Tangent: Conversations with Real Estate & Tech Innovators

Raj Singh is the co-founder and CEO of Altrio, a deal management platform for commercial real estate investors, lenders, and brokers. Altrio brings deals from broker emails and online listings into a single pipeline and screens each one against a firm's investment criteria. Before founding Altrio in 2020 with CTO Jon Simpson, Singh founded and led Voyanta, held product leadership roles at Altus Group and Cadre, and began his career at Brookfield Asset Management. Raj is based in Toronto. Recorded live from the floor at CREtech NY.

(01:46) How Altrio automates deal sourcing for acquisitions teams
(03:43) Inbox and sourcing agents for broker emails and online listings
(05:40) Speed to offer: how teams use the time they get back
(07:55) Customer insight as the competitive edge
(10:17) Real estate PE fundraising and consolidation
(14:28) What's overhyped in CRE AI
(17:39) Data governance and process orchestration
(18:45) The Anthropic and Blackstone AI venture
(20:49) Collaboration Superpower: Steve Jobs

🏙️ Learn more:
-Visit Altrio
-Raj Singh on LinkedIn
-Altrio's new deal sourcing agent

🏙️ In-person Events:
-Finance Forum: NYC | 11/3
-State of Office Forum: NYC | 11/4
-Breakthrough Awards Breakfast | NYC | 12/2
-All upcoming Commercial Observer events

🏙️ Virtual Events:
-AI & Real Estate: You’ve Hired an Alien Superintelligence. Now What?: 11/10
-AI & Innovation Forum: 11/18

🏙️ Connect with Tangent:
-Edward Cohen on LinkedIn
-Zach Aarons on LinkedIn
-Tangent on LinkedIn

Creators and Guests

Host
Edward Cohen
Host & Executive Producer at Tangent
Guest
Raj Singh
CEO & Co-founder of Altrio

What is Tangent: Conversations with Real Estate & Tech Innovators?

A podcast community for real estate and tech leaders, investors, operators and innovators.

A new era is upon us. Tangent💚Proptech unites Proptech founders💡, Real Estate investors and operators🏢, Venture Capital investors, urban leaders🏙 and passionate creators🌎 who are improving our communities and cities. Join us to learn how we can solve present day challenges with innovative technology and greater collaboration.

Join Proptech entrepreneur Edward Cohen, to learn about housing innovation, the future of work and climate tech. We examine these themes through interviews and conversations with Proptech CEO's, real estate owners and operators, and venture investors, and how we can leverage tech and collaboration to help solve the housing crisis, figure out the future of work and how to decarbonize the built environment.

If you would like to get your company’s or organization’s mission featured on Tangent, email us at community@tangentproptech.com.

Stay curious and always be learning! 🤓

Raj Auphonic
===

[00:00:00] Hi, I'm Edward [00:00:01] Cohen, and this is [00:00:02] Tangent, a Commercial [00:00:03] Observer podcast, [00:00:04] coming to you live from [00:00:05] CREtech New York at [00:00:06] the Javits Center, [00:00:07] [00:00:08] [00:00:09] [00:00:10] [00:00:11] Commercial [00:00:12] real estate acquisition [00:00:13] teams are [00:00:14] drowning in broker [00:00:15] emails, and the [00:00:16] best deals are [00:00:17] buried somewhere in their [00:00:18] inbox.

[00:00:19] Most firms are still [00:00:20] sorting through them [00:00:21] manually [00:00:22] Our guest [00:00:23] today is Raj [00:00:24] Singh, CEO [00:00:25] of Alltreo. [00:00:26] [00:00:27] [00:00:28] Raj, how [00:00:29] is New York City Real Estate [00:00:30] Week treating you? [00:00:31] so far so [00:00:32] good. Really mostly here [00:00:33] just for the, the [00:00:34] CREtech conference. I [00:00:35] understand there are some other events [00:00:36] happening as well, but, [00:00:37] uh, our [00:00:38] focus is on, on this [00:00:39] one and, and so far it's, [00:00:40] uh, it's been a good day.

[00:00:41] [00:00:42] So Raj, let's [00:00:43] jump right into it. [00:00:44] Acquisition teams at [00:00:45] real estate investment firms [00:00:46] are some of the most [00:00:47] data-driven [00:00:48] professionals in the [00:00:49] industry, [00:00:50] yet a lot of them are still [00:00:51] managing deal [00:00:52] flow in Excel [00:00:53] and sorting through [00:00:54] broker emails [00:00:55] manually. [00:00:56] So tell us [00:00:57] how Alltreo [00:00:58] is working [00:00:59] with folks like [00:01:00] these and what you're [00:01:01] building.[00:01:02]

Yeah, we've always been [00:01:03] very focused [00:01:04] on trying to solve this [00:01:05] problem. I mean, the [00:01:06] industry is [00:01:07] famously [00:01:08] decentralized, right? [00:01:09] It's very fragmented, [00:01:10] very opaque. [00:01:11] Uh, if you're a [00:01:12] real estate investor or [00:01:13] lender, [00:01:14] obviously your goal [00:01:15] is to [00:01:16] construct a [00:01:17] great portfolio, [00:01:18] and that means [00:01:19] doing great [00:01:20] transactions, and that [00:01:21] means actually [00:01:22] sourcing these [00:01:23] transactions, which, you know, [00:01:24] unlike in other asset [00:01:25] classes where there's [00:01:26] greater transparency, [00:01:27] you can log into [00:01:28] a Bloomberg terminal, [00:01:29] or you've got access to s- [00:01:30] you know, something a little bit [00:01:31] more, more [00:01:32] digital.

In real [00:01:33] estate, it really [00:01:34] hasn't changed [00:01:35] since [00:01:36] brokers stopped sending [00:01:37] out envelopes [00:01:38] and started emailing [00:01:39] OMs digitally [00:01:40] instead, right? It's still [00:01:41] very much about who [00:01:42] you know. A lot of the [00:01:43] time real estate [00:01:44] investors [00:01:45] spend [00:01:46] is spent on, [00:01:47] reaching out to brokers to [00:01:48] remind them that they're still, [00:01:49] still there and [00:01:50] sort of remind them what deals they're [00:01:51] looking for, or they're [00:01:52] going to [00:01:53] conferences, or they're [00:01:54] searching different online [00:01:55] listing sites, [00:01:56] and it's, it's [00:01:57] very inefficient.

[00:01:58] And all of these [00:01:59] investors, they sort of live [00:02:00] in fear [00:02:01] of missing the [00:02:02] next great [00:02:03] deal that could be like [00:02:04] a really great add for their [00:02:05] portfolio. Mm-hmm. [00:02:06] So we've always, always been [00:02:07] very focused on of [00:02:08] solving that problem. [00:02:09] For years now, [00:02:10] we've [00:02:11] been [00:02:12] automating, the process [00:02:13] of sorting [00:02:14] through inbound [00:02:15] deal flow.

So [00:02:16] just to give you some of the [00:02:17] details. Mm-hmm. Our [00:02:18] customers for years have been [00:02:19] essentially forwarding [00:02:20] broker emails, [00:02:21] uploading OMs, [00:02:22] brochures, et cetera, [00:02:23] and we've been [00:02:24] using AI actually [00:02:25] since, you know, long before [00:02:26] AI became quite as popular [00:02:27] as it is now. We've been doing this [00:02:28] for almost ten years to [00:02:29] sort of pull the key [00:02:30] details out of these [00:02:31] documents and [00:02:32] present all of the [00:02:33] opportunities from sort of a [00:02:34] common apples to [00:02:35] apples kind of easy [00:02:36] way to sort of sort through the good [00:02:37] from the bad.[00:02:38]

What [00:02:39] AI's allowed us to do [00:02:40] is take that to the next [00:02:41] level. Earlier this [00:02:42] year, we [00:02:43] released an [00:02:44] inbox agent [00:02:45] that can actually [00:02:46] connect directly [00:02:47] into our users' email [00:02:48] inboxes, [00:02:49] find broker [00:02:50] emails, whether they're [00:02:51] broker blasts or [00:02:52] update emails, you know, [00:02:53] revising the guidance [00:02:54] price or the bid date, et [00:02:55] cetera.

Mm-hmm. [00:02:56] Automatically [00:02:57] create deals in their [00:02:58] pipeline based on those [00:02:59] emails, update them [00:03:00] based on the updated [00:03:01] information that's coming in, [00:03:02] removing really all the [00:03:03] friction. [00:03:04] And what that really allows [00:03:05] real estate investors to [00:03:06] do is to [00:03:07] cast a wider net. [00:03:08] previously A [00:03:09] lot of investors would've [00:03:10] been reluctant to [00:03:11] sort of, go out and [00:03:12] invite more deal flow [00:03:13] 'cause they'd be worried [00:03:14] that they'd drown in the [00:03:15] volume and they'd end up [00:03:16] missing the next great [00:03:17] deal.

Kind of needle in the [00:03:18] haystack. The more you sort of [00:03:19] try to, to [00:03:20] increase top of the funnel, the [00:03:21] more likely you're gonna get a lot of [00:03:22] stuff that doesn't fit. [00:03:23] By using [00:03:24] AI [00:03:25] to [00:03:26] completely automate that [00:03:27] initial [00:03:28] ingestion and [00:03:29] screening step, [00:03:30] real estate folks [00:03:31] really have no [00:03:32] reason not to try to [00:03:33] see as many deals as they [00:03:34] possibly can because the [00:03:35] time it takes to screen [00:03:36] those has gone to [00:03:37] zero.

So more [00:03:38] recently, we've actually, [00:03:39] just announcing it this [00:03:40] week, we've [00:03:41] released a sourcing [00:03:42] agent- Hmm ... [00:03:43] which [00:03:44] actually goes out [00:03:45] every night [00:03:46] to dozens of [00:03:47] brokerage sites, [00:03:48] basically scans [00:03:49] thousands of listings, [00:03:50] looks for new [00:03:51] listings, updated [00:03:52] listings, and anything [00:03:53] that's found that matches [00:03:54] our customer's [00:03:55] investment criteria [00:03:56] are [00:03:57] automatically pulled down and [00:03:58] actually injected into the top [00:03:59] of their funnel.[00:04:00]

So [00:04:01] really [00:04:02] creates a single [00:04:03] place now where our [00:04:04] users can see [00:04:05] the deals [00:04:06] brokers have sent them via [00:04:07] email and the [00:04:08] deals that are [00:04:09] listed online [00:04:10] without having to really [00:04:11] do anything, [00:04:12] but just- Fascinating ... just turn [00:04:13] it on, right? Yeah. [00:04:14] So we're getting [00:04:15] close to finally [00:04:16] actually solving the [00:04:17] sourcing problem [00:04:18] that's, uh, plagued investors [00:04:19] for a long time.

Just [00:04:20] turning it on, you know? It [00:04:21] sounds, sounds [00:04:22] like the dream. That's [00:04:23] what a real estate, [00:04:24] uh, investor would want, [00:04:25] right? They- It's, it's the [00:04:26] easy button ... they wanna [00:04:27] focus on, on [00:04:28] their job, They don't wanna [00:04:29] focus on the [00:04:30] unsexy part in this [00:04:31] case that actually [00:04:32] doesn't bring them [00:04:33] more money or better [00:04:34] deals.[00:04:35]

You're [00:04:36] helping all these teams [00:04:37] save time. [00:04:38] Are you seeing that [00:04:39] the, the saved time [00:04:40] is now translating to [00:04:41] them [00:04:42] looking more [00:04:43] in depth at the [00:04:44] good deals that they [00:04:45] want, or just being [00:04:46] able to look at more [00:04:47] deals in general? [00:04:48] A- and maybe this is [00:04:49] too early, but just in [00:04:50] terms of h- what you're [00:04:51] seeing or how are you [00:04:52] envisioning [00:04:53] this saved [00:04:54] time be [00:04:55] reallocated by these [00:04:56] teams?

[00:04:57] Inevitably, you're gonna [00:04:58] have the ability to look [00:04:59] at more [00:05:00] opportunities, right? You're gonna have [00:05:01] a wider net that [00:05:02] you're able to cast, [00:05:03] and the time you [00:05:04] get back is going to [00:05:05] allow you to [00:05:06] not necessarily [00:05:07] spend more [00:05:08] time looking at the [00:05:09] deals, sort of doing deeper [00:05:10] analysis, but allow you to [00:05:11] move more quickly, [00:05:12] right?

The time [00:05:13] you, you get [00:05:14] back will potentially [00:05:15] put you in pole position [00:05:16] ahead of, you know, your [00:05:17] competition, getting, being able to get [00:05:18] back to the broker with [00:05:19] a, with an offer [00:05:20] earlier. The real estate [00:05:21] market is [00:05:22] not in the best [00:05:23] shape it's been in ever right [00:05:24] now, but you know, there are [00:05:25] still competitive [00:05:26] pockets there's still a lot of [00:05:27] capital out there chasing the [00:05:28] best opportunities, [00:05:29] and [00:05:30] any advantage your team [00:05:31] can get by [00:05:32] leveraging software to [00:05:33] automate, you know, [00:05:34] some of the lower value [00:05:35] add steps [00:05:36] just gives you more time to [00:05:37] focus on the things that really [00:05:38] do move the needle and [00:05:39] help your overall [00:05:40] competitive positioning.

[00:05:41] But really the, the [00:05:42] time saved is only [00:05:43] one element of it. [00:05:44] It's [00:05:45] the [00:05:46] avoidance of just [00:05:47] missing the [00:05:48] opportunity that you would oth- [00:05:49] You know, we've seen really [00:05:50] silly things. We've seen [00:05:51] deals just end up in people's [00:05:52] spam folders. [00:05:53] As the operator [00:05:54] of a [00:05:55] platform that's used by, [00:05:56] you know, a lot of real [00:05:57] estate investors, [00:05:58] and brokers, we're able [00:05:59] to sort of [00:06:00] see the deal flow almost [00:06:01] in real time.

We can [00:06:02] see the deals that brokers are [00:06:03] listing, we can see the [00:06:04] deals that investors are looking [00:06:05] at, and [00:06:06] we can see how [00:06:07] inefficient the [00:06:08] market is, right? [00:06:09] Brokers are sending [00:06:10] deals often to the wrong [00:06:11] people, very often, [00:06:12] right? You know, your [00:06:13] industrial deals [00:06:14] getting sent to multifamily [00:06:15] investors, et cetera.

Mm-hmm. [00:06:16] And at the same time, [00:06:17] we can see on our [00:06:18] platform that there are deals that [00:06:19] actually fit [00:06:20] in the buy boxes [00:06:21] of some of our customers [00:06:22] that they're just not getting [00:06:23] because those [00:06:24] relationships aren't there. They don't [00:06:25] know the brokers. Brokers don't [00:06:26] know them. [00:06:27] So, you know, we think [00:06:28] the time saving is [00:06:29] great, but just [00:06:30] connecting [00:06:31] capital to [00:06:32] opportunities, connecting buyer to [00:06:33] seller is where we [00:06:34] think there's a, a [00:06:35] much bigger opportunity just [00:06:36] around making it [00:06:37] possible to do these [00:06:38] transactions at [00:06:39] all, right?

Because [00:06:40] you can't do a deal you didn't [00:06:41] know existed. You can't bid on [00:06:42] a, a property you [00:06:43] didn't know was in the market. [00:06:44] Nope. Right? [00:06:45] Spam folder [00:06:46] missed deal. [00:06:47] Ouch. Oh, yeah. [00:06:48] No, there, there have been a lot [00:06:49] of ouches. [00:06:50] [00:06:51] Talking about [00:06:52] competition [00:06:53] and talking about [00:06:54] staying ahead, and [00:06:55] every other week it [00:06:56] seems like- [00:06:57] Anthropic's [00:06:58] model is the, [00:06:59] the best one according to the [00:07:00] benchmarks, and the next [00:07:01] week it's OpenAI, and [00:07:02] the next, you know, it [00:07:03] now open weight [00:07:04] models and open source [00:07:05] are really [00:07:06] being, uh, [00:07:07] threatening, if you [00:07:08] will, the closed [00:07:09] ecosystem LLMs that we [00:07:10] have.

But [00:07:11] from your side, [00:07:12] how do you stay [00:07:13] ahead in terms of, [00:07:14] like, this week [00:07:15] you launched a [00:07:16] almighty [00:07:17] powerful deal [00:07:18] sourcing [00:07:19] agent. Sounds [00:07:20] super exciting. [00:07:21] Next week, [00:07:22] something new comes up. A- [00:07:23] and you've been doing this since [00:07:24] before it was cool, [00:07:25] right? Since you... Before it [00:07:26] was a buzzword to do [00:07:27] AI in real estate, [00:07:28] uh, which I think brings [00:07:29] a lot of [00:07:30] credibility, in what you're doing.[00:07:31]

But how do you [00:07:32] differentiate [00:07:33] yourself ultimately [00:07:34] from all the [00:07:35] solutions out there, or [00:07:36] even from the [00:07:37] generalist LLMs? [00:07:38] So [00:07:39] what's new [00:07:40] today with these [00:07:41] technologies that have come [00:07:42] out that... It, it's the [00:07:43] speed, right? [00:07:44] You're able to [00:07:45] build things [00:07:46] much more [00:07:47] quickly and take [00:07:48] things to market much [00:07:49] more quickly.[00:07:50]

Not even in [00:07:51] terms of just the actual [00:07:52] software build, but even [00:07:53] building all [00:07:54] the marketing [00:07:55] collateral and the [00:07:56] onboarding material. You can just [00:07:57] move more [00:07:58] quickly across the [00:07:59] board. Mm-hmm. So [00:08:00] that's the part that's [00:08:01] new, and it [00:08:02] raises the bar, right? It [00:08:03] forces people at [00:08:04] our company and others [00:08:05] to, to really sort of [00:08:06] stay on your [00:08:07] toes.

You've got to keep [00:08:08] the intensity up, [00:08:09] right? Because you know that [00:08:10] it's now [00:08:11] possible for your competition to [00:08:12] move much more quickly as [00:08:13] well. [00:08:14] But [00:08:15] that's a, a rising [00:08:16] tide lifting [00:08:17] all boats, [00:08:18] right? Everyone can move more [00:08:19] quickly. [00:08:20] There's still gonna be [00:08:21] comparative advantage [00:08:22] between firms, [00:08:23] and [00:08:24] our view is that the [00:08:25] biggest comparative advantage [00:08:26] is customer [00:08:27] insights.

It's always been the [00:08:28] case. If you stay [00:08:29] close to your [00:08:30] customers, you keep your [00:08:31] ear to the ground, you [00:08:32] understand what their pain points are, [00:08:33] you understand what their goals [00:08:34] are, and their goals are [00:08:35] changing very quickly now as well [00:08:36] with, all these changes [00:08:37] in, in the tech [00:08:38] landscape. [00:08:39] But if [00:08:40] you stay [00:08:41] committed to [00:08:42] evolving and [00:08:43] adapting with your [00:08:44] customers [00:08:45] and just [00:08:46] making the right decisions [00:08:47] around what you [00:08:48] build [00:08:49] and, you know, how you [00:08:50] support those products you [00:08:51] build, how you take them to [00:08:52] market, how you implement them, et [00:08:53] cetera, that will [00:08:54] remain, we [00:08:55] believe [00:08:56] The primary source of [00:08:57] advantage, right?

So [00:08:58] everyone's gonna move [00:08:59] quicker, but [00:09:00] the [00:09:01] quality of the decisions you're [00:09:02] making still matter, [00:09:03] and the quality of [00:09:04] the decisions [00:09:05] ultimately stem from how well you [00:09:06] understand [00:09:07] the market and the customers [00:09:08] you serve. [00:09:09] [00:09:10] Fascinating, fast [00:09:11] evolving [00:09:12] landscape that we live in. [00:09:13] Let's talk [00:09:14] about the macro [00:09:15] and how it's affecting [00:09:16] some of your [00:09:17] clients, if at all.

But [00:09:18] real estate private [00:09:19] equity is, is going through [00:09:20] a, a rough patch, [00:09:21] if you can call it that. [00:09:22] Private real estate [00:09:23] fundraising [00:09:24] hit its lowest [00:09:25] quarterly level [00:09:26] since [00:09:27] 2013- Yeah ... this past [00:09:28] summer. A lot of [00:09:29] competition for capital out [00:09:30] there. A lot of [00:09:31] competition. Capital is [00:09:32] more expensive than [00:09:33] what it used to be when, uh, [00:09:34] interest rates were near [00:09:35] zero.

I mean, we've [00:09:36] had EQT [00:09:37] just acquiring [00:09:38] Stockbridge, a [00:09:39] 20-year-old [00:09:40] manager with over [00:09:41] $16 billion [00:09:42] in assets under [00:09:43] management. It got [00:09:44] acquired for just over [00:09:45] half a billion dollars. [00:09:46] [00:09:47] So for a firm [00:09:48] sitting in the [00:09:49] middle of all of [00:09:50] this, how does that change your [00:09:51] approach in terms [00:09:52] of what their [00:09:53] needs are? [00:09:54] Or [00:09:55] how do you take advantage of [00:09:56] this consolidation to [00:09:57] bring even more value [00:09:58] to the survivors, [00:09:59] if you will?[00:10:00]

So there's no [00:10:01] way to [00:10:02] spin or [00:10:03] avoid talking about [00:10:04] the fact that there [00:10:05] are some, like, major [00:10:06] headwinds in the [00:10:07] industry. The [00:10:08] cost of capital [00:10:09] has always [00:10:10] been [00:10:11] paramount. the growth [00:10:12] of the real estate investment [00:10:13] management industry over the last [00:10:14] 20 years was really [00:10:15] tied to the fact that [00:10:16] interest rates were [00:10:17] at all-time [00:10:18] lows for a really long [00:10:19] time.

And [00:10:20] as an asset [00:10:21] class, it was just more [00:10:22] attractive than a lot of [00:10:23] alternative asset classes, right? [00:10:24] Today, obviously, with [00:10:25] interest rates where they are [00:10:26] and the [00:10:27] demand for [00:10:28] capital coming from [00:10:29] AI, [00:10:30] the bar is just gonna be [00:10:31] higher. The number, [00:10:32] the sheer number [00:10:33] of real estate [00:10:34] investments that are gonna actually [00:10:35] produce an attractive [00:10:36] return, [00:10:37] there are just fewer of [00:10:38] them, right?

[00:10:39] Which means [00:10:40] [00:10:41] Overall, the [00:10:42] industry will probably [00:10:43] get [00:10:44] smaller. There will [00:10:45] still be firms [00:10:46] out there, [00:10:47] making great [00:10:48] investments, developing [00:10:49] great properties, [00:10:50] operating properties really [00:10:51] well, and, and creating [00:10:52] profits. [00:10:53] And [00:10:54] we're gonna be there to [00:10:55] support them, to serve [00:10:56] them. [00:10:57] But again, there's, [00:10:58] there's really no way [00:10:59] to, get around or [00:11:00] spin the fact that [00:11:01] real estate as an [00:11:02] asset class [00:11:03] is [00:11:04] strictly based [00:11:05] on where interest rates are [00:11:06] going to [00:11:07] be less [00:11:08] competitive than some [00:11:09] other asset classes, [00:11:10] right?

So there will be [00:11:11] consolidation, there'll be fewer [00:11:12] players, [00:11:13] and, uh, yeah, that's a [00:11:14] headwind for us. [00:11:15] But the industry [00:11:16] might be getting smaller. It's still [00:11:17] a massive industry. [00:11:18] Real estate is still a [00:11:19] massive industry. [00:11:20] It's famously [00:11:21] cyclical. There definitely have [00:11:22] been ups and [00:11:23] downs, you know, many of them over [00:11:24] the years.

[00:11:25] And if [00:11:26] interest rates started [00:11:27] heading downward again, guess [00:11:28] what? This industry would grow [00:11:29] again because [00:11:30] it is very much [00:11:31] tied to, uh, to those [00:11:32] interest rates. So, the [00:11:33] industry's been around for a long [00:11:34] time. We're here for the [00:11:35] ups and downs. We're [00:11:36] gonna stay focused on, on [00:11:37] serving our customers. [00:11:38] Spot on.

I think, I [00:11:39] mean, certainly the, [00:11:40] the, the macro [00:11:41] environment, which you [00:11:42] correctly pointed out, it's always been [00:11:43] tied to commercial [00:11:44] real estate [00:11:45] success or otherwise. [00:11:46] It certainly made a lot [00:11:47] of people [00:11:48] look really [00:11:49] smart in the last twenty [00:11:50] years, [00:11:51] and a lot of them probably [00:11:52] are. A lot of them [00:11:53] were lucky. But [00:11:54] maybe it also attracted [00:11:55] certain [00:11:56] player, the, the [00:11:57] speculator, if you will, or the [00:11:58] one that wasn't in it for [00:11:59] the long run that, [00:12:00] you know, maybe wanted to make a [00:12:01] quick buck here and there.

So [00:12:02] I think there are [00:12:03] positives to [00:12:04] this, uh, [00:12:05] recalibration that we're going [00:12:06] repricing, if you [00:12:07] will. A lot [00:12:08] of pain, a lot of [00:12:09] pain out there. [00:12:10] Assets that were worth [00:12:11] double, [00:12:12] triple, even more [00:12:13] just a couple years ago are [00:12:14] not worth that [00:12:15] anymore. Mm-hmm. And they probably [00:12:16] won't be back [00:12:17] at those valuations [00:12:18] anytime soon.

[00:12:19] And I think that reality [00:12:20] has set in. [00:12:21] Just last week, [00:12:22] a [00:12:23] massive [00:12:24] sophisticated hedge fund like Two [00:12:25] Sigma [00:12:26] halted [00:12:27] fundraising for its [00:12:28] real estate unit [00:12:29] after raising [00:12:30] less than half of [00:12:31] its two billion dollar [00:12:32] target. Sure. [00:12:33] So I [00:12:34] think we're gonna have, [00:12:35] like you said, probably less [00:12:36] players, but maybe [00:12:37] [00:12:38] Better capitalized [00:12:39] players and, the [00:12:40] more sophisticated [00:12:41] players will ultimately, with the [00:12:42] better technologies, will [00:12:43] survive Yeah, [00:12:44] absolutely.

[00:12:45] Absolutely. When you have, a [00:12:46] situation like we're seeing [00:12:47] where there is [00:12:48] consolidation, [00:12:49] where only the [00:12:50] best can make it through, [00:12:51] right? It's, you know, it's [00:12:52] Darwinian [00:12:53] pressure on the whole [00:12:54] industry. The best [00:12:55] companies [00:12:56] come out of times like [00:12:57] this, [00:12:58] and times like this [00:12:59] make good [00:13:00] companies [00:13:01] better. If you're [00:13:02] really not, you [00:13:03] know, if you're over- [00:13:04] [00:13:05] overcapitalized or, you're not [00:13:06] really run [00:13:07] very efficiently, then [00:13:08] you may be one of the companies that [00:13:09] doesn't make it through.

[00:13:10] But, you know, the [00:13:11] companies that do make it through always [00:13:12] come out of these things [00:13:13] stronger. And [00:13:14] sort of this is where you get [00:13:15] your sort of long [00:13:16] generational [00:13:17] success stories [00:13:18] is through these pressure [00:13:19] moments where you're [00:13:20] really sort of forced [00:13:21] to, uh, get your [00:13:22] fundamentals right Hundred [00:13:23] percent. [00:13:24] What do you think is [00:13:25] overhyped [00:13:26] right now for [00:13:27] AI in commercial real [00:13:28] estate and what [00:13:29] is underrated?[00:13:30]

That's a great [00:13:31] question. I'm not sure [00:13:32] if this is [00:13:33] changing. I feel like it probably [00:13:34] is. These questions, [00:13:35] the answer almost [00:13:36] changes weekly. [00:13:37] Things are moving so [00:13:38] quickly right now. There [00:13:39] was a bit of a [00:13:40] trend, maybe there [00:13:41] still is, [00:13:42] a little while [00:13:43] ago, [00:13:44] around [00:13:45] specializing [00:13:46] AI models [00:13:47] for different [00:13:48] applications, right?

So [00:13:49] generating an [00:13:50] OM using [00:13:51] AI, for example, [00:13:52] [00:13:53] underwriting [00:13:54] property, extracting a [00:13:55] lease document, [00:13:56] whatever the case may [00:13:57] be. These [00:13:58] little [00:13:59] very specific [00:14:00] [00:14:01] AI-powered solutions [00:14:02] were popping up, [00:14:03] and they were actually they were, [00:14:04] they were getting [00:14:05] funded by venture [00:14:06] capitalists. They were, you know, [00:14:07] signing pilot [00:14:08] agreements with big, [00:14:09] very well-known [00:14:10] real estate [00:14:11] companies.

And, you know, there was a lot of [00:14:12] buzz around them. I [00:14:13] feel like we're already starting to [00:14:14] see that [00:14:15] fizzle out. I [00:14:16] think, uh, [00:14:17] folks [00:14:18] are starting [00:14:19] to realize [00:14:20] that [00:14:21] AI really [00:14:22] isn't a tool. [00:14:23] You [00:14:24] really shouldn't be looking to [00:14:25] buy an [00:14:26] AI solution. [00:14:27] [00:14:28] AI is, [00:14:29] it's an agent, right? [00:14:30] It's a teammate. [00:14:31] It's, uh, it's an [00:14:32] employee, [00:14:33] and it works [00:14:34] beside you in your [00:14:35] organization, and [00:14:36] it uses [00:14:37] tools.[00:14:38]

So [00:14:39] if a, a company [00:14:40] out there is, is sort [00:14:41] of selling an [00:14:42] AI [00:14:43] tool and they, and they [00:14:44] like, you know- [00:14:45] AI generation for [00:14:46] X, whatever that happens [00:14:47] to be. I think [00:14:48] there's probably not a lot of [00:14:49] future in that sort [00:14:50] of solution, [00:14:51] because [00:14:52] those [00:14:53] solutions [00:14:54] inevitably are just acting [00:14:55] on [00:14:56] data or [00:14:57] using [00:14:58] tools like the ability to [00:14:59] generate a [00:15:00] PowerPoint, for example, or a [00:15:01] PDF, or the ability [00:15:02] to do web [00:15:03] research, whatever it is, [00:15:04] right?

But [00:15:05] the generic [00:15:06] solutions out there, [00:15:07] you know, the Claude [00:15:08] Coworks and [00:15:09] ChatGPTs of the [00:15:10] world, [00:15:11] they can use all [00:15:12] the same tools, [00:15:13] and [00:15:14] with [00:15:15] every new version of [00:15:16] the model, [00:15:17] they become [00:15:18] as [00:15:19] good at or better [00:15:20] than all of the sort [00:15:21] of specialized [00:15:22] applications [00:15:23] that people were [00:15:24] previously kind of building [00:15:25] as these kind of [00:15:26] one-off [00:15:27] offerings.

So for [00:15:28] example, [00:15:29] today you might [00:15:30] have a, an [00:15:31] AI [00:15:32] tool that [00:15:33] generates X [00:15:34] using Y [00:15:35] data. Well, [00:15:36] tomorrow Claude is gonna be able to [00:15:37] do that by [00:15:38] itself. And this is [00:15:39] kind of our house view at [00:15:40] Altria as well, [00:15:41] is [00:15:42] AI features [00:15:43] and AI [00:15:44] tools I think are [00:15:45] all going [00:15:46] to, or a lot of them are gonna [00:15:47] fizzle out very [00:15:48] quickly as people [00:15:49] realize [00:15:50] that it's actually [00:15:51] a, a [00:15:52] colleague, it's a user, it's [00:15:53] not a s- it's not a [00:15:54] tool.

And [00:15:55] [00:15:56] Inevitably, you're [00:15:57] gonna want [00:15:58] the [00:15:59] same agent [00:16:00] to work [00:16:01] with and [00:16:02] use a [00:16:03] whole suite of [00:16:04] tools and a whole set of [00:16:05] data, not [00:16:06] be sort of tethered [00:16:07] to or embedded in [00:16:08] any one tool [00:16:09] or one set of data. [00:16:10] And I think the [00:16:11] market is gonna [00:16:12] largely coalesce, [00:16:13] and, in fact, I think it [00:16:14] already has sort of [00:16:15] coalesced [00:16:16] around things like Claude [00:16:17] Cowork [00:16:18] and other [00:16:19] open weight models too, [00:16:20] maybe, right?

I think over [00:16:21] time, maybe more and [00:16:22] more. [00:16:23] But in any [00:16:24] firm, you're gonna [00:16:25] have a [00:16:26] handful of these [00:16:27] that [00:16:28] do a lot of things, that work [00:16:29] across entire [00:16:30] processes, that [00:16:31] work in groups [00:16:32] to get things done. [00:16:33] And [00:16:34] I think [00:16:35] the, the [00:16:36] technologies that [00:16:37] will [00:16:38] persist and be [00:16:39] useful even in [00:16:40] this future [00:16:41] are tools that AI [00:16:42] can use.

[00:16:43] So, structured data [00:16:44] sets with all kinds [00:16:45] of [00:16:46] governance and [00:16:47] guardrails baked in, [00:16:48] communication [00:16:49] platforms, communication [00:16:50] networks, [00:16:51] process [00:16:52] orchestration [00:16:53] solutions, [00:16:54] solutions that [00:16:55] allow you to [00:16:56] get consistency out [00:16:57] of your AI, AI [00:16:58] agents, allow you to get [00:16:59] scalability, [00:17:00] auditability- Yeah ... right? [00:17:01] These are the things that are really [00:17:02] gonna survive.[00:17:03]

And, you know, you asked what's [00:17:04] under-hyped. I think [00:17:05] sometimes those types of [00:17:06] solutions don't look [00:17:07] or feel very [00:17:08] sexy. [00:17:09] People are looking for the [00:17:10] whiz-bang, "Ooh, look, [00:17:11] AI just generated this [00:17:12] beautiful thing for me." [00:17:13] But [00:17:14] that's gonna be such a [00:17:15] commodity. Any [00:17:16] frontier model [00:17:17] or even any sort of like [00:17:18] sophisticated [00:17:19] open, open weight [00:17:20] model is gonna be able to [00:17:21] do all the [00:17:22] same whiz-bang [00:17:23] things.

[00:17:24] What's gonna be important is [00:17:25] that they are doing [00:17:26] those things on [00:17:27] a [00:17:28] shared, standardized, [00:17:29] governed set of [00:17:30] data and a platform that the [00:17:31] whole company coalesces [00:17:32] around. [00:17:33] Those things, I think are gonna [00:17:34] actually be, [00:17:35] are gonna be the things that have [00:17:36] staying power and, you [00:17:37] know, maybe should be [00:17:38] seen as sexier than they [00:17:39] are.

I [00:17:40] agree with you. [00:17:41] We've seen [00:17:42] Anthropic and Blackstone [00:17:43] launch [00:17:44] a $1.5 billion [00:17:45] enterprise [00:17:46] AI service [00:17:47] firm earlier this [00:17:48] year, explicitly [00:17:49] targeting real estate, [00:17:50] and their pitch [00:17:51] is they're [00:17:52] embedding AI engineers [00:17:53] directly into [00:17:54] portfolio operations. [00:17:55] You- Thought that was a big [00:17:56] nothing burger, to be honest, [00:17:57] but maybe that's a controversial [00:17:58] take.

[00:17:59] I-- That's what we're here for. [00:18:00] I, I, I haven't [00:18:01] seen anything in, in the [00:18:02] real world, right? We [00:18:03] haven't seen this [00:18:04] play out. We- I mean, it [00:18:05] was- We know these- It was, it [00:18:06] was a big announcement [00:18:07] that was essentially, [00:18:08] "Hey, we're, uh, we're [00:18:09] doing a big enterprise [00:18:10] IT build." [00:18:11] Like, I mean, come on. I've [00:18:12] been doing this a long [00:18:13] time.

these companies [00:18:14] are always announcing these [00:18:15] big enterprise [00:18:16] IT builds, and, like, there was [00:18:17] honestly nothing in that [00:18:18] announcement that sounded [00:18:19] even a little bit original to me. [00:18:20] Again, maybe a [00:18:21] controversial take, [00:18:22] but we'll, I guess we'll [00:18:23] see what comes out of that. [00:18:24] We need more takes like [00:18:25] that because [00:18:26] honestly, it, it's something that I, [00:18:27] I also saw the [00:18:28] announcement.

I haven't [00:18:29] heard of [00:18:30] anyone acting on [00:18:31] it, nothing [00:18:32] happening. Well, I don't think it's [00:18:33] anything, like... That's [00:18:34] happening all over the [00:18:35] place. Right. Right? They're, [00:18:36] they made a big announcement [00:18:37] about it, but I know lots of big [00:18:38] real estate companies that are [00:18:39] doing lots [00:18:40] of really interesting [00:18:41] internal builds. [00:18:42] And again, like, that's [00:18:43] all great.

I [00:18:44] just think that [00:18:45] the idea that [00:18:46] you can [00:18:47] find some sort of [00:18:48] alpha [00:18:49] In doing [00:18:50] something like that today, [00:18:51] it's like [00:18:52] where's the secret [00:18:53] sauce? [00:18:54] Right? I'm sorry. No. [00:18:55] Don't be ... the-- I can [00:18:56] also use Anthropic, [00:18:57] right? All my customers can [00:18:58] use Anthropic, right? [00:18:59] So I think it's [00:19:00] probably just [00:19:01] a, a really [00:19:02] good way to spend a [00:19:03] lot of money [00:19:04] and kinda drive down [00:19:05] your ROI when you [00:19:06] try to make a [00:19:07] big swing like that.[00:19:08]

Big [00:19:09] swing IT [00:19:10] projects [00:19:11] have been a thing for a [00:19:12] long time. [00:19:13] They [00:19:14] inevitably disappoint in terms [00:19:15] of their actual [00:19:16] outcomes. Like, the [00:19:17] bigger the swing you [00:19:18] take with these, these [00:19:19] massive IT builds, the [00:19:20] more likely [00:19:21] someone's gonna get [00:19:22] fired and there's gonna be, like, a [00:19:23] lot of disappointment, [00:19:24] right? Boiling the water- [00:19:25] It's, it-

the ocean ... boil the [00:19:26] ocean. Yeah, it's, much [00:19:27] better [00:19:28] to focus [00:19:29] on solving [00:19:30] real problems [00:19:31] incrementally, [00:19:32] iteratively, and sort [00:19:33] of going at the value [00:19:34] and not [00:19:35] getting swept up in [00:19:36] the grandiose, [00:19:37] "We are gonna build the [00:19:38] be-all, end-all AI [00:19:39] solution for real estate." Like [00:19:40] that's... I don't know. [00:19:41] It sounded a lot like a lot of [00:19:42] hot air to me, to be [00:19:43] honest.

I love [00:19:44] your [00:19:45] honesty. Collaboration [00:19:46] superpower. If you could choose [00:19:47] one person, [00:19:48] historic or living, [00:19:49] real or [00:19:50] fictional, to do a [00:19:51] partnership with, [00:19:52] who would it be? [00:19:53] Oh my [00:19:54] God, what a [00:19:55] question. I have a [00:19:56] lot of heroes. I'm a [00:19:57] bit of an amateur [00:19:58] [00:19:59] technology historian. I read a [00:20:00] lot about [00:20:01] the way that [00:20:02] technologies have evolved over [00:20:03] time.

I have a [00:20:04] lot of heroes, but I [00:20:05] definitely have got a bit of a [00:20:06] soft spot for [00:20:07] Steve Jobs. [00:20:08] definitely not the most original [00:20:09] answer. It's, I hear it a [00:20:10] lot of people, but [00:20:11] if I could [00:20:12] pick one [00:20:13] person to [00:20:14] have the [00:20:15] privilege of working [00:20:16] with on [00:20:17] innovation, it would [00:20:18] be him, the [00:20:19] legend, right? [00:20:20] He is. And, uh, [00:20:21] uh, we can't [00:20:22] say any new things that [00:20:23] probably haven't been said, but [00:20:24] for me personally, [00:20:25] I just keep [00:20:26] discovering new things [00:20:27] that he had [00:20:28] influence on or that [00:20:29] he directly [00:20:30] inspired. [00:20:31] So yeah, [00:20:32] I, I would say [00:20:33] Elon Musk or Steve [00:20:34] Jobs are [00:20:35] answers that we often [00:20:36] get, and, uh, I, it's [00:20:37] understandable.

[00:20:38] Elon Musk [00:20:39] pre-Twitter. [00:20:40] Fair. [00:20:41] That's not a hot take. I think [00:20:42] that's a fair take. Oh [00:20:43] my God. Yeah. [00:20:44] Raj, where can [00:20:45] Tangent listeners [00:20:46] and real estate [00:20:47] investment teams learn [00:20:48] more about [00:20:49] Altrio and connect with [00:20:50] you? Yeah, [00:20:51] we'd love for folks to [00:20:52] reach out and get in [00:20:53] touch. Our, our [00:20:54] website is [00:20:55] www.altrio, [00:20:56] [00:20:57] A-L-T-R-I-O, [00:20:58] .com.

And a [00:20:59] lot of the features and [00:21:00] sort of exciting things [00:21:01] we've been releasing [00:21:02] recently, they're actually [00:21:03] all available [00:21:04] to try for [00:21:05] free. It's, um, [00:21:06] unlike a lot of solutions in [00:21:07] our space that require you to [00:21:08] go through a whole sales [00:21:09] cycle, [00:21:10] and [00:21:11] demos, and talk to [00:21:12] salespeople, and then [00:21:13] do an onboarding [00:21:14] project, our new [00:21:15] solution actually is [00:21:16] something you could be up and [00:21:17] running on in, in five [00:21:18] minutes.

In fact, I've actually signed [00:21:19] up a number of people here at the [00:21:20] conference. Wow. So yeah, [00:21:21] if you wanna, you wanna [00:21:22] try, you know, our, our [00:21:23] inbox agent, our [00:21:24] sourcing agent, [00:21:25] or any of our [00:21:26] AI-powered solutions, [00:21:27] you can actually do that yourself [00:21:28] just on our website. [00:21:29] [00:21:30] Raj Singh, [00:21:31] CEO and [00:21:32] co-founder of [00:21:33] Altrio. Thank you [00:21:34] so much for [00:21:35] coming to Tangent today.[00:21:36]

Thanks, Edward. It's a [00:21:37] pleasure.

Edward: [00:21:38] [00:21:39] [00:21:40] [00:21:41] Muchas [00:21:42] gracias. [00:21:43] If you learn something [00:21:44] new or enjoy the [00:21:45] conversation. [00:21:46] Text a friend the [00:21:47] link to this episode [00:21:48] right now.

[00:21:49] [00:21:50] You can find [00:21:51] links, resources, and [00:21:52] ways to connect with [00:21:53] us in the show [00:21:54] notes [00:21:55] [00:21:56] [00:21:57]