Subscribe
Share
Share
Embed
Discover how a Jewish 'gunslinger' from the JUCO ranks became an icon at BYU, leading a top-10 resurgence and a legendary rivalry comeback.
Discover how a Jewish 'gunslinger' from the JUCO ranks became an icon at BYU, leading a top-10 resurgence and a legendary rivalry comeback.
ALEX: Imagine you are a practicing Reform Jew from Southern California. You wear a Star of David around your neck, you keep kosher, and you’ve just been named the starting quarterback for the most famous religious school in America—Brigham Young University, where 98 percent of the students are Latter-day Saints.
JORDAN: That sounds like the setup to a movie that would get rejected for being too unrealistic. There’s no way the culture fit works, right?
ALEX: Not only did it work, but the fans in Provo gave him a nickname that stuck like glue: 'BYJew.' Today, we’re talking about Jake Retzlaff, the man who went from having zero college offers to becoming a folk hero in one of the most intense rivalries in sports.
JORDAN: I love a good underdog story, but how does a guy with 'zero offers' end up leading a Top 10 team in the Big 12?
ALEX: It started with a total lack of respect from scouts. Jake grew up in Corona, California, playing for a powerhouse high school, Centennial. But he was stuck behind older kids who were already committed to major programs, so he barely saw the field.
JORDAN: So he’s a benchwarmer at a big school. Usually, that’s where the dream ends and the intramural flag football career begins.
ALEX: Not for Jake. He transferred to Corona High just to get some tape, but by the time he graduated in 2021, his recruiting profile was a ghost town. No Division I coaches were calling.
JORDAN: That’s brutal. So he takes the 'scenic route,' I’m guessing? The JUCO grind?
ALEX: Exactly. He heads to Golden West College in Huntington Beach and just explodes. He throws for over 3,000 yards and 23 touchdowns in one year, but the big schools still aren't biting. So, he doubles down and transfers to Riverside City College to play for Tom Craft, a legendary quarterback whisperer.
JORDAN: And he wasn't alone at Riverside, right? I heard there was a family connection.
ALEX: The ultimate connection. His brother, Reggie Retzlaff, was the star wide receiver. It was like backyard football on steroids. Jake threw 44 touchdowns that season, and 23 of them went straight to his brother.
JORDAN: Okay, at that point, you can't ignore the stats. That’s video game stuff.
ALEX: It worked. By late 2022, 247Sports ranked him as the number one junior college pro-style quarterback in the entire country. And that’s when BYU—preparing for their big move to the Big 12 conference—finally came calling.
ALEX: Jake arrives in Provo in January 2023, but he’s not the starter yet. He’s backing up Kedon Slovis, a veteran transfer. But then, in late October, Slovis gets hurt, and Jake is thrown into the deep end.
JORDAN: Let me guess: he comes in and wins the Heisman immediately?
ALEX: The exact opposite. It was a disaster. He started the final four games of the 2023 season against teams like Oklahoma and West Virginia, and BYU lost every single one of them.
JORDAN: Ouch. So the 'JUCO sensation' goes 0-and-4 to start his major college career?
ALEX: 0-and-4. He turned the ball over seven times. The fans were restless, and the coaches were worried. So, going into 2024, they brought in another transfer to compete with him. Everyone thought Jake was done.
JORDAN: But he won the job back? How?
ALEX: Pure resilience. He outplayed the veteran in training camp, and then he completely transformed the offense. He’s what coaches call a 'gunslinger'—think Brett Favre. He takes massive risks, he throws from weird arm angles, and he runs like his hair is on fire.
JORDAN: Does that actually work against Big 12 defenses, or does he just throw more interceptions?
ALEX: Both! That’s the 'Gunslinger Paradox.' In 2024, he threw 11 interceptions, but he also led BYU to a 9-and-0 start. The peak of the legend happened on November 9th—the 'Holy War' against their archrival, Utah.
JORDAN: The biggest game of the year. Please tell me he didn't choke.
ALEX: BYU was down by two points with less than two minutes left. They had zero timeouts and were backed up in their own territory. Jake engineered a 9-play, 65-yard drive under suffocating pressure, converted a fourth-and-long, and set up the game-winning field goal with three seconds left.
JORDAN: In Salt Lake City? That’s how you become a legend. You can throw all the interceptions you want if you win the Holy War like that.
ALEX: What makes this even more significant is the cultural impact. BYU has a strict Honor Code—no alcohol, no tobacco, no coffee.
JORDAN: For a kid from Southern California, that sounds like a lifestyle shock.
ALEX: Jake actually embraced it. He said the discipline of the school matched the discipline of being an athlete. The BYU nutritionists even worked with him to make sure he had kosher meals during road trips.
JORDAN: It’s cool to see a community that’s so homogenous embrace someone who is so clearly 'other' on paper.
ALEX: It’s a bridge-building story. You’ve got a Jewish quarterback wearing a Star of David while leading the flagship school of the LDS church to a top-10 ranking. He’s joined the ranks of BYU legends like Steve Young and Zach Wilson, but he did it his own way.
JORDAN: So, looking back at the whole wild ride—the JUCO years, the 0-and-4 start, the Holy War—what’s the one thing we should remember about Jake Retzlaff?
ALEX: Remember that Jake Retzlaff proved the 'scenic route' isn't a detour; it's a forge that builds the kind of resilience you need to win when the world thinks you've already lost.
JORDAN: That’s Wikipodia — every story, on demand. Search your next topic at wikipodia.ai
Any Topic. As a Podcast. On Demand.
Turn any Wikipedia topic into a podcast. Science explained simply. Historical events brought to life. Technology deep dives. Famous people biographies. New episodes daily covering black holes, World War II, Einstein, Bitcoin, and thousands more topics. Educational podcasts for curious minds.