WEBVTT

NOTE
This file was generated by Descript 

00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:02.519
Dorothy Burwell: The best thing that
boards need to be able to do is not

00:00:02.519 --> 00:00:05.610
to be able to predict the future
because things are changing too fast.

00:00:05.610 --> 00:00:09.390
It's about building adaptive capacity
so that you can deal with the

00:00:09.390 --> 00:00:11.130
emerging realities as they come.

00:00:13.421 --> 00:00:16.681
Ralph Grayson: Welcome to The Boardroom
Path by Sainty Hird & Partners.

00:00:17.026 --> 00:00:20.916
I'm your host, Ralph Grayson, a
partner in the board practice.

00:00:21.284 --> 00:00:25.844
In this series, we'll offer practical
steps and useful perspectives for

00:00:25.844 --> 00:00:28.184
aspiring and newly appointed NEDs.

00:00:29.010 --> 00:00:34.650
Today's guest is Dorothy Burwell, Global
Head of Board Advisory at FGS Global.

00:00:35.310 --> 00:00:39.720
She's a board director at Post
Holdings and Pennan PLC, and one of

00:00:39.720 --> 00:00:43.350
the most original thinkers working
at the intersection of governance,

00:00:43.410 --> 00:00:45.180
strategy, and human behaviour.

00:00:46.170 --> 00:00:51.240
Dorothy began her career at Goldman Sachs
in energy investment banking before making

00:00:51.240 --> 00:00:57.090
what she describes as an almost accidental
move into strategic communications at

00:00:57.090 --> 00:01:02.760
Finsbury, now part of FGS Global, where
she spent nearly two decades advising

00:01:02.760 --> 00:01:08.850
boards, CEOs, and leadership teams through
moments of transformation, activism,

00:01:09.120 --> 00:01:11.490
crisis, and reputational pressure.

00:01:12.420 --> 00:01:16.140
But what makes Dorothy particularly
interesting is not simply her

00:01:16.140 --> 00:01:19.890
communications background,
it's the lens through which she

00:01:19.890 --> 00:01:21.780
views leadership and governance.

00:01:22.530 --> 00:01:25.080
She's previously told me that
the most fascinating part of

00:01:25.080 --> 00:01:29.430
board life is not the financial
engineering or the technical process.

00:01:29.940 --> 00:01:34.290
It's understanding how human beings
actually make decisions under uncertainty.

00:01:34.920 --> 00:01:40.470
It's how trust is built, how influence
works without authority, and why some

00:01:40.470 --> 00:01:45.150
leadership teams adapt while others
freeze, and how boards can become

00:01:45.150 --> 00:01:49.230
either part of the solution or part
of the problem when pressure arrives.

00:01:50.280 --> 00:01:54.120
Alongside her executive career,
Dorothy has built a significant board

00:01:54.120 --> 00:01:59.670
portfolio, spanning listed companies,
regulated industries, consumer brands,

00:01:59.820 --> 00:02:01.860
and public interest organisations.

00:02:02.640 --> 00:02:07.290
Her experience ranges from ESG and
stakeholder governance through to

00:02:07.290 --> 00:02:12.030
succession planning, crisis management,
and investor engagement across both

00:02:12.030 --> 00:02:14.610
the UK and the U.S. Board systems.

00:02:15.570 --> 00:02:21.060
She's also co-author of the FGS Paper,
The Board's Role in a Rewired World,

00:02:21.480 --> 00:02:26.250
which explores how boards must evolve in
response to geopolitical fragmentation,

00:02:26.640 --> 00:02:31.470
AI disruption, collapsing trust in
institutions, and the accelerating

00:02:31.470 --> 00:02:33.060
complexity of decision-making.

00:02:33.900 --> 00:02:39.060
The paper argues that modern boards need
something beyond experience, what Dorothy

00:02:39.060 --> 00:02:44.760
calls adaptive capacity, the ability
to absorb new realities, challenge old

00:02:44.760 --> 00:02:49.950
assumptions, and make better decisions
in increasingly uncertain environments.

00:02:50.850 --> 00:02:55.620
So in this conversation, we're going to
explore how boards really make decisions

00:02:55.620 --> 00:03:00.840
under pressure, why communication is
now a core governance capability, what

00:03:00.840 --> 00:03:06.420
separates adaptive boards from declining
ones, how CEOs and boards build trust,

00:03:06.900 --> 00:03:11.340
and why the future of governance may
depend less on certainty and more on

00:03:11.340 --> 00:03:13.470
the quality of collective judgement.

00:03:13.859 --> 00:03:15.539
Dorothy, welcome to The Boardroom Path.

00:03:16.036 --> 00:03:17.056
Dorothy Burwell: Thank
you very much, Ralph.

00:03:17.056 --> 00:03:17.686
Thanks for having me.

00:03:18.293 --> 00:03:22.763
Ralph Grayson: I'd love to start just
with a bit about your career background.

00:03:22.763 --> 00:03:28.043
So you moved from Goldman Sachs into
communications and then into governance.

00:03:28.343 --> 00:03:34.083
So what capabilities perhaps have lent
themselves to that career revolution and

00:03:34.133 --> 00:03:35.243
how did you find yourself on that journey?

00:03:35.889 --> 00:03:37.262
Dorothy Burwell: Yeah, it's not linear.

00:03:37.312 --> 00:03:41.032
But basically I started out in
banking, which in and of itself was

00:03:41.032 --> 00:03:44.222
a bit of a surprise cause I wanted
to be a journalist many years ago.

00:03:44.442 --> 00:03:45.882
And that led me to the uk.

00:03:45.882 --> 00:03:49.902
I did a stint in strategy somewhere in
the middle and then moved into comms to

00:03:49.902 --> 00:03:51.612
try to get back to that journalism route.

00:03:51.972 --> 00:03:54.792
I think the thing that I picked up
from both of those guises is being an

00:03:54.792 --> 00:03:59.422
advisor has been very useful because
it teaches you the skill of how to put

00:03:59.422 --> 00:04:03.622
forward an argument for a management
team to consider without meddling in

00:04:03.622 --> 00:04:07.222
how it actually gets used and executed,
which I think is really useful.

00:04:07.552 --> 00:04:10.732
I've also, in my time at FGS,
been part of the management team.

00:04:10.732 --> 00:04:15.809
So I was a defacto CMO for a while,
did that for five years, and so also

00:04:15.809 --> 00:04:19.079
understanding what it actually means to
be part of management, having to manage

00:04:19.079 --> 00:04:23.299
a budget, having to deal with all the
different machinations and the politics

00:04:23.719 --> 00:04:27.919
of trying to execute on a strategy
from your own silo, within a business.

00:04:28.339 --> 00:04:31.009
Being able to relate to a management
team is also very important.

00:04:31.069 --> 00:04:35.659
I think we sometimes find that people have
only been advisors, management teams have

00:04:35.659 --> 00:04:39.229
a hard time identifying with them, and
people who've only been in management can

00:04:39.229 --> 00:04:43.609
sometimes meddle because they long for the
days when they were actually in control

00:04:43.614 --> 00:04:45.834
of a particular part of the strategy.

00:04:45.834 --> 00:04:47.754
So it's good to have both sides.

00:04:48.254 --> 00:04:51.104
Ralph Grayson: The human dynamic of
all of this is something I'm really

00:04:51.104 --> 00:04:53.964
keen to explore in this podcast.

00:04:54.414 --> 00:04:59.151
One of the places I start, Dorothy
because I'm fascinated by one of the

00:04:59.151 --> 00:05:05.204
things you said, which that quote, "The
right answer is often obvious. Getting

00:05:05.204 --> 00:05:09.615
everyone to agree is the difficult
part." That feels to me like the perfect

00:05:09.615 --> 00:05:16.635
description of modern boardrooms and
I'd love to just posit the question that

00:05:17.135 --> 00:05:21.785
boards are ultimately more about human
behaviour than governance frameworks?

00:05:22.285 --> 00:05:24.625
Dorothy Burwell: Yeah, until
we're all replaced with AI, I

00:05:24.625 --> 00:05:25.885
think that's probably right.

00:05:26.185 --> 00:05:31.005
When we put together a board as
you'll very well know, we have our

00:05:31.335 --> 00:05:34.695
skills matrices, we try to make sure
that we have an operating leader,

00:05:34.725 --> 00:05:38.835
we've got a marketing leader, we've
got the ex accountant, et cetera.

00:05:39.045 --> 00:05:40.960
So that part of it's pretty easy.

00:05:41.250 --> 00:05:45.270
The difficult part is how is this
group of individuals going to

00:05:45.270 --> 00:05:48.990
blend with management and be able
to help influence them over time?

00:05:49.330 --> 00:05:53.400
And also what proclivities are
they bringing with them into the

00:05:53.400 --> 00:05:58.980
room that will put colour on their
judgement and how they make decisions.

00:05:59.190 --> 00:06:02.100
So a lot of times people
say the board is a team.

00:06:02.160 --> 00:06:02.940
The board's not a team.

00:06:03.440 --> 00:06:07.400
The board is a group of individuals
who come together in the UK six times

00:06:07.400 --> 00:06:12.200
a year in the US probably four times
a year to form what maybe what you

00:06:12.200 --> 00:06:16.306
call a pop-up team that is supposed
to make a decision and help management

00:06:16.616 --> 00:06:19.404
through critical points in the year.

00:06:19.806 --> 00:06:23.466
If you have to do that at speed, you
actually have to have the human skill of

00:06:23.466 --> 00:06:26.356
being able to connect with each other and
also connect with management to ensure

00:06:26.356 --> 00:06:30.766
that you get one to the right decision
intellectually, but to also be able to

00:06:30.766 --> 00:06:33.061
inspire management to follow it as well.

00:06:33.561 --> 00:06:35.481
Ralph Grayson: Fascinating
framing of boards there.

00:06:35.691 --> 00:06:37.251
Can we just maybe step back a bit?

00:06:37.281 --> 00:06:40.045
Cause you are both a
practitioner as an active NED.

00:06:40.545 --> 00:06:44.065
Maybe just talk me through that that
the role, mission, purpose of the

00:06:44.065 --> 00:06:49.595
group at FGS, where you want FGS to fit
into part of this boardroom dynamic.

00:06:50.053 --> 00:06:50.413
Dorothy Burwell: Yeah.

00:06:50.773 --> 00:06:55.503
So at FGS one of the things that we
recognised is that the board's role

00:06:55.503 --> 00:06:56.823
is different from management's role.

00:06:57.123 --> 00:06:58.893
The board's role is to govern.

00:06:59.193 --> 00:07:02.103
And the way that I think about it, and
one of the reasons why I got involved

00:07:02.103 --> 00:07:08.033
with boards is when the board comes in to
think about the strategy of a business,

00:07:08.063 --> 00:07:12.353
we are trying to make sure that we are
fulfilling on our promises to each of the

00:07:12.353 --> 00:07:17.483
stakeholder groups that we are touching
as an organisation and the management

00:07:17.483 --> 00:07:21.773
team is there to make sure that we
execute well, that we hit profitability,

00:07:21.773 --> 00:07:23.933
et cetera, on a day-to-day basis.

00:07:24.583 --> 00:07:28.033
That therefore puts you in slightly
different positions in terms of how

00:07:28.033 --> 00:07:32.173
you're held to account by shareholders
and by other external parties.

00:07:32.473 --> 00:07:36.383
When things are not going well there
can be a divergence in how you need to

00:07:36.383 --> 00:07:38.453
triage the decisions and the next steps.

00:07:38.783 --> 00:07:42.083
And so one of the things that we'd like
to focus on is, one, how you pick the

00:07:42.083 --> 00:07:43.883
right CEO and set them up for success.

00:07:44.223 --> 00:07:48.173
And so yourself, you would help
pick the right CEO, but what we want

00:07:48.173 --> 00:07:52.083
to think about is what is going to
happen once they get in the seat?

00:07:52.353 --> 00:07:55.983
How do we make sure that everything
that they bring with them, we understand

00:07:55.983 --> 00:08:00.003
their reputation, we understand
what is expected of them and the

00:08:00.003 --> 00:08:03.543
business out in society and with
their internal stakeholders as well.

00:08:03.659 --> 00:08:07.829
How do we set them up to be able
to inspire, communicate, and

00:08:07.829 --> 00:08:09.509
meet all of those expectations?

00:08:09.959 --> 00:08:13.819
The other part of it for the board,
and particularly for the chair, is when

00:08:13.819 --> 00:08:18.019
we're dealing with shareholders who have
very specific demands, how do we make

00:08:18.019 --> 00:08:21.079
sure that you are communicating well
with your shareholders, understanding

00:08:21.079 --> 00:08:25.729
what they need, but also fending
off what might be some contentious,

00:08:26.119 --> 00:08:29.989
proposals or anything of that nature
or activists, which we may talk about

00:08:29.989 --> 00:08:32.914
later, in the event of an AGM or EGM.

00:08:33.224 --> 00:08:36.499
So those are the two guises in
which we work with the board

00:08:36.499 --> 00:08:38.479
and the CEO on an ongoing basis.

00:08:38.979 --> 00:08:42.209
Ralph Grayson: So I'd love to
just dig in a bit more to this

00:08:42.209 --> 00:08:44.829
idea of boards as human systems.

00:08:45.309 --> 00:08:50.149
So you've said that your fascination isn't
about balance sheets but it's actually

00:08:50.149 --> 00:08:52.309
about how humans arrive at decisions.

00:08:52.729 --> 00:08:57.449
So is that something you've learned
from commercial interest and work

00:08:57.449 --> 00:09:00.359
or have you learned that as a
practitioner in the boardroom?

00:09:00.539 --> 00:09:02.399
Where does the balance and
perspective come from on that?

00:09:02.883 --> 00:09:04.743
Dorothy Burwell: It comes from
what I noticed when I came into

00:09:04.743 --> 00:09:06.283
the boardroom for the first time.

00:09:06.923 --> 00:09:10.883
I've sat on small charity boards, I've
sat on a hybrid board, which was both

00:09:10.883 --> 00:09:15.383
charity and a for-profit business,
and I've sat on two corporate boards.

00:09:15.623 --> 00:09:18.893
And I think a commonality across
them, when you walk into the room,

00:09:18.893 --> 00:09:23.200
you realise everybody is ambitious and
they come in with their own agendas.

00:09:23.410 --> 00:09:25.030
They also come in with their own biases.

00:09:25.030 --> 00:09:27.750
And I don't mean that in a
pejorative sense, I mean every

00:09:27.750 --> 00:09:29.730
life experience creates your lens.

00:09:29.980 --> 00:09:33.190
And some of them come in with
their own entrenched views

00:09:33.280 --> 00:09:34.420
of how things should be done.

00:09:34.840 --> 00:09:39.010
And so when you're trying to work
out how a decision's going to be

00:09:39.010 --> 00:09:43.690
made or how a discussion needs to
be to unfold, to get to the right

00:09:43.690 --> 00:09:45.880
outcome, that's all human behaviour.

00:09:46.300 --> 00:09:49.570
None of that has to do with the
skills that each person has.

00:09:49.570 --> 00:09:50.500
They're all very clever.

00:09:51.220 --> 00:09:53.530
But we really need to make sure
that we're productive as well.

00:09:54.190 --> 00:09:57.270
Ralph Grayson: There's a theme we've
come back to a number of times on recent

00:09:57.480 --> 00:10:03.470
podcasts with Maureen Beresford at the FRC
who is talking about real board leadership

00:10:03.640 --> 00:10:06.370
is explaining why you are not complying.

00:10:06.710 --> 00:10:11.770
And a great podcast we did with Kimberly
at Schroders who was talking about

00:10:11.770 --> 00:10:18.520
the importance of stewardship not
being a tick box exercise, but being

00:10:18.520 --> 00:10:21.310
much more interactive and engaged.

00:10:21.700 --> 00:10:26.967
I'd love to just explore how you think
about that alignment in that respect.

00:10:27.204 --> 00:10:30.794
So let's just have your technical
expertise on one side and then

00:10:30.794 --> 00:10:32.474
human alignment on the other side.

00:10:32.474 --> 00:10:33.704
How does that all fit together for you?

00:10:34.204 --> 00:10:36.894
Dorothy Burwell: When we talk about
technical expertise, each person

00:10:36.894 --> 00:10:39.604
on management, should have an
alignment with someone on the board.

00:10:39.604 --> 00:10:42.674
So, I myself, I chair
ESG on one of my boards.

00:10:42.854 --> 00:10:46.984
I engage with the head of
corporate affairs, because they

00:10:46.984 --> 00:10:48.094
have to deal with the public.

00:10:48.604 --> 00:10:53.504
I engage with the head of environment
and ESG internally as well.

00:10:53.797 --> 00:10:56.527
I need to have a working
relationship, with both of them.

00:10:56.737 --> 00:11:00.847
I may not have as deep technical expertise
in some of the areas that they're in, but

00:11:00.847 --> 00:11:02.257
I need to be able to speak their language.

00:11:02.537 --> 00:11:06.377
And I also need to be able to work
with them and bring in some outside

00:11:06.377 --> 00:11:11.117
perspective and influence how they think
about things on a day-to-day basis.

00:11:11.117 --> 00:11:14.687
And so I think there's a balance between
how do you build a relationship with

00:11:14.687 --> 00:11:18.197
management so that they trust you, but
also make sure that you have enough

00:11:18.197 --> 00:11:20.417
technical heft that they respect you.

00:11:20.814 --> 00:11:26.924
There was a study that I read where most
management teams actually said that they

00:11:26.924 --> 00:11:30.854
find their boards useless and I think
that really has to do with whether or not

00:11:30.854 --> 00:11:35.214
those boards are tooled up and current and
actually bringing something to the table

00:11:35.214 --> 00:11:36.814
that they don't already know themselves.

00:11:37.024 --> 00:11:40.024
And so that's why I think the technical
expertise is still important and it's

00:11:40.084 --> 00:11:43.624
important that we continuously learn
and continuously understand what it is

00:11:43.624 --> 00:11:47.524
that we can bring to help them move at
the pace that society is moving now.

00:11:48.024 --> 00:11:51.294
Ralph Grayson: So provocative question,
can you have effective governance

00:11:51.324 --> 00:11:54.234
without requisite emotional intelligence?

00:11:54.734 --> 00:11:55.484
Dorothy Burwell: I don't think so.

00:11:55.884 --> 00:12:00.554
Ultimately, if we're to work together
effectively, one of the things

00:12:00.554 --> 00:12:02.054
that boards need are information.

00:12:02.554 --> 00:12:04.114
We need timely information.

00:12:04.114 --> 00:12:08.104
We need transparency from management
because if we're only seeing through

00:12:08.104 --> 00:12:11.434
a very small aperture, it's very
difficult for us to actually dole

00:12:11.434 --> 00:12:13.280
out anything that's worthwhile.

00:12:13.700 --> 00:12:18.560
So that interpersonal connection and that
human behaviour that's what's going to

00:12:18.560 --> 00:12:21.410
make the difference between whether or not
a manager comes in and feels comfortable

00:12:21.410 --> 00:12:24.560
being vulnerable, feels comfortable
bringing a problem without a solution

00:12:24.860 --> 00:12:28.370
so that you can actually work on it
together, versus people who just try to

00:12:28.370 --> 00:12:29.650
give you everything as a fait accompli.

00:12:30.160 --> 00:12:32.690
Ralph Grayson: Randall Peterson at
LBS, whether you know him, but he's

00:12:32.690 --> 00:12:37.560
done some brilliant work around this
idea of board room behaviour and safe

00:12:37.560 --> 00:12:43.400
spaces in which board members can
really get to the heart of debate.

00:12:43.900 --> 00:12:49.140
What behaviours in your experience
distinguish productive disagreement

00:12:49.140 --> 00:12:53.910
in that respect from unconstructive
or indeed destructive disagreement?

00:12:54.052 --> 00:12:58.062
Dorothy Burwell: Yeah, in one of my
boards one of the things I noticed

00:12:58.062 --> 00:13:02.282
is that the management team very
much tried to over manage the board.

00:13:02.522 --> 00:13:06.988
They would bring papers and give questions
for the board to answer for them.

00:13:07.348 --> 00:13:10.288
Now, that could be good because they're
saying, okay, these are problems that

00:13:10.288 --> 00:13:13.138
we'd like to workshop with you, or it
could be bad because they're trying

00:13:13.138 --> 00:13:15.728
to shut you down a very specific path.

00:13:16.088 --> 00:13:18.818
And I think that things need to be
a little bit more fluid than that.

00:13:19.148 --> 00:13:24.188
When a management team says, I actually
am looking at this and these are all

00:13:24.188 --> 00:13:29.198
of the factors that we have, now let's
discuss what the real question is, then

00:13:29.198 --> 00:13:33.398
I think we have a good relationship
because we're being transparent around,

00:13:33.488 --> 00:13:38.028
not every problem has a tailor made
solution and sometimes we just need

00:13:38.028 --> 00:13:41.958
more heads in the game, more eyes on
it in order for us to really triage it.

00:13:42.228 --> 00:13:46.008
So I think it's the fluidity of that
communication that definitely shows

00:13:46.008 --> 00:13:47.208
whether or not you have productivity.

00:13:47.708 --> 00:13:50.578
Ralph Grayson: I guess there's
board process there, but

00:13:50.578 --> 00:13:52.847
there's also board interactions.

00:13:52.847 --> 00:13:56.306
Is it the role of the chair to
create that psychological safety?

00:13:56.696 --> 00:13:59.951
Or is it incumbent in every
member of the board to make

00:13:59.951 --> 00:14:01.286
their own contribution to that?

00:14:01.786 --> 00:14:04.306
Dorothy Burwell: The first person
in charge of that is the chair and

00:14:04.306 --> 00:14:06.166
their relationship with the CEO.

00:14:06.166 --> 00:14:10.846
If that relationship breaks down, it just
trickles down throughout the all sides.

00:14:10.846 --> 00:14:14.794
So the executive committee
as well as the board itself.

00:14:15.144 --> 00:14:18.894
But there are things that board members
and, thinking about some of the people

00:14:18.894 --> 00:14:22.044
who might be listening to this podcast
who might be aspiring to become on

00:14:22.044 --> 00:14:26.384
a board or new in seat, whatever
committee you're sitting on, if you

00:14:26.384 --> 00:14:29.744
are frequently interacting with someone
in management, it's good to build a

00:14:29.744 --> 00:14:31.214
relationship with that person as well.

00:14:31.424 --> 00:14:35.474
On my very first board, or very
first large board, one of the

00:14:35.474 --> 00:14:38.414
things that I made it my business
to do was to connect with the CMO.

00:14:38.654 --> 00:14:42.254
And he was the CMO, he was the head
of sustainability, and we had offline

00:14:42.254 --> 00:14:46.004
conversations between our meetings in
order for me to understand what is it that

00:14:46.004 --> 00:14:49.994
he's working on and is there anything that
I can help him with or is there anything

00:14:49.994 --> 00:14:54.014
I need to understand before the meeting
that would help to guide the discussion

00:14:54.014 --> 00:14:55.484
and get people into the right place.

00:14:55.844 --> 00:15:00.134
The other thing is, could I give him
any tips on how to present an issue

00:15:00.344 --> 00:15:04.334
so that he actually is addressing
the questions before they come up and

00:15:04.364 --> 00:15:07.724
building that level of dialogue and
that level of trust meant I came into

00:15:07.724 --> 00:15:09.854
the meetings more prepared and he
came into the meetings more prepared.

00:15:10.145 --> 00:15:14.185
Ralph Grayson: Is good preparation
and good format, a function of good

00:15:14.185 --> 00:15:19.170
analysis, or is it a function of
good dynamic amongst the individuals?

00:15:19.918 --> 00:15:20.638
Dorothy Burwell: I think it's both.

00:15:20.888 --> 00:15:24.638
I don't want to leave you with the
impression that I think you can

00:15:24.638 --> 00:15:27.781
come in and just be really good with
people and be a great board member.

00:15:28.501 --> 00:15:29.581
I don't think that's the case.

00:15:29.581 --> 00:15:31.591
I think you do need to come
with the requisite technical

00:15:31.591 --> 00:15:34.471
expertise and analysis skill.

00:15:34.771 --> 00:15:38.121
A lot of the problems that we're dealing
with they are difficult by nature and

00:15:38.121 --> 00:15:41.361
so you do need people who have the
level of experience and who have seen

00:15:41.361 --> 00:15:45.651
some of the types of problems before in
order to be able to parse through them.

00:15:45.801 --> 00:15:48.801
But in the end, you also need to know that
you don't know everything and you're not

00:15:48.801 --> 00:15:53.061
always right and so it is a back and forth
with people who are living it day to day.

00:15:53.561 --> 00:15:56.771
Ralph Grayson: So I'd love
to get into this FGS report,

00:15:56.771 --> 00:15:58.061
which we referred to earlier.

00:15:58.361 --> 00:16:04.301
The core thesis, I think, is that
boards need adaptive capacity, as

00:16:04.301 --> 00:16:06.431
you've called it not just experience.

00:16:06.611 --> 00:16:10.751
But perhaps you can bring that to life
a little bit for us in terms of what

00:16:10.751 --> 00:16:12.251
was the purpose of writing the report?

00:16:12.251 --> 00:16:15.871
Anything particularly surprise you and
what were the conclusions you came to?

00:16:16.352 --> 00:16:20.602
Dorothy Burwell: Yeah, at the beginning
of every year we do a report called Radar

00:16:20.892 --> 00:16:24.792
and that looks at what's been happening in
the world over the past year and what do

00:16:24.792 --> 00:16:28.787
we think is going to happen in the coming
year, or what are the issues that business

00:16:28.787 --> 00:16:29.927
leaders are going to be wrestling with.

00:16:29.927 --> 00:16:33.567
So we speak to over 20,000 people around
the world, and then we speak to over

00:16:33.567 --> 00:16:38.927
200 business leaders, people who are
former heads of government secretaries of

00:16:38.927 --> 00:16:42.447
state, et cetera, as well as individuals
who are very senior in the media.

00:16:42.777 --> 00:16:46.077
And that forms a view of these are the
challenges that we're actually going to

00:16:46.077 --> 00:16:50.547
be wrestling with and we decided this
year that we actually wanted to take

00:16:50.547 --> 00:16:52.227
that to the boardroom very specifically.

00:16:52.227 --> 00:16:56.547
And so we did a follow up where we
spoke to board members in the US, in the

00:16:56.547 --> 00:17:02.147
UK, and across Europe as well as some
in Asia, to say, "Okay, what exactly

00:17:02.207 --> 00:17:04.247
is this prism that we're looking at?"

00:17:04.247 --> 00:17:07.937
And when I say the prism, we're
looking at a rise in nationalism.

00:17:07.937 --> 00:17:11.687
We're looking at AI and what does
that mean, not just for efficiency,

00:17:11.687 --> 00:17:15.227
but for business's role in
society and their responsibility.

00:17:15.287 --> 00:17:18.857
What does the rise in pessimism
across jurisdictions really

00:17:18.857 --> 00:17:21.477
mean for your business dynamics?

00:17:21.477 --> 00:17:26.220
So for example, one of the questions
that we asked was, do you think as

00:17:26.220 --> 00:17:30.030
a everyday citizen, the best years
in your country are ahead of you or

00:17:30.030 --> 00:17:32.610
behind you across every single country?

00:17:32.910 --> 00:17:36.930
The majority said behind them, even in
the US which is very optimistic nation.

00:17:37.420 --> 00:17:40.630
That says a lot about consumer
confidence, and it says a lot about your

00:17:40.630 --> 00:17:42.910
ability to plan and to deploy capital.

00:17:43.300 --> 00:17:46.820
We hadn't even gotten to the point
in which the Iran war has started but

00:17:46.820 --> 00:17:50.720
people were already also feeling the
pressure of never ending change and the

00:17:50.720 --> 00:17:54.727
cycle of political change that was also
making things a little bit unsteady.

00:17:55.227 --> 00:17:58.947
So when we spoke to board members
our curiosity was, what's actually

00:17:58.947 --> 00:18:01.930
going to make you successful and
what's made you successful up till

00:18:01.930 --> 00:18:06.310
now that you're going to continue to
employ in order for you to be able

00:18:06.310 --> 00:18:07.510
to manage through this environment?

00:18:07.780 --> 00:18:12.000
And through all of that, what we
concluded is that the best thing

00:18:12.000 --> 00:18:14.970
that boards need to be able to do is
not to be able to predict the future

00:18:15.360 --> 00:18:16.920
because things are changing too fast.

00:18:16.920 --> 00:18:20.700
It's about building adaptive capacity
so that you can deal with the

00:18:20.700 --> 00:18:22.440
emerging realities as they come.

00:18:22.940 --> 00:18:23.570
Ralph Grayson: So interesting.

00:18:23.570 --> 00:18:28.010
We did a recording with gentleman called
Nic Gowing who's a BBC journalist,

00:18:28.010 --> 00:18:32.060
but he's now doing a lot of thought
leadership around what he calls Thinking

00:18:32.060 --> 00:18:39.240
the Unthinkable and his core thesis is
all the reference points we've had for

00:18:39.240 --> 00:18:41.510
the last 50 years have now been moved.

00:18:41.760 --> 00:18:45.683
So everything that we've based
our assumptions on, are no

00:18:45.683 --> 00:18:47.933
longer relevant and valid.

00:18:48.413 --> 00:18:52.423
But perhaps most importantly, from
a human perspective, what he says is

00:18:52.633 --> 00:18:58.298
therefore the way we have to think
within a board context and ask questions

00:18:58.533 --> 00:19:03.993
that may be unpalatable uncomfortable,
and use judgement in that respect

00:19:04.323 --> 00:19:06.123
are becoming so much more profound.

00:19:06.553 --> 00:19:11.023
I'd love just to explore this adaptive
capacity, if I'm hearing you right.

00:19:11.138 --> 00:19:15.878
What you are saying there is how judgement
in a VUCA world, as a lot of people

00:19:15.878 --> 00:19:18.178
are labelling it now is preeminent.

00:19:18.495 --> 00:19:22.125
Dorothy Burwell: Yeah, so when we set
adapt to capacity, just to unpack it

00:19:22.125 --> 00:19:26.595
a bit, what we were saying is that
basically people in the boardroom

00:19:26.625 --> 00:19:32.095
need to be able to look at new
realities, new emerging realities.

00:19:32.095 --> 00:19:38.365
They need to be able to employ new skills
and they need to be able to both learn and

00:19:38.365 --> 00:19:44.515
unlearn, at the same time, in order to get
to new conclusions, about those realities.

00:19:44.515 --> 00:19:49.305
And when I say learn and unlearn all of us
come in with, and mostly in the boardroom,

00:19:49.305 --> 00:19:54.045
it'll be 30 plus years of experience that
you've had from your prior incarnations.

00:19:54.045 --> 00:19:57.555
But as you've just said, those
realities are not the same anymore.

00:19:57.775 --> 00:20:01.475
When I started out in work
there were no smartphones.

00:20:01.475 --> 00:20:04.945
Like there's just a very different
world that we're living in and so

00:20:05.335 --> 00:20:10.825
if that is your pretext, you very
much need to make sure that what

00:20:10.825 --> 00:20:14.935
you assume, or the assumptions that
you're making and you bring into the

00:20:14.935 --> 00:20:16.285
boardroom, are actually still valid.

00:20:16.285 --> 00:20:20.725
So can you challenge yourself in order
to say, "Okay, does this actually still

00:20:20.725 --> 00:20:23.755
work in the current context, or do I
actually need a completely new frame

00:20:23.755 --> 00:20:28.255
of mind in order to do that?" And those
who are able to do that best and able

00:20:28.255 --> 00:20:32.495
to make sure that they are keeping up
to date can and are willing to change

00:20:32.495 --> 00:20:34.265
their minds are going to be successful.

00:20:34.765 --> 00:20:36.115
Ralph Grayson: I love the duality of that.

00:20:36.355 --> 00:20:41.575
It seems to me it's not only what are
we thinking about now, but how are

00:20:41.575 --> 00:20:43.795
we thinking about it as a collective.

00:20:44.112 --> 00:20:48.792
So does that imply the traditional
governance model is no longer valid?

00:20:49.292 --> 00:20:50.492
Dorothy Burwell: I think
there's two parts to that.

00:20:50.532 --> 00:20:52.242
I'm not saying that boards are obsolete.

00:20:52.512 --> 00:20:54.642
I won't go that far, but I
do think that the way that

00:20:54.642 --> 00:20:56.382
boards operate needs to change.

00:20:56.802 --> 00:21:00.372
I think it can be, it can't
be episodic, as an example.

00:21:01.432 --> 00:21:04.912
I remember one of my very first mentors
when they were explaining to me about

00:21:04.912 --> 00:21:07.882
how boards work, and they said, oh, we
come together, and this was in the U.S.

00:21:08.152 --> 00:21:09.622
We come together four times a year.

00:21:09.622 --> 00:21:13.692
We kind of review everything and
we, make a few proclamations and

00:21:13.692 --> 00:21:16.862
we walk out and we are, we're not
seen for another three months that,

00:21:16.952 --> 00:21:18.242
that can't work like that anymore.

00:21:18.502 --> 00:21:22.402
Things are moving too quickly and the
decisions are too consequential in between

00:21:22.402 --> 00:21:27.202
meetings in order for you to govern
your own time in that way, or to see

00:21:27.202 --> 00:21:29.602
your responsibility as being periodic.

00:21:29.602 --> 00:21:33.962
Your responsibility is 12 months a
year and you need to be in contact with

00:21:33.962 --> 00:21:37.382
management much more frequently in order
to have the right information in order to

00:21:37.382 --> 00:21:39.872
be up to date so that you can be useful.

00:21:39.872 --> 00:21:43.622
So that you can help them through
decisions and you can't wait for backward

00:21:43.622 --> 00:21:45.752
looking reporting in order to do that.

00:21:46.252 --> 00:21:49.122
Ralph Grayson: Makes me think
about the cadence of a board.

00:21:49.242 --> 00:21:53.769
Everything's got a rhythm of vocabulary,
a culture, and from what you see

00:21:53.769 --> 00:21:58.428
from the outside is the cadence of
today's boardroom keeping up with

00:21:58.428 --> 00:22:00.678
the pace of that VUCA evolution.

00:22:00.968 --> 00:22:01.898
Dorothy Burwell: I don't think so.

00:22:02.038 --> 00:22:03.118
There's a certain logic to it.

00:22:03.348 --> 00:22:07.818
A lot of it is really around when we
report to market, that's what helps to

00:22:07.818 --> 00:22:09.978
govern when the board comes together.

00:22:09.978 --> 00:22:11.448
We need to review the
financial statements.

00:22:11.448 --> 00:22:13.428
We need to let everybody
know how we performed.

00:22:13.984 --> 00:22:14.824
It is what it is.

00:22:15.064 --> 00:22:18.574
And you can't report out to the
market every two weeks because

00:22:18.574 --> 00:22:19.954
that's just not how business works.

00:22:20.454 --> 00:22:25.126
However, I speak to board members all
the time and many of them who have

00:22:25.126 --> 00:22:29.416
very active boards say, "Oh gosh, I
have a meeting with my board every

00:22:29.416 --> 00:22:32.716
other week now." Ad hoc meetings
that are constantly in the diary, it

00:22:32.716 --> 00:22:35.266
becomes a little bit more unmanageable.

00:22:35.536 --> 00:22:38.476
And I think we're probably going to
need to get to a point in which those

00:22:38.686 --> 00:22:41.986
types of touch points become more
frequent and maybe the board meetings

00:22:41.986 --> 00:22:46.496
themselves becomes shorter because you've
actually dealt with some of the issues

00:22:46.796 --> 00:22:52.306
on a regular but more frequent basis
in order for us to be able to manage.

00:22:52.806 --> 00:22:56.996
Ralph Grayson: And how does a board
member listening to this recognise

00:22:57.266 --> 00:23:03.486
good IE How do they know they've got
this adaptive capacity in real life?

00:23:03.516 --> 00:23:06.066
What are the signals they should
be assessing themselves on?

00:23:06.066 --> 00:23:09.966
Or what does good look like when you walk
into a boardroom and say, this is a board

00:23:09.966 --> 00:23:13.742
with adaptive capacity, or it hasn't
got it, and what can we do about it?

00:23:13.752 --> 00:23:15.942
Dorothy Burwell: Yeah, so I think
boards should actually have a

00:23:15.942 --> 00:23:19.403
culture, of learning within the board.

00:23:19.669 --> 00:23:23.239
The idea that you need to continuously
learn is really important, and

00:23:23.239 --> 00:23:25.909
it should be encouraged by the
chair for all board members to

00:23:26.119 --> 00:23:27.289
make sure that they're up to date.

00:23:27.599 --> 00:23:32.019
I think the other thing is bringing
in people into the boardroom that

00:23:32.019 --> 00:23:33.279
are independent of management.

00:23:33.279 --> 00:23:35.859
Most of the information that you
get is always going to be filtered

00:23:35.859 --> 00:23:38.349
through the management lens, but
how do we know management is right?

00:23:38.749 --> 00:23:42.339
How do we know that we are giving
them that external viewpoint if

00:23:42.339 --> 00:23:46.509
we're not actually taking in external
views in a very strategic way?

00:23:46.509 --> 00:23:48.699
So I think that culture of
learning needs to be there.

00:23:48.999 --> 00:23:55.469
I also think that, if we think about
the different elements of learning and

00:23:55.469 --> 00:24:00.539
also how you actually engage with the
management team, it's how often do we

00:24:00.539 --> 00:24:05.459
actually work together to actually test
our decision frameworks to know that

00:24:05.459 --> 00:24:07.619
we're actually able to move at speed?

00:24:08.119 --> 00:24:11.029
Most management teams don't just
get stuck about the decision

00:24:11.059 --> 00:24:12.829
is how to make the decision.

00:24:13.129 --> 00:24:16.669
So if a crisis comes up and you need
to make a decision very quickly,

00:24:17.169 --> 00:24:20.209
do we actually know what roles
we're supposed to play and how

00:24:20.239 --> 00:24:21.739
we're actually supposed to execute?

00:24:21.989 --> 00:24:23.069
Sometimes we don't.

00:24:23.069 --> 00:24:26.359
I've sat on boards where people have
jumped in and said, "Okay, I'm going to

00:24:26.359 --> 00:24:29.359
roll up my sleeves. It's a crisis. I know
how to deal with this kind of crisis." And

00:24:29.359 --> 00:24:30.679
then now they're just getting in the way.

00:24:30.964 --> 00:24:34.114
We don't necessarily need everybody
to suit up and get back in the game.

00:24:34.384 --> 00:24:38.464
So being able to practise that and
work through that is going to be

00:24:38.464 --> 00:24:41.194
much more helpful to the management
team where everybody knows how

00:24:41.194 --> 00:24:44.734
they can be helpful before it
really arises or a crisis comes up.

00:24:45.254 --> 00:24:49.278
Ralph Grayson: And the boards
you see and advise are they

00:24:49.278 --> 00:24:50.688
worrying about the right things?

00:24:51.082 --> 00:24:54.562
Should AI be more of a
threat than geopolitics?

00:24:54.562 --> 00:24:57.412
Or we can come up with a multiplicity
of things that should be keeping

00:24:57.742 --> 00:25:00.942
people awake but are people cognizant
of what's going on around them?

00:25:01.442 --> 00:25:02.692
Dorothy Burwell: I think
people are cognizant.

00:25:02.692 --> 00:25:06.572
What they have trouble with is
prioritisation and that's what I was

00:25:06.572 --> 00:25:08.042
getting at with the decision framework.

00:25:08.042 --> 00:25:12.122
So the way that we look at it is it's a
little bit like emergency room medicine.

00:25:12.162 --> 00:25:15.312
When you come in, if you're dealing
with a mass casualty in an emergency

00:25:15.312 --> 00:25:19.472
room, you've got people coming into
the ER everyone's got an injury,

00:25:19.662 --> 00:25:23.613
everyone's bleeding and you have to
decide how you're going to treat them.

00:25:23.763 --> 00:25:26.433
The instinct is treat everyone who comes
in the door as soon as they get there.

00:25:26.433 --> 00:25:28.413
But if you do that, people will die.

00:25:28.716 --> 00:25:30.246
That can't be the way
that you approach it.

00:25:30.546 --> 00:25:35.076
Do the balance between severity of the
problem and the speed of escalation and

00:25:35.076 --> 00:25:40.846
decide in that way and by having that
sort of decision framework and matrix

00:25:40.946 --> 00:25:44.486
you're able to then decide how you help
management prioritise their time because

00:25:44.486 --> 00:25:48.026
we're limited on resources from a finance
perspective, from a time perspective,

00:25:48.146 --> 00:25:51.510
and from a body's perspective,
usually within every organisation.

00:25:52.010 --> 00:25:56.710
Ralph Grayson: I love in the report
that this idea of boardroom triage

00:25:56.960 --> 00:26:02.470
and the framework you suggest, that
is effectively an emergency medicine.

00:26:02.770 --> 00:26:09.960
So how do people adapt their
traditional board processes that are

00:26:09.960 --> 00:26:12.410
perhaps too slow for modern crisis?

00:26:12.410 --> 00:26:13.520
Where's the A&E here?

00:26:13.732 --> 00:26:14.152
Dorothy Burwell: Okay.

00:26:14.602 --> 00:26:19.125
So most boards go through their risk
register as a full board once a year.

00:26:19.755 --> 00:26:24.505
You may look at it a little bit more often
in the audit committee but the full board

00:26:24.505 --> 00:26:26.275
will look at it traditionally once a year.

00:26:26.785 --> 00:26:29.888
You put everything on heat map
and you say, "Okay, these are the

00:26:29.888 --> 00:26:32.798
really urgent ones" and they'll
be on the agenda very frequently.

00:26:33.218 --> 00:26:37.448
But we don't necessarily do the next
step of, "Okay, if something does come

00:26:37.448 --> 00:26:41.858
up, how do we actually decide based upon
the things that are on our agenda where

00:26:41.858 --> 00:26:43.568
it actually goes in a priority order?"

00:26:43.958 --> 00:26:48.648
So what we encourage people to
do is to go through this decision

00:26:48.648 --> 00:26:50.658
framework ahead of time and decide.

00:26:50.658 --> 00:26:54.598
So the first thing is thinking about
whether or not something is happening to

00:26:54.598 --> 00:26:57.478
everyone, or is it happening just to me?

00:26:57.728 --> 00:27:02.168
And is it something that's going
to happen gradually over time or

00:27:02.168 --> 00:27:05.468
is it something that is a sudden
shock and it's very much immediate?

00:27:05.798 --> 00:27:09.398
And by looking at it through that matrix,
you'll be able to understand where it

00:27:09.398 --> 00:27:12.968
goes in the priorities and whether or not
you need to monitor, you need to adapt,

00:27:13.148 --> 00:27:14.828
you need to react or you need to act.

00:27:15.248 --> 00:27:19.458
So if you are monitoring something,
for example, that's something

00:27:19.458 --> 00:27:21.978
that might be a gradual change
and it's affecting everybody.

00:27:21.978 --> 00:27:23.298
So I'm just going to keep an eye on it.

00:27:23.508 --> 00:27:28.058
So that's shifts in demographics, in
your particular country, we're not

00:27:28.058 --> 00:27:30.908
going to be able to really affect that
and everybody's going to be hit by it.

00:27:31.238 --> 00:27:36.368
But if it's something that's a gradual
change, but it affects me specifically, we

00:27:36.368 --> 00:27:38.258
might need to go ahead and adapt to that.

00:27:38.258 --> 00:27:43.208
So an example of that is you run
a coastal manufacturing chain and

00:27:43.208 --> 00:27:47.329
you're seeing climate change erode
some of the coastline where you are.

00:27:47.629 --> 00:27:48.739
That's very specific to you.

00:27:48.739 --> 00:27:51.769
You're going to have to do something
about it and plan for it right now.

00:27:52.249 --> 00:27:56.019
But you have some time versus if
it's a sudden change and it affects

00:27:56.019 --> 00:28:00.219
you specifically and that would be
there's an armed conflict and that's

00:28:00.219 --> 00:28:03.069
going to disrupt your supply chain
as many people are saying right now.

00:28:03.369 --> 00:28:05.139
That's something you need to
react to because you need to

00:28:05.139 --> 00:28:08.109
plan around it because you've got
orders that need to be fulfilled.

00:28:08.359 --> 00:28:12.259
Versus if you just need to act and
you have a little bit more time, it's

00:28:12.259 --> 00:28:16.149
a sudden change, but it's affecting
everybody and that's something like GenAI.

00:28:16.249 --> 00:28:17.569
We need to do something about it now.

00:28:17.569 --> 00:28:18.769
We need to be planning for it now.

00:28:18.769 --> 00:28:22.489
But we know that we're going to
be judged over years, not days.

00:28:22.969 --> 00:28:27.169
So once you are able to stick something
into that sort of priority matrix that

00:28:27.169 --> 00:28:29.809
helps you talk to management and say,
"Okay, this is something we need to

00:28:29.809 --> 00:28:33.379
react to, it's going to jump to the
front of the queue" versus this is

00:28:33.379 --> 00:28:36.919
something that can be number five or
six on your list versus everything

00:28:36.919 --> 00:28:38.239
else we prioritise for the year.

00:28:38.739 --> 00:28:39.309
Ralph Grayson: Fascinating.

00:28:39.309 --> 00:28:43.419
It segues beautifully into something
I talked to Helle Bank Jorgensen at

00:28:43.419 --> 00:28:47.209
Board Intelligence about recently cause
She was saying too many boards in her

00:28:47.209 --> 00:28:52.753
experience wait for perfect information
and they rely on information overload.

00:28:52.753 --> 00:28:55.573
So they get too much data and they can't
actually see the wood from the trees.

00:28:55.973 --> 00:28:59.783
But they also keep kicking it as a
long grass keeping that analogy going.

00:29:00.085 --> 00:29:02.939
So how do you model this if
you don't know what's coming?

00:29:03.439 --> 00:29:08.979
How can you model and practise before you
find yourself in that emergency triage?

00:29:09.479 --> 00:29:12.890
Dorothy Burwell: Yeah, I wouldn't go
so far to say model because you're not

00:29:12.890 --> 00:29:14.960
necessarily looking at numbers per se.

00:29:14.960 --> 00:29:16.790
We're looking at how you make decisions.

00:29:16.790 --> 00:29:19.190
So what are the factors that are at play?

00:29:19.440 --> 00:29:23.430
And then you go ahead and say, "Okay,
we're going to run a simulation." So if

00:29:23.430 --> 00:29:27.510
we want to understand what disruption
at our biggest manufacturing plan is

00:29:27.510 --> 00:29:31.260
going to be like, it's not necessarily
that we need to know every single dollar

00:29:31.260 --> 00:29:34.320
and cent, but we need to know how we're
going to make a decision when that thing

00:29:34.320 --> 00:29:39.570
happens and we need to know what role each
person's going to play in that process.

00:29:40.410 --> 00:29:42.990
If we're going to have this
disruption, who's actually dealing

00:29:42.990 --> 00:29:44.220
with the government about this?

00:29:44.250 --> 00:29:46.603
Because there's going to be some
sort of on the ground response

00:29:46.603 --> 00:29:48.593
that needs to be taken care of.

00:29:48.803 --> 00:29:52.223
Who's actually running things
at the local operation?

00:29:52.403 --> 00:29:54.473
Who's dealing with the local communities?

00:29:54.653 --> 00:29:57.083
Who's dealing with the shareholders?

00:29:57.323 --> 00:30:01.263
All of those things need to be taken
care of and management is going

00:30:01.263 --> 00:30:04.833
to be most concerned about getting
the operation back up and running.

00:30:05.013 --> 00:30:06.303
So what is the board doing?

00:30:06.423 --> 00:30:09.213
Is the board asking 20 questions
and slowing them down and

00:30:09.213 --> 00:30:10.653
actually getting to the response?

00:30:10.833 --> 00:30:14.643
Or is the board fulfilling a useful
purpose that frees them up to be able to

00:30:14.643 --> 00:30:16.113
do the things that are mission critical?

00:30:16.293 --> 00:30:19.353
And I think that is really
helpful for people to understand.

00:30:19.353 --> 00:30:22.113
So no one's stepping on each other's
toes or just getting in the way.

00:30:22.613 --> 00:30:24.803
Ralph Grayson: Yeah, I love the
idea of that command and control.

00:30:24.863 --> 00:30:29.953
Why do so many boards, certainly
according to external perception,

00:30:29.953 --> 00:30:33.988
confuse activity with effective
decision making in that respect?

00:30:34.488 --> 00:30:37.008
Dorothy Burwell: Think we're getting
back to the human behaviour piece.

00:30:37.398 --> 00:30:38.988
We all want to be useful, right?

00:30:39.378 --> 00:30:44.438
And I think people will say, "Okay,
I'm going to be on the hook for if

00:30:44.438 --> 00:30:47.558
a shareholder comes and says, what
were you doing?" You need to be able

00:30:47.558 --> 00:30:49.411
to say what questions did you ask.

00:30:49.601 --> 00:30:50.891
How you got involved.

00:30:51.211 --> 00:30:54.811
What you actually encourage management
to do is if you think about some of

00:30:54.811 --> 00:30:59.771
the crises that we've seen at operating
businesses for example, if you think about

00:30:59.771 --> 00:31:02.071
Boeing it's a very unfortunate situation.

00:31:02.071 --> 00:31:03.901
The board got sued in that situation.

00:31:03.901 --> 00:31:06.391
I'm not making a judgement
either way on what happened

00:31:06.391 --> 00:31:07.681
cause I wasn't in that boardroom.

00:31:08.041 --> 00:31:12.381
But I'm sure that they've been asked,
"What did you do? How did you push

00:31:12.381 --> 00:31:16.011
management? How are you involved?"
So I think that spectre of that type

00:31:16.011 --> 00:31:21.791
of scrutiny is what pushes people
to really try to play positions that

00:31:21.971 --> 00:31:23.381
actually shouldn't be owned by them.

00:31:23.621 --> 00:31:26.878
Most of the things, by the time you get
to that crisis point, are factors that you

00:31:26.878 --> 00:31:29.638
should have been dealing with beforehand
because you should have had better

00:31:29.638 --> 00:31:34.508
information in order for you to be able
to say what we need to do at this point.

00:31:34.508 --> 00:31:37.298
Not try to go back and
redo history in real time.

00:31:37.798 --> 00:31:40.128
Ralph Grayson: And everybody talks
about the importance of the chair-CEO

00:31:40.258 --> 00:31:41.758
relationship in that respect.

00:31:41.758 --> 00:31:44.578
But I'd like just take that back
a level and just look at the

00:31:45.061 --> 00:31:47.551
overall psychology and trust.

00:31:47.761 --> 00:31:52.061
It's something in the report, or certainly
some FGS research I've seen, talks about

00:31:52.061 --> 00:31:54.451
tight, loose coupling as a framework.

00:31:54.861 --> 00:31:56.171
Just bring that to life for us a bit.

00:31:56.609 --> 00:31:59.089
Dorothy Burwell: Yeah, the tension
between the chair and the CEO.

00:31:59.089 --> 00:32:03.709
The CEO needs to feel that they have
the confidence and the backing of the

00:32:03.709 --> 00:32:09.199
board in order for them to do their
job and to manage their executive team

00:32:09.199 --> 00:32:10.849
and to push forward with strategy.

00:32:11.159 --> 00:32:17.249
They want to be able to look at the board
as wise counsellors but not as people who

00:32:17.279 --> 00:32:20.549
are coming in to force their own agendas.

00:32:20.789 --> 00:32:27.119
And I think between a chair and a CEO,
and I've been through two recent CEO

00:32:27.119 --> 00:32:32.429
changes or in the midst of of them, making
sure that the CEO can come to the chair

00:32:32.429 --> 00:32:37.169
and say, "These are the things that I
believe are the priorities" and the chair

00:32:37.169 --> 00:32:40.259
can equally say, "These are things that
I think are the priorities" and they

00:32:40.259 --> 00:32:45.179
can come together, agree on those, and
then let the CEO go and work on them,

00:32:45.299 --> 00:32:49.049
and then periodically come together to
say, "where are we in this journey?"

00:32:49.229 --> 00:32:51.779
I think that is the ideal scenario.

00:32:52.109 --> 00:32:57.755
What you can find, when you have a chair
who feels under pressure from shareholders

00:32:57.755 --> 00:33:02.525
or otherwise, is they may be a little
bit more heavy handed and then you

00:33:02.525 --> 00:33:06.665
find you have a CEO who's a little bit
more reticent to give over information

00:33:06.665 --> 00:33:11.655
and that breakdown is something that
can make a board nervous that they're

00:33:11.655 --> 00:33:12.975
not getting enough information.

00:33:12.975 --> 00:33:16.235
You're management team becomes even
more reticent to bring things that don't

00:33:16.235 --> 00:33:20.595
seem to be fully baked because they're
getting too much accusatory questioning.

00:33:21.075 --> 00:33:25.875
I heard from one CEO previously that
they felt like they were being audited

00:33:25.995 --> 00:33:29.235
every time they came into a board meeting
and that's not a really good feeling.

00:33:29.565 --> 00:33:30.735
That's a really bad feeling.

00:33:30.885 --> 00:33:32.915
You don't want to feel like
you're under a microscope.

00:33:33.125 --> 00:33:37.735
You want to feel like you are coming
in and workshopping with people

00:33:38.265 --> 00:33:39.735
and sometimes it will be reporting.

00:33:40.065 --> 00:33:45.755
But that is a better environment
and ecosystem within the boardroom

00:33:46.025 --> 00:33:48.725
and a more constructive ecosystem
than it is for people to feel

00:33:48.725 --> 00:33:50.645
like they're sitting on the stand.

00:33:51.145 --> 00:33:52.045
Ralph Grayson: Makes a lot of sense.

00:33:52.045 --> 00:33:56.225
I sent a panel recently and there was
a CEO he used the expression of the

00:33:56.225 --> 00:34:01.635
board as a thought partner, rather than
an overseer, and I thought that was

00:34:01.635 --> 00:34:05.505
so interesting cause he reframed this
whole idea of the role of the board

00:34:05.505 --> 00:34:10.915
to be foresight, insight, oversight,
and he said we got to move away from

00:34:10.915 --> 00:34:16.255
this oversight, this box ticking to
be much more in the current crisis

00:34:16.315 --> 00:34:17.965
era that we're in at the moment.

00:34:18.385 --> 00:34:21.415
The board there as an ally
rather than as a prefect.

00:34:21.589 --> 00:34:22.569
Dorothy Burwell: I agree with that.

00:34:22.659 --> 00:34:23.949
I'm going to go off piece a little bit.

00:34:23.949 --> 00:34:28.422
I think I sit on a board in the UK and I
sit on a board in the US and the models

00:34:28.422 --> 00:34:30.012
and the responsibilities are different.

00:34:30.132 --> 00:34:32.742
And so you end up with different
behaviours, for example.

00:34:32.922 --> 00:34:37.662
So in the UK we really pride ourselves
on having fantastic corporate governance

00:34:37.662 --> 00:34:43.272
standards and I think that I learn
more and I'm more active in the UK.

00:34:43.572 --> 00:34:50.792
But what that encourages, for some people,
is that they become a little bit too

00:34:50.852 --> 00:34:53.072
involved, a little bit too heavy handed.

00:34:53.585 --> 00:34:57.505
Therefore that's how you end up
with this interference situation.

00:34:57.745 --> 00:35:01.885
And I think what we want is for people
to understand that even though the

00:35:01.885 --> 00:35:04.855
code says that we're responsible
for strategy on a day-to-day basis,

00:35:04.855 --> 00:35:06.385
we don't execute the strategy.

00:35:06.685 --> 00:35:09.715
So therefore we need to take
responsibility for the decision making

00:35:09.715 --> 00:35:11.275
process, but then be able to let go.

00:35:11.775 --> 00:35:16.475
Ralph Grayson: So how does a good board
balance that duty of accountability to

00:35:16.475 --> 00:35:22.855
the stakeholders with that safe space
where everybody is free to talk about

00:35:22.855 --> 00:35:28.085
everything and, I presume, that should
lead to better upward information

00:35:28.085 --> 00:35:29.765
from the executive to the board.

00:35:30.265 --> 00:35:33.715
But it seems to me that isn't
happening in an uncertain world

00:35:33.715 --> 00:35:34.745
as much as it probably should be.

00:35:35.245 --> 00:35:35.695
Dorothy Burwell: Yeah.

00:35:35.999 --> 00:35:36.719
It's a tricky one.

00:35:36.719 --> 00:35:40.199
I won't say that there's some silver
bullet or a single right answer.

00:35:40.699 --> 00:35:44.179
I think some of it is taking the
discussions outside of the boardroom

00:35:44.679 --> 00:35:46.179
so it doesn't feel so pressured.

00:35:46.179 --> 00:35:48.309
There's a pressure to perform
when you're in the boardroom

00:35:48.309 --> 00:35:49.389
as a management team member.

00:35:49.719 --> 00:35:54.209
So you need to take some of the discussion
out so that people feel a little bit

00:35:54.209 --> 00:35:58.119
more comfortable, like they're having
a one-to-one conversation and able to

00:35:58.119 --> 00:36:01.269
say, "Okay, this is the thing that I'm
thinking about bringing to the board.

00:36:01.299 --> 00:36:06.745
How might we go about it?" And therefore
you've already set the scene, so to speak,

00:36:06.975 --> 00:36:11.786
that allows people to either unpick within
a committee meeting and then come to

00:36:11.786 --> 00:36:17.016
the board and report how that decision
process unfolded, or unpick it before

00:36:17.016 --> 00:36:20.076
the board meeting at least, and then say,
this is how we're going to go about it.

00:36:20.316 --> 00:36:24.546
But I think that helps people instead of
just coming in and trying to do it cold.

00:36:25.046 --> 00:36:28.646
Ralph Grayson: So when the proverbial
hits the fan, what goes wrong first?

00:36:28.646 --> 00:36:32.331
The process, the trust or
the clarity of the data?

00:36:33.011 --> 00:36:36.241
Dorothy Burwell: The trust is the first
thing to go, most definitely, because

00:36:36.241 --> 00:36:40.931
people come in and then question the
process and say "What broke down?"

00:36:40.931 --> 00:36:43.661
If they believed in the process in
the first place, they say "What broke

00:36:43.661 --> 00:36:48.081
down?" and "Who didn't follow the
process that we agreed?" Or "Who didn't

00:36:48.081 --> 00:36:51.471
give me the correct data?" So all of
that is really circling around trust.

00:36:51.998 --> 00:36:55.268
Once you get into a situation in which
the trust is broken down, then you get

00:36:55.268 --> 00:36:59.231
into people going around the process and
thinking they need to shortcut in order to

00:36:59.231 --> 00:37:04.341
get to the answer and then pulling out the
data that really runs across all of it.

00:37:04.341 --> 00:37:08.044
So you either didn't have the right
data in the beginning or the system is

00:37:08.044 --> 00:37:11.854
not able to produce data fast enough in
order to deal with the current situation.

00:37:12.354 --> 00:37:15.234
Ralph Grayson: So how does a
good board balance speed against

00:37:15.324 --> 00:37:16.644
verification in that respect?

00:37:16.944 --> 00:37:20.251
Dorothy Burwell: So really that
goes back to my point around

00:37:20.251 --> 00:37:25.401
needing to have the decision making
protocol practised in advance.

00:37:25.701 --> 00:37:31.281
So generally when we think about and
this is very true in the AI era because

00:37:31.281 --> 00:37:37.401
things move quite quickly in this guise
is we really need to know what are

00:37:37.401 --> 00:37:42.021
the agreed questions that we baseline
need to answer and we've already

00:37:42.021 --> 00:37:46.461
identified them and then we need to
have practised some of these one in 1000

00:37:46.461 --> 00:37:48.771
scenarios or one in a million scenarios.

00:37:49.268 --> 00:37:51.728
Let's think about M&S
and the cyber crisis.

00:37:51.818 --> 00:37:53.198
We didn't know that was going to happen.

00:37:53.448 --> 00:37:57.378
And I can't necessarily say, partly
because I wasn't in the room, but

00:37:57.478 --> 00:38:00.868
looking at a lot of other businesses
that others would've been able to

00:38:00.868 --> 00:38:04.088
adapt any faster than M&S was able to.

00:38:04.488 --> 00:38:08.538
A lot of that really has to do with,
we didn't actually model that scenario.

00:38:08.538 --> 00:38:11.388
We didn't actually practise this
scenario in order for us to know, "Okay,

00:38:11.388 --> 00:38:15.738
we're going to need to be able to run
a store without access to our systems

00:38:15.738 --> 00:38:19.698
for a certain amount of time." So all
of that needs to be discussed at some

00:38:19.698 --> 00:38:23.828
point and in on somebody's list of
things that we need to be prepared for.

00:38:24.328 --> 00:38:27.988
Ralph Grayson: So where does AI
fit in that speed verification

00:38:27.988 --> 00:38:29.758
modelling, master or servant?

00:38:30.258 --> 00:38:32.148
Dorothy Burwell: I think it's
a little bit of both actually.

00:38:32.458 --> 00:38:36.971
If I just give you a couple of stats
AI powered fraud, it's estimated

00:38:36.971 --> 00:38:42.551
that's going to cost the business
community 40 billion by 2027.

00:38:42.581 --> 00:38:43.541
That's only next year.

00:38:44.021 --> 00:38:47.701
That is a hell of a lot of money
and only one in three executives

00:38:47.701 --> 00:38:51.151
think they're actually prepared
for AI related fraud today.

00:38:51.651 --> 00:38:58.101
I think the last thing I saw or that we
found in our own research is that only

00:38:58.341 --> 00:39:03.448
just above 50% of the time people can
really identify something that's been

00:39:03.448 --> 00:39:08.388
generated by AI versus something that's
been genuinely created by human hands.

00:39:08.813 --> 00:39:13.983
So I think AI is going to fuel a lot of
what people need to be able to respond to.

00:39:14.283 --> 00:39:19.063
I think in order for us to deal with that
we need to one, understand how to use AI

00:39:19.063 --> 00:39:22.903
to speed up those verification protocols,
but also what is the human element of it?

00:39:23.023 --> 00:39:25.063
How do we as humans make decisions?

00:39:25.298 --> 00:39:30.938
And if we can't get to a person to verify
who is outside of that loop that has a

00:39:30.938 --> 00:39:35.798
protocol already in place that can be
enacted in that particular scenario.

00:39:36.298 --> 00:39:38.848
Ralph Grayson: Are there board
members who are no longer fit for

00:39:38.848 --> 00:39:41.723
purpose because they can't get their
heads around the application of AI?

00:39:42.223 --> 00:39:44.713
Dorothy Burwell: I would like to
optimistically say that we can all learn

00:39:45.113 --> 00:39:49.603
but there probably are board members who
are not as current as they need to be.

00:39:50.283 --> 00:39:51.663
Let's call a spade, a spade.

00:39:52.103 --> 00:39:56.753
So if you are not actually willing
to use a AI in your day-to-day life.

00:39:57.003 --> 00:40:00.800
If you haven't actually looked at the
applications for the business that

00:40:00.800 --> 00:40:02.510
you're involved in, you are behind.

00:40:02.930 --> 00:40:05.330
So you really need to be able to do that.

00:40:05.330 --> 00:40:09.020
And some people will say, "Oh, I
need to get an AI director." One,

00:40:09.170 --> 00:40:10.670
it's not one person's responsibility.

00:40:10.940 --> 00:40:12.140
I really don't believe in that.

00:40:12.140 --> 00:40:15.230
And two, you don't want somebody
who's just sitting in the one silo

00:40:15.230 --> 00:40:17.030
in which an AI question has come up.

00:40:17.150 --> 00:40:18.290
Maybe they can answer it.

00:40:18.800 --> 00:40:23.060
You want everyone to be able to understand
that this is the way of life now.

00:40:23.270 --> 00:40:26.510
This is how businesses are operating,
and so therefore this is a tool

00:40:26.510 --> 00:40:29.960
that needs to be within my toolkit
if I'm going to be credible at all.

00:40:30.500 --> 00:40:34.354
Ralph Grayson: Love to just widen that a
little bit to just get your understanding

00:40:34.354 --> 00:40:39.967
or your, thoughts on succession planning,
onboarding, training, and development.

00:40:40.267 --> 00:40:43.687
Do you have a particular view from your
experience of what works well, what

00:40:43.687 --> 00:40:46.987
doesn't work well, where you've seen
it be effective and less effective?

00:40:48.077 --> 00:40:50.074
Dorothy Burwell: In succession
planning, and as I've just said,

00:40:50.074 --> 00:40:54.864
I don't think that you just add a
technological director to your board.

00:40:54.864 --> 00:40:58.657
I do think that you need to be thinking
whose current and I think this other

00:40:58.657 --> 00:41:02.527
part of it is making sure that you have
a ongoing education programme, in order

00:41:02.527 --> 00:41:03.967
to make sure people are up to speed.

00:41:03.967 --> 00:41:07.267
So whether that's your annual
strategy day, making sure that

00:41:07.267 --> 00:41:08.707
people know what they're doing.

00:41:08.707 --> 00:41:12.317
Whether that's at each board meeting
or a couple of board meetings a year,

00:41:12.317 --> 00:41:16.187
bringing in an external advisor or an
external expert who can come in and

00:41:16.187 --> 00:41:21.017
really help you get up to speed or
workshop with you on a specific issue.

00:41:21.257 --> 00:41:24.617
I've had in board meetings where we
brought in a professor who's done deep

00:41:24.647 --> 00:41:27.737
research in a specific area where we're
looking at changing the business model

00:41:27.887 --> 00:41:31.547
and they just talked with us about
the particular conundrum and walked us

00:41:31.547 --> 00:41:34.577
through, this is what they've seen in
their research and this is what's emerging

00:41:34.757 --> 00:41:38.221
in emerging research right now and that
opened the eyes to many of the directors

00:41:38.221 --> 00:41:42.451
who just either didn't come from industry
or were retired and don't get to have

00:41:42.451 --> 00:41:43.951
that dialogue on a day-to-day basis.

00:41:43.951 --> 00:41:48.431
I think that's really what's required
and then there's also making sure you're

00:41:48.431 --> 00:41:51.611
having a little bit more frequent contact
with management when there are things

00:41:51.611 --> 00:41:53.141
that are very specific to the business.

00:41:53.641 --> 00:41:55.591
Ralph Grayson: What I find very
interesting at the moment is our

00:41:55.591 --> 00:41:59.701
coaching team are doing more and more
work with NEDs as opposed to executives

00:42:00.201 --> 00:42:01.401
and there's a real trend here.

00:42:01.401 --> 00:42:03.381
I'd love to do some more
statistical work around it.

00:42:03.731 --> 00:42:08.741
But more and more NEDs, I think, are now
saying, "I need to look in the mirror to

00:42:08.741 --> 00:42:13.361
see where I can really lead and how I add
most value in this really changing world."

00:42:13.781 --> 00:42:18.381
Any perceptions you've seen on just
coaching as a tool that a board member

00:42:18.381 --> 00:42:20.451
can use to get the best out of themselves?

00:42:20.701 --> 00:42:21.181
Dorothy Burwell: Yeah.

00:42:21.250 --> 00:42:25.117
I've had coaches in my life and most
of the time what the coach is focusing

00:42:25.117 --> 00:42:26.947
on is how you show up as a leader.

00:42:27.247 --> 00:42:28.897
You're a different kind of
leader when you're on the board.

00:42:29.227 --> 00:42:34.897
So developing a leadership skill
that doesn't require you to check

00:42:34.897 --> 00:42:39.987
in daily, but encourages people to
want to come to you is actually a

00:42:39.987 --> 00:42:41.637
new skill that you need to bring in.

00:42:41.982 --> 00:42:46.542
That level of coaching is really useful
in order for it to feel as if there's

00:42:46.542 --> 00:42:51.712
some demand for you, as opposed to you
pushing and trying to get in the door.

00:42:52.092 --> 00:42:54.962
It's a very frustrating place for
a lot of boards where they feel

00:42:54.962 --> 00:42:57.612
like they're not getting what
they need to be able to be useful.

00:42:57.622 --> 00:43:00.212
So you need to cultivate
that type of relationship.

00:43:00.712 --> 00:43:01.402
Ralph Grayson: Fascinating.

00:43:01.902 --> 00:43:05.202
Let's bring that to life when it
comes to that crisis management, which

00:43:05.202 --> 00:43:08.222
FGS are often called in a lot on.

00:43:08.446 --> 00:43:13.586
What changes when suddenly there's
an activist or an event has happened

00:43:13.586 --> 00:43:17.956
which means the board is thinking not
just about its future strategy, but

00:43:17.956 --> 00:43:22.160
either its legitimacy or its action
at this particular moment in point.

00:43:22.660 --> 00:43:27.606
Dorothy Burwell: Yeah, so when I think
about accountability versus legitimacy.

00:43:28.066 --> 00:43:35.876
The board is accountable to a very wide
aperture or list of stakeholders and a

00:43:35.876 --> 00:43:40.466
lot of times it comes through the activist
lens because someone who isn't a classic

00:43:40.466 --> 00:43:44.456
shareholder has decided to get a share
in a business or a set of shares in the

00:43:44.456 --> 00:43:48.686
business in order to make sure that their
list of issues is able to come to the

00:43:48.686 --> 00:43:50.786
fore and that can turn into activism.

00:43:51.500 --> 00:43:55.700
And we've seen a lot of this where climate
activists will get shares in a business

00:43:55.700 --> 00:43:58.770
in order to make sure that they can put
forward proposals to make sure that you

00:43:58.770 --> 00:44:00.870
are not polluting the water, et cetera.

00:44:01.200 --> 00:44:04.170
That means you as a board member,
that they could use that tool to

00:44:04.170 --> 00:44:06.870
say, we're going to vote off the
head of this committee, are going

00:44:06.870 --> 00:44:08.100
to vote off this other person.

00:44:08.175 --> 00:44:10.950
So as a board member, what I'm
thinking in the back of my mind

00:44:11.010 --> 00:44:15.030
and when I'm reading my papers is
how are we addressing these issues?

00:44:15.250 --> 00:44:17.920
And one, you need to know that
those issues are going to come up.

00:44:18.230 --> 00:44:21.480
And two if you don't know that
those issues are going to come up,

00:44:21.480 --> 00:44:24.240
you need to know how to work with
management to be able to address them

00:44:24.750 --> 00:44:26.460
before it ends up on the AGM floor.

00:44:26.850 --> 00:44:31.710
So I do think that makes board members
have to be a, little bit more up to speed

00:44:31.710 --> 00:44:35.880
on fringe issues that don't necessarily
hit the balance sheet and the P&L.

00:44:36.380 --> 00:44:39.140
Ralph Grayson: So that's
the event driven side.

00:44:39.140 --> 00:44:41.210
Let's just turn that more proactively.

00:44:41.460 --> 00:44:45.270
What's the FGS playbook or your
advice to a board in terms of its

00:44:45.330 --> 00:44:51.750
reputational management of identifying
with particular issues, how you align

00:44:51.750 --> 00:44:56.880
mission and purpose with statement
in the media or in the press?

00:44:57.090 --> 00:45:00.470
Dorothy Burwell: Yeah, so the
board isn't the mouthpiece of the

00:45:00.470 --> 00:45:02.480
organisation and it shouldn't be.

00:45:02.930 --> 00:45:07.730
But we do need to make sure that
what the CEO says is actually backed

00:45:07.730 --> 00:45:10.340
up with the process that's actually
happening in the business and we

00:45:10.340 --> 00:45:11.570
need to pay attention to that.

00:45:11.600 --> 00:45:15.810
We need to be alive to it and more than
just when we get to the annual report,

00:45:15.810 --> 00:45:17.070
but actually throughout the year.

00:45:17.570 --> 00:45:21.730
I think the other thing is to
think about where it is that you're

00:45:21.730 --> 00:45:23.530
actually able to engage in between.

00:45:24.480 --> 00:45:28.750
So not in the live scenario, but
beforehand in order to be able to

00:45:28.810 --> 00:45:32.710
manage that and manage the reputation
of the business to avoid it.

00:45:32.710 --> 00:45:36.686
So some people may have great
government connections because of the

00:45:36.686 --> 00:45:39.596
virtue of their past incarnations.

00:45:39.596 --> 00:45:40.976
You'll be able to leverage those.

00:45:41.186 --> 00:45:44.336
But in a crisis scenario, you'll need to
be able to pull on those relationships

00:45:44.336 --> 00:45:47.576
and pull on all those strings in order
to make sure that the business comes

00:45:47.636 --> 00:45:49.496
out the other side with minimal damage.

00:45:49.996 --> 00:45:54.566
Ralph Grayson: So just before we leave
the activist discussion I'm fascinated to

00:45:54.566 --> 00:45:57.536
know when does FGS typically get mandated?

00:45:57.896 --> 00:46:02.296
Is there an FGS playbook insofar
as you can protect confidentiality?

00:46:02.546 --> 00:46:04.646
Are there a couple of case
studies you might just talk about?

00:46:04.750 --> 00:46:06.900
Dorothy Burwell: Sure I'll talk
about a couple that are public

00:46:06.900 --> 00:46:08.650
knowledge that they'll make it easy.

00:46:08.890 --> 00:46:12.740
I think the first thing is not
activists, every activist, comes

00:46:12.740 --> 00:46:14.930
across or shaped in the same.

00:46:15.214 --> 00:46:16.624
Let's take contentious votes.

00:46:16.624 --> 00:46:20.404
So let's broaden the aperture, not
just a activist campaign, but when

00:46:20.404 --> 00:46:23.674
we're actually helping a board,
when they're dealing with potential

00:46:23.674 --> 00:46:26.224
no votes or alternative proposals.

00:46:26.254 --> 00:46:28.714
Tesla is one big example
that we had last year.

00:46:29.224 --> 00:46:33.094
There was a lot of controversy around Elon
Musk pay that actually turned into a lot

00:46:33.094 --> 00:46:37.474
of proposals and a lot of recommendations
to vote against the director specifically,

00:46:37.474 --> 00:46:39.364
as well as many other things.

00:46:39.804 --> 00:46:45.094
And so with us getting involved, a lot of
what we did was look at how do we actually

00:46:45.094 --> 00:46:48.754
need to get to the voters, but also
what does the board need to do in order

00:46:48.754 --> 00:46:50.374
to deal with the various stakeholders?

00:46:50.374 --> 00:46:54.124
So we're trying to minimise the
amount of blow back that we're getting

00:46:54.184 --> 00:46:56.704
publicly from various counter voices.

00:46:56.914 --> 00:47:01.174
We're making sure that the shareholders
have actually met the board members,

00:47:01.174 --> 00:47:04.084
looked in the whites of their eyes,
and the board members importantly

00:47:04.294 --> 00:47:07.864
know what to say to reassure them that
they've got their hands on the wheel.

00:47:08.124 --> 00:47:11.184
We're also thinking about, okay, what's
the composition of the shareholder base?

00:47:11.364 --> 00:47:12.924
It's not just institutions.

00:47:12.924 --> 00:47:16.954
In Tesla's case, they actually had a
lot of individual shareholders, which

00:47:16.954 --> 00:47:18.484
are historically very difficult to get.

00:47:18.814 --> 00:47:21.814
That's a big change from what we're
used to and we'll probably see a little

00:47:21.814 --> 00:47:25.624
bit more of this coming to the UK
where you're going out to retail and

00:47:25.624 --> 00:47:29.784
it's designing a campaign that's very
targeted that to get to shareholder

00:47:29.814 --> 00:47:32.634
A, B, and C, wherever they are.

00:47:32.784 --> 00:47:36.684
So it's a very concerted effort and
communications effort to convince people

00:47:36.684 --> 00:47:40.164
to vote for things that they may not
actually be on their radar day to day.

00:47:40.434 --> 00:47:44.184
So I think it's changed a lot
the way that we think about how

00:47:44.184 --> 00:47:46.284
activism can play out in the public.

00:47:46.674 --> 00:47:50.344
Also, I think the other thing is that
activists have gotten smart and they don't

00:47:50.344 --> 00:47:54.574
just come and put forward proposals, they
actually get your shareholders on side.

00:47:54.574 --> 00:47:59.954
So a lot of what we do is actually pre
getting to an AGM or an EGM, how do we

00:47:59.954 --> 00:48:04.274
actually support the chair or support
the individual board directors in making

00:48:04.274 --> 00:48:08.794
sure that they actually can take command
of shareholder meetings and not just

00:48:08.794 --> 00:48:11.704
leave it over to the management team
because ultimately the vote is about them.

00:48:11.854 --> 00:48:15.304
The vote isn't necessarily for
the COO or someone else who

00:48:15.304 --> 00:48:16.564
might be sitting alongside you.

00:48:17.064 --> 00:48:17.874
Ralph Grayson: So interesting.

00:48:18.054 --> 00:48:23.314
So investment trusts, we've seen a lot of
activist influence there in what has been

00:48:23.314 --> 00:48:27.444
traditionally a very staid environment
and where I think most people I know

00:48:27.444 --> 00:48:30.804
who've joined the board of an investment
trust haven't quite expected suddenly

00:48:30.804 --> 00:48:34.674
see an activist on the share register is
a and that's got a particular reference

00:48:34.674 --> 00:48:37.504
to now engagement with retail investors.

00:48:37.784 --> 00:48:40.304
Is there something there in,
in the FGS playbook that would

00:48:40.304 --> 00:48:41.264
address some of those issues?

00:48:41.446 --> 00:48:44.756
Dorothy Burwell: I think it'll be very
similar in the investment trust space.

00:48:44.796 --> 00:48:48.366
They've been in their unfortunate
position in that the entire

00:48:48.646 --> 00:48:50.536
segment has been undervalued.

00:48:50.536 --> 00:48:52.156
So that's what's made them vulnerable.

00:48:52.156 --> 00:48:56.566
I think that the one thing that we have
said is that we need to make sure that

00:48:56.566 --> 00:48:58.306
we can keep things out of the public.

00:48:58.586 --> 00:49:03.801
We had another big notable activist
in the US in which the playbook

00:49:03.801 --> 00:49:06.531
that we use there is very useful
and that was with Southwest.

00:49:06.831 --> 00:49:09.651
A lot of times the activists
want something that you can

00:49:09.651 --> 00:49:11.001
deal with behind the scenes.

00:49:11.241 --> 00:49:14.841
And so how do you actually deal with your
external stakeholders and come up with

00:49:14.841 --> 00:49:18.741
a plan for them while actually dealing
with the substance so that you actually

00:49:18.741 --> 00:49:20.781
don't actually get to vote in the end?

00:49:20.781 --> 00:49:24.681
And that's how we dealt with it in that
case where they originally said they

00:49:24.681 --> 00:49:27.381
wanted to remove the CEO, they wanted
to remove the chair, they wanted to

00:49:27.381 --> 00:49:28.971
remove several of the board directors.

00:49:29.271 --> 00:49:32.811
We were able to get to a good
outcome in which the majority of the

00:49:32.811 --> 00:49:34.581
board members stayed on the board.

00:49:34.611 --> 00:49:36.801
They kept the power seats on the board.

00:49:36.801 --> 00:49:39.291
The committee chairmanships, the
chairmanship of the board, and the CEO

00:49:39.291 --> 00:49:44.345
kept their seat as well, because we
were able to work with them around the

00:49:44.345 --> 00:49:49.055
negotiations and buy them some time to get
to a place that was best for all parties.

00:49:49.535 --> 00:49:55.085
Ralph Grayson: Were there signals in the
BP AGM in terms of the number of people

00:49:55.085 --> 00:50:00.125
who voted against the appointment of
the chair that should have raised flags

00:50:00.395 --> 00:50:05.365
to see what then happened in terms of
the replacement of the chair and other

00:50:05.365 --> 00:50:09.325
examples in perhaps in that case study
that you might take to your clients at

00:50:09.325 --> 00:50:11.665
FGS and say, you can learn from this.

00:50:12.041 --> 00:50:14.061
Dorothy Burwell: Yeah, in that
particular case, I think it's

00:50:14.061 --> 00:50:15.711
more than a shareholder issue.

00:50:16.011 --> 00:50:20.371
I think that's it's the votes I
think are probably slightly divorced

00:50:20.371 --> 00:50:24.271
from the reason why the chair was
removed in that particular situation.

00:50:24.271 --> 00:50:26.911
So I think yes, you need to
pay attention to the votes, you

00:50:26.911 --> 00:50:27.761
need to have a plan for that.

00:50:28.011 --> 00:50:31.521
But having not been in the board
seat, I think you also need to pay

00:50:31.521 --> 00:50:34.581
attention to what the reputation
is of board members when they have

00:50:34.581 --> 00:50:35.931
frequent interactions internally.

00:50:36.081 --> 00:50:37.761
All of those things really come into play.

00:50:37.761 --> 00:50:39.231
So it's a multifaceted issue.

00:50:39.731 --> 00:50:42.431
Ralph Grayson: So let's just try
and pull all this together then.

00:50:42.431 --> 00:50:48.361
So a couple of quick summaries, so
what behaviours do you see that are

00:50:48.361 --> 00:50:50.311
limiting board effectiveness today?

00:50:50.811 --> 00:50:54.501
Dorothy Burwell: I think that's poor
information flow is the preeminent thing

00:50:54.531 --> 00:50:57.801
and I don't know just mean that the
learning piece but what they're actually

00:50:57.801 --> 00:51:01.461
surfacing from management means that
they just can't act quickly enough.

00:51:01.961 --> 00:51:05.251
Ralph Grayson: And the key signs
that you see that show the difference

00:51:05.251 --> 00:51:09.046
between an adaptive board and a
board that's losing its relevance.

00:51:09.546 --> 00:51:13.326
Dorothy Burwell: The key attributes are
all the willingness to learn and unlearn.

00:51:13.826 --> 00:51:18.546
Ralph Grayson: Great advice, and
everybody says, if we were starting, we

00:51:18.546 --> 00:51:20.166
wouldn't start from where we are today.

00:51:20.666 --> 00:51:26.236
But if you could redesign board governance
or do one thing that you think would

00:51:26.296 --> 00:51:27.856
reflect the future rather than the past.

00:51:28.356 --> 00:51:30.396
Dorothy Burwell: It would be how
we actually review information.

00:51:30.396 --> 00:51:35.406
I would spend a probably a little bit
less time trying to triage the past

00:51:35.556 --> 00:51:38.976
and a bit more time speaking about
what we're planning for the future.

00:51:39.476 --> 00:51:39.986
Ralph Grayson: Super.

00:51:40.046 --> 00:51:41.816
That has been so fascinating.

00:51:41.816 --> 00:51:43.436
So many other things we could talk about.

00:51:43.686 --> 00:51:47.196
If you've picqued listeners interests
and they either feel that they need

00:51:47.556 --> 00:51:51.976
some help from FGS or they'd like to
keep following some of your comments

00:51:51.976 --> 00:51:55.526
or commentary or other thought
pieces that we touched on earlier.

00:51:55.556 --> 00:51:56.816
How do they follow FGS?

00:51:56.816 --> 00:51:57.596
How do they follow you?

00:51:57.812 --> 00:51:57.992
Dorothy Burwell: Yep.

00:51:58.022 --> 00:52:00.485
So you can follow us at fgs global.com.

00:52:00.485 --> 00:52:02.465
We're also on LinkedIn
just like everyone else.

00:52:02.645 --> 00:52:03.485
I'm Dorothy Burwell.

00:52:03.515 --> 00:52:04.640
You can als also find me there.

00:52:05.140 --> 00:52:05.620
Ralph Grayson: Super.

00:52:05.680 --> 00:52:07.510
Dorothy, thank you so much for your time.

00:52:07.510 --> 00:52:08.260
It's been fascinating.

00:52:08.468 --> 00:52:09.968
Dorothy Burwell: Ralph, thank
you for having me again.

00:52:10.329 --> 00:52:13.599
Ralph Grayson: I hope that you've enjoyed
listening to this podcast and have found

00:52:13.599 --> 00:52:17.859
it helpful when thinking about how to
approach your own path to the boardroom.

00:52:18.749 --> 00:52:21.889
If you would like to push this a
little bit further, Sainty Hird

00:52:21.909 --> 00:52:26.699
runs a bespoke one to one programme
designed specifically to this end.

00:52:27.034 --> 00:52:31.718
For more information, please visit
our website saintyhird.com, follow

00:52:31.718 --> 00:52:37.573
us on LinkedIn, and subscribe to the
Boardroom Path to receive new episodes.

00:52:37.919 --> 00:52:38.869
Thank you for listening.