attention throughout the whole of Europe at the time."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Voice Actor",
      "startTime": "658.25",
      "endTime": "695.28",
      "body": "Christie's suspends Paris sale of world's first calculator. Christie's Auction House said on Wednesday, November 19, 2025, that it was suspending the Paris auction of one of just a handful of examples of the world's first calculating machine, developed by French mathematician and inventor Blaise Pascal, in 1642. The auction of La Pascaline had been scheduled for Wednesday afternoon, but late on Tuesday a Paris court suspended its export authorization, meaning buyers would not be able to take it abroad."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Voice Actor",
      "startTime": "695.52",
      "endTime": "731.1",
      "body": "This example is one of only nine still existing, and the only one believed to be in private hands. Others are held in museums. Christie's had dubbed the box, decorated with ebony, as the most important scientific instrument ever offered at auction, and it was expected to fetch 2 to 3 million euros. Scientists and researchers had urgently appealed to the administrative court to block the potential export of the machine. They want the instrument to be classified as a national treasure. Le Mond newspaper 2025."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "731.84",
      "endTime": "756.88",
      "body": "He was a bit of an entrepreneur and so one of the other things he did was again that got him quite well known at the time was to create a this extraordinary calculating machine. His father was as was a tax official and it was quite a controversial thing at the time because taxes are never popular but they were particularly unpopular at the time because they were going to fund some very unpopular wars that the King of France was waging at the time."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "757.12",
      "endTime": "776.34",
      "body": "And So his father would be kind of agonizing over these tax calculations and what tax people should be paying and so Pascal saw his father kind of being anxious about this. And so thought, well maybe I can think of a machine that will help him do the ta tax calculations."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "776.42",
      "endTime": "791.17",
      "body": "And so he built this thing called which he called the Pascaline, which was a which was actually quite a beautiful piece of engineering, which had all sort of little wheels on it and every time, you know, every time you add a number, the wheel goes around, then the next wheel goes around, then the next wheel goes around."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "791.33",
      "endTime": "813.01",
      "body": "And when the story of the development of the digital computer is told, obviously Pascal's calculating machine is often part of that story. It was one of the very first functioning calculating machines that worked and it could have to do addition, subtraction, multiplication, up to around, you know, tens and hundreds of millions. So it was a brilliant piece of work."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "813.34",
      "endTime": "846.59",
      "body": "I asked Graham a few more questions about the scientific and mathematical brilliance of Blaise Pascal, and then I remembered an Australian mate who works down the road from where we were and who more than dabbles in probability mathematics. So I did a kind of live phone a friend, or a West Wing walk and talk, with Sam Cohen, professor of mathematics and fellow of New College at the University of Oxford. Is it graduation day or something? Is that what's going on there?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "846.75",
      "endTime": "848.19",
      "body": "Last week. Last week was graduations."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "848.67",
      "endTime": "849.71",
      "body": "What's the big ceremony in there?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "849.79",
      "endTime": "851.47",
      "body": "I've got no idea. Okay. It's always something going"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "851.47",
      "endTime": "851.47",
      "body": "on."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "851.63",
      "endTime": "862.99",
      "body": "There's always something going on. Okay, Sam, so you're a mathematician and can you confirm for my audience that maths is maths?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "863.23",
      "endTime": "864.35",
      "body": "Well, what else would it be?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "864.51",
      "endTime": "864.91",
      "body": "Maths."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "865.07",
      "endTime": "887.43",
      "body": "Well the no the thing is, so maths, when you're talking about maths in the abstract, although One thing that's been pointed out to me when just similar discussions we've had in the department about this is about when you've got maths in something like mathematical biology or mathematical finance, then it's math, because you're briefing a mathematical and so it's math, bio or math finance."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "887.75",
      "endTime": "890.15",
      "body": "So mathematics equals maths. Maths."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "890.23",
      "endTime": "891.99",
      "body": "A mathematical goes to math."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "892.23",
      "endTime": "896.87",
      "body": "Okay. Good. Well Nessosystem. Yeah, from an Oxford professor of math."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "897.11",
      "endTime": "899.18",
      "body": "Yep. No, no."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "899.42",
      "endTime": "900.7",
      "body": "What's what's your particular field?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "900.94",
      "endTime": "910.06",
      "body": "So in probability theory, a lot of applications to do with finance, engineering problems, a lot of AI theory, this type of work at the moment."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "910.22",
      "endTime": "915.82",
      "body": "Wow. So probability, that's something I'm pretty sure I remember Pascal was into."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "916.06",
      "endTime": "916.86",
      "body": "He was one of the first."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "917.1",
      "endTime": "921.18",
      "body": "Okay, so tell me about his connection to the whole idea of probability."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "921.42",
      "endTime": "942.79",
      "body": "Yeah, so he was writing to Pierre de Fermat, the same guy who did the Fermat's last theorem. firm up. And they wrote some letters to each other particularly about how do you divide up the stakes if you're in the middle of a game and you get interrupted. So if you're a cricket fan, Duckworth Lewis, how do you decide what the score should be when rain interrupts play?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "943.03",
      "endTime": "946.07",
      "body": "Same with Have you got a baseball analogy for the third of the audience?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "946.39",
      "endTime": "950.47",
      "body": "I think baseball it would be something like calculating the win probability in the middle of the game."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "950.71",
      "endTime": "950.95",
      "body": "Got it."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "951.91",
      "endTime": "960.58",
      "body": "Nothing exactly the same in baseball. Sure. Yeah, so they're writing about this and trying to figure out and they were the first to do that in a proper mathematical way. Mm-hmm."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "961.86",
      "endTime": "963.14",
      "body": "Have we just come to your office?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "963.3",
      "endTime": "963.54",
      "body": "Yes."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "963.7",
      "endTime": "967.86",
      "body": "I mean it's not I have to go like this. Tell us about your office, mate."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "968.1",
      "endTime": "968.9",
      "body": "It's an old barn."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "969.14",
      "endTime": "970.34",
      "body": "I mean, it looks like you're in a barn, yeah."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "970.58",
      "endTime": "971.14",
      "body": "It is a barn."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "971.22",
      "endTime": "971.38",
      "body": "Yeah."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "971.54",
      "endTime": "973.06",
      "body": "It's a barn from 1402."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "973.38",
      "endTime": "980.14",
      "body": "So did Pascal have a big influence? Did he kick off this Probability studies?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "980.62",
      "endTime": "1003.1",
      "body": "So he had a big influence in a variety of things. So he was working on physics, he's working on mathematics, and this was one of the first people to try and do probability. And that then got picked up by others. So there's this whole sequence of people, particularly in France, writing about probability, then in Russia and then into the 20th century where it becomes a modern, rigorous mathematical area."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1003.42",
      "endTime": "1004.14",
      "body": "Was he good?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "1004.38",
      "endTime": "1004.78",
      "body": "Yeah."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1005.1",
      "endTime": "1008.91",
      "body": "Pascal was good? Yeah. I mean for his 17th century context and etcetera etc."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "1009.15",
      "endTime": "1015.15",
      "body": "He's very he's very geometric. He likes arguing things with geometry. That's what he considers real maths."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1015.47",
      "endTime": "1015.87",
      "body": "Yes."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Voice Actor",
      "startTime": "1019.71",
      "endTime": "1063.0",
      "body": "Fire. God of Abraham. God of Isaac. God of Jacob, not of the philosophers and of the learned. Certitude. Certitude. Feeling. joy, peace. God of Jesus Christ, my God and your God, your God will be my God, forgetfulness of the world and of everything except God. He is only found by the ways taught in the gospel. Grandeur of the human soul. Righteous Father, the world has not known you, but I have known you. Joy, joy, joy, tears of joy."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1063.85",
      "endTime": "1097.95",
      "body": "On the night of Monday, twenty third of November, from about half past ten to half past midnight, Blaise Pascal had an extraordinary experience that would change the trajectory of his life. He had a vision of sorts, and then he scribbled it down on a piece of parchment that he sewed into the lining of his coat to keep it close to his heart, I suppose. It became known as Pascal's Memorial, and the night vision was called Pascal's Night of Fire."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Voice Actor",
      "startTime": "1099.23",
      "endTime": "1124.45",
      "body": "I have departed from him. They have forsaken me, the fount of living water. My God, will you leave me? Let me not be separated from him forever. This is eternal life that they know you, the one true God, and the one that you sent, Jesus Christ. Jesus Christ. Jesus Christ. I left him."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Voice Actor",
      "startTime": "1125.01",
      "endTime": "1151.84",
      "body": "I fled him, renounced, crucified. Let me never be separated from him. He is only kept securely by the ways taught in the gospel. Renunciation. total and sweet. Complete submission to Jesus Christ and to my director. Eternally in joy for a day's exercise on the earth, not to forget your words. Amen."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1152.88",
      "endTime": "1193.19",
      "body": "Disillusioned with the cultural Christianity that he saw all around him in France, Blaise Pascal was drawn to the Jansenists. This is a group sometimes described as the Catholic Puritans. They were into uber devotion to Jesus. I spoke with Graham more about Blaise Pascal's religious background, which club members can hear much more about in the extended episode. Meanwhile, Pascal was becoming famous in Paris for his scientific and mathematical achievements, so he found himself torn between science and spiritual devotion, until the night of fire."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1193.96",
      "endTime": "1216.92",
      "body": "We only or his friends only learnt of, I guess, the seriousness of a spiritual conversion. After his death, one of his carers was looking after his body and taking off his clothes and noticed a piece of paper sewn into a jacket. Tell us about that."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1217.44",
      "endTime": "1234.56",
      "body": "Yeah, well, this story goes, as you say, he when he died, and he died age thirty-nine, he wasn't old when he died, and they were preparing his body for burial, and one of the servants who was doing the work felt something in the jacket and opened it up and inside were actually two pe two pieces of paper."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1234.72",
      "endTime": "1251.07",
      "body": "And on these two pieces of paper was a very similar account of an ex of s of a an experience, and it's dated, 30th of November, 1654. We know exactly the date, and even times it. between half past ten in the evening and half past midnight. So it lasted for two hours."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1252.35",
      "endTime": "1280.25",
      "body": "And this document is called the often called the Memorial. And it describes a really vivid encounter that Pascal had with God. And it describes this experience of God, which is a which was a very powerful one for Pascal. And As you say, he told no one about it. No one knew about it until they discovered this document with the date and the time on it."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1280.41",
      "endTime": "1313.14",
      "body": "And if you like looking back, I think his friends thought, oh, that kind of makes some sense because something shifted around that period of time. And I think what was happening until that point was that he was wrestling with this kind of calling to be an intellectual figure. popular within the salons of Paris. Everybody wanted to hear from Pascal. He was famous because of the experiments he'd done on the vacuum, the kind of mathematical works that he'd done, his work on probability theory and so many other things."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1313.46",
      "endTime": "1337.3",
      "body": "But on the other hand, there was his sister Jacqueline, who joined the convent and had shut herself off from the world, and the Jansenists who were saying, No, you must leave behind that world and join this world of intense devotion. And he really struggled with these two things in his mind. Anyway, you look back at that period up to 1654 and you can see some of the wrestling going on in his own mind, in his own thought."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1338.18",
      "endTime": "1349.06",
      "body": "And this experience seems to have just shifted things for him. This very powerful experience of the presence of God. And I think it shifted in two particular ways."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1349.62",
      "endTime": "1381.93",
      "body": "One thing it didn't do, it didn't mean that he left off all his scientific and philosophical and mathematical works altogether he still did those he still is involved in that kind of world but they take a lesser place in his life than they did before what you do find is two particular things happened to Pascal from that time number one is that he finds this new devotion to the poor he finds himself drawn to the experience of people who live in real poverty."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1382.01",
      "endTime": "1386.01",
      "body": "And there were many people who lived in poverty in Paris and in France at the time."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1394.81",
      "endTime": "1400.01",
      "body": "He also invented buses. So the bus story you mentioned is towards the end of his life."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1401.31",
      "endTime": "1419.55",
      "body": "you became very concerned for the poor of Paris, poor people in Paris. And Paris grew in size. It doubled in size in the first half of the 17th century, which is fine for the rich, they could get around in their carriages, but if you were poor, that was a problem. How do you get from one place to another? If your family were living in the north, you were living in the south, how do you visit them?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1419.63",
      "endTime": "1440.79",
      "body": "And so Pascal had this idea, what if we bought up a series of carriages and you get them to go from point A to point B and various stops along the way. And if you were poor, you could get on a carriage, you could pay a small amount of money. The figure was cinq sous, five cents, if you like, and there was it was called the carrosse à Sax Saint-Sol."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1441.35",
      "endTime": "1455.67",
      "body": "So you pay your five pence or five cents or whatever, and you go as far as you want to, you get off, and then you do your business and you get on again. And he devised this, raised some money from his friends, they established five different routes across Paris."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1455.83",
      "endTime": "1477.5",
      "body": "So basically it was the first public transportation system that was ever devised in Europe, and Pascal was right at the heart of it. He gives away a lot of his possessions, he lives a very simple, kind of austere life, and that's part of his devotion to the poor. And he says, you know, I love poverty because Jesus was poor. I love the poor because Jesus loved the poor."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1477.74",
      "endTime": "1503.98",
      "body": "And this devotion to Jesus Christ became really important for him. But the second thing that the night of fire, as it's often called, this experience. The second thing that it did for Pascal is that he found himsi inside himself a desire to try to reach out to these people he knew of in the salons of Paris, these people who were often called in French it's called the honnet homme. They kind of literally means honest men."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1504.06",
      "endTime": "1526.61",
      "body": "But what it means is sophisticated, men about town who were interested in gambling and women and socializing and having a good time and playing tennis and everything else. They weren't they were kind of nominal Catholics. They didn't really that they found God rather boring. And Pascal thought, how can I persuade them that they will find their true happiness only in relationship to this God of Jesus Christ?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1526.77",
      "endTime": "1538.62",
      "body": "And so he starts this project where he's trying to kind of he wants to write something that will persuade such people to really turn to God and to find their true happiness in God."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Voice Actor",
      "startTime": "1539.5",
      "endTime": "1566.18",
      "body": "All men seek happiness. This is without exception. Whatever different means they employ, they all tend to this end. And yet, after such a great number of years, no one without faith has reached the point to which all continually look. A trial so long, so continuous, and so uniform should certainly convince us of our inability to reach the good by our own efforts. What is it then that this desire and this inability proclaim to us?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Voice Actor",
      "startTime": "1566.34",
      "endTime": "1596.19",
      "body": "But that there was once in man a true happiness of which there now remains to him only, the mark and empty trace, which he in vain tries to fill from all his surroundings, seeking from things absent the help he does not obtain in things present? But these are all inadequate, because the infinite abyss can only be filled by an infinite and immutable object. That is to say, only by God himself. Blaise Pascal, Ponse."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1597.55",
      "endTime": "1599.07",
      "body": "And this is the Ponsee."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1599.31",
      "endTime": "1601.15",
      "body": "This is what became the Pensée."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1601.39",
      "endTime": "1610.03",
      "body": "Tell us about this. I mean it's amazing because it wasn't a published book in his time, no. It's notes that we've put together."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1610.19",
      "endTime": "1610.83",
      "body": "Yep."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1611.55",
      "endTime": "1616.43",
      "body": "So tell us about what he was trying to do and how he was trying to do it."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1616.59",
      "endTime": "1641.57",
      "body": "Yep. Well he maybe best to start with how. What he started to do and was to and perhaps Pascal's way of thinking, I think he was a very fertile mind. Thoughts were coming to him all the time. And what he would do is when a thought came to him he would write it down and sometimes it's a line, sometimes it's a paragraph, sometimes it's more like a page. Some of them are more like kinda longer essays."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1641.73",
      "endTime": "1658.21",
      "body": "And he would write these pieces and on pieces of paper and he would collect them in his room. And As you as you w when you buy a copy of the Ponsee today, you are you are picking up a book which is not which was as an unfinished book."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1658.69",
      "endTime": "1683.73",
      "body": "So Pascal never got round to finishing this book at all. When his when he died, his friends found all these scattered bits of paper in his room and they collected them together. Some of them had been organized by Pascal into chapters, some of them were just randomly around the room and they gathered them all together and they wondered what to do with them, and they decided eventually to publish them as the Pensee, The Thoughts of Monsieur Pascal on religion and various other subjects."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1684.29",
      "endTime": "1715.53",
      "body": "And as you can imagine, it's been through many, many different editions since then. And so this is the this is the pensée, this is Pascal's unfinished Apology for the Christian religion. And really what he's trying to do is try to address these you know, these sophisticated men that he knew of, and they may weren't mainly men, there were some women as well, but these people who were just not interested in God. They were nominally Christian, but not r didn't really take that faith very seriously."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1715.77",
      "endTime": "1726.09",
      "body": "And he wants to engage them, not if you like by proving Christianity to them, because that's one of the things about Pascal. He doesn't think you can prove Christianity."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1726.25",
      "endTime": "1729.05",
      "body": "He says And not because of the weakness of the evidence."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1729.29",
      "endTime": "1729.69",
      "body": "Exactly."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1730.19",
      "endTime": "1731.79",
      "body": "Because of the corruption of the"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1732.35",
      "endTime": "1765.16",
      "body": "Because of the weakness of the human heart, exactly. Well, I think he thinks there are a number of reasons why you can't prove God by reason. He says, you know, God, God is known not with the reason, but with the heart. And he thinks he thinks we can't know God by reason. Firstly because of our own our own hearts are so are made in such a way that we do not think straight. that our hearts are stronger than our heads, our longings are stronger than our logic. And therefore we believe what we want to believe."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1765.96",
      "endTime": "1782.21",
      "body": "And actually when you think about it, you know, I I'm quite good at doing that. I'm quite good at believing that chocolate biscuit over there is not going to do it do me any harm. It's not going to make me fat, it's going to just be nice and pleasure and I can eat as many of them as I like to without thinking about what it's gonna do to me."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1782.61",
      "endTime": "1785.49",
      "body": "Jonathan Haidt's righteous mind is entirely about that, isn't"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1785.49",
      "endTime": "1785.49",
      "body": "it?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1785.81",
      "endTime": "1790.77",
      "body": "Precisely, yeah. I mean you read Jonathan Haidt and you think this is this is Pascal and it's Augustine, it's St. Augustine."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1790.85",
      "endTime": "1791.17",
      "body": "Yeah, yeah."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1791.33",
      "endTime": "1800.69",
      "body": "You know, our longings, our desires are the most important thing about us. And therefore he thinks reason is not reliable in that sense."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1801.09",
      "endTime": "1830.48",
      "body": "In his 2012 bestseller, The Righteous Mind, American social psychologist Jonathan Haidt explored why good people disagree so wildly over politics, religion, and morality, and honestly, it's one of my favorite books of the last two decades. He offers the analogy of a writer and an elephant, to make the point that intuitions come first and strategic reasoning comes second."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1830.64",
      "endTime": "1856.83",
      "body": "The writer is our conscious, rational mind, and the elephant is everything else about us, our motives, desires, assumptions, gut feelings. His point is that the psychological literature makes pretty clear the elephant is a lot bigger than the rider. When the elephant wants to go one way, but the rider wants to go another way, the elephant, the gut, is gonna win."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1857.07",
      "endTime": "1881.44",
      "body": "And then when that happens, According to the psychological research that Haidt outlines, our rational self, the writer, works over time to invent rationalizations to support our gut instincts, to sort of justify the direction the elephant wants to go in. And we all do it, atheists and the religious, the left and the right."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1882.18",
      "endTime": "1910.74",
      "body": "educated and not so educated. And at this point Haite is walking in the footsteps of Blaise Pascal. Pascal, who was himself hyper rational, insisted that reason is often the servant of the passions, not the master of the passions. He famously wrote, The heart has its reasons, of which reason knows nothing."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1911.21",
      "endTime": "1932.09",
      "body": "So he has this very powerful image that actually he gets, he borrows it from the French author Montaine from the previous century, and he says, you know, put the put the world's greatest philosopher on a plank that is suspended 200 feet above the ground. His reason will tell him he's perfectly safe walking across that plank, but his imagination will prevail and he will be terrified."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1932.25",
      "endTime": "1950.05",
      "body": "And in fact, when you think about it, you couldn't imagine doing it. And you can imagine, you know, you walk across a plank on the ground, just a foot wide, not a problem at all. Suspended 100, 200 feet in the air, a real problem, because your imagination kicks in. And so our imagination is stronger than our than our logic and our reason."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1950.13",
      "endTime": "1968.17",
      "body": "So that's one of the reasons why he thinks reason doesn't get us to God. Another reason is because he thinks God is not an object within the world that you can explain. And I can explain why this chair got here because it was made by particular people and there's a cause and effect that led to the existence of this chair."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "1969.05",
      "endTime": "1991.65",
      "body": "That's not true of God. God is not the product of cause and effect. And in fact, in The Night of Fire, one of the most famous lines in the memorial is where he talks about God of Jesus Christ, not the God of the philosophers. So this is not a God that you can somehow find at the end of some syllogism or logical process of reasoning."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "1991.97",
      "endTime": "2010.35",
      "body": "This reminds me of Sorin Kirkigore, who thought the same thing slightly later, I'm writing, yeah, I guess. And it is quite potent when you think about it, because a god that I could fully know by my puny mind."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2010.51",
      "endTime": "2010.75",
      "body": "Yeah."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "2010.99",
      "endTime": "2012.67",
      "body": "Would it be worth believing in, really?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2012.83",
      "endTime": "2020.67",
      "body": "Yeah, exactly. That's right, yeah. And there are lots of similarities between Pascal and Kierkegaard. Later on."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2021.55",
      "endTime": "2028.19",
      "body": "It's that thing of St. Augustine, you know, who wrote, if you can understand it, it's not God."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "2028.27",
      "endTime": "2028.75",
      "body": "Yes."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2029.55",
      "endTime": "2036.03",
      "body": "If God could be understood by the human mind, then it would be a rather diminished God."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "2036.39",
      "endTime": "2047.59",
      "body": "Some of my skeptical listeners will go, aha, proof Christianity is not rational. You have to leave your rational mind behind. How would Pascal? Well Pascal and Tomlin respond."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2047.75",
      "endTime": "2075.33",
      "body": "Well Pascal would say, no, no, you do not have to leave your rational mind behind. In fact, he thinks there are very good reasons for believing in Christianity. And you'll find within the pot in the pensée the strong reasons that he thinks that point towards Christian faith being true. But he thinks he thinks that our minds are not set up to access those. If you're actually going to access those, you have to go through a kind of bit of a spiritual process beforehand."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2076.21",
      "endTime": "2085.73",
      "body": "And so what and one of the other ways in which he would he would think about this is he comes very clean and he says God is not obvious."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2085.89",
      "endTime": "2121.0",
      "body": "Now you know in some ways whether you're a Christian or not you can recognize that you know when i walk down the street god does not usually appear to me he doesn't usually sort of speak audibly out of the skies you can go through this life quite happily not believing in god or at least god is not obvious to you now the atheists will then say well there you are you know there's no evidence for god doesn't exist the christian apologists might say oh yes but i can give you all kinds of reasons why god exists at all And Pascal doesn't think either of those really works because the reasons don't carry you to kind of full proof."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2121.16",
      "endTime": "2130.04",
      "body": "But then Pascal Khan says, well, there's a third possibility. The possibility is that there is a God, but that he's a hidden god. And this idea of the hidden God is a really important one for."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "2130.44",
      "endTime": "2134.76",
      "body": "Which is a big philosophical subject now. It is. But he's talking about it in the 17th century."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2135.08",
      "endTime": "2135.56",
      "body": "Yeah, he is."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "2135.88",
      "endTime": "2136.76",
      "body": "What does he say?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2137.08",
      "endTime": "2144.76",
      "body": "Well he says, he says that if there is a God, then he must be a hidden god, because he doesn't show himself, more obviously."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2146.16",
      "endTime": "2163.2",
      "body": "And so he raises this intriguing possibility that there may be a God that is there, a God who stands behind everything that we know, everything that we experience, everything that we enjoy, but that he deliberately hides himself. And then you ask, well, why does he hide himself?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2163.44",
      "endTime": "2185.41",
      "body": "And Pascal would say something like this. He would say, well, because God isn't interested in being the kind of God that you can just sort of say, okay, I believe in God, take that off, get on with the rest of my life. as if God shows himself in that way. This is a God you can only know in intense relationship. You can only know when you give your soul, your whole heart and soul to him."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2187.81",
      "endTime": "2210.19",
      "body": "And the ne the other point I think that Pascal makes, which again is one of the reasons why in this sort of slightly roundabout way he does give you reasons to believe in God, or even the God of the God of Christian faith, is he says, well if there is a if there is a true religion it must proclaim a hidden God, not an obvious God. And he says, well, look at the world religions, which is the one that speaks about a hidden God?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2210.43",
      "endTime": "2240.47",
      "body": "And he says, well, if you think about Christianity for a moment, Christianity says that the suit the place where God has revealed himself most fully is in the person of Jesus Christ. But even there you find God is hidden, because Jesus Christ was, in one sense, a man like you and me. You could meet Jesus, you could shake him by the hand, and you could entirely miss the fact that you were talking to God. In other words, God is hidden in the very place where he reveals himself most fully to the eye of faith."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2240.63",
      "endTime": "2262.63",
      "body": "And so he sees it's like two bits of a jigsaw. Here is our experience of the world that tells us if there is a God, he's hidden. And here is this other piece of the jigsaw that Christianity is telling you, here is God who is revealed in Jesus Christ, and even there he's hidden, and the two bits of the jigsaw fit together. Now, he doesn't say it amounts to proof, but he says it's a pretty good indication that this is where the truth might be found."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "2262.87",
      "endTime": "2266.76",
      "body": "But why does he think God chose to be less obvious."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2267.0",
      "endTime": "2287.16",
      "body": "I think he does it because he says he only wants to be known by those who are serious about knowing him, not just ticking him off as an intellectual exercise, but engaged with God, heart and soul and mind. And so that sense of a you can only know God by the heart."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2288.12",
      "endTime": "2311.08",
      "body": "And again, that's another thing about Pascal, that he feels that God that he believes quite strongly that God is God is known by the heart in the sense that the heart for Pascal is not emotion, it's not romance, it's not that sort of thing. It's a kind of deep, kind of pre-rational instinct that there is a God. That's the kind of way we where we begin."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2311.92",
      "endTime": "2332.08",
      "body": "a kind of an awareness and a knowledge of God. Now that has to then be explored further, and that's the task of Christian theology and apologetics and everything else. But that's how God is known through the heart. And it that and because this is a God who can only be known by the heart, that's why I feel like he closes off the route to knowing him purely by the reason."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Voice Actor",
      "startTime": "2332.8",
      "endTime": "2346.42",
      "body": "It is the heart which perceives God and not the reason. That is what faith is. God perceived by the heart, not by the reason. Blaise Pascal, Ponsey."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Voice Actor",
      "startTime": "2349.62",
      "endTime": "2378.54",
      "body": "Either God is, or he is not. But to which view shall we be inclined? Reason cannot decide this question. Infinite chaos separates us. At the far end of this infinite distance is a coin being spun, which will come down heads or tails. How will you wager? Reason cannot make you choose either. Reason cannot prove either wrong. Blaise Pascal. Ponse."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "2380.22",
      "endTime": "2401.65",
      "body": "The wager. Pascal's wager. Which is ridiculed by many thoughtful sceptics. But you're quite insistent that we've mostly misunderstood the wager, and the weight it plays, but also the function it plays in Pascal. So over to you, Graham Tomlin. Tell us about the wager."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2402.37",
      "endTime": "2418.29",
      "body": "Yeah, well, as you say, John, the wager is often depicted as a kind of slam dunk argument that is meant to make you believe in God. So if it's a sort of arm wrestle and the kind of Christian apologist wins the argument and you've got to believe in God because of the wager."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2419.56",
      "endTime": "2442.28",
      "body": "But actually, I don't think it works like that. I don't think that's what it plays in Pascal's mind. And I don't think it does, partly because for what we've just been talking about, you know, Pascal doesn't believe that you can strong arm someone into belief. He doesn't believe that you can somehow prove Christianity in that way. And I think the wager works in a different way. So the wager, I think, it comes into the context of Pascal's life story."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2444.46",
      "endTime": "2461.5",
      "body": "So for example, one of the one of the bits of mathematical work he did was on probability theory, which he did in correspondence with his friend Pierre de Fermat. Some people may have heard of Fermat's last theorem. That's the guy that Pascal was kind of sort of, you know, he knew and he was in correspondence with."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2461.66",
      "endTime": "2480.52",
      "body": "And one of the things that they worked on was this thing called the règle de parti, the kind of the rule of games. And the idea is if you've got a game, And in Pascal's time it might be in a card game or a you know sort of tennis match or whatever, or a in a series of tossing coins."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2481.24",
      "endTime": "2494.36",
      "body": "And the game is going to be played over a period of time, but at some point during the game, the game has to be interrupted. And if you've had people who've laid bets on one side or the other, how do you allocate the stake?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2496.08",
      "endTime": "2514.88",
      "body": "This was a kind of common problem that mathematicians worked at. And some people said, well, you can't because it's all chance, that's what games are like, and you can't predict it at all. But some people thought there was a way of doing this. And Pascal and Ferma in particular thought, well, there was a there is a way of working out the probability of how this is going to work out."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2515.04",
      "endTime": "2533.82",
      "body": "And they could have worked out a system of that. Now, Pascal says, if you think about it, life is a bit like that. You know, we are At this particular moment, whatever you're when you're listening to this or we're recording this, you've lived a certain part of your life, you've got a bit of your life to come. You don't know what's going to be the end of it."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2534.06",
      "endTime": "2546.3",
      "body": "And at the end of your life, there will be, Pascal puts it like this, there is a coin being tossed at the far edge of the universe. Either God exists or he doesn't. Which one are you going to choose?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2547.02",
      "endTime": "2569.82",
      "body": "And he says, this is the basic choice we have. At the end of our lives, we will discover either there is a God or there isn't a God. We all know. But you have to kind of, you have to bet. So life is like an unfinished game. And so this comes in the context of a kind of conversation. And the guy who's talking to Pascal would then say to him, Well, do I have to choose? Can't I just be agnostic about this?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2569.98",
      "endTime": "2593.79",
      "body": "And Pascal says, well, you do have to choose because in some ways you've already chosen. you're already living your life as if God exists or as if God doesn't exist. So you've already bet. You can't be neutral on this. And so the guy says, well, is there any is there any evidence to push me one way or the other? And Pascal says, well, there is. There's some reason, good reasons to believe, but it's not conclusive. It's not going to fully prove it one way or the other."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2594.59",
      "endTime": "2608.43",
      "body": "And then so then the guy says, well, what do I do then? And Sir Pascal says, okay, well, let's work out the probability. Let's work out the different options that we have. And so he goes through this fairly complicated bit of sort of probabilistic mathematics."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2608.75",
      "endTime": "2626.59",
      "body": "And basically it comes down to this. If you believe that God doesn't exist, and you're right, well, you haven't gained a great deal. You don't believe in God, there is no God, maybe a bit of pleasure in this life, but when your life ends, that's it, you go into nothingness. You gain a little bit of pleasure, but not much else."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2627.53",
      "endTime": "2658.22",
      "body": "But if you bet that God doesn't exist and you're wrong, then you've got a problem, because you will then meet that God face to face and you face the prospect of eternal damnation or whatever that might mean. But if you bet that God does exist and you're wrong, you and you're wrong, well, again, you have lost a great deal, maybe a bit of self sacrifice, a bit of time of prayer, this kind of life, but it's a fairly short period of time, and then you go into nothingness like everything else."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2658.3",
      "endTime": "2677.02",
      "body": "But if you're right, you stand to gain the jackpot because you will go into eternal blessedness for all eternity with God. And so he says, if you were being entirely rational about it, you'd always bet on belief, because the odds are much better on that side than they are on the other side."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2677.26",
      "endTime": "2701.7",
      "body": "Now, this is where of course a lot of People have criticized him for being very kind of functional and very kind of materialistic about it and very self-oriented, but that misses the point. Because what happens at that com at that point in the conversation is that the other guy comes back to Pascal and says, Yeah, I know, well, you may be right, but I can't make myself believe something I don't believe. And Pascal says, absolutely right. Of course you can't."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2702.17",
      "endTime": "2718.01",
      "body": "Okay, that's not the way conversion works. You can't change your own heart. But he says, this is the key point. He says, at least get it into your head that the reason you don't do not believe is not because of your reason, it's because of your passions. In other words, reason is telling you to believe, but you can't do it."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2718.25",
      "endTime": "2737.23",
      "body": "And it's pointing people to the real source of unbelief, which is not rational, it's not reason, it's to do with the heart. And so it's always that's the point of the par of the wager, it's trying to get us to the to the real reason why we believe and why we don't believe. And then the guy says to him, well, what do I do then if I can't change my own heart?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2737.39",
      "endTime": "2749.15",
      "body": "And Pascal said, well, there's something you can do, which is that you can begin to live as if it was true. You can start to live your life as if it's true, even if you're not sure it is."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2749.87",
      "endTime": "2768.54",
      "body": "So he would say, go to church, take holy water, go to mass and so on. You know, we might say, start going into every day, treating each person you meet as if they are something sacred given to you by God in that moment. Try reading the Bible as if it is God's word speaking to you each day. Try praying as if God is listening."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2769.82",
      "endTime": "2786.69",
      "body": "You know, start treating this world as if it's God's gift to you rather than just a bit of stuff that you live on. And he says, if you do that, you will put yourself in the place where it's possible that God's grace might touch you and begin to change your heart, and you will begin to slowly realize that it's true."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2786.93",
      "endTime": "2798.37",
      "body": "So that's really, I think, the way the wager works. And therefore, because it's not a slam dump dunk argument, a lot of the criticisms of the wager don't really hit the mark. It's designed in a different way and for a different purpose."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "2798.61",
      "endTime": "2804.85",
      "body": "Yeah, so take this bet really just means taste and see."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2805.0",
      "endTime": "2838.15",
      "body": "Yeah, he does. He does, exactly. Yeah. And Pascal thinks, he thinks that conversion, Christian conversion is fundamentally not a change of the mind to believe certain things. It's not a change of the of morality, you know, act a certain way. It's a change of the heart. It's fundamentally that you start loving something different. That, you know, for him, he used to love all the adulation of the crowd, all the fame he got from being this famous scientist and mathematician."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "2838.31",
      "endTime": "2870.56",
      "body": "And conversion meant for him that the love for those things became less powerful and the love that he found for Jesus Christ became much stronger. And that was the motivation of his life. And that's why, you know, that's why, you know, conversion is something of the heart and not the head or the behavior fundamentally. It then has an impact on the head. all our you know, on our minds and our we have to think our way through what that really means, and then it turns out in behaviour, but it's a fundamental heart thing for him."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Voice Actor",
      "startTime": "2873.6",
      "endTime": "2897.12",
      "body": "I should like to arouse in man the desire to find truth, to be ready, free from passion, to follow it wherever he may find it, realizing how far his knowledge is clouded by passions. I should like him to hate his concupiscence, which automatically makes his decision for him. so that it should not blind him when he makes his choice, nor hinder him once he has chosen."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Voice Actor",
      "startTime": "2898.88",
      "endTime": "2922.3",
      "body": "Concentrate, then, not on convincing yourself by multiplying proofs of God's existence, but by diminishing your passions. You want to find faith, and you do not know the road. You want to be cured of unbelief, and you ask for the remedy. Learn from those who were once bound like you, and who now wager all they have. Blaise Pascal, I'll see."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "2925.74",
      "endTime": "2950.58",
      "body": "Pascal's wager, Graham says, was meant to shock us, and it certainly did. Many of Pascal's seventeenth century Christian contemporaries believed that reason was enough to settle the question of God. I mean, this was the dawn of the Enlightenment when confidence in our human reasoning capacities was beginning to rise to new heights."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "2950.82",
      "endTime": "2978.52",
      "body": "Now, of course, Pascal accepted that the rational arguments for Christianity were pretty good, but he knew that evidence alone could never settle this matter. In a way, he was like the later Danish philosopher Sorin Kierkegaard, and by the way, that Kirkigore episode, can't remember what number it is, but it's called Faith's Leap. is one of my all-time favorites that we've ever produced, certainly top five."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "2978.84",
      "endTime": "3008.31",
      "body": "John was obviously distracted at this point because the episode he's talking about is called blind faith, not faith sleep. Both of these brainiacs, Blaise Pascal and song Kirky Gore, were deeply wary of boxing reality into our tiny reasoning powers. If God exists, they reckoned, he wouldn't be less than reason could comprehend, but it would have to be much, much more."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "3008.71",
      "endTime": "3039.33",
      "body": "Otherwise it's really ourselves we believe in, not the Almighty. If you think that you've fully explained the Almighty, they'd say you haven't even begun to know the true and living God. Both men wanted to shake Western cultural elites from their distractions, cultural, intellectual distractions, and face reality. Certainly Pascal had quite a lot to say about distraction."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Voice Actor",
      "startTime": "3042.05",
      "endTime": "3072.01",
      "body": "The sole cause of man's unhappiness is that he does not know how to stay quietly in his room. The only good thing for men, therefore, is to be diverted from thinking of what they are, either by some occupation which takes their mind off it, or by some novel and agreeable passion which keeps them busy, like gambling, hunting, some absorbing show, in short, by what is called diversion. Blaise Pascal, Pensey."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "3072.49",
      "endTime": "3081.01",
      "body": "One of the interesting things he talks about is What you might call stillness. Yeah. Versus distraction."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3081.17",
      "endTime": "3106.34",
      "body": "Yep. Yeah, it's a big theme for Pascal because as he looked out on his friends, these, you know, educated sort of men about town that he that he knew, he thought they spent a lot of their time just distracting themselves with all kinds of stuff. It's why they went traveling or they you know played tennis or they went gambling or whatever it might be."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3106.58",
      "endTime": "3129.17",
      "body": "And he this what he suggests is this experiment you know try sitting in your own inner room with nothing to distract you and he says you know you know you try it today you know go into a room no books no phone No internet, no TV, no radio, nothing."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3129.41",
      "endTime": "3143.57",
      "body": "And just try to sit on your own for a couple of hours. It's almost impossible. You know, w in our day we whenever you feel the most slightest moment of boredom, we whip out our phones and go through the videos or the news or whatever it might be."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3144.29",
      "endTime": "3166.02",
      "body": "He knew about the human tendency to distraction before w we did, even at a time when we don't have these methods of distraction that we have in our world. And it's his way of saying, I think what he's trying to get people to do in that little experiment is to kind of realize the emptiness that is at the heart of all of us."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3166.26",
      "endTime": "3187.75",
      "body": "He's saying that if you if you take away the distractions, if you take away the books, the podcasts, the conversations, the people, we find it almost impossible just to be alone with our own thoughts, with nothing to do, nothing to distract us. Because if you do that, you suddenly become aware there's an emptiness inside you."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3187.83",
      "endTime": "3216.25",
      "body": "And if you like all the stuff that we that we f we you know we watch and we listen to and we read and we sort it's like filling that emptiness. but it can never totally be filled. And I think the other part of this is what Pascal says in one of his pensées where he talks about how that there is within each of us a an infinite abyss and it's an infinite abyss because it can only be filled by an infinite object."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3216.41",
      "endTime": "3235.42",
      "body": "And that only infinite object is God himself. It's the famous idea he never uses the phrase, but what is sometimes called the God-shaped gap. The idea that there is within the human heart and soul a space that is made for God. And unless it's filled by God, until it's filled by God, it always aches."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "3235.74",
      "endTime": "3238.38",
      "body": "The opening paragraph of Augustine's Confessions."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3238.54",
      "endTime": "3264.28",
      "body": "Yeah, exactly. That's right, yeah. There's this holy ache within us that longs for something. And we try to fill it with all these distractions. We try to distract us from that emptiness. we just distract ourselves from it. But he actually wants people to face up to that emptiness because only if you face up to that emptiness do you realize that actually what you really need to fill that emptiness is the God of Jesus Christ."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3264.52",
      "endTime": "3282.97",
      "body": "And so he sees distraction as a these things which seem very innocent and, you know, trivial, but they're quite serious in one sense for Pascal because what they are is they're a just deflecting mechanism. f from our realizing the emptiness inside which can only be filled by God."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Voice Actor",
      "startTime": "3286.17",
      "endTime": "3316.29",
      "body": "What else does this craving, and this helplessness, proclaim but that there was once in man a true happiness, of which all that now remains is the empty print and trace? This he tries in vain to fill with everything around him, seeking in things that are not there the help he cannot find in those that are. though none can help, since this infinite abyss can be filled only with an infinite and immutable object, in other words, by God Himself."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Voice Actor",
      "startTime": "3318.93",
      "endTime": "3355.31",
      "body": "It does not take great intelligence to realize that here below there is no true and solid satisfaction, that all our pleasures are but vanity, that our ills are infinite, and that death which threatens us constantly will infallibly set before us, in a few years, the dread alternative of being annihilated, or of being unhappy for all eternity. Nothing is more real than that, nor more frightening. We can act as bravely as we like. This is the end that awaits the finest life in the world, hence it is that men so greatly love noise and commotion."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "3355.63",
      "endTime": "3368.84",
      "body": "Blaise Pascal, Anse How did he die?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3369.4",
      "endTime": "3375.56",
      "body": "Well, he died through his life. Sickness was a kind of constant companion for Pascal."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3377.56",
      "endTime": "3391.41",
      "body": "He actually once said, I've never had a day in my adult life without pain of some kind. Sometimes it was worse, sometimes it was better. He would go through some periods where the pain was less, but they reckon he died of a sort of probably of stomach cancer."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3391.57",
      "endTime": "3411.3",
      "body": "He had very intense stomach pains towards the end of his life, also headaches, possibly a brain tumour of some kind, obviously people didn't know at the time, but the symptoms seemed to carry that out. As I say, he died age 39, never reached his 40th birthday, and so ex achieves an extraordinary amount in that very short life."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3412.34",
      "endTime": "3441.93",
      "body": "He wrote a very powerful prayer for the good use of sickness. And it's a very countercultural thing for us, because you know we tend to think of sickness as something we want to get rid of as soon as possible. Pascal in his sort of maturer spiritual phase of life towards the end of his life sees sickness as a kind of as a kind of unwelcome but holy gift in some way. that is enabling him to focus on the things that really matter in life."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3442.09",
      "endTime": "3445.29",
      "body": "So it's a very powerful prayer, it's worth kind of looking at. But that's basically how he did."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "3445.53",
      "endTime": "3449.21",
      "body": "Was it a big deal in France when he died? Was it, you know, on the front page?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3449.53",
      "endTime": "3450.33",
      "body": "Not particularly."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "3450.49",
      "endTime": "3450.73",
      "body": "Right."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3450.97",
      "endTime": "3481.67",
      "body": "No, he was as I say he would i in many ways in his own life, most of the things we know him for today, were not known at the time. So the Ponsee, Nobody knew the Ponsee was being written. One of the other things that he'd that he wrote that had a big impact at the time was a thing called the Provincial Letters, which was a series of satirical letters that he wrote on behalf of his Jansenists' friends against their enemies, the Jesuits."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3481.75",
      "endTime": "3517.39",
      "body": "And the Jesuits were trying to kinda silence the Jansenists and put them down and all Pascal's friends were Jansenists and he wrote these they're really quite funny i mean he was a genius at comedy as well as anything else he wrote these letters now he was kind of he wrote them anonymously because they were they became bestsellers they were they kind of went viral around Europe at the time when or down in France when he wrote them but no one knew who wrote them he wrote them under a pseudonym Louis de Montalt nobody knew who Louis de Montalt was and he was only revealed as its author a couple of years before he died."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3517.84",
      "endTime": "3534.16",
      "body": "And so, again, a lot of his scientific works were only published after he died as well, so he wasn't really a very famous figure during his time. And apart from his scientific explorations, but there were many others who were doing similar things around that time as well."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3534.32",
      "endTime": "3553.99",
      "body": "So it's really only since then, and particularly since the publication of the pensée and the realization that here is someone who speaks to the modern world. I often think of Pascal as a bit of a time bomb, if you like. During his time, Descartes was much more famous than Pascal. Descartes has much more influence, perhaps, on Western philosophy than Pascal has."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3554.15",
      "endTime": "3582.71",
      "body": "But I think Pascal speaks to the modern mind much more than Descartes does. Descartes is all about certainty, it's all about, you know, r rationality and reason and finding a kind of certainty in the mind. You know, I think, therefore I am. Pascal, I think, is much more attuned to the modern world. He knows that he's living in the era, you know, it's this is the time when the telescope had recently been in invented. In other words, he knew how small we were within the universe."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3582.79",
      "endTime": "3606.13",
      "body": "And he writes in this very evocative way about how human beings are these tiny specks of life on this small planet in a small corner of the solar system and we seem so sort of infinitely small. You know, we are frail, weak beings that are morally compromised, we're always in competition with each other. He says all men all men hate each other is what he says."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3606.29",
      "endTime": "3638.1",
      "body": "But actually underneath our civility is this competition that we have because our ourselves always ought to kind of impose themselves. But on the other hand, he writes about how we have this incredible capacity to understand the world, you know, to love one another at times, this the our minds are able to grasp some of the mysteries of the universe. So how do you make sense of this strange enigma, this puzzle of human life, this the weakness and the greatness, the grandeur and the misère of humanity?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3638.5",
      "endTime": "3656.07",
      "body": "And in this way I think he speaks to the modern world in a very powerful way, and he steers a really interesting route between kind of, you know, rationalistic modernism and a sceptical postmodernism at the same time, and I think he's very interesting for us for those reasons."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "3667.11",
      "endTime": "3679.88",
      "body": "Finally, w what can we get from Pascal? You know, thinking of his whole life and the influence that he eventually had, thinking first of the Christian believer."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3680.04",
      "endTime": "3680.36",
      "body": "Yep."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "3680.6",
      "endTime": "3693.16",
      "body": "What do you think they can get from this man? But I'm especially interested in what you reckon someone who's a doubter, someone who's a you know a thoughtful, not yet decided person. So start with the Christian."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3693.32",
      "endTime": "3723.34",
      "body": "Yeah. I think for the Christian, what Pascal does, I think is well what I found him very helpful in is thinking through you know we we've been through quite a sort of intellectual journey over the past 50, 100 years or so from and he recognizes this. So there are two impulses in human philosophy, broadly speaking. One is the rationalist approach. Descartes is the is the great exemplar of that."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3723.42",
      "endTime": "3744.28",
      "body": "And there is a kind of rationalist strand of philosophy that we can we can understand, we can use our minds to know about the world. And you know, Descartes is in his time, probably Richard Dawkins is a similar one in our time. You know, by the scientific method, by the use of our minds, we can find a level of certainty. Science can tell you everything you need to know, and the rest of it is pretty rubbish."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3744.44",
      "endTime": "3754.76",
      "body": "So there's that kind of rationalist impulse. But on the other hand, in more recent times, we've known the kind of postmodern influence. And you think of people like Jacques Derrida, you think of people like Camp."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3757.53",
      "endTime": "3779.05",
      "body": "you know Baudrian and others, Foucault, Foucault and others, exactly, saying that effectively there is a the kind of anti-rationalist that actually we can't really know much about this world at all. That all our attempts at certain knowledge are illusory. All there is different perspectives or different stories. There's no one single truth to be found."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3779.21",
      "endTime": "3806.42",
      "body": "And in Pascal's time, You know, the example of that was Michel de Montaigne, the seventh, 16th-century philosopher who was the great sort of skeptical, skeptic of his times. So Pascal kind of has Descartes on one side, the rationalist tradition, Montaigne on the other, the sceptical tradition. And we feel that as well. You know, we've got, you know, Foucault on the one side, the great skeptic, you've got Dawkins on the other side, the great rationalist sort of scientific person."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3807.83",
      "endTime": "3823.11",
      "body": "And Christians, you know, which way do we go in that? What Pascal says is, which I think is really sort of brilliant in his own time, is he said, well, these two things, they're part of the history of human race, of the human ways of thinking about our worlds."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3824.15",
      "endTime": "3842.23",
      "body": "You've got Descartes saying, you know, I think, therefore I am. Thinking is what makes us human. You've got Montaigne whose phrase is, what do I know? Cusager, what do I know? I don't really know anything for sure. And these two kind of cancel each other out. They can't they can't account for each other."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3842.39",
      "endTime": "3859.11",
      "body": "You know, the rationalist has to come to the to realize there are certain things that just don't seem to make sense. You know, a lot of what we do is just custom, it's just things that we've kind of developed over time, it's not kind of rooted in some you know, rationalistic objective fact."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3859.27",
      "endTime": "3871.66",
      "body": "But on the other side, the skeptic has to realize that there are certain things that are. embedded in the nature of things. You know, even the most skeptical philosopher puts the kettle on and expects it to boil. You know, there are kind of the laws of nature, if you like."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3871.9",
      "endTime": "3900.06",
      "body": "And so Pascal says that actually Christianity explains these two because it tells us that we live in a world which is where we are made in God's image, we are made with godlike capacity to understand, to use our minds, that explains our greatness. But on the other hand, we are fallen. we are radically fallen, which explains our inability to understand and the kind of ways in which our longings overpower our logic."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "3900.22",
      "endTime": "3920.7",
      "body": "And so Christianity explains this polarity between rationalism and skepticism and can offer a bigger picture that explains why it is. And so one of the Pascal's strong arguments I think is for the explanatory power of Christianity to make sense of so much for the rest of human life. So I think that's one of the things he offers to the Christian."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "3921.65",
      "endTime": "3943.97",
      "body": "Let's press pause. I've got a five-minute Jesus for you. The argument for religion in general and Christianity in particular is cumulative and I feel powerful. The signposts of the argument, not the argument itself, that's the whole underception show, I guess, just the signposts are for me fivefold."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "3945.0",
      "endTime": "3973.4",
      "body": "First, the philosophical arguments for God's existence seem to me to be very strong, especially the first cause argument, which we dealt with in a recent episode, and the teleological argument, the fact that everything seems spookily arranged and purposeful, from the smallest particle to the furthest reaches of the cosmos. The whole thing speaks of mind and intention."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "3974.16",
      "endTime": "4010.45",
      "body": "Secondly, the historical arguments for Jesus, which we've covered in multiple episodes, are especially strong. There's more than enough evidence, not to prove Christianity, but to show that the Jesus story looks like the X marks the spot of God touching the earth in a tangible way. we have exactly the kind of evidence you'd expect from ancient history if the Jesus narrative really were true, and much more evidence pointing in that direction than you'd expect if it were made up."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "4011.09",
      "endTime": "4045.96",
      "body": "Third, Christianity's moral outlook, especially its insistence that every human being is made in God's image and equally and inestimably precious, is frankly superior to anything ever proposed. And Jesus' radical ethic of love, even love of enemies, is self-evidently superlative. That's why even highly secular cultures are drawn to this ethic and shaped by it. It's divine."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "4046.37",
      "endTime": "4099.13",
      "body": "Now remember, these are just signposts in a cumulative argument. Fourth, personal spiritual experience, remarkable coincidences following prayer, encounters with what I've perceived to be God Himself. And perhaps most astonishingly, the experience of being transformed inwardly by Jesus' ethic. becoming much less of a jerk than I am by nature, than I would be without Christ. It's almost miraculous. Fifth, Christianity lights up everything. Biblical faith explains stuff, the universe's elegant rational order, why science itself works in the first place, why the arts and music are so important."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "4100.08",
      "endTime": "4137.73",
      "body": "the universal human longing for the divine, the profound corruption of the human heart, and our aspiration for remedy, for redemption, for the goodness of the world. All of this makes perfect sense within a Christian frame. It's like Christianity lights up everything. C.S Lewis put this beautifully in his paper, Is Theology poetry. The waking world is judged more real because it can thus contain the dreaming world."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "4137.97",
      "endTime": "4185.32",
      "body": "The dreaming world is judged less real because it cannot contain the waking one. For the same reason, I am certain that in passing from the scientific point of view to the theological, I have passed from dream to waking. Christian theology can fit in science, art, morality, and the sub Christian religions. The scientific point of view cannot fit in any of those things, not even science itself. I believe in Christianity, as I believe the sun has risen, not only because I see it, but because by it I see everything else. You can press play now."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "4190.92",
      "endTime": "4207.24",
      "body": "I think to the to the to the non Christian, I would often give someone the pensée, 'cause it's such an interesting read, and it's the kind of work where some of it it's kinda difficult to understand, unless you really know Pascal well, you don't know understand how all of it's like, and you just skip over those bits."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "4207.35",
      "endTime": "4226.55",
      "body": "But every now and again you come across a bit and you think, yeah, that kind of makes sense. He, as I say, he understands the human condition and he speaks right to our age. He speaks to our distracted age. He speaks to our age of a bit awareness of human frailty and weakness as well as our greatness."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "4227.03",
      "endTime": "4250.96",
      "body": "He understands our position within this vast universe where we're kind of small but significant. How do we explain that sense that we feel ourselves to be significant, we mean something, but in one sense we are just a tiny speck of life within what seems like an indifferent universe? And he offers Christian faith as a way which makes sense of this experience of being human."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "4252.0",
      "endTime": "4274.19",
      "body": "And I think the his way of persuading someone to begin to take Christian faith seriously. Try it and see if it see if it makes sense. Try it on for size. Like when you know you go to a shop and you look at a coat. I don't know whether that's what this looks like, but you try it on, see what it feels like. After a while it becomes part of, you know, it becomes familiar."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "4274.43",
      "endTime": "4288.27",
      "body": "And he's saying that is a way to discover Christianity. And I've often found that has helped when I've spoken to people who are kind of weighing it up, you know, there's some reasons to believe in God, some not to believe in God. Which way do I go? Do I become a Christian? Do I not become a Christian?"
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "4288.44",
      "endTime": "4304.92",
      "body": "Pascal's advice, and I've often used it myself to other people, is to say, well, just try and live as if it's true for a while. Just even before you know whether it's true, just try it, try it out. Live as if it's true. Try it for size. And that I think is a really good way to get into Christian faith right at the beginning."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "4305.16",
      "endTime": "4306.92",
      "body": "Graeme Tomla, thank you so much."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Graham Tomlin",
      "startTime": "4307.08",
      "endTime": "4308.04",
      "body": "Thank you, John."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "4325.12",
      "endTime": "4370.94",
      "body": "Underceptions is hosted by me, John Dixon, produced by Kayleigh Payne and directed and edited by Mark Hadley. Sophie Hawkshaw is on socials and membership. Siobon McGuinness is our online librarian. Lindy Leverston remains my wonderful assistant. Santino DiMarco is chief finance and operations consultant. Our voice actors today were Yannick Laurie and Dakota Love. You can become a member of the Underceptions Club and get access to all those special extras that Kaylee locks away in her lockbox, underceptions.com forward slash club. Becoming a member is the best way to help Underceptions help others look deeper. An Underceptions podcast."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "4375.88",
      "endTime": "4389.72",
      "body": "I believe in Christianity, as I believe the sun has risen, not only because I see it, but because by it I see everything else. You can press play now."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Voice Actor",
      "startTime": "4394.4",
      "endTime": "4407.76",
      "body": "Less of a jerk. I waited specifically for you to say. Oh, John, you must have been a real jerk before Christianity. The mind boggles."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "4408.0",
      "endTime": "4411.12",
      "body": "You don't know the half of it. Okay."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "Sam Cohen",
      "startTime": "4412.8",
      "endTime": "4416.64",
      "body": "Did you probably didn't notice our faces? Yeah, I know I didn't."
    },
    {
      "speaker": "John Dickson",
      "startTime": "4416.8",
      "endTime": "4418.64",
      "body": "I was being very spiritual."
    }
  ]
}
