Scalability School

This episode dives deep into how much your tracking setup actually controls your Meta performance, and why most brands only pay attention to the pixel when things break.

Brett walks through his journey from old-school media buying into early Facebook ads and how that evolved into Tag Hero, a specialist shop focused purely on technical conversion tracking across Meta, Google, TikTok, Snapchat, Pinterest, etc. He explains why data quality is the real throttle on performance and how you can have the best creative in the account, but if Meta isn't getting clean signals, the algorithm just can't do its job.

Key Takeaways:
  • How you can tell if your Shopify → Meta tracking setup is actually "good enough"… or silently leaking conversions.

  • If Meta says you're getting 8–13% more events with CAPI, are you actually set up to capture that lift—or just assuming you are.

  • The easiest way to verify your pixel and CAPI events are deduplicating correctly instead of double-counting purchases.

  • The Event Match Quality scores you should care about, and when a score is good vs a legit red flag

  • Why this one tracking perameter is arguably more valuable than email for optimization.

  • Why optimizing around a specific EMQ score might just be gaming a number that doesn't move revenue.

  • When Shopify's default Facebook Sales Channel App is the right call and when it might be time to graduate to Elevar/Blotout/EdgeTag-style stacks.

  • The incremental tracking upgrades that actually pay for themselves after you start spending 6 figures or more a month in ads.

  • The truth of what exactly happens when Meta flags you as 'Health & Wellness' brand and depricates your lower funnel.

  • How you can still win in health & wellness categories on Meta

  • The key steps to confidently rule out tracking as the culprit when your ads stop working so you're not re-building creative for a data problem?
This episode is sponsored by Northbeam, the marketing attribution platform that we love here at Scalability School. If you're ready to cut through the noise, stop guessing, and actually see which ads are driving your business, book a demo at northbeam.io/demo, and tell them Scalability School sent you. Join the club. To connect with Brett Fish over at TagHero, you can DM him at https://x.com/brett_fish or head over to their site: https://taghero.io/ To connect with Andrew Foxwell send an email Andrew@foxwelldigital.com To connect with Brad Ploch send him a DM at https://x.com/brad_ploch To connect with Zach Stuck send him a DM at https://x.com/zachmstuck Learn More about the Foxwell Founders Community at https://foxwellfounders.com/

What is Scalability School?

Scalability School is your cheat code for building a more profitable DTC brand or agency.

We break down tactical strategies, real-time wins, and tough lessons from three powerful perspectives: operator, agency, and community. It's not theory—it's what's actually working in the wild. Skip the fluff, steal what works, and scale with confidence.

It's a quantitative way for meta to kind of
tell you how well, how confidently can

we match this event, this action on your
website to a user on our platform.

That's, that's the gist of it.

Um, so, you know, it's, it's what data
are we passing back to help

meta make those matches, which drives
optimization, which obviously helps

your ads performance and efficiency.

One client referred to it as a mysterious
force, which is, I think is

about as specific as we can be.

Meta has not produced any like documentation
or comms on this, but you

know, once we saw it across.

Dozens and dozens of accounts, you're like,
okay, this isn't just a one-off.

This is a, this is a trend.

This is a thing where spend dropping
conversion rate, dropping CPA, like

going out, like negative impact on the ad
account, maybe introducing some

upper funnel events just will sort of tweak
and shock the system a little bit

and go after a different pool and sort of
cohort of users on the platform

and bring them in.

So I think like optimizing for that stuff
is definitely worth a test, like

optimizing for upper funnel events.

So I think in that same light, if you want
to optimize for a quiz completion,

that's pretty high intent.

And now let's take a listen to the
scalability school podcast.

Welcome to another episode of the
scalability school podcast.

Um, pixel perfect with Brett Fish
from tag hero Brett.

So glad to have you on the show.

Honestly, friend of the pod, um, friend in
life, actually, Brett's been on, uh,

one of my family vacations this year
already with my, with me and got

another one coming to December.

So, you know, that's, you know, we, we
have really gone full circle here.

Um, but we're excited to have
you on you and Zach.

We're talking about a whole bunch of stuff
with pixel and Zach, you want to

give the backstory about why you
wanted to have Brett on?

Yeah.

I mean, uh, TLDR is we were concerned,
um, about some just like auditing

our pixel, essentially we were starting
to have some issues with performance

and we were trying to back into, if it
could, if it could be any errors

that we were firing on, on the pixel.

And then we, uh, we hired Brett, Brett
and his company and they came in and.

Did a bunch of cool shit and
I didn't understand it.

So it was like, Hey, Brett, can we, uh,
have a conversation so you can

explain this to me like I'm five.

And that conversation was incredible.

And I was like, Hey, you have to come on
the podcast and explain all the cool

things, Cappy, EMQ, all these acronyms that
get thrown out there that I didn't

know what they were, uh, but wanted to,
wanted to know more about them.

So that's what the episode is
going to be about today.

I was trying to think about
like what the,

what the, what it compares
this to in real

life, because I feel like a pixel is not,
you know, the pixel and pixel setups is

like, you don't realize outside of the basics,
really, you know, it's important

to have a pixel set up, but you don't realize
how, how bad it is until it breaks.

It's kind of like insurance.

That's why I came up with, I don't know if
it's a great comparison, but it's like.

Shit, it broke.

I don't have this thing and I don't
know what to do to fix it.

Um, and, uh, yeah, no, I'm excited
to dig into this.

So Brett's gonna, Brett's
gonna tell us why

it's important, uh, how to fix
it before it breaks.

This episode is brought to you by our friends
over at Northbeam, the marketing

attribution platform that a lot of us at
listen to scalability school and the

host of scalability school, you know, we
swear by and use Northbeam rolled out

something brand new that I think
is pretty awesome.

It's a real unlock, I think called clicks
plus deterministic views.

And it's the first ever deterministic
view through attribution model.

I mean, let's be honest, right?

One day click had us flying a little bit
blind, you know, the drill, right?

Your Tik TOK or your CTV campaigns are building
awareness, clearly driving site

traffic and lifting sales
across channels,

but your attribution dashboard
still gives

all the credit to Google search.

Cause it was last click.

It's like tracking who made the final shot
in the basketball game, but ignoring

the five assists, right?

That got the ball there.

So clicks plus deterministic views flips
that it ties actual impressions, not

guesses, but verified impressions
to real conversions.

We're talking direct integrations with meta,
Tik TOK, snap, Pinterest, and even

CTV, and Northbeam uses hard identifiers like
order IDs and hashed emails to prove

that someone saw the ad didn't
click, but later bought.

That means you can finally measure the real
impact of upper funnel campaigns.

And the results are pretty nuts.

One brand saw 283% more attributed
conversions on Tik TOK.

Another got 175% more attributed revenue
than they knew even existed.

And you know, another one drove 59%
row as lift on Pinterest.

So if you're tired of under budgeting awareness,
because attribution can't keep

up, this is your chance to see the real
journey in the full journey.

So Northbeam click plus deterministic
views is live now head over to

Northbeam.io forward slash demo to book
a walkthrough and tell them we at

scalability school.

So, I mean, first of all, Brett, anybody you
want to flame, uh, and talk about on

the internet, I'm just kidding.

Who do you hate?

Who do you, who, who do
we hate this week?

Um, who's driving the spunkers?

I don't think I can lead in with that.

You might have to warm up warm up.

That's just, that's just, uh, that's
just to get everybody laughing.

We're, we're good.

We're, we're all friendly people here.

Uh, it's all love.

Um, Brett, uh, do you want to tell
everybody about like how you got

into this first, like briefly?

Like, how did you start doing tracking so

that, and like, what is it
that you do now?

Exactly.

Yeah, absolutely.

Uh, well first, uh, pleasure and a
privilege to be on with you guys.

Um, highly respect all three of you on the
work side and then getting to know you

all, you know, in real life as people
too, it's been awesome.

So it's a privilege to join you.

Um, yeah, so it's, it's totally accidentally
is how I'm like here with

Tag Hero, uh, my background was all
in traditional marketing.

So like, I'm, I date myself.

I'm old, like my, my original work in
marketing was like old school media

buying print, radio, TV, billboards,
all that stuff.

And then my career are kind of coincided
with the emergence of digital.

So I started buying digital banner ads
and stuff like that and saw the

tracking and the potential of like, you
know, a billboard, you put up a phone

number and you hope someone calls it with
the banner ads, we could see clicks.

And every, I'm like, this is amazing.

Had the opportunity with some early job
roles to spend money and work heavily

with early Facebook ads when they were
right column classified ads,

power editor era and days.

Um, and so I got to experiment
with a lot of work on it.

And after I'd done that career stops a couple
of times, I like, I know what I'm

doing here, I'm pretty good at this and,
and split off to do my own thing,

start my own paid social agency.

I was like eight or nine years ago.

Um, and just a couple of years into the agency
though, we were constantly having

issues with the stuff we're about to talk
about, like technical tracking,

pixels, backend stuff, and you know, now what,
like seven years ago, six years ago,

previous era in digital marketing, right?

Even less available in resources
than there are now.

And so I got sick of it.

And so I'm like, okay, we're
figuring this out.

This is not going to be a
pain point anymore.

Cause it was hindering our ability
to serve our clients.

And that was the main thing.

And, um, did some networking, brought some
people in from outside that have like

dev backgrounds and stuff like that and kind
of built it into a core competency

of our agency and then very sort of, uh, timing
wise coincidentally, right around

the same time we got pulled into a program
with meta called their technical

partners program.

So we were a third party, um, trained vetted
and paid by meta to help their

advertisers with all the tracking
stuff on the backend.

Cappy really wasn't a thing back then at
that time, but pixel catalog feeds,

all that kind of good stuff.

So we did that for about
four or five years.

And when meta kind of quickly and unceremoniously
ended that program, we

had a lot of people coming to us like, do
I have to run ads with you to have

you fix my tracking?

And it was like, it was so awkward.

It was like a sub bullet point
of our agency.

And that's when I decided to spin it off
and do its own thing as tag hero.

And that was almost three years ago.

Uh, so, and then, you know, it's taken
off since then and there's

clearly been a need for it.

So now I'm fully committed and a hundred
percent of my time is on the tag

hero side, helping people.

So, um, when we talk about all this stuff,
like pixels, server side event tracking,

all the backend conversion tracking for
platforms like meta and Google and

Tik TOK and Snapchat and
Pinterest and all

the others, heavy Google
tag manager stuff.

Um, you know, all the backend technical
conversion tracking stuff that drives

these platforms, that's our expertise and
what we can help, uh, brands and

advertisers and agencies with.

Yeah.

And you're the technical partner, chief
technical partner of the

Foxville founders membership.

And they've helped literally every member
probably with an issue because they

don't stop these fricking issues.

Um, so constant.

Yeah.

It's like, yeah, Brad made a great point.

Like no one cares about tracking
really until it breaks.

It's one of those kinds of like given things
that you expect to work until it

breaks, but when it breaks, what you realize,
and, and I've always been adamant

about this and why I went full in on tiger
was it's such a foundational part

of success on these platforms
that has to be in place.

You can produce the most banger creative
that's ever been produced.

And if the platform's not getting the
right signal off of that,

it's not doing it justice.

Um, so creative and CRO and offers and
all super important to success.

But at the end of the day, these
are all algorithms, right?

Good data in good output, garbage
in garbage out.

So the data and the signals are really
critical to success.

Um, but people don't really care until it
breaks and something goes sideways.

And then that's when we usually come in.

We'll talk a little bit later about how
we're trying to get ahead of that.

Brad talked about insurance, but, um, yeah,
we, we help them sort that stuff

out when it's not working
like they expect.

Yep.

So let's go ahead and just
jump right in, right?

Like out of the gates, actually, Brad, you
had a story you wanted to talk about.

Yeah, I have two things.

Um, Brett mentioned things breaking in
literally the last seven days on meta

has been like literally the entire platform
just keeps having perpetual

disruptions, I think ad spend for all of
our clients stop for like two hours or

like an hour, at least in the
middle of the day today.

So fun, fun timing on things breaking
completely unrelated to the

pixel or the pixel things
out of our control.

Um, I just want to share something I saw
this weekend, uh, or actually heard

from a friend is like somebody
outside the industry.

And so that makes it even
more compelling.

My ears start to perk up when I hear people
like interacting with brands in real

life, because I spend all time, all my time
talking to, uh, you, you two, you

two morons in particular, volunteering,
of course.

And so I was like, okay, you're
perpetually in the weeds.

You don't really, you don't really take a
step back and zoom out and like, see

how people interact with stuff.

Long story short, sitting next to my friend
that I've known for since, since, um,

elementary school at a wedding and he starts
telling me about his sunglasses

and whatever it's like a normal conversation
about some glasses.

He's like, yeah, you know, I just
lose them all the time.

So, but I'm really, I have a, I have a pair
from shady raise and I really like

them, um, and I have their, I'm in
their replacement program.

So I just like, they just replaced
them for me for free.

It's like they're $75 sunglasses and
they replace them for free.

And I was like, Oh, that's cool.

Like completely for free.

And he's like, well, no, I pay shipping.

And I was like, okay, how much, how
much do you pay shipping?

He's like, Oh, like 15 bucks.

But like they're $75 on glass.

They're like, okay, these, these, these sunglasses
probably cost them $2 to make.

They probably cost like $7 in shipping.

And most of that's like, because they have
to go into a box, they don't get crushed

in the mail because they weigh nothing.

Um, they're making margin on the replacement
program and they're, but like

the way that he worded it to me
was he was so gassed up.

He's like, I get my sunglasses
replaced for free.

I don't have to remember it.

I don't feel bad about this.

It's like his perception of their replacement
program was I get free sunglasses.

My perception is they're making money.

It's like everybody loses
their sunglasses.

It's incredible.

I like, I like that the first time you
left your house since we've

started this podcast, you have a story.

Yeah.

Oh yeah.

Look, I'm going to Vegas this weekend
for another wedding.

So who else might not interrogate about
their D to C shopping experiences?

So yeah, I thought that was
really fascinating.

That's that's fascinating.

It's good marketing.

So, uh, Brett, like let's just jump
in and talk about, um, what

does the essential setup look
like Shopify default?

Does it cover meta?

Okay.

Or does it cover like what, what are the
issues with just a default setup?

Yeah.

Um, no issues with the default setup
is I think the main thing.

Um, I remember a while back there was
kind of this big wave of concerns

and questions about Shopify's app and
the tracking and to be fair, the

apps, you know, it's had
its evolution and

changes it was originally
owned by Shopify.

I think now it's owned by
meta or vice versa.

Like it actually changed hands of like
who is owning and maintaining it.

But, but the long story short is.

Look, if, if you're the majority, I'd
probably guess of Shopify brands

and stores out there and you know, you do
decent business, but nothing crazy.

I think the app works great.

You get pixel and conversion API server
side tracking out of it.

It passes back all the parameters
to match

up with your catalogs and all that stuff.

So from like a data standpoint,
it's pretty solid.

Um, does it squeeze every last single drop
out of a potential data connection?

No, but, but, but it's a free, very
quick and easy to set up app.

So I think for a lot, we, you know, we,
we always recommend to go that route

wherever possible and wherever
it makes sense.

Um, you know, one of the things with it is
it's designed for out of the box, right?

So if you want to do anything custom outside
of the typical e-commerce funnel

and flow of page view, view content, add
to cart purchase, all that stuff.

If you want to do something custom,
it's not going to do that.

It's kind of just intended for out of the
box e-commerce, but it does that well.

So is it perfect?

No, it's not perfect, but I don't think you're,
you know, at a major disadvantage

or it's detrimental if you're using it.

I think it works just fine for a lot of
brands and takes, takes a lot of

the guesswork out of it, because anytime
you go outside of something, you

start doing custom things, there's more
things that can to be considered.

But, uh, no, I think it's pretty solid.

Um, and for a lot of stores, it's,
it's, it's totally adequate.

If you're at a size and a scale with
traffic and volume and revenue and

everything, where a small incremental lift
in your overall kind of data would

offset the cost of putting that all
into maintaining it, sure.

Explore.

There are other solutions that are
a little more advanced, but

like I'd say for the average store and advertiser,
it does a really good job.

I want to come back to what you're saying
for like, when you want to squeeze

things a little bit more and like when
that starts to make sense.

Uh, but coming back up one step, like,
okay, so the Shopify setup, I think

most people listening to this will understand,
but just for the sake of

making sure we, we, we get everybody that's
literally, you go into Shopify,

you go into sales channels, you install
meta and you just like go through the

setup process, you select max data sharing
or whatever your settings need to

be and that, that sets up the pixel on
the front end, um, saying boards that

might not fully understand front end and
then back end is conversion API.

Um, is that fair?

Correct.

Yeah.

It's tight.

It's called the Facebook and Instagram Shopify
sales channel app still, but yeah,

you go in and in the settings, there's a
section for data sharing and you can

connect your business manager and your
dataset or pixel ID and everything.

And, um, you can, I recommend
setting it to maximum.

There's a couple levels set it
to maximum data sharing.

And that'll handle, um, to your point pixel,
it'll handle server side events.

And one of the things that we can dive
into layer, but one of the really

important things when you have pixel
and server side is that they

deduplicate properly because I didn't an
ideal setup from meta standpoint.

And we were talking about like, what is
an ideal setup, Sam set up look like.

You're supposed to send a pixel event, which
is a front side event and a server

side event for every event.

So if I go to Zach store and I go through
and I make a purchase that purchase

event for me should send a pixel and a
server side event, but they should

both be carrying a unique identifier
called an event ID to deduplicate.

So it doesn't count as two purchases.

Cause I only made one purchase.

That's the best practice set up to ensure
you're capturing that event.

Um, but if you don't deduplicate them,
then you, then you have over counting

and over reporting and all
sorts of issues.

So, um, the app handles all of that for
you, which is why I think it's,

it's a really good option.

So it'll automatically take care
of all that, but correct.

Yeah, Brad, you, you set it up, connect
it and you're off to the races.

You really don't.

Um, actually, Andrew, there was a founder's
member the other day who was

like rebooting their store and we went through
and set it up and like, I think

it was like a minute and
a half on a call.

And he's just like, Oh, like that was it.

I was like, that's it buddy.

You're all set.

So, um, it's really straightforward
overall, but yeah, it works well.

Nice.

Cool.

So that, that covers it for the vast
majority of brands, but there's

obviously people, um, like Zach who want
to crank it up a couple of notches.

So like, what is there like a threshold for
when it starts to make it like, okay.

So I'm sure there's a couple of ways to
look at it, like thresholds and

revenue traffic or however you
want to define it.

And then there's those like unique scenarios
where you're like health and

wellness, which I'm sure we'll come back
to, or you're doing something custom,

like maybe some like quiz stuff or, you
know, other stuff that we could, I'm

sure we can, we can talk about that too.

But, um, any way that you like think about,
okay, we need to maybe go a little

bit deeper than this, like, how are you,
how are you looking at it?

And how are you advising folks
on when to do it?

Yeah.

But, you know, there's, there's not really
a line and actually Zach would probably

be more equipped to speak to that than I
would be, but there's not really a line

as I see it, it's just, if you get to a point
where you're like, you know, we're

at a certain level of size and scale, we want
to make sure our data is, you know,

cause some of these tools that aren't the
app, you know, the app is designed

to do exactly what it does.

Um, some of these solutions
out there, um,

L of R blot out edge tag,
all like there's

other things because that's
not pure tracking.

I mean, it includes tracking, but there's
other things that software can do.

It can do like user fingerprinting and session
stitching and some other things.

And, and what I always tell people is.

Will you get more purchase events?

Not necessarily.

That's not what it is.

It's like you're capturing more purchases,
but like you might have more user data

on those upper funnel events that tells the
platform, you know, for prospecting

campaigns and things like that, who's hitting
your website more effectively

and helps it optimize.

Like that's what I mean when I say
incremental, it's not, you're not

necessarily going to capture and report more
revenue, more purchases and things

like that, those events should still fire
and be captured in a more regular setup.

But those, those tools can add additional
things from a SaaS standpoint.

They can enrich your data and squeeze
a little more out of it.

Um, I always consider that
somewhat incremental.

So it really comes down to me to what is
the cost of that platform cost?

Um, with some of them, what's
the ongoing like upkeep?

Like we, I can tell you, we audit
a lot of tracking of.

We signed up for this tool and
we don't use it anymore.

And we're not sure what the
aftermath looks like.

Like we get a lot of that.

So some of them can be technical
and require some upkeep.

That's more than some brands are
equipped or willing to do.

So you have to kind of consider all that.

But if, if, if that all makes sense and
lines up for what it gives you, then,

then I think it's could be
worth it to try.

Um, but I don't have like a hard, like at
this dollar of revenue or at this

amount of traffic or events,
does it make sense?

There's no like, like hard line on that.

It's just kind of, I think when it
starts to make sense for

you as a brand to look at it.

Yeah.

I mean, the way that I justified is
like, if you're spending a few

hundred thousand dollars a month on ads,
probably should take a look at this.

Right.

And make sure everything's dialed in.

Right.

I think that that's just like the
baseline thought on my end.

Oh, yeah.

I mean, I think let's, let's
get into like

some of the other things that you can do.

Right.

So I remember like one of the, one of the
questions that we had for you,

Brett was, is there a way for us to see and
run pixel events for a new customer

purchase versus returning
customer purchase?

Cause maybe we want to test optimizing
off of that to see if we can

get focus on new customers, right?

Is there, is there some level of event
data or something that's happening on

the backend that might be able to actually
show better performance if we

just opt to optimize off of new purchase?

Like tell us more about the other things
that we can start to do with like

going a step deeper than just
the standard setup.

Just to at the high level.

Yes.

You can definitely capture events, um,
either through like a platform,

like an L a bar or a blot out Shopify actually
has that as part of their core

web API.

So even if we do something with like
Google tag manager, we can still

determine was this event from a new customer
that's never bought from you

before, or is it not a new customer?

Right now you're returning customer and
you can fire like a custom meta event.

For example, um, you could even do a custom
Google conversion if you wanted,

but, um, you know, you can fire those respectively
where you say, this is a

new customer purchase versus this is
a returning customer purchase.

And then you could choose to optimize
for a new customer.

That's the technical side.

My opinion and soapbox on it is I don't
actually know how useful that is.

I'm always at like a results talk, right?

So if it works and it works and we can
repeat that like any other kind of

experiment, like great, like what does my
opinion matter it works, right?

But my thing with that has always been
there's no metric in metasys.

And I think we talked a little bit
about this Jack, Zach.

And you mentioned something that you had talked
about on a call as like alternate

reasoning that I think would be worth like
going through, but from the technical

side, there isn't a metric in meta system

that says it's new customer
that you like.

There's no recognition and metaside like,
Oh, this is a new customer.

Um, so when you're passing a new customer
event, you're really just passing a

subset of your overall purchase event.

And is meta going to be able to optimize
toward that group of users as a new

customer and go find other people who
have not bought from you before?

Not necessarily.

So I know some people that have tried optimizing
for it and it worked for a

little stretch and then maybe kind of,
you know, petered off over time.

Um, I've never been super sold on the
technical backend of it, but it's

definitely possible and so we try
and it's worth testing.

For sure.

We just wanted to try it.

Right.

Similar thought.

It was like, let's just see what happens.

No bump in performance.

So like, I don't think, and again, that's
just one dataset to use is just us, but

same, but for us, by the way.

Okay.

Got it.

Yeah.

I mean, this last week, we tried it.

Didn't do anything.

I think optimize enough of the main standard
purchase event is probably

the way to go 99% of the time.

Right.

So, um, yeah, I'm glad that you
called that out though.

Yeah, that and exclusions, right?

I mean, using as robust of exclusions as you
can in your ads, I think is probably

a better overall approach than just trying
to optimize toward an audience of

people who it's their first
time buying from you.

Um, and, and I could be wrong
about that, right?

Meta could have something in their infinite
data point structure that says

like this person interacted with this store
for the first time or whatever, but

we haven't really seen any proof
or evidence of that.

Um, so it's all kind of speculation.

Honestly, I think it's been a little bit more
almost marketing fodder for like data

tools to say, Oh, we can do this.

Then it is like real actual practical execution
and like results off of that.

But, um, it's like, I've heard some
for some periods it's worked.

So it's definitely worth testing
and trying if you want to.

And it's definitely something that's available,
especially if you're on like

Shopify, um, this is a, this is an ask for
a house to sponsor the next, uh, I

don't know, handful of podcasts and give
me house for free so I can technically

trial that, you know, trial this out and
run it by, uh, you know, the book.

But outside of that, yeah, we
tried it ourselves.

No difference.

Um, should we get into EMQ?

Um, yeah.

So the one I would love to talk about EMQ
and just like really briefly, can I

actually let's talk about Cappy first.

If you don't mind, um, you have the
default install and just so I

understand what Cappy does.

Cappy goes on your site and if someone is
filling out a form or puts in their

email to capture it, it tags
that together.

Is that what Cappy is part
of what Cappy is?

What is Cappy?

No, it was a good try.

It was a good try Foxwell, but, um, no,
so, so what Cappy is, is it's an

alternate route to send
your data to meta.

Then the pixel, the pixel we all know and
love that's been around forever.

So it's an alternate route.

Um, the pixel is JavaScript.

So it's code that lives on your
website and it shoots data

directly back to meta from there.

The issue with that is it can be disrupted
and blocked by all sorts of things.

So like browser load errors, slow internet
connections, ad blockers,

JavaScript blockers, there's a myriad
of things that can disrupt that

pixel sending that signal back.

So Cappy stands for conversion API.

And it's, it's met as terminology for server
side tracking, but it's essentially

a, instead of sending it via JavaScript
via the pixel to meta, we're actually

going to capture that on our own servers.

And then our servers are going to connect
to meta servers directly with

an API and pass them that data.

Right.

And it's capturing, it's capturing
the things that they're

doing though on the site.

The same events.

It's all the same data and all of the
same events that the pixel sends.

Correct.

So that's what I meant.

Like it's capturing action, not
related to the pixel.

I didn't say that properly, but it's
like, if they put in their email or

they start filling out a form or they click
add to cart, like it's capturing

all that information just independently
of the pixel.

Yeah.

It's same information, but sending it to meta
different that's less likely to get

disrupted.

Okay.

I was thinking about if I was going to
ask this on the podcast, because it

risking looking stupid, but
I don't fucking care.

So I'm stupid.

So I just wanted to make sure like
that's what I thought.

And I want, so that's what Cappy is.

Is there anything that people can do to
help improve the Cappy experience?

Uh, I think one main sort of distinction to
make up front is, is that Cappy is like

server side events when it comes to emails
and stuff like that, that's EMQ.

And that's what Zach mentioned that we can
definitely dive into in more depth in a

minute.

Um, when it comes to Cappy, really, you
just want to make sure you have it

implemented.

So the numbers kind of move, but metas official
documentation has always been

you get somewhere between eight to 13%
more events by having Cappy in place

alongside your pixel in a redundant
setup than just pixel alone.

So Cappy is really valuable in that sense of
you would have some signal loss if you

just were using the pixel.

Whereas if you have Cappy, I mean, let's
say ballpark nine or 10%, that can be a

huge swing as far as like revenue and purchase
of activity reported and things

like that.

Um, in regard to make making it like, I guess,
as effective as possible, you just

want to make sure it's a, it's a
strong, robust Cappy setup.

It's a true redundant setup.

So like the Shopify app would take
care of that for you.

If you're using Google tag manager or something
like that, just making sure you

have a Cappy implementation in place alongside
your pixel that captures all

the same events, you should
be in good place.

It's it copies really a backstop to get any
of those events that the pixel loses

or drops or their signal disruption.

How would someone know?

How would they know if the pixel, if like
the Cappy setup isn't good?

So, so let's say I have the default installed
and I'm like, I feel like I'm

not doing good here and then I'm like,
see an ad for, you know, one of these

tracking things I'm like, should I sign
up with it flat out or whatever?

Like, can I just, where do I look
to solve this on my own?

Yep.

So the main, the main place you'd want to
go where we spend most of our time is in

the meta events manager.

So if you go into meta business manager,
um, the events manager tool in section

will show you all the events that
are coming into your site.

And in that overview on that dashboard,
there's a column that says connection

method, and if it says multiple, that
means you're getting events via both

pixel and Cappy, and you can actually
expand any of the individual events.

And there's a chart, there's a graph
that's actually really useful.

And it shows you, here's the server
events that are coming in.

Here's the pixel events
that are coming in

and they should be pretty
tightly correlated.

So if that all is there and is in place,
um, you're probably in, in good shape.

I mean, shameless plug.

If you're unsure how to check that we offer
that as we do meta tracking audits

to make sure all that stuff's in place and,
and dialed in, but, um, yeah, that's

where you'd want to look to see if you see
that multiple, like it's coming in

from multiple channels and you look at that
graph and you're getting server and

pixel events pretty consistently, you're
probably in good shape.

So meta events manager would be where
you want to take a look at that.

I have a pull up right now.

I'm looking at it.

Does automatic website matching impact,

um, like conversion API or
EMQ or not really?

No.

So, so EMQ, when we look at it and meta events
manager is actually, that's all from

copy.

So if you don't have a copy connection, that
tab won't even show in events manager.

Um, automatic advanced matching, if we
distill it down is really just what

you're telling the pixel, it's a pixel based
tool is any page that the pixels

installed on that you're saying, go ahead
and scan that page in that code.

And if you see things that are email addresses,
phone numbers, names, named

fields, go ahead and pass that data back
with the pixel for match purposes.

So you're just giving it some automated
leash to identify that information and

send it back and that does help match rates,
which we can dive into more, but

that's really like how the
platform optimizes.

So if I go on, um, Zach store and I make a
purchase meta needs to match that action

up that purchase on his site up with
a user on their platform.

So they need to connect that back.

And then once they know I'm a user on their
platform, then they're like, okay,

let's go find other Brett fishes who with
all of our data points has similar

interests and we think would also
be a prospective customer.

That's how the meta optimization
engine works for ads.

So it's really important that you pass as
much of that, that match data back as

possible to help the platform do that and
more efficiently optimize your ads.

So it's a pixel based thing.

The automatic advanced matching, but we highly
recommend having it on and having

any of the match keys on, unless you have
like a strong business reason.

Some of them aren't as important, like
gender date of birth, probably not as

important, but like name and email and
external IDs and things like that are

really good to pass if you can.

Yeah.

I mean, that's like one of the first things
that we check in audits just as

like to make sure it's turned on and almost
always not all of this turned on.

So maybe that's like a low hanging fruit
thing that people can do.

The other thing I would tell anybody, I
call it the silent killer and that's

probably a little dramatic, but I can,
I can't tell you how many audits

we find issues with this.

There's a section in the settings
tab of events manager.

If you scroll down that says event set
up tool and event set up tool is

a codeless tool that meta offers.

So if your pixel is installed on a site
and you really need to get an event

tracking on like a button click or a link
click, but you don't have access

to the code and you can't add events and
stuff, you can use this event set up

tool, which is a codeless tool
for meta to do that.

The problem is, is what we see with so many
advertisers is at some point in the

past, too many cooks in the kitchen, summer
marketing intern, whatever, has

set up events via the event set up tool.

And they have a normal regular e-commerce
tracking set up in place.

So they'll be getting like huge duplication
on like add to carts or

sometimes purchases and things like that.

And if you look in the site code, even
you won't see it, it doesn't exist.

You can only see it if you're in
that event set up tool.

So that's always something I recommend
people check too.

It's just like, make sure there's
no events in there.

It serves its purpose, but you can't pass
back like dollar values and

skews or anything else.

It's just a pure like event tracking.

So, um, that's always one I recommend in
the settings too, Brad, that you check

on audits because it can cause
all kinds of problems.

So probably some intern reading the Foxville
digital blog, you know, full

of a lot of goodies on there, your conversation
with Brett about the EMQ

and about your own EMQ.

What, what were you trying to solve?

And then like, what is it?

And what did you know about it?

And then what did Brett kind of
illuminate for you there?

So I was curious on.

Like, I mean, I had the, I had the
understanding that event

match quality, the better it is, the better,
you know, better results you get,

right, the more data you can send back to
meta, I would hope that the better

performance we get out of, out
of our ad account, right?

So simply put, that's all I knew.

Right.

What is it actually in, what was my
question for Brett was like,

what do the numbers mean?

Right?

Is a nine good, is a seven good?

I have no idea.

It's out of 10.

So like, what are these scores
actually mean?

And what do I need to get worried?

Right?

So one of the things that we were running
on one of the brands is that we were

having issues, all sorts of issues with,
with our, um, basically pixel tracking.

We had health and wellness hit us.

A bunch of stuff started to happen.

Um, that was all accidental
that we got reversed.

But, um, one of the things I was curious
on is like this, this event, event

match quality, and I was like, okay.

I see the number went down
and it came back up.

Like, where should this be?

So that was one of my first questions was
like, I don't know what's a good score.

You know, sometimes you get graded.

Is it, is a nine good?

Is that an A or is that actually,
you know,

are we, you know, curving
that a little bit?

Like, I don't know.

Right.

So that was the first question was like,
what do the numbers actually mean?

And how good do they need to be?

Do they need to be 10 out of 10 or
can they be lower than that?

What does that look like?

So Brett, why don't you like
go through that?

Let's talk to you like the main events that
we would see page view, add a cart,

purchase the sheet checkout, like,
how do you think about those?

What, what did the numbers look like?

Is there a number that kind of raises
a red flag for you or yeah.

Tell us more about those.

Yeah.

So, um, so the first thing is EMQ stands
for event match quality.

So that's, it's important to remember because
that's what we were just talking

about is it's a, it's a quantitative way
for meta to kind of tell you how well,

how confidently can we match this event, this
action on your website to a user on

our platform that's, that's
the gist of it.

Um, so, you know, it's, it's what data
are we passing back to help meta make

those matches, which drives optimization,
which obviously helps your ads

performance and efficiency and
all that good stuff.

Um, it's on a scale out of 10.

I've never seen a 10 on any
event with real data.

So don't obsess about that
to those listening.

Like I've never seen an actual real 10.

The other thing I would say before we
kind of dive into the details is

EMQ is a little funny, funky.

Um, it's weighted.

It can be gamed.

There's, there's a lot of elements to it.

So I think what we can go through is like,
what are the important things to focus

on and to care about and not dwell on like
it's not a 10 or it's, or it's this

score, but more like what
we're sending back.

So, um, it, it, so the first
thing is EMQ will vary.

It's always starts the lowest on like
the highest funnel event.

So when the user hits your website and
you get like a page view event, that

first landing page view, you're going to
get the lowest EMQ scores of your range

there, um, and we see everything there from
like a four and a half to like low

sixes, um, depending on what
gets passed back.

So for what it's worth hollow, I'll
just run through my numbers.

And then we can use this as an example,
seven on the dot 7.0 page view,

which seems high, which is great.

So I've got a 6.3 pulled up.

So you're winning.

And we can dive in in a minute to a little
bit of what's like fueling that and why,

but that's a good score.

So page view 7.0 view content.

So to your point, like as you kind of
get through the funnel, right?

To add to cart.

So page view seven view content, seven one,
add to cart 7.2 purchase nine points

or initiate checkout 8.5 purchase 9.0.

Um, so just to give an example, live example
brand that we're spending, you

know, seven figures a month on, there's a
lot of events going through this.

So not just a few.

Um, but yeah, keep going, Brett.

All right.

Yeah.

And the reason, but the re and the reason
for that is when, when someone hits your

website, they haven't given
you any information.

They haven't submitted anything.

You don't have any of that user
match data to send back.

There are some technical parameters that you
can capture like when they first hit.

So, um, uh, Facebook's Facebook has two
parameters and FVP and an FBC, which

we'll dive in a little more.

Cause I think the FBC is a really important
one and valuable to dive in a

little more on in a second, but there's
those, there's like your IP address.

There's a bunch of things that you can
pass when a user hits before

they've submitted anything to you.

That's what's going to fuel that,
that page view score.

Um, also a lot of stores will like, if
you have a user logged in, possibly

that has an account that's logged in, you
might have access to their email

and their phone number or something right
away when they hit the site.

So those things all fuel that page view,
EMC score, E and Q score right

when someone hits, but they haven't made
a transaction, you know, they

haven't submitted like their name or
their email or anything like that.

So we get those technical
kind of parameters.

Shopify also has one.

There's a parameter called an external
ID, which is just like a customer ID.

Um, Shopify assigns a unique one when
the user hits your site and it

carries through their, their
whole session.

So you can pass all those things when
you use your hits before

they've made a transaction and sent you.

So that's, that's what fuels those likes.

Like we see a lot of like fives,
low sixes, seven is great.

You must have some like logged in users.

There's another thing to mention here is
there's, there's some data providers

that also use like IP geolocation.

And this gets a little in the weeds, but
like they look at your IP address and

they guess your city, state, and country
and all that based on your IP.

And they pass that information back.

So sometimes we go in an audit and it's
like a page view and we're like,

we're getting state and country and zip
code on a hundred percent of events.

How's that possible?

Like we don't know that yet.

That's usually like IP geolocation.

And that's what I mean by like, EMC
can be gained a little bit.

So when you see those numbers and for
anyone that wants to look,

if you want to look at what your EM
actually makes up your EMQ score,

the main overall scores will be in your
events manager overview tab.

But if you expand on any of the events
and go into the event details,

there's a little sub tab called
event quality.

And you can see like the rate of all
these things being captured.

Um, that's just that they're
being captured.

It's not saying they're unique
or authentic value.

So I could put Brett Fish as the first and
last name on every event on a site.

And it would say I'm capturing first and last
name a hundred percent of the time.

Although that's not valuable
to the platform, right?

So it can be gained a little bit, but,
but that's what's fueling

those like upper funnel EMQ scores.

Um, the more data to exact original point,
of course, the more data you send the

better, as long as it's actual real authentic
relevant data and not just

like, I'm just obsessed with trying
to drive up my EMQ score.

So I'm going to send a bunch of
kind of BS back to meta.

That's not, that's not helping
your efforts at all.

Anyway.

And then you get all the way down
the funnel to a purchase.

I make a purchase on the site.

I'm probably submitting my name, my email
address, my actual address,

shipping address and all that.

So now we can pass all that additional
information back in addition

to what we had passed before.

And that's what you gets you up into
the high eights, low nines.

Um, typically for a purchase, which let's
be honest, purchase events,

probably the most important.

It's what the majority of advertisers
are optimizing toward.

So the match rates really critical.

We see usually like high eights to low
nines, like nine three is usually

like the highest I've seen it.

Um, high eights you're probably fine.

Like eight six, eight seven, anything
below an eight.

Jack speaking to red flags is something
we would be like, we want to

at least look at this and see why.

Um, metas official documentation is that
a six is the minimum they recommend

to actually use to optimize your ads on,
but a purchase event with all the data

that should be available there.

You should be in the high eights, low
nines in that, in that area.

So you're going on, you go through this,
you're looking at this, you're

grandeur listening to this and you're
looking at the numbers.

What are the things that you go in and
would do to, to like some top things

you go in and try to solve this to make these
a little bit better for some folks.

Right.

Or is it all over the map?

It's, it's a little relative
to each event.

Like what you could practically hope to
capture and send with each event.

I think you just have to be
realistic about that.

Um, what we would do if like we were going
to look through it is what are

we receiving at each stage and
does that make sense?

Um, like, and, and it's, there's a little
bit of common sense, not even technical.

It's like, if someone's added something
to their cart, do you have their email

address, probably not unless
they're logged in.

So am I worried, you know, if, if there's
no email on an ad to cart, no, but we

should be getting their IP address.

We should be getting other things.

Um, two, two important things I think
is a good time to mention.

The two most important highest priority
match keys and metas whole system.

And they have documentation on this
are the Facebook click ID, the

FBC parameter and the email,
the user email.

Those are the two most important things.

If you don't, if you can't send anything
else, if you send those two parameters

and Facebook click IDs, definitely like
the top one, and I'll talk about

that in just a second, but those
are the two most important.

So especially on a purchase event, I
would really focus on those.

I'd look at like, are we
getting an email?

We should probably have it on a
hundred percent of events.

And then are we getting the
Facebook click ID?

Now here's the caveat with the
Facebook click ID.

And this came up when I was talking to
Zach, it's not going to be at a

hundred in your events manager.

Events manager is every event your
site is receiving, not just

what's being driven by ads.

So even if a user originates from an organic
Google search, you're going to

get a purchase event fire when they purchase
on your site, the click ID,

that FBC parameter is only going to be
present on sessions and purchases

that came from a meta ad on
one of their entities.

So a lot of times we'll go into a purchase
and like FBC parameter will be like

27% of purchase events have
the Facebook click ID.

That's not a red flag.

That's not a problem.

What we always recommend is this.

Like, if you have the data, like compare
that to generally what you think

that the volume of the proportion of your
purchases are that come from meta ads.

So like, if, if you think that 75% of all
your purchases come from a meta ad,

but you're only at 20% click ID, maybe
that's something to look at because

there should be more of those events then
that have that click ID, but it's

not a red flag to see that number lower
than usual in the events manager, a

lower than a hundred because it's only
going to be from the events

that came from meta ads and that's
we're looking at all events.

Would, so you said compared to kind of
what you think meta is driving.

So it could be, it could be higher than
that in the event that maybe you have

a ton of organic traffic, but meta ads
are doing a solid job at capturing

that and retargeting it with like a DPA or
maybe some other stuff, but it might

be lower than that if you have like a high
AOV and the purchase, the person

took 30, well, maybe you can, you could
tell me it's like if they click on the

ad and they went and researched and came
back to it two weeks later after they

saw something else, are they going to pass
through is a Facebook click ID going

to exist on that purchase event?

It's possible.

It all comes down to the cookie expiration
because what happens is, and we

won't get too technical in the weeds, but
what happens is when a user clicks

your ad on Facebook or Instagram, meta
pens, a URL parameter to that link

coming through to your website, kind of
like a UTM that a lot of people are

familiar with, and it's the FBC LID
is you can see it in the URL.

That is a really important value because
what that says to meta is it's just a

string value, but it says this user clicked
this ad at this time and then

went to your site, so it's
super deterministic.

So if you pass that back with your events,
medic can look at that FBC and

be like, well, Brett fish, click this ad
at this time at this, and then made a

purchase on Zach site 10 minutes after we're
definitely attributing that purchase.

So it's really deterministic, but what happens
is when you hit the site, if you

have the meta pixel installed, it'll grab
that URL parameter and store it as a

cookie in the browser.

And so it really just comes down to the cookie
expiration, which a lot of times

is like, I mean, your attribution and ads manager,
a lot of people use like a seven

day click attribution, but the cookie
expiration is usually around like 28

days. So that value to your question, Brad
should still be in there if they come

back, but you know, in ads manager, if you're
only using seven day attribution,

if it's passed out, it won't attribute, but
that click ID will still should still

be valid as long as the cookie is valid.

Got it.

Cool.

And if you had to Google what deterministic
meant when Brett said that

word, like you're not alone,
so it's all good.

Um, I get it.

It's the most important though.

And I, the reason and Zach and I talked a
little bit about this on our call, it is

the most important parameter because
it's meta provided, right?

It's not like I'm submitting an email and
we hope the email that I submit on my

order on the store matches my email that
I'm registered with on, on Facebook and

Instagram, so we can match that up.

That value is coming directly from meta.

They know who the user is, when they
click the ad, what ad they clicked.

So it's, it's very, very deterministic.

If you're going to pass one parameter,
that's the one and there's, there's

a lot of misunderstanding around it.

Um, but it is important.

So, but I always want to point out just
because it's not on a hundred

percent of your events, that's not a red
flag or anything to freak out about.

That's normal, but that is a really
important one to make sure you're

capturing and passing, especially if
you, um, if you happen to be an

advertiser that's doing like Cappy
only and not using the pixel.

So you don't have that automatic mechanism
of setting the cookie and all that.

You want to make sure you're manually,
you can still manually capture

that value and pass it with Cappy.

You want to make sure you're doing that.

Cause that's a really important
value to your optimization

and add success on the platform.

Is there anything else that you guys
talked about in your call that you

think you don't want to dig into or do
you want to switch over to the

health and wellness, uh,
total non-disaster?

I think.

Yeah.

I mean, that was mostly, that
was mostly it, right?

I think it was just like getting
the understanding of what,

really how Cappy works.

It's kind of like two channels of information,
trying to match some of

that to like, you know, be duplicate
information, ideally Cappy or

server side data is even stronger to your
point to give meta, even more.

Data back than what you might miss, uh,
that, that the pixel might miss.

Um, so that clarity was helpful.

The EMC, EMCQ, uh, event managed quality
component was important too, because

again, like without the context of like,
is a nine good for purchase?

You kind of freak out and you're like,

maybe this is why my ads aren't,
aren't working.

So I think that was just like peace
of mind more than anything.

FPC component of it too.

Like we were looking across the multiple
brands that we own and operate.

And one of them was at like 48%
um, FPC and purchase.

And one was at like 63 and it was like,
okay, that makes more sense on the 63

one, because it's very impulse
purchase related.

Like I think more of our traffic is actually
from meta driving that purchase

than even other channels, organic email,

other, other, you know, click
based traffic.

So to get the FPC tag to carry through
makes a lot of sense.

So again, I think for me, it was more just
making sure everything was in good

standing and that if there was something
missing that we could at least identify

it, so, um, which I think is really like
the best rationale of like these audits

with bread is like to get that
peace of mind, right?

Cause otherwise you might just be thinking
your ads are, you know, working

great where they might not be, or you're
freaking out like I was thinking that

that's the issue.

So, um, meta health and wellness.

Let's get into that.

Just before we dive into that though, is,
you know, met is one of the main growth

engines and channels for most
advertisers and brands.

These, these same things kind of about
EMQ, like, um, Google has what

they call enhanced conversions.

Um, tick tock has match rates, all
the same kind of stuff.

So this is more and more like across all
major digital ad platforms is with

like what medicals EMQ, but is passing
back as much user data as possible so

that these platforms can match website
actions with their platform users.

It's big across all channels.

Obviously with meta, it's very like granular
and broken down and like, you

can really dive in and see it, but it is
relevant and important on, on a lot

of these ad channels, not just meta, but
metas like, you know, where most people

focus and where it's like really easy to
dive into your scores and all that.

So for what it's worth health and wellness,
what's, uh, what's the business?

What's going on?

Everybody, everybody freaking out for no reason,
or, uh, is it actually a problem?

No, it's a problem.

Um, there's a lot of people I know that
would, would definitely tell you

it's a problem, uh, I can give, I mean,
feel free to ask any questions like

you guys have on it, but I can give kind
of the quick, we were kind of like

accidentally ex sort of experts
in this area.

Um, but I can give you the quick kind
of backstory and framing.

So that does sound good.

Yeah, absolutely.

So the real start of this is met has been
hit with a lot of class action lawsuits

about, about user data and privacy.

And that becomes even more.

Important and critical around industries like
health and finance, where that data

is very, you know, obviously a lot of people
have heard of HIPAA, um, health

privacy data policies and
things like that.

Um, it becomes even more sensitive
and important around

things like health and finance.

So back in it's, we started getting notices,
I think in December of 24.

So this last year, and then things really
started rolling out in January of this

year, but so meta had rolled out
this essentially this.

Process and set up in their system where
they scan the website, the URL, where

you're sending all of these great events
that we've been talking about, like

purchase events, things like that.

When those come in, they scan that website
with an automated system and kind

of like how the ad review process works
and how they scan ad landing pages.

Similar, but different and distinct.

They scan and look for, for any content
or data that could be.

Sensitive.

So health and wellness related financial
related things like that.

Um, the original rollout that happened in
January, they started it, I think

their highest priority level, which was

anything that goes after a
specific condition.

So if you're selling a treatment for.

Anxiety or cancer or something like, like
very specific, they went after those

advertisers first and what happens is
they scan the URL on the website.

And then they apply a category that's
like a health and wellness category.

Um, if you're curious, if you are, are in
that category, it might be in the

events manager that we talked about in
the settings, there's a section that

says manage data source categories.

And you can go in there and see if your
domain has been categorized, but.

Um, they rolled out a category that was
health and wellness condition.

And there to your point, Brad, this is a
big deal because the restriction that

came that accompanied that in events manager
was you lost your lower funnel

events, most likely, um, the reason for that
is those are all intent based events.

Right.

So anyone can accidentally click an ad
hit a website, but let's say I have

athletes foot, right?

Gross.

I go, I see an Adam like best athletes,
but treatment suite, I go to the site.

I add to cart and I purchase that sending
a pretty strong signal back to meta that

that I have athletes foot because I purchased
a treatment and that's what

that site's about.

So that's what they were trying to
eliminate is so they eliminated

everything below, lower in the
funnel interview content.

So I had the car initiate checkout, all
the pay ad payment method purchase,

all that stuff and went away.

So that's a huge deal because 90% of
advertisers are, are optimizing for

purchase, you lose that event.

Your performance is going to pretty much
start degrading immediately,

which is what we saw.

So, um, you know, there were some
options that came up.

There were options on X that were talked a
lot about like, um, using custom events.

Ironically, meta originally
said, don't do that.

They produce documentation that
said, don't do that.

But now there's like.

Dozens of firsthand accounts of meta reps
actually telling advertisers

use custom events and just
keep advertising.

But that was the solution then was, you
know, um, use an event that in all

practical purposes is a purchase event,
but call it something else, call it

success or call it, you know, whatever.

And we'll pass that back.

Only those standard events like
purchase are blocked.

So you can keep using these
custom events.

And that was, that was a solution
for a while that worked.

I'd say it was probably about Mike, just
my take was about 60% successful.

We heard some that it didn't work for,
but some it did work for.

Um, and then in June, they introduced a
new wrinkle and they introduced a new

categorization that was health and wellness
other, which is a lot more gray

area and like generalistic, but it's essentially
any business that's like,

or advertiser that's tangential
to health and wellness.

So not even a condition, but, um, you
know, it can be all sorts of things

that are related to health and wellness.

And you get hit with this health and
wellness other categorization.

And the restriction is, is that you get
put into what's called core setup.

You don't get lose your bottom of
funnel events necessarily,

but they put you into core setup.

Core setup.

I've seen some stuff on Twitter from
some people like, oh, core

setup will destroy your ad account.

I don't totally agree with that
on a technical level.

Cause core setup was around before
health and wellness.

They've used it in like other
industries like finance.

It's just a way to close some data loopholes
so that as advertisers, we

can't pass sensitive data back in like URL
parameters like UTMs or in event data.

So I can't add a custom parameter
to my purchase event.

That's like credit score, right?

They block that cause they're
like, you're in finance.

You can't send that stuff.

So it's a, it's a way to close
data loopholes.

What's been interesting though is, and
this is from talking to dozens

and dozens of advertisers.

It seems though, however, when that categorization
is applied to the dataset,

that there is some negative impact
on the ad account.

Um, one client referred to it as a mysterious
force, which is, I think

is about as specific as we can be.

Meta has not produced any like documentation
or comms on this, but you

know, once we saw it across.

Dozens and dozens of accounts, you're like,
okay, this isn't just a one-off.

This is a, this is a trend.

This is a thing where once that health
and wellness categorization hits the

dataset and you're put into core setup,
we've seen like spend dropping

conversion rate, dropping CPA, like going

up, like negative impact
on the ad account.

And so all we're left to sort of deduce
from that is once you get categorized,

there is a negative impact on your ad
account and a lot of advertisers

have been struggling with that.

So to your point, Brad, like, I know that
was like a long winded backstory,

but it's a very real thing.

And there's a lot of really high level
operators that I respect.

And I know they know their stuff where
they're like, nothing else changed.

This happened and it's been like a decline
since then and immediately.

So it's definitely a real thing.

It's impacted a lot of advertisers.

Unfortunately, there hasn't been a lot of
clarity and comms around like who

qualifies or doesn't the only real option
you have is there's a manual review

button that you can be like
request review.

And then you sit there like this
and hope that that works.

And then if it comes back and is
like your SLL that's it.

And so, um, there are some options.

But it's, that's really all you can do.

No, no great options.

Um, I mean, since I've been running and

he's dick pills.com, it's
been tough for us.

Honestly, though, there's no, a lot of
your own information back to meta.

Yeah, there isn't, there doesn't seem to
be a great way to navigate this, which

is one of the most depressing things that
I tell, like we had a rash of people

that joined off of a blog post.

Um, that we still regularly have people
that are affected by this.

And I'm like, there's really not anything
magical I can tell you to do.

Those that approach you, Brad,
is it similar?

Like you said, there's not, are there
anything that they can do?

I mean, you can obviously eliminate claims
from your landing pages, you know,

that kind of thing, but it doesn't,
not anything technically.

There are options.

Um, there are solutions that I won't necessarily
go into detail on the podcast.

Um, one of those 387 listeners might be
an engineer at meta and I don't

want them coming for me, but, um, there are,
there are a couple of things we can

do that we've helped some advertisers
put in place to deal with that.

Um, if anyone that's listening is interested,
just reach out, um, my

emails, just Brett, be our ETT at tag hero.io
or send a message to our website.

But just, just reach out and like, we can
talk through like what we would want to

look at is exactly what are you seeing?

Like what restrictions do you have?

What are you facing?

And then we could talk about what are
some potential solutions.

Um, there are some things
that can be done.

Um, candidly, there's nothing that the
only things you can do that comply

with terms, metas terms are you use your
like good old view content

event for optimization, which is an ideal,
or you try to scrub your site

and submit for a review, but like we've
had clients be like, even if we could

do that, like, especially in medical,
they're like, it's going to take us

almost like a year between generating all
the new copy, running it through

legal approvals, like getting it up on
the site and redesign, like it's

just going to take forever.

So there's not a lot of good options.

And candidly, we've seen a really low
success rate on those reviews.

Um, the ones we've heard about that are
successful usually have aggressive,

um, reps at meta inside to help push that
stuff through, but we see a

really low rate on those.

We have seen some successful,
but overall low rate.

So outside of those things, there are a
couple of technical things that we

might be able to do to help, but it really
depends on your situation and,

and what you're seeing and dealing with.

And then maybe there's some ways we can
help, but, um, it's, it's tough for

everyone because, you know, a lot of these
advertisers, we, you know, you, we

have a client and a friend who sells bath
bombs and they were categorized and

he's just like WTF, right?

Like where we sell bath bombs, like, is
this really health and wellness?

And it's tough.

And they were having, you know, some
pretty significant negative

impact on their ad account.

So it has really impacted a
lot of advertisers.

And it's one of those things that's
just curve ball, right?

And like very frustrating
for a lot of them.

Yeah.

I mean, I, I was quoted in an investor
business daily article that I got

interviewed for about this, that I think
it's fundamentally unfair that some of

these people, some people can like hound
a rep and can like get basically, you

know, oh yeah, no worries.

And then there's all these other people
that exist in the world that are like

running completely legitimate companies
that don't have the same level.

This just feels it's just unfair.

And there's always the golden rule
with that too, right?

If you spend enough gold, you
can break the rules.

So like there's elements of that too.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Um, guys, anything else?

I have, um, maybe this is like two in
the weeds and maybe this is a

topic for another discussion, but have
you seen, um, anything work well

related to not optimizing for purchase?

Like you've set up, so you mentioned like
the new, new customer event, but

that's still kind of related to purchase.

But I know there's a bunch of like quiz
funnel completions you could try.

I know Cody from Jones road has talked about,
um, other mid funnel events that

he's testing, he's seen, he's seen some success
with, he specifically mentioned

they had a great podcast with, um, Eric.

I don't want to say his last
name, Seafruit maybe.

Um, and they kind of talked about this
idea of signal engineering.

Something that Cody said that
was really interesting.

And I think Eric said on the podcast,
these are try is like adding in some

friction if you're going to try a mid funnel
event, like, Hey, send people to

the landing page, but don't fire the view
content on the landing page, but

optimize review content, which is
the next page after that.

So somebody has to go through the landing
page and then get to the product

page, have you seen any like crazy setups
that have actually been meaningful?

Everybody's just guessing and
seeing if it works.

No, I mean, and at the end of the day,
it's hard because I'd say like, try

test it and every account is so different
that like, it's rare that blanket

advice just works for everybody.

Um, you know, and the other thing I'd
just be upfront about is we, we, we

don't always get the backend, like media
buying insight and results.

Like after we've worked on stuff or put
things in, they don't come back to us

necessarily and be like, we do it definitely
here on some things like this

works versus not, but like, um, I think
some of that stuff is definitely worth

testing, you know, I think, I think especially
for large brands, like a

Jones road, high spend, right?

I think you get to a certain point where you
can almost tap out like the purchase

event optimization.

Cause if you think about it, when that is
really doing is saying, well, we were

talking about earlier with the MQ, Brad, you
go on Jones road, you get, you know,

some, some exfoliant, whatever it is.

And they're like, cool, Brad bought this.

Let's go find more brands.

Well, you get to the point where that, where
that process you start like with

huge daily spends and stuff, you
start to tap that out.

So I've definitely heard of large brands
with large spends, like over time,

especially where it's like, we've
been running ads for years.

We're spending a hundred thousand
dollars a day or whatever.

And it's like, you get to the point where
maybe introducing some upper funnel

events just will sort of tweak and shock
the system a little bit and go after a

different pool and sort of cohort of users
on the platform and bring them in.

So I think like optimizing for that stuff
is definitely worth a test, like

optimizing for upper funnel events.

And then, yeah, I mean, I, I think at the
end of the day, what is a purchase

event to meta, right?

It's an intent.

It's this user converted on the site.

So we want to go find more of them.

So I think in that same light, if you want
to optimize for a quiz completion,

that's pretty high intent.

Someone clicked your ad and went to a
site and went through a whole quiz

process and submitted some info.

That's pretty high intent.

Let's go after other people who are
going to complete the quiz.

Cause at the end of the day, worst case
scenario, maybe they're not converting

immediately, but you are getting like,
they're, they're getting pixeled when

they hit your site for retargeting or,
you know, you're getting their email,

maybe with the quiz for email
marketing and retention.

There's, there's some other things, positives
that can come out of it too,

other than just a pure like purchase
transaction conversion.

So I think it's definitely worth
testing that stuff.

One, just like anecdotal thing we saw a
long time ago when I was running more

on my agency, we had a client that
was very lead based.

They, they produce tons of lead magnets,
like recipes and things like that.

And initially we were optimizing
for the lead event, right?

Which was great.

We got tons of leads and like we put these
lead magnets out and got a lot of leads.

But when we did a cohort analysis afterward,
they weren't, we were getting a

lot of leads and they're, you know, they
might've been converting other ways,

but we weren't getting actually a ton of

like purchase conversions
at the end of it.

Like commensurate with the lead volume.

So we ran a test and instead of optimizing
for leads, we actually optimized

for purchases so that those ads with those
lead magnets were actually shown to

people who were more like our purchasers and
not people who were just more likely

to complete a lead and it takes a little
bit of work outside of just like period

platform metrics, but when we looked at the
cohort analysis on the backend, that

group, even though it was a lead magnet,
they're just down there.

The purchase value of that cohort was much
higher than the lead event optimization.

So I definitely think there's an element
of like signal engineering and kind of

like what you want.

I would still tell most advertisers optimize
for what you want, which is a

purchase, but I think if you get to certain
size and scale or you want to try

other intent based things like, like quizzes
or, you know, the thing with like

the view content after a landing page to
add a little more friction, what that

does is that makes that view content event
have a little more intent to it

because you had to take an extra step.

Um, I know the guys that are obvious at
one point, we're working on this too.

Cause like they were like,
how much signal

can we send the minute they
hit the website?

So we're capturing as much as possible.

Like there's a couple of different ways to
look at that, but, um, especially the

stuff on the higher intense stuff like
quizzes, I think it's fire an event.

When you complete a quiz, optimize toward
that and see what that does.

Maybe take some winning ads that you know
are successful and try that and

see how the results compare.

Um, I think a lot of that is definitely
worth testing and accounts for sure.

Yeah.

And we saw the same thing with lead optimization
for what's worth with people

who do like early access to new product
launches and things like that.

Um, and then that's probably ultimately
also why meta changed the way that you

can optimize for a conversion based lead
in more recently where you can connect

your CRM and actually tell them, okay, people
are actually progressing down the

funnel and that you can optimize for those
things, those things better because

yeah, optimizing for lead might just
get you a bunch of shit leads.

If you don't add some friction there.

So yeah, that's a great point.

Yep.

Cool.

Brett, thank you for joining us
and, uh, we appreciate it.

And, uh, if anybody has any questions,
feel free to hit up tag hero or

email me, Andrew at Foxwell, digital.com.

Um, I've had five people do that.

So wow, big numbers and, uh, everybody's
one of them.

Yeah.

Everybody have a great rest of the day.

Thank you.

This episode is brought to you by Homestead's
email and SMS service.

Honestly, we've, we've done an episode
with, with Jacob from Homestead.

He's the man and he's got, he's got to
be probably one of the smartest

email and retention operators like on
the agency side hands down.

I look forward to seeing the tweets that
he puts out basically every

single month with like a recap of the
designs and as amazing as the

designs themselves are, it's the actual
like tactical behind the scenes work.

Where he just like knows what he's doing.

And the team at Homestead, like really
know what they're doing on email.

SMS probably, if not the number one,
very, very close to competing for

a number one retention agency
in the DTC space.

So just killing it.

Yeah, absolutely agree.

You know, if you are looking at your emails
and you're like, these are terrible

and you know, you can optimize the flows
and you know, you can do SMS better.

You got to look at the Homestead team.

So check them out, reach out and they can
definitely help make your entire

email and retention and SMS program
so much better.

And I'm not just saying that we've
all seen the work.

I actually had a member who sat down with,
with Jacob at the founder meetup

that we had, and he came over to me and said,
I just talked to him for 10 minutes

and literally he, he's revolutionized
my entire email department.

So agencies are modeling themselves off of
what Jacob is giving them for advice.

So anyway, onwards to hopefully
working with them.

The only way that we grow this podcast is
by you sharing it with your friends.

Honestly, like reviews kind of don't really
mean anything too much anymore.

They're really meaningful, but they don't
do a lot for the growth of the podcast.

And so sharing YouTube links, sharing Spotify
links, sharing Apple, whatever

we call it under the podcast app now,
anything you can share, the better

we're going to be guys, anything else
you want to say on this?

Yeah, please go check us out on YouTube.

Rack up those views for us.

We'd love to see it.

And then subscribe.

Make sure to subscribe on
YouTube as well.

And I relentlessly refresh the YouTube
comments because it dictates

my mental health for the day.

So please say something nice
about all of us.

Thank you everyone.

Thanks for listening.

Honestly.