The American Record

On October 2, 1789, George Washington sent twelve proposed amendments to the states for ratification. Ten would become the Bill of Rights — though one waited two centuries to take effect.

What is The American Record?

A daily history podcast from Patriot Compass. Each episode explores the events that shaped America on this day in history, told through expert narration and grounded in primary sources.

Narrator:

A post writer swings up onto his horse outside the president's house. In his saddlebag, a single folded document, two signatures, 12 numbered articles. No crowd has gathered. No one is cheering. He rides north toward New Hampshire, and the fate of American liberty rides with him, one muddy road at a time.

Narrator:

This is the American record from Patriot Compass, one story from this day in American history. It's 10/02/1789. The Constitution is two years old, and a lot of Americans still don't trust it. They think it hands too much power to a distant federal government and says nothing about protecting individual freedom. James Madison, a Virginia congressman who once called a bill of rights merely useful, not essential, had changed his mind under political pressure.

Narrator:

He wrote a set of amendments. Congress argued over them for months. Now President Washington has the final version on his desk, and it's his job to send it out into a country that has to agree on it, one state legislature at a time. Rewind four months. Madison stands in the House on June 8 with 17 proposed amendments in hand.

Narrator:

He's not doing this out of pure conviction. He'd promised voters back home he'd push for a bill of rights just to win his own house seat against a rival who very nearly beat him. Now he has to deliver. The House spends the summer cutting his list down. By August 24, they pass a revised set and send it to the Senate.

Narrator:

The Senate trims it further, down to 12 articles by September 9. Neither chamber agrees completely, so a joint conference sits down and hammers out a final compromise on September 25. 12 articles survive the fight. Five are gone entirely. And this had already been a fight with real heat behind it.

Narrator:

Two years earlier, at the Massachusetts ratifying convention, a Federalist delegate and an anti Federalist delegate, a man named Elbridge Gerry, who'd already lost this exact argument once at the Philadelphia convention, came to blows on the convention floor. Gerry believed, physically believed, that the new government could swallow up individual liberty. Massachusetts settled its fight not with fists, but with a promise, ratify now, amend later. That promise is what Madison is now making good on. So on October 2, the finished resolution lands on Washington's desk.

Narrator:

It carries two signatures. Speaker Frederick Muhlenberg and John Adams, presiding officer of the Senate. There's no grand speech. Washington had already given his big address back in April, urging Congress toward what he called a reverence for the rights of free men without spelling out what that meant in law. This is the spelling out.

Narrator:

A cover letter, a post writer, and a two year waiting game begin. Each state legislature has to take up all 12 articles, debate them, and vote. Some ratify quickly, others stall. It isn't until 12/15/1791, more than two years later, that Virginia becomes the eleventh state to approve, finally pushing 10 of the 12 articles over the three fourths line needed to become law. The twelfth article, about how congressional districts should be sized, never did clear that bar.

Narrator:

It's technically still pending today. And the second article, limiting when Congress could raise its own pay, just sat there, forgotten. Until a college student in Texas revived it two centuries later, and it finally became the twenty seventh amendment in 1992, two hundred and three years after Washington first put it in the mail. What left Washington's desk that day wasn't a finished law. It was a question handed to 13 separate legislatures about what freedom actually requires in writing.

Narrator:

10 of those answers became the standard every American free speech and due process claim is still measured against. And the method Washington used that day, sending Congress's work to the states rather than treating it as final, remains the only way the constitution can be amended. It's still the process Congress is using right now as lawmakers debate changes to the federal courts. Washington's post writer was carrying the rule book for every argument about American government that would follow. That document took two hundred years to finish its journey, and October 2 has a habit of marking days when power finally, formally changes hands.

Narrator:

In 1967, Thurgood Marshall took the oath as the first African American justice on the Supreme Court. In 1919, president Woodrow Wilson suffered a disabling stroke inside the White House, one that was kept hidden from the public for months. And in 1980, the House voted 376 to 30 to expel Congressman Michael Myers after a bribery scandal. This has been the American Record from Patriot Compass. Come back tomorrow for another story from America's past.

Narrator:

Before you go, if you like knowing exactly how a document like the Bill of Rights actually made its way into law, clause by clause, state by state, That's the whole idea behind this show. The American Record comes from Patriot Compass, a free app with a new piece of American history every day, plus deeper dives on the stories worth more of your time. Find it at patriotcompass.us.