Welcome to Energy Bytes with John Kalfayan and Bobby Neelon. Your essential guide to the intersection of data and energy. This podcast dives deep into the world of energy, shedding light on how data, AI, and technology are revolutionizing this sector. Each episode equips listeners with insights into the most efficient tools and resources, paving the way for a data-driven future in energy. From technical nuances to broader industry trends, Energy Bytes offers an unparalleled perspective on the evolution of the energy industry. Join us as we decode the algorithms of energy, one byte at a time.
But uh no, we're super excited to have um Brian [clears throat] Becker, the founder of Class Four with us today. And Brian and I are on a daily uh text chain with Jeremy Funk where we do the Immaculate Grid uh for Major League Baseball. If you've never done that, I highly recommend it. Um but do it for a sport that you know because I've tried the NBA one and I'm awful, but uh but yeah, really excited to have uh Brian here. He's a cyber security, you know, I'll call him a cyber security expert. I don't know if he'll agree or not. Um, but definitely excited to pick his brain on his, you know, a ton of experience he's got. He's doing a class 4. I, uh, I actually came across, I was looking up Mamba is like the the ML uh, model of the week this week and, uh, I was looking up Mamba models on Hugging Face and I actually, one of the ones, the few that exist over there that I found was one of them was a a security focused Mamba model, and I was like, "Oh, that's really interesting." like an IT focused mamba model but um no I'm very curious like interesting I don't feel like enough people talk about understand everyone thinks of security and IT as like oh man yeah it's like the we're going to have to go deal with those guys or they're going to step in the way of something but when you talk about energy infrastructure a lot of it is pretty critical in all the IP and everything else that goes on and then of course you think about it higher level of like national security and all of those things and a lot of instances and stuff like that. And so I'm really glad to to have you on. Excited about the conversation today. [snorts] Yeah, glad to glad to join. Uh I've actually created some GPTs for cyber security. It's kind of fun. Yeah. To play around with the the OpenAI stuff and GP chat GPT for teams and uh be able to I had a nice conversation on LinkedIn I think the other day of someone was saying, "Oh, no one will ever replace pentesters, but I'm like they're going to get 90% of the way there. Yeah, just basically do the same thing for every client and then you drill in. So it's it's a unique field. It's an always changing field. It's going to be an everpresent field and especially as you know there's no other field I don't think out there that once a company's in the news they start taking cyber security more seriously. Right. [laughter] So, um that's it's unfortunately, right, that's the uh that's always the trigger, but um no, I mean I'm I'm curious just how have you always kind of been into into technology and and coding or how did you kind of start out get into in the tech side? Yeah, so uh funny story. I was born and ra dairy farm in rural Iowa and I went basically through, you know, all my high school. I was like, am I going to go into the dairy route or the the the FFA route or egg teacher or I'm going to go into technology? I chose technology, right? And so, um, you have enough animals to take care of at home [laughter] deal with more, right? So yeah, I was like uh won some like state awards with FFA uh in high school with utilizing technology and PowerPoint which was pretty new 20 30 years ago to help tell stories about my FFA projects and my chicken project at one state and stuff like that. I chose to parlay that into a computer science degree. And then from there, it's always been like I've been heavy into the network infrastructure, cloud infrastructure, virtualization um in my early career. And then I got into when I moved to Colorado, I started working for a boutique uh cyber security firm up in Boulder, Colorado um called Applied Trust. Got acquired down the line and I started really digging into the cyber security intersection of networks and servers and cloud with cyber security. then eventually evolved into networks and cyber individually with compliance and just there's so many domain domains in the side of cyber that it just uh kind of all merged together for me that I parlayed it into a pretty good career. Um turned that into running uh cyber security and founding the the cyber security program over uh for Stan Crocky's businesses over at KSC. Uh who? Okay. Yeah. Sorry. I was gonna make make sure people Yep. So, owner of S uh uh the LA LA Rams, um a whole lot of land, the Wagner Ranch down in Texas, they have some oil and gas leases there. Um the Colorado Avalanche, Denver Nuggets, etc. And then he's got a whole bunch of other businesses as well. Um funny story is um I was working quote unquote on opening night, like my second year there, and I was at the game where the Nuggets had a big tip off and the power went out. And so immediately as a cyber security guy, I was like, "Oh [ __ ] [laughter] is somebody in in there?" So I immediately went into conversion from active fan kind of observing to this is on national TV. Our power is out. Is there someone in our infrastructure? Right? So uh had to run through the traps there and then uh ran it for an oil and gas company uh with doing both cyber security, IT, and data and then parlayed that into starting class 4. So uh in a nutshell, that's what I do. I've got a question for you and this is just like anecdotal. Yeah. My experience. Do you feel like most I feel like most of the security guys that I've met have a foundation or are very interested in the networking side like at at the core right and do you feel like that is a pretty I mean obviously it's a very important thing on the cyber security side but I feel like that's kind of the foundation of it. Is that a good assumption? Because especially now with everything being connected, right? Like most of the threats are coming from the outside, not from the inside, even though there are inside threats, right? Well, you use the outside to get to the inside, then you use the inside to distribute. So the the goal is to drill in from the outside, find a person. Usually it's done through somebody clicking a link or a vulnerability on a server, and they use that to pivot typically everywhere. Yeah. Um in the older days the cyber security um assessments and such the goal was to get in the network and then pivot and then like that's why like one of our number one top recommendations was segment your network right and then put you know security membranes or deepacket inspection or some strict firewall rules between it a lot of compliance standards have that especially PCIs you got to have a strict firewall rules etc. Now with the more cloud-based, it's like the AM is almost your firewall, right? And so it's breaking in and you want to secure your your zero trust, your level of identities, your authorization, authentication, your multifactor. So if someone breaks in is able to get into your computer and try to steal a token to get into your QuickBooks architecture, your AWS, etc., you have levels of of security to get there. But for the most part, network is always a big piece of it because it's how you travel the roads and and bridges to get in and out of your infrastructure. So I would say uh as a part of typical old school IT firewalls, your IDS sensors, your API gateways, everything's always been tied to a network. So yeah, I would say that's it's relatively true is that you can be a great web application pen tester or an application pen tester, but for you to really truly pivot outside of breaking that you need to know and understand how network and authentication and AD works and and how all that all that happens. How do you have any idea like as far as just I'm very curious like on a at a corporate type level are most of the like threats so to speak is it like a majority like fishing type you know getting trying to get someone to click a link so that they now immediately have access to the internal network versus you know trying to hack into a vulnerability on a network or software or app or whatever. Do you have any idea what that like distribution kind of is? [snorts] Well, I can tell you from my experience and I can't give you exact numbers, but there are two types. I'm going to group it very roughly into two groups. Number one is people that are trying to make a quick dollar, which are trying to spray and pray that someone clicks a link or they may do some sort of targeted fishing on people to either get business email compromise, which is like, hey, send a wire over to me here, or I'm going to ransom your entire network and then just pay money to get it back. Easy in, quick return, quick buck. You're done. It's a smash. So, you're seeing a lot of like uh That's right. You're seeing a lot of like uh syndicates, crime syndicates from overseas that they have, you know, offices full of people that all they're doing is fishing and, you know, Nigerian prince schemes and things like that. No. What's that YouTuber? And then you get into there's a YouTuber that Yeah. that hacks reverse hacks them or whatever. Yeah. acts like a an old lady and sends them a link or keeps them on the phone for half a day so that he can pinest their network and send them pictures from their webcams. You bet. [laughter] I love that channel. That channel is fantastic. Hey, we're here. Yeah. Yeah. [snorts] And then uh then then you have the people that scare the [ __ ] out of me, which are your geopolitical people that are hacking not for monetary, right? And those are the people that are what's the movie? Dark Knight that just want to see the world burn. Yeah. And um they they want to hack to cause absolute chaos and destruction. These are the people that wrote the ransomware that that broke the Iranian uh the they wrote a specialized SCADA uh software. I can't remember off the top of my head. It's been a few years that broke their um nuclear program. These are the people that are um doing zero days on iPhones that are excfiltrating whatever you know. So that they are super talented. They're most likely sponsored by a government. I was going to say um we saw a little bit little bit with that with the Colonial Pipeline. I believe that was attributed back to Russia to disrupt that that almost think of this as an act of war. No, for sure. I mean that's and so there's a lot of theories about the uh the nuclear reactor that that was also part of a government entity kind of forcing a hand [laughter] and then oh look the policy started changing against that that uh government. It's like, and you [snorts] got to and like those those type of type of people if they have their targets on you, um, you really either have to be dialed in and have DoD level funding or some Microsoft level security program or you just basically try to minimize the blast radius, right? Okay. And for for most companies in oil and gas specifically, you need to know understand what your risk level is, what you're willing to accept, and what your compliance standards. they actually may set for you like the Department of Homeland Security or if you're a a power plant, um you may have a higher level of requirements that you need to do just to basically be everything's on a local network. Yeah. Things like that. Well, I mean, it's totally isolated, not connected. Yeah. Air gap. Air gap. That's what So, and we had someone else on a week or two ago and you know, they're a little more little looser on on security, you know, but his whole thing was well, I can do all I want. Doesn't matter. I I can walk onto just about any well site and like most people have the damn password on the skated computer could walk right in, plug into it. I mean uh so let's talk about I mean I guess there's two things here. Can we talk about your journey into oil and gas and just what surprised you or didn't surprise you or whatever? But then just also just the how much time you got? Yeah. [laughter] But then just like even just the people aspect of cyber security um and that like you can have again to your point the best network infrastructure and this and that and the other but you know if one person potentially you know does the wrong thing that there's your point in and it can just you know can you know you can it can destroy you from that side. We have a weird like I'm very you know I've said this before but I I genuinely feel like most businesses regardless of industry all have the same problems. They all have their own nuances and constraints and stuff and but they generally speaking all like everyone's focused on cyber security right the issue one of the big issues I feel like for the energy space is that you have this unique condition where you have these distributed remote assets that are typically you know incredibly high risk just as an operation no less if someone is actually trying to like they're high-risisk hard stop they're even more high risk because they are now [clears throat] targets for bad actors potentially, even just like like you said, just [ __ ] that want to screw [ __ ] up. My father-in-law has a bunch of stripper wall production up in Louisiana. And we woke up, it was like the I think it was Thanksgiving day to a call that uh you know there was one of their tank batteries was leaking at by the Cat Lake and so they had to run out there and they had someone on a on a camera going out there getting drunk and [ __ ] with the tank battery and just like intentionally opening, you know, just like, "Hey, that's great." But it you like, "Hey guys, check this out." Right. Yeah. No, I mean that's exactly what it was. But the whole point is we h we have a a very unique instance in that not all industries have this. Some do, some don't, but that distributed OT infrastructure that organically exists in our industry is just like such a prime opportunity in most cases for for that penetration. But that's also why everyone typically gets in fights with IT departments at oil and gas companies because they know that that is such a big risk. And so talk to to Bobby's point like dive into you know how you manage those different levels because it's not just like hey we're a software company and all we have to do is manage our digital assets. It's we have digital assets and we have physical assets that can be controlled by those digital assets good or bad and so yeah dive into that. Sorry Bobby I kind of no just wanted to get more detail lot to unpack there. Yeah lot to unprocess. So let's just go ahead and start with um I came into oil and gas without a lot of background. So um I'm specifically working for oil and gas. So I had a complete clean slate. You know nothing, no biases, whatever. I was like yeah I know that you know the good times we make a lot of money and the bad times people are getting laid off. You know it's a it's a cyclical environment commodity based. What I underestimated was the level of um after I got in and saw how the sausage was was being pumped out of the ground and and and made was um the level of amount of field technology and how it all has to work together and the disperate amount of systems that you guys have covered multiple times on this with Zach Warren and Mark Ver all these guys of how it all makes it works. They're all siloed. It's all came through. booms a bus from one operator, whatever. It's all kind of pieced together with barbwire duct tape to get, you know, skated to work to talk to P2, to talk to Merrick, to talk and then eventually get royal royalty checks out, right? And um the concerns that I had immediately from a cyber security perspective on the top of my head was like uh why can we talk to this well from the internet with a default password? Um why why when I go into showdan and I search for a certain line that I can see a number of wells by a number of providers uh that made my my alarm bells just go off because um if it can be seen from the internet someone's going to try to hit it. Yeah. And uh we we probably and many oil and gas providers I'm probably not exaggerating is like they probably had somebody that they don't know been in their environment at some point. Yeah. Just seeing what's going on and they have no idea just by the nature of the scanner and the nature of the network the field networks the the remoteness the cell modems to the pointto points etc. And so um I realized is that okay so what's the balance security is always a balance too much security you choke the business not enough security you get chaos right what's the level of balance that we need to put in here based on our compliance requirements and being able to have the business operate to have that right happy goldilock zone where if I if I'm being sued by a class action lawsuit or my uh or my you know lease holders that hey you guys were negligent on your cyber that I'm comfortable getting on the sand and saying, you know what, we put these best practices in. We gauge this. Yeah. Sometimes cyber security in a lot of CISOs is a is a is a uh CYA exercise. Yeah. Is is doing that kind of decision. So, from a very high point there, um, all oil and gas operators need to be thinking about what is the level you're ready to testify on in front of a court, in front of a class action lawsuit, especially with the new SEC guidelines out of we did our due diligence. We we showed our due care to take care of these assets, but oh, whoops, they got hit, right? So um those are the types of things that uh software surprised me especially on gas is like really they're still running software on these on this type of technology virtual machines. I was like okay you know [laughter] so um it it's a great field I think for using innovation in working with the blueco collar people in and coming up with with some great ideas on how to squeeze the most of technology that may be limited by code base by vendor um that's why Bobby I think you guys are super successful in using data in in writing software but um I still think oil and gas producers are behind the eight balls especially when it comes to cyber security and knowing and understand the assets that they have um the how the SEC is coming down on public companies um of the true nature of cyber security risk. So um in short you're seeing that underestimate estimate by the entire industry in general by the rising skyrocketing cyber security premiums or companies that can't even be insured. Yeah. Uh so it's it's a weird space right now. It's hyperchanging with the amount of requirements. Um every single state seems like they're putting out their own privacy policy and cyber security regulations. Um Department of Homeland Security gets involved with pipelines etc. So uh you IT company IT organizations really have to be mindful on overall cost because you could I say this a lot to my IT customers is any IT technological problem can be thrown solved by throwing buckets of money at it right it's what's the right amount of security what's the right amount of expectation that you can reasonably accept that you can deal with the consequences later well the thing too I I've always mentioned with it is that [clears throat] like you're going to put these things up. People are going to work around it. Like I mean even on my side as like we have a central data team like if I put too much friction they're going to find their way around and they're just going to use Excel or do something you know so you have to allow you know certain gives and takes so that they'll most people will do it the right way you know and give them you know a path to do it the right way at the very least. But uh one thing you know why I wanted to have you on for a while and it comes up but we haven't had the right person to talk about it. Can you talk about uh socks compliance and what that is and what that means just at a high level for people who may not understand everyone everyone's pushing sock 2 compliance as well vendor requirements and stuff like that well sock sock two and sarbain oxley are two different babies I want to talk about also I used to think that too but socks and sock 2 and maybe talk about both of those yeah if you can independently but so sarbain oxley socks uh is a requirement in which that publicly traded companies need to to make sure that they meet certain amount of rules when it comes to truthfulness and transparency in financial reporting. And there's a cyber security component to that in which that you need to know and have restrictions for anyone that can change systems or software that could affect financial reporting. So when you go through an IPO readiness or you do your uh a number of things when it's like hey who went in here and edited this who has access you need to be able to provide who who did what who changed what because you need to be able to go fully back and audit your financial reports if something's broken sock 2 is like an attestation that the AISCPA I think is a is a is an organization of accountants in which that they set standards for companies in which that they are meeting a baseline to um to be a a Sock 2 compliant company, right? So, for example, if you're going to do a SOCK 2 or a SOCK 2 type one, that's a point in time assessment in which that you go to a company, most often a third party provider that's giving you solutions or software as a service in which that a third party that's verified with this this uh AI SCPA can do a sock analysis of where you are in a point in time according to these standards. A lot of companies require that especially the larger organizations that if you're going to do business with them, you need to be sock 2 compliant. I know that uh my previous employer is that we we tried to for most of our vendors that we worked with that offered us software in the cloud that they showed at testation to a sock 2 type one s like a SAS level etc. A sock two type two is a more indepth assessment in which that they take your controls that you are saying hey we meet them in a sock two type one but you have demonstrated uh you have demonstrated examples over the past year. So it's a full year-long compliance that they can just go and say pick any log any incident any ticket in your system and verify that you follow your processes and procedures to be that fully uh assessed. Let's go back to Sarbain Oxley for a second or the socks or the SEC. They just came out with these new cyber security rules and disclosures in which that uh they want to know how cyber security risk could affect financial reporting in results. So they've made a number of rules to change that public companies in the United States have to disclose as a part of their annual 10ks or your quarterly quarterly reviews of what you're doing from a cyber security program perspective so that any breach or any cyber security risk doesn't materially affect the financial reporting or or a negligent or a problem that could say hey my earnings are down 10%. It's just for more uh information to the shareholder. So for example, the biggest thing is if you have a breach that materially affects your uh reporting, you have to report that within 4 days of discovering the materiality. So what's going to happen is that you have say you have a business email compromise in which that you pay Hal that your drilling company pays Hallebertton $10 billion rather than one and then Hallebertton has it lost somewhere else, right? what level of cost of this cyber security breach that the downtime or the lost dollars is material. So all companies need to have that's publicly traded have a process or a method to determine this is a material breach. We have to report this, right? So we've had like three or four that's been reported now. Um, and then you're just then after those go out, whether you're the breach has been cleaned up, whether that the vulnerability has been patched, you have to disclose it to the street. So, it could open up to a whole another bunch of problems. And then that basically brings in, you know, just should cyber security people have DNO insurance to cover what might happen with all the all these breaches and cy and Uber's CISO was found criminally liable by the by the SEC. they sued them and so is a big old CIA. It's it's kind of a quagmire right now and it's going to be kind of nuts. And that rule went into place last December. So for you publicly traded oil and gas companies, there better be something in your annual 10K on how you are doing your cyber security. Are you adhering to ISO? Are you adhering to NIST? Like what are you doing to help meet those standards of the SEC to be able to meet the compliance of this? That's fascinating. No, that's Yeah, but that but that's definitely a much different uh kind of approach as far as just like, oh, we've got a company and we're going to go do something, right? Like being able to to have auditable logs about anything that impacts your financials. [laughter] It's uh it's deep, man. That's uh that's a lot of stuff. Like if you sign into Inertia, do you have a log of that person that signed in and made a change to a a field to anything? Yeah. Right. No, that's [clears throat] Yeah, I don't I don't envy that that position. That's that's pretty wild. I'm actually curious because I've heard I'm not a security guy. I'm not even I mean I'm not a developer. Um but I've heard a lot of kind of I've hear I hear both sides of the sock 2 compliant kind of argument, right? Like obviously there's very good things that come from that. But then I also hear the flip side of that where and I've worked at previous startups where they're just like this is just highway robbery because there's a dozen, you know, sock two audit companies that can make you compliant and that's all there is and they all charge the same prices and the prices just keep going up and then like I can't do business unless I have this compliance but then how the hell am I supposed to pay to get audited for the compliance and have all those tools in place so that I am compliant and so I'm very curious like kind of where do you where do you sit on that just from a you know actual practicality perspective and from a security perspective it it infuriates [clears throat] me. I'll tell you why. So I used to be a PCI assessor um in my previous life where I would go into a company and I look at their cyber security controls for accepting credit cards and it's all gray area and it's all interpretation of the assessor. M so if you get a SOCK 2 and I've looked like SOCK 2 will the these AISPA will not give you a checklist of what you have to do to solve the test to be sock 2 compliant. I like well you got to get a readiness assessment to do that. I was like, "Okay, so why don't you just tell me what it is so I don't have to guess?" Right? And so like what I end up recommending my clients is like go through the CIS top 18 cyber security controls. Do all of those go into NIST, make sure you know and understand NIS 800, see where the cyber security controls overlap and then see if that will get through sock 2. And then they'll probably most likely find something because assessors aren't doing the job unless they find a problem. And it's just to some point it just is infuriating in which that it's it's just all kind of abstract and up to interpretation of the assessor and they're going to charge you a pretty penny to do that. Yeah. But it's it's necessary because like do you want the government saying every single company needs to to meet this meet the NIS 853 even people like me doesn't make sense right? So the industry is trying to regulate themselves a little bit. Um, and then with especially with PCI and HIPPA, HIPPA is more of a governmental thing, but like uh anytime I think that the government really dives in and says you have to do it something in absolute is a bad deal. So I think it's a you know um I'd [clears throat] rather pay Peter than you know Ralph and Paul. I'd rather deal with the devil that I know than the devil that I don't [laughter] you're going to have some sort [clears throat] of you know government board. It it just doesn't make a lot of sense to me. But It is what it is. Do you think that are they intentionally vague? Like I mean cuz sometimes I wonder like if you lay out the rules like here are the things then hackers can take those rules and code against them. I mean you see it across the board right like financial the law anytime you put something hard then people will find all of the loopholes around that. But I also understand it from the engineering side. It's like tell me what I need to do to be compliant. don't just show up and start pulling random [ __ ] out and then now I've got to go back and fix it and then I've got to pay you again to come and audit and then this just endless cycle of that most companies you know most companies are startups or growth trying to break into that [ __ ] I can't spend right and then so how am I supposed to go work for an operator if I can't get compliant because I have only existed for six months and I need a year like all this fun stuff right yeah I'm doing this right now for a client is trying to get them sock 2 type one ready and it's a matter of you know let's get some best practices in place which will rhyme with the actual compliance standards but they're best practice anywhere so like there are some very very soft standards or soft rules that you know most companies should have in place like for example I haven't I don't know if I've met a compliance standard that doesn't have inventory of your systems and softwares or a vulnerability management program anywhere right that's typically good to have because it shows shows the company and it shows that you're being assessed against is you know what you have, you know the problems and you're looking for problems with what you have and you're documenting and have a process to deal with it, right? But then you can get into like you must have a firewall these rules and then it gets to a point where you must have comments about what these firewall rules are for and then change management etc. So they're all over the place. Um I that's why I like the CIS topy team. You know they have uh some very very general if you don't know what you're doing in cyber security you always start there right inventory firewall security awareness training software development life cycle uh aggregation on know where your data is backups etc. So that's [clears throat] fascinating. What do you what do you see as like the most common gaps in the in the oil and gas security side like across you know upstream at least or across whatever your experiences in but um you know where do you see like the gaps? Do you see a lot of people doing things right or some areas where people could quickly do things right put things in place? Yeah, great question. gaps are with um usually the executive leadership team. They expect hey your IT cyber security should fall under you and just deal with it. Right. That is not the case. Yeah. Now you're legally liable. Your technology Yeah. correct. Your technology and I've been saying this I think for a couple years now. your data that you produce is the you know the digital digital manifestation of your people's hard work and it should be created as an asset and should be protected as such but if you put to to quote you know Patrick sees if you put baby in a corner cyber security in a corner it's always going to be the dodged around you know redheaded stepchild that nobody wants to deal with it's going to be minimized it's going to be underappreciated you're going to have a CISO and his security team is burnt out because they are trying to protect everyone from themselves. Whereas it's more of a in an oil and gas company, safety is everyone's responsibility, cyber security is also that way, too. Yeah. It's just the way that it needs to be, especially if we're going to be on a computer eight hours a day, 5 days a week or even more, you know, and if we're going to put, you know, our wells with RTUs and next generation sensors and all this stuff that can control the well, you know, that need to be considered as well. Then you've got SCA apps on your phone and all of that other fun, right? Like it gets fun. Yeah. [laughter] So, I shouldn't answer my CEO's text message from a weird number. Correct. Or I I see this all the time is like people are texting or like we get new employees that update LinkedIn and immediately they do some sort of data breach. They go search for it. It's all automated. They will text them, hey, send me some gift cards. You know, hey, this is Christopher. This is uh uh this is name your CEO. This is Darren Woods. If you have a minute, right? Yep. So, um th those types of things where we're doing it right is they're start is people are starting to get it a little bit more in the forefront. I've heard of multiple oil and gas companies that are starting to engage with like managed service providers and doing engagements from like a cyber security perspective where like, hey, we're actually going to not just test our data center. We're actually going to go send somebody out to the well site and try to plug in and see what they can get to. The biggest nightmare there is that you plug into a well site and then you have no what's called network segmentation that they can get every single well from a well site, right? Um I I once did a cyber security assessment where I was able to hack the most um sensitive part of a network from a a phone at the front desk. You just plugged into the phone and I was able to bypass all their security and just jump behind it. That's the same same thoughts and thinking. It was just an IP phone you plug into a Well, can you get in and control the entire field? Yeah. Right. Terrifying stuff. Yeah. No, I didn't even think about that. But yeah, all the VoIP phones now that everyone has. I don't know why people have desk phones to begin with these days. But Right. I was like, everyone's got a cell phone. Just pick their cell phone and like no one answers the desk phone when you call it. [laughter] That's right. I'm going to send you a team or Slack message if I work with you or counting Nina speaking. [laughter] Just a moment. Yeah. Uh just a moment. But you me but you mentioned people is like people are starting to even through whether that they want to or not like cyber security insurance is requiring people to like show me your cyber security awareness training. So they're starting to come around by the hammer method. I would love to see a little bit more uh a little bit more carrot and less stick but the stick tends to work because it it threatens people and and pay a fine. You don't nobody wants to [clears throat] pay a fine because Sally in the county didn't finish their cyber security awareness training, right? So, she wrote a VBA, she downloaded a spreadsheet off of a website that she thought would make it 10 minutes faster that had a nice malicious VBA script in it. Yeah. So, [snorts] time for some shameless self-promotion on your side. I mean, you're you're a fractional you're a fractional CISO generally is kind of what your you know, class 4 does, right? I mean, I think you do a few other things, but that's kind of one of your big things. Can you talk about that? A if people aren't even aware of like the fractional business model, but then like kind of what a fractional CISO allows. I mean again I'd go to bet I mean we're a good size company. We don't have a CISO. We have a CIS admin but we don't have a CISO or a lot of companies probably can't afford or don't want to have one or don't know they need one. You know correct. Let's talk about you know that business model and then you know what you can [snorts] afford or someone in the similar position can afford a company. For sure. So, um, fractional CISO right now is kind of all the rage and especially with a lot of the service providers too is like they're advertising fractional CISO or fractional executives at a very very high level. It's someone that is outside of your company that will come in and help run a program that may not be needing a full-time CISO. Full-time CISO these days, depending on how experienced they are, will make cost you 400, 500 total comp. Um, many companies, especially smaller producers, don't need that. But what they might want to do is have someone come in and say, "Okay, here's a program. Here's a roadmap. Here's uh your biggest risks. Here's your cyber security, your compliance problems you may have with the state, the federal government, etc." Um, even if you're having a whole bunch of people in your royalty, you know, your royalty database, your CRM, those private data, we'll come and give you, help you get a plan, help you do an assessment, manage your vendors if we need to, and basically get you on a roadmap to be able to uh tell to your investors, tell your board, tell to the public, hey, we're doing the right thing with cyber security, right? someone that's keeping track [clears throat] of your risk, uh taking track and managing your 10Ks and and making sure that you are disclosing where needed or figuring out materiality or you know what maybe you know allowing uh certain thing the way that you operate operating things from the internet unsecure is not the best way of doing things. So bringing a third party in to do that. Um uh what was the second part of that question? Yeah and yes that I offer I offer those services. Um, I know a number of other teams do. We usually have a bunch of partners that we can help set you up with if you need to do an assessment, if you need to do a risk assessment or if you need to do even talk to your cyber security insurance provider. God forbid you have an incident, you need somebody to come in and help, you know, bring chaos or bring uh some calm to the chaos or yeah, orderly chaos, right? So, um, it's a it's a it's a kind of a burgeoning field, especially with the explosion of all these compliance requirements and things like that that helps businesses know that they're doing the right thing. So, um, usually they'll come in, the cyber security exec will come in with the system. They'll say, "All right, do a quick assessment checklist. Where you at here, here, and here? What's the overall, you know, approach of the business? What's the risk tolerance of the business? Where's the risk management fall up to?" Have a couple conversations. Um, if it's an SEC, uh, if it's a public company, there has to be a cyber security person on the board that can know and speak to it that they'll probably have to work with. So, taking point on all that and helping a company execute, pull pull molecules out of the ground and do it so do it so securely and helping businesses do it that way. Nice. And then like say and maybe more specifically to you, but I mean how much of it then is implementation or is it more some of that high level type work? Yes. Or or is it getting your hands dirty and like helping configure networks or do stuff like that too or does it just depend on the person and how much they want to do? Is it like an audit or is it more of like a a strategy plus implementation or is it just really based off what they want to do? If you want an audit, we can we can do an audit. There's tons of companies that done an audit. Well, where you're going to find with a cyber security shortage and you know someone that can speak business and can speak risk and also can speak technical technical chops, right? That can actually explain to you why you know what what's the purpose of having to you know bring all of our SCADA behind a firewall or do you know remote tunneling etc. rather than having exposed, right? They can actually tell that story and then try to assign, hey, cost of this breach is this. Most likely you're going to deal with a class action lawsuit. You're going to deal with this. You know, it might if we spend 10% of what an overall breach might might be, it it would save us in the long run, right? So, being able to translate risk and uh technical controls to a business sense is a very very powerful trait that you should look for in a fractional executive. A lot of companies out there, you know, they may have the technical chops, but they don't speak business. They're just trying to offer that to get some more money in the door, right? Um, so look for experience when you do look for a CF a CSO. Just like, are you going to hire a fractional CFO that's never, you know, closed the books before? Yeah. It kind of behooves you to uh be mindful of what you're doing there. So, but but Brian, all my stuff's in the cloud. Isn't Isn't that taken care of? Isn't that what I pay them for? [laughter] No, not even close. There there's a thing. Most people that go to the cloud don't understand what the shared responsibility model is. That means Amazon does stuff to a point and then it's all you, baby. Yeah. And so if you're not patching your, you know, your servers, if you're not doing good code, code code development, even just exposing your setting up your AM and stuff properly, like just I having used mostly AWS and GCP, like there's got to be a better interface for AM and user management and a little bit of Azure as well, I guess. But like that's just it's so terrible. [laughter] Like hey, here's the infinite list of services we provide. Would you like how would you like this user to have access to every single one of them? Like there's so many ways to do it, but there's got to be a way to make zero trust easier, right? Yeah. No, I mean that's I feel like that's the the the commonality between all things that are like kind of more pushing the edge and new, right? where it's like crypto or AI or it's like hey these things that we use are really simple but the actual things that are happening that behind the scenes of that tool are very complicated and if you're responsible for having to do that on your own it's a lot different story than just pulling it out of the box. But yeah, um I wanted to ask where so you were talking about the gift cards and stuff. I was Bobby and I were both laughing because that happened to us at one of our companies prior. [laughter] Uh, I don't remember where was it to was like Target or was it uh whatever it was it ended up being Apple gift cards. It was iTunes gift cards. That's what it was. So, guess guess what the company got? Rand employees at the company got for Christmas uh presents that year. Everyone got iTunes gift cards. Fortunately, yeah, fortunately we figured it out before he actually gave over all the uh or that's when he figured it out when they're like, "Yeah, give me the codes." And he was like, "What?" But yeah, [laughter] it was the same thing. it was like, you know, text message or email from someone that had spoofed the the CEO's name and uh yeah, just not paying attention to it. And you know, that [ __ ] happens all of the time, right? Or the same I've also been at a company where they've done the same thing where, you know, whatever fishing they got in and from set up, you know, some simple email rules where they were sending emails to all of our vendors, accounting departments saying, "Hey, we've updated our account. move it to this and then deleting the send receipt and forwarding any replies to a different email so that they never even showed up in in the email and it's like damn that's that's a really good way to lose a [ __ ] ton of money very quickly and no one has any idea a single compromise right yeah um yeah people that's why security awareness training is basically on every single questionnaire and everything is like making people aware of what can happen and and what's the consequence of doing so I worked with a company before that had their CEO was hacked uh basically because they they found the password in a password dump and then [snorts] they were sending this person a ton of like multifactor requests accept accept accept and they were just spamming it spamming it spamming it and they're like I just got sick of it and I just hit accept and I'm like what are you doing dude it's like the most do not know how this works right that whole call action do this now like Yeah. So, like training your people, even though people, you know, we're we we go overboard, not not overboard on training, but we're very safety focused, you know, it's like wear your hard hat and things like that. It should be almost like don't click on stuff in your email. You know, it should be second nature that we should know and understand. Yeah. If some random person's that from an email that you don't know somehow makes it through the firewall and into your inbox and there's like a PDF that says invoice in it, it's probably not from Yeah. someone you know like [laughter] it's there's so many of those. But I'm cur like what is your the tools are getting good with MLA too. Yeah. So but well it's they should be picking that up but still they still get through. They're getting smart. Yeah. It's tricky because like we fight that on the media side, on the marketing side, right? Where it's like we have we send out emails to people who have subscribed and have bought stuff from us or attended events and stuff in the past and it's like well [ __ ] At one point we were trying to send out like our invites from the app weren't making it through certain people's firewalls and we didn't realize it and then we'd follow up with them and be like, "Hey, you know, did you get the email?" And like, no. And it was either in spam or never delivered. And you're like, "God, that's a whole another we could have a whole episode on that's a whole another domain of all that stuff, the domain and all of those practices and stuff, but where do you see like Yeah. Demarcist? Yeah. Oh [clears throat] god, I actually talked to you about that because I need to uh figure out some stuff there. But where do you see the most like at least in the energy space, where do you see like the most common kind of points of penetration or attempts of penetration? I mean, is it is it in, you know, obviously there's the remote actor, you know, government kind of piece, but is it I mean, I would assume that most of it is the spray and prey fishing kind of Yeah. side of it. Is that a majority? So, vast vast vast majority because they out outnumber it. Um, there's a saying that uh that I like to tell a lot of clients is that, you know, sometimes you don't have to be the fastest [clears throat] person running away from the bear. You just have to be faster than the slowest person. [laughter] Um, it's true. So, attackers go, you know, there was a a famous bank robber that was asked like, "Why do you rob banks? Is that's where the money is." while you go where the easiest people is to get access to that money and that's you know people that will respond to those emails that will click on things that will the easiest way in is always through the people. Yeah. And then the second easiest way in is through publicly accessible services that you don't know about that are that have vulnerabilities in it. And then the third probably easiest way in is literally through the front door and plugging in. Yeah. So like number two, you know, Microsoft and SharePoint have had a lot of zero days the past, you know, couple six months that people can remotely access and get in without doing anything. That's why vulnerability project problem or vulnerability management programs are so important knowing what you have and and right if they're patched and then literally someone walking in your front door and plugging into that phone or plugging into that wall. It's a poor intersection of physical security controls. um access management, IM, etc. vendors, contractors, visitors. Yeah. I mean, if they can get in your your network's not secure, they can get anywhere, right? Yeah. No, I think that's another good point, too, going back to the distributed assets and OT side, right? Is like and we talk about this from the data side where most of the data generated by an oil and or for an oil and gas company is not actually generated by them, right? So, it's generated by somebody else. Well, it's the same once you get into the field with all the services, the equipment, the installation, the skatus, like they're buying, you know, they're buying uh sensors from a handful of companies. They're buying PLC's and modems and all that other stuff from those handful of companies and then another company comes and installs that, right? and then they set up the whole like there's all these opportunities for someone to just slide in a little p back door or you know just be lazy and leave you know the the default password set up because they're not part of your company [clears throat] and they don't care like the scary thing is guys yeah and the scary thing is guys is 99% of those RTUs and PLC's I guarantee are not have not been patched in the day that the well was drilled right I'm I'd be curious to know Do you imagine doing pin tested even like Yeah. Think about how many I mean how many year old things are sitting out in the field still? Yeah. Imagine the Barnet shell midcon you know they've got the stuff in there that's never been replaced or touched because he doesn't make a lot of sense that well's making less right less product every year. Why invest in it? That's that's I will say that's probably one of the like trickiest parts of the industry is that you've got these long-term assets that you know the hardware on them is normally pretty old. It's it was robust at the time but is nowhere near as robust as it should be. But that specific asset is towards the end of its life and not making any money. So why would you go spend any more money on it to just to patch the security piece of it? And so yeah, the incentive versus hammer thing starts to come into play there for sure. Well, again, if you [snorts] don't have anyone, again, most of these companies don't have a cyber security expert. Like most people, it's not not even the negligence. They don't even think, well, it's negligent, but they're not even thinking about it. It's not even cross their not on their radar until something bad happens normally. Yeah. Um, one thing I did the startup the startup is like, oh, go ahead. No, no, you're good. Because I'm Oh, it's like a startup is like why? Yeah. As a Yeah. It's like a startup, you know, why would I secure something that I not making money on, right? There's that a balance of those incentives, right? [clears throat] Um, yeah, I was kind of wanted to switch gears because you are more than just a cyber security monkey. Um, but thanks. [laughter] You had a blog about your personal tech stack and like stuff that you've been using. I kind of want to dive in on that just kind of things that are helping you be more productive each day and what what are because that's one of our kind of core things with this podcast was just like what are some technologies out there that people are using to be more effective at at what they're doing. So yeah or even new stuff that you think is super promising for people you know companies corporate CISOs etc to check out be start playing around with. Well, I know this has been beaten to death, but chat GPT has saved me so much time it's not even funny. Like, help time and money. Just look this over. Help me with this email. Yeah. Uh, what's a quick write me a quick script to do this, right? It's it's well worth the money that I pay for it. Um, have you messed with other stuff? I use my tech copilot. Have you messed with Microsoft Copilot yet? Uh, a little bit. So I've played because I have to I have as a consultant I do like VCIO stuff too. So fractional CIO I need to know all players. So I've played a little bit with the co-pilot. Um I have a I have Bard I have all those like uh anthropic try to compare and contrast see what they're good for. I use Jasper to help write content. Yeah. Um just to see you know what their capabilities are. Um, OpenAI has been so far the best that I use on a daily driver, but I've also, you know, played around with Google just to make sure that I'm up up to speed on a lot of things. You should also try out Medium or I'm sorry, Mistl's medium model. Uh, we've been doing a bunch of tests here recently and uh like nice sideby-side comparisons across a bunch of them. And the Mistl media model outperforms most of them most of the time. not just with the answer but also with the time and the cost like comparison. So I'm actually I've been Is that an open source model? Is it open source? Yeah. Yeah. The Yeah, there's they just I think within the last month was when it was posted on hugging face but it uh or no that might have been Mamba I don't remember but it uh it's a newer one but it uses the concept of consensus of experts. So you essentially have a bunch of models that are experts on specific things and then it's different uh it's a different setup. I don't know all the details around it but it's a lot faster and performant than uh they claim that it's as good as GPT4. So it's fun thing to check out for everybody on hooking face if you I will do that for sure. Thank you. Um other things I've been using I've been playing around with Air Table quite a bit. Yeah. Uh just from an ad hoc spin up throw anything at a database. I've had hit or miss with it how successful it is. It's easy to track deliverables and links and things through there. It's easy to tie into it and code into it. Um been a big fan of uh zapiering everything to Slack or zap zapping everything to Slack lately. Yeah, I just got I just got my uh my Zapier Slack integration for all my o my zero uh logs. Y so I'm like oh this is so much nicer. So it's just like oh yeah I just live in it. um live in Slack on a day-to-day basis and just ties everything together. If I have a HubSpot, something from HubSpot, something from ASA, something from any of the apps that I'm using, it just ties right in. Um somebody modifies something from one of my clients, I can see it right away on the side. It's just it's really easy to work with. Um, the app I've been using a lot and I think has a lot of um, opportunity is an app called Twos because as a dad of two young twos, okay, and as a dad of two young kids in a family that has a lot of stuff going on and me just thinking of [ __ ] all the time. Um, I don't want to have like a big old notion database of here's all the things you need to do. I just need to have a quick checklist. I can go, send it, share, whatever. And um I like it a lot more than like the Apple reminders app or the Microsoft tasks app. You just stick it in your phone and it just and then you can use natural language to say remind me to call Bobby tomorrow and it will set up an an alert and then it will auto tie into your calendar and it shows your whole day in front of you on your iOS and your Mac device or whatever. So big been a big fan of that. I'm hoping can have some more integration into it Zaps and Slacks and just my general calendar, but um it's it's been helpful for me so far. Yeah, the uh oh [ __ ] I was going to say something. Oh, you mentioned notion. Um, so we use we use notion internally for our kind of knowledgebased internal stuff and they recently rolled out their AI or language model on top of it and it's actually I've been very impressed with like my biggest gripe with notion is if you don't set up where the documents are and if somebody doesn't share the link directly with you it tends to be hard to find. Now with this AI, you can literally say like where is our vac like what is our vacation policy and it will return [laughter] the vacation policy from the notion it everything in notion is accessible. It's pretty I've been pretty impressed with it um as like alternative on that end. And then I was going to also mention uh you know your GPT coding uh stack. I use GPT. GBT is very very good at coding app scripts which is some flavor of Java but in Google and I've been using that with sheets as my service you know my functional service environment to call APIs to do whatever and then dump it into a sheet and now it's in this poor man's database that I can use to play around with and or push you know pull stuff from one API push it to another do all kinds of fun stuff. It's a uh a very slept on uh functionality in my opinion. But [snorts] what what what tools on the cyber security side are you kind of interested in excited about see kind of promise in
uh whiz site game friend of mine runs site game uh helps you do zero trust audits very very quickly. Um, there's a there's a company called Total that does basically seek to mess one install, the rule of them all, which always makes me nervous, but they seem [laughter] like they're doing the right thing. It makes the customer happy. It makes the cyber sec the security guys incredibly nervous, right? Like, yeah. Uh, then you're seeing a lot of zero trust going on. So, like your, you know, your Prisma clouds, your palo Altos. Yeah. Let's actually talk about that cuz I I want to understand what is that especially around like identity identity management and stuff like what is this passwordless future that we're we're being fed right now or people are talking about like how does that actually work and do you think that's going to like that is the future? So you always go back to your oh sorry the passwordless future is like you go back to MFA right or your levels of of access that allows you to get into something it's something that you have something that you know and something that you are um and it's trying to streamline all that to make it easier on the user um because users are awful at doing passwords awful. Um, I remember the first time that I did a password hack over at uh KSC and most of their passwords were easily accessible. Um, and we're just getting away from passwords because they're notoriously insecure and easily hacked, right? So, if you go into so it's not something that you know, but something that you have or something that you are, if you can do both of those, um, you can usually be pretty safe. So if you save a pass key, this is a cryptographically secure, you know, string of characters onto a one password or your, you know, your password vault on your phone or your laptop that's tied specifically to that device and you authenticate against a service with that. You pass something that I have, the phone and some in the passcode, TPM modules, things like that and something that you are usually use a biometric, right? face ID marker to get in. And so, um, that's something that it's don't really have to change unless you lose your device. Passwords, you know, a lot of requirements say you have to change it every 90 days, every time it's breached, etc. Well, unless your your phone is copied and they have it your thumb or your face, you're not getting in, right? So those are the types of things that they do combined with conditional access rules of hey, you know, why are you logging in from from Abu Dhabi when we saw you, you know, last two hours ago in Colorado Springs, right? So they're getting smarter with that and zero trust is basically because of of Biden uh Biden's recent cyber security executive order is being the law of the land for anything federal government um to to implement and put in zero trust. So, uh, gone are the days, um, of, you know, logging into a VPN to get your email or hopefully get access to, you know, anything. And then if you do zero trust and a lot of times they can do what's called zero trust network access or or network edge where they will pipe all your traffic into a central location so they can see right log what services are being used and and and proxy that identity to even another layer of security. So what um like what to you we're talking about passwords, right? I'm a huge proponent of password managers and and MFA and stuff. What what I mean what are some simple things that people can do to to secure their stuff, right? Like obviously password managers one, but what are simple things and then what are some tools like you know one pass is one you mentioned. What are tools that people should look at and tools that people should probably avoid because they have, you know, in your experience or opinion have some sort of a potential compliance issue? [snorts] Yeah. The first thing I would always do is if you don't have to use a password, don't. So, uh, passwordless, use a pass key, UB key. Some companies do that, whatever. Don't do it. Second thing is is that always sign up for the multiffactor option is uh and then use it with biometrics or use it with the you know don't use the SMS or the phone call use the actual app and I'll get into the tools that I use to help simplify that. And the third thing is is that if you can sign up with Google or sign up with with uh Microsoft or something do that and make sure that it your corporate side has the the passwords in uh passwords there. So like I recommended a lot of times in my previous roles is like hey if you're going to sign up for a service log in with OOTH or log in with Google because it puts our password policy on that authentication mechanism. So it's it's just one headed chop. So that person leaves the company or you make one change and it's trickle down to every single service everywhere. Yeah. Using a tool I guess for common people. My I somehow trained my wife to use one password to autogenerate passwords where she has to. Um you can also uh that means you only have to remember one very very difficult password to have a passcode. You can also like take screenshots of the the QR code within one password so that you don't even have to have it anywhere else, right? So um that makes the security a little bit easier. I still can't get my mom and dad off of having a password, but you know what? it's locked in their house and saved somewhere. You know, [snorts] there's there's worse things I've seen done like putting a password literally on the point of sale or a computer [clears throat] that's stored in wide open spaces or literally on the you know the bank password is literally on a post-it note. I've seen that many times. Oh yeah. No, that's I Yeah, that I I struggle the same with my parents, but I do also agree with you. as long as it's not some generic password and as long as it you know you're you're not click on dumb stuff that you shouldn't click on. Like I tell them that I'm like if you get an email or a text or something and you're not sure about it, just send it to me and I will tell you whether or not it's legit or not because like don't just click on it because that's exactly you're the person. I just tell them don't click on anything. Yeah. Yeah. Don't [snorts] click on it. Don't click on anything. And you know what? If they really want to get a hold of you or they need you to do something, they'll send certified mail. That That's what the government does. If they really want you to do something. Yeah. If you have a if it's questionable at all, just call, right? Like that's such an easy people don't do it because that's how we are these days. Um I mean, look at the email address. I mean, like click into the email and go into the sender and click in so you can actually see the email address. Don't just take what the name is up there for for what it is. especially if it's mildly suspicious or has a file attached or anything like that. Yeah. Um the call the bank before you send a wire in. Yeah. Yeah. Now, so you mentioned uh the password manager. What do you what do you recommend for the uh the 2FA? Do you have any like favorites or ones that you don't think people should use? Yeah, I use one password and then for 2FA I typically use a a product called Offy. Yeah. Um both both are solid. You use Google authenticator, Microsoft authenticator. I think trusting any of the thing guys, you're fine. Duo is fine. Um, for the most part, you want to have it tied to a publicly traded company or somebody that's going to take responsibility for it. It's not going to back door you. Um, yeah, it's one password is what I typically use. The last thing just because this is kind of relevant time-wise. Uh there was a there was some hack earlier this week I think right where there was like there were a bunch of uh [snorts] I think it was mostly social networks of some like but like MySpace and like like OG was the mother of all hacks. Yeah. Yeah. Uh so like what should people do when that type of stuff happens or you know they run uh what is it? I've been pawned and see that their their stuff has been, you know, leaked. Well, also do that people if you haven't. Uh [laughter] go search and see if your emails and stuff are out there on the dark web. Those are free tools that you can use anytime you want. Um and even now, like the the password managers are getting better now where they'll go and scrape the web and see if you your passwords have been compromised and they'll tell you about it. But you know what's like a a good plan of action for for that where it's like hey I wasn't directly involved but I am on this platform that does have or was how do I go about fixing it? Obviously changing your password is probably the first step right. [snorts] Sure. Yeah. Um obviously use a password manager use the second factor if possible. Um the mother of all hacks was done through a data bro I think it was done through a data brokerage where somebody had a huge leak that aggregates all the data. So, um, and then obviously you were talking about have I been pawned? Sure. But the the password manager is probably the best thing that a a person can use. Um, they can unlock with your face. It'll automatically pop up and says, "Hey, this password's been compromised." You know, one click, it'll take you in to change it. Then from a personal standpoint is like if you think that you are under attack or you think that you're nervous about uh cyber security, what they want is there is your money. They want you to they want to be able to take out a loan in your name. They want to be able to get into your bank account. They want to be able to do a number of things. They want to steal your identity. So put on Identity Guard. Go uh I use Credit Karma. Yeah. Yeah. They're taking my data, but you know what? I'd rather know when something's happening for sure, especially now. So, you know, premium versions out there where it's like it still lets you monitor the things that are important, but you don't have to pay for it. Like, you should be monitoring the stuff because that's how people ruin your life. Yeah. [laughter] Um, yeah. I I don't know if I pay for life lock or something like that, but for parents, it might make a lot of sense. I know that many uh very rich individuals I advise is like if you don't if you're going to pay for everything in cash just freeze your credit and just don't even do it right don't even unfreeze it you know so that way nobody can take out a loan in [laughter] your name and I've seen that happen multiple times so um those are from a very very high level is that multifactor authentication you know one password don't have an open Wi-Fi thing at your house and don't connect to open Wi-Fi number of things that at the airport or at concerts. Yeah. [snorts] Yeah, that's a that's a tough one. Um because it's so ubiquitous anymore. It's offered as a service. Um many companies, especially DoD or a lot of companies, will require you to have an always on VPN that comes back to the zero trust network edge. Uh and I use I use a company called uh you know, private internet access and I know Mac is or uh if you have like iCloud plus it'll give you a VPN anymore too. So, um, or you just don't do banking while you're at Starbucks, right? Just go check Facebook. Who cares? [laughter] Yeah. No, that's a that's a good point. I actually saw uh Man, what is that? It's this it kind of gone viral over the last year, but it's a little uh programmable like Wi-Fi, Bluetooth. It's got all kinds of RF frequencies. I don't remember the name of the product. I'm terrible these products. I would love for you to send me one because I want to play with it. But, uh, it's orange and white. It's got a little a screen on it, but you can. It's like a hacker's dream. Um, but I saw this guy, he paired it up with like a a router essentially at a hotel, and he renamed it, you know, to the whatever myriad Wi-Fi, and he was sitting there just watching people. He was like, "This is literally how easy people can hack you in public Wi-Fi. Y'all should stop." And he could see every piece of traffic that was coming across. Yeah. Wow. And [snorts] so, yeah. And like that device is like a 100. like it's super cheap and super easy to to do apparently. But [snorts] um yeah, just be be careful. Even like when we were working together, I remember that uh article that Rebecca sent out about the uh like charging your phones and USB ports at public places. Now people are skimming those as well. It's crazy, but [snorts] Yep. Yep. They can get into your phone through plugging things in. I always take a I always take like an anchor charger. Yeah. Just a big big bank. Just use that. Yeah, just using as far as what you're talking about the Yeah, the RF the RF thing. I've seen I've literally seen during assessment somebody bump into somebody and then right scan their badge and they literally had access everywhere. That's insane. Yeah. Yeah. They can just read the NFC off your It's just like you see in the movies. I literally watched him bump into somebody, copy their badge, and then he could get in anywhere. Yeah. No, there was some YouTube channel that I watched for a while that it was a security guy and he would go to these companies and be like and they'd be like, "Oh, we've got a great security blah blah blah." And then he would most of the time his act was he would pose as a repair man or like a HVAC guy or whatever. The secretary at the office had no idea and just like let him in because he was dressed up and had a ladder and a toolbox and he went into the IT room and plugged directly in, you know, just like Yeah, it it it's it happens. Anyway, we're uh that hour engineering. Yeah, I've got so many we need to have some more some more security stuff. Probably even do a topic type thing. Yeah. Where can uh where can people find you, learn about you, hit you up if they uh want to chat? Yeah. Uh classiv.com. Class4. Beckerclass4.com. That's class4 with clasiv.com. Um I'm on the Twitter at Beckerb. Um, I usually post about baseball and Joe Mau and and [laughter] uh Joe Bar Joe Barry being an awful an awful defensive coordinator. Um, but yeah, otherwise in Denver, hit me up. Grab a cigar or drink or whatever. Yeah. Awesome. I appreciate it, man. Yeah. Glad to come on. Thank you. Yeah. Thanks guys for the invite. Yeah. Thanks. Nice to meet you guys hopefully in person next time. Absolutely. We we'll be uh DW's coming up coming back to Denver this year for uh for Energy Tech night. So, I will absolutely uh hit you up and and try and get you there. Good time for a shameless plug. Energy Tech Night tickets are are now on sale. Go check them out. We're going to I think six cities uh this year. Houston, Fort Worth, Midland, Oklahoma City, Denver, and I believe Calgary. Oh, nice. Going international. Um so check those out. Uh, thanks for for listening and watching everybody. If you like this, uh, check out some more episodes right here.