In this episode of Uncorked: Wine-Business-Life, hosts Bill Green and Jerrold Colton sit down with Fred Fraenkel, a Wall Street veteran and wine enthusiast whose career spans decades of financial success and entrepreneurial ventures.Fred takes us on a journey from his early days growing up in Allentown, Pennsylvania, to becoming one of the most influential figures in investment banking. Hear how Fred's relentless drive and strategic thinking led him to roles at Goldman Sachs, Lehman Brothers, Cowen, and beyond. His insights into financial markets, investment strategies, and the evolution of Wall Street make this episode a must-listen for anyone interested in the world of finance.Beyond business, Fred shares his passion for wine with an enthusiasm and expertise that are nothing short of remarkable. His wine palate is both sophisticated and adventurous, with an impressive knowledge that spans Old World classics to New World innovations. Fred reflects on his first taste of fine Bordeaux, his love for bold Italian reds, and his experiences with rare vintages at prestigious auctions. As a dedicated collector and connoisseur, he shares unforgettable stories of meeting legendary winemakers and exploring renowned vineyards, offering listeners a masterclass in appreciating and curating exceptional wines.Join Bill, Jerrold, and Fred for a captivating discussion blending financial acumen, entrepreneurial wisdom, and a shared love for extraordinary wines. Cheers!
Join host Bill Green on Uncorked, a captivating conversational podcast that blends wine, business, and life into one flavorful journey. Each episode features engaging discussions, drawing from Bill's decades of entrepreneurial success across a wide variety of industries and his fresh perspective as he ventures into the wine industry at Saddlehill. Bill is joined by a diverse lineup of fascinating guests, including successful business leaders, accomplished athletes, and other remarkable individuals who share their stories and insights. Together, they offer entrepreneurial insights, leadership tips, and strategies for building successful businesses, as well as Life Reflections that explore personal stories, life philosophies, and the pursuit of balance in relatable and authentic conversations. And because enjoying great wine is simply a part of life, they take a few moments to share Wine Insights, discussing their discoveries and passion for wine.
Kind: captions
Language: en
welcome to Uncorked Wine Business and
Life with Bill Green i'm Gerald Colton
along with Bill Green from beautiful
Boca Raton Florida and we have another
very special guest today Bill we do we
do my good friend new friend we are in a
wine club together Fred
Frankle and
Fred because we're even though we're in
Bocert Return Florida we have deep
Philly roots and uh Fred grew up in
Allentown and you know like just
everybody else in Allentown then you
know got their MBA from Wharton mhm not
exactly the Billy Joel song not the
Billy Joel song but Fred I really want
you to tell us about those early years
and how you became one of the most
iconic Wall Street bankers for a long
long time well I don't think I did but
I'll tell you how I got tell you how I
got to where I'm going got a little
company like Lehman Brothers i mean you
got all kinds of cool stuff going on all
kinds of Yeah i the the common
denominator is I was lots of places
because I just couldn't hold a job i had
to keep like finding the next thing to
do so that's that uh kept a fire behind
me going um I yeah I was in Allentown
and I grew up in Allentown and I went to
college 10 miles away in Bethlehem
Pennsylvania which is what the Billy
Joel was really about it was really
about Bethlehem which was a steel town
but it didn't rhyme in his Did it fix it
a lot better a lot better yeah and there
was you know all kinds of overtones so
uh and then I went then I made a huge
move all the way down to Philadelphia
for graduate school so I was I had a
60-mile ring around me for the first 24
years of my life i didn't get out of
that out of that ring but um I was I you
know I had gone to Lehi for
undergraduate and another man went to
Lehi for undergraduate and both of us
went to Wharton so I stayed in touch
with him and uh we were getting near the
end of our second year and uh I had no
idea what I wanted to do and so I said
"What are you going to do?" He said "I'm
going to be an investment banker." And I
said "Well I don't really want to be an
investment banker." He said "Well what
do you want to do?" I said 'I don't
know.' And he said 'What are you good
at?' I said 'I'm pretty good at going to
school.' He said 'Oh there's a job like
that it's called security analyst you
study about stuff you write reports you
tell people instead of paying tuition
they pay you a whole lot of money i said
"Oh that's great that's for that's
that's the first good thing I've heard
since I've been here." And so I went to
the library and they just Institutional
Investor magazine had just rolled out
this magazine uh with the Allameric
Research Team and somebody was number
one in every category which is all
industries and so they had a a cover and
everyone's in a football jersey and
they're like standing there and they're
this is the all-America team and I said
wow this is so cool this is what I want
to do so I went uh through the whole
process of everything I had learned to
try and get on a job track to be a
security analyst on Wall Street and back
then in dur when the first all-star team
came out the firm that was number one
was Oenheimer so I wanted to go to
Oppenheimer and I did all the networking
and my uncle knew one of the partners
there and he said I'll get you an
interview so I come into this interview
and I sit down with this guy and the guy
said why do you want to be an analyst
and I give him this MBA answer that I
had prepared and he stands up and points
at me and
goes this interview's over and you're
never going to be an analyst the only
reason you want to be an analyst is to
make a lot of money that's the only
reason you'll get up early and do the
stuff you have to do i said
"Whoa." So then by myself I got an uh an
interview at an upand cominging research
department really wasn't that good then
called Goldman Sachs and I go into
Goldman Sachs and there's this guy
sitting there and he kind of looks like
my grandfather and I sit down with him
and he said "Why do you want to be in a
security analyst?" And my life passes in
front of me oh my god do I tell him to
make a lot of money or do I give my MBA
answer so I look at him and I said I'm
going to give him my NBA answer and I do
and he goes
"Wow that sounds good we'll have you
come back to New York and talk to
people." So I go back to New York seven
interviews later because I didn't know
that we I was entering the job market in
one of the biggest bare markets in
history uh
7374 and no one was giving jobs and
Goldman Sachs had decided that they were
going to hire one MBA so after seven
different interviews that it was down to
me and a guy from Harvard and they had
decided that the guy from Harvard was
getting the job and I go back in for the
eighth time and I'm sitting down again
with this guy who is the administrative
head of research who looked like my
grandfather from the first interview and
he's about to tell me I didn't get the
job and knock knock knock on the door
and the partner in charge of research
walks in and he says
"Um I need your bond tables because I
have to value my bond portfolio." And I
put I look at him and I go "Oh I
actually can do that my parents bought
me this fancy calculator for my
graduation and I can do that for you."
And he brings it over and I give him all
the values and he goes "This would be a
good young man to have around here."
walks out and the guy from Harvard still
doesn't know I didn't get the job so
that was like a real sort of I mean
timing is everything yeah and I'll give
myself credit because I was willing to
put my hand up and say I can do that but
other than that it was just pure luck
100% you had well but you had to get
there in the first place be in that get
to the final interview but there there
are there are a lot of things in that
lessons for everybody so you get your
first job then on Wall Street yeah yeah
and uh had a little firm called Goldman
Sachs what a little firm called Goldman
Sachs yeah absolutely but they have to
me go through my whole career because
you can ask me other stuff too but the
the next interesting step is when I left
Goldman Sachs because a good friend of
mine the first boss I ever had and when
I had him he was not a good friend of
mine as a boss but over the next 50
years he's been a really good friend was
Leon Coopermanman he was running
research at at
uh at Goldman Sachs and so uh Leon lives
in our neighborhood here yeah he doesn't
drink wine so I never became friends
with him no he doesn't drink wine but uh
but but so uh he and another guy named
Bill Keely were building a great
research department and I didn't have
any idea but that was going to come back
to be unbelievably valuable to me later
on watching them do that and the people
that they had there the people we were
there with were amazing really they all
turned out to be big famous people and
and I I had gotten a call from my father
and my uncle and they had put our some
of our family's money into this like
crazy ass company in
Philadelphia that was one of the first
companies that was inventing cellular
technology and there was nothing there I
mean there was there wasn't a flip phone
there wasn't anything there was no dyn
attack there's nothing here are we still
in the 70s or were we in the 80s now the
70s okay '7s and
um they put money in and the guy the
scientists spent all the money and they
said "Uh we don't know what to do should
we just pull the cork or should we give
them more money?" And they said "Why
don't you and your brother get on the
Metroliner and come down to Philly and
ask them questions and tell us what we
should do?" So we do all that come back
and I said "This could be an amazing
company but these guys will just if you
give more money they're just gonna spend
it." And they I said "Somebody has to
run this thing there's not they're not
business people." And they said "Well go
run it." And I said "What do you mean?"
I'm like at Goldman Sachs so I go into
Bill Keely and he said "You're out of
your freaking mind you're friend with
this guy Freeman he's going to run the
firm you're going to be one of the
youngest partners just go back to your
office and write reports on banks." And
I said "Yeah that does make sense." Then
I go into Leon Cooperman's office and I
tell him the same story he said "Well
how much money could you make?" And I
said "Well I think we could take this
thing public in a couple of years." He
goes "Oh you got to go." And so I I quit
and went down and did that and but that
was like another sort of What was the
name of that company at the time it was
called International Mobile Machines
because the founder wanted it to be like
International Business Machines turned
into Interdigital Corp and they did
about so far they've done six or seven
billion dollars worth of of royalties
because they never ever really went into
making everything but everybody had to
use all their technology they did uh 1G
2G 3G 4G they didn't do 5G but they did
everything else and they did all the
initial technical the signaling
technologies and everything else and I
very quickly after I did this figured
out I don't know anything about radio
frequency engineering and if we're going
to take this public we need to get a
real guy in here and we did we got a the
fourstar general who was running the
signal core and I went back to Wall
Street that was like the And you didn't
you didn't go back to Goldman at that
time no you went to uh Leon
Coopermanman's
uh junior strategist he was like one of
the great strategists of all time his
junior strategist turned out to be one
of the greatest strategists of all time
and he was at EF Hutton and he told me
to come there and work for him there
which I did and and Fred you met your
wife at a pretty young age i did and
she's part of the journey all the way
partners so so she didn't mind the crazy
idea of going to Philadelphia and
leaving because I'm not sounding too
good what i'm going to take a
serious but but look your your your
journey started with taking some chances
absolutely and um and I think there's
such a great lesson for people there you
know you could have worked for Goldman
Sachs and had a great career in my
father had a laundry company i could
have worked there and he did industrial
laundry and uniform rental and stuff i
could have done that and in fact there
is another point and I'm not going to
take you through everything but there is
another point in our career where they
asked my father and my uncle asked me to
come back and I'm sitting there with my
wife and they said I said they want me
to come back and run one of the plants
and then take over the company and she
said where would we go and I said we'd
we'd end up in we'll either be in
Reading Pennsylvania or Harrisburg
Pennsylvania or Lancaster Pennsylvania
why you say it like that you're not
selling it very hard i wasn't selling it
hard because I knew I I knew who was on
the other side of the sales pitch and
she said "Let's go to Wall Street." Yeah
that's great and we we we stayed we
stayed on Wall Street and uh I went
through uh Hutton and then I went to
Lehman and Leman was really um it was
fairly early in my career but it was it
was like my I feel like still looking
back on 50 years of this and about sort
of 25 that were in the world of
investment banking and 25 that were in
the world of investing um I still think
at Lehman that was my greatest uh
accomplishment because I was uh I had I
had moved on the the president of uh
Hutton had gone to to uh Credential
Securities which was called Credential
Base then and he took three of us with
him from Hutton so I ended up going
there and I was running research and
then I was solicited by Lehman to come
to
research to run research there because
they had a disaster they really had a
very bad research department because um
when they merged um Shears and Lehman
there had been a a a horrible event
where the Lehman guy was made the
director of research the Shears guy was
fired he went around and fired all the
Shears guys and then quit and went to
another firm and all the Lehman guys
were just there with no leader i mean
and it turned into research anarchy over
a few years and it was a big investment
bank that had didn't have a research
department makes it really hard to do
deals and you got out you left Leman in
mid '9s yeah I did i did and um was that
when you started drinking wine no I
started drinking wine i was a kid oh so
we really important really crazy yeah uh
when when you when I got out out of
college I was drinking like matus or
gallow from a jug or something like that
and uh farm Strawberry Hill was my first
one three of my friends said "Uh we're
going over to Tommy's cousin." And this
guy was you know he was in his 30s we
were just out of college and we went
over to his house and he said "Uh we're
gonna have a special wine tonight." And
we all went "Okay that sounds fine with
us." And he said "We have I have this
thing called Chateau Lefit Rothschild
and it's really good." And he poured
some and we tasted and we said "Oh this
is really different than anything we've
ever had before." He said "This costs
$15 a bottle." I said "How could
anything possibly ever cost $15 a bottle
i'm paying like a $1.75 like what is
this about?" And uh and caught our
attention and that was that was really
enough for me that start was enough for
me to get me interested and and so mid90
uh how no this was like you were really
70s and then I I I when I first went to
in this in the mid70s when I went to New
York um and I went and I was at Goldman
Sachs um my brother and I took the wine
tasting course at the World Trade Center
of Blessed Memory and at the Four
Seasons Restaurant of Blessed Memory and
we took two different wine tasting
courses and we got
really bit and caught and you you've
been you've been into wine a lot longer
than I have but with that being said I'm
going to tell you my wine investment
backing story but while we're doing that
the wine with the ring around it I want
you to taste that you have an you of all
my guests so far you've had the best you
have I know you have the best wine
palette so I'd love to give your
thoughts on that while you're tasting
this and while you're thinking about it
Fred I want to um I want to tell you my
wine story
1996 how many years ago that's a long
time ago 30 years ago almost 30 years
ago I was taking my company public and
um I was in the Beverly Hills Hotel with
my investment banker and you know when
you take company public kind of all the
expenses kind of just go under the table
doesn't really matter i'm with my
investment banker the lead was Alex
Brown and my chief financial officer and
we're in the hotel and he says "Um what
kind of wine would you drink?" I said
"I'm not really not into John can I have
a Tom Collins?" And the guy says "No
seriously you got to try them." I said
"I really don't like wine you know come
on try." Well you got any white wine no
no no so here's the menu and he hands me
the menu the wine menu he goes "Pick
anything you want." like gez I you know
I want this guy to think I'm a you know
don't know anything about anything and I
really
didn't and I see a bottle of wine and I
don't remember it was Mutan or Lefit but
I knew the last word was Rothschild and
it was $800 in 1996 and it was probably
only worth like a hundred right but
that's restaurant open up
so we get the bottle and I'm like what
can this possibly taste like and I go
like this and I taste my first
I said "Phil oh my god that's like
candy." And he goes "Yeah that's fine
wine." So for the next two two and a
half weeks we traveled the rest of the
country pitching all the banks firmman
cells being one of them went to Europe
and three days after I got back I needed
to sleep for a while i went to a friend
of mine who actually worked in a liquor
store and I said "Teach me about wine."
And I will tell you six weeks later I
was at Southern's auction couldn't keep
my paddle down wow buying great wine so
wow you're collecting wine a lot longer
than I am and you have a great pal what
do you think i like this i I really do
like that i like the
smell there's a lot going on here and
and it's and and it's all pleasant to me
so I mean I really do like this wine um
I've never had it i don't know what it
is as far as I don't I don't know you
know I'm tasting how about regions can
you can you I'm tasting like Cabernet
and Cabernet Franc and I don't know if
either of those are in it but that's
what I taste well since I made the wine
not personally but since this is Saddle
Hill wine I will tell you we got
Cabernet Franc it's a Bordeaux blend we
got Cabernet Franc we got uh Cabernet
Svenon Malbeck unbelievable really
unbelievable
but this is this is good i mean the
Cabernet Franc when you're in the
Bordeaux blends and when you're in the
United States
um you know people making Bordeau in the
United States the Cabernet Franc is is
is
normally pretty identifiable it is
compared to other things and and it's
now it's become a standalone favorite in
Napa too people really like when I
started planting in 2000
2021 I really decided and I don't know
if it was a good decision or not but we
planted 10 acres of Cabernet Franc so
we'll get um when was that 2021 actually
I planted most of my frunk in 22 which
we're going to have our first 2025 har I
think 2021 was the first year that I
heard everybody in Napa like talking
about it frunk
that's when it was really starting to It
was only a blender for forever forever
and then now you can go in and you can
buy Cabernet because I have I have a
friend who was I mean you know a young
friend not my age who was blending it in
the late 90s and
200 three four you know started to
really make a lot of it um but it was
but he never made a bottle of Cabernet
Franc and his he's a great wine maker
actually and I got actually was the wine
maker for this for Oh we will get to
that we're going to get to that but um
you know I got to tell you here's you
know we talk about entrepreneurs and
taking risk you know I'm sitting here
today over you know three years later
from planting that 10 acres of Cabernet
Franc and I'm like [ __ ] um I don't know
if it's going to it's a risk i took a
risk i'm I'm betting on the fact that a
it's going to continue to be a great
blender and we're going to sell it a lot
into our single variety wines and what
else can we do with it and I'll tell you
something else that's interesting
our rosé is Cabernet Front yeah so I
mean we we're finding ros stuff now yeah
and then my wine maker you know we have
two year he won't touch anything unless
it's been on the vines for three years
and even then he's a little shaky with
bringing it out and we had two year
Cabernet Franc you know what we made
sangria out of it oh I mean I know like
from a Where did you get the clones from
or
where our our clones are from Napa a
little bit a little bit from the
Fingerlakes um but most of our clones
are most of our clones are from Napa but
it does this in Jersey because some of
the stuff that you get I mean some of
the people that you know clone Frank and
put it in different places you get
really kind of like a crunchy Cabernet
Franc taste that this does not have that
this is very true to what you want we
like this this is a we are pushing the
envelope here it's probably the most
expensive New Jersey wine 60 70 bucks
that that that's pushing the envelope i
lived in New Jersey for 30 years and I
this is the first wine I've ever had
that was made there ever good i think we
spent $15 history in the making back
back in the 70s
but but Bill it's uh there's been so
many things about Fred's career that
fascinate me and one of them is I I look
at the the Baron's year end roundt to me
must have been unbelievable
you know it was really amazing because
the people that are on the Baron year
end route table over an extended period
of time now for you know for 50 years
how do you get on it alan Abson used to
run Barrens and he used to literally
pick who would be on but he would take
he would take um ideas from staff
writers at Barrens and one of the staff
writers at
Barrens before she went to Barrens had
been an editor at Goldman Sachs and I
was friends with her
and there and the when they came to me
we things were just changing in the
United States when they came to me
and we our little group I had a group of
there was three of us one of one of the
guys still is one of the greatest
economists in the world that guy named
Edardenni who's still practicing and is
still at the absolute top of his craft
and is on everything all the time is
like the guy who's been the most
accurate for the last at least these 10
years um and this other guy Greg Smith
and I were working on what was going to
be different now that Reagan was
president and we basically said
everything you're going to have
disinflation and it's going to be
extensive and it's going to be long
lasting and no one agreed with that
everybody thought inflation was coming
back after the 80 recession then you had
a double dip that with in ' 82 and
that's when they came to us because we
were talking about disinflation we had
just done a they had just done a Baron's
article that said EF Hutton talks
because that was like what their
commercials were and it was and it was
Greg Smith and I were were were
interviewed about what we thought about
what was going on in the world and so
this whole disinflation thing was like
really um unique and different and I was
I was not not that bright but I was
confident so they I mean you know this
this writer knew that and she went to
Abbleton and said have this kid on this
kid's got all kinds of stuff to say
that's different than everybody else and
blah blah blah blah and
uh actually there was a guy named Joe
Granville who was like a a
bizarre big shot on Wall Street then he
was a technician and I one of the stocks
that I recommended was the com that com
cell company that I talked about
international mold machines which which
was little nothing and he broke out into
laughter when he heard me say that and
explained what it was and and you know
and I I was like kind of scared and
shocked but I did it for five years and
and uh it was all the best people on
Wall Street and over the five years some
of them were old enough that they were
starting to retire but um then I was
moving into things where there's a real
conflict it was it was really a conflict
being on that and being in the cell side
of Wall Street where you're making these
recommendations because you know you
make the recommendations then you go in
and pump them when you go into the Baron
round table and say it's better it was
better for money managers to be doing it
rather than brokers so there was a
natural kind of exit point for me to to
take away from the potential problems
but it was so much fun listening to all
these guys and being a really young guy
listening to these older guys
pontificate and you just got to be an
observer and then participate that was
that was beyond it's as good as I
thought it was it was beyond yeah it was
great it was really interesting so is
um when you went how much after
that stint was cowan
oh it was really long i mean if I I'm
not going to tell you all the stories
but basically what happened was um you
mentioned it already but after Lehman
Brothers was the most fun because we
took the 15th best research department
on Wall Street and there only were 17 to
first in four years and these things
usually move like one rank a year so and
we just got to number one in four years
and we stayed there so that that be that
was like kind of fame creating for me
and then the firm and sales guys came
after me and said "We're going to change
you know we're buying firm and sales
back from from Xerox and we're going to
fix it all up and we want you to help
us." And so I went to Ferman cells and
after the the Ferman cells thing we we
did fix it up some people
were cynical about it and said it was
becoming Lehman Brothers North because
there's I and another guy from Lehman
Brothers were both hired and we were we
were bringing people that didn't want to
be in Lim Brothers anymore up there and
it was definitely helping us it was
definitely helping us but we grew 300%
in three years and then a Dutch bank
bought us named ING and it was they
bought us for six times book value which
is just insane i mean there's a bank's
never worth that so that was like
amazing and then I I went a friend of
mine who was an Israeli engineer that I
had known from buying software from him
over the years on Wall Street he had
gone and started to do uh venture
capital deals and I didn't even know
what that meant and he but when we sold
uh firm and sales he came and said let's
do deals i said I know what that means
and he says "Well yeah you you do you
know all these different industries and
you all the know all the best analysts
and you know a lot of stuff." And so we
we started doing deals together venture
deals at the time in American financial
history when there had never been a
bigger wind at the back of venture deals
like anything we touched was just like
explosively going up and it was it was
at least in the beginning the late 90s
yeah it was the late '9s and like
anything and and so people were
institutions and other people that we
were going to and raising money for
deals said why don't you start a fund we
don't want to have to approve these
deals one at a time just start a fund so
we started a fund the year 2000 which is
the worst year ever started a venture
fund because you're about to go over the
waterfall in March of 2000 and then we
spent nine years earning the people a
return on their money and uh and so I
had a venture firm for nine years I was
running with this other guy and then at
the end of that he wanted to do it
again and I we had done no IPOs that
decade there was only there were only
IPOs for companies that were over a
billion dollars between 2000 and 2009
yeah when I took my company public in 96
we were midcap three years later we were
small cap and it was and it was really
really really crazy matter of fact so
99 was just a crazy year for me because
my company was performing 25 30% organic
plus acquisitions you know and it was
and it was an amazing time but because
of all those venture startups I remember
Priceel line you know oh my god the
valuation they didn't they didn't they
didn't have much at all let alone profit
they didn't even have much sales and it
was companies like that that the my
investors said "Well we're going to
pivot out of good companies that are
just making money and we're going to
take these flyers right because what am
I going to give them you know 10 15%
growth a year they want 50%." Well that
was right at the time when Julian
Robertson who's one of the greatest
hedge fund managers of all time closed
down because he wasn't willing to put
money in that crap but he was getting
outperformed and all of his clients were
didn't want to have their money with him
anymore a year later the whole world
collapsed so we had we we had an
opportunity and my I guess the higher
end my stock was about 28
uh late 98 and then 99 because of all
this stuff that was going on you know
I'm sitting here at $13 and I'm talking
to my bankers we had five bankers on the
and I'm like what's going on he goes
nothing you're doing this is the market
and I said wow so you're telling me my
personal net worth is now halfed because
I'm just not popular anymore that sounds
like you know pretty bad recipe so we
decided to take the company private
turned out to be amazing of course I
this is typical MO with me on personal
real estate and businesses that I I I I
I sell too low but I'm not much of a
gambler you know and I always had the
feeling that never look a profit in the
face it hasn't hurt you no it hasn't
hurt me but like I said earlier I make
my investors more money than I make
myself but uh No the I've seen that
happen many many many times yeah why
everyone loves and then of course um you
know the story got really great after
that and the valuation I mean it was on
the private markets that went again
public in '05 which I had already I had
already left the business but um yeah um
the bankers I would probably say that
when I left my first business in 2002
um the bankers I I had so many great
relationships and they're relationship
guys right relationship absolutely
and treat them right don't sugarcoat
don't screw over the analyst right yep
don't make him look like a bad guy but
you can't give them the inside scoop
because they're No that's right and
there was always that Chinese wall now
the Chinese wall came back came down
after the World come Yes debacle but
there you never knew why did my stock
matter of fact we were we were looking
to sell our sell the business while we
were public to
um WW Gringanger it was a pretty high
flyer i mean at the time they were 7
billion and
um I remember we were the the price was
24 and I think at the time we were
trading at 22 and I said I'm I'm all in
on this and then you just tell somebody
in the banking community and next thing
you know it's all screwed like I
literally just so the saying is loose
lips sink ships right and there's no
better truth than you got to keep your
mouth shut on Wall Street 100% and even
if you do sometimes other people aren't
so you can't even totally control it
yeah without without doubt but then you
know the the uh the interesting part
that kind of got me going on the other
side was that 2000 to 2009 was really
interesting for me watching it from like
originally having been trained as a
strategist because he came into it and
everybody was convinced that stocks were
the best thing in the world the people
had all everybody owned stocks and they
were all going to go up you know 10% a
year that was like a god-given right and
no one paid any attention that it's
going to go up 20% a year like we've had
the last couple of years that maybe
you're ahead of yourself and there's
going to be a comeuppance and there was
such a big comeuppance in 2000 2001
2002 that uh people just didn't they
couldn't they couldn't understand how
they had been lied to that they weren't
going to get 10% a year and that they
lost money so then they went through
this other that Wall Street you know had
to find something new because that's
what they do so they went for this other
bait which was that well the price of
houses never goes down so then you had a
whole decade of people just buying
houses and you know people that had a
regular job buying six houses and
leveraging up and all this other stuff
until you got to the point where all the
mortgages were being falsified and
accommodating every action that took
place and you got to the this huge
housing collapse and then people are
going oh my god what do I do now gold's
been doing nothing uh stocks were bad
and they're good and then they're bad
really bad and now houses are bad and
what do I money everything is bad yeah
so you mentioned 2009 so we all know
what happened in 2008 and n so I was on
So I started collecting wine in 96 and
of course I went to all the high-end
Napa wines because I want to get on the
mailing list you can't buy those wines
right right
so from
96 uh I'm on Scream Eagles uh mailing
list and in
um
2009 oh no it was
10 they they I think they sent me a
letter and uh they said you're on well
all the hedge fund guys that were paying
stupid amount of money for a bottle of
wine can't afford it anymore way right
so this next wine bread is 2009
Screaming Eagle wow and this was the
first Screaming This is the first
Screaming Eagle that I I was able to buy
for a dumb freaking amount of money but
it's actually probably one of my best
investments cuz it's probably forexed
what was your first when you raised your
paddle for the first time yeah so that
was actually a funny story where's my
ride um we went to Southern Bees and I
had done a lot of homework i became a
student of Robert Parker i had a list i
knew exactly you get the catalog and um
but I'm getting caught up because I'm
super competitive and I don't want to
lose so when somebody says we got 80 we
got a case of 82 Lefit let's you know
doing the auction thing and I'm like
[ __ ] I really want to own this so I
broke my own rules i had it written down
what I wanted to pay and I went over but
anyway long story short we go to check
out that night and the lady says "Um
that'll be
$53,200 i need two credit cards for this
one." And uh that's kind of how that's
kind of how that whole story started but
what I
learned and it took me a couple years to
learn it you got to stay disciplined on
buying anything and especially wine so
Sbees and Christies had you could fax
your bid in because once I got in that
room and I saw the guy out bidding me I
just didn't it didn't matter yeah yeah
but if I faxed in my bid then you're
disciplined that's it that was it so I'd
wake up in the morning that it would go
out all night long i'd wake up that's
really interesting because I don't go to
auctions anymore for the same reason oh
you get caught up i just I just bid and
and and if I get it I get it if I don't
I don't and I'll live okay if I don't
get it but it was a it was like um you
know it was it was like throw enough
[ __ ] against the wall so I would fax my
bids in and I would maybe bid on 25 30
wines to get Yeah but that's how as I
learned that's how I didn't get my ass
kicked on valuation and that's why my
collection back there is it's no
different it's just discipline
discipline in your purchasing investment
you're right no you're right but now
let's share this shared so much great
stuff with us let's share i think I
think the Saddle Hill is better than
just
Well it's different this is just cab
i think it's
um It is 100% right yeah it should be i
think so we had a Kan on our last
episode that was only 87%
oh yeah kan you know uh 13 oh is it yeah
we had the um Tennessee
State um so I I guess it guess they do
call it a Cabernet Svenon and California
it has to be all Cabernet Svenon it
can't be like in New Jersey it's an 85%
no this is great yeah this is pretty
special isn't it and we need a steak
right the first B the f the first I was
going to tell you the first bottle of
Screaming Eagle that I ever opened I had
with hamburgers
and it was it was great we had big thick
juicy hamburgers and fries no fries
i want to know the restaurant that
hamburgers and Screaming Eagle no it was
it was my backyard okay
Fred you um in our wine club i don't
remember the name you you you have a lot
of knowledge about a lot of different
wines but you you really have an Italian
I do you really love Italian i do i do
and um I just had the best wine
experience of my life in Italy did I did
I tell you about remember we're back at
we're back here at camp you know oh yeah
so um we went it was my 75th birthday uh
this past September and my wife and I
went to Italy and we went to Lake Cuomo
and we went to Milan which we love both
of those places but then we drove down
to Barbaresco and I had gone through
this i I knew all the details you you
basically can't there's a lot of amazing
wine places in Italy that you can go to
one of the places that you can't go to
is Gaia y'angelo Gaia makes amazing
stuff in Barbaresco and so I I explored
the whole thing and basically if you
offer to give a charitable contribution
to the local hospital they will have the
winder the wine the head of marketing
take you around and show you the place
oh my god i didn't So I said "Okay we're
going to do this." So we did it and and
we show up and the head of marketing
comes out and she grabs us and she
brings us in
and I are talking to her she takes us
into a room and she starts telling us
about some of the things on the wall and
I'm completing her stories and and then
we go to the next room and she's telling
us about this one wine and the whole
story and I was telling her stuff she
didn't know about it and she said wait a
minute we don't get a lot of people like
you here and she just like runs out of
the room and Angelo Gaia walks in and he
spends an hour talking to us not about
wine just about life and then he brings
Guaia who's his daughter in who's the
CEO of the company and she does an hour
tasting with us from her library so it
was the best yeah so for for our our
viewers listeners um Gaia is probably
the gold standard for Italian wine and
they they're all over with barbesco
fascinating guy because when he when his
father was making
Barbaresco 40 years ago Barbaresco was
table wine that cost like $7 it was
nothing and and there was like 15 makers
and they all made crappy wine and he
decided we can do a we have all the
stuff here to do this we have the ground
we have the the right uh terowa we have
the right sun angles we have the right
stuff in the ground we just have to
bring in the right clones and we can we
don't have to just make nebula we can do
everything and he starts changing
everything about how they did wine there
all the Barbaresco people copied him and
they turned Barbresco from a nothing
into a big something and they all got
rich off of one guy's vision and and
and really work so and it is you know so
if you take the US you can really say
that it's the West Coast Napas
particularly that's really driving the
price market in the whole country unlike
Italy where you have the Tuscan regions
outside of Florence and then the Pimonte
region where we're talking about Barbco
which my wife and I just spent um some
time there in June out from a vacation
or anything other i kind of really
prefer the Tuscan region yeah there's
not a lot going on there we love
Tuskanyany i mean we love Tuskini i
don't I don't I we we went to Barrisco
for one day and that's all that's all we
were doing that trip we weren't going to
Have you had any GD vajra yes yes we we
met Jeppe we drank some wine with Jeppi
and as it turns out his US importer is
in based in Philadelphia oh really so he
promises us a visit this year to Saturn
Hill great so we're excited about that
and Northern Italy has some people like
that they have individuals who are
amazing wine craft people that really
have taken wherever they are in Northern
Italy and made stuff but when you
Tuscanany is a whole different thing
tuskan is just like an amazing place to
hang out and do stuff and visit and see
amazing
andrea and I have seen amaz some amazing
things in Tuscany we went to one guy's
vineyard and he had a he had a at least
a onemile driveway and along the
driveway up to his house he had
airplanes all along the driveway
including like a Russian MIG all the
most amazing airplanes and when you got
up to his house the top floor was every
motorcycle ever made i mean and you know
like where did what's that from you know
and and and and there's like a lot of
ancient history in some of the towns in
Tuscanyany really it's just Italy is
amazing italy is amazing yeah i think if
somebody said to me "You can't live in
the United States any more." Me too yeah
both of you yeah world travelers that
says a lot yeah me too fred just just
taking it back slightly to your career
and and the whole path you went on any
words you would have to a
young like-minded business student
didn't know what he wanted to do today
education's taken some strange turns in
our country you got an MBA from one of
the elite schools in the world in
Wharton what what words would you have
for somebody the young Fred Frankle you
know I don't I actually don't think that
the I don't think the school's um
curriculum is where you get any dramatic
insight i think it's the practice of
whatever your business is that gives you
the opportunity to either add or or um
supplant something that's going on in
your company in your industry in the
world etc the when I I mentioned that
our our my my best accomplishment as
Lehman Brothers when we turned around
that that uh research department that
wasn't just it wasn't like uh it wasn't
like the Yankees we weren't just going
out and buying analysts we were growing
analysts and we were growing a culture
and a lot of that gets down to what did
you observe that you thought was wrong I
had observed a few things I had observed
that there weren't any training programs
on Wall Street people were just sort of
trying to figure out from other people
how to do stuff and you can formalize
that and improve things i also figured
out that the management of very smart
and very um accomplished people can't be
done in can't be done well in a normal
pyramid kind of hierarchy you you you
normally look at it and you say "Okay
here's the boss and under him there
people that work for him and then under
them there those people are the boss and
so on and so on down to to accomplish
things that you want to accomplish with
people that are really productive you
have to turn that whole pyramid upside
down you basically have to have the boss
taking away the problems of the people
that report to him they have to be
taking away the problems of the people
that report to them and by the time you
get to the top if all the problems have
been taken away for the big mass of
people that are working there you're
going to get a lot done and you're going
to accomplish a lot but that's a
cultural item because you can't feel
that um that somehow if you're the boss
you have to have authority and you have
to have respect and all those kinds of
things it gets in the way of
accomplishment and those kinds of uh
observations sometimes business schools
are really good at coming up with them
and and sharing them but a lot of the
time people have to manufacture that
from their own experience base too fred
we're going to wind down sure and I this
is just so the whole interview here has
been wildly intriguing expect like I
mentioned to everybody here in this room
that you have the best wine palette of
any of our guests so far and that's
clearly proven
give me a couple of your if you can just
you know roll back the tape in your mind
50 years two two things you're most
proud of and and not business-wise like
like we know the or maybe it's no wine
wise no oh yeah anything well wait a
minute because you've had such an iconic
business career why don't we give give
me two business ones the things that I'm
most proud proud of yeah sure
um I the last thing I did I'm actually
very very proud of even though it got
totally screwed up and that's not
abnormal it's not abnormal but when I
went to Cowan um I went to Cowan to help
them figure out what they wanted to do
and they they knew they were going to
get this company to a point where they
could sell it so that that was going to
happen but after I was there for a very
short period of time the CEO and the
presidents took me aside and said "Look
our asset management company's all
screwed up would you fix it and I said
"Well I don't think that's fair because
I'm I made a deal with you i'm going to
be in Florida half the time and New York
half the time and you have all these
really great people on that platform
that are really um looking for guidance
and I'm not I would only be there half
the time." They said "Well you know
that's okay do it." So I I I said "Okay
I'll I'll I'll try to do that." And it
was the first year was very rugged
because they had a lot of very bad
pieces and you they had to be fired and
you know I'm not trying to say that I'm
was Donald Trump you're fired kind of
thing but I was we had we literally had
to go through and if if you weren't
going to offer something that was going
to be good for your investor clients you
got to get rid of it so we got rid of it
and it was about half the place was gone
and then we had to figure out how must
have been real popular yeah i wasn't
wasn't at all in fact there's I'm not
even going to mention but there's a guy
in our community who was not directly
involved but was ancillarly involved and
he heard from his friends that that I'm
like a black hood kind of guy and he
still won't even he doesn't even look at
me when I when I see him so I mean that
yeah it definitely didn't help me in
that regard but then we we figured out
that Cowan was good at certain things
and if we were going to be credible at
delivering good investment products for
people we'd have to do in those things
we were really good in biotechnology
we're really good in green technology
there's things we were really good at
that were are important so we went on a
tear to build those products and we were
just super duper successful at it we got
um we got some of the biggest investors
in the world to invest in our funds we
raised a whole lot of money billions of
dollars for our funds and then um
eventually the company was sold and the
bank that bought us didn't want any of
that so they basically just gave it back
to the portfolio managers that were
running it which is great for them
because they have their own little That
was TD Bank td Bank yeah yeah and uh I I
you know I did not know that TD Bank was
going to get caught doing bad stuff in
the United States and be fined billions
of dollars i didn't know any of that
stuff but the day of the TD Bank um
closing I resigned and retired and that
was uh February of 2023
newly retired you're not bored yet um
there are days when I'm not as busy as I
would want to be but you're still busy
but in general I've still got a lot of
stuff going so that was that was that
was a big accomplishment and then the
other one was was back at Lehman
Brothers when I took hundreds of people
to this party of becoming number one
which was couldn't have been more fun
and what about the wine highlights you
were going to say yeah I mean you know
there are wine high like I love this guy
Gaia thing because it just happened and
because it was so Angelo Gaia is bigger
than life and he's amazing person but as
far as like on the wine stuff I had an
almost uh you know people you people
overuse phrases they said "I had a
religious experience tasting this wine."
It wasn't religious but I had a
tremendously
um
awakening experience tasting Domain
Roman Ecante for the first time in
Burgundy i I I mean it it really I knew
it was going to be I knew it was like
one of the most expensive wines in the
world it was one of the rarest wines in
the world i knew there's only like you
know five vineyards that are all as big
as this table you know all the essential
elements but and I knew it was going to
be good but it really is a special event
to taste and drink that so Oh I've never
had a DRC oh well I've never had one the
next time that we go out I I think we
should not waste that wine on our wine
club friends i think the four of us
should go out absolutely to one of the
great restaurants down here in South
Florida you bring wine let's do it we'll
bring I'll bring a Bordeaux killer let's
do it the problem is you can't go to
Keller's restaurant in Miami Beach
because they have it on the wine list
and they won't let you bring it every
time I go there which is a great
restaurant but like I'm I'm always it's
like a game you have to take out their
wine list and try and find something
great that's not on it that you can
bring so I mean that's that's They had
some training from French Laundry they
charge networking fee um it's up to $250
yeah it's in It's insanity if you Except
when you look at the wine list you get a
crappy bottle of wine for $400 so like
yeah it's a good deal so you bring one
of yours and you pay the $250 you know
we went to the French Laundry this is
many years ago and I brought a bottle of
Bordeaux and paid $200 to Yeah yeah
french Laundry per se and and the one in
in Florida is are they're fabulous
restaurants they truly are yeah chris
thanks for the
wine business and life stories they're
they're all fabulous an amazing 75 years
with I think a whole lot more to go
thanks thank you buddy thank you i
really appreciate it cheers cheers we'll
see you next time on Unccorked cheers