LiftingLindsay's More Than Fitness

Lindsay explains that frustration in fat loss often comes from unmet expectations, highlighting a common mismatch between choosing a conservative or moderate calorie deficit while expecting aggressive results like losing 20 pounds in 3–6 months. She outlines three drivers of fat-loss speed: the size of the deficit, how accurately the plan is followed, and individual body response, including water-weight fluctuations. She advises choosing an approach you can sustain, matching goals to timelines, and committing to accurate tracking.

Topics discussed:
00:00 Welcome
00:56 Black Friday Macro Plans
02:48 Three Fat Loss Drivers
04:43 Deficit Size Explained
06:15 12 Week Deficit Examples
10:34 The 20 Pound Reality Check
12:14 Adherence Beats Intensity
14:41 Accuracy Over Effort
15:56 How Your Body Responds
17:31 Water Weight and Trends
20:17 Realistic Weekly Loss Rates
26:29 Set Your Next Cut Up
30:23 Final Takeaways and Wrap

Connect With Lindsay
Instagram: @liftinglindsay

Join the BeStrong Community for science based training, nutrition education, coaching, live calls, and a supportive community of women who want to get stronger, build muscle, and improve their health.

Learn more at liftinglindsay.com

Ready To Train With Us?
If this episode resonated with you and you're ready to experience this style of training for yourself, it's not too late to join us inside the BeStrong app.

Our newest hypertrophy phase has already begun, but you're absolutely not behind.

This training block focuses on:
✔ Lengthened position training
✔ Strategic pauses and isometrics
✔ Improving muscle tension
✔ Building strength and muscle with intentional execution
✔ Learning how to make the target muscle do more of the work

You'll get access to the complete training program, exercise video demonstrations, nutrition guidance, live coaching calls, and a community of women committed to getting stronger together.

Join us HERE

Creators and Guests

Host
Lindsay
Wife and mother of three. I have a deep passion for learning and teaching. I also really love lifting weights and fitness.

What is LiftingLindsay's More Than Fitness?

Dive into the joy of fitness with Lindsay and other guests exploring how it goes well and beyond the gym floor, the number on the scale, the size of your waist or the calories you're counting.

Lindsay: Hello and welcome, welcome
to "The Lifting Lindsay Podcast."

I'm so excited to talk to you guys today.

This one is gonna be short and sweet,
or at least I say that right now and

my editor is probably chuckling because
he's probably looking at the time and I

don't know, it's short and sweet for me.

Is that what?

45 minutes?

Who knows.

We will see.

I guess that's-- we'll take this
journey together 'cause usually when I

say short and sweet he laughs because
he's like, "Yeah, 60 minutes later,

that wasn't short and sweet, Lindsay."

Anyways, I really wanna help you
guys manage your expectations.

Years ago I read a book and
one line really struck me.

The author said, "All frustration
comes down to unmet expectations."

Man, I think about that all the time.

In fact, it haunts me.

lately I've been thinking about it even
more though because we just had a huge

Black Friday sale with a discount on my
app, but then when you signed up for the

app you, you can also get a macro plan.

So I've been writing a lot, a
lot, a lot of macro plans and

I keep noticing the same thing.

So on the intake form I ask what kind of
approach you want and a lot of people are

saying they want conservative, like maybe
eating closer to maintenance or maybe,

maybe even like a, a moderate approach.

Then I follow that up with a question
asking: Well, what does success

look like in three to six months?

And a lot of times the answer is
something like they wanna eat close to

maintenance but in three to six months,
they really want to be down 20 pounds.

Okay.

So that is a huge gap between expectations
and reality and my fear is that you're

gonna take that mild cut, follow
it, and not see the results that you

pictured, the, the aggressive results.

You wanna eat near maintenance but
you want the results of someone

who chose an aggressive cut.

Now, let that sit with you.

How many of you right now are
being like, "Hmm, is that me?"

That's a really good
question to ask, right?

So what happens?

A lot of times people do this.

they'll be like, "Well, I want a
conservative, eat near maintenance,

but I also wanna chip away at body fat.

But, but I also, you know, at the end
of three months, wanna lose 20 pounds."

Oh, okay.

Well, what happens with that?

A lot of times people don't get
those aggressive results, and

then they start telling themselves
stories like, "Oh, my body's broken.

My metabolism's broken.

Uh, this works for everybody else but me."

And that's just not true.

So I'm not trying to call anybody out,
but I do wanna call attention to the three

things that really decide whether you
lose fat and how fast you lose it, right?

Doesn't that sound like a really
good thing to understand so that you

understand, are, are these expectations
that I have, are the- are these realistic?

So there's three things.

The first one is the size of
the deficit you choose, okay?

So you can choose a mild, a
moderate, or an aggressive approach.

And generally speaking, what we
do is we take your maintenance or

what your maintenance should be
for your activity level, 'cause a

lot of people are like, "Well, I
don't know what my maintenance is.

I've never tracked in maintenance.

I've always just tracked in fat loss."

So they don't really know, their
maintenance numbers, and that's fine.

That's fine.

What we do is we can kind of guesstimate
based off of general population, based

off of, their, their body, their,
uh, expenditure, meaning how much

they're moving throughout the day.

So we can get a- kind of get an idea
of what their maintenance is, and

then from there, we kind of choose, do
we want a mild approach, a moderate,

or an aggressive calorie deficit?

The second thing that really determines
if you lose body fat and how fast you lose

it is do you actually follow the plan?

And I'm not saying kind of
sort of follow the plan.

Like, I'm talking about
are you following the plan?

Are you every day tracking
and following the plan?

The third thing is how your
body personally responds.

Okay, so I was kind of
getting ahead of myself.

We're gonna break down each one of
those numbers right now so you can

see exactly what this looks like.

So one, the first one I listed was
the size of the deficit you chose.

So this is the one people skip.

The percentage of a deficit sets
the ceiling on your results.

You can't choose a mild cut
and expect aggressive results.

It's just not gonna happen.

Now, unfortunately, a lot of times women
will think, "Well, if I just get into a

cut, all I need is a calorie deficit."

And, and in part, that's kind of the,
the fitness industry's fault because

they're like, "Just get in a calorie
deficit, just get in a calorie deficit."

They don't often tell you that there's
different kinds of calorie deficits.

So somebody will just get into a calorie
deficit and then be like, "Hmm, how come

I didn't see the results that I wanted?"

And, and a lot of times I'll ask
people, "Well, what percentage

of a deficit were you in?"

They're like, "I don't know,
I just got in a deficit."

Oh, okay.

Well, now I understand
why you're frustrated.

You have no idea.

Like, we have not much to work with.

So then I'll ask them, "Well,
what are your daily calories?

And give me, um, y- your
information so that I can kind

of see what deficit you're in."

Oh, you were in a conservative deficit.

So that's why you were losing body
fat at a slower pace, not because

anything's broken, but because you,
you were in a conservative deficit.

But let me give you numbers.

Let me give you an example.

Picture this.

Picture a woman who's
about 5'4", 150 pounds.

She's around 40.

She lifts three to four days a week
and is hitting about 8,000 steps a day.

Now, her maintenance is going to be
roughly around 2,000 calories, okay?

Roughly around there, maybe around 2,050.

So here's what 12 weeks
looks like at that approach.

Now, listen carefully 'cause I'm
gonna kind of go through this.

If she chose a conservative
approach, which would be around

17% deficit That would make her
daily calories around 1,720.

Now, for 12 weeks, if she was on
plan every day, she's gonna see

around eight pounds lost, give
or take some, but around there.

That's about what we end up seeing.

Once again, if she's on plan every day.

If she's not on plan every day, let's
say she's on plan maybe five-ish days

a week, then you're looking at closer
to maybe four or five pounds down,

depending on how crazy her weekends get.

She might even only be three
pounds down after 12 weeks.

So do you see how the calorie deficit
will determine about, not precisely,

our bodies are not some math equation.

I wish they were, it would make
all of this so much easier.

But remember what we talked about.

We talked about the size of the
deficit, how closely you follow it,

and how your body responds, and we're
gonna get into that body responding

thing a little bit later too.

Now, let's say the same woman
chose a moderate approach.

That is somewhere around 22%.

So that's her moderate approach.

Well, now, if she's on point every
day, her fat loss is going to look like

somewhere closer to 11 to 12 pounds lost.

Now, if she's not on-- She chose
that plan of 1615, 1,615 calories,

that moderate 22% deficit.

If she chose that, but then she's not
really following it, maybe just five

days a week, and then on the weekends
fall off, then she's probably gonna

lose closer to six, seven pounds.

Okay?

Do, do you get how all of these
things are impacting it now?

Now, let's say she chose
an aggressive approach.

She's like, "No, I really
want to be down, though.

I'm gonna choose an aggressive approach.

We're gonna do 27%."

So now she went from maintenance
somewhere around like 2,000,

2,100 down to 1,500 calories.

This is an aggressive approach,
and she may lose closer to 14, 15

pounds if she's on point every day.

That's over a 12-week period.

That's great.

That's successful.

She killed it.

Oh, but what if she had in her head,
"Oh, but I wanted to lose 20 pounds.

I didn't hit my goal.

My body's broken.

It does…"

Do you see how important these stories
we tell ourselves are, and how we need

to base these off of, okay, based off of
how aggressive we chose and off of are

we following the plan every day, we're
gonna get a certain amount of results.

That aggressive approach that was around
1,500 calories for this individual,

let's say for 12 weeks she was only
on plan, you know, five days a week,

and the weekends kind of took it off.

Then she might only lose anywhere between,
you know, around eight-ish pounds.

So man, being on point to that
aggressive, she's gonna lose like

maybe possibly twice as much, right?

So it's so important to understand this.

But 20 pounds in 12 weeks, do you know
how hardcore her deficit would have to be?

About 40% deficit.

That's how much.

A 40% deficit.

And if she chooses that insane
1235, that would be 1,235

calories, around 1200 calories.

That would be insane for her.

I mean, I've seen people do it.

I'm not saying it can't be done,
but that is beyond aggressive.

That's a 40% deficit, and for her to
hit that 20 pounds, she would have to

really be on point every single day.

If she wasn't, she
wouldn't hit that, okay?

This is really, really important

So what you pick really
does determine the rate.

If somebody really wants that 20 pounds,
man, they're gonna be eating th- and,

and their information is like this
woman's that we laid out, you know,

5'4", 150 pounds, around 40, lifting
three to four days a week, 8,000 steps.

She's really gonna have to drive
low, low calories to hit that.

So I ask you, are you willing to do that?

If your answer is no, that's totally
okay, but then you have to realize the

expectation of seeing that 20 pounds go
down in three months, once again, for this

informati- based off of this information
that I presented of this woman.

That's what it's gonna have to require.

So let's now move into two.

Are you actually following the plan?

Because choosing your deficit is step
one, Following the plan is step two.

This is where so many results
just quietly disappear.

So if we look back at this information
that I laid out, that same woman, the

same moderate plan, the moderate plan was
22%, she would be eating 16, 15 calories

That same woman could be losing 11, 12,
13 pounds if she's on point every day.

But like I said, I, I really
wanna emphasize this again.

If she's only tracking Monday through
Friday-ish and then the weekend, maybe

Friday night, Saturday, Sunday, not
tracking, then she will lose half as much.

She might as well have chosen the
conservative plan of 17% that she

could actually adhere to, eat a
little bit more, which would be 1720.

Do you know what I'm gonna do?

I'm gonna actually-- I'm gonna make
this into a spreadsheet that you guys

can kind of look at at the bottom of
the, like click on and maybe see in the

notes so you can get an idea of this.

'Cause I think it's really
important to visualize this.

Instead of choosing a moderate approach
that she can't follow all the time, and

on the weekends maybe binge, choosing
a conservative approach of 17% deficit,

eating 1720 calories, she will enjoy
the deficit more, eat more every day,

have higher energy, and she will see the
same amount of fat loss had she chosen

that and adhered to it than a more
moderate or aggressive and didn't adhere.

I see this all the time.

People choose aggressive results, then
they m- mildly follow the plan and are

upset that they didn't see the aggressive
results if they-- What's kind of funny

is they choose the aggressive plan
Follow it maybe five out of seven days

and get the same results that somebody
just choosing a conservative plan and

were able to finally follow the plan,
they see the same amount of fat loss.

Does that make sense?

This is so important to understand

so one thing that I do want to emphasize
too, is I'm not talking about effort.

A lot of times people will
choose an aggressive approach.

They feel like they're giving a
big effort, but really they're not

following the plan very much, but they
base everything off of effort and not

off of actually following the plan.

So I'm not talking about effort.

Like I said, everybody feels like their
effort is high in a fat loss phase.

I'm talking about accuracy.

Are you hitting your numbers every day?

Are you logging the oil, the
bites off your kids' plates, the

BLTs, bites, licks, tastes, sips,
the dinner out on the weekend?

You cannot expect 100% of the reward
when you are 70% to 80% accurate, period.

You just can't do that.

Same thing the other way around, right?

So if you choose a really aggressive
approach, like I said, follow it

mildly and still expect res- ex-
aggressive results, once again, you

guys, it's just not gonna cut it.

A moderate plan you actually
follow will always beat an

aggressive plan you don't Three.

This is the one that, uh,
I really wanna talk about.

Three.

' Cause we talked about the first
two, which are the size of the

deficit, two, how closely you follow
it, three, how your body responds.

We cannot overlook this one.

Everybody's body responds a
little differently to a cut.

Think of it like a bell curve.

About 80% of people fall right
into the normal range of fat loss.

About 10% will blow past expectations.

They'll get a little bit more.

And about 10% are slower responders.

Now, here's the hard part, and I've
talked about this so many times.

Everybody thinks that
they're the slow responder.

Everybody.

I get messages from app members
all the time saying and asking,

"I've been following this
and my body's not responding.

I've only lost two pounds in
the past three to four weeks."

Then I look over their whole plan and
I'm like, "No, that's actually amazing.

Good job.

You're not a slow responder.

You're normal, and that's great."

Now, once again, I'm looking at things
like how mild was your approach or maybe

how aggressive was it and how have you
been, you know, following the plan.

And once I usually get to the bottom
of that, I can tell, "Oh, yeah, you're,

you're actually responding exactly how
we thought you would respond," right?

So here's the thing, though.

Your body just is not a maci- machine.

It's not a machine.

It's not a m- a, a calculation.

Fat loss can be happening while
the scale sits flat or even goes up

because water moves the scale way
more than fat does day to day, okay?

So let's say you started a new training
program and now you're really sore.

Sore muscles hold water while they repair.

Uh, let's say you ate a bunch of
new foods or more salt than usual.

Okay, that's more water.

You had more carbs than normal and
your muscles stored them with water.

That's more water.

Poor sleep, stress, your cycle, hormone
shifts, all of that can massively

move water in your system, okay?

None of that is fat.

So we never judge a cut by one weigh-in.

We look at the trends over two to
three week, plus your measurements, how

your clothes fit, and your strength.

And I will even go on to say this much.

In, in helping women through fat
loss phases, one of the things that

I think is really fascinating is
to actually step back and look at

trends of each individual woman.

I have right now three-- one
one-on-one client and two, clients

from my, uh, 90-day rapid fat loss
challenge, and all of them, they're…

It is so fascinating to watch this.

Without fail, right before a large dip in
the scale Over about four to five days,

the scale just ticks up and then all of
a sudden plummets down, and then ticks

back up and then plummets even lower,
and then ticks back up and then plummets.

It is the funniest thing in the world.

Now, it's not funny to them because
it's almost like they have amnesia

and don't remember that this
happened just a few weeks ago.

But I am on the other side being
very non-emotional about it because

it's not my body, so it's easier
for a coach to be non-emotional.

That's actually one of the, the
powerful things about having a coach,

is that we can see this, and I just
constantly remind them, like, "But

remember how your body responds."

Do you know what?

I, I am no different.

I need those reminders all the time.

It's like I forget how my body responds
right before my period every single,

you know, 30 days, and Alex is there
being like, "But, um, remember how

every 30 days this happens," right?

I am no different than those that I coach.

And so I am not calling anybody out.

We are all human, and
we're all in this together.

And frankly, I love
helping clients see this.

I love help th- helping them see
the trends of their own bodies.

It's really empowering So now I want to go
into what is a realistic rate of fat loss.

So it is important to understand
that research gives us ranges,

not a magic number, right?

So it's gonna give about, um, maybe 0.25

to 1% of your body weight
per week, obviously just

depending on what you choose.

So I love using percentages
because they fit your body.

When people are like, "Well, it should
be going down one to two pounds a

week," and I'm like, "Okay, you are
120 pounds and you are 19% body fat,"

yeah, um, nope, it is not gonna be
going down one to two pounds a week,

and that would be wild if it did.

But then I have another client who may
be around 170 pounds with higher body fat

percentage, and seeing one to two pounds
a week would be, "Oh yeah, you're right

on track for what we chose for you."

Right?

So I, I really like using percentages.

I, I feel like they're
so much healthier, right?

So here's how I, um…

This is how I label it.

If we are doing a conservative recomp
approach, which a really conservative

recomp, we're usually gonna be sitting
near a 10% deficit, and these aren't

exact numbers, they're abouts, okay?

You gotta keep that in mind.

About.

So a recomp approach of about
10% deficit, we are going to be

seeing somewhere closer to 0.25%

of body weight going down per week.

Now, here's the problem.

Remember what we just talked about
with how much water we hold in

our body and how much it moves.

It moves a lot.

So in seven days, if
you were to lose 0.25%

of body weight, 0.2%

of fat, then That can be easily covered
up by changes in water, in water weight.

So there's nothing
magical about seven days.

We're not gonna look at seven
days and be like, "Oh, wait,

the scale didn't move down."

Because what if this person also
is trying to build a ton of muscle?

Then the scale could actually
stay relatively the same.

That's usually what happens around recomp.

It stays relatively the same.

But what people start noticing after
six, eight, 12 weeks of this type

of approach is they start noticing
shifts in their body composition.

We're not actually looking for
the scale to move down, and that

is really, really important.

now if we're looking at a moderate
approach, a moderate approach, now

we are leaning in towards, okay, this
is leaning into more of a deficit.

We are primarily trying to maintain
muscle mass, see some fat loss.

Um, this is gonna be around-ish a 22%.

Now we're gonna be looking at a 0.5%

target rate of loss a week.

But once again, we can't always
see that in one week, in seven

days, because water can shift.

So maybe you lost that, but water shifted
up, so then the scale looks the same.

I bring that up, that is so
important, because we are

looking at trends over time.

And with any coach that has worked
with women, we really do have to watch

how their body responds, not over the
first week, not over two weeks, but

we're looking at three-plus weeks.

What is the trajectory that we are
seeing overall over a three-week period?

Over that time period, are
we seeing this trend of the

rate of fat loss that we want?

And in a moderate approach, it's usually
somewhere between half a percent to

possibly leaning as high as 0.75%.

That would be over a three-week period,
we could get a good idea of that trend.

Now, an aggressive, um, that one
is going to look more like 0.7

to 1%.

An aggressive approach is usually
above 26, 26 and above percent.

It's usually around 27% to 30% is
usually what people are looking at over

aggressive approaches, and those ones are
going to give you a bit more fat loss.

So that is going to give you 0.75

to 1%.

Now, keep in mind that 1% is this
person is responding really well, okay?

So if you were to take somebody through
an aggressive, like I said, that was 150

pounds, and they go down 1%, that could be
then one to one and a half pounds a week.

Once again, though, that's
an aggressive approach.

So that is them being on point
in an aggressive approach.

Now, beyond that, we typically don't talk
about kind of crash territory of like

40% and stuff, because that's where we're
going to lean into losing more muscle

tissue, and we never really wanna do that.

So I think that that's really
important to kind of keep that in mind.

So this is, this is how I want you to
set expectations before your next cut.

So even before you start your
next fat loss phase, I want you

to walk through a few things.

One, decide what you want more of.

Do you want faster fat loss?

That means a bigger deficit.

That means more steps, possibly
more cardio and more discipline.

Um, do you want to be eating closer
to maintenance, which means more

food, more support for your muscles,
but that will take more time to

see the fat loss you want, right?

You get to choose.

You just can't choose both, okay?

You can't choose aggressive
results and a mild approach.

So kind of get an idea of, okay, what
is an approach that I can sustain?

That is so unbelievably
important to ask yourself.

What calorie deficit will get me
the rate of fat loss that gets me

excited, but that I can sustain?

I mean, 1% gets everybody
excited, but can you sustain

that That's, that's a lot, right?

The second thing, match
your goal to your approach.

If you want 20 pounds gone,
look at how long that actually

takes at the deficit you picked.

For our 150-pound woman, moderate
gets her there in about five months

if she's on plan, and, um, and
closer to seven months at five days

a week if she's not on plan, right?

So here's, here's what
I, I tell people to do.

That 20 pounds you want gone, that
might just take two fat loss phases.

If you don't want the aggressive
approach, um, if you want a more

moderate approach because you can
adhere to that better, then plan on

two fat loss phases to get you there.

Or maybe you can, uh, up your steps more.

Get…

I mean, remember the 150-pound
woman, she had 8,000 steps.

What if we upped that?

What if we upped that to, to 14,000?

what if we included cardio in that?

then possibly within three, four months,
she could be down that 20 pounds, right?

So you just kind of have
to weigh these things out.

Uh, the third thing is commit to
the accuracy your approach needs.

Log every day, everything.

Plan your meals ahead so decisions are
already made before you're hungry, right?

The next day you should be
planning everything so that you

set yourself up for success.

The worst thing is to try to macro Tetris
your way through a day, and when you

are tired and fatigued, then sit there
and be like, "What am I gonna eat?"

That is the worst way to have success
The fourth thing, judge your progress

in two to three-week windows.

Remember what I talked about with women?

Water weight shifts everything.

So one weigh-in doesn't mean anything.

We need to watch the trends
in your measurements, your

clothes, your lifts, everything.

Five, give it really three weeks of real
data before you change anything, okay?

If after three weeks the trend
stalls, check your tracking, check

your steps, and your activity levels
before you cut calories, okay?

When your plan and your expectations
line up, the frustration goes away.

You stop thinking your body's
broken, and you start trusting

the process because you know what
it's supposed to look like, okay?

So bringing this all back, there are
the three main things that decide

how fast you lose fat: the size of
the deficit you chose, how closely

you're actually following it, and how
your body responds, water and all.

If you want aggressive results, you
need an aggressive rep- approach, and

you need to follow it close to 100%.

If you want a mild or moderate
approach, that's great.

Then expect mild or moderate results
and give it the time that it needs.

Honestly, for most women, for most
women, especially in perimenopause, a

moderate approach tends to work best.

An aggressive approach can work, but
it usually needs the aid of a coach.

It really does.

Of somebody really holding your feet
to the fire, giving you guidance

and love along the way, okay?

But either way, choose your
deficit based on what you can…

primarily what you can commit to,
and then make sure that the results

are tied to that commitment, right?

And then if you grabbed a macro plan
during your, uh, during the Black

Friday sale, this is exactly why
your plan looks the way it does and

why I set, uh, many of you, I set
your expectations right up front.

I said, "Hey, there's, some mix-up
of approach and expectations."

And so I just want you to
know that because it, it is so

freeing when you understand this.

Um, once again, really just wanna close
by reiterating choose the plan that

you can work with and then adjust your
expectations to the plan that you can

truly commit to, and that is when you
really start Following, you feel better

because you're actually following the
plan and you're not off all the time,

which comes with a lot of shame and
regret and frustration and a lot of

feelings of, "I can't do this," and
all the stories that come with that.

When we choose a moderate approach that
we can adhere to, we oftentimes have

more energy for our training, so we feel
better for life and lifts and sleep.

And just moderate your
expectations a little bit.

Bring them down.

There's nothing wrong with lining
up those expectations with the

approach that you can give in
the time of life that you're in.

That's, that's it, guys.

That is where health and happiness
and results really all come together.

So hopefully this was helpful.

You guys are amazing.

I appreciate each one of you.

You guys have an incredible day