This is day 3:42 forming an opinion. Have you ever stopped to consider how you formed a particular opinion? This could be a Viewpoint about conditions in the area of a war of the world that you've never visited a conspiracy theory that you believe or do not believe a religion that you have dismissed or political stance that you've decided to take what formed this opinion. The next question to consider is how strongly do I believe this could anything change my mind? Growing up. I was involved in speech and debate which was called forensics at the time. I think that word has become associated with crime scene investigation. So now we just say debate. Although I like referring to it as forensics because that was truly what it was. We were immersed in the consideration and effectiveness of claims. And how those could be backed up by various sources of evidence. We would frequently borrow from different fields, especially the legal field to bring stronger arguments to defeat various expert opinions. Debate is notorious for making causal causal link chains that lead to some serious impact. When I was younger, the favorite topic was nuclear war. Everything would lead to a nuclear war if you kept linking the evidence together. and the way that demonstrated some causality debate teams were arguing that all kinds of things would lead to nuclear war from over harvesting Amazon jungles to underfunding public education. There was always a way to link these to social unrest trade imbalances and therefore Global Thermo nuclear war. That then became Global Ice Age my children were on a debate team in college and their great Calamity that everything was linked to was global warming. However, just having a causal causal link was not strong evidence. Debate would often digress into a speed round to determine who could read the most evidence as fast as they possible. They called the spreading the ability to just dump a bunch of evidence leading toward one of these terrible potential outcomes. So you either had to become really Adept at reading evidence briefs or you had to learn to tear apart arguments that there seems by attacking evidence quality. I chose the latter. As a consequence, I've always had in the back of my mind. What causes me to form an opinion? Psychologists seems to they distinguish between the strength of an opinion and the strength of the basis for an opinion which are not the same thing. Someone can be extremely certain of something with almost no support for that opinion. The word here would be epistemic. You may have a strong opinion, but your epistemic foundation could be very weak. So what is this epistemic Foundation? If we were in a courtroom and you tried to bring evidence to prove your opinion, you would run smack into the necessity of providing a foundation for any evidence to be introduced into that courtroom. You would suddenly find yourself swimming in a sea of evidentiary rules that have been adjudicated for centuries. Many people want to argue a defense of their opinion on the basis of intuition. It just feels wrong to me rely on their feelings their instincts or their preferences. This is the weakest foundation for an opinion. And people learn that very quickly in a courtroom. Next might be an appeal to Authority. That can be an authority derived from your Society your peers your tribe or perhaps just hearsay. Everyone is saying this. Sometimes this can be stronger meaning it comes from an authority that people trust and that case it will carry more weight, but the fact remains in an opinion only on the testimony of others is also a weak epistemic Foundation. The next up is anecdotal. This is from personal experience. I saw this happen myself or this is what happened to me. Those are difficult arguments to defend against however, they are just that individual experience. They may be strong for the particular person, but not strong in terms of formulating a basis for an opinion that others should adopt as well. This is still pretty weak evidence but stronger than Intuition or hearsay. And a courtroom this would be considered eyewitness testimony. Then we get to the higher levels of establishing an epistemic foundation for an opinion. An informed opinion is one in which you have multiple sources facts experience and have done at least some rudimentary analysis. You might say I've looked into this and several sources support it. Higher than an informed opinion is one that you have investigated this implies you have done research your evidence is of high quality and from independent sources and that you have competing explanations weight against your findings. And research circles. This is called being peer-reviewed. Finally the best and the strongest epistemic foundation for an opinion would be one that is robust. Meaning the you have strong convincing evidence. The methods of deriving that evidence are well understood and you have tested counter-evidence more importantly you have a strong conclusion, but that conclusion remains revisable and you know exactly what new evidence would change your mind. Putting this all together. If you have a weak foundation and express high confidence in your opinion, then you are being dogmatic. If you have a strong foundation on high confidence, then you can be considered a well-supported conviction. There's a big difference between these two. If you have low confidence in a weak Foundation, then you are just speculating. That's okay. As long as you're open about what you're trying to do. If you have low confidence with a strong Foundation, then you're just being careful or perhaps just too nice. We tend to talk about opinions as though they are all epistemically equivalent. That is just not true and dangerous. You might have heard the popular phrase opinions are like a-holes. Everyone has one. Well, this is true. But that phrase stopped short and rhetorical critique is that everyone has an opinion and you can indeed judge the basis on which that opinion was formed.