Retailgentic, presented by the ReFiBuy Media Network and hosted by Scot Wingo, is where Agentic Commerce meets retail innovation. We help retailers and brands prepare for the future of agent-driven shopping with actionable news, expert insights, dxis, forward-looking predictions, and practical guidance on Agentic Commerce Optimization (ACO).
I think what's even more interesting perhaps, is just surveys that we do with consumers. It's not 100%, but it's certainly indicative of a lot of willingness among consumers to use agents to do shopping. There are a lot of people who don't like to shop. There are a lot of people who are intimidated by price comparisons. And some of these are big ticket items as well.
Speaker 1:So it's not that difficult to come up with a forecast for Agentic Commerce just based on a significant number of people willing to shop this way.
Speaker 2:Welcome to the Retailgentic podcast where we explore the intersection of retail, ecommerce, and AI agents, which we call Retailgentic. Our mission is simple. We are shining a bright light on the new Agentic AI shopping megatrend which will disrupt the trillion dollar digital retail market. The stakes are high. Google, OpenAI, Microsoft, Perplexity, Amazon, Apple, Meta, and Anthropic are all fighting to be the Consumer AI Shopping Agent winner.
Speaker 2:There are gonna be some tough decisions for online brands and retailers to make. What happens to checkout? How should payments work? Could you continue to invest in retail media networks? What does the world look like when over half of your traffic is not from humans but from AI agents?
Speaker 2:These existential questions are the tip of the iceberg. On this podcast, we're talking to industry experts, analysts, and influencers to get answers to these questions, identify trends, and best practices. This is Retailgentic, your podcast partner in navigating our AI shopping agent future. And now here's your host, Wingo.
Speaker 3:Welcome to this episode of Retailgentic. Before we jump in, I wanted to remind everyone that at Refi Buy, we recently announced our Agentic Commerce Optimization Everywhere, ACO Everywhere strategy. And, as part of that, we are opening up a design partner program for Amazon where we will help you optimize Alexa shopping. We have a couple slots left open for that. If you are interested, let me know.
Speaker 3:Sometimes fellow entrepreneurs ask me, hey, Scot, why do you spend so much time talking to all these Wall Street people and going to the various trade shows at Wall Street, our guest conferences? That's a good question. And the answer is as CEO, as a startup in this very fast moving space, it's my job to try to predict the future and that's very hard. So I find the more pieces of data I can get my hands on, the clearer the future becomes. And I can, even with all that, I can only see six months out in this kind of, time frame.
Speaker 3:So it's kind of fun and scary all at the same time. What I really have to do is understand the super macro fundamentals. You know, what's going on with AI? What's going on with all this investment everyone's making? How's that impacting retail?
Speaker 3:And then how do Wall Street investors think about all the individual companies? Because these companies are... That fuels micro, but these companies are now $4.05, 6,000,000,000,000 companies. That's not micro. That's macro.
Speaker 3:And so I find that this is the best lens out there for me to understand what's going on. One of the top folks in this field is Colin Sebastian, and he is today's guest. Colin is the Managing Director of Internet Research at RW Baird, commonly just Baird, and he is one of the leading Wall Street analysts on the sell side. So he covers Amazon, Google, Meta, eBay, Shopify. That's a subset of what he covers.
Speaker 3:He also does a bunch of other things that he'll go into, in the conversation. But with... Just with those, five companies, that's over $12,000,000,000,000 in market cap that that that he has an influence on and follows very closely to the point of, you know, very detailed financial models on every company, conversations with management, channel checks, the amount of information these guys gather, and they have a team, is very, very impressive. And and it's super helpful to talk to them because they can hold it all in their head, which is, also impressive. In this wide ranging conversation, we talk about how Wall Street thinks about Agentic Commerce.
Speaker 3:Are they excited about it? Do they understand it? Then we go through the big players in sequence. We go Meta, Amazon, Google, eBay, Shopify. And then in that conversation, we take a couple of side journeys over to retail media networks and Amazon ads.
Speaker 3:We talk about payments and the impact there. And then we talk about who the winners and losers are as e commerce changes more in the next twenty four months than it has in the last fifteen years. And now here is my conversation with Colin Sebastian. Welcome to Retailgentic. My guest today is Colin Sebastian.
Speaker 3:He is Baird's Managing Director of Internet Research. Colin, welcome to the pod.
Speaker 1:Yeah. Thanks, Scot. Really, really happy to be here. You're sort of turning the tables on me this time.
Speaker 3:Yeah. Yeah. You and I just did a Wall Street event. Let's see. It was kind of, early June.
Speaker 3:Is that right? Or was it late May? Yeah. And, yeah, it was a lot of fun. And that conversation...
Speaker 3:So it's, you know, it's it's a couple of us in a room, and and then the audience is bunch of investors. And it was really always interesting to hear their questions. And I know you also... The questions you ask are from from them as well. So I thought...
Speaker 3:I was thinking to myself, I thought... I think the audience, the Retailgentic audience would be interested in hearing what is Wall Street thinking about as it relates to Agentic Commerce. Because as practitioners, we... We're down in the weeds. And then you're you're you're pretty unique from a Wall Street analyst perspective.
Speaker 3:I've known... First of I've known you for... I'm gonna guess at least... I think you're, like, one of the earliest catalysts at ChannelAdvisor if I recall. You were always like.
Speaker 1:It's been a little while.
Speaker 3:Yeah. You're known for going to trade shows and kinda, like, really doing a lot of research on the ground, kinda like boots on the ground type research, which is great. So you've you've, you know, you've gone to most of the shop talks. I I remember you going to Internet retailer back in the day. Let's So just call it, like, about twenty years, I would say.
Speaker 3:That's how long we've known each other. Fifteen years Yeah. And, you know, and and in that time, one thing I I love is you you understand what we do in our world from not quite a practitioner, but right touching what we do is like day to day all the way up to the Wall Street part. So I I thought that would be interesting to pick your brain.
Speaker 1:Happy to be here. Thank you.
Speaker 3:Before we do that, help people understand a little bit about your background, some of the firms you've been, how you got in to being an analyst, and then we'll go from there.
Speaker 1:Twenty years on Wall Street. I think we're rounding numbers. That's fine. I actually started out in investment banking, that side of the business for a couple of years, but sort of saw the lights and found my way over to the equity research side. But before all of that, I worked as a business analyst developing a new software application for a bond underwriting company.
Speaker 1:And before that, I worked as a bartender and dishwasher during college. Those are my credentials for covering e commerce, I suppose. Yeah, covering Internet at Baird for the past fifteen years, and that really means e commerce, social media, and online advertising. I dabble a little bit in video games as well. And there are so many companies that fall under these sectors that I really only cover a selection of those, particularly ones that we feel are strong companies with good long term growth prospects.
Speaker 3:What's your coverage universe at Baird?
Speaker 1:We cover from the mega caps, including Amazon, Alphabet, Meta, through the mid caps, Airbnb, Shopify, eBay, Instacart, all the way through some of the smaller cap companies like Pattern, again, within the e commerce, social media, and online advertising spaces. So it's a pretty broad coverage, but as Wall Street defines Internet, that's where we sit.
Speaker 3:One Wall Street acronym it took me a while to unpack is TMT, which stands for technology, media, and telecom. So a lot of the a lot of the banks have these, like, kind of big chunks of industries that are put together. But it's interesting because you cover Amazon, but you're not, somewhere at Baird is a retail analyst. I don't happen to know the gentleman's name, but I'm sure there's... Or or lady, there's an analyst there that covers retail, and it...
Speaker 3:It's kind of interesting. Like, I know you guys tend to... Other other, analysts kinda, like, fight for a name, or there's, like, kind of a little bit of a discussion internally because because you're set up with these verticals, but then many companies break that and cut across verticals.
Speaker 1:Yeah, that's right. And I think one of the common denominators among these so called Internet companies is they are really technology companies, first and foremost, as opposed to being a content company or a retailer first and foremost. So that's traditionally how we define the space, that's worked pretty well.
Speaker 3:Yeah. I think you're the only Internet analyst I know that also covers the video game category. So that... That's a... An interesting side side hustle that you have there.
Speaker 1:There's not much left, be honest, on that front, but there are a few holdouts.
Speaker 3:This this is the time. So we got GTA six coming out. What do you, I know that's not what listeners are here for, but I'm intellectually curious what are what are your... Is that gonna be just a record breaking? I know there's, like...
Speaker 3:People are... There's so much anticipation of this game. Like, there's some guy on the Internet that goes out and, like, monitors their parking lot for how many people are working at at Rockstar Games to see how many... Yeah. See see if he thinks it's getting close to go time and all this kind of stuff, but we're we're we're at the cusp of that coming up.
Speaker 1:Yeah. Well, you you know how we do our research now, so that's boots on the ground, right? Yeah, this should be the biggest entertainment launch of all time. And I guess if it's not, that would be a disappointment. But it's certainly going to set a new cycle for pop culture.
Speaker 1:And think about tens of millions of people buying the game at launch and and then playing it for for many years. So if you don't know what GTA six is today, I'm sure you'll know by the end of November.
Speaker 3:And I think you had a note where... I don't wanna say the number, but but you you had a pretty big kinda launch prediction for that. What... Remind me of the number.
Speaker 1:We have modeled 35 to 40,000,000 units for the game within their first sort of reported period. So that... That's a pretty significant number of people buying the game.
Speaker 3:Yeah. And what's that translate to in dollars?
Speaker 1:Well, it's... We we project it to be, you know, well over a billion dollars over its first year. So that's That's great. That's what defines the record launch.
Speaker 3:Yeah. You compare that to movie box office, very few movies make it past $100,000,000 much less up to that billion mark.
Speaker 1:Yeah. Good point.
Speaker 3:It's gonna be the biggest cultural event of Q4. So get ready everybody.
Speaker 1:We hope so.
Speaker 3:And then explain to the audience how the buy side and the sell side... I think I have a pretty good understanding, but you you can probably explain it better than I do, just so that folks understand that.
Speaker 1:Yeah. So, you know, the buy side means the institutional investors who own stock and all these companies we're talking about, they're often some of the largest shareholders of public and private companies. They often have a lot of influence and make their views heard, you well know, Scot. So these are mutual funds, pension funds, hedge funds predominantly, and those are our clients. So the sell side where I am, we provide services such as equity research, advising the buy side and their investments, providing perspective and information related to specific sectors and companies.
Speaker 1:You mentioned attending conferences, boots on the ground. So that's information we gather and distill for the buy side. And then we also have trading desks where the buy side will buy and sell stock. And then for companies, the sell side offers help in raising capital through IPOs and private placements or debts, and then advisory services such as M and A. So think buy side of the investors, the sell side are the service providers to those investors.
Speaker 3:Yeah. And the investors are further kind of segmented into mutual funds, some... What do you call the ones like altimeter that's a hybrid where it does private and public? And then then you have hedge funds, and and there's like a whole bunch of sub
Speaker 1:cash Pension funds.
Speaker 3:Pension funds. Yeah. It's it's really interesting to kinda get to know that as as... Yeah. And I had the...
Speaker 3:I was fortunate enough because I got to meet most... A lot of the Wall Street folks before we took channel adviser public, and then after public, I got to really experience the whole the whole... The good and the bad of all the Wall Street stuff. It's pretty crazy.
Speaker 1:As you know well, a lot of the distinction is between long only funds, companies that hold stock, buy stock and hold stock versus short funds, which... Know, hedge funds typically that that short stock on companies. So that's that's often how we distinguish between the funds as well.
Speaker 3:And then another thing you have to do is you have to... You know, you don't just get sit sit there and write like I do. You have to make some calls. Right? Because people are, you know, you you know, you have to pick winners, and...
Speaker 3:Which is interesting because we... You know, I've been doing a bunch of predictions for a long time, and it... It's an... It's incredibly hard. And today...
Speaker 3:It's always been hard, and it's increasingly getting harder in today's world. And so so explain to folks your rating system that you have at Baird and maybe reveal a couple of your top picks right now.
Speaker 1:Yeah. So our feet are held to the fire pretty closely on our on our stock picks, but that's that's just part of the job. So I guess first and foremost, mean, mentioned the ratings. We have outperform rating for stocks that should outperform the market, neutral and then underperform, so stocks that would, we think, underperform markets. So it doesn't...
Speaker 1:Assuming they go down or up, it just means relative performance versus the S and P or NASDAQ. That's the way a lot of investors are evaluated as well. So that's aligned with our clients. But we need an investment framework and covering Internet, for us, we use something that we call SPEED, and that's really an acronym for scale, product, engineering, efficiency, and data. And when you have all of those, you get to the point where there's so much gravitational pull.
Speaker 1:We see this in platform companies or winner take all markets, but those also tend to be the best stocks. So last year, our top pick was Alphabet or Google, and that played out well as thought investors were really underestimating Google's capabilities in Gen AI and overestimating Open AI's moat. So luckily enough, Google got to work and was able to show through Gemini and Google Cloud some of the innovations there. This year we made Meta our topic, sort of counter consensus, but we think the market has been punishing the stock due to all the spend on AI engineering and infrastructure, but without the benefit of seeing new products and services that come to market. And so like Google last year, we felt that as Meta models see the light of day this year, and those are incorporated into the family of apps, you'll get things like business agents and WhatsApp, Meta AI and Instagram, and things like Agentic Commerce ultimately.
Speaker 1:And you'll start to see that in usage and monetization. So starting to see this play out, we think, but the verdict isn't isn't quite in just yet.
Speaker 3:And as we're recording this, they they started licensing out their data centers. So they're they're becoming a, you know, network network infrastructure kind of company, which is interesting. And then some of their GPUs, and then they announced a model. So that... And then the stock's on a little bit of a bump.
Speaker 3:So, you know, I'll... I I won't... I don't wanna curse it, but you're on your
Speaker 1:And your cross.
Speaker 3:Looking pretty good. Yes. Got it. And then, so so that's good. You mentioned our favorite topic a little bit.
Speaker 3:Let's jump into it, Agentic Commerce. I always like to ask folks, because, we've discovered everyone has a very wide range of this, what's your definition of Agentic Commerce?
Speaker 1:The way I look at it, again, looking at it from a Wall Street investment perspective, but understanding how companies are approaching it, it's about, I think, collapsing the traditional shopping funnel. And if you think about moving from a messy series of clicks towards what I think will be a single closed loop transaction layer and AI agents do all the heavy lifting, that is, I guess, the pure form of Agentic Commerce, but clearly multiple steps before we get to the point where transaction checkout fulfillment are all sort of handled automatically. And I think this speaks to one of the issues as an analyst, which is we often kind of get stuck not thinking beyond where we are today. And so in this current stage of Agentic Commerce, which may be more about discovery as a way of using AI apps, if that were the end game, then maybe it's debatable if that's Agentic Commerce, but it's really just a stage of development. And we're going to move to a stage where AI actively helps us complete purchases.
Speaker 1:We can see that with aggregating carts, applying loyalty programs, handling the checkout flow directly inside these conversational interfaces. So I think we're getting a lot of indications or breadcrumbs as to how this will play out. But full autonomy is where I think a lot of the debate is happening, real automation. But if you think about things like recurring purchases where you can easily tell your AI assistant you're out of toilet paper and you don't need to be searching and shopping for stuff like that, I don't think it's too controversial to say that we'll let the agent do the walking. So I would say that's not really an answer, but that's how I think about Agenda Commerce.
Speaker 3:The tricky thing some of the naysayers do is they're kind of like, Well, the only thing that can be automated is toilet paper and stuff. Therefore, the TAM of this is tiny, and therefore, it's a mirage. So they they use the definition to then make all these kinda, like, you know, further on assumptions that I don't think are are fair because I think I think people will use it in assisted kinda way. They'll they'll they'll dip in and out. It'll be just like a tool set in your tool bag as a shopper that you use, just like Google Search was.
Speaker 1:I think the complexity of running fully autonomous shopping is where some people stumble. I mean, whether it's thinking about payments and authentication and all the post purchase support that's involved, right? But it doesn't take a lot of imagination to see a future where, just like agents are helping people in a lot of other use cases, obviously we're seeing in coding, we're seeing in marketing services, we're seeing it sort of this domino effect across different parts of the economy and different use cases. Shopping is just one of those use cases. And in that context, as agents are acting more autonomously, it makes a ton of sense for a lot of people to allow you just to do shopping on their behalf.
Speaker 1:So I'm not as skeptical probably as some others are.
Speaker 3:I I like to ask questions I know the answer to already, but it's for the audience. Do you have, like, a initiation report on Agentic Commerce where you kinda came out and said, this is what it is. This is how big I think it is. Have you have you done something kinda like a big tome like that for Agentic Commerce?
Speaker 1:We we've estimated, you know, that there are eventually trillions of dollars to be spent through stages of Agentic Commerce. I think what's even more interesting perhaps, is just surveys that we do with consumers. And I think there's already... It's not 100%, but it's certainly indicative of a lot of willingness among consumers to use agents to do shopping. There are a lot of people who don't like to shop.
Speaker 1:There are a lot of people who are intimidated by price comparisons. Some of these are big ticket items as well. So it's not that difficult to come up with a forecast for Agentic Commerce just based on a significant number of people willing to shop this way by the amount of spend that they do each year on shopping and then increasing that over time. So yeah, we have put together research on this. I would say it suggests it will be a significant part of e commerce over the next five years.
Speaker 3:Yeah. Do you think it will be... So that that kind of makes it seem kind of like we're changing the slice of the pie or that it's kind of cannibalistic to e commerce. Do you think there's any incrementality or have you seen evidence of that at all?
Speaker 1:Oh yeah, I definitely think it's incremental. I think it's, I mean, first of all, e commerce is still likely less than 20% of total retail. So we're talking not only just where e commerce is conducted, but it's the other 80% of retail spend. And anything that helps unlock that, whether it's a new marketplace or new technology, we can see that accelerate that share shift from offline to online. And Agentic Commerce is certainly going to cannibalize some existing ways of shopping online, but it's also gonna facilitate more shopping versus what people do today in stores.
Speaker 1:So in that case, we think it accelerates e commerce.
Speaker 3:What year do you think... Are you looking at, like, 2030 before we feel that? Like, where... When do you think we'll start to kinda be able to measure that and say, holy cow. There's been a material acceleration here.
Speaker 1:I think we'll see it this holiday. I think we'll see it. Still, the numbers may be relatively small, but I think I think you'll...
Speaker 3:But a point or two on 8% is material Yeah.
Speaker 1:That's right.
Speaker 3:A material acceleration.
Speaker 1:And, of course, we'll debate still over the holidays what Agentic Commerce really means. But in terms of using AI agents to facilitate shopping, if we can define it that way, I think we'll see another step function after this holiday.
Speaker 3:So in your coverage universe, have on one side, you you kinda called them the mega caps, but they're kind of the big platform companies, and they have all this distribution. You got Amazon, Google, Meta, eBay. EBay is kinda weird because they kinda... And so is Amazon to some degree because then they're also... On the other side, have merchant service type companies.
Speaker 3:And, you know, Shopify is obviously in that camp. Instacart's kind of there, but they're also consumer, and then you could argue eBay. I think sometimes you put eBay in that bucket as well. But let... Let's start at the big platform companies, and, you know, walk us through what you see at at those big guys, and what they're doing around Agentic Commerce.
Speaker 3:So for example, you you talked about Meta. That's one that that I write a lot about, and I don't think a lot of people are taking them seriously. But, and I just I just noticed, we just posted this out on LinkedIn that they've they've taken the Meta AI, and they've put some of the Facebook marketplace, inventory in there, which I thought was pretty interesting. So you get that local. So you get the the kinda like the nationally available and a local kind of flavor.
Speaker 3:So walk us through your your your big caps and and what you think's going on there and where you see it going.
Speaker 1:Getting with with Meta, since you mentioned it, I I think... I mean, they have a really differentiated angle here because of the social graph. They have the combination of all of your personal preferences. They have immediate and intense signals. Obviously, from a merchant's perspective, brand's perspective, they have billions of users sitting at the gate ready to go.
Speaker 1:And they are rolling it out through a combination of business agents across the apps, and that turns chat threads into direct conversational discovery to checkout channels. But in MedAI, which you mentioned, I mean, is sort of like your own personal ChatGBT within Instagram or Facebook or WhatsApp merged with all your social data. That's a really unique approach to search and shopping over time, we think could be very impactful with respect to Agentic Commerce, and certainly something they are investing a lot in front of. As you indicated, you'll start to see shopping becoming a more important part of that, and we'll see how they monetize that, if it's just through ads or perhaps through some sort of outcome or transaction model. Amazon, this is one where we debate a lot with investors.
Speaker 1:Right now they're sort of at the crux of the open versus closed debate. And what they want to do is they want to shift their position from being a shopping destination to being sort of the discovery or origin layer. And to that end, they're focused on their first party agent, Rufus, or I guess that's Alexa for shopping now. And they want to maintain the Prime shopping experience, along with capturing more of the search and discovery flow. So that's their public posture.
Speaker 1:It's about trust. It's about Prime. What they don't want is to be associated with external bots where deliveries are late or the prices aren't correct or there's some other bad experience. What we think will happen is that they will do deals with the LMs over time, maybe even this year, but they're just holding the line until those companies agree to Amazon's terms effectively. But to date, they're a big proponent of Agentic Commerce, right?
Speaker 1:They're seeing big increases in engagement through their own first party agents. They're rolling out features like Buy For Me, and they're also licensing their architecture externally, like with Kate Spade. So I I think that they are going to be one of the most important players here, not too surprisingly. I think they're a much bigger advocate of Agentic Commerce than maybe they let on, especially given their posture relative to the LLMs, but I think that'll change pretty quickly.
Speaker 3:Yeah. One one of the debates on Amazon is they joined UCP, and there's a set of folks that believe they're, like you, they're they're kinda writing the code, and they will eventually sell on ChatGPT. I'm I'm not... You know, you you kinda hinted at some point they may do them. I think it's actually the other way for UCP, because I think I think they get really worried because there's lot of brands that don't wanna sell on Amazon.
Speaker 3:So they've got the shop direct thing where they can get... Just kinda crawl and let... And send people there. And increasingly, you see... I I spent a lot of time in the artist previously known as Rufus, now Alexa.
Speaker 3:And it it it increasingly... It will send you off-site pretty pretty regularly and maybe even a bit... Like, sometimes even before a third party seller. I'm not exactly... They're probably tuning that, but it's kind of unusual.
Speaker 3:Anyway, I think they're gonna they're gonna have it where you can buy third party stuff. They already have the buy for me thing, but it's pretty fragile. It's a web based form fill, and it... It's got, like, six... You have to do this and this and this and this.
Speaker 3:So the percentage of companies that can do it is, like, two, or, like, there's only two companies at the end of the day out of, the top 2,000 retailers. And, anyway, they... So so I think they're gonna use that as a way to, you know, basically, it it have a sphere. The the Amazon will have... If it had one p and three p forever, now we'll have, like, this other, like, you know, use...
Speaker 3:You know, Agentic Commerce purchasing from Amazon, you know, inside of that walled garden. So they're gonna pull stuff into the walled garden versus the walled garden coming down and letting stuff out. They could do both, but I think the sooner thing, the earlier thing they'll do is they'll do that.
Speaker 1:That makes sense to me, and you're obviously very in tune with that. But as Agentic Commerce overall, my general view is that they're gonna be a strong advocate. However, the details sort of work themselves out on their platform.
Speaker 3:Yeah. Think they mentioned it the most if you count occurrences of the, you know, the the terminology and the name of the... Their their bot, they're they're definitely... And they're they're increasingly... I mean, we're seeing this over at Walmart too.
Speaker 3:I know it's not in your coverage universe, but we just discovered wall... Sparky in the in the Walmart search engine on mobile. It is now about half the screen real estate is prompting you to actually ask Sparky something. So so... And we're starting to see that in the core Amazon search experience where if a if a prompt gets...
Speaker 3:It's not just the length of it, but, like, the complexity of this... The search query, it it promptifies it and sends it over to Alexa automatically, which is interesting. Because I think I think they now can... They now have enough data that they see the the Alexa slash Sparky stuff converts pretty darn well, and they're they're feeling increasingly confident sending traffic over there, which is interesting.
Speaker 1:Yeah, in our studies, I think we see conversion rate and spending definitely both increasing as consumers are engaging with these agents. So no wonder that they're sort of doubling down at this point on that.
Speaker 3:Okay. I interrupted your list of the mega caps. So we were at Amazon, Google?
Speaker 1:Yeah. Probably worth mentioning Google. Right? They're kind of taking the other end of the other approach is the open infrastructure layer for Agentic Commerce and shifting monetization model from clicks to outcomes. I mean, it's really impressive how quickly they have pivoted in a way, and not only through Gemini and AI mode and AI overviews and linking those to more shopping experiences, but you already mentioned UCP.
Speaker 1:Mean, they're standardizing the open ecosystem, right? They're co developed, I guess, with Shopify, but also with Stripe and Wayfair and Amazon and practically everybody else on board now. And I think that lets users effectively check out natively inside Gemini, and that's an important place for them to be, especially if you consider, I think, what you've articulated before, Scot, as well, just in terms of traditional search and keyword based marketing, just how quickly that is changing and the open web is collapsing, right? So this is really Google's way of retaining its role in the shopping funnel. And so far, it looks like they've done a really good job with that.
Speaker 3:Yeah. Do you worry they've they've kinda fallen behind the model wars a little bit? So we... We've seen chat to be tea with Sol, s o l, and and I guess, what is it, five six, and and then the the mythos class, we... We've seen this, like, really leap...
Speaker 3:Another leap up in model capability. In Gemini, at Google IO, everyone was very... You know, there's visible moans from the developers there that that they actually weren't gonna release the the pro version of the new model. Do you think that's a big deal, or it's just kinda doesn't matter as long as you have distribution?
Speaker 1:Yeah. I mean, our our thesis, is that the model layer actually gets commoditized for most users, for most consumers certainly, and for plenty of enterprises as well. The incremental gains at this point from the models, unless we're talking about superintelligence or general intelligence, are probably somewhat incremental. Each of the major model companies, including Google or Gemini, plenty good enough, I think, for what they're trying to achieve with respect to Agentic Commerce at this point relative to the others. So it really then becomes the differentiation is within the applications and the platform, that's where Google really shines, I think, with UCP in this specific context and with all the other services that they can provide merchants and brands and consumers.
Speaker 1:So think of models as commoditizing and think of more the value accruing to the platform, application, infrastructure layers.
Speaker 3:I actually, I love eBay and I've had a lot of relationships with eBay over the years, but I've kind of lost track of what they're doing. I know the stock's been up and people like it, but give us a bit of an update on what good old eBay is up to.
Speaker 1:A lot of stocks in e commerce are being evaluated in terms of the perceived positioning within Agentic Commerce, right? We're gonna, sure, we'll talk about Shopify on the other side. Another point, we've talked about Amazon. And I think with eBay, the view is they're in a unique position with, at least relative to other e commerce companies, retailers that sell new and seasoned product. That eBay is somewhat insulated from potential disintermediation because of what they sell, because of the long tail used unique product catalog.
Speaker 1:So I think that's a big part of the thesis and probably what helps support the stock. But to be fair to eBay, they've also put a lot of work into verticalizing by category, focus categories, they call it, and they're seeing a lot of growth in things like luxury watches, bags, trading cards, collectibles, and whether that's a function of specific efforts they've made or that's how the market has moved, I guess we don't know for sure, but they've certainly invested a lot in that. Moving from just a horizontal approach to more of a vertical approach. So I think it's a combination of of those of those things that that has essentially pushed eBay back into growth, which is important for investors, and then also from a from a narrative standpoint, their position in Agentic Commerce.
Speaker 3:Inflation is... A lot of the the re... Recycled fashion type places are really doing well because the inflation has people thinking about, you know, well, if we could find something kinda used for half off, that's a there's a lot of trading down going in, and eBay always wins in those cycles as as people look to... You... You've got the kind of the collectible expensive old stuff, and you've got the cheap old stuff kinda angled that they're always good at.
Speaker 1:Yeah. That's true. I mean, there is that dynamic, and we've even seen it in things like gold bullion and where where they benefit from inflation and and both, you know, commodity inflation, but also the way consumers react to that.
Speaker 3:And then we'll talk about the merchant guys in a second, but let's stay on this topic. Another interesting thing I get a lot of questions about is is in the in the big retailer world, we've got Amazon is blocking bots, and they've got the kind of walled garden approach, and then Walmart's taken the opposite approach. They they they both are investing a lot on their on-site retailer agents or, know, both with Alexa and Sparky. But what do you... Is that something that investors find interesting in...
Speaker 3:Out there? Do you get a lot of questions on that, or is that... You know, what do you what do think about all that?
Speaker 1:Yeah. I think investors are trying to figure out why some companies were very quick to integrate with OpenAI and the LMs in general, others were not. And I think the initial conclusion was that some companies were perhaps afraid or uncertain around their position in Agentic, and so maybe were holding off, and others were more confident in their position and integrated faster. I actually think that view has sort of now turned around, now the view tends to be, Okay, maybe companies that sell new and seasoned product are not as differentiated, were the first or early to integrate with LLMs, and those that were more confident in their own position kind of holding back. So we've seen, in addition to Amazon holding back, eBay for some time held back.
Speaker 1:This is a little off the charts a bit, but Airbnb kind of held back while booking.com reselling hotel rooms was very early in integrating. But Airbnb, because they have a unique collection of short term rentals, held back. They didn't want to give away shop, so to speak. So I think investors are still trying to figure this out, but in general, I think that's the current view, is that those that were very fast to integrate with LMs were probably the ones that were actually feeling potentially most threatened. But for Amazon, I think they own the highest intent shopping traffic, and obviously Prime, they have the full stack.
Speaker 1:They can afford to gate access and demand that the agents play by their roles. And I think Walmart is moving in that direction in their own way with more fulfillment services and the like, but I think that helps explain the difference between the two.
Speaker 3:Yeah, Amazon, I've gotten to know the Amazon. It took me a while to talk to them. They have such their own way of thinking there. And the thing that unlocked it for me was their management principle guide. And in there, one of them...
Speaker 3:And they talk pretty openly about this now. It used to be super secret, but now they've kind of put them on the website and stuff. They have this concept of a decision framework where you have two way doors where you can turn it on and off, and therefore, you can make that decision quickly, and one way doors. And this is very much a one way door. Right?
Speaker 3:Like, putting your reviews out there in your entire product catalog. Once it's out, it's out. You you you... It is a one way door. So so I I kinda think that's that's interesting.
Speaker 3:I think they're they're waiting... There is a world where you wait and see because that's a pretty big one time decision that you can undo, and it it may be worth waiting and seeing what... How the world unfolds a bit. Yeah. Exactly.
Speaker 3:This is kind of... It's kind of playing out in marketplaces, if I'm right. Because I think... I believe eBay is blocking... They're they're kinda...
Speaker 3:It's confusing because I see them in a fair number of searches, but then sometimes they're not at, like, if you... It seems like they're they're very much as gated access is kind... I guess, my guess of what they're doing. Well, Etsy has been like a, you know, kinda like more like Walmart where they're just, like, throwing the door open and Etsy's everywhere type situation. Has eBay publicly kind of said what their stance is on this?
Speaker 1:I think they've been more willing to partner with LLMs than Amazon, but they have also their own terms that they... As opposed to OpenAI or others defining the terms, eBay has chosen to define the terms they're willing to integrate with. And I think that's just been a process of getting the LMs on board with that.
Speaker 3:What is that? Is that economics or is it like a data usage thing? What are the pieces of that? Or if you don't know, would what just speculate on there?
Speaker 1:Yeah. My suspicion is that a lot of it has to do with advertising. So where the user lands on eBay, whether it's the product detail page or some other part of the marketplace. And I think this is also an issue for a lot of other e commerce companies, right? It's how do we preserve that other source of revenue?
Speaker 1:So for eBay, I think it was not just sending the traffic to the checkout page or to that product detail page, but a place on eBay where they can also sell advertising.
Speaker 3:You brought up the advertising word, so let's pivot to that. I know I get a lot of investor conversations around retail media networks, and this is what... You know, brands are interested by it. A lot of the naysayers are in this RMN group because I think they they... A little bit of this fear, uncertainty, and doubt.
Speaker 3:I think they're pretty scared about what would happen here. And the the... Basically, the the bear case goes, and we'll use Amazon as example because in the retail media network, Amazon's at least half by everyone's definition. And their ad business is at what? Like a $7,080,000,000,000 dollar rate...
Speaker 3:Run rate right now? Yeah. And so that makes them number three. But if you take their growth rate and keep projecting it, at some point, they'll cross Meta. Right?
Speaker 3:So they're... Do you think they're on a trajectory to be number two, or do you think Meta fends that off?
Speaker 1:I think Meta's done a pretty good job growing their own ad business. So let's just say Amazon's a solid number three.
Speaker 3:Gotcha. And they've done that pretty fast, which is pretty impressive. The risk is if they open the door to agents and they skip the p d... They they skip past... Most of the ads are shown on the home page, the search engine experience, the browse experience, so on and so forth.
Speaker 3:Then you have a PDP, and the PDP has some, but at that point, it's such a high intention person, they don't really interact with ads very much. It it... It's probably the lowest converting page on the stack of of the website. So if the traffic is going into the PDP, then it's skipping all the ads. So it's kinda like closing your eyes when you're on the street and not seeing the billboards type of a situation.
Speaker 3:Do you do you do you think that's a valid concern? Do you think it's overdone? Do you think people, like like, it seems like eBay is doing something. Now I'm curious. I need to go experiment and click on some of those links I've seen to see if it it is kinda landing higher up in the tree or something.
Speaker 3:Do you think there's a way to navigate that? What what... What's your point of view Is that ad business at risk at Amazon?
Speaker 1:Well, I think if merchants... If these sites did nothing to adapt, then yes, it would be a pretty significant risk to this part of their business. But I don't think that's the way it's going to play out. I probably don't have the same view on how devastating this could be to the retail media network. It kind of reminds me of going back to Google, right?
Speaker 1:Well, if they didn't do anything to innovate search, then yeah, of course they would have been massively disintermediated by ChatGPT, but these are pretty sophisticated companies and they're not standing still. Obviously, they only have so much control over it. But in terms of retail media, I think it relates back to issues with the open web and the funnels compressing. And as that happens, our view is that that can actually make retail media even more valuable. In other words, pushing more ad dollars onto new surfaces.
Speaker 1:So it's one thing to change the user interface. It's another thing to understand how merchants and brands are gonna redirect all of their ad dollars. And so you mentioned Amazon as an example. Amazon now has sponsored prompts within their own agent, and they have tools to help optimize content for agent indexing, that sort of thing. And so that's some of the adaptability that we're seeing.
Speaker 1:And it depends on the marketplace, it depends on the site, but in general, I think it could be a more valuable tool for merchants and brands just given the compression of shopping and essentially the collapse of the open web.
Speaker 3:Have you heard any of the efficacy as you do your channel checks? Are you hearing that these new kind of Agentic ad formats are working? I know OpenAI isn't public, therefore, it's not in your coverage universe. Hopefully, you get to cover it when it does come out. But are...
Speaker 3:What are you hearing about OpenAI and their ads, or or how is that impacting other things you cover?
Speaker 1:I mean, I would say it's not necessarily impacting other parts of the ad market yet, but there's a lot of interest among merchants and brands in those ad formats. That's also true within Gemini. It's also true within Amazon, their sponsored prompts. And I think they're very tantalizing to advertisers. They're viewed as being closer to not just product discovery, but also closer to transaction.
Speaker 1:There's a view that there's a lot more attention. The impressions are more valuable. So some of us will have to see and track how it works over time, but the interest level in some cases is off the charts from the advertiser perspective, which I do think it speaks to some of those issues around the open web, Right? Where am I putting the ad dollars if I can't spend them through traditional banner ads anymore?
Speaker 3:Yeah. And OpenAI pretty publicly has out there a 100,000,000,000 by, I think it's 2029 or 2030, which would put them as the number three. You know? That that assumes Amazon doesn't get to a 100,000,000,000 first, but it's gotta come from somewhere. I guess it could come from offline.
Speaker 3:I'm not sure it has to come from online, but but some of it would have to be cannibalistic. But but here's a logic trail. See if this pencils for you. So so, yeah, the the the the place I'm gonna end up in is we're... We had this interesting event happen where Gemini leaned in to checkout and OpenAI leaned out.
Speaker 3:Right? And Agentic Commerce checkout. I don't I don't think that makes sense for them to do that, and they'll come back. And here's here's my chain of thought. The reason Amazon has built an $80,000,000,000 ad business so quickly is because they have first party data.
Speaker 3:And, you know, it gets rid of... In advertising, there's a lot of leakage to this attribution problem. And cookies cookies were helpful, but they they they were just a bread crumb. They they didn't kinda, like, tell you exactly what happened. Well, they're they're kinda go...
Speaker 3:You know, third party cookies are going away. First party is where it's at. And if you can you can definitively say the the the shopper started here, they saw your ad, they bought, Then you get rid of all the attribution problem, and that's the beauty of the Amazon ad system. It's just very pure, and they benefited from all this privacy lockdown, the ATT thing, and the death of cookies, third party cookies. I think I think Google sees that as a threat, and and then that's why they...
Speaker 3:They're leaning into the checkout. They're kinda like, we finally... This this new technology unlocks. Now we can have a a closed loop one p type setup where we actually see the transaction. And and I think, therefore, if OpenAI...
Speaker 3:My logic is if OpenAI wants to build a $100,000,000,000 ad business, they will not be able to do that unless they have a closed checkout for for our vertical, which is the lion's share of of this. You know? If you look at if you look at Google, it's always been reported about 30% of their ad business is revenue. Amazon, it's a 100%, is gonna be ecommerce. Right?
Speaker 3:So so we know that it's a big chunk of the ad spend out there across things. Therefore, my conclusion is OpenAI has to revisit this checkout thing.
Speaker 1:Well, I don't think they're only focused on shopping and e commerce in terms of their ad There's
Speaker 3:other verticals.
Speaker 1:Yeah. They definitely see a lot of potential in other verticals, right? But shopping or e commerce and retail probably are the most lucrative form of online advertising, so they clearly want to be there. And the economics are going to accrue to whoever owns authenticated consumers, stored credentials and facilitate transactions. That would be supportive of your theory.
Speaker 1:That doesn't mean they won't try to do it without that and maybe fall a few times along the way. Maybe they need to make an acquisition here. Maybe that's something they found building that out. And they have people experienced, right? Fiji and others who built Instacart, not just the marketplace, but the advertising business there as well.
Speaker 1:I mean, they have a lot of insight into how this works. Doesn't mean they won't try to build it without having that layer, but I agree with you. It definitely helps when you have as close to a closed loop as you possibly can. And I don't know why they wouldn't, quite frankly. I was surprised that they were so quick to give up on instant checkout or postpone whatever the reality is there and still try to keep their 4%, right?
Speaker 1:So we'll see what happens. But I think I think in general, makes a lot of sense.
Speaker 3:Yeah. Know you were on vacation there, but I can't remember when it was, but Fiji announced that she's actually leaving. So... Yeah.
Speaker 1:Yeah. She did. But but her... A lot of her lieutenants are there.
Speaker 3:Her her people are there. Absolutely. Yeah. Let's talk briefly about payments. So so, you know, one of the concerns that that comes up from from everybody and and all the...
Speaker 3:You know, from the vendors I talked to, but you deal with more with the the analysts, the buy sides, is that various parts of this ecommerce stack can get skipped. Right? And we talked about going from going from the home page down to the PDP. That's one slippage that happens in there, potentially. Another one is the payment layer.
Speaker 3:So there... There's this, you know, kind of the argument... The bare argument on payments is, well, in Agentic Commerce, you can... It's very easy to plug in whatever payment you want. If you wanna be as economical as possible, maybe a lot of this goes to stablecoin type things.
Speaker 3:I don't think consumers are going to get into stablecoins, but if underneath the hood it's happening and it's cheaper, they'll be happy if it doesn't have to change any if it feels just like traditional e commerce. And what what do you make of that? Is there is there a lot of risk in the payment world? Because we've we've seen... Do you cover PayPal?
Speaker 1:Yeah. I cover PayPal within
Speaker 3:the within the They kinda, like, went through this little bit of an... You know, this is my framing, not yours. They they kind of went through this weird implosion where they had it. I liked the the CEO they had, and he was, like, betting big on this. But then it seems like the board gave up and bought in a guy from HP that was, like, on the printer division, which I don't a 100% understand.
Speaker 3:So they seem... And then there's always rumors that the pieces are getting sold off and all kinds of chaos. They... The Perplexity deal has basically been shut down. So what what do you think is going on in the payment world?
Speaker 1:With PayPal, it's very interesting because, I mean, the the big squeeze is kind of hitting the middle layer is the lack of proprietary consumer relationship. PayPal has a two sided network with consumers, but I think they're more focused, I think they're trying to bring a turnaround expert in, but really focused on the branded ecommerce checkout franchise. The risk for any of these companies is being commoditized into a background transaction layer. There are obviously a bunch of companies that operate there. But when an agent buys something for you, the consumer doesn't necessarily see a PayPal button or any branded checkout.
Speaker 1:Brands don't know where agents necessarily will route demand, so why are they going to necessarily fund big proprietary builds with payment companies? I think, on one hand, if there is efficiency on the payment side within the middle layer, this is the perfect opportunity for those to start to gain some traction. Like I said before, I think the economics here do accrue eventually to those that own the authenticated consumer and the credentials and have that kind of full stack even through fulfillment, to your earlier point. Probably the more likely companies to win in this environment are Amazon or Shopify with Shop Pay or Google with Gemini Checkout, as you sort of alluded to earlier. If OpenAI ultimately doesn't move to more of a checkout model, they'd be exposed there.
Speaker 1:So there's that element to it. Then there's the protocol standards, which you talked about a bit with UCP, and there's ACP as well, and I guess a couple of others. But if I were PayPal, I think I would try to use their hundreds of millions of credentialed shoppers as an abstraction layer across the various AI apps, and that that would be something very powerful for them to take advantage of.
Speaker 3:Yeah. There's consumer angle there that I seem to be overlooking. And then I know we're up against time, so we'll we'll do the lightning round and and have you back if we wanna do a deep dive on this. But the the number one question that I got at your conference in the hallways, like, people didn't wanna talk about this openly, which I... Is also interesting, was Shopify.
Speaker 3:So there's a there's a lot of people really worried about Shopify, I would say. What's what's going on there? Like, what... Why why is there... And I've heard Harvey get kinda uncharacteristically a little frustrated on the conference calls about about some of the questions he gets.
Speaker 3:What's going on at Shopify that... That's got investors kind of a little shaken?
Speaker 1:Yeah. I mean, at a high level, there's the broader software sector, right, facing tremendous downward pressure, in terms of the stock prices at least, as AI's viewed as an existential risk to pricing models, right, moving from subscriptions and seat bait licenses to outcome or transactional models. I think, ironically, Shopify already monetizes that way, but we'll get into that. But in terms of Shopify more specific, I think it's storefront disintermediation. I think the view investors are concerned that if autonomous agents handle the entire transaction, then the consumer facing digital storefront is less relevant and that threatens Shopify's core business or at least their front end.
Speaker 1:And then secondly, if these same agents are routing around Shopify checkout, then their transaction based revenue model would also be disintermediated. So I think those are the concerns or the uncertainty. If you're an investor on Wall Street, uncertainty is a big negative variable, Right? You put a very high discount rate on stocks or on their potential free... Future free cash flows if there's uncertainty.
Speaker 1:And that's what's happening right now with Shopify. Investors don't know how this is gonna play out, and so they're putting a very significant discount rate on the stock.
Speaker 3:Colin, we'll have to have you back and go a little bit deeper than that. I think it's kind of interesting to push on that one and just kind of understand a little bit more. But unfortunately
Speaker 1:Happy to introduce
Speaker 3:our available time. It's always so fun talking to you. I lose track of time, and we... I think I've done it again.
Speaker 1:Yeah, Scot. Thanks so much. I love our conversation, so appreciate you having me on.
Speaker 3:And will I see you at... You're going to Retail Club, or I've gotta convince you to come to Retail Club. I'll I'll work on you.
Speaker 1:I I think I'll I'll see you in Nashville at Shop Talk, I hope.
Speaker 3:Okay. Gotcha. Alright. Well, good seeing you. Thanks for coming on.
Speaker 1:Thanks, Scot.
Speaker 2:Follow, rate, and share to stay up to date with Retailgentic, your guide to the future of AI shopping agents.