This is a Physician in the Loop special topic. Two arbitrators benched Federal regulators have barred two of the 17 surprise-billing arbitrators from new disputes, citing their performance. Which standards they missed, and what becomes of their open cases, the agencies have not yet said. On Nov. 4 three federal departments denied recertification to two of the private organizations that settle surprise-billing disputes between insurers and the doctors and hospitals outside their networks. Health and Human Services, Labor and the Treasury said that Island Peer Review Organization, a nonprofit that does business as IPRO, and Network Medical Review Company had "failed to meet minimum performance standards." Neither firm may now accept a new dispute. A study published in September found that, in cases filed in 2023, one of them had sided with providers more often than most arbitrators, and the other less often. The firms are arbitrators under the No Surprises Act. The law banned balance billing, the practice of charging patients the gap between an out-of-network price and what their insurer paid, in the situations it covers, which are emergency care, air ambulance flights and care from an out-of-network clinician during a visit to an in-network hospital or other facility. It also set up arbitration to settle that gap between insurer and provider. When the two sides cannot agree on their own, each submits an offer and a certified entity chooses one, after weighing factors set out in the law. The side whose offer is not chosen generally pays the arbitrator's fee. Certification lasts five years, and this autumn the agencies have been reviewing the firms that applied to renew. The work has grown quickly. Parties filed more than 2.5 million disputes in 2025, according to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, or CMS, and in the second half of that year the provider's side, whether a clinician, a hospital or an air ambulance service, won about 85% of the payment decisions. In the first nine months of this year nearly 2.9 million were filed, already more than in all of 2025. That is more than 10,000 a day. Until recently the government's public files did not say which arbitrator had decided each case. CMS began naming the firm behind each decision only with its data for the second half of 2025. The September study, by Philip Valtadoros of the economics department at the University of Texas at Austin, drew instead on records of cases filed in 2023 that he obtained under the Freedom of Information Act. Taking each disputed service separately, IPRO chose the provider's offer 89% of the time, against 81% overall. Network Medical Review Company chose it 74% of the time. The study describes these differences without explaining them. Its author writes that they are not causal estimates, because disputing parties can choose an arbitrator for each dispute and each arbitrator's mix of cases may differ. The agencies' notice says that certified firms must keep meeting requirements related to timeliness, accuracy, and independence and impartiality in making payment decisions, without saying which of them the two firms missed. Guidance the agencies issued in July says a renewal review may weigh, among other things, whether a firm decides large numbers of disputes on time, rules accurately on eligibility and payment, explains its payment decisions as the rules require and handles fees properly. Applicants are also checked for conflicts of interest. On Oct. 1 Mehmet Oz, the administrator of CMS, and Daniel Aronowitz, an assistant secretary of labor, met representatives of every certified firm. Users of the process had complained of ineligible disputes, unclear reasons for decisions, and awards paid late or not at all. Later in October CMS opened public petition periods, in which anyone could object to a firm's renewal, for five firms and then three more, among them Maximus Federal Services and Acentra. The agencies say that the other firms that applied to renew are still under review now that those periods have closed, and that they will announce their status later. Insurers and employers had asked for more. In letters to top administration officials in October, the Coalition Against Surprise Medical Billing, a payer advocacy group, and the ERISA Industry Committee, which represents large employers, urged CMS to stop approving arbitrators until it adopted more rigorous standards. The coalition also wanted the five-day window for objections stretched to at least 30 days. The American Society of Anesthesiologists and other physician groups, for their part, have opposed a House bill from Representative Frank Pallone Jr. of New Jersey, who helped write the law. Under it, physicians who treat patients out of network at in-network facilities would lose federal arbitration for services provided from 2028. Patrick Giam, the society's president, said that giving insurers even greater control over physician payments was not the solution to concerns about the process. Network Medical Review has said that it plans to appeal, and IPRO that it is considering next steps that may include an appeal. Much else is still open. The two firms have 30 business days from their written notice to appeal, and the agencies will not issue a final denial until that time has run out and any appeal has been considered. Parties with cases before either firm have been told to expect further guidance on next steps. The July guidance says that a firm denied recertification that appeals may keep working on disputes already assigned to it until its five-year term ends, though it may take no new ones. When the term ends, its unfinished disputes go to other certified firms and its fees for them are refunded. The notice does not say how that will apply here, how many cases the two firms hold or when their certifications end. For now the government's list of certified arbitrators still shows 17 names. Two of them, IPRO and Network Medical Review Company, carry a note saying that the firm is not accepting new disputes at this time. This special topic was read by an AI voice. Its sources are linked at physicianintheloop.org.