WEBVTT

NOTE
This file was generated by Descript 

00:00:00.027 --> 00:00:02.487
Megan Pantelides: We've got
data now from nearly 1,700

00:00:02.487 --> 00:00:04.227
organisations on their board packs.

00:00:04.277 --> 00:00:07.961
About two-thirds of board packs,
according to our data set, would be

00:00:07.961 --> 00:00:10.271
classified as weak or poor quality.

00:00:10.522 --> 00:00:12.879
More information does not
make boards better informed.

00:00:14.148 --> 00:00:17.395
Ralph Grayson: Welcome to The Boardroom
Path by Sainty Hird & Partners.

00:00:17.740 --> 00:00:21.630
I'm your host, Ralph Grayson, a
partner in the board practice.

00:00:21.998 --> 00:00:26.558
In this series, we'll offer practical
steps and useful perspectives for

00:00:26.558 --> 00:00:28.898
aspiring and newly appointed NEDs.

00:00:29.544 --> 00:00:32.964
Today, I'm back in the offices
of Board Intelligence with

00:00:32.964 --> 00:00:37.494
Megan Pantelides, overlooking
Cornhill and the Royal Exchange.

00:00:38.214 --> 00:00:41.544
Megan is Director of Research
at Board Intelligence and one

00:00:41.544 --> 00:00:44.900
of the leading commentators on
board effectiveness, governance,

00:00:44.900 --> 00:00:49.310
decision-making, organisational culture,
and the use of AI in the boardroom.

00:00:50.110 --> 00:00:54.400
Megan joined me previously to discuss what
makes boards effective, why the quality

00:00:54.400 --> 00:00:58.420
of board information matters, and whether
governance has become too focused on

00:00:58.420 --> 00:01:00.490
compliance rather than value creation.

00:01:01.290 --> 00:01:04.170
Since then, Board Intelligence
has published the third edition

00:01:04.440 --> 00:01:06.090
of its Board Value Index.

00:01:06.450 --> 00:01:11.760
This is its most internationally extensive
study yet, drawing on more than 400 NEDs,

00:01:11.970 --> 00:01:19.350
CEOs, and CFOs across the UK, US, Middle
East, and for the first time, the Nordics.

00:01:20.130 --> 00:01:22.410
The findings raise some
difficult questions.

00:01:22.830 --> 00:01:26.520
Only 37% of respondents believe
their board is an essential

00:01:26.520 --> 00:01:27.930
tool for value creation.

00:01:28.500 --> 00:01:34.740
Only 18% say their board strongly
enables innovation and some 86% report

00:01:35.040 --> 00:01:40.290
that board processes have contributed
to a delayed, rushed or poor decision.

00:01:40.890 --> 00:01:46.020
Whilst only 19% have identified
an internal CEO successor

00:01:46.350 --> 00:01:48.060
ready to step in immediately.

00:01:48.750 --> 00:01:52.530
So we're going to update on the
first podcast and examine some

00:01:52.530 --> 00:01:53.970
of these findings in detail.

00:01:54.180 --> 00:01:56.340
So Megan, welcome back
to the Boardroom Path.

00:01:56.880 --> 00:01:57.440
Megan Pantelides: Thank you for having me.

00:01:57.450 --> 00:01:58.260
It's good to see you again.

00:01:58.380 --> 00:02:01.500
Ralph Grayson: Well, I've come to you for
a change, so it's great to be in the City.

00:02:02.237 --> 00:02:07.387
So look, before we get into that detail
if you had to reduce the Summer 2026

00:02:07.387 --> 00:02:11.527
Board Value Index to one conclusion,
what do you think it might be?

00:02:12.327 --> 00:02:14.517
Megan Pantelides: That things move
very slowly in the board world

00:02:14.727 --> 00:02:17.327
and I think it's been a year since
we published the first edition.

00:02:17.390 --> 00:02:22.410
As many days as there are already,
it feels like a very short time.

00:02:22.934 --> 00:02:28.574
One of the things I was conscious of
is that many boards might have only

00:02:28.574 --> 00:02:30.824
met four, five, six times in that time.

00:02:30.824 --> 00:02:34.154
So, if people are responding to this
research and thinking about what

00:02:34.154 --> 00:02:36.164
they might need to do differently,
there's not an awful lot of time

00:02:36.164 --> 00:02:37.407
for that to see in the data.

00:02:37.407 --> 00:02:39.480
So, there's a lot going
on in the outside world.

00:02:39.480 --> 00:02:40.560
Things are moving very slowly.

00:02:40.586 --> 00:02:44.212
Ralph Grayson: So what surprised
you most and did any finding

00:02:44.292 --> 00:02:45.512
particularly worry you?

00:02:45.842 --> 00:02:47.282
Megan Pantelides: I think one of
the most interesting things about

00:02:47.312 --> 00:02:50.702
the research this time around was
a new question that we introduced.

00:02:50.972 --> 00:02:54.372
So previously, we've asked directors,
"What are your biggest barriers to

00:02:54.372 --> 00:02:57.102
decision-making?" And we've asked them
to pick two from a list or three from a

00:02:57.102 --> 00:03:01.586
list and that tells us what they think
the issues are relative to each other.

00:03:01.916 --> 00:03:04.826
But what it doesn't tell us is whether
any of those issues actually make

00:03:04.826 --> 00:03:06.566
a difference to board performance.

00:03:07.366 --> 00:03:13.146
This time, we asked them to tell us if
across all of those common boardroom

00:03:13.146 --> 00:03:17.946
challenges, if any of them had caused
their board to delay, rush, or make a

00:03:17.946 --> 00:03:19.596
poor decision in the past six months.

00:03:20.102 --> 00:03:24.872
I was very surprised to see what
we got back from that question.

00:03:25.202 --> 00:03:28.977
For every one of those dimensions,
from information quality through to

00:03:29.157 --> 00:03:32.901
directors' preparation for meetings, board
members' skills and expertise, across

00:03:32.901 --> 00:03:38.241
every one of those dimensions, between,
I think, 78% and 86% of directors said

00:03:38.361 --> 00:03:42.591
that had happened in their boardroom,
that issue had caused a rushed, a poor,

00:03:42.591 --> 00:03:45.951
or a delayed decision in the last six
months and in each of those cases,

00:03:45.951 --> 00:03:50.211
again, around about half of respondents
said that happened more than once.

00:03:50.511 --> 00:03:52.221
So these weren't isolated incidents.

00:03:52.221 --> 00:03:54.891
These were things that were potentially
happening in every boardroom.

00:03:55.691 --> 00:04:01.561
Decisions being rushed, being made
poorly, decisions being delayed altogether

00:04:01.561 --> 00:04:06.893
because of issues that were, I think, on
the face of it, in large part solvable.

00:04:07.073 --> 00:04:10.943
They were not inevitable problems
that were impossible to address.

00:04:11.663 --> 00:04:13.343
So I think that was the
thing that surprised me most,

00:04:13.343 --> 00:04:14.303
actually, about the research.

00:04:14.621 --> 00:04:17.591
As ever with this research, one of
the powerful things about it is that

00:04:17.603 --> 00:04:18.926
these are directors telling us this.

00:04:18.926 --> 00:04:22.346
This is not our assessment looking
into the boardroom from the outside.

00:04:22.346 --> 00:04:26.126
This is not what governance professionals
think of boards or executives.

00:04:26.126 --> 00:04:27.866
These are the people in the room.

00:04:28.666 --> 00:04:30.706
Ralph Grayson: There's a
lot to pick apart there.

00:04:30.736 --> 00:04:34.176
So, what was the purpose
of the board value index?

00:04:34.176 --> 00:04:39.696
And does the study suggest, which
is a theme that we keep coming back

00:04:39.696 --> 00:04:44.436
to, are boards underperforming or
are the expectations of boards just

00:04:44.436 --> 00:04:46.056
becoming increasingly unrealistic?

00:04:46.856 --> 00:04:48.656
Megan Pantelides: I think one of the
things we wanted to achieve with the

00:04:48.656 --> 00:04:53.427
research, with this index, was to
cast a spotlight on something that is

00:04:54.057 --> 00:04:56.337
quite hard to see from the outside in.

00:04:56.437 --> 00:04:57.997
Are boards really delivering value?

00:04:57.997 --> 00:05:01.807
And how do directors feel about
the impact that they're having?

00:05:02.417 --> 00:05:04.877
This is an anonymous survey, so I
suppose what we're hoping to do is

00:05:04.877 --> 00:05:09.277
create maybe an overused phrase,
a safe space for directors to say,

00:05:09.997 --> 00:05:10.867
"I'm going to put my hands up.

00:05:10.867 --> 00:05:14.437
I don't think we're doing the job
that we're here to do." I think what's

00:05:14.437 --> 00:05:19.377
compounding some of the challenges that
we've identified in the research, and I

00:05:19.377 --> 00:05:23.317
suppose some of the issues that we're able
to put data against whereas previously we

00:05:23.317 --> 00:05:28.777
weren't, is that the external context is
becoming so complex and so challenging.

00:05:29.170 --> 00:05:33.997
As you  already hinted at, I think
expectations on boards are rising and I

00:05:33.997 --> 00:05:36.937
think one of the, one of the questions
I'm spending a lot of time thinking

00:05:36.937 --> 00:05:41.047
about at the moment is the extent
to which AI is making that easier or

00:05:41.047 --> 00:05:45.317
actually contributing to the sense
of the challenge and the complexity.

00:05:45.317 --> 00:05:50.027
Because I think it's obviously introduced
a whole new level of uncertainty around

00:05:50.027 --> 00:05:54.282
business models and industries and
the future of work and the workforce

00:05:54.282 --> 00:05:58.312
and human capital, how we think about
everything that we we build businesses on.

00:05:58.742 --> 00:06:04.126
But I think it's also adding to questions
around what can directors reasonably

00:06:04.126 --> 00:06:06.896
be expected to know and understand when
they walk into a boardroom when they

00:06:06.896 --> 00:06:07.506
have access to information, knowledge

00:06:09.906 --> 00:06:14.613
is now increasingly
democratised and easy to reach.

00:06:14.893 --> 00:06:17.413
Can we expect directors to
be across as much information

00:06:17.413 --> 00:06:18.763
as they now have access to?

00:06:19.293 --> 00:06:23.253
So I think that's one of the things I
think is sitting underneath all of this.

00:06:23.353 --> 00:06:26.263
Let's shine a spotlight on this
stuff because it's tricky and we

00:06:26.263 --> 00:06:29.023
want directors to be able to admit
that their job is really hard.

00:06:29.120 --> 00:06:32.191
In large part that doesn't really
happen for lots of very good reasons.

00:06:32.991 --> 00:06:35.594
Ralph Grayson: I was trying to think
as I came over, what's changed over the

00:06:35.594 --> 00:06:40.634
last 12 months from my perspective as far
as doing board searches or evaluations

00:06:41.004 --> 00:06:46.044
and coaching and I think the key word
that's coming up now much more than it

00:06:46.044 --> 00:06:48.324
was 12 months ago is that judgement word.

00:06:48.894 --> 00:06:54.824
And that judgement is contextual to
a realisation that boards are almost

00:06:54.824 --> 00:06:56.744
living in a different paradigm now.

00:06:56.894 --> 00:06:58.394
It's as though we've had a time warp.

00:06:58.968 --> 00:07:02.248
We'll come back to the dreaded
AI, I'm sure, but in terms

00:07:02.248 --> 00:07:03.388
of how it can solve for that.

00:07:03.688 --> 00:07:08.428
But I think one of the things that's come
up a lot on the podcast recently has been

00:07:08.428 --> 00:07:16.078
that all the givens and all the goalposts
that we've had for the last 20 years, over

00:07:16.078 --> 00:07:19.988
the last couple of years, have shifted and
what that means is the people who've been

00:07:19.988 --> 00:07:27.058
hired onto boards were there to solve for
a past era, not the next era and that's

00:07:27.058 --> 00:07:30.508
not only the skills, experience, knowledge
they need to be effective on the board,

00:07:31.138 --> 00:07:33.328
but it's how they use their judgement.

00:07:33.778 --> 00:07:37.498
So what for you has changed over the
12 months and where does that resonate?

00:07:37.948 --> 00:07:39.778
Megan Pantelides: There's a caveat
to the research and that it's a

00:07:39.778 --> 00:07:41.128
different group of people every time.

00:07:41.128 --> 00:07:43.888
So I suppose what I can't say is that
directors feel more confident now

00:07:43.888 --> 00:07:48.118
than they did a year ago, because
it could just be that we've sampled

00:07:48.118 --> 00:07:51.978
anonymously on a bunch of directors who
are just fundamentally wired different

00:07:51.978 --> 00:07:52.908
and have a different worldview.

00:07:53.568 --> 00:07:57.078
I think we are all becoming more
comfortable with the concept of perma

00:07:57.078 --> 00:08:00.418
crisis and that there are many things
that we can't control, and that one of

00:08:00.418 --> 00:08:04.498
the things that we need to do, whether
you're on a board or in a leadership team,

00:08:04.828 --> 00:08:08.338
is roll with the punches a little bit
more and be a little bit more agile and a

00:08:08.338 --> 00:08:11.098
little bit more prepared to change tack.

00:08:11.183 --> 00:08:15.181
One of the questions that this
all raises is, is the board

00:08:15.181 --> 00:08:17.571
construct fit for that environment?

00:08:17.751 --> 00:08:20.871
Is meeting four or six times
a year really good enough?

00:08:21.201 --> 00:08:24.201
Is that sufficient to
enable your organisation to

00:08:24.201 --> 00:08:25.850
respond to these challenges?

00:08:26.177 --> 00:08:29.759
Ralph Grayson: So I'm going to quote from
one of your colleagues Pippa Begg and

00:08:29.759 --> 00:08:34.939
I'm paraphrasing but what she said when
I read some background to the Value Index

00:08:34.939 --> 00:08:41.179
is that many boards are using structures,
information flows, and behaviours that

00:08:41.179 --> 00:08:43.459
have been designed for a different era.

00:08:44.119 --> 00:08:48.139
So what do you think that
previous era looks like?

00:08:48.139 --> 00:08:50.614
And what instinctively do
you think must replace it?

00:08:51.414 --> 00:08:54.624
Megan Pantelides: Well, I think if
we look at where boards have been

00:08:54.774 --> 00:08:59.214
and the journey that they've been
on over the last 25 years or so.

00:08:59.727 --> 00:09:06.814
So obviously, post-financial crisis,
there was a very valid demand for boards

00:09:06.814 --> 00:09:11.144
to do a better job from an oversight
and a risk management perspective.

00:09:11.654 --> 00:09:14.894
A lot of the controls and a lot of
the skillsets that were brought into

00:09:14.894 --> 00:09:19.394
boards, a lot of the processes, did a
great job of dialling up the level of

00:09:19.394 --> 00:09:23.914
oversight, the level of scrutiny, the
level of of attention to risk and so

00:09:23.914 --> 00:09:25.035
on that was going on in boardrooms.

00:09:25.035 --> 00:09:30.565
I think that response to that crisis I
think did what was needed at the time.

00:09:31.012 --> 00:09:32.712
I think this is always
about balance, isn't it?

00:09:32.712 --> 00:09:36.152
And what I hear from directors
and what I see in the research

00:09:36.152 --> 00:09:38.192
is that the balance has shifted.

00:09:38.992 --> 00:09:42.412
The space that needs to be created
and maintained in the boardroom for

00:09:42.412 --> 00:09:48.127
conversations that touch on strategy,
innovation, growth, value creation

00:09:48.817 --> 00:09:53.304
has diminished as the space dedicated
to risk management and compliance

00:09:53.304 --> 00:09:54.714
and financial performance has grown.

00:09:55.544 --> 00:10:01.184
One of the challenges that boards have
over the coming years, months probably,

00:10:01.184 --> 00:10:04.574
actually, rather than years, is to
think about how they get that balance

00:10:04.890 --> 00:10:06.700
right for the age that we're living in.

00:10:07.030 --> 00:10:12.040
And I think the age that we're living in
demands a much greater focus on strategy,

00:10:12.070 --> 00:10:14.080
innovation, growth than it ever has.

00:10:14.487 --> 00:10:18.377
That has lots of implications for
things like how frequently boards

00:10:18.377 --> 00:10:22.517
meet, for example, or the information
sets that they rely on, or the skills

00:10:22.517 --> 00:10:23.657
that they have around the table.

00:10:24.349 --> 00:10:28.313
Just as an example, I started doing
a piece of research about a year ago,

00:10:28.313 --> 00:10:33.033
actually, where I just took a snapshot
view of the FTSE 350 and the backgrounds

00:10:33.033 --> 00:10:34.754
of the people sitting on those boards.

00:10:35.414 --> 00:10:39.224
And just analysing for patterns in
terms of skill sets or backgrounds that

00:10:39.224 --> 00:10:44.884
people in those roles had and the vast
majority of people sitting on those boards

00:10:44.884 --> 00:10:46.394
had a general management background.

00:10:46.394 --> 00:10:47.474
They've been CEOs.

00:10:47.654 --> 00:10:48.884
They've been CFOs.

00:10:48.884 --> 00:10:53.954
They've been lawyers, accountants,
you know, professional services roles.

00:10:54.054 --> 00:10:57.594
Very few of them had a background
in anything that looked remotely

00:10:57.594 --> 00:11:02.844
entrepreneurial or scientific
or innovation or tech-focused.

00:11:02.844 --> 00:11:07.674
And I think that kind of shows we've
staffed boards with skillsets that

00:11:07.704 --> 00:11:12.704
do a really important job, which
is monitor performance, deliver for

00:11:12.704 --> 00:11:17.444
shareholders, that ensure that we're
compliant and we're managing risk

00:11:17.444 --> 00:11:20.594
appropriately, that we're delivering
against our regulatory obligations

00:11:21.014 --> 00:11:24.884
and our kind of duty to society to
look after other people's money.

00:11:25.684 --> 00:11:31.174
But what we're not doing is equipping
boards to be supportive or enabling of

00:11:31.174 --> 00:11:34.144
innovation in the organisation to really
push the boundaries in terms of what the

00:11:34.144 --> 00:11:38.284
organisation thinks might be possible
and I think it's really about balance.

00:11:38.284 --> 00:11:41.554
I feel like boards would be well-served
over the coming years, I think, to

00:11:41.554 --> 00:11:44.324
really think hard about whether they're
setting themselves up to do that role,

00:11:44.534 --> 00:11:45.734
as well as they are the other one.

00:11:46.334 --> 00:11:48.044
And I don't think it's an either-or thing.

00:11:48.434 --> 00:11:52.007
This is about balance and I think
that's one of the things I'm keenest

00:11:52.007 --> 00:11:55.307
to focus on in my research at the
moment because I think that balance

00:11:55.307 --> 00:11:56.387
is a difficult one to strike.

00:11:56.560 --> 00:12:00.700
Boards, governance teams need
practical support to help navigate

00:12:00.700 --> 00:12:04.230
that challenge because they've got
to serve multiple stakeholders.

00:12:04.530 --> 00:12:05.730
The stakes are rising.

00:12:05.796 --> 00:12:08.646
The environment outside the boardroom
is becoming more complex as well.

00:12:09.446 --> 00:12:10.166
Ralph Grayson: So interesting.

00:12:10.546 --> 00:12:14.356
Do you think boards, individually and
collectively, have matured in their

00:12:14.786 --> 00:12:20.076
thought process around how they add
value and how they might measure that

00:12:20.146 --> 00:12:21.753
other than their self-confidence?

00:12:22.417 --> 00:12:27.460
Megan Pantelides: One of the issues is
that very few boards really engage in

00:12:27.460 --> 00:12:29.590
that conversation, are we adding value?

00:12:29.770 --> 00:12:31.600
What are we here to do?

00:12:31.660 --> 00:12:34.420
What does value add look like
in the context of this board?

00:12:35.220 --> 00:12:39.150
And we've worked in many environments
in which you ask individual members

00:12:39.150 --> 00:12:42.870
of the board that question and you
get a whole host of different answers.

00:12:43.310 --> 00:12:45.230
And I think that's one of
the, one of the problems.

00:12:45.230 --> 00:12:46.790
So it's one of the, the difficulties.

00:12:47.590 --> 00:12:51.470
Ralph Grayson: So that brings us to
one of the headlines I wrote down

00:12:51.480 --> 00:12:53.340
on the way over thinking about this.

00:12:53.550 --> 00:12:56.130
The uncomfortable 37%, as I called it.

00:12:56.400 --> 00:13:01.610
So your report says 37% of
respondents regard their board as an

00:13:01.610 --> 00:13:03.800
essential tool for value creation.

00:13:04.520 --> 00:13:08.150
And nearly half believe the
board performs reasonably well,

00:13:08.480 --> 00:13:10.250
but could have greater impact.

00:13:10.640 --> 00:13:14.150
And 15%, it adds little or no
value if I've got all that right.

00:13:14.950 --> 00:13:18.037
So is 37% a governance crisis?

00:13:18.837 --> 00:13:22.260
Megan Pantelides: I think there are many
who would agree with you on that point.

00:13:22.850 --> 00:13:26.960
I think this research has attracted
quite a lot of interest because that

00:13:26.960 --> 00:13:28.730
is quite a provocative statement.

00:13:29.000 --> 00:13:32.810
37% of directors think their board
is an essential value creation tool.

00:13:33.230 --> 00:13:34.700
What do the rest of them think?

00:13:35.110 --> 00:13:37.330
And I'm glad it raises that question.

00:13:38.130 --> 00:13:46.230
Whether it's a governance crisis or it
is a collective recognition that it's

00:13:46.230 --> 00:13:48.720
a blooming hard job being on a board.

00:13:49.350 --> 00:13:52.710
I'm glad we're asking the question,
because I think it gives people a

00:13:52.710 --> 00:13:55.950
bit of a framework for having that
conversation in their own boardroom.

00:13:55.950 --> 00:13:57.540
So which group would we be in?

00:13:58.020 --> 00:13:59.640
And what is it that we're here to do?

00:13:59.730 --> 00:14:02.730
And what are the things that we
think are getting in our way?

00:14:02.760 --> 00:14:06.570
Do we have that balance right between
strategy and growth and innovation

00:14:06.570 --> 00:14:07.890
and risk management and control?

00:14:07.890 --> 00:14:09.210
Do we have the right skills?

00:14:09.480 --> 00:14:13.350
Are we thinking about how our
board evolves in the future?

00:14:13.553 --> 00:14:16.550
The other questions we ask in that
research are really all about unpacking

00:14:16.760 --> 00:14:22.790
that headline figure and I think we can
see lots of signs in the research, in the

00:14:22.790 --> 00:14:25.430
data about what might be driving that.

00:14:26.230 --> 00:14:30.190
I think it would be a crisis if the things
that were driving that were not solvable,

00:14:30.190 --> 00:14:32.200
but I think a lot of them are, actually.

00:14:32.590 --> 00:14:36.050
I think a lot of them stem
from inherited practices.

00:14:36.370 --> 00:14:40.300
They stem from perhaps the wrong
mix of skills around the table.

00:14:41.100 --> 00:14:43.577
People setting out with different
views on what they're there

00:14:43.577 --> 00:14:44.987
to do and how to add value.

00:14:45.087 --> 00:14:46.557
I think a lot of that is addressable.

00:14:47.427 --> 00:14:49.137
Ralph Grayson: So what's the
practical application there?

00:14:49.517 --> 00:14:54.307
We've identified the problem, you're
implying to me that needs a lot of

00:14:54.307 --> 00:14:59.827
self-evaluation and may indeed, dare
I say it, a more formal and regular

00:14:59.917 --> 00:15:04.657
external board evaluation, just to
shine a lens on what good looks like.

00:15:05.137 --> 00:15:09.157
But if people are trying to self-help
here, what are the practical

00:15:09.157 --> 00:15:12.097
things that they should be thinking
about to go from good to great?

00:15:12.397 --> 00:15:14.497
Megan Pantelides: Well, the things I'd
focus on are the things that I hear

00:15:14.497 --> 00:15:16.567
directors complain privately about.

00:15:16.667 --> 00:15:20.707
One is the board pack and the other is
how they spend their time as a board.

00:15:21.137 --> 00:15:25.417
So I guess looking at the board
pack first I think it's clear

00:15:25.417 --> 00:15:29.077
to most directors and governance
professionals what good looks like.

00:15:29.407 --> 00:15:32.857
We've just been on a nine-month
process with the Chartered Governance

00:15:32.857 --> 00:15:36.187
Institute of updating their guidance
on effective board reporting.

00:15:36.727 --> 00:15:40.777
During that process, we crunched a
lot of data, and we spoke to a lot of

00:15:40.777 --> 00:15:43.267
governance professionals, and every
one of them could articulate to us

00:15:43.267 --> 00:15:44.287
what they thought good looked like.

00:15:44.797 --> 00:15:49.147
The challenge is building a
system that delivers it routinely.

00:15:49.947 --> 00:15:53.427
In a lot of cases, you have a
governance team that are toiling

00:15:53.487 --> 00:15:58.917
late into the night, locked to the
laptops, editing other peoples' papers,

00:15:58.917 --> 00:16:03.147
reformatting them, nudging people,
chasing people to get the data out.

00:16:03.947 --> 00:16:08.117
Unfortunately, that effort is not
always rewarded because directors

00:16:08.117 --> 00:16:11.807
generally, on the whole, think their
board packs are not fit for purpose.

00:16:11.897 --> 00:16:15.557
They are battling against poor information
rather than being enabled by it.

00:16:16.357 --> 00:16:20.827
To the extent that about two-thirds
of board packs, according to our data

00:16:20.827 --> 00:16:25.357
set, would be classified as weak or
poor quality in pretty much any given

00:16:25.357 --> 00:16:26.617
year that we look at the data actually.

00:16:26.617 --> 00:16:28.027
We've been collecting
the data for eight years.

00:16:28.387 --> 00:16:32.587
We've got data now from nearly 1,700
organisations on their board packs.

00:16:32.643 --> 00:16:36.870
More information does not make boards
better informed and delivering a

00:16:36.870 --> 00:16:40.840
high-quality board pack is an operational
challenge for a lot of governance teams.

00:16:41.640 --> 00:16:47.190
We're at the point now where you can write
a first draft of a board paper in minutes.

00:16:47.190 --> 00:16:51.180
If you've got the source materials, the
right data to put into it, your financial

00:16:51.180 --> 00:16:54.870
metrics, and your notes on what you think
you want to talk about, and you've got

00:16:54.870 --> 00:16:58.050
a bit of a brief from the governance
professional running the process, or

00:16:58.050 --> 00:17:01.050
your board as to what they want to talk
about, you can click a button and have

00:17:01.050 --> 00:17:02.310
a good board paper in a few seconds.

00:17:02.310 --> 00:17:07.010
So I think there are tools that are
going to help us to put that good

00:17:07.010 --> 00:17:11.763
practice, that sense of what good looks
like into practice, much more robustly

00:17:11.763 --> 00:17:13.053
and rigorously than ever before.

00:17:13.103 --> 00:17:17.393
I add a big caveat to that, which is
not every AI tool can do that well,

00:17:17.423 --> 00:17:20.333
and you need to know exactly what
you're asking it to do and how to

00:17:20.333 --> 00:17:21.683
get it to give you a good answer.

00:17:22.483 --> 00:17:27.763
Because what boards cannot afford is
to use AI to increase the volume of

00:17:27.763 --> 00:17:30.913
information that they have to engage
with before meetings or turn that

00:17:30.913 --> 00:17:32.953
information into AI slop, right?

00:17:32.953 --> 00:17:37.153
I think they already struggle with
board packs because they're too

00:17:37.153 --> 00:17:39.583
backward-looking, they're hard to
read, they're too dense, too full

00:17:39.583 --> 00:17:43.993
of data, poorly written, read like
they've been written by five different

00:17:43.993 --> 00:17:47.523
people, so the voice is changing all
the time, format's moving around.

00:17:48.133 --> 00:17:51.433
All that sort of stuff can
be made a lot easier with AI.

00:17:51.853 --> 00:17:55.303
But it's not a panacea if it's
just used blindly and without

00:17:55.303 --> 00:17:58.493
that kind of really thorough
grounding in what good looks like.

00:17:58.493 --> 00:18:01.913
But I'd say, yeah, information quality
is something that is fixable and

00:18:01.913 --> 00:18:05.333
we know it is because we've worked
with clients on this for 20 years.

00:18:05.920 --> 00:18:10.060
You put a system of interventions in
place and you can transform the quality

00:18:10.060 --> 00:18:13.630
of your board packs that your board is
properly equipped with the information

00:18:13.630 --> 00:18:14.980
it needs walking into the boardroom.

00:18:15.760 --> 00:18:20.080
They're using their prep time to
engage with the issues, not to

00:18:20.118 --> 00:18:22.856
wade through data, trying to figure
out what the point of it all is.

00:18:23.196 --> 00:18:24.996
There is a way of defining
what good looks like.

00:18:25.056 --> 00:18:27.336
We've written guidance on it with the CGI.

00:18:27.426 --> 00:18:28.326
It's available now.

00:18:29.186 --> 00:18:35.476
We know what works, templates, training,
proper briefs, all that sort of stuff make

00:18:35.476 --> 00:18:37.262
a huge difference to board pack quality.

00:18:37.442 --> 00:18:41.475
The other point around agenda
planning, how boards use their time.

00:18:42.275 --> 00:18:45.455
Again, that's a common complaint that
I hear from directors, we spend too

00:18:45.455 --> 00:18:48.545
much time looking backwards and not
enough time looking forward and it plays

00:18:48.545 --> 00:18:53.485
into this issue around boards being
sufficiently focused and geared up to

00:18:53.485 --> 00:18:56.125
deal with innovation strategy and growth.

00:18:56.955 --> 00:19:01.035
When we see organisations really
engaging with that problem, you have

00:19:01.065 --> 00:19:07.085
the chair, the CEO, and the COSEC
spending time every six to 12 months

00:19:07.085 --> 00:19:09.905
really thinking hard about what their
forward calendar needs to look like.

00:19:09.905 --> 00:19:13.265
What are the big conversations that
need to happen in our boardroom?

00:19:13.265 --> 00:19:14.675
What are the big
decisions we need to make?

00:19:14.675 --> 00:19:16.265
And thinking about that in
a really structured ways.

00:19:16.265 --> 00:19:19.835
We've developed models and frameworks
that can help with this, six conversations

00:19:19.835 --> 00:19:25.695
model for example, that help you pinpoint
what those conversations are and then work

00:19:25.695 --> 00:19:29.475
in a structured way to map them out in
your calendar so that you are protecting

00:19:29.475 --> 00:19:32.758
time for those big conversations and
you're fitting everything else that needs

00:19:32.758 --> 00:19:33.958
to happen in the boardroom around it.

00:19:33.988 --> 00:19:36.901
I think what happens in practice
is that people start with the

00:19:36.901 --> 00:19:39.601
last agenda, and they just roll it
forward and change a few things.

00:19:40.081 --> 00:19:44.281
They start every meeting with the
procedural and the performance

00:19:44.281 --> 00:19:47.701
monitoring elements of what the
board's there to do and they leave

00:19:47.701 --> 00:19:50.791
all the big strategic knotty questions
for the second half of the meeting

00:19:50.791 --> 00:19:55.452
when everyone's energy has been used
up and they're running on caffeine.

00:19:55.792 --> 00:19:59.002
Not the best foundation for a really
high-quality discussion, especially

00:19:59.002 --> 00:20:00.552
around questions that are hard to answer.

00:20:01.042 --> 00:20:04.106
In many respects there's
just so much complexity.

00:20:04.106 --> 00:20:07.370
It's really hard for governance teams
to manage all the interdependencies

00:20:07.370 --> 00:20:12.354
between different forums and
governance structures and entities

00:20:12.354 --> 00:20:15.624
and managing all the regulatory
requirements and we have to just

00:20:15.624 --> 00:20:16.764
discuss this at this time of the year.

00:20:16.764 --> 00:20:18.324
I think there's just a lot
of complexity to it as well.

00:20:18.324 --> 00:20:21.714
So I think they need probably more support
than people realise to manage all of that.

00:20:22.054 --> 00:20:24.867
Two things that I think
are really fixable.

00:20:25.089 --> 00:20:27.730
The key thing here is that you
need the COSEC, the chair in

00:20:27.730 --> 00:20:29.170
particular working in tandem.

00:20:29.200 --> 00:20:30.880
It's not something that
the COSEC can fix alone.

00:20:31.662 --> 00:20:34.518
Ralph Grayson: And what about
the chair-CEO relationship and

00:20:34.518 --> 00:20:36.768
the board and the executive team?

00:20:36.768 --> 00:20:41.748
One of the things I found very interesting
in the report is that executives

00:20:41.748 --> 00:20:43.518
seem more positive than the NEDs do.

00:20:43.518 --> 00:20:48.438
So again, if I've got it right, 43%
of CEOs and CFOs regard the board as

00:20:48.438 --> 00:20:51.664
essential compared with only 33% of NEDs.

00:20:51.921 --> 00:20:55.311
So why do you think management might have
a more positive view of the board than

00:20:55.311 --> 00:20:57.403
the NEDs do of themselves in that respect?

00:20:58.026 --> 00:21:01.080
Megan Pantelides: I think it's possibly
because they're more in control

00:21:01.090 --> 00:21:03.310
of the conversation, in a sense.

00:21:03.372 --> 00:21:07.606
They're able to ask the board questions
and get answers to them and if the

00:21:07.606 --> 00:21:10.876
board is able to answer those questions
or to help them think through the

00:21:10.876 --> 00:21:13.276
answers to those questions, then I
think you're going to feel like you're

00:21:13.276 --> 00:21:14.716
getting value from the exchange.

00:21:15.126 --> 00:21:18.956
I suspect a lot of directors probably
feel a little bit carried along by the

00:21:18.956 --> 00:21:25.526
corporate cycle and what's expected of
them and they don't necessarily have a lot

00:21:25.526 --> 00:21:30.836
of ownership or agency in terms of shaping
what the board actually talks about.

00:21:31.536 --> 00:21:34.476
I'm speculating, but I think
that might be part of it.

00:21:34.776 --> 00:21:37.843
The irony is not lost on me that
our board meeting is going on in the

00:21:37.843 --> 00:21:42.843
room next door at the moment  and
when I speak to our exec team about

00:21:42.843 --> 00:21:46.863
what value they get from the board
meeting, I think it is exactly that.

00:21:46.863 --> 00:21:53.183
It is this is a forum for us to ask for
advice and to get input from a group

00:21:53.183 --> 00:21:56.153
of people who have a very different
knowledge and experience set to our

00:21:56.153 --> 00:21:59.423
own, very different frames of reference
and ways of looking at the world,

00:21:59.873 --> 00:22:02.843
and to get them to engage with the
questions that we're asking ourselves

00:22:03.323 --> 00:22:05.213
on a daily, weekly, monthly basis.

00:22:05.643 --> 00:22:09.240
That's achieved in practice when the
process of collaborating on the board

00:22:09.240 --> 00:22:11.681
agenda is a collaborative one, actually.

00:22:11.801 --> 00:22:16.061
It's not something that happens in someone
else's office and you get sent it and

00:22:16.861 --> 00:22:18.691
you turn up and go through the motions.

00:22:18.691 --> 00:22:20.461
It is a really collaborative exercise.

00:22:20.461 --> 00:22:23.071
It says, "What are the things
that we really need to talk about

00:22:23.461 --> 00:22:26.531
in this board meeting versus the
next one in two months' time?"

00:22:27.045 --> 00:22:28.845
Ralph Grayson: Brings to
my perennial question.

00:22:29.035 --> 00:22:31.285
What does board leadership look like?

00:22:31.675 --> 00:22:36.305
Do you think in terms of defining
the role, do you think board members

00:22:36.305 --> 00:22:41.135
have matured or thinking has matured
around what does board leadership

00:22:41.405 --> 00:22:47.272
look like and how can the board lead,
the old noses in fingers out, over

00:22:47.272 --> 00:22:49.655
executive behaviour of board members?

00:22:50.349 --> 00:22:52.717
Megan Pantelides: I think it probably
has and I think it comes back to

00:22:52.717 --> 00:22:56.990
that point you made earlier about
judgement because I think board

00:22:56.990 --> 00:22:59.990
members are becoming more cognizant
of the need to exercise judgement.

00:23:00.074 --> 00:23:04.344
There's more academic work being done
on this, your own included, that really

00:23:04.404 --> 00:23:07.944
raises the question as to what the
board is there to do and the board is

00:23:07.944 --> 00:23:11.814
there ultimately to exercise judgement
to help the executive team make the

00:23:11.814 --> 00:23:16.060
right decisions, to help ensure that the
team have the right sort of parameters

00:23:16.060 --> 00:23:20.830
and guiding principles to deliver what
the organisation exists to deliver.

00:23:20.830 --> 00:23:25.744
And I think the reality is that there's
so much to be done in the boardroom

00:23:26.544 --> 00:23:30.650
that many directors, are cognizant
of the need to get the balance right.

00:23:30.700 --> 00:23:32.770
Having said that, I think when
people do get too into the weeds,

00:23:32.770 --> 00:23:35.561
that is a contributing factor to the
sense that you're overstretched and

00:23:35.561 --> 00:23:37.151
don't have enough time to do things.

00:23:37.151 --> 00:23:39.325
So probably two, two
sides of a coin there.

00:23:40.305 --> 00:23:44.201
Ralph Grayson: Clearly the role
has become a lot more onerous in

00:23:44.201 --> 00:23:45.761
terms of the personal visibility.

00:23:45.761 --> 00:23:50.127
I think certainly from my perspective
chairs have become as visible as

00:23:50.127 --> 00:23:54.437
CEOs these days and success and
failure are increasingly equally

00:23:54.437 --> 00:23:55.247
weighted between the chair.

00:23:55.457 --> 00:23:56.807
BP is classic example, right?

00:23:57.227 --> 00:24:04.056
So if we look at this efficiency
in that respect, and you've touched

00:24:04.056 --> 00:24:07.796
on a number of different ways in
which a board can be more efficient.

00:24:08.396 --> 00:24:13.436
Again, the board findings, 89% of
respondents regard their board processes

00:24:13.436 --> 00:24:19.856
and meetings as efficient, yet 86% say
they have overly rigid or inconsistent

00:24:19.856 --> 00:24:23.576
processes, which, and I think you touched
on this, of course, delayed, rushed or

00:24:23.576 --> 00:24:26.186
poor decisions in the previous six months.

00:24:26.651 --> 00:24:29.743
So how can a board be efficient?

00:24:30.543 --> 00:24:33.513
And the million dollar question, how
can they still make poor decisions?

00:24:33.957 --> 00:24:34.797
Megan Pantelides: That's
a really good question.

00:24:34.863 --> 00:24:37.233
I suspect one of the things that
underlies that sense that boards

00:24:37.233 --> 00:24:40.399
are operating efficiently is that
there isn't a lot of slack or

00:24:40.399 --> 00:24:41.899
downtime in what boards do, right?

00:24:41.899 --> 00:24:46.389
They are trying to eke as much value
out of every interaction that they can.

00:24:46.779 --> 00:24:51.679
I also think that they probably don't
see the half of what goes on behind the

00:24:51.679 --> 00:24:56.329
scenes in terms of supporting the board
and delivering the board cycle, right?

00:24:56.329 --> 00:24:59.749
So they don't see those late nights
that the governance team are pulling

00:24:59.749 --> 00:25:03.529
to try and get the board packs
in the right format, out on time.

00:25:03.799 --> 00:25:07.589
They don't see the work that the
management team are doing draft

00:25:07.649 --> 00:25:10.469
after draft of the board paper
as it goes up and down the chain.

00:25:10.956 --> 00:25:13.969
That's possibly something to
kind of flag about that figure.

00:25:13.969 --> 00:25:17.873
I think it's probably slightly inflated
and I think, if you ask different people

00:25:18.153 --> 00:25:19.533
you might get a slightly different answer.

00:25:19.613 --> 00:25:21.693
Ralph Grayson: Well, and to that
point, sorry to jump in, but it's been

00:25:21.693 --> 00:25:23.163
fascinating in the last few podcasts.

00:25:23.493 --> 00:25:29.993
Those and some people you know well in
the stewardship world are still fixated

00:25:29.993 --> 00:25:34.493
about the issue of board packs and
the board process being a box ticking

00:25:34.493 --> 00:25:37.733
exercise rather than a focus on outcomes.

00:25:38.473 --> 00:25:41.413
What's the value index tell you
or your conversations around this?

00:25:41.626 --> 00:25:42.436
Where's your head on this?

00:25:42.696 --> 00:25:45.406
Megan Pantelides: Yeah, well, I think
one of the factors that contributes to

00:25:45.436 --> 00:25:52.213
the vast time and resource that goes
into writing board papers and the growing

00:25:52.273 --> 00:25:56.113
volume of information that directors are
expected to engage with every board cycle

00:25:56.203 --> 00:26:00.243
is a cover my backside sort of mentality.

00:26:00.566 --> 00:26:02.626
Which comes from a very sensible place.

00:26:02.826 --> 00:26:06.056
It's a very rational response
to the situation we're in where

00:26:06.056 --> 00:26:09.566
boards are raked over the coals for
not having known certain things.

00:26:10.366 --> 00:26:11.416
Well, include it.

00:26:11.896 --> 00:26:14.686
Give them everything they could
possibly need to know, and then

00:26:14.866 --> 00:26:15.886
no one's going to get in trouble.

00:26:16.606 --> 00:26:19.795
Ralph Grayson: So sorry, is
that the mindset or is that a

00:26:19.855 --> 00:26:23.295
process practical application?

00:26:23.365 --> 00:26:24.465
Megan Pantelides: I
think it's a bit of both.

00:26:24.495 --> 00:26:25.365
I think it's a bit of both.

00:26:25.425 --> 00:26:30.332
I think in an ideal world, there would be
sufficient intellectual and psychological

00:26:30.332 --> 00:26:35.362
safety within organisations to be able
to choose exactly what you think the

00:26:35.362 --> 00:26:38.512
board needs to see, and to give them
all the bad stuff, as well as the good

00:26:38.512 --> 00:26:42.232
stuff, in a really open and transparent
way, because you know that they want

00:26:42.232 --> 00:26:43.342
to engage with it in the right way.

00:26:43.793 --> 00:26:47.298
When things go wrong, I think there's
a fear that will come back to bite you.

00:26:47.578 --> 00:26:52.818
But I think it is also a bit
of process because I think the

00:26:52.818 --> 00:26:57.468
reality is that we have lots of
information at our fingertips.

00:26:57.468 --> 00:27:01.308
We have limited time, because we're trying
to do our day jobs and run the business.

00:27:01.408 --> 00:27:05.258
But I also think there's a lack of
training and awareness within teams

00:27:05.258 --> 00:27:08.078
as to what the board really needs, and
there's a lack of a conversation about

00:27:08.738 --> 00:27:11.768
what the board really needs and I think
in a lot of cases, the governance team

00:27:11.768 --> 00:27:16.088
doesn't feel empowered or supported to
really push back on that or to put the

00:27:16.358 --> 00:27:20.273
steps in place that they know will make
a difference to that and to fill that gap

00:27:20.273 --> 00:27:21.863
in terms of knowledge and expectations.

00:27:21.863 --> 00:27:23.423
So I think it's both.

00:27:23.885 --> 00:27:28.115
Ralph Grayson: So going back to the
goalposts have moved in terms of that

00:27:28.115 --> 00:27:32.855
clarity of what are we here for in today's
world rather than yesterday's world.

00:27:33.655 --> 00:27:38.715
Is there a way that AI or is there
a way that Board Intelligence can

00:27:38.715 --> 00:27:43.645
help board members and boards as a
living organism think about that?

00:27:44.227 --> 00:27:44.867
Megan Pantelides: Yeah, absolutely.

00:27:45.035 --> 00:27:50.494
I mean, this has been the question that
has consumed so much of our time and

00:27:50.494 --> 00:27:56.524
energy over the last few months because
we want to deploy AI responsibly for

00:27:56.524 --> 00:28:01.414
boards and governance teams and we want
to deploy AI in a way that actually makes

00:28:01.414 --> 00:28:04.494
their lives easier and outcomes better.

00:28:04.894 --> 00:28:08.840
I think the temptation with so much of the
innovation that's happening around AI is

00:28:08.840 --> 00:28:13.640
just to focus on finding ways to shortcut
things and make things quicker and easier.

00:28:14.367 --> 00:28:18.817
But I think what we can't risk
in boardrooms is shutting off

00:28:18.817 --> 00:28:23.377
our critical thinking muscle and
giving up all responsibility for

00:28:23.737 --> 00:28:25.714
exercising judgement to AI, right?

00:28:25.722 --> 00:28:26.710
Nobody wants that.

00:28:26.760 --> 00:28:29.310
Ralph Grayson: And to the critical
thinking point, can't miss a plug here,

00:28:29.550 --> 00:28:33.030
you co-wrote a book with some of your
colleagues here on critical thinking.

00:28:33.180 --> 00:28:35.340
It's a must read it if you're
interested in governance.

00:28:35.340 --> 00:28:36.953
Sorry, governance geek in me coming out.

00:28:37.753 --> 00:28:39.583
Megan Pantelides: Thank you for
the plug, Collective Intelligence.

00:28:39.903 --> 00:28:44.123
Critical thinking is so fundamental
to the point that Jen Sundberg,

00:28:44.173 --> 00:28:48.460
who co-founded Board Intelligence,
has now set up a holiday camp for

00:28:48.460 --> 00:28:49.870
kids to help them think critically.

00:28:49.952 --> 00:28:54.120
It's such an essential life skill and
we're not equipping people with it early

00:28:54.120 --> 00:28:57.126
enough and I think in the boardroom,
it's become even more important.

00:28:57.126 --> 00:29:01.526
So I think everything we're trying to do
at Board Intelligence is about supporting

00:29:01.526 --> 00:29:04.586
directors to exercise their critical
thinking muscle to apply their judgement

00:29:06.686 --> 00:29:08.426
. That is fundamentally
what they're there to do.

00:29:08.846 --> 00:29:13.196
They bring their unique perspectives,
their unique ways of thinking about things

00:29:13.196 --> 00:29:18.266
and dissecting problems, their unique
knowledge and frames of reference, and

00:29:18.266 --> 00:29:22.616
they pull them all together to come to a
decision about something, or to analyse

00:29:22.616 --> 00:29:24.146
a problem, or work out a solution.

00:29:24.829 --> 00:29:27.342
We're all going on our own
personal journeys with AI, right?

00:29:27.342 --> 00:29:32.262
We all have our tools that we use and
I think I'm probably quite typical

00:29:32.262 --> 00:29:37.752
in that I engage with AI tools that I
have at my disposal very differently

00:29:37.752 --> 00:29:38.892
to the way I did a year ago.

00:29:38.892 --> 00:29:42.882
A year ago, it was like, "Brilliant, this
can do all this stuff super fast for me."

00:29:42.882 --> 00:29:46.155
But then you start to think, "I'm not
sure I really trust it, and I don't think

00:29:46.155 --> 00:29:49.965
I'm giving it the right prompts." I use
it as much now as a critical thinking

00:29:49.965 --> 00:29:53.635
partner as a do things faster partner and
I think the same is true in boardrooms.

00:29:53.635 --> 00:29:59.321
So we've launched a new tool a couple
of months ago, which essentially allows

00:29:59.321 --> 00:30:04.001
directors in the meeting prep phase, it's
not a tool that sits in the boardroom

00:30:04.001 --> 00:30:10.391
and intervenes during discussions, but it
sits within their board portal and allows

00:30:10.391 --> 00:30:16.331
them to engage with a really wide range
of alternative perspectives on topics.

00:30:16.331 --> 00:30:21.101
So if you're looking at a paper
on sustainability, for example,

00:30:21.101 --> 00:30:22.721
you're not a sustainability expert.

00:30:23.521 --> 00:30:25.021
What's the latest thinking on this?

00:30:25.801 --> 00:30:28.505
I need to ask some questions to
understand these topics and what are

00:30:28.505 --> 00:30:32.615
the questions it's asking in more
detail, these terms, these scenarios

00:30:32.665 --> 00:30:34.615
this regulatory context, et cetera.

00:30:34.855 --> 00:30:37.701
It allows you to go really deep into
that subject matter expertise and

00:30:37.701 --> 00:30:42.055
engage in a kind of self-propagated
kind of inquiry process before

00:30:42.055 --> 00:30:43.105
you've even walked into the room.

00:30:43.105 --> 00:30:47.025
So the idea is that you walk
into the room better equipped to

00:30:47.025 --> 00:30:48.465
contribute to that discussion.

00:30:48.945 --> 00:30:54.485
It also, references your past pack history
and your organisation's internal kind of

00:30:54.485 --> 00:30:59.645
knowledge bank or strategy documents, et
cetera, to help you ask questions about

00:30:59.705 --> 00:31:01.291
the information you've been presented.

00:31:01.341 --> 00:31:05.934
For example, have we fully considered the
impact of this on all of our stakeholders?

00:31:06.384 --> 00:31:10.324
Are we making any assumptions in this
paper that need to be tested further?

00:31:11.104 --> 00:31:14.044
Have we thought about all the different
scenarios that might play out here?

00:31:14.611 --> 00:31:17.191
You've kind of got a whole team
of people sitting around you.

00:31:17.291 --> 00:31:18.061
Ralph Grayson: Is there a
danger of data overload here?

00:31:18.491 --> 00:31:21.391
Writing data on top of data on
top of data, which doesn't solve

00:31:21.391 --> 00:31:22.831
for good judgement, does it?

00:31:22.891 --> 00:31:23.851
Or maybe it does.

00:31:23.974 --> 00:31:30.448
Megan Pantelides: So I think what it
enables directors to do is to use their

00:31:30.448 --> 00:31:38.588
meeting prep time, not to wade through
documents and try and work out whether

00:31:38.798 --> 00:31:43.948
this data point here aligns with this
data point over here, or this assumption

00:31:44.048 --> 00:31:46.418
does that contradict any of the other
assumptions we've made elsewhere?

00:31:46.418 --> 00:31:47.888
They don't have to do that kind of work.

00:31:48.278 --> 00:31:50.498
What they're doing is really thinking
through the questions that are

00:31:50.498 --> 00:31:51.788
being asked of them by management.

00:31:52.091 --> 00:31:55.568
I think there is a risk that directors
can feel slightly overwhelmed by the

00:31:55.568 --> 00:31:57.578
range of sources of information out there.

00:31:57.968 --> 00:32:01.628
But I think doing it in a sort of curated
way that's anchored to the board pack

00:32:01.628 --> 00:32:05.533
and the company's kind of institutional
knowledge and aligned to the things that

00:32:06.333 --> 00:32:10.623
we know boards need to engage with the
topics that are coming up most frequently.

00:32:10.993 --> 00:32:15.753
Individual directors tend to be less
well-equipped, because you can't

00:32:15.753 --> 00:32:18.693
have an expert on all of these things
around every board table, right?

00:32:18.723 --> 00:32:21.993
It would be a United Nations
kind of council that was

00:32:21.993 --> 00:32:23.163
never able to make a decision.

00:32:23.163 --> 00:32:27.853
So it's just about trying to amplify
that sort of preparation process and

00:32:27.853 --> 00:32:31.240
make sure that they can walk into the
boardroom engaged in the discussion,

00:32:31.630 --> 00:32:35.300
already thinking through second,
third, fourth order implications,

00:32:35.540 --> 00:32:38.280
and ask the right questions so that
the board can reach a better outcome.

00:32:39.300 --> 00:32:42.930
I suppose it's about supercharging what
the directors bring to the room rather

00:32:42.930 --> 00:32:45.740
than shortcutting it or replacing it.

00:32:46.140 --> 00:32:51.330
As we stand today, it is the duty of
a director to exercise independent

00:32:51.330 --> 00:32:56.090
judgement I think the challenge that
we have at the moment is that because

00:32:56.551 --> 00:33:01.083
they get so much information, they have
limited time, I'm not sure they're doing

00:33:01.143 --> 00:33:03.513
that as well as they might actually.

00:33:03.603 --> 00:33:06.093
So I don't think we're starting from a
perfect place and it's going to get worse.

00:33:06.093 --> 00:33:10.143
I think we're starting from quite a low
base and this stands to help improve it.

00:33:10.943 --> 00:33:15.283
Ralph Grayson: Did one of your earlier
reports, I've highlighted a quote, "Less

00:33:15.283 --> 00:33:20.530
information, more insight." How does
a board member get that balance right?

00:33:20.580 --> 00:33:22.290
Is that down to the company secretary?

00:33:22.560 --> 00:33:24.690
Is it down to the chair
talking to the CEO?

00:33:25.180 --> 00:33:26.276
How do we optimise it?

00:33:26.752 --> 00:33:28.522
Megan Pantelides: Getting out of
the habit of sharing information for

00:33:28.522 --> 00:33:33.063
information's sake and sharing insight
is absolutely crucial to fixing this

00:33:33.063 --> 00:33:36.526
board information problem because I
think that is the crux of it really.

00:33:37.266 --> 00:33:41.676
One of the most valuable aspects of
the board reporting process is actually

00:33:41.676 --> 00:33:47.996
the opportunity it gives management
to sit back, think, and engage with

00:33:49.036 --> 00:33:54.096
what's going on in their function
or their business in a critical way.

00:33:54.696 --> 00:33:59.306
When management do that, when they're
writing a board paper, when they give

00:33:59.306 --> 00:34:03.206
themselves a kind of structured framework
for thinking through the questions,

00:34:03.536 --> 00:34:06.056
when they have a good steer from the
board of what the board is interested

00:34:06.056 --> 00:34:08.886
in, then I think what you get in the
board paper is much more likely to

00:34:08.886 --> 00:34:10.236
offer insight than just information.

00:34:10.317 --> 00:34:13.594
I think one of the most useful
things that comes from writing a good

00:34:13.594 --> 00:34:17.134
board paper is the opportunity for
reflection that it gives management.

00:34:17.934 --> 00:34:23.554
Ralph Grayson: So how does a good board
paper improve board behaviour and help

00:34:23.554 --> 00:34:28.713
the chair create that safe space in which
people dare ask the provocative question?

00:34:29.566 --> 00:34:30.856
Megan Pantelides: We
know it definitely does.

00:34:30.956 --> 00:34:34.376
So I think in our the research that
we've just done with the CGI some quite

00:34:34.376 --> 00:34:37.796
interesting stats about the impact of
board reporting to support what we've

00:34:37.796 --> 00:34:39.216
covered in the Board Value Index as well.

00:34:39.216 --> 00:34:42.936
So I think 42% of the people we
surveyed in that poll said that they

00:34:43.166 --> 00:34:45.696
thought their board materials were
limiting their board's effectiveness.

00:34:45.696 --> 00:34:48.726
So I think there is an understanding
that there is a direct link between

00:34:49.236 --> 00:34:51.696
board paper quality and board outcomes.

00:34:52.096 --> 00:34:56.795
When you look at an individual board pack
or a board paper when it's done well.

00:34:57.275 --> 00:35:00.939
So first thing it does is it
orients the board with a really

00:35:00.939 --> 00:35:04.129
good understanding of where the
organisation is or where it's heading.

00:35:04.629 --> 00:35:10.489
I think it then guides the directors
to engage their brains around the

00:35:10.489 --> 00:35:13.579
topics that are going to make the
biggest difference to changing that

00:35:13.579 --> 00:35:15.259
trajectory and achieving those goals.

00:35:15.709 --> 00:35:18.889
So the board aren't left trying to
figure out what the big questions are.

00:35:19.689 --> 00:35:23.559
They're not left trying to figure out
what's really going on with performance.

00:35:23.889 --> 00:35:27.129
They walk into that room with a really
clear understanding of where the

00:35:27.299 --> 00:35:30.989
organisation's at, a shared understanding
of where it's going and what the issues

00:35:30.989 --> 00:35:34.229
are that they need to engage with and
a really clear set of questions for

00:35:34.229 --> 00:35:35.669
them to grapple with in the meeting.

00:35:35.669 --> 00:35:38.069
It's really clear what the expectation
is from management as to what they're

00:35:38.069 --> 00:35:41.009
going to talk about and what they're
going to decide, what input and

00:35:41.009 --> 00:35:42.179
advice they're going to give back.

00:35:42.449 --> 00:35:43.529
So I think that's the first thing.

00:35:43.919 --> 00:35:47.069
I think the other characteristic
of a great board paper or great

00:35:47.069 --> 00:35:48.449
board pack is that it is candid.

00:35:48.959 --> 00:35:51.659
So that picture of where the
organisation's at and where it's

00:35:51.659 --> 00:35:57.688
heading is not a rose-tinted spectacles
view it is the warts and all view.

00:35:57.688 --> 00:36:02.758
Because actually, sometimes the board's
advice is best directed towards,

00:36:02.788 --> 00:36:03.838
"Okay, we're doing really well here.

00:36:03.838 --> 00:36:07.708
How can we do more of this?" But equally
it can be, "What's the thing coming

00:36:07.708 --> 00:36:09.958
down the track that I'm not thinking
about that I need to be thinking

00:36:09.958 --> 00:36:13.938
about?" Both of those conversations
add value, but if you've only got a

00:36:13.938 --> 00:36:16.698
board pack that tells you everything's
fine, thank you very much for asking.

00:36:17.418 --> 00:36:19.548
I'd like my pat on the back and I'd
like to get out of here as quickly

00:36:19.548 --> 00:36:21.948
as possible, then you're not going
to get the advice that you need.

00:36:22.488 --> 00:36:25.038
And we all know boards hate surprises.

00:36:25.638 --> 00:36:28.488
and it will show up as a surprise
in the data and the narrative

00:36:28.488 --> 00:36:31.788
sometime later, which does nothing
for your kind of credibility as an

00:36:31.788 --> 00:36:33.138
individual reporting into the board.

00:36:33.138 --> 00:36:36.142
So I think those are the main
impacts that we see, certainly.

00:36:36.542 --> 00:36:38.673
Ralph Grayson: So when boards
have had the wisdom to have this

00:36:38.673 --> 00:36:43.923
super-duper board intelligent
sufficient process, does that change

00:36:44.583 --> 00:36:49.893
the nature of the skills, experience,
knowledge of the individual NED?

00:36:49.980 --> 00:36:52.320
Are we moving away from
the generalist NED?

00:36:52.770 --> 00:36:54.870
Are we still having a T-shaped NED?

00:36:56.150 --> 00:36:59.330
What does the human look like
once the board has implemented

00:36:59.330 --> 00:37:00.680
the Board Intelligence process?

00:37:01.130 --> 00:37:03.260
Megan Pantelides: I think it
probably supports the case for

00:37:03.260 --> 00:37:04.400
more generalists, actually.

00:37:05.040 --> 00:37:09.060
Ralph Grayson: I think what's
interesting is when we are coaching

00:37:09.060 --> 00:37:14.990
NEDs as opposed to executives, there
is this lack of clarity in many NED's

00:37:14.990 --> 00:37:18.620
minds as to what do I now solve for?

00:37:18.800 --> 00:37:21.620
I used to know what I solved for on
a board, and therefore I knew the

00:37:21.620 --> 00:37:24.570
roles I was going to go for and the
types of boards I want to be on and

00:37:24.570 --> 00:37:31.230
whether that's technical skill, sector
experience, or board behaviour, I

00:37:31.230 --> 00:37:34.890
think there's less clarity and the more
confusion if that's not an oxymoron.

00:37:35.400 --> 00:37:37.346
I just wonder what your
experience with this is?

00:37:37.883 --> 00:37:40.653
Megan Pantelides: I guess even
generalists, they have spikes

00:37:40.653 --> 00:37:41.763
in particular areas, right?

00:37:41.763 --> 00:37:43.423
And I think you still need that blend.

00:37:44.023 --> 00:37:45.463
You're never going to find
five people that look and

00:37:45.463 --> 00:37:46.573
sound exactly the same, right?

00:37:46.573 --> 00:37:48.903
And I think you should always be
looking to think in a structured way

00:37:48.903 --> 00:37:52.083
around kind of what skills, where your
organisation's heading, the challenges

00:37:52.083 --> 00:37:54.513
it's going to face, and skills that
are best suited to tackling that.

00:37:54.873 --> 00:37:58.533
To engage with AI tools, to engage with
the information that management are giving

00:37:58.533 --> 00:38:00.132
you, a level of knowledge is required.

00:38:00.132 --> 00:38:02.612
We've not completely democratised
access to all knowledge, right?

00:38:02.642 --> 00:38:07.482
You still need to be able to sense
check and understand the answers that

00:38:07.482 --> 00:38:10.787
you're getting from the tools and the
information that you're being served.

00:38:11.287 --> 00:38:15.642
I think the bar is being raised in
terms of expectations of directors.

00:38:15.792 --> 00:38:17.082
It continues to be raised.

00:38:17.292 --> 00:38:21.212
I think this is something we've all
seen over the last however many years.

00:38:21.482 --> 00:38:24.140
Expectations are raised the range
of things you're having to engage

00:38:24.140 --> 00:38:25.520
with as a board is expanding.

00:38:25.790 --> 00:38:34.130
I think the reality is you can't
solve for every topic or decision by

00:38:34.220 --> 00:38:35.561
bringing specialists onto the board.

00:38:35.570 --> 00:38:36.870
There isn't enough space for them.

00:38:37.670 --> 00:38:41.120
Build pop-up boards or whatever it is
that you need to do to bring that kind

00:38:41.120 --> 00:38:42.980
of expertise in as and when you need it.

00:38:42.980 --> 00:38:45.990
Engage with tooling, bring
in outside perspectives.

00:38:46.530 --> 00:38:48.950
But I don't think you can solve
your way to dealing with all these

00:38:48.950 --> 00:38:52.100
big challenges, fixing all the
problems that your organisation may

00:38:52.100 --> 00:38:53.570
face by bringing specialists in.

00:38:53.570 --> 00:38:57.014
But it puts the onus on the individual
to be really clear about what it

00:38:57.014 --> 00:38:59.564
is that they bring and everyone
does bring something unique.

00:38:59.684 --> 00:39:01.724
But I don't think it makes
it easier to get onto boards.

00:39:01.994 --> 00:39:04.514
If anything it probably makes it
harder, and maybe that's right.

00:39:04.588 --> 00:39:08.170
Maybe in this age what we need
people to be doing is really

00:39:08.170 --> 00:39:11.800
thinking hard about whether they can
add value and how they add value.

00:39:11.891 --> 00:39:13.760
Ralph Grayson: And at what point
do we replace a human with a bot?

00:39:14.910 --> 00:39:17.420
Megan Pantelides: Well, that's the
million dollar question, isn't it?

00:39:18.490 --> 00:39:20.150
I can't see that happening anytime soon.

00:39:20.180 --> 00:39:23.866
I mean, there certainly are
organisations that have put AI tools

00:39:24.286 --> 00:39:27.166
into roles with decision-making agency.

00:39:27.976 --> 00:39:30.346
We've seen it in investment committees
in the Middle East and so on.

00:39:31.146 --> 00:39:34.776
I can't see it happening
in the UK anytime soon.

00:39:35.046 --> 00:39:37.506
Not least because our regulatory context
just doesn't allow for it, right?

00:39:37.869 --> 00:39:39.879
Ralph Grayson: So I'm going to
throw some of your own data at you.

00:39:39.939 --> 00:39:39.999
Megan Pantelides: Yeah.

00:39:40.079 --> 00:39:40.409
Go for it.

00:39:41.019 --> 00:39:45.449
Ralph Grayson: So 84% of boards have
engaged with the question of human-led

00:39:45.449 --> 00:39:47.309
versus AI-led decision-making.

00:39:47.999 --> 00:39:52.829
Only 49% are actively moving from
discussion into review or implementation.

00:39:53.629 --> 00:39:57.259
Board Intelligence's separate
readiness analysis found that only

00:39:57.259 --> 00:40:03.259
11% of boards meet even a relatively
conservative AI readiness threshold.

00:40:03.702 --> 00:40:08.502
So are we discussing AI because
it's genuinely on the agenda?

00:40:09.302 --> 00:40:14.432
Or is it because directors think or
know it ought to be or they ought to be

00:40:14.432 --> 00:40:16.114
seen and heard to be talking about it?

00:40:16.661 --> 00:40:19.241
Megan Pantelides: The interesting
thing about that data point, the first

00:40:19.241 --> 00:40:25.001
data point, is that it shows that the
conversation about AI is evolving from

00:40:25.001 --> 00:40:28.421
being "What is AI and how do we use it?

00:40:28.451 --> 00:40:30.251
How's this going to
disrupt our business model?

00:40:30.286 --> 00:40:32.296
What governance frameworks do we
need to put in place to make sure

00:40:32.296 --> 00:40:34.816
that this is deployed responsibly in
our organisation, et cetera." It's

00:40:34.816 --> 00:40:37.926
moved from that to "What extent are
we happy with AI making decisions?

00:40:37.926 --> 00:40:41.314
And which decisions do we think AI can
make versus which decisions need to

00:40:41.604 --> 00:40:45.049
remain kind of human-led?" And that's
exactly the kind of question that we

00:40:45.049 --> 00:40:46.549
asked if boards were engaging with.

00:40:47.169 --> 00:40:49.579
I don't think this suggests that
boards have fundamentally changed

00:40:49.609 --> 00:40:54.229
how they operate to meet the
challenges of an AI-enabled world.

00:40:54.679 --> 00:40:59.137
I think that the readiness radar
data shows that the processes and

00:40:59.137 --> 00:41:02.977
the practices around governance are
moving much more slowly than the

00:41:02.977 --> 00:41:04.717
conversation around AI is moving.

00:41:05.077 --> 00:41:07.477
And I think that sort of sits
at the heart of quite a lot

00:41:07.477 --> 00:41:08.677
of what we talked about today.

00:41:08.677 --> 00:41:13.374
I think the outside world is moving
at one pace, and boards are moving

00:41:13.374 --> 00:41:17.064
at another pace and I think that's
where there's a bit of a gap forming.

00:41:17.844 --> 00:41:22.884
We know that AI has this immense
capability and in lots of parts

00:41:22.884 --> 00:41:26.851
of the world it's moving way
faster than we hear in the UK can

00:41:26.851 --> 00:41:28.231
imagine, I think, at the moment.

00:41:28.741 --> 00:41:33.191
Certainly those who are developing the
technology at the kind of pioneering

00:41:33.611 --> 00:41:38.001
edge of things have very big and
bold ideas about what AI can do.

00:41:38.401 --> 00:41:42.421
Board practices are not likely
to keep up with that pace.

00:41:42.821 --> 00:41:45.521
One other interesting observation
from this research was that

00:41:47.731 --> 00:41:50.881
the extent to which boards themselves
are thinking about how their own

00:41:50.881 --> 00:41:52.621
role and how they work might change.

00:41:52.964 --> 00:41:58.167
The takeaway was that too few boards
anticipate the sort of change that

00:41:58.174 --> 00:42:02.374
I think is necessary to rise to that
challenge and to ensure that we're

00:42:03.174 --> 00:42:05.664
harnessing AI rather than being led by it.

00:42:06.114 --> 00:42:11.334
Ralph Grayson: Surely the answer to this
is that the pace of change means that

00:42:11.364 --> 00:42:15.474
the regularity, quarterly nature of board
meetings is no longer fit for purpose.

00:42:16.134 --> 00:42:22.054
So do you think that is the trend
and how can AI be the bridge between

00:42:22.054 --> 00:42:23.378
those quarterly board meetings?

00:42:24.086 --> 00:42:27.179
Megan Pantelides: I don't know whether
AI needs to be the bridge between

00:42:27.179 --> 00:42:28.259
those quarterly board meetings.

00:42:28.533 --> 00:42:35.019
I think boards are finding ways
to get together more frequently

00:42:35.049 --> 00:42:36.999
and in more of a bite-sized form.

00:42:37.189 --> 00:42:40.806
I don't think anyone's really solved
this yet and I suspect everything that

00:42:40.806 --> 00:42:46.236
we've seen has been experimentation
rather than a marked shift and a kind

00:42:46.236 --> 00:42:47.676
of trend that people are following.

00:42:47.676 --> 00:42:50.046
I think people are still trying to get
their heads around it, to be honest.

00:42:50.526 --> 00:42:54.306
What we are likely to see is that
those organisations already have a

00:42:54.306 --> 00:42:57.926
relatively slow moving board cycle.

00:42:58.385 --> 00:43:02.972
Unless the rest of their organisation
is moving like a sports car, and

00:43:02.972 --> 00:43:05.912
for some reason, the board operates
at a more of an oil tanker pace.

00:43:06.362 --> 00:43:09.329
Unless that's the case, they're
going to find themselves behind.

00:43:09.526 --> 00:43:12.006
If you think about a board that
meets 10 times a year, they're

00:43:12.006 --> 00:43:15.456
just pooling their expertise and
their insight much more frequently.

00:43:15.456 --> 00:43:18.636
They're looking at decisions and
revisiting them much more frequently.

00:43:19.116 --> 00:43:22.176
They have their finger on the pulse
in a way that it's just impossible

00:43:22.176 --> 00:43:26.466
to do when you turn up once a quarter
having read a 400-page board pack

00:43:26.466 --> 00:43:27.546
that was produced six weeks ago.

00:43:27.576 --> 00:43:30.686
The reality is that we'll just
start to see organisations

00:43:30.686 --> 00:43:31.976
move at very different paces.

00:43:32.776 --> 00:43:34.156
Ralph Grayson: Let's just try
and pull this together then.

00:43:34.166 --> 00:43:40.796
So a couple of recommendations for either
chairs or NEDs when you put the pen

00:43:40.796 --> 00:43:43.586
down figuratively on this year's report.

00:43:44.036 --> 00:43:50.686
Megan Pantelides: Inviting the board to
explore where the board might need to go

00:43:51.016 --> 00:43:55.396
and how it might need to evolve to meet
these challenges, I think is a good idea.

00:43:55.696 --> 00:43:59.128
I know there's an awful lot of subjects
competing for space in a board agenda.

00:43:59.743 --> 00:44:02.623
But this is precisely the sort of thing
that you should be talking about at a

00:44:02.623 --> 00:44:06.182
strategy day or off the back of a board
effectiveness review or something.

00:44:06.553 --> 00:44:08.713
Everyone around the table will
have a perspective on this.

00:44:08.833 --> 00:44:10.513
Management will have
a perspective on this.

00:44:10.663 --> 00:44:15.763
There'll be lots of people that you can
ask for advice and support and ideas to

00:44:15.763 --> 00:44:16.993
help challenge your own thinking on this.

00:44:16.993 --> 00:44:19.260
But I think  you've got to start
with what your own board thinks.

00:44:19.317 --> 00:44:21.087
How do we think our
role is going to change?

00:44:21.117 --> 00:44:21.777
Will it change?

00:44:21.777 --> 00:44:22.827
Do we need it to change?

00:44:23.487 --> 00:44:27.057
I think that is a conversation
that I'd love to see boards having.

00:44:27.127 --> 00:44:31.527
That's the key thing I'd recommend
boards do and then fix your board pack.

00:44:32.327 --> 00:44:36.257
Ralph Grayson: So look, I think we've
ascertained that this year's Board Value

00:44:36.257 --> 00:44:42.297
Index raises a number of fundamental
questions to my mind, not simply whether

00:44:42.327 --> 00:44:47.367
boards are compliant, busy, or efficiently
administered, but whether they improve

00:44:47.367 --> 00:44:53.187
the quality of the organisation's thinking
and its most consequential decisions.

00:44:53.237 --> 00:44:56.087
There still seems to be a considerable
gap to my mind between the potential of

00:44:56.087 --> 00:45:01.877
the board and the contribution that many
boards currently make and closing that

00:45:01.877 --> 00:45:06.627
gap will require Board Intelligence to
step in to provide better information

00:45:06.657 --> 00:45:10.927
and processes but in particular to
Megan's point, better preparation,

00:45:11.287 --> 00:45:17.437
clearer role definitions, adaptability,
and that new magic word, judgement

00:45:17.437 --> 00:45:22.627
So thank you, Megan, for those
insights and I look forward to the

00:45:22.627 --> 00:45:25.057
next episode of the Board Value Index.

00:45:25.357 --> 00:45:29.227
Where do people find this year's reports?

00:45:29.527 --> 00:45:30.937
How do they follow you?

00:45:30.967 --> 00:45:33.277
How do they keep up to date
with what Board Intelligence

00:45:33.277 --> 00:45:34.297
are writing and talking about?

00:45:34.597 --> 00:45:35.137
Megan Pantelides: Well, yeah.

00:45:35.137 --> 00:45:36.007
Thank you, Ralph.

00:45:36.017 --> 00:45:37.397
So go to our website.

00:45:37.397 --> 00:45:40.477
The report's available to download
there under the resources section.

00:45:40.577 --> 00:45:41.717
Follow me on LinkedIn.

00:45:41.817 --> 00:45:44.337
There aren't many Megan Pantelides on
there, so you should be able to find me.

00:45:44.617 --> 00:45:46.387
But also I recommend signing
up to our newsletter.

00:45:46.447 --> 00:45:49.027
So Board Intelligence has a weekly
newsletter called What Matters on

00:45:49.027 --> 00:45:52.947
Monday and that's where we share
all of our research insights first.

00:45:53.047 --> 00:45:58.257
I would also recommend when it comes out
soon, going and downloading the Effective

00:45:58.257 --> 00:46:01.887
Board Reporting Guidance from the CGI
website, because that is a treasure

00:46:01.887 --> 00:46:04.707
trove of advice on everything I've
talked about relating to board packs.

00:46:04.990 --> 00:46:07.197
Ralph Grayson: Of which I can see
the new episode, which hasn't been

00:46:07.197 --> 00:46:08.607
released yet sitting in front of me.

00:46:09.407 --> 00:46:10.187
Megan, thank you.

00:46:10.247 --> 00:46:13.067
As always, insightful and hugely relevant.

00:46:13.257 --> 00:46:13.707
Megan Pantelides: Thank you.

00:46:13.935 --> 00:46:17.205
Ralph Grayson: I hope that you've enjoyed
listening to this podcast and have found

00:46:17.205 --> 00:46:21.465
it helpful when thinking about how to
approach your own path to the boardroom.

00:46:22.355 --> 00:46:25.495
If you would like to push this a
little bit further, Sainty Hird

00:46:25.515 --> 00:46:30.305
runs a bespoke one to one programme
designed specifically to this end.

00:46:30.640 --> 00:46:35.324
For more information, please visit
our website saintyhird.com, follow

00:46:35.324 --> 00:46:41.179
us on LinkedIn, and subscribe to the
Boardroom Path to receive new episodes.

00:46:41.525 --> 00:46:42.475
Thank you for listening.