00:00:00.544 --> 00:00:01.294
Gregory Treat: All right, everybody.

00:00:01.330 --> 00:00:05.102
Hello and welcome to episode
37 of the Great Houses forum.

00:00:05.653 --> 00:00:10.284
So we are, I'm, I am, uh,
trialing a new, uh, a presentation

00:00:10.288 --> 00:00:13.288
mechanism for, for those that are,
that are here on the live call.

00:00:13.560 --> 00:00:16.913
And so it's, it's gonna be an exciting,
it's gonna be an exciting day.

00:00:17.384 --> 00:00:21.514
today we're gonna talk about
representative glory, right?

00:00:21.519 --> 00:00:25.541
So last week we talked about the
fact that authority is not unitary.

00:00:25.891 --> 00:00:29.258
The, the household, the church,
the state govern different things.

00:00:29.667 --> 00:00:32.745
Um, we also talked about the fact
that, that help or assistance,

00:00:32.747 --> 00:00:36.565
you know, especially payments
of money, is not status, right?

00:00:36.567 --> 00:00:40.613
It doesn't give you the ability
to, um, to adjudicate things.

00:00:40.613 --> 00:00:44.957
It doesn't give you the ability to
create your own kind of illegible spaces.

00:00:45.254 --> 00:00:49.550
and, and I, I think that, uh, that
we will, we will not have families,

00:00:49.561 --> 00:00:54.008
families will not have children again
en masse until, uh, they hold the power

00:00:54.008 --> 00:00:57.048
and status to, to treat those children
as, as the future of their house.

00:00:57.048 --> 00:00:59.890
So, you know, I think the, the,
the great question, and we'll talk

00:00:59.891 --> 00:01:03.842
more about this, is, you know, who
do your children belong to, right?

00:01:04.289 --> 00:01:06.932
And, um, you know, sometimes
people will, will state this as

00:01:06.933 --> 00:01:08.566
who owns the children, right?

00:01:08.972 --> 00:01:14.527
And, and I think that's, that's a, it's
a m- that's a missing… That's not

00:01:14.528 --> 00:01:16.211
the right way to, to ask the question.

00:01:16.221 --> 00:01:20.234
The right way to ask the question is
not actually who owns these people.

00:01:20.419 --> 00:01:22.687
The right question is
who do they belong to?

00:01:23.289 --> 00:01:27.291
And 'cause it's belonging that is,
is the, the, the thing that, that we

00:01:27.291 --> 00:01:30.345
wanna, we wanna understand, and that's
the thing I think we're missing.

00:01:30.585 --> 00:01:36.843
If you belong to no one, it's going to be
very difficult, uh, for you to encourage

00:01:36.845 --> 00:01:38.329
people to do the things they need to do.

00:01:38.329 --> 00:01:40.287
It's gonna be very difficult
for covenants to form.

00:01:40.529 --> 00:01:47.750
People are not going to feel the
desire to, um, engage in all of these,

00:01:48.473 --> 00:01:53.371
these socially necessary, but kind of
individually non-rational things, right?

00:01:53.759 --> 00:01:55.971
So today I want to do
a meditation on glory.

00:01:56.356 --> 00:02:00.174
Uh, we'll talk about glory as an
office, glory as, as an exchange.

00:02:00.174 --> 00:02:02.537
What does it mean to have,
have representative glory?

00:02:02.857 --> 00:02:06.629
Uh, what does it mean to, to, to
be an ideal for, for somebody?

00:02:06.976 --> 00:02:09.255
Um, a- and really what we're
talking about here is, is why

00:02:09.255 --> 00:02:10.919
would I ever be a noble, right?

00:02:11.413 --> 00:02:14.571
Um, you know, a lot of people
view nobles as people who just

00:02:14.571 --> 00:02:17.712
kind of irrationally do things to
hurt the people under their care.

00:02:17.861 --> 00:02:20.132
Why would you ever wanna
be such a person, right?

00:02:20.132 --> 00:02:23.394
We even have that sense to, that in order
to do a good job as a noble, you have

00:02:23.395 --> 00:02:27.942
to acquire power, direct personal power
over the people, uh, in your life, of

00:02:27.942 --> 00:02:31.407
the kind that liberalism has accustomed
us to believing is automatically

00:02:31.465 --> 00:02:32.876
corrupt- uh, you know, corrupting.

00:02:33.158 --> 00:02:35.927
And, and, and I think, you know,
it's important to start by, by, uh,

00:02:35.948 --> 00:02:37.446
recognizing that it is corrupting.

00:02:37.983 --> 00:02:43.796
Um, there is this sense in which it
is very difficult, very dangerous,

00:02:43.814 --> 00:02:49.855
very hard to, you know, know what
is it that, that, that will happen

00:02:50.189 --> 00:02:52.894
if we, if we become corrupt.

00:02:53.206 --> 00:02:56.298
What will happen if we,
if we acquire power?

00:02:56.299 --> 00:02:58.475
There's a moral hazard here, right?

00:02:58.748 --> 00:02:59.945
and, and it's a serious one.

00:02:59.952 --> 00:03:03.327
Like, it's not, I don't wanna, I don't
wanna just kind of wink and nod at that.

00:03:03.726 --> 00:03:06.963
Uh, there, there, there is a real
sense where if you, if you have the

00:03:06.964 --> 00:03:11.146
power to be noble, you also have
the power to be a tyrant, right?

00:03:11.358 --> 00:03:14.877
And, and we're, we're… W- the
question that we're having, the

00:03:14.880 --> 00:03:18.141
conversation that we're having, I
think, as a culture really comes back

00:03:18.141 --> 00:03:21.556
to is that just automatically bad?

00:03:21.556 --> 00:03:23.868
And, and I think the first step,
the first question is, you know,

00:03:23.868 --> 00:03:25.485
can we even really avoid it?

00:03:25.907 --> 00:03:30.176
Um, I did a, I did a post, uh, this
week, an article, um, on the, the

00:03:30.178 --> 00:03:33.277
Avalon Circle Sub Stack, and the, the,
the comment that somebody made was

00:03:33.447 --> 00:03:36.745
how do we, how do we persuade people?

00:03:36.766 --> 00:03:40.747
I was talking about, um, this, this
idea that we can have broadly a

00:03:40.748 --> 00:03:46.538
capital-friendly society at large, and we
can get many of the benefits of fertility

00:03:46.690 --> 00:03:52.415
if we will just allow households to have
their, their spaces, their illegible

00:03:52.416 --> 00:03:55.299
spaces that they can protect and they can
build and they can do stuff with, right?

00:03:56.001 --> 00:03:58.584
some- the, the question that I got,
the, the, the comment that I got

00:03:58.586 --> 00:04:03.307
was, well, how do we convince people
that, that this is a good thing?

00:04:03.312 --> 00:04:07.358
How do we move towards this type three
world where it's sort of broadly capital

00:04:07.368 --> 00:04:11.939
friendly, but allows for the creation
of spaces that are ordered to fertil-

00:04:12.058 --> 00:04:16.199
you know, fertility and, um, and,
and, and reproduction and discipleship

00:04:16.204 --> 00:04:17.677
and all of those things, right?

00:04:18.121 --> 00:04:22.998
uh, my answer, uh, the, the, the,
is, is basically Evan Amato, right?

00:04:23.328 --> 00:04:26.163
So, uh, Evan Amato is
a cultural influencer.

00:04:26.174 --> 00:04:27.995
Evan Amato is one of our guys.

00:04:28.010 --> 00:04:34.508
He is, he is kind of part of the, the,
the, the group of right-wing online,

00:04:34.575 --> 00:04:40.098
um, people that are looking for a way
out of our current cultural malaise,

00:04:40.140 --> 00:04:43.352
and that, that … He, I think he's
done a really good job of, you know,

00:04:43.353 --> 00:04:46.276
not succumbing to the black pills, you
should never succumb to the black pills,

00:04:46.687 --> 00:04:48.321
um, and, and has built a following.

00:04:48.321 --> 00:04:51.533
And, and recently he has
become … He started a

00:04:51.535 --> 00:04:53.979
partnership with Edward Habsburg.

00:04:54.478 --> 00:04:58.569
And if you don't know who Edward Habsburg
is, he is literally the descendant,

00:04:58.582 --> 00:04:59.715
he's the bloodline descendant.

00:04:59.715 --> 00:05:04.011
If, if the Habsburgs still ruled Austria,
he would be the Archduke of Austria.

00:05:04.394 --> 00:05:04.817
Okay?

00:05:05.171 --> 00:05:07.166
Um, now, and I think he
is still technically.

00:05:07.168 --> 00:05:10.505
The, the, the, the, the, the title is
something that he is allowed to use.

00:05:10.648 --> 00:05:13.128
The title doesn't carry any
political power at present.

00:05:13.584 --> 00:05:17.255
Um, but I just wanna, I wanna note that.

00:05:17.267 --> 00:05:19.250
Like, something, something is happening.

00:05:19.250 --> 00:05:21.786
It's very interesting that,
that, that, that this, this

00:05:21.793 --> 00:05:23.175
partnership is happening at all.

00:05:23.484 --> 00:05:28.743
Um, and, and so, you know, the, the, the
podcast they're, they've started is called

00:05:28.745 --> 00:05:32.996
The Habsburg Way, and they put out a, a
number of really interesting episodes.

00:05:33.328 --> 00:05:37.959
Um, and, and they, they did an episode
recently called What Is Catholic Nobility?

00:05:37.961 --> 00:05:41.931
And, and, you know, it's … I, I thought
it was a worthwhile episode for, for,

00:05:41.958 --> 00:05:43.604
for Protestants as well as Catholics.

00:05:43.605 --> 00:05:46.212
There really wasn't that much … I
mean, they, they quoted a pope a bunch.

00:05:46.612 --> 00:05:50.420
Um, but aside from that it was
all very … I don't think there

00:05:50.420 --> 00:05:54.269
was anything that a, that a mature
Protestant worldview would disagree with.

00:05:54.703 --> 00:06:00.947
Um, I think that, that, that we, we
should be striving to be excellent,

00:06:00.973 --> 00:06:04.046
to be people that, that are leaders
in our community, and that's basically

00:06:04.046 --> 00:06:04.659
what they were talking about.

00:06:04.921 --> 00:06:08.224
But, but, you know, he also told
this interesting story about his,

00:06:08.224 --> 00:06:12.917
uh, his maternal grandfather, uh,
Prince Karl Loewenstein, w- and I'm

00:06:12.917 --> 00:06:14.574
pronouncing that badly I think probably.

00:06:14.910 --> 00:06:20.697
Um, and, and I, I'm not gonna tell, retell
the story, but, but, but basically the,

00:06:20.700 --> 00:06:27.425
the people, the people that belonged
to Prince Karl believed that the,

00:06:27.437 --> 00:06:28.888
their prince would take care of them.

00:06:28.889 --> 00:06:32.240
So when World War happened, World
War I happened, and Bavaria, which is

00:06:32.240 --> 00:06:36.168
Southern Germany, gets, gets bombed
or gets attacked, uh, people flood

00:06:36.169 --> 00:06:40.804
into Austria, these refugees, and
they come to their prince, right?

00:06:40.807 --> 00:06:42.340
The prince who they belong to.

00:06:42.340 --> 00:06:46.406
And because they belong to him,
in some sense he belongs to them.

00:06:46.905 --> 00:06:51.268
And, you know, I think that, that we,
when we talk about nobility, when we

00:06:51.269 --> 00:06:55.699
talk about great houses, when we talk
about what it, what it means to, to

00:06:55.699 --> 00:06:59.215
rebuild the foundations of our society,
we need something like nobility.

00:06:59.440 --> 00:07:02.596
Nobility is a thing that caused,
in the people that were concerned

00:07:02.597 --> 00:07:06.125
with it, that belief that the
prince will take care of us, right?

00:07:06.196 --> 00:07:09.610
And nobility was doing what it
took to make that not a lie.

00:07:09.611 --> 00:07:12.368
And, and as Edward Habsburg
notes, that continued on for the

00:07:12.370 --> 00:07:13.350
rest of those people's lives.

00:07:13.366 --> 00:07:17.607
They stuck around and, and lived
around the prince, and created a, a

00:07:17.841 --> 00:07:19.981
undoubtedly a warm and rich community.

00:07:20.196 --> 00:07:23.116
You know, people talk about, well,
how do we form communities, right?

00:07:23.116 --> 00:07:26.116
And, and, and there's a bunch of kind
of community alchemy that you can engage

00:07:26.116 --> 00:07:29.593
in, and you, you arrange the houses in
this way, and you, you make sure that

00:07:29.593 --> 00:07:33.600
there's loans and credit available, and
you try to have communities of affinity.

00:07:33.600 --> 00:07:36.867
And, and, and I think that's all, that's
all well and good and worth doing.

00:07:37.010 --> 00:07:41.812
Um, but I just wanna take a moment
and point out that, that, guys, the

00:07:41.839 --> 00:07:46.400
overwhelming majority of communities
that have ever been created by humans

00:07:46.780 --> 00:07:51.419
have been created consistently around
one family that holds up the sky.

00:07:51.974 --> 00:07:55.663
There is one family that says,
"I'm gonna plant my flag here.

00:07:55.890 --> 00:08:00.384
I'm gonna be a person who keeps the laws
of hospitality, who shows, who keeps the

00:08:00.384 --> 00:08:05.153
faith, who is available to, to work on
things, who, who will help people who

00:08:05.174 --> 00:08:09.270
are on my side and, and, you know, be,
be a, a good friend and a terrible enemy.

00:08:09.468 --> 00:08:14.550
And, and I'm going to plant my flag here."
And then people gather around them, okay?

00:08:15.028 --> 00:08:18.296
Um, that is the, the bulk of the
way that we get, you know, the

00:08:18.297 --> 00:08:21.227
communities that we, we spend all this
time insisting that we want, right?

00:08:22.174 --> 00:08:25.004
And, you know, this, this
phenomenon is, is real.

00:08:25.017 --> 00:08:28.802
People will flee towards a man who will
feed them and find them work and still

00:08:28.804 --> 00:08:30.028
be there when they are old, right?

00:08:30.313 --> 00:08:33.711
But if you stop there, you will think
the noble is an insurance company.

00:08:34.262 --> 00:08:39.136
Um, and, and that's not actually
exactly what's going on.

00:08:39.398 --> 00:08:41.511
Why does a, why does a prince do this?

00:08:41.603 --> 00:08:44.230
Uh, why does a man faced with the
fail… I mean, you think about Carl

00:08:44.230 --> 00:08:51.588
Loewenstein, um- He, he was facing in
World War I the death of his culture.

00:08:51.755 --> 00:08:54.214
And, and, and, and I think
these people knew it.

00:08:54.953 --> 00:08:57.007
I think that they were
really, really smart.

00:08:57.391 --> 00:08:59.461
I think they were really,
really well-educated.

00:08:59.788 --> 00:09:03.621
I think they knew what was happening
in World War I. I think they understood

00:09:03.621 --> 00:09:07.318
that this was the beginning of a process
that, that had already basically started,

00:09:07.457 --> 00:09:12.039
and at the end of that process, they
weren't going to have the political

00:09:12.045 --> 00:09:14.206
power that they had previously enjoyed.

00:09:14.206 --> 00:09:16.535
They weren't going to be… They
weren't gonna receive tax revenues.

00:09:16.535 --> 00:09:20.202
Like, it was a fair bet by the time,
you know, all these refugees are

00:09:20.204 --> 00:09:27.260
streaming in that, you know, the the,
the rights and privileges of nobility

00:09:27.261 --> 00:09:30.772
that they had formerly enjoyed were,
were about to be cut off by, by

00:09:30.792 --> 00:09:32.624
modern, you know, Westphalian states.

00:09:32.871 --> 00:09:34.240
That was what was happening.

00:09:34.646 --> 00:09:35.748
So why does he do this?

00:09:36.114 --> 00:09:38.364
You know, he's facing the
extinguishment of his way of life,

00:09:38.366 --> 00:09:41.015
of his political power, of his
ability to benefit from the exchange.

00:09:41.019 --> 00:09:41.931
Why does he keep doing it?

00:09:42.456 --> 00:09:44.534
And why do the people
believe in, in him, you know?

00:09:44.895 --> 00:09:49.105
Um, th- there's a poem that I love
from, uh, uh, people debate where,

00:09:49.135 --> 00:09:52.246
when it was written, the 9th or 10th
century, something like that, called

00:09:52.266 --> 00:09:57.275
The Wanderer, where a man talks
about he's, he's mourning the loss

00:09:57.278 --> 00:10:01.331
of his lord and mourning the loss of
the household that lord supported.

00:10:01.491 --> 00:10:07.281
And he basically says, "You know, I, I, I
would give anything to be able to be there

00:10:07.309 --> 00:10:13.004
just for one more night, just one more
time to hear my master's voice," right?

00:10:13.016 --> 00:10:16.439
"To walk across that door to
this warm and welcoming home."

00:10:17.627 --> 00:10:18.947
And I think about that, right?

00:10:18.947 --> 00:10:21.869
You know, uh, you know, all, I think
most of the people on this call have

00:10:21.869 --> 00:10:23.306
heard at least some of my story.

00:10:23.306 --> 00:10:26.140
If you, if you, if you haven't, you
know, I have a, I have an episode

00:10:26.140 --> 00:10:27.744
with the, the great Josh Rashid.

00:10:27.750 --> 00:10:32.167
This is my first episode on his podcast,
um, where I talk about my family and

00:10:32.167 --> 00:10:34.513
the, the land and, and what we lost.

00:10:34.574 --> 00:10:38.671
And, you know, when I was listening to
this podcast and listening to Edward

00:10:38.672 --> 00:10:41.274
Haffster talk about his grandfather,
I have, you know, of course thought

00:10:41.275 --> 00:10:44.553
about my grandfather and, and I thought
about, about my grandfather's funeral.

00:10:46.208 --> 00:10:50.742
And I thought about the men who had
been my grandfather's hands, who had

00:10:50.743 --> 00:10:54.356
been, while they were working for my
grandfather, while they were on, you

00:10:54.357 --> 00:11:00.925
know, Tides Inn Ranch, um, honorable
men, men who had a place in the world,

00:11:00.981 --> 00:11:05.201
who belonged somewhere, and that the
place they belonged defended them

00:11:05.201 --> 00:11:08.931
and, and, and gave them a, a sense
of certainty, a sense of identity.

00:11:08.932 --> 00:11:10.615
They, they knew how to solve problems.

00:11:10.615 --> 00:11:15.648
They knew that ultimately there was
someone who was for them, right?

00:11:15.885 --> 00:11:20.135
There was someone who made it his
business that they be successful.

00:11:20.766 --> 00:11:23.895
Um, and I… You know, my, my, my
grandfather basically thought all this,

00:11:23.911 --> 00:11:26.986
this idea of, you know, you have… You,
you have people, and you, you get them

00:11:26.987 --> 00:11:29.973
for the 9:00 to 5:00 workday, and then
you send them out with a sum of money,

00:11:29.973 --> 00:11:32.865
and they're just supposed to solve all
their problems, their housing problems,

00:11:32.865 --> 00:11:36.209
their marital problems, all by themselves,
and he just thought that was utter folly.

00:11:36.833 --> 00:11:38.453
Um, and it is utter folly.

00:11:38.454 --> 00:11:41.341
You think about, you know, um, inflation.

00:11:42.207 --> 00:11:45.815
You think about who is best
placed to deal with inflation.

00:11:45.826 --> 00:11:47.612
How, how do you handle inflation?

00:11:48.188 --> 00:11:52.165
Um, well, you, you need to have
certain economies of scale.

00:11:52.165 --> 00:11:53.318
You need to store up.

00:11:53.485 --> 00:11:58.111
You need to, you know, kind of be planning
on s- you know, decades-long timescales.

00:11:58.123 --> 00:11:59.577
You need to be watching commodities.

00:11:59.582 --> 00:12:03.176
You need to be understanding just a lot of
the stuff that requires a life of leisure.

00:12:03.851 --> 00:12:08.602
Um, as a practical matter, you probably
can't do that as an ordinary person.

00:12:09.231 --> 00:12:12.292
You, you certainly can't do
that if you're a farmhand.

00:12:13.847 --> 00:12:16.940
That, that's not the type of people
that my grandfather hired, and so if

00:12:16.941 --> 00:12:20.472
he was going to just pay them a sum
of money and then expect them to go

00:12:20.473 --> 00:12:23.877
out into kind of an inflation-rich
environment and solve all the problems

00:12:23.877 --> 00:12:25.775
for themselves, that was not a good bet.

00:12:26.868 --> 00:12:30.238
It was not, it was not how that was
gonna play out, And, and, you know, I

00:12:30.238 --> 00:12:32.121
just, I think that we, we forget this.

00:12:32.121 --> 00:12:36.814
We, we want to pretend that this is
not how, this is not how it works.

00:12:37.207 --> 00:12:42.200
Um, and I remember them, hearing those
guys talk at my grandfather's funeral

00:12:42.202 --> 00:12:46.125
and, and the summation, and I, I heard
stories from several of them, was that

00:12:46.125 --> 00:12:50.326
basically after, after my grandfather
had lost the ability to employ them

00:12:50.326 --> 00:12:55.714
and after they had gone off, um, that
nothing had ever gone right for them.

00:12:56.084 --> 00:12:58.802
That they had never again
entered into a place.

00:12:58.803 --> 00:13:02.414
There was never… They were never
again offered a covenantal relationship

00:13:02.414 --> 00:13:05.918
where they belonged and they had
a place, and they were, you know,

00:13:06.147 --> 00:13:12.281
able to, um, to have any confidence
in the people that were above them.

00:13:12.306 --> 00:13:14.470
That, that they, that they
had any sense that there was

00:13:14.472 --> 00:13:16.716
someone who was for them, right?

00:13:17.567 --> 00:13:21.812
And I think that I, I, I, I want
us to understand the cost of

00:13:21.812 --> 00:13:23.559
what we have done in modernity.

00:13:23.559 --> 00:13:25.980
And in modernity you have systems, right?

00:13:25.981 --> 00:13:29.459
And, and, and, and the whole point of
systems is that you have rights, and you

00:13:29.463 --> 00:13:33.731
go to the bureaucrats who are supposed
to be these neutral, impartial arbiters

00:13:33.749 --> 00:13:37.304
of a, of a fair or basically fair system.

00:13:37.492 --> 00:13:40.691
And, and so long as you get, you
know, your rights… There's this

00:13:40.692 --> 00:13:47.532
famous scene, um, from a, from a,
a, a play called Fences, um, that's,

00:13:47.546 --> 00:13:50.203
that's, uh, several African Americans.

00:13:50.332 --> 00:13:54.332
Denzel Washington has a version where
he plays in Fences and I think, um, the,

00:13:54.342 --> 00:14:00.289
the, the guy who was the voice of, um,
of, um, Mufasa and, uh, and Darth Vader,

00:14:00.631 --> 00:14:03.679
uh, that, that great actor whose name
is escaping me, he also played, he has a

00:14:03.680 --> 00:14:05.593
version of, of, of him playing in Fences.

00:14:05.594 --> 00:14:09.561
And there's, there's this scene where
this man, um, this African American

00:14:09.562 --> 00:14:15.144
man who's, for whom life has not gone
terribly well, is talking to his son,

00:14:15.145 --> 00:14:21.430
and he's telling his son kind of the,
the, the fundamental way, um, that,

00:14:22.293 --> 00:14:23.993
that he needs to operate in the world.

00:14:24.338 --> 00:14:28.638
And he teaches his son in this
scene that it doesn't really

00:14:28.638 --> 00:14:30.372
matter if people like you.

00:14:30.397 --> 00:14:34.746
It doesn't matter if they, if
they have,   Affection for you.

00:14:34.746 --> 00:14:37.736
It doesn't really even
matter, if you belong to them.

00:14:38.299 --> 00:14:40.608
What matters is that you
get what you're owed.

00:14:41.010 --> 00:14:46.140
That if you do work, you receive your
pay, and there, there, there isn't

00:14:46.145 --> 00:14:50.494
supposed to be any kind of interaction
on, on, on an effective level, right?

00:14:51.285 --> 00:14:54.918
And he frames fatherhood in, in
explicitly economic terms, right?

00:14:54.918 --> 00:14:59.291
That he's gonna provide for his son, and
that's all that his son should ask of him.

00:15:00.137 --> 00:15:03.745
And I think that, that there's, there's
a very real sense, I, I think that's

00:15:03.745 --> 00:15:07.356
a true telling, and not, not, not just
a true telling, I think that's a true

00:15:07.359 --> 00:15:12.948
telling of, of the optimal strategy
for many people living in our, our

00:15:12.956 --> 00:15:17.935
big modernistic systems in the last,
you know, 50, 75 to 100 years, right?

00:15:17.936 --> 00:15:22.169
Especially people that are coming up from
nothing, that, that, that don't have any

00:15:22.169 --> 00:15:27.070
wealth, that don't have the ability to,
to establish any, any barriers, any moats

00:15:27.104 --> 00:15:29.142
against the oncoming tide of modernity.

00:15:29.566 --> 00:15:30.402
That's what you have to do.

00:15:30.402 --> 00:15:33.092
You have to just kind of always be
tracking your rights, and you gotta

00:15:33.094 --> 00:15:35.968
go, and you gotta insist that you
get your rights, and if you're paid,

00:15:36.307 --> 00:15:38.663
you know, what you should be, then,
then it'll all work out, right?

00:15:39.010 --> 00:15:43.158
and if that doesn't work out, then
we need to upend the whole system to

00:15:43.158 --> 00:15:47.348
get more rights for everyone, 'cause
the only guarantor, the only patron,

00:15:47.349 --> 00:15:52.246
the only granter of rights, the only
thing that you can belong to, the

00:15:52.259 --> 00:15:57.051
thing that ul- in some sense ultimately
owns you, is the state, right?

00:15:57.376 --> 00:16:01.114
And that's the way that we work,
That's why it's good advice, this

00:16:01.114 --> 00:16:04.366
advice that Denzel Washington gives
his, you know, his son in Fences.

00:16:05.213 --> 00:16:06.982
And man, what a thing.

00:16:06.982 --> 00:16:08.925
I, I, I think about that.

00:16:09.404 --> 00:16:10.916
I think about that from time to time.

00:16:10.916 --> 00:16:17.662
I think about what a different
frame that is from how people lived

00:16:17.872 --> 00:16:19.476
through most of history, right?

00:16:19.477 --> 00:16:23.318
Certainly how the West was composed, you
know, from, you know, the 10th century

00:16:23.320 --> 00:16:25.061
all the way up to, to World War I.

00:16:25.131 --> 00:16:26.601
And again, and it endured.

00:16:26.896 --> 00:16:28.860
Like this is, this is the
thing that I wanna tell people.

00:16:28.863 --> 00:16:33.137
These, these principles of, of household,
of, of what it means to be a landowner and

00:16:33.138 --> 00:16:37.524
a landowner's wife, which are, which are
the principles of nobility,  They endured

00:16:38.088 --> 00:16:42.169
up until, you know, um, in my family,
up until the, the early '90s, right?

00:16:42.170 --> 00:16:46.007
When we finally lost our land, um, or
lost the ability to operate, right?

00:16:46.729 --> 00:16:49.561
It's we moderns who are
an aberration, right?

00:16:49.561 --> 00:16:53.894
This, this idea of, well, all that
I have is a set of kind of abstract

00:16:53.894 --> 00:16:57.819
rights which I can get from any
interchangeable government office.

00:16:57.820 --> 00:17:02.341
They all have to give me my rights and,
you know, maybe there's, we, there's

00:17:02.341 --> 00:17:05.693
some sense in which I, I, I, I have
to kind of work with an employer.

00:17:05.958 --> 00:17:10.620
But as much as possible, we're gonna try
to also make the employers these neutral

00:17:10.743 --> 00:17:15.929
just kind of money-vending institutions
where I give you a, a one cog of labor

00:17:15.931 --> 00:17:20.042
and, and that, that results in me being
given one unit of money, and this is

00:17:20.042 --> 00:17:22.027
supposed to work out for me, right?

00:17:22.027 --> 00:17:23.152
This is supposed to work out for everyone.

00:17:23.164 --> 00:17:27.276
And if it doesn't, again, we've gotta,
we've gotta flip the whole, the whole

00:17:27.390 --> 00:17:29.604
system and grant everyone more rights.

00:17:29.606 --> 00:17:31.803
And of course, we're kind of coming
to the end of that process, 'cause

00:17:31.808 --> 00:17:35.250
for a while we were really rich, and
so we just kind of gave ev- anytime

00:17:35.252 --> 00:17:38.803
somebody put their hand up, you know,
and increasingly smaller minorities

00:17:39.005 --> 00:17:41.327
put their hand up and said, "Well, we
want this, and, well, we want this."

00:17:41.327 --> 00:17:45.749
And we go, "Okay, well, we just,
let's just redesign everything and

00:17:45.749 --> 00:17:53.054
burden everyone so that you can have
your rights everywhere." Instead

00:17:53.127 --> 00:17:57.427
of saying, you know Well, what if
we had people that were for you?

00:17:57.435 --> 00:17:59.427
What if you belonged to someone?

00:17:59.439 --> 00:18:04.191
What if there was a place for
you where you had a certain level

00:18:04.232 --> 00:18:07.573
of, of ability to be treated in
the way that you've been treated?

00:18:07.708 --> 00:18:09.682
Now, of course, if you did that Right?

00:18:10.079 --> 00:18:15.187
Then the, the, uh, the cultural sets,
you'd j- you'd sort of be starting

00:18:15.188 --> 00:18:18.277
a competition between cultural sets,
and the cultural sets that were

00:18:18.384 --> 00:18:23.010
incredibly toxic and destructive
would immediately collapse, right?

00:18:23.011 --> 00:18:27.562
And the cultural sets that, that, that
created, um, you know, health and, and

00:18:27.562 --> 00:18:32.511
wealth and prosperity and, and, and
beauty and order and children, those

00:18:32.513 --> 00:18:35.717
would all, would all thrive, and they'd
be able to keep their children, right?

00:18:36.199 --> 00:18:38.333
Like, that's, that's what
would immediately happen.

00:18:38.679 --> 00:18:40.126
But of course, we, we, we can't do that.

00:18:41.021 --> 00:18:43.966
But, but it's, it's, it's we
moderns that are the aberration.

00:18:44.476 --> 00:18:46.635
Like, I, I, I want us to say that.

00:18:46.635 --> 00:18:50.067
I think, I think we need to, we
need to understand that, that.

00:18:50.575 --> 00:18:53.528
Um, so it, you know, and then I was
in a, in a group chat, an illustrious

00:18:53.544 --> 00:18:58.212
group chat, um, and, and someone
asked, well, why modern people are

00:18:58.213 --> 00:19:01.768
so offended by the idea of using your
money to create more power, right?

00:19:01.768 --> 00:19:04.252
And, you know, this, this kind of,
this background assumption, the

00:19:04.254 --> 00:19:08.613
minute you say more power, that people
say, hear domination or they hear,

00:19:08.831 --> 00:19:10.492
you know, a benefits plan, right?

00:19:10.566 --> 00:19:13.422
Um, the, the, the, the, there's,
there's really this, this,

00:19:13.434 --> 00:19:14.616
there's only two things, right?

00:19:14.686 --> 00:19:18.766
Somebody can, who has power can,
um, must be like an evil domineering

00:19:18.769 --> 00:19:21.753
person, or they must just be like
a piggy bank that I can go to.

00:19:21.754 --> 00:19:25.835
We were having this discussion in one of
the exit groups of, well, there's this

00:19:25.841 --> 00:19:30.624
attitude of, well, if you, if, if you show
any nepotism at all, if you preference

00:19:30.626 --> 00:19:34.956
your own in any way, well, then you have
to extend that to everyone who knows you.

00:19:35.216 --> 00:19:36.864
which is just not true, right?

00:19:37.188 --> 00:19:40.668
Um, and, and you're not allowed to look
at whether or not, uh, somebody is loyal

00:19:40.668 --> 00:19:42.791
to you, which is also not true, okay?

00:19:42.816 --> 00:19:44.287
And, and not sane.

00:19:44.403 --> 00:19:48.826
Like, these are, these are
impossible standards, yeah?

00:19:49.096 --> 00:19:52.821
so I, and, and I think, you know,
the, the, the main reason is this.

00:19:52.875 --> 00:19:58.152
Uh, using money to acquire power probably
cashes out as, as mass patronage, right?

00:19:58.401 --> 00:20:02.629
So mass patronage is this idea of
you got, you, you got patron who's a

00:20:02.629 --> 00:20:06.340
patron for a larger number of people,
and those people belong to you.

00:20:06.341 --> 00:20:12.399
And again, whenever people belong to you,
you belong to them in some sense, who

00:20:12.399 --> 00:20:13.906
will show up, they'll have expectations.

00:20:13.911 --> 00:20:18.290
And, and I think a lot of our, a lot
of our modern elites, um, they don't

00:20:18.290 --> 00:20:20.135
want, they don't want expectations.

00:20:20.187 --> 00:20:22.982
They don't want people to show up
and, and make demands on them, right?

00:20:22.982 --> 00:20:28.209
I mean, uh, you know, I, I, number
one, most, most, uh, most people,

00:20:28.216 --> 00:20:31.001
most, uh, rich people are not set
up from that, for that from, from

00:20:31.004 --> 00:20:32.349
like a liquidity perspective.

00:20:32.364 --> 00:20:35.790
Like when you, when you actually, if,
if, if you take those, those obligations

00:20:35.795 --> 00:20:39.013
seriously and kind of reduce them to
financial things, they, they're basically

00:20:39.015 --> 00:20:43.211
a pension plan, and pension plans have
been really, really hard to keep solvent

00:20:43.211 --> 00:20:46.906
for the last, you know, fifty, fifty,
sixty years, um, to the point where no

00:20:46.906 --> 00:20:48.369
one, no one does them anymore, right?

00:20:48.379 --> 00:20:52.258
Everyone has their kind of individual
401, or they don't do pension plans

00:20:52.258 --> 00:20:53.750
that are actually tied to an employer.

00:20:54.046 --> 00:20:58.954
And that's, you know… But, and, and even
this, like, the, the problem here is that,

00:20:58.973 --> 00:21:04.577
that this is still viewing the prince,
viewing the noble as, as a one-to-one

00:21:04.588 --> 00:21:06.358
replacement for an insurance company.

00:21:06.547 --> 00:21:10.635
And, and, and what I wanna say
to you is something much more

00:21:10.635 --> 00:21:13.714
important was going on, right?

00:21:14.286 --> 00:21:18.784
Have you ever thought about, like,
why, why the other retainers of

00:21:18.784 --> 00:21:22.171
the Habsburgs didn't, like, get
upset when this… Uh, well, it

00:21:22.171 --> 00:21:23.265
would be the Lowenstein, I suppose.

00:21:23.525 --> 00:21:27.079
Uh, why, why they, why the, the other,
the other retainers of this prince didn't

00:21:27.080 --> 00:21:29.351
get upset when he rescues his people?

00:21:29.442 --> 00:21:31.403
And, and there's this sense, I think
people are, "Well, if the prince

00:21:31.410 --> 00:21:33.636
takes care of them, then he'll
take care of me," which is good.

00:21:33.916 --> 00:21:36.254
But it's, it's not, that's not complete.

00:21:36.257 --> 00:21:37.839
That's not really what's going on.

00:21:38.075 --> 00:21:42.670
there, there… If, if you, if you look
at this and you think, "Oh, well, all of

00:21:42.670 --> 00:21:46.302
this talk about honor and all of this talk
about glory, this is just some kind of,

00:21:46.302 --> 00:21:51.721
like, psychological delusion," you, you're
missing, you're missing the whole thing.

00:21:52.527 --> 00:21:56.813
And, and, and, and, and, and what I wanna
point out, like, the, the… If, if, if

00:21:56.839 --> 00:22:00.940
glory and honor and all of this talk,
if that doesn't matter, if that doesn't

00:22:00.946 --> 00:22:05.808
cash out to something real, well, then
no one would be a noble ever, right?

00:22:05.832 --> 00:22:07.442
Like, you would refuse this office.

00:22:07.486 --> 00:22:09.095
Everyone would refuse this office.

00:22:09.400 --> 00:22:12.276
And they would have refused
it back in the day, okay?

00:22:12.276 --> 00:22:16.017
If it was just a financial,
exchange, 'cause it's not a, it's

00:22:16.018 --> 00:22:20.196
not… The, the, the, the financial
piece is, is, is hard, right?

00:22:20.208 --> 00:22:23.891
That's, that's why these people kind of
required constant government infusions

00:22:23.893 --> 00:22:25.905
of cash to keep them going, right?

00:22:26.079 --> 00:22:29.395
That's why they got tax revenues
because the thing that they were doing

00:22:29.396 --> 00:22:32.384
was often not financially viable.

00:22:32.385 --> 00:22:35.130
They would get into a position, you
know, in the, even in, like, the British

00:22:35.131 --> 00:22:38.334
context, there's a lot of evidence
that the British government was, was

00:22:38.342 --> 00:22:43.435
kind of creating these, these, these
kiddie pools where people could, these,

00:22:43.445 --> 00:22:46.643
these new aristocrats, these young
aristocrats could learn how to engage

00:22:46.665 --> 00:22:49.961
in this kind of, this financial back
and forth that they wanted, right?

00:22:50.401 --> 00:22:52.177
So anyway, back to the, the group chat.

00:22:52.677 --> 00:22:56.488
So I, I talked about three barriers,
Uh, why the, the, the mean modern

00:22:56.488 --> 00:22:59.824
billionaires are, are not interested
in, in, in doing mass patronage.

00:23:00.034 --> 00:23:02.964
Um, and the first is, is
that the rainy day fund.

00:23:03.254 --> 00:23:06.352
Uh, the second is that you have to be
set up to, to benefit from their labor.

00:23:06.353 --> 00:23:09.288
And then the third is, is this, this
concept of representative glory.

00:23:09.330 --> 00:23:13.420
So the rainy day fund, um, basically you
have to think about every person you take

00:23:13.420 --> 00:23:15.455
on as a retainer is a liability, right?

00:23:15.498 --> 00:23:19.466
There, there is a potential that they
could show up and demand something

00:23:19.466 --> 00:23:21.495
from you and your honor, right?

00:23:21.507 --> 00:23:27.079
The, the kind of relationship that you've
entered into would require you to extend

00:23:27.367 --> 00:23:32.776
money, to, to extend resources, to, to
take care of them, to keep them hale and

00:23:32.778 --> 00:23:36.203
whole and, and well fed and clothed, and
to, to, to make sure that there's some

00:23:36.210 --> 00:23:38.712
minimum guarantee of options, right?

00:23:38.925 --> 00:23:41.166
Um, or sorry, excuse me,
of outcomes for them.

00:23:41.458 --> 00:23:45.187
you know, if you're trying to solve that
with, with classic liquidity, that's,

00:23:45.248 --> 00:23:46.896
that's a really hard pension problem.

00:23:47.174 --> 00:23:50.484
now I had a guy named Mike
Faulkner on, on the podcast.

00:23:50.566 --> 00:23:53.278
Uh, Mike is really good at really
difficult pension problems.

00:23:53.278 --> 00:23:56.828
So there, there, there is, there
are still ways of solving that.

00:23:57.036 --> 00:23:59.734
But, but I'll note that, you know, the
cheapest way to do that is to acquire

00:23:59.735 --> 00:24:03.379
real property, to carefully manage the
liquidity and just kind of have a bunch

00:24:03.380 --> 00:24:07.145
of shovel-ready jobs so that when people
show up, you can put them to work.

00:24:07.299 --> 00:24:11.417
You can receive maybe not a lot of
benefit, but some marginal benefit

00:24:11.574 --> 00:24:15.225
more than the cost of housing them and
feeding them and clothing them, okay?

00:24:15.626 --> 00:24:19.563
and, and with a little bit of thought and,
and certainly at the scale of, of, of my

00:24:19.565 --> 00:24:23.998
grandfather's ranch, three hundred, you
know, acres or so, that was very doable.

00:24:24.133 --> 00:24:28.615
Like it was, it was, if the ranch
was running, we definitely could keep

00:24:28.623 --> 00:24:31.803
people going, Um, the second thing is,
is that you, you have to, you know,

00:24:31.808 --> 00:24:33.553
be set up to, to receive the work.

00:24:33.564 --> 00:24:36.442
You have to be set up to benefit
from people that, that want to

00:24:36.444 --> 00:24:37.729
go where you tell them to go.

00:24:38.079 --> 00:24:41.078
Um, and, and, and I'll acknowledge
that's not always straightforward.

00:24:41.388 --> 00:24:45.283
Um, that it is true that, that most
people are gonna complain, especially,

00:24:45.634 --> 00:24:49.766
well There's a lot of bad behavior that
goes on in these, in these contexts.

00:24:49.766 --> 00:24:53.708
I think that, that a lot of
wealthy people, they imbibe a lot

00:24:53.709 --> 00:24:57.216
of content, uh, that's kinda like
the, the meritocracy content.

00:24:57.238 --> 00:25:01.516
Y- Johan Kurtz did a series on this
a year, maybe two years ago now, the,

00:25:01.527 --> 00:25:05.081
his, his meritocracy series, where he
tries- talks about how toxic it is to

00:25:05.082 --> 00:25:06.949
see yourself as a self-made person.

00:25:07.384 --> 00:25:09.839
Um, but for a lot of these guys, a lot
of these wealthy guys, that's like a

00:25:09.839 --> 00:25:12.246
really core part of their identity.

00:25:12.752 --> 00:25:17.010
Um, it's, it's a big… It's, it's the
thing that, that made them who they are.

00:25:17.011 --> 00:25:21.020
They, they, they believe very intensely
that they, they're self-made, that they

00:25:21.020 --> 00:25:25.039
did this for themselves, to themselves,
and, and so they shouldn't have to, uh…

00:25:25.100 --> 00:25:27.079
And, and so should everyone else, right?

00:25:27.310 --> 00:25:30.508
and, and so they, they kind
of, they, they, they take on

00:25:30.511 --> 00:25:32.091
a lot of, a lot of content.

00:25:32.114 --> 00:25:36.100
And basically, my, my experience, what,
what I, what I've seen happen is if,

00:25:36.140 --> 00:25:40.530
if they stop listening to that kind of
content and start listening to guys like

00:25:40.531 --> 00:25:44.042
Johan, and now, you know, Evan Amato,
and, and, and they start thinking about,

00:25:44.339 --> 00:25:46.686
"How can I be a more noble person?"

00:25:46.954 --> 00:25:50.614
Um, or, or even, you know, they just kind
of get, get really into, into religion.

00:25:50.614 --> 00:25:51.541
They get into their faith.

00:25:51.556 --> 00:25:52.987
They, they get baptized.

00:25:53.006 --> 00:25:54.478
They start showing generosity.

00:25:54.704 --> 00:25:57.109
Um, in a couple weeks we're
gonna have, um, a gentleman named

00:25:57.126 --> 00:25:58.485
Eric Dunavant come on the show.

00:25:58.735 --> 00:26:02.784
Um, Eric's a, a friend of mine and a
financial advisor, and he has, he's done a

00:26:02.784 --> 00:26:09.852
really good job of helping people, um, get
their- their philanthropic affair set up.

00:26:09.853 --> 00:26:13.776
So he's really good at coming into a high
net worth family and helping that family

00:26:13.777 --> 00:26:18.108
see, "Hey, you would be better off if
you started giving a, a certain amount

00:26:18.110 --> 00:26:22.338
of your money away. Um, here's… there's
some tax benefits to it." But just it

00:26:22.351 --> 00:26:25.505
helps you, it helps your family mature.

00:26:25.505 --> 00:26:29.585
It helps your family to be able
to, uh, engage with reality,

00:26:29.585 --> 00:26:30.566
engage with each other.

00:26:30.780 --> 00:26:33.330
Um, and there's a lot of, there's a
lot of wealthy kids that, that have

00:26:33.331 --> 00:26:37.312
imbibed, you know, socialism and
communism from their educational system,

00:26:37.324 --> 00:26:40.161
which their parents sent them to and
paid for, but that's another issue.

00:26:40.541 --> 00:26:43.611
Um, and, and so they, they, their kind
of default is, "Well, my parents are

00:26:43.611 --> 00:26:45.792
just basically evil or borderline evil."

00:26:46.142 --> 00:26:50.385
And setting up a, a philanthropic board,
having standards and saying, "Hey, we're

00:26:50.385 --> 00:26:53.450
gonna go out, we're gonna give money
away," and, and actually just letting

00:26:53.450 --> 00:26:55.405
the kids see how that, how that goes.

00:26:55.668 --> 00:26:56.647
Um, right?

00:26:56.719 --> 00:26:58.849
Uh, many, many times actually
giving people money does

00:26:58.849 --> 00:26:59.949
not solve their problems.

00:26:59.990 --> 00:27:02.738
And, and allowing a, a
young child from a…

00:27:02.748 --> 00:27:06.147
or not a young child, these are probably
teenagers or 20-somethings, right?

00:27:06.183 --> 00:27:10.895
Allowing them to experience that,
"Hey, I, I was a patron, I gave

00:27:10.895 --> 00:27:14.072
you money, and it did not solve
the problem. In fact, sometimes

00:27:14.074 --> 00:27:15.620
it made the problem worse," right?

00:27:15.620 --> 00:27:17.081
You were happy to get the money, right?

00:27:17.081 --> 00:27:19.327
The, the, the beneficiaries are
almost always happy to get the money.

00:27:19.673 --> 00:27:23.234
Um, but you know, it's, it's not
in fact the case that if we just

00:27:23.234 --> 00:27:27.362
dispersed our assets that there would
be this immediate and unquestioned,

00:27:27.578 --> 00:27:30.196
you know, ripple of blessing that
would, that would go around the world.

00:27:30.196 --> 00:27:32.579
You can't just sort of pay
it forward infinitely, right?

00:27:33.092 --> 00:27:37.783
Um, and having, you know, philanthropic
ventures really teaches that.

00:27:37.797 --> 00:27:40.360
It just kinda, it teaches the, the
kids that their families are not evil.

00:27:40.370 --> 00:27:42.557
And so… And it's a
very doable thing, right?

00:27:42.563 --> 00:27:45.863
For any family of means, you could
probably spin up some kind of a

00:27:45.866 --> 00:27:48.996
philanthropic, uh, thing, start giving
out grants and, and, and involve

00:27:48.996 --> 00:27:52.575
your kids and it's, it, there's just
enormous family benefits for it.

00:27:52.692 --> 00:27:52.966
Okay?

00:27:53.309 --> 00:27:56.608
Um, and, and, and that's kind of
like a, a lesser version or a, a, a

00:27:56.614 --> 00:28:00.372
starter version of, of what Johann
talks about with, with thousand-year

00:28:00.373 --> 00:28:01.802
families and legacy families, okay?

00:28:02.323 --> 00:28:07.006
But I really think that, the, the,
the serious barrier is, is this

00:28:07.013 --> 00:28:10.390
concept of glory, Because this is
the thing that we have forgotten.

00:28:10.393 --> 00:28:13.184
This is the, this is the
central piece, right?

00:28:13.190 --> 00:28:18.212
For a thousand years, Christendom
talks about glory and honor constantly.

00:28:19.259 --> 00:28:20.250
They focus on it.

00:28:20.250 --> 00:28:21.479
They write poems about it.

00:28:21.479 --> 00:28:23.068
They… their art is about it.

00:28:23.497 --> 00:28:27.540
and you know, we moderns, we kinda
look back at that and go, "Wow, I

00:28:27.540 --> 00:28:30.776
mean, were they just all brainwashed?
Like, what was going on there?"

00:28:31.259 --> 00:28:34.225
And, and I think what, what
retainers really want is for

00:28:34.226 --> 00:28:36.187
their Lord to be glorious, right?

00:28:36.329 --> 00:28:38.335
You think about, you think about life.

00:28:38.358 --> 00:28:42.164
You think about all of the challenges
that you face, and you think about,

00:28:42.164 --> 00:28:47.351
man I wish that I could be… I
wish that I could participate.

00:28:47.351 --> 00:28:51.405
I, I… Now, obviously we'd like to be
the people, we'd like to be the ideals,

00:28:51.406 --> 00:28:55.113
we'd like to be the people that are
being super virtuous and super glorious.

00:28:55.483 --> 00:29:00.914
but if we can have a relationship with
someone who is excellent, who is virtuous,

00:29:01.080 --> 00:29:04.994
and who is ours, who we have the right…
This is what, really what belonging means.

00:29:05.282 --> 00:29:05.515
Okay?

00:29:05.696 --> 00:29:10.068
Belonging means when you do
something glorious, I get

00:29:10.069 --> 00:29:11.459
a little bit of that glory.

00:29:12.234 --> 00:29:17.338
And so I wanna build you up so
that you can be excellent, right?

00:29:17.338 --> 00:29:20.077
I mean, and, and, and I think we, we've
broken this down at every level, right?

00:29:20.077 --> 00:29:23.625
The Bible talks about that, you know,
the, the, the glory of man is his wife,

00:29:23.625 --> 00:29:27.100
and the glory of the woman is her hair
and, you know, we, we, uh, the, there's,

00:29:27.105 --> 00:29:30.351
there's constant references in the
ancient world to, you know, the, the,

00:29:30.362 --> 00:29:32.653
the glory of a father is his son, right?

00:29:32.824 --> 00:29:35.814
This, this modern idea that we
have, you know, we have a real

00:29:35.814 --> 00:29:40.821
problem in modernity of parents
competing with their children, right?

00:29:40.913 --> 00:29:44.546
Of, of, of parents being, of women
being mad that their daughters are

00:29:44.546 --> 00:29:48.212
beautiful, of men being mad that
their sons are successful, right?

00:29:48.337 --> 00:29:51.454
Certainly, that their sons are more
successful than they are, right?

00:29:52.176 --> 00:29:57.964
And that was just not a thing
in the ancient world because the

00:29:57.965 --> 00:30:02.633
glory of the son always rebounded
to the glory of the father, right?

00:30:03.419 --> 00:30:04.986
Actually, you know, it's
interesting 'cause it was, that

00:30:04.987 --> 00:30:05.866
was less true of the women.

00:30:05.866 --> 00:30:08.351
They did sometimes have problems
with mothers being jealous

00:30:08.352 --> 00:30:09.288
of their daughters' beauty.

00:30:10.014 --> 00:30:12.298
Something a little, little
deep-coded in there, I suppose.

00:30:13.046 --> 00:30:17.724
But when people believed, hey, there,
there is glory and there is belonging,

00:30:17.724 --> 00:30:21.329
and we can, we can have this, this
sense of covenantal unity so that what

00:30:21.330 --> 00:30:24.797
you do benefits and blesses me, right?

00:30:24.820 --> 00:30:29.189
That, that we're doing as a, as a
house, a great and glorious thing.

00:30:29.189 --> 00:30:33.831
You know, a, a, a while back, my
household pulled somebody out of a,

00:30:33.911 --> 00:30:39.325
of a pretty rough situation and showed
them hospitality, and I sent two of the

00:30:39.327 --> 00:30:44.112
men of my household out on a, like a
three-day, you know, journey, and they

00:30:44.114 --> 00:30:47.946
took a couple of trucks and showed up
at a place and loaded a family's things

00:30:47.947 --> 00:30:52.391
into the back and, and, and, and, and
took them away from a, from a situation

00:30:52.391 --> 00:30:53.736
that was a pretty hard situation.

00:30:54.826 --> 00:30:57.966
And my guys were excited about that.

00:30:58.028 --> 00:31:02.387
They were excited to do… Now, I mean,
a year earlier I'd done for those people

00:31:02.678 --> 00:31:04.081
what, what they were doing for this guy.

00:31:04.423 --> 00:31:06.875
but they were excited to
participate and they were excited

00:31:06.875 --> 00:31:09.073
to, to go on this quest, right?

00:31:09.117 --> 00:31:13.612
To show hospitality, to bring someone,
you know, out of a, out of a dark

00:31:13.613 --> 00:31:16.533
situation, 'cause that was the right
thing to do, and I think we all know

00:31:16.566 --> 00:31:17.849
that that was the right thing to do.

00:31:18.189 --> 00:31:21.321
But everyone has these conversations
and they hear about someone that's,

00:31:21.330 --> 00:31:25.156
that's hurting or in trouble or
whatever, and they go, "Oh, man, that

00:31:25.159 --> 00:31:29.262
sucks. That's so terrible. That's
sad." And then they don't do anything

00:31:29.262 --> 00:31:31.300
about it because they can't, right?

00:31:31.436 --> 00:31:34.385
Their house is not set
up to receive people.

00:31:34.506 --> 00:31:36.799
They are not set up to…

00:31:36.835 --> 00:31:40.750
And, and, and I think, I think in, in
a certain sense, I mean, maybe we'll,

00:31:40.799 --> 00:31:44.492
at some point, maybe AI will usher in
this, this, this infinite prosperity

00:31:44.493 --> 00:31:47.592
and anyone who wills will, will
have the perfect replicator, right?

00:31:47.640 --> 00:31:49.163
People talk about the
Star Trek replicator.

00:31:49.619 --> 00:31:52.724
and so we'll just be able to help as
many people as we want infinitely.

00:31:53.103 --> 00:31:55.930
But historically and traditionally,
and I think we're, we're, we're coming

00:31:55.930 --> 00:31:59.649
to the point where we're bumping up
against these, these problems once

00:31:59.650 --> 00:32:05.564
again you need certain designated
people in your world, in your

00:32:05.573 --> 00:32:09.003
community, and, and, and, and they'll
just kind of arise naturally, right?

00:32:09.003 --> 00:32:12.327
They talk in, in, uh, in certain,
uh, Christian circles they talk about

00:32:12.328 --> 00:32:16.094
that, that elders are not appointed,
they are, they are recognized, right?

00:32:16.095 --> 00:32:19.235
If they're appointed, they're appointed
by God, and the church's job is to

00:32:19.236 --> 00:32:23.664
look around and see who it is that God
has already, has already appointed.

00:32:23.909 --> 00:32:26.929
And there should be signs, there should
be evidences of something, something

00:32:26.973 --> 00:32:30.999
unusual in this person or something,
something exceptional in their setup,

00:32:31.000 --> 00:32:34.077
in their money-making ability, in their
management ability, in the, the way

00:32:34.077 --> 00:32:38.265
that they, they run their house so that
they can engage in hospitality, so that

00:32:38.265 --> 00:32:42.902
they can fulfill these things, so that
they can keep the covenants, right?

00:32:43.159 --> 00:32:44.036
And this is the thing.

00:32:44.275 --> 00:32:44.963
This is the thing.

00:32:45.217 --> 00:32:49.619
you know, if, if you can step out of
the modernist egalitarian world, right?

00:32:49.621 --> 00:32:53.353
If you can step into a more traditional,
a more classical, a more biblical

00:32:53.705 --> 00:32:59.025
frame of mind, you don't have to be the
person that solves everything, right?

00:32:59.026 --> 00:33:01.900
You, you know, I, I … So, you
know, one of the, one of the things

00:33:01.901 --> 00:33:05.681
is I, I, I believe that Christian
schools are, are, are valid and,

00:33:05.723 --> 00:33:07.645
and, and, and allowed, right?

00:33:08.143 --> 00:33:11.983
I don't believe that every family has to
individually homeschool their children.

00:33:12.576 --> 00:33:16.590
Now, when you hand over your kids
to someone, you should … And

00:33:16.591 --> 00:33:19.348
then this, this is the, this is
where that becomes troublesome.

00:33:19.714 --> 00:33:23.655
you should make sure that the
person you're handing them over to

00:33:24.132 --> 00:33:26.826
understands what your goals are, right?

00:33:26.832 --> 00:33:30.592
'Cause, 'cause God is gonna come to you
at the end of your days and say, "Did

00:33:30.593 --> 00:33:33.656
you raise your children in the nurture
and admonition of the Lord?" Okay?

00:33:33.954 --> 00:33:36.776
And, and I don't believe, you know,
in, in, in God's providence, I don-

00:33:36.800 --> 00:33:40.604
I don't think that every family is
necessarily gonna have the skillset

00:33:40.620 --> 00:33:42.317
to homeschool their kids, right?

00:33:42.674 --> 00:33:46.912
But when you hand over your kids to i-
ideally to someone who has a remarkable

00:33:46.915 --> 00:33:51.558
gift, a 1 out of 50 or a 1 out of 100 gift
of teaching, and, and organization, and

00:33:51.741 --> 00:33:54.929
keeping things going, you need to make
sure that you're, you're … there's a

00:33:54.936 --> 00:33:58.481
covenantal alignment so that peop- that
that person that you're handing them over

00:33:58.482 --> 00:34:00.723
to says, "Hey, I'm going to respect this."

00:34:00.724 --> 00:34:02.185
You need that to be enforceable.

00:34:02.405 --> 00:34:05.700
You know, you, you need to have
some reasonable expectation that the

00:34:05.700 --> 00:34:10.576
person you're entrusting these hopes
of glory to is going to do the right

00:34:10.577 --> 00:34:14.622
thing, is going to, to … I- is, uh,
at the end of the day, the way this

00:34:14.622 --> 00:34:18.828
stuff cashes out is, is this person a
servant of the same God that you serve?

00:34:18.839 --> 00:34:22.193
That, that's, that's really where
it, it just kinda, kinda all goes.

00:34:22.473 --> 00:34:23.630
And that's what's missing.

00:34:24.093 --> 00:34:29.222
What's missing is an understanding
of, hey, what people really want

00:34:29.362 --> 00:34:30.732
is for their Lord to be glorious.

00:34:30.733 --> 00:34:32.939
That's why the money is not enough, right?

00:34:32.939 --> 00:34:35.171
And there, and there's some cultural,
like there's some, some status

00:34:35.177 --> 00:34:37.443
creation, some culture creation
things that go along with that.

00:34:37.715 --> 00:34:39.272
I've, I've, I've talked
about that in the past.

00:34:39.273 --> 00:34:40.878
I probably need to do
a public episode on it.

00:34:41.467 --> 00:34:47.679
if we can get this idea of, wow, what
people really want is to participate

00:34:47.680 --> 00:34:51.257
in something that is cov- that
is keeping its covenants, right?

00:34:51.257 --> 00:34:55.354
Where collectively this whole body of
people knows, hey, if somebody comes

00:34:55.354 --> 00:34:59.408
to me and asks for hospitality because
they're being, you know, persecuted,

00:34:59.574 --> 00:35:03.634
right, in the name of Christ, and
I've got some, some duty to help them,

00:35:03.987 --> 00:35:08.754
right, as a Christian, a- and I don't
personally have the resources, I have

00:35:08.755 --> 00:35:13.169
someone who I can go to who will find
the resources or who has the resources.

00:35:13.340 --> 00:35:17.891
And so my covenantal duty is met because
the person who came to me and said,

00:35:18.100 --> 00:35:22.145
"I have this need," I was able to say,
"We- I'm in covenant with somebody.

00:35:22.324 --> 00:35:26.000
They will take care of you." And,
a- and that means that I, I am

00:35:26.000 --> 00:35:27.440
not, I am not an oath breaker.

00:35:27.441 --> 00:35:29.183
I am not a covenant breaker, okay?

00:35:29.248 --> 00:35:32.206
That's the glory that we… And, and,
and now obviously there's somebody

00:35:32.207 --> 00:35:33.632
that's actually doing the thing.

00:35:33.642 --> 00:35:36.504
There's somebody that, that's actually
doing the, the great and glorious thing.

00:35:36.504 --> 00:35:38.907
I think, I think for a lot of
people our, our podcasters, our

00:35:38.920 --> 00:35:40.251
influencers are this for us, right?

00:35:40.252 --> 00:35:44.962
Well, I can't do this, but I follow
someone online who, you know, owns

00:35:44.963 --> 00:35:46.169
the libs or whatever it is, right?

00:35:46.855 --> 00:35:50.898
Um, I can't go to a school board, or
I won't go to a school board meeting,

00:35:51.097 --> 00:35:53.842
but I, I, I watch and I participate.

00:35:54.096 --> 00:35:56.768
and, and I think that's a…
I think there's something,

00:35:56.984 --> 00:35:58.008
there's something there.

00:35:58.065 --> 00:36:02.185
There's something deep there that
obviously can go wrong, okay?

00:36:02.390 --> 00:36:03.563
And we're gonna talk
about how it can go wrong.

00:36:03.968 --> 00:36:05.872
but there's something worthwhile
there, and that's really

00:36:05.872 --> 00:36:06.871
what everyone is looking for.

00:36:06.894 --> 00:36:08.435
That is what everyone is asking for.

00:36:08.860 --> 00:36:09.137
Okay?

00:36:09.157 --> 00:36:14.464
So if you think about your life in, in,
in a series of e- you know, economic

00:36:14.464 --> 00:36:18.443
exchanges, well, this doesn't, this
doesn't, this doesn't really work.

00:36:19.060 --> 00:36:23.797
But if you think of it as, hey, the
purpose of life is not… Like you have

00:36:23.800 --> 00:36:28.028
economic needs, but the purpose of life
is not just to survive or to, to have, to,

00:36:28.201 --> 00:36:29.998
to meet your, your, your economic goals.

00:36:30.177 --> 00:36:33.228
The purpose of life is to
participate in glory, right?

00:36:33.229 --> 00:36:36.515
The, the, the, uh, the Presbyterians
have this, this phrase from their

00:36:36.515 --> 00:36:41.385
catechism, um, you know, "The chief end
of man is to, uh, to enjoy, to enjoy

00:36:41.404 --> 00:36:43.905
God and glorify him forever," right?

00:36:44.623 --> 00:36:45.382
And I think that's real.

00:36:45.383 --> 00:36:47.722
I think that's, that's,
that's, that's right.

00:36:47.987 --> 00:36:52.599
And so if you can be, be, be connected
with something, if you can be

00:36:52.614 --> 00:36:57.372
participate with something, uh, that,
that allows you to, to have access

00:36:57.373 --> 00:37:00.378
to more glory, to be able to say,
"We fulfilled more of the covenant."

00:37:00.378 --> 00:37:03.631
You think about like imaging God, and we
talk about, you know, Christ, the, the

00:37:03.633 --> 00:37:06.384
marriage, husband and wife is an image
of Christ and the church, and we talk

00:37:06.384 --> 00:37:08.899
about how we have the image of God, right?

00:37:09.190 --> 00:37:14.116
Well, all human relationships are in
some way… Everything that humans

00:37:14.116 --> 00:37:17.979
do is imaging a piece of God, right?

00:37:18.565 --> 00:37:21.946
The church is supposed to image God in His
Heaven, you know, the, the, the, the, the,

00:37:22.149 --> 00:37:24.328
the hosts of Heaven as they praise God.

00:37:24.328 --> 00:37:26.982
We're, that, that's why we do choirs,
that's why we… And, and again, you

00:37:26.984 --> 00:37:28.339
can, you can take different positions.

00:37:28.669 --> 00:37:31.577
Um, but, but basically all of those
different positions on what church is,

00:37:31.587 --> 00:37:35.615
is, is a disagreement on what is the
most important pieces of God's nature

00:37:35.616 --> 00:37:39.617
that we should be reflecting and, and,
and creating in a given moment, okay?

00:37:39.766 --> 00:37:46.470
But everyone agrees there's some aspect
of God that we should be demonstrating

00:37:46.470 --> 00:37:51.032
or proving or, or being an example
of, and this is what glory is.

00:37:51.312 --> 00:37:55.269
Glory is imaging God in our world, okay?

00:37:56.222 --> 00:37:59.693
And I think that that's, that's
the function of the noble, right?

00:37:59.958 --> 00:38:03.114
Again, I don't think that the
noble is actually, just a, a

00:38:03.114 --> 00:38:07.463
one-to-one replacement of the, uh,
of the insurance company, right?

00:38:07.486 --> 00:38:10.049
The, the, the retainer does
not just want a pension.

00:38:10.563 --> 00:38:13.074
Um, he wants to participate
in a man who's being an ideal.

00:38:13.074 --> 00:38:14.477
And, and service, right?

00:38:14.836 --> 00:38:17.252
Is how he gets inside that glory, right?

00:38:17.253 --> 00:38:20.666
It's, it… Now he'll get, for his
service, he'll get taken care of, but,

00:38:20.693 --> 00:38:21.941
but why will he get taken care of?

00:38:21.942 --> 00:38:26.534
Why, why does Prince Lowenstein take
these people from Bavaria into his house

00:38:26.534 --> 00:38:28.393
and inconvenience everyone in his world?

00:38:28.787 --> 00:38:31.297
And why are the people that,
that, that are the locals, why

00:38:31.297 --> 00:38:32.921
are they happy that he does so?

00:38:33.595 --> 00:38:38.905
Because he is being a glorious Christian
prince, and it's good to see that.

00:38:39.494 --> 00:38:41.206
It's wonderful to see that, right?

00:38:41.533 --> 00:38:43.984
I think that a lot of the family stuff
that we struggle with, you know, I've

00:38:43.984 --> 00:38:48.792
talked about that, that I, that I've, I've
seen, um, very productive high-powered

00:38:48.794 --> 00:38:51.700
people who, uh, were uncles, right?

00:38:51.701 --> 00:38:54.030
And that was kind of the, the
primary way that they interacted

00:38:54.030 --> 00:38:57.120
with, with fertility was, well,
they didn't really have any kids.

00:38:57.120 --> 00:39:00.660
Many of them married later in life,
and so they had no children, or it

00:39:00.660 --> 00:39:01.911
just wasn't a priority for them.

00:39:02.170 --> 00:39:07.712
But family was super important to these
guys, and the way that that manifested in

00:39:07.712 --> 00:39:09.224
their life was they were a devoted uncle.

00:39:09.224 --> 00:39:10.427
They showed up at every Christmas.

00:39:10.428 --> 00:39:11.232
They gave gifts.

00:39:11.233 --> 00:39:13.041
They, they were a financial backstop.

00:39:13.049 --> 00:39:14.575
Sometimes they would pay for college.

00:39:14.828 --> 00:39:18.544
They had specialized, but they were
retaining this larger family structure,

00:39:18.804 --> 00:39:20.737
and they were participating in the glory.

00:39:20.737 --> 00:39:23.733
You know, a lot of, oftentimes, um, I, I
just kinda have this constant thing where

00:39:23.739 --> 00:39:26.957
when I tell people that I have seven kids,
they, they assume that I am, you know,

00:39:26.961 --> 00:39:31.238
some ogre who keeps his wife, you know,
under lock and key or whatever, barefoot

00:39:31.238 --> 00:39:33.926
and, you know, pregnant between the,
the, the bedroom and the, and the kitchen

00:39:33.926 --> 00:39:35.096
or something of this nature, right?

00:39:35.710 --> 00:39:41.648
And If I want to horribly offend a woman
who has basically accused me of that,

00:39:42.244 --> 00:39:48.721
then I will explain my wife's view, which
is, as far as I understand it, and honey,

00:39:48.721 --> 00:39:51.662
you can correct me in the Q&A if I've,
if I'm, if I'm gonna get this wrong,

00:39:52.132 --> 00:39:56.871
it's that the glory of, of, of a woman
is her children, and she wants as much

00:39:56.890 --> 00:39:58.980
glory as God is willing to give her.

00:39:59.745 --> 00:40:02.012
And that's why we have as many kids
as we have, and that's why we're

00:40:02.013 --> 00:40:08.382
gonna more kids if God permits,
because my wife wants more glory.

00:40:08.399 --> 00:40:10.303
And she is entitled to
that from me, right?

00:40:10.481 --> 00:40:12.617
Like, this is the thing that
everyone doesn't understand.

00:40:12.667 --> 00:40:17.890
All I want is to give my wife as
much glory as she wants, right?

00:40:18.149 --> 00:40:22.012
I want, I wanna do what I can, right?

00:40:22.368 --> 00:40:26.204
If, if, if money is the barrier, if
my wife says, "Hey, I want more glor-

00:40:26.221 --> 00:40:28.613
I wanna be more glorious," right?

00:40:28.832 --> 00:40:31.969
In, in, in, in her glory as a
woman- And the, and the reason

00:40:31.970 --> 00:40:33.235
why we can't do that is money.

00:40:33.252 --> 00:40:35.779
Well, boys, I'm gonna go out there
and I'm gonna get more money.

00:40:36.414 --> 00:40:36.806
Okay?

00:40:37.599 --> 00:40:39.169
I'm gonna figure out how to earn more.

00:40:39.617 --> 00:40:41.451
I'm gonna figure out
how to be more valuable.

00:40:41.451 --> 00:40:42.416
I'm gonna work harder.

00:40:42.416 --> 00:40:49.090
I'm g- I'm gonna do whatever I can do so
that we are, we are more glorious, right?

00:40:50.037 --> 00:40:53.193
And, and, you know, over time,
like I… Honestly, that was

00:40:53.193 --> 00:40:54.254
actually really hard for me.

00:40:54.990 --> 00:40:58.843
Like, everyone thinks that I'm, I'm just
this, you know, super far right person.

00:40:59.258 --> 00:41:00.655
That was really hard for me.

00:41:00.866 --> 00:41:04.207
Um, I knew what the right answer was
'cause I was, I was well-educated.

00:41:04.208 --> 00:41:08.265
I knew I could do the covenantal math and
say, "No, no, Greg, like, if you believe

00:41:08.266 --> 00:41:11.839
the things you say, you have to figure
out how to give your wife as many children

00:41:11.841 --> 00:41:15.514
as she wants." Especially when she's
ha- she has that attitude for it, right?

00:41:16.132 --> 00:41:17.484
but it was really hard.

00:41:17.770 --> 00:41:22.413
And then, you know, I, I work
with some brilliant, amazing

00:41:22.521 --> 00:41:26.313
people, people that I'm, I'm proud
to be associated with, right?

00:41:26.715 --> 00:41:30.513
Um, people that, that, that, that change
the world, that change people's lives,

00:41:30.513 --> 00:41:35.592
that, that rebuild marriages and, you
know, hold hospitals together and, and,

00:41:35.645 --> 00:41:39.400
and, you know, keep our world running
in a, in a dark and terrible time.

00:41:39.401 --> 00:41:43.054
You know, there's a family that I work
with that, there is an entire city

00:41:43.578 --> 00:41:48.053
that I'm convinced would be basically
Pottersville without their influence

00:41:48.056 --> 00:41:53.039
these past 20, 25 years, They have stood
in the gap, and they have made it happen.

00:41:53.276 --> 00:41:55.430
Many of them only had
two or three children.

00:41:55.844 --> 00:42:00.582
And w- without going into details, like
for many of these people that have big

00:42:00.591 --> 00:42:04.941
visions, that have great things, they
need, they, they need more children.

00:42:05.066 --> 00:42:06.414
They don't have enough children.

00:42:06.665 --> 00:42:11.485
And, and I, and I, and I witnessed
the frustration of patriarchs, right?

00:42:11.664 --> 00:42:17.384
Who didn't see the value in kids, but
also didn't, didn't, you know, have

00:42:17.384 --> 00:42:21.136
that conversation with their wife,
and now they're, they are coming

00:42:21.137 --> 00:42:25.051
to the point where their ability
to expand or their, sometimes even

00:42:25.052 --> 00:42:29.710
their ability to sustain the amazing
thing that they've done, right?

00:42:30.218 --> 00:42:33.896
Is in jeopardy, is under threat
because they don't have as many

00:42:33.903 --> 00:42:35.381
children as they could have.

00:42:35.848 --> 00:42:36.083
Right?

00:42:36.496 --> 00:42:37.761
And that's real, guys.

00:42:37.793 --> 00:42:41.289
And then I, and I remember, I remember
when that hit me one day as I, as

00:42:41.290 --> 00:42:45.346
I was kind of walking through a
family thing that, that ultimately

00:42:45.348 --> 00:42:49.617
cashed out to this guy was frustrated
that he didn't have another son.

00:42:49.769 --> 00:42:52.840
And so he was kind of going back and
forth between one of his daughters and

00:42:52.841 --> 00:42:58.042
this employee, and he was putting both
of them in a kind of a hard situation.

00:42:58.048 --> 00:43:00.685
And, and at a certain point I kinda
had to say, y- you know, "Sir,

00:43:00.728 --> 00:43:04.322
respectfully, why are you doing this?
Like, you're better than this. This is

00:43:04.324 --> 00:43:10.831
not how you behave." And what came out
of him was, was just a lot of stuff.

00:43:10.944 --> 00:43:14.694
And as I was kind of parsing that
walking away, I realized, you know what?

00:43:15.160 --> 00:43:19.064
I don't think I'm gonna have that problem
if, if the Lord grants me success because

00:43:19.082 --> 00:43:22.052
my wife was focused on glory Right?

00:43:22.238 --> 00:43:26.441
And the same thing is true, you know,
she, she honors me in that, that, you

00:43:26.442 --> 00:43:29.555
know, whenever I have a harebrained
business idea, she wants me to

00:43:29.566 --> 00:43:31.662
have as much glory as I can, right?

00:43:31.662 --> 00:43:35.485
When I, when I wanna, when I wanna
show hospitality to people, she wants

00:43:35.495 --> 00:43:39.506
me to have as much glory as I can, and
those are the things that I do, right?

00:43:39.506 --> 00:43:43.138
When I, when I wanted to start this
podcast, she encouraged me because

00:43:43.350 --> 00:43:44.381
that's what you're supposed to do.

00:43:44.388 --> 00:43:46.231
You're supposed to have
the people in your life.

00:43:46.389 --> 00:43:50.160
If the people in your life stop being
glory motivated, if they stop being

00:43:50.162 --> 00:43:54.045
glory… If they stop striving, aiming
for the best thing, then your world

00:43:54.045 --> 00:43:59.216
will get smaller and darker because
living with covenant breakers sucks, man

00:43:59.679 --> 00:44:01.428
Like that, that it is just a bad deal.

00:44:01.548 --> 00:44:04.196
And this is what people
don't understand, right?

00:44:04.377 --> 00:44:07.334
This is what people don't understand
about, about this, this whole topic

00:44:07.335 --> 00:44:09.419
is yes, there's insane vulnerability.

00:44:09.859 --> 00:44:12.958
Yes, you're giving these people
power to hurt you, but, but you

00:44:12.961 --> 00:44:15.146
all have power to hurt you, right?

00:44:15.166 --> 00:44:18.240
Th- th- there's, there's a sense in
which you all covenantal relationships,

00:44:18.242 --> 00:44:20.881
there's so much vulnerability,
there's so much power, and, and

00:44:20.881 --> 00:44:22.116
sometimes that, you know, people…

00:44:22.347 --> 00:44:25.318
The reality is the p- the power actually
frequently switches, switches sides.

00:44:25.318 --> 00:44:28.265
It goes from, from one to the other
and kind of getting good at passing

00:44:28.265 --> 00:44:32.012
the, the, the dominant and vulnerable
position back and forth is kind of what,

00:44:32.121 --> 00:44:34.278
what success is as far as I can tell.

00:44:34.815 --> 00:44:37.425
but any of these people can destroy you

00:44:37.771 --> 00:44:41.002
And that's that, like And maybe
not destroy you in the short term.

00:44:41.016 --> 00:44:44.063
Maybe you can defect, and maybe you
can get access to the cash system,

00:44:44.064 --> 00:44:46.506
and maybe you can, maybe you can
fly around the world, and maybe

00:44:46.506 --> 00:44:47.871
you can do, do the globe-trotting.

00:44:47.883 --> 00:44:49.014
You know, the digital nomad thing.

00:44:49.015 --> 00:44:50.851
And, and, and the digital nomad
thing is not always, like,

00:44:50.852 --> 00:44:51.913
a bad, wicked thing, okay?

00:44:52.171 --> 00:44:55.875
But for many people, it's a,
it's a means of defecting away

00:44:55.880 --> 00:44:59.454
from covenantal responsibilities
that they're running from, okay?

00:44:59.615 --> 00:45:02.567
And I know this 'cause I've, I've worked
with a lot of digital nomads or people

00:45:02.567 --> 00:45:06.141
that are trying to stop be- being digital
nomads, and there, there is a, there is

00:45:06.143 --> 00:45:10.250
a moment where I… that I have come to
expect when I serve those families and

00:45:10.250 --> 00:45:16.957
when I serve those people, where they
tell me exactly what it was that they

00:45:16.968 --> 00:45:21.209
said no to God or to, to someone that
they, they believed they had a moral…

00:45:21.220 --> 00:45:24.501
Th- there's some moral obligation
that they ran away from.

00:45:25.668 --> 00:45:31.831
And, you know, the piper always comes
due, But the whole point is to get

00:45:31.833 --> 00:45:35.958
access to, to certain covenantal goods
which are glorious things, right?

00:45:35.961 --> 00:45:39.054
And again, children are the, children
are the one that I… But, but having a,

00:45:39.097 --> 00:45:43.350
a valid business, having something that,
that works, that provides value, having

00:45:43.350 --> 00:45:47.502
a church that stands the test of time,
having, having people that, that, that,

00:45:47.512 --> 00:45:51.816
that, that know your teaching, that walk
around spreading the things that you say.

00:45:52.005 --> 00:45:53.144
All of these things are good.

00:45:53.160 --> 00:45:57.432
Ultimately, having a city, having a polis,
having a state that, that, that, that

00:45:57.432 --> 00:45:59.632
reflects justice as you understand it.

00:46:00.761 --> 00:46:03.778
that is, is the things that
I believe that, that, that

00:46:03.778 --> 00:46:06.093
God asks of a father, right?

00:46:06.093 --> 00:46:09.458
And, and one of them is,
is, is good laws, right?

00:46:09.874 --> 00:46:12.673
That you should strive to have
a land where there's good laws.

00:46:13.773 --> 00:46:14.482
And I believe that.

00:46:14.482 --> 00:46:18.520
I believe that's part of what it means to
be a father, to strive for that, right?

00:46:18.524 --> 00:46:22.063
'Cause if you don't, you know… My
grandfather, I loved my grandfather.

00:46:22.560 --> 00:46:25.561
My grandfather had
frustrations with his father.

00:46:25.775 --> 00:46:29.657
My great-grandfather, as far as,
as I can tell, was basically John

00:46:29.662 --> 00:46:33.692
Dutton from the Yellowstone series,
down to the way that John Dutton

00:46:33.693 --> 00:46:35.786
famously solves problems, okay?

00:46:36.069 --> 00:46:36.412
Right?

00:46:36.447 --> 00:46:38.260
Which is to say that all
options are on the table.

00:46:38.735 --> 00:46:41.121
And my grandfather didn't
wanna be that kind of guy.

00:46:41.136 --> 00:46:43.657
He didn't wanna be a guy that was
violent, that occasionally hurt

00:46:43.661 --> 00:46:47.007
people, that, you know, might have,
you know, done, done horrible things.

00:46:47.600 --> 00:46:51.474
and so he didn't play politics, and
he just kind of rested on his laurels.

00:46:51.752 --> 00:46:56.010
And if there's a reason why my family
lost its land, that's, that's why, because

00:46:56.012 --> 00:46:57.654
we did not contend in the city gates.

00:46:57.655 --> 00:47:01.727
We just let them be taken, We didn't, we
didn't, we weren't involved in politics.

00:47:01.731 --> 00:47:05.029
We, we We didn't have any voice.

00:47:05.737 --> 00:47:09.034
My grandfather just didn't
want to do that part of it.

00:47:09.034 --> 00:47:11.590
And, and so as, you know,
sort of a classic, right?

00:47:11.590 --> 00:47:13.835
You know, first they came for this
group, and then they came for this

00:47:13.836 --> 00:47:16.987
group, and then they came for this
group, and we were the last, right?

00:47:17.367 --> 00:47:20.354
The three ranches right next to my
grandfather when, when the private

00:47:20.354 --> 00:47:24.555
equity people had just strip-mined
the almond farms, um, when they, you

00:47:24.555 --> 00:47:28.402
know, when they had destroyed a bunch
of the local dairies and, and, and,

00:47:28.445 --> 00:47:31.390
and, uh, you know, essentially all
of the ag businesses just driven,

00:47:31.702 --> 00:47:35.476
uh, the, the, the, um, the Mennonites
basically got driven out of the county.

00:47:35.476 --> 00:47:37.958
They all moved down to, to, to
Turlock with the, with the rest of the

00:47:37.962 --> 00:47:39.543
Mennonites in kind of Central California.

00:47:40.058 --> 00:47:43.708
But all of those groups got driven
out, and my grandfather just kinda, we

00:47:43.708 --> 00:47:47.265
just kind of bided our time and waited
on our land, and we weren't involved.

00:47:47.622 --> 00:47:48.863
It wasn't our problem.

00:47:49.277 --> 00:47:51.874
And then, you know, as the phrase
goes, when they came for us,

00:47:51.874 --> 00:47:55.354
there was no one left to speak
for us 'cause we were the last.

00:47:56.227 --> 00:47:58.166
We were the last, you
know, basically ag family.

00:47:58.170 --> 00:47:59.386
And, and I've been back there now.

00:47:59.707 --> 00:48:03.018
I went back for, uh, for my grandmother's
funeral last time I was in California, and

00:48:03.019 --> 00:48:07.967
I drove through that town, and it is, you
know, just a wall-to-wall suburb, right?

00:48:08.299 --> 00:48:09.803
Just everything is paved over.

00:48:09.803 --> 00:48:14.143
Some of the best, most fertile land
that God ever gave to humanity, and

00:48:14.145 --> 00:48:18.489
it's all paved over, and strip malls
and cookie cutter, you know, chain

00:48:18.491 --> 00:48:23.675
stores and, And I'm not saying that my
grandfather could have stopped it, right?

00:48:23.983 --> 00:48:26.596
Maybe he could, maybe he
couldn't have, but he didn't try.

00:48:27.084 --> 00:48:30.175
He thought, "Well, I don't wanna do
that. I don't wanna, I don't wanna get

00:48:30.177 --> 00:48:34.099
involved. I don't wanna, I don't wanna
pick a fight." You know, I was on X the

00:48:34.100 --> 00:48:37.741
other day, you know, and so take this with
a grain of salt, and there was this thing

00:48:37.743 --> 00:48:39.750
about, you know, the hero, a- a- any…

00:48:39.775 --> 00:48:43.404
But something like, an animal will
fight if it's, if it's cornered.

00:48:43.418 --> 00:48:44.823
Anything will fight if it's cornered.

00:48:44.874 --> 00:48:47.996
A hero is someone who steps into
the fight when he doesn't have to.

00:48:48.377 --> 00:48:54.083
And that is what makes
someone glorious, right?

00:48:54.083 --> 00:48:59.847
When you don't have to pick this
fight, but you do because there are

00:48:59.847 --> 00:49:03.319
people that you love, because there
are things that you love, right?

00:49:03.319 --> 00:49:06.973
When you're fighting not to save
your own life or to save your own

00:49:06.975 --> 00:49:10.847
skin, but when you're fighting for
the things that you love, right?

00:49:11.305 --> 00:49:14.270
And I wanna acknowledge, right,
before I, before we enter the Q&A,

00:49:14.532 --> 00:49:18.384
being the focus of people's glory is
perilously close to worship, right?

00:49:18.418 --> 00:49:19.702
In, in kind of the religious sense.

00:49:19.703 --> 00:49:22.495
And, and even when it doesn't
stray into, you know, blasphemy

00:49:22.495 --> 00:49:25.280
and idolatry and all these things,
it is still intensely addictive.

00:49:25.288 --> 00:49:29.208
There is nothing in the world like…
I mean, you think that having the power

00:49:29.208 --> 00:49:31.429
is sometimes people get… They'll,
they'll, they'll climb a little bit of

00:49:31.429 --> 00:49:33.399
the corporate ladder, and they'll get
the right to tell other people what

00:49:33.399 --> 00:49:34.809
to do, kinda be the manager, right?

00:49:35.362 --> 00:49:37.207
And there, there's a little
bit of a rush there, right?

00:49:37.208 --> 00:49:39.871
It's kinda cool to tell people
what, what to do and it's,

00:49:39.882 --> 00:49:40.800
and it's somewhat addictive.

00:49:40.801 --> 00:49:46.541
I mean, you know, if, if, if Me Too
meant anything, okay, uh, it meant that

00:49:46.542 --> 00:49:48.695
there's a whole bunch of managers, right?

00:49:49.143 --> 00:49:51.772
Uh, you know, they, they, they talk
about, uh, people talk about work

00:49:51.778 --> 00:49:56.405
wives and work husbands and work harems
and various things of these nature.

00:49:56.759 --> 00:50:01.203
And I mean, anybody that doesn't
think that those, those things are

00:50:01.406 --> 00:50:05.291
treading on the bounds of adultery
is, is out of their mind, okay?

00:50:05.493 --> 00:50:08.938
Like, if you have a work wife, you should,
you should stop that and then you should

00:50:08.970 --> 00:50:11.223
go home and repent to your wife, okay?

00:50:11.231 --> 00:50:15.787
Or you should marry that girl if you're
unmarried and just move forward, right?

00:50:16.289 --> 00:50:19.144
Yeah, I mean, that's, that's I think
really what, what, what is, is the,

00:50:19.154 --> 00:50:23.027
the, the great, the great problem that,
that people have with the boomers,

00:50:23.557 --> 00:50:24.828
um, is that they're anti-nobles.

00:50:24.846 --> 00:50:27.929
They thought they'd built a perfect
system, and that system would make all

00:50:27.930 --> 00:50:31.123
the decisions, and all they had to do
was be neutral arbiters of that system.

00:50:31.328 --> 00:50:34.310
And it, as it turns out, when
they got into positions of power,

00:50:34.313 --> 00:50:35.961
power was still very addictive.

00:50:36.280 --> 00:50:39.595
Power was still something that,
that, that they, they enjoyed having,

00:50:39.766 --> 00:50:43.277
and that they, they had to exercise
a bunch of moral judgments, and

00:50:43.278 --> 00:50:44.718
they had to think about things.

00:50:44.757 --> 00:50:47.617
And when they screwed up, it was
bad, and when they did well, it

00:50:47.617 --> 00:50:50.330
was good, it was glorious, and
they wanted more of that glory.

00:50:50.608 --> 00:50:51.664
As we all do.

00:50:52.161 --> 00:50:53.689
But they didn't prepare themselves.

00:50:53.710 --> 00:50:56.315
They didn't think, oh… 'Cause
this is what no- this is the,

00:50:56.354 --> 00:50:57.435
the third thing that nobility is.

00:50:57.589 --> 00:51:02.445
Nobility is recognizing, hey, having
power is incredibly addictive.

00:51:02.635 --> 00:51:04.457
It's, it, it's a, it's an incredible rush.

00:51:04.462 --> 00:51:10.221
Successfully being the vector, the means
by which someone's desire to not be a

00:51:10.223 --> 00:51:15.394
covenant breaker, the way they look at
you, the way they interact with you, i-

00:51:15.433 --> 00:51:17.124
there's nothing else in the world like it.

00:51:17.583 --> 00:51:20.803
A- and, and in some ways it's
like, okay, you're, you're, you're

00:51:20.813 --> 00:51:22.829
gambling your sanity, right?

00:51:22.905 --> 00:51:27.247
You're, you're, you're, you're
risking losing yourself in that rush.

00:51:27.247 --> 00:51:28.919
You know, people are talking about in
the, in the influencer world, they're

00:51:28.919 --> 00:51:31.170
talking about audience capture, right?

00:51:31.328 --> 00:51:32.927
and audience capture, right?

00:51:32.947 --> 00:51:34.076
Like, that's a real thing.

00:51:34.440 --> 00:51:38.078
But you gotta ask yourself, is,
is that a reason to never speak?

00:51:38.100 --> 00:51:42.079
Is that a reason not to, not to build
a following, not to build something,

00:51:42.080 --> 00:51:43.775
not to do the glorious thing, right?

00:51:43.775 --> 00:51:48.674
Is it better to never risk falling
into these things, or is it better,

00:51:49.014 --> 00:51:52.306
is it better to be glorious, You
know, and, and, and again, I think it

00:51:52.308 --> 00:51:53.629
all comes back to belonging, right?

00:51:53.629 --> 00:51:56.369
This is what is going on when, when
you get to use the possessive pronoun.

00:51:56.758 --> 00:52:00.083
My friend Kevin Dolan says, you
know, y- you don't own them.

00:52:00.094 --> 00:52:02.479
Like, th- none of these, none of
these relationships are really about

00:52:02.530 --> 00:52:04.199
owning in the, in the modern sense.

00:52:04.555 --> 00:52:06.964
but they do belong to you,
and you belong to them.

00:52:06.966 --> 00:52:11.091
This is, this is an inescapable
part of being, Here's the thing.

00:52:11.242 --> 00:52:18.032
Like, let's say that, that, um, that glory
and wielding glory and being noble is like

00:52:18.369 --> 00:52:20.041
cocaine or something highly addictive.

00:52:20.488 --> 00:52:21.195
That's a risk.

00:52:21.239 --> 00:52:25.505
A- a- a- and a, a, a, a regular
person is gonna be repelled by that.

00:52:25.505 --> 00:52:27.215
They're gonna say, "Man, I
d- I don't wanna do this.

00:52:27.215 --> 00:52:28.280
This is not actually like…"

00:52:28.421 --> 00:52:33.236
Yes, it's fun, and it is fun, but it's
also, man, couldn't, couldn't there

00:52:33.242 --> 00:52:34.795
be another way for me to do this?

00:52:35.225 --> 00:52:38.200
And if there's not another way, and
again, the failure of our modern

00:52:38.201 --> 00:52:41.681
system's the fact that we cannot
design a perfect neutral system

00:52:41.682 --> 00:52:44.973
where we can have perfect neutral
bureaucratic arbiters that dispense

00:52:44.978 --> 00:52:48.463
people's rights and, and that work,
'cause that is what's going on, right?

00:52:48.463 --> 00:52:52.225
We are facing the end of that,
If we can't do that, then we

00:52:52.226 --> 00:52:53.510
need people to contend for us.

00:52:53.513 --> 00:52:54.857
We need someone who is for us.

00:52:54.887 --> 00:52:58.792
Everyone needs someone who is for them,
someone who will take the time and

00:52:58.792 --> 00:53:05.279
say, "It's part of my job on this earth
to make sure that you get a chance at

00:53:05.279 --> 00:53:09.301
glory." Now, a chance at glory might
be a very dangerous thing, right?

00:53:09.754 --> 00:53:12.208
Maybe I don't come back
from my chance at glory.

00:53:12.618 --> 00:53:18.311
But if I don't, then my Lord, who got
me the chance at glory, will take care

00:53:18.312 --> 00:53:21.731
of my wife and children, 'cause to not
do that would be to sully the glory.

00:53:22.068 --> 00:53:22.336
Okay?

00:53:22.338 --> 00:53:24.584
This is what makes it
all make sense, right?

00:53:24.832 --> 00:53:27.671
You know, and, and, and let's say
that civilization depended upon a

00:53:27.671 --> 00:53:30.904
group of people doing something highly
addictive and doing it really well.

00:53:31.085 --> 00:53:33.168
How would you make that work?

00:53:33.382 --> 00:53:35.585
Well, you would, take it seriously.

00:53:35.585 --> 00:53:38.779
You would say, "We're gonna have to
do something that's gonna pull on

00:53:38.779 --> 00:53:41.895
us. We're gonna have to do something
that, that risks our sanity and

00:53:41.895 --> 00:53:45.685
risks us falling into… There's,
there's a lot of moral hazard here."

00:53:46.099 --> 00:53:47.699
And there is a lot of moral hazard.

00:53:48.233 --> 00:53:49.834
But we have to engage in it.

00:53:49.835 --> 00:53:50.806
Power is addictive.

00:53:50.809 --> 00:53:54.086
I'm not, I'm not, I'm not denying
it, but power is also necessary.

00:53:54.545 --> 00:53:58.360
And again,  the reason why… Like,
what I want you to do to convince you

00:53:58.362 --> 00:54:00.785
to do this is actually look around.

00:54:01.113 --> 00:54:04.139
Look at your wives, look
at your children, right?

00:54:04.202 --> 00:54:07.973
Look at the things, the way you solve
problems, and ask yourself if you're happy

00:54:07.974 --> 00:54:12.295
with the, the cultural option sets that
your, your, your, your culture gives you.

00:54:12.646 --> 00:54:15.765
From the, from the top to the bottom,
like when, when, when people in your

00:54:15.765 --> 00:54:19.316
town, when they lose their jobs,
when bad things happen to them, when

00:54:19.317 --> 00:54:23.515
they get canceled, right, m- what,
what, what are you expected to do?

00:54:23.528 --> 00:54:26.351
You are expected to sit there
and shut up and let it happen

00:54:26.811 --> 00:54:28.005
And are you happy with that?

00:54:28.818 --> 00:54:30.240
Is that how, is that how you wanna…

00:54:30.356 --> 00:54:33.184
And, and this is again, this is why people
can't do the multi-generational thing.

00:54:33.334 --> 00:54:37.654
Because if you look at your son and you
say, "Hey, I kinda live, we kinda survive

00:54:38.247 --> 00:54:43.313
by doing this, this in, this, this,
this inglorious, this awful, this, this,

00:54:43.347 --> 00:54:48.188
this betrayal thing. We, we survive by
defecting, my son." Well, guess what?

00:54:48.707 --> 00:54:52.550
Your son's gonna defect from you too,
Cause that's what you taught him to

00:54:52.551 --> 00:54:55.675
do, what you did in front of him, okay?

00:54:55.907 --> 00:54:59.257
And again, this is, this is why we
are frustrated with the boomers,

00:54:59.839 --> 00:55:02.613
and, and I think it's important
to, to recognize, hey, you gotta

00:55:02.625 --> 00:55:03.786
have a standards that you can keep.

00:55:03.786 --> 00:55:05.360
I'll probably talk about
that more next time.

00:55:05.441 --> 00:55:07.748
Uh, the, the, the, the final
point I'll make is you can't

00:55:07.766 --> 00:55:09.141
ask your nobles to be Jesus.

00:55:09.147 --> 00:55:09.931
That's not gonna work.

00:55:09.978 --> 00:55:11.738
Only Jesus was Jesus, right?

00:55:12.185 --> 00:55:12.688
I remember that.

00:55:12.688 --> 00:55:16.127
That was from, uh, you know, the,
a church, a church membership class

00:55:16.165 --> 00:55:18.520
years, that I attended years ago, and
they said, "Hey, guys, just, you know,

00:55:18.523 --> 00:55:21.635
one of the things we wanna say is
don't expect the pastors to be Jesus.

00:55:21.761 --> 00:55:24.746
They're not." Um, now
they can image Jesus.

00:55:25.387 --> 00:55:29.435
They can stand up and for
a brief qualitative moment,

00:55:29.720 --> 00:55:31.332
they can do the right thing.

00:55:31.332 --> 00:55:34.421
They can, they can say, you know,
they can speak as though they're

00:55:34.447 --> 00:55:36.797
uttering the oracles of God, right?

00:55:36.821 --> 00:55:37.685
Which is a Bible verse, right?

00:55:37.685 --> 00:55:39.304
That's actually a command
to a, to a preacher.

00:55:39.320 --> 00:55:41.874
Preacher's gotta speak as though
he's uttering the oracles of

00:55:41.874 --> 00:55:44.843
God, even though he's not, right?

00:55:44.854 --> 00:55:46.172
He didn't have an angel come to him.

00:55:46.178 --> 00:55:47.212
He's supposed to read the Bible.

00:55:47.212 --> 00:55:48.135
He's supposed to study.

00:55:48.322 --> 00:55:50.702
He's supposed to have… I mean,
sometimes I suppose in certain

00:55:50.702 --> 00:55:52.951
traditions people believe that,
the, that angels come to them.

00:55:53.024 --> 00:55:56.798
but by and large, you're supposed
to look at it, and you're supposed

00:55:56.798 --> 00:56:01.119
to behave, you're supposed to
image that thing because that's

00:56:01.120 --> 00:56:03.496
the glorious thing to do, right?

00:56:03.697 --> 00:56:06.778
And I think we also just need to recognize
many of the ti- many times the, the

00:56:06.779 --> 00:56:09.717
literal people telling us, "Well, this,
this person needs to be more Christ-like.

00:56:09.719 --> 00:56:12.368
This per- Hey, is this, is
this like Jesus," right?

00:56:12.725 --> 00:56:16.843
M- many times, like, you just need to have
a, have a kind of a real world awareness

00:56:16.847 --> 00:56:19.466
of this person is not a neutral arbiter.

00:56:19.467 --> 00:56:21.903
They are, they, they have an agenda,
and they're just, they're trying to

00:56:21.903 --> 00:56:24.562
get a certain political outcome, and we
would all be better off if we just kinda

00:56:24.563 --> 00:56:25.827
paid attention to those things, okay?

00:56:26.789 --> 00:56:31.292
And in conclusion Keeping
covenants is glorious.

00:56:32.227 --> 00:56:33.256
This is the purpose of life.

00:56:33.270 --> 00:56:37.384
This is, this is what it means
to, to have a good thing.

00:56:38.733 --> 00:56:41.681
Like, it's not about accumulation
of, of, of economic goods.

00:56:41.682 --> 00:56:47.838
It's about the accumulation of the ability
to image God as you understand him.

00:56:48.173 --> 00:56:50.859
And to do that in increasing
areas of life, and to have…

00:56:51.017 --> 00:56:54.144
Like, you know, you know, uh, th-
blow it up to the big picture, right?

00:56:54.195 --> 00:56:59.120
I, I don't have the ability when, when,
when Christians are butchered in Nigeria

00:56:59.312 --> 00:57:02.644
to send a contingent, you know, to, to
start a crusade and send a contingent.

00:57:02.925 --> 00:57:06.419
And, and it appears that my whole
culture does not have that ability,

00:57:06.613 --> 00:57:10.168
that no one is going to come and
rescue those, those people, right?

00:57:10.202 --> 00:57:13.822
And I wish I could, but I also
wish, and, and we need to start with

00:57:14.179 --> 00:57:17.769
How do we take care of the people
in our families, in our towns?

00:57:17.955 --> 00:57:20.480
And you gotta hold them to, to…
They gotta hold them accountable.

00:57:20.480 --> 00:57:23.934
They c- they, they don't get
to take away the glory, right?

00:57:24.148 --> 00:57:27.259
If they indicate, "Well, I don't care
about glory," well, then they, th- th-

00:57:27.278 --> 00:57:29.002
then, then, then that's the rubric.

00:57:29.031 --> 00:57:31.328
Then that's how we know, okay,
we don't, we don't include you in

00:57:31.328 --> 00:57:33.838
this because you're not playing
the game that we're playing.

00:57:33.999 --> 00:57:35.748
You're not motivated by the same thing.

00:57:35.927 --> 00:57:38.957
And, and, and if there's not a glory
exchange, it's not gonna work, right?

00:57:39.103 --> 00:57:43.191
'Cause you're not gonna do the things
that you need to do, Have the kids to

00:57:43.193 --> 00:57:48.359
do the humble work that is necessary
for the great, grand, glorious

00:57:48.359 --> 00:57:49.738
dreams to come to fruition, right?

00:57:49.748 --> 00:57:53.590
W- the… What you're doing if, if, if,
if the, the, the covenantal inferiors,

00:57:53.591 --> 00:57:58.802
the, the people that serve, if they're
not also glory motivated, then ultimately

00:57:58.803 --> 00:58:02.340
the dreams and aspirations of the,
the Lord will, will get cut off.

00:58:02.343 --> 00:58:07.172
His, his way won't iterate, And you will
lose access to, to, to the covenantal

00:58:07.183 --> 00:58:10.171
goods, which are always necessary, at
least on, on a long-term timescale.

00:58:10.184 --> 00:58:13.327
So anyway, I've gone over
time, uh, but I did start late.

00:58:13.377 --> 00:58:14.776
So, thanks everybody.

00:58:14.776 --> 00:58:18.588
These, this concludes my prepared
remarks, yeah, we will… Now let's,

00:58:18.593 --> 00:58:20.316
uh, let's move into the, into the Q&A