Exceptional Educators Podcast by FrenalyticsEDU

In this episode, we sit down with Jeremy Batchelor, Superintendent of Youngstown City School District, whose journey from juvenile probation officer and special education teacher to district leader fuels his relentless dedication to whole-child equity. Bringing lived experience as both an educator and a father to a daughter with special needs, Jeremy shares how authentic connection, systemic alignment, and community trust can revitalize an urban district.

Jeremy opens up about the ambitious 'One Vision, One Youngstown' consolidation, revealing how student agency and civic pride are forging a brand-new identity with the Defender Owl mascot. He details how Youngstown cut suspensions nearly in half through restorative discipline and robust PBIS practices, while emphasizing why districts cannot intervene their way out of a Tier 1 instruction problem. Listeners will walk away with inspiring, actionable leadership strategies for meeting at-promise learners where they are and removing barriers to student achievement.

What is Exceptional Educators Podcast by FrenalyticsEDU?

Welcome to the Exceptional Educators Podcast by FrenalyticsEDU β€” where innovation meets inclusion in education!

Each episode features candid conversations with district leaders, school leaders, classroom changemakers, EdTech founders, and executives β€” all dedicated to transforming learning for each student, especially our learners with unique abilities.

With a focus on extraordinary educators and the exceptional students they serve, we explore the latest in special education, accessible technology, and inclusive leadership. Whether you’re shaping special education policy, pioneering new EdTech tools, or looking to grow your impact in the classroom, this podcast is your front-row seat to the future of inclusive education.

Listen. Learn. Lead. Be Exceptional. πŸŽ™οΈ

Antonayah Ellis (00:01)
Welcome to the Exceptional Educators podcast by FrenalyticsEDU, where innovation meets inclusion in education. I'm your co-host, Antonayah Ellis.

Matt Giovanniello (00:10)
and I'm Matt Giovanniello the CEO and co-founder of Frenalytics At Frenalytics, we put special education and English language learners front and center. Our award-winning FrenalyticsEDU platform helps streamline progress monitoring, improve communication and compliance, and offers truly personalized learning to your students of all abilities.

Antonayah Ellis (00:29)
Each episode of our podcast features candid conversations with district and school leaders, classroom changemakers, ed tech founders, and industry executives, all dedicated to transforming learning for each student, especially our learners with unique abilities. With the focus on extraordinary educators and the exceptional students they serve, we explore the latest in special education, except blah, blah. My bad. Accessible technology and inclusive leadership.

Matt Giovanniello (00:55)
Cabins.

Antonayah Ellis (00:59)
In this episode, exceptional educators is exceptionally thrilled to welcome Jeremy Batchelor, superintendent of Youngstown City School District. Since stepping into his role, Jeremy has led with a clear focus on data-driven instruction, inclusive practices, and community partnerships that support the whole child. His leadership reflects a belief that when systems are aligned and people are supported, real change is possible. Welcome to the podcast, Jeremy. We're so happy to have you.

Jeremy Batchelor (01:28)
Thank you, Antonayah. Thank you, Matt. I'm honored to be here. I'm excited. I love talking education. I love talking education, period. But especially when we talk about innovation, we'll talk about maybe some of our most at-promise learners that maybe sometimes people forget about. I'm a special education teacher by trade. I don't know if you guys knew that. And I have a daughter that has special needs. And so I'm

definitely always a passion, all students, every day is what we focus on. So thank you for having me.

Matt Giovanniello (02:04)
I love at Promise. The honor is ours, Jeremy. We did know you were a special education teacher, but not about your daughter. So the connection is doubly real. the honor is ours. Thank you for hopping on.

Jeremy Batchelor (02:07)
to me.

Absolutely.

Antonayah Ellis (02:15)
So we want to know, I mean, I feel like we kind of already know from what you kind of already shared with us, but we want to know what is your why, what brought you to education and what keeps you in this place?

Jeremy Batchelor (02:19)
Yeah.

Ooh, man, all right, I'm gonna try to keep this brief, okay, because it can be long. I mean, my why, honestly, I was not honestly a traditional educator initially. I actually used to be a juvenile probation officer. It was my first job out of college. And then I realized when I was working with those young people that education, and I know I've known this, education is the key to changing trajectory. And what I noticed is that a lot of my young people that I was working with that were on probation were missing school a lot.

and they were having problems in school. And so I had given thought to getting an education in my last year of college. And I was like, no, I'm not going to change my major now. But then after that, decided I'm going get back in education. So I had an opportunity to move to North Carolina back in 1997 and actually teach and work on my teaching license at the same time and coach. And I wanted to coach back then. I'm to be a football coach and this kind of thing. But my wife has always been people. My family business, my mother was a human offering.

officer, my grandmother had foster children in and out of her home, all of our childhood, and so we've always been about helping people. And so I felt education was the way that I could do that the most. And so my why is always making sure that I can give young people the same opportunities that I had. And that's my goal. I approach every day to try to do that. And sometimes that can be difficult, but that is really why I come to work every day and why I do. And I did not choose to

necessarily become a superintendent. If you would have asked me 30 years ago whether that was where I would land, I would have told you you were crazy. But it shows me. And I do believe that it has been a good journey. It's been a good ride. But my why is helping young people.

Matt Giovanniello (04:10)
I love that Jeremy. I believe everything happens for a reason and so while you may not have believed it 30 years ago, you better believe it now because that's where you are and imparting such wisdom and change on our next generation of students, especially the ones who are at most promise, which I love that phrase that you brought up before. So let's get into that some more because you come from a non-traditional education background, you find yourself becoming a special education teacher all of a sudden, walk us through that journey, how you wound up in North Carolina,

Jeremy Batchelor (04:15)
Yeah.

is.

Matt Giovanniello (04:35)
and what you hold onto from that time in the classroom as you now think about your role as a superintendent.

Jeremy Batchelor (04:40)
So one of my other mentors that I've worked with closely now and I've actually been studying him for a long time and I've really been using his practices and his phrases even before I knew him or knew of him. But rigor, relevance, and relationship from Dr. Bill Daggett. But rigor, making sure that our kids are getting what they need to get at a challenging level. But To me, relationships is the key because kids don't know how much, don't care how much you know until they know how much you care.

And so from initially my early on, it's really been about relationships. Before I really knew what I was doing as a teacher, I knew I could relate to kids. I knew I could ⁓ meet them where they were, hold them accountable still, but also because of a relationship that we had built that I could get the best out of them then they would, they would do things for me. So I did, I'm a city boy, Youngstown, Ohio, but I spent some good amount of time in rural North Carolina. And I had a good friend of mine, his name is Mark Bridges.

who was the principal and I was his assistant principal. And he would say, Mr. Bachelor, if you build relationships with kids, they'll drink out of a mud hole for you. And I was like, that's kind of nasty, but I understand what he's saying. ⁓ If you build relationships with kids, they'll do what you need them to do, not for you, but for themselves. And because we approach it every day, we want them to get the skills and the things they need so they can be successful. So my career has really been about building relationships, moving in North Carolina even early on as a teacher.

I was able to build those relationships. And then that led me to get into situations where to me getting the administration called me. I was living in Roanoke, Virginia for a period of time and I was working for an alternative school with our 40 most difficult students in Roanoke City Schools. They were all in one location called Villa Heights Alternative School. And our administrator had some family tragedy.

and ended up having to leave in the middle of the year. And before she left, whenever she was out of the building, she would name me the principal. So because of the relationships and I could kind of get kids to calm down and those types of things. Well, after she left, ⁓ the district would send a principal over there for a day or two. And that's about all they would stay because our kids were challenging and then they wouldn't show up anymore. And then after a while, they just stopped sending people.

And so we had to run the school for the rest of the year with the staff that we had there, our security folks. And so that was my first taste into administration because I was the one that handled operations and dealt with everything. We had a teacher who did all the IEPs and handled all that piece. We all just kind of banded together and decided how we were going to finish running the school to serve these kids for the year. And so that was my first taste into administration. And then as they closed that school after another year or so,

Then I moved back to Ohio. And then when I got into administration, I was actually working for a charter school. And they moved me into an administrative role. And the rest is history. And I've just kind of been rolling around from assistant principal. And then I got into some turnaround work down in North Carolina at East Blayton High School. And that has really kind of been my calling ever since.

Matt Giovanniello (07:57)
That's incredible that the experiences you went through early on as an educator did not scare you, but gave you a really healthy challenge to be like, okay, I'm ready. I'm ready for some more. Give me a turnaround district. Give me a charter. Give me a big urban school, the big eight. Like most people are like, I don't think so. Like I went through that once that was scarring. Don't make me a principal when I'm not. And I got no training. And yet here you are. And you just kept taking on more and more and more of these leadership positions. I think growing and scaling along the way, but also inspiring a lot of others to be like, Hey, if I can do it, you can do it too. And like we're.

Jeremy Batchelor (08:07)
Yeah.

Right.

Right.

Absolutely.

Matt Giovanniello (08:26)
in this together kind of a deal. It's not, we can't turn on each other now. But just so inspiring. I just wanted to, wanted to call that out. Thank you, Jeremy.

Jeremy Batchelor (08:33)
I think a lot of that stems from, I would say from my athletic background, my football background, and I played for a legendary coach. Listen, we gotta get the job done. And so I've always approached it that way. ⁓ that, maybe some scars and maybe some plays that we get stuffed at the line of scrimmage, but we gotta keep coming back and running. And if you watch my podcast that we talked about, you kinda hear that story about belly left. And so that's just kinda how I approach the work every day.

Matt Giovanniello (09:02)
I love that. Okay, we need to get more into your podcast. I'm sure Antonayah, you're dying to know about that too. So first, Jeremy, pull back the curtain on your podcast that your students run, that you're a part of. And then I also want to separately, but after that, get into some of your personal stories. You're no stranger to tragedy and how you've overcome that in the role that you're now in Youngstown City School. So let's start with your podcast and then we'll go back to your past couple of years of what things have looked like for you.

Jeremy Batchelor (09:05)
you

Okay.

Well, one of my friends, I'm a cliche cold guy, so you got to deal with that a little bit. But communication is the food that feeds us all. And so as a school leader and as a district leader in a district, any district, but especially in a district like ours that has had its challenges. And there's some things that we're trying to accomplish to kind of rebound. Communication is key. so having those communication things, but then also telling the story of the district and not letting others tell the story for you, because that has been our supply as well.

Everybody has an opinion and everybody knows how to run a school because they went to school. ⁓ y'all didn't catch that. but, ⁓ and so the podcast is an opportunity for me to, of all, talk about leadership because I believe leadership matters. ⁓ but also express the fact that we're all leaders, including our scholars, ⁓ people that work in our classrooms, our teachers, other administrators, and our community partners. So the guests on our show are anything from.

everybody from our kids, know, middle school, high school kids that I've had on the show, valedictorians, some of our other folks. I've had principals on the show. I've had central office people, I've had board members, and then I've had community members. I've had our mayor on the show to just talk about leadership and also their relationship and impact on our school district. I've had our treasurer on so that he could talk to the community about what school finance really is, not what the newspapers report.

because they do not report accuracy all the time. And so our community needs to know from the treasurer, what does it mean when we're deficit spending? What does that mean? Does that mean we're broke? No, it doesn't. But that means we need to tighten the belt a little bit. And so I had him on and talk about those things. But the key piece for me was this was an opportunity for us to utilize our CareerTech programs that we are so proud of because they are the highest rated CareerTech program in all of the urban districts in Ohio. They have a five star rating and we're

growing and expanding. And so I allow those students to get hand-ons and experience where we record the show in their lab and we have a podcast studio. And then they go through and they'll edit if there needs to be any edits and then they'll make the recordings and then they will post it on, they have their own YouTube channel, it's called Shofen Broadcasting. And then we post it and we drop an episode about every two weeks. And so...

It's fun. breaks up my week, but it also allows me to really talk to people and kind of get things out there. And it's kind of taken off. We even won some awards from the National School Public Relations Association last year, myself and our communications department, which is the department of one, shout out to Stacey Keowness. But our kids, we've made them a part of this communications team, you know, by default. And so we're just really proud of it because to me, it shows us being innovative.

to communicate with our community in a different way, and then also create outreach for some community partners to get on. And we had a meeting called the Defenders Dialogue, about in September. And then after we were done, we had people asking, can I get on the podcast? Can I come on the podcast? And I'm like, yeah, come on. Let's set it up. Set it up with Stacey. So, you know, kind of cut the long story short is that I'm really proud of the podcast and proud of the work that our kids do and everything that we try to do, even if

I get some credit for it. want it to be a credit for our district. And that's really, it's really helping because it's really helping morale. It's helping our kids believe in themselves. And like, no matter what people might say about our test scores, which still need to be improved. We're doing things for the whole child to make sure that our kids are getting what they need. So that's the podcast. It is called Belly Left Leadership.

And it is based off of a simple football play that we ran on my high school team that was really strong and powerful. And our high school coach used to tell us if you run it and you practice it and you repeat it and you keep doing it and you do it well, you can go up to the line and scrimmage and tell the other team what you're doing. And it's not being cocky, but being confident. And then you keep running it until they stop it. ⁓ and so that's kind of how I lead is that

We do think what we do well, we do it well. There's no need in trying to do 85 different things just to just to say you can do them. Let me find the five or six things that I do well and let's do those well and let's make it happen. And that's kind of how I lead and how I try to make sure this organization is moving to.

Antonayah Ellis (13:59)
I admire this level of like connection that you kind of set the tone for by going into the school and working side by side with the students. I'm sure it's not something that students can say often. yeah, I talk to my superintendent every other week and we hang out and stuff. So I'm just curious, what are the relationships with the students and you and what type of leadership do you feel or model do you feel that you kind of?

Just show teachers about working with students side by side. How do you think that has influenced some of your staff and their practices?

Jeremy Batchelor (14:36)
I'm hoping that they see that they see that everything we do when I say it, it's not just words, that everything we do is about giving our scholars opportunities to grow opportunities to get the skills that they need. I think we're going to talk about the portrait of a graduate later on or a little bit. And so everything we do ties back into giving them what they need. I'm not here. I want to school. All right. My job is to make sure that this next generation gets what they need.

And so working with our kids, also have a scholar advisory committee. So we have scholar advisory that meets with me every month and they get feedback on what's going on. So I try to just do as much as I can. Obviously I can't be, I'm running an organization, so I can't be in schools every day. I can't be in classrooms, but as much face time as I can get with our young people as I can, we try to do and give them voice. And so when they say things or bring things to us, that it's not just like falling on deaf ears.

And so right now we're going through, as I told you guys, we're going through ⁓ what we call one vision, one Youngstown where we're consolidating our schools. And so our kids, even though we had to make some executive decisions, us in the board, but once we've made those decisions to do this, we have brought them to the table to have input and voice on some of the decisions that we're making, including our new mascot, including our colors and those types of things. So I'm excited about that. My wife is an educator as well, and she reminds me all the time.

As a superintendent, don't forget to be what it was like to be a principal. OK? And then, OK, when you were a she would always tell me, don't forget what it was like to be a teacher. OK? And then as a teacher, we always said, don't forget we like to be a student. We have three of our own that are now adults. And we try to make sure that our kids are in our Youngstown City Schools are getting the same opportunities that my three children got. I tell them every year at graduation, you guys have

three brothers and sisters. And my kids know they have 4,500 brothers and sisters because that's the way that we approach the work. And I tell kids, if I would fess at my own son for doing this, I'm surely going to fess at you about doing this. If I'm going to praise my own son or daughter for doing this, I want you to get the same praise as well. So try to spend as much time with kids as possible.

Matt Giovanniello (16:52)
You

That's really cute that your student body has three brothers and sisters and your three kids have 4500, a lot more than what most people want. But that's really cute to think about the camaraderie and the family that you're building. And I think to tie it back to a point that you were just bringing up that we also talked about before we started recording Jeremy, this transformation that your district is going through, this one vision, one Youngstown model, consolidation is often times perceived as a negative thing. And I think going back to your PR piece through your podcast,

Jeremy Batchelor (17:06)
Absolutely.

You

Matt Giovanniello (17:31)
if you're leaving blanks in your sentences, they will get filled and not necessarily by the truth, but what may be perceived as the truth. And so let's work through what that's looked like, your conversations with your board, your conversations with your students, your conversations with your community about how this consolidation is actually a really good thing. You brought up a couple examples before. Let's expand on those of like, by the time you're done with this consolidation project, Youngstown will be better off as a result. How are you going through that messaging? What are the positive pieces you're perceiving? Tell us what that journey has been like.

Jeremy Batchelor (17:58)
Okay, so the journey has been honestly the city of Youngstown. mean, Youngstown was once a booming steel mill industry. Okay. And we sit, you know, on a direct path between New York city and Chicago where we also seen the ugly side of that by being a, you know, quote unquote mafia town. Okay. In the past. And then we had the steel mills and the steel mills crashed in 1977 when I was three years old.

And I say all the time, sometimes unpopularly, that we're still waiting for them to come back. And that's just not going to happen. So we need to reinvent ourselves. And I do believe that the city of Youngstown is right now on the cusp of doing that. OK, it's been it's been a lot of work. ⁓ But part of that has been the population has declined. Education has changed as well. Youngstown used to have over one hundred and forty thousand people in the city.

Right now we're probably less than 40,000 in the city. ⁓ There were once six high schools in this city. We're now going to have one. So while we can be nostalgic and we are, we miss it. The reality is, is are we ever going to be that city of 140,000 again? Probably not. And that's okay. We just need to accept who we are and then maximize what we do have. Cause we still have the mentality from the steel mills, that grit, that hard work.

We just need to maximize on that and then right size ourselves so that we can give the best opportunity from an industry standpoint, from an education standpoint. We still can be, we still sit in the city. have a strong university that sits in our backyard. We have some partnerships going on with them where our scholars, if you graduate from Youngstown City Schools, we have a foundation that will pay for our young people to go to Youngstown State University for free. It's called the Youngstown Foundation.

And so we have things to build off of, but we have to make sure that we prepare our kids for that. So back to the original, the journey has been this. This is something that probably should have been done 20 years ago, guys, but it wasn't. And so now we're here and our current board who has done a great job of coming together. We've had issues with governance. We were a state takeover district and we actually still are, but we're hopefully coming out of that.

pretty soon with all the things that were going legislatively are happening. But this board said we need to really do our job and do it diligently. And so let's come together as one Youngstown. So we had a work session back in May. We had the conversations all last winter, all last year. And then in May we had a work session and they said, we're ready to do this. You're the guy and your team to help make it happen. I said, all right, I need the board to be unified, one vision, one Youngstown.

and I will make it happen with our team. And they absolutely did. So on May 9th, we had a press conference. We announced it. We announced the plan. We laid it out. Our communications person, Stacey, she's awesome. My chief of staff, Rob Kearns, and everybody, we came together and we developed a kind of a roadmap of how we would do this in a timely manner. We made a decision that it was time for a new identity.

And so we weren't going to just borrow from old mascot. We're going to borrow from bold names. So we said, we're to do this. We start over. We honor the past because that's been our tagline, honor the past and embracing the future. We're still honored to pass, but it's time to move forward. It's time to not wait on the steel mills to come back anymore. It's time to create a new pathway. And so we said, we're going come up with a new name. So we did a town hall and we got some feedback. We brought kids together. We brought community together.

⁓ most people were happy. You're going to have some, the two remaining schools, which were Chaney and East. ⁓ of course, the alumni's, you're going to get rid of our bear and our cowboy. ⁓ and we respectfully listened to those things, but it was time for the kids to pick a new mascot. So we did a contest, we did surveys and the kids decided that we would know now they had options, but one of the options was a defender. And so we started this whole mantra about a year ago of.

defending the Y, defending Youngstown. And so our kids kind of picked up on that and they were like, we want that to be our name. They overwhelmingly in the survey, they chose that. Now they didn't choose like a animal or whatever how it would be. So they said they want that name. And so we went with that and then I had a graphic guy who said, let's use a defender owl, owls or birds of prey. But they're also indigenous to, I mean, there's.

barred owls and horned owls are both Ohio native. And so let's come with that. And they represent knowledge and wisdom, but they also can be fierce when they need to be. And so that has taken off, man. We announced that we're going to be the defenders and the owl is our mascot now. We're getting ready. We worked with a marketing firm that just wrote out a plan to us yesterday. We're going to do a thing where we're going to come up with a name for the owl and all this other stuff. So it's been a journey and it's still a journey because we're in the midst.

The consolidation or One Vision One Youngstown will not fully take place until the 26-27 school year. But I'm proud because my board and our team, we didn't wait until three months before that. We've been working on it since May of last year. And every month we have milestones that we check in. We've had young people and students from both high schools that are coming together. We created a one general student council and they're meeting together once a month now. And they've been off to, we have a camp called Camp Fitch.

about an hour away, they went to that for a leadership camp. And they'll be doing more of that all year. Our high school principals that are coming together from two different schools, they've been meeting regularly. So we're doing it the right way, in my opinion, and we're going to be ready to hit the ground running when next August happens.

Matt Giovanniello (23:56)
There we go. I love it. Sorry, Andrea. Are you trying to chime in? If so, you're on mute.

Jeremy Batchelor (24:01)
Yeah

Antonayah Ellis (24:01)
I was trying, but I couldn't get my microphone off. I I just also, I just kind of wanted to hop in and say like, what a process. I was gonna kind of interrupt and ask like, what were the community responses to doing such things? I'm in Colleen, it's kind of going through, it's also a small town in Texas.

going through some changes, some consolidation, and the community was not happy about it. So whenever I hear other districts are going through these things, the first thing I think of is what is the community response and how do you take that on? Are the parents talking to the kids? Is it giving the kids a negative, I don't know, persona of what's going on in the district? Did you guys have to deal with any of those things?

Jeremy Batchelor (24:46)
we did I mean I would say this I mean the response has been mostly positive But I would say I grew up in this community. And so we've had this thing. I remember We've had this thing where sides of town were kind of against each other But that was when we had six high schools too and we had six communities six sides of town different high schools That has changed so much even what our current two high schools right now We have East High School and Cheney High School that are operating right now that will come together as one and we have an early college program as well, which is another situation but

The kids at East High School, because of the way the city is set up and the way the boundary lines are drawn, over half of the kids that go to East High School live on the South side of Youngstown. So that whole side of town rivalry thing is played out. It's really not true. And so we did have a town hall and then we had a big meeting and I gave a pretty emotional speech. My wife was mad at clowning me because I actually kind of broke down because I'm passionate about our kids. And I don't like when, quite honestly, when adults make issues that are adult issues that

Kids are just not even thinking about. But if we put them out there, then they become their issues. We're putting our issues on them. And I have a problem with that. And so I kind of told our community, it's time for us to turn the page. It's time for my generation to stop talking about, I didn't go to the East side or I didn't go to the South side. we're going to, our kids don't care about it. They're already playing a little league football together. Half of them are already going to school together anyway. At Shoffin, all of our kids in 11th 12th grade at both schools, they're already going to school together anyway.

So what are we talking about? And so one of the things that the community has been, we are a community that is still plagued by some community violence. We really are. And so people are worried about, well, are there going to be more fights? Or are going to be this and that? And those are the things that we really continue to have conversations, including going out to the schools now, myself and my team, going out and asking the kids, why do you think these things are happening? And what are the things that you think we can do to anticipate?

I will tell you, I'm a pretty, I'm a firm, fair, consistent disciplinary. And so young people who have decided that they want to disrupt rather than learn, we do have an alternative school. until you, and you're going to get a free and appropriate public education, but you're not going to disrupt others from learning as well. And that is kind of how I've always operated as a teacher, how I've always operated as a principal and a superintendent.

I believe all kids can and do want to learn. And even those who act up, they're just asking for attention. So we need to give it to them, but we need to give it to them in a manner that they're going to learn how to properly behave and do the right things. I'm not saying we throw them away and then we throw them up and throw away the key. Absolutely not. But we have to have a continuum of services. And just like we do in special education, we have to have those continuum of services in regular education as well. And so we just continue to have

ongoing conversations. I update the board regularly. We have an ad hoc committee that was established for this. And so we have meetings with that team. Those are still public meetings and people can bring concerns to us. ⁓ But I don't believe we're going to have any more issues than we already have had. I believe honestly, us coming together and starting to work with our young people and letting them establish what it's going to look like is actually going to be exciting.

Matt Giovanniello (28:11)
I'm

really glad that you're bringing this topic up, Jeremy. It's a touchy subject, right? And I think it also leads directly to increasingly complicated social emotional issues and behavioral issues that are the underlying cause for all these outbreaks for increased violence and for the struggles that schools currently face on how to resolve them, right? Like if we're just throwing students in alternative learning centers or pre-probationary centers or they're on the juvenile bound track, will that address the underlying problem? Maybe, but maybe not, right? I think it's just going to

say like okay you're a distraction off you go to the other end and to your point it might be the attention that they're looking for like great mission accomplished this student acted out they got exactly what they wanted but to address those underlying problems it's far more complicated and to know that you're making strides in a violence-prone community especially historically in offering that free and appropriate education for students who have behavior problems is really good to know it's not easy and but I commend you and your team for that work.

Jeremy Batchelor (29:11)
I just want to add, you you mentioned when you introduced you said data driven and we use data to drive everything. And really, even from that standpoint, ⁓ I would look at even when I was a high school principal, I would look at our data and it would show. And at that time, I had to kind of do everything by hand. But now we got some pretty sophisticated things. But I can I could look at and know that probably 10 students were causing 80 percent of the problems.

Matt Giovanniello (29:17)
yeah.

Jeremy Batchelor (29:40)
And so am I going to throw the baby out with the bathwater? Absolutely not. Am I going to demonize those young people? Absolutely not. But am I going to try to put things in place? And so one of the things that we're doing is we would take young people away for some leadership and conflict resolution. But what I found out is we were taking away the Jeremy Bachelors of the world who really didn't need it. So I ran the data, and I found our 30 students who had the highest DRS, which we call our disciplinary referrals

and had some of the lowest attendance. And I asked the person who would do those trainings for us, who actually ended up with a childhood friend of mine, I said, I need you to take those 30 to camp. And he kind of looked at me like, ⁓ wait a minute now. I mean, I want I want the good kids. These are my good kids. That's what I told him. I said, these are the good kids. I said, I need you to take these young people to camp and teach them some of the things that we've been talking about. So he did.

Matt Giovanniello (30:26)
Well the easy way out.

Jeremy Batchelor (30:37)
And then when they came back, we tracked their attendance and we tracked their behavior and it improved 50%. Absolutely. And so that's when I say what we're going to do now, I can hopefully do those things at a larger district level. And we are, we are PBIS district, state of Ohio is big on PBIS. We are gold standard district. So we have all the systems in place.

It's just about execution and making sure everybody understands the expectations. and doing those things. And again, if we have to discipline, because it does have to happen sometime, what are we doing different when the student returns or when we do something different?

how our practice is changing. And that comes from my background, period in social services, my background in special education. We can't just throw away our children, we gotta teach them. And so how are we changing our adult implementation behaviors?

Matt Giovanniello (31:37)
You got that right. Okay. But hang on. You brought up a couple of really big pieces there, Jeremy. So nonchalantly these kids go to a camp that you run. We're enforcing or we're implementing PBIS and enforcing it and doing a really good job at it. The state of Ohio is recognizing us for our impact there. We have a strong data driven process. Let's unpack each of those pieces a little bit more because it sounds like those are really business test stories to the extent that it's applicable to our podcast. Of course there's, you know, the statistics around students who are with a label with an IEP. They tend to also be labeled with behavioral.

Jeremy Batchelor (31:42)
Okay.

Matt Giovanniello (32:07)
problem and they're in these programs disproportionately higher than students who are in general education. And I hate the label phrase but when it's applied both ways it's like okay this is now a pattern that we need to really dig a little bit deeper into and focus on solving. It sounds like you've done that with some of these programs and done so pretty well. So tell us about what camp looks like and then tell us about what the tracking mechanisms you have in place after these programs that students go through that's actually moving the needle on their attendance on their behaviors on their academic performance.

Jeremy Batchelor (32:35)
So there's a guy, a friend of mine, name is Guy Burney. He works with, actually worked to the community institute to reduce violence. And he does separate from the school district, but we have developed a relationship and he's done some training work with our staff. He's done training work with folks all across the city, all across the county. And he's done individual little pieces with schools of ours. And what I was explaining was a situation we had when I was at East High School as the principal. So I was a principal in his district before I became chief of staff and then superintendent.

And so we had a situation where we really asked him to, he does a really good job on teaching young people in ways to handle conflict, ways to handle, ⁓ be resilient and those types of things. And so I did a little pilot. wanted him to take some young people who had experienced some problems and he did. And what we saw when he came back, we tracked, have a system that we call our illuminate system and we can track attendance.

and behaviors and grades and our tech folks built it out several years ago where weekly it updates and it gives us their attendance. It gives us whether any classes they may be filling, how many DRFs they had. So we were able to look at those and those 30 students that he sent to camp, we tracked those things. Now we didn't make that didn't really translate into like a mandate to all schools because I was the principal at that time. But through our PBIS work, we have designated an individual.

Even though people try to say we're over staff, we put our money where I believe it helps. And so we have designated an administrator to be like over PBIS and make sure that things are done with fidelity. then in the last two years, she and our director of culture and climate have put together what we call sale and all toss. And I'm going to mess it up, but they're mostly basically short-term and long-term alternatives to suspensions. And we've been able to see our suspensions decrease.

by close to 50%. And that doesn't mean, I know some people, some critics may say, well, you just aren't suspending kids and you aren't doing this. And that's not the case. We're not, because we're not suspending kids for things they shouldn't be suspended for. We're providing interventions and support in the building and utilizing the resources that we have to teach the behavior we want our kids to have. And so ⁓ those are things that we have done.

And I would love, know, maybe a separate episode where we could talk, dig into those sales and all tasks that they really came up with. They built it off of some of the things that we started when I was at East and then some of the things they saw from a data standpoint to help us deal with the behaviors that our kids were having, but from a restorative standpoint.

Matt Giovanniello (35:19)
I think we are gonna need a part two, Jeremy, because we are already at our time and I have so many more things I wanna talk to you about. I need to know more of the specifics behind your PBIS, your short-term and long-term alternatives to suspension. I think it's critically important to understand how that's working well because...

In an urban setting, if you have cracked that code and have found a way to reduce your incidences of suspension by nearly half as you're saying, that's huge. And it's way more like how convenient and easy for to say, we're just not suspending kids as often as we were prior. Like it's not like there's a switch to be like, okay, reduce the suspensions by half without the students still acting out unless you're addressing those underlying behavioral problems. And I think that when students are more present, when they're not acting out, when they're not physically harming other students, now everybody shows up in an environment where they're more ready and eager and willing to learn.

Jeremy Batchelor (35:45)
Right, right,

Matt Giovanniello (36:03)
And with or without a disability, students are going to be participating more and second and third order effects will allow them to raise those academics, raise those behaviors, raise those life skills rates and learn a little bit more as they're intending to do in school. So I think that there are a lot of like downstream impacts in a really positive way to a successful and strong PBIS strategy. I'm glad that you're just scratching the surface. Yes, I will take you up on that offer. We need to get all into that. That'd be a fun episode to have in and of itself. There we go.

Jeremy Batchelor (36:27)
Please do. would even let you. You can even get my team members on whatever you need, man. We got it.

Matt Giovanniello (36:32)
Yeah, that'd be amazing. I'd love that. Okay, I'm going to need to prioritize a couple of our remaining topics and then we'll wrap it up from here. But you've been getting a little bit into data-driven. So let's talk about how PBIS is a part of your broader MTSS structure, how you're supporting students who have IEPs or in 504 programs, your growing English language learner population. How is MTSS playing a role in this transformative journey the district has been taking on these past couple of years to improving academic outcomes?

Jeremy Batchelor (37:00)
I'm an old school guy and I've been around for a while. So I remember when before it was MTSS we had response to intervention RTI was kind of the term. the, we all the alphabet soup of the world and education. ⁓ but, ⁓ MTSS is at the core of everything. And I'll be honest, it has been a struggle. It continues to be a struggle. It's a ongoing fluid process. ⁓ let's be honest when, when educators or when we're having issues, we want something done.

Matt Giovanniello (37:08)
You

Jeremy Batchelor (37:30)
well, it doesn't just happen overnight and you got to try supports and you got to try interventions and you have to document those things and follow processes and the MTSS lays out those processes, but sometimes it's difficult because people veer from the process because they're impatient. And I get it, but we have to and so administratively we have been very, very strategic in that we're not going to deviate from the process and like people.

get upset because they'll somebody this kid is doing this and he's just said, what we had an MTSS process, which steps are we at? What steps have we followed? And you know they'll say sometimes? Well, we haven't, what are we talking about? And so I would say from the top down, we continue to push back on those conversations, but we also provide training. You also provide resources. Some people say we're overstaffed. I will say we are overstaffed in the right areas.

because we have supports, have special ed supervisors who aren't necessarily, they shouldn't be the gatekeeper of getting kids into special ed, but they are resources and experts in interventions and accommodations and things of that nature. We also have instructional coaches that can help our folks identify the right ⁓ interventions that they should be putting in place for kids. And so we also, as a district, really put a lot of focus on tier one instruction. As a...

district that has struggled and continues to struggle, sometimes tier one instruction has been a struggle. And so we've been a very strategic in our professional development and making sure that we're getting better with tier one instruction and not trying to intervene away a tier one problem. Because quite honestly, if your tier one is not strong, you can intervene all day long and we're just kind of spinning our circles. ⁓

Honestly, we really started the science of reading has been key here in Ohio and we as a district actually started doing the science of reading practices back in 2018 before it a state thing. I remember I was a high school principal, we had Keys Literacy come in and we really focused on those types of things. So just making sure that our tier one is strong and then making sure that our people understand the steps of intervention from a behavioral standpoint, from an academic standpoint.

and they're following those steps.

Matt Giovanniello (39:54)
I think you're making a couple of really good points, Jeremy, as it relates to MTSS. The first is, yes, alphabet soup of acronyms. RTI was yesteryear's piece of interventions, and now we have MTSS. That said, I think the critical first piece is making sure that an entire district and all of its support staff, all of its educators, all of its admins have a universal understanding of what MTSS mean and doesn't mean and what those tiered pieces are. Because to your point, and we say this a lot on this podcast, you can't tier two and tier

Jeremy Batchelor (40:05)
Yes.

Right.

Matt Giovanniello (40:24)
three you're way out of a tier one problem. If your tier one is weak then everybody's in tier three all of sudden and that's not the point of the reverse triangle as we know and providing the most intensive of supports when your general education curriculum which is meant to be strong is not effective. So everybody's going to be going through that tier and then as I'm sure you know your next problem then ends up becoming

Jeremy Batchelor (40:31)
Absolutely.

Matt Giovanniello (40:43)
over-identification of students with disabilities that don't actually have a disability. So I think that's among the many reasons why strong and effective MTSS is critically important for students, especially nowadays where those interventions are necessary in the wake of COVID, in the wake of all of these externalities that are making education even more complicated than in years past. But at the same time, if we don't have that shared mutual understanding, then MTSS will be a perpetual journey for districts. And you're not alone in that quest, if it makes you feel any better.

Jeremy Batchelor (40:46)
100%.

I want to be I want to be completely honest that you know, we we do I think we work hard at it and we do a good job as best we can but we're not there yet we're not where we need to be in terms of the whole MTSS process and everybody quite understanding it but I tell you we work at it. We work at it. We really do.

Matt Giovanniello (41:29)
Good, I love to hear that. You're on your way, you're on the journey, you've started it at least. It's not like, yeah, we'll do it next year. No, we're doing it now. I love it. Jeremy, we are hitting the end of our time for today's conversation and we will see you back for more, don't you worry. But as we wrap up today's episode, I'd like to pose one more question to you that we love to ask all our guests as we wrap up. That question for you, Jeremy, is what does being an exceptional educator or being an exceptional leader mean to you?

Jeremy Batchelor (41:31)
Absolutely. Yep. That's it. That's it. ⁓

Okay.

Wow. I would say, yeah, so being an exceptional educator is understanding your why, as you asked when we first came on. And at the end of the day, it is about our scholars and about our kids. And we do call them scholars here in our district, and I believe in them as scholars. so understanding your why and really for me, doing everything that you can to ensure that young people get the opportunity and access to a high quality education each and every day.

Matt Giovanniello (41:59)
You can take a moment.

Jeremy Batchelor (42:27)
In terms of leadership, as I am a superintendent right now, I believe my job is to make sure that teachers are free to teach and students are free to learn. And so it's my job to try to remove as many barriers as I can to making sure that teachers can teach at a high level. ⁓

Sometimes that means removing barriers that they put in their own way and challenging them on some things and respectfully and professionally. But then also making sure that I create an environment where our young people know that they're loved and cared for. But they also know that they're going to be held accountable. so that teaching and learning can take place at a high, high level. So approaching every day for me, as I said earlier, as an exceptional educator is that I'm teaching 4,500 young people.

that I consider just as important as my own children.

Matt Giovanniello (43:19)
I love that. And it feels so authentic, Jeremy. I don't think you're just saying that you're walking the walk. You gave so many examples today of how you're as real as it gets. And I'm inspired and Antonayah, I'm sure you are as well. And it's amazing to know that these students have such an exceptional leader leading the charge and helping guarantee a more successful outcome for them as they graduate and go into their college career in life than the previous generations had in Youngstown. So thank you for staying committed to your community, Jeremy. It was so awesome to hear about all the ways that you're advancing things even over your past couple of years there. So thank you.

Jeremy Batchelor (43:49)
Thank you so much. I appreciate you guys having me and I'm serious if we want to have me back where I may reach out to you guys and have you on our podcast and uh Conversation going

Matt Giovanniello (43:56)
my God, that'd be so fun, yes. I'll have my people talk to your people. I'm there, count us in, that'd be a ton of fun. Jeremy, thank you again for coming on today and for everybody listening to today's episode of the Exceptional Educators podcast. Thank you for joining us, spread the word, and we'll see you on our next episode. Cut.

Jeremy, thank you. I'm going to leave the recording on for just two more minutes. I'm going to have you do that intro part that I spoke about at the very beginning to jog your memory. Hi, I'm Jeremy Batchelor, Superintendent of Youngstown City Schools in Ohio, and I blank as it relates to exceptional educators, leaders, students, however you want to take that.

Jeremy Batchelor (44:21)
Okay.

Okay. Hello, I'm Jeremy Batchelor. I'm the superintendent, the proud superintendent of the Youngstown City School District. And I believe that young people deserve the access to a high quality education each and every day. And they deserve us to show up as our authentic selves and give them everything we have so that they can be successful.

Matt Giovanniello (44:55)
there we go. I love it. I love it.

Jeremy Batchelor (44:57)
Thank