WEBVTT

00:00.000 --> 00:19.640
Hey everyone, it's Mikki here. You're listening to Mikkipedia. This week on the podcast, Cliff and I get together and have a wide-ranging conversation about wearables, running, carbohydrate fueling, alcohol, and how we interpret health risk.

00:19.640 --> 00:31.220
Broadly, it's a conversation about looking at the totality of evidence, communicating risk accurately, and focusing on the behaviours that matter most for long-term health.

00:31.540 --> 00:42.640
So, as per usual with these conversations, you really are a fly on the wall as you listen in on Cliff and I really just sort of chewing the fat on some of our favourite topics.

00:42.640 --> 00:48.420
And in fact, even last week, we just jumped on a call about something entirely different, and it could have actually been a podcast.

00:48.420 --> 00:54.240
And I don't doubt that you've listened to several of Cliff's episodes now because he's such a regular on the show.

00:54.820 --> 00:57.900
So, I'm pretty sure that you're really going to enjoy this one.

00:58.460 --> 01:09.740
So, for those of you unfamiliar with Cliff, which is a surprise to me, Cliff Harvey, PhD, is New Zealand's expert on the effects of a ketogenic diet in a healthy population.

01:09.740 --> 01:11.500
But he is so much more than that.

01:12.020 --> 01:18.360
He has been helping people to live healthier, happier lives and to perform better since starting clinical practice.

01:18.420 --> 01:20.420
Back in the late 1990s.

01:21.060 --> 01:28.000
Over this time, he has been privileged to work with many Olympic professional Commonwealth and other high-performing athletes.

01:28.620 --> 01:33.820
He has also worked with many people to overcome the effects of chronic and debilitating health conditions.

01:34.980 --> 01:42.720
Along the way, he has founded or co-founded many successful businesses in health, fitness, and wellness space, including the Holistic Performance Institute,

01:42.720 --> 01:47.940
New Zealand's leading certification and diploma for health, nutrition, health coaching,

01:48.420 --> 01:55.840
and performance that has many of the world's experts teaching on the course, such as Dr. Eric Helms and me.

01:56.460 --> 01:59.800
So, students really are learning from the best.

02:00.400 --> 02:07.140
And honestly, I get asked so often from people who are just hungry to learn more in this space.

02:07.460 --> 02:16.820
And I'm always sending them over to Holistic Performance Institute, particularly if you are interested in clinical nutrition, which is an area that they really excel in.

02:17.620 --> 02:18.100
Cliff has over 20 years of experience in health, fitness, and wellness.

02:18.100 --> 02:18.120
So, I'm sure you've heard of him.

02:18.120 --> 02:18.340
So, I'm sure you've heard of him.

02:18.340 --> 02:18.400
So, I'm sure you've heard of him.

02:18.420 --> 02:20.760
He has over 20 years of experience as a strength and nutrition coach.

02:21.060 --> 02:30.320
And in addition to his PhD research, he's a registered clinical nutritionist, he's a qualified naturopath, and holds a diploma in fitness training and health coaching in patient care.

02:30.760 --> 02:34.260
And you can find Cliff over on Instagram, at Cliff Doggy Dog.

02:35.020 --> 02:43.700
Or you can find him over at cliffharvey.com, or also check out holisticperformanceinstitute.com.

02:44.020 --> 02:48.340
Before we crack on into the show, though, I would like to remind you that the best way to support this podcast is by following me on Instagram.

02:48.340 --> 02:51.980
And if you're not following this podcast, be sure to hit subscribe on your favorite podcast listening platform.

02:52.320 --> 02:57.700
That increases the visibility of Mikkipedia, and amongst literally thousands of other podcasts out there.

02:57.880 --> 03:02.260
So, more people get to hear from the guests that I have on the show, like Dr. Cliff Harvey.

03:02.780 --> 03:04.560
All right, guys, you enjoy this conversation.

03:07.440 --> 03:10.980
Okay, well, even if it was, okay, that's good.

03:11.040 --> 03:12.940
We're recording, but tell me anyway.

03:14.200 --> 03:18.280
I have an old Oura ring, and Kirsten had given it to me.

03:18.280 --> 03:18.320
I have an old Oura ring, and Kirsten had given it to me.

03:18.320 --> 03:24.040
because Will didn't like wearing it you know you got to wear it at night to get the best

03:24.040 --> 03:30.480
data and stuff like that so I got a lot out of that because I was using it to monitor RHR and

03:30.480 --> 03:35.220
HRV just for recovery and stuff like that I found it was really good if you started especially with

03:35.220 --> 03:41.380
the kids you know you start to get sick but you're not sure yet but RHR spikes by like 10 beats per

03:41.380 --> 03:44.080
minute and that tells you that maybe you're getting sick or whatever so I found it really

03:44.080 --> 03:49.280
useful anyway but it started malfunctioning because it's pretty old now it's a gen 2 or

03:49.280 --> 03:53.400
something so it's really old so I was looking into getting another one but now you have to

03:53.400 --> 03:57.280
pay a subscription so I thought I don't like wearing anything at night anyway are there any

03:57.280 --> 04:04.220
other options and I bought a Withings sleep analyzer oh what is this it's really dope it's

04:04.220 --> 04:11.560
like a pad that you put under your mattress yeah and it tracks your sleep sleep apnea respiratory

04:11.560 --> 04:14.060
rate HRV RHR all that stuff and it's really good so I bought a sleep analyzer and I bought a sleep

04:14.080 --> 04:18.820
that kind of stuff so I don't need to wear anything now wow so just go to sleep wake up in

04:18.820 --> 04:25.420
the morning cool yep everything looks good oh my god and is there good sort of data I mean as well

04:25.420 --> 04:32.400
as much as any of these tracking devices can does it give you kind of solid data um comparing it to

04:32.400 --> 04:40.080
another measure my understanding is yes because I think Withings they make a lot of medical grade

04:40.080 --> 04:43.620
equipment so I think it's pretty good I think it's as good as any of the other

04:44.080 --> 04:47.740
sort of well it's not a wearable but it's as good as the other wearables I think and it's

04:47.740 --> 04:52.300
certainly good enough for what I use it for it's like a blanket almost as a wearable but like an

04:52.300 --> 04:59.120
under bed blanket um how much it's quite small oh is it yeah oh okay I had it in my head that

04:59.120 --> 05:03.080
you were like putting it like some sort of like undercover for the bed but is it just

05:03.080 --> 05:07.240
and it literally goes underneath your mattress not the mattress protector so there's still

05:07.240 --> 05:13.260
quite a bit of gap oh yeah crazy um and I think it was 230 bucks

05:14.080 --> 05:18.740
that's really reasonable does Bella have one as well no we didn't get one because she doesn't

05:18.740 --> 05:24.140
really we're on a bit of a budget at the moment she doesn't really care much for that vehicle

05:24.140 --> 05:29.960
bio feedback type stuff um but we would have got one had you know we got a discount on a second

05:29.960 --> 05:34.580
one unit or whatever and we're going to see how it goes with my one too and if she wants to get

05:34.580 --> 05:39.960
one we can get one that makes sense and you really highlighted one of the reasons why I haven't gone

05:39.960 --> 05:43.920
down that route of tracking my sleep or my HRV etc.

05:44.080 --> 05:49.440
because I just don't I don't enjoy I've got a watch which by all accounts the data you get from

05:49.440 --> 05:55.180
your watch isn't great anyway a lot of people swear by it but um I from what I understand it's

05:55.180 --> 06:01.760
not the best uh second point the reason why you don't didn't want to get another aura is exactly

06:01.760 --> 06:05.580
why I don't want to get an aura I don't want a subscription I mean that just sounds expensive to

06:05.580 --> 06:12.680
me um and and also I don't know where I'd wear it because I've already got my you know my wedding

06:12.680 --> 06:14.060
rings and then my mum's ring and then my mum's ring and then my mum's ring and then my mum's ring

06:14.080 --> 06:22.680
so I'm like I've run out of fingers uh and then the third reason is that um well actually those

06:22.680 --> 06:26.960
are the really the two big reasons but this sounds like something that I could buy into

06:26.960 --> 06:33.080
because it's no effort you're not wearing it it's not that expensive equally um Hubster is

06:33.080 --> 06:38.320
probably not that fast either he'd be a bit like Bella like well I mean maybe but you just go right

06:38.320 --> 06:44.060
ahead yeah I hate wearing things at night so the aura ring was kind of a compromise

06:44.080 --> 06:49.260
because it was if I wear a watch at night I'll wake up and without even realizing it I've taken

06:49.260 --> 06:53.720
it off in the morning it just annoys me so and the ring was kind of the same sometimes like I

06:53.720 --> 06:57.400
hate having something on my fingers especially with jiu-jitsu and stuff you know because

06:57.400 --> 07:02.000
sometimes your fingers get swollen from all the grabbing and you know arthritic old joints and

07:02.000 --> 07:09.460
stuff yes so yeah so it'll be interesting because I I'm not a big fan of tracking in one respect

07:09.460 --> 07:14.060
either because I think it's kind of like food tracking it can drive a bit of stress

07:14.080 --> 07:20.420
around you know being too overly committed to the data and you know worrying too much about it

07:20.420 --> 07:24.180
trying to make all these changes and if it's not going to be something that's actionable what's

07:24.180 --> 07:28.520
the point anyway and the only reason I shifted that over the last couple of years was I did

07:28.520 --> 07:33.580
notice that it helped me to be aware of a few other things like if there was an impending

07:33.580 --> 07:40.360
cold or flu it sort of gave me an early warning sign I did find that using RHR as sort of an acute

07:40.360 --> 07:43.300
measure was quite good for adjusting

07:44.080 --> 07:49.080
training loads HRV similarly you know it's a bit more of that sort of chronic measure and I know

07:49.080 --> 07:54.460
that there's a lot of flaws with it because people will say well you know even when HRV is depressed

07:54.460 --> 07:59.780
and RHR is high you know athletes can still go in and hit a PB it's like yeah sure they can and

07:59.780 --> 08:05.160
that might be appropriate for an elite athlete in their early 20s but for me a sort of semi-retired

08:05.160 --> 08:12.520
recreational something in their late 40s if it tells me that if the data is telling me maybe I

08:12.520 --> 08:14.060
should back off sure I'm going to do it but I'm not going to do it because I'm not going to do it

08:14.080 --> 08:18.220
I might hit a PB but maybe I'm better off not doing that anyway just you know have a bit of a

08:18.220 --> 08:23.560
lighter day and just be aware of that kind of stuff it was also pretty interesting looking at

08:23.560 --> 08:30.540
the sort of correlation just personally between if I inadvertently had a higher nickel day the

08:30.540 --> 08:36.760
day before and how that was affecting those metrics so sometimes you know reversing that

08:36.760 --> 08:41.720
it's like oh well RHR is a little bit up what did I eat yesterday oh yeah we went out to that

08:41.720 --> 08:44.060
restaurant and maybe I didn't know what was in the

08:44.080 --> 08:50.240
food and maybe I did spike my nickel a little bit so yeah it's all interesting stuff well I was

08:50.240 --> 08:55.020
laughing Cliff as you were talking about potentially getting obsessive with data because

08:55.020 --> 09:01.920
I mean I can go either way really and what I noticed for myself is about two or three weeks

09:01.920 --> 09:08.260
ago I realized that I was on a Garmin step streak so I had managed to beat my step goal

09:08.260 --> 09:14.020
like almost every day for about I think 40 days and I'm like oh okay yeah

09:14.080 --> 09:20.060
okay and then I'm like wow I really want to keep this going and so up until this morning I was on

09:20.060 --> 09:27.940
day 58 day 59 I was I was always meeting my step goal and I was so stoked equally though in my head

09:27.940 --> 09:32.680
I thought at some point I'm going to need to break this and I'm going to have to deal with

09:32.680 --> 09:37.840
the consequence of how I'm going to feel about that and I almost wanted something to sort of

09:37.840 --> 09:44.000
do it for me so I didn't have to be the initiator of the breakup between me and my data so this

09:44.080 --> 09:50.020
morning I had a couple of webinars I did yesterday it was a super busy day I then got to bed quite

09:50.020 --> 09:55.760
late because it took a while to unwind but it also was up a bit early because it's just what I do

09:55.760 --> 10:02.500
and then I left the house to go for my run drove to the gym got out the car went to turn my watch

10:02.500 --> 10:09.600
on wasn't on my wrist so I forgot I forgot to pick my watch up and I'm like there goes that

10:09.600 --> 10:13.920
there goes that step streak I didn't even care that I wasn't able to

10:14.080 --> 10:19.920
track my run albeit I did track my run because um I had my phone and I am interested in my run

10:19.920 --> 10:26.080
data and I'll I can explain more in a minute um and obviously my steps are still going to be my

10:26.080 --> 10:31.940
steps regardless of whether my watch is on my wrist or not but now but now I it's the Garmin

10:31.940 --> 10:38.040
step goal that I've broken not the actual step goal so yeah I was a bit bummed if I'm if I'm

10:38.040 --> 10:43.840
honest well I think you know I think steps are really important and you know we I think we've

10:44.080 --> 10:49.460
asked before that research where even where people are getting in that sort of higher intensity

10:49.460 --> 10:52.940
exercise you know doing their weight training and they're not getting their steps they still

10:52.940 --> 11:01.640
have poorer morbidity and mortality outcomes but I also think there's this idea which I don't agree

11:01.640 --> 11:09.700
with and you know particularly the social media sphere where you have to be doing cardio and you

11:09.700 --> 11:13.920
know weight training cannot function in any sort of cardiovascular sense and

11:14.080 --> 11:18.440
neither can any of the higher intensity forms of activity and I just think that's garbage because

11:18.440 --> 11:22.520
a lot of people say well and I've had this advice before you need to do more zone two

11:22.520 --> 11:30.060
I'm like yeah but I walk the dog every day and it's only 20 minutes but I go to jiu-jitsu twice

11:30.060 --> 11:35.060
a week 90 minute sessions sure maybe half an hour of that's really intense but 60 minutes is just

11:35.060 --> 11:39.140
kind of rolling around on the floor and doing positional stuff I'm sure my heart rate's elevated

11:39.140 --> 11:44.060
and even doing things like housework you know a lot of people say well that's not

11:44.080 --> 11:51.000
cardio but hey if like when I was wearing the aura it read it as activity my heart rate was

11:51.000 --> 11:55.180
moderately elevated like I think there's a lot of nuance there where

11:55.180 --> 12:02.400
personally I don't think people need to do strict cardio if they're doing movement at

12:02.400 --> 12:08.640
varying intensities through the week I just don't think it matters in any meaningful way right

12:08.640 --> 12:13.260
interesting because I feel differently actually this is this might be the one thing that we

12:13.260 --> 12:13.880
disagree on

12:14.080 --> 12:20.140
actually I'm sure there are many things that we disagree on but um I I maybe it is the endurance

12:20.140 --> 12:27.160
nature you know my you know I'm an endurance girl at heart I love cardio like I cannot tell you I

12:27.160 --> 12:32.080
cannot put into words how much I love running it is you know that meaningful to me not that

12:32.080 --> 12:39.580
everyone needs to run but um but I do think that in this era of social media particularly and maybe

12:39.580 --> 12:44.040
it's the cohort that I see and in my little um

12:44.080 --> 12:50.540
in my little box on social media or whatever when I hear a lot of macro coaches whoever they are

12:50.540 --> 12:56.520
um say you don't need to do any cardio walking and strength training is all you need to do

12:56.520 --> 13:02.520
and I'm like what what about how heart health you know it's just it's so dialed into just

13:02.520 --> 13:06.680
fat loss and I know that's their gig that's the thing they talk about that's I mean I

13:06.680 --> 13:11.820
love talking about that but it's not the only thing that is important it's overall health

13:11.820 --> 13:14.000
which is which is important so I'm

13:14.080 --> 13:20.280
so i absolutely champion um aerobic activity and and i can't speak to housework because i actually

13:20.280 --> 13:24.580
don't do it but anyway well i don't disagree with you though and i'm certainly not saying

13:24.580 --> 13:30.480
that housework is um like cardio per se it's low intensity it gets the heart rate up enough that a

13:30.480 --> 13:34.200
wearable is going to track it for example what i was more meaning is that let's say i'm doing two

13:34.200 --> 13:40.300
hours a week of low to moderate intensity jujitsu where my heart rate is elevated that entire time

13:40.300 --> 13:46.660
i've got to consider that that that's kind of like it's kind of like cardio right just because

13:46.660 --> 13:51.760
i'm not jogging yeah doesn't mean that that's not cardio but a lot of people would say well it's not

13:51.760 --> 13:58.260
you need to do in addition to that x or y and then i think similar to my um aversion to the idea of

13:58.260 --> 14:04.080
you know the the volume hunters and strength training so you've got to have more and more

14:04.080 --> 14:08.660
volume right for hypertrophy same thing i've seen in the zone two space where people like

14:08.660 --> 14:10.220
the more you can do the

14:10.220 --> 14:10.280
the more you can do the

14:10.280 --> 14:16.640
there's no limit it's like yeah i get it but we've got lives you know and am i going to get

14:16.640 --> 14:23.180
a meaningful benefit in addition to my 20 minute walk a day 30 minutes of strength training every

14:23.180 --> 14:28.040
day 90 minutes of jujitsu you know maybe the odd harder walk hike in the weekend or whatever

14:28.040 --> 14:33.680
would adding some survival shuffle jogging through the week really do anything apart from

14:33.680 --> 14:39.720
screw my knees up it's a good question it's a good question and in fact it reminds me of i

14:39.720 --> 14:40.260
remember listening to a podcast where i was like oh my god i've got to do this i've got to do this

14:40.260 --> 14:43.720
and i remember listening to um rob and Mikki talking about talk about it on the healthy

14:43.720 --> 14:48.240
rebellion podcast i used to love that podcast they've they're no longer or at least they haven't

14:48.240 --> 14:54.400
they've taken a long hiatus anyway um and they got in they were very much i believe in the same

14:54.400 --> 15:01.500
space as what you're discussing then they got into doing some defasted um zone two work a few

15:01.500 --> 15:06.300
mornings a week and just just to see how they felt and just to see whether it helped with some of the

15:06.300 --> 15:10.240
things that they were trying to achieve and for all for whatever they were doing they were trying to

15:10.260 --> 15:17.360
do it for they um noticed a change and so i guess the the real question really is cliff is that you

15:17.360 --> 15:21.560
don't think it would make a difference give it a crack but unless you unless you run that i mean

15:21.560 --> 15:26.380
if you care and if not no big deal but that would be it would be interesting right for 90 days

15:26.380 --> 15:33.200
if you did i don't know or for three months you did three extra sessions of zone two for 30 minutes

15:33.200 --> 15:38.340
a session i don't know i don't know what would you notice well maybe that's an experiment i need to

15:38.340 --> 15:38.600
do

15:38.600 --> 15:45.400
watch the space let's do that i totally um i tell you i'll update you on my running because i know

15:45.400 --> 15:50.920
you are fascinated by it i'm fascinated by running it's my just my favorite thing yeah yeah and

15:50.920 --> 15:56.720
particularly my running um so i've been feeling particularly slow and listeners of the podcast

15:56.720 --> 16:03.000
would have heard me say snippets of this over the last however long but most but our events over the

16:03.000 --> 16:08.520
last couple of years have been the long slow events it's been the multi-day stage race

16:08.600 --> 16:15.180
where you run and you hike and you you shuffle and you jog and and the idea is to get get to the

16:15.180 --> 16:22.600
end of each day recover and go again anyway um i've had my significant injury issues again i

16:22.600 --> 16:26.060
won't bore i think i've already talked to you about it in person and bored the listeners with

16:26.060 --> 16:33.700
it already but over the last month i've just um i i don't know if you do you know david roche have

16:33.700 --> 16:38.080
you heard of him no he is a super high carb guy

16:38.600 --> 16:44.980
he is in his um ultra running events he's a he's a coach first and foremost and his wife is a coach

16:44.980 --> 16:53.640
as well uh and and he his if you say someone has a claim to fame his would be advocating for a super

16:53.640 --> 17:01.420
high carb approach um and he was he consumes 150 grams of carbs an hour during his ultra runs which

17:01.420 --> 17:08.160
is quite a feat in itself given that it's a hundred mile event right so and he won i'm

17:08.600 --> 17:15.780
once maybe he won leadville twice i'm not sure maybe just once um on this method and outside of

17:15.780 --> 17:21.960
that him and his wife are they've got excellent training programs and and they managed to weave

17:21.960 --> 17:29.100
in a lot of you know strength training and um and other aerobic work in a way that sort of means that

17:29.100 --> 17:33.860
you can just follow the plan and not have to do the mental arithmetic yourself as to where i'm

17:33.860 --> 17:38.340
going to fit the strength and etc um but because i was feeling so rubbish cliff

17:38.600 --> 17:44.760
and just really sluggish and slow i i did two things which i never thought that i would

17:44.760 --> 17:51.300
necessarily do the first one is start stretching and so i did uh les mills online hip mobility

17:51.300 --> 17:57.340
classes they've made such a difference such a 15 minutes such a difference sorry listener you've

17:57.340 --> 18:02.720
heard me say this talk about this before um and then and then the next thing i the other thing

18:02.720 --> 18:08.260
i've done is i've just like i haven't gone full noise on the carbs but man i've upped my carb game

18:08.600 --> 18:16.040
has made a world of difference pre-running during running after running during the day

18:16.040 --> 18:27.340
like i feel so good my recovery is excellent my appetite is also excellent um and all i care about

18:27.340 --> 18:33.260
is how well i'm running like it is it is it is such a great feeling actually i love this because

18:33.260 --> 18:38.480
i i was just watching a video by anthony chaffee on facebook where he was saying again

18:38.600 --> 18:46.720
that you do not need one gram of dietary carbohydrate not one and i mean i i i just

18:46.720 --> 18:51.020
will love to watch the comments on this because i'm sure there'll be some people jumping in saying

18:51.020 --> 18:57.920
you know you don't need those carbs for exercise etc but uh karen and i co-wrote the chapter on

18:57.920 --> 19:06.000
sports performance in the um ketogenic textbook and you know consistently we find and there's not

19:06.000 --> 19:08.580
a huge amount of data right now but the studies that have been published have shown that the

19:08.600 --> 19:14.600
consistently find that those people who are even habitually low carb thriving on a low carb diet

19:14.600 --> 19:21.100
benefit basically to the same extent from the same dosage of carbohydrate during exercise

19:21.100 --> 19:26.720
so that tells us like it's not so much about high carb versus low carb it's just about you know

19:26.720 --> 19:32.060
follow the diet that fits your lifestyle your goals all that kind of stuff but recognize that

19:32.060 --> 19:37.320
when you're putting your body under those more intense loads longer durations of exercise etc

19:37.980 --> 19:38.500
you're just

19:38.600 --> 19:43.940
going to benefit from that extra short-term fuel like it that's fine like and who cares

19:43.940 --> 19:48.660
why become so dogmatic about something that you wouldn't just have a little bit of carb during

19:48.660 --> 19:56.360
training hey interestingly talk about those really big carb loads during or carb doses during

19:56.360 --> 20:04.520
exercise joe and i did some field research with the irel endurance team going back to probably

20:04.520 --> 20:08.580
2002 i think yeah and at the time a lot of people were saying that they were not going to be able to

20:08.600 --> 20:10.660
do it again because they were not going to be able to do it again and i think it was a lot of people

20:10.660 --> 20:13.480
were still very much in that idea that i can't remember what the threshold was you'll probably

20:13.480 --> 20:18.460
remember but there were thresholds you cannot take in more than x amount of carbohydrate per hour

20:18.460 --> 20:25.960
it was yeah 60 it was often um 60 grams with just glucose but 90 grams with glucose fructose

20:25.960 --> 20:31.040
but they were the the limits yeah right and and we found that when we were testing

20:31.040 --> 20:37.040
glucose and lactate every circuit of the moon ride 24 hour mountain bike ride

20:37.440 --> 20:38.520
we found that our

20:38.520 --> 20:46.600
athletes needed significantly more than that to preserve performance lactate etc and and even to

20:46.600 --> 20:51.180
keep blood glucose relatively stable because we knew that if this glucose in those relatively

20:51.180 --> 20:56.120
short circuits was suddenly spiking that didn't necessarily mean that was coming from exogenous

20:56.120 --> 21:00.100
carbs that wouldn't be possible it means that they're getting a bit of a liver dump right

21:00.100 --> 21:03.280
yeah so we were trying to keep them as stable as possible and we found

21:03.280 --> 21:08.180
for these top level athletes that they were having to take in a lot more than they previously

21:08.180 --> 21:08.500
thought

21:08.520 --> 21:13.420
and so i i think that that started getting out into endurance circles because people started

21:13.420 --> 21:20.160
talking about it so maybe um joe and i had some role to play back in the day oh oh i don't doubt

21:20.160 --> 21:26.520
it i don't doubt it like it's it's so interesting isn't it cliff like and david um roach came across

21:26.520 --> 21:33.260
on my radar because he was so adamantly against low carb and initially you get defensive and

21:33.260 --> 21:37.640
you're like come on mate like that's not what the research shows you don't you know you can't have

21:37.640 --> 21:38.500
a hundred you can't say you can't do it you can't do it you can't do it you can't do it you can't do it

21:38.520 --> 21:43.840
that 150 grams of carbs is what everyone needs and and then of course i just listened to him on

21:43.840 --> 21:49.740
a podcast i'm like well he's not really saying everyone needs 150 grams of carb um and it just

21:49.740 --> 21:55.640
sort of like and you know i've had there's been loads in this research space of what that sort of

21:55.640 --> 22:01.980
uh that minimum requirement might be in order to boost performance you know rather than looking

22:01.980 --> 22:08.500
you know and there's of course all of the studies that have been assessing whether 120 grams of

22:08.520 --> 22:12.500
carbs produces better performance outcomes and we don't have the research to show that they do

22:12.500 --> 22:20.220
at all actually and dan has done a great job of sort of distilling that um scientific um information

22:20.220 --> 22:26.180
and did a great paper and i just released that podcast a couple of weeks ago but i did think

22:26.180 --> 22:31.580
cliff i'm like you know i mean i've been low carb forever for as long as it's been since we've been

22:31.580 --> 22:37.320
talking about low carb at aut which is 2011 but well before that as well because i was just

22:37.320 --> 22:38.280
naturally a restrictive

22:38.520 --> 22:46.660
person so so the um so i'm like you know what i just need to start listening to other information

22:46.660 --> 22:52.720
than just my biased um little neck of the woods that always talks about how great low carb is i

22:52.720 --> 22:57.720
actually just now need to start listening to other voices just to get a better balance of

22:57.720 --> 23:03.960
what might work and i mean i tell you what it's been game changing man so good i just think some

23:03.960 --> 23:06.420
of those voices in the low carb space are

23:08.520 --> 23:14.340
ignoring the evidence they know and you know for people who are listening to this and don't know me

23:14.340 --> 23:20.440
i've been prescribing ketogenic diets for nearly 30 years and i i you know like i say i wrote the

23:20.440 --> 23:26.780
co-authored the textbook on ketogenic diets i've got a phd which you know Mikki helped supervise

23:26.780 --> 23:33.160
part of my pathway towards that in ketosis ketogenesis ketogenesis so it's not that i'm

23:33.160 --> 23:38.320
against keto at all i've probably used it more than most people on the planet and in practice

23:38.520 --> 23:45.120
and you know through personal experience but we can't deny that there is robust research out

23:45.120 --> 23:49.680
there showing that some people benefit way more from higher carb some people benefit more from

23:49.680 --> 23:56.020
low carb some of that is physiological some of it's psychosocial and so you know from a personal

23:56.020 --> 24:01.540
perspective it really comes down to horses for courses not just per individual but even

24:01.540 --> 24:08.140
temporarily like i've really thrived on keto in the past but that was because i was

24:08.520 --> 24:15.080
wanting to stay lean stay light for fighting or weight lifting i'd maybe forget to eat and keto

24:15.080 --> 24:19.000
was better because i could just go through you know a couple of three-hour lectures when i was

24:19.000 --> 24:23.760
lecturing at the college or university and not have to worry too much about my cognition so much

24:23.760 --> 24:28.360
and whatnot whereas at other times if i'm trying to put on muscle or i'm maybe a little bit more

24:28.360 --> 24:35.340
prone to hypomania and and you know not eating and whatnot it's probably a little bit better to

24:35.340 --> 24:38.360
have higher calorie intake higher carbon

24:38.520 --> 24:43.780
be a bit more structured with eating so you know it just it all depends right yeah oh that's super

24:43.780 --> 24:50.580
interesting and i i completely agree um i think it's very easy to get stuck in a certain way of

24:50.580 --> 24:57.880
doing things and you just you do become blind to to other information or other research like i mean

24:57.880 --> 25:04.280
if you think about the path towards infestating low carb in the first place but at least for me

25:04.280 --> 25:07.120
i'd only learned that higher carb was the way to go

25:08.520 --> 25:14.740
and and i'd put my blinkers on to any other information until until it you know we started

25:14.740 --> 25:21.060
talking about it at aut when when we were there equally you can then just go the opposite direction

25:21.060 --> 25:26.760
and not think about that in fact not everyone needs to be low carb and i think actually that's

25:26.760 --> 25:31.760
what i was going to say brandon has been a very you know his work's very insightful to me because

25:31.760 --> 25:37.860
he works with a lot of women who are you know metabolically healthy who who

25:38.520 --> 25:44.880
are on board like 400 grams of carbs a day and are completely fine and probably until i get see

25:44.880 --> 25:49.340
cases like that i don't wouldn't have quite believed that that would be possible because

25:49.340 --> 25:55.540
i'd probably been down so far down the rabbit hole in that space well i think there's there's way too

25:55.540 --> 26:04.240
much but but but but right we see these people who thrive on a high carb vegan diet and then

26:04.240 --> 26:07.160
the carnivore and keto crowd will say yeah but but but

26:08.520 --> 26:12.740
all of those buts don't matter because the fact is they're eating a diet they're healthy they're

26:12.740 --> 26:20.400
living these long lifespans therefore all your butts don't actually matter in the same way that

26:20.580 --> 26:25.840
you know i talked about this with with trex we mentioned this at the last sni conference

26:25.840 --> 26:32.560
we both sort of said the same thing in that if for example the plants are trying to kill you

26:32.560 --> 26:36.480
argument was correct we would see it and we talked about this before as well we'd see it in the

26:36.480 --> 26:38.500
research right we would see it in those

26:38.520 --> 26:43.080
big cohort studies where there would be the smoking gun, just like there is with smoking,

26:43.300 --> 26:46.900
like what we're going to talk about today, like there might be in some cases for alcohol. You'd

26:46.900 --> 26:52.100
see it, but you don't. Therefore, if there's all these plausible reasons why something might be

26:52.100 --> 26:57.380
bad, if there's all these plausible reasons why every gram of carbohydrate might be damaging you,

26:58.180 --> 27:02.100
maybe you've got a plausible reason, but it doesn't matter functionally

27:02.100 --> 27:05.260
because we see people thriving, right? Yeah.

27:05.260 --> 27:11.360
And I can't stand the argument of, yeah, but what if they had gone carnivore,

27:11.420 --> 27:15.900
they'd do even better. Like, you don't know that. You can't say that at all. It's a ridiculous

27:15.900 --> 27:24.320
argument. To the same, and on that same note, it's like when Dan won the age group race in Kona

27:24.320 --> 27:29.780
on very little carbohydrate. A lot of people like, imagine if he had carbohydrate. And it's like,

27:30.140 --> 27:34.640
actually, you know what? I don't think, I don't know what kind of difference that would have made.

27:34.640 --> 27:35.240
But what?

27:35.260 --> 27:39.140
Was it low carbohydrate? Because all my conversations with Dan have always been that

27:39.140 --> 27:45.380
he lives low and competes high. Oh, no, it was low. And I think he had one gel

27:45.380 --> 27:50.240
through the entire run. So he was, he, he. Interesting.

27:50.560 --> 27:55.520
Yeah. Yeah. But, but he, but it was, he did have carbohydrate, but it certainly wasn't

27:55.520 --> 28:01.380
at the, at the heroic levels with which a lot of athletes are having. So, so yeah, no, I'm,

28:01.380 --> 28:05.240
yeah. But to that point, it's not like he would have,

28:05.260 --> 28:11.860
he would have gone better. Who knows? Who knows? But had he been chugging 120 grams carbs an hour?

28:12.080 --> 28:16.740
Do you remember when Michael Phelps got like busted for smoking cannabis?

28:17.500 --> 28:18.100
Oh, no.

28:18.500 --> 28:22.820
And so much of the commentary was about, oh, what a shame. Imagine how much faster he would

28:22.820 --> 28:25.360
have gone if he wasn't doing that. Or imagine how many more medals. It's like,

28:25.680 --> 28:28.180
how fast do you want this guy to go? He's like the greatest swimmer in time.

28:28.640 --> 28:32.420
How many, how many gold medals do you think he needs to get on top of that?

28:32.420 --> 28:35.220
Do you really think smoking that joint that one time?

28:35.260 --> 28:45.620
That is ridiculous. And quite, quite hilarious. So, so yeah, so that's, that's what's been going

28:45.620 --> 28:50.300
on in my neck of the woods, really, Cliff. Have you been having the odd beer?

28:51.320 --> 28:54.220
Always have the odd beer. So, and this is.

28:54.640 --> 28:55.560
How dare you?

28:55.960 --> 29:00.800
I know. I do know. Okay. So this is, I'm so pleased we're having this conversation

29:00.800 --> 29:04.740
today about alcohol in part, because I know Cliff,

29:04.740 --> 29:11.500
that you're, so when I see information about alcohol being, you know, killing you,

29:11.620 --> 29:16.300
essentially shortening life, essentially, there's that part of my brain that probably

29:16.300 --> 29:23.600
gets a bit defensive and goes, come on, that can't be true. Totally true. And then of course,

29:23.640 --> 29:29.340
I see there, there was a research study a couple of months ago that showed that exercise was

29:29.340 --> 29:34.700
protective from a health perspective in terms of the harmful effects of alcohol. So I'm like,

29:34.700 --> 29:38.980
well, that's great. That absolutely plays into my bias. Because I do enjoy a beer.

29:40.080 --> 29:41.700
Yeah. As do I.

29:42.660 --> 29:47.840
Yes. But you are, you're not, I think I would probably enjoy a beer more than you enjoy a beer.

29:48.880 --> 29:53.700
Yes. I would say, well, enjoy more maybe, but.

29:53.980 --> 29:57.460
Maybe, maybe, maybe we enjoy it the same, but maybe the frequency is slightly different.

29:57.500 --> 30:01.020
You enjoy it more frequently? I'd say so. One of the big reasons I don't

30:02.780 --> 30:04.660
drink as frequently as I otherwise.

30:04.700 --> 30:11.340
Would is purely because of that ApoE4 gene risk, right?

30:11.420 --> 30:12.220
Oh, you've got that.

30:12.660 --> 30:19.000
Yeah. So where there's that proclivity towards, well, interestingly, the research doesn't really

30:19.000 --> 30:24.140
tell us there's much association between alcohol and Alzheimer's, right? But maybe in those people

30:24.140 --> 30:28.420
who are genetically predisposed to those kinds of challenges, you just don't want to take the risk.

30:29.140 --> 30:34.140
So I don't really have a lot of the other risk factors that would preclude alcohol at the normal

30:34.140 --> 30:34.680
sort of health level. So I don't really have a lot of the other risk factors that would preclude

30:34.680 --> 30:41.640
that healthy dose or normal healthy intake. But because of that, I tend to try and limit it

30:41.640 --> 30:48.140
to sort of three drinks a month. The way I do that functionally is just to buy generally a dozen

30:48.140 --> 30:50.780
beers for the month. Oh, nice.

30:51.260 --> 30:55.620
And that's it. And if I drink them in the first couple of weeks, because maybe we go up north and

30:55.620 --> 31:01.540
have lots of Barbies or whatever, then that's done. And if they last longer than the month,

31:01.540 --> 31:03.980
that's fine too. But it's just an easy way to

31:04.680 --> 31:09.620
sort of self-regulate that in the same way that I'll buy a block of chocolate every week and I

31:09.620 --> 31:15.100
can eat that however I want. Just having those little sort of rules for yourself that are easy

31:15.100 --> 31:22.440
to apply. Oh, yeah. I love guardrails. I find them really helpful in terms of me not having

31:22.440 --> 31:32.700
to make decisions around anything. So with regards to alcohol, my guardrail is three times a week.

31:32.700 --> 31:40.240
Um, I'm going to enjoy a drink. And in fact, the amount that I drink now is definitely less than

31:40.240 --> 31:46.060
it was two years ago, actually. And I think just because unfortunately I don't feel great

31:46.060 --> 31:52.100
the day after when I do. And it really does, and particularly red wine, unfortunately really does

31:52.100 --> 31:57.440
impact my sleep, but ultimately I don't love waking up feeling sluggish. And I, I love the,

31:57.440 --> 32:02.080
I love waking up feeling fresh. Um, but of course it's a trade-off and I,

32:02.700 --> 32:08.540
enjoy that. My most favorite times to enjoy alcohol is just when Hubster and I are at home.

32:08.540 --> 32:15.460
Like I don't like if we're out, um, you know, if I'm out at, uh, like a party or we're out to dinner

32:15.460 --> 32:19.700
with friends or whatever, it doesn't really phase me whether or not I drink. In fact, a lot of the

32:19.700 --> 32:23.380
times I prefer not to, cause it feels like a wasted opportunity. Cause I'd much rather just

32:23.380 --> 32:29.360
enjoy it in the best possible way. Um, that's like me with the, with dessert. Oh yeah. I never,

32:29.360 --> 32:32.560
I never want to order dessert out because I feel like I'm not enjoying it. I'm,

32:32.700 --> 32:35.560
talking and stuff. And by the time you finish it, it's like gone. It's like,

32:35.580 --> 32:39.520
oh, I didn't really enjoy that. Yeah, that's exactly, that's exactly the same thing with me.

32:39.520 --> 32:45.640
So, um, but I will say that those guardrails are, um, sometimes they're a little bit, um,

32:45.640 --> 32:50.220
they don't do their job because sometimes I can just like, for example, we've gotten back from,

32:50.220 --> 32:55.980
uh, Melbourne, um, this week and, and I already, and I've said, well, I'm not drinking Friday night

32:55.980 --> 33:01.580
cause I've got my long run on Saturday, but I, you know, if Barry came home this evening and said,

33:01.580 --> 33:07.620
oh, well, we have a glass of red. I'd probably go. Yeah. All right. So, so I, so I do have my

33:07.620 --> 33:13.800
phases as well. It's a work on, let's just say. Yeah. Hey, you brought up mortality just before.

33:14.860 --> 33:20.780
And I think that's really important for people to initially, at least, at least focus in on,

33:21.420 --> 33:30.460
because it tends to be that, I guess, similarly to some other areas, people forget that most

33:30.460 --> 33:39.360
imperative of outcomes. Are you going to die early? I agree. And this isn't about, um, saturated

33:39.360 --> 33:45.160
fat or anything like that, but, but this is the same sort of problem or issue with saturated fat,

33:45.160 --> 33:51.440
right? We diet, we focus in on one outcome specific to a particular condition rather than

33:51.440 --> 33:55.740
just the overall outcomes. Is that, am I right? Yeah. A hundred percent. Exactly. Yeah. And I

33:55.740 --> 34:00.040
think, you know, as well, you'll know, I, I, I don't know how,

34:00.460 --> 34:04.980
all other researchers work, but I think a lot of us in that sort of public health nutrition space,

34:04.980 --> 34:11.400
we will default to that quite rightly. So as being the, the, the pointiest end point,

34:11.620 --> 34:18.120
do you die earlier? And I think that's particularly important when it comes to discussing alcohol,

34:18.120 --> 34:22.880
because I'm not advocating for people to drink. Like I think if people don't drink,

34:22.880 --> 34:29.580
keep on not drinking. If you want to drink, then you can probably find a way to do that safely.

34:30.460 --> 34:36.160
If you can't find a way to do that safely, don't drink, right? That's the, the pragmatic advice.

34:36.340 --> 34:42.220
But I think a lot of people don't understand that according to the research we have at this point,

34:42.980 --> 34:48.660
the bandwidth you have is actually quite wide. If we're just looking at overall mortality,

34:48.660 --> 34:54.700
you know, 18 drinks a week for women, what is it? 30, is it 34 drinks a week for men?

34:56.080 --> 35:00.060
Is that what, is that the, what the data says,

35:00.340 --> 35:00.440
Claire? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

35:00.460 --> 35:03.840
If you look heavily, if you look at the mortality data,

35:03.980 --> 35:09.700
is it that risk increases if a woman has more than 18 drinks in a week?

35:11.020 --> 35:16.240
I believe that's what it does say. Yeah. Yeah. Go, go check and we can just edit out whatever.

35:18.280 --> 35:23.160
The only group for which there was a significantly increased risk of all cause mortality were those

35:23.160 --> 35:27.200
drinking more than 45 grams of alcohol per day. So in New Zealand and Australia, that's four and a

35:27.200 --> 35:30.280
half standard drinks. A day. So,

35:30.280 --> 35:37.660
are you saying that for men, for women, it's two and a half drinks per day? Wow. On average.

35:38.220 --> 35:43.280
And that this is the meta-analysis that most people point to. The Zhao and colleagues meta-analysis

35:43.280 --> 35:48.660
from 2023 published in the Journal of the American Medical Association. So a lot of people point to

35:48.660 --> 35:55.240
this as being the main evidence that there is no safe dose of alcohol. Where I think the confusion

35:55.240 --> 36:00.160
lies is that, you know, all the previous, well not all, but most of the previous meta-analyses and a

36:00.160 --> 36:07.940
cohort studies showed that there was potentially benefits to low intakes of alcohol. So it was that

36:07.940 --> 36:13.620
idea that there is a healthy dose of alcohol. And a lot of people reviled against that saying, yeah,

36:13.840 --> 36:17.720
but is that because of these different confounding influences? Probably, you know,

36:17.720 --> 36:21.620
and we can get into that a little bit, but the Zhao and colleagues meta-analysis

36:21.620 --> 36:29.960
pretty much put the nail in the coffin of that idea and really showed as well as later,

36:30.160 --> 36:37.200
studies have sort of supported this, that there is no healthy dose. But it didn't conclude that

36:37.200 --> 36:42.900
there was no safe dose. Although a lot of the conclusions that the authors themselves make,

36:42.900 --> 36:48.460
or that other people interpreting the studies make as to, well, the likely safest dose is zero,

36:48.740 --> 36:54.860
doesn't mean there's no safe dose. Because if we don't see any significant increase in those

36:54.860 --> 36:59.920
mortality risk outcomes, up to two and a half to four and a half drinks per day,

36:59.920 --> 36:59.940
that's not a safe dose. So I think that's a good idea. I think that's a good idea.

36:59.940 --> 37:01.120
I think that's a good idea. I think that's a good idea. I think that's a good idea.

37:01.120 --> 37:02.820
Like that's quite a lot, right?

37:03.160 --> 37:08.960
That is a lot. That is a surprising amount. Is it just that the data isn't there? Is the data

37:08.960 --> 37:15.820
that we're relying on just a little bit flaky? Is it not reliable? Like what's your read on that?

37:16.580 --> 37:23.440
I think if we're talking about there being, you know, power of numbers, I'd say we have

37:23.440 --> 37:28.180
the data because how are you going to look at it? You know, we've talked about this before.

37:28.180 --> 37:29.900
Are we going to?

37:29.940 --> 37:34.500
Do long-term randomized controlled trials giving people high doses of alcohol? Probably not.

37:35.660 --> 37:44.400
All we've got, like any of these potentially vice-related lifestyle factors, we rely on the

37:44.400 --> 37:51.400
cohort evidence. So we rely on temporally strong, but yes, somewhat weak in terms of confounding

37:51.400 --> 37:58.640
influences research. But the Zhao and colleagues meta-analysis had from memory 107 studies and

37:58.640 --> 37:59.920
over 700 different studies. So we rely on the cohort evidence. So we rely on the cohort evidence.

37:59.920 --> 38:06.000
So there's a lot, right? The population, I can't even remember that was included,

38:06.120 --> 38:13.360
but it's massive. Looking at big cohorts, right? So we have a lot of data. But I think digging

38:13.360 --> 38:20.020
into your point, the big variability we see is the different disease endpoints. And so this is

38:20.020 --> 38:23.880
where people get sidetracked, I think, and start to go down the cancer route, which, you know,

38:23.880 --> 38:28.740
we'll talk about. But for cardiovascular diseases, typically,

38:29.920 --> 38:34.140
there's a safe dose, which is pretty high. And I think it was somewhere between, you know,

38:34.160 --> 38:37.680
a lot of the research shows that are 7 to 12 drinks a day for men.

38:37.680 --> 38:38.460
Wow. Wow.

38:38.640 --> 38:42.560
I know, right? So you pretty much aren't increasing your risk if you're a pretty happy drinker.

38:43.340 --> 38:48.040
Now, I don't think any of us who are in clinical practice would ever advise our clients that that's

38:48.040 --> 38:48.360
okay.

38:48.640 --> 38:50.520
Yeah. Yeah, absolutely.

38:51.100 --> 38:55.740
But then that's brought down a lot by the cancer risk, which is, you know, far more grave.

38:56.380 --> 38:59.460
And that's, I think, where a lot of people then default to. It's like, well,

38:59.920 --> 39:08.140
sure, that's what the all-cause mortality data says, but what about cancer incidence? And that's

39:08.140 --> 39:16.520
where things really shift. But, you know, to your earlier point, can we tell people that they just

39:16.520 --> 39:28.580
should not ever have a social drink because of one disease incidence factor versus the larger topic

39:28.580 --> 39:29.700
of, will this actually...

39:29.920 --> 39:36.060
Cause you to die early. And that's a lot less clear. What does appear to be true is that there

39:36.060 --> 39:41.260
is, you know, like I say, a fairly wide range there within which people could potentially

39:41.260 --> 39:49.120
enjoy some low intake of alcohol and still be very healthy. Like the cancer thing, sure,

39:49.180 --> 39:52.780
it's the elephant in the room. And I think it's really important to consider because

39:52.780 --> 39:59.900
we don't want to be telling people that you can drink, you know, two to five drinks a day.

39:59.920 --> 40:05.340
Because a lot of those people might have a familial risk or a genetic risk of cancer.

40:06.540 --> 40:13.780
And so for that, I think the interesting take home is that there probably is a stronger case

40:13.780 --> 40:20.000
to be made that specifically to cancer, there's no safe dose. But I still don't think that that is

40:20.000 --> 40:24.200
as nuanced a conclusion as it needs to be.

40:24.960 --> 40:29.820
What makes you think that, Cliff? Not just think that, but what is it about the data that you

40:29.920 --> 40:36.160
look at that, and you're like, actually, that's something that we could say, but it's not

40:36.160 --> 40:42.960
necessarily set in stone. Like what's the, what's the go? Because cancer is everywhere. People are,

40:43.420 --> 40:48.640
myself included, we have the, it's one of the most frightening things to have,

40:48.860 --> 40:52.960
to be diagnosed with, or to know someone who's been diagnosed with. And of course,

40:52.960 --> 40:59.460
we want to avoid it at all costs. And it is one of the reasons why women are so understandably,

40:59.920 --> 41:05.220
I am, I'm anxious about something like breast cancer, yet we've got a higher rate of death

41:05.220 --> 41:10.300
or risk of death from cardiovascular disease, for example. But, you know, it's just really

41:10.300 --> 41:15.800
set into our brains, understandably so. I think the main way, the main reason is the way

41:15.800 --> 41:21.560
the data are typically presented is in the average daily intakes.

41:23.300 --> 41:29.600
And they're typically fairly, is the right term, ordinal, in that you're looking at sort of a daily

41:29.920 --> 41:38.980
intake of one. And that can increase one's risk of cancer, specifically the female predominant

41:38.980 --> 41:45.720
cancers, and particularly, obviously, the cancer-related, sorry, alcohol-related cancers.

41:47.300 --> 41:51.640
Not all studies show that, though. You know, that that finding is somewhat equivocal if you're

41:51.640 --> 41:56.140
looking at individual studies. Obviously, we will default to meta-analyses, though,

41:56.180 --> 41:59.220
and they typically tend to show, yes, there is a risk at sort of one

41:59.220 --> 41:59.900
rate of death. But, you know, that's, that's, that's, that's, that's, that's, that's, that's,

42:00.100 --> 42:07.440
standard drink per day. Other research has suggested that that risk might be sort of a

42:07.440 --> 42:12.600
tipping point of around half a drink per day. And, you know, that small increase in risk,

42:12.640 --> 42:17.240
we're talking about after full adjustment, probably about a 5% increase in overall risk.

42:18.260 --> 42:22.700
So the first question to ask is, is that meaningful in terms of, you know, the actual

42:22.700 --> 42:28.580
absolute numbers, absolute effect on, say, mortality outcomes, et cetera. But here,

42:28.580 --> 42:29.900
particularly, we're talking about cancer.

42:29.920 --> 42:35.480
So, I mean, that's still probably a risk that a lot of people wouldn't want to take. But even with

42:35.480 --> 42:40.400
those fairly low thresholds, particularly when we're looking at the very common one of one drink

42:40.400 --> 42:46.760
per day increasing cancer risk, what does that actually mean for people who have relatively low

42:46.760 --> 42:56.160
intakes? Because if you have three drinks per week, you're under half a drink per day, right?

42:56.160 --> 42:59.000
And so that's where I sort of think, well,

42:59.000 --> 43:06.460
at those lower ends of intake, it's very washy, it's very inconclusive. And

43:06.460 --> 43:12.480
the effect sizes are so minuscule, we can't really say anything.

43:12.960 --> 43:19.000
Cliff, can you describe for the listener the difference between relative risk and, you know,

43:19.080 --> 43:25.720
as you see it presented in the media, presented on, you know, other social channels

43:26.580 --> 43:28.980
and journal articles, and how that,

43:29.000 --> 43:34.260
differs from absolute risk? And do we know numbers of absolute risk around these things?

43:35.320 --> 43:40.860
For what it's worth, I can quickly do a quick search for absolute risk as well. If you don't

43:40.860 --> 43:45.260
have them on the top of your head, I will go look. Yeah, you'll have to pull it up.

43:45.660 --> 43:52.080
Yeah, I will. I totally. So in terms of absolute risk, we're thinking about absolute numbers of

43:52.080 --> 43:57.540
people who develop a condition, right? So if it's breast cancer, and there is like, say,

43:57.540 --> 43:58.740
one in 10,000,

43:59.000 --> 44:06.460
risk of developing breast cancer, if you have a drink a day, that might increase your risk by 20%.

44:06.460 --> 44:14.660
But that then takes that absolute risk from one in 10,000 to 1.2 in 10,000. Is that how I would

44:14.660 --> 44:20.040
describe relative versus absolute risk? It's a great way to describe it. I got stuck because

44:20.040 --> 44:25.700
I used to explain this to my students, looking at the absolute versus relative risk from

44:25.700 --> 44:28.980
the effects of certain drugs,

44:29.000 --> 44:35.600
used in therapies. And when you sort of explain things that way, sometimes when there's a really

44:35.600 --> 44:39.400
high risk of adverse events and things, people might re-evaluate whether they're prepared to

44:39.400 --> 44:43.000
take something or maybe even a supplement or something like that. But I was getting caught

44:43.000 --> 44:49.680
up in the weeds of how to apply that to alcohol. Oh, yeah, no worries. This comes from the 45 and

44:49.680 --> 44:55.840
up study. Did you look at that study? No. Okay, cool. It's an Australian cohort study. So who

44:55.840 --> 44:57.540
knows? But

44:59.000 --> 45:03.100
Dazale and Stockhol, that's the one that you used, isn't it?

45:03.820 --> 45:05.060
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yep.

45:05.920 --> 45:08.300
Yeah. Nice one. I'm seeing that there. Yeah.

45:08.300 --> 45:13.500
Which is kind of the biggest one. And it's the one that most people talk about. Although

45:13.500 --> 45:22.220
we saw another study referenced recently, which is that health effects associated with alcohol

45:22.220 --> 45:26.080
consumption, a burden of proof study, which was published in Nature. So we're talking about

45:26.080 --> 45:28.980
pretty big prestigious journals, right? JAMA and Nature.

45:29.000 --> 45:33.080
Yeah. That interestingly didn't look at mortality, though.

45:33.800 --> 45:35.680
Yes. Right? That was looking at

45:35.680 --> 45:43.440
disease risk. And there was an increased risk for all cancers at any intake

45:43.440 --> 45:50.160
from that study. And that's what a lot of people are now speaking to. Is it worth the risk? But

45:50.160 --> 45:58.200
again, it wasn't all cancers. Well, across the board, it was. And in terms of total cancer

45:58.200 --> 45:58.960
incidents, yes.

45:59.000 --> 46:04.700
There was an increase. But some cancers did not see increases, right? Esophageal, liver,

46:04.700 --> 46:11.980
prostate, stomach. There were obviously risks for all sort of alcohol-related cancers,

46:12.200 --> 46:17.600
the female-specific cancers. But we're talking here about disease risk. And again, they categorized

46:17.600 --> 46:27.520
it as low intakes being around one or two drinks per day. Now, I still think that most people who

46:27.520 --> 46:28.860
would consider themselves to be...

46:29.000 --> 46:36.280
Low or infrequent, low-dose drinkers would probably not be having a drink or two a day.

46:37.040 --> 46:37.480
Agree.

46:38.040 --> 46:44.040
And I think that's particularly true nowadays. Maybe back in the day. But nowadays, I think a

46:44.040 --> 46:47.640
lot of people are more likely to have one or two drinks one or two nights of the week.

46:48.720 --> 46:57.040
And interestingly, when we look at frequency data, the people who tend to, in at least a lot

46:57.040 --> 46:58.800
of the research, have the best...

46:59.000 --> 47:03.720
Long-term health and mortality outcomes are those drinking around three or four times a week.

47:04.720 --> 47:10.560
More than that, negative effects. Less than that, negative effects. Now, why would those people

47:10.560 --> 47:15.280
drinking less than that have negative effects? Well, my presumption would be that it's because

47:15.280 --> 47:20.540
those people are episodic binge drinkers, which we also know to be quite negative.

47:21.840 --> 47:28.980
So where people are having, let's say, one drink, two, three, four times a day,

47:29.000 --> 47:36.020
a week, they're probably not predisposing themselves to any market risk. And I think

47:36.020 --> 47:39.560
you mentioned earlier, there are a lot of mitigating factors there too, right?

47:40.340 --> 47:43.980
And this is where... It's interesting, eh? Because

47:43.980 --> 47:48.800
confounding happens in a lot of different ways, and it's not unidirectional.

47:49.440 --> 47:54.820
One of the interesting things that happened in this area of research is that a lot of the suspected,

47:54.820 --> 47:58.720
I guess, negative outcomes,

47:59.000 --> 48:05.000
from abstaining, because abstainers often ended up looking worse than people who were having

48:05.000 --> 48:09.900
a couple of drinks a week. But it was actually, I think it was Zhao and colleagues

48:09.900 --> 48:16.800
previously to their 2023 meta-analysis had looked into this, and they had looked at abstainer bias.

48:17.240 --> 48:20.480
And predominantly what they were looking at there is, why do people abstain?

48:21.440 --> 48:24.600
There are people that are going to abstain because they have health-positive behaviors,

48:24.860 --> 48:28.340
but they're also going to people who abstain because they are

48:28.340 --> 48:35.320
alcoholics, former problematic drinkers. There's going to be people who abstain because they have

48:35.320 --> 48:39.920
serious health conditions, right? And that provides quite a lot of bias. And when that's

48:39.920 --> 48:44.500
accounted for, it pretty much washes out any of that effect. So then we do start to see that,

48:44.580 --> 48:50.020
yeah, people who abstain are probably in the best position. But then maybe people who are having

48:50.020 --> 48:54.600
one or two drinks a week, there's really no difference. Yeah, that's interesting. I'm

48:54.600 --> 48:58.320
looking at information from the British Journal of Cancer,

48:58.340 --> 49:03.500
which, to your point, are looking at all of the causes of cancer. And I think you mentioned this,

49:03.580 --> 49:10.180
but what's interesting to me is the categories with which people are at risk and what they're

49:10.180 --> 49:20.920
compared to. So to your point, a lot of the categorization appears to be women who drink

49:20.920 --> 49:26.760
over 10 drinks a week versus women who drink sort of zero to one drink a week. There's

49:28.340 --> 49:33.780
quite a variation in terms of, and that's actually just looking at greatest risk related to health

49:33.780 --> 49:41.620
outcomes versus no risk or lowest risk related to health outcomes. And I think that I've got this

49:41.620 --> 49:50.580
right, but to your point, a lot of the mouth and esophageal cancers, liver cancers, obviously

49:50.580 --> 49:57.140
they're very high numbers in terms of their relative risk, like 2.58, 2.89, like significant,

49:57.140 --> 49:57.700
albeit.

49:58.340 --> 50:02.900
It's a significant amount of alcohol as well, like over 30 drinks a week versus less than three

50:02.900 --> 50:08.960
drinks a week. So, you know, it's a significant amount. And the others are, you know, for every

50:08.960 --> 50:15.060
10 weeks, 10 drinks per week, you get an increase of like 5% in terms of risk. If you look at all

50:15.060 --> 50:20.540
cancers combined, actually was their major sort of finding. And that was Weber 2026. Super

50:20.540 --> 50:27.960
interesting. Yeah. And I mean, I think, and I don't think any of us would deny that alcohol is a

50:28.340 --> 50:36.440
toxin and it's, it's neurotoxic. It's systemically toxic. It's, it's not a health positive thing,

50:36.520 --> 50:42.560
just in an absolute sense, but like anything that are the poisons in the dose. And one thing that

50:42.560 --> 50:47.460
needs to be considered is also confounding influences there. Residual confounding, obviously

50:47.460 --> 50:55.580
we try to adjust for in research, but adjustments never, it's never precise. And it really depends

50:55.580 --> 50:57.780
on what is being adjusted for.

50:58.340 --> 51:08.060
We would obviously assume given that there are linchpin behaviors and crossover of health

51:08.060 --> 51:14.980
effects, you know, within people's diet and lifestyle, that those people who, who make an

51:14.980 --> 51:22.180
effort to, and are able to drink very moderately are probably fairly moderate people. They probably

51:22.180 --> 51:27.200
have other health behaviors, just like healthy abstainers are likely to have a whole bunch of

51:27.200 --> 51:28.320
other health promoting behaviors. And so, you know, I think, you know, it's, it's, it's, it's

51:28.340 --> 51:39.080
you know, the, the healthiest lifestyle overall. Now some, some will be, we all know athletes who

51:39.080 --> 51:43.180
eat well, train hard and go out and get hammered two nights of the week.

51:44.600 --> 51:50.640
They're going to be the sort of outliers in that category, but Hey, maybe they're also mitigating

51:50.640 --> 51:56.020
some of the damage, not entirely. And I'm still not suggesting that anyone do that, but you know,

51:56.020 --> 51:58.040
we, we have evidence.

51:58.340 --> 52:04.180
that, for example, following a healthy Mediterranean diet, and interestingly, and I don't know

52:04.180 --> 52:10.300
exactly what this means when they say this, but a Mediterranean, I think it's called an

52:10.300 --> 52:13.400
alcohol consumption pattern or something like that, or alcohol drinking pattern.

52:14.320 --> 52:18.680
Those people who follow a Mediterranean diet and adhere to it well and also follow that

52:18.680 --> 52:25.060
sort of Mediterranean alcohol drinking pattern, their risk of mortality is drastically reduced

52:25.060 --> 52:30.700
in the same way that physical activity drastically reduces mortality risk from alcohol.

52:32.220 --> 52:36.420
When we consider across the board that, yes, residual compound is going to come into this,

52:36.420 --> 52:42.520
but when we consider across the board that while the big bandwidth we previously talked

52:42.520 --> 52:48.720
about of having maybe up to two and a half to four and a half drinks per day, still probably

52:48.720 --> 52:52.520
not worth the risk, I would say, because of that increase in cancer risk.

52:53.260 --> 52:54.620
There's also Mendelian randomization.

52:55.060 --> 52:58.100
There's also Mendelian randomization studies, which show that risk does increase, albeit

52:58.100 --> 53:05.100
marginally, after, say, one drink per day, but it actually falls down to one drink.

53:06.220 --> 53:11.620
Maybe it's just that abstainer bias and stuff like that, but what that's pretty much telling

53:11.620 --> 53:17.160
us is that there's probably a likely lower threshold of around one drink per day.

53:18.160 --> 53:21.480
For the cancer outcomes, as we've already discussed, it's probably somewhere between

53:21.480 --> 53:23.700
half and one drink per day.

53:25.060 --> 53:32.400
So we wouldn't want to necessarily be at that upper threshold for mortality, but according

53:32.400 --> 53:38.900
to all the other data, hey, it's likely that if we are having those safe amounts of maybe

53:38.900 --> 53:47.840
half to one drink per day, on average, and we're eating well, we're exercising, we're

53:47.840 --> 53:53.580
sleeping well, doing all those things, would any potential negative effect, which we can't

53:53.580 --> 53:55.040
really actually see in the research anyway.

53:55.060 --> 53:59.500
But if there is some specter of that, is it going to be meaningful anyway?

53:59.900 --> 54:01.160
I'd say probably not.

54:03.020 --> 54:08.000
Yeah, I feel like, and I guess people would wonder why it's even worth having the discussion

54:08.000 --> 54:14.660
if alcohol is a toxin, then why don't we just, for safies, just to be safe, just say that

54:14.660 --> 54:16.240
there's no safe amount.

54:17.140 --> 54:19.080
And that's a really good point.

54:19.460 --> 54:23.780
And I could completely buy into why people would say that, and that's why I wouldn't

54:23.780 --> 54:24.960
be overly critical of people.

54:25.060 --> 54:29.240
Saying, hey, just to be completely risk-averse, why bother?

54:30.120 --> 54:35.440
But the reality is, some people like, you know, they like it.

54:35.740 --> 54:36.760
Some people like the taste.

54:36.860 --> 54:37.900
Some people like to have a beer.

54:38.500 --> 54:45.660
Some of us like the gentle, relaxing effect of, say, one beer.

54:46.940 --> 54:54.360
And if that's not promoting any great increase in mortality or morbidity risk, then what's

54:54.360 --> 54:54.760
the point?

54:54.760 --> 55:00.900
And I often will frame it this way, is that there are so many targets for health, potentially.

55:01.620 --> 55:02.820
We can't do them all.

55:03.420 --> 55:04.260
It's just not feasible.

55:04.440 --> 55:06.640
People have limited bandwidth.

55:06.940 --> 55:09.520
They have limited cognitive ability.

55:10.020 --> 55:13.540
You know, cognitive load grows exponentially with all the other things we're trying to

55:13.540 --> 55:13.820
do.

55:14.780 --> 55:21.080
And so if something is just really not meaningful, then why would we put all that time and effort

55:21.080 --> 55:23.740
into trying to change it, if it is, in fact, an effort for us?

55:24.760 --> 55:27.660
You know, there might be some potential benefits.

55:27.660 --> 55:31.300
And I know this idea has been supposedly put to rest.

55:32.440 --> 55:40.500
But if someone does enjoy the occasional drink, and that is socially lubricative for them,

55:40.700 --> 55:46.480
if that has psychosocial benefits in some way, then maybe for that person, it does actually

55:46.480 --> 55:46.780
help.

55:47.600 --> 55:52.820
You know, why is it that we see people following a healthy diet who also have that Mediterranean

55:52.820 --> 55:54.640
style drinking pattern?

55:54.760 --> 55:56.300
Getting pretty good outcomes.

55:57.420 --> 56:01.840
Now, it may not be that the alcohol is actually providing anything definitively beneficial.

56:02.740 --> 56:07.180
But again, it points to the idea that maybe it's not doing anything meaningfully harmful

56:07.180 --> 56:08.100
at all.

56:08.960 --> 56:12.780
And this, you know, speaks again to what you were talking about with absolute versus relative

56:12.780 --> 56:13.260
risk.

56:13.300 --> 56:17.300
And I would even simplify that even further as to just the magnitude of the risk.

56:17.620 --> 56:18.060
Yeah, okay.

56:18.300 --> 56:19.840
And what's the difference there?

56:20.820 --> 56:23.040
Well, you know, it's similar.

56:23.240 --> 56:24.480
When you put it into the relative.

56:24.760 --> 56:25.860
This is absolute risk numbers.

56:25.860 --> 56:27.420
It makes it clearer for people.

56:27.680 --> 56:40.400
But if we're seeing a, you know, let's say we're seeing a risk of 1.03 with a 95% confidence

56:40.400 --> 56:44.240
interval of 1.01 to 1.05 or something.

56:45.300 --> 56:49.520
What we're talking about there is like a 3% increase in risk, right?

56:51.320 --> 56:54.620
But is that meaningful in terms of?

56:54.760 --> 56:57.880
The amount of days lost off your life?

56:57.940 --> 57:03.480
Is it meaningful in terms of the actual increase in numbers of people who are dying?

57:03.680 --> 57:06.260
I mean, you could make a claim either way.

57:06.560 --> 57:11.580
But more importantly, it's so small, it may not even be true.

57:12.880 --> 57:13.220
Right?

57:14.680 --> 57:22.300
And when it's that small, and the research is based so much on those cohort studies,

57:22.840 --> 57:24.500
with so many residual confessions.

57:24.760 --> 57:35.700
Maybe it's just

57:35.700 --> 57:46.140
losing their Vegeta, or losing our

57:46.140 --> 57:47.300
rights, or losing value, right?

57:49.280 --> 57:49.580
So,

57:49.700 --> 57:52.360
And that's where when we look after investors, the retail and retail brings them up to 1%,

57:52.360 --> 57:52.560
right?

57:52.560 --> 57:52.840
So,

57:53.060 --> 57:53.100
theiu

57:53.100 --> 57:53.760
think the

57:53.760 --> 57:54.760
Sa

57:54.760 --> 58:00.920
the message that's going to serve the most people most of the time right and i don't think we can

58:00.920 --> 58:09.780
be looking at well yeah but your incidence of you know right hand pinky finger cancer will go up by

58:09.780 --> 58:16.600
20 but if every other thing is not really affected is that likely and is that going to cause any

58:16.600 --> 58:22.060
meaningful effect on overall mortality outcomes probably not so i think you know we start with

58:22.060 --> 58:27.680
mortality data and then we look at that pragmatically and i think we do go down to

58:27.680 --> 58:32.340
the lowest common denominator so would i feel comfortable drinking four and a half drinks per

58:32.340 --> 58:37.500
day given that that's the threshold you know as shown by the meta-analyses no i wouldn't

58:37.500 --> 58:42.080
because i've got my own genetic stuff my own considerations but also i'd look at the other

58:42.080 --> 58:46.240
studies which show that hey maybe the tipping point is actually lower than that maybe it is

58:46.240 --> 58:52.040
around one drink per day irrespective of gender or sex and so i would go to the

58:52.060 --> 58:57.680
lowest common denominator but i'd also consider you know do i want to if i do have some unknown

58:57.680 --> 59:04.600
familial or genetic proclivity to cancer do i even want to risk that not really so maybe i do

59:04.600 --> 59:12.160
want to stick it around you know half a drink or less per day but even within that that allows for

59:12.160 --> 59:17.340
some more freedom and flexibility than just telling people no and i think that's really

59:17.340 --> 59:21.320
important because like i say i think drinking habits are changing thankfully

59:22.060 --> 59:28.980
um you know i remember um what's this i i hope this is not apocryphal i hope this is actually a

59:28.980 --> 59:33.000
true memory that i have as a kid but i remember watching i won't say who it was because i don't

59:33.000 --> 59:36.400
want to throw the guy under the bus he's a legend but one of the greatest all blacks of all time came

59:36.400 --> 59:44.640
along to speak to us when we were kids at a um you know junior boys rugby event and he took up to

59:44.640 --> 59:50.620
the podium for his probably five minute speech two pints and he finished them right if i drink two

59:50.620 --> 59:52.040
pints it's basically two pints and i'm like oh my god i'm so sorry i'm so sorry i'm so sorry i'm so

59:52.040 --> 59:57.660
sorry four beers i'm gonna be buzzed yeah yeah but that was the culture just and doing it in

59:57.660 --> 01:00:02.520
front of kids and you know you had the rugby teams and the league teams and all the you know

01:00:02.520 --> 01:00:06.720
professional teams sponsored by alcohol companies and cigarette companies back in the day tobacco

01:00:06.720 --> 01:00:11.720
companies and we had you know you know what it's like we're a similar age when you're younger we

01:00:11.720 --> 01:00:18.960
had a very strong drinking culture strong in a negative way in this sense and i think we all

01:00:22.040 --> 01:00:29.920
had what would now be considered to be problematic drinking patterns right drink too much episodic

01:00:29.920 --> 01:00:35.980
binge drinking all that kind of stuff you know when i was younger if you turned up to a party

01:00:35.980 --> 01:00:44.480
with light beers are you gay it's like stupid you know stupid horrible homophobic and misogynistic

01:00:44.480 --> 01:00:50.020
things it's just so ridiculous whereas now that's the norm you'd see people coming to a party with

01:00:50.020 --> 01:00:52.020
light beer going out to a barbecue with zero

01:00:52.040 --> 01:00:58.380
beers you know non-alcoholic options it's just so much more normal now which is great and i think

01:00:58.380 --> 01:01:03.560
the the beauty of that is that not only is that a good shift in culture for health but it also

01:01:03.560 --> 01:01:09.800
allows that flexibility for people who do want to occasionally have a drink because it might give

01:01:09.800 --> 01:01:15.280
them some other benefit they can do that and still be well under what we would consider any meaningful

01:01:15.280 --> 01:01:21.800
risk threshold because if you're having two drinks a week like i really don't think that that is

01:01:21.800 --> 01:01:22.020
you know it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's

01:01:22.040 --> 01:01:27.000
an issue you should be worried about yeah it's interesting isn't it like i remember back in the

01:01:27.000 --> 01:01:31.980
day when i used to have a lot of clients and i would see people and they were you know this was

01:01:31.980 --> 01:01:37.660
maybe 15 years ago 16 years ago and you know they'd come into my office and they have corporate

01:01:37.660 --> 01:01:43.080
jobs and they're out wining and dining clients and it's very normal for them to get through a

01:01:43.080 --> 01:01:49.420
bottle of wine a night themselves get up the next day go ahead go back to work do they were

01:01:49.420 --> 01:01:52.020
functionally they were they were essentially they were they were they were they were they were

01:01:52.040 --> 01:01:58.140
actually functional alcoholics although they didn't obviously see themselves as such and i do

01:01:58.140 --> 01:02:03.360
think that has shifted somewhat albeit i'm not seeing as many people so maybe that hasn't but

01:02:03.360 --> 01:02:07.860
i'm i'm pretty sure that that has sort of shifted over the years and i'm sure there's still a lot

01:02:07.860 --> 01:02:14.520
of people out there who have you know problematic drinking behaviors who don't realize it i remember

01:02:14.520 --> 01:02:20.700
running not running people through the screening test but you know people would run themselves

01:02:20.700 --> 01:02:21.800
through the screening test for

01:02:21.800 --> 01:02:26.180
alcoholism and be really surprised that they were categorized as such even though they just thought

01:02:26.180 --> 01:02:31.040
that they were doing the norm and they were just doing the norm you know what we all potentially

01:02:31.040 --> 01:02:37.240
did back in the day and like i say thankfully that has really shifted and you know again that

01:02:37.240 --> 01:02:45.260
the key thing is that it allows that flexibility and i think the i used to say when i was teaching

01:02:45.260 --> 01:02:51.480
and this got me in a bit of trouble there's probably a safe dose of anything right the

01:02:51.800 --> 01:02:56.560
thing that got me in trouble is i was like you know cannabis yeah whatever there's there's a safe

01:02:56.560 --> 01:03:04.200
dose it might be so minuscule as to to be inconceivable but there is you know that safe

01:03:04.200 --> 01:03:08.620
dose and i think when the data points in one direction but everyone is saying something else

01:03:08.620 --> 01:03:15.400
that is just patently untrue that's when as a scientist i kind of think well let's explore

01:03:15.400 --> 01:03:21.460
that further because you're drawing the wrong conclusion from this and the biggest take-home

01:03:21.800 --> 01:03:26.560
is that there is no healthy dose of alcohol probably according to the research but there

01:03:26.560 --> 01:03:33.280
may well be a safe dose and we can probably point to what that is even if we are taking a really

01:03:33.280 --> 01:03:39.960
risk-averse approach and it doesn't mean that we necessarily have to say none because you know

01:03:39.960 --> 01:03:46.300
let's say in clinical practice we say that to all of our clients don't drink it's not going to work

01:03:46.300 --> 01:03:50.140
and it's going to turn people off and then we get

01:03:51.800 --> 01:03:58.220
confluence of of issues there where you know you would have seen this in practice where if someone

01:03:58.220 --> 01:04:03.520
fails on one element of their plan it often translates to the rest of the plan uh i've

01:04:03.520 --> 01:04:09.760
screwed it up i'm just going to go go rogue now whereas when they had that flexibility and

01:04:09.760 --> 01:04:15.180
particularly when they're able to do that with very specific tactical interventions that can

01:04:15.180 --> 01:04:20.740
allow them to have the guardrails and you know the the approach that i've used has translated

01:04:20.740 --> 01:04:21.780
really well to a lot of my clients and i think that's a really good point and i think that's

01:04:21.800 --> 01:04:28.300
it's like well how much would you consider to be here's you know what the evidence is and how much

01:04:28.300 --> 01:04:34.260
would you consider to be what your sort of threshold or limit would be let's maybe pull

01:04:34.260 --> 01:04:40.420
that back just a little bit and how do we work that now and it might be that you know a male

01:04:40.420 --> 01:04:47.460
with no other health factors no risk that we can see or large risk for for cancers and things

01:04:47.900 --> 01:04:51.320
might say well you know what i'd feel comfortable cutting back

01:04:51.320 --> 01:04:51.780
right now and i'm not going to do that i'm not going to do that i'm not going to do that i'm not

01:04:51.800 --> 01:04:52.260
going to do that i'm not going to do that i'm not going to do that i'm not going to do that

01:04:52.260 --> 01:05:00.020
to buying one dozen light beers a week so one dozen light beers approximately six drinks

01:05:00.020 --> 01:05:07.200
a week it's probably not too bad and that's well within the the risk thresholds for that individual

01:05:07.200 --> 01:05:12.240
likely now maybe over time they're going to realize that you know what i don't even need

01:05:12.240 --> 01:05:18.800
that maybe i could just get that dozen a month and that might work really well but

01:05:18.800 --> 01:05:21.780
it still allows again that that risk threshold to be there and i think that's a really good point

01:05:21.780 --> 01:05:25.480
flexibility and it means that there's not such a strong imperative on that one thing

01:05:25.480 --> 01:05:31.260
in the same way that we will often see in practice people come to us who have been told don't drink

01:05:31.260 --> 01:05:40.580
coffee why that that's an even easier one to combat because it's like dude there's no evidence

01:05:40.580 --> 01:05:46.760
for that suck all the joy out of their life why don't they exactly you know cliff i what i think

01:05:46.760 --> 01:05:51.760
of when i'm when i'm discussing this topic obviously as someone who enjoys a drink it's

01:05:51.780 --> 01:05:58.760
it warms my heart to see the evidence that endurance um or aerobic activity is is protective

01:05:58.760 --> 01:06:06.860
in in some capacity what i think a big picture problem with messages like zero tolerance or

01:06:06.860 --> 01:06:13.720
zero alcohol is the only safe dose is that it sort of erodes trust because to your point that's

01:06:13.720 --> 01:06:20.180
actually not what the data says and so if the data says one thing yet the public health message

01:06:20.180 --> 01:06:21.540
says something different

01:06:21.780 --> 01:06:26.620
then people are not going to then that just sort of erodes the trust in the people making

01:06:26.620 --> 01:06:34.160
those decisions and putting those messages out i think yep 100 and it also silos

01:06:34.160 --> 01:06:43.200
health positive people in this sort of absolutist basket and i think that's an issue

01:06:43.200 --> 01:06:47.840
in the health and nutrition space is that there are those people who are real purists

01:06:47.840 --> 01:06:51.760
you know you should not have any sugar you should not have any coffee

01:06:51.780 --> 01:06:57.040
you should not drink any alcohol you know it's all these thou shalt not and yes some people do

01:06:57.040 --> 01:07:04.280
that and all power to them i don't care but where there's not demonstrable harm from those things and

01:07:04.280 --> 01:07:11.280
in some cases it's just completely futile for a lot of people the caffeine one again is such a

01:07:11.280 --> 01:07:14.560
prime example of that because yes there are people who are really sensitive to caffeine

01:07:14.560 --> 01:07:18.240
and yes for some people they should abstain but they're not the majority of people in fact they're

01:07:18.240 --> 01:07:21.760
probably a very small minority for most people they're not the majority of people they're not the

01:07:21.780 --> 01:07:28.460
as we've discussed many times having a coffee or two in the morning even dare i say it if they

01:07:28.460 --> 01:07:33.260
have it on an empty stomach is probably not going to do a damn thing negative for their health

01:07:33.260 --> 01:07:39.360
if anything we'd probably look the other way where the evidence trends towards showing benefits over

01:07:39.360 --> 01:07:43.280
the long term and it's not going to adversely affect their cortisol responses and all that

01:07:43.280 --> 01:07:47.780
kind of stuff it just doesn't really matter and you know this is where we get back to

01:07:49.180 --> 01:07:51.620
um really zooming out which is what i get

01:07:51.780 --> 01:07:55.780
all my students to do zoom out man like you got to zoom out and look at this person's diet and

01:07:55.780 --> 01:08:02.140
lifestyle pattern what are they doing and when we see and you know we're specifically with respect

01:08:02.140 --> 01:08:07.960
to alcohol what patterns are conducive to the best outcomes yes it's drinking less but it doesn't

01:08:07.960 --> 01:08:17.460
have to be zero let's say it's one to two drinks maximum on three to four days of the week

01:08:17.460 --> 01:08:21.260
co-ingested with um with food

01:08:21.260 --> 01:08:26.620
is a really important mitigating factor as well this is potentially one of the reasons why in

01:08:26.620 --> 01:08:32.600
different populations we see different outcomes because in some cultures like here in the states

01:08:32.600 --> 01:08:40.760
and other you know of those types of um i guess anglo-centric originally countries we tend to drink

01:08:40.760 --> 01:08:46.980
to have a couple of beers or whatever right and a lot of other cultures you seldom have

01:08:46.980 --> 01:08:51.240
alcohol without food and that is actually a big mitigating factor and that's why we see a lot of

01:08:51.260 --> 01:08:51.820
people who drink a lot of alcohol and that's why we see a lot of people who drink a lot of alcohol

01:08:51.820 --> 01:08:55.220
especially when those foods are healthier and especially when the dietary band is healthier

01:08:55.220 --> 01:08:59.140
and especially when people are exercising and sleeping well so all of these things again

01:08:59.140 --> 01:09:04.480
coalesce so you know we we need to always be zooming out rather than focusing on that one

01:09:04.480 --> 01:09:08.860
specific thing who knows maybe i haven't looked into this but maybe coffee has a mitigating effect

01:09:08.860 --> 01:09:15.100
as well i did put into chat gpt i'm like what's going to be worse for me a coke zero or a wine

01:09:15.100 --> 01:09:20.620
at this time of night um and it spat out the wine was going to be worse for my sleep um i'm curious

01:09:20.620 --> 01:09:21.240
about this meditation i'm curious about this meditation i'm curious about this meditation i'm

01:09:21.260 --> 01:09:29.120
wondering if this is just another solid vote for day drinking if i'm honest like are people just

01:09:29.120 --> 01:09:33.640
drinking at lunch are they drinking at lunch and that is the thing they do in all of my romance

01:09:33.640 --> 01:09:40.860
novels that i read my middle-aged woman romance novels well i think that that probably plays

01:09:40.860 --> 01:09:47.940
into it you know maybe not drinking quite so late but not necessarily in the morning um but not not

01:09:47.940 --> 01:09:51.240
drinking quite so late you know with food and maybe the time that i'm drinking at lunch is

01:09:51.260 --> 01:09:51.640
maybe the time that i'm drinking at lunch is

01:09:51.640 --> 01:09:56.860
alcohol does play some role although i'm i'm skeptical of that even though there is research

01:09:56.860 --> 01:10:01.480
to suggest that you know beer and cider is worse or liquor you know spirits are the worst

01:10:01.480 --> 01:10:07.720
beer and cider maybe not quite so good as wine i i wonder whether that is just so

01:10:07.720 --> 01:10:15.680
confounded i think so everyone i speak to feels far better when they avoid red wine

01:10:15.680 --> 01:10:21.080
of any wine it's red wine that really makes a difference i always feel so much better

01:10:21.260 --> 01:10:29.360
i i definitely notice myself if i'm drinking beer it's an easy it's it's far um less affected

01:10:29.360 --> 01:10:34.120
my sleep is far less affected actually but that's in my personal experience but white red wine

01:10:34.120 --> 01:10:39.600
that surprises me that beer comes out as being again it may well be related to

01:10:39.600 --> 01:10:44.840
again you know stepping out what what patterns are associated with that

01:10:44.840 --> 01:10:50.920
and people tend to have wine with meals maybe if they're a wine drinker they might tend to be

01:10:51.260 --> 01:10:58.280
maybe more affluent yeah oh good call maybe maybe they're more likely to be following a

01:10:58.280 --> 01:11:02.100
more mediterranean style healthy diet pattern or some other healthy diet pattern you know

01:11:02.100 --> 01:11:07.340
who knows there's a lot of different things that can play into that um you know people

01:11:07.340 --> 01:11:12.640
underestimate their serving sizes anyway but maybe if people are drinking liquor i don't know

01:11:12.640 --> 01:11:17.080
maybe that's an easier to underestimate i'm not sure i'll have to sort of dig into that

01:11:17.080 --> 01:11:21.240
but you know i don't want to say that i don't want to say that i don't want to say that i don't want

01:11:21.260 --> 01:11:27.340
to make excuses for alcohol either because again alcohol is a toxin so we know that but some other

01:11:27.340 --> 01:11:33.800
things will affect how an individual feels right i know that if i have more than say

01:11:33.800 --> 01:11:39.480
two or three drinks i'll feel a little bit shady in the morning not too bad but shady and i notice

01:11:39.480 --> 01:11:44.020
it now whereas i wouldn't have noticed it as much when i was younger probably because my recovery

01:11:44.020 --> 01:11:47.680
ability was better but also because we were more commonly drinking and you just sort of accepted it

01:11:47.680 --> 01:11:49.460
now i'm not prepared to accept that either

01:11:51.260 --> 01:11:57.320
i don't know that if i have a a beer that's higher nickel because you know i know i talk about it all

01:11:57.320 --> 01:12:00.520
the time but it's just an interesting thing because i have a nickel allergy if i have a

01:12:00.520 --> 01:12:06.120
beer that's higher in nickel i'll feel pretty terrible more or less straight away whereas if i

01:12:06.120 --> 01:12:13.460
have a golden rum or maybe a really um not not light in terms of alcohol content but a light

01:12:13.460 --> 01:12:20.140
golden lager that's lower in nickel you know made from different grains not just malt or barley malt

01:12:21.260 --> 01:12:27.520
i'll be fine a lot of people will be more reactive to certain congeners as well which are you know

01:12:27.520 --> 01:12:32.460
those metabolic cofactors that are produced during fermentation they're going to differ per the

01:12:32.460 --> 01:12:39.440
grain or the base that's fermented so that's why some people will have issues with say whiskey

01:12:39.440 --> 01:12:44.640
and they won't have the same issue with vodka it's not just a myth although sometimes people

01:12:44.640 --> 01:12:48.000
say you know you can drink vodka without a hangover no you can't no it's alcohol it's

01:12:48.000 --> 01:12:51.240
going to give you a hangover but if you're talking about maybe having a hangover you're going to have

01:12:51.260 --> 01:12:55.960
one drink and you're getting a hangover then yeah maybe that is because of the congeners

01:12:55.960 --> 01:13:03.580
right so there are going to be differences in terms of people's direct perception of alcohol

01:13:03.580 --> 01:13:07.980
and their effects and how it's going to affect their quality of life and cognition and those

01:13:07.980 --> 01:13:12.520
types of things and that's that's all important too because that then plays into risk mitigation

01:13:12.520 --> 01:13:16.960
because what are we really looking to do it's not just about long-term health it's also about how

01:13:16.960 --> 01:13:21.240
do you feel if you feel better that's good and in that respect

01:13:21.260 --> 01:13:27.120
having that if you want to drink if you don't cool but if you do want to drink and you're doing

01:13:27.120 --> 01:13:31.980
so safely then finding those drinks that work best for you that aren't going to make you feel like

01:13:31.980 --> 01:13:35.780
crap as well that's obviously a good thing because then it might play into some of the potential

01:13:35.780 --> 01:13:41.340
positives you know i know that some recent commentators mainly in this is a sort of

01:13:41.340 --> 01:13:46.620
sociology space rather than the health space have said that one of the reasons that young men

01:13:46.620 --> 01:13:50.320
are so disaffected now is that they're not going out and drinking with their mates

01:13:51.260 --> 01:13:58.840
now i think that's garbage but because i think men going out in groups and getting hammered

01:13:58.840 --> 01:14:03.920
together as a lot of us used to do is not positive for society it's not positive for anyone it's not

01:14:03.920 --> 01:14:08.440
positive for their partners it's not positive for women overall it's actually a shitty situation but

01:14:08.440 --> 01:14:15.900
if we're talking about maybe people not going out for that one beer with their buddy or their

01:14:15.900 --> 01:14:21.200
friend whatever i say buddy because it's typically people are going to default to

01:14:21.260 --> 01:14:25.660
men and i don't think we should default any anything to gender but if people are just you

01:14:25.660 --> 01:14:29.160
know averse to that because of the fear of drinking then yeah that's not going to be a

01:14:29.160 --> 01:14:35.700
positive thing and if maybe the social lubrication of you know feeling that little bit more relaxed

01:14:35.700 --> 01:14:41.420
at the end of the day because of the one drink is going to help you to maybe express your emotions

01:14:41.420 --> 01:14:45.600
to your friend or whatever then sure on a case-by-case basis maybe there is something there

01:14:45.600 --> 01:14:50.700
having said that if that one drink causes you to be an arsehole then yeah don't drink

01:14:51.260 --> 01:14:58.860
100 that's i think that there is i 100 agree with i will say cliff that i think that um

01:14:58.860 --> 01:15:05.200
when we um dial in and focus on one thing to your point like where should people

01:15:05.200 --> 01:15:11.140
pay most of their attention to yes this is important i don't know guys i just think

01:15:11.140 --> 01:15:17.380
being active really does uh make such a difference to your overall health and it's like

01:15:17.380 --> 01:15:21.140
it touches almost every part of your health and longevity

01:15:21.260 --> 01:15:26.580
so to my mind maybe we should just spend more time and attention getting people

01:15:26.580 --> 01:15:31.960
out there being active which would probably be far more effective than telling people they can't

01:15:31.960 --> 01:15:40.240
drink alcohol yeah i think there are potentially a lot of different linchpin behaviors i feel like

01:15:40.240 --> 01:15:44.800
activity would be one of the biggest and it's certainly got some of the biggest impacts on

01:15:44.800 --> 01:15:49.360
long-term health right so 100 i think you know making

01:15:49.360 --> 01:15:51.240
big changes in our lives and i think that's a big part of it i think that's a big part of it

01:15:51.260 --> 01:15:58.680
where people can to an otherwise poor diet is going to have a way bigger impact than maybe

01:15:58.680 --> 01:16:03.840
marginally decreasing alcohol intake i think there are other things that have really big

01:16:03.840 --> 01:16:10.200
effects on overall health and on every aspect of health within it that people don't necessarily

01:16:10.200 --> 01:16:17.300
recognize recognize the the real profundity of right and i i think we've discussed this before

01:16:17.300 --> 01:16:20.980
but um my good buddy guy i respect you know

01:16:21.260 --> 01:16:26.900
definitely um dr joe klimczewski talked about the lack of efficacy for

01:16:26.900 --> 01:16:35.020
health and particularly body fat loss of uh non-diet interventions like health at every

01:16:35.020 --> 01:16:39.220
size and stuff like that really good for psychological health not so good for metabolic

01:16:39.220 --> 01:16:45.400
health but one thing one non-diet intervention he didn't talk about which i brought up in a

01:16:45.400 --> 01:16:51.040
panel later was um mindfulness and meditation which is really effective for improving

01:16:51.040 --> 01:16:51.240
health and i think that's a really good thing to talk about and i think that's a really good thing

01:16:51.260 --> 01:16:55.420
because people tend to eat a heck of a lot better when they're practicing mindfulness and in some

01:16:55.420 --> 01:17:01.920
research they do better with their diets and better for say fat loss metabolic health than

01:17:01.920 --> 01:17:06.860
they do if they're following a diet intervention so we're talking about alcohol how does that play

01:17:06.860 --> 01:17:13.060
into things well where people are more mindful they're less likely to be engaging in as many of

01:17:13.060 --> 01:17:18.880
the problematic behaviors as maybe coping mechanisms or because it's an almost you know

01:17:18.880 --> 01:17:21.240
semi-autonomic response or reaction to the health of the body and so i think that's a really good

01:17:21.260 --> 01:17:25.360
example of where people are more able to have that little junction where they can step back and say

01:17:25.360 --> 01:17:30.700
oh maybe i don't actually need that drink right now so you know this is just one example of where

01:17:30.700 --> 01:17:37.500
all those health factors coalesce and where we might have linchpin behaviors that are going to

01:17:37.500 --> 01:17:43.900
translate across various health factors and how that plays into what should we do first right and

01:17:43.900 --> 01:17:49.840
if someone's like sleeping really poorly and that's causing them as it often does for them to

01:17:49.840 --> 01:17:50.800
eat really poorly

01:17:51.260 --> 01:17:56.440
which is causing them to have you know more shitty sleep and that's meaning at the end of the day

01:17:56.440 --> 01:18:00.380
they're finding it really hard to relax so they have a couple of drinks i mean maybe the thing

01:18:00.380 --> 01:18:05.400
that's really going to help them is to get on top of their sleep then they might end up eating better

01:18:05.400 --> 01:18:11.300
and then maybe they might end up drinking less and then be able to get to a place fairly comfortably

01:18:11.300 --> 01:18:17.200
through those linchpin actions that they are having a much better overall pattern which is

01:18:17.200 --> 01:18:21.160
exactly you know what we've been talking about right yeah yeah nice

01:18:21.260 --> 01:18:27.780
one cliff so um what's the take-home what's the take-home clifford i've already told you mine

01:18:27.780 --> 01:18:33.340
drink at lunchtime and exercise they're my take-homes hey well i think that's really good

01:18:33.340 --> 01:18:40.660
advice right yeah and i think where where we look where we would end up i think if we're looking at

01:18:40.660 --> 01:18:46.900
the research pragmatically is that if we're having no more than say

01:18:46.900 --> 01:18:51.060
well what would it be actually

01:18:51.260 --> 01:19:00.660
one drink three to four days a week let's say one drink three days a week yeah one drink every

01:19:00.660 --> 01:19:06.380
second day if you do it that way you have three three drinks one week four drinks the next week

01:19:06.380 --> 01:19:12.700
yeah yeah what i um used to say to my clients which i think was a pretty good middle ground was

01:19:12.700 --> 01:19:19.120
you know no more than two drinks with more days of the week alcohol free than with alcohol

01:19:19.120 --> 01:19:21.240
that keeps people jet-lagged and i think that's a really good thing i think that's a really good thing

01:19:21.260 --> 01:19:26.860
generally pretty much there or thereabouts with those risk thresholds and then we could add on top

01:19:26.860 --> 01:19:33.220
of that wherever possible have some food some healthy food with you know alongside alcohol

01:19:33.220 --> 01:19:37.680
then obviously all the other stuff we would work on eat a healthy diet overall

01:19:37.680 --> 01:19:44.260
get some exercise hey things are probably going to be pretty okay yeah no i love it and that really

01:19:44.260 --> 01:19:50.920
speaks to um what i pretty much advocate as well i mean clearly alcohol in terms of your

01:19:51.260 --> 01:19:52.620
drinking habits and how you're going to live your best life if it's going to impact behaviors that

01:19:52.620 --> 01:19:57.620
then impact on what you you know how you want to live your best life then you need to really sort

01:19:57.620 --> 01:20:02.120
of consider that which is of course everything that you've just discussed so i think that's a

01:20:02.120 --> 01:20:07.360
nice i don't think it i don't think it's a middle ground but i think it's a good a good place to land

01:20:07.360 --> 01:20:14.980
on yeah and if your drinking affects anyone else negatively then that's you know that's not okay

01:20:14.980 --> 01:20:20.320
and you should rein it in yeah no i love it i love it cliff so now where can people find out

01:20:20.320 --> 01:20:21.180
just remind me

01:20:21.260 --> 01:20:26.440
i mean i think you've been on the show like about 10 times at this point which is so good um maybe

01:20:26.440 --> 01:20:30.720
not quite so many but almost i reckon more than that really oh i'm gonna need to do the math yeah

01:20:30.720 --> 01:20:36.360
i know um uh and of course this is going out on your pod as well but let people know where they

01:20:36.360 --> 01:20:41.480
can find you well they can find me mostly at the holistic performance institute which is just

01:20:41.480 --> 01:20:48.900
holisticperformance.institute and we'll have this um full review on alcohol and mortality up in

01:20:51.260 --> 01:20:57.360
you know very aligned with Mikkipedia i love it our um database of living review articles it'll be

01:20:57.360 --> 01:21:03.320
going up probably next week wonderful well we will put links over on Mikkipedia to that as i'm sure you

01:21:03.320 --> 01:21:09.880
will on your pod as well and we'll have obviously all the info about Mikki Mikkipedia in the show

01:21:09.880 --> 01:21:16.400
notes links out to Mikki's amazing programs and and this amazing podcast amazing which always

01:21:16.400 --> 01:21:20.260
recommend we reckon we if someone's got the triumvirate of the

01:21:21.260 --> 01:21:27.300
Mikkipedia translating nutrition and iron culture by mass they're pretty much covering everything

01:21:27.300 --> 01:21:33.680
they really are maybe sorry i gotta call out danny as well sigma nutrition yeah nice one i love it

01:21:33.680 --> 01:21:40.220
even if we disagree on some things he has a bloody good podcast awesome cliff oh and the one last one

01:21:40.220 --> 01:21:45.280
is of course i mean brandon de cruz if you really want to go into the weeds on any topic he's

01:21:45.280 --> 01:21:49.220
amazing yeah love the way that that oh now we're starting to open the floodgates there's going to

01:21:49.220 --> 01:21:51.220
be more and more i know stop stop

01:21:51.260 --> 01:21:54.460
stop already cliff you have a great day you do mac

01:21:54.460 --> 01:22:13.080
all righty hopefully you uh really enjoyed that um i just i think you do really why wouldn't you

01:22:13.080 --> 01:22:18.420
because i mean i do so if you're anything like me and you're listening to the show you will too

01:22:18.800 --> 01:22:21.100
um i just want to tell you actually that i'm

01:22:21.260 --> 01:22:27.840
i have a glp1 webinar that is taking place on sunday the 4th of october 12 p.m new zealand time

01:22:27.840 --> 01:22:35.040
completely free come along learn nutrition supplement and training related information

01:22:35.040 --> 01:22:41.900
if you're someone thinking about coming on going on a glp1 if you're wondering how to manage these

01:22:41.900 --> 01:22:46.420
things when you're on it or you're thinking about whether or not you're going to be tapering off

01:22:46.420 --> 01:22:50.740
what are the things you need in place i've got it all there for you there so

01:22:51.260 --> 01:22:55.880
pop a link in the show notes to that as well and um would love to see you along all right guys

01:22:55.880 --> 01:23:01.960
enjoy the week you can catch me i'm on instagram threads and x at Mikki Williden facebook at

01:23:01.960 --> 01:23:07.440
Mikki Williden nutrition or head to my website mikkiwilliden.com book a call there all right

01:23:07.440 --> 01:23:09.420
guys you have the best week see you later

01:23:21.260 --> 01:23:21.760
you