Transformative Principal

Jethro Jones and Cybertraps co-host Fred explain what ChatGPT really is, where it helps and misfires in schools, and why to teach for a world with generative text.

Show Notes

Jethro Jones and Fred, co-host of the Cybertraps podcast, break down what ChatGPT is and what it means for AI in schools. Fred argues that what the press calls AI is predictive text from large language models, which guess the next word from huge amounts of data.

They get specific about where it goes wrong. Fred describes an administrator who used ChatGPT to write a note to the school community after a mass shooting, and people noticed it lacked compassion. He also warns that teachers can use ChatGPT as an excuse to downgrade a student. Fred compares the panic to the calculator.

What you'll learn

  • Explain to staff that ChatGPT predicts the next word from huge amounts of text, so it sounds intelligent without being intelligent.
  • Try Writebettr by forwarding one of your own weak emails to it and comparing the rewrite.
  • Skip ChatGPT for messages that need real compassion, since the administrator's AI-written note after a shooting came across as clearly artificial.
  • Think twice before using a hunch that a student used ChatGPT as grounds for a lower grade, since Fred says it is hard to prove either way.
  • Change your teaching and assessments, as schools did with calculators, so the tool is not determinative of the outcome.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Summer of AI and AILeader.info
  • 5:10 Why ChatGPT is predictive text, not AI
  • 7:12 Writebettr: try AI by sending an email
  • 9:14 Alan Turing and the Turing test
  • 13:11 AI doing work we thought only people could
  • 14:40 Could computers teach what works?
  • 19:56 When ChatGPT gets used badly in schools
  • 23:42 A calculator for words and new assessments

Times are for the episode without ads. Your player may be off by the length of any ads.

Questions this episode answers

Is ChatGPT really artificial intelligence?
Fred says what the press calls AI is closer to predictive text. Large language models take vast amounts of text, analyze it with sophisticated algorithms, and make an educated guess about the next word. He says that is not intelligence, though it can come close.

Should schools treat student use of ChatGPT as cheating?
Jethro compares it to spell check and says students using ChatGPT are using another resource. Fred compares it to the old calculator panic, says teaching and assessments should change so the tool is not determinative of the outcome, and suggests an episode called a calculator for words.

What are the risks of using ChatGPT in schools?
Fred points to an administrator who used ChatGPT for a note after a mass shooting, which lacked empathy, and to teachers who may claim a student's writing style is not their own as an excuse to downgrade them. Proving use either way is hard.

About Fred

Co-host and resident historian of the Cybertraps podcast, which simulcast this conversation.

Links and resources

Working on this at your school? Get a free preview of a 10-week leadership pathway built from episodes like this one at transformativeprincipal.com/start.


Thanks to our Sponsor Broadcast Made Easy who help you start a news broadcast at your school by having everything you need in one easy-to-download place. Check it out today and get your kids creating. 

We’re proud to be sponsored by IXL. 

IXL’s comprehensive teaching and learning platform for math, language arts, science, and social studies is accelerating achievement in 95 of the top 100 U.S. school districts. Loved by teachers and backed by independent research from Johns Hopkins University, IXL can help you do the following and more:
  • Simplify and streamline technology
  • Save teachers’ time
  • Reliably meet Tier 1 standards
  • Improve student performance on state assessments

🚀 Ready to see why leading districts trust IXL for their educational needs? Visit IXL.com/BE today to learn more about how IXL can elevate your school or district.

Creators and Guests

Host
Jethro Jones
SA
Guest
Summer of AI
The Summer of AI Series included folks from a range of perspectives talking about AI.

What is Transformative Principal?

Jethro Jones interviews instructional leaders from around the nation to learn and teach what it takes to become a transformative principal. Episodes address topics like Response to Intervention (RTI), Multi-Tiered System of Support (MTSS), Positive Behavior Interventions and Supports (PBIS), the latest advances in educational research, standards-based grading, and interviews with industry leaders like Bill Daggett, Rick Wormeli, Todd Whitaker and even people outside the education like Seth Godin, JeVon McCormick, Liz Wiseman, and more.

If you've been thinking about news broadcast, but don't know where to start and don't want to have that lift, use BroadcastMadeEasy.com to make it super easy for yourself. I am really excited about our sponsor, Broadcast Made Easy. As a principal, I created a daily news show at all of my schools, but you know what? It took a ton of work. Broadcast Made Easy makes it super simple for you to get started.

They provide templates, scripts, job descriptions, applications, the whole nine yards. You buy it once, no subscription, and it makes getting started so much easier. Another thing they have is specific videos for every holiday you could possibly imagine so that as part of your news broadcast, you can share what holidays are coming up, less than a minute, and very simple, straightforward, just the facts that makes it really easy to start conversations about those holidays.

So go check it out at BroadcastMadeEasy.com and let them know that you heard about it on Transformative Principle. That's BroadcastMadeEasy.com. This B Podcast Network show is presented by IXL. IXL's all-inclusive online teaching and learning platform simplifies edtech needs and accelerates achievement in 95 of the top 100 U.S. school districts. IXL delivers personalized learning across a comprehensive pre-K-12 curriculum, including math, language arts, science, and social studies, and helps you assess student performance through actionable, real-time insights at every level of your school or district.

This one solution performs work that typically requires dozens of tools. Want to find out why so many leading districts trust IXL? Visit IXL.com slash B-E. That's IXL.com slash B-E.

Welcome to Transformative Principle, where I help you stop putting out fires and start leading. I'm your host, Jethro Jones. You can follow me on Twitter at Jethro Jones. We're going to simulcast this on Transformative Principle and the Cybertraps podcast because I'm doing a summer of AI series on Transformative Principle where we're talking about all of this stuff. And the other thing that I've created is this thing called AIleader.info, which is where people can go to learn about it as school leaders so they can get a better understanding of it, and I created what are called three-minute masterclasses where people can learn little bits about artificial intelligence in just three minutes because it's very complex, but it doesn't have to be that complex, and it's very unapproachable to understand how it really works.

One of my gifts is being able to condense things down and explain it in three minutes or less. So I've created that, AIleader.info. Go check that out if you want. I think that's a really powerful place for people to get started. And the reason why we're talking about all of this stuff is because it's got everybody's attention and we want to help educators especially make good choices around it.

If you've been listening to Transformative Principle for any amount of time, you know that I have a love-hate relationship with EdTech. We have the ability to personalize learning for every single one of our students, and yet so many of our EdTech tools fall short. We need our technology to do more for us. That's why it's so important for me to know that IXL provides true personalized learning across the entire pre-K-12 curriculum, and that it's proven to benefit all student populations, including English language learners and students in special ed programs.

As a principal, I've used this in my school. As a parent, I've had my children use it as well. And let me tell you, this is a tool that definitely helps students learn and practice better. IXL is research proven to accelerate achievement. Studies across 45 states show that IXL schools outperform non-IXL schools on state assessments, and independent research from Johns Hopkins University verifies that IXL meets ESSA Tier 1 standards.

With those results combined with IXL's teacher-friendly reputation, what more could you ask for? Now, you also know that I don't care so much about test scores, but I know that they are legislatively convenient and something that we have to deal with and manage on a day-to-day basis. If you can implement something that is easy and effective, why wouldn't you do it? If you have a goal to increase achievement for all students, make sure to find out what IXL can do for you.

Visit IXL.com slash B for a demo. That's IXL.com slash B E. Hey there, Jethro. Hey, Fred. A long time no see. We are starting season four of Cybertraps. Fantastic. I noticed that we had crossed, what, 100? This is our 155th episode, believe it or not. And I am excited to rededicate ourselves to the climb to 200th. So that feels good. Going to be here before we know it.

That sounds excellent. Well, it is good to chat with you. We have had a lot of things going on since we last chatted. I think one of our more recent conversations, I was actually in Ghana. Yes. And that wrapped up at the end of March. I came back and good old COVID arrived and slid through the apartment. And that kind of wiped out a chunk of time.

But knock wood, at least, we seem to have gotten past that. Well, good. I'm glad to hear that. And thankfully, knock on wood, I still have not gotten that disease. And hopefully, it will stay that way for the rest of my life. I am not encouraging you to try it. It's not a lot of fun. And I will say, I mean, because of my quote-unquote advanced years, I was able to get a prescription for Paxlovid very quickly.

I actually started taking it the first night I felt symptoms. And it was a little annoying because I felt fantastic for the five days that I was on it. Like, it was amazing. Oh, man. Amazing. And then you go off it. And like, probably 20 or 25% of people, boom. It was like it was just lurking out there for me. So you came back from Africa. You and I both have been doing a lot of stuff around artificial intelligence over the last few months.

And yes, we have. I've been at conferences for executive directors of principals associations. You presented at ASTI in Alaska and lots of conversations and opportunities around that because everybody's being exposed to it now. Speaking bigly, why are we able to be focused on it now? And even though it's been around for such a long time? Well, it's an interesting thing, Jethro, because certainly the concept of AI has been around for quite a long time.

No question about that. And, you know, to be honest, you know, humans have explored the concept of artificial life for centuries. You know, probably the most famous example is Frankenstein is literally, you know, it's alive. Think about the great parody, young Frankenstein. So, you know, this is absolutely fascinating to human beings in general. I mean, we have one fairly well known method for creating life. But then the question is, are there other forms of life that we can create?

What people are jumping up and down about right now, which is known colloquially as AI, has actually only been around for six months for all intents and purposes when ChatGPT was released in November 2022. And I think people should understand that what is being referred to as AI in the press is not actually AI. It's what I would call predictive text. It basically consists of what are called large language models, which are able to produce intelligent sounding, quote unquote, material simply by taking vast quantities of text and breaking it down using incredibly sophisticated algorithms and making a, for lack of a better term, educated guess about what the next word should be in a given request.

So, for instance, if I go on to ChatGPT and I ask it to write an email to you, Jethro, I can give it certain parameters and it will write something in the tone I request, but it will predict what it thinks the next word should be. And you can really tweak that with the prompts you write. As a matter of fact, there's a new career, a prompt engineer, which is just remarkable.

But that's the basic concept is that these things take vast, vast quantities of data. They analyze it. And using that information, they try to predict what a rational sounding output would sound like. Yeah. And that's not intelligence. It's not intelligence, but it almost is. And it is, to be honest, the thing that has been so amazing to me is how it can do a good enough job for so many things.

And I mean, I've got to say for the vast majority of things that I typically write on a regular basis, what it creates is totally sufficient. And so I created a little tool called Write Better, write, W-R-I-T-E-B-E-T-T-R.com, writebetter.com. And what it does is it gives you an email address and you send an email to this email address and it will rewrite your email to be more professional.

And that is, that is it. Like what I wanted to do is give people an opportunity to try something out that was as simple as sending an email, which people do already. And whenever I demo it or share it with people, I say, first thing you should do is try this out. Like just take an email that you've already sent to someone that wasn't really a great email and just forward it to it and see what it creates for you.

And the thing that that's really remarkable about that is that I'm just using a no code code tools. And it was very simple for people to check it out and try it out and see what it's like. And that, that is part of what has made this surge in, in using these tools so valuable is that it's so easy to get started and it's not complex and it's not difficult.

Um, and chat GPT made it so that it was really, uh, simple for somebody to start using something like this and feel like they could, uh, you know, do something worthwhile. And, and I think that that is, that is really cool. So the idea of chat really started with Alan Turing and because you are the resident historian on our, on our podcast, tell us about, uh, Alan Turing and the Turing test and where that came from and why chat was the, the thing that makes sense.

That is the thing that everybody is focused on right now. Well, this is definitely one of those. How much time do you have? Yeah. Three minutes. Yeah. Right. So I will not begin to do Alan Turing justice in three minutes, but let's just do the highlights real quickly. Um, British mathematician and computer scientist born in 1912 died in 1954. Um, he is most famous for his work during world war two in Bletchley park, which was where the code breakers of the enigma machine were based.

Uh, if you want to go see the imitation game with Keira Knightley and Benedict Cumberbatch, uh, you know, a little bit of literature, you know, historical license, but a really nicely done, uh, portrayal of that period. And I think Cumberbatch as Alan Turing was just brilliant casting in any case in 1950, you know, he was, he was a theoretical computer scientist in 1950, he developed a, um, proposed test for when we might be able to say that artificial intelligence has arrived.

And his basic concept was that if you put somebody in a room and they're using a teletype to communicate with somebody or some thing. And on the other side of the wall, there is either a human being or a computer. If the person at the teletype cannot tell whether or not the other respondent is artificial or human, then you could argue that that device has now passed the Turing test that we actually have achieved artificial intelligence.

And it's a little bit facetious to call him the father of chat, because I don't think he had any idea, you know, what this might end up being used for, but really chat GPT or Bing or Jasper or some of these other AI fueled services are pretty much answering the Turing test, right? If you sit down, there are lots of people who are using chat GPT as a therapist.

Um, quite honestly, you could easily persuade yourself that you're getting a human response from these, uh, chat engines. And it's, it's really remarkable stuff. You know, when you were talking, uh, Jethro, I also have used, uh, chat GPT for a number of quote unquote mundane tasks. And it's really, really helpful to get started. What, where things start to get a little bit freaky, and this is something people should really play around with is when you give it something that requires it to come up with unexpected responses.

And my quick two second example of this is I was reading a Vanity Fair article about a woman who, uh, went and worked on the set of a Hallmark Christmas movie. And they churn these things out by the dozens every year, you know, it's just a cottage industry and people sit down and watch them. And I was wondering if I could get chat GPT to put together a movie pitch for a Christmas Hollywood Hallmark type movie, but incorporating technology.

So it came up actually with a secret organization called Elf that was going to be responsible for retrieving Santa's naughty and nice list. And yeah, you'd want to work it and tweak it a little bit, but you know, you could run with it. And it came out of the blue. There's no precedent for that. Right. So that to me says we're dealing with some stuff that's a little bit fuzzy, you know, in terms of how we interact with it.

Well, yeah. And especially as it relates to education, lots of people are using it to create, uh, lesson plans and assessments and all kinds of things. And I think there's, there, there is a lot of power in being able to come up with some off the wall things. And I really, the, the big surprise is that we thought that AI was going to take over all these low level jobs before, but now it seems like it's, it's taking over all these things things that we thought computers could never do.

And it turns out they're actually pretty darn good at it. Well, it does say something about the legal profession, a fairly large number of legal interns and low level attorneys are losing their jobs, you know, particularly in corporate paper mills where they're just churning out one contract after another. I got to say, if you've got a database of several hundred thousand contracts, you don't need an attorney to come up with a new version of that.

You know, you can put parameters in, you can tell it what it, what you want. And I think that's, that's actually a really important point for people to be aware of. Yeah, I think so too. And it's, it's something where that relates to a standardized education as well. And on the transformative principle podcast, we're talking with some people who, who are in that space and creating content and lesson plans and things like that.

And the reality is, and you know, people in education don't like it when I say this, but if we, if we know that there's a specific way to teach something that every single kid is going to be able to learn, if we teach it that way, then why are we wasting time and energy with a human being who's going to not teach it that way when we know that there's a right way to do it and that can be replicated.

And like, if that's the case, we really should be having a computer teach that if we know that there's a quote unquote right way to do it, that leads to kid success. And so for example, kids need to know how to read. And if, if we can teach them how to read in a fast and efficient way, then we can use the adults and paid teachers to do other things.

One of the, one example of that, that I experienced many years ago was this program called Imagine Learning, which is a program for kids who are learning English here in the United States who come from other countries. And one of my schools was a top 10% school using that because I just saw with my own experience, my own two eyes that the students who did Imagine Learning did better at speaking English and reading and understanding English.

And so I was like, look, let's make it part of our day that these kids are on this application using it on a regular basis because it helps them. And what they need is exposure. And if we can get condensed exposure and help them learn what these vocabulary words are and understand sentences, like it's going to make a huge difference. And sure enough, it did. And these kids did great and they improved on their abilities.

But more importantly, they were able to communicate more effectively because we basically said, you have to spend an hour doing this every single day. It doesn't matter what else you got going on, an hour every day. And we saw results very quickly from that. And I mean, so I had a teacher who basically made sure kids were on it, wasn't a very good use of her time in the moment.

But because kids were able to progress through her quickly, she could do other things with them because of what they were learning there. I think that's going to be the big question right there, though, Jethro, isn't it? What are the other things, you know, that teachers can do if they're incorporating this technology? And I, you know, you've got the frontline experience, which is huge for this kind of discussion.

So I'm curious to hear your thoughts on this. You know, if we look at ChatGPT as a tool, perhaps for teaching writing or helping with reading or theoretically with programming, right? You know, one of the things that I think people are really going to be concerned about is if I'm a programmer, yet ChatGPT or its equivalent can spit out code in a nanosecond, what do I do?

You know, where's my value added in that particular situation? And I think that's a question a lot of educators are going to be asking. I mean, this is kind of the meta cyber trap for educators, right? We're going to use this technology one way or the other. How do we incorporate it in ways that help preserve the expertise of teachers? Yeah, I think that's a really great question that I don't think we have the answer to yet.

No, I don't think so either. Yeah. Here's the truth. School leadership is demanding. It's rewarding, but it can also feel lonely and so overwhelming sometimes. That's why we created Linked Leaders, to make sure great leaders keep leading and good leaders get the support to become great. At Linked Leaders, you're never on your own. Whether you're building culture, navigating board relations, or tackling special education challenges, you'll find solutions from leaders who've been in your shoes.

And the best part, you don't have to wait months for a big conference or spend thousands of dollars hoping to make the right connection. With Linked Leaders, you can log in today, get straight answers from experienced mentors, and walk away with a playbook that works right when you need it. Linked Leaders is efficient, personalized support that keeps you moving forward. Sign up for free at linkedleaders.com. I think that it's going to take some evolution, as with all technology.

We're like, how do we start by just replacing what we're already doing? And then we can start to adapt it and do things differently that will be more meaningful and beneficial to what we're trying to do. But at the very least, if we can save hours by using this technology and make it so that if nothing else, the teacher just doesn't have to go home and plan lessons and spend as much time planning lessons, to me, that's a big win right there, that we can improve their quality of life by having that be an opportunity for them.

Well, let me give you a couple of examples real quickly, because I've been researching this area for some of the stuff that I've been doing. And, you know, there's, as you know, with the cyber traps, obviously, there's always good and there's bad. So, you know, there were a couple of teachers in England who did something similar to what you did in terms of incorporating AI. They did this, I think, probably four months ago.

But they created a website that you could go on to, and you could type in a series of bullet points about each of your students, and their website would automatically generate a year-end review. And it was literally doing what you're talking about, saving teachers hours from kind of a repetitive task. But, you know, clearly, the teacher knew the relevant bullet points for each of their students. They just didn't have to compose the structure around those bullet points.

And that, I thought, was really interesting. The flip side, and we're just starting to see the potential issues for educators, is, number one, using ChatGPT in inappropriate circumstances. So, for instance, there was one administrator who, following a mass shooting, used ChatGPT to write a note to the school community, and it was just clearly artificial. And it lacked any real compassion or empathy, and people picked up on that.

So that was stupid. And then the other thing that has popped up, and actually, this has been in higher education as well, is the potential to use the existence of ChatGPT to harass students. And by that, I mean, if a professor or a teacher has an issue with a student, ChatGPT can be an excuse to downgrade that student by the teacher saying, I don't recognize this as part of your writing style, so I'm going to assume that you use this new tool.

Now, of course, kids are. But I think there's a real risk if teachers are using that as an excuse to punish or, in some ways, denigrate one of their students. It's very hard to check both pro and con as to whether or not someone used ChatGPT to actually do an assignment. Yeah, and it's so fascinating because that's one of the things that we should really do a whole episode on, on whether or not we should be looking for, whether we should be calling that cheating or not, or whether we should be looking for it or seeking it out or what.

And the reality is, is that so many of the great books, especially that are written today that we love, are written by not the author. And I know that that upsets you as someone who does write his own books. But, but a recent- Yeah, I've done, I've done ghost writing, you know, so. See, it's out, it's out. So the, the, the, the, the most popular book that was open about it is called Who Not How by Dan Sullivan and Benjamin Hardy.

And in that book, Ben Hardy is the one who's actually writing it. And they say it from the very beginning that Dan Sullivan, the whole premise of that book is you should, you should look for who can do something, not how you can accomplish something. And so in that book, he said, my philosophy is I should find the person who can do the work. And the work of writing is Ben's job.

And my job, Dan is to, to say, this is what's going to be in the book. And then Ben is going to write the whole book. And that is exactly what happened. And they actually explain how that worked. And it's nice that, you know, Ben got a, a co-author credit on that instead of just being a ghost writer and not. Right. Tell me about it. Not having, not having his name on there at all.

But, but that's something that is really a distinction that we, we think that, you know, for students, if they, if they use chat GPT, then they are quote unquote cheating when really they're just using another resource at their disposal to help them. If they use spell check on their computer, when they were typing it, would we still say that they were cheating? No, we'd say they were working on creating a professional and good final draft.

And there's, we wouldn't say there was anything wrong with that at all. And anyway, we can get more into that in a further episode. We certainly should. And I think, you know, my working title almost immediately for that episode is a calculator for words, because that is what we're dealing with. You know, I, I came through the school system when calculators were in exactly the same position as chat GPT.

People were freaking out about the fact that I could buy a cigarette case size calculator with red LED lights, which had had, I think, four functions. I'm not sure if it had all four, but in any case, it was a very old calculator. And there were real consequences if you brought a calculator into school, but of course, everybody knew the kids were using them at home, right?

So the question became, and I think that, you know, other, other subjects have gone through this. How do you change the way you're teaching and how do you change your student assessments so that the tool is not determinative of the outcome? And I think that's really what we're going to see happening over the next few years is people really saying, well, you know, they're going into a world now where generative text is a reality.

So how do, what, what do we need to educate for that world as opposed to one in which it doesn't exist? Yeah. And, and that's really the question that we need to be asking. And that's the question that you and I are going to continue to be asking as we go through all of this. And there's a lot more to come as we talk about this. And, and I encourage people to keep listening, share this episode and reach out to us if you have questions or thoughts about what we should be talking about on here, because this is, these are big questions.

And I think a lot of people are, are looking at it in different ways than you and I are. Right. Which is wonderful because it's such a overarching technology that it's going to touch everybody. And so everybody's going to have a perspective on what its role should be. How do we integrate it into what we do? Some people are going to be saying, how do we kill it?

Which is a whole different conversation. But I will say to people that there's a wide range of topics in the show notes for this particular episode that we did not get to, but very much like a prompt for chat GPT. We will use these to seed our conversations in the future.

And, you know, whether or not we actually get chat GPT on here to engage in a dialogue, that's a different question, but we could probably figure out actually how to do that. Yeah, actually, I did do that on episode 357 of transformative principle, I believe. I had, I use an AI voice for the whole entire episode and I use chat GPT to generate much of the script, not all of it, but a ton of it.

And so I definitely encourage people to go check that out because I will do that actually. That sounds really, yeah. Well, actually, just as a sneak preview for February, assuming that I get a chance to go back up to Asti, one of the tentative presentation ideas is to work with an educator up there and have a basically talk off between Bing, for instance, and chat GPT or whatever the leading candidates are at that point.

So all I can tell you is that seven months from now, we don't know what's going to be going on. So yeah, that is, that is the truth. Do you want to simplify your school's technology, save teachers time, improve students' performance on state assessments? You can do it all, but don't waste another minute. Head straight to IXL.com slash BE to learn how IXL's research proven teaching and learning platform can help you achieve all these goals.

That's IXL.com slash BE. When I was a principal at a Title I elementary school, we had Playworks and it dramatically changed how our school functioned. Kids show up to school when they want to be there and that's the whole idea behind Playworks. What they do is they train staff to build belonging and connection right into recess so the kids feel connected and want to come back. They have tons of games that they teach the kids that are fun, enjoyable, and games where either everybody wins or the loss gets you back in the game very quickly.

One principal put it, when the teacher hops in the game and everyone's playing together, that builds camaraderie between students and adults. And the research backs it up. There was a UC Berkeley study that found that Title I schools partnering with Playworks had significantly lower chronic absenteeism. If you're thinking about attendance this year, and we all are, visit Playworks.org slash podcast to get the 30-day attendance reset and additional helpful resources that you can find.

you can implement today. Don't wait on this.