Does Church Membership Even Matter?

What does it actually mean to be a member of a church—and is church membership even biblical?

In this episode of the A Lot of Words podcast, we walk through the ideas behind Mere Membership and take a closer look at how modern churches define membership compared to what we see in Scripture. Many people think of membership as a class, a list, or a formal process, but the Bible presents a deeper and more meaningful picture of what it means to belong to the body of Christ.

We talk through the purpose of church membership, what makes the church visible, and why practices like baptism and the Lord’s Table matter more than most people realize. We also address common misunderstandings, including how churches try to define membership administratively and what that can miss.

If you’ve ever wondered whether church membership is biblical, why it matters, or how it should actually function in the life of a church, this conversation will help you think through it in a clear and grounded way.

0:00 Intro & Podcast Banter
2:45 What Problem Did You See in the Church That Led to This Book?
9:30 What Does Church Membership Actually Mean?
16:20 Are Churches Solving Church Membership the Wrong Way?
26:10 What Does “Fencing the Table” Mean?
29:40 How Do You Handle Church Discipline Without Membership Lists?
35:10 What Would Change If Churches Got Membership Right?
40:00 Does Swearing on the Bible Break “Let Your Yes Be Yes”?
43:30 What About Praying in Tongues in 1 Corinthians 14?
48:30 What Happens to Children at the Rapture?

=======================================
Buy Pastor Matt's new book 'Mere Membership':
https://a.co/d/04ryklXw

Have a question you want answered on the podcast?
https://alotofwordspodcast.com/contact

Shop our merch store. Your support fuels the show:
https://alotofwordspodcast.com/shop

Want more teaching from Pastor Matt Smith?
Watch his sermons and full teaching series at Barabbas Road Church on YouTube:
https://www.youtube.com/@BarabbasRoadChurch

Visit our Barabbas Road Church in San Diego:
https://www.barabbas.com/

Want your podcast to look like this?
We build and produce professional video podcasts in San Diego.
Start here: https://www.vortexstudios.live

Like, subscribe, and share if you want more honest, biblical conversations without hype.

Subscribe to our channel for more:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/alotofwordspodcast/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ALotOfWordsPodcast/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@alotofwordspodcast
X (Twitter): https://x.com/alotofwordscast
Truth Social: https://truthsocial.com/@alotofwords
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/a-lot-of-words-podcast
Rumble: https://rumble.com/c/c-7820768?e9s=src_v1_cbl

More ways to listen:
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/4BDk62lDqdUFdOGh81MGUT?si=z5dHsYidRdmsbYzVtd-ziw
Apple Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/a-lot-of-words/id1874390630
Amazon Music: https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/636dd985-7c53-43fc-85d1-a0e129495180
Transistor.fm: https://alotofwords.transistor.fm/

What is A Lot of Words?

A Lot of Words is a conversational deep-dive podcast hosted by Pastor Brett Schoeneck and Pastor Matt Smith, created for listeners who want biblical clarity applied to real-life questions. Each episode pulls apart the questions people actually ask—not the ones theologians wish people were asking.

From tough topics like anxiety, AI, politics, prayer, sexuality, and suffering to practical questions about how to read the Bible, how to think Christianly in a digital world, and how to follow Jesus in a noisy culture, Brett and Matt aim to give listeners honest, pastoral, and intellectually serious answers.

The show blends theology, humor, cultural analysis, and pastoral insight—inviting you into a conversation that is purposeful, biblical, and surprisingly entertaining. If you’ve ever wanted a podcast where you can actually get your questions answered, welcome to A Lot of Words.