Automatically generated transcript. Not manually reviewed. Names, quotations, and speaker attribution may contain errors. In the last episode, I wrestled with the question of how perfect moral agents could sin. But after a recent conversation with a friend, I realized that there is still a glaring aspect of the problem of evil which I haven't addressed. I may have thought through the moral motivations of Adam and Eve to sin, but how is evil philosophically possible in the first place? In this episode, I want to go beyond the exploration of the human and divine nature, and instead look at a proposed explanation for the metaphysical possibility of evil in a world whose source is morally perfect. I think the early notion of evil as a negation, an absence, or a lacking is a good start. There are definitely some problems with this view, as the book that I've been linking in the show notes this season expounds on very well. The book entitled Mallum. However, I think there is a lot of merit to the privation theory of evil. It seems to me that evil isn't something added into the world, but rather the negation of something. Augustine's notion of evil as the misordering of loves is very helpful here, I think. God's world and his creatures are good. For me to love my family, my house, or my pet is not a bad thing. But for me to love my pet more than my family, or my family more than God, is morally problematic. Everything in God's creation is good, but those goods ought to be appropriately loved. The appropriate love will look different depending on what is being loved, who is doing the loving, and the relationship that those objects or creatures share. At this point, I want to break off into an extended analogy, which I think is going to be helpful for us as we continue the discussion here. So energy transformations, something I did teach a lot back in eighth grade, so that's probably where my mind was when I created this, but energy transformations occur constantly throughout our lives. The chemical energy of food turns into physical energy as we move our bodies, and then into thermal energy as our bodies move and heat up. The chemical energy of gasoline in our cars, it turns into mechanical and thermal energy as well. The mechanical energy of my hand on a doorknob or a screwdriver or a ratchet transfers to more mechanical energy as the knob or the ratchets turns. However, in each of these energy transformations, some energy is lost, usually as heat, and that's called entropy. The energy I put into a system will always be greater than the energy that I get out of it. Some energy is going to be lost as waste, which usually ends up being thermal energy or heat. Every machine has a particular function, but due to their parts contacting other parts, friction is created and energy is lost. This produces two primary problems. First, it produces wear and tear on the machine, as well as the creation of thermal energy. Now, while a perfect machine would be one where there is no energy loss, as far as I know, there are no systems where zero energy loss is possible. Perpetual motion machines are an impossibility because when you have a device which moves, it will always come in contact with other matter and create friction and thermal waste. Now we can minimize the waste, but that waste is always going to be there. Because we recognize the impossibility of constructing a machine which has no friction or no waste, we do two things. First, we try to mitigate the negative impacts of friction on wear and tear and energy loss. We do this by using things like lubricants or introducing cooling systems and fans. The second thing that we do is we try to capture and use the byproduct of friction, to use heat, to use it for something purposeful. A car heater is a perfect example of this, I think. As your engine produces unwanted thermal energy, which just dissipates into the atmosphere normally, your car is able to transform some of that unwanted heat energy in order to provide desirable warmth in the winter. And whereas you need a special system to provide air conditioning in order to make your car cooler, with things like Freon and stuff if they still use that, your car only needs a blower and a path for the heat, which is naturally produced by the engine, to make its way into the cabin. Now I'm not a car guy, so I'm sorry if I totally got that wrong, but I think that's how it works. And either way, it could work that way, so I think you get the gist. And the important thing to note here is that even though we speak of energy being lost, it isn't at all lost in the grand scheme of things. We just mean that it escapes the subsystem that we have in view. Heat may escape from my tires as I drive down the road, but it only escapes from my car and becomes useless to me. It doesn't escape from the air on this planet or from the universe as a whole. It doesn't at all escape from the system altogether. So while my car is an open system from which heat can escape, the universe is a closed system from which heat will never escape. Now hopefully you were able to hang in through all of that because now I want to turn the analogy into our discussion on the problem of evil. Let's think about the moral universe here. Upon creation, a perfect creator made everything good. Just like matter is the instantiation of energy, right? Einstein's famous E equals MC squared. So, God's creation are instantiations, representations, or housings of His goodness. It's His goodness exemplified, instantiated. Now, God could only create good things, and his creation, running in perfect harmony, was good. Functioning is good, with no moral waste or friction. Good is not an addition to God's creation, it is his creation. There is no such thing as super-arrogation or the adding of goodness, just like there is no subtraction of evil. The moral universe is a closed system. Now Jesus shows us what this perfect goodness looks like. He tells us that he is the vine and we are the branches, and to have true life we are to abide in him. Jesus tells us many ways to reduce moral friction in our lives. If we abide in him, love God, love others, that will show up in our lives in various ways, including but not limited to generosity, love, joy, peace, patience, enemy love, and all that goes with all that. Now, we'll also include an appropriate ordering of our loves, which will place God and others above things like money and power. A life like Christ's would be a well-ordered, morally frictionless life. However, when two instantiations of God's goodness come in contact with each other, moral friction has the potential to occur. And this, of course, is where our analogy is going to break down a little bit because It has the potential to occur, whereas as far as we know, in physics, in our world, anytime two objects come in contact, there will inevitably be friction and thermal energy and such. Nevertheless, let's stick with the analogy here. When I, a moral mover, a decision maker, come in contact with something like money, I may inappropriately order my loves. I may rub up against that money the wrong way. I'm probably not going to order that love completely wrong. I'll give some money to God and some money to others, but almost certainly I will at least mismanage some of my love towards God and others through the use of money or through a growing idolatry of it, a misordering of my loves. Likewise, when two moral agents come in contact with each other, a misordering of loves is almost inevitable in our fallen world. As two wills rub up against each other, there will be moral friction, and that friction will be greater to the degree that those agents are failing to abide in Christ and ordering their loves appropriately. Evil, then, is like thermal energy. It's like heat. Friction. It is a byproduct of two aspects of creation, two objects, two goods, because the world was created good. Two goods coming in contact with each other, where at least one of those goods is a moral mover or agent. Now, just like our physical universe, the moral universe is a closed universe. I can't add good to the system through super-arrogation. I can only comport with and preserve the good. Now, likewise, neither can I add evil. I can only misallocate my loves towards various goods. The more appropriately ordered is my love, the less friction, or wasted, mis-aimed goodness there is. The more appropriately ordered is my love, the more peace, the more shalom there is. Now, my inordinate love for money or sex doesn't make money or sex bad. Neither does my objectification of another image-bearer destroy the invaluable image of God which both I and they bear. A misallocation or misordering of my loves creates a moral friction, the byproduct of which is what we call evil. Now evil is not, therefore, any sort of addition. It is the dissipation of love from its ideally directed goal. But in this good world gone awry with misplaced loves, our God is a magnificent God. We see time and time again in the Bible that God is renowned for his ability to direct human evil for good. We see this with Joseph's slavery in Genesis 50, with Assyria's judgment in Isaiah 10, and the crucifixion of Jesus at the hands of sinful men in Luke 3. Romans tells us that God works all things together for good to those who love him. There's absolutely no evil that occurs which God can't direct for good. And that's exactly what he does. God makes the heavens to declare his glory. And even in the rebellion of humanity, God brings about his glory. And God's glory is our good. He uses the byproduct of moral friction to bring about good in the world. Just as the physical universe would one day end in full entropy and heat death were God not to form a new heavens and new earth, so it will be with good and evil. While it appears that the world's evil is gratuitous and unsalvageable at times, it seems like it's just waste, just pure entropy, and the moral universe is going to end in a heat death just like the physical universe. But God is able to and willing to accomplish the directing of all wasted love back towards its appropriately ordered object. Now this is obviously a very simplistically formulated idea at the moment, a simple analogy It sheds little to no light on things like the emotional problem of evil or the natural problem of evil. But this episode is meant to stand, especially with the previous episode, to kind of add to that. As well as the other surrounding episodes, which are going to give you a fuller picture of the whole discussion on the problem of evil. But my hope is that this episode at least allows you to get a more well-rounded view of how evil can not only enter a good creation, but how it can, in turn, be directed towards the ultimate good. That's all for now. So peace, and because I'm a pacifist, when I say it, I mean it. This podcast is a part of the Kingdom Outpost Network. Please check out the links below to find other great podcasts and content related to nonviolence and kingdom living.